1
1
Manchester Community CollegeSocial Sciences Division
Urban Geography
Lecture 12. Planning a Better City
Adjunct Lecturer:Donald J. Poland, MS, AICPE-mail: [email protected]
Web: www.donaldpoland.com
2
Chapter Thirteen
Planning the Better City
3
Make no little plans. They have no magic to stir men's blood and probably themselves will not be realized. Make big plans; aim high in hope and work, remembering that a noble, logical diagram once recorded will never die, but long after we are gone will be a living thing, asserting itself with ever-growing insistency. Remember that our sons and grandsons are going to do things that would stagger us. Let your watchword be order and your beacon beauty. Think big.
Daniel Burnham, Chicago architect. (1864-1912)
“For we must have the great things of the past to enjoy and study, but with that valuable experience and pleasure as guide and criterion, we must surely seek to live in the present and to try to create the new forms which are to be our legacy to the future."
- A. Everett “Chick” Austin, 1936, Hartford, CT
4
A Context Planning
Today, planning is carried out by many people who would not necessarily be considered professional planners. Planning takes place whether or not “planners” are involved. Professional planning has evolved as a means to add rational thought, methods, and experience to the process. Sometimes planners leave a bigger mess than theyfound, but often they perform an important function of minimizing costs and increasing benefits. We will discuss the rationales, bases, and activities of modern urban planning. The tools of planning—the comprehensive plan, zoning, fiscal incentives, and others—developed throughout the course of the twentieth century. Today, some of these tools are under attack as helping to contribute to some of problems of modern urban society. At the same time new planning solutions have been devised and are beginning to be implemented in various communities across the country.
2
5
Making the Case for Planning
Most would agree that some form of urban planning is desirable. The alternative—a city based on the unfettered exercise of the free market—would just be too chaotic. For this reason, every city, town, and village in North America is planned to some degree. Aesthetics: deals with the appearance of cities—buildings and uses. This was most evident during the Baroque era, prior to industrialization, many cities were designed according to the Grand Manner:
A coordinated design for streets and avenues that help connect various monuments, statutes, and other focal points. Attention to the topography of the site, as the city was aligned so as to create vistas that could overlook the city and certain urban landmarks. Attention to streetscapes, particularly for the main streets in the city. Broad tree-lined boulevards were the rule. Versailles and DC. The City Beautiful Movement (Daniel Burnham) emphasized the creation of an aesthetically pleasing public city.
6
Making the Case for Planning
Efficiency: Planning also was motivated by efforts to create a city that could operate more efficiently. Modern examples of this are smart growth and the anti-sprawl movement. Cost of land uses and cost of sprawl.Social Equity Planning: Private urban development helps to create vibrant, bustling cities that can accommodate the needs and desires of many segments of the population. Yet, the poorest members of society are often left out. Land-use decisions are rarely made with their interests in mind. The poor are either neglected—given no housing choices, few shopping opportunities, and no green space—or they are exploited by lenders, high-interest “money-shops” and slumlords. Reforms to look out for and protect the poor collectively are referred to as social equity planning. Today, this is still true.
7
Making the Case for Planning
Maintaining Property Values: The explosive growth of cities and the increased concentration let to a desire for the government to step in and regulate building and property use as means of minimizing negative externalities and maintaining property values. The issue of property value is closely tied to a property owner’s dilemma and the nature of landed property as a commodity.
If a property owner renovates her property but others doe not renovate theirs, she will not realize much in the way of increased property values. Conversely, if the neighbors renovate their property but she does not renovate hers, she property value will still increase. Thus, there are no individual incentives for people to maintain or improve their property.
Zoning came about as a way to control these negative externalities by regulating exactly what could be placed where. Zoning is simply the establishment of districts that permit only specific types of land use.
8
Making the Case for Planning
Environmental Protection: The environmental planning movement started as a parks movement led by Fredrick Law Olmsted.
Vision of parks: “believed that parks helped to release workers from the drudgery of city life and were an antidote to the evil influences of the slum.
Central Park. Private Parks. Bushnell Park. Olmsted and Hartford.Today environmental planning covers many more issues and topics.
3
9
Development of Modern Planning
Visionaries and the Urban Ideal: In the early twentieth century, advocates offered up a number of visions of what the modern cityshould be like. The utopian visions were even larger in scope than Burnham, and required the building of cities from the ground up. Like Burnham, the visionaries were private individuals with little public institutional authority. Most were architects. Nevertheless, they has a great deal of moral authority, and, as a result, their visions influenced the development of cities.
Ebenezer Howard and the Garden City Movement. Le Corbusier’s City of Towers. Frank Lloyd Wright’s Broadacre City.
