Overview of the Compulsory Student Services Fees (CSSF) framework
Roger Smyth
Group Manager, Tertiary Education
Compulsory Student Services Fees
What are Compulsory Student Services Fees (CSSF)?
Compulsory fees charged by tertiary education providers as a condition of enrolment ....
.... to deliver services that are not directly connected to the provision of education ...
.... but nevertheless enhance the student experience
The legal framework in 2010
In 2010, the Education Act 1989 allowed the Government to limit compulsory tuition fees, but not student services fees.
The Problem
Problems arising in 2010
The scale of the increase in CSSF
Providers could circumvent the regulation of tuition fees by collecting additional money through CSSF levies
There was no clear definition of CSSF
Lack of transparency
Potential risks to student services posed by the introduction of voluntary student membership
Categories of CSSF in 2010
Universities ITPs Institutions that charged a fee in 2010 8 14 Learner support services Careers information 7 6 Library services 1 2 Study support 3 3 Disability support 3 5 Māori and Pasifika 3 4 Adult students 1 3 Advocacy services 2 2 Student orientation 3 3 Pastoral care Health, counselling and chaplaincy services 7 11 Accommodation services 4 3 Financial support and hardship funds 5 7 Crèches/Early Childhood Education services 1 0 Sports and recreation 5 2 Other Building maintenance and capital development 6 0 Internet access 5 3 International student support services 2 2 Transport subsidies 1 1 Administration 1 2 Enrolment fee 1 0
Government’s Objectives
In regulating the CSSF framework, Government wanted to:
Enable greater involvement of students in the setting of the fees
Require more transparency in the setting and administration of the fees
Set clearer limits on what services should be funded through these fees
Ensure that appropriate limits were set on the amount that providers may charge
Options considered by Government
Status quo
Setting explicit controls through legislation
Giving the Minister the power to set directions on how providers may charge fees for services
The Ministerial Direction on CSSF – Decision-Making
If a provider decides to charge a CSSF levy, it has to comply with decision-making, accounting and reporting requirements:
Decision-Making Requirements
Providers have to make arrangements for decisions to be made jointly, or in consultation with the students, or their representatives, on the following matters:
The amount that students will be charged for student services The types of services to be delivered The procurement of these services The method for authorising expenditure on these services.
The Ministerial Direction on CSSF – Accounting and ReportingAccounting
Providers charging a CSSF levy must either hold CSSF income in a separate account or ensure that CSSF income and expenditure is accounted for separately in the accounting system.
Reporting on CSSF Universities, Polytechnics and Wānanga must provide information on CSSF in their annual reports. The following information must be included: A description of the services funded out of the CSSF A statement of the fee income and expenditure for each
student service The compulsory student services fee levy charged per
Equivalent Full Time Student A note to their reporting stating how they are complying
with the accounting requirements of the direction.
Categories of Student Services
Providers may charge compulsory student services fees to support the delivery of the following categories of services:
Advocacy and Legal Advice
Career Information, Advice and Guidance
Counselling Services
Employment Information
Financial Support and Advice
Health Services
Media
Childcare Services
Clubs and Societies
Sports, Recreation and Cultural Activities.
Progress to Date and Next Steps
Yearly increases down to 2% on average in 2013
Compliance with reporting requirements improving, but variable
Compliance with decision-making requirements variable
2014 .... The same trend – low rises, improving compliance
Next Steps
The Ministry of Education is carrying out a review of the CSSF framework
Your feedback is essential