1
UNIVERSIDAD COMPLUTENSE DE MADRID FACULTAD DE BIOLOGÍA
Departamento de Ecología José Antonio Nováis, 12
28004, Madrid, Spain [email protected]
Tel: (34) 91 394 5123 Fax: (34) 91 394 5081
MIGUEL ANGEL CASADO GONZÁLEZ, Profesor Titular del Departamento de Ecología de la Universidad Complutense de Madrid, director de la presente Tesis Doctoral, HACE CONSTAR: Que el trabajo descrito en la presente memoria, titulado “Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo: Comunidades de suelo y efectos del manejo”, ha sido realizado por Dª Sandra Magro Ruiz, dentro del Programa de Doctorado Ecología. Conservación y Restauración de Ecosistemas, adscrito al Departamento de Ciencias de la Vida, de la Universidad de Alcalá. Esta Tesis Doctoral reúne todos los requisitos propios de este tipo de trabajo: rigor científico, aportaciones novedosas y aplicación de una metodología adecuada y que, por lo tanto, tiene mi Visto Bueno para su presentación.
Madrid, 17 de Octubre de 2014
Miguel Ángel Casado González
2
3
UNIVERSIDAD COMPLUTENSE DE MADRID
FACULTAD DE BIOLOGÍA
Departamento de Biología Vegetal I José Antonio Nováis, 2
28004, Madrid, Spain
LUÍS BALAGUER NÚÑEZ, Profesor Titular en el Departamento de Biología Vegetal I de la Universidad Complutense de Madrid, director de la presente Tesis Doctoral, falleció en Madrid el 19 de marzo de 2014. Por lo tanto, yo, MIGUEL ÁNGEL CASADO GONZÁLEZ como director de la presente tesis me comprometo a supervisar la tesis en su totalidad y asimismo, hago constar que: El profesor Balaguer dirigió hasta el momento de su fallecimiento la presente Tesis Doctoral, participando activamente en todas las fases de la misma. Luis confió en la capacidad de Sandra Magro Ruíz para llevar a cabo cada uno de los trabajos que se desarrollan en ésta tesis y mantuvo la ilusión y la certeza de que ésta tesis alcanzaría la calidad suficiente para superar con éxito la etapa de defensa. Sin duda, ésta tesis no habría sido posible sin su perspectiva de futuro, su ilusión y su constante apoyo científico, por lo que solicito que se mantenga como co-director de la misma.
Madrid,17 de Octubre de 2014
Miguel Ángel Casado González
4
5
DEPARTAMENTO DE CIENCIAS DE LA VIDA
Edificio de Ciencias Campus Universitario 28871 Alcalá de Henares
(Madrid) Telf. +34918854927 Fax: +34918854929 E-mail: [email protected]
GONZALO PÉREZ SUÁREZ, Director del Departamento de Ciencias de la Vida de la Universidad de
Alcalá,
HACE CONSTAR:
Que el trabajo descrito en la presente memoria, titulado “Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera
en ambiente mediterráneo: Comunidades de suelo y efectos del manejo”, ha sido realizado por Dña.
Sandra Magro Ruíz dentro del Programa de Doctorado Ecología. Conservación y Restauración de
Ecosistemas (D330) y reúne todos los requisitos necesarios para su aprobación como Tesis doctoral, por
acuerdo del Consejo de Departamento celebrado el día de de 2014.
Alcalá de Henares, de de 2014
Gonzalo Pérez Suárez
6
7
Departamento de Ciencias de la Vida Departamento de Ecología
Unidad Docente de Ecología
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente
mediterráneo: Comunidades de suelo y efectos del manejo
Memoria presentada para optar al grado de Doctor por la Universidad de Alcalá
Programa de Doctorado
“Ecología, Conservación y Restauración de Ecosistemas” (D330)
Sandra Magro Ruíz
Directores:
Miguel Ángel Casado González
Luís Balaguer Núñez
Alcalá de Henares, XXX 2014
8
Esta Tesis Doctoral ha sido financiada por una Beca de
Formación de Profesorado Universitario (FPU–AP2009–
0094), concedida por el Ministerio de Educación, cultura y
Deporte del Gobierno de España. Asimismo, los
experimentos realizados durante el desarrollo de esta tesis
han recibido financiación del proyecto CLEAM AIE-
156/2007 (CENIT 2007/2017) concedido por el Ministerio
de Economía y Competitividad del Gobierno de España; y
del Gobierno Regional de la Comunidad de Madrid, a
través de la Red REMEDINAL2-CM (S2009/AMB-1783)
y el apoyo del proyecto ECONET (CDTI IDI-20120317).
Diseño de Portada: Beatriz Vicente
Dibujos originales:Samdra Magro
9
A mi madre, por el calor
A mi padre, por la fuerza
A mi hermano, por la claridad
Y a Luís, obviamente.
10
11
AGRADECIMIENTOS
Intentar ponerle un punto y final a esta tesis es casi igual de difícil que cerrar una maleta
después de un largo viaje. Mientras haces el último esfuerzo por intentar que todo entre y llegar a
tiempo, los recuerdos se agolpan contra las costuras y, a pesar del desgaste, es imposible no
esbozar una sonrisa y exhalar un suspiro por lo que se acaba y lo que no. Estos últimos años
dando pasos por el mundo científico han supuesto para mí una verdadera metamorfosis, un
cambio de fondo y de forma en que se han reorganizado mis estructuras, he descifrado mis
procesos y mis dinámicas y… Lo que en un principio se planteaba como un chapuzón en los
espacios degradados y la Restauración Ecológica, se ha convertido en un proceso de
Restauración interna que se mantiene activo, que fluye sin más. En este tiempo me he enamorado
cientos de veces de esta carrera y he querido dejarla otras cien. Me he visto descubriéndome
capacidades impesables pipeta en mano, con la americana puesta. He reido frenéticamente por
encontrar un resultado y he llorado todas y cada una de las veces que se apagó la luz. Se me han
puesto los pelos de punta al saber que la ciencia es inmensa, que no sabemos nada, que las
preguntas son infinitas pero que no lo son las respuestas, y que al final esto se trata de observar,
de discutir y construir el pensamiento, lentamente, paso a paso, disfrutando de cada idea que
conseguimos poner después de la anterior y sobre todo de poder vivir para contarlo. La sensación
es tan rica que sé que es esto - de alguna u otra manera - a lo que quiero dedicarme, a construir y
contar historias de lo que pasa en esta Tierra. Pero sin duda, lo más importante de este ciclo que
ni acaba ni empieza, es que me ha permitido encontrarme con grandes espejos en los que
mirarme y aprender. A todos ellos, a cada una de las personas que han contribuido a alumbrar
12
este camino con su luz está dedicada esta sección. Intentaré no dejarme a nadie olvidado pero no
prometo ser breve.
En primer lugar quiero dar las gracias al Grupo de Investigación de Ecología Evolutiva
y Restauración Ecológica de la Universidad Complutense, por acogerme y enseñarme cómo
funciona la ciencia y cómo no. En especial, quiero dar las gracias a mi director, Miguel Ángel
Casado por haber estado al quite y ser el padre adoptivo de esta tesis. Esto no hubiera salido
adelante si tu ayuda, sin tu ojo crítico y tus ánimos. A Iñaki Mola, por la claridad en todo
momento y por el aliento en las horas bajas. Tu sensibilidad extrema y tu diligencia son las
mejores características que se pueden tener. ¡Eres grande compañero! Mil gracias a Adrián
Escudero, por aparecer en el momento justo, por tu cercanía, por el entusiasmo y por toda la
ciencia que llevas dentro y que espero que podamos seguir compartiendo en un futuro. Gracias
infinitas a los Obviously; a mis hermanos de la ciencia Juanma y Rocío, por el campo, los cafés,
los cigarros (activos o pasivos), las sesiones de pizarra y las manos que siempre llegan a tiempo.
A Adri por compartir alegrías y penas de co-granteds. A Ana por echar una mano siempre, por
gestionarnos la vida más de una vez! A Peri porque los abrazos de pasillo son de ida y vuelta,
por tus iluminaciones estadísticas y la paz que me transmites. Y como no, a Agus, porque
conocerte, amiga, ha sido de las mejores cosas de los últimos tiempos. Gracias por las sesiones
de science in pijamas, por ser y estar.
Quiero dar las gracias a la Estación Experimental de Zonas Áridas de Almería (“El
chumbo”), en especial a Paco Pugnaire y Sara Hortal por dejarme participar de sus
experimentos y su mundo científico. También a Nuria, Meire, Carme y Olga por acogerme
13
siempre con una sonrisa y por ser tan espectacularmente buenas científicas. Mucho ánimo
mujeres!! También quiero agradecer al Netherland Institute of Ecology (NIOO KNAW), en
especial a Eiko Kuramae: It was a very big pleasure to work with you, not only during my
internship but also afterwards. You are a really good scientist and a wonderful person. Gracias
Clau, Stef, Kostas, Moli y Paolo por hacer que mi vida en Holanda se haya quedado grabada en
mi ADN para siempre. No sé si hubiera sobrevivido sin vosotros! Mención especial a las Saras
(Sara B y Sara C) por haberos dejado liar tanto, por todo el tiempo y el esfuerzo que habéis
dedicado a esta tesis. Es un gusto haber trabajado con vosotras y veros crecer cada día.
Gracias a mis socios y nuevos compañeros de camino en Creando Redes: Ana, Adri,
Alberto y Jorge. Gracias de verdad por querer construir este proyecto tan bonito que para mi es
vital. Vamos a cambiar el mundo, aunque el resto todavía no lo tenga claro. Pero las gracias se
quedan cortas para expresar mi gratitud hacia Quico Balaguer. Te agradezco infinitamente el
aprendizaje personal y profesional, y el apoyo incondicional. Me alegro mucho de que la vida
nos haya hecho encontrarnos aquí y ahora y que nos mantenga dando pasos en la misma
dirección. Mnhe!
Gracias especiales a mis amigas Viky, Paloma y Bea, por comprenderme siempre
incluso cuando ni yo misma me entiendo, por haber soportado todas mis escapadas de cenicienta
y haberos ajustado a mis agendas de infarto. Por los jueves de arreglar el mundo y los viernes de
arreglarme a mi. Por estar siempre. Porque sois un absoluto tesoro! Os quiero mucho! Gracias
además a Javi, Rodri, Dina, Alba, Sergio, Freiji, Katy, Dani, Irene, Airin, Carmen, Julia,
14
Bárbara, Ange, Dudi, Andrés, Bea y a todos los [+1] que de una u otra manera han particpado
en el proceso
A mis padres, gracias por no haber puesto nunca en tela de juicio mis capacidades y mis
sueños. Gracias por apoyarme siempre incluso cuando es difícil de entender. La fuerza, el
positivismo, la perseverancia y la ilusión por hacer que cada día el mundo sea un poco mejor son
los mejores regalos que habéis podido hacerme nunca! Gracias en especial a Edu, por tener
siempre la palabra indicada para cada momento, por la confianza infinita. Es un orgullo tener una
familia asi!
Y todo acaba donde empieza y siento del todo que no estés hoy en primera fila, con tus
ojos vivos y la sonrisa puesta. Te has ido antes de que acabe la función y eso duele, no te
imaginas cuánto. Es dura la sensación de no saber si conseguí transmitirte la importancia
capital que has tenido en mi vida. De verdad que conocerte ha supuesto un antes y un después
en mi manera de ver el mundo, en mi manera de verme a mi. Gracias por haberme enseñado
tanto, por inspirarme, por las sesiones de trabajo, vino y café. Gracias por haberme llevado de
la mano los primeros pasos de este camino que está aún por recorrer. Prometo seguir volando
alto como siempre, como nos gusta. Nos vemos en la próxima, jefe.
15
“Y cuando la tormenta de arena haya pasado, tú no comprenderás como has
logrado cruzarla con vida. ¡No! Ni siquiera estarás seguro de que la tormenta
haya cesado de verdad. Pero una cosa si quedará clara. Y es que la persona
que surja de la tormenta no será la misma persona que penetró en ella. Y ahí
estriba el significado de la tormenta de arena”
Haruki Murakami
Kafka en la orilla
16
17
ÍNDICE RESUMEN .......................................................................................................................... 19
SUMMARY ......................................................................................................................... 27
CAPÍTULO I:
Introduction and Objectives ............................................................................................. 35
CAPÍTULO II
Soil functionality at the roadside: Zooming in on a microarthropod community in an anthropogenic soil ......................................................................................................... 75
CAPITULO III
Roadside microbes: factors affecting community structure and composition in urban soils from road embankments ............................................................................. 103
CAPITULO IV
Roadside ecosystems: the effect of management on soil functions and microbial community structure ........................................................................................................ 135
CAPÍTULO V
Community ontogeny at the roadside: Critical life‐cycle events throughout a sequential process of primary colonization ................................................................. 175
CAPÍTULO VI
General discussion ............................................................................................................ 205
CONCLUSIONES ........................................................................................................... 223
CONCLUSIONS .............................................................................................................. 229
18
19
RESUMEN
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
20
Resumen
21
Esta Tesis Doctoral estudia el desarrollo de las comunidades biológicas de taludes en
diferentes carreteras de la comunidad de Madrid, así como los efectos de distintas técnicas de
manejo sobre la composición, la diversidad y los procesos ecológicos responsables de la
funcionalidad ecosistémica. El objetivo principal es aportar nuevos conocimientos que permitan
mejorar la efectividad de los esfuerzos de restauración en estos ambientes, de modo que se asista
a la recuperación de las comunidades de suelo, los procesos edafogénicos y el establecimiento de
comunidades de plantas resilientes.
El Capítulo I, de introducción, revisa el estado actual de las investigaciones llevadas a
cabo sobre los efectos de la construcción de carreteras en la composición de las comunidades, su
diversidad y los procesos ecológicos a escala regional y local, así como las aproximaciones
utilizadas para la compensación de dichos efectos en la cuenca Mediterránea.
Los capítulos II y III analizan las comunidades de microartrópodos y bacterias en suelos
de origen antrópico presentes en terraplenes de carretera. Se ha prestado especial atención a estas
comunidades de suelo ya que están implicadas en procesos ecológicos básicos que determinan el
desarrollo y el mantenimiento a largo plazo de los ecosistemas terrestres. En concreto, el
Capítulo II analiza las comunidades de microartrópodos edáficos en terraplenes de carretera así
como los factores que determinan la variación en la composición de estas comunidades. Además
se evalúa la funcionalidad de suelo utilizando estas comunidades de invertebrados como
indicador. Con este fin, se seleccionaron seis terraplenes construidos en 2004 en los cuales se
extendió tierra vegetal tras su construcción, y que fueron estudiados durante dos años (2009 y
2010). En cada terraplén se tomaron muestras de suelo de las que se extrajeron los
microartrópodos edáficos y en las que se evaluaron las propiedades físico-químicas del suelo.
Además se tomaron sondas de suelo para determinar su estructura. El índice de Calidad
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
22
Biológica del Suelo (QBS) fue calculado para cada muestra usando la información relativa a la
composición de la comunidad de microartópodos.
Nuestros resultados mostraron que estas comunidades están dominadas por Ácaros y
Colémbolos. Sin embargo, observamos que la composición de la comunidad de artrópodos varió
en el espacio y en el tiempo desde comunidades caracterizadas por una mayor abundancia de
ácaros Actinédidos, Gamásidos y Acarídidos, grupos primocolonizadores o de hábitos más
generalistas, hacia otras comunidades dominadas por Oribátidos (Ácaros) y Sinfipleones
(Colémbolos), ambos sensibles a las perturbaciones y ligados a condiciones edáficas estables.
Los cambios en la composición observados durante el periodo de estudio fueron debidos
fundamentalmente a variaciones en el contenido de material orgánica, el contenido en arcillas y
la humedad del suelo. Además, los valores de QBS obtenidos para los suelos de terraplenes de
seis años de antigüedad mostraron que la funcionalidad en estos suelos es, en algunos casos,
comparable a la observada en sistemas Mediterráneos naturales con coberturas de vegetación
leñosa. Este es el resultado principal de este estudio y sugiere que, en paralelo al desarrollo de la
comunidad de plantas, la consolidación de suelos totalmente funcionales en taludes de carretera
es un proceso clave para el mantenimiento de sistemas auto-sostenibles, capaces de albergar la
diversidad local y la provisión de servicios ecosistémicos como el control de la erosión y la
integración estética en zonas urbanas.
El Capítulo III estudia las comunidades bacterianas de terraplenes de carretera así como
los factores que determinan el desarrollo de estas comunidades y su organización espacial. Para
ello se seleccionaron cuatro terraplenes de carretera: dos en Barajas, cerca del aeropuerto
internacional y que fueron construidos en 2004, y dos en El Molar, construidos en 2007 y 2008.
En todos los terraplenes se extendió una capa de tierra vegetal tras su construcción y se aplicaron
Resumen
23
mezclas comerciales de hidrosiembra. En cada terraplén, se analizaron las propiedades físico-
químicas y la estructura del suelo, así como la composición y diversidad de las comunidades
bacterianas, usando técnicas de pirosecuenciación. Los resultados mostraron que las
comunidades de bacterias de terraplenes poseen unos niveles de diversidad similares a los
observados en otros suelos de origen antrópico como suelos agrícolas de Europa, tal y como
muestran otros estudios. Estas comunidades de bacterias están dominadas por Actinobacterias,
Acidobacterias, y Planctomicetos, relacionados con la dinámica de la materia orgánica del suelo
e indicadores de condiciones edáficas estables. También se encontraron abundancias relativas
bajas de Cianobacterias, Bacteroidetes, Gemmatimonadetes y Firmicutes, que indican procesos
de sucesión secundaria en estos taludes desde que fueron construidos. La composición de la
comunidad bacteriana varió entre terraplenes y los principales factores relacionados con este
cambio fueron el pH y la textura del suelo (contenido en arcillas y arenas).
Los siguientes capítulos describen los efectos de distintas técnicas convencionales usadas
en la restauración y mantenimiento de taludes de carretera. El Capítulo IV evalúa el efecto de
las siegas, la aplicación de fertilizantes y la adición experimental de biomasa sobre la
composición y la diversidad de las bacterias del suelo, así como sobre la descomposición de la
hojarasca y la disponibilidad de fases minerales de nitrógeno en el suelo. Este experimento fue
desarrollado en los mismos terraplenes estudiados en el Capítulo III, en cada uno de los cuales se
establecieron las parcelas experimentales. Los resultados mostraron que los ecosistemas de
taludes de carretera son sensibles a las perturbaciones, lo que se traduce en una alternación
rápida y significativa tanto de la estructura de las comunidades bacterianas como de los procesos
ecológicos del suelo. Específicamente, la adición de biomasa y la aplicación de fertilizantes
afectaron la diversidad y la composición de las comunidades de bacterias, mientras las siegas
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
24
modificaron las condiciones físico-químicas de suelo y la tasa de descomposición de hojarasca.
El hecho de que tanto la estructura como la función de la comunidad no se vean afectadas
simultáneamente por el mismo tratamiento puede estar relacionado con atributos de la
comunidad del suelo como la redundancia o plasticidad funcional.
Por último, en el Capítulo V, se analizan los procesos de primocolonización y
ensamblaje de comunidades en un desmonte de carretea, de exposición sur, con una pendiente
superior al 40% y donde no se han aplicado técnicas de manejo convencional de manera previa a
nuestro estudio. Los filtros ambientales de tipo abiótico como la disponibilidad de agua y
nutrientes, así como la disponibilidad de lugares aptos para la retención de semillas y el
reclutamiento, son los principales factores que determinan el desarrollo de las comunidades de
plantas en desmontes de carretera. Por ello, en este capítulo se describe un experimento en que
esto filtros han sido manipulados mediante la aplicación de dos tratamientos diferentes:
extendido de tierra vegetal y escarificación de la superficie del talud. Además se establecieron
parcelas control donde no se aplicó ningún tipo de tratamiento. El efecto de los tratamientos se
analizó sobre la disponibilidad de semillas (en el banco de semillas de suelo y en la lluvia de
semillas proveniente de la matriz circundante), sobre la emergencia y supervivencia de plántulas,
así como sobre la riqueza de especies y la cobertura vegetal total durante los años 2010 y 2011.
Los resultados mostraron que el extendido de tierra vegetal facilitó el ensamblaje temprano de la
comunidad de plantas en desmontes mediante la mejora del contenido de nutrientes, el pH, la
textura del suelo y la estabilidad de sustrato. Además, este tratamiento favoreció la emergencia
de un mayor número de especies y la supervivencia de plántulas lo que se tradujo en mayores
niveles de riqueza y cobertura en la comunidad durante los dos años siguientes a la construcción
de la carretera. A pesar de no haber observado un efecto del escarificado sobre la disponibilidad
Resumen
25
de semillas, la emergencia o la supervivencia de plántulas, la escarificación de la superficie del
desmonte en combinación con la aplicación de tierra vegetal aumentó la riqueza de especies en la
zona alta del desmonte al final del experimento, en 2011.
En conclusión, nuestros resultados mostraron que las condiciones edáficas locales
relacionadas con la materia orgánica, el pH, la textura y la estructura del suelo son en gran parte
responsables de la organización de las comunidades de suelo y de los procesos de sucesión
secundaria en taludes de carretera. Además, la aplicación de técnicas de manejo convencional
orientadas a la mejora de las condiciones abióticas de desmontes facilitó el re-ensamblaje de la
comunidad vegetal. Sin embargo, otras técnicas como la aplicación de fertilizantes o las siegas
que han sido usadas tradicionalmente para el mantenimiento y restauración de taludes, inducen
cambios significativos en las comunidades de suelo, homogeneizándolas y favoreciendo una
mayor abundancia de grupos asociados con baja disponibilidad de recursos. Asimismo, estas
técnicas afectaron la funcionalidad del suelo acelerando la descomposición de la hojarasca.
Teniendo en cuenta que los cambios en las comunidades de suelo pueden afectar a las
comunidades de plantas y vice versa, nuestros resultados deberían ser considerados durante el
proceso de selección de técnicas de manejo y restauración de taludes de carreteras de cara a
mantener los servicios ecosistémicos que estos sistemas pueden proveer. En base a los resultados
obtenidos, las técnicas de manejo empleadas deben ir orientadas a la mejora de las condiciones
edáficas en los primeros momentos tras la construcción del talud, y después deben asegurar y
promover la estabilidad del suelo que permita que se verifiquen procesos de sucesión secundaria
y el desarrollo de este tipo de ecosistemas.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
26
27
SUMMARY
28
Summary
29
This Doctoral Thesis studies the development of biological communities in roadslopes
from different highways in Madrid, as well as the effects of varying management techniques on
the composition, diversity and ecological processes that are in turn responsible for ecosystem
functionality. The goal is to provide new insight and knowhow to improve the effectiveness of
efforts to assist the recovery and reassembly of soilborne biota, pedological processes, and
resilient plant communities in these highly perturbed settings.
Following an introductory chapter, chapters II and III of the thesis analyze
microarthropod and bacterial communities in heavily disturbed, anthropogenic soils, or
Anthrosols in roadside embankments. These topics were given priority in the thesis in view of
the importance of these soilborne communities in basic soil processes that underlie long term
development and resilience of terrestrial ecosystems. Specifically, Chapter II analyzes
microarthropod communities in road embankments as well as factors determining community
composition. Moreover, soil functionality is evaluated using microarthropod communities as an
indicator. In the present study, six road embankments constructed in 2004 were selected and
studied over two years (2009-2010). After construction, all embankments were covered by with a
layer of topsoil that had been collected at the site, and preserved. On each road embankment soil
samples were collected, microarthopods were extracted, and physico-chemical soil properties
were measured. Additionally, soil structure was analyzed by means of extracted soil cores. The
well-known QBS index (Biological Soil Quality) was obtained for each soil sample using
information related to microarthropod community composition.
Our results showed that microarthropod communities from these road embankments were
dominated by Acari and Collembola. However, we observed a transition between pioneer
communities in which Actinenida, Gamasida and Acaridida (Acari) are more abundant to other
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
30
communities characterized by higher abundances of Brachypilina (Oribatida; Acari) and
Symphypleona (Collembola) both indicative of stable soil conditions and sensitive to disturbance.
Changes in soil community composition between sites after two years were mostly explained by
changes in organic matter content, clay content, and soil humidity. Furthermore, QBS index
values obtained from the six-year old road embankments studied showed that soil functionality
in these settings was in some cases comparable to that observed in other, much longer
established Mediterranean natural systems such as woodlands and scrublands. This is a major
result of the study, and suggests that along with plant community assembly, consolidation of a
fully functional soil may be an important key to successful roadside restoration toward self-
sustaining and resilient ecosystems that harbor biodiversity and provide direct ecosystem
services such as erosion control and aesthetic values in urbanized areas.
In Chapter III, studies on bacterial communities in anthrosols from the road
embankments under study are presented, as well a discussion of the factors underlying soil
community development with regards spatial organization and changes in community
composition and diversity over time. To this end, four embankments were selected: two sites
from Barajas constructed in 2004, and two sites from El Molar constructed in 2007 and 2008,
respectively. In all embankments, a topsoil layer was spread after construction. On each
embankment soil samples were studied with respect to physicochemical properties, bacterial
community composition and diversity (using pyrosequencing techniques). Results showed that
bacterial communities from these anthrosols had diversity levels similar to those observed in
other anthropogenic soils, namely European agricultural soils, as reported in other studies. Soil
bacterial communities were dominated by Actinobacteria, Acidobacteria, and Planctomycetes,
all groups related with organic matter dynamics in soil and indicative of soil stable conditions.
Summary
31
Relatively low abundances of Cyanobacteria, Bacteroidetes, Gemmatimonadetes, and Firmicutes
were also observed, which indicates that secondary succession processes are taking place in these
anthrosols since the roadslopes were artificially constructed and then covered with topsoil.
Differences in bacterial community composition were observed between sites. The driving
factors underlying this pattern were found to be soil pH and soil texture (clay and sand content).
The next two chapters of the thesis describe the effects of different commonly used
techniques employed to restore and maintain roadside ecosystems. Chapter IV evaluates the
effect of mowing, fertilizing, and also experimental biomass addition, on the composition and
diversity of soil bacterial communities, and on ecological processes such as rate of litter
decomposition and soil nutrient availability, especially nitrates and ammonium. This experiment
was carried out in the same four road embankments studied in Chapter III, in each of which
experimental plots were set up. Results revealed that roadside ecosystems are sensitive in their
response to treatments with both bacterial community structure and processes being rapidly and
significantly affected. In particular, biomass addition and fertilization affected diversity and
community composition, while mowing affected soil properties and litter decomposition. The
fact that neither structure nor function was affected under the effect of a given treatment may be
related to bacterial community attributes such as functional plasticity or redundancy.
Finally, Chapter V analyzes primary colonization and early community assembly in a
south-oriented roadcut constructed in 2008 with slope greater than 40%, and where no
management techniques were applied prior to our investigations. Abiotic filters such as water
and nutrient availability, as well as the abundance of safe-sites for incoming seeds and
propagules are the main constraints for plant community development in this kind of relatively
harsh environment. Thus, in this chapter we describe an experiment in which we manipulated
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
32
abiotic filters through the application of two different treatments, namely topsoil spreading and
shallow tillage. We also set up control plots. Specifically, we analyzed the effect of treatments on
seed availability (both soil seed bank and seed rain), seedling emergence, and seedling survival,
as well as their effects on plant community attributes such as species richness and plant cover
from 2010 to 2011. Results showed that topsoil spreading facilitated early community assembly
by improving soil properties in term of nutrients, pH, soil stability, and texture. Additionally, it
favored the emergence of higher species and improved seedling survival, with further
consequences on plant community richness and cover. This treatment also increased species
recruitment over two years after road construction. Although there was no effect of tillage on
seed availability, emergence, and survival, by the end of the experiment in 2011, it appeared that
this treatment had increased plant species richness on the upper-slope zone.
In conclusion, our results showed that local soil conditions mainly related with organic
carbon, pH, soil texture, and structure, were in large part responsible for the organization of soil
communities and secondary succession processes on roadside sites undergoing restoration in our
study area. Moreover, the application of conventional techniques oriented to overcome abiotic
filters through the improvement of soil conditions did facilitate plant community reassembly.
However, other management techniques that have been traditionally used in roadslope
engineering and restoration, such as fertilization and mowing, significantly changed soil
community structure, by increasing evenness and the abundance of certain groups related to low
resource availability; they also affected functionality, by accelerating biodegradation of leaf
litter. Given that changes in belowground communities may also induce changes in aboveground
communities and vice versa, our results should be taken into account when selecting
management techniques in order to ensure the maintenance of the ecosystem services that these
Summary
33
‘young’ or emerging ecosystems are expected to provide. Based on our results, conventional
management techniques applied in roadside systems should be oriented to improve soil
conditions after roadslope building, and aim to preserve and promote soil stability in the
subsequent stages in order to ensure secondary succession processes and ecosystem
development.
34
35
CAPÍTULO I
Introduction and Objectives
Este capítulo reproduce parcialemente el manuscrito
Understanding Mediterranean roadside ecosystems to increase restoration
success: A review. (En preparación)
36
Capítulo I
37
Changes in land use due to human activities have been described as one of the main
drivers of ecosystem degradation (Foley et al. 2005). The huge transformation in ecosystem
attributes gave rise to the term Anthropocene (Crutzen 2002), defining a new era beginning 1800
with the industrial revolution. Since the mid 20th century, and as a result of the rapid growth in
the human population, the consequences of human activities on land transformation have
intensified (Steffen et al. 2007). In particular, earth works associated with the development of
road networks, that aim to satisfy the needs of social connection and economic development
(Coffin 2007), is today one of the principal geomorphological agents, even more important than
natural relief-modeling forces (Hooke et al. 2012). Despite the unquestionable benefits of road
network growth from a social perspective, road construction is associated with the
transformation and, in many cases, destruction of natural systems.
The effects of road construction are obvious across-scale, with direct consequences on the
abiotic and biotic components of ecosystems. At a landscape scale, road construction contributes
to fragmentation which, depending on the area of the land fragments, may be associated with a
rapid decrease in habitat quality with dramatic biodiversity loss (Forman & Alexander 1998).
Moreover, fragmentation has a direct effect on landscape connectivity limiting or impeding
dispersal processes, which in turn jeopardizes the persistence of species, populations and
communities in the short term (Marcantonio et al. 2013). This paradigmatic set up is currently
being revised as recent studies have highlighted the existence of parallel positive effects of roads
under specific conditions. For example, roadsides can act as shelter for a number of native
species in severely altered environments (Tikka et al. 2000). They also function as corridors
facilitating the movement of species and connecting different habitat patches (Haddad et al.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
38
2003). These areas can play a key role in metapopulation and metacommunity dynamics by
boosting stepping-stone processes (Deckers et al. 2005).
At a local scale, road construction creates new rectilinear landforms much different from
equilibrium reliefs, in which natural drainage networks tend to develop quickly. Thus, during the
first months or years after road construction, geomorphic processes are highly relevant.
Specifically, on roadcuts, steep slopes with smooth and compacted surfaces, coupled with the
absence of vegetation, generate vast areas that are highly exposed to erosion (Andrés et al. 1996),
which results in sediment emission to road drainage systems. On the other hand, road
embankments are constructed by aggregate and foreign materials that confer particular features
to roadslope substrates such as specific granulometry related to project demands (Alfaya 2013),
poor in nutrients with high pH levels (Lehmann & Stahr 2007). These newly created
environments may also favor the establishment of new plant community assemblages, usually
including alien species that more easily access limiting resources and rapidly spread in the
absence of strong competitive processes exerted by native species (Hansen & Clevenger 2005;
Hobbs et al. 2009). Other local effects are derived from road operations such as ditch-cleaning,
seasonal mowing to increase visibility and reduce fire risk, re-grading and other disturbance
regimes, which set back succession to early developmental stages (Forman & Alexander 1998;
Spooner 2005). The effect of these common practices has not been studied in depth despite their
implications in ecosystem structure and functionality. Moreover, road traffic also contributes to
local impacts through roadkills (which in turn affects road security) and the increase in pollutants
(Clavenger et al. 2003; Forman et al. 2002).
Social perception about the consequences of road construction on human well-being has
contributed to the development of lines of research and environmental policies oriented toward
Capítulo I
39
compensating for possible impacts. Regarding landscape scale impacts, the first studies about
fragmentation were carried out in the United States and Europe in the 1970’s. These studies
contributed to prioritizing the construction of animal crossing structures to favor connections
between patches (Coffin 2007 and references there in). At the same time, a huge battery of
techniques aimed to compensate for local effects emerged. These measures were largely
influenced by agronomy and forestry and were principally focused on meeting geotechnical
demands (substrate stabilization and erosion control) by the establishment of a dense vegetation
cover. Hydroseeding, plantings, fertilizing application, mulches, and other so-called
bioengineering techniques have been used to this end.
All of these approaches later arrived in the Mediterranean countries where the urgency
for curbing the impacts of rapid development forced technicians to use the same integration
measures that were developed in northern countries, pursuing the same goals related to
exploitation risks and overcoming geotechnical constraints. However, Mediterranean ecosystems
differ from those in northern Europe. Mediterranean ecosystems have been historically shaped
by human activities such as agriculture, livestock and the effects of fire (Naveh 1974). These
perturbation dynamics along with Mediterranean climatic conditions characterized by summer
drought (Aschman 1973), have given rise to nutrient-poor soils exposed to wind and water
erosion processes (Pausas & Vallejo 1999). The particular climate and the long history of land-
use changes in the Mediterranean Basin have given rise to rich plant communities dominated by
annual species that are highly dynamic over time (Figueroa & Davy 1991). Hence, there is some
uncertainty associated with the application of conventional integration measures, given their lack
of adaptation to the local environment. Moreover, these measures are associated with low costs
of design but high investment in material implementation. Some decades after their first
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
40
implementation, the new economic and ecological context increased the need to review the
effectiveness of these integration practices under Mediterranean conditions. Furthermore, the
growing field of research developed around road ecology offers a good opportunity to reinterpret
roadside restoration directly tackling causes of degradation, suggesting scientifically-based
approaches oriented to the recovery of ecological processes and ecosystem functionality and
ensuring the efficient environmental integration of transport infrastructures.
The purpose of this introduction is to present the state of art of restoration measures
developed in the Mediterranean Basin, to analyze how conventional solutions perform under
Mediterranean conditions. We attempt to identify new knowledge frontiers to advance a more
ecological interpretation of these newly created environments and thus, more successful
restoration approaches. Conclusions from this review may also be applicable in other
Mediterranean regions, which share not only climatic characteristics but also highly diverse
biological communities that must be considered in the development phase of new road
restoration approaches. Thus, the first section of the introduction provides a synopsis of the
effects of roads at a landscape scale, considering how road construction affects animal behavior
and the effectiveness of defragmentation measures aimed at favoring connectivity, including the
effect of roads in plant dispersal. The second section deals with the available information of local
effects of road construction and the effectiveness of the measures that have been taken to
compensate for them. Since plant cover has been identified as a key element to control erosion
and trigger ecosystem development in these environments, the effects of environmental factors
and processes limiting plant community development in roadside ecosystems are addressed in
this section. We place special emphasis on the importance of seed availability and site limitations
(abiotic and biotic) in which the suitability of current techniques oriented to re-vegetation are
Capítulo I
41
also reviewed. We include other local effects derived from road operations such as roadkills or
the effect of pollutants generated by traffic. The final section discusses the importance of
considering a more ecological point of view in the restoration of roadside ecosystems as well as
the lines of research that would contribute to the recovery of ecosystem functionality and
provision services in these environments. The studies cited in the introduction were selected
using a systematic review of the literature related to roadslopes (roadcuts and road
embankments) or roadverges, specifically looking for those dealing with defragmentation,
connectivity, seed dispersal and restoration measures. Scientific papers published in international
journals related to ecological theory and technical approaches, as well as the very few
dissertation theses developed on roadside restoration, were considered.
Research and approaches to compensate large scale effects
Fragmentation and connectivity
Roads have been described as one of the main barriers to animal movements in
Mediterranean landscapes (Velasco et al. 1995). However, this effect appears to be context
dependent. For instance, Brotons and Hernando (2001) showed a general decrease in forest bird
species with road proximity, although the intensity of this effect varied depending on the
previous degree of fragmentation of forest habitat close to the road (Silva et al. 2012). This effect
of road proximity on bird breeding also depends on the species considered (Peris & Pescador
2004). Moreover, road proximity may affect not only community structure and connectivity but
also the genetic diversity and physiological status of individuals, which compromises their
fitness, as well as the long-term maintenance of populations (Grilo et al. 2012; Navarro-Castilla
et al. 2014).
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
42
To improve the connectivity between animal populations and compensate for these
negative effects, different crossing structures have been designed and constructed (Rosell &
Velasco 1999). At the same time, a relatively large field of research has developed around the
efficiency of these structures to restore animal movements. The efficiency of wildlife structures
is mainly determined by the species considered, width of the passages, animal behavior and
seasonality (Jacques et al. 1982; Vassant et al. 1993a, 1993b). In this sense, both engineered
wildlife passages (specific crossing structures constructed for animal crossing) and non-wildlife
passages (general structures associated with road construction such as culverts, drainages, etc.)
are used by animals of different size, suggesting that the adaptation of functional structures of the
road could be a cost effective measure to ensure animal connectivity (Mata et al. 2003). Most
species show preferences among crossing structures, and special attention should be paid to those
species that are especially reluctant to use the passages when the crossing areas are designed
(Grilo et al. 2010; Mata et al. 2005; Mata et al. 2008). Seasonal variability is related to an
individual's activity period, microclimatic conditions and plant cover at the entrance of crossing
structures, although traffic intensity of the road can also affects the use of crossing structures
(Mata et al. 2009; Serronha et al. 2013, Villalva et al. 2013).
After ten years of research, it is clear that there is some bias in the analysis of
fragmentation due to the fact that almost all studies are focused on terrestrial vertebrates.
Moreover, most of the studies reviewed showed that the effectiveness of crossing structures are
context- or species-dependent, and this measure does not seem to be useful in counteracting the
effect of roads as barriers for animal movements. Thus, to increase a company's awareness of the
importance of incorporating animal ecology into road plans and design is the first step toward a
Capítulo I
43
more efficient integration of infrastructure that ensures animal population connectivity and
sustainability (Ruiz-Capillas et al. 2013b).
There are also some studies that highlight the positive effect of road verges as shelters or
corridors for fauna and flora in Mediterranean countries. In severely transformed agricultural
lands, road verges tend to preserve remnants of natural vegetation that offer refuge and food
resources, especially for small mammals (Ascensão et al. 2012; Barrientos & Bolonio 2009;
Planillo & Malo 2013; Ruiz-Capillas et al. 2013a; Sabino-Marques et al. 2011) and may serve as
reservoirs for endangered species (Pita et al. 2006). Changes in animal behavior triggered by the
presence of roads can produce a cascade effect leading to the reconfiguration of food webs, in
which some prey are favored and some predators are excluded by direct competition (Ruiz-
Capillas et al. 2013c). The shelter effect was also visible in roadside plant communities, although
the capacity of roadslopes to preserve populations of endangered plant communities seems to be
context dependent (Filibeck et al. 2011).
