Light Water Reactor Sustainability R&D Program
Overview of Expanded Materials
Degradation Analysis and Research
Roadmap for Cable and Cable Insulation
J.T. Busby Oak Ridge National Laboratory
D. Mantey
Electric Power Research Institute
MEETING BETWEEN THE U.S. NUCLEAR
REGULATORY COMMISSION STAFF AND
INDUSTRY
TO DISCUSS SUBSEQUENT LICENSE RENEWAL
Cable and Cable Insulation
April 30, 2014
2 © 2014 Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
Expectation for Subsequent License Renewal
• Provide “reasonable assurance” that cables will perform
through subsequent license renewal period of operation
• How do you provide reasonable assurance?
– Can EQ qualification extended out to 80 years?
– Can condition monitoring results of lab accelerated aging
be used to develop criteria for “qualified condition”?
• Reasonable assurance is evaluated based on
• Remaining environmental qualified life, or
• Remaining life based on “qualified condition”
3 © 2014 Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
Research Roadmap Areas of Focus
• Submergence
• Material Degradation and Harvesting Cable Data
• Assessment of Condition Monitoring Elements
• Improved Lifetime Prediction Models and Accelerated
Aging Studies
• Improved Condition Monitoring/NDE Tools
• Potential Lead Plant Activities
• Cable Rejuvenation
4 © 2014 Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
Research Needs for LTO
• Understand degradation issues
– Submergence of medium and low voltage cables
– Research identified issues based on original EQ qualification
• Is natural aging more severe than identified by cables aged in absence of oxygen (diffusion limited oxidation)
• Do cables at low dose rates and temperature degrade faster than at high temperature/high dose (inverse temperature effect)
• Is sequential application of dose and radiation less severe aging technique than if applied simultaneously
• How can you determine remaining useful life
• What condition monitoring or non-destructive evaluation tools are best for cable assessment
• Can cables life be extended through rejuvenation
Given the complexity of the reactor systems and
materials degradation, a prioritization tool for
research was developed
• “Knowing the unknowns” is a difficult problem that must be addressed.
• This is a particularly difficult issue for such a complex and varied material/environment system.
• An organized approach similar to the US NRC’s Proactive Materials Degradation Assessment (PMDA) (NUREG/CR-6923 was employed .
• Together with the U.S. NRC, the LWRS Program is working to expand the initial PMDA activity to encompass broader systems and longer lifetimes
– Core internals and primary piping
– Pressure Vessel
– Concrete
– Cabling Proactive Materials Degradation Assessment Matrix
5
NRC and DOE are investigating issues of reactor
aging beyond 60 years to identify possible
knowledge gaps
Final draft versions were submitted for final approval and publication in December 2013.
6
The cable expert panel included a diverse
background and considerable depth of
experience
• S. Ray (US NRC) • R. Bernstein (SNL) • S. Burnay (J. Knott
Associates) • C. Doutt (US NRC) • K. Gillen (retired) • R. Konnik (Marmon
Innovations) • K. Simmons (PNNL) • G. Toman (EPRI) • Greg Von White (SNL)
Cable and Cable Insulation
Group
7
The cable panel used established PIRT
processes to complete their assessment
• The expert panel assembled a list of common insulation manufacturers, materials, and environments.
• A detailed assessment of modes of degradation and key mechanistic understanding gaps was generated.
• Assessment of level of knowledge, susceptibility, confidence, for each of degradation modes/mechanisms made by each panel member for each of the classes of structures
• Spreadsheet reflecting assessments prepared and utilized to determine mean, median, and standard deviation for each potential degradation mode/component combination
• EMDA matrix figures constructed
8
Several potential knowledge gaps and
recommendations were identified by the expert
panel. (1 of 3)
1. A reassessment may be made to determine the number of circuits and types of cable that are in the high-radiation zones (i.e. 70 Mrad over 80 years (up to 1 Gy/hr) between 45 to 55 °C (113 to 131 °F)).
2. Measurements of the operating temperatures of cables in plant are needed, particularly for those cable groups that are subjected to EQ, to quantify the actual temperatures to which cables are exposed.
10
Several potential knowledge gaps and
recommendations were identified by the expert
panel. (2 of 3)
3. If, as expected, environmental information demonstrates that thermal aging is the dominant process for nearly all cables in US NPPs, then it is important that the activation energy for the specific cable materials used, under specific environment, be estimated with increased confidence level.
