8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
1/80
DEPARTMENT OF SALES TAX
MANUALOF
PROCEDURE
REFUND & REFUND AUDIT
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
2/80
REFUND & REFUND AUDIT MANUAL
INDEX
Sr. No. Subject Page No.
From - To1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
Objectives of the branch.
Organisational Structure.
Relevant provisions of Act and Rules.
Relevant Internal and Trade Circulars.
Competent Authorities and Targets.
The process in brief.
Procedure of Branch.
Refund Audit Procedure.
Duties & Responsibilities.
Inspection procedure & frequency.
Responsibility & date for updating the manual.
Record filing system.
Reporting Formats of the Branch.
Various control Registers.
Annexures.
3
4 to 5
6 to 15
16 to 32
33
34
35 to 41
42 to 62
63 to 70
71
71
71
72 to 74
75 to 76
77 to 84
10109
2
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
3/80
2. OBJECTIVES OF THE BRANCH:-
Processing refund claims within the prescribed time limits.
To ensure that, the refund claim made in the return is valid
and accurate by audit.
3
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
4/80
3. ORGANISATIONAL STRUCTURE:-
A) MUMBAI :-
Design.J.C. D.C. A.C. STO STI Clerk
Other
Total
Sanctionedstrength
1 8 26 21 70 70 67 263
B) MOFFUSIL :-Sanctioned strength as per re-organisation:-
Designation D.C. A.C. STO STI Clerk Total
Thane Division
Thane 2 2 4 7 11 26
Kalyan 1 3 3 7
Thane Rural Division
Thane Rural 1 3 7 16 17 44
Nalasopara 1 2 3 6
Raigad Division
Raigad 2 2 1 8 8 21
Pune Division
Pune 4 6 14 36 32 92
Solapur 2 1 3 9 10 25Osmanabad 1 1 1 3
Barshi 1 1 1 3
KolhapurDivision
Kolhapur 2 2 5 12 12 33
Satara 1 1 2 2 6
Sangli 1 1 2 2 6
Ratnagiri 1 2 3 6
Oras 1 1 2 4
NasikDivision
Nasik 2 2 3 8 10 25
Malegaon 1 1 2 4
Ahemadnagar 1 3 2 6
Dhule Division
Dhule 2 2 3 10 8 25
Jalgaon 1 2 2 5
Nandurbar 1 2 3
4
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
5/80
Designation D.C. A.C. STO STI Clerk Total
NagpurDivision
Nagpur 2 2 5 12 12 33
Chandrapur 1 1 1 3
Gondia 1 1 2
Gadchiroli 1 1
Vardha 1 1 2 4
Bhandara 1 2 3
AmravatiDivision
Amravati 2 2 3 9 7 23
Yeotmal 1 1 2 4
Khamgaon 1 1 2 4Akola 1 2 5 8
Vashim 1 1 2
AurangabadDivision
Aurangabad 2 2 3 12 8 27
Beed 1 1 2 4
Jalna 1 1 2 4
Nanded 2 2 3 10 12 29
Parbhani 1 1 2 4
Latur 1 2 3 6Hingoli 1 2 3
5
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
6/80
RELEVANT PROVISIONS OF ACT AND RULE:-
3.1 RELEVANT PROVISIONS OF ACT:-
3.1.1 Section-22. Audit
(1) With a view of promoting compliance with the provisions of this Act, the
Commissioner may arrange for audit of the business of any registered dealer.
For the purpose of this section, the selection of dealers for audit shall be made
from amongst the dealers,
(a) who have not filed returns by the prescribed dates; or
(b) who have claimed refund of tax; or
(c) where the Commissioner is not, prima-facie, satisfied with the
correctness of any return filed by a dealer or is not satisfied with any claim
made, deduction claimed or turnover disclosed in any return filed by the
dealer; or
(d) who are selected by the Commissioner on the basis of the application
of any criteria or on a random selection basis; or
(e) where the Commissioner has reason to believe that detailed scrutiny of
the case is necessary.
(2)..
(3) On the appointed day or, as the case may be, at anytime within the aforesaid
period, any officer to whom the powers and duties under this section have been
delegated, by the Commissioner, in writing, may conduct audit of the business.
(The above sub-section (3) is deleted by the Maharashtra Act No. XXV of 2007
Dt. 06.08.2007).
(4) ..
(5) (a) During the course of the audit, the officer may require the dealer,
(i) to afford him the necessary facility to inspect such books of accounts or
6
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
7/80
other documents as he may require and which may be available at such place,
(ii) to afford him the necessary facility to check or verify the cash or stock
which may be found therein. And
(iii)to furnish such information as he may require as to any matter which may
be useful for or relevant to any proceedings under this Act.
(b) The officer conducting the audit shall on no account remove or cause to he
removed any books of accounts, other documents or any cash or stock.
(6) ...
(7)..
(8) ...
3.1.2 Section-50. Refund of excess payment
(1) Subject to the other provisions of this Act and the rules made there under,
the Commissioner shall, by order refund to a person amount of tax, penalty,
interest, deposit and fee except when the fee is paid by way of court fee
stamp , if any, paid by such person in excess of the amount due from him. Therefund may be either by deduction of such excess from the amount of tax,
penalty, amount forfeited and interest due, if any, in respect of any other
period or in any other case, by cash payment:
(In the above para for the words the commissioner shall refund the words
the Commissioner shall, by order refund are substituted by the
Maharashtra Act No. XXXII of 2006 Dt. 05.08.2006)
Provided that, the Commissioner shall first apply such excess towards the
recovery of any amount due in respect of which a notice under subsection (4)
of section 32 has been issued, or, as the case may be. any amount which is due
as per any return or revised return but not paid and shall then refund the
balance, if any.
(2) Where any refund is due to any dealer according to the return or revised
return furnished by him for any period, then subject to the other provisions of
7
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
8/80
this Act including the provisions regarding provisional refunds such refund
may provisionally be adjusted by him against the tax due and payable as per
the returns or revised return furnished under section 20 for any subsequent
period: the word, subsequent shall be deleted with effect from 20th June
2006.
Provided that, the amount of tax or penalty, interest or sum forfeited or all of
them due from, and payable by, the dealer on the date of such adjustment
shall first be deducted from such refund before making the adjustment.
(For the above subsection (2) the following subsection (2) is substituted by the
Maharashtra Act No. XXXII of 2006 Dt. 05.08.2006)
(2) If a registered dealer has filed any returns, fresh returns or revised
returns in respect of any period contained in any year and any amount is
refundable to the said dealer according to the return, fresh return or revised
return, then subject to rules, the dealer may adjust such refund against the
amount due as per any return, fresh return or revised return for any
subsequent period contained in the said year, filed under this Act or the
Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 or the Maharashtra Tax on the Entry of Goods into
Local Areas Act, 2002.
3.1.3 Section-51. Grant of Refunds
(1) Where a registered dealer has in any return, fresh return or revised return
shown any amount to be refundable and has not undertaken to adjust such
amount against the amount due as per any subsequent return in accordance
with section 50, the Commissioner shall, on an application made by the dealer
and subject to rules, and the other provisions of this Act, grant refund of such
amount to the said dealer.
(2) (a) The registered dealer, may after the end of the year to which the
return, fresh return or revised return relates, make an application in the
prescribed form after filing the said return for grant of refund of the amount
8
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
9/80
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
10/80
then he may apply in the prescribed form to the Commissioner after filing the
return for grant of refund relating to the period covered by a return, fresh
return or revised return; or
(b) The Commissioner, within one month of the receipt of the said
application,
(i)may require the dealer to furnish such bank guarantees for such amounts
from such banks, for such periods and to such authorities as may be
prescribed; and
(ii) may call for such additional information as he may think necessary.
(4) The Commissioner shall grant the refund under this section within three
months of the receipt of application or receipt of additional information
whichever is later. If the additional information is not furnished, then the
refund shall be granted within six months of the receipt of the application.
(5) Notwithstanding anything contained in paragraph (a), the dealer may at
his option furnish a bank guarantee for such amount, from such bank, for
such periods and to such authorities as may be prescribed and on the dealer
furnishing such bank guarantee, the Commissioner shall grant the refund due
under sub-section (2) or (3) within one month of the furnishing of the bank
guarantee irrespective of whether the additional information has been
furnished.
(6) (a) If before the grant of refund under this section, a notice for assessment
covering the period to which the return relates is issued or if any proceedings
under sub-section (3) or sub-section (4) of section 64 are initiated in respect of
the period to which the return relates, then,
(i) if the dealer has not furnished a bank guarantee then no refund under this
section shall be granted ; and
(ii) if the dealer has furnished a bank guarantee then an amount equal to the
guaranteed amount shall be refunded.
