Click here to load reader

Cults, religion, and brainwashing lecture 2014

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

My slides

Citation preview

2. OverviewReligionWhat is religion?How is religiousness perceived?Is being religious good or bad for you?CultsWhat is a cult?Who joins cults?How are people brainwashed?How do people feel after leaving a cult?Social psychology and cultsUnderlined references are in BlackboardThese are questions to think about for your blog 3. Religion and well-beingA search for significance in ways related to thesacredPargament, 2002 (pg. 169)Literature offers mixed picture of religionAltermeyer & Hunsberger (1992): fundamentalismwas associated with more right-wing politicalviewsSethi & Seligman (1993): adherents have highlevels of well-being an optimism 4. How might religion benefit health?http://padlet.com/psychology_expe/religionhealth 5. Religion and healthGeorge, Ellison, & Larson (2002): why doesreligion benefit health?Health practices: religion often prohibits theimbibing of harmful substances e.g. alcohol, orthe performance of detrimental actions e.g.promiscuity.Social support: sense of community andrelationship with others who share world-viewenhances well-being and coping 6. Psychosocial resources: enhancement of self-esteem,self-efficacy which have health benefitsSense of coherence/meaning:Antonovsky (1980) beliefs that make worldmeaningful, predictable, and manageable makestressful events easier to bearReduces stress-related health problems etc. 7. Why might religion beproblematic?http://padlet.com/psychology_expe/religionproblem 8. Detrimental aspects of religionExline (2002): Religious feeling may lead toseveral stumbling blocksReligious arguments: aligning oneself explicitlywith a religious movements can lead toarguments!Negative relationships with non-believers:individuals outside of the religious group may findpractices distasteful 9. Disappointment or anger towards deity: If thingsgo wrong, we may feel betrayed and disappointedwith GodStruggling with logical or ethical issues: Findingflaws with religious beliefs, or finding theirpractices inappropriate is disquietingConfrontation with ones own imperfections:Failing at being virtuous can damage self-esteemand cause depression 10. Summary so farReligion has been show to have some benefits onhealth and well-beingHowever, religion does not ALWAYS make peoplefeel better! 11. What is a cult?http://padlet.com/psychology_expe/religioncultUse online resources if you like, but NOTWIKIPEDIA 12. What is a cult?Definition: any religion held together more bydevotion to a living charismatic leader whoactively participates in the group-decision makingthan by adherence to a body of doctrine orprescribed set of rituals (Zablocki & Robbins,2001 p. 5)I.e. A group that does what a leader tells them to domore than following a set of beliefs. 13. Definition issuesWoody (2009): The word cult has negativeconnotations and should be used with cautionOlson (2006): substituting cult for new religiousmovement decreased acceptance and positivefeelingWord is laden with meaning, and usually pejorativeMembers of cults most likely do not refer to them assuch! 14. Who joins a cult?http://padlet.com/psychology_expe/religionjoin 15. Who joins a cult?Curtis & Curtis (1993):Weak spirit and emotional vulnerabilityTendency to dissociative statesPoor family relations and social support networksInadequate means of dealing with hard knocksHistory of child abuse or neglectExposure to eccentric family patternsDrug problemsInability to manage stressPoor socioeconomic conditionsAll increase susceptibility to joining a cult 16. How would you recruit orbrainwash people to be in YOURcult?http://padlet.com/psychology_expe/recruit-for-cult 17. Cult brainwashing techniquesWalsh (2001):Stifling of communication between a member andthe outside worldSeparation of friends and familyRelinquishing of jobDictating how members should think, act, and feelKeeping members tired assists with thisDemand for purity and conformity with group normsNB This is purity for the group, not for society as a whole! 18. Public acknowledgement of bad former lifeSymbolically shows relinquishing of previousidentityIncreases social pressurePurveying the idea there are deeper truths thatcan only be discovered through unquestioningstudyCult-specific language to increase social identityand division with non-membersEncouragement of new identity as part of thegroup organism, rather than individualDerogation of non-believers 19. Results of being in a cultWalsh, Russell, & Wells (1995) high levels of:Neuroticism(tendency to experience negative emotional states: e.g. guilt,anxiety, depression etc)Sociotropy(high dependence and need to please others)Autonomy(preference for independent functioning)In ex-cult members 20. What can social psychology tell usabout cults?http://padlet.com/psychology_expe/social-psych-cults 21. Social psychology and cultsHow does social psychology account forattraction to, and behaviour within, cults?Social identity theorySocial influenceDeindividuation 22. Social identity theoryTajfel, 1978Individual possess social identities part of theirself-concept that derives from group membershipA social identity describes how one should think,feel, and act as a good group member 23. Leader?Rebel?Brain?Pet?Interesting situations arisefrom role conflicts orconfusions 24. Social identity theoryTajfel, 1978Individual possess social identities part of theirself-concept that derives from group membershipA social identity describes how one should think,feel, and act as a good group memberIndividuals are motivated to maintain positive socialidentities this increases self-esteem and well-beingCategorisation of in-group and out-group assistswith thisIf an individual lacks other meaningful identities,a cult may provide one 25. Social influenceTwo types of social influence (Deutsch & Gerard,1955)Informational social influence using others as aguide when we are uncertain or in an ambiguoussituation 26. 1 2 3 27. 1 2 3 28. Social influenceTwo types of social influence (Deutsch & Gerard, 1955)Informational social influence using others as aguide when we are uncertain or in an ambiguoussituationIf we feel like we are unsure what to do, or what isappropriate, we may conform to the wishes of othersmoreWhen feeling vulnerable or aimless, individuals maywelcome the structure and normalcy of a cultNormative social influence doing things so otherslike you!Particularly powerful if friends also join a cult. Hard toresist peer pressure to also join 29. DeindividuationAnonymity within a large group leads to loss ofidentity (Propst, 1979; Zimbardo, 1970)May lead to deviant behaviour 30. DeindividuationAnonymity within a large group leads to loss ofidentity (Propst, 1979; Zimbardo, 1970)May lead to deviant behaviourPostmes & Spears (1998) Deindividuation may leadto group-norm conformityIn a cult, the presence of others acting and looking thesame increases conformity and reduces incidents ofquestioning and rebellion. 31. SummaryCults are groups which venerate a living leaderPersonality and socio-economic traits can influencesusceptibility to cult influenceCults have a variety of techniques available to gainnew recruitsMembership in a cult can have far-reachingconsequences, even after leavingSocial psychological research can tell us a lot aboutwhy people join cults and why cults are so influential 32. References not in WebCTAntonovsky, A. (1980). Health, stress, and coping. SanFrancisco: Jossey-BassCurtis, J. M., & Curtis, M. J. (1993). Factors related tosusceptibility and recruitment by cults. PsychologicalReports, 73, 451-460.Postmes, T., Spears, R., & Lea, M. (1998). Breaching orbuilding social boundaries? Side-effects of computer-mediatedcommunication. Communication Research, 25,689 - 716Tajfel, H. (1978). Differentiation between social groups:Studies in the social psychology of intergroup relations.London: Academic Press.Zablocki, B. & Robbins T. (2001). Misunderstanding cults:Searching for objectivity in a controversial field. Toronto:University of Toronto PressZimbardo, P. G. (1970). The human choice: Individuation,reason, and order versus deindividuation, impulse, andchaos. In W. J. Arnold and D. Levine (eds). Nebraskasymposium on motivation 1969 (pp