4. Inverse temperature effects need to be understood better if semi-crystalline materials, such as some XLPE/XLPO and EPR insulations, are determined from plant assessment (item 1 above) to be exposed to radiation in-plant dose rates that exceed 0.1 Gy/h (10 rad/h). At that level of radiation dose rate, significant degradation may be observed after 60 years for temperatures < 50C (122F).
11
Several potential knowledge gaps and
recommendations were identified by the expert
panel. (3 of 3)
5. Little is known regarding the consequences of long-term wetting of both low- and medium-voltage cables. Research in that area would enable safety significance assessments of long-term submerged cables.
6. For loss of coolant accident simulations, this research has identified oxygen concentration in the atmosphere during a loss-of-coolant accident to be important, needing a consideration of this aspect in engineering simulations.
12
Collaborative research is underway to address
these potential knowledge gaps
• Research has been underway to support these gaps for several years
– EPRI/industry projects
– DOE LWRS programs
– International efforts
• Collaborative efforts have been strong among all research partners
• Frequent meetings are held to coordinate and align ongoing research
13
14 © 2014 Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
Research Needs for LTO
• Understand degradation issues
– Submergence of medium and low voltage cables
– Research identified issues based on original EQ qualification
• Is natural aging more severe than identified by cables aged in absence of oxygen (diffusion limited oxidation)
• Do cables at low dose rates and temperature degrade faster than at high temperature/high dose (inverse temperature effect)
• Is sequential application of dose and radiation less severe aging technique than if applied simultaneously
• How can you determine remaining useful life
• What condition monitoring or non-destructive evaluation tools are best for cable assessment
• Can cables life be extended through rejuvenation
16 © 2014 Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
Submergence
• Condition assessment using 0.1 hertz Tan δ testing
• Submergence qualification research
• Low voltage wet susceptibility research
17 © 2014 Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
• Develop field guide for cable harvesting (web-based and
Android/Ipad formats)
• Cable Polymer Handbook
• Medium Voltage Cable Failure Mechanism Research
Degradation Assessment and Cable
Harvesting
18 © 2014 Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
• Evaluate effects of aging stressors
– Diffusion Limited Oxidation (DLO)
– Inverse Temperature Effects
– Synergistic effects of radiation and temperature
• Development of qualified condition data
Improved Lifetime Prediction Models
19 © 2014 Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
Improved NDE/Condition Monitoring Tools
20 © 2014 Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
Member Actions and Cable Rejuvenation
Summary
• While preliminary, the EMDA process identified several potential knowledge gaps for cable and cable insulation. – Cataloguing of materials and environments
– Characterize activation energies and inverse temperature effects
– Long-term wetting
– LOCA performance
• Joint research is underway in these key areas
• Upcoming presentations will provide more detail into these research projects
21
Andrew Mantey Senior Technical Leader-Plant Engineering
Bo Clark
Program Manager – Plant Engineering
Discussion with NRC Division of License Renewal April 30, 2014
Cable Aging Research &
Development
Electrical Cables – the EPRI ‘Journey’
Much research previously conducted
• EPRI began Electrical Cable research in mid-1980’s –Numerous areas of research
• Other non-EPRI entities began even earlier
The research continues……
• Support of member implementation of cable aging management programs
• Support of Subsequent License Renewal (SLR) needs
Significant data available, particularly on thermal and radiation aging effects
What you will hear from EPRI today…..