1
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
11/80
(b) If it is found as a result of any order passed under this Act that the refund
granted under this section is in excess of the refund, if any, determined as per
the said order, then the excess amount shall be recovered as if it is an amount
of tax due from the dealer and the dealer shall be liable to pay simple interest
at the prescribed rate per month or part thereof from the date of the grant of
refund.
(7) No refund under this section shall be granted unless an application as
provided is made and no application under this section shall be entertained
unless it is made within three years from the end of the year containing the
period to which the return relates.
3.1.4 Section- 52. Interest on amount of refund
Where refund of any tax becomes due to a registered dealer, he shall, subject
to rules, if any, be entitled to receive, in addition to the refund, simple interest
at the prescribed rate on the amount of refund for the period commencing on
the date next following the last date of the period to which the refund relates
and ending on the date of the order sanctioning the refund or for a period of
twenty four months, whichever is less. The interest shall be calculated on the
amount of refund due to the registered dealer in respect of the said period
after deducting therefrom the amount of penalty, sum forfeited and interest, if
any, charged in respect of the said period and also the amount of refund, if
any, adjusted towards any recovery under this Act or any earlier law or as the
case may be, under the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956. If, as a result of any orderpassed under this Act, the amount of such refund is enhanced or reduced, as
the case may be, such interest shall be enhanced or reduced accordingly. If the
interest is reduced, then the amount granted in excess shall be recovered as if
it is an amount payable under this Act.
Provided that, interest under this section shall not be granted towards any
refund granted under section 51.
Explanation. For the purposes of this section, where the refund of tax,
1
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
12/80
whether in full or in part, includes any amount of refund on any payment of
tax made after the date prescribed for making the last payment in respect of
the said period, then the interest, in so far as it relates to the refund arising
from such payment, shall be calculated from the date of such payment to the
date of such order.
3.1.5 Section-53. Interest on delayed refund -
(1) Where an amount required to be refunded by the Commissioner to any
person, by virtue of the provisions contained in section 51 or by virtue of an
order passed under any other provision of this Act, is not so refunded to him
within ninety days of the end of the respective period provided in section 51
or, as the case may be, of the date of the said order, the Commissioner shall
pay such person simple interest at the prescribed rate on the said amount
from the date immediately following the expiry of the period of ninety days
to the date of the refund.
Provided that, where the amount becomes refundable by virtue of an order of
the Tribunal or the High Court or the Supreme Court, the interest under the
provisions of this section shall be payable from the date immediately
following the expiry of period of ninety days from the date of receipt of the
order of the Tribunal, the High Court or the Supreme Court, by the officer
whose order forms the subject of the proceedings before the Tribunal, the
High Court or the Supreme Court, to the date of refund. The applicant dealer
or person may supply to the said officer a certified copy of such order and ifthe copy is so furnished, interest shall become payable after the expiry of
period of ninety days from the date of such supply.
Explanation. If the delay in granting the refund within the period of ninety
days aforesaid is attributable to the said person, whether wholly or in part,
the period of the delay attributable to him shall be excluded from the period
for which interest is payable.
(2) Where any question arises as to the period to be excluded for the purposes
1
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
13/80
of calculation of interest under the provisions of this section, such question
shall be determined by the Commissioner, whose decision shall be final.
1.1.5 Other Relevant provisions of the Maharashtra Value Added Tax Act,2002
Section 20 Returns and Self-assessment.
Section 21 No notice for Assessment in certain cases.
Section 23 Assessment.
Section 48 Set-off, refund, etc.
Section - 49Refund of tax on declared goods sold in the course of interstatetrade or commerce.
Section 65 Cross-checking of transactions.
Section 96 Savings
3.2 RELEVANT PROVISIONS OF RULE:-
3.2.1 Rule-60. Grant of Refund.-
(1)Application for refund under section 51 shall be made in form 501.
(2)When the Commissioner is satisfied that a refund is due, he shall pass
an order in Form 502, showing the amount of refund due and shall
communicate the same to the dealer.
(3)When an order for refund has been made under any rule, theCommissioner shall, if Applicant desires payment in cash, issue to him a
refund payment order either in form 503 or in form 504. If the dealer
desires adjustment of refund, against tax payable in respect of any
subsequent period contained in the year to which the refund relates under
this Act, the Central Sales Tax Act,1956, or the Maharashtra Tax on Entry
of Goods into Local Areas Act, 2003, the Commissioner shall issue a
Refund Adjustment Order in form 506.
1
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
14/80
3.2.2 Rule-61. Bank Guarantee.-
The Bank Guarantee shall be obtained from any branch of a bank notified as a
Government Treasury. The maximum period for a Bank Guarantee shall beof 36 months. It shall be furnished to respective Joint Commissioner in charge
of grant of refunds. The Bank Guarantee shall be for such amounts and such
periods as the Commissioner may by public notice notify from time to time.
3.2.3 Rule-62. Order sanctioning interest on delayed
refunds:-
(1) Where upon an application by any person claiming interest on any
delayed refund or otherwise the Commissioner is satisfied that such
interest is due and payable to the applicant or any person under section
53, the Commissioner shall record an order specifying therein the amount
of refund, the payment of which was delayed, the period of delay for
which interest is payable and the amount of interest payable by the
Commissioner therefore, and shall communicate the same to the applicant
or person concerned.
(2) When an order for payment of interest on any delayed refund has been
made under this rule, the Commissioner shall issue to the applicant or
person concerned an interest payment order in Form 505.
3.3 Other Relevant provisions of the Maharashtra Value Added Tax
Rule, 2005
Rule 17 Submissions of returns.
Rule 18Special provision for first and last return in certain cases and fordealers under the package scheme of incentives
Rule 19 Separate return.
Rule 20 Complete and self-consistent return.
Rule 21 Form of Notice for assessment.
Rule 23 Form of order of assessment.
Rule 24 Application for cancellation of assessment order.Rule 25 Order imposing penalty or interest.
1
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
15/80
Rule 51Claim and grant of set-off in respect of purchases held in stockon the appointed day.
Rule 52Claim and grant of set-off in respect of purchases made in theperiods commencing on or after the appointed day.
Rule 53 Reduction in set-off.
Rule 54 Non-admissibility of set-off.
Rule 55Condition for grant of set-off or refund and adjustment ofdrawback, set-off in certain circumstances.
Rule 68 Preservation of books of accounts, registers, etc.
Rule 77Particulars to be specified in a tax invoice, bill or cashmemorandum.
Rule 79 Refund of tax to eligible units.
Rule 88 Rates of interest.
4. Relevant Internal and Trade Circulars:-
4.1 Guidelines issued vide Internal Circular no.
No.:- VAT-2008/JC./ Refund and Refund Audit / B- 4579 Mumbai, Dt :
13.03.2008, Internal Circular No. 6A of 2008.
Sub : Refunds under MVAT Act.
Modifications in Internal Circular 5A of 2008
Ref:- Internal Circular No. 37A of 2007 Dt. 28.12.2007 .
Internal Circular No. 5 A of 2007 Dt. 05.03.2008.
1) INTRODUCTORY :-
This office had earlier issued Internal Circulars No. 37 A of 2007 Dt.
28th December, 2007 and 5A of 2008 Dt. 05.03.2008. These circulars were
issued to provide the guidelines for facilitating early processing of refunds
and to remove the difficulties faced in processing the refund claims.
The pendancy of the refund has been reviewed and in addition to
earlier instructions, fresh guidelines are given hereunder, to expedite the
process of granting of refund and completion of refund audits.
1
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
16/80
2) GRANT OF REFUND :-
. All the cases, where the dealer has filed returns for the relevant
period on or before 25th February 2008 would be eligible for grant
of refund without prior Refund Audit and application in Form 501
is filed on or before 19th March 2008, The refund without pre audit,
as per earlier circulars was not allowed in respect of the claimant
dealers (both manufacturers and traders) of Iron and Steel and
Dyes & Chemicals. However, certain relaxations are hereby given
to process the refund claims in respect of such dealers, if they fulfill
any of the following conditions. This relaxation is made only for the
refund processed up to 31.03.2008.
) If the Refund Audit is completed by the Refund Audit Branch
of such dealers for any previous period and no substantial
reduction in refund amount is noticed after the Refund Audit
or
) If such dealers have submitted the Statutory Audit Report in
Form 704 for previous year.
) If the dealer is a manufacturer.
The departmental authorities are instructed to start the Refund Audit
immediately after 1st April, 2008 of the dealers to whom pre audit
refund is granted. The above mentioned categories will be audited on
priority.
. The copy of Return claiming the refund should be obtained from
the Return Branch. The dealer may be called to produce the copies
of the challans, if necessary. The instructions contained in Circular
5 T of 2008 should be scrupulously followed. However, the
claimant dealer if encloses certified copies of the returns along
with the application in Form 501, then such certified copies may
be considered.
