Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Neighbourhoods for Life
Neighbourhoods for Life
Lynne Mitchell OISD: WISE
Oxford Brookes University
Lynne Mitchell OISD: WISE
Oxford Brookes University
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Introduction
WISE (Wellbeing in SustainableEnvironments) research unit
– Investigating impacts of the built environment on people’s wellbeing and quality of life
– Evidence-based design guidance and CPD sessions
– Focus on older people, but extending to other ages and groups
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Content
Neighbourhoods for Life (Ns for L) conceptWhy have Ns for L?Basis for Ns for LDesign issuesDesign principlesKey recommendationsImplementationConclusions
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Ns for L concept
Developed from research on designing the outdoor environmentto improve quality of life (QoL) of older people with dementia (OPwD)
Ns for L are neighbourhoods that are inclusive – easy and enjoyable to use by all members of society, regardless of age or ability
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Ns for L concept
Neighbourhoods that people find easy to access, find their way around, use and enjoy as they grow older, helping them to continue living at home
Neighbourhoods that are designed to maximise the QoL of OPwD
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Why have Ns for L?
Dementia project showed essentialfor OPwD to be able to live in their own homes and to get outdoors
Extension of inclusive design concept to neighbourhood scale
Need for outdoor equivalent of Lifetime Homes to support independence in old age
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Why have Ns for L?
Can contribute to creating sustainable communities
– Social sustainability includes social cohesion, social inclusion and maximising people’s quality of life
Getting outdoors is also very important for stimulation, exerciseand health
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Why have Ns for L?
Some quotes about going out: – I feel great, I would live out– I rejoice– I feel in charge of myself– The world belongs to me just for
that bit of time– I get claustrophobic if I don’t go out– It’s very comforting
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Basis for Ns for L
3 year, EPSRC-funded research– In-depth interviews
• older people, with and without dementia – their views, use and experiences of local neighbourhoods
– Accompanied walks • wayfinding techniques and design
features that help or hinder them– Surveys
• design characteristics of participants’neighbourhoods that influence participants’ sense of QoL
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Basis for Ns for L
6 key design principles and 17 main recommendations
– For designers, developers and users of outdoor environments
– Some can only be applied to new development or redevelopment but many can be used to improve existing outdoor urban environments
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Design issues
Older people are not homogenous– Vast age range – Great variety of abilities, lifestyles,
health and mobility levels
But we are all likely to face certain physical and mental challenges as we grow older
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Design issues
Strength and stamina– People in their mid-70s have half
that of people in their 20sMobility
– Older people often develop a shuffling, unsteady gait and/or a stooped posture
– Vulnerable to falls– Difficulties walking up hills or for
over roughly 10 mins without a rest
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Design issues
Hearing loss– Longer reaction times
Visual impairment– 90% of blind and partially sighted
people are aged over 60– People aged 60+ need 3-5 times
more light than younger adults– Greater sensitivity to glare and
contrasts of dark and light can cause loss of balance and falls
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Design issues
Impaired depth perception– Sharp colour contrasts or patterns
on ground seen as steps or holes– Shiny surfaces look slippery– Busy patterns can cause dizziness
Colour agnosia– Difficulties seeing certain colours,
especially violets, blues and greens, and distinguishing colours of similar dark or light tones
– Reds and oranges easiest to see
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Design issues
General mental decline– Can take longer to process, react
to and recall information or to learn new information
– Can have problems remembering names of people, places and objects (semantic memory) or future tasks e.g. keeping appointments (prospective memory)
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Design issues
Dementia – Likelihood of developing dementia
increases with age– Irreversible and incurable – Alzheimer’s disease is the most
common form of dementia– Causes cognitive, behavioural and
personality changes– Tends to exacerbate normal
physical decline
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Design issues
Our participants with dementia– regularly went out alone– generally enjoyed going out– planned and visualised routes– used landmarks and other
distinctive visual wayfinding cues if familiar to older people and if regularly encountered
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Design issues
But they– became anxious, disoriented or
confused in complex/busy places or when startled by loud noises