10
Development of Modern Planning
Legal Basis for Planning: The visions of what a city could be were important milestones. They furnished the ideas that helped guide urban design and helped the nascent field of urban planning to see the city as a whole. But the weakness is these visions was precisely that they assumed everything could be controlled by a central authority. In democratic countries, such was not possible, and ideals of urbandesign were forced to confront the realities of law. In all capitalist countries, planning must contend with the rights of property owners.
In the US, the right to private property is written into the Fifth Amendment of the Constitution, which states “nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.”This is called the takings clause of the Constitution.
11
Comprehensive Plans and Tools of Modern Planning
Modern planning begins with a document known as the comprehensive plan. The comprehensive plan (plan of conservation and development in CT) is a plan that is intended first to catalog he existing land uses, population, and an economic profile within acommunity and then to guide community development well into the future. From a political point of view, the comprehensive plan becomes a critical document that helps to lay out the goals for a community, institutionalize the planning process, create a legal foundation for specific regulations, and bring together all of the different stakeholders with a community.
12
Comprehensive Plans and Tools of Modern Planning
Elements and Steps in Comprehensive Plan Development:1. A long-rang vision for the community that usually is presented as a series of goals for the community. 2. A snapshot of the physical and human geography of the community. Inventory of existing conditions. 3. An overview of historical and projected trends. 4. Implementation. Methods on how to handle the overall and specific community goals. 5. Review procedures that show how the community administration will handle these changes and implement any new proposals and how community citizens will be able to participate.
4
13
Comprehensive Plans and Tools of Modern Planning
Zoning: is a way to regulate the use of land. Land is divided into zones in which the number, types, and features of buildings are restricted, prohibited, or permitted. Zoning developed as a means of excluding incompatible uses.Problems with Zoning and Responses: Zoning has had a dramatic effect on the development of cities and towns. It alters the impact of land value and the land value curve. By prohibiting certain uses, zoning regulations may prevent a property owner from developing his or her property to its most lucrative use. Behind the more technical aspects of zoning are an array of local interests who stand to gain or losedepending on the delineation of zoning lines and the precise wording of zoning definitions.
14
Comprehensive Plans and Tools of Modern Planning
Exclusionary Zoning of Class and Race: Another problem of modern zoning is that it has been used to create uniform places designed to keep people out that a community may consider “undesirable.” The political of all this has to do with how local governments seek to encourage particular housing types and classes while they discourage all others. Generally, governments are interested in maximizing their property tax base, minimizing the need for certain services (those for low-income people), and promoting higher property values. The mechanisms for accomplishing this are fairly simple. The easiest way is through the use of zoning. Communities may designate a large minimum lot size—and they can also require such amenities as a two-car garage, a minimum square footage, a minimum number of bedrooms, or a required number of bathrooms. Zoning may also exclude multi-family housing; this tends to minimize rentals.
15
Comprehensive Plans and Tools of Modern Planning
Growth Management: has become a major aspect of planning, particularly in fast-growing suburban areas. Within newer suburbs residents often express concerns that their way of life is disappearing in the onslaught of new housing development, shopping centers, and more traffic. In many cases, the issue is focused on the loss offarmland. Strategies include agricultural zoning, building restrictions, growth boundaries, impact fees, and open space preservation.
16
Development of Modern Planning
Growth of Planning as a Profession in the United States: The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports in 2004 there were 32,000 planners, up from 13,000 in 1980. Planning is still mainly a public-sector activity. Seventy percent of planners work for local government, private firms employ planners as well, a bit less than 20 percent of the total of planners. Growth in government, government services, and more complicated land use requirements are most likely the cause of such increase in planning as a profession.
5
17
Development of Modern Planning
Political Nature of Planning: Regardless of the particular activities in which planners are involved, it is important to note that planning is a highly political activity. We can look at this reality in regardless to
(1) the different scales of planning concern and (2) the many different stakeholders involved in the planning process.
Planning takes place at several spatial scales. In most cases, local governments are on the frontlines of planning. It also occurs at county or regional levels, and state and federal levels. At any scale, planners have to be politically astute. Most planners are thrust in the middle of a very political process. The must consider the interests of many stakeholders who would be affected by the plans.
Stakeholders is an umbrella term that includes all of the interests involved: government, private developers, financiers, and residents. NIMBY and LULU.
18
A Historical Context of Planning
A Greater Understanding of Planning
19
Fundamentals of Cities and UrbanizationWhy do communities plan?
Planning as a Response to Problems of Urbanism
Do you need to plan for this?
Do you need to plan for this?