1
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
17/80
. A certificate should be obtained from the dealer, certifying that,
no dues are outstanding against him and he has not carried
forward this refund in any of the earlier or subsequent returns.
. The dealer should be asked to submit the necessary information
required to process the refund claim. This communication should
invariably be made in writing and the dealer should be made
aware that his claim of refund shall not be processed unless the
requisite information is submitted by him.
. In case, the refund granting authority decides to assess the dealer,
then the notice for assessment should be issued within a period of3 months from the date of submitting Form 501.
. The refund should be granted only in respect of the refund which
is due. e.g. in case of a P.S.I. dealer who holds the entitlement
certificate for part of an industrial undertaking through
investment in a expansion unit and whose production from the all
JC old and expansion investments is identifiable, (i.e. production
facilities are separate), then in such cases, the refund will be
granted only in respect of purchases corresponding to the
production of the expansion unit in the total production. Cases in
which the investment in expansion unit does not result in
identifiable (separate) production capacity but
strengthens/upgrades the existing technology, product quality or
quantity, purchases entitled for refund shall be worked out inproportion to the new (PSI) investment in the total investment.
. Where the dealer has submitted application in Form 501 and
subsequently revised the corresponding return claiming refund
for any reasons, then the corresponding application in Form 501
would become redundant and such dealer should be asked to
submit fresh application in Form 501 to that effect. In cases where,
after submitting the applications in Form 501 and if it is noticed
1
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
18/80
that the returns are not filed as per the periodicity, in such case
the dealer should be asked to submit the revised returns as per
the correct periodicity and also the new application in Form 501 .
Only those cases wherein the claim of refund remains unaltered
shall be eligible for pre audit refund as per this circular. No fresh
annexure will be required if the contents of the earlier annexure
remains unaltered. This action on the part of the dealer should
have been completed on or before 19th March 2008.
. The completed Form 502 should be submitted to R.P.O. section for
issue of Refund Payment Orders. All the actions of granting
refund in the above mentioned cases should be completed on or
before 25th March, 2008.
3). POST GRANT OF REFUND ACTIONS / REFUND AUDIT
After grant of refund all the cases be audited as per
principles laid down hereunder.
I.
Desk Audit :- If the refund claim is less than Rs. 5 lakh per Form 501 ,then only desk audit is to be done (No field visits.). The desk audit is
to be conducted immediately after the grant of refund. The desk
audit is to be completed in the following manner.
a) The copies of Form 704 to be obtained from Business Audit
Branch .( If available)
b) The refund granting officer should first ascertain from
MAHAVIKAS the position regarding the filing of returns by all
the suppliers of the refund claiming dealer.
c) While checking, the audit officer must check that the turnover of
sales and the taxes paid by the supplier are enough to cover the
claim of ITC of the refund claimant in respect of that supplier.
d) In cases, where the dealer has effected Interstate Sales, the details
of availability of declarations under CST Act should be checked
1
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
19/80
by calling the dealer with details and pass the appropriate order
accordingly (wherever necessary).
e) Visit is not necessary in these cases unless there are special
circumstances due to which visit is found necessary. For this
approval of JC concerned should be taken.
II. Field Audit :- The Field Audit is to be conducted in all the cases
wherein the refund claim is Rs. 5 lakh or more.
4 ) CROSS CHECKING OF THE TRANSACTIONS :-
While conducting the Desk Audit or the Field Audit, the cross
checks to be done in the following manner-
. The officer should confirm filing of returns by all the suppliers of the
refund claiming dealer from the MAHAVIKAS and from Return
Branch.
. For the purpose of cross checking, where total ITC claim in respect
of a supplier is of Rs. 50,000/- and above and where return has been
filed, 10 % of suppliers will be selected by way of Random Sampling
Method (duly approved by the concerned JC) and to be sent for cross
checking to the cross check section .
. Where ITC claims in respect of any supplier is less than Rs. 50,000/-
per supplier and where return has been filed , 5 % of suppliers will
be selected by way of Random Sampling Method (duly approved by
the concerned JC) and be sent for cross checking to the cross check
section. During the cross check, if it is found that any transaction is not
accounted for by a particular supplier in his books of accounts , then
a comprehensive Business Audit of that supplier is to be taken
immediately by the Refund Audit Branch. The Cross Check Cell
should immediately inform this fact to the Refund Audit Branch.
Also, instead of the sample cross check, 100% of the cross checks of
the claimant dealer is to be issued immediately. The claimant dealer
1
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
20/80
should be informed about such result and reasons for issuances of
100% cross checks in his case. The claimant dealer should also be
informed if any of his suppliers is not available on the given address.
. It is pertinent to note here that, the information about such suppliers
should be shared with all officers through E-mail. The list of such
dealers should be prepared and monthly updating should be done by
the Cross Check Section. The information about such suppliers may
also be published on the official Web Site of the department after
canceling the R.C. of the concerned dealer to make aware the dealers
at large. If it is found during the process of cross check that the
supplier is not found at the address given, then list of such dealers
should be shared with all the officers through Email. The action to
cancel the TIN Certificate or Registration Certificate should be
initiated in respect of such suppliers, in due course. The details of
such suppliers should be reported to the Registration Branch to
initiate the actions of cancellation of R.C.
. No cross checks to be issued for a single bill containing tax upto
Rs.5,000/-, Rs.4,000/- and Rs.3,000/- for the cases audited by Deputy
Commissioner, Assistant Commissioner and Sales Tax Officer
respectively .
. It is needless to add that in case, any of the supplier has not filed the
relevant return, then refund to the extent of ITC claim of that supplier
should be reduced by passing appropriate order. In any case, the ITC
claim in respect of any supplier should not be granted, unless it is
verified that the supplier has filed the return for the corresponding
return period. If it is found after cross checking, that a particular
supplier is not traceable, then the refund to the extent of purchases of
such dealer should be withdrawn by passing an appropriate order.
All the departmental officers are directed to follow above instructions
scrupulously.
2
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
21/80
4.2 Guidelines issued vide Internal Circular bearing no. 37A, dt:
28.12.2007, are reproduced herewith,
Sub: Refunds under MVAT Act.
A) Background: The issue of pending refund claims is reviewed on 17th of
December 2007 to expedite early finalisation of refund claims. Considering the
huge pendancy, delay in completing audit, some major decisions are taken in
the public interest in the meeting related to grant of refund and audit of such
cases.
The decisions taken in the meeting should be followed by all the Joint
Commissioners (Refund and VAT-Adm) with immediate effect.B) GRANT OF REFUND: All the cases except those are mentioned in para
(D), where the dealer has filed form 501 on or before 31st DECEMBER 2007 are
eligible for grant of balance or full refund prior to audit subject to the
following conditions:-
1. Form 501 must have been received on or before 31st DECEMBER 2007
2. Only cases in which refund is due as per provisions of the Maharashtra
Value Added Tax Act (MVAT Act) will be eligible for refund.
3. All Form-501 must be accompanied with annexure in proper format. If
data is huge, the department may accept this annexure in Excel format. If
Form-501 is already received and annexure is not appended, then obtain
annexure from claimant dealer within 10 days.
4. The certified copy of return in which net refund is claimed be obtained
from Returns Branch or claimant dealer. The certified copies of returns in
which refund is carried forward may also be obtained from the dealer.
5. The dealer should also certify that no sales tax dues are outstanding
against him & also that he has not carried forward the said refund in any
other subsequent return/s or previous return/s nor has adjusted it against
any of his liability.
6. It goes without saying that all the above mentioned certification must be
done by duly authorized person of the firm and should carry the stamp ofthe firm & name of the authorized person
2
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
22/80
7. DISPOSAL: All the actions in the above mentioned cases must be
completed on or before 31st January 2008.
8. As per procedures, all cases in which Form-502 is completed, must be
submitted to RPO section for issue of RPOs.
9. All these cases will be taken up for post refund audit as per following
procedure :-
C) POST GRANT OF REFUND ACTIONS : After grant of refund all the
cases will be audited as per principles laid down hereunder:
1. Audit : The term audit refers to two stage process i.e. i) visit & detailed
scrutiny at the place of business of the claimant dealer and ii) summary audit
& cross-checking through MAHAVIKAS and/or visiting place of business of
the supplier dealers.