Road verges also served as corridors for alien plant and animal species. Research
developed in the Canary Islands showed that road construction strongly alters microclimatic
conditions favoring the rapid spread of alien species in the surroundings closest to the road edges
(Arévalo et al. 2008, Delgado et al. 2013), depleting native species richness and homogenizing
community composition at a local scale (Arévalo et al. 2010). The corridor function of roads for
alien species is mostly related to stress gradients, in which resource availability rather than
competitive interactions or exclusion by native ruderal species promotes higher abundances of
alien species (Arévalo et al. 2005). These stress gradients are related to altitude, with invasive
species more likely to dominate plant communities at intermediate elevations (Otto et al. 2014).
However the potential of these linear infrastructures as conduits for these types of species often
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
44
depend on their proximity to urban areas (Arteaga et al. 2009). Moreover, new plant assemblages
that characterize roadside vegetation also have an effect on mutualistic relationships among
species. In this sense, plant communities modify ecosystem features with further effects on the
relative abundance of other plants and animal communities (Martínez & Wool 2006; Rotholz &
Mandelik 2013). Habitat provided by roadside ecosystems simultaneously affects animal and
plant communities, not only within road verges, but having further effects on surrounding
habitats and diversity. For this reason, roadside restoration plans should take into account this
source/sink and corridor function, orienting restoration efforts to maintain biodiversity, reduce
invasive species establishment and promote connectivity and landscape continuity with adjacent
areas.
Seed dispersal processes
Although the study of large scale effects of roads have primarily focused on animal
communities and their connectivity, recent work has developed on the effects of dispersal
processes in roadside reclamation under Mediterranean climatic conditions. Some studies
highlight the importance of surrounding vegetation as a reservoir for species susceptible to the
colonization of roadside areas (Tormo 2007). Anemochores species are more likely to arrive in
these environments during primary succession. However, to leave roadslope colonization in the
"hands of passive restoration", remnants of natural vegetation in the nearby surroundings are
necessary (Bochet et al. 2007b). Likewise, the availability of these seed sources and the
occurrence of dispersal processes will strongly depend on the spatial structure of surrounding
vegetation as well as the historical land use that had shaped plant dispersal traits and animal
communities, especially for zoochorus species, at a landscape scale (De Torre 2014;
Capítulo I
45
Marcantonio et al. 2013). Although seed dispersal does not seem to be an important process in
constraining roadside revegetation (Mola et al. 2011), dispersal limitations associated with the
quality of the surrounding patches and dispersal vectors may affect plant community
composition in these ecosystems (García-Palacios et al. 2011b).
Research and approaches to compensate for local scale effects
Plant community development
It is well known that the effects of road construction usually exceed the limits of the road
itself (Forman & Alexander 1998). However, most of the studies developed in the Mediterranean
Basin have focused on local scale effects and specifically on the processes affecting plant
community development in these environments. Plant colonization is fundamental to roadside
restoration because it is widely accepted that vegetation plays an important role in the
stabilization of motorway slopes (Andrés et al. 1996; Andrés & Jorba 2000; Cerdá 2007).
Although in the beginning, most work was related to the factors limiting the establishment of an
unspecific plant cover meeting the goal of erosion control, more and more studies attempt to go
further in our understanding of the processes underlying functionality of roadside ecosystems.
By doing this, our capacity to improve ecological restoration and to enhance the environmental
services that these scenarios can provide has increased. In this section, we present the main
processes constraining the development of plant communities in roadslopes and the ecological
filters that species must overcome. The picture is completed with the effect of other factors
derived from road traffic on plant communities.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
46
Seed availability
The first barrier to successful plant colonization is in-site seed availability. This limitation
for colonization was traditionally ensured by hydroseeding applications as an easy way to obtain
high vegetation cover in the short term (Merlin et al. 1999). After many years of using this
technique without a clear sense of its efficiency, some lines of research were promoted by private
companies to fill this gap in knowledge (Andrés, Jorba and García-Fayos, Com. Pers). The first
results highlighted that hydroseeded species do not perform better than those from the
surroundings (Matesanz et al. 2006) and even more importantly, that successful hydroseeded
species are usually grasses that provide poor ground cover with little contribution to erosion
control (Tena 2006). This failure is partially associated with the fact that hydroseeding mixtures
commonly include non-native species unadapted to Mediterranean conditions. For this reason,
some studies have tested the suitability of enriching hydroseeding mixtures with native species.
Generally, the inclusion of native species in sowing mixtures significantly improves plant cover
and richness in Mediterranean roadslopes (Bochet et al. 2010b; Katritzidakis et al, 2007; Martin
et al. 2002; Matesanz & Valladares 2007). Moreover, Estaún and colleagues (2007) found that
the performance of hydroseeding mixtures improves with the inoculation with arbuscular
mycorrhizal fungi favoring plant establishment and growth. Unfortunately, and despite the fact
that this technique has been widely used in this region, recent works indicate the low value of
this revegetation technique. On the one hand, it does not improve site conditions or soil
processes (García-Palacios et al. 2010). On the other, and in relation to the capacity of
hydroseeded species to “kidnap” succession, it conditions plant community composition in the
long term and impedes the establishment of other late-arrival species (García-Palacios et al.
2010; Matesanz & Valladares 2007; Zelnik et al. 2010).
Capítulo I
47
Likewise, the topsoil removed during the first stages of linear infrastructure construction
is a valuable resource for roadside restoration as it is expected to preserve original seed and
propagule banks (Balaguer 2002). However, the very few studies considering the positive effect
of spreading topsoil on plant community development in Mediterranean roadslopes, found that
effects were not related with soil seed banks (Mola et al. 2011; Tormo et al. 2007). These
findings are related to the fact that typical topsoil management strongly affects the viability of
seeds and the ability to recruit from seed bank sources (Rivera et al. 2012b). Hence, if seed
availability mostly depends on seed rain and propagules provided by surrounding vegetation,
restoration actions should prioritize the maintenance or recovery of sustainable rich plant
communities near roadslopes. Thus, in order to optimize biodiversity in roadslopes, management
techniques should be oriented to ensuring succession and the establishment of later-arrival
species.
Abiotic filters
In parallel, many works have highlighted the importance of environmental filters as main
constraints to plant community development on roadslopes (Alborch et al. 2003; Mola et al.
2011; Tormo et al. 2006). These filters are especially important in roadcuts and are directly
related to construction features such as soil compaction, steep slopes, smooth surfaces or aspect
(Bochet et al. 2009; Bochet et al. 2010a; Bochet & García-Fayos; 2004; Cano et al. 2002;
Navarro 2002; Tormo et al. 2009). Given that Mediterranean areas are subjected to strong
seasonal variability characterized by torrential rains and summer drought (Romero et al. 1998),
roadslope surfaces are highly exposed to runoff and erosive events, which in turn contribute to
sediment and nutrient loss. Moreover, runoff decreases water permeability and availability for
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
48
plants, which has been described as the main constraint for seed germination with further effects
on plant community composition and structure (Bochet et al. 2007a; Tormo et al. 2008).
Other studies reinforce the importance of plant-soil relationships in early successional
stages in roadslopes (García-Palacios et al. 2011a; Jiménez et al. 2013), and for this reason recent
work has been developed to test how soil improvements contribute to plant community
establishment and growth in these environments. For instance, topsoil used in restoration projects
increases water retention and improves nutrient contents at the same time that it triggers the
development of a more diverse plant community independent of topsoil layer depth (Mola et al.
2011; Rivera et al. 2014). Although the positive effect of topsoil on critical soil processes such as
litter degradation has not yet been demonstrated (Jáuregui et al. 2012), it has been shown that
this treatment has positive effects on microbial activity (Rivera 2012). In addition to topsoil
spreading, the effect of organic and inorganic amendments on the habitat carrying capacity of
roadside systems has been tested. On the one hand, horse manure improves physico-chemical
soil properties and generates similar plant covers to those with topsoil use, but results in less
diverse plant communities (Rivera 2012). On the other hand, sewage sludge seems to be a useful
amendment to improving soil conditions since it decreases soil pH, increases organic matter
content and maintains heavy metal soil concentrations at acceptable values (Ferrer et al. 2011).
However, this treatment slightly increases plant cover development and its effect is often diluted
and can not be distinguished from topsoil effects. It is worth noting the interesting work
developed by García-Palacios and colleagues (2011a, 2011b and 2012) who demonstrated that
the effect of traditional roadside management techniques such as irrigation or inorganic
fertilization is strongly site-dependent and often driven by dominant plant communities that were
established before any treatment was applied. They then go on to suggest the importance of
Capítulo I
49
testing the effect of management below-ground, probably one of the most forgotten ecosystem
compartments, and found that fertilization enhanced plant compositional shifts that translate into
changes in soil functionality, principally during the first stages of plant community development
and colonization (0 to 5 year old slopes).
The techniques applied in Mediterranean countries in order to overcome abiotic factors
constraining roadside ecosystem development are comparable to those commonly used in
northern countries and show similar results regarding geotechnical goals. However, the most
interesting insight provided by these studies is the importance of soil compartments in the
organization of roadside communities. Hence, further research on how to promote soil
functionality is needed to efficiently restore these environments.
Biotic filters
Mediterranean ecosystems at pioneer stages are dominated by annual plant species with
lower productivity due to abiotic stress. Therefore, competitive relationships among species are
expected to be of less importance than abiotic factors on plant community dynamics (Maestre et
al. 2009). However, under certain circumstances, biotic interactions between plant species may
be critical in Mediterranean roadslopes (García-Palacios et al. 2010, Valladares et al. 2008). In
road embankments, where the colonization process is easier due to gentle slopes and topsoil
spreading, the rapid growth of hydroseeded or non-hydroseeded species leads to competitive
exclusion processes that shape plant community composition in the short term (de la Riva et al
2011). Along these lines, Raevel and colleagues (2013) evaluated plant community assembly
processes in roadcuts in a time span of 80 years and found that early succession was
characterized by a transition between ruderal to long-lived species, in which the former better
compete for light, water and nutrients, and the latter appeared and remained in low abundances
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
50
until the end of the cronosequence due to their more efficient “water economy”. Some studies
suggest that competitive exclusion may emerge with the co-occurrence of certain functional traits
that were previously filtered by roadside environmental conditions. For instance, plant
assemblages present in road embankments tend to maximize their functional dissimilarities to
avoid competition for the same resources, while in roadcuts plant species tend to share some
functional traits and seem to be more similar than expected by chance (Tena 2006), suggesting
the existence of a more critical abiotic filter in these environments. To manage competition
among species, mowing has been proposed as a useful tool (Simões et al. 2013). This treatment
should be applied twice a year, in spring and in autumn, to ensure road safety and promote the
maintenance of roadside habitat quality.
Besides competition, other types of biotic interactions may be relevant in the
development of roadside ecosystems. In this regard, García-Palacios and colleagues (2011a)
highlighted the importance of soil microbes in the first stages of roadside ecosystem
development as well as the relationships between certain plant species and some microbial
functional groups. However, their results revealed that these interactions tend to disappear with
time, with plants being primarily responsible for ecosystem development in the long term
(García-Palacios et al. 2011b). Management should be oriented to handle biotic relationships
among species to maintain diversity levels in roadside communities, also considering relevant
above/below-ground interactions.
Local effects derived from road operations: roadkills and pollutants
Once the road is opened to traffic, other local impacts such as pollution appear. The
intensity of emissions has been measured in different countries in the Mediterranean Basin.
Pollutants generated by traffic may vary with many surrogates of economic development such us
Capítulo I
51
tourism, way of life, car-to-person ratio and vehicle age (Waked & Afif 2012). Petrol-burning,
break wear, and road risk barriers are principal sources of heavy metals (Scher & Thiery 2005),
being swept along with water runoff and jeopardizing water quality (Vieria et al. 2013). These
pollutants tend to accumulate in the upper layers of roadside topsoil and on plant leaves through
air deposition (Azkoy & Öztürk 1997; Teutsch et al. 2011). Heavy metals also make up a portion
of the fine fraction of particulate matter, while more coarse fractions are made up of soil dust re-
suspended by road traffic (Amato et al. 2011; Amato et al. 2012; Oliveira et al. 2010). Particulate
matter seems to be one of the most important pollutants affecting human health and for this
reason some measures, such as road watering or the application of dust binders, are now
common. However, the efficiency of these measures should be explored in depth (Amato et al.
2014; Karanasiou et al. 2014). Although the effects of pollutants to humans are obvious, very
few studies have been conducted in Mediterranean countries about their effect on wildlife and
ecosystem functionality. Scher & Thyeri (2005) evaluated the side effects of roads on insects and
amphibians in water retention ponds and their results indicated a general decrease in species
richness. A very recent study highlighted that the increase in CO2 due to traffic intensity depletes
photosynthetic rates in plants, decreasing their fitness and increasing bioaccumulation of heavy
metals (De Torre 2014).
On the other hand, the effect of traffic upon animal communities through roadkills is
well-known, and principally affected by species-specific features, habitat type and infrastructure
characteristics. Although there is some debate, the age of individuals seems to affect road
fatalities: depending on the species, adults or juveniles are the most vulnerable individuals
(Gomes et al. 2009; Grilo et al. 2009). Roadkill incidence also varies with life-history
phenological periods, more prone to occur during dispersal, meeting or breeding periods, where
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
52
females are most susceptible (Carvalho & Mira 2011; Grilo et al. 2009; Medinas et al. 2013).
Behavior also plays a role since species that tend to avoid roads are less likely to be killed
(Battisti et al. 2012; Gomes et al. 2009; Grilo et al. 2009). Moreover, it has been shown that
carnivores are especially vulnerable because of their larger home range (Grilo et al. 2012), and
because road verges tend to concentrate food resources (Barrientos & Bolonio 2009; Barrientos
& Miranda 2012; Carvalho & Mira 2011). Regarding habitat features, patches of suitable habitat
near the roads increase roadkills (Carvalho & Mira 2011), as does the proximity to urban areas in
the case of species linked to human activities (Grilo et al. 2012). Finally, road construction
features, like sinuosity, bridges or other structures adjacent to the road, increase the number of
road fatalities (Barrientos & Bolonio 2009; Barrientos & Miranda, 2012; Gomes et al. 2009).
Likewise, traffic intensity strongly conditions roadkills, although it is not clear if low or high
traffic levels correspond to less or more collisions (Barrientos & Bolonio 2009; Grilo et al. 2009;
Grilo et al. 2012). To increase road safety and to decrease the impacts of traffic upon animal
communities, road planning and design should take into account animal behavior and its spatial
distribution especially during the breeding season.
New frontiers for roadside restoration: towards an ecological approach and new goals for
roadside ecosystems
The Mediterranean region will be impacted by global change in the coming decades (Sala
et al. 2000). However, socio-economic factors may have greater effects than climate as drivers of
changes in land use (Schröter et al. 2005). Road network growth as a consequence of socio-
economic development as well as its effects on terrestrial ecosystems is expected to increase
(Sanderson et al. 2002). There is an increasing need for new approaches that ensure the efficient
integration of road infrastructures minimizing impacts on terrestrial ecosystems and optimizing
Capítulo I
53
the provision of environmental goods and services. Ecological restoration approaches applied to
novel roadside ecosystems is a useful tool to reinitiate ecological processes to ensure self-
organization, sustainability and ecosystem service provision in the long term (Clewell &
Aronson 2013). Nevertheless, after reviewing the literature on restoration (rehabilitation) of
areas affected by road construction in the Mediterranean Basin, it is clear that most studies have
done little to promote ecological processes, focusing on the recovery of ecosystem structure
applying the same approaches used in other countries. It is known that earth works such as those
derived from mining or road construction create new reliefs in which geomorphology and
hydrology is severely altered. These features give rise to stressful abiotic conditions described as
main constraints for ecosystem development (Bochet & García-Fayos 2004; Moreno de las Heras
et al. 2011). The recovery of stable landforms using geomorphic approaches (Martín-Duque &
Bugosh 2013), as well as functional soils that trigger the development of biological communities,
is the first step toward the efficient integration of roads with their environment.
Most research developed in this field is on plant communities probably because they are
considered good surrogates of functionality, and because it is thought that geotechnical risks are
minimized with an adequate vegetation structure. However, in the new context of global change
in which the Mediterranean ecosystem´s diversity is expected to be severely threatened (Sala et
al. 2000), the role of biodiversity maintenance in man-made systems and the provision of high
value ecosystem services, is key to effective land use management (Díaz et al. 2003). Given the
importance of roadside ecosystems as species reservoirs, new goals must be set to preserve the
local species pool. To do this, a more ecological interpretation of plant community dynamics in
roadside systems is needed. Moreover, the vegetation colonization process should be interpreted
under the paradigms of the emergent Coexistence Theory (Götzenberger et al. 2012; Hille Ris
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
54
Lambers et al. 2012; Temperton et al. 2004;) to identify the rules underlying the reconfiguration
of roadside communities, alternative stable states and thresholds that must be overcome to guide
restoration efforts (Suding & Hobbs 2009).
This introduction sheds light on the importance of soil in the development of roadside
ecosystems. However, most studies carried out in the context of road restoration interpret the soil
as a substrate from an agronomic point of view, and not as a whole system in which essential
ecological processes occur. The importance of soil fauna and microorganisms in key ecosystems
processes such us nutrient cycling are well known, and these are directly linked to the provision
of environmental goods and services (Van der Heijden et al. 2008). Thus, more attention should
be paid to this belowground community compartment as well as its interaction with the
aboveground community (Kardol & Wardle 2010).
Roadside restoration has developed as an entire empirical practice but without a solid
basis in scientific knowledge or theoretical foundation, often lacking clear and ambitious
objectives. Thus, often, success cannot be properly evaluated (Hobbs & Harris 2001). These
facts contribute to a lack of trust in ecological restoration as a solution for efficient
environmental integration of linear infrastructures. Another point to highlight is that novel
ecosystems such as those derived from road construction appear to be somewhat unpredictable
and fragile (Lindenmayer et al. 2008). Roadside ecosystem dynamics are still poorly understood
due to the dearth of large scale or long-term studies, suggesting that to restore these novel
ecosystems we need to understand them more fully. Roadside ecosystems are usually subjected
to different types of management and it is essential to understand how these systems respond to
provide useful guidelines that ensure restoration success.
Capítulo I
55
Objectives
Even though soil is the basis of terrestrial ecosystem development, and most key
processes in regulating services occur in soil, insufficient attention has been paid to this
ecosystem component. Thus, in this Doctoral Thesis, we aim to fulfill some gaps in knowledge
related to soil communities inhabiting roadside anthrosols and their functionality. Specifically,
we aim to examine the factors affecting the spatial organization and temporal variation of
microarthropod and bacterial communities and to ascertain how roadside communities and
ecological processes respond to conventional management practices applied in these scenarios.
These issues are particularly relevant to the ecological restoration of roadside ecosystems.
Firstly, they provide new insight into soil communities that, despite their key role in soil
processes such as nutrient cycling and soil formation, have been overlooked. Secondly, they
interpret roadside ecosystems from a more ecological point of view and provide useful
guidelines to efficiently restore them. The study sites were selected because they are
anthropogenic systems, where physico-chemical conditions have been severely altered and
original biological communities have been eliminated. Thus, these scenarios are a test-bed for
ecological theories and for studying how the system re-configures itself under natural conditions
and under the effect of soil treatments. This thesis is organized into four different chapters in
which general and specific objectives are addressed to provide useful guidelines for practitioners.
Each chapter has been written in a research article format, with a specific introduction including
the theoretical framework, specific methods, results and discussion. After these chapters a
general discussion that integrates main results is also included. Specific objectives for each
chapter are the following:
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
56
In Chapter II soil microarthropod communities in anthrosols from road embankments as
well as their temporal dynamics are considered. Microarthropods are involved in litter
degradation and organic matter turnover and have been shown to be biological indicators of soil
health and quality, both surrogates of ecosystem functionality. Assessing road ecosystem
functionality is the first step to ensure the maintenance of biological communities and ecosystem
services on the roadside. Specifically, functionality is estimated based on the QBS index (Qualitá
Biologica del Suolo), obtained from microarthropod community composition and their specific
adaptations to the soil environment. In this chapter the following questions are addressed:
1. Are anthropogenic soils from road embankments functional based on their QBS values?
2. If so, which processes determine soil community structure and hence soil quality?
In Chapter III soil bacterial communities in anthrosols from road embankments under
natural conditions are analyzed. Soil bacterial communities are known to play a key role in
nutrient cycling and soil formation, and more often modulate the relationship between
aboveground species. Moreover, bacterial community composition and its spatial organization
may provide valuable information about soil processes and historical effects driving functionality
in roadside ecosystems. Thus, in this chapter the following questions are addressed:
1. What are the main groups of bacteria present in these types of soils?
2. What is the relevant spatial scale that explains changes in bacterial community composition
and diversity and what are the main factors underlying changes in community structure?
In Chapter IV, the response of soil bacterial communities and soil processes to
conventional management applied on roadslopes, such as mowing and fertilization, is analyzed.
Capítulo I
57
Roadside management implies a disturbance that, in terms of community features (e.g.,
resistance, resilience), may affect both structure and functionality with further effects on
environmental services provided by roadside ecosystems. To elucidate the effects of
management on these scenarios, the present chapter addressed the following questions:
1. How does management modify soil factors?
2. How does management modify soil bacterial community composition and diversity?
3. How does management affect soil processes such as litter decomposition and nutrient
availability?
In Chapter V, the early plant community assembly in a sun-exposed roadcut is studied.
Roadcut community assembly is a process usually constrained by abiotic factors. We usually
interpret this process is as fixed, but it is in fact the result of different transitions between life-
history stages occurring at an individual scale and in which every life-stage is precarious. The
present chapter aims to ascertain how an individual’s life-stages respond to different treatments
aimed at loosening environmental filters and how these responses translate to the final
configuration of the plant community. Thus, the following questions are addressed:
1. Does the response to environmental filters change across life-history stages?
2. Is there a threshold at any of the life-history stages throughout the early process of community
assembly? If so, to what extent do these thresholds affect the abundance, richness, and cover of
the emerging community?
3. What are the implications for the current revegetation practices on roadcuts?
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
58
References
Aksoy, A., & Öztürk, M. A. (1997). Nerium oleander L. as a biomonitor of lead and other heavy
metal pollution in Mediterranean environments. Science of the Total Environment, 205:
145-150.
Alborch, B., García-Fayos, P., & Bochet, E. (2003). Estimación de los filtros ecológicos que
controlan la colonización de taludes de carretera a partir del estudio del banco de semillas
del suelo. Ecología, 17: 65-75.
Alfaya, V. (2013) Colonización de taludes artificiales por medio de la vegetación natural.
Doctoral dissertation.
Amato, F., Karanasiou, A., Cordoba, P., Alastuey, A., Moreno, T., Lucarelli, F., Nava, S.,
Calzolai, G.,& Querol, X. (2014). Effects of road dust suppressants on PM levels in a
Mediterranean urban area. Environmental Science & Technology, 48: 8069–8077. DOI:
10.1021/es502496s
Amato, F., Karanasiou, A., Moreno, T., Alastuey, A., Orza, J. A. G., Lumbreras, J., Borged, R.,
Boldoe, E., Linares, C., & Querol, X. (2012). Emission factors from road dust
resuspension in a Mediterranean freeway. Atmospheric Environment, 61: 580-587.
Amato, F., Viana, M., Richard, A., Furger, M., Prévôt, A. S. H., Nava, S., Lucarelli, F.,
Bukowiecki, N., Alastuey, A., Reche1, C., Moreno, T., Pandolfi, M., Pey, J., & Querol,
X. (2011). Size and time-resolved roadside enrichment of atmospheric particulate
pollutants. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, 11: 2917-2931.
Andrés, P., Zapater, V., & Pamplona, M. (1996). Stabilization of Motorway Slopes with
Herbaceous Cover, Catalonia, Spain. Restoration Ecology, 4:, 51–60.
Capítulo I
59
Andrés, P., & Jorba, M. (2000). Mitigation strategies in some motorway embankments
(Catalonia, Spain). Restoration Ecology, 8: 268-275.
Arévalo, J. R., Delgado, J. D., & Fernández-Palacios, J. M. (2008). Changes in plant species
composition and litter production in response to roads and trails in the laurel forest of
Tenerife (Canary Islands). Plant Biosystems-An International Journal Dealing with all
Aspects of Plant Biology, 142: 614-622.
Arévalo, J. R., Delgado, J. D., Otto, R., Naranjo, A., Salas, M., & Fernández-Palacios, J. M.
(2005). Distribution of alien vs. native plant species in roadside communities along an
altitudinal gradient in Tenerife and Gran Canaria (Canary Islands). Perspectives in Plant
Ecology, Evolution & Systematics, 7: 185-202.
Arévalo, J. R., Otto, R., Escudero, C., Fernández-Lugo, S., Arteaga, M., Delgado, J. D., &
Fernández-Palacios, J. M. (2010). Do anthropogenic corridors homogenize plant
communities at a local scale? A case studied in Tenerife (Canary Islands). Plant Ecology,
209: 23-35.
Arteaga, M. A., Delgado, J. D., Otto, R., Fernández-Palacios, J. M., & Arévalo, J. R. (2009).
How do alien plants distribute along roads on oceanic islands? A case study in Tenerife,
Canary Islands. Biological Invasions, 11: 1071-1086.
Ascensão, F., Clevenger, A. P., Grilo, C., Filipe, J., & Santos-Reis, M. (2012). Highway verges
as habitat providers for small mammals in agrosilvopastoral environments. Biodiversity
& Conservation, 21: 3681-3697.
Aschmann, H. (1973). Distribution and peculiarity of Mediterranean ecosystems. Mediterranean
Type Ecosystems. Ecological Studies, 7: 11-19
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
60
Balaguer, L. (2002). Las limitaciones de la restauración de la cubierta vegetal. Revista
Ecosistemas, 11 ( http://revistaecosistemas.net/index.php/ecosistemas/article/view/307)
Barrientos, R., & Bolonio, L. (2009). The presence of rabbits adjacent to roads increases polecat
road mortality. Biodiversity & Conservation, 18: 405-418.
Barrientos, R., & de Dios Miranda, J. (2012). Can we explain regional abundance and road‐kill
patterns with variables derived from local‐scale road‐kill models? Evaluating
transferability with the European polecat. Diversity & Distributions, 18: 635-647.
Battisti, C., Amori, G., De Felici, S., Luiselli, L., & Zapparoli, M. (2012). Mammal road-killing
from a Mediterranean area in central Italy: evidence from an atlas dataset. Rendiconti
Lincei, 23: 217-223.
Bochet, E., & García‐Fayos, P. (2004). Factors controlling vegetation establishment and water
erosion on motorway slopes in Valencia, Spain. Restoration Ecology, 12: 166-174.
Bochet, E., García‐Fayos, P., & Poesen, J. (2009). Topographic thresholds for plant colonization
on semi‐arid eroded slopes. Earth Surface Processes & Landforms, 34: 1758-1771.
Bochet, E., García‐Fayos, P., & Tormo, J. (2007a). Road slope revegetation in semiarid
Mediterranean environments. Part I: seed dispersal and spontaneous colonization.
Restoration Ecology, 15: 88-96.
Bochet, E., García‐Fayos, P., & Tormo, J. (2010a). How can we control erosion of roadslopes in
semiarid Mediterranean areas? Soil improvement and native plant establishment. Land
Degradation & Development, 21: 110-121.
Bochet, E., García-Fayos, P., Alborch, B., & Tormo, J. (2007b). Soil water availability effects on
seed germination account for species segregation in semiarid roadslopes. Plant & Soil,
295: 179-191.
Capítulo I
61
Bochet, E., Tormo, J., & García‐Fayos, P. (2010b). Native species for roadslope revegetation:
selection, validation, and cost effectiveness. Restoration Ecology, 18: 656-663.
Brotons, L., & Herrando, S. (2001). Reduced bird occurrence in pine forest fragments associated
with road proximity in a Mediterranean agricultural area. Landscape & Urban Planning,
57: 77-89.
Cano, A., Navia, R., Amezaga, I., & Montalvo, J. (2002). Local topoclimate effect on short-term
cutslope reclamation success. Ecological Engineering, 18: 489-498.
Carvalho, F., & Mira, A. (2011). Comparing annual vertebrate road kills over two time periods, 9
years apart: a case study in Mediterranean farmland. European journal of wildlife
research, 57: 157-174.
Cerdá, A. (2007). Soil water erosion on road embankments in eastern Spain. Science of The
Total Environment, 378: 151-155.
Clevenger, A. P., Chruszcz, B., & Gunson, K. E. (2003). Spatial patterns and factors influencing
small vertebrate fauna road-kill aggregations. Biological Conservation, 109: 15-26.
Clewell, A. F., & Aronson, J. (2013). Ecological restoration: principles, values, and structure of
an emerging profession. Island Press.
Coffin, A. W. (2007). From roadkill to road ecology: A review of the ecological effects of roads.
Journal of Transport Geography, 15: 396-406.
Crutzen, P. J. (2002). Geology of mankind. Nature, 415: 23-23.
De la Riva, E. G., Casado, M. A., Jiménez, M. D., Mola, I., Costa‐Tenorio, M., & Balaguer, L.
(2011). Rates of local colonization and extinction reveal different plant community
assembly mechanisms on road verges in central Spain. Journal of Vegetation Science, 22:
292-302.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
62
Deckers, B., Becker, P. D., Honnay, O., Hermy, M., & Muys, B. (2005). Sunken roads as
habitats for forest plant species in a dynamic agricultural landscape: effects of age and
isolation. Journal of Biogeography, 32: 99-109.
De Torre, R. (2014). Procesos ecológicos implicados en el ensamblaje de comunidades en
taludes de carretera y su aplicación a la restauración ecológica. Doctoral dissertation.
Díaz, M., Tietje, W. & Barret, R. (2013) Effects of management on biological diversity and
endangered species. Mediterranean oak woodland working landscapes: Dehesas of Spain
and Ranchlands of California (Ed. Campos, L. Huntsinger, J.L. Oviedo, M. Díaz, P.
Starrs, R.B. Standiford and G. Montero), pp. 213–243. Springer, New York.
Enciso, J., García-Fayos, P., & Cerdà, A. (2000). Distribución del banco de semillas en taludes
de carretera: efecto de la orientación y de la topografía. Orsis, 15: 103-113.
Estaún, V., Vicente, S., Calvet, C., Camprubi, A., & Busquets, M. (2007). Integration of
arbuscular mycorrhiza inoculation in hydroseeding technology: effects on plant growth
and inter‐species competition. Land Degradation & Development, 18: 621-630.
Ferrer, A., Mochón, I., De Oña, J., & Osorio, F. (2011). Evolution of the soil and vegetation
cover on road embankments after the application of sewage sludge. Water, Air, & Soil
Pollution, 214: 231-240.
Figueroa, M.E., & Davy, J.A. (1991) Response of Mediterranean grassland species to changing
rainfall. Journal of Ecology, 79: 925-941.
Filibeck, G., Cornelini, P., & Petrella, P. (2012). Floristic analysis of a high-speed railway
embankment in a Mediterranean landscape. Acta Botanica Croatica, 71: 229-248.
Foley, J. A., De Fries, R., Asner, G. P., Barford, C., Bonan, G., Carpenter, S. R., Chapin, F. S.,
Coe1, M. T., Daily, G. C., Gibbs, H. K., Helkowski, J. H., Holloway, T., Howard, E. A.,
Capítulo I
63
Kucharik, C. J., Monfreda, C., Patz, J. A., Prentice I. C., Ramankutty, N., & Snyder, P. K.
(2005). Global consequences of land use. Science, 309: 570-574.
Forman, R. T. T., Sperling, D., Bissonette, J. A., Clevenger, A. P., Cutshall, C. D., Dale, V. H.,
et al. 2002. Road ecology: science and solutions. Island Press, Washington, D.C.
Forman, R. T., & Alexander, L. E. (1998). Roads and their major ecological effects. Annual
Review of Ecology & Systematics, 29: 207- 231.
García-Palacios, P., Bowker, M. A., Chapman, S. J., Maestre, F. T., Soliveres, S., Gallardo, A.,
Valladares, F., Guerrero, C., & Escudero, A. (2011a). Early-successional vegetation
changes after roadside prairie restoration modify processes related with soil functioning
by changing microbial functional diversity. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 43: 1245-1253.
García-Palacios, P., Bowker, M. A., Maestre, F. T., Soliveres, S., Valladares, F., Papadopoulos,
J., & Escudero, A. (2011b). Ecosystem development in roadside grasslands: biotic
control, plant-soil interactions, and dispersal limitations. Ecological Applications, 21:
2806-2821.
García-Palacios, P., Querejeta, J. I., Maestre, F. T., Escudero, A., & Valladares, F. (2012).
Impact of simulated changes in rainfall regime and nutrient deposition on the relative
dominance and isotopic composition of ruderal plants in anthropogenic grasslands. Plant
& Soil, 352: 303-319.
García-Palacios, P., Soliveres, S., Maestre, F. T., Escudero, A., Castillo-Monroy, A. P., &
Valladares, F. (2010). Dominant plant species modulate responses to hydroseeding,
irrigation and fertilization during the restoration of semiarid motorway slopes. Ecological
Engineering, 36: 1290-1298.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
64
Gomes, L., Grilo, C., Silva, C., & Mira, A. (2009). Identification methods and deterministic
factors of owl roadkill hotspot locations in Mediterranean landscapes. Ecological
Research, 24: 355-370.
Götzenberger, L., de Bello, F., Bråthen, K. A., Davison, J., Dubuis, A., Guisan, A., Lepš, J.,
Lindborg, R., Moora, M., Pärtel, M., Pellissier, L., Pottier, J., Vittoz, P., Zobe, K., &
Zobel, M. (2012). Ecological assembly rules in plant communities—approaches, patterns
and prospects. Biological Reviews, 87: 111-127.
Grilo, C., Bissonette, J. A., & Cramer, P. C. (2010). Mitigation measures to reduce impacts on
biodiversity In Highways: Construction, Management, and Maintenance (Eds. Nova
Science Publishers). pp: 73-114.
Grilo, C., Bissonette, J. A., & Santos-Reis, M. (2009). Spatial–temporal patterns in
Mediterranean carnivore road casualties: Consequences for mitigation. Biological
Conservation, 142: 301-313.
Grilo, C., Sousa, J., Ascensão, F., Matos, H., Leitão, I., Pinheiro, P., Costa, M., Bernardo, J.,
Reto, D., Lourenço, R., Santos-Reis, M., & Revilla, E. (2012). Individual spatial
responses towards roads: implications for mortality risk. PloS one, 7. DOI:
10.1371/journal.pone.0043811
Haddad, N. M., Bowne, D. R., Cunningham, A., Danielson, B. J., Levey, D. J., Sargent, S., &
Spira, T. (2003). Corridor use by diverse taxa. Ecology, 84: 609-615.
Hansen, M. J., & Clevenger, A. P. (2005). The influence of disturbance and habitat on the
presence of non-native plant species along transport corridors. Biological Conservation,
125: 249-259.
Capítulo I
65
Hille Ris Lambers, J., Adler, P. B., Harpole, W. S., Levine, J. M., & Mayfield, M. M. (2012).
Rethinking community assembly through the lens of coexistence theory. Annual Review
of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics, 43: 227-248.
Hobbs, R. J., Arico, S., Aronson, J., Baron, J. S., Bridgewater, P., Cramer, V. A., Epstein, P. R.,
Ewel, J. J., Klink, C. A., Lugo, A. E., Norton, D., Ojima, D., Richardson, D. M.,
Sanderson, E. W., Valladares, F., Vilà, M., Zamora, R., & Zobel, M. (2006). Novel
ecosystems: theoretical and management aspects of the new ecological world order.
Global Ecology & Biogeography, 15: 1-7.
Hobbs, R. J., & Harris, J. A. (2001). Restoration ecology: repairing the earth's ecosystems in the
new millennium. Restoration Ecology, 9: 239-246.
Hooke, R. L., Martín-Duque, J. F., & Pedraza, J. (2012). Land transformation by humans: a
review. GSA Today, 22: 4-10.
Jacques, J. C., & Garnier, G. (1982). Influences des autoroutes sur la faune terrestre et aérienne.
Reveu Géneral des Routes et Aérodromes, 582: 39-45.
Jáuregui, B. M., Rivera, D., & Peco, B. (2013). Does topsoil accelerate the decomposition of
litter on roadslopes? Ecological Engineering, 52: 88-95.
Jiménez, M. D., Ruiz‐Capillas, P., Mola, I., Pérez‐Corona, E., Casado, M. A., & Balaguer, L.
(2013). Soil development at the roadside: a case study of a novel ecosystem. Land
Degradation & Development, 24: 564-574.
Karanasiou, A., Amato, F., Moreno, T., Lumbreras, J., Borge, R., Linares, C., Boldo, E.,
Alastuey, A., & Querol, X. (2013). Road dust emission sources and assessment of street
washing effect. Aerosol and Air Quality Research, 14: 734-743.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
66
Kardol, P., & Wardle, D. A. (2010). How understanding aboveground–belowground linkages can
assist restoration ecology. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 25: 670-679.
Katritzidakis, M., Liapis, A., Stathakopoulos, I., Pipinis, E., Kekis, G., Ververidou, E., &
Sevastou, E. (2007). Erosion control by application of hydroseeding methods along the
Egnatia Motorway (Greece). In: Eco-and Ground Bio-Engineering: The Use of
Vegetation to Improve Slope Stability. pp. 393-400. Springer Netherlands.
Lehmann, A., & Stahr, K. (2007). Nature and significance of anthropogenic urban soils. Journal
of Soils and Sediments, 7: 247-260.
Lindenmayer, D. B., Fischer, J., Felton, A., Crane, M., Michael, D., Macgregor, C., Montague-
Drake1, R., Manning, A., & Hobbs, R. J. (2008). Novel ecosystems resulting from
landscape transformation create dilemmas for modern conservation practice.
Conservation Letters, 1: 129-135.
Maestre, F. T., Callaway, R. M., Valladares, F., & Lortie, C. J. (2009). Refining the stress‐
gradient hypothesis for competition and facilitation in plant communities. Journal of
Ecology, 97: 199-205.
Marcantonio, M., Rocchini, D., Geri, F., Bacaro, G., & Amici, V. (2013). Biodiversity, roads, &
landscape fragmentation: Two Mediterranean cases. Applied Geography, 42: 63-72.
Martin, A., Khater, C., Mineau, H., & Puech, S. (2002). Rehabilitation ecology by revegetation.
Approach and results from two Mediterranean countries. Korean Journal of Ecology 25:
1: 9-17.
Martínez, J. J., & Wool, D. (2006). Sampling bias in roadsides: the case of galling aphids on
Pistacia trees. Biodiversity & Conservation, 15: 2109-2121.
Capítulo I
67
Mata, C. (2003). Effectiveness of wildlife crossing structures and adapted culverts in a highway
in Northwest Spain. Road Ecology Center.
Mata, C., Hervás, I., Herranz, J., Malo, J. E., & Suárez, F. (2009). Seasonal changes in wildlife
use of motorway crossing structures and their implication for monitoring programmes.
Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, 14: 447-452.
Mata, C., Hervás, I., Herranz, J., Suárez, F., & Malo, J. E. (2005). Complementary use by
vertebrates of crossing structures along a fenced Spanish motorway. Biological
Conservation, 124: 397-405.