– were less aware of potential dangers and of losing the way
– struggled to remember routes or purposes of trips
Importance of staying in familiar home and neighbourhood
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Design principles
Neighbourhoods for Life are– Familiar– Legible– Distinctive– Accessible– Comfortable– Safe
Many recommendations but 17 key ones
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
1. Small blocks laid out on an irregular grid (legibility)– Varying lengths (60m to 100m)– Staggered, forked and t-junctions
rather than crossroads
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
2. A hierarchy of familiar types of streets, including high streets and residential side streets (familiarity)
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
3. Gently winding streets (legibility)
4. Varied urban form and architecture (distinctiveness)
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
5. Mix of uses, including plenty of services, facilities and open space (accessibility)– Housing located no further than
500m from local primary services and facilities including:• food store• Post Office• GP surgery/health clinic• green space• public transport stops
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
– Housing located no further than 800m from local secondary services and facilities, including:
• a variety of open space: parks, allotments, recreation grounds, public squares
• library• dentist and optician• places of worship• community and leisure facilities
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
6. Buffer zones between road and footway on busy routes e.g. trees, grass verge (comfort & safety)
7. Buildings/facilities designed to reflect uses (familiarity & legibility)
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
8. Landmarks and visual cues (legibility & distinctiveness)– Variety of historic, civic and
distinctive buildings and structures – Variety of places of interest and
activity, e.g. nature reserves, tennis courts
– Variety of aesthetic and practical features in designs OPwD are familiar with and can understand
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
9. Special/distinctive features at junctions (legibility)
10. Obvious entrances to buildings (legibility & accessibility)
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
11. Footways separate from cycle tracks (safety)
– Wide, flat, smooth, non-slipsurfaces
– Plain, non-reflective in clear colour and textural contrast to traffic calming measures
– Clean and well maintained
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
12. Frequent pedestrians crossings (safety)
– Visual signals on both sides of crossing
– Audible cues at pitch and timing suitable for frail older people
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
13. Level changes only when unavoidable (accessibility)
– Gentle slopes rather than steps for slight level changes
– Choice of steps and ramp with max. gradient 1:20, for greater level changes
– Steps/ramps clearly marked and well lit with handrails and non-slip, non-glare surfaces
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
14. Clear signs throughout (legibility)
– Minimal signs giving simple, essential and unambiguous information at decision points
– Directional signs on single pointers
– Locational signs for primary services positioned perpendicular to the wall
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
– Large, realistic graphics in clear colour contrast to background
– Non-glare lighting and non-reflective coverings
15. Sturdy public seating with arm and back rests (comfort)
– Every 100-125m– In ‘warm’ materials, e.g. wood
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
16. Enclosed bus shelters, with seating and transparent walls or large clear windows (comfort & safety)
17. Ground level toilets (comfort & safety)
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Recommendations
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Implementation
When and where?– New towns, sustainable
communities, urban villages and extensions, housing developments
– Redevelopment, regeneration of urban areas, infill development, small-scale additions/new buildings
– Maintenance/refurbishment of urban areas, open spaces, streets or specific Ns for L upgrading
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Implementation
How?– Each recommendation of benefit,
some more crucial than others– Other solutions possible, scope for
creativity– Seamless design for life
• implement alongside lifetime homes, buildings, transport, healthcare etc.
– Also need to consider other requirements, e.g. environmental concerns, conservation of heritage
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Conclusions
Recommendations based on views of relatively small sample of users
– more research needed to confirm or add solutions to Ns for L concept
Conflicts with other users, other transport modes and other aspects of sustainability need to be considered in greater depth
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Conclusions
Ns for L could– improve older people’s QoL– allow OP to live at home for longer– improve sustainability of
neighbourhoods– improve inclusiveness
“Good design for older people is good design” - Mike Lake, Director General, Help the Aged, 21st June 2007
Oxford Institute for Sustainable Development
Conclusions
Number of publications on Ns for L including papers, leaflets & book available on WISE stand