ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 1
Three dichotomies in the Kavalan demonstrative system
Haowen JiangRice University
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 2
Outline
• Intro to the Kavalan language• Kavalan demonstrative system• Dichotomy 1: -zi vs. -zui• Dichotomy 2: yau vs. zau• Dichotomy 3: yau vs. wi• Conclusion
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 3
Outline
• Intro to the Kavalan language• Kavalan demonstrative system• Dichotomy 1: -zi vs. -zui• Dichotomy 2: yau vs. zau• Dichotomy 3: yau vs. wi• Conclusion
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 8
Kavalan people
Hsieh and Huang (2007)
Kavalan Population in Fongbin Township
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 9
Kavalan language• Atayalic (Atayal, Seediq) • East Formosan
– Northern (Basai-Trobiawan, Kavalan) – Central (Amis) – Southwest (Siraya)
• Puyuma• Paiwan• Rukai• Tsouic (Tsou, Saaroa, Kanakanabu) • Bunun• Western Plains
– Central Western Plains (Taokas-Babuza, Papora-Hoanya) – Thao
• Northwest Formosan (Saisiyat, Kulon-Pazeh)• Malayo-Polynesian Blust (1999)
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 11
Outline
• Intro to the Kavalan language• Kavalan demonstrative system• Dichotomy 1: -zi vs. -zui• Dichotomy 2: yau vs. zau• Dichotomy 3: yau vs. wi• Conclusion
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 12
Types of DEMs• Nominal—can occur in an NP with a noun or
pronoun (e.g. “[this stone] is hot”) or, in most languages, can make up a complete NP (e.g. “[this] is hot”).
• Local adverbial—occur either alone (e.g. “put it here”) or with a noun taking local marking (e.g. “put it (on the table) there”)
• Verbal “do it like this”, with an accompanying mimicking action — can occur as the only verb in a predicate, or together with a lexical verb.
Dixon (2003: 62)
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 14
Nominal DEMs• zau, unay/’nay, and wi’u can make up a
complete NP, but yau cannot.
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 15
Nominal DEMs• All nominal demonstratives can occur in an
NP. For zau, yau, and wi’u, a linker is preferably used between the head noun and the demonstrative. For unay/’nay, however, no linker is needed.
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 17
Nominal DEMs• Interestingly, unay, but not yau or wi’u, also
refers to some temporal point away from now, whether in the past or in the future.
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 18
Local adverbial DEMs• Local adverbial demonstratives are
frequently followed by a locative phrase specifying the exact location.
• The following examples are from the same speaker in the same conversation occurring at the same place. Distance from near to far with respect to the speaker: PakteRung > the church or the school > the huge rock.
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 20
Verbal DEMs• Verbal demonstratives are crosslinguistically rare.
“I know of only two languages with verbal demonstratives—Boumaa Fijian and Dyirbal—and in each instance there is just one verb “do it like this” (with transitive and intransitive variants in Dyirbal). Further work may well reveal a language with a contrast between two verbal demonstratives, but I suspect that most languages which show this category will have a single item.”(Dixon 2003: 88)
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 21
Verbal DEMs• Kavalan shows a contrast between two
verbal demonstratives: (s)nazau ‘do/be like this’ and (s)nayau or snaunay ‘do/be like that’.
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 22
Verbal DEMs• Syntactically, Kavalan verbal
demonstratives function as the head of a predicate, whether there is another lexical verb in the same clause or not.
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 24
Verbal DEMs• In terms of functions, Kavalan verbal
demonstratives can be used deictically or anaphorically.
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 25
Outline
• Intro to the Kavalan language• Kavalan demonstrative system• Dichotomy 1: -zi vs. -zui• Dichotomy 2: yau vs. zau• Dichotomy 3: yau vs. wi• Conclusion
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 26
Dichotomy 1: -zi vs. -zui
• ta N-an, maq-N, paqa-N, pasa-N, s-N• -zi ‘this place’; -zui ‘that place’
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 29
Dichotomy 1: -zi vs. -zui• In Li & Tsuchida’s (2006: 513) Kavalan
Dictionary, wis- is listed as a morpheme meaning ‘go to’.E.g. wis-tati or wi s-tati
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 30
Dichotomy 1: -zi vs. -zui• Other lexical items that show the contrast
between -zi and -zui:
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 31
Outline
• Intro to the Kavalan language• Kavalan demonstrative system• Dichotomy 1: -zi vs. -zui• Dichotomy 2: yau vs. zau• Dichotomy 3: yau vs. wi• Conclusion
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 37
Dichotomy 2: zau vs. yau
• For the contrast between (s)nazau ‘do/be like this’ and (s)nayau ‘do/be like that’, please see examples (12-18).
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 38
Outline
• Intro to the Kavalan language• Kavalan demonstrative system• Dichotomy 1: -zi vs. -zui• Dichotomy 2: yau vs. zau• Dichotomy 3: yau vs. wi• Conclusion
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 46
Dichotomy 3: yau vs. wi• Deictic particles in Tokelauan (Oceanic)
also indicate aspect (Hooper 2002). While mai ‘toward speaker’ expresses progressive aspect, atu ‘away from speaker’ expresses inchoative aspect.
• The relationship of nominal demonstratives with existential/locative predicates and tense/aspect markers in other Formosan languages.
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 47
Dichotomy 3: yau vs. wi
• Central Amis: ra ‘that’; ira ‘exist’ (< i-ra‘LOC-that’); a-ira indicates future tense.
(44)
Zeitoun et al. (1999: 23)
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 48
Dichotomy 3: yau vs. wi
• Northern Paiwan: zua ‘that’; izua ‘exist’ (< i-zua ‘LOC-that’); izua-zua indicates progressive aspect.
(45)
Zeitoun et al. (1999: 24)
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 49
Dichotomy 3: yau vs. wi
• Labuan Rukai: kai ‘this’; yakai ‘exist’ (< i-a-kai ‘LOC-REAL-this’); yakaikai indicates iterative aspect.
(46)
Zeitoun et al. (1999: 24)
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 50
Outline
• Intro to the Kavalan language• Kavalan demonstrative system• Dichotomy 1: -zi vs. -zui• Dichotomy 2: yau vs. zau• Dichotomy 3: yau vs. wi• Conclusion
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 51
Conclusion
• Kavalan illustrates all the three types of demonstratives as described in Dixon (2003). While nominal and local adverbial demonstratives show a contrast between three terms, verbal demonstratives make a two-way distinction, with the latter category being typologically rare.
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 52
Conclusion
• Not all nominal demonstratives are created equal: whether a DEM can make up a complete NP, requires a linker when modifying an NP, or can refer to time.
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 53
Conclusion• Three dichotomies are found in the Kavalan
demonstrative system: the contrast between -zi and -zui is primarily manifested in local/directional adverbials; the contrast between zau and yau in demonstrative human pronouns and verbal demonstratives; finally the contrast between yau and wi in their diverse functions, including place deixis, motion predicates, and aspectual auxiliaries.
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 54
Conclusion
• In Formosan languages, it is not unusual for a particular nominal demonstrative to be closely related to existential/locative predicates and tense/aspect markers. In addition to Kavalan, languages like this include Central Amis, Northern Paiwan, and Labuan Rukai. However, Kavalan is unique in using exactly the same form (i.e. yau) across the board.
ICAL-11, 2009 Haowen Jiang 55
Acknowledgements
• Prof Shuanfan Huang• NTU Corpus of Formosan Languages• Kavalan informants abas, api, buya, ngengi,
pilaw