7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
1/29
Origins of the
American Republic
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
2/29
Historical Sources of the Constitution British customs and traditions (Magna
Charta, English Bill of Rights) Colonial experiences (power of electedassembly)
State constitutions written after the
Declaration of Independence Experiences under Articles of
Confederation
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
3/29
Constitutional Convention 1787
Background: Declaration of Independence
Revolutionary War
Articles of Confederation and itsweaknesses
Shays Rebellion
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
4/29
Toward Unity and Order
Goal: to bring the thirteenstates together while allowingeach state to remainindependent
Proposed in 1775 and debated
almost longer than theyexisted--Adopted on March, 1,1781 Under the Articles, each
state issued its owncurrency
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
5/29
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
6/29
Weakness of Articles
No power to tax No chief executive
No national judiciary No power to regulate interstateor foreign commerce
No national currency Unanimous vote for any changes
No Power to Tax for Army orNav
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
7/29
What other factors contributed tothe economic crisis for farmers in
Massachusetts that led to ShaysRebellion?
A: Changes in the Landby William Cronin
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
8/29
The early republic produced rapid deforestation inthe region between the Atlantic Ocean and
Mississippi River.
1. 360 million acres of trees stretched between these
areas. 1 of the worlds greatest deforestations inhistory. Comparable to the current Amazondeforestation
2. there is no such thing as an environmentally neutralaction What do you think of this statement
3. Like all organisms humans radically change theirecosystem
4. Beavers radically effect their ecosystem by creatingdams that capture water and sediment gradually
transforming forests and streams into ponds andmeadows 18 feet dee and 4 000 feet lon .
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
9/29
5. Amerindians altered their ecosystem by cuttingdown trees for firewood and burning for theclearing of lands.
6. This had little effect because of their small
numbers and lack of permanent dwellings.7. White settlers cut down trees to clear farm land,
to produce naval stores and potash and toproduce energyfire. Deforestation had 3 important ecological consequences
1. The destruction of animal habitat lowered speciesdiversity.
2. The lack of tree canopies affected the climate, makingSummers hotter and Winters colder.
3. The lack of trees increased the volume of water thatflowed directly into streams, leaving the soil drier and
vulnerable to erosion.
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
10/29
The climate during the New Republic wasunpredictable and dangerous!
The century between 1750 and 1850 was the transition between theLittle Ice Age (1350-1850) and our modern climate.
Unpredictable weather made farming a high stakes gamble. In 1788 and 1789 poor harvests in NY, PA, and New England were
blamed on the Hessian Fly, but the real culprit was climate. Climatic instability from the end the Little Ice Age contributed to the
economic distress of the farmers and helped to precipitate ShaysRebellion.
Farmers in Western MA ran into debt because the growing season for13 years was so short as to result in a total loss for farmers (1774-1787).
There were several other domestic insurrections in addition to ShaysRebellion (1786/87): NH, VT, upstate NY, & VA
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
11/29
Whats the Point?
Shays rebellion was a symptom oflarger national problems not really acause for writing the constitution.
There is typically more to the story!
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
12/29
Annapolis Convention George Washington as the president of a company
dealing with an interstate trade commission led to aproposal to invite PA and DE to join negotiationsand create a commercial policy for the river system.
1786: Called to improve Articles of Confederation(AofC)
Ultimately this meeting included invitations to all ofthe 13 states to meet in Annapolis; only 12representatives from 5 states attended
End result was to call for a new meeting to makechanges to the AofC in Philadelphia
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
13/29
Delegates
well-read, well-bred, well-fed, and well-wed - James
McGregor Burns (historian)
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
14/29
55delegates attended the C.C. 4 delegateswithdrew in protestJohn Francis Mercer, LutherMartin, Robert Yates and John Lansing RIboycotted the convention and VT was not invited
34 lawyers, 26 were college graduates, 9 wereforeign-born 16 were slave owners, 33 were landgentry
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
15/29
Each state had 1 vote, 7 states made quorum, andeach delegate was limited to 2 speeches/issues
The delegates kept the changes a secret toinsulate it from outside pressures
The official journal of the ConstitutionalConvention was published in 1819 & JamesMadisons notes in 1840
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
16/29
Notable participants James Madison Father of Constitution
because of leadership and detailed notesof proceedings. George Washington presiding officer Benjamin Franklin elder statesman
Gouverneur Morris largely responsible forthe final wording
Alexander Hamilton most forcefuladvocate for strong central government
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
17/29
Quiz Question
What was Charles A. Beards view ofthe delegates present at theconstitutional convention?