20
Fundamentals of Cities and UrbanizationClassical Urbanism (Greeks and Romans)
Who cares?Greeks: City-states & ‘organic cities’
FormsAcropolis, Agora, Temples, Theaters, SportsUnplanned
HousingCourtyard styleMixed neighborhoods
Quality of Urban LifeUrban Design
Grids as a means of organizing space
6
21
Fundamentals of Cities and UrbanizationClassical Urbanism (Greeks and Romans)
Context of an Economic/Military EmpireTrade, Colonialism, and Wealth
RoadsTrading townsMilitary settlements (castra towns)
Urbanization and Urban DevelopmentMassive investment in major cities Investment in Social & Physical Infrastructure
Innovations: The Roman Arch & ConcreteVaulted CeilingsBasilicasConcrete
22
Fundamentals of Cities and UrbanizationThe Renaissance City
Planning and the CityTrade, Money, and PowerChanging defensive roll of the city
GunpowderRapid urbanization
Grid patterns reintroducedPublic spaces an city life-squares, piazzas, etc.
Practical usesSymbolic uses
23
Fundamentals of Cities and UrbanizationThe Baroque Period
ContextEmpires, MonarchiesEarly Colonialism and its financial influencesCity as home to the wealthy
‘Formal’ CitiesElementsVersailles & Paris as model
Who cares?Impact on the communities of the western hemisphereBaroque planning and capital cities
24
Fundamentals of Cities and UrbanizationThe Baroque Period
7
25
Fundamentals of Cities and UrbanizationThe Origins of Planning Cities
Planning as a way to improve our livesPlanning becomes more important when we live in citiesEvolution of Cities/Planning
What were cities like prior to the 1800What was planning like prior to 1800Rural ideal in U.S.
Rebirth of capitalism & its urban influence
26
Fundamentals of Cities and UrbanizationEarly Urban America
The 1st American citiesEuropean Traditions
New England, New Amsterdam & village traditionTidewater and the ‘Town Acts’The Carolinas/Georgia & Renaissance StyleL’Enfant-Washington DC & Baroque Style
The Economics of Transporting GoodsIn 1690 only 10% of the population was urbanResource Exploitation and TradePopulation lived in small coastal/river valley villages
27
Fundamentals of Cities and UrbanizationUrbanizing America After the Revolutionary War
The Revolutionary War and its ImpactsIn 1800 only 6% of the population was urbanIn 1800 85-90% of the labor force were farmingOnly 24 communities with over 2500 inhabitantsNYC had 100,000 residents in 1800
Stabilizing the frontierExpansion of the frontierTrading routes into the interiorGrowing population providing markets for rural productsRelative drop in urban population
28
Fundamentals of Cities and UrbanizationWhat Happens in the 1800s?
The frontier becomes more distant & less appealingThe topography of the new frontierConditions on the frontier
Massive immigrationmany East Coast cities top 100,000NYC 100,000 in 1800, over 2,000,00 by 1880
Technology Change & Urban GrowthWater power to steamTrainsElevators and steel
The Industrial and Urban Revolutions
8
29
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningGarden Cities of Tomorrow
Ebeneezer Howard ‘Garden Cities of Tomorrow’
Anti urban ‘satellite’ cities (village life as ideal)
Some good things to know….Small self-supporting communitiesLimited populationGreenbelts and open spaceLetchworth, Welwyn, Hampstead G.S.Columbia, MD
Leads to New Towns Movement in the U.S.‘Satellite’ cities in U.S.S.R
30
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningThe City Beautiful Movement
Big Projects as catalyst for growth & civic pride
See Adriaen’s Landing, Radio City, the Big Dig…
Some good things to know…The Columbian Exposition of 1893 ‘White City’Daniel Burnham’s Plan for Chicago (1909)
“Make no little plans they have no magic to stir men’s blood…”
1ST PLANNING COMMISSION-Hartford in 1907
What they learnedBeautification and adornment (at huge costs) had limited practicality for most cities. Hmmmm…
31
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningThe City Beautiful Movement - Hartford
32
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningWhat to do about the problem?
Zoning and the Public Health MovementRegulations to benefit the human condition
New Towns, Garden Cities, & Streetcar SuburbsBring housing to nature or start from scratch
The City Beautiful and City PlanningThe first generation of urban renewal
9
33
Cities as unhealthy placesMassive migration/immigration/population growthIndustrial Impacts‘The Great Stink’, Cholera, Tuberculosis, Alcoholism….