• EPRI Cable Program Goals and Objectives
• Our on-going research
• Submergence research
• Efforts to develop methodologies for ‘Determination of Remaining Useful Life’
Cable Program Goals and Objectives
• Support on-going member aging management program implementation and LTO strategic needs:
– via Cable Users Group
– Collection, evaluation of tan δ test data (on-going)
– Cable failure mechanism identification
– Submergence
• Address concerns for medium voltage cable
• Determine susceptibility of low voltage cable to wet degradation
• Provide methodology for members to provide “reasonable assurance” of cable reliability through subsequent license renewal
EPRI Research Areas of Focus
• Apply existing research
• Address submergence concerns
• Evaluate material degradation and harvesting cable
• Improved lifetime prediction models and accelerated aging studies
• Improved condition monitoring/NDE tools
• Potential lead plant/member activities
Apply Existing Cable Research
Research Area Subject EPRI Report
Cable Aging Management Aging management program guidance
1020804, 1021629, 3002000557
Cable Testing Test applicability matrix: Tan Delta test evaluation:
1022969 1025262
MV Cable Failure Mechanism Research
Evaluation of wet aging of various MV cable types
1018777,1021069, 1022965, 1024894, 300200554
Life cycle management End of life guide for MV cable and accessories
1025259
Cable LTO Research In-containment radiation and temperature data
3002000816
•Cable research has been on-going at EPRI since the mid-1980’s (first low and later medium voltage cables)
•We need to leverage that work and fill identified gaps
Submergence- Medium Voltage Cables
• Goal: Create a cable qualification for cable types not believed to be degraded in wetted environments (submerged or high moisture environments)
• Approach:
– Obtain service-aged brown and “modern” pink ethylene propylene rubber (EPR) cables in long term service, wetted environments
– Apply an accelerated aging protocol (elevated voltage and frequency)
– Through an ongoing qualification determine the useful life of the cable insulation type
Submergence (continued)
• Results to-date:
– Brown EPR 22 year wet service aged cable which has been in accelerated aging protocol for 1¾ years to-date
• No failures under test protocol
• No change in tan δ results
• Breakdown testing will be performed at end of 2 years aging to determine if acceleration has been achieved
• Continue aging remaining cable
• Repeat breakdown testing
• Results expected to be published in 2015-16
Submergence (continued)
• Future work: – Pink EPR cable obtained with ~22 years wetted service
– Will be placed into similar qualification protocol this year
– Results should be available by 2017
Submergence- Low Voltage Cable-Pilot
• Goal: Determine susceptibility of low voltage cables to degradation in wetted conditions (submerged or high relative humidity)
• Approach: – Evaluate commonly found cross-linked polyethylene (XLPE)
and ethylene propylene rubber (EPR) cable types – Follow EM-60 protocol used by cable manufacturer’s for
electrical stability in submerged condition: • 90°C water bath with high salinity(194°F) • Energized (250 Vdc, 277 Vac) • Individual conductors were used only (external jacket of multi-
conductor cable were removed) • Some thermal damage • Some reduced insulation wall (shaved)
Submergence- Low Voltage Cable-Pilot
• Approach:
– Commonly used in nuclear plants (Rockbestos, BrandRex, Okonite, Boston Insulated Wire)
Submergence- Low Voltage Cable-Pilot
• Results: – XLPE (Rockbestos, BrandRex) cables shown below had
no electrical failures or noticeable physical changes other than surface discoloration
Submergence- Low Voltage Cable-Pilot
• Results:
– EPR (Okonite and Boston Insulated Wire)
• Boston Insulated Wire had swelling and separation of chloro-sulfunated polyethylene (Hypalon) jackets from EPR occurred, but EPR insulation layer was in good condition (not swollen)
• Okonite cables had no bulging of jacket/insulation, but some electrical failures of EPR possibly due to errors in shaving to increase voltage stress
Submergence- Low Voltage Cables Follow-up
• No follow-up research is warranted at this time for the XLPE cables (Rockbestos and BrandRex) due to positive results in the pilot study
• Further study is planned for the EPR cables using same cable types, but with configuration typically seen in actual service, i.e. multi-conductor cables with outer protective jacket, no increased voltage stress (shaving) to see effects on cable insulation functionality
• It needs to be seen if the protection of the outer jacket (45 mil thickness) will reduce or preclude insulation damage
Material Degradation and Cable Harvesting
• Cable Harvesting Guide – Provide members (nuclear power plant operators)
methodology to maximize research use of service-aged cables they remove (will be available in late Summer 2014)
• Cable Material Handbook – Knowledge capture of polymer formulations,
degradation mechanisms for cables used in nuclear power plants
• Medium voltage cables will be first (available early 2015), low voltage power, instrument and control to follow
• Appendices to be forensic analysis of harvested, service-aged cable evaluations
Material Degradation and Cable Harvesting
• Medium voltage cable failure mechanism research
– Forensic research on service-aged, wetted cables (submerged and high relative humidity) to determine degradation mechanisms
– Six reports to-date