Mata, C., Hervás, I., Herranz, J., Suárez, F., & Malo, J. E. (2008). Are motorway wildlife
passages worth building? Vertebrate use of road-crossing structures on a Spanish
motorway. Journal of Environmental Management, 88: 407-415.
Matesanz, S., & Valladares, F. (2007). Improving revegetation of gypsum slopes is not a simple
matter of adding native species: Insights from a multispecies experiment. Ecological
Engineering, 30: 67-77.
Matesanz, S., Valladares, F., Tena, D., Costa‐Tenorio, M., & Bote, D. (2006). Early dynamics of
plant communities on revegetated motorway slopes from southern Spain: is hydroseeding
always needed? Restoration Ecology, 14: 297-307.
Medinas, D., Marques, J. T., & Mira, A. (2013). Assessing road effects on bats: the role of
landscape, road features, and bat activity on road-kills. Ecological Research, 28: 227-237.
Merlin, G., Di‐Gioia, L., & Goddon, C. (1999). Comparative study of the capacity of
germination and of adhesion of various hydrocolloids used for revegetalization by
hydroseeding. Land Degradation & Development, 10: 21-34.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
68
Mola, I., Jiménez, M. D., López‐Jiménez, N., Casado, M. A., & Balaguer, L. (2011). Roadside
reclamation outside the revegetation season: management options under schedule
pressure. Restoration Ecology, 19: 83-92.
Navarro, J. (2002). Control de la erosión en desmontes originados por obras de infraestructura
viaria: aplicación al entorno de Palencia Capital. Doctoral dissertation.
Navarro-Castilla, A., Mata, C., Ruiz-Capillas, P., Palme, R., Malo, J. E., & Barja, I. (2014). Are
Motorways Potential Stressors of Roadside Wood Mice (Apodemus sylvaticus)
Populations? PloS one, 9. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0091942.
Naveh, Z. (1974). Effects of fire in the Mediterranean region. In Fire and Ecosystems, (Ed. T.T.
Kozlowski ). pp. 321- 364. Academic Press, New York.
Oliveira, C., Pio, C., Caseiro, A., Santos, P., Nunes, T., Mao, H., Luahana, L., & Sokhi, R.
(2010). Road traffic impact on urban atmospheric aerosol loading at Oporto, Portugal.
Atmospheric Environment, 44: 3147-3158.
Otto, R., Arteaga, M. A., Delgado, J. D., Arévalo, J. R., Blandino, C., & Fernández-Palacios, J.
M. (2014). Road Edge Effect and Elevation Patterns of Native and Alien Plants on an
Oceanic Island (Tenerife, Canary Islands). Folia Geobotanica, 49: 65-82.
Pausas, J.G., & Vallejo, V.R. (1999) The role of fire in European Mediterranean ecosystems. In
‘Remote Sensing of Large Wildfires in the European Mediterranean Basin’. (Ed. E
Chuvieco) pp. 3–16. Springer: Berlin
Peris, S. J., & Pescador, M. (2004). Effects of traffic noise on passerine populations in
Mediterranean wooded pastures. Applied Acoustic, 65: 357–366.
Capítulo I
69
Pita, R., Mira, A., & Beja, P. (2006). Conserving the Cabrera vole, Microtus cabrerae, in
intensively used Mediterranean landscapes. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment,
115: 1-5.
Planillo, A., & Malo, J. E. (2013). Motorway verges: paradise for prey species? A case study
with the European rabbit. Mammalian Biology-Zeitschrift für Säugetierkunde, 78: 187-
192.
Raevel, V., Muñoz , F., Pons , V., Renaux , A., Martin , M., & Thompson, J.D. 2013. Changing
assembly processes during a primary succession of plant communities on Mediterranean
roadcut. Journal of Plant Ecology, 6: 19-28.
Rivera, D. (2012). Dinámica de la revegetación de taludes de infraestructuras lineales: manejo y
optimización de la cobertura vegetal. Doctoral dissertation.
Rivera, D., Jáuregui, B. M., & Peco, B. (2012b). The fate of herbaceous seeds during topsoil
stockpiling: restoration potential of seed banks. Ecological Engineering, 44: 94-101.
Rivera, D., Mejías, V., Jáuregui, B. M., Costa-Tenorio, M., López-Archilla, A. I., & Peco, B.
(2014). Spreading Topsoil Encourages Ecological Restoration on Embankments: Soil
Fertility, Microbial Activity and Vegetation Cover. PloS one, 9. DOI:
10.1371/journal.pone.0101413.
Romero, R., Guijarro, J. A., Ramis, C., &Alonso, S. (1998) A 30-year (1964–1993) daily rainfall
data base for the Spanish Mediterranean regions: first exploratory study. International
Journal of Climatology, 18, 541-560.
Rosell Pagés, C., & Velasco Rivas, J. M. (1999). Manual de prevenció i correció dels impactes
de les infraestructures viáries sobre la fauna. Generalitat de Catalunya. Departamet de
Medi Ambient, Catalunya.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
70
Rotholz, E., & Mandelik, Y. (2013). Roadside habitats: effects on diversity and composition of
plant, arthropod, and small mammal communities. Biodiversity and Conservation, 22:
1017-1031.
Ruiz-Capillas, P., Mata, C., & Malo, J. E. (2013b). Beyond the biological perspective of the
road/fauna conflict: vertebrates in the decision making of Spanish motorway. Oecologia
Australis, 17: 386-396.
Ruiz-Capillas, P., Mata, C., & Malo, J. E. (2013c). Community Response of Mammalian
Predators and Their Prey to Motorways: Implications for Predator–Prey Dynamics.
Ecosystems, 16: 617-626.
Ruiz-Capillas, P., Mata, C., & Malo, J. E. (2013a). Road verges are refuges for small mammal
populations in extensively managed Mediterranean landscapes. Biological Conservation,
158: 223-229.
Sabino-Marques, H., & Mira, A. (2011). Living on the verge: are roads a more suitable refuge
for small mammals than streams in Mediterranean pastureland? Ecological Research, 26:
277-287.
Sala, O. E., Chapin, F. S., Armesto, J. J., Berlow, E., Bloomfield, J., Dirzo, R., Huber-Sanwald,
E., Huenneke, L. F., Jackson, R. B., Kinzig, A., Leemans, R., Lodge, D. M, Mooney H.
A., Oesterheld, M., Poff, N., L., Sykes, M. T., Walker, B.H., Walker, M., & Wall, D. H.
(2000). Global biodiversity scenarios for the year 2100. Science, 287: 1770-1774.
Sanderson, E. W., Jaiteh, M., Levy, M. A., Redford, K. H., Wannebo, A. V., & Woolmer, G.
(2002). The Human Footprint and the Last of the Wild: The human footprint is a global
map of human influence on the land surface, which suggests that human beings are
stewards of nature, whether we like it or not. BioScience, 52: 891-904.
Capítulo I
71
Scher, O., & Thièry, A. (2005). Odonata, Amphibia and environmental characteristics in
motorway stormwater retention ponds (Southern France). Hydrobiologia, 551: 237-251.
Schröter, D., Cramer, W., Leemans, R. et al. (2005) Ecosystem service supply and vulnerability
to global change in Europe. Science, 310: 1333-1337.
Serronha, A. M., Mateus, A. R. A., Eaton, F., Santos-Reis, M., & Grilo, C. (2013). Towards
effective culvert design: monitoring seasonal use and behavior by Mediterranean
mesocarnivores. Environmental Monitoring& Assessment, 185: 6235-6246.
Silva, C. C., Lourenço, R., Godinho, S., Gomes, E., Sabino-Marques, H., Medinas, D., Neves,
V., Silva, C., Rabaça, J. E., & Mira, A. (2012). Major roads have a negative impact on
the Tawny Owl Strix aluco and the Little Owl Athene noctua populations. Acta
Ornithologica, 47: 47-54.
Simões, M. P., Belo, A. F., & Souza, C. (2013). Effects of mowing regime on diversity of
Mediterranean roadside vegetation–implications for management. Polish Journal of
Ecology, 61: 241-255.
Steffen, W., Crutzen, P. J., & McNeill, J. R. (2007). The Anthropocene: are humans now
overwhelming the great forces of nature. Ambio: A Journal of the Human Environment,
36: 614-621.
Spooner, P. G. (2005). On Squatters, Settlers and Early Surveyors: historical development of
country road reserves in southern New South Wales. Australian Geographer, 36: 55-73.
Suding, K. N., & Hobbs, R. J. (2009). Threshold models in restoration and conservation: a
developing framework. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 24: 271-279.
Tena, D. (2006). Implicaciones funcionales y evolutivas de la estructura y dinámica de
comunidades herbáceas de bordes de carretera. Doctoral dissertation.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
72
Temperton, V. M., Hobbs, R. J., Nuttle, T., & Halle, S. (Eds.) (2004). Assembly rules and
restoration ecology: bridging the gap between theory and practice. Island Press.
Teutsch, N., Erel, Y., Halicz, L., & Banin, A. (2001). Distribution of natural and anthropogenic
lead in Mediterranean soils. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 65: 2853-2864.
Tikka, P. M., Koski, P. S., Kivel, R. A., & Kuitunen, M. T. 2000. Can grassland plant
communities be preserved on road and railway verges? Applied Vegetation Science, 3:
25-32.
Tormo , J. (2007). Factores que influyen en la colonización vegetal y la revegetación de taludes
de carreteras en ambiente mediterráneo. Doctoral dissertation.
Tormo, J., Bochet, E., & García-Fayos, P. (2006). Is seed availability enough to ensure
colonization success?: An experimental study in road embankments. Ecological
Engineering, 26: 224-230.
Tormo, J., Bochet, E., & García‐Fayos, P. (2007). Roadfill revegetation in semiarid
Mediterranean environments. Part II: Topsoiling, species selection, and hydroseeding.
Restoration Ecology, 15: 97-102.
Tormo, J., Brochet, E., & García-Fayos, P. (2009). Restauración y revegetación de taludes de
carreteras en ambientes mediterráneos semiáridos: procesos edáficos determinantes para
el éxito. Revista Ecosistemas, 18.
(http://revistaecosistemas.net/index.php/ecosistemas/article/view/62)
Tormo, J., García-Fayos, P., & Bochet, E. (2008). Relative importance of plant traits and
ecological filters in road embankment revegetation under semiarid Mediterranean
conditions. Ecological Engineering, 33: 258-264.
Capítulo I
73
Valladares, F., Tena, D., Matesanz, S., Bochet, E., Balaguer, L., Costa‐Tenorio, M.,Tormo, J., &
García‐Fayos, P. (2008). Functional traits and phylogeny: What is the main ecological
process determining species assemblage in roadside plant communities? Journal of
Vegetation Science, 19: 381-392.
Van Der Heijden, M. G., Bardgett, R. D., & Van Straalen, N. M. (2008). The unseen majority:
soil microbes as drivers of plant diversity and productivity in terrestrial ecosystems.
Ecology Letters, 11: 296-310.
Vassant, J., Brandt, S., & Jullien, J.M. (1993a). Effects of the wildlife passage over motorway
A5 on the populations of red deer and wild boar in the Massif d’Arc-en-Barrois. Part 2:
case of the population of wild boar. Bulletin Mensuel de l’Office National de la Chasse,
184: 24-33.
Vassant, J., Brandt, S., & Jullien, J.M. (1993b). Effects of wildlife passage over motorway A5 on
the populations of red deer and wild boar. Part 1: case of the population of red deer.
Bulletin Mensuel de l’Office Nationale de la Chasse, 183:15-25.
Velasco, J.M., Yanes, M., & Suárez, F. (1995). El Efecto Barrera En Vertebrados. Medidas
Correctoras En Las Vías De Comunicación. CEDEX, Madrid.
Vieira, R., Fernandes, J. N., & Barbosa, A. E. (2013). Evaluation of the impacts of road runoff in
a Mediterranean reservoir in Portugal. Environmental Monitoring & Assessment, 185:
7659-7673.
Villalva, P., Reto, D., Santos-Reis, M., Revilla, E., & Grilo, C. (2013). Do dry ledges reduce the
barrier effect of roads? Ecological Engineering, 57: 143-148.
Waked, A., & Afif, C. (2012). Emissions of air pollutants from road transport in Lebanon and
other countries in the Middle East region. Atmospheric Environment, 61: 446-452.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
74
Zelnik, I., Šilc, U., Čarni, A., & Košir, P. (2010). Revegetation of motorway slopes using
different seed mixtures. Restoration Ecology, 18: 449-456.
75
CAPÍTULO II
Soil functionality at the roadside: Zooming in on a microarthropod community in an anthropogenic soil
S. Magro, M,. Gutiérrez-López, M.A. Casado, M.D. Jiménez, D. Trigo, I. Mola, &
L. Balaguer
Ecological Engineering (2013) 60: 81-87.
76
Capítulo II
77
Abstract
Earth movements for road construction give rise to nutrient-poor anthrosols. Early onset of soil
processes in these environments has been reported on the basis of plant cover establishment.
Evidences of full soil functionality, however, would reveal the emergence of a self-sustainable
ecosystem on these man-made substrates. The aims of the present study involved (1) assessing
soil functionality on six-year-old road embankments by means of the QBS index, based on
microarthropod communities (2) elucidating soil properties responsible for the composition of
soil microartrhopod communities, and (3) exploring the practical implications of soil quality for
road embankment management. Road embankments were functional with QBS values
comparable to those found in natural systems (>100). Soil quality in these environments
depended on soil organic carbon dynamics. Among the 36 arthropod groups found, Acari and
Collembola dominated the soil community. Variation in microarthropod community composition
was best explained by higher abundances of Brachypilina (Oribatida, Acari) and Symphypleona
(Collembola). These trends in soil community structure were intimately linked to soil organic
carbon content, clay content and humidity. Given its relevance, the acknowledgment of the early
functionality attained by these roadside anthrosols should lead to the revision of current
protocols for roadslope monitoring and management.
Keywords: Anthrosols; Embankments; Mesofauna; QBS index; Soil organic carbon
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
78
Introduction
In the last two centuries, human activities have become main drivers of ecosystem
transformation (Hooke et al. 2012; Vitousek et al. 1997). These changes have led to the term
‘Anthropocene’ (Crutzen 2002), which describes a new age in which the Earth is undergoing a
rapid human-mediated change, with evident consequences for biodiversity and ecosystem
functioning. This new scenario is giving rise to ecosystems that emerge from within the pre-
existing ones, but which exhibit differential attributes affecting their dynamics and ecological
behavior (Hobbs et al. 2006). Within these emergent ecosystems, recently created substrates,
known as anthropogenic soils (first introduced as a class in FAO 1988), are the basis for pioneer
community development.
Anthropogenic soils or Anthrosols (ISRIC-FAO 2006) have been described as soils
created or profoundly modified by human activities. A particular case of these soils are urban
soils (sensu Lehman & Stahr 2007) characterized by high pH values as well as a large amount of
coarse materials and soil organic matter, which influence porosity dynamics (Nehls et al. 2006).
Among them, soils on road embankments also exhibit high pH values but clearly differ in their
low levels of organic matter as they have been developed from parent materials poor in nutrients
(Jiménez et al. 2013). However, neither the structural characterization nor even partial reports on
nutrient processes account for the degree of functionality of these particular soils.
Soil functionality integrates the interactions between structure and processes (cf. TEEB
2010). Within this integrative approach, soil functionality is also related with the soil quality
concept regarding the soil capability to sustain biotic communities and air and water quality
(Gardi et al. 2002). Recent studies have highlighted the importance of incorporating biological
indicators to evaluate the quality of anthropogenic soils (Hartley et al. 2008). The best indicators
Capítulo II
79
of soil quality will be responsive to land use or management (Doran & Zeiss 2000). Thus, Parisi
and coworkers (2005) proposed a soil-quality indicator focusing on soil microarthropod
communities and tested in different land-use scenarios. Soil microarthropods play a vital role in
the maintenance of soil functions and they have therefore been proposed as suitable indicators of
soil quality for environments impacted by human activities (Parisi et al. 2005; Tsiafouli et al.
2005; van Straalen & Verhoef 1997). Microarthropod communities are involved in pedogenesis,
soil aggregate stability, hydraulic properties, and plant performance (De Deyn et al. 2003;
Lavelle 1996; Liiri et al. 2002; Neher 1999). Particularly, soil microarthropods are always
present in litter and they control soil functions, such as litter decomposition. They resize and
fragment plant residues, increase surface area for microbial attack and the leaching of water-
soluble constituents, and control the structure and activity of the decomposer community
(bacteria and fungi) (Beare et al. 1997; Seastedt 1984). Microarthropods therefore contribute
directly to humus formation and police the soil, playing an important role in mineral turnover
and the dynamics of soil organic matter (Butcher et al. 1971).
Within microarthropod communities, apterygote Acari and Collembola are generally
dominant both numerically and in terms of biomass (Seastedt 1984). Acari are often the most
numerous group in soils with a well-developed O-horizon rich in mor-type humus. In most
ecological studies Acari are traditionally divided into four suborders Oribatida, Gamasida (the
current O. Mesostigmata), Actinedida (the current O. Trombidiformes) and Acaridida (now
taxonomically included within Oribatida but considered functionally different) (following the
classification of Krantz & Walter 2009). Although they all include macrophytophages feeding on
decaying higher plant materials, Oribatida are microphytophages, feeding mainly on bacteria,
yeasts and fungi; Gamasida are mainly predators of small invertebrates; Actinedida exhibit
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
80
mixed feeding habits and Acaridida are mainly saprophagous. The intimate relationship between
these soil invertebrates and their ecological niches (van Straalen 1998), coupled with the fact that
some (i.e. oribatids) lead sedentary lives characterized by low mobility and, in many cases, low
growth rates make these groups sensitive to disturbance (Maraun et al. 1999). Collembola
community composition has also been observed to be sensitive to human-induced disturbances, a
fact that reduces the presence of rare or restricted distribution groups, mostly Isotomidae and
Onychiuridae, and increases the number of expansive or not so demanding species in terms of
soil moisture and organic matter content, these mainly being Entomobryidae and Neanuridae
(Sousa et al. 2003). Other Apterygota (Protura, Diplura and Thysanura), Micromyriapoda
(Simphyla, Pauropoda and Polyxenidae) or small Diptera larvae and Coleoptera may be locally
important (Lavelle & Spain 2001).
In the present study, we attempt to elucidate to what extent anthropogenic soils from road
embankments are functional or impaired, using microarthropod communities as a soil quality
proxy. Although this crucial feature of ecosystem functioning and dynamics has been studied in
depth in other anthropogenic soils (Arshad & Martin 2002; Giller et al. 1997; Lavelle 1996), it
remains largely unexplored in new soils created by earth movements and urbanization, such as
road embankments. To date, previous studies have addressed soil functionality on roadslopes
through plant cover response (see for instance Ferrer et al. 2011). However, under Mediterranean
conditions, plant cover is only descriptive at best during the first stages after road construction
(Jiménez et al. 2013). In order to tackle roadslope soil functionality from a more accurate
perspective, we applied the QBS index (Quailitá Biologica del Suolo) on six road embankments,
which have been monitored since their construction. The QBS index is an eco-morphological
index based upon the degree of linkage between the microarthropod character syndrome and soil
Capítulo II
81
environment (Parisi 2001). Due to the fact that soil microarthropods are highly heterogeneous in
space and time (Ettema & Wardle 2000) we conducted our study during two consecutive years.
We specifically attempt to address the following questions: 1. Are anthropogenic soils from road
embankments functional based on their QBS values? 2. If so, which processes determine soil
community structure and hence soil quality? Finally, we wished to explore the practical
implications of soil quality for road embankment management.
Material & Methods
Study area
The study area was located on the M-12 and M-13 highways (Barajas International Airport,
Madrid, Central Spain 40º29’N, 03º34’W; Fig. 1). These highways were both built from January
2002 to June 2004. Average annual temperature from 2009 to 2010 was approximately 15°C and
total annual precipitation was 360 mm. Soils in the surrounding area are nutrient-poor,
characterized mainly by silica sands and presenting basal conglomerates, gravels, silts and clays,
corresponding to river floodplains (Blanco-García et al. 2007). For further information see Mola
et al. (2011) and Jiménez et al. (2013).
Experimental design and background of sites
We selected six embankments (T1-T6) constructed in 2004, upon which topsoil was spread.
All of them had similar slope angles (32.1º ± 0.75) and size (12.0 ± 2.5 m). Distances among
road embankments ranged from 1900 to 20 m, with an average distance of 769.12 m ± 236.54
between them. The plant cover of each embankment was visually surveyed every spring from
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
82
2005 to 2010 by two different observers. Because of the strong influence on soil functionality of
feedbacks between belowground and aboveground communities (Bever et al. 1997), we decided
to set up our study from 2009 to 2010 when plant cover was stabilized (Fig. 2). On each
embankment, four points for soil and microarthropod samplings were established one meter apart
at medium-slope level and separated one meter from one another.
Figure 1. Map of Madrid (Spain) showing the location were the present study was conducted, six road
embankments (T1-T6) in the vicinity of the Barajas airport (aircraft symbol).
Soil properties
On each embankment, we collected four soil samples (12.5 x 12.5 x 5cm) of approximately
500 g weight previously removing the vegetation from on top. Samples were air-dried and sieved
through a 2 mm mesh. In each sample, soil texture was determined following Guitian and
Carballas (1976); as well as percentage of organic carbon by means of micro-plates (adapted
from Anne, 1945) and percentage of nitrogen with the Kjeldahl method, as described by Page et
Capítulo II
83
al. (1982). We also analyzed soil porosity (percentage of pores in soil), soil humidity (percentage
of these soil pores occupied by water) and soil aeration (percentage of soil pores occupied by air)
from four soil cores of known weight and volume collected on each embankment, following
Guitian and Carballas (1976).
Figure 2. Percentages of plant cover surveyed from 2005 to 2010 at the study sites (embankments T1 to
T6). Arrows indicate the years in which the present study conducted.
Microarthropod sampling and QBS index
Four vegetation-free soil samples (25 x 25 x 10 cm) were collected on each embankment for
microarthropod extraction. Microarthropods were extracted from 2 kg of homogenized soil with
the Berlese-Tullgren method (Krantz 1978). They were preserved in Scheerpeltz solution
(alcohol 70ºC, glycerol and acetic acid) until they were counted and identified under a
stereomicroscope (Motic SMZ-168 Series- Zoom 7.5X-50X). To assess soil quality on the
roadslopes, we chose the QBS index (Parisi et al. 2005). This index classifies microarthropods
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Pla
nt co
ver
(%
)
Time (years)
T-1
T-2
T-3
T-4
T-5
T-6
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
84
by their morphological features and do not require species level identification. An eco-
morphological score (EMI) from 1 to 20 is assigned to each taxonomical group according to its
adaptation level to soil. This level of adaptation is revealed through some morphological
characters such as: reduction or loss of pigmentation and visual structures; smooth body form,
reduced and more compact appendages (hairs, antennae, legs); reduction or loss of flying,
jumping or running adaptations; reduced water-retention capacity—e.g. thinner cuticle, lack of
hydrophobic compounds on the outer surface (Parisi 1974). Thus, the underlying concept is that
soil quality is positively correlated with the number of microarthropod groups that are well
adapted to soil habitats. The QBS index of each sample is the sum of EMI scores and it was
calculated for each soil invertebrate sample, in both years (2009 and 2010).
Data analysis
To analyze microarthropod community composition, a Detrended Correspondence Analysis
(DCA) was performed with most abundant microarthropod groups (Acari and Collembola).
Pearson correlation analyses were performed between DCA axes, plant cover, and soil properties
in order to test whether soil fauna composition varied in relation to site characteristics. We
analyzed variation of soil quality in space and time using repeated ANOVA (ANOVAR)
measures including embankment as a factor. We also correlated the QBS index with soil
variables and the QBS index in 2009 with the variation in soil quality during the study period
(ΔQBS= QBS 2010 – QBS 2009). Variables were transformed, if necessary, to achieve the
assumptions of normality and homogeneity of variances. For pair-wise comparisons, the Tukey
HSD test was performed. All statistical analyses were conducted using STATISTICA 9.1
software (StatSoft 2009).
Capítulo II
85
Results
Soil characterization
Anthropogenic soils from embankments were sandy-loam and very poor in nutrients, as
shown by their very low levels in soil organic carbon and nitrogen (Table 1). Although soil
carbon remained stable during the study period, total nitrogen content dramatically decreased
toward 2010 (nearly 50%), from normal values to low ones. This decrease had an impact on C/N
ratio, which duplicated its value in 2010, although it remained low.
Table1. Mean values (± SE) of soil variables measured in all roadslopes (T1-T6) during the study period (2009-
2010).
Soil properties (%) 2009 2010
%
%
Humidity 10.24 ± 0.50
9.82 ± 0.39
Porosity 49.97 ± 1.16
48.65 ± 1.14
Aeration 39.73 ± 1.30
38.83 ± 1.25
Sand content 61.56 ± 1.84
66.45 ± 1.47
Loam content 20.94 ± 1.26
17.65 ± 1.06
Clay content 17.50 ± 0.85
15.90 ± 1.02
Organic carbon content 0.33 ± 0.03
0.39 ± 0.03
Nitrogen content 0.16 ± 0.01
0.09 ± 0.01
C/N ratio 2.04 ± 0.72
4.59 ± 0.03
Soil quality
The QBS index was calculated for each sample (Table 2). ANOVAR results showed that soil
quality significantly varied among roadslopes (F [5,36] = 3.806; p < 0.01), embankment T4 being
the one with the highest soil quality, which increased towards 2010 (F [1,36] = 7.377; p < 0.05).
The QBS index in 2009 was negatively correlated with the variation in the index from 2009 to
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
86
2010 (r = -0.51; p < 0.05; Fig. 3). Across years, the QBS index was positively correlated with the
percentage of organic carbon (r = 0.571; p < 0.001).
Table 2. Mean values (±SE) of QBS index by road embankments both in 2009 and 2010.
Road
Embankment 2009 2010
T1 66.750 ± 7.782 144.000 ± 13.410
T2 90.250 ± 22.462 84.750 ± 19.610
T3 103.000 ± 12.179 123.000 ± 12.049
T4 144.250 ± 12.612 170.000 ± 16.114
T5 80.250 ± 9.286 126.250 ± 28.944
T6 119.500 ± 15.650 116.500 ± 21.941
Figure 3. Pearson correlation analysis between QBS index values in 2009 and the variation of the index during the
study period [ΔQBS= QBS 2010 – QBS 2009].
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
0 50 100 150 200
Δ Q
BS
QBS 2009
r= -0.51; p< 0.05
Capítulo II
87
Microarthropod community structure and dynamics
From the soil invertebrate samples, 36 groups of arthropods were recorded (Table 3).
However, only nine groups of euedaphic microarthropods were considered in the analysis of
community patterns. Groups selected for DCA analysis were as follows: Gamasida, Actinedida,
Acaridida, Oribatida Macropylina and Brachypilina (which includes Poronota and Gymnonota),
Symphypleona (which included the Sminthuridae and Dicyrtomidae families), Poduromorpha
(which included the Neanuridae, Hypogastruridae, Poduridae and Onychiuridae families) and
finally, Entomobriomorpha (which included the Tomoceridae, Isotomidae and Entomobryidae
families).
The first and second axes of the DCA analysis explained 35.1 and 19.3% of the variance,
respectively. The first axis was positively correlated with Gamasida and Acaridida and
negatively with Poronota and Symphypleona abundances. This axis also separated cases from
2009 from those from 2010, which suggests temporal changes at the community level (Fig. 4).
There was, however, certain plot aggregation by embankments which was apparent only in 2009.
As for 2010, we observed a general displacement of plots toward the negative extreme of the
first axis. Differences in plot coordinates from 2009 to 2010 however were not similar in all
embankments, with the highest displacements in the T5 and T6 samples and the lowest ones in
the T4 samples. Correlation between Axis 1 and edaphic and vegetation variables, showed a
significant correlation with percentage of organic carbon (Fig. 5).
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
88
Table 3. Mean density (number of individuals/kg of soil) (± SE) of different taxonomic groups of soil invertebrates
found on road embankments (T1-T6) for each sampling year (2009 and 2010).
Taxonomical group 2009 2010
individuals / kg.of soil individuals / kg.of soil
SC.Acari*
Gamasida (O. Mesostigmata) 70.112 ± 7.834
66.691 ± 13.033
Actinedida (O. Tombidiformes) 31.362 ± 5.399
246.886 ± 53.690
S.O. Oribatida
Macropylina 3.417 ± 0.957
7.434 ± 2.743
Brachypilina
Gymnonota 12.566 ± 3.227
61.874 ± 15.718
Porononota 30.137 ± 8.318
233.851 ± 63.537
Acaridida (Cohort Astigmatina) 20.071 ± 5.721
5.542 ± 1.928
O. Arachnida 1.375 ± 0.749
1.086 ± 0.219
O. Collembola
Fam. Sminthuridae 0.603 ± 0.246
5.497 ± 2.321
Fam. Dicyrtomidae - - - -
- - - -
0.292 ± 0.252
Fam. Neanuridae - - - -
- - - -
0.682 ± 0.365
Fam. Hypogastruridae 0.298 ± 0.214
0.833 ± 0.437
Fam. Poduridae - - - -
- - - -
0.516 ± 0.347
Fam. Onychiuridae 7.875 ± 4.179
2.090 ± 0.862
Fam. Tomoceridae - - - -
- - - -
0.292 ± 0.175
Fam. Isotomidae 12.320 ± 2.884
17.711 ± 5.195
Fam. Entomobryidae 0.625 ± 0.323
25.950 ± 6.592
O. Protura 0.375 ± 0.261
0.042 ± 0.042
O. Diplura 2.171 ± 0.919
5.287 ± 1.359
O. Thysanura - - - -
- - - -
0.042 ± 0.042
O. Psocoptera - - - -
- - - -
0.208 ± 0.170
O. Isoptera - - - -
- - - -
1.061 ± 0.549
O. Embioptera 0.500 ± 0.458
3.624 ± 1.805
O. Coleoptera 5.913 ± 1.665
9.192 ± 1.904
O. Dictioptera - - - -
- - - -
0.095 ± 0.066
O. Thysanoptera 1.917 ± 0.812
1.826 ± 0.886
O. Diptera 1.635 ± 0.317
4.401 ± 1.226
O. Hemiptera 7.671 ± 1.604
14.605 ± 4.807
O. Hymenoptera 4.402 ± 0.947
11.771 ± 4.835
O. Lepidoptera 0.042 ± 0.042
0.042 ± 0.042
O. Pauropoda 0.638 ± 0.271
0.304 ± 0.212
O. Symphyla - - - -
- - - -
0.919 ± 0.362
O. Polixenida - - - -
- - - -
0.242 ± 0.145
O. Julida 0.208 ± 0.104
0.061 ± 0.061
O. Litobida 1.728 ± 0.697
0.125 ± 0.069
O. Scolopendrida 0.144 ± 0.109
0.455 ± 0.196
O. Isopoda 0.542 ± 0.241
0.417 ± 0.210
Capítulo II
89
Figure 4. Distribution of the sample plots in the space defined by the two first axes of a DCA analysis. Colored
arrows mark the trajectory of the samples from each study road embankment (blue=T1; orange= T2; green=T3;
red=T4; grey=T5 and yellow=T6). Empty dots correspond to samples collected in 2009 while solid ones correspond
to those from 2010.
The second axis was positively correlated with Gymnonota and negatively with
Actinedida. Samples from 2010 also showed a displacement toward the negative extreme of the
second axis in most of the cases (Fig. 4). This axis was significantly correlated with physical
properties of the soil such as percentage of soil humidity and percentage of clay content (Fig. 5).
Gymnonota
Poronota Symphypleona
Gamasida
Acaridida
Entomobryomorpha
Actinedida
Macropylina
Poduromorpha
Axis 1
Axis 2
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
90
Figure 5. Significant Pearson correlations (p< 0.05) obtained from the analysis of the relationship between DCA
Axes and soil variables.
0.00 0.10 0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70
DC
A a
xis
1
% Organic Carbon
0.00 5.00 10.00 15.00 20.00
DC
A A
xis
2
% Humidity
0.00 5.00 10.00 15.00 20.00 25.00 30.00
DC
A A
xis
2
% Clay
r= -0,44; p< 0.01
r= 0.44; p< 0.01
r= 0.535; p<0.001
Capítulo II
91
Discussion
Our results showed that anthropogenic soils on six-years-old road embankments are fully
functional as supported by the values and variation of soil quality indicators (i.e. QBS), and by
the composition of the soil microarthopod community.
Nearly all soils from the road embankments exhibited QBS values above 100 during the
study period, which has previously been interpreted as indicative of well-developed and
functional soils (Parisi et al. 2005). Indeed, the maximum QBS values obtained in the present
study were similar to those found by Parisi and coworkers (2005) in natural systems. Moreover,
QBS spatio-temporal variation was largely accounted for by soil organic carbon content. This is
one of the main results of the present research. In road embankment soils, singled out among
other urban soils by very low levels of organic matter, only a slight increase of approximately
0.6% in organic carbon is enough to trigger a significant change in soil functionality. In these
anthropogenic soils, organic carbon increases with time due to litter input at the early stages of
plant community establishment (Jiménez et al. 2013). However, the observed negative
correlation between the QBS values in 2009 and the QBS increment in 2010 suggest attenuation
in soil quality over time, although two years of data is clearly insufficient with regard to
detecting a representative temporal trend. Strikingly, this attenuation appears to overlap with that
observed in plant cover.
Beyond its contribution to QBS-index definition, microarthropod community
composition also provides further evidence of anthropogenic soil functionality. The presence of
certain groups and the mechanisms regulating their relative abundances are intimately linked to
soil functionality (Cole et al. 2005). During the study period, the soil community on the road
embankments was dominated by Acari and Collembola, groups involved in organic matter
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
92
decomposition and soil microstructure formation (Palacios-Vargas et al. 2007). Among them,
some Acari groups better explained variation in the microarthropod community during the study
period. The presence of Oribatida Brachypilina (i.e., Poronota and Gymnonota), given their
phytophagus habits, is linked to soil availability in organic matter, particularly plant material and
microflora (Luxton 1972). Acaridida, very abundant in 2009, usually occur sporadically except
in dry soils, such as arable lands and deserts (Wallwork 1970, 1976). It is a generalist group of
microarthropods that easily colonize new habitats because of their facility of dispersion due to
the long hairs that enable them to be phoretic (Norton 1980). Gamasida and many species of
Actinedida are basically predators (Koehler 1997; Lavelle & Spain 2001) and tend to concentrate
in areas where the soil fauna they prey upon is highly abundant (Gutiérrez-López et al. 2003).
Thus, the dominance of these mites in 2009 could be attributed to the availability of Acaridida,
and perhaps to the scarcity of competitors, such as some species of Coleoptera, Diplura or
centipedes. Actinedida is a highly heterogeneous group with regard to ecological requirements
(Kethley 1982), whose meaning in terms of soil functionality has been assessed with respect to
the relative abundance of Oribatida (Loots & Ryke 1967). The oribatid mites Poronota and
Gymnonota, on the other hand, are indicative of more stable soil conditions, as they are very
sensitive to soil disturbance (Wallwork 1970, 1976) owing to their slow development (Maraun et
al. 1999). The intimate dependence of oribatids upon soil conditions relies on their involvement
in the decomposition of organic matter and nutrient cycling and soil formation (Behan-Pelletier
1999). They process litter fragments and resize them for suitable intake (Norton 1980), and
influence soil structure by means of their fecal pellets, increasing the area for microorganism-
mediated nutrient mineralization. Among Collembola, Symphypleona are also indicative of soil
stability. Collembolans play a major role in soil microstructure development at the early stages
Capítulo II
93
of pedogenesis, and in more developed soils contribute to disintegrating macro- and mega-fauna
excrements, accelerating the incorporation of nutrients into the soil (Rusek 1998 and references
therein). Previous studies have found total organic matter to be the most important variable in the
organization of the Oribatida and Collembola communities (Hale 1971; Hasegawa 2001;
Maraun et al. 1999). Different groups respond differently to the type and amount of organic
matter. For example, Oribatida abundances have been correlated with the lightest organic matter
density fraction (Vreeken-Buijs et al. 1998), which is the one that preferably shows an increases
in urban soils (Scharenboch et al. 2005) and the abundances of this microarthropod have also
been correlated with the development of urban soils (Bever et al. 1997).
Conclusions
Changes in microarthropod community composition are usually shaped by land use and
management through their effects on soil properties (Butcher et al. 1971; Gutiérrez-López et al.
2010; Sousa et al. 2003). In our study the microarthopod community transition, from groups less
dependent on soil to those characteristic of more stable soils, was driven by variations in clay
content, soil organic carbon and humidity. Previous studies reported an increase in clay content
in anthropogenic soils (Scharenbroch et al. 2005) related with clay translocation, which is
indicative of soil development (Beyer et al. 1995). Our results showed an increase in clay
content, organic matter and soil humidity resulting in higher abundances of Oribatida. Clays in
soil usually associate with higher levels of organic matter, which in turn ultimately affect soil
porosity (Porta et al. 1999). The habitat created by small but numerous pores sift many
microarthropod species out of the emergent community. In general terms, Oribatida remain
associated with the 6-90 m pore size class (Vreeken-Buijs et al. 1998). In our study, the
Gymnonota observed were most often small-sized oribatids of the Oppiidae family.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
94
To our knowledge, the present study is the first to substantiate the occurrence of
functional soils on young road embankments. Soil functioning as ecosystem functioning relays
on nutrient cycling, substrate stability and maintenance of hydrological processes as well
absorption and transfer of energy (Whisenant 1999), which are processess intricately linked with
the activity of microarthropods communities (Lavelle 1996; Liiri et al. 2002; Neher 1999). This
finding is sufficiently relevant to justify revision of current roadslope management and
monitoring practices. Pertinence of roadslope reprofiling actions and drainage works should be
appraised in the light of this emerging ecological capital. To date, roadslope monitoring has
focused on plant cover, while microarthropod community seem to provide a more accurate
assessment of soil processes. The key to successful roadside restoration toward self-sustained
ecosystems probably lies in the consolidation of a fully functional soil.
Acknowledgements
We are indebted to Marga Costa, Ana Buades and Mónica Otero for field and lab support, and to
Mr. Cormac de Brun for the English revision of the text. We also wish to thank the R&D
Department at OHL and Eje-Aeropuerto for their help and permission to conduct the research.
This study was funded by OHL, the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness
(ECONECT project: CDTI IDI-20120317), Madrid Regional Government (REMEDINAL-2 S-
2009/AMB-1783), and by an FPU grant program of the Spanish Ministry of Education, Culture
and Sports (FPU-AP2009-0094).
Capítulo II
95
References
Anne, P. (1945). Sur le dosage rapide du carbone organique des sols. Annales de Agronomie, 2:
162-172.
Arshad, M. A., & Martin, S. (2002). Identifying critical limits for soil quality indicators in agro-
ecosystems. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 88: 153-160.
Beare, M.H., Reddy, M.V., Tian, G., & Srivastava, S.C. (1997). Agricultural intensification, soil
biodiversity and agroecosystem function in the tropics: the role of decomposer biota.