All the refund claims (per Form-501) above Rs 5 Lac shall be
fully audited i.e. visit, scrutiny as well as summary audit & cross checking. All
refund claims (per Form-501) of Rs 5 Lac or below shall be done through
summary audit and cross-checking only (i.e. a visit is not necessary in these
cases unless there are special circumstances due to which visit is found
necessary)
2. Procedure of Summary Audit & Cross Checking :
i) All the ITC claim will be checked for whether return has been filed
by the supplier whose invoice the ITC claim is being asked for.
ii) While checking, audit officer must check that the turnover of sales
and taxes paid by the supplier is enough to cover the claim of ITC.
iii) In all cases where return has been filed, all ITC claims of Rs 25000/-
& above per supplier will be sent for cross checking to the cross check
section.
iv) In ITC claims which are below Rs 25000/- per supplier for which
return have been filed, cross checking may be carried out for 5% of the
suppliers by random selection
2
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
23/80
v) In cases where supplier is detected as non-filer, ITC claim to that
extent be disallowed and such list be sent to Returns Branch for
appropriate action.
3. If as a result of audit it comes to notice that excess refund has been granted
to any claimant dealer, then the audit officer should immediately initiate and
pass an assessment order as per section 23 of the MVAT Act and demand so
raised shall be deducted from subsequent refund payable to the claimant
dealer. If no refund is payable subsequently, then dues shall be recovered as
per the provisions of MVAT Act.
4. In cases where declarations under CST Act are missing, assessment order
under CST Act shall be passed and necessary recovery actions shall be taken
accordingly.
D) In cases where claimant dealer is dealing in Iron & Steel and Dyes &
Chemicals, refund prior to the audit shall not be granted. In those cases,
refund shall be granted after the completion of detailed audit.
E) All the departmental officers are directed to follow above instructions
scrupulously.
4.3 Gist of other relevant Internal Circulars :-
1.InternalCircular No. 2A of2006, dt: 24.01.2006.
Instructions for issuing refundunder VAT System.
2.InternalCircular No. 3A of2006, dt: 27.01.2006.
Provisional refunds to the dealerscovered under the PackageScheme of Incentives Timelypayment of due refunds before
31.03.006.
3.InternalCircular No. 6A of2006, dt: 3.03.2006
Early grant of provisional refund.
4.Internal Circular No. 5 A of2007 Dt. 05.03.2008
Refunds under MVAT Act.Modifications in Internal Circular37A of 2007.
4.4 Guidelines issued vide Trade Circular bearing no.VAT/MIA10-
07/ADM-5/3 Mumbai, dt.23.08.2007, Trade Circular No.- 56 T of
2007, are reproduced herewith,
2
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
24/80
Sub: Refund under MVAT.
1. Introductory:-
Section 51 of the Maharashtra Value Added Tax Act, 2002 deals with
refund as per return. The corresponding Rules are, Rules 60 and 61 of the
Maharashtra Value Added Tax Rules, 2005. Till date, the refund U/s. 51 were
granted on ad-hoc basis by issuing various Trade Circulars from time to time.
This was done keeping in view that the automation and reorganization of the
department were not completed. The automation of the department is still
few months away. However, it is now decided to lay down a stable procedure
for the grant of refund.
Applicability of this Circular
(i). The instructions contained in this circular will apply to all returns filed
before the date of this circular, (subject to making an application in Form-
501,) and will also be applicable for all the subsequent refund claims filed
after the date of this circular.
(ii). It is to be noted that for further grant of refund, unless a specific circular
is issued, the instructions contained in this circular would continue to apply.
The dealers should therefore follow the instructions in this circular for
claiming the refund for the subsequent periods also.
Refund and Due Returns:
i)It may be noted that refunds as per returns would be payable only in respectof the returns which the dealer is due to file as per the rules. For example, if
a dealer is due to file a quarterly return but instead files monthly returns,
then the refund would not be granted in respect of the monthly return.
Accordingly, no refund under this circular will be allowed for a returns filed
for an incorrect period.
ii)The return should be correct, complete and self consistent. The application
in Form 501 should be consistent with the return.
2
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
25/80
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
26/80
(i) The refund for the financial year 2005-06 in case of dealers who have
filed the return alongwith form 501 before the issue of this circular shall be
granted on or before 31st October, 2007, if the applicant fulfills the other
conditions of this circular.
(ii) There could be cases for the year 2005-06 wherein only part of the
refund is granted till date and the balance refund is pending due to various
reasons. In all such cases also the balance refund shall be granted on or before
31stOctober, 2007, if the applicant fulfills the other conditions of this circular.
Grant of Refund:-
(i). The refund of dealers U/s. 8(3) of MVAT Act shall be granted within 30
days from the date of making the application or from the date of filing the
necessary details as may be required by the refund authority, whichever is
later, provided the claim of refund is made alongwith the application in
Form 501 filed with the respective refund branch.
(ii). The dealers holding a certificate of entitlement under the package
scheme of incentive shall be granted a refund within a period of three
months from the date of application in Form 501 or from the date of
submitting the necessary details to refund authority, whichever is later.
(iii). In case of a P.S.I. dealer who holds the entitlement certificate for part of
an industrial undertaking through investment in a expansion unit and
whose production from the old and expansion investments is identifiable,
(i.e. production facilities are separate), then in such cases, the refund will be
granted only in respect of purchases corresponding to the production of the
expansion unit in the total production. Cases in which the investment in
expansion unit does not result in identifiable (separate) production capacity
but strengthens/upgrades the existing technology, product quality or
quantity, purchases entitled for refund shall be worked out in proportion to
the new (PSI) investment in the total investment.
(iv). In all cases other than the above mentioned cases the refund will be
granted within 3 months from the date of making the application in Form
501/or from the date of submitting the details, whichever is later.
2
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
27/80
(v). There could be some pending cases of refund for the year 2006-07,
wherein the entire refund claim of the dealer is pending or part of the
refund, i.e. 10% or 40% is pending, as the refund audit/cross checking of the
transactions are not completed. In all such cases, the refund will be granted
on or before 30th November, 2007.
Non availability of CST declarations:-
(i) There could be cases wherein a refund cannot be granted only because
all or some of the declaration under Central Sales Tax Act for any period
either [2005-06 or 2006-07] are not received by the dealer. In all such cases,
after deciding the CST payable as per Section 8 of the CST Act in respect of
unreceived declarations the balance refund will be granted as per the above
guidelines. Needless to say that the dealer will have to submit the list of
declarations received and not received alongwith the Form 501.
(ii)If after the grant of refund, the dealer receives the declarations under
the CST Act then the dealer can make a fresh application before the refund
granting authority alongwith an application in Form 501. However, no such
application will be entertained within a period of six months from the date of
order granting the refund and not more than one such application shall be
entertained by the Refund granting authority.
Bank Guarantee:-
(i) Following parameters will be applied to the dealers willing to
submit the B G for early refund.
SrNo
Category of the DealerResult of previous
auditsExtent of Bank
Guarantee
Extent of Pre-audit refundto be issued
1All Dealers No Discrepancy in
previous FOUR audits10 per cent 100 per cent
2All Dealers No Discrepancy in
previous three audits15 per cent 100 per cent
3All Dealers No Discrepancy in
previous two audits20per cent 100 per cent
4 Newly Registered Dealers Not Applicable 100 per cent 100 per cent
2
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
28/80
SrNo
Category of the DealerResult of previous
auditsExtent of Bank
Guarantee
Extent of Pre-audit refundto be issued
5
Dealers who have effectedinterstate sales
i) No Discrepancy inprevious two audits
i) 50 per cent
ii) First claim ii) 100 per cent
100 per cent
6
Govt Organization andPSU
No discrepancies Zero BG100 per cent
Discrepancies Zero BG 90 per cent
7Diplomatic authorities No B G 100 % on
same day
8 All dealer First time claim 100% BG 100percent
Note:-
1. If dealer falls under more than one category, he should be treated in
the category with higher amount of BG.
2. Discrepancy means the disallowance exceeding 5 per cent in the
refund audit period or Rupees one lakh whichever is less.
(ii) It may be noted that the refund against the Bank Guarantee can be given
only in those cases wherein the refund is due. The cases wherein the refund is
not due, such as, the cases covered by Para 7 (iii) of this circular or the return
not filed as per the periodicity would not be covered by this clause. And in
such cases the dealer can not claim the refund by furnishing the Bank
Guarantee. Once the Bank Guarantee is accepted, then the refund must be
granted within 3 days.
(iii) If after the Refund Audit no discrepancies are found, then the BG
submitted by the dealer could be released or roll-over for the further period,at the option of the dealer.
Assessment of Refund:-
(i). Section 51(6)(a) of the MVAT Act 2002 provides that the dealer can not
make a claim of refund as per Section 51 of the Act, if the notice U/s. 23 is
issued. Before granting the refund, the refund granting authority may like to
obtain certain details and / or may like to conduct a refund audit. If the
dealer has not submitted the details as required by the authority or has not
2
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
29/80
cooperated with the officer during the course of audit or if the auditor is of
the view that the assessment of the dealer is necessary then the officer shall
issue a notice U/s. 23 of the Act and assess the dealer accordingly.
(ii). Unless, such notice U/s. 23 is issued, the refund claim of the dealer can
not be withheld and the same shall be granted as per the instructions of this
circular.