– Major findings:
• Black EPR/Butyl Rubber low resistance tunnels
• Compact design jacket/shield layer separation
• Insulation defects in dry section of pink EPR
Remove and send cable to forensics lab for analysis
Isolate the problem section(s)
Forensic Evaluation (continued)
Improved Lifetime Prediction Models
Goal: Develop “qualified condition” methodology and apply to cable types covering approximately 90% of those found in current fleet of US nuclear power plants
Approach: – Review existing research and see if existing data provides
useful information on thermal and thermal and radiation accelerated aging
– Evaluate data for which methods (tensile, elongation at break, indenter, gel, nuclear magnetic resonance, etc.) provide reasonable discrimination of cable aging near end of useful life
– Given one and two above, what point can be chosen as an acceptance criteria to ensure functionality post-LOCA without sacrificing too much useful life of the cable (qualified condition)
Improved Lifetime Prediction Models
• Gaps that are identified will be evaluated by obtaining service-aged cables
• Cables will be harvested from plants recently shutdown, decommissioning, or from operating plants
Qualified Condition
• Condition of cable is such that should a design basis accident occur the cable is still capable of allowing the end device it feeds to perform its intended function (50% elongation at break in this example)
Improved Lifetime Prediction Models
• Cables will be evaluated for remaining life using service time and quantitative cable condition as determined using the appropriate test method
Improved Lifetime Prediction Models
• EPRI is investigating actual plant temperatures and radiation levels that cables operate in to determine delta between actual and qualification based dose and temperature conditions (i.e. why do service aged cables that have been evaluated not show signs of DLO, inverse temperature and synergistic effects related degradation) – In-containment cable radiation and temperature data
collection (technical update 3002000816, issued in December, 2013)
– Follow-up research to obtain actual cable specific in-containment data is being planned
– If dose levels are low, thermal aging becomes major aging degradation factor
Improved Condition Monitoring/NDE Tools
• Collaboration with NDE group to identify existing NDE technologies that can be applied to cable
Active Thermography
IR camera
Heat source
Terahertz (THz)
(air)
Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR)
Only FTIR Test results to be presented
Dielectric Measurement
Potential Lead Plant/Member Activities
• Fully implement EPRI cable aging management programs (1020804, 1021629, 3002000557)
• Support gathering cable radiation and temperature data
• Establish a submerged cable strategy
• Shift from “qualitative” to “quantitative” evaluation of cables to manage cable aging in accordance with research results for “qualified condition” acceptance criteria and remaining useful life
Summation
• There is a wealth of cable research supporting nuclear power plants that already exist – Applying it in current cable aging management programs is on-
going – Aging management programs required for license renewal and due
to regulatory requirements are developing and need to continue to identify cables in need of aging management (scope)
• Cable aging questions and concerns identified in the EMDA and through operating experience are being evaluated and are being addressed by NRC/DOE/EPRI research roadmap
• Nuclear power plant operators will need to apply this research – A shift in philosophy from mostly qualitative to mostly quantitative
evaluation of cables to manage aging and ensure reliability of cables through plant operation is needed
Light Water Reactor Sustainability R&D Program
DOE R&D Project Status & Planning for
Cables
R. Bernstein, M. Celina, E. Redline, and G. Von White III Sandia National Laboratory
L. Fifield, A. Pardini, M. Prowant, P. Ramuhalli, and K. Simmons
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory
J.T. Busby Oak Ridge National Laboratory
MEETING BETWEEN THE U.S. NUCLEAR
REGULATORY COMMISSION STAFF AND INDUSTRY
TO DISCUSS SUBSEQUENT LICENSE RENEWAL
Cable and Cable Insulation
April 30, 2014
The DOE-NE Light Water Reactor Sustainability Program
is supporting subsequent license extension decisions
Vision
• Enable existing nuclear power plants to safely
provide clean and affordable electricity beyond
current license periods (beyond 60 years)
Program Goals
• Develop fundamental scientific basis to understand,
predict, and measure changes in materials as they age
in reactor environments
• Apply this knowledge to develop methods and
technologies that support safe and economical long-
term operation of existing plants
• Research new technologies that enhance plant
performance, economics, and safety
Scope
• Materials Aging and Degradation
• Advanced Instrumentation and Controls
• Risk-Informed Safety Margin Characterization
More information and recent reports are available on
www.inl.gov/lwrs 56
LWRS research in materials aging and
degradation areas provide results in several ways
• Measurements of degradation: High quality data will provide key information for mechanistic studies, but has value to regulators and industry on its own.
• Mechanisms of degradation: Basic research to understand the underlying mechanisms of selected degradation modes will lead to better prediction and mitigation.