Applied Soil Ecology, 6: 87-108.
Behan-Pelletier, V.M. (1999). Oribatid mite biodiversity in agroecosystems: role for
bioindication. Agriculture Ecosystems & Environment, 74: 411-423.
Bever, J.D., Westover, K.M., & Antonovics, J. (1997). Incorporating the soil community into
plant population dynamics: The utility of the feedback approach. Journal of Ecology, 85:
561-573.
Beyer, L., Blume, H.P., Elsner, D.C., & Willnow, A. (1995). Soil organic matter composition
and microbial activity in urban soils. Science of the Total Environment, 168: 267-278.
Blanco-García, I., Rodas, M., Sánchez, C.J., & Alonso-Azcarate, J. (2007). Gravel washing
wastes from Jarama river deposits (Spain), an undervalued raw material. Environmental
Geology, 52: 1097-1115.
Butcher, J.W., Snider, R., & Snider, R.J. (1971). Bioecology of edaphic Collembola and Acarina.
Annual Review of Entomology, 16: 249-289.
Cole, L., Buckland, S.M., & Bardgett, R.D. (2005). Relating microarthropod community
structure and diversity to soil fertility manipulations in temperate grassland. Soil Biology
& Biochemestry, 37: 1707-1717.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
96
Crutzen, P.J. (2002). Geology of Mankind. Nature. 415: 23.
De Deyn, G.B., Raaijmakers, C.E., Zoomer, H.R., Berg, M.P., de Ruiter, P.C. Verhoef, H.A.,
Bezemer, T.M., & van der Putten, W.H. (2003). Soil invertebrate fauna enhances
grassland succession and diversity. Nature, 422: 711-713.
Doran, J.W., & Zeiss, M.R. (2000). Soil health and sustainability: managing the biotic
component of soil quality. Applied Soil Ecology, 15: 3-11.
Ettema, C.H., & Wardle, D.A. (2000). Spatial soil ecology. Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 17:
177-183.
FAO (1988). Soil map of the world, 1: 5,000,000. UNESCO, Rome.
Ferrer, A., Mochón, I., De Oña, J., & Osorio, F. (2011). Evolution of the soil and vegetation
cover on road embankments after the application of sewage sludge. Water, Air & Soil
Pollution, 214: 231-240. DOI: 10.1007/s11270-010-0419-8.
Gardi, C., Tomaselli, M., Parisi, V., Petraglia, A., & Santini, C. (2002). Soil quality indicators
and biodiversity in northern Italian permanent grasslands. European Journal of Soil
Biology, 38: 103-110.
Giller, K.E., Beare, M.H., Lavelle, P., Izac, A.M.N., & Swift, M.J. (1997). Agricultural
intensification, soil biodiversity and agroecosystem function. Applied Soil Ecology, 6: 3-
16.
Guitián, F. & Carballas, T. (1976). Técnicas de análisis de suelos. Pico Sacro, Santiago de
Compostela. 288 pp.
Gutiérrez-López, M., Ramajo, M., Jesús-Lidón, J.B., & Díaz-Cosín, D.J. (2003). The effect of
Hormogaster elisae (Hormogastridae) on the abundance of soil Collembola and Acari in
laboratory cultures. Biology & Fertility of Soils, 37: 231-236.
Capítulo II
97
Gutiérrez-López, M., Jesús- Lidón, J.B., Trigo, D., Fernández, R., Novo, M., & Díaz-Cosín, D.J.
(2010). Relationships among spatial distribution of soil microarthropods, earthworm
species and soil properties. Pedobiologia, 53: 381-389.
Hale, W.G., (1971). Colémbolos. In: Burgues, A., Raw, F. (Eds.) Biología del Suelo. Ediciones
Omega, Barcelona, pp 463-479.
Hartley, W., Uffindell, L., Plumb, A., Rawlinson, H.A, Putwain, P., & Dickinson, N.M. (2008).
Assessing biological indicators for remediated anthropogenic urban soils. Science of the
Total Environment, 405: 358-369.
Hasegawa, M. (2001). The relationship between the organic matter composition of a forest floor
and the structure of a soil arthropod community. European Journal of Soil Biology, 37:
281-284.
Hobbs, R.J., Arico, S., Aronson, J., Baron, J.S., Bridgewater, P., Cramer, V.A., Epstein, P.R.,
Ewel, J.J., Klink, C.A., Lugo, A.E., Norton, D., Ojima, D., M. Richardson, D.M.,
Sanderson, E.W., Valladares, F., Vilà, M., Zamora, R., & Zobel, M. (2006). Novel
ecosystems: theoretical and management aspects of the new ecological world order.
Global Ecology & Biogeography, 15: 1-7.
Hooke, R. L., Martín-Duque, J.F., & Pedraza, J. (2012). Land transformation by humans. GSA
Today, 22: 4-10.
ISRIC-FAO. (2006). World reference base for soil resources 2006. World soil resources reports,
103. UNESCO, Rome.
Jiménez, M.D., Ruiz-Capillas, P., Mola, I., Pérez-Corona, E., Casado, M.A., & Balaguer, L.
(2013). Soil development at the roadside: A case study of a novel ecosystem. Land
Degradation & Development, 24: 564–574.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
98
Kethley, J. (1982). Acariformes. In Parker, S.P. (Ed.). Synopsis and classification of living
organisms. 117-145 pp. Mc-Graw-Hill, Book Co., New York.
Koehler, H.H. (1997). Mesostigmata (Gamasina, Uropodina), efficient predators in
agroecosystems. Agric Ecosyst Environ, 62: 105-117.
Krantz, G.W. (1978). A manual of acarology. Oregon State University Book Stores, Inc.
Krantz, G.W. & Walter, D.E. (2009). A Manual of Acarology. 3rd ed. Texas Tech University
Press, Lubbock.
Lavelle, P. (1996). Diversity of soil fauna and ecosystem function. Biology International, 33: 3-
16.
Lavelle, P., & Spain, A.V. (2001). Soil Ecology. Kluwer Academic Publishers. Springer.
Netherlands.
Lehmann, A., & Stahr, K. (2007). Nature and significance of anthropogenic urban soils. Journal
of Soils & Sediments, 7: 247-260.
Liiri, M., Setälä, H., Haimi, J., Pennanen, T., & Fritze, H. (2002). Relationship between soil
microarthropod species diversity and plant growth does not change when the system is
disturbed. Oikos, 96: 137-149.
Loots, G.C., & Ryke, P.A.J. (1967). The ratio Oribatei: Trombidiformes with reference to
organic matter content in soils. Pedobiologia, 7: 121-124.
Luxton, M. (1972). Studies on the oribatid mites of a Danish beech wood soil. I. Nutritional
biology. Pedobiologia, 12: 434-463.
Maraun, M., Alphei, J., Bonkowski, M., Buryn, R., Migge, S., Peter, M., Schazfer, M., & Scheu,
S. (1999). Middens of the earthworm Lumbricus terrestris (Lumbricidae): microhabitats
for microand meso-fauna in forest soil. Pedobiologia, 43: 276-287.
Capítulo II
99
Mola, I., Jiménez, M.D., López-Jiménez, N., Casado, M.A., & Balaguer, L. (2011). Roadside
reclamation outside the revegetation season: Management options under schedule
pressure. Restoration Ecology, 19: 83-92.
Neher, D.A. (1999). Soil community composition and ecosystem processes. Comparing
agricultural ecosystems with natural ecosystems. Agroforestry Systems, 45: 159-185.
Nehls, T., Jozefaciuk, G., Sokołowska, Z., Hajnos, M., & Wessolek, G. (2006). Pore-system
characteristics of pavement seam materials of urban sites. Journal of Plant Nutrition and
Soil Science, 169: 16-24.
Norton, R.A. (1980). Observations on phoresy in oribatid mites (Acari:Oribatei). International
Journal of Acarology, 6: 121-130.
Page, A.L., Miller, E.M., & Keeney, D.R. (1982). Methods in Soil Analysis. Part 2. Chemical
and Microbiological Properties. Soil Science Society of America, Inc., Madison.
Palacios-Vargas, J.G., Castaño-Meneses, G., Gómez-Anaya, J.A., Martínez-Sánchez-Irizar, A.,
Mejía-Recamier, B.E., & Martínez-Sánchez, J. (2007). Litter and soil arthropods
diversity and density in a tropical dry forest ecosystem in Western México. Biodiversity
& Conservation, 16: 3703-3717.
Parisi, V. (1974). Soil biology and ecology, techniques of researches. Boringhieri, Torino (in
Italian).
Parisi, V. (2001). The biological soil quality, a method based on microarthropods. Acta Naturalia
de L’Ateneo Parmense, 37: 97-106.
Parisi, V., Menta, C., Gardi, C., Jacomini, C., & Mozzanica, E. (2005). Microarthropod
communities as a tool to assess soil quality and biodiversity: a new approach in Italy.
Agriculture Ecosystems & Environment, 105: 323-333.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
100
Porta, J., López-Acevedo, M., & Roquero, C. (1999). Edafología para la agricultura y el medio
ambiente. 2ª Edición. Ediciones Mundi-Prensa. Madrid. 849 pp.
Rusek, J. (1998). Biodiversity of Collembola and their functionalrole in the ecosystem.
Biodiversity & Conservation, 7: 1207-1219.
Scharenbroch, B.C., Lloyd, J.E., & Johnson-Maynard, J.L. (2005). Distinguishing urban soils
with physical, chemical, and biological properties. Pediobiologia, 49: 283-296.
Seastedt, T.R. (1984). The role of microarthropods in decomposition and mineralization
processes. Annuual Review of Entomology, 29: 25-46.
Sousa J.P., da Gama M.M., & Ferreira C.S. (2003). Effects of replacing oak-woods by
eucalyptus on edaphic Collembola communities: does the size and type of plantation
matter? Acta Entomológica Ibérica e Macaronésica, 1: 1-10.
StatSoft. (2009). STATISTICA 9.1. Statsoft, Inc., Tulsa, OK.
TEEB (2010). The economics of ecosystems and biodiversity: Ecological and Economic
Foundations. Kumar,P.( Ed.). Earthscan, London.
Tsiafouli M.A., Kallimanis, A.S., Katana, E., Stamou G.P., & Sgardelis S.P. (2005). Responses
of soil microarthropods to experimental short-term manipulations of soil moisture.
Applied Soil Ecology, 29: 17-26.
van Straalen, N.M. & Verhoef, H.A. (1997). The development of a bioindicator system for soil
acidity based on arthropod pH preferences. Journal of Applied Ecology, 34: 217- 232.
van Straalen, N.M. (1998). Evaluation of bioindicator systems derived from soil arthropod
communities. Applied Soil Ecology, 9: 429-437.
Vitousek, P.M., Mooney, H.A., Lubchenco, J., & Melillo, J.M. (1997). Human Domination of
Earth’s Ecosystems. Science, 277: 494-499.
Capítulo II
101
Vreeken-Buijs, M.J., Hassink, J., & Brussaard, L. (1998). Relationships of soil microarthropod
biomass with organic matter and pore size distribution in soils under different land use.
Soil Biology & Biochemestry, 30: 97-106.
Wallwork, J.A. (1970). Ecology of soil animals. McGraw Hill, London.
Wallwork, J.A. (1976). The distribution and diversity of soil fauna. Academic Press, London.
Whisenant, S.G. (1999). Repairing Damaged Wildlands. Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 312 pp.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
102
103
CAPITULO III
Roadside microbes: factors affecting community structure and composition in urban soils from road embankments
S. Magro, E.E. Kuramae & L. Balaguer
Urban Ecosystems (Submitted)
104
Capítulo III
105
Abstract
Human-mediated changes in terrestrial ecosystems give rise to urban soils such as those present
in road embankments. Interest in biological communities associated with these environments has
increased in the last few decades. However, despite the key role of biological communities in
soil processes, little is known about their bacterial community structure. In the present study, we
analyzed bacterial communities in anthrosols from road embankments and determined the
relevant scale for community self-organization. We collected 12 bulk soil samples in four
different road embankments (n=48) and analyzed soil bacteria community composition and
diversity by means of 16S rRNA partial gene sequences, and soil factors (C, N, C:N, texture, soil
structure and pH). Bacterial communities from road embankments present diversity levels
similar to other anthrosols and are dominated by Actinobacteria, Acidobacteria and
Planctomycetes, indicative of stable soil conditions. We also found low abundances of
Bacteroidetes, Firmicutes, Gemmatimonadetes and Cyanobacteria that could be related to
secondary succession pathways. Soil-borne bacterial community structure in these soils is site-
dependent and mainly conditioned by local soil factors as pH and soil texture. Given that plant
community dynamics in road embankments depending on biotic interactions, our results can be
used to guide the management and maintenance of local bacterial community composition,
considering further implications on the goods and services that urban environments may provide.
Keywords: road slopes, anthrosols, microbial ecology, soil factors, 16S rRNA, pyrosequencing
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
106
Introduction
Changes in land use and land cover significantly affect the structure of terrestrial
ecosystems across biomes (Lambin et al. 2001). Long-term impacts of historical and ongoing
human–mediated changes have altered soils, giving rise to alternative ecosystem configurations,
the so-called anthropogenic soils or anthrosols (ISRIC-FAO 2006). For instance, anthrosols as
those derived from agricultural practices differ in quantity and quality of organic matter
(Eisenhauer et al. 2012), and exhibit a severely altered nutrient storage and soil structure (Guo &
Guifford 2002; Murty et al. 2002). These changes may result in bacterial communities of lower
biomass than those present in natural systems (Gunapala & Scow 1998). Human activities also
shapes soil bacterial community composition (Acosta-Martínez et al. 2008) and its spatial
variability and distribution (Ettema & Wardle 2002). Locally, anthrosols are characterized by
bacterial communities with a simplified composition and low diversity levels, dominated by
specific groups (Buckley & Schmidt 2001; Hartmann & Widmer 2006). Across scale, the spatial
organization of bacterial communities may vary from micrometer to thousands of kilometers
(Nunan et al. 2002; Van der Gucht et al. 2007). This structure may result from both local factors,
such as soil pH (Fierer & Jackson 2006), and landscape and regional processes, such as dispersal
limitations (Van der Gucht et al. 2007).
Urban soils are specific type of anthrosols result of earthworks and infrastructure
construction (Lehmann & Stahr 2007). A particular case of urban soils are those derived from
road construction (Lehmann 2006). The differential characteristics of these anthropogenic soils
emerge from the interaction between their constructive features and the subsequent management,
both aimed to ensure geotechnical stability and plant cover development (Tormo et al. 2007).
Road embankments are constructed by heaping and compacting layers of aggregate materials
Capítulo III
107
that create new reliefs with slopes less than 51 %, and heterogeneous substrates with specific
granulometry that accomplishes with constructive project demands (Alfaya 2013), with very low
organic matter content (under 0.20%) and total nitrogen (around 0.02%) and high pH levels
(above 7.5) (Jiménez et al. 2013). Management of these newly created environments usually
involves the application of topsoil and hydroseeding with mixtures of commercial species
(Balaguer 2002). In Mediterranean regions, the effect of topsoiling coupled with the gentle slope
of embankments boosts primary production that may result in plant cover of around 100 %
during the first growing season after road construction (Mola et al. 2011). This increase in
biomass production leads to high carbon inputs to the soil, from litter fall and root turnover,
which ultimately results in seasonal pulses of organic matter accumulation (Lehmann & Stahr
2007). The specific characteristics of these soils shape the structure and spatial distribution of
the biological communities present on road embankments, giving rise to a particular combination
of plant species and soil microarthropod communities as described in recent studies (García-
Palacios et al. 2011; Magro et al. 2013). Despite the importance of lower levels of soil food webs
in ecosystem functionality (Holtkamp et al. 2011) and the reasonable expectation that specific
characteristics of these anthrosols may result in new assemblages of soil bacteria, little is known
about the community composition and spatial distribution of these organisms on road
embankments.
In the present study, we analyzed soil-borne bacterial communities in anthrosols from
road embankments in order to address the following questions: 1.) What are the main groups of
bacteria present in these soils? In order to answer this question, bacterial community structure
was analyzed by means of 16S rRNA partial gene sequences. We hypothesized that bacterial
communities are low in diversity and show a simplified composition similar to those present in
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
108
other anthropogenic soils (i.e., agricultural soils) because anthrosols on roadsides are
unstructured substrates; 2.) What is the relevant spatial scale at which to explain changes in
bacterial community composition and diversity and what are the main factors underlying changes
in community structure? We analyzed the spatial variation in bacterial communities considering
distances ranging from meters to kilometers. To elucidate local and regional factors underlying
spatial patterns of community similarity we used a Multi–Model Inference (MMI) (Burnham &
Anderson, 2002) approach. We hypothesized that bacterial communities in nearby embankments
are more similar in composition than those far away because of the influence of regional factors
related to road construction features, surrounding vegetation or roadside management.
Material & Methods
Site description and experimental design
The experiment was conducted in four road embankments located in two highways in
Madrid, central Spain: highway N-1 at El Molar (40º 43' 4.42'' N, 3º 39' 44.28'' W) and highway
M–13 at Barajas, next to the International Airport (40º 28' 49.74'' N, 3º 38' 15.91'' W). The
distance between highways was around 27 km. During the study period, average annual
temperature was approximately 15 ◦C and total annual precipitation was 308 mm
(http://www.tutiempo.net/clima/Madrid_Barajas/82210.htm). Road embankments from El Molar
(M1 and M2) were separated by 4.7 kilometers, and those from Barajas (T1 and T2), separated
by 0.7 km (Table 1). Anthrosols from embankments are artificial and heterogeneous due to the
combined effect of construction materials (aggregates from primary rock, sand and gravels) and
applied topsoil (Hill et al. 2011; Ministerio de Fomento 2002). To capture soil heterogeneity
within sites in our sampling, we constructed twelve experimental plots (2x2m) on each road
Capítulo III
109
embankment. In order to avoid the effect of slope position, all experimental plots where located
in the lower–slope zone, that in road embankments correspond to the further zone to the road that
do not suffer any management such as roadslope re-grading, mowing or herbicide application.
Table 1. Main characteristics and soil properties of the four sites studied. Numerical values are means ± SE (n =
48).(*) Indicates plant cover at the beginning of the experiment.
Soil factor M1 M2 T1 T2
Coordinates 40°45´54´´N 40°43´53´´N 40°29´39´´N 40°29´18´´N
3°36´21´´W 3°34´12´´W 3°36´13´´W 3°36´04´´W
Motorway A1 A1 M12 M12
Year of
construction 2008 2007 2004 2004
Total lenght (m) 180 165 140 250
Hieght (m) 20 24 14 12.5
Aspect WSW NW W E
Topsoil Spreading Yes Yes Yes Yes
Hydroseeding Yes Yes Yes Yes
Soil type Gneisses Gneisses Coarse sand Coarse sand
Plant cover* 100 100 100 100
C (%) 1,09 ± 0,11 1,38 ± 0,07 0,88 ± 0,02 0,92 ± 0,08
N (%) 0,04 ± 0,01 0,06 ± 0,00 0,05 ± 0,00 0,04 ± 0,00
C/N 31,17 ± 4,84 22,40 ± 1,14 16,73 ± 0,74 22,63 ± 1,08
Sand content (%) 77,06 ± 0,62 71,58 ± 0,85 57,43 ± 3,69 68,27 ± 0,98
Loam content (%) 9,94 ± 0,59 11,95 ± 1,07 26,61 ± 4,73 17,67 ± 1,63
Clay content (%) 13,00 ± 0,19 16,47 ± 0,82 15,95 ± 1,17 14,06 ± 1,32
Humidity (%) 4,48 ± 0,55 4,96 ± 0,52 8,57 ± 1,08 5,18 ± 0,60
Porosity (%) 78,89 ± 2,47 81,37 ± 1,49 68,25 ± 3,82 75,70 ± 1,33
Aeration (%) 74,40 ± 2,26 76,41 ± 1,28 59,68 ± 4,30 70,53 ± 1,30
Bulk density
(g/cm3) 0,69 ± 0,05 0,62 ± 0,03 1,00 ± 0,11 0,72 ± 0,04
pH 7,80 ± 0,15 7,09 ± 0,10 7,95 ± 0,06 8,18 ± 0,08
Soil sampling and physicochemical analyses
Soil samples were collected at the end of the spring (June 2011) agreeing on the principal
activity period in Mediterranean environments. We collected 48 bulk soil samples (1 bulk sample
per experimental plot* 12 experimental plots per embankment* 2 embankments* 2 locations).
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
110
Bulk samples were composed of four soil subsamples (12.5 x 12.5 x 5cm) from different points
of the experimental plot. From each, a small amount of soil was preserved at –40°C for
molecular analyses. The remaining soil sample was air-dried and sieved through a 2 mm sieve.
Then, texture (percentage of sand, clay and loam) was analyzed following the procedure outlined
by Guitián and Carballas (1976). Soil organic carbon and total nitrogen were analyzed by means
of a basic microanalyzer LECO CHNS–932 (analyses were performed by C.A.I Microanálisis
Elemental UCM). We also measured soil pH of each soil sample in deionized water in a
proportion 1:2.5, with a Crison pH meter. Finally, from each experimental plot, a soil core of
known weight and volume was collected to analyze soil structure (percentages of aeration,
humidity and porosity of soil and bulk density) (Guitián & Carballas 1976).
Nucleic acid extraction and 16S rRNA gene amplification
Soil DNA from samples (n=48) was isolated using the Power Soil kit (MoBio, Carlsbad,
CA), and quantified on an ND–1000 spectrophotometer (Nanodrop Technology, Wilmington,
DE). Region V4 of the 16S rRNA gene was amplified with primers 515F and 806R (Lauber et al.
2009). The 515F primer included the Roche 454-B pyro-sequencing adapter and GT linker,
while 806R included the Roche 454-A sequencing adapter and GG linker. A 12-bp barcode was
included in both primers. The PCR was carried out using 0.2 units of Hot Start Taq Polymerase
(Roche Applied Sciences, Indianapolis, IN, USA), 2.5 ml of 2 mM dNTP and 0.5 mM of each
primer. PCR conditions were an initial denaturation step at 95 °C (5 min), 30 amplification
cycles of denaturation at 95 °C (30 s), annealing at 54 °C (60 s), and extension at 72 °C (60 s),
followed by a final extension at 72 °C (10 min). Negative controls were carried out with water.
Five independent PCR amplifications were performed from each sample and were pooled
Capítulo III
111
together. Pooled PCR products were purified with the QIAgen PCR purification kit (Qiagen,
Valencia, CA) and reduced to a final volume of 25 µl in an Eppendorf Speedvac Concentrator
5301. Samples were sequenced (Macrogen Inc. Company, South Korea) on a Roche 454
automated sequencer and GS FLX system using titanium chemistry (454 Life Sciences,
Branford, CT).
Data analysis
Sequences and quality information were extracted from the Standard Flowgram Format
(SFF) files using the SFF converter tool in the Galaxy interface (Goecks et al. 2010 ). Only
sequences with a length of 200 to 350 base pairs were accepted and bases with a quality score
lower than 20 were trimmed. Sequences were further analyzed with the Qiime version 1.2.1
scripts (Caporaso et al. 2010), which have been made available in the Galaxy interface. Firstly,
all the sequences with a perfect match to the primer sequences containing no homopolymer run
exceeding six nucleotides and without ambiguous characters were assigned to samples by
matching to barcode sequences. Reverse complementary sequences were put in the forward
orientation and assigned to samples by partially matching to barcode sequences. This step was
confirmed by the V-REVCOMP tool using Hidden Markov Models (HMMs) (Hartmann &
Widmer 2006). Secondly, sequence errors introduced during pyrosequencing were detected using
the option for titanium data in the Denoiser 0.91 program (Reeder & Knight 2010). The
sequences were also checked for PCR chimeras using UCHIME (Edgar et al. 2011). Only
sequences with a length of 200 to 350 base pairs were accepted and bases with a quality score
lower than 20 were trimmed. The low quality sequences were discarded. The obtained high
quality sequences were clustered into Operational Taxonomic Units (OTUs) using UCLUST
version 1.2.21 (Edgar 2010) with a minimum sequence identity cutoff of 97 %. For each OTU
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
112
the most abundant sequence was selected as a representative for all sequences within an OTU.
Taxonomy was assigned to the representative sequences using the Ribosomal Database Project
(RDP) 2 classifier (release 10.4). Finally, the OTU table was filtered for specific taxonomic
terms using scripts provided by Qiime. Singleton OTUs were removed for community analyses.
The OTU table was rarified considering the lowest number of reads per sample. To explore
variation of bacterial communities from road embankments, a Non–metric Multidimensional
Scaling (NMDS) was performed using Bray–Curtis distance. Shannon diversity index (i.e.,
entropy), Simpson index (i.e., 1–dominance) and Equitability (i.e., Shannon diversity divided by
the logarithm of number of taxa) were calculated per sample using PAST (software v. 2.17c;
Palaeontologia Electronica [http://palaeo–electronica.org/2001_1/past/issue1_01.htm]). General
Linear Models (GLM) were applied to elucidate spatial patterns underlying bacterial community
composition and diversity (Statistica; v. 7.0, StatSoft, 2009). NMDS axis and α–diversity indices
were included as response variables, and location (Barajas and El Molar) and site (embankments
M1, M2, T1 and T2) as fixed factors (Zuur et al. 2009). Due to the hierarchical relationship
between fixed factors, the site factor was nested within location. Pairwise comparison was
performed using the HSD Tukey test. To analyze the contribution of soil factors to microbial
community structure in road slopes we selected the Multi–Model Inference (MMI) (Burnham &
Anderson 2002) approach. MMI is increasingly being used and recommended for the analysis of
observational data collected over ecological gradients (Maestre et al. 2012). This approach may
be of special interest in the analysis of factors affecting bacterial community composition
because soil factors are most often closely correlated with one another and it is difficult to
differentiate the relative contribution of each upon the process we aim to explain. In this sense,
the main advantage of this approach compared with traditional hypothesis testing focused on the
Capítulo III
113
variables to include versus exclude in a selected model, is that MMI ranks all predictor variables
according to their relative importance (Burnham & Anderson 2002). In MMI analysis, the first
axis of NMDS was included as a response variable and soil characteristics as factors. Loam soil
content was excluded in order to avoid redundant information because it is estimated from sand
and clay content. All models were ranked using Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) (Akaike
1973) applying the correction for small sample sizes (Shono 2000). Best model (with the lowest
AIC value) was selected in order to elucidate the percentage of the variance explained by
environmental factors. If differences in AIC between models was lower or equal to 2, then the
models were considered not to be significantly different (Motulsky & Christopoulos 2004). All
models were fit using GLMs in R (R 2.9.2, R Development Core Team 2008) and associated
packages available in CRAN (http://cran.r–project.org).
Results
Soil bacteria community composition
The total number of 16S rRNA sequences was 48,723 ranging from 1,041 to 10,593
sequences per sample. After rarefaction, sequences were classified into 211 different OTUs
corresponding to 22 phyla. Predominant bacterial phyla in urban soils from road embankments
were Actinobacteria, Planctomycetes and Acidobacteria accounting for 18.80, 16.62 and 11.34%
of the total number of sequences, respectively. The phyla Gemmatimonadetes, Bacteroidetes,
Firmicutes and Cyanobacteria were among the less abundant with relative abundance under 2%.
Archaea relative abundance was very low (< 1.5%) (Fig. 1).
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
114
Fig
ure
1.
Rel
ativ
e ab
un
dan
ce o
f m
icro
bia
l g
rou
ps
(Mea
n ±
SE
) fo
un
d i
n a
nth
roso
ls f
rom
em
ban
km
ents
. a)
Mai
n p
hy
la o
f b
acte
ria
and
Pro
teo
ba
cter
ia c
lass
es
(
A
lph
a–,
Bet
a–,
Del
ta a
nd
Ga
mm
ap
rote
ob
act
eria
) an
d b
) A
rch
aea
and
les
s ab
un
dan
t p
hy
la o
f b
acte
ria.
Capítulo III
115
Spatial variation of soil community composition and diversity
NMDS analysis did not show a clear spatial pattern in soil bacterial communities from
road embankments (Fig. 2). However, GLM analysis performed using the first axis of NMDS as
a response variable revealed significant differences in soil bacterial community composition at a
local scale (F [2,43]=28.421, p site <0.001). Pairwise comparison between sites showed three
homogeneous groups of road embankments regarding bacterial community composition (Fig. 3),
in which there were no differences between sites from Barajas (T1 and T2), at the same time that
those from El Molar (M1 and M2) were different from each other but M1 was similar to T2.
Figure 2. NMDS results showing changes in the structure of soil microbial communities from road embankments
(M1= Open triangles; M2= Solid triangles; T1= Open squares; T2= Solid squares). Circles grouped samples with
95% of similarity regarding microbial community composition.
-0,5 -0,4 -0,3 -0,2 -0,1 0,0 0,1 0,2 0,3 0,4Axis 1 [ R^2 = 0.568]
-0,5
-0,4
-0,3
-0,2
-0,1
0,0
0,1
0,2
0,3
0,4
Axis
2 [
R^
2=
0.2
68
]
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
116
Figure 3. Tukey HSD test results (Mean ±SE) after obtaining significant site effect (p<0.001) upon NMDS Axis
1, which summed up changes in microbial community composition from road embankments. Different letters
indicate significant differences between means at p<0.05.
In El Molar roadlopes, the Shannon index was 3.80±0.06 in M1 and 3.85±0.04 in M2,
while in Barajas roadlopes, this index was slightly higher, 3.88±0.05 in T1 and 3.86±0.03 T2.
Simpson index was 0.95 in M1 and 0.96 in the rest of the embankments (M2, T1 and T2).
Finally, the Equitability was lower in M1 and M2 with an average value of 0.38±0.02 and
0.39±0.01 respectively, while in Barajas the Equitability was 0.41 in both T1 and T2. GLM
analyses did not show any significant variation in diversity indices among sites or locations (F
Shannon [3,43]=0.49. p= 0.69; F Simpson [3,43]= 0.72; p =0.55, F Equitability [3,43]= 1.15, p=0.34).
-0.3
-0.2
-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
Ax
1
Site
M1 M2 T1 T2
b
bc
c
a
Capítulo III
117
Soil factors affecting spatial distribution of the bacterial community
Best–fitting models explained over 35% of the variation of bacterial community composition
in road embankments (Table 2). Among the ten soil factors considered in MMI analysis, results
showed that soil pH best explained this variation, followed by factors related to soil texture, soil
structure and finally nutrient content (Fig. 4).
Table 2. Best–fitting models explaining variation in soil microbial community structure from road embankments.
Each column represents a soil factor (predictor variable). Of all 1024 possible models, models with AICc ≤ 2 are
presented. AIC estimates the relative goodness of fit of a given model; the lower its value, the more likely it is that
this model is correct.
Nutrient content Texture Structure
C N C/N Sand Clay Humidity Porosity Aeration Bulk density pH AIC ∆AIC R²
–80,10 0,00 0,360
–78,40 –1,70 0,334
–78,33 –1,77 0,363
–78,14 –1,96 0.361
–78,13 –1,97 0,361
–78,13 –1,97 0,361
–78,10 –2,00 0,360
–78,10 –2,00 0,360
606
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
118
Figure 4. MMI results illustrating relative contributions of each soil factor explaining changes on the structure of
soil microbial communities from road embankment. Ax1 of NMDS analysis has been used as response variable.
Contribution of each soil factor is calculated depending on the number of models in which the factor appeared,
weighted by the importance of each model.
Discussion
To our knowledge, this is the first study describing bacterial community composition and its
spatial structure in urban soils from road embankments. Our results showed that these
communities have similar diversity and slightly lower equitability values than those observed in
other anthrosols (Øvreås & Torsvik 1998), with a predominance of Actinobacteria,
Acidobacteria and Plactomycetes. Although Actinobacteria has been reported as dominant in
agricultural soils (Buckley & Schmidt 2001), higher abundances of this group have been also
observed in grasslands and abandoned soils (Acosta–Martínez et al. 2008; McCaig et al. 1999).
Capítulo III
119
Actinobacteria are associated with soils of low organic matter, although they may respond well
to carbon inputs (Bell et al. 2013). They have also been found in latter successional states in soils
with high pH values (Kuramae et al. 2010). Thus, higher abundances of Actinobacteria may
indicate transition to a grassland steady state (Acosta-Martinez et al. 2008). On the other hand,
Acidobacteria are ubiquituous in soil and have been observed as one of the main components of
bacterial communities in grasslands (Will et al. 2010) and managed systems (Jesús et al. 2009;
Navarrete et al. 2013), but tend to decrease in abundance under the effect of pollutants (Ros et al.
2009). Acidobacteria showed oligotrophic habits that enable them to grow and reach high
abundances in soils with scarce resource availability and low carbon mineralization rates (Fierer
et al. 2007). Surprisingly, Planctomycetes showed higher abundances in anthrosols from road
embankments than those previously reported by Whitman and colleagues (1998) in other
anthropogenic systems (15% in road embankments vs. 7% of the total rRNA extracted from
agricultural soils). The presence of Planctomycetes in soil is highly correlated with historical
management practices, such as nutrient and organic amendments (Buckley et al. 2006). The
relative abundance of this group dramatically decreases with changes in plant community
structure (Wakelin et al. 2013) and agricultural practices such as tillage (Buckley & Schmidt
2003), and increases in soils with high values of organic matter content, pH and Ca++
(Buckley
2006). For that reason, Planctomycetes could be ecologically interpreted as an indicator of stable
soil conditions due to the fact that its relative abundance is linked to parameters that take a long
time to recover.
Among less abundant groups, we found Bacteroidetes, Cyanobacteria, Firmicutes and
Gemmatimonadetes, also scarce in other anthropogenic systems (Rodrigues et al. 2013; Shange
et al. 2012). Low abundances of these groups seem to be related with secondary succession
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
120
processes, at least in regards to Bacteroidetes and Cyanobacteria, which have been described as
highly abundant in intensively managed systems (Kuramae et al. 2011). Bacteroidetes are
copiotrophs that rapidly colonize soil aggregates and easily exploit available forms of carbon
(Acosta-Martinez et al. 2008). Cyanobacteria represents between 6 to 40% of sequences
obtained in different soils (Nemergut et al. 2007). Relative abundance of Cyanobacteria
increases under abiotic stress (Bowker 2007). In that sense, relatively low abundances of
Cyanobacteria observed in anthrosols from road embankments may be linked with the high
productivity of these environments, which improves general soil conditions. Firmicutes and
Gemmatimonadetes are also stress-tolerant (De Bruyn et al. 2011; Kuramae et al. 2010).
Specifically, Firmicutes have the ability to form spores (Wakelin et al. 2013). These
characteristics may explain their presence in anthrosols from road embankments, which usually
exhibit cycles of high temperature and low moisture (Lehmann & Stahr 2007). Still, community
composition results should be taken with caution because of the time of the sampling, having in
mind that bacterial community composition in anthrosols may experiment seasonal variation
(Smit et al. 2001). On the other hand, pyrosequencing approaches allowed us to detect not only
active bacteria but also others that have been taken part of the community in other time point.
Our findings reveal that bacterial communities on road embankments located around 30 km
apart shared a common composition pattern. At regional scales, dispersal limitations are
expected to become increasingly apparent at finer taxonomic resolutions set in the present study
at the phylum level. Despite this methodological limitation, the significant variation found
between sites from the same location suggests a critical role for local environmental factors,
consistent with previous reports on bacterial communities (Van der Gucht et al. 2007). Soil pH
has been described as the first or even the unique factor explaining spatial variation in microbial
Capítulo III
121
communities across biomes and land uses (Fierer et al. 2012; Lauber et al. 2008). Soil pH is
usually correlated with other soil features, whose effects could be hidden depending on how data
analysis was performed (Kuramae et al. 2011; Navarrete et al. 2013). In this, sense the MMI
approach used in the present study allowed us to identify other factors affecting bacterial
community self-organization and to classify them by their importance. Our results support a
primary role for pH and soil texture as drivers of change in bacterial community composition and
a relatively low importance of nutrients. In anthrosols from road embankments, soil pH is higher
than in other managed systems; likely because of the use of lime as one of the embankment
layers to stabilize the substrate and avoid mass movements (Ministerio de Fomento 2002). These
lime particles are susceptible to vertical movements due to drastic changes in temperature and
evapotranspiration processes, which alkalinizes the soil surface. This alkalization may influence
the uptake of nutrients by microbes in soil, with further effects on bacterial community
composition and diversity (Navarrete et al. 2013). Soil bacteria community composition may
also vary with the shape of soil particles and the type of soil aggregates (Ranjard & Richaume
2001). Higher nutrient contents associated with clay increase bacterial diversity and may trigger
differences in composition, at the same time that the sand fraction may be linked to bacterial
species that are better adapted to nutrient poor conditions and also able to use a wider range of
substrates (Sessitsch et al. 2001). Bacterial community development also interacts with soil
particles through the production of extracellular polysaccharides (Foster 1988), which contribute
to aggregate soil particles and to the construction of soil microstructure. Because of this, there is
an increase in the heterogeneity of resources that also modify community composition (Chenu
1993).
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
122
However, our results also showed that soil factors just partially explain changes observed in
bacterial community composition and its spatial variation, which suggest that they may be other
factors underlying this process. Roadside ecosystem dynamics at local scale is driven by topsoil
spreading and sowing techniques, and its interaction with the regional pool of species susceptible
to colonize a road embankment, which has been historically shaped by land use (García-Palacios
et al. 2010; Moreno–de las Heras et al. 2008). Moreover, plant community assembly and
vegetation dynamics on road embankments are most often driven by plant-plant interactions (De
la Riva et al. 2011; Valladares et al. 2008), which may adversely affect ecosystem service
provision by roadside landscapes (Balaguer et al. 2011). Hence, plant assemblages from
roadlopes are expected to show different composition at local scale affecting the quantity and
quality of organic matter that is incorporated in soil and influencing microbial functional
diversity with further effects in roadside ecosystem functionality at short term (García-Palacios
et al. 2011). In this sense, differences in the quality of topsoil spread in road embankments or the
differences in seed mixtures applied by hydroseeding, may explain the variation of roadside
bacterial communities we observed at local scale. Due to the critical role of plant-soil feedbacks
on the maintenance of roadside ecosystems, further research is needed about the implications of
management techniques that may alter above-belowground relationships.
Knowing that urban soils perform important functions as buffering temperature and water
variations, as well as nutrient store (De Kimpe & Morel 2000), identifying factors affecting the
development of bacterial communities that are responsible of most of these functions is a key
issue. Moreover, the rising importance of ecosystem services provided by plant communities in
urban environments (Robinson & Lundholm 2012), coupled with the fact that vegetation
dynamics in road embankments also depends on biotic interactions; the local microbiological
Capítulo III
123
control of road embankments may provide new options for the fine–tuning of the complex
below–above–ground links between plants and soil bacterial communities. This control might be
exerted on the infrastructure construction process or in a more straightforward and efficient way,
during the maintenance practices undertaken by road transport operators and highway
concessionaires. In this sense, our results may provide useful guidelines for practitioners in order
to enhance and maintain the ecosystems services that urban areas can deliver.