Alcoholism, distillation & the Temperance MovementSome good things to know
Housing sanitation-NYC Tenement Law of 1867Housing safety-NYC Tenement Law of 1901
The ‘Dumbell’ TenementParks movement & F.L. Olmsted
Central Park (1866) Fenway (1880) Stanley Quarter Park1st Regulations against noxious uses in cities
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningThe Public Health Movement
34
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningPlanning in the 1920s and 1930s
Planning and the CarPlanning and ArchitecturePlanning and Economic DevelopmentRegional PlanningPlanning RegulationsPlanning and the Courts
35
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningArchitects and the ‘Modern’ City
Industrial age urban constructsThe Progressive Movement
The ‘Modern’ context20th Century Architecture
The Culturalists / Romanticists
The ‘Traditional’ contextAchitectural inspirations from the past
36
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningThe Culturalists
Drawing from traditionEvolving from the public health movement
Garden Cities & Ebenezer HowardCity Beautiful & Burnham
NostalgicInspired by our cultural heritageCriticizes current situation in light of the pastWork with and/or add to existing urban context
10
37
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningThe Progressives
Breaking from traditionEvolving from the public health movement
BUTFuture orientedInspired by vision of social progressRevolutionary visionsBreaks with the existing urban contextProgressive evolves into ‘Modernism’
38
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningModernism
Modernism is a reaction against the crisis of urban disorder, impoverishment, congestion and anarchy through the imposition of rational order.Modern = Rational & efficient. Machine as metaphor.
The city is the factory of modern lifeThe machine is our medium of modern designThe house is a machine for modern living“Home is nothing more than a factory for the production of happiness” (Good Housekeeping, 1910)
39
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningModernist…
Modernists think…Large scale, metropolitan wide, rational, efficient, functionalist (form follows function), organized, and monumental
Modernists are trying to come to grips with…Explosive urban growth, industrialization, rural to urban migration, failing urban health, social uprisings, and the ‘despair of the cities’
You may be a modernist if you like…1970’s architecture, minimalism, multi-purpose sports stadiums (with the old kind of artificial turf), glass box architecture, or anything from IKEA.
40
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningDivergent trends in modernism
Arts & Crafts-Frank Lloyd WrightFuturist-Walter Gropius & Tony GarnierRadical-Le CorbusierWhy should we care…
Dominated architecture into the late 1980’s
11
41
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningUtopianism and Planning
What is Utopia?
Utopia as a concept in writing, design, thinkingThe Culturalist / Romantic UtopiaThe Progressive/Modernist Utopia
New Urbanism—a return to the “utopia’ of traditional neighborhoods and cities
What would we do with a blank slate?
Is one man’s utopia another man’s hell?
42
Post-War Urbanism and Planning
A Greater Understandingof Planning
43
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningPutting Modernism to Work
Housing Modernist attempts at housingDifferent European contextsThe U.S.?
Garden Cities & New Towns1920’s and 1930’sUnwin and the ‘Greenbelt’ towns, Radburn N.J.Modern versions of garden cities.
44
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningPlanning and the Great Depression
Boom to Bust in the U.S. EconomyPlanning Impacts (the New Deal)
Economic Development PlanningEnvironmental ConservationEarly Urban RenewalLots of housing legislationFinance ProgramsFirst Efforts at Highway Planning (parkways)First Efforts at Regional Planning
12
45
Evolutionary track of regulationsMilestones
First city plan (Cleveland 1903)First state ‘enabling legislation’ (WI 1909)First city-wide zoning ‘code’ (LA 1909)Standard State Zoning Enabling Act (1922)Cincy adopts 1st comprehensive plan (1925)Euclid vs. Ambler Realty (1926)Standard City Planning Enable Act (1928)
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningRegulatory Planning
46
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningPlanning and the Post War Period
Building on foundations of the 1930’s+Growing car ownership +Population growth & the Baby Boomers +Urban Renewal and Economic Growth +Highway Planning and the Suburb +Growth in home ownership =
The 1960’s City
47
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningThe Car and the City
Growing automobile ownershipBenefits of the car vs. mass transitProblems of the car vs. mass transitLand use impacts of the carPlanning impacts of the carThe car and the suburbs
(See highway impacts)
48
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningThe Baby Boom and Housing Change
The Baby BoomPost-war fertility and birth rate growthShort and long term effects
Post War HousingFHA & VA loan programsSingle family housing dominatesLevittownMove up markets growChanges in who owns homes
13
49
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningEconomic Growth
The Post-War Economic Boom The U.S. Position after WWIIDevastation in EuropeThe lack of competition
Fueling GrowthHighwaysConsumer SpendingUrban Renewal
50
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningUrban Renewal
Basic ConceptsThe U.S. perspectiveThe European perspective
Impacts
Urban Renewal, Housing, Public Housing
ProblemsNegativesCostsAmbitionsEconomic downturns
51
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningThe Coming of the Highway
ParkwaysHighwaysJustification/funding for highwaysConstruction of the highwaysImpacts of highways between citiesImpacts of highways within cities
52
Fundamentals of Cities and Planning1960s - The Urban Crisis
What was it?The causes
The world catches upIndustry moves outOut-migration and urban poverty
The taxation crisisDeclining urban environmentRacially/ethnically biased practices
CatalystsThe Vietnam WarThe assassinations of JFK & MLK
14
53
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningChildren of the 60s
Public awareness of the problemResponses to the Urban Crisis
Grassroots PlanningCivil rightsAdvocacy & Non profits
Environmental PlanningThe Media & ‘Silent Spring’Federal Government Actions
Regional Planning
54
Fundamentals of Cities and PlanningThe Ragan Legacy
Limiting Federal InvolvementBig government ‘slims’ down
Independent CommunitiesHome rule not regions
Funds and not StructuresGrant programs
Planning for EconomicsGrowth pole economics
NIMBYism
55
Planning, The Law, and Planning Documents
A Greater Understandingof Planning
56
Fundamentals of the Legal Foundation of Planning How does government get us to do what it wants us to do?