• Modeling and simulation: Improved modeling and simulation efforts have great potential in reducing the experimental burden for life extension studies. These methods can help interpolate and extrapolate data trends for extended life.
• Monitoring: While understanding and predicting failures are extremely valuable tools for the management of reactor components, non-destructive monitoring must also be utilized.
• Mitigation strategies: While some forms of degradation have been well-researched, there are few options in mitigating their effects. New technologies may overcome limits of degradation in key components and systems.
57
Presentation outline and summary of LWRS
activities in cable and cable insulation aging
• Joint research activities and coordination
• Cable aging and performance studies: SNL
• Development of NDE for cable insulation: PNNL
• Rejuvenation of aged cable insulation: PNNL
• Coordination with stakeholders and partners
59
Building consensus in predictive cable aging with
stakeholders has been a key goal
• A coordination meeting was held between partners (EPRI/NRC/PNNL/SNL) at EPRI in October 2013
• A community teleconference, “Joint LWRS-EPRI LTO Cable R&D Meeting Reconnect” on December 13, 2013
• Joint development of cable aging roadmap • EPRI Cable User Group Meeting in Phoenix (Jan 20 – 24,
2014). – A consensus of the meeting attendees was reached
between EPRI/NRC/PNNL/SNL on the goals of R&D cable aging activities covering predictive models, wear-out aging (field-returned specimens), and CM strategies.
– SNL to host the next group meeting July 9-10, 2014
• Quarterly meetings and coordination calls will continue.
60
• The ultimate goal: Understand current cable insulation material state and
expected performance under extended service conditions to enable decisions for cable requalification or replacement recommendations
• Deliver science-based engineering solutions
• Provide best guidance for aged material state, remaining life and expected performance
• Combine generic engineering tests with best practices from polymer degradation science
• Develop improved (and validated) lifetime predictions models which incorporate known material behaviors
Cable performance research has been established to support closing knowledge gaps
2D Graph 1
Temp-1 [10-3 K-1]
2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 3.0 3.2 3.4 3.6
Tim
e t
o 1
00
% e
lon
ga
tio
n [
yr]
0.1
1
10
100
140°C 110°C 80°C 50°C 25°C
New cable + accelerated
thermal aging predicts 100 year
lifetime
Plant-harvested cable + wear-out aging predicts 30
year lifetime!
Spatially-Resolved Degradation Models
Lifetime Predictions Material Aging Correlations
Surface vs bulk degradation Loss in tensile properties is used as a failure criterion
63
• Thermal aging only (FY14-15) – Consolidate existing thermal aging data and extent with gap filling data sets where possible
– These aging behaviors are to be compared with wear-out behavior (field returned samples)
– IMPACT: Final report with best estimates for projected residual lifetimes and uncertainties FY15
• Thermal-rad aging of EPR and non-inverse T effect materials (FY15-16) – Review existing data (dose, temperature) for predicted lifetimes
– These aging behaviors are to be compared with wear-out behavior (field returned samples)
– IMPACT : Final report with best estimates for projected lifetimes and uncertainties FY17
• Thermal-rad aging of XLPO and some EPR inverse T effect materials (FY15-18) – Review existing data and extent with new accelerated aging experiments
– These aging behaviors are to be compared with wear-out behavior (field returned samples)
– IMPACT : Final report with best estimates for projected lifetimes and uncertainties FY18
Aging experiments, predictive models and
correlations with field returned cable materials will
enable best residual lifetime projections
64
Priorities in FY14 cover several key areas
• Extensive effort by LWRS (with community input: EPRI, NRC, PNNL) to support cable requalification – Understand current cable insulation material state and expected performance
sufficiently well to enable joint decisions with EPRI and NRC for cable requalification or replacement recommendations
• HFIR Cable Samples Analysis Report – Experiments completed. Documentation of studies underway from evaluation
of HFIR field return samples
• Argentinian Silicon Cable Radiation Aging Evaluation Report – Experiments completed. Collaboration with CNEA completed. Drafting final
report
• Analysis of Recent and Historical Data • LICA Experimental Apparatus Radiation Exposure Upgrades • On-going Effort for Acquisition of Field Returned Samples
– Preference is for most common materials in service: • Brandrex XLPO with Hypalon Jacket • Anaconda Durasheath EPR, it may likely also have a Hypalon jacket
65
Accelerated aging has continued on service cable
materials to assess remaining useful life
Anaconda Densheath EPR cables returned from service at HFIR at ORNL (~45 yrs of age, Tavg ~27 °C, RH ~70%). These cables were subjected to further thermal aging to assess remaining tensile properties.