Refund Audit and cross checking:-
(i). In cases wherein the refund is granted prior to refund audit or after
incomplete refund audit, the audit will be completed expeditiously.
(ii). It will be the endeavor of the department to complete the refund audit
and also the cross checking of the transactions as early as possible and in
any case within the time limit prescribed above.
(iii). To facilitate the cross checking of transactions, the dealers are requested
to submit the details of sales and purchases in a electronically prescribed
format to the department as and when asked for. This will facilitate cross
checking of the transactions and will also avoid the multiple visits for cross
checking to the dealers place of business. This should ensure the
expeditious grant of refund.
(iv). If a particular dealer claims a refund in any return /s in a Financial
Year, he would be audited by the Refund Audit Branch only. In such case
no separate Business Audit would be conducted by the Business Audit
Branch. However, in all such cases the Refund Audit Branch would
conduct a Desk Audit at the end of the year on the basis of Audit Report in
Form 704 and may conduct the Business Audit of the same dealer with prior
approval of concern Joint Commissioner of Sales Tax.
Adjustment of refund in the subsequent period:
Although, the law provides for compulsory claiming of the refund at
the end of the Financial Year, a facility was provided by way of Trade
Circular to adjust the refund for the years 2005-06, 2006-07 in the subsequent
years return. It is hereby clarified that, henceforth such facility for the
adjustment of refund in the subsequent financial year will not be given and
2
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
30/80
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
31/80
Act,2002.
8.Trade Circular No. 3T of2007 , Dt: 10.01.2007.
Refund Audit under MVAT Act.
9.
Trade Circular No. 4T
of 2007, Dt. 12.01.2007.
Refund for the period from 01/04/2005
onwards.
10.Trade Circular No. 14 Tof 2007, Dt. 08.02.2007.
Grant of Provisional Refund.
11.Trade Circular No.22T of2007, Dt. 01.03.2007.
Grant of Refund.
12.Trade Circular No.41T of2007, Dt. 21.05.2007.
Adjustment of refund of the FinancialYear 2006-07 to the Financial Year 2007-08.
13.Trade Circular No. 1T of2008, Dt: 25.01.2008
Procedure for Issuance of Statutory Formsunder Central Sales Tax Act, 1956.
14.Trade Circular No. 3T of2008, Dt. 06/02/2008.
Filing of correct and complete returns andfurnishing copies of the returns to theSales tax authorities.
15.Trade Circular No. 5T of2008, Dt. 28/02/2008.
Furnishing of copies of challans / returnsto the Sales Tax Authorities.
16.Trade Circular No. 6T of2008, Dt. 01/03/2008.
Grant of Refunds : Bank Guarantee
5. COMPETENT AUTHORITIES & TARGETS:-
5.1 The competent authorities to process / audit and authorize the cases
are as follows:-
Processing / auditingOfficer
Authorising Officer Amount of refund claim
Sales Tax Officer Dy. Commissioner Below Rs. 3.5 lakh
Assistant Commissioner Dy. Commissioner Above Rs. 3.5 lakh uptoRs. 10 lakh
Dy. Commissioner Joint Commissioner Above Rs. 10 lakh
5.2 The competent authority to issue RPO & Advice Notes:-
Amount of refund Competent authority to issue RPOs /Advice Notes
3
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
32/80
Equal to or less than Rs. 5 lakh Asstt. Commissioner
Above Rs. 5 lakh to Rs. 25 lakh Dy. Commissioner
Above Rs. 25 lakh Joint Commissioner
5.3 TARGETS:-
6. THE PROCESS IN BRIEF:-
3
Sr.No.
DesignationUnitsSanctionedstrength
Target permonth
Target perannum
Individual Unit Individual Unit
1 D.C. 8 8 64 80 640
2 A.C. 26(24+2) 11 264 110 26403 STO 16 (8+8) 15 120 150 1200
Total 256 448 4480
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
33/80
7. PROCEDURE OF BRANCH:-
Refund claim in form 501 received in the office of JCST of R&RA.
Acceptance on MAHAVIKAS & entry in Centralised Register.
Refund claim in form 501without Bank Guarantee.
Refund claim in form 501against Bank Guarantee.
Allotment to concernedDC Unit
Sub-Allotment to DC/AC/STO
Visit to dealer & verificationof books of accounts.
Issue Cross-checks toCross-check cell.
Custody of BG and BGAcceptance Order to bepassed by DesignatedOfficer in the office ofC R&RA
As per Audit findings,confirmation of Refundclaim.
Amend the claim byRevised Return /AcceptanceLetter.
If dealer disagree-then notice inForm 301 to be
Assessment order in
Orderresulting inRefund
Authorisation of claim byRefund AuthorisingOfficer.
Issue Audit Form 6
Issue RSO Form 502.
RPO issued by RPO Signing
Authority
Allotment to concernedDC Unit.
Sub-Allotment to DC / AC /STO
Orderresulting inDues
Update CentralisedMaster File.
Claims processed withBank Guarantee.* * (Follow theprocedure except issueof Form 502).
Reconciliation ofpaid Advice Notesreceived from RBI byDesignated Officer inthe office of JCR&RA.
Send recovery toRecovery Branch.
As per Audit findings,variation in RefundClaim.
Authorisation of claim byRefund AuthorisingOfficer.
3
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
34/80
7.1 Fast Track Window
for acceptance of return wherein refund is claimed :-
7.1.1 The returns of claimant dealers shall be accepted atFast Track
Window specially created for this purpose.
7.1.2 After acceptance, such returns will be photo copied by the
Refund & Refund Audit Branch and such photo copies are to be
retained with the Branch.
7.1.3 The photocopy of the return is to be certified by the AC / STO
(in-charge for return acceptance) & such certified copies ofreturn will be forwarded to the concerned unit dealing the case.
7.1.4 Thereafter, original return will be sent back to the concern
authority of the Return Branch, within 7 days and receipt for the
same, to be obtained.
7.1.5 Returns filed up to 20.06.2006:- In some cases, it has been
observed that, dealers who have filed returns up to 20.06.06
have not applied for refund in Form-501. To claim the refund, it
has been made mandatory to file application in form 501, w. e. f.
20.06.2006. Hence, in such cases, the courtesy letter is to be
issued and if dealer failed to apply in Form 501, then assessment
should be initiated and necessary actions to be taken.
7.2 Single Window System
for acceptance of Application for Refund in Form 501 :-
7.2.1 The application for refund in Form 501 is to be accepted, in the
office of the Joint Commissioner of Sales Tax, Refund & Refund
Audit Branch, where the Single Window System for acceptance
is introduced.
7.2.1 The Officer in-charge for acceptance of Application for Refund
in Form 501, shall keep ready the checklist for documents
required to be submitted along with application for refund in
3
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
35/80
Form 501 and such checklist is required to be displayed near
Single Window System.
7.2.2 The Sales Tax Inspector shall face-check the application for
refund in Form 501 along with return and documents,
submitted by the dealer. And only correct & complete
applications will be accepted.
7.2.3 In case of incorrect and / or incomplete and / or defective
application for refund in Form 501, the Officer in-charge shall
issue duly signed letter, narrating the reason / reasons for non-
acceptance of such application.
7.2.4 The receipt for an application for refund in Form 501 is to be
generated through the MAHAVIKAS System. In exceptional
cases, the concerned staff person at the Single Window System
shall record the reason / reasons on the application itself, for
non generation of receipt through MAHAVIKAS System.
7.2.5 The applications for refund in Form 501 received from dealers of
the category of Large Taxpayers Unit (LTU) are to be forwarded
to Large Taxpayers Unit, for further actions. For this purpose,
the Officer in-charge should keep the list of dealers of such
category.
7.2.6 The entry of applications for refund in Form 501 is to be taken in
Centralised Register No. R&RA-1 (format enclosed), in the
office of the Joint Commissioner.
7.3 Acceptance and custody of Bank Guarantee :-
7.3.1 If correct & complete application is received from the dealer
claiming refund against Bank Guarantee and the Bank
Guarantee furnished is in the prescribed format as notified by
the Commissioner for the prescribed amount and period, then,
7.3.2 The details of such Bank guarantee furnished by the dealer
should be entered in the Bank Guarantee Register (Reg. No.
R&RA-5)
3
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
36/80
7.3.3 The register of Bank Guarantee (Reg. No. R&RA-5) is to be
maintained in the Office of the Joint Commissioner.
7.3.4 An Officer has to be designated and the custody of such bank
guarantees should be assigned to him.
7.3.5 The Bank Guarantees for higher amounts have to be
authenticated from the concerned Banks.
7.3.6 For this purpose, the Designated Officer shall issue letter to the
Manager or Officer In-charge of the Branch / Bank, requesting
him to affirm the facts related to said Bank Guarantee such as
amount and period, as enumerated in the said Bank Guarantee.