Acknowledgements
We thank F. Pugnaire (EEZA–CSIC), S. Hortal (Hawkesbury Institute for the Environment,
Sidney) and A.S. Pijl (NIOO–KNAW) for assistance with molecular work, the research group of
plant ecology and ecological restoration UCM, and S. Bachiller and S. Correa for field and lab
support. We also thank Sarah Young for English editing. This study was funded by OHL, the
Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness (ECONECT project: CDTI IDI–20120317),
Madrid Regional Government (REMEDINAL–2 S–2009/AMB–1783), and by an FPU grant
program of the Spanish Ministry of Education, Culture and Sports (FPU–AP2009–0094). The
accession number of sequencing data in SRA is PRJEB5308.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
124
References
Acosta–Martínez, V., Dowd, S., Sun, Y., & Allen, V. (2008). Tag–encoded pyrosequencing
analysis of bacterial diversity in a single soil type as affected by management and land
use. Soil Biology & Biochemestry, 40: 2762- 2770.
Akaike, H. (1973). Information theory and an extension of the maximum likelihood principle.
2nd International Symposium on Information Theory. Akademiai Kiadó, Budapest.
Alfaya, V. (2013). colonización de taludes artificiales por parte de la vegetación natural.
Dissertation, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Spain.
Balaguer, L., Valladares, F., Escudero, A., Mola, I., & Alfaya, V. (2011) Restauración ecológica
e infraestructuras de transporte: perspectivas y recomendaciones, in: Valladares F,
Balaguer L, Mola I, Escudero A, Alfaya, V (Eds.) Restauración ecológica de áreas
afectadas por infraestructuras de transporte. Bases científicas para soluciones técnicas.
Fundación Biodiversidad, Madrid, España. pp 303- 314.
Balaguer, L. (2002). Las limitaciones de la restauración de la cubierta vegetal. Ecosistemas, 11.
http://www.revistaecosistemas.net. Accessed 8 August 2014
Bell, T.H., Yergeau, E., Maynard, C., Juck, D., Whyte, L.G., & Greer, C.W. (2013). Predictable
bacterial composition and hydrocarbon degradation in Arctic soils following diesel and
nutrient disturbance. The ISME Journal, 7: 1200-121.
Bowker, M.A. (2007). Biological soil crust rehabilitation in theory and practice: An
underexploited opportunity. Restoration Ecology, 15: 13-23.
Buckley, D.H., & Schmidt, T.M. (2001). The structure of microbial communities in soil and the
lasting impact of cultivation. Microbial Ecology, 42: 11-21.
Capítulo III
125
Buckley, D.H., & Schmidt, T.M. (2003). Diversity and dynamics of microbial communities in
soils from agro–ecosystems. Environmental Microbiology, 5: 441-452.
Buckley, D.H., Huangyutitham, V., Nelson, T.A., Rumberger, A., & Thies, J.E. (2006). Diversity
of Planctomycetes in soil in relation to soil history and environmental heterogeneity.
Applied & Environmental Microbiology, 72: 4522-4531.
Burnham, K.P., & Anderson, D.R. (2002). Model selection and multi model inference: a
practical information–theoretic approach, 2nd ed. Springer, New York.
Caporaso, J.G., Kuczynski, J., Stombaugh, J., Bittinger, K., Bushman, F.D., Costello, E.K.,
Fierer, N., Gonzalez- Peña, A., Goodrich, J.K., Gordon, J.I., Huttley, G.A., Kelley, S.T.,
Knights, D., Koenig, J.E., Ley, R.E., Lozupone, C.A., McDonald, D., Muegge, B.D.,
Pirrung, M., Reeder, J., Sevinsky, J.R., Turnbaugh, P.J., Walters, W.A., Widmann, J.,
Yatsunenko, T., Zaneveld, & J., Knight, R. (2010). QIIME allows analysis of high–
throughput community sequencing data. Nature Methods, 7: 335-336.
Chenu, C. (1993). Clay–or–sand polyssacharide associations as models for the interface between
micro–organisms and soil: water related properties and microstructure. Geoderma, 56:
143-156.
De Bruyn, J.M., Nixon, L.T., Fawaz, M.N., Johnson, A.M., & Radosevich, M. (2011). Global
biogeography and quantitative seasonal dynamics of gemmatimonadetes in soil. Applie
Environmental Microbiology, 77: 6295-6300.
De Kimpe, C.R., & Morel, J. L. (2000). Urban soil management: a growing concern. Soil
Science, 165: 31-40.
De la Riva, E.G., Casado, M.A., Jiménez, M.D., Mola, I., Costa–Tenorio, M., & Balaguer, L.
(2011). Rates of local colonization and extinction reveal different plant community
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
126
assembly mechanisms on road verges in central Spain. Journal Vegetation Science, 22:
292-302.
Edgar, R.C., Haas, B.J., Clemente, J.C., Quince, C., & Knight, R. (2011). UCHIME improves
sensitivity and speed of chimera detection. Bioinformatics, 27: 2194-2200.
Edgar, R.C. (2010). Search and clustering orders of magnitude faster than BLAST.
Bioinformatics, 26: 2460-2461
Eisenhauer, N., Cesarz, S., Koller, R., Worm, K., Reich, P.B. (2012). Global change below
ground: impacts of elevated CO2, nitrogen and summer drought on soil food webs and
biodiversity. Global Change Biology, doi: 10.1111/j.1365–2486.2011.02555.
Ettema, C.H., & Wardle, D.A. (2002). Spatial soil ecology. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 17:
177-183.
Fierer, N., Bradford, & M.A., Jackson, R.B. (2007). Toward an ecological classification of soil
bacteria. Ecology, 6: 1354-1364.
Fierer, N., & Jackson, R.B. (2006). The diversity and biogeography of soil bacterial
communities. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 103: 626-631.
Fierer, N., Leff, J.W., Adams, B.J., Nielsen, U.N., Bates, S.T., Lauber, C.L., Owens, S., Gilbert,
J.A., Wall, D.H., & Caporaso, J.G. (2012). Cross–biome metagenomic analyses of soil
microbial communities and their functional attributes. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences, 109: 21390-21395.
Foster, R.C. (1988). Microenvironments of soil microorganisms. Biology &. Fertility of Soils, 6:
189-203.
García-Palacios, P., Bowker, M.A., Chapman, S.J., Maestre, F.T., Soliveres, S., Gallardo, A.,
Valladares, F., Guerrero, C., & Escudero, A. (2011). Early-successional vegetation
Capítulo III
127
changes after roadside prairie restoration modify processes related with soil functioning
by changing microbial functional diversity. Soil Biology & Biochemestry, 43: 1245-
1253.
García-Palacios, P., Soliveres, S., Maestre, F.T., Escudero, A., Castillo-Monroy, A.P., &
Valladares, F. (2010). Dominant plant species modulate responses to hydroseeding,
irrigation and fertilization during the restoration of semiarid motorway slopes. Ecological
Engineering, 36: 1290-1298.
Goecks, J., Nekrutenko, A., Taylor, J., & Galaxy, T. (2010). Galaxy: a comprehensive approach
for supporting accessible, reproducible, and transparent computational research in the life
sciences. Genome Biology 11.
Guitián, F., & Carballas, T. (1976). Técnicas de análisis de suelos. Pico Sacro, Santiago de
Compostela.
Gunapala, N., & Scow, K.M. (1998). Dynamics of soil microbial biomass and activity in
conventional and organic farming systems. Soil Biology & Biochemestry, 6: 805–816.
Guo, L.B., & Guifford, R.M. (2002). Soil carbon stocks and land use change: a meta- analysis.
Global Change Biology, 8: 345-360.
Hartmann, M., & Widmer, F. (2006). Community structure analyses are more sensitive to
differences in soil bacterial communities than anonymous diversity indices. Applied &
Environmental Microbiology, 72: 7804-7812.
Hill, P., Krištůfek, V., Dijkhuizen, L., Boddy, C., Kroetsch, D., & van Elsas, J.D. (2011). Land
use intensity controls actinobacterial community structure. Microbial Ecology, 61: 286-
302.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
128
Holtkamp, R., van der Wal, A., Kardol, P., van der Putten, W.H., de Ruiter, P.C., & Dekker, S.D.
(2011). Modelling C and N mineralisation in soil food webs during secondary succession
on ex-arable land. Soil Biology & Biochemestry, 43: 251-260.
ISRIC–FAO. (2006). World reference base for soil resources. In: World soil resources reports,
103. UNESCO, Rome.
Jesus, E.C., Marsh, T.L., Tiedje, J.M., & Moreira, F.M.S. (2009). Changes in land use alter the
structure of bacterial communities in Western Amazon soils. The ISME Journal, 3: 1004-
1011.
Jiménez, M.D., Ruiz‐Capillas, P., Mola, I., Pérez‐Corona, E., Casado, M. A., Balaguer, L.
(2013). Soil development at the roadside: a case study of a novel ecosystem. Land
Degradation & Development, 24: 564-574.
Kuramae, E.E., Gamper, H.A., Yergeau, E., Piceno, Y.M., Brodie, E.L., De Santis, T.Z.,
Andersen, G.L., van Veen, J.A., & Kowalchuk, G.A. (2010). Microbial secondary
succession in a chronosequence of chalk grasslands. The ISME Journal, 4: 711-715.
Kuramae, E.E., Yergeau, E., Wong, C., Pijl, A.S., van Veen, J.A., & Kowalchuk, G.A. (2011).
Soil characteristics more strongly influence soil bacterial communities than land–use
type. FEMS Microbiology Ecology, 79: 12-24.
Lambin, E.F., Turner, B.L., Geist, H.J., Agbola, S.B., Angelsen, A., Bruce, J.W., Coomes, O.T.,
Dirzo, R., Fischer, G., Folke, C., George, P.S., Homewood, K., Imbernon, J., Leemans,
R., Li, X., Moran, E.F., Mortimore, M., Ramakrishnan, P.S., Richards, J.F., Skåness, H.,
Steffen ,W., Stone, G.D., Svedin, U., Veldkamp, T.A., Vogel, C., & Xu, J. (2001). The
causes of land–use and land–cover change: moving beyond the myths. Global
Environmental Change, 11: 261-269.
Capítulo III
129
Lauber, C.L., Hamady, M., Knight, R., & Fierer, N. (2009). Pyrosequencing-based assessment of
soil pH as a predictor of soil bacterial community composition at the continental scale.
Applied & Environmental Microbiology, 75: 5111-5120.
Lauber, C.L., Strickland, M.S., Bradford, M.A., & Fierer, N. (2008). The influence of soil
properties on the structure of bacterial and fungal communities across land–use types.
Soil Biology & Biochemestry, 40: 2407-2415.
Lehmann, A., & Stahr, K. (2007). Nature and significance of anthropogenic urban soils. Journal
of Soils & Sediments, 7: 247-260.
Lehmann, A. (2006). Technosols and other proposals on urban soils for the WRB (World
Reference Base for Soil Resources). International Agrophysics, 20: 129-134.
Maestre, F.T., Quero, J.L., Gotelli, N.J., Escudero, A., Ochoa, V., Delgado–Baquerizo, M.,
García–Gómez, M., Bowker, M.A., Soliveres, S., Escolar, C., García–Palacios, P.,
Berdugo, M., Valencia, E., Gozalo, B., Gallardo, A., Aguilera, L., Arredondo, T., Blones,
J., Boeken, B., Bran, D., Conceição, A.A., Cabrera, O., Chaieb, M., Derak, M., Eldridge,
D.J., Espinosa, C.I., Florentino, A., Gaitán, J., Gatica, M.G., Ghilouf, W., Gómez–
González, S., Gutiérrez, J.R., Hernández, R.M., Huang, X., Huber–Sannwald, E., Jankju,
M., Miriti, M., Monerris, J., Mau, R.L., Morici, E., Naseri, K., Ospina, A., Polo, V.,
Prina, A., Pucheta, E., Ramírez–Collantes, D.A., Romão, R., Tighe, M., Torres–Díaz, C.,
Val, J., Veiga, J.P., Wang, D., & Zaady, E. (2012). Plant species richness and ecosystem
multifunctionality in global drylands. Science, 335: 214-218.
Magro, S., Gutiérrez–López, M., Casado, M.A., Jiménez, M.D., Trigo, D., Mola, I., & Balaguer,
L. (2013). Soil functionality at the roadside: Zooming in on a microarthropod community
in an anthropogenic soil. Ecological Engineering, 60: 81-87.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
130
McCaig, A.E., Glover, L.A., & Prosser, J.I. (1999). Molecular analysis of bacterial community
structure and iversity in unimproved and improved upland grass pastures. Applied &
Environmental Microbiology, 65: 1721-1730.
Ministerio de Fomento. (2002). Dirección General de Carreteras: Pliego de Prescripciones
Técnicas Generales para Obras de Carreteras y Puentes PG–3. Ediciones Liteam,
Madrid.
Mola, I., Jiménez, M.D., López–Jiménez, N., Casado, M.A., & Balaguer, L. (2011) Road–side
reclamation outside the revegetation season: management options underschedule
pressure. Restoration Ecology, 19: 83-92.
Moreno–de las Heras, M., Nicolau, J.M., & Espigares, T. (2008). Vegetation succession in
reclaimed coal–mining slopes in a Mediterranean–dry environment. Ecological
Engineering, 34: 168-178.
Motulsky, H., & Christopoulos, A. (2004). Fitting models to biological data using linear and
nonlinear regression: a practical guide to curve fitting. Oxford University Press
Murty, D., Kirshbaum, M.U.F., McMurtie, R.E., & McGilvray, H. (2002). Does conversion to
agricultural land change soil carbon and nitrogen? a review of the literature. Global
Change Biology, 8: 105-123.
Navarrete, A.A., Kuramae, E.E., de Hollander, M., Pijl, A., van Veen, & J., Tsai, S.M. (2013).
Acidobacterial community responses to agricultural management of soybean in Amazon
forest soils. FEMS Microbiology Ecology, 83: 607-621,
Nemergut, D.R., Anderson, S.P., Cleveland, C.C., Martin, A.P., Miller, A.E., Seimon, A., &
Schmidt, S.K. (2007). Microbial community succession in an unvegetated, recently
deglaciated soil. Microbial Ecology, 53: 110-122.
Capítulo III
131
Nunan, N., Wu, K., Young, I.M., Crawford, J.W., & Ritz, K. (2002). In situ spatial patterns of
soil bacterial populations, mapped at multiple scales, in an arable soil. Microbial
Ecology, 44: 296-305.
Øvreås, L., & Torsvik, V. (1998). Microbial diversity and community structure in two different
agricultural soil communities. Microbial Ecology, 36: 303-315.
Ranjard, L., & Richaume, A. (2001). Quantitative and qualitative microscale distribution of
bacteria in soil. Research in Microbiology, 152: 707-716.
Reeder, J., & Knight, R. (2010). Rapidly denoising pyrosequencing amplicon reads by exploiting
rank-abundance distributions. Nature Methods, 7: 668-669.
Robinson, S.L., & Lundholm, J.T. (2012). Ecosystem services provided by urban spontaneous
vegetation. Urban Ecosystems, 15: 545-557.
Rodrigues, J.L.M., Pellizari, V.H., Mueller, R., Baek, K., Jesus, E.C., Paula, F.S., Mirza, B.,
Hamaoui, G.S.Jr., Tsai, S.M., Feigl, B., Tiedje, J.M., Bohannan, B.J.M., & Nüsslein, K.
(2013). Conversion of the Amazon rainforest to agriculture results in biotic
homogenization of soil bacterial communities. Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences USA, 110: 988-993.
Ros, M., Pascual, J.A., Moreno, J.L., Hernandez, M.T., & Garcia, C. (2009). Evaluation of
Microbial Community Activity, Abundance and Structure in a Semiarid Soil Under
Cadmium Pollution at Laboratory Level. Water, Air & Soil Pollution, 203: 229-242.
Sessitsch, A., Weilharter, A., Gerzabek, M.H., Kirchmann, H., Kandeler, & E. (2001). Microbial
population structures in soil particle size fractions of a long–term fertilizer field
experiment. Applied & Environmental Microbiology, 67: 4215–4224.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
132
Shange, R.S., Ankumah, R.O., Ibekwe, A.M., Zabawa, R., & Dowd, S.E. (2012). Distinct soil
bacterial communities revealed under a diversely managed agroecosystem. PloS One,
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0040338.
Shono, H. (2000). Efficiency of the finite correction of Akaike’s Information Criteria. Fisheries
Science, 66: 608-610.
Smit, E., Leeflang, P., Gommans, S., van den Broek, J., van Mil, S., & Wernars, K. (2001).
Diversity and seasonal fluctuations of the dominant members of the bacterial soil
community in a wheat field as determined by cultivation and molecular methods. Applied
& Environmental Microbiology, 67: 2284-2291.
Tormo, J., Bochet, E., & García–Fayos, P. (2007). Roadfill revegetation in semiarid
Mediterranean environments. Part II: Topsoiling, species selection, and hydroseeding.
Restoration Ecology, 15: 97-102.
Valladares, F., Tena, D., Matesanz, S., Bochet, E., Balaguer, L., Costa–Tenorio, M., Tormo, J.,
& García–Fayos, P. (2008). Functional traits and phylogeny: What is the main ecological
process determining species assemblage in roadside plant communities? Journal of
Vegetation Science, 19: 381-392.
Van der Gucht, K., Cottenie, K., Muylaert, K., Vloemans, N., Cousin, S., Declerck, S., Jeppesen,
E., Conde–Porcuna, J.M., Schwenk, K., Zwart, G., Degans, H., Vyverman, W., & De
Meester, L. (2007). The power of species sorting: Local factors drive bacterial
community composition over a wide range of spatial scales. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Science USA, 104: 20404-20409.
Wakelin, S.A., Barratt, B.I.P., Gerard, E., Gregg, A.L., Brodie, E.L., Andersen, G.L., Santis,
T.Z., Zhou, J., He, Z., Kowalchuk, G.A., & O’Callaghan, M. (2013). Shifts in the
Capítulo III
133
phylogenetic structure and functional capacity of soil microbial communities follow
alteration of native tussock grassland ecosystems. Soil Biology & Biochemestry, 57: 675-
682.
Whitman, W.B., Coleman, D.C., Wiebe, & W.J. (1998). Prokaryotes: The unseen majority.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Science USA, 95: 6578-6583.
Will, C., Thürmer, A., Wollherr, A., Nacke, H., Herold, N., Schrumpf, M., Gutknecht, J., Wubet,
T., Buscot, F., & Daniel, R. (2010). HorizonsSpecific bacterial community composition
of German grassland soils, as revealed by pyrosequencing–based analysis of 16S rRNA
genes. Applied & Environmental Microbiology, 76: 6751-6759.
Zuur, A.F., Ieno, E.N., Walker, N.J., Saveliev, A.A., & Smith, G.M. (2009). Mixed Effects
Models and Extensions in Ecology with R. Springer, New York.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
134
135
CAPITULO IV
Roadside ecosystems: the effect of management on soil functions and microbial community structure
S. Magro, E.E. Kuramae, A. Escuero. & L. Balaguer
Journal of Environmental Management (Summited)
136
Capítulo IV
137
Abstract
Road construction is today one of the main forces of change in terrestrial ecosystems, generating
new reliefs and steep slopes in which hydrology and biological communities are severely altered.
These roadside ecosystems are subjected to conventional management such as mowing or
fertilization in order to reduce fire risk and maintain plant communities to control erosion
processes. However, is not known how this management affects soil microbial communities or
soil processes (i.e., litter decomposition or mineralization) that in turn influence functionality and
the provision of ecosystem services. Thus, the aim of the present study was to elucidate how soil
microbial assemblages in anthrosols from road embankments respond to conventional techniques
applied in roadslope management. To this end, we conducted an experiment on four road
embankments in which we applied different treatments oriented to modify organic matter inputs
and soil fertility. We assessed the microbial community by 16S rRNA gene fragment
pyrosequencing. Our results show that mowing, fertilizing and biomass addition generally
changed ecosystem components such as soil physicochemical parameters, soil microbial
community structure and diversity, and soil processes. However, we did not find a consistent
pattern among treatments in which the variation in soil community translates to changes in soil
processes and vice versa, which suggests that these new ecosystems are fragile and respond to
management in an unpredictable way. Deepening the knowledge about how roadside ecosystems
respond to management is highly relevant in the context of new frontiers in roadside restoration.
Keywords. Pyrosequencing, 16S rRNA, embankment, litter decay, fertilizer, mowing
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
138
Introduction
Earth works constitute one of the main current drivers of global change in terrestrial
ecosystems (Hooke et al. 2012). Construction activities such as road building result in emerging
novel ecosystems characterized by new reliefs generated by compacted layers of aggregate
materials, leading to anthrosols or technosols (ISRIC-FAO 2006). One type of anthrosols is that
in road embankments (Lehmann & Stahr 2007), characterized by simplified substrates, high
spatial heterogeneity, depleted nutrients and high soil pH. These soil features give rise to pioneer
plant communities characterized by particular combinations of fast-growing species that
ultimately affect soil organic matter dynamics and belowground community performance
(Garcia-Palacios et al. 2011; Jiménez et al. 2013). Moreover, roadside ecosystem development
and dynamics are subjected to changes in land use as a consequence of management. To date,
conventional management such as mowing or fertilization is aimed at reducing fire risk and
compensating for low fertility, respectively (Petersen et al. 2004; Spooner 2005). Such practices
also aim to maintain plant communities responsible for controlling erosion processes. However,
they are often applied without sound knowledge of the consequences of these actions on
ecosystem features and function. This is especially critical in relation to the maintenance and
dynamics of microbe soil communities, since it is well known that they are responsible for key
ecosystem processes.
Land use effects on soil bacterial communities have been studied across biomes (Lauber et
al. 2008; Lupatini et al. 2013; Navarrete et al. 2011; Navarrete et al. 2013). Land management
affects the biotic and abiotic conditions with further effects in soil community structure and
functions (Fig. 1). Soil microbial composition and diversity depend on both aboveground
vegetation and soil environments (Wardle et al. 2004). For instance, different plant species may
Capítulo IV
139
favor some bacterial groups within the local microbial diversity pool (Kuramae et al. 2010;
Kuramae et al. 2011; Mendes et al. 2014) through the synthesis of different compounds via
rhizodeposition and litter decay (Kuramae et al. 2013; Singh et al. 2004). However, some studies
revealed that the effect of changes in aboveground vegetation in soil microbial community
composition seems to be weak, and it is unclear if this effect results directly or indirectly from
modifying the quantity and quality of soil resources or providing novel microhabitat conditions
(Kielak et al. 2008; Singh et al. 2008). On the other hand, soil physicochemical factors such as
pH, organic carbon content, total nitrogen, C:N ratio, soil texture and moisture have been
described as determinants of the presence and relative abundance of soil organisms (Drenovsky
et al. 2004; Kuramae et al. 2012; Lauber et al. 2009; Lu et al. 2011). A complex picture emerges
when considering all of these factors: a patent feedback in which soil microbes affect key
ecosystem processes such as nutrient and carbon cycling and soil formation (Van der Heijden et
al. 2008), while such soil conditions -depending on aboveground structure- profoundly affect soil
microbial composition and structure. As a consequence, changes in soil microbial community are
expected to induce changes in ecosystem functionality (Acosta-Martínez et al. 2008). However,
direct links between shifts in soil microbial composition or diversity and its reflection in the
outcomes of soil processes depend on the attributes of soil bacterial assemblages. For instance, if
soil bacterial communities are resistant to disturbance, neither soil community structure nor
processes are expected to change with perturbations (Bowen et al. 2011). Contrarily, if soil
bacterial communities are functionally redundant, the ecosystem perturbation could induce
changes in community structure and composition but not in soil functions (Shade et al. 2011).
Unlike these two opposite scenarios, if soil bacterial communities are sensitive to disturbance
and functionally dissimilar, then both community composition and ecosystem processes may be
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
140
affected with further consequences in ecosystem functionality and in the ecosystem services they
provide (Allison et al. 2008).
Figure 1. Conceptual framework of the effects of land use in soil bacterial community structure and soil processes,
with further effects on ecosystem services. Land use changes the biotic and abiotic components of ecosystems.
These changes may induce variation in bacterial community diversity and composition. Due to the key role of soil
bacteria in maintaining soil processes, changes in community structure could affect the rates and outputs of these
processes. At the same time, ecosystem services arise from the interaction between structure and processes. In this
sense, if land use has an effect either on bacterial community structure or on soil processes in roadside ecosystems,
environmental services provided by these factors may be jeopardized.
Despite the well documented effects of soil microbes in ecosystem functioning (Torsvik
& Øvreås 2002), very few studies have analyzed the structure and composition of microbial
communities and its relationship to some critical ecosystem processes in roadside ecosystems
Capítulo IV
141
such as plant colonization, soil stability and nutrient cycling (García-Palacios et al. 2011;
Jáuregui et al. 2013). Moreover, to our knowledge, none have addressed how roadside microbial
communities and soil processes (i.e., litter decomposition or mineralization) respond to their
management. This is very important in the context of new frontiers of roadside restoration and
management. Thus, in the present study we attempt to elucidate how soil microbial assemblages
in anthrosols from road embankments respond to conventional techniques applied in roadslope
management. To this end, we conducted an experiment with different treatments aimed at
modifying organic matter inputs in the system. Specifically, we analyzed how management
modifies 1) soil features, 2) soil microbial community composition and diversity and 3) soil
processes such as litter decomposition and nutrient availability.
Material & methods
Site description and experimental design
Since heterogeneous conditions of roadslopes constrain both microbial community assembly
and ecological processes at a fine scale (García-Palacios et al. 2011; Moreno–de las Heras et al.
2008), we selected two areas located in Madrid, central Spain: El Molar (40º 43' 4.42'' N, 3º 39'
44.28'' W) and Barajas (40º 28' 49.74'' N, 3º 38' 15.91'' W), both in dry Mediterranean climates.
Average temperatures were 14.4 ± 0.37 ºC (El Molar) and 15.5 ± 0.39 ºC (Barajas), and total
annual precipitation was 399 mm (Barajas) and 201.5 mm (El Molar) during the study period
(June 2011- June 2012) (www.aemet.es). Lithology in El Molar is glandular gneisses and
amphibolite schists with patches of arkoses, sandy clays and silts, whereas in Barajas, the
substrate is detritic, consisting mainly of coarse sand. Vegetation of the surroundings in both
locations results from agricultural and livestock activities that gave rise to a deforested
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
142
landscape, with a mosaic of abandoned croplands, annuals-dominated grasslands and scattered
scrublands. At each location, we selected two road embankments (sites: M for El Molar and B
for Barajas): M1 and M2 on highway N–1, separated by 4.7 km, and B1 and B2 on highway M–
13, separated by 0.7 km. Different experimental treatments were applied: Mowing, where the
standing vegetation was cut and removed; Biomass addition, where the cut biomass in mown
plots was spread; Fertilized plots, in which 130 g/plot (32 g/m2) of commercial NPK fertilizer
(Compo©, concentration 12-8-16), commonly used in roadside management in Mediterranean
conditions, was applied; and finally, Control plots (not treated). We sampled 48 plots (2
locations*2 sites*4 treatments*3 replicates per treatment).
Soil sampling and physical-chemical analyses
Soil samples were collected at the end of the spring (June 2011), before treatment application
(t0); and in June 2012 (t1) after treatments. Four soil subsamples (12.5 x 12.5 x 5cm) were
collected randomly on each experimental plot. Soil subsamples of the same plot were then
bulked and mixed, and 40 g of soil was stored at -40 °C for molecular analyses. Organic carbon
and nitrogen contents were analyzed from the remaining fraction by means of a basic
microanalyzer LECO CHNS-932 (analyses were performed by C.A.I Microanálisis Elemental
UCM) and soil pH measured with a Crison pH-meter both in water and KCl (0.1 M) following a
1:2.5 proportion, in order to estimate real and potential pH. Soil texture as the percentage of fine
sand, clay and loam was analyzed following Guitián & Carballas (1976). Finally, a soil cores
from the experimental plots were analyzed for percentages of aeration, humidity and porosity
(Guitián & Carballas 1976).
Capítulo IV
143
Nucleic acid extraction, 16S rDNA gene amplification and pyrosequencing
Total DNA was extracted from ninety-six soil samples (48 samples from t0 and 48 samples
from t1) using Power Soil kits (MoBio, Carlsbad, CA) and DNA was quantified on an ND–1000
spectrophotometer (Nanodrop Technology, Wilmington, DE). Region V4 of the 16S rRNA gene
was amplified with 515F and 806R primers (Lauber et al. 2009). The 515F primer included the
Roche 454-B pyrosequencing adapter and GT linker, while 806R included the Roche 454-A
sequencing adapter and GG linker. A 12-bp barcode was included in the 515F primer. Each PCR
was carried out using 1 µg of DNA, 0.2 units of Hot Start Taq Polymerase (Roche Applied
Sciences, Indianapolis, IN, USA), 2.5 µl of 2 mM dNTP and 0.5 mM of each primer. PCR
conditions were an initial denaturation at 95 °C (5 min), 30 amplification cycles of denaturation
95 °C (30 s), annealing at 54 °C (60 s), and extension at 72 °C (60 s), followed by a final
extension at 72 °C (10 min). Negative controls were carried out with water instead of DNA. Five
independent PCR amplifications for each sample were performed and pooled. Pooled PCR
products/samples were purified with a QIAgen PCR purification kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA).
Samples were equimolar mixed and sequenced (Macrogen Inc. Company, South Korea) on a
Roche 454 automated sequencer and GS FLX system using titanium chemistry (454 Life
Sciences, Branford, CT). Due to technical issues, two samples (M1-fertilizing treatment (t0) and
M1-mowing treatment (t1)) were discarded. The sequences were deposited at SRA with the
ascension PRJEB5308.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
144
Soil functional processes
Nutrient availability
Ion exchange resin bags were prepared in nylon mesh (20 µ mesh) with 7 g of cation
exchange resin (IRA-120) and 5 g of anion exchange resin (IRA-402), separately. A pair of
cation and anion exchange resin bags were buried on each experimental plot after treatment
application, in 2011, and then removed at the end of the experiment in 2012. Bags were
maintained at 4 ºC until they were processed and then cleaned with deionized water. Ion
extraction was performed in 50 ml of 2M KCl solution in one hour of continuous agitation (300
rpm). The extracts were then filtered and kept in a freezer until nitrate and ammonium contents
were analyzed. Ion concentration analysis was performed using a SKALAR SAN++ nutrient
analyzer (Nutrilab - URJC, Móstoles, Madrid).
Litter decomposition
Litter mesh bags (2 mm mesh) were placed on the soil surface after treatment application
(September 2011). Each mesh bag had 6 g of standard mix of dry grass plants (Bromus sp.,
Lolium sp., Festuca sp.). Litter organic carbon content was 43% and total nitrogen 0.76%. In
May 2012, the mesh bags were removed from soils and remaining litter in each bag was cleaned
with deionized water. The plant material from each sample was then dried in an oven at 60 ºC
and dry-weight was determined. The plant decomposition rate (K) was estimated by negative
exponential model (Olson 1963): xt/x0 = e –kt
, where x0 is the initial dry litter mass, xt is the
remaining dry litter mass at time t, and k is the daily decay constant expressed in day −1
.
Capítulo IV
145
Data analysis
General Linear Models (GLMs) were applied to analyze the effect of management on soil
properties at the end of the experiment (t1) as well as on their temporal dynamics (t1-t0),
calculating the rates with the standard deviation instead of mean values. In each model, site and
treatment were included as additive fixed factors (Zuur et al. 2009).
Pyrosequence data and quality information were extracted from the Standard Flowgram
Format (SFF) files using the SFF converter tool in the Galaxy interface (Goecks et al. 2010).
Only sequences with a length between 200 and 350 base pairs were accepted and bases with a
quality score lower than 20 were trimmed. Sequences were further analyzed with the Qiime
version 1.2.1 scripts (Caporaso et al. 2010), which have been made available in the Galaxy
interface. Firstly, all the sequences with a perfect match to the primer sequences containing no
homopolymer run exceeding six nucleotides and without ambiguous characters were assigned to
samples by matching them to barcode sequences. Secondly, sequence errors introduced during
pyrosequencing were detected using the option for titanium data in the Denoiser 0.91 program
(Reeder & Knight 2010). The sequences were also checked for PCR chimeras using UCHIME
(Edgar et al. 2011). Only sequences with a length between 200 and 350 base pairs were accepted
and bases with a quality score lower than 20 were trimmed. The low quality sequences were
discarded. The high quality sequences were clustered into Operational Taxonomic Units (OTUs)
using UCLUST version 1.2.21 (Edgar 2010) with a minimum sequence identity cutoff of 97%.
For each OTU the most abundant sequence was selected as a representative for all sequences
within an OTU. Taxonomy was assigned to the representative sequences using the Ribosomal
Database Project (RDP) 2 classifier (release 10.4). Finally, the OTU table was filtered for
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
146
specific taxonomic terms using scripts provided by Qiime. Singleton OTUs were removed for
community analyses. The OTU table was rarified considering the lowest number of reads in a
sample.
Species richness, Dominance (1-Simpson index) and Evenness of each sample were
calculated at the end of the experiment (t1) and for their temporal dynamics (t1-t0) at the level of
taxonomical order. The same indices were also calculated at the twelve phyla levels,
corresponding to functional groups: Archaea, Acidobacteria, Actinobacteria, Bacterioidetes,
Firmicutes, Planctomycetes, Gemmatimonadetes, Alphaproteobacteria, Betaproteobacteria,
Deltaproteobacteria, Gammaproteobacteria, Verrucomicrobia and other minority groups. In all
models for these taxonomic and functional diversity estimates, the treatments and the sites were
included as additive fixed factors. Redundancy Analysis (RDA) with samples collected at the
end of the experiment (t1) was performed in order to elucidate the main trends of change within
soil microbial community composition. These changes were confirmed by two-way
Permutational Analysis of the Variance (PERMANOVA) by including site and treatment as
additive fixed factors. PERMANOVA post-hoc was performed following Anderson (2001).
Finally, GLM was used to analyze the effect of treatments upon soil processes. K-Olson decay
rate, as a measure of litter decomposition and accumulation rates of ammonia and nitrate
contents in soil, as a measure of nutrient availability were included as response variables and
treatment and site as fixed factors. In order to meet the assumptions of normality and
homogeneity of variance, different models were adjusted and the best model was selected by
Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) (Akaike 1998). All statistical analyses were performed in
the R environment using stats, nlme (Pinheiro et al. 2014) and vegan (Oksanen et al. 2013)
packages.
Capítulo IV
147
Results
Effects of management on soil factors
Table 1. GLM results showing site and treatment effects on soil properties at the end of the experiment (t1) and on
temporal dynamics (t1-t0). Bold numbers indicate significant effects.
Soil factor Main effects (t1) (t1-t0)
Soil organic carbon
(%) df F p value df F p value
Site 3 20.755 0.000 3 1.788 0.165
Treatment 3 0.180 0.909 3 0.694 0.561
Residuals 41
41
Total nitrogen (%) df F p value df F p value
Site 3 13.747 0.000 3 6.480 0.001
Treatment 3 0.047 0.986 3 0.680 0.569
Residuals 40
40
C:N ratio df F p value df Chi p value
Site 3 14.143 0.000 3 59.193 0.000
Treatment 3 0.209 0.890 3 47.004 0.007
Residuals 39
45 131.431
Sand content (%) df F p value df F p value
Site 3 55.707 0.000 3 0.951 0.425
Treatment 3 1.115 0.354 3 0.708 0.553
Residuals 40
40
Loam content (%) df Chi p value df Chi p value
Site 3 25.466 0.000 3 122.560 0.000
Treatment 3 22.614 0.415 3 100.880 0.000
Null 45 51.186 46 153.520
Clay content (%) df F p value df F p value
Site 3 94.348 0.000 3 0.843 0.479
Treatment 3 1.813 0.160 3 0.508 0.679
Residuals 40
41
Humidity (%) df F p value df F p value
Site 3 12.652 0.000 3 5.724 0.000
Treatment 3 0.263 0.852 3 2.326 0.089
Residuals 41
40
Porosity (%) df F p value df F p value
Site 3 3.007 0.041 3 6.915 0.000
Treatment 3 0.676 0.572 3 0.824 0.489
Residuals 41
40
Aeration (%) df F p value df F p value
Site 3 2.940 0.044 3 5.039 0.005
Treatment 3 0.649 0.588 3 1.016 0.395
Residuals 41
41
pH df Chi p value df F p value
Site 44 0.900 0.922 3 1.359 0.269
Treatment 41 0.892 1.000 3 1.181 0.329
Null 47 1.388 41
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
148
GLMs showed that almost all soil factors varied significantly between sites (Table 1) either
at the end of the experiment (Table 2) or in time (Table 3). Moreover, mowing significantly
increased C:N ratio (Fig. 2A) and loam soil content in time (Fig. 2B).
Table 2. Means (±SE) of soil properties that significantly varied between sites from Barajas (B1, B2) and El Molar
(M1, M2)) at the end of the experiment (t1). Letters by rows show significant differences between site levels after
the HSD Tukey test.
Table 3. Means (±SE) of the temporal dynamics (t1-t0) of soil properties that significantly varied between sites
(Barajas (B1, B2) and El Molar (M1, M2)). Letters by rows show significant differences between site levels after the
HSD Tukey test.
Soil factor
Soil organic carbon (%) 1.078 ± 0.049 b 0.854 ± 0.071 b 0.903 ± 0.041 b 1.488 ± 0.077 a
Total nitrogen (%) 0.083 ± 0.005 b 0.056 ± 0.005 c 0.0717 ± 0.005 bc 0.105 ± 0.014 a
C:N ratio 12.803 ± 0.361 b 15.375 ± 0.305 a 12.839 ± 0.424 b 14.14 ± 0.689 a
Sand content (%) 59.833 ± 1.530 c 68.463 ± 1.576 b 78.498 ± 0.575 a 71.247 ± 0.500 b
Loam content (%) 14.091 ± 1.440 b 16.636 ± 1.589 a 10.833 ± 0.580 c 9.833 ± 0.438 d
Clay content (%) 19.917 ± 0.542 a 15.000 ± 1.137 c 9.583 ± 0.364 d 18.333 ± 0.488 b
Humidity (%) 2.34 ± 0.171 ab 2.069 ± 0.116 b 1.448 ± 0.136 c 2.755 ± 0.170 a
B1 B2 M1 M2
Soil factor
Nitrogen (%) 0.02 ± 0.003 ab 0.009 ± 0.002 b 0.025 ± 0.003 a 0.03 ± 0.009 a
C:N ratio 2.33 ± 0.469 c 4.583 ± 0.749 b 11 ± 3.148 a 5.75 ± 0.705 b
Loam (%) 4.73 ± 3.583 a 3.583 ± 1.235 a 1.417 ± 0.580 b 1.67 ± 0.639 b
Humidity (%) 3.9 ± 0.784 a 2.216 ± 0.401 b 2.019 ± 0.362 b 1.56 ± 0.341 b
Porosity (%) 11.6 ± 1.833 a 10.173 ± 1.504 ab 3.783 ± 0.894 c 10.2 ± 2.142 ab
Aeration (%) 13.5 ± 2.489 a 9.054 ± 1.593 ab 3.848 ± 0.794 b 7.06 ± 1.868 ab
B1 B2 M1 M2
Capítulo IV
149
Figure 2. Means (±SE) of the temporal dynamics (t1-t0) of A) C:N ratio and B) Loam content (%) under the effect of
treatments. Letters show significant differences (p<0.05) between treatment levels after the HSD Tukey test.