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Te
nsile
Elo
ng
atio
n,
%
102
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
103
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
104
t, hrs
T, ºC 40 64 80 109 124 138
Measure Tensile Data at Varying Times and Temperatures Superpose Tensile Data and Determine Activation Energy
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Ten
sile
Elo
nga
tion
, %
10-1
100
101
102
103
104
105
t, hrs, Reference 99 °C
T, ºC aT
40 0.01 64 0.07 80 0.25 109 1.96 124 5.04 138 11.43
Ea ~ 79 kJ/mol
66
• Primary data show decrease in tensile elongation at 138 to 109°C.
• No change observed at 80 to 40°C within 1.2 yrs
• Superposition of the limited 138 to 109°C data yields an Ea = 79 kJ/mol
Accelerated aging has continued on service cable
materials to assess remaining useful life (cont.)
67
While there is some uncertainty in linear behavior at long lifetimes, data suggests that additional remaining lifetime is at least a few decades. Anaconda Densheath EPR cables returned from service at HFIR at ORNL (~45 yrs of age, Tavg ~27 °C, RH ~70%). These cables were subjected to further thermal aging to assess remaining tensile properties.
Projections for linear Arrhenius behavior
The CNEA cables have provided valuable insights
on performance under irradiation
Measure Tensile Data at Varying Doses
A single rad-thermal exposure shows tensile elongation decreasing with dose at 100°C.
Data shown is for silicone rubber cables provided by CNEA in Argentina. Cables were irradiated at ~39 Gy/hr at 100 C. This work directly supports the US-Argentina BEWG.
68
Measure other properties as a Function of Dose
The CNEA cables have provided valuable insights
on performance under irradiation (cont.)
Understanding property correlations, like gel content and solvent uptake factors, can be leveraged for future condition monitoring of cables employed in service!
Data shown is for silicone rubber cables provided by CNEA in Argentina. Cables were irradiated at ~39 Gy/hr at 100 C. This work directly supports the US-Argentina BEWG.
69
Gel content [%]
96.0 96.5 97.0 97.5 98.0 98.5
Te
ns
ile
Elo
ng
ati
on
[%
]
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
Solvent uptake factor
1.7 1.8 1.9 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3
Te
ns
ile
Elo
ng
ati
on
[%
]
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
Temp (°C)Brandrex
XLPO
Rockbestos
XLPO, black,
green and red
Anaconda
Durasheeth
EPR
50 O O O
64 O
65 O O
80 O O O
95 O O
99 E E
100 O OE, TS, D, M,
O
109 E, O E, TS, O E, O
110E, TS, D, M,
S, G
124 OE, O, NMRgreen,
TSE, O
125 EE, TS, D, M,
S, G, O
138 OE, O, D, Sgreen,
Ggreen
140 E, TS, D, M
150 O E, TS, O O
151E, D, S, G (all
green)
160 E
An examination of past and present rad-thermal
data is ongoing
• This examination of historical data helps to finalize thermal-oxidative aging work
70
The historical analysis is providing a more
complete set of data under different conditions
71
• This work is providing a consolidation and evaluation previous work for trends and future property cross-correlations.
• The primary focus is on XLPO, plus perhaps one EPR material and supplement with oxidation rates. Others will be considered if priorities evolve.