7.3.7 The Designated Officer shall carry out the work related to
release or roll over of such bank guarantees after results of
refund audit relevant to said refund claims, as per the dealers
desire.
7.3.8 The Designated Officer shall keep the status and follow up of
cases wherein Bank Guarantee has been accepted.
7.3.9 JCST, R&RA should keep follow up and ensure that, refund
audit to be expedited in such cases, where period of the said
Bank Guarantee is likely to be expired.
7.4 Allotment of cases within the Division:-
7.4.1 The correct & complete applications shall be allotted to the
respective unit by the Joint Commissioner.
7.4.2 Certain cases are to be retained with the Designated Officer in
the office of JCST, R&RA for such processing of refund claims
such as,
(i) claims of miscellaneous refund,
(ii) refund claims pertaining to dealers of Non Resident Circle
category,
(iii) refund claims pertaining to un-registered dealers i.e. in case of
TDS etc.
3
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
37/80
(iv) and refund claims pertaining to last return in respect of
cancellation of Certificate of Registration etc.
7.4.3 Through the MAHAVIKAS system, applications pertaining to
the category of SEZ dealers covered under section 8(3) of the
Maharashtra Value Added Tax Act, 2002, will be forwarded to
the unit designated for such category of the dealers, for
processing of refund claims.
7.4.4 In case of other category dealers, applications will be distributed
to different units through the MAHAVIKAS system,
7.4.5 The allotment of cases is to be done on the basis of TIN.
7.4.6 The JCST R&RA may reallocate or transfer the cases within the
units, depending on the work load with each unit.
7.5 Allotment of cases within the Unit :-
7.5.1 On receipt of cases from the office of JCST, R&RA, all such cases
have to be entered in Unit wise Register for Acceptance of Form
-501 (Register No. R&RA-2), for this purpose, each unit should
maintain the said Register.
7.5.2 Intra unit allotment of cases is to be done by the DCST, R&RA,
as per following slabs:-
Amount of refund claimed
per form 501
Designation of
Refund Processing
Authority
Above Rs. 10 lakhs Dy. Commissioner
Rs. 3.51 to 10 lakhs Asstt. Commissioner
Below Rs. 3.5 lakhs Sales Tax Officer
7.5.3 In exceptional cases, the changes in aforesaid slab will be done
by DCST, R&RA with prior approval of JCST, R&RA.
7.5.4 Cases shall be distributed to different authorities within the unit
through the MAHAVIKAS system,
3
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
38/80
7.5.5 As far as possible, DCST, R&RA should ensure that, various
refund claims made by the dealer within one financial year are
to be allotted to same authority.
7.5.6 Processing of refund claims should be done as per the
procedure laid down hereinafter.
7.5 Processing of Refund Claims made against Bank Guarantee :-
7.5.1 Procedure for grant of refund, is to be followed as per the
guidelines issued vide Trade Circular No. VAT/MIA10-
07/ADM-5/3 Trade Circular No. 56T of 2007 dt. 23.08.2007.
(Refer page No. 25)
7.5.2 Such refund claims are to be processed on priority basis and
refund has to be granted within three days, as per the guidelines
issued vide para 9(iii) of the Trade Circular 56T of 2007 dated
23/08/2007.
7.5.3 The Refund Processing Authority shall submit refund
processing report to the Refund Authorising Authority, for
authorisation of such claim.
7.5.4 After authorisation, the concerned Refund Processing Authority
shall pass Refund Sanctioning Order in Form 502.
7.5.5 Entry of Refund Sanctioning Order in Form 502 shall be taken in
a Refund Sanction Order Register (Reg. No. R&RA-4).
7.5.6 Thereafter, proposal for issue of Refund Payment Order
(Annexure - B) should be forwarded / submitted to the
concerned RPO signing authority (ACST R&RA /DCST R&RA
/JCST R&RA as per the prescribed limit).
7.5.7 After grant of refund, the claim is to be audited by the
concerned officer, as per the procedure laid down in chapter 8 of
the Manual,
7.5.8 The concerned authority should ensure that, the refund audit
procedure should be completed within the prescribed period of
the said Bank Guarantee,
3
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
39/80
7.5.9 The proposal for adjustment of Bank Guarantee towards dues
raised on account of excess grant of refund if any, is to be
submitted to the office of JCST, R&RA,
7.5.10 After completion of Refund Audit procedure, the proposal for
release or roll over of the Bank Guarantee as per the dealers
desire, is to be submitted to the office of JCST, R&RA.
7.6 Processing of refund claims made without Bank Guarantee :-
7.6.1 The Refund Processing Authorities should ensure that, the
actions regarding the processing of refund claims should be
initiated on FIFO basis, i.e. in order of the date of receipt of
application for refund in form 501,
7.6.2 Immediate face-checking of the return including revised return,
if any and application in Form 501 should be done by the
Refund Processing Authority with respect to the periodicity of
return, eligibility of refund as per the return in relation to
provisions of the Act / Rule i.e. whether the dealer is entitled for
refund as per the periodic return or at the end of year.
7.6.3 On face checking of return if it is found that, there is defect in
the return; take necessary steps to intimate the same to the
dealer and request him to correct the same and to file fresh
application for refund in form 501 accordingly. The copy of such
intimation should be forwarded to the concerned authority of
Return Branch, for necessary actions.
7.6.4 In case of refund claims made without bank guarantee,
procedure for grant of refund is to be followed as per the
guidelines issued vide Internal Circular No. VAT-2007/Adm-
7/Refund & Refund Audit/B- 503 Mumbai, dt: 28.12.2007
Internal Circular No. 37 A of 2007.
3
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
40/80
8. REFUND AUDIT PROCEDURE :-
Vide Internal Circular No. 37 A of 2007, it is stated that,
The term audit refers to two stage process i.e.
i) visit & detailed scrutiny at the place of business of theclaimant dealer and
ii) summary audit & cross-checking through MAHAVIKAS
and/or visiting place of business of the supplier dealers.
Vide Internal Circular No. 5 A of 2008, it is stated that,
After grant of refund all the cases be audited as per principles laid
down hereunder.
. Desk Audit :- If the refund claim is less than Rs. 5 lakh per Form
501 , then only desk audit is to be done (No field visits.). The desk
audit is to be conducted immediately after the grant of refund. The
desk audit is to be completed in the following manner.
a) The copies of Form 704 to be obtained from Business Audit
Branch .( If available)
b) The refund granting officer should first ascertain fromMAHAVIKAS the position regarding the filing of returns
by all the suppliers of the refund claiming dealer.
c) While checking, the audit officer must check that the
turnover of sales and the taxes paid by the supplier are
enough to cover the claim of ITC of the refund claimant in
respect of that supplier.
d) In cases, where the dealer has effected Interstate Sales, the
details of availability of declarations under CST Act should
be checked by calling the dealer with details and pass the
appropriate order accordingly (wherever necessary).
e) visit is not necessary in these cases unless there are special
circumstances due to which visit is found necessary. For this
approval of JC concerned should be taken.
4
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
41/80
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
42/80
periods. Then in such cases, the refund audit should be carried
out from the period, from where the refund has been brought
forwarded.
8.2.5 The Refund Processing Authority shall prepare summary, short
notes regarding sales transactions eligible and ineligible to tax
and claims on purchase side at different tax slabs,
8.3 C. During the visit scrutiny & checks :-
8.3.1 Record the particulars of visit i.e. date of visit, time of entry and
place of visit etc.,
8.3.2 While initiating the audit, carry out brief interview with the
authorised person regarding nature of business, business
process, commodity dealt, inputs, intermediates and outputs
and their ratio,
8.3.3 If there are any changes in the registration details, are to be
communicated to the Registration Branch accordingly,
8.3.4 Record particulars regarding the books of accounts / documents
produced by the dealer and verified,
8.3.5 Inspect the business premises / factory / warehouse, etc. to
ascertain the equipment / capital goods in use, inputs and the
outputs of the dealer.
8.3.6 Details regarding inputs, to be verified :-
i. Reconciliation of turnover of purchase as per ledger,
register and return,
ii. Verify purchases effected by the dealer from Registered
Dealers, Un-registered Dealers, interstate, imports & high
seas etc and
iii. Verify all tax invoices against which the dealer have
claimed Input Tax Credit (ITC),
iv. Record particulars regarding the commodities purchased
i.e. inputs against each tax rate,
4
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
43/80
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
44/80
xvi. In case of purchase of Capital Goods, verify the tax invoice,
physical examination of goods whether such goods exist or
disposed off.
xvii. In case of a P.S.I. dealer who holds the entitlement
certificate for part of an industrial undertaking through
investment in a expansion unit and whose production from
the old and expansion investments is identifiable, (i.e.
production facilities are separate), then in such cases, the
refund will be granted only in respect of purchases
corresponding to the production of the expansion unit in
the total production. Cases in which the investment in
expansion unit does not result in identifiable (separate)
production capacity but strengthens / upgrades the
existing technology, product quality or quantity,
purchases entitled for refund shall be worked out in
proportion to the new (PSI) investment in the total
investment.