Effects of management on microbial diversity and microbial community composition
A total of 458,072 quality sequence reads were obtained in 94 samples. The number of
sequences ranged from 1,041 to 12,245 per sample. Sequences were classified at the taxonomical
order level resulting in 165 different orders. All analyses of soil microbial community and
diversity were performed on a subset of taxonomical orders (Appendix 1).
Biomass addition increased richness of the microbial community whereas fertilization
significantly increased evenness at the end of the experiment (t1). Evenness also varied between
sites with the highest values in M2 (Tables 4. No changes in diversity indices in time were
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
C:N
rat
io
b
bb
a A
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Control Mowing Biomass
addition
Fertilizing
Lo
am c
on
ten
t (%
)
b
ab
b
a B
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
150
observed. Moreover, none of the community diversity indices at the phyla level varied between
sites or between treatments or time points (t1-t0) (Table 5).
Table 4. GLM results showing site and treatment effects on microbial community diversity indices calculated with
sequence classified at the taxonomical order level, both at the end of the experiment (t1) and on the temporal
dynamics (t1-t0). Bold numbers indicate significant effects.
(t1) (t1-t0)
Community attribute Main effects df F p value df F p value
Species Richness
Site 3 1.737 0.175 3 0.465 0.708
Treatment 3 3.476 0.025 3 0.052 0.984
Residuals 40 39
Dominance (1-Simpson)
Site 3 1.856 0.154 3 0.591 0.623
Treatment 3 1.702 0.183 3 0.963 0.420
Residuals 37 37
Evenness
Site 3 6.225 0.002 3 0.791 0.506
Treatment 3 4.117 0.013 3 0.406 0.749
Residuals 37 39
Figure 3. Means (±SE) of microbial A) Species richness and B) Evenness at order level at the end of the experiment
(t1). Letters show significant differences (p<0.05) between treatment levels after the HSD Tukey test.
0.780
0.785
0.790
0.795
0.800
0.805
0.810
0.815
0.820
0.825
0.830
0.835
Control Mowing Biomass
addition
Fertilizing
Ev
en
ness
b
ab
ab
aB
58.00
60.00
62.00
64.00
66.00
68.00
70.00
72.00
74.00
76.00
Control Mowing Biomass
addition
Fertilizing
Ric
hn
ess [
nu
m.
OT
Us/s
am
ple
] (S
)
ab
ab
a
b
A
Capítulo IV
151
Table 5. GLM results showing site and treatment effects on microbial community diversity indices calculated with
sequence classified at the phylum level, both at the end of the experiment (t1) and on the temporal dynamics (t1-t0).
No significant effects were found.
(t1) (t1-t0)
Community attribute Main effects df F p value df F p value
Dominance (1-Simpson)
Site 3 1.149 0.341 3 2.087 0.118
Treatment 3 0.505 0.681 3 0.172 0.915
Residuals 40 39
Evenness
Site 3 0.877 0.461 3 1.753 0.172
Treatment 3 1.027 0.391 3 0.460 0.712
Residuals 40 39
RDA explained around 14% of the variation in soil microbial composition (RDA1= 10.18%;
RDA2=3.64%). RDA axis 1 and 2 were significantly correlated with soil microbes (F RDA1 [1,40]=
5.16, p< 0,01; F RDA2 [1,40]= 1.84, p<0.05) and with experimental treatments (FTreatment[1,40]=1.83,
p<0.01) (Fig.4). PERMANOVA results confirmed these findings and showed that soil microbial
community composition significantly varied between treatments (F [3,40]= 0.189, p<0.05) and, to
a lesser extent, between sites (F [3,40]=0.121; p<0.05).
PERMANOVA post-hoc showed that, specifically, community composition was significantly
affected by fertilizing treatment (Control-Fertilizing: F[1,22] = 0.231, p<0.01; Mowing-Fertilizing:
F[1,23] = 0.130, p<0.05; Biomass addition-Fertilizing: F[1,22] = 0.240, p<0.01). Other comparisons
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
152
were not significant. Principal groups of soil microbes Gemmatimonadetes and Chlamydiae
changed with fertilization treatment (Fig. 4).
Figure 4. Redundancy Analysis (RDA) based on Bray Curtis distance calculated from bacterial 16S rRNA gene
sequences. Sites (B1, B2, M1, M2) and treatments (Control = co, Mowing= mo, Biomass addition= db and
Fertilizing= fe) are represented as centroids. References for the name of taxonomic groups are included in Apendix
1.
Effects of management on soil processes
Mowing significantly accelerated litter decomposition (F [3,39]= 9.197, p<0.001, Fig. 5). Both
litter decay and nitrate accumulation rate in soil varied between sites (F K-Olson [3,39]=14.774, p<
0.001; F Nitrate [3,38]=2.964, p<0.05). However, ammonium accumulation rate in soil did not vary
Capítulo IV
153
between sites or between treatments (F Site [3,37]= 0.2486, p> 0.05; F Treatment [3,37]= 0.8892, p>
0.05).
Figure 5. Mean (±SE) of K-Olson values that show the effect of treatments on litter decay rate. (*) Indicates
significant differences (p<0.05).
Discussion
Our results show that soil bacterial communities in road embankments are sensitive and
responsive to management in a very unpredictable way. Roadside management changed
ecosystem components such as physical environment, soil microbial community structure and
soil processes, but we did not find a consistent pattern among treatments. Thus, variations in soil
community do not translate to predictable changes in soil processes or vice versa. Moreover, we
observed that the effect of management on community attributes (diversity and composition) and
processes were very idiosyncratic and also varied at a fine scale.
-0.0265
-0.0260
-0.0255
-0.0250
-0.0245
-0.0240
-0.0235
Control Fertilizing
Biomass
addition Mowing
K-O
lso
n d
ecay
rat
e [g
*d
ay-1
]*
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
154
Effects of management on soil physicochemical properties
Roadside management affected the abiotic component of the anthrosols from road
ecosystems. In fact, mowing changed nutrient stocks and soil texture, increasing the C:N ratio
and loam content. Both effects can be explained as an indirect consequence of the influence of
this type of management on vegetation. On the one hand, it is known that mowing can favor soil
nitrogen removal by fast growing grasses (Rizand et al. 1989; Robson et al. 2007) and promote
nitrogen leaching from soil with a subsequent decrease in nitrogen availability for the whole
ecosystem (Maron and Jefferies 2001; Roscher et al. 2008). Although some studies have
suggested that mowing must be periodically applied to mobilize nitrogen pools (Jenkinson &
Powlson 1976; Jenkinson & Rayner 1977), in anthrosols from road embankments in which initial
total nitrogen content was very low (around 0.5%) the effect of mowing may be apparent in the
short term with subsequent effects on the C:N ratio. The lack of vegetation generated by mowing
also favored erosion and the loss of the finest particles in soil (clay), translating to a relative
increase in loam content in mown plots compared to plots without this treatment (Castillo et al.
1997). On the contrary, no effects of biomass addition or fertilizer on soil properties were
observed. It is known that plant communities play a key role in edaphic processes on road slopes
(Bochet et al. 2010; Jiménez et al. 2013). In this sense, the lack of response that we found may
be related to the intensity of disturbance exerted by the different types of management (Berga et
al. 2012), with techniques affecting plant communities more likely to affect soil features on road
embankments.
Capítulo IV
155
Effects of management on soil microbial community structure
Our results also show that roadside microbial communities are sensitive to disturbance,
where biomass addition and fertilizing are the main drivers of change in microbial community
diversity and composition. However, the different types of management generated dissimilar
response patterns in community diversity and composition. On the one hand, biomass addition
increased taxonomic diversity. This effect has been tied to new microclimatic conditions created
by surface litter accumulation, buffering temperature fluctuations in soil and increasing moisture
(Holland & Coleman 1987). Moreover, the accumulation of a surface-litter layer serves as a
barrier against drop impacts in soil by reducing soil compaction and preserving microhabitat
with further effects on microbial diversity (Pengthamkeerati et al. 2011). On the other hand, we
observed that evenness was favored by fertilizing, which could be related to the general decrease
in the abundance of almost all taxonomic groups. In this line, many studies have shown that
nitrogen addition has an overall effect of reducing microbial diversity in terrestrial ecosystems
(see for instance Fierer et al. 2012; Lu et al. 2011) at the same time that other studies find that the
effect of nitrogen enrichment in human-impacted environments appears to increase equitability
(Nogales et al. 2010 and references there in). We also observed that fertilization triggered
changes in microbial community composition in soils from road embankments, changing the
relative abundance of certain orders of bacteria. Previous studies have shown that nitrogen
addition induces changes in soil microbial composition and decreases microbial activity by
shifting the metabolic capabilities of soil communities (Fierer et al. 2007; Ramírez et al. 2012).
In concordance with other studies, fertilizing modified the relative abundance of
Gemmatimonadetes (Fa-si et al. 2012; Ge et al. 2008). This group is considered to include
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
156
oligotrophic bacteria. Changes induced by fertilization indicate slight shifts in the metabolism of
C recalcitrant compounds that may affect carbon stock in road embankment soils in the long
term (Nemergut et al. 2008). Unlike these management tools, mowing did not affect microbial
community structure. These results together indicate that microbial communities from road
embankments are either resistant or sensitive depending on the type of management applied. This
agrees with other studies that have observed that the relationship between disturbance and
community structure is context-dependent (Mackey & Curie 2001) and more often related to
community traits such as growth rate (Haddad et al. 2008).
Effects of management on soil processes
We also found that soil processes from road embankments are sensitive to management, but
the effects are not consistent between treatments and strongly depend on the process considered.
Generally, litter decomposition varies with climatic factors and evapotranspiration regimes (Berg
et al. 1991), with temperature and moisture the most relevant controlling factors. However, the
relative importance of these two factors on decomposition rates is usually modified when the
disturbance effect is considered (Fortunel et al. 2009). In fact, we observed that mowing
accelerated litter decay. The effect of cut vegetation on litter decay may be due to changes in
quantity and quality of organic matter inputs in soil (Zhang et al. 2008). Moreover, changes in
litter decomposition rate under the effect of mowing may be due to photodegradation. Henry and
coworkers (2008) described that in Mediterranean ecosystems, plant litter thickness strongly
influences litter degradation, with the thinner the litter layer the faster the decomposition due to
the higher exposure to sun light. This effect could be intensified under semiarid conditions
(Brandt et al. 2010). On the contrary, we did not observe any changes in nitrogen dynamics
Capítulo IV
157
through experimental management (measured as nitrate and ammonia accumulation rates). In
line with our findings, Maron and Jefferies (2001) described a weak correlation between mowing
and nutrient mineralization because of nitrogen uptake by annual grasses during the growing
season. Moreover, in the same study, it was shown that the effect of mowing on nitrogen
dynamics in soil is expected to take many years to become evident. However, in roadside
grasslands a significant increase of mineralization after mowing has been observed in the short
term (i.e., two weeks, Schaffers 2000). Nitrogen dynamics in soil is expected to change under
the effect of fertilization. Both carbon and nutrients should be more available to soil
microorganisms in more productive sites, and hence nitrogen mineralization rates are expected to
be higher if fertility is improved (Fisk & Fahey 2001 and references therein). In contrast, our
results did not show any effect of this type of management on the accumulation rates of nitrate
and ammonia in soil. This effect may be explained by the fact that fertilizing treatment was
insufficient to increase soil nitrogen (this treatment did not significantly increase nitrogen
content in soil, nor did it improve C:N ratio). Thus, even when nitrogen is sufficient to maintain
mineralization, the process is highly energy-demanding and nitrogen accumulation rates remain
low. A small increase in soil nitrogen increased microbial diversity and its associated
relationships with plants. This results in an increase in nitrogen fixation that also reduced
nitrogen accumulation in soil (Ollivier et al. 2011).
In summary, although the different types of management applied in the present study
partially affected microbial diversity and composition or soil processes, we did not find a clear
link between disturbance and changes in microbial community structure and soil processes
functionality. Previous studies showed a weak or non–existing relationship between changes in
structure and function suggesting that this relationship is context-dependent and highly
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
158
conditioned by the process considered (Berga et al. 2012; Patra et al. 2008). In our case, mowing
affected litter decomposition without affecting microbial diversity or composition. One possible
explanation for this result could be related to the existence of a high level of functional plasticity
of roadside microbial communities. This would concur with Agrawal`s finding (Agrawal 2001),
who pointed out that changes in ecosystem functionality were not coupled with changes in
community structure. Regarding nitrogen dynamics, fertilizing affected both soil community
diversity and composition without any effects on litter degradation or nutrient availability, which
may indicate that for this novel ecosystem and management approach, the roadside microbial
communities are functionally redundant.
Conclusions and implications for practice
Roadside management today involves the application of conventional techniques such as
mowing or fertilizing. However, to date, the consequences of these standard approaches have not
been evaluated. Our results highlight that the use of these management techniques change
microbial community structure and function at a local scale. Moreover, the way in which
microbial communities from road embankments respond to different types of disturbance,
suggest a certain level of fragility, which in turn may affect ecosystem functionality and the
goods and services that these novel scenarios provide. This is not trivial if we account for the
role that roadslopes play as reservoirs of local biodiversity in severely disturbed landscapes
(Forman & Alexander 1998) or as important patches of habitat that influence connectivity among
populations under a stepping-stone landscape architecture (Kimura & Weiss 1964). Because of
the relevance of roadside ecosystems, there is a need for reviewing current technical approaches
Capítulo IV
159
in order to optimize roadside restoration with the objective of ensuring the maintenance of
ecosystem services.
Acknowledgements
We thank A.S. Pijl (NIOO–KNAW) for assistance with lab and molecular work and the research
group of Evolutionary Ecology and Ecological Restoration (UCM) for field and lab support, and
especially J.M. Arenas. We also thank Sarah Young for English editing. This study was funded
by OHL, the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness (ECONECT project: CDTI
IDI–20120317), Madrid Regional Government (REMEDINAL–2 S–2009/AMB–1783), and by
an FPU grant program of the Spanish Ministry of Education, Culture and Sports (FPU–AP2009–
0094).
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
160
Ap
end
ix 1
. S
ubse
t of
ord
ers
use
d t
o a
nal
yze
ch
ang
es i
n s
oil
bac
teri
a co
mm
unit
y s
truct
ure
, div
ersi
ty a
nd c
om
posi
tion.
(1 o
f 4)
Cla
ssif
icat
ion
ID
Cla
ssif
icat
ion
ID
Arc
haea
Bact
eria
P
hyl
um
Cre
narc
haeo
ta
P
hyl
um
Aci
dobact
eria
C
l. M
isce
llaneo
us
Cre
narc
haeo
tic
Gro
up;O
ther
A
rc1
C
l. A
cidobact
eria
A
ci11
C
l. Soil
Cre
narc
haeo
tic
Gro
up
O
. SJA
-149
Aci
12
O
. C
andid
atu
s N
itro
sosp
haer
a
Arc
2
C
l. H
olo
phagae
O
. O
ther
A
rc3
O
.32-2
0
Hol1
P
hyl
um
Eu
ryarc
haeo
ta
O
. 43F
-1404R
H
ol2
C
l. M
ethanom
icro
bia
O
.CA
002
Hol3
O
. M
ethanosa
rcin
ale
s A
rc4
O
. Sva
0725
Hol4
C
l. T
her
mopla
smata
O
.iii
1-8
H
ol5
O
.Ther
mopla
smata
les
Arc
5
P
hyl
um
Act
inobact
eria
B
act
eria
C
l. A
cidim
icro
bii
a
P
hyl
um
Aci
dobact
eria
O
. A
cidim
icro
bia
les
Act
1
C
l. A
cidobact
eria
C
l. A
ctin
obact
eria
O.1
1-2
4
Aci
1
O
. C
ory
neb
act
eria
les
Act
2
O. A
cidobact
eria
les
Aci
2
O
. F
ranki
ale
s A
ct3
O
. C
andid
atu
s C
hlo
raci
dobact
eriu
m
Aci
3
O
. G
lyco
myc
etale
s A
ct4
O
. C
andid
atu
s Soli
bact
er
Aci
4
O
.Kin
eosp
ori
ale
s A
ct5
O
. D
A023
Aci
5
O
. M
icro
cocc
ale
s A
ct6
O
. D
S-1
00
Aci
6
O
.Mic
rom
onosp
ora
les
Act
7
O
.Ele
v-16S-1
166
Aci
7
O
. P
ropio
nib
act
eria
les
Act
8
O
. In
cert
ae
Sed
is
Aci
8
O
. P
seudonoca
rdia
les
Act
9
O
. O
ther
A
ci9
O
. Str
epto
myc
etale
s A
ct10
O
. R
B41
Aci
10
O
. Str
epto
spora
ngia
les
Act
11
Capítulo IV
161
A A
pen
dix
1.
Subse
t of
ord
ers
use
d t
o a
nal
yze
chan
ges
in s
oil
bac
teri
a co
mm
unit
y s
truct
ure
, div
ersi
ty a
nd c
om
posi
tion. (2
of
4)
Cla
ssif
icat
ion
ID
Cla
ssif
icat
ion
ID
P
hyl
um
Act
ino
ba
cter
ia
P
hyl
um
Ch
loro
flex
i
C
l.N
itri
liru
pto
ria
C
l. A
naer
oli
nea
e
O
.Eu
zeb
yale
s A
ct1
2
O
. A
na
ero
linea
les
Ch
x1
C
l. R
ub
rob
act
eria
Cl.
Ca
ldil
inea
e
O.R
ubro
bact
era
les
Act
13
O
. C
ald
ilin
eale
s C
hx
2
C
l. T
her
mo
leop
hil
ia
C
l. C
hlo
rofl
exi
O.S
oli
rub
rob
act
era
les
Act
14
O.
Ch
loro
flex
ale
s C
hx
3
P
hyl
um
Arm
ati
mo
na
det
es
O.
Her
pet
osi
ph
on
ale
s C
hx
4
C
l. A
rmati
mo
na
dia
Cl.
Kte
do
no
ba
cter
ia
O
. A
rmati
mon
ad
ale
s A
rm
O.
Kte
do
no
ba
cter
ale
s C
hx
5
P
hyl
um
Bact
ero
idet
es
C
l. T
her
mo
mic
rob
ia
Cl.
Cyt
op
ha
gia
O
. A
KY
G1
72
2
Ch
x6
O
. C
yto
ph
aga
les
Ba
c1
O
. J
G3
0-K
F-C
M4
5
Ch
x7
C
l. F
lavo
ba
cter
ia
U
nkn
ow
n C
hlo
rofl
exi
class
O
. F
lavo
bact
eria
les
Ba
c2
O.
Oth
er
Ch
x8
C
l. S
phin
go
ba
cter
ia
Ph
ylu
m C
yan
ob
act
eria
O
. S
phin
goba
cter
iale
s B
ac3
S
ub
sect
ionII
I
P
hyl
um
Ch
lam
ydia
e
G.
Ch
am
aes
iph
on
Cya
1
Cl.
C
hla
myd
iae
G.
Lep
toly
ng
bya
C
ya2
O.
Ch
lam
ydia
les
Ch
m
G. M
icro
cole
us
Cya
3
Ph
ylu
m C
hlo
rob
i
G.T
rich
oco
leu
s C
ya4
Cl.
Ch
loro
bia
Su
bse
ctio
nIV
O
. C
hlo
robia
les
Ch
b
Su
bg
rou
pI
(Su
bse
ctio
nIV
) C
ya5
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
162
Ap
end
ix 1
. S
ubse
t of
ord
ers
use
d t
o a
nal
yze
ch
ang
es i
n s
oil
bac
teri
a co
mm
unit
y s
truct
ure
, div
ersi
ty a
nd c
om
posi
tion. (3
of
4)
Cla
ssif
icat
ion
ID
Cla
ssif
icat
ion
ID
P
hyl
um
Dei
noco
ccu
s
S0134 t
erre
stri
al
gro
up
Gem
4
Cl.
D
einoco
cci
P
hyl
um
Len
tisp
haer
ae
O. D
einoco
ccale
s D
ei
C
l. L
enti
sphaer
ia
P
hyl
um
Elu
sim
icro
bia
W
CH
B1
-41
Gem
5
Cl.
Elu
sim
icro
bia
P
hyl
um
Nit
rosp
irae
L
inea
ge
IIa
Elu
1
C
l. N
itro
spir
a
L
inea
ge
IIb
Elu
2
O
. N
itro
spir
ale
s N
it
L
inea
ge
IV
Elu
3
P
hyl
um
Pla
nct
om
ycet
es
P
hyl
um
F
ibro
bact
eres
C
l. P
hyc
isphaer
ae
C
l. F
ibro
bact
eria
O
. P
hyc
isphaer
ale
s P
la1
O. F
ibro
bact
erale
s F
ib
C
l. P
lanct
om
ycet
aci
a
P
hyl
um
Fir
mic
ute
s
O
. P
lanct
om
ycet
ale
s P
la2
C
l. B
aci
lli
P
hyl
um
Pro
teobact
eria
O. B
aci
llale
s F
ir1
C
l. A
lphapro
teobact
eria
O. L
act
obaci
llale
s F
ir2
O
.Caulo
bact
erale
s A
pb1
C
l. C
lost
ridia
O
.Rhiz
obia
les
Apb2
O
. C
lost
ridia
les
Fir
3
O
. R
hodobact
erale
s A
pb3
C
l. E
rysi
pel
otr
ichi
O
. R
hodosp
iril
lale
s A
pb4
O
. E
rysi
pel
otr
ichale
s F
ir4
O
. R
icke
ttsi
ale
s A
pb5
P
hyl
um
Gem
mati
mon
adet
es
O
.Sphin
gom
onadale
s A
pb6
C
l. G
emm
ati
monadet
es
C
l.B
etapro
teobact
eria
AT
425-E
ubC
11 t
erre
stri
al
gro
up
Gem
1
O. B
urk
hold
eria
les
Bpb1
BD
2-1
1 t
erre
stri
al
gro
up
Gem
2
O. M
ethyl
ophil
ale
s B
pb2
O. G
emm
ati
monadale
s G
em3
O.N
itro
som
onadale
s B
pb3
Capítulo IV
163
Apendix 1. Subset of orders used to analyze changes in soil bacteria community structure, diversity and
composition. (4 of 4)
Classification ID
Phylum Proteobacteria
Cl.Betaproteobacteria
O. Rhodocyclales Bpb4
Cl. Deltaproteobacteria
O. Bdellovibrionales Dpb1
O. Desulfobacterales Dpb2
O. Desulfurellales Dpb3
O. Desulfuromonadales Dpb4
O. Myxococcales Dpb5
Cl. Gammaproteobacteria
O. Acidithiobacillales Gpb1
O. Alteromonadales Gpb2
O. Enterobacteriales Gpb3
O. Legionellales Gpb4
O. Methylococcales Gpb5
O. Oceanospirillales Gpb6
O. Pseudomonadales Gpb7
O. Xanthomonadales Gpb8
Phylum Verrucomicrobia
Cl. Opitutae
O. Opitutales Ver1
O. Other Ver2
Cl. Spartobacteria
O. Chthoniobacterales Ver3
Cl. Verrucomicrobiae
O. Verrucomicrobiales Ver4
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
164
References
Acosta-Martinez, V., Dowd, S., Sun, Y., & Allen, V. (2008). Tag-encoded pyrosequencing
analysis of bacterial diversity in a single soil type as affected by management and land
use. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 40: 2762-2770.
Agrawal, A. A. (2001). Phenotypic plasticity in the interactions and evolution of
species. Science, 294: 321-326.
Akaike, H. (1998). Information theory and an extension of the maximum likelihood principle.
In Selected Papers of Hirotugu Akaike (pp. 199-213). Springer New York.
Allison, S. D., & Martiny, J. B. (2008). Resistance, resilience, and redundancy in microbial
communities. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 105: 11512-11519.
Anderson, M. J.( 2001). A new method for non‐parametric multivariate analysis of
variance. Austral Ecology, 26: 32-46.
Berg, B., & Ekbohm, G. (1991). Litter mass-loss rates and decomposition patterns in some
needle and leaf litter types. Long-term decomposition in a Scots pine forest.
VII. Canadian Journal of Botany, 69: 1449-1456.
Berga, M., Székely, A. J., & Langenheder, S. (2012). Effects of disturbance intensity and
frequency on bacterial community composition and function. PloS one, 7: DOI:
10.1371/journal.pone.0036959.
Bochet, E., García‐Fayos, P., & Tormo, J. (2010). How can we control erosion of roadslopes in
semiarid Mediterranean areas? Soil improvement and native plant establishment. Land
Degradation & Development, 21: 110-121.
Capítulo IV
165
Bowen, J. L., Ward, B. B., Morrison, H. G., Hobbie, J. E., Valiela, I., Deegan, L. A., & Sogin,
M. L. (2011). Microbial community composition in sediments resists perturbation by
nutrient enrichment. The ISME Journal, 5: 1540-1548.
Brandt, L. A., King, J. Y., Hobbie, S. E., Milchunas, D. G., & Sinsabaugh, R. L.( 2010). The role
of photodegradation in surface litter decomposition across a grassland ecosystem
precipitation gradient. Ecosystems, 13: 765-781.
Caporaso, J. G., Kuczynski, J., Stombaugh, J., Bittinger, K., Bushman, F. D., Costello, E. K.,
Fierer , N., Peña , A. G., Goodrich , J.K., Gordon , J. I., Huttley , G.A., Kelley , S. T.,
Knights , D., Koenig , J. K., Ley , R. I., Lozupone , C.A., McDonald , D., Muegge , B.
M., Pirrung , M., Reeder , J., Sevinsky , J. R., Turnbaugh , P. J., Walters , W. A.,
Widmann , J., Yatsunenko , T., Zaneveld, J., & Knigh, R.( 2010). QIIME allows analysis
of high-throughput community sequencing data. Nature Methods, 7: 335-336.
Castillo, V. M., Martínez-Mena, M., & Albaladejo, J. (1997). Runoff and soil loss response to
vegetation removal in a semiarid environment. Soil Science Society of America Journal,
61: 1116-1121.
Drenovsky, R. E., Vo, D., Graham, K. J., & Scow, K. M. (2004). Soil water content and organic
carbon availability are major determinants of soil microbial community
composition. Microbial Ecology, 48: 424-430.
Edgar, R.C. (2010). Search and clustering orders of magnitude faster than BLAST.
Bioinformatics, 26: 2460-2461.
Edgar, R.C., Haas, B.J., Clemente, J.C., Quince, C., & Knight, R. (2011). UCHIME improves
sensitivity and speed of chimera detection. Bioinformatics, 27: 2194-2200.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
166
Fa-si, W., Yong-feng, G., Zhi-fang, J., Yong-jun, L., Xiao-jun, M., Li-zhe, A., wang, W. F., &
Hu-yuan, F. (2012). The community structure of microbial in arable soil under different
long-term fertilization regimes in the Loess Plateau of China. African Journal of
Microbiology Research, 6: 6152-6164.
Fierer, N., Bradford, M. A., & Jackson, R. B. (2007). Toward an ecological classification of soil
bacteria. Ecology, 88: 1354-1364.
Fierer, N., Leff, J. W., Adams, B. J., Nielsen, U. N., Bates, S. T., Lauber, C. L., Owense, S.,
Gilberte, J. A., Wallh, D. H., & Caporaso, J. G. (2012). Cross-biome metagenomic
analyses of soil microbial communities and their functional attributes. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences, 109: 21390-21395.
Fisk, M. C., & Fahey, T. J. (2001). Microbial biomass and nitrogen cycling responses to
fertilization and litter removal in young northern hardwood forests. Biogeochemistry, 53:
201-223.
Forman, R. T., & Alexander, L. E. (1998). Roads and their major ecological effects. Annual
Review of Ecology and Systematics, 29: 207-231.
Fortunel, C., Garnier, E., Joffre, R., Kazakou, E., Quested, H., Grigulis, K., Lavorel, S., Ansquer,
P., Castro, H., Cruz, P., Doležal, J., Eriksson, O., Freitas, H., Golodets, G., Jouany, C.,
Kigel, J., Kleyer, M., Lehsten, V., Lepš, J., Meier, T., Pakeman, R., Papadimitriou, M.,
Papanastasis, V. P., Quétier, F., Robson, M., Sternberg, M., Theau, J. P., Thébault, A., &
Zarovali, M. (2009). Leaf traits capture the effects of land use changes and climate on
litter decomposability of grasslands across Europe. Ecology, 90: 598-611.
Capítulo IV
167
García-Palacios, P., Bowker, M. A., Maestre, F. T., Soliveres, S., Valladares, F., Papadopoulos,
J., & Escudero, A. (2011). Ecosystem development in roadside grasslands: biotic control,
plant-soil interactions, and dispersal limitations. Ecological Applications, 21: 2806-2821.
Ge, Y., Zhang, J. B., Zhang, L. M., Yang, M., & He, J. Z. ( 2008). Long-term fertilization
regimes affect bacterial community structure and diversity of an agricultural soil in
northern China. Journal of Soils & Sediments, 8: 43-50.
Goecks J, Nekrutenko A, Taylor J., & Galaxy T. (2010). Galaxy: a comprehensive approach for
supporting accessible, reproducible, and transparent computational research in the life
sciences. Genome Biology, 11
Guitián, F., & Carballas, T. (1976). Técnicas de análisis de suelos. Pico Sacro, Santiago de
Compostela.
Haddad, N. M., Holyoak, M., Mata, T. M., Davies, K. F., Melbourne, B. A., & Preston, K.
(2008). Species’ traits predict the effects of disturbance and productivity on
diversity. Ecology Letters, 11: 348-356.
Henry, H. A., Brizgys, K., & Field, C. B. (2008). Litter decomposition in a California annual
grassland: interactions between photodegradation and litter layer thickness. Ecosystems,
11: 545-554.
Holland, E. A., & Coleman, D. C. (1987). Litter placement effects on microbial and organic
matter dynamics in an agroecosystem. Ecology, 68: 425-433.
Hooke, R. L., Martín-Duque, J. F., & Pedraza, J. (2012). Land transformation by humans: a
review. GSA Today, 22: 4-10.
ISRIC - FAO. (2006). World Reference Base for Soil Resources 2006.World Soil Resources
Reports. 103.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
168
Jáuregui, B. M., Rivera, D., & Peco, B. (2013). Does topsoil accelerate the decomposition of
litter on roadslopes? Ecological Engineering, 52: 88-95.
Jenkinson, D. S., & Powlson, D. S. (1976). The effects of biocidal treatments on metabolism in
soil—V: a method for measuring soil biomass. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 8: 209-213.
Jenkinson, D. S., & Rayner, J. H. (1977). The turnover of soil organic matter in some of the
Rothamsted classical experiments. Soil Science, 123: 298-305.
Jiménez, M. D., Ruiz‐Capillas, P., Mola, I., Pérez‐Corona, E., Casado, M. A., & Balaguer, L.
(2013). Soil development at the roadside: a case study of a novel ecosystem. Land
Degradation & Development, 24: 564-574.
Kielak, A., Pijl, A. S., Van Veen, J. A., & Kowalchuk, G. A. (2008). Differences in vegetation
composition and plant species identity lead to only minor changes in soil‐borne microbial
communities in a former arable field. FEMS Microbiology Ecology, 63: 372-382.
Kimura, M., & Weiss, G. H. (1964). The stepping stone model of population structure and the
decrease of genetic correlation with distance. Genetics, 49: 561.
Kuramae, E., Gamper, H., van Veen, J., & Kowalchuk, G.A. (2011). Soil and plant factors
driving the community of soil-borne microorganisms across chronosequences of
secondary succession of chalk grasslands with a neutral pH. FEMS Microbiology
Ecology, 77: 285-294.
Kuramae, E. E., Gamper, H. A., Yergeau, E., Piceno, Y. M., Brodie, E. L., DeSantis, T. Z.,
Andersen, G. L., van Veen, J. A., & Kowalchuk, G. A. (2010). Microbial secondary
succession in a chronosequence of chalk grasslands. The ISME Journal, 4: 711-715.
Kuramae, E.E., Hillekens, R.H.E., de Hollander, M., van der Heijden, M.G.A., van den Berg, M.,
van Straalen, N.M., & Kowalchuk, G.A. (2013). Structural and functional variation in
Capítulo IV
169
soil fungal communities associated with litter bags containing maize leaf. FEMS
Microbiology Ecology, 84: 519-531.
Kuramae, E. E., Yergeau, E., Wong, L. C., Pijl, A. S., Veen, J. A., & Kowalchuk, G. A., (2012).
Soil characteristics more strongly influence soil bacterial communities than land‐use
type. FEMS Microbiology Ecolog, 79: 12-24.
Lauber, C. L., Hamady, M., Knight, R., & Fierer, N. (2009). Pyrosequencing-based assessment
of soil pH as a predictor of soil bacterial community structure at the continental
scale. Applied & Environmental Microbiology, 75: 5111-5120.
Lauber, C. L., Strickland, M. S., Bradford, M. A., & Fierer, N. (2008). The influence of soil
properties on the structure of bacterial and fungal communities across land-use
types. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 40: 2407-2415.
Lehmann, A., & Stahr, K. 2007. Nature and significance of anthropogenic urban soils. Journal of
Soils & Sediments, 7: 247-260.
Lu, M., Yang, Y., Luo, Y., Fang, C., Zhou, X., Chen, J., Yang, X., & Li, B. (2011). Responses of
ecosystem nitrogen cycle to nitrogen addition: a meta‐analysis. New Phytologist, 189:
1040-1050.
Lupatini, M., Jacques, R.J.S., Antoniolli, Z.I., Suleiman, A.K.A., Fulthorpe, R.R., & Roesch,
L.F.W. (2013). Land-use change and soil type are drivers of fungal and archaeal
communities in the Pampa biome. World Journal of Microbiology & Biotechnology, 29:
223-233.
Mackey, R. L., & Currie, D. J. (2001). The diversity-disturbance relationship: is it generally
strong and peaked? Ecology, 82: 3479-3492.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
170
Maron, J. L., & Jefferies, R. L. (2001). Restoring enriched grasslands: effects of mowing on
species richness, productivity, and nitrogen retention. Ecological Applications, 11: 1088-
1100.
Mendes, L.W., Kuramae, E.E., Navarrete, A.A., van Veen, J.A., & Tsai, S.M. (2014).
Taxonomical and functional microbial community selection in soybean rhizosphere. The
ISME Journal. DOI:10.1038/ismej.2014.17.
Moreno-de Las Heras, M., Nicolau, J. M., & Espigares, T. (2008). Vegetation succession in
reclaimed coal-mining slopes in a Mediterranean-dry environment. Ecological
Engineering, 34: 168-178.
Navarrete, A.A., Kuramae, E.E., de Hollander, M., Pijl, A.S., van Veen, J.A., & Tsai, S.M.
(2013). Acidobacterial community responses to agricultural management of soybean in
Amazon forest soils. FEMS Microbiology Ecology, 83: 607-621.
Navarrete, A.A., Taketani, R.G., Mendes, L.W., Cannavan, F.S., Moreira, F.M.S., & Tsai, S.M.
(2011). Land-use systems affect archaeal community structure and functional diversity in
western Amazon soils. Revista Brasileira de Ciencias do Solo, 35: 1527-1540.
Nemergut, D. R., Townsend, A. R., Sattin, S. R., Freeman, K. R., Fierer, N., Neff, J. C.,
Bowman, W. D, Schadt, C. W., Weintraub, W. N., & Schmidt, S. K. (2008). The effects
of chronic nitrogen fertilization on alpine tundra soil microbial communities: implications
for carbon and nitrogen cycling. Environmental Microbiology, 10: 3093-3105.
Nogales, B., Lanfranconi, M. P., Piña‐Villalonga, J. M., & Bosch, R. (2011). Anthropogenic
perturbations in marine microbial communities. FEMS Microbiology Reviews, 35: 275-
298.
Capítulo IV
171
Oksanen, J., Blanchet, F.G., Kindt, R., Legendre, P., Minchin, P.R., O'Hara, R. B., Simpson,
G.L., Solymos, P., Stevens, M.H.H., & Helene Wagner. (2013). Ordination methods,
diversity analysis and other functions for community and vegetation ecologists. R
pacakve version 2.0-10, http://vegan.r-forge.r-project.org/
Ollivier, J., Töwe, S., Bannert, A., Hai, B., Kastl, E. M., Meyer, A., Su, M. X., Kleineidam, K.,
& Schloter, M. (2011). Nitrogen turnover in soil and global change. FEMS Microbiology
Ecology, 78: 3-16.
Olson, J. S. (1963). Energy storage and the balance of producers and decomposers in ecological
systems. Ecology, 44: 322-331.
Patra, A. K., Le Roux, X., Grayston, S. J., Loiseau, P., & Louault, F. (2008). Unraveling the
effects of management regime and plant species on soil organic carbon and microbial
phospholipid fatty acid profiles in grassland soils. Bioresource Technology, 99: 3545-
3551.
Pengthamkeerati, P., Motavalli, P. P., & Kremer, R. J. (2011). Soil microbial activity and
functional diversity changed by compaction, poultry litter and cropping in a claypan
soil. Applied Soil Ecology, 48: 71-80.
Petersen, S. L., Roundy, B. A., & Bryant, R. M. (2004). Revegetation Methods for High‐
Elevation Roadsides at Bryce Canyon National Park, Utah. Restoration Ecology, 12: 248-
257.
Pinheiro, J., Bates, D., DebRoy, S., Sarkar, D. & R Core Team. (2014). nlme: Linear and
Nonlinear Mixed Effects Models. R package version 3.1-117, http://CRAN.R-
project.org/package=nlme
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
172
Ramírez, K. S., Craine, J. M., & Fierer, N. (2012). Consistent effects of nitrogen amendments on
soil microbial communities and processes across biomes. Global Change Biology, 18:
1918-1927.
Reeder, J., & Knight, R. (2010). Rapidly denoising pyrosequencing amplicon reads by exploiting
rank-abundance distributions. Nature Methods, 7: 668-669.
Rizand, A., Marrs, R. H., Gough, M. W., & Wells, T. C. E. (1989). Long-term effects of various
conservation management treatments on selected soil properties of chalk grassland.
Biological Conservation, 49: 105-112.
Robson, T. M., Lavorel, S., Clement, J. C., & Roux, X. L.( 2007). Neglect of mowing and
manuring leads to slower nitrogen cycling in subalpine grasslands. Soil Biology &
Biochemistry, 39: 930-941.
Roscher, C., Thein, S., Schmid, B., & Scherer‐Lorenzen, M. (2008). Complementary nitrogen
use among potentially dominant species in a biodiversity experiment varies between two
years. Journal of Ecology, 96: 477-488.
Schaffers, A. (2000). Ecology of roadside plant communities. Landbouwuniversiteit Wageningen
(Wageningen Agricultural University).
Shade, A., Read, J. S., Welkie, D. G., Kratz, T. K., Wu, C. H., & McMahon, K. D. (2011).