• This work provides several deliverables over FY14. – Oxidation rate measurements compete with tensile and wear out experiments. XLPO and EPR are
common insulation materials with XLPO and some EPR materials exhibiting IT behavior
– Thorough characterization of the materials, including testing for known potential anomalies NEPO 9 - Brandrex XLPO
Dose [kGy]
10-1 100 101 102 103 104
Te
ns
ile
Elo
ng
ati
on
[%
]
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
280 Gy/hr, 27°C
176 Gy/hr, 25°C
36 Gy/hr, 25°C
210 Gy/hr, 22°C (1994)
16.8 Gy/hr, 22°C (1991)
Data for rad-thermal of Brandrex XLPO
Dose rate [Gy/h]
101 102 103 104
DE
D (
e=
10
0%
) [G
y]
8e+4
9e+4
2e+5
3e+5
4e+5
5e+5
6e+5
1.0e+5
22°C 1993
41°C 1993
New 27°C 2013
The gamma-irradiation facility at SNL is being
upgraded to support LTO evaluations
• Upgrade facility to conduct thermal-radiation experiments - provides unique critical ability to simultaneously expose materials to thermal and irradiation environments – Included updated electronics for
irradiation experiments to enhance safety
– Experiments will be more representative of field-aged conditions, resulting in improved models for predictive aging
• Estimated completion: Spring 2014
72
RAD
Future work will provide a model capability to
predict localization of oxidative damage in a
cable assembly
Surface oxidative degradation is likely under EQ testing IEEE323-1974
• Cable degradation behavior depends on local rates which can differ between surface and bulk depending on aging conditions and oxidation properties/processes
• DLO is the phenomenon which introduces variations in behavior under thermal and rad-thermal conditions
• This also affects measurements of ox-rates and CM approaches
Accelerated rad-thermal conditions, which can apply to NIST/NRC LOCA requalification
Homogeneous aging expected under plant conditions
73
DOE’s NDE is built upon a roadmap workshop*
that identified three important R&D targets
• Identify key indicators of aging – Correlate aging with macroscopic material properties
• Advance state-of-the-art NDE methods and develop new/transformational NDE methods – Enable in-situ cable condition measurements
– Collect data from laboratory-aged and fielded cables (Need naturally aged cables to be available!)
• Develop models for predicting remaining useful life based on cable condition measurements – Use cable condition index data from new and aged cables above,
existing databases, and other available/relevant sources
75
*LWRS NDE R&D Roadmap for Determining RUL of Aging Cables in NPPs, Simmons, Hashemian, Ramuhalli, Konnick, Brenchley, Ray, Coble, PNNL-21731, 2012
NDE of cable performance will be based on key
indicators of cable aging
• Chemical Properties – Functional group content (e.g., oxidation, cross-
linking) – Additive/filler content (e.g., loss of antioxidant) – Molecular weight (e.g., chain scission) – Degree of crystallinity
• Physical Properties – Melting point, glass transition temperature – Density – Gas permeation, liquid uptake – Coloration – Refractive index
76
Key indicators of cable aging (continued)
• Mechanical Properties – Stiffness (e.g., cross-linking)
– Strength (e.g., chain scission)
– Percent elongation
– Hardness
– Acoustic velocity
• Electrical Properties as Indicators – Conductivity/resistance (mobility, carrier density)
– Dielectric strength
– Permittivity
77
Example: Key chemical
properties
• Thermal (and irradiative) stressors generate radicals that lead to polymer chain scission, cross-linking and associated formation of new C-O and C=C chemical bonds
• Carbonyl (C=O) index is a measure of extent of oxidation
• Phase transitions indicated chemical bonding and content changes
78
TGA
FTIR
DSC
Temperature (°C) Temperature (°C)
Example: Key electrical properties
79
• Thermal and irradiative stresses lead to chain scission, cross-linking, and formation of new C-O and C=C chemical bonds
• Chemical changes result in changes in charge mobility, polarizability and local variations in electric field strength
• Dielectric permittivity and loss tangent measure the polarizability and relaxation phenomena which are impacted by the changes above
Frequency (GHz)
Rel
ativ
e P
erm
itti
vity
Maximum permittivity (from multiple measurements on two identically aged specimens) plotted
Thermal aging time
Aging time (hours)
Rel
ativ
e P
erm
itti
vity
(at
7
.5 G
Hz)
Thermally aged EPR Cable
A test-bed for cable NDE has been established
• Laboratory-scale test-bed for measurements of electrical properties of degraded cable insulators
– Measurements without disconnecting cable
– Other samples aged and available for developing and evaluating other NDT techniques
80
Laboratory scale measurements and tests are
now being performed
• Laboratory-scale test-bed for in-situ electrical measurements on degraded cables
– Data to approximately 1200 hrs
• Laboratory-scale NDE measurements on degraded cable insulation
81 High Applied Load (Drill Press) Low Applied Load (Oscilloscope)
Green is source current Blue is load current
Current Measurements
Baseline
Elastic properties are being examined in
different geometries
• Acoustic velocity (bulk and surface waves)
• Acoustic impedance • Correlation to indenter testing, density
and EAB
82 82
Permittivity is being examined in different
geometries
83
• Previous measurements of complex permittivity showed variability due to specimen geometry and thickness
• Quantification of variability and impact of conducting backplane (cable conductor) needed for in-situ measurements – Okonite EPR sheet material – 10 flat, square samples (known geometry) – Sample dimensions: 21.5mm(L) x 21.5mm (W) x 1.6mm(H) – No aging, baseline measurements
Electrical properties have been the focus of
recent efforts
84
Single sample
Single sample backed with metal
Single sample stacked to >12mm thickness
Tests are also being conducted in geometries
relevant to service conditions
85
Individual Samples Samples Stacked >12mm High
6-9GHz previously investigated bandwidth for cable aging
Variations in individual sample measurements could be due to pressure variations and compression of the foam used to press the samples against the probe, or physical surface variations from sample to sample.