How were they different from the leaders ofthe revolutionary era?
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
18/29
Charles Beards Economic Interpretation
of the United States (1913) Constitution written by propertied class therefore, it
naturally reflects those interests: (4 Groups)1. creditors2. holders of public securities3. manufacturers and4. traders and shippers
Beard claimed that 83% of the delegates stood to gain
financially from the adoption of the Constitution Rebuttals:
Most people owned property Even the poor (had hopes of someday owning property)
wanted to protect property Establishing a democratic government involved risks &
dangers need to build in safeguards and protections
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
19/29
The Constitutional Convention of
1787: Consensus
The commonphilosophy accepted
by most of thedelegates was that ofbalanced government
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
20/29
Areas of agreement among the founders
Scrap the Articles of Confederation
Establish a republican government Establish a constitutional government Establish a balanced govt where no single
interest dominated
Suffrage for property owners only Stronger central govt Protection of property rights (main purpose
of govt)
Keep the proceedings secret
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
21/29
Areas of disagreement (Compromises) Representation among the states
Large states favored the Virginia Plan (JamesMadison, Edmund Randolph): based uponpopulation VA, NY, PA, MA, wanted proportionaterepresentation
Small states favored the New Jersey Plan
(William Patterson): equal representation CN,NJ, DE, NC, SC, & GA Should DE 59,000 receive equal rep. with VAs
748,000 Debate over representation lasted about 1 month
June 19-July16
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
22/29
The Constitutional Convention of 1787:Conflict and Compromise
The Conflict
State-based approach versus anindividual-based approach
The Compromise
House of Representatives:Proportional; Senate: Equal numberof representatives from each state
The Conflict
The fact that Northerners hated slaveryworried Southerners who feared that
their greater representation in Congresswould be used to end slavery
The Compromise
The Constitution was to protectthe Atlantic Slave Trade for at
least twenty years
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
23/29
The Constitutional Convention of 1787:Conflict and Compromise
The ConflictIf representation is proportional
in the House ofRepresentatives, how should
slaves be counted?
The Compromise
Three-Fifths of the slaves in eachstate would be counted
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
24/29
The Great Compromise The Great Compromise July 5, 1787 had 3
provisions Equal representation for the States in the Senate but the
Senators would vote as individuals
Proportionate representation for the House ofRepresentatives and the house had the sole authority toinitiate appropriate bills
Slaves counted 3/5 of a person for representation in the
House of Representative the 3/5 clause and the GreatCompromise pass 5-4-1CN, NJ, DE, MD, NC, voted forthe Great Compromise
PA and VA voted against the Great Compromisebecause of the 3/5the clause they wanted 5/5ths
NY left, NH had not yet arrived, and RI never came
MA was divided
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
25/29
Ratification politics Federalists (Leaders: Hamilton, Madison,
Washington, Jay) Supporters: property owners, creditors,merchants
Main principles
Elites most fit to govern Feared excesses of democracy Favored strong central government
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
26/29
Federalists versus Anti-Federalists
The Federalist Papers
James Madison, AlexanderHamilton and John Jay
To rally support for theratification of the Constitution
Ratification, 1788: by stateratifying conventions of popularly-elected delegates
The Brutus Essays
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
27/29
Ratification politics (cont)
Anti-federalists (Leaders: Henry, Mason, Jerry) Supporters: small farmers, frontiersmen, debtors,
shopkeepers
Main principles
Feared concentration of power in hands of elites Believed that govt should be closer to the people
Feared strong central government favored stronger stategovernments
Feared the lack of Bill of Rights (their strongest argument)
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
28/29
Ratification politics (cont
Federalist advantages Were better represented in state legislatures
Controlled the press
Began ratification procedures quickly before
Anti-federalists could get organized Agreed to a Bill of Rights after ratification of
the constitution
7/31/2019 Origins of the American Republic
29/29
Election of the President
Life term v. annual election compromiseof a 4 year term Method of election
Some wanted election by Congress
Some wanted election by state Legislatures Some wanted direct election
Compromise Electoral College