8.3.7 Details regarding outputs, to be verified:-
i. Reconciliation of turnover of sales as per ledger, register and
return,
ii. Record particulars regarding the commodities sold i.e.
outputs against each tax rate,
iii. As far as possible, record the Central Excise Tariff Heads of
outputs, especially in case of Excisable Units.
iv. Sales shown at different tax rates is to be verified and total
VAT payable as per tax slab wise is to be compiled and same
to be reconciled with figures shown in the return.
v. In certain cases like Pharmaceutical Dealers, DPCO and non-
DPCO medicines are to be segregated and summary to be
prepared,
4
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
45/80
vi. Identify and ascertain amount of VAT payable on account of
sale of fixed asset or capital goods,
xviii. Verify claims regarding goods return, discounts and
Dr./Cr. Notes.
vii. Verify the Branch Transfers / Consignment transfers, if any
viii. Verify and record details regarding tax free sales and job
work charges received.
ix. Verify interstate sales shown against declarations and list
out declaration received and not received, if any.
x. In case of Exporter, verify the documents viz.
i. commercial evidence of export,
ii. copy of custom clearance certificate,
iii. contract with foreign buyer,
iv. evidence of export (bill of lading / airway bill), etc.
v. evidence of payment for the goods or a letter of credit.
(Note that, all above details are illustrative in nature and are not exhaustive,
depending upon the fact and necessity of the case the Auditing Officer should apply
his mind).
8.4 D. Concluding the visit:-
8.4.1 Prepare the summary of transactions relevant to the period.
8.4.2 Prepare summary / verification report in the view of Audit
Form 5.
8.4.3 The documents & statements to be taken at the time of visit and
to be kept on record are given in Annexure-C8. Before concluding the visit, the Refund Audit Officer should
obtain signature of the dealer on the proceedings, narrating
the facts of visits and additional requirement to be furnished
and intimating the date on or before which he has to comply
the same etc.
4
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
46/80
8.5 Submission of preliminary visit report:-
8.5.1 Refund Processing / Auditing Officer should immediately
prepare a preliminary visit report envisaging the details of visit
and the same should be submitted for perusal, to the RefundAuthorising Officer, as per the slabs set right vide para 5.1 of the
manual.
8.5.2 Along with preliminary submission, a visit report in Form No.
R&RA-5 is to be prepared by the Refund Processing / Auditing
Authority and the same should be submitted for perusal, to the
Refund Authorising Officer.
8.6 CROSS CHECKS:-
8.6.1 In order to verify genuineness of the ITC claimed by the dealer,
it is required to check the tax liability and payment of tax of the
vendors.
8.6.2 For this purpose cross checks are to be issued to Cross check
Unit.
8.6.3 The details regarding the cross checks issued, are to be entered
in the Cross Check Register (Reg.No.R&RA-3).
8.6.4 The procedure for cross checking is to be followed as per
guidelines issued vide Internal Circular 6A of 2008 dated
12/03/2008, which reproduced herewith,
While conducting the Desk Audit or the Field Audit, the cross
checks to be done in the following manner-
. The officer should confirm filing of returns by all the suppliers
of the refund claiming dealer from the MAHAVIKAS and
from Return Branch.
. For the purpose of cross checking, where total ITC claim in
respect of a supplier is of Rs. 50,000/- and above and where
return has been filed, 10 % of suppliers will be selected by
way of Random Sampling Method (duly approved by the
4
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
47/80
concerned JC) and to be sent for cross checking to the cross
check section .
. Where ITC claims in respect of any supplier is less than Rs.
50,000/- per supplier and where return has been filed , 5 % of
suppliers will be selected by way of Random Sampling
Method (duly approved by the concerned JC) and be sent for
cross checking to the cross check section
. During the cross check, if it is found that any transaction is
not accounted for by a particular supplier in his books of
accounts , then a comprehensive Business Audit of that
supplier is to be taken immediately by the Refund Audit
Branch. The Cross Check Cell should immediately inform this
fact to the Refund Audit Branch. Also, instead of the sample
cross check, 100% of the cross checks of the claimant dealer is
to be issued immediately. The claimant dealer should be
informed about such result and reasons for issuances of 100%
cross checks in his case. The claimant dealer should also be
informed if any of his suppliers is not available on the given
address.
. It is pertinent to note here that, the information about such
suppliers should be shared with all officers through E-mail.
The list of such dealers should be prepared and monthly
updating should be done by the Cross Check Section. The
information about such suppliers may also be published on
the official Web Site of the department after canceling the R.C.
of the concerned dealer to make aware the dealers at large. If it
is found during the process of cross check that the supplier is
not found at the address given , then list of such dealers
should be shared with all the officers through Email . The
action to cancel the TIN Certificate or Registration Certificate
should be initiated in respect of such suppliers, in due course.
4
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
48/80
The details of such suppliers should be reported to the
Registration Branch to initiate the actions of cancellation of
R.C.
. No cross checks to be issued for a single bill containing tax up
o Rs.5,000/-, Rs.4,000/- and Rs.3,000/- for the cases audited
by Deputy Commissioner, Assistant Commissioner and Sales
Tax Officer respectively .
. It is needless to add that in case, any of the supplier has not
filed the relevant return, then refund to the extent of ITC claim
of that supplier should be reduced by passing appropriate
order. In any case, the ITC claim in respect of any supplier
should not be granted, unless it is verified that the supplier
has filed the return for the corresponding return period. If it is
found after cross checking, that a particular supplier is not
traceable, then the refund to the extent of purchases of such
dealer should be withdrawn by passing an appropriate order.
8.6.5 On receiving the results of Crosschecks, the corresponding
entry in the Register No. R&RA-3 is to be rounded and follow
up should be made for the un-received cross checks.
8.6.6 In case, where the cross checks of supplier resulted in non-
confirmation of ITC claim, then show cause notice for citing the
provisions of sub-section 48(5) should be served on the dealer
and after affording reasonable opportunity of hearing, such ITC
reductions are to be made from the refund claim.
8.7 CONCLUDING THE AUDIT :-
8.7.1 Auditing Officer shall keep on record documents & statements
as enlisted in Annexure-C, which are submitted by the dealer at
the time of visit and during the Refund Audit proceedings.
8.7.2 On receipt of total results of cross checks, it is required to
summarise the same and such summary should be kept onrecord.
4
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
49/80
8.7.3 The summary of sales and purchases relevant to the said period
is to be prepared i.e. VAT payable, ITC eligible, Tax liability
under the CST Act etc. and its reconciliation with the details
disclosed as per the return / returns, is to be made.
8.7.4 A proposal highlighting the effect in totality should be prepared
by the Auditing Officer.
8.7.5 The Refund Audit may result in two types of contingencies :-
(I) Refund Audit resulted in confirmation of the
refund claim,
(II) Refund Audit resulted in variation of the refund
claim.
8.8 Refund Audit resulted in confirmation of the refund claim :-
8.8.1 Submit the case for authorisation of the claim along with Audit
Form No.R&RA-6 duly signed by the Refund Processing
Authority.
8.8.2 Refund Authorising Authority should scrutinise the proposal
submitted and should note his remarks if any and if the
proposal is found to be correct and in order, then authorise the
proposal and should sign on Audit Form No.R&RA-6.
8.8.3 After the claim has been authorised, the concerned Refund
Processing Authority should pass the Refund Sanctioning Order
in Form 502.
8.8.4 Entry of Refund Sanctioning Order in Form 502 shall be taken in
a Refund Sanction Order Register (Reg. No. R&RA-4).
8.8.5 Thereafter, the proposal for issue of Refund Payment Order
(Annexure - B) should be forwarded / submitted to the
concerned RPO signing authority (ACST R&RA /DCST R&RA
/JCST R&RA as per the prescribed limit).
Refund Audit resulted in variation of the refund claim :
1.9. Appropriate corrective actions will be initiated by the
auditor. If the dealer accepts the auditors findings, then he
4
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
50/80
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
51/80
6.10. The return branch officer will make the necessary
endorsement on the original return on the basis of the list
received by him and update records.
7.10. The Return Branch officer will acknowledge the list received
by him.
8.10. The authority issuing the R.P.O. should maintain a register,
viz., Refund Payment Register (R&RA-7). He should make a
note of R.P.O. number and advice note number in the refund
file, should keep a record of the dealers to whom the R.P.Os.
have been issued by them along with their registration
number and address.