Resistance, resilience and recovery: aquatic bacterial dynamics after water column
disturbance. Environmental Microbiology, 13: 2752-2767.
Singh, B. K., Dawson, L. A., Macdonald, C. A., & Buckland, S. M. (2009). Impact of biotic and
abiotic interaction on soil microbial communities and functions: A field study. Applied
Soil Ecology, 41: 239-248.
Capítulo IV
173
Singh, B. K., Millard, P., Whiteley, A. S., & Murrell, J. C. (2004). Unravelling rhizosphere–
microbial interactions: opportunities and limitations. Trends in Microbiology, 12: 386-
393.
Spooner, P. G. (2005). Response of Acacia species to disturbance by roadworks in roadside
environments in southern New South Wales, Australia Biological Conservation, 122:
231–242.
Torsvik, V., & Øvreås, L. (2002). Microbial diversity and function in soil: from genes to
ecosystems. Current Opinion in Microbiology, 5: 240-245.
Van Der Heijden, M. G., Bardgett, R. D., & Van Straalen, N. M. (2008). The unseen majority:
soil microbes as drivers of plant diversity and productivity in terrestrial
ecosystems. Ecology Letters, 11: 296-310.
Wardle, D. A., Bardgett, R. D., Klironomos, J. N., Setälä, H., Van Der Putten, W. H., & Wall, D.
H. (2004). Ecological linkages between aboveground and belowground
biota. Science, 304: 1629-1633.
Zhang, D., Hui, D., Luo, Y., & Zhou, G. (2008). Rates of litter decomposition in terrestrial
ecosystems: global patterns and controlling factors. Journal of Plant Ecology, 1: 85-93.
Zuur, A., Ieno, E. N., Walker, N., Saveliev, A. A., & Smith, G. M. (2009). Mixed effects models
and extensions in ecology with R. Springer.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
174
175
CAPÍTULO V
Community ontogeny at the roadside: Critical life‐cycle events throughout a sequential process of primary colonization
S. Magro, M.D. Jiménez, M.A. Casado, I. Mola, J.M. Arenas, J.F. Martín-Duque & L. Balaguer
Applied Vegetation Science (2014), 17 (3): 493- 503.
176
Capítulo V
177
Abstract
Questions: How does the response to environmental filters change across the life-cycle of
pioneer plants through the early process of community assembly? Is there a threshold at any of
the life-history stages during roadcut primary colonization?
Location: A very steep, sun-exposed, low-fertility and low-water-retention roadcut in a
Mediterranean-continental site in Madrid, central Spain.
Methods: We tracked density of individuals, plant cover, species richness and community
composition throughout the sequential process of primary colonization of a newly-exposed
roadcut surface. We monitored from seed arrival to seedling emergence, seedling survival, and
plant growth across species over two growing seasons. We manipulated the intensity of
environmental filters in twelve experimental plots (10 x 8 m) following a full-factorial design of
two treatments (topsoil spreading and shallow tillage).
Results: The response to environmental filter manipulation varied throughout the individual life-
cycle. Under an equal seed rain, the higher carrying capacity caused by topsoil spreading gave
rise to the emergence of a larger number of species which either persisted or occasionally
appeared in some of the stages of the early community assembly. Then, topsoil spreading
enhanced seedling survival across species, and subsequent plant growth. We therefore detected
two life-history stages acting as thresholds in plant community assembly, due to an ontogenetic
niche shift across species. The first one, at seedling emergence, in response to environmental
cues with lasting consequences in community composition and species richness; and the second
one, at the transition to the adult stage, in response to local resource availability, with
consequences in subsequent plant growth and community cover.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
178
Conclusions: During primary colonization, ontogenetic development of pioneers was paralleled
by the action of environmental filters throughout the community assembly process. On roadcuts,
the confluence of both processes gives rise to a community ontogeny marked by two thresholds
determining community richness and cover under Mediterranean conditions. Our findings shed
light on the underlying mechanisms involved in technical solutions, such as topsoil spreading,
and provide a more efficient approach to roadside restoration.
Keywords: ecological restoration; community assembly; environmental filters; life history;
primary succession; threshold points.
Capítulo V
179
Introduction
Primary colonization entails propagule arrival plus the concurrent struggle for survival
throughout pioneers’ life history. On barren surfaces, where a severe disturbance has removed all
vestiges of biological activity, community assembly “starts from scratch” and colonists build up
an initial soil seed bank (cf. Walker & del Moral 2003). Primary colonization is therefore a
sequential process in which stochastic arrival of seeds from the regional species pool is followed
by the development of an ontogenetic sequence whose pace varies across species (see for
instance Walker et al. 1986). From an assembly perspective, the emergent community is shaped
by environmental filters in which both biotic and abiotic factors are intricately linked
(Temperton 2007). In this highly selective process, each life-cycle stage becomes precarious
(Elmarsdottir et al. 2003; Haper 1977). In an attempt to overcome this precariousness, each life-
cycle stage displays a range of responses to the environmental filters. For instance, seedling
emergence may potentially range from negative density dependence (i.e. a decrease in
performance with increasing density), to positive density dependence, or density independence
(Lortie & Turkington 2002 and references therein). At each life-cycle stage, differential
responses of species become accentuated by the hostile environments of early primary
succession (Walker & del Moral 2008). Within a single species, the action of these filters also
changes in magnitude and sign over an individual’s life cycle (Goldberg et al. 2001; Luzuriaga &
Escudero 2008). This phenomenon, known as ontogenetic niche shift, may involve either species
niche contraction or expansion over the individual’s life cycle (Eriksson 2002). It may also
consist of an uncoupling of environmental requirements, or of a change in the biotic interaction
sign among life stages (Eriksson 2002; Miriti 2006). This population-based approach, however,
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
180
neglects the community-level factors shaping community structure through their effects on
parameters such as birth or death rates (Lortie & Turkington 2002).
At the community scale, it seems reasonable to expect that the overall effect of
environmental filters will give rise to life-history stages that are critical because they act as
thresholds (sensu Suding et al. 2004), which hamper the community assembly process, but which
once crossed, hinder the return to previous states (Hobbs & Norton 2004). During the early
stages of community ontogeny, the response of any of these life-stages to subtle variations in
environmental conditions would eventually lead to large changes in community cover, richness
and/or composition. If so, this would highlight the importance of considering life history traits
and performance for planning restoration programs, as previously recommended (Kleyer et al.
2008; Knevel et al. 2003; Walker & del Moral 2008).
In our study, we explored the occurrence of ontogenetic threshold points during the initial
stages of primary colonization of a roadcut and their implications for ecological restoration. It
has been reported that plant establishment on recently exposed roadcuts follows a process of
primary succession (Jiménez et al. 2013; Mola et al. 2011). Mass earthwork and grading in road
construction deeply transform the geomorphologic, hydrologic, edaphic, and biotic conditions at
the roadsides (Steinfeld et al. 2007). On roadcuts, all the biological structures that could act as
local foci for vegetation development have been lost, and plant colonization and early
community assembly are shaped by the environmental filters resulting from habitat carrying
capacity or microsite limitations (de la Riva et al. 2011; Valladares et al. 2008). Roadcut
environmental harshness arises from slope steepness, soil compactness, and sun exposure
(Bochet & Garcia-Fayos 2004), which in turn result in nutrient shortage and low water capacity
and retention (Jiménez et al. 2013).
Capítulo V
181
In this scenario, we wanted to ascertain to what extent the across-species response to
environmental filters during the primary colonization process affects the density and species
richness of the plant community. Specifically, we studied the response of soil seed bank,
seedling emergence, seedling survival, vegetation cover (during the first and the second growing
season) and seed rain, in order to elucidate the coupling between individual life cycle across
populations and plant community early assembly. To this end, we experimentally manipulated
environmental harshness by varying resource levels and recruitment conditions, increasing the
carrying capacity of the system. In an attempt to enhance applicability, these experimental
manipulations were implemented and grounded in an actual road construction process. Thus, we
applied two different treatments (topsoil spreading and shallow tillage), at the early stages of
community assembly on the roadcut. We address three questions: (1) Does the response to
environmental filters change across life-history stages? (2) Is there a threshold at any of the life-
history stages throughout the early process of community assembly? If so, to what extent do
these thresholds affect the abundance, richness, and cover of the emerging community? and (3)
what are the implications for the current revegetation practices on roadcuts?
Material & methods
Study area
The present study was conducted in Torres de la Alameda, Madrid, Central Spain (3° 21'
47.43" W; 40° 24' 22.37" N) from 2009 to 2011. One roadcut was selected on the M-224
highway which was constructed in 2008. It is oriented southwards, and is 150 m wide and
approximately 10 m high, with an average slope exceeding 40°. The climate is Mediterranean
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
182
with a mean annual temperature of 15.23 ±0.32 °C and total annual precipitation of 340.52
±42.15 mm, recorded during the study period. These values were within the range for the last
two decades (12-16 °C; 200-750 mm, Alcalá de Henares weather station). The relief in the
vicinity of the roadcut was soft, comprising mainly moorlands. Lithological composition consists
of lacustrine clay and fluvial arkosic sands of the Tertiary age (ITGE 1990). Soils at the study
location are clayey and covered with therophytic grasslands, unirrigated croplands with pulses
and plantations of scattered olive trees.
Experimental design
The experimental design was intended to manipulate abiotic filters in order to analyze the
response at different life-history stages. After roadcut construction, in November 2009, two
treatments with two levels each were applied following a full factorial design, which was
replicated three times, giving a total of 12 (4 x 3) experimental plots, grouped following a
spatially-balanced complete block design (van Es et al. 2007). Variables related to plant
community development across life stages were measured in May 2010 and May 2011.
Treatments were applied in consecutive 10 x 8 m plots, and consisted of topsoil spreading (TS:
topsoil spreading; NTS: no topsoil spreading) and a shallow preparation of the roadcut surface
(T: shallow tillage; NT: not tillaged). Topsoil spreading (sensu Rivera et al. 2012) is a common
practice only in embankment restoration because it is assumed that topsoil application on
roadcuts with a slope steepness over 34º increases sediment delivery to the road drainage system
(Ramos 1974; Segura 2002). However, application thereof at our study site was intended to
improve substrate characteristics in terms of nutrient content, texture and water retention, while
shallow tillage aimed at enhancing roughness and safesite availability on the roadcut surface.
Capítulo V
183
Soil properties
After treatment application, six 10 cm deep cores with a diameter of 5 cm were collected
on each experimental plot. To cover the slope gradient, two cores were extracted in the upper-
slope zone, two in the middle one and two in the lower-slope zone. In each sample, we measured
the following set of soil properties: granulometry, calculated as the percentage of sand and silt in
soil (Bouyoucos 1962); organic carbon content using the Walkley-Black procedure (Nelson &
Sommers 1982) then converted to soil organic matter (SOM) by means of the van Bemmelen
factor (Jackson 1958); total nitrogen by means of Kjeldahl and mineral phases of nitrogen
(nitrate and ammonium) with a solid soil sample analyzer SKALAR. Finally, we measured the
pH of each soil sample by means of an ion-selective electrode (Metrohm Ltd., Herisau,
Switzerland), and soil electrical conductivity with a conductivity-meter (CRISOM, model CM
35).
Seed bank sampling
To determine the influence of abiotic filter manipulations on the soil seed bank, we
collected three samples from each experimental plot. The sample dimensions were 12.5 cm x
12.5 cm x 5 cm and were distributed along the slope gradient described above. Samples were
preserved at 4° C until processed. They were spread on aluminum tubs on a mixture of peat and
vermiculite (3:1). The tubs were placed in a germination chamber at 20 °C and 15% RH, with a
12-hour photoperiod during six months. The tubs were well-watered and maintained at field
capacity and rotated in order to avoid the effects of position. We stopped watering tubs from July
2010 to September 2010 to ensure germination conditions for the whole species pool. Finally, all
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
184
tubs were placed in a greenhouse and watered again. Viable seed density (viable seeds /m2) and
species richness were recorded in each sample.
Field monitoring of seedling emergence and survival
Seedling emergence was recorded in the lower-slope zone of the roadcut by means of
series of three photographs corresponding to an area measuring 0.25 m2 each. Photographs were
taken 2.15 m, 4.25 m and 6.75 m away from the left margin of each experimental plot. We
repeated each series of photographs monthly from April to September 2010. On each
photograph, seedlings were counted, identified at species level when possible and were marked
using Adobe Photoshop Elements (Adobe Systems 2002, San Jose, California, USA). We
determined the phenological stage of individuals through time as well as the density of seedlings
and number of emerged species per photograph. The plant life-cycle stages considered were:
emergence (only with cotyledons), seedling (true leafs), adult (with flowers or fruits), or dead
plants. With the number of emerged seedlings that became adults, we calculated a survival rate
per individual. Likewise, with the number of species that reached the adult state (surviving
species), we constructed a survival rate per species.
Vegetation sampling
Plant cover by species and species richness was visually estimated by the same observers
at the end of the vegetative period (May) both in 2010 and 2011. We used six quadrats (50 x 50
cm) evenly distributed in each experimental plot: 2 quadrats at upper-slope zone, 2 quadrats at
middle-slope zone and 2 quadrats at the lower-slope zone. Each quadrat was placed 1 m away
Capítulo V
185
from the right and left margin of each experimental plot to avoid border effects and also to allow
the observers to move freely along the slope without affecting treatment application.
Seed rain sampling
To determine seed rain input, two funnel traps were placed in each experimental plot in
May 2010. We used funnel traps with 0.38 m2
of effective capture area per trap (22 cm in
diameter). Traps were placed in the upper- and lower-slope zones of the roadcut. Trapped seeds
were collected every two months until May 2011. Seeds were classified within a morphotype
defined by size and dispersal/morphological attributes.
Data analysis
General Linear Models (GLM) were performed to test the effect of filter manipulation on
soil carbon content and soil organic matter (SOM), silt content, nitrate, ph and conductivity as
response variables, including topsoil and shallow tillage as fixed factors and topsoil*shallow
tillage as interaction term. The effect of treatments upon total nitrogen, sand and ammonium soil
content was analyzed by Kruskal Wallis test. GLM were also performed for seedling density and
species richness during emergence, and survival rate per individual and survival rate per species
as response variables, including topsoil and tillage as fixed factors and topsoil*tillage as the
interaction term. Seedling density and survival rate per individual were square-root transformed.
Variation in response to environmental filter manipulation of seedbank, seed rain, and plant
cover in 2010 and 2011 was also tested by means of GLM where treatment (topsoil spreading
and shallow tillage) and slope position (upper-, middle- and lower-slope zones) were included as
fixed factors following Zuur et al. (2009) and position*topsoil, position*tillage and
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
186
position*topsoil*tillage were included as interaction terms. Plant cover from 2010 and 2011
were also square-root transformed. Pairwise comparisons were performed applying HSD Tukey
test, and sum of squares Type III were used for all the F-statistics. All analyses were performed
with R (R Development Core Team, 2012), with the additional packages “car” (Fox & Weisberg
2011), “sciplot” (Morales 2011) and “multcompView” (Graves et al. 2012).
Results
Experimental manipulation of environmental filters
Topsoil spreading significantly changed soil nutrient content (Kruskal Wallis test H Total
Nitrogen [1,71]=17.430, p < 0.05; F Organic Carbon [1,67]= 8.81, p < 0.01; F SOM= [1,67]= 8.81, p < 0.01;
Kruskal Wallis test H Ammonium [1,71]= 17.238, p < 0.001). It increased total nitrogen content by
over 50%, organic carbon by over 30% and SOM by 35%, and reduced ammonium by around
8%, in comparison with controls. Furthermore, topsoil spreading significantly modified soil
texture, enhancing silt content by 6% (F [1,67]= 8.29, p < 0.01), and marginally increased sand
content by 8% (Kruskal Wallis test H[1,71]= 3.558, p=0.059). Finally, topsoil spreading
significantly reduced other chemical soil conditions such as pH and electrical conductivity (F pH
[1,67]= 24.80, p < 0.001; F Conductivity [1,67]= 14.937, p < 0.001) by 2% and 17%, respectively.
Nitrate content in soil was not affected by treatments (F [1,67] = 0.01, p > 0,05). Shallow tillage
and its interaction with topsoil spreading did not generate significant modifications (p>0.05) in
any soil factors compared to the original substrate (Table 1).
Capítulo V
187
Table 1. Means (± SE) of soil factors significantly affected by treatments (C=control; T= Tillage; TS=Topsoil).
Letters by columns show significant differences between levels of treatments after HSD Tuckey test. (*) Letters in
this case, showed differences between groups after Kruskal-Wallis test. No significant interactions between
treatments were found
.
Soil seed bank
The soil seed bank showed an average density of 46 viable seeds/m2 from nine species
(Fig. 1). GLM results showed that neither seed-bank density (F position[2,36]= 0.69, p > 0.05; F Topsoil
[1,36]=0.72, p > 0.05; F Tillage[1, 36]= 0.20, p > 0.05) nor seed-bank richness (Fposition [2,36]= 0.86, p >
0.05; FTopsoil [1,36]=0.43, p > 0.05; F Tillage [1, 36]= 0.43, p > 0.05.) were affected by treatments or
slope position. In all cases, interactions were not significant (p>0.05).
Field monitoring of seedling emergence and survival
During the study period, 840 individuals from 22 species were monitored at the roadcut
(Fig. 1). At the population and community level, seedling emergence and mortality co-occurred
during this period, although there is a higher incorporation of individuals at the beginning of the
growing season, while mortality increased towards the end of the summer (Fig. 2a).
Silt content Total Nitrogen * Organic carbon
Soil organic
matter Ammonium * pH Conductivity
% % % % % µs
C 33.617 ± 0.858 b 0.026 ± 0.002 b
0.309 ± 0.033 b 0.533 ± 0.057 b
3.399 ± 0.050 a 8.542 ± 0.064 a
110.950 ± 4.943 a
T 33.292 ± 0.742 b 0.030 ± 0.002 b
0.228 ± 0.029 b 0.393 ± 0.049 b
3.352 ± 0.051 a 8.599 ± 0.027 a
114.789 ± 3.850 a
TS 35.482 ± 0.632 a 0.040 ± 0.003 a
0.363 ± 0.032 a 0.626 ± 0.056 a
3.214 ± 0.030 b 8.349 ± 0.047 b
93.256 ± 3.895 b
T*TS 35.714 ± 0.723 a 0.045 ± 0.004 a
0.356 ± 0.027 a 0.614 ± 0.047 b
2.975 ± 0.188 b 8.316 ± 0.046 b
93.924 ± 6.893 b
1
T*TS
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
188
Figure 1. Species composition across community ontogeny process (SB= Seed Bank; SE= Seedling Emergence; SS
= Seedling Survival; PC10 = Plant Cover in 2010; PC11= Plant Cover in 2011). Established species included all
species found in consecutive life-stages while occasional ones are those that appeared by turns across community
life history. Topsoil spreading treatment included experimental plots TS-T (topsoil spreading- shallow tillage) and
TS-NT (topsoil spreading- not tillaged), and No topsoil spreading treatment, NTS- T (no topsoil spreading- shallow
tillage) and NTS-NT (no topsoil spreading- not tillaged). Species not identified at least at genus level, are not shown.
The effect of shallow tillage was omitted because community composition of TS-T plots (topsoil spreading- shallow
tillage) and TS-NT plots (topsoil spreading – not tillaged) overlapped 52.5 % and of NTS-T plots (no topsoil
spreading- shallow tillage) and NTS- NT plots (no topsoil spreading- not tillaged) overlapped 40%. (*) Epilobium
brachycarpum is the only non native species that appeared at the study site during the study period.
Species SB SE SS PC10 PC11 Species SB SE SS PC10 PC11
Lolium rigidum Bassia scoparia
Papaver rhoeas Papaver rhoeas
Anagallis arvensis Lolium rigidum
Atriplex patula Polygonum aviculare
Avena barbata Aegilops triuncialis
Polygonum aviculare Avena barbata
Salsola kali Bromus diandrus
Bromus diandrus Bromus madritensis
Convolvulus arvensis Carduus pycnocephalus
Fumaria cf. parviflora Carthamus lanatus
Lactuca serriola Chrozophora tinctoria
Vaccaria hispanica Diplotaxis erucoides
Asterolinon linum-stellatum Lactuca serriola
Bromus rubens Vaccaria hispanica
Coronilla scorpioides
Epilobium brachycarpum*
Euphorbia serrata
Rapistrum rugosum
Scabiosa stellata
Sinapis arvensis
Sonchus asper
Tragopogon porrifolius
Amaranthus albus Anagallis arvensis
Avena sterilis Atriplex patula
Bassia scoparia Convolvulus arvensis
Biscutella auriculata Hordeum murinum
Brassica barrelieri Salsola kali
Bromus madritensis Veronica hederifolia
Bromus sp.
Bromus sterilis
Capsella bursa-pastoris
Carthamus lanatus
Cerastium cf. pumilum
Chrozophora tinctoria
Diplotaxis erucoides
Eruca vesicaria
Galium tricornutum
Kickxia lanigera
Papaver argemone
Veronica hederifolia
Topsoil spreading Not Topsoil spreading
Est
ab
lish
ed s
pec
ies
Occ
asi
on
al
spec
ies
Capítulo V
189
Figure 2. Temporal patterns of seedling emergence and survival over the first growing season (2010). (a) Total
density of individuals across treatments and (b) Survival rates on topsoiled vs. no topsoiled plots. Trend lines with
R2 greater than 96% are shown.
Topsoil spreading, switched the survival temporal pattern from convex to concave (Fig.
2b). GLM results showed that topsoil spreading significantly increased the number of emerged
species (F [1,32]= 8.76; p Topsoil < 0.01, Fig. 3b). However, seedling density was not affected by
filter manipulation (Table 2, Fig. 3a). Topsoil spreading also increased the number of individuals
that reached the adult state (F [1,31]= 11.829; p Topsoil <0.01, Fig 3c ) but did not affect community
composition (Fig. 1), or survival rate per species (Table 2, Fig. 3d).
Table 2. GLM results showing the effects of treatments (TS= topsoil spreading; T= tillage) on seedling density
(Seedling/m2); emerged species (number of species/photograph); survival rate per individual (SRI*) (adult
plants/m2) and survival rate per species (SRS*) (surviving species/photograph).
Seedling density Seedling richness SRI* SRS*
nº seedling/m
2
nº
species/photo adult plants/m
2
surviving
species/photo
Treat. df F p df F p df F p df F p
TS 1 0.499 0.485 1 8.758 0.006 1 11.829 0.002 1 2.386 0.132
T 1 0.044 0.835 1 0.757 0.391 1 0.252 0.619 1 1.656 0.208
TS*T 1 0.504 0.483 1 0.015 0.903 1 0.045 0.833 1 0.202 0.656
Resid.
3
2
3
2
3
1 31
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
April May June July September
Su
rviv
al
rate
No Topsoil Spreading Topsoil Spreading
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
April May June July September
Den
sity
(In
idiv
idu
als
/m2
)Living plants Dead plants a b
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
190
Figure 3. Means (± SE) of (a) Seedling density, (b) Survival rate per individual (number of adults/ total number of
individuals per m2) (c) Seedling richness and (d) Survival rate per species (number of species that reached the adult
stage/ total number of species found per photograph), under the effects of the treatments ( NTS-NT: no topsoil
spreading - not tillaged; NTS-T: no topsoil spreading- shallow tillage; TS-NT: topsoil spreading - not tillaged; and
TS-T: topsoil spreading combined with shallow tillage ). Seedling density and survival rate per individual were root
transformed in order to achieve normality and homocedasticity. Letters show significant differences (p < 0.05) after
HSD Tukey test.
Vegetation cover, composition and richness
Percentage of plant cover in 2010 varied among treatments and along the slope gradient,
reaching maximum values with topsoil spreading in the lower-slope zone of the roadcut (Table 3,
Fig. 4a). In 2011, differences in plant cover among treatments decreased and the interaction
between topsoil spreading and position interaction disappeared. However, plant cover during this
growing season was also significantly increased in the lower-slope zone and under the effect of
topsoil spreading and tillage separately (Table 3). The number of species increased over the
Capítulo V
191
years (Fig. 1). Plant species richness was higher in the lower-slope zone, specifically in the
topsoiled plots during 2010 (Table 3, Fig. 4b), and influenced by topsoil spreading, lower
position and the interaction between slope position and tillage during 2011 (Table 3, Fig. 5).
Table 3. GLM results showing the effect of treatments (TS=topsoil spreading; T= tillage), the slope gradient (P=
position) and their interactions, on plant cover 2010-2011 (% total plant cover/quadrat), and on species richness
(species/quadrat).
Figure 4. Effect of the interaction of topsoil spreading and slope position on (a) percentage of plant cover sampled
in 2010 and (b) species richness in 2010. TS: topsoil spreading; NTS: no topsoil spreading. Figures showed mean
values grouping shallow tillage treatments because of the null effect of this treatment or its interaction with topsoil
spreading. Vertical bars are ± 1 SE.
Plant cover 2010 Species richness 2010 Plant cover 2011 Species richness 2011
% total plant
cover/quadrat species/quadrat
%total plant
cover/quadrat species/quadrat
Factors df F P df F p df F p df F p
TS 1 4.242 0.044 1 2.085 0.154 1 5.377 0.024 1 6.238 0.015
T 1 0.959 0.331 1 0.927 0.340 1 5.820 0.019 1 3.355 0.072
P 2 7.940 0.000 2 26.525 0.000 2 4.231 0.019 2 11.442 0.000
TS*T 1 0.656 0.421 1 0.724 0.398 1 3.380 0.071 1 1.996 0.163
P*TS 2 5142 0.009 2 14.073 0.001 2 0.777 0.464 2 0.194 0.824
P*T 2 1.203 0.307 2 0.135 0.874 2 2.341 0.105 2 4.057 0.022
P*T*TS 2 0.618 0.543 2 0.087 0.917 2 1.581 0.214 2 1.308 0.278
Residuals 60 60 60 60
1
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
192
Figure 5. Effect of the interaction of shallow tillage treatment (T: shallow tillage, NT: not tillaged) and slope
position on species richness during 2011. Vertical bars are ± 1 SE.
Seed rain
From July 2010 to May 2011, a total of 144 seed rain traps was analyzed. Therein, we
recorded an average of 5132 seeds/m2
from 42 different morphotypes. We did not find
differences in seed rain density between treatments and slope position (p>0.05). However, seed
rain richness significantly increased toward the lower-slope zone (F [1, 24] = 5.23; p position < 0.05,
Table 4).
Table 4. Means (±SE) seed rain density (seed/m2*year) and morphotype richness (morphotypes/trap). GLM results
indicated a significant effect of slope position (F [1, 24] = 5.23; p position < 0.05) on the number of seed morphotypes
found in the funnel traps.
Slope position Seed rain density Number of morphotypes
seed/m2*year morphotypes/trap
Upper-slope zone 6818.0 ± 1561.145 7.5 ± 0.744
Lower-slope zone 3447.4 ± 972.460 10.1 ± 0.967
Capítulo V
193
Discussion
Our results highlight the relevance of colonization and early community assembly in the
development of practical guidelines for roadside restoration from an applied ecology perspective.
In this scenario, the present study is the first, to our knowledge, to address at the community
level the link between plant ontogenetic progression and the early assembly sequence, critical in
the context of primary succession. Our results showed that the response to microsite limitations
changes throughout community life history, and that this phenomenon results in a colonization
process mediated by response thresholds with pivotal effects on the composition, richness and
cover of the eventual plant community.
Changes in the response to environmental filters throughout life history
Viable seed persistence in topsoil stockpiling is affected by burial depth and diurnal
fluctuations in light and temperature (Rivera et al. 2012; Rokich et al. 2000). After treatment
onset, topsoil spreading and shallow tillage, however, did not affect roadcut seed bank density or
richness, likely due to the lack of differences in seed rain and to the extremely poor seed bank
provided by the topsoil, in consonance with previous reports (Mola et al. 2011). Conversely,
toposoil-mediated changes in soil nutrient availability, soil texture, electrical conductivity, and
pH significantly affected the number of emerged species. That is to say, topsoil enlarged the
recruitment window of a greater number of pioneer species. These pioneers either persisted or
occasionally appeared in some of the stages of the early community assembly. This eventuality
may be a sampling artifact, or more likely reflects that successful colonization is often the result
of repeated arrival events under a strong environmental control (Ejrnæs et al. 2006). The
manipulation of environmental filters as a result of topsoil spreading also increased seedling
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
194
survival and growth but did not discriminate among species. Across experimental plots, the
sustained effect of filter manipulation on emergence and survival led to a cumulative increase
both in plant abundance and species richness over the years. This is probably due to the typical
low levels of plant cover observed at the early stages of community development on roadcuts.
Even at the lower slope zone, where maximal plant cover values were recorded, they remained
below 50%, and the increase in plant cover along the slope gradient was associated with a
parallel increase in species richness. In Mediterranean grasslands, a unimodal relationship has
been reported between these variables, in which maximum richness is reached at values close to
60% of herbaceous cover (Casado et al. 2004). On road embankments, it has been observed that,
where topsoil spreading provided greater soil resource availability, plant cover exceeded 60%,
which triggered competitive exclusion with drastic effects on species richness (de la Riva et al.
2011). In the light of these previous reports, our results show that the shift of interaction
dynamics does not take place as plants move from seedling to adult life stages, as described
elsewhere (Howard & Goldberg 2001), but rather as plant community structure shifts from
scattered pioneers to densely vegetated grasslands. The absence of strong biotic interactions is
also in consonance with the apparent lack of historical or priority effects (sensu Chase 2003).
The high proportion of species shared between treatments suggest that early community
assembly of roadcut vegetation is controlled by environmental filters rather than by the arrival
order of species, as previously reported in grasslands (Ejrnæs et al. 2006).
Thresholds in early stages of plant community assembly
Our results show that not all life-history stages represent a threshold in the community
assembly process on roadcuts. Manipulation of environmental filters triggered two threshold
Capítulo V
195
responses. First, at seedling emergence stage, changes in ecosystem carrying capacity due to
topsoil spreading led to significant and sustained changes in community richness and
composition. Seedling emergence has previously been described as a crucial process during
primary colonization on roadcuts (Bochet et al. 2007). Our results showed that beyond its
implications in terms of density of individuals, this stage represents a threshold for the species
composition and richness of the emerging community. This threshold arises because seedling
emergence on roadcuts is a density independent process at the community level, largely
unaffected by neighbors, as described elsewhere (Howard & Goldberg 2001). In primary
succession, species interference is limited to interactions between plants at the same life-history
stage. In that sense, Soliveres and coworkers (2012) have recently highlighted that competition
for resources during the emergence of pioneer seedlings is lower than the observed at subsequent
successional stages, which likely explains the higher number of species found under the topsoil
conditions. Although this neighbor effect seems be consistent across life-history stages
(Goldberg et al. 2001; Howard & Goldberg 2001), our field results suggest variation in density
response to environmental conditions between seedling emergence and survival.
The second threshold that we detected during the early community assembly was related
to the transition from seedling to adult stage. The observed overlapping between seedling
emergence and survival suggest that the described threshold has not a temporal but an
ontogenetic meaning. In other words, it does not occur abruptly in time but sequentially through
the plant community development. This transition seems to occur earlier under the effect of
topsoil spreading (shift from convex to concave temporal patterns). When the emergent
community crosses the threshold of seedling survival under suitable conditions for plant growth,
a sudden shift in community structure occurs, which will become apparent in terms of plant
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
196
cover. At the individual level, this threshold change represents the transition from the juvenile to
reproductive phases of most herbaceous species, which will ultimately enable community
persistence during the following years. At the community level, this threshold response is
accompanied by an ontogenetic niche shift across community species, in which seedlings
respond to windows of opportunity in temperature, light and water pulses (Bazzaz 1979), while
habitat suitability for adult plants depends on resource availability such as soil stability, or
nutrient and water (Erikson & Erikson 1998). At the ecosystem level, crossing this threshold
likely leads to biological feedbacks, such as enhanced litterfall or new habitats for colonizing
species, and to physical feedbacks, such as the effects of the larger vegetation patches on the
capacity to retain rainfall and foster water infiltration (Tongway & Ludwig 2010).
Implications for practice
Current guidelines advise against topsoil spreading on roadcuts, given their average
steepness of over 34º and the consequent risk of sediment delivery to the road drainage system
(Ramos 1974; Segura 2002). Although questioned by experimental evidence (Mola et al. 2011),
this recommendation has been widely followed in the context of construction in Spain. Our
findings show, however, that when the abiotic filters in this scenario are not modified by topsoil
spreading, the seedling emergence threshold can hardly be overcome and the pioneer community
will invariably be limited to very few species at most. Under these circumstances, the emerging
community becomes highly vulnerable in the face of the subsequent survival/growth threshold.
Failure to overcome this second critical threshold leads to a strong dependence on the arrival of
propagules of a limited number of species. Consequently, our results indicate that a roadcut
under harsh Mediterranean conditions likely remains as a ‘sink’ habitat (sensu Pulliam 1988),
Capítulo V
197
that serves as a net importer of individuals. Conversely, topsoil spreading provided suitable
conditions for the establishment of a self-sustained richer plant community that may act over
seasons as a source of propagules from a larger number of species. This process is expected to be
particularly active on the bottom half of the slope, where the filter manipulation effect was found
to be more effective. Based on our results, we recommend shallow tillage to extend this effect to
topsoil pockets higher up on the slope. In conclusion, we suggest topsoil spreading on those
roadcut segments where a longer distance between the slope and the drainage system reduces the
risk of sediment deposition in the road ditch. This practice would give rise to a mosaic of sink
and source vegetation patches with functional advantages. First, it would minimize seed dispersal
distance, which is critical at the roadside as seed rain density decreases as a function of distance
from the parent plants (Bochet et al. 2007; Mola et al. 2011). Second, the presence of propagule
sources on the roadcut itself reduces the dependence on remnant vegetation patches located
outside the road boundaries and subject to uncertain disturbances. Finally, it limits the topsoil use
to scattered patches, optimizing the allocation of this scarce resource.
Conclusion
In primary succession, the interplay between seedling colonization, plant ontogeny, and
early community assembly results in a process that can be called ‘community ontogeny’. This
process involves a developmental shift in the perception of and response to local environmental
filters across individuals and species. Analysis of the mechanisms underlying community
ontogeny on roadcuts reveals two sequential thresholds that regulate species richness, and
community composition and cover. A better understanding of these mechanisms should prompt
the reappraisal of current road reclamation practices and help to implement an ecological
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
198
restoration approach, as well as promoting an alternative perspective based on processes such as
seed dispersal, plant recruitment or environmental filter manipulation, rather than on agronomic
principles, such as fertilization, species selection, or biomass yield.
Acknowledgements
We are indebted to Marga Costa, Ana Buades and Silvia Murillo for their field and lab support,
and to Mr. Cormac de Brun for revision of English. We also wish to thank OHL’s R&D
Department for their help and permission to conduct this research, and all the referees that highly
improve this manuscript with their comments and suggestions. Finally, we would like to thank
Rocío de Torre, Adrián G. Escribano Rocafort, Carlos Granado-Yela and Agustina Ventre
Lespiauq for further discussion of ideas during this process. Soil analyses were performed by
Nutrilab (URJC). This study was funded by OHL, the Spanish Ministry of Economy and
Competitiveness (ECONECT project: CDTI IDI-20120317), the Madrid Regional Government
(REMEDINAL-2 S-2009/AMB-1783), and by the FPU grant program of the Spanish Ministry of
Education, Culture and Sports (FPU-AP2009-0094). None of the co-authors have any conflict of
interest regarding to the information contained in the manuscript
Capítulo V
199
References
Bazzaz, F.A. (1979). The physiological ecology of plant succession. Annual Review of Ecology
and Systematics, 10: 351-371.
Bochet, E., & García-Fayos, P. (2004). Factors controlling vegetation establishment and water
erosion on motorway slopes in Valencia, Spain. Restoration Ecology, 12: 166-174.
Bochet, E., García-Fayos, P., & Tormo, J. (2007). Road slope revegetation in semiarid
Mediterranean environments. Part I: seed dispersal and spontaneous colonization
Restoration Ecology, 15: 88-96.
Bouyoucos, G.J. (1962). Hydrometer method improved for making particle size analyses of soils.
Agronomy Journal, 54: 464-465.
Casado, M.A., Castro, I., Ramírez-Sanz, L., Costa-Tenorio, M., de Miguel, J.M., & Pineda, F.D.
(2004). Herbaceous plant richness and vegetation cover in Mediterranean grasslands and
shrublands. Plant Ecology, 170: 83-91.
Chase, J.M., (2003). Community assembly: when should history matter? Oecologia, 136: 489-
498.
De la Riva, E.G, Casado, M.A., Jiménez, M.D., Mola, I., Costa-Tenorio, M., & Balaguer, L.
(2011). Rates of local colonization and extinction reveal diverse plant community
assembly mechanisms on road verges in central Spain. Journal of Vegetation Science, 22:
292-302.
Ejrnaes, R., Bruun, H. H., & Graae, B. J. (2006). Community assembly in experimental
grasslands: suitable environment or timely arrival? Ecology, 87:1225-1233.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
200
Elmarsdottir, A., Aradottir, A.L., & Trlica, M.J. (2003). Microsite availability and establishment
of native species on degraded and reclaimed sites. Journal of Applied Ecology, 40: 815-
823.
Eriksson, O. (2002). Ontogenetic niche shifts and their implications for recruitment in three
clonal Vaccinium shrubs: Vaccinium myrtillus, Vaccinium vitis-idaea, and Vaccinium
oxycoccus. Canadian Journal of Botany, 80: 635-641.
Eriksson, O., & Eriksson, A. (1998). Effects of arrival order and seed size on germination of
grassland plants: Are there assembly rules during recruitment? Ecological Research, 13:
229-239.
Fox, J., & Weisberg, S. (2011). An R Companion to Applied Regression. Second Edition. Sage,
Thousand Oaks CA. [R package version 1.0-9]
Goldberg, D.E., Turkington, R., Olsvig-Whittaker, L., & Dyer, A.R. (2001). Density dependence
in an annual plant community: variation among life history stages. Ecological
Monographs, 71: 423-446.
Graves, S., Piepho, H.P., Selzer, L., & Dorai-Raj, S. (2012). multcompView: Visualizations of
Paired Comparisons. [R package version 0.1-5: http://CRAN.R-
project.org/package=multcompView]
Harper, J.L. (1977). Population Biology of Plants. Academic Press, New York. Blackwell
Publishing Ltd.
Hobbs, R., & Norton, D. (2004). Ecological filters, thresholds, and gradients in resistance to
ecosystems reassembly. In: Temperton, V., Hobbs, R., Nuttle, T. & Halle, S. (eds).
Assembly rules and restoration ecology: bridging the gap between theory and practice,
pp. 72–96. Society for Ecological Restoration International. Indian Press. Washington.
Capítulo V
201
Howard, T.G., & Goldberg, D.E. (2001). Competitive response hierarchies for germination,
growth, and survival and their influence on abundance. Ecology, 82: 979-990.
ITGE. (1990). Mapa Geológico de España 1:50.000, Alcalá de Henares (560), Instituto
Tecnológico Geominero de España, Madrid (map and written report).