NDE development will remain a priority for LWRS
• Complete aging and NDE studies on first set of cables
– In-situ monitoring and measurements
– NDE measurements on aged specimens
• Complete analysis of sensitivity of key indicators to aging effects
– Work with polymer aging SME to use results to define next set of aging experiments
86
Cable rejuvenation may provide an additional
bridging strategy for cable service
88
• DOE is performing additional studies on mitigation strategies that may provide an alternative to replacement for non-safety non-EQ related cables.
• The work is being performed in several key stages 1. Proof of Concept Treatment of
Highly Accessible Cable Material
2. Diffusion-based Treatment of Cable Specimens
3. Field Deployable Treatment of Intact Cable
Chemical strategies for cable rejuvenation
89
• Combined approaches could be applied.
• Initial work has focused on using plasticizers to recover performance.
Plasticizers Cross-linking Polymerize-able monomer
An Ethylene-Propylene Rubber (EPR)
cable was used for initial tests
90
• Okoguard Aerial Jumper “Medium Voltage” Cable 15kV 90°C Rating
• Several hundred dog bone specimens were cut from cable (~5.5mm thick)
Cable rejuvenation through chemical soak
91
• Aged specimens
• Room temperature
• Atmospheric Pressure
• Soaked for up to 50 days for kinetics
• Weight change over time determined
• Selected mass uptake values targeted for testing (5%, 10%)
• Results showed improved modulus, but not improved strength or ductility
Future processes will apply a combined approach
92
• Initial work with added plasticizers and single-site reactive silane showed improved Tg and modulus, but no improvement in strength or Elongation at Break
• Future work will aim at covalently healing cleaved chains in polymer backbone to restore strength and EAB performance
• Repair of thermally-damaged scissioned bond through the use of energetically favorable chemical reactions will the a high priority
Evolution of Rejuvenation Scheme
Discussions on joint cable research have been
positive and frequent
• All key stakeholders (DOE, EPRI, NRC, others) have been very active and open in sharing needs, resources, and opportunities for sharing
• Quarterly coordination calls involving all parties are routinely being held with next call being held in June 2014.
• Frequent face-to-face meetings are also being held. – Last meeting was attached to EPRI Cable User’s meeting
– Next proposed meeting is in July at SNL.
• Joint road map development has been a positive and productive activity
94
LWRS will be supporting decisions by providing
information in coming years:
• Cable Aging and Performance – Complete report detailing highest priority needs and concerns for future testing of cable
insulation, September 2010 – COMPLETED – Initiate testing on key degradation issues for cabling and cable insulation, November 2010 –
COMPLETED – Acquire relevant plant cable insulation for additional testing, June 2012 – COMPLETED – Initiate predictive modeling capability for cable degradation, November 2014 – Begin benchmarking of cable degradation model, March 2016 – Deliver predictive model for cable degradation, August 2019
• Cable NDE Development – Complete assessment of cable insulation precursors to correlate with performance and NDE
signals, September 2015 – Demonstrate prototype system for NDE of cable insulation in laboratory setting, September
2016 – Demonstrate field testing of prototype system for NDE of cable insulation, March 2017
• Repair Technique Development – Initiate evaluation of possible mitigation techniques for cable insulation degradation, March
2011 – COMPLETED – Complete assessment of cable mitigation strategies, September 2015
95
Summary
• Several potential knowledge gaps for cable insulation in the subsequent operating period have been identified. – Assessment of service materials and characterization
of environments – Activation energy determinations – Inverse temperature effects – Long-term wetting – Oxygen effects in LOCA conditions
• Joint research is underway in these key areas • Coordination and cooperation is an important
factor in closing these potential knowledge gaps
96