Risk of Autism and Birth Certificate Data:
A Utah Population Based Study
Robert Satterfield1, EpidemiologistJudith P. Zimmerman2, Ph.D.
Shaheen Hossain1, Ph.D. Lynne M. MacLeod1, M.Stat.
Judith Miller2, Ph.D.William McMahon2, MD.
1 Utah Department of Health2 Utah Registry of Autism and Developmental Disabilities
Background
Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitoring Network (ADDM)
Utah Registry of Autism and Developmental Disabilities (URADD)
Special project to study how many individuals with ASDs and developmental disabilities there are in Utah
Public awareness campaign
Self-reporting registry
Background: Impact of ASD
Frequency: Recent increases Severity: Lifelong impairment Identified in all races, ethnic groups, social classes Costs: Significant – $90 billion in 2000* Preventability: Unknown cause but genetics
implicated; other exposures have been blamed Environmental contaminants Vaccines
*Jarbrink K, Knapp M, 2001 London School of Economics, 2001
Other Autism Studies
Male / female ratio varies from 1.33 to 16.0 with a median ratio of 2.55 (mean 3.7)
Cognitive impairment in classic autism – ~80% Less in PDD-NOS Not associated with Aspergers
Seizures: range 4.8-26.4% with a median rate of 16.7%
2006 Israeli study suggests offspring of men 40 years or older were 5.75 times more likely to have ASD
Fombonne, 1999Reichenberg, et. al. 2006
Changing Prevalence
Numerous studies with different methodologies
Pre-1985: 2 cases per 10,000 for classic autism; 4-5 cases per 10,000 for all ASDs
Post-1985: 20-40 cases per 10,000 for classic autism; 34-67 cases per 10,000 for all ASDs
2005: NHIS Autism Estimates 5.7 per 1000
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
Chronological Autism Studies from 1966 - 2003
Adapted from Fombonne, 2001
Utah School Autism Exceptionality Prevalence Data: 1996-2005
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Year
Pre
va
len
ce
pe
r 1
0,0
00
Purpose
To determine the prevalence of ASDs and also to identify potential risk factors related to ASDs
Study Question
Is there an association between certain maternal pregnancy / delivery complications and the risk of autism?
Utah Demographics
Population: 2,358,330
Growth Rate: 7th (1.6% from 2003-04)
Fertility Rate: 1st (2.56 births)
Household Size: 1st (3.13 persons)
Age of Population: 1st (youngest, 27.5 years)
*Pupil/Teacher Ratio: 22.4 (U.S. average 15.9)Governor’s Office of Planning and Budget, *2005 National Center for Education Statistics, 2006
Study Demographics
Utah’s 2002 study year population
Born in 1994
Lived in Davis, Salt Lake, and/or Utah Counties in 2002
Received special education and/or diagnoses associated with ASD and/or cognitive impairment before 12/31/02
Demographics
Number Percentage
State of Utah 38,751
Males 19,991
Females 18,760
100.0%
51.6%
48.4%
Study Area 26,108
Males 13,464
Females 12,644
67.6%
51.6%
48.4%
Salt Lake 14,856 38.3%
Davis 4,423 11.4%
Utah 6,829 17.6%
Methodology
Utah birth certificate and URADD data were used for this study
Data were linked using SAS version 9, with a deterministic followed by probabilistic approach
Performed multivariate logistic analysis
Results
Characteristics Autism Cases Birth Cohort(n=114) (n=26,830)
Male 82.5%** 51.7%
Female 17.5%** 48.3%
Avg. Birth Weight (grams) 3192* 3338
Prenatal Care in 1st trimester 92.0% 86.3%
Avg. Prenatal Care Visits 11.4 10.9
* Significant at <.05** Significant at <.001
Results
Risk Factors Adjusted OR* Confidence Intervals
Breech 2.39 (1.24 - 4.63)
Primary C-Section 1.96 (1.15 - 3.34)
Assisted Ventilation <30 0.36 (0.05 - 2.60)
Assisted Ventilation >30 3.67 (1.42 - 9.48)
* Model controlled for multiple gestations, tobacco use during pregnancy, gestational age, maternal age, maternal education, maternal marital status, and parity
Method of Delivery
MOD Autism Cases % Birth Cohort %
Vaginal 67.5** 80.8
Primary C-Section 20.2** 9.2
Repeat C-Section 5.3* 6.9
VBAC 7.0* 3.0
* Significant at <.05** Significant at <.001
Maternal Characteristics
Characteristics Autism Cases Birth Cohort
Maternal Age (years) 27.2 26.6
Maternal Education (years) 13.8 13.3
Hispanic Origin 4.4% 7.0%
Paternal Characteristics
Characteristics Autism Cases Birth Cohort
Paternal Age (years) 29.3 29.2
Paternal Education (years) 14.2 14.0
Hispanic Origin 4.5% 6.5%
Conclusions
The study found a nearly 5 to 1 autism occurrence in males vs. females (82.5% p < .0001)
Autism cases had significantly higher histories of breech presentation (AOR=2.39 CI 1.24 – 4.63)
Autism cases had significantly higher occurrences of Primary C-section (AOR=1.96 CI 1.15 – 3.34)
Conclusions
Significant differences were found in average birth weight for children with autism compared to the general birth cohort (3192 grams verses 3338 grams, p <.005)
Autism cases had significantly higher occurrences of Assisted ventilation > 30 minutes (AOR=3.67 CI 1.42 – 9.48)
Analyses showed no statistically significant association between risk of autism and parity, number of PNC visit and entry into prenatal care
Implications
Invaluable use of multi-sourced linked data Early identification of risk factors related to
autism may facilitate early intervention and treatment and can significantly improve a child’s development
The recent rise in medial attention on causes of autism, clearly deserve more resources and investigation into these areas
Future direction, Merging with: Hospital Discharge, prescription medication database, Medicaid data
Acknowledgement
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (funded by Cooperative Agreement UR3/CCU822365)
Utah State Office of Education Alpine, Davis, Jordan, Granite, Murray, Nebo, Provo, & Salt Lake
School Districts Utah School for Deaf and Blind University of Utah Hospital and Clinics Intermountain Health Care Valley Mental Health & Carmen B. Pingree School of Autism Wasatch Mental Health & GIANT Steps Autism Program Davis Mental Health & Northern Utah Autism Program The Children’s Center Utah Attorney General’s Office Local Health Departments Utah Department of Health, Office of Vital Records and Statistics
Questions?
Thank You!
Contact Information:
Robert Satterfield, Epidemiologist II
UDOH / CFHS / MCH / DRP
(801) 538-6967