9.10. The authority issuing R.P.O. will also issue advice notes to
the banks simultaneously. Caution should, however, be
taken to ensure that the advice note should reach the banks
before the R.P.O is presented by the dealers bank to the
Reserve Bank of India or State Bank of India for payment.
10.10. Custody and account of RPO and advice notes. The books
of the refund payment orders and the advice notes should
remain in the personal custody of the officers who are to
issue the refund payment orders.
11.10. Accounts of stationery of RPO books and advice note
books. -- The R.P.O. books and advice note books will
hereafter be issued by the stationery cell to the respective
Joint Commissioners. On receipt thereof, an entry of the
book numbers along with voucher numbers therein should
be kept in a register to be maintained for this purpose by the
concerned Joint Commissioner.
12.10. This register and the RPO books / advice note books should
invariably figure in the charge report whenever there is a
change of officer holding the job. It would be in the interest
of the officers themselves to take a receipt from their
5
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
52/80
successor of having handed over the RPO books (both used
and unused), advice note books and register of accounts.
13.10. Inspection of register of R.P. Os and advice notes. -- During
office inspection of any of the officers issuing RPOs and
advice notes, the inspection should invariably cover
verification of the register of RPOs and advice notes to make
sure that it has been correctly and kept up to date and that
the physical stock of RPO books and advice note books tally
with the register.
14.10. Apart from the above, the officers should carry out frequent
check of the RPOs issued, physical stock of unused forms
and uptodateness of the stock register.
15.10. Specimen signatures of refund signing officers.-- The officers
who would hereafter be issuing the refund payment orders
and advice notes should send their specimen signatures to
the Reserve Bank of India, Mumbai, (for officers situated in
Greater Mumbai ) and to the State Bank of India/State Bank
of Hyderabad at the district headquarters/places where the
refund payment orders will ultimately come for
clearance/payment (for officers situated outside Greater
Mumbai ). Whenever there is a change in the incumbency of
any of these posts, the specimen signatures of the newly
appointed officer should immediately be sent to the
concerned banks as mentioned above. For Greater Mumbai,
the work of sending the specimen signatures of refund
signing authority should be centralised in the office of the
Joint Commissioner (Head Quarters-1) and in mofussil the
respective Joint Commissioner.
16.10. Entry of R.P.0. number, date and amount.-- After an R.P.O.
has been issued by the R.P.O. Issuing Authority, entry of the
R.P.O. number, its date and the amount should invariably be
5
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
53/80
made in different places, namely, proceeding sheet of the file
for the relevant period; the Refund Proposal Register and
Refund Payment Register maintained by the Refund
Processing and Issuing Authority, respectively ; order in
Form 502; and the copy of the return or order kept in the
return file of the dealer.
17.10. Scroll to be obtained from Treasury / Banks. It is hereby
clarified that the scrolls including e-scrolls regarding the
paid R.P.O.s should be obtained from the Treasury /Banks
only, which in most of the district places would be the State
Bank of India..
18.10. Separate R.P.O. books for each RPO issuing authority.
For this purpose, it is suggested that the number of R.P.O.
books being used by the Joint Commissioner of Sales Tax
and the Assistant Commissioner of Sales Tax may be
communicated to the Treasury / Bank under a common
letter so that the work of Treasury / Bank for checking also
become simplified. This work should be coordinated by the
concerned Joint Commissioner.
19.10. It is clarified that all RPOs should invariably be sent to the
dealers by the R.P.O. Issuing Authority itself under RPAD
letters.
20.10. Toprevent any misuse of these RPOs, all the RPOs should be
crossed and made A/c payee only by putting an
endorsement A/c payee only on the left hand top corner of
the R.P.O. issued. Further, the amounts should be written,
both in figures and words, in the counterfoils or office copies
apart from Refund Payment Order to be issued to the
dealers.
21.10. The name of bank, branch and account number of dealer is to
be incorporated on the RPO to prevent misuse of RPO.
5
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
54/80
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
55/80
the R.P.O. may be referred to the Joint Commissioner of
Sales Tax (H.Q.-1), Maharashtra State, Mumbai.
25.10. No re-validation of R.P.O.s The R.P.O. should not be
revalidated and no corrections should be carried out in the
same R.P.O. Most of the R.P.O.s would not be encashed only
if they are not presented within three months from the
month of issue of R.P.O. The returned back R.P.O. should be
cancelled by making proper endorsement of cancellation on
the same. After canceling such R.P.O., it should be kept in
the record of the dealer and a note regarding cancellation
should be taken in the remarks column of Refund Proposal
Register and Refund Payment Register. A new Refund
Payment Order should beissued in lieu of the duly cancelled
R.P.O and a fresh entry should be taken in the Refund
Proposal Register and Refund Payment Register. Cross
reference of old entry as well as new entry should be taken
in the remarks column. In the remarks column of oldentry
the endorsement should be cancelled on . . . . . . . . . . . Fresh
R.P.O. issued at Sr.No . . . . .. Similarly, in the remarks
column ofthenew entry, the endorsement should be Issued
in lieu of R.P.O. at Sr. No.
26.10. Necessary endorsement to that effect should also be made in
the following:
(i) proceeding sheet of the file for the relevant period;
(ii) the Movement-cum-Accounts Register maintained by the
Refund Processing and Issuing Authority respectively in the
format given in
(iii) order in Form 502; and the copy of the return or order
kept in the return file of the dealer.
27.10. Partly used R.P.O. Books. Partly used R.P.O. books
containing some blank R.P.O. vouchers should not be used
5
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
56/80
for issue of R.P.O. to the dealers. Unused R.P.O. vouchers in
such books should be cancelled and such books along with
the used R.P.O. books should be returned to the respective
Joint Commissioner. While doing so, a list of R.P.O. books
showing the Sr. No. of vouchers therein should be prepared.
The respective Jt. Commissioner should, in turn, prepare a
list for his division and send these R.P.O. books (both fully
used and also partly used) to the Jt. Commissioner (H.Q.-1) ,
Mumbai along with the list for safe custody.
28.10. Reconciliation of RPOs with banks. -- It is necessary to
carry out periodic reconciliation of the Advice Notes issued
by the various officers and payments as recorded in the bank
(paid Advice Notes). For this purpose, the periodicity of
reconciliation should be a three calendar months i.e. all the
scrolls received for a particular three calendar months
should be examined together. Cases of over payment, if any,
should be immediately investigated.
29.10. The dedicated officer of Pay & Accounts cadre may be
assigned these works. It shall be ensured that the officer
issuing cheque and officer carrying reconciliation shall be
different one.
30.10. To reconcile the paid Advice notes received from Reserve
Bank of India / Treasury, is to be carried out by the
Designated Officer in the office of JCST R&RA.
31.10. Reconciliation of paid advice notes and relevant record
pertaining to the refund claim, is to be verified and
reconciled from following authorities.
Amountas perpaidAdvice
Notes
Refund ProcessingAuthority
Refund SigningAuthority
5
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
57/80
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
58/80
1.13. Form 704 in refundable cases should be collected from the
Business Audit Branch, where the dealer is required to file
the same.
2.13. Desk audit of all Form 704 in refundable cases is to be done.
3.13. Desk audit of cases in which Form 704 is subsequently filed
by the dealer.
4.13. Verify the correctness of the refund claim made with returns
during the period, books of accounts and Form 501.
5.13. If any discrepancy is found, take necessary actions including
business audit of the case with prior approval of Joint
Commissioner.
6.13. Business Audit in refund cases:- If the dealer has filed
application in Form 501 in any period of financial year, then
Refund Audit should be taken for complete financial year.
Form 704 submitted by the dealer to Business Audit Branch
is to be obtained. Desk Audit of all Form 704 is to be
undertaken in comparison with the refunds granted.
7.13. Chapter 6 of Business Audit Manual, is reproduced here for
reference,
6.1 Note: A separate manual has been prescribed for
Refund Audits. The case wherein the dealer has already
filed application in form 501, the audit is to be conducted by
the refund audit branch for whole of the year. The cases
which are selected for business audit and as a result of audit
it is found that the dealer stands to get a refund, that is the
case results in over declaration, in such cases the auditor
while carrying out the business audit shall also apply the
procedure prescribed for the refund audit in refund audit
manual for carrying out the refund audit and thereafter
completing the procedure and coming to the conclusion in
the matter should give such findings in audit form 7. The
5
8/6/2019 Refund & Refund Audit
59/80
dealer may be advised to file the revised return and on such
filing the dealer may file the prescribed form 501 with the
refund audit authorities. The refund audit branch , however
may give the refund on basis of the findings of the Auditor
issued to dealer in form Audit form 7. The refund audit
branch need not again carry out the Audit as prescribed in
their manual. The auditor of business audit branches at end
of each mont