Jackson, M.L. (1958). Soil Chemical Analysis. Prentice Hall: Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
Jiménez, M.D., Ruiz-Capillas, P., Mola, I., Pérez-Corona, E., Casado, M.A., & Balaguer, L.
(2013). Soil development at the roadside: A case study of a novel ecosystem. Land
Degradation and Development, 24: 564-574.
Kleyer, M., Bekker, R.M., Knevel, I.C., Bakker, J.P., Thompson, K., Sonnenschein, M.,
Poschlod, P., van Groenendael, J.M., Klimeš, L.,Klimešová, J.,Klotz, S., Rusch, G.M.,
Hermy, M., Adriaens, D., Boedeltje, G., Bossuyt, B., Dannemann, A., Endels, P.,
Götzenberger, L., Hodgson, J.G., Jackel, A.-K., Kühn, I., Kunzmann, D., Ozinga, W.A.,
Römermann, C., Stadler, M., Schlegelmilch, J., Steendam, H.J., Tackenberg, O.,
Wilmann, B., Cornelissen, J.H.C., Eriksson, O., Garnier, E., & Peco, B. (2008). The
LEDA Traitbase: a database of life-history traits of the Northwest European flora. Journal
of Ecology, 96: 1266-1274.
Knevel, I.C., Bekker, R.M., Bakker, J.P., & Kleyer, M. (2003). Life-history traits of the
northwest European flora: the Leda database. Journal of Vegetation Science, 14: 611-614.
Lortie, J., & Turkington, R. (2002). The effect of initial seed density on the structure of a desert
annual plant community. Journal of Ecology, 90: 435-445.
Luzuriaga, A., & Escudero, A. (2008). What determines emergence and net recruitment in an
early succession plant community? Disentangling biotic and abiotic effects. Journal of
Vegetation Science, 19: 445-456.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
202
Miriti, M.N. (2006). Ontogenetic shift from facilitation to competition in a desert shrub. Journal
of Ecology, 94: 973-979.
Mola, I., Jiménez, M.D., López-Jiménez, N., Casado, M.A., & Balaguer, L. (2011). Roadside
reclamation outside the revegetation season: Management options under schedule
pressure. Restoration Ecology, 19: 83-92.
Morales, M. (2011). sciplot: Scientific Graphing Functions for Factorial Designs.[R package
version 1.0-9: http://CRAN.R-project.org/package=sciplot]
Nelson, D.W., & Sommers, L.E. (1982). Total carbon, organic carbon, and organic matter. In:
Page, A.L., Miller, R.H. & Keeney, D.R. (eds). Methods of soil analysis part 2, chemical
and microbiological properties, pp. 539–579. Soil Science Society of American. Incana,
Madison, WI.
Pulliam, H. R. (1988). Sources, sinks, and population regulation. American Naturalist, 132: 65-
661.
R Development Core Team (2011). R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R
Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. ISBN 3-900051-07-0
Ramos, F. (1974). Tratamiento funcional y paisajístico de taludes artificiales: revisión de
problemas. Datos experimentales. Ministerio de Agricultura, Pesca y Alimentación,
ICONA, Madrid, Spain.
Rivera, D., Jáuregui, B.M., & Peco, B. (2012). The fate of herbaceous seeds during topsoil
stockpiling: Restoration potential of seed banks. Ecological Engineering, 44: 94-101.
Rokich, D.P., Dixon, K.W., Sivasithamparam, K., & Meney, K.A. (2000). Topsoil handling and
storage effect on woodland restoration in Western Australia. Restoration Ecology, 8: 196-
208.
Capítulo V
203
Segura, R. (2002). Impacto ambiental de las líneas de alta velocidad. Medidas preventivas,
correctoras y compensatorias. Colegio de Ingenieros de Caminos, Canales y Puertos,
Madrid, Spain.
Soliveres, S., Monerris, J., & Cortina, J. (2012). Irrigation, organic fertilization and species
successional stage modulate the response of woody seedlings to herbaceous competition
in a semi-arid quarry restoration. Applied Vegetation Science, 15: 175-186.
Suding, K.N., Gross, K.L., & Houseman, G.R. (2004). Alternative states and positive feedbacks
in restoration ecology. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 19: 46-53.
Temperton, V. (2007). The recent double paradigm shift in restoration ecology. Restoration
Ecology, 15: 344-347.
Tongway, D.J., & Ludwig, J. (2010). Restoring disturbed landscapes: Putting principles into
practice. Island Press, Washington, DC.
Valladares, F., Tena, D., Matesanz, S., Bochet, E., Balaguer, L., Costa-Tenorio, M., Tormo, J., &
García-Fayos, P. (2008). Functional traits and phylogeny: What is the main ecological
process determining species assemblage in roadside plant communities? Journal of
Vegetation Science, 19: 381-392.
van Es, H.M., Gomes, C.P., Sellmann, M., & van Es, C.L. (2007). Spatially-Balanced Complete
Block designs for field experiments. Geoderma, 140: 346-352.
Walker, L.R., & del Moral, R. (2003). Primary succession and ecosystem rehabilitation.
Cambridge University Press. Cambridge, UK.
Walker, L.R., & del Moral, R. (2008). Lessons from primary succession for restoration of
severely damaged habitats. Applied Vegetation Science, 12: 55-67.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
204
Walker, L.R., Zasada, J.C., & Chapin, III, F.S. (1986). The Role of Life History Processes in
Primary Succession on an Alaskan Floodplain. Ecology, 67: 1243–1253.
Zuur, A.F., Ieno, E.N., Walker, N.J., Saveliev, A.A., & Smith, G.M. (2009). Mixed Effects
Models and Extensions in Ecology with R. Springer, New York.
205
CAPÍTULO VI
General discussion
206
Capítulo VI
207
This Doctoral Thesis broadens our knowledge of the relatively unknown features of
roadside ecosystems that are of great relevance in guiding the science and practice of ecological
restoration efforts in this kind of setting. In this chapter, we discuss the importance of soil
variables in the organization of key soil communities such as microarthropods and
microorganisms. Moreover, we analyze how different types of management can affect soil
community structure and functionality as well as early phases of plant community assembly.
The soil system: variables affecting soil community development along the roadside
Soil is the basis of terrestrial ecosystem development due to the fact that most ecological
processes that give rise to regulation services such as nutrient cycling, water holding capacity
and carbon storage, occurs underground (de Groot et al. 2002). Despite its importance,
insufficient attention has been paid to this ecosystem compartment in the context of roadside
engineering and restoration. The recovery of functional soils is especially important in areas
affected by road construction where relief and hydrology been severely altered during the
construction process, and all vestiges of biological communities have been eliminated (Balaguer
2002). For this reason, roadside ecosystems must acquire a minimum carrying capacity to
support biological communities that, once established, trigger feedback processes in which these
communities can contribute to soil formation and stability (Odum 1969). Plant and soil
organisms live in an intimate relationship with the soil environment in which they increase soil
complexity through root development, microarthropod movements, bacterial growth etc., and
help create new conditions for other species with further synergistic effects on biodiversity and
soil functionality (Ettema & Wardle 2002). Thus, in order to maintain and restore soil processes
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
208
in roadslopes, the first step is to acquire and refine our knowledge of the soil characteristics
affecting the communities intimately involved in soil functionality.
Our results show that physicochemical soil variables determine the organization and
variation of edaphic communities (e.g., microarthropods and bacteria) in roadside ecosystems.
Road embankments are productive and –or should be- nutrient-rich ecosystems where the rapid
development of plant biomass is incorporated into the soil thereby generating organic matter
pulses that, in turn, trigger early edaphogenic processes (Jiménez et al. 2013). We detect that the
increase in soil organic matter facilitates the transition from more generalist/pioneer
microarthropod communities characterized by higher abundances of Gamasida and Actinedida,
to other taxa indicative of more stable states mainly dominated by Oribatid mites (Poronota and
Gymnonota) and Collembola (Symphypleona). This is in line with other studies that show
organic matter content as the best predictor for Oribatida and Collembola community structure
(Hasegawa 2001). Oribatid mites are litter feeders and are involved in the resizing of particulates
that facilitate the subsequent colonization of soil microorganisms, at the same time that they
contribute to fungi and bacteria dispersion (Norton 1990). Due to their specific ecological
requirements and their low mobility, Oribatid mites are highly dependent on stable soil
conditions and hence are commonly used as indicators of soil quality and health (Beham-
Pelletier 1999). Collembolans play an important role in soil organic matter decomposition and
humification through the degradation of recalcitrant compounds by means of the enzymatic
activity in their guts (Saur & Ponge, 1988). Collembolans also contribute to soil microstructure
and the development of topsoil layers through feces deposition and bioturbation processes. Some
species of Collembolans are geophages, whose activity enhances the formation of organo-
mineral complexes in soil (Wolters 2000 and references therein). Owing to the intimate
Capítulo VI
209
relationship between Collembolans and soil conditions, it is expected that community
composition could change under the effect of disturbance. Specifically, Symphypleona are
commonly found in unaltered environments and thus are also good indicators of soil stability
(Badeano et al. 2006).
The incorporation of organic matter into the soil affects ion exchange and decreases soil pH
(Parfitt et al. 1995). However, in road embankments the effect of construction materials coupled
with the strong evapotranspiration processes characterizing Mediterranean environments, tend to
alkalinize the soil (Alfaya 2013). Our results show that soil pH is one of the principal factors
determining bacterial community composition in road embankments. The effect of soil pH on
bacterial community composition and diversity has been previously observed in different types
of soil across biomes and land uses (Fierer et al. 2012; Lauber et al. 2008). Soil pH directly
constrains bacterial physiology, impeding the growth of certain taxa and altering competitive
outcomes that, in turn, affect community composition and diversity (Lauber et al. 2009). More
specifically, previous work shows that some groups of Acidobacteria are negatively correlated
with soil pH, while other groups of the same phylum as well as Actinobacteria, tend to thrive
under higher pH levels (Rousk et al. 2010 and references therein), also in agreement with our
results. However, pH is known to act as an integrative variable that may hide the effect of many
other soil properties (Laubert et al. 2009). This too agrees with our findings revealing that other
variables related to soil texture, such as clay and sand content, are also relevant in the
organization of bacterial communities. Soil bacteria community composition varies with the
shape of soil particles and the type of soil aggregates (Ranjard & Richaume 2001). In this way,
higher nutrient contents associated with clay content increase bacterial diversity and may trigger
differences in composition, at the same time that the sand fraction may be linked to bacterial
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
210
species that are better adapted to nutrient poor conditions (Sessitsch et al. 2001). Bacterial
community development also interacts with soil particles through the production of extracellular
polysaccharides (Foster 1988), which contributes to aggregate soil particles and to the
development of soil microstructure. Soil heterogeneity and the microenvironments created by the
interaction of microorganisms and soil particles, affect soil structure in terms of porosity and
moisture (Porta et al. 1999, Tisdall &Oades, 1982). The habitat created by small but numerous
pores, leads to many microarthropod species dropping out or being excluded from the emergent
community. For example, and in general terms, Oribatida remains associated with the 6–90 m
pore size class (Vreeken-Buijs et al. 1998). In line with these findings, we determined that
porosity is responsible for changes in community structure, increasing the abundance of small-
sized Oribatids from the Opiidae family.
In light of our results, it is worth noting that some soil variables (mainly nutrient content, pH,
texture, and structure) distinctly change the composition and self-organization of soil
communities. Interestingly, these variables are subject to severe changes during the constructive
processes. For instance, either in road embankments (where foreign aggregate materials are used
during construction) or in roadcuts (where bedrock is exposed), some of these variables (i.e.,
texture and pH) may change drastically. In addition, conventional management techniques such
as the application of topsoil, mowing and organic/inorganic amendments not only have direct
effects on soil conditions but also boost changes in aboveground communities that subsequently
affect the soil environment, especially through the incorporation of soil organic matter. However,
the effect of these types of management on key soil communities is unknown in the context of
roadside restoration. Therefore, in this thesis we have tested the effects of some of these
Capítulo VI
211
treatments on the assembly of different biological communities as well as on relevant ecological
processes.
Managing management: roadside restoration and the maintenance of functionality
Ensuring restoration success it is essential to identify the ecological thresholds that are
constraining an ecosystem´s self-organization (Suding & Hobbs 2009), and then to select the
technique or techniques that facilitate ecosystem recovery with minimum cost and intervention.
The degree of impairment as well as the nature of thresholds that must be overcome, determines
in large part the restoration actions (King & Hobbs 2006). At the same time, the setting of goals
and objectives should be realistic, particularly in the early stages (Ehrenfeld 2000). For instance,
in highly degraded sites and ecosystems, such as roadcuts and road embankments, mine sites,
and elsewhere, where abiotic and biotic components of the local ecosystems have been
drastically altered, full recovery of ecosystem functionality and native biodiversity will be slow,
and will require significant inputs of resources. Thus, project managers should not expect to
achieve very ambitious goals at these sites in the short-term.
In some Mediterranean road embankments, both construction and management
techniques may facilitate plant colonization and establishment, giving rise to high biomass
production. In these scenarios, biotic thresholds derived from competitive exclusion processes
among different species can shape plant community development (De la Riva et al. 2011;
Valladares et al. 2008). Although in older embankments plant species seem to be the decisive
factor in roadside ecosystem organization (García-Palacios et al. 2010), during the earliest stages
of community assembly process the interaction between plant and microbial communities plays a
major role in roadside ecosystem functionality (García-Palacios et al. 2011). Conventional
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
212
management applied in Mediterranean roadslopes is oriented to the maintenance of plant
communities and does not consider their effects upon soil microbial communities. Some studies
reveal that restoration practices that do not take into account feedback processes among different
ecosystem compartments could give rise to unpredictable outcomes (Suding et al. 2004). Thus,
our results reveal that bacterial community structure as well as soil processes are highly sensitive
to the choice of management practices employed. In particular, fertilization favors community
evenness and alters bacterial community composition. These changes in bacterial community
structure under the application of fertilizers have been observed previously both in natural and
anthropogenic systems (Fierer et al. 2012; Nogales et al. 2010). This effect is related to the fact
that nitrogen addition shifts the metabolic capabilities of soil communities thereby changing
competitive relationships among them with subsequent effects in community composition (Fierer
et al. 2007; Ramírez et al. 2012). Moreover, we observed that biomass addition treatments
increase taxonomical diversity. This could be related to the buffering effect of litter accumulation
in microclimatic soil conditions in road embankments (De Torre 2014), in conjunction with the
fact that the litter layer protects the soil surface against rain drop impacts, preserving soil
microhabitats and increasing bacterial diversity (Pengthamkeerati et al. 2011). Our results also
showed that mowing treatments affect soil properties, thereby altering nutrient stocks and soil
texture, as well as soil processes, while also accelerating litter decay and other basic processes.
These effects may be related mainly to the changes induced in plant communities by mowing
practices. On the one hand, mowing increases niche availability for a large number of fast-
growing plant species that immobilize soil nitrogen (Rizand et al. 1989, Robson et al. 2007),
while on the other hand the relatively low vegetation cover induced by this treatment may favor
leaching processes, decreasing the proportion of nitrogen with further effects on the C:N ratio in
Capítulo VI
213
the soil. Moreover, this lack of vegetation can also explain changes in soil texture under the
effect of this treatment. Bare soil exposure to rain events plus the common design of roadslopes
characterized by steep slopes, favor erosion processes that enhance the movement of finer soil
particles (clay) (Castillo et al. 1997), hence increasing the relative content of loam, as we
observed in our experiments. The effect of mowing on plant communities could also be
translated to compositional changes that affect the quantity and quality of organic matter
incorporated into soil with further effects on decomposition rates (Zhang et al. 2008). However,
another plausible explanation for the acceleration of the litter decay rate that we observed is the
lack of vegetation in mown plots, which increases the sun exposure of the soil surface to strong
sunlight, thereby promoting high rates of litter photodegradation. This process has been
described as one of the main factors related to litter decay in Mediterranean climates (Henry et
al. 2008).
Despite the importance of plant cover in the stabilization of roadslope substrates (Andres
& Jorb, 2000), roadside vegetation does not usually recover spontaneously within a time frame
appropriate to an infrastructure construction schedule (Mola et al. 2011). For this reason, some
restoration measures are taken to boost roadside vegetation recovery. Unfortunately, most efforts
in Mediterranean roadslopes have been focused on the development of the plant community
structure, leading to the waste of considerable amounts of money in hydroseeding, fertilizers, or
other plantings with poor results (Tena 2006). For instance, in roadcuts the steep slopes (often
higher that 40%), smooth and compacted surfaces and soils with lower water-holding capacity,
create stressful abiotic conditions and a scarcity of safe-sites that constrain ecosystem recovery
(Bochet & García Fayos 2004). Moreover, the effect of these abiotic filters may have effects
both at an individual species scale, by constraining the transition between different life stages
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
214
during early community development, and at the community scale by determining the attributes
of the final community. Our results reveal that topsoil spreading helps to overcome some of these
abiotic filters and favors the community assembly processes. Considering the individual life-
cycle of plants, topsoil facilitates the emergence of more species and the transition from seedling
to adult stages. This result may be related to the fact that topsoil induced changes in soil texture
and decreased soil conductivity, which in turn modified osmotic potential in the soil matrix
facilitating water intake by seedlings (Lamsal et al. 1999). This is in line with previous studies
(e.g., Bochet et al. 2007) that point to water availability as the main factor conditioning seed
germination and species segregation in Mediterranean roadslopes. In other words, two life-
history events (emergence and survival) acting as thresholds during community assembly and
with further consequences at community scale were overcome by the spreading of topsoil. This
treatment affects roadside vegetation giving rise to communities with higher species richness and
higher plant cover. Habitat suitability for adult plants mainly depends on resource availability
such as nutrient content and soil stability (Erikson 2002). Thus, the improvement of soil
properties by topsoil spreading, which enhances nitrogen and soil organic matter content,
facilitates an ontogenic niche shift and favors the establishment and growth of more species. On
the contrary, our results show that tillage, which was applied to increase roughness and safe-sites
for recruitment, does not improve recruitment conditions for pioneer plant communities. For
instance, far from enhancing soil heterogeneity, this treatment homogenizes the soil surface and
contributes to substrate instability. This effect may be related to lithological characteristics at the
study site. Substrates there are mainly composed of expansive clays exposed to ‘popcorn’
processes (J.F. Martin-Duque, comm. pers.) derived from cyclic rewetting and desiccation
processes, which create very unstable substrates that usually lead to small mass movements
Capítulo VI
215
(Mokthari & Dehghani 2012), reducing plant colonization and establishment. However, a
slightly positive effect of tillage on species richness was observed in the upper part of the roadcut
when combined with topsoil spreading: tillage seems to have had the desirable effect of creating
topsoil pockets on steep slopes.
Implications for practice
Professionals undertaking ecological restoration in areas affected by road construction must
carefully analyze the key ecological processes affected, while techniques they apply to boost
ecosystem recovery should be goal-oriented. Regarding the results obtained in this Doctoral
Thesis, some implications for practice can be drawn:
1. Promote soil stability in road embankments: Microarthropod communities present in
the road embankments studied indicate that 6 years after road construction, these
anthrosols are fully functional. Furthermore, soil bacterial community composition from
road embankments suggests successional processes that give rise to higher abundances of
groups of bacteria implicated in organic matter turnover, indicative of ecosystem stable
states. Assemblages of both soil communities depend mainly on soil, organic carbon, soil
texture and structure. Thus, conventional management affecting soil properties such as
mowing and re-grading should be avoided to prevent the alteration of these soil factors
and to maintain favorable soil conditions that promote ecosystem functionality and
capacity to deliver ecosystem services.
2. Maintain soil cover: Our results indicate that biomass addition increases bacterial
community diversity. However, mowing adversely affects key soil properties responsible
for soil bacterial communities at the same time that it accelerates litter decomposition,
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
216
with further effects on organic matter dynamics in soil. Given that mowing is a common
practice in conservation activities of road embankments, we recommend not removing
leaf litter from the soil surface to preserve soil conditions that ensure the maintenance of
soil communities and associated processes.
3. Topsoil spreading in roadcuts: Topsoil spreading in roadcuts is not a common practice
because of its possible impacts on road security. However, we demonstrate that topsoil
properties rapidly boost plant community development in these scenarios. The
application of this treatment increases plant cover and promotes the establishment of a
higher numbers of local species. Nevertheless, topsoil spreading should be carefully
planned to optimize the use of this scarce resource and to cope with operational
requirements. One plausible option could be to apply topsoil in thin and discontinuous
layers, in combination with other practices that facilitate its retention, on those roadcut
segments where a greater distance between the slope and the drainage system reduces the
risk of sediment deposition in the road ditch. In this way, ecosystem carrying capacity
can be locally increased, and the recruitment of plant species can be favored without
jeopardizing vehicle drivers’ security.
Capítulo VI
217
References
Alfaya, V. (2013). Colonización de taludes artificiales por medio de la vegetación natural.
Doctoral dissertation.
Balaguer, L. (2002). Las limitaciones de la restauración de la cubierta vegetal. Revista
Ecosistemas, 1 (http://revistaecosistemas.net/inde1x.php/ecosistemas/article/view/307).
Behan-Pelletier, V. M. (1999). Oribatid mite biodiversity in agroecosystems: role for
bioindication. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 74: 411-423.
Bedano, J. C., Cantú, M. P., & Doucet, M. E. (2006). Soil springtails (Hexapoda: Collembola),
symphylans and pauropods (Arthropoda: Myriapoda) under different management
systems in agroecosystems of the subhumid Pampa (Argentina). European Journal of Soil
Biology, 42: 107-119.
Bochet, E., & García-Fayos, P. (2004). Factors controlling vegetation establishment and water
erosion on motorway slopes in Valencia, Spain. Restoration Ecology, 12: 166-174.
Bochet, E., García-Fayos, P., Alborch, B., & Tormo, J. (2007). Soil water availability effects on
seed germination account for species segregation in semiarid roadslopes. Plant & Soil,
295: 179-191.
Castillo, V. M., Martínez-Mena, M., & Albaladejo, J. (1997). Runoff and soil loss response to
vegetation removal in a semiarid environment. Soil Science Society of America Journal,
61: 1116-1121.
De Groot, R. S., Wilson, M. A., & Boumans, R. M. (2002). A typology for the classification,
description and valuation of ecosystem functions, goods and services. Ecological
Economics, 41: 393-408.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
218
De la Riva, E. G., Casado, M. A., Jiménez, M. D., Mola, I., Costa-Tenorio, M., & Balaguer, L.
(2011). Rates of local colonization and extinction reveal different plant community
assembly mechanisms on road verges in central Spain. Journal of Vegetation Science, 22:
292-302.
De Torre, R. (2014). Procesos ecológicos implicados en el ensamblaje de comunidades en
taludes de carretera y su aplicación a la restauración ecológica. Doctoral dissertation
Ehrenfeld, J. G. (2000). Defining the limits of restoration: the need for realistic goals.
Restoration Ecology, 8: 2-9.
Eriksson, O. (2002). Ontogenetic niche shifts and their implications for recruitment in three
clonal Vaccinium shrubs: Vaccinium myrtillus, Vaccinium vitis-idaea, and Vaccinium
oxycoccus. Canadian Journal of Botany, 80: 635–641.
Ettema, C.H., & Wardle, D.A. (2002). Spatial soil ecology. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 17:
177–183.
Fierer, N., Bradford, M. A., & Jackson, R. B. (2007). Toward an ecological classification of soil
bacteria. Ecology, 88: 1354-1364.
Fierer, N., Leff, J. W., Adams, B. J., Nielsen, U. N., Bates, S. T., Lauber, C. L., Owens, S.,
Gilbert, J. A., Wall, D. H., & Caporaso, J. G. (2012). Cross-biome metagenomic analyses
of soil microbial communities and their functional attributes. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences, 109: 21390-21395.
Foster, R.C. (1988). Microenvironments of soil microorganisms. Biology & Fertility of Soils, 6:
189–203.
García-Palacios, P., Bowker, M. A., Chapman, S. J., Maestre, F. T., Soliveres, S., Gallardo, A.,
Valladares, F., Guerrero, C., & Escudero, A. (2011). Early-successional vegetation
Capítulo VI
219
changes after roadside prairie restoration modify processes related with soil functioning
by changing microbial functional diversity. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 43:1245-1253.
García-Palacios, P., Soliveres, S., Maestre, F. T., Escudero, A., Castillo-Monroy, A. P., &
Valladares, F. (2010). Dominant plant species modulate responses to hydroseeding,
irrigation and fertilization during the restoration of semiarid motorway slopes. Ecological
Engineering, 36: 1290-1298.
Hasegawa, M. (2001). The relationship between the organic matter composition of a forest floor
and the structure of a soil arthropod community. European Journal of Soil Biology, 37:
281-284.
Henry, H. A., Brizgys, K. & Field, C. B. (2008). Litter decomposition in a California annual
grassland: interactions between photodegradation and litter layer thickness. Ecosystems,
11: 545-554.
Jiménez, M. D., Ruiz-Capillas, P., Mola, I., Pérez-Corona, E., Casado, M. A., & Balaguer, L.
(2013). Soil development at the roadside: a case study of a novel ecosystem. Land
Degradation & Development, 24: 564-574.
King, E. G., & Hobbs, R. J. (2006). Identifying linkages among conceptual models of ecosystem
degradation and restoration: towards an integrative framework. Restoration Ecology, 14:
369-378.
Lamsal, K., Paudyal, G. N., & Saeed, M. (1999). Model for assessing impact of salinity on soil
water availability and crop yield. Agricultural Water Management, 41: 57-70.
Lauber, C.L., Hamady, M., Knight R., & Fierer, N. (2009). Pyrosequencing-based assessment of
soil pH as a predictor of soil bacterial community composition at the continental scale.
Applied & Environmental Microbiology, 75: 5111–5120.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
220
Lauber, C.L., Strickland, M.S., Bradford, M.A., & Fierer, N. (2008). The influence of soil
properties on the structure of bacterial and fungal communities across land–use types.
Soil Biology and Biochemestry, 40: 2407–2415.
Mokhtari, M., & Dehghani, M. (2012). Swell-Shrink Behavior of Expansive Soils, Damage and
Control. Electronic Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, 17: 2673-2682.
Mola, I., Jiménez, M.D., López-Jiménez, N., Casado, M.A., & Balaguer, L. (2011). Roadside
reclamation outside the revegetation season: Management options under schedule
pressure. Restoration Ecology, 19: 83–92.
Nogales, B., Lanfranconi, M. P., Piña-Villalonga, J. M., & Bosch, R. (2011). Anthropogenic
perturbations in marine microbial communities. FEMS Microbiology Reviews, 35: 275-
298.
Norton, R.A. (1990). Acarina: Oribatida. In Soil biology guide. Edited by D.L. Dindal. John
Wiley & Sons, Inc., Toronto, Ont. pp. 779–803.
Odum, E. P. (1969). The strategy of ecosystem development. Science, 16 : 262-270.
Parfitt, R. L., Giltrap, D. J., & Whitton, J. S. (1995). Contribution of organic matter and clay
minerals to the cation exchange capacity of soils. Communications in Soil Science &
Plant Analysis, 26: 1343-1355.
Pengthamkeerati, P., Motavalli, P. P., & Kremer, R. J. (2011). Soil microbial activity and
functional diversity changed by compaction, poultry litter and cropping in a claypan
soil. Applied Soil Ecology, 48: 71-80.
Porta, J., López-Acevedo, M., & Roquero, C. (1999). Edafología para la agricultura y el medio
ambiente. 2ª Edición. Ediciones Mundi-Prensa. Madrid. 849 pp.
Capítulo VI
221
Ramírez, K. S., Craine, J. M., & Fierer, N. (2012). Consistent effects of nitrogen amendments on
soil microbial communities and processes across biomes. Global Change Biology, 18:
1918-1927.
Ranjard, L., & Richaume, A. (2001). Quantitative and qualitative microscale distribution of
bacteria in soil. Research in Microbiology, 152: 707–716.
Rizand, A., Marrs, R. H., Gough, M. W., & Wells, T. C. E. (1989). Long-term effects of various
conservation management treatments on selected soil properties of chalk grassland.
Biological Conservation, 49: 105-112.
Robson, T. M., Lavorel, S., Clement, J. C., & Roux, X. L. (2007). Neglect of mowing and
manuring leads to slower nitrogen cycling in subalpine grasslands. Soil Biology &
Biochemistry, 39: 930-941.
Rousk, J., Bååth, E., Brookes, P. C., Lauber, C. L., Lozupone, C., Caporaso, J. G., Knight, R., &
Fierer, N. (2010). Soil bacterial and fungal communities across a pH gradient in an arable
soil. The ISME Journal, 4: 1340-1351.
Saur, É., & Ponge, J. F. (1988). Alimentary studies on the Collembolan Paratullbergia
callipygos using transmission electron microscopy. Pedobiologia, 31: 355-379.
Sessitsch, A., Weilharter, A., Gerzabek, M.H., Kirchmann, H., & Kandeler, E. (2001). Microbial
population structures in soil particle size fractions of a long–term fertilizer field
experiment. Applied & Environmental Microbiology, 67: 4215–4224.
Suding, K. N., & Hobbs, R. J. (2009). Threshold models in restoration and conservation: a
developing framework. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 24: 271-279.
Suding, K. N., Gross, K. L., & Houseman, G. R. (2004). Alternative states and positive
feedbacks in restoration ecology. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 19: 46-53.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
222
Tena, D. (2006). Implicaciones funcionales y evolutivas de la estructura y dinámica de
comunidades herbáceas de bordes de carretera. Doctoral dissertation.
Tisdall, J. M., & Oades, J. (1982). Organic matter and water-stable aggregates in soils. Journal
of Soil Science, 33(2): 141-163.
Valladares, F., Tena, D., Matesanz, S., Bochet, E., Balaguer, L., Costa-Tenorio, M., Tormo, J.,
& García-Fayos, P. (2008). Functional traits and phylogeny: What is the main ecological
process determining species assemblage in roadside plant communities? Journal of
Vegetation Science, 19: 381-392.
Vreeken-Buijs, M.J., Hassink, J., & Brussaard, L. (1998). Relationships of soil microarthropod
biomass with organic matter and pore size distribution in soils under different land use.
Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 30: 97-106.
Wolters, V. (2000). Invertebrate control of soil organic matter stability. Biology & Fertility of
Soils, 31: 1-19.
Zhang, D., Hui, D., Luo, Y., & Zhou, G. (2008). Rates of litter decomposition in terrestrial
ecosystems: global patterns and controlling factors. Journal of Plant Ecology, 1: 85-93.
223
CONCLUSIONES
224
Conclusiones
225
De los cuatro capítulos experimentales que se presentan en esta tesis doctoral se pueden
extraer las siguientes conclusiones:
1. El cambio en la composición de microartrópodos edáficos desde comunidades dominadas por
grupos generalistas o primocolonizadores a otras asociadas a condiciones edáficas estables,
está relacionado con el carbono orgánico, el contenido en arcillas y la humedad del suelo.
2. Este cambio en la composición se traduce en una mayor abundancia de Oribátidos (Ácaros)
y Sinfipleones (Colémbolos) que están implicados en la degradación de la materia orgánica,
y en el desarrollo de la microestructura del suelo. Dada la estrecha dependencia de estos
organismos con la estabilidad en las condiciones edáficas, son considerados como
indicadores de calidad de suelo.
3. Según el índice de calidad biológica de suelo (QBS), los valores máximos obtenidos en
suelos de terraplenes de carretera de más de 6 años de antigüedad son comparables a los
valores de funcionalidad observados en suelos de ecosistemas naturales.
4. Los terraplenes de carretera presentan una diversidad taxonómica de bacterias baja y similar
a los observados en otros suelos de origen antrópico, dominando unos pocos grupos de
bacterias como son Actinobacteria, Acidobacteria y Planctomycetes. Estos grupos están
implicados en la dinámica de la materia orgánica del suelo y son indicadores de estados
sucesionales estables.
5. Entre los grupos taxonómicos observados en las comunidades bacterianas de terraplenes se
han encontrado también Bacteroidetes, Firmicutes, Gemmatimonadates y Cyanobacteria. La
baja abundancia relativa de estos grupos está asociada con el avance de la sucesión en estos
suelos.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
226
6. La composición de las comunidades bacterianas de terraplenes varía a escala local y está
relacionada con las características edáficas, especialmente el pH y la textura del suelo.
7. Las técnicas de manejo convencional aplicadas en terraplenes de carretera inducen cambios
en la estructura de las comunidades bacterianas de estos ambientes. En concreto, la
acumulación de biomasa aumenta la diversidad taxonómica al tiempo que la aplicación de
fertilizantes favorece una mayor equitatividad dentro de la comunidad. Además, este último
tratamiento modifica la composición de la comunidad favoreciendo el desarrollo de grupos
como los Gemmatimonadetes relacionados con una baja disponibilidad de nutrientes.
8. La aplicación de siegas en terraplenes de carretera aumenta la relación C:N, incrementa la
proporción de limos en el suelo y acelera la tasa de descomposición de hojarasca. Estos
efectos pueden estar relacionados con los cambios inducidos en la composición de plantas y
con la ausencia temporal de vegetación, que favorece procesos erosivos que arrastran las
partículas más finas (arcillas). Además, la exposición del suelo a la radiación solar, aumenta
la fotodegradación de la hojarasca, proceso típico de ambientes mediterráneos.
9. La aplicación de tierra vegetal en desmontes de carretera permite rebajar el efecto de los
filtros abióticos que condicionan el ensamblaje de la comunidad de plantas en estos
ambientes. En concreto, la aplicación de este tratamiento aumenta el contenido de carbono y
nitrógeno en el suelo, el contenido de limos y arenas, y disminuye el pH y la conductividad
eléctrica.
10. La respuesta de los distintos estadios vitales de las plantas a los tratamientos estudiados
permite detectar dos procesos que actúan como umbrales para el ensamblaje de la comunidad
de taludes: la emergencia y supervivencia de plántulas. La tierra vegetal permite sobrepasar
Conclusiones
227
esos umbrales favoreciendo el ensamblaje de la comunidad de plantas en desmontes de
carretera.
11. La tierra vegetal incrementa la ventana de oportunidad para la emergencia de un mayor
número de especies ya que induce mejoras en la estabilidad de sustrato, la retención hídrica y
la captación de agua por parte de las plántulas. Este aumento del número de especies se
traduce en una mayor riqueza a escala de comunidad en los dos años siguientes a la
aplicación del tratamiento.
12. El extendido de tierra vegetal favorece la supervivencia de plántulas y el establecimiento de
individuos adultos, que dependen de una mayor disponibilidad de recursos. Este efecto se
traduce en comunidades con mayor cobertura vegetal en los dos años siguientes a la
aplicación de este tratamiento.
13. La escarificación de la superficie del talud en combinación con la extensión de tierra vegetal
favorece la retención de esta en las partes altas del desmonte y permite el reclutamiento de un
mayor número de especies en esta zona del talud dos años después de la aplicación de los
tratamientos.
14. Las actividades de manejo aplicadas en taludes de carretera deben ir orientadas a aumentar la
capacidad de carga durante los estadios tempranos tras la construcción de la infraestructura y
asegurar la estabilidad de las condiciones edáficas en estadios posteriores de cara a favorecer
los procesos de sucesión secundaria en estos ambientes. En este sentido y en base a los
resultados obtenidos en esta tesis, se recomienda la aplicación de tierra vegetal en desmontes
de carretera para favorecer los procesos de colonización primaria y se desaconsejan las
técnicas convencionales de manejo que impliquen la modificación o desestructuración de los
suelos presentes en terraplenes de carretera.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
228
229
CONCLUSIONS
230
Conclusions
231
From the four experimental chapters included in this Doctoral Thesis, the following
conclusions can be drawn:
1. The transition observed in microarthropod community composition from
pioneer/generalist components to those associated with more stable soil conditions is
correlated to changes in organic carbon content, clay content, and soil humidity.
2. This successional change in microarthropod community composition is illustrated by
higher abundances of Oribatid mites (Acari) and Symphypleona (Collembola), both
implicated in organic matter turnover and soil formation. Due to the dependence of these
organisms on stable soil conditions, their presence is used as an indicator of soil quality.
3. Regarding the QBS (Biological Soil Quality) index, soils from road embankments are
fully functional and, in some cases, comparable to those found in other soils under natural
land cover, such as Mediterranean woodlands and shrublands.
4. Soil bacterial communities from road embankments are low in species diversity such as
those observed in other anthrosols, and they are dominated by the taxonomic groups such
as Actinobacteria, Acidobacteria, and and Planctomycetes. These groups are involved in
soil organic matter dynamics and are indicative of mature to advanced successional
stages.
5. Soil bacterial communities from road embankments include representatives of
Bacteroidetes, Firmicutes, Gemmatimonadates, and Cyanobacteria. The relatively low
abundance of these groups indicates secondary succession processes in these anthrosols.
6. Changes in soil bacteria community composition observed at the local scale were mainly
driven by changes in pH and soil texture, namely sand and clay content.
Restauración ecológica de taludes de carretera en ambiente mediterráneo
232
7. Conventional roadside management techniques trigger changes in soil bacteria
community structure. Specifically, biomass addition increases diversity while at the same
time that fertilization increases community equitability or, in other words, this treatment
homogenizes bacterial communities. Notably, fertilization increases the relative
abundance of Gemmatimonadetes, which is a group that is commonly associated with
low nutrient availability.
8. Mowing increases the C:N ratio as well as loam content and accelerated litter
degradation. These effects may be related to changes induced by mowing on plant
community composition or the total lack of vegetation on some slope patches, both of
which favors erosive processes that carry away finer particles along with surface runoff
water. This lack of vegetation also increases sunlight arriving to the soil surface and the
subsequent acceleration in litter decomposition (photodegradation), which is a common
process processes, typical in Mediterranean environments.
9. Topsoil spreading in roadcuts reduces the effect of abiotic filters constraining plant
community assembly in these environments. In particular, this treatment increases
nitrogen, carbon, silt, and sand content, and decreases soil pH and electrical conductivity.
10. Responses in life-history stages of plant communities to the varying management
treatments intended to manipulate environmental filters, allow us to detect two processes
acting as thresholds for plant community assembly, namely seedling emergence and
survival. Topsoil spreading helps to overcome these thresholds and boost the plant
community assembly processes.
11. Topsoil spreading also increases the opportunity for emergence of higher numbers of
plant species through the improvement of soil stability, soil water retention and,
Conclusions
233
consequently, improved water uptake by seedlings. The increase in the number of species
at the seedling stage translates into richer plant communities during the first two years
following treatment application.
12. Topsoil spreading favors seedling survival and the establishment of adult plants, which
usually depends on higher nutrient availability. This effect translates into communities
with higher plant cover during the first two years following treatment application.
13. Shallow tillage combined with topsoil spreading facilitates the retention of topsoil in the
upper slope zone, which in turn increases the recruitment of a higher number of species in
the first two years after the application of treatments.
14. Roadside management should aim to improve soil conditions during the early stages of
roadside ecosystem development, and to ensure soil stability in subsequent years to
facilitate secondary succession and increased functionality. Therefore, we recommend the
application of topsoil spreading to trigger plant colonization and the assembly of richer
plant communities seems a valuable intervention. Concurrently, management techniques
that alter or modify soil conditions in roadside embankments should be avoided.
234