RegulationsZoningSubdivisionWetland
RewardsTax Incentives
AdvisingPublic Service Announcements
15
57
Fundamentals of the Legal Foundation of Planning Planning as Land Use Regulations
Planning as a Police PowerPublic InterestPublic Health, Safety, and Welfare Public Participation
(These give government authority over us and the authority to create laws)
Legal Precedent
58
Fundamentals of the Legal Foundation of Planning The Creation of Law
Enabling LegislationStatutory Laws
Vs.
Case Law
Enabling LegislationBasisTerms DefinedPowers EstablishedResponsibilities DefinedLinks to other StatutesAdministration
59
Fundamentals of the Legal Foundation of Planning The Advancement of Government Power
How did government power advance during the 20th
Century?Power to Control Land Use (late 1800’s)Power to Plan (1920’s)Economic Development & Housing (1930’s)Civil Rights Powers (1950’s/1960’s)Environmental Preservation (1960’s/1970’s)Land Rights (1990’s)
Evolutionary track of regulationsMilestones
First city plan (Cleveland 1903)First state ‘enabling legislation’ (WI 1909)First city-wide zoning ‘code’(LA 1909)Standard State Zoning Enabling Act (1922)Cincy adopts 1st comprehensive plan (1925)Euclid vs. Ambler Realty (1926)Standard City Planning Enable Act (1928)
60
Fundamentals of the Legal Foundation of Planning Why is land such an issue?
Control/direct developmentHow, when public only owns about 10% of the land?
Preserve/improve community characterHow do you preserve/improve what you don’t own?
Protect/conserve the environmentHow, when most of the property is privately owned?
Benefit the health & welfare of residentsHow does your community generate revenues?How does your community generate additional revenues?
16
61
Fundamentals of the Legal Foundation of Planning Land as Property – Land as Rights?
Land Rights and the Cone of Ownership
Surface RightsSubsurface RightsSupersurface RightsRight of AccessBoundary EstablishmentAdverse OccupanceTransient Resources
62
Fundamentals of the Legal Foundation of Planning What impacts land values?
LocationQuality of the landQuality of associated resources(unlimited use, reasonable
use, use rights)What is on the landFor what is the land usefulHow the land is usedRegulations affecting the landConfidence and Predictability
Land Value and Takings
63
Fundamentals of the Legal Foundation of Planning What Empowers and Limits Government Power
Enabling Legislation (Statutory Laws)Case Law
(Both empower and limit)
vs.
The Constitution (limits)Amendment 1Amendment 5Amendment 14
64
Fundamentals of the Legal Foundation of Planning Why Single Out the 5th Amendment?
Planning today deals extensively with property (mostly land) issues.
The ownership of propertyThe use of propertyThe value of property
The 5th Amendment - Trial and Punishment, Compensation for Takings
…nor shall any person…be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.
17
65
Fundamentals of the Legal Foundation of Planning Land, Law, and ‘Takings’
5th Amendment and Property SeizureEminent Domain and CondemnationThe Concept of a Taking (by regulation)The Concept of Rational Nexus
66
Fundamentals of the Legal Foundation of Planning Planning and the 1st Amendment
Free speech, religion, and sexWhen is a sign protected?When isn’t a sign protected?Does regulating a place of worship conflict with it?Does regulating adult entertainment conflict with it?
Amendment 1 - Freedom of Religion, Press, Expression.
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
67
Fundamentals of the Legal Foundation of Planning Government, the Law, and Ethics – The 14th Amendment
Why do ethics matter in a discussion of government powers?The 14th Amendment and Town Plans
A town plan presents the community’s goals. It indicates what is in the ‘best interest’ of the community.Planning is meant to make those goals a reality.How can you use the tools of planning without having a plan to justify them?
Amendment 14 - Citizenship Rights.
