TRENDS AFFECTING SCHOOLS
Challenges and Challenges and opportunities in the quest for excellence and equity
Dr. Dirk Van Damme
OECD – EDU/CERI
Overview
• Trends:– Demography
– Social and cultural changes
Economy and technology– Economy and technology
– Learning societies
• The impact of the crisis
• Conclusions
17 April 2009 2ECIS Conference
Demography
• Falling birth rate…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 3
Demography
• …and increasing life expectancy…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 4
Demography
• …lead to ‘top-heavy’ age structure…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 5
Demography
• …and higher ‘old age dependency ratio’.
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 6
Demography
• And education?– Fewer children, less schools, …: less resources
for education or higher spending per child?
– Rethinking what education should do to prepare young people for ‘long-life’ societies
– Pressures for earlier entry in the labour market and different life-course arrangements of learning and working
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 7
Social and cultural changes
• More people on the move, more diverse populations, …
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 8
Social and cultural changes
• …less stable families…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 9
Social and cultural changes
• …with more single-parent families, …
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 10
Social and cultural changes
• …changing value systems…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 11
Social and cultural changes
• …and consumption patterns…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 12
Social and cultural changes
• …have important educational consequences– How to cope with increasing cultural diversity:
are schools and teachers well prepared?
– Are home-school relations weakening?
– More pedagogical responsibilities for schools and teachers in socialisation and health?
– Has emphasis on self-expression and less deference for authority also consequences for pedagogy, role of teachers and authority of schools?
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 13
Economy and technology
• More global and knowledge-intensive…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 14
Economy and technology
• … with rapidly changing technology…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 15
Economy and technology
• …but also with more insecure jobs…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 16
Economy and technology
• …lead to new demands for education:– Are schools preparing young people for the new
economic environment?
– Are schools themselves innovative enough to support the need for innovation in the economy?
– What kind of new knowledge and skills ( ‘21st C skills’) are needed for the knowledge-intensive economy?
– Are the learning styles of the ‘new millennium learners’ or ‘digital natives’ changing?
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 17
Learning societies• An ‘educational revolution’ has taken place…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 18
Learning societies• …and educational investment is still increasing…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 19
Learning societies• …but there still is room for educational growth…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 20
Learning societies• …and tertiary level participation will continue to rise
Scenario 1 = Status-quo Scenario 2 = Trend
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 21
Learning societies• But outcomes are uneven between countries…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 22
Learning societies• …but even so within countries, especially for
lower-class and immigrant pupils…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 23
Learning societies• …affecting also their opportunities in higher
education…
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 24
Learning societies• …especially in countries where inequalities between
schools (c.q. sorting and selecting) are high.
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 25
Learning societies• But there is no trade-off between excellence and
equity: several countries succeed in achieving both– E.g. Finland, Canada, Japan, Korea
By serving differentiated student populations well– By serving differentiated student populations well
– By avoiding early tracking and high differentiation of school choice
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 26
Learning societies• Will education remain the engine of social
mobility and meritocracy?– Need to offer equal opportunities to all talents
– From ‘pedagogy of failure’ to ‘pedagogy of success’: selection may have been appropriate in educationalselection may have been appropriate in educational systems aimed at producing relatively small elites, but is much less in societies that need to develop all talents
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 27
Learning societies• Need to value diversified talents
– Social selection, upward social mobility, meritocratic functions all value mostly cognitive talents
– Creative, imaginative, innovative elements of education systems often preserved for elitist parts ofeducation systems often preserved for elitist parts of system
– Parents’ expectations often value the more traditional functions and approaches of schooling
– The scientifically enquiring mind is not very different from the creative or imaginative mind
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 28
Learning societies• Women are overtaking men in upper secondary
and higher education attainment.
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 29
Learning societies• And there are more international students.
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 30
Learning societies• Huge investments in ICT in schools…
70
8090
100
Broadband in primary and secondary schools of OECD countries, 2006 or latest available year
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 31
01020
3040506070
Greece
PolandCze
ch R
epublic
Germany
Irelan
dAustr
ia Italy
Portuga
lBelgiumFrance
United K ingdo
mHungary
Luxembourg
SpainSwedenNorw
ayFinlan
dDenmark
Netherlands
US (2005
)
Learning societies• … but schools/teachers are rather slow to innovate
80
90
100
Teachers and pupils in compulsory education who have not used a computer in the classroom in the past 12 months (2006) in EU countries
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 32
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
DK UK NL NO SE AT FI DE CZ IE IS MT IT SK BE LU ES SI CY FR PT PL EE LT HU LV EL
Teachers
Pupils
The impact of the crisis
• Financial/Budgetary impact:– Need for governments to cut low-priority
expenses• Because of higher debt and high-priority spending
– But at the same time more students in schools• Be it not in fee-paying schools• Lower budgets per student?
– And educational institutions in financial difficulties
• Due to loss of fees, endowment income, fundraising
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 33
The impact of the crisis
• Impact on educational demand– ECEC may be affected by unemployment and
lower labour market participation of women– Extended stay in schools of young people not
entering labour market– Shift from private to public schools– Increased enrolment in higher education
(possibly leading to over-schooling)• But enrolment and drop-out could also be affected
by decreasing part-time jobs and weakening student support systems
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 34
The impact of the crisis
• Impact on educational demand– VET may be particularly affected
• Need to tune qualifications to labour market needs
• VET as alternative to unemploymentVET as alternative to unemployment
– Higher demand for adult education in view of re-skilling of the labour force
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 35
The impact of the crisis
• Impact on educational supply– Teacher shortage will decrease and quantity
and quality of teacher training recruitment will improvep
– Educational infrastructure will benefit from stimulus packages
• Opportunity to innovate learning environments
– Less apprenticeships and school-work interactions may lead to less practical training
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 36
The impact of the crisis
• Educational concerns in policy responses– Stimulus packages should include
investments in education
– Education is vital for long-term andEducation is vital for long term and sustainable economic recovery
– Maintaining equity and protecting the most vulnerable is crucial
– Educational innovation is necessary for economic and social innovation
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 37
Conclusion
• What can we learn from the trends?– The ‘educational revolution’ is not finished– New economic, social and cultural demands– Schools and teachers have an even greater g
role to play than before– But their task is becoming increasingly
complex and difficult– And at the same time schools are asked to
become more innovative: ‘more of the same’ will not suffice
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 38
Conclusion
• Which road to follow?– Despite the temptation for mediocrity and
‘laisser-faire’, only educational excellence can help societies to survive
– But excellence should not be confined to the formation of elites: all talents need to be mobilised
– Equity and excellence are no antagonisms– More educational innovation is needed to
counter all challenges
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 39
Resources
• Education Today: the OECD Perspective, 2009
• Trends Shaping Education, 2008 (also as webbook)
• Demand-Sensitive Education? Evidence and Issues, 2006
• Think Scenarios, Rethink Education, 2006
• Personalising Education 2006• Personalising Education, 2006
• Networks of Innovation: towards new models for managing schools and systems, 2003
• What Schools for the Future? 2001
• Learning to Change: ICT in Schools, 2001
• Learning to Bridge the Digital Divide, 2000
• Innovating Schools, 1999.
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 40
Trends Shaping Education –2008 Edition
d i iLes grandes mutations qui transforment l’éducation –Édition 2008
www oecd org/edu/ceri
THANK YOU !
www.oecd.org/edu/ceri
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 42
17 April 2009 ECIS Conference 43