….No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
68
A Little Bit About Zoning
A Greater Understandingof Planning
18
69
Fundamentals of the Land Use System Zoning Basics
‘By right’ and permitted uses
Conditionally or special permit uses
Non-permitted uses
Bulk and density limitations
Accessory uses vs. Accessory buildings
70
Fundamentals of the Land Use System The Roles and Responsibilities of Land Use Agencies
Land Use Commissions
Authority and Role
Policy Legislative Administrative
Planning Commission
PolicyLegislativeAdministrative
Create, adopt, and implement Plan of C & D
Create and adopt Subdivision Regulations
Administer applications, permits, and enforcement
Zoning Commission
LegislativeAdministrative
X Create and adopt Zoning Regulations
Administer applications, permits, and enforcement
Conservation Commission (wetlands)
LegislativeAdministrative
X Create and adopt Wetland Regulations
Administer applications, permits, and enforcement
Zoning Board of Appeals
Quasi-JudicialAdministrative
X X Administer hearings for Appeals and variances
71
Fundamentals of the Land Use System Purpose and Authority – Zoning Commission (Chapter 124)
C.G.S. Section 8-2 (Zoning Regulations):The zoning commission of each city, town or borough is authorized to regulate…the height, number of stories and size of buildings and other structures; the percentage of the area of the lot that may be occupied; the size of yards, courts and other open spaces; the density of population and the location and use of buildings, structures and land for trade, industry, residence or other purposes, including water-dependent uses…and the height, size and location of advertising signs and billboards.Such bulk regulations may allow for cluster development…Such zoning commission may divide the municipality into districts of such number, shape and area as may be best suited to carry out the purposes of this chapter; and, within such districts, it may regulate the erection, construction, reconstruction, alteration or use of buildings or structures and the use of land.
72
Fundamentals of the Land Use System Purpose and Authority – Zoning Commission (Chapter 124)
C.G.S. Section 8-2 (Zoning Regulations): All such regulations shall be uniform for each class or kind of buildings, structures or use of land throughout each district, but the regulations in one district may differ from those in another district, and may provide that certain classes or kinds of buildings, structures or uses of land are permitted only after obtaining a special permit or special exception… the regulations may…designate, subject to standards set forth in the regulations and to conditions necessary to protect the public health, safety, convenience and property values. Such regulations shall be made in accordance with a comprehensive plan and in adopting such regulations the commission shall consider the plan of conservation and development…Such regulations shall be designed to lessen congestion in the streets; to secure safety from fire, panic, flood and other dangers; to promote health and the general welfare; to provide adequate light and air; to prevent the overcrowding of land; to avoid undue concentration of population and to facilitate the adequate provision for transportation, water, sewerage, schools, parks and other public requirements.
19
73
Fundamentals of the Land Use System Land Use Applications and Permits
Land Use PermitsAuthorized
By Commissions
Explanation Comments
Site Plan The review of a proposed development to ensure the development complies with the regulations. No hearing required.
Less significant development proposals are sometimes approved by staff (example, interior change of use)
Special Permit orSpecial Exception
Site plan review for a development or use that may have adverse impacts and additional review/standards. Public hearing required.
Use/developments that may not be suitable for all locations with a zone.
Subdivision andResubdivision
The review of a proposal to divide land into 3 or lots or subsequent revision to approved lots and public infrastructure.
1st cut from a lot-of-record is exempt from approval.
Variance A permit to legally violate the zoning regulations where the regulations create an unusual hardship.
Hardship cannot be financial or self-created and must be unique to the parcel and not the zone.
74
Fundamentals of the Land Use System Land Use Concepts – Setbacks and Yards
Minimum setbacks - front, side, and rear setbacks
Establishment of yards
Source: Bloomfield Zoning Regulations
75
Fundamentals of the Land Use System Land Use Concepts – Height and Measurement
Maximum building height and measurement for Gable Roof
Maximum building height and measurement for Mansard Roof
Source: Bloomfield Zoning Regulations
76
Fundamentals of the Land Use System Land Use Concepts – Height and Measurement
Calculating Average Grade
Measuring height
Source: Ridgefield Zoning Regulations
20
77
Fundamentals of the Land Use System Land Use Concepts – Height and Measurement
Source: Ridgefield Zoning Regulations
78
Fundamentals of the Land Use System Land Use Concepts – Lot Coverage
Calculating Lot Coverage
Source: Ridgefield Zoning Regulations
79
Fundamentals of the Land Use System Land Use Concepts – Types of Lots and Yard Locations
Displays the configuration of lots and location of required yards:
Front Lot (Corner)Front LotFront Lot (Pie Shaped)Rear Lot
Source: Bloomfield Zoning Regulations 80
Fundamentals of the Land Use System Land Use Concepts – Conservation Subdivision
Development is clustered to preserve more open space or to protect critical habitat.Regulations may provide for density bonuses or reduced minimum lot size.Designs standards often include low impact drainage design:
Narrower streetsSoft shouldersSwales in place of pipesWetlands used for drainage capacity
Source: Branford Plan of Conservation and Development
21
81
Fundamentals of the Land Use System Site Development Plans and Subdivisions
82
Planning as a Profession
A Greater Understandingof Planning
83
Fundamentals of Planning as a ProfessionWhat does it mean to be a professional?
Someone who provides a service for othersSomeone who is paidSomeone who is educatedSomeone who is experiencedSomeone who acts ‘professionally’Someone who is certified (or equivalent)
84
Fundamentals of Planning as a ProfessionProfessional Applications of Planning
State/Regional/Town PlanningEnvironmental ManagementTransportation EngineersEmergency Management Land Use/Development LawEconomic Developers/RealtorsUrban Designers/Facility DesignCampus/Facilities Planners
22
85
Fundamentals of Planning as a ProfessionTypes of Town Government in Connecticut
MayoralManagerialFirst Selectman/LegislativeTown Meeting(Chapters 7 & 8 of the CT State
Statutes)BENEFITS OF EACHLIABILITIES OF EACH
Planners are Civil Servants in government
86
Fundamentals of Planning as a ProfessionThe job of planner in your town
Control/direct developmentPreserve/improve community characterProtect/conserve the environmentBenefit the health and welfare of community residents
***Provide Direction and Improve the Quality of Life***
87
Fundamentals of Planning as a ProfessionWhat do planners really do?
Planning FunctionsConduct ResearchCreate PoliciesMake Plans and ProgramsImplement Plans/ProgramsFund Plans/Programs $$$$
Office FunctionsPublic OutreachTechnical AdvisingCoordinate public sector development activitiesReview ProposalsAdminister/EnforceBudget
88
Fundamentals of Planning as a ProfessionPlanners don’t…
Approve policiesThey draft them for others’ approval
Approve plansThe create them for others’ approval
Decide on fundingThey make proposals that others consider
Planners role is advisoryWho do they advise?
23
89
Understanding Plans and Planning
A Greater Understandingof Planning
90
Understanding Planning and Plans What is the planning process?
Regardless of where it is conducted or what it is called, the planning process involves identifying, analyzing and solving problems.
The planning process typically involves the following steps:WHERE WE ARE?WHERE WE WANT TO GO?HOW WE WILL GET THERE?IMPLEMENTATION?
The planning process works best as a continuous and iterative process. Planning should be conducted as cyclical process in which experience provides new insights that lead in new directions.
91
Understanding Planning and Plans What is the most important part of the planning process?
Implementation is the real purpose of the planning process.
Preparing a plan may be an interesting and exciting venture, it will not be considered a success if it is not implemented.
Preparing a Plan of Conservation and Development may last one totwo years.
The implementation phase may last for ten to twenty years.
Implementation is the whole reason that we plan.
92
Understanding Planning and Plans What are some planning principles?
Planning establishes a long term vision that is used to guide short-term decision making. Planning promotes:
coordinated efforts,consistent results, andefficiency and economy in implementation.
Long-term community vision should be established by an open discussion of current policies. Planning can help establish general agreement on future direction.The planning process should establish a basic framework for future decision making. Conditions may change through the planning process—readjustment may be needed.Planning must be flexible in the face of changing circumstances. No one has a crystal ball. Planning is most successful as a continuous, iterative process of self-improvement.
24
93
Comprehensive Plans
A Greater Understandingof Planning
94
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansWhat empowers a community?
ACTUALLY HAVING A PLANNeed a reason to use the toolsNeed a goal for use of the of the toolsA plan may be needed or required in order to justify public expenditures
95
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansComprehensive Plans
Comprehensive PlanDefinitionRequirements for Success In Connecticut (Plans of Development)Empowered by CT State Statutes10 year planning ‘windows’
96
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansComprehensive Plans Lead to Other Planning
If you have a comprehensive plan then you have empowered…
Site PlanningDepartmental PlanningCapital Improvements PlanningZoningSubdivision RegulationsHistoric District RegulationsEtc. Etc. Etc.
These can be used to put the plan into effect
25
97
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansThe ‘Rational’ Planning Method: Problems-Plans-Actions-Results
The FoundationWhat’s the problem?How do you know?What are our goals?Where are we now?What are our limits?What are our resourcesWhere are we going?
Projection/Prediction
Plan CreationCreating SolutionsTesting Solutions
Going ForwardEvaluation and SelectionImplementation
Looking BackReview
98
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansThe Land Component of Comprehensive Plans
Tools of Comprehensive PlanningGoals
Avoid adversarial usesPromote complementary usesImprove the ‘look’ of a communityPromote efficient use of landMinimize public costsIncrease public revenuesPromote social equityProtect the public health, safety, and welfare
99
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
What is a Plan of Conservation and Development?
Is a tool for guiding the growth of a community. Its purpose is to establish a vision for the future of a community and then determine policies that will help attain that vision. Primarily, it is a statement of recommendations addressing the physical development of our town. Wording of from Section 8-23 that best reflect what a Plan of Conservation and Development is all about:
"Such plan shall show the commission's recommendations for the most desirable use of land within the municipality for residential, recreational, commercial, industrial and other purposes and for the most desirable density of population in the several parts of the municipality."
The Plan should be viewed as outlining the future physical layout of the community as well as the means of arriving at that future layout. The Plan is also intended to address the social and economic development of the community.
100
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Typical Plan organization:Introduction
An introduction to town, Plans of C & D, and the recommendations.
Overall Conditions and TrendsInformation on issues that affect town residents as they prepare for the future.
Natural Resource ConservationOverview, assessment, and program for natural resource conservation.
Open SpaceOverview, assessment and program for open space protection and preservation.
Housing and Residential AreasOverview, assessment and program for housing and residential development.
Economic DevelopmentOverview, assessment and program for business and economic development.
Community FacilitiesOverview, assessment and program for town facilities and programs.
TransportationOverview, assessment and program for transportation and circulation.
Future Land Use PlanA compilation of the recommendations into an overall Plan for Roxbury.
ImplementationAn overview of how the Plan is to be implemented during the planning period.
ConclusionA summary of the plan and the planning process.
26
101
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Natural Resources—Land Cover
Types of cover:WaterFarmForestGrassUrban/developedLocations
What does it tell us?UseChange over time
Source: Woodbury Plan of Conservation and Development102
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Natural Resources—Water Resources
LocationsType—streams, rivers, ponds, lakes, etc.Water Quality—surface, groundwaterAquifer protectionUse—Drinking, recreation, fire?
Source: Woodbury Plan of Conservation and Development
103
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Natural Resources—Water Resources
State Water Quality Classifications
Source: Woodbury Plan of Conservation and Development104
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Open SpaceLocationTypes of Open Space:
Managed Open SpacePreserved or Protected Open SpacePerceived Open Space
Source: Woodbury Plan of Conservation and Development
27
105
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Natural Resources—Open Space
Protected and “Temporary”or Perceived Open SpaceWhy do care about the location of both?
Plan for future open space acquisition to create larger areas and connections.
Source: Woodbury Plan of Conservation and Development106
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Natural Resources—Open Space
AnalysisWhere we are?Where we want to go?How we get there?
Source: Woodbury Plan of Conservation and Development
107
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Evaluation of Residential Development
Pattern of DevelopmentDeveloped LandUndeveloped Land
Residential Build-out Analysis
Intent and PurposeMathematical CalculationGIS AnalysisBenefitsIssues
Source: Woodbury Plan of Conservation and Development108
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Pattern of Residential Development
SubdivisionsExisting open spaceOpen Space acquired as a result of subdivisions
Source: Woodbury Plan of Conservation and Development
28
109
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Evaluation of Commercial Development
Pattern of DevelopmentDeveloped LandUndeveloped Land
Source: Woodbury Plan of Conservation and Development110
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Evaluation of Specific Interest or Concern
Pattern of DevelopmentDeveloped LandUndeveloped LandConcerns or issues?
Source: Woodbury Plan of Conservation and Development
111
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Community Facilities Planning
Location of existing facilitiesParks/RecreationGovernment AdministrationPublic SafetySewer/water facilities
Need for expansion?Potential for expansion?Available land?
Town ownedOther
Source: Woodbury Plan of Conservation and Development112
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Community Facilities – Case Study of Specific Facility and Area
Location of facilitiesNeed for expansionPotential for expansionAvailable landSite development
Source: Woodbury Plan of Conservation and Development
29
113
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Existing Zoning DesignationsTotal land by zone/districtResidential, commercial, industrialPotential needs?Opportunities?Available land?Developable land?
Source: Woodbury Plan of Conservation and Development114
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlans of Conservation and Development
Future Land Use Plan (FLUP)
A geographic display of desired policy outcomes?Land to be developed for residential, commercial, and industrial useLand to be protected and preserved—open spaceRecreationAreas for historic preservation
Source: Woodbury Plan of Conservation and Development
115
Fundamentals of Planning and PlansPlan of Conservation and Development
GOOD PLANNING SHOULD:
Establish a long-term vision that guides short-term decisions in a consistent way.Produce a vision based on open discussion and consensus.Result from open discussion and debate.Establish basic parameters for future decision making.Provide information on the logic and parameters of a recommendation.Be flexible in the face of changing circumstances.Be a continuous, iterative process where implementation leads to new goals.
NO PLANNING MAY:
Result in decisions that are inconsistent, inefficient, or conflict with other goals.Result in conflicts over the future direction of the community.Result in intuitive decision-making.Establish precedents that constrain solutions to future needs.Complicate future decisions due to the lack of understanding of previous efforts.Foreclose or constrain the consideration of future options.Result in a series of “one shot”efforts that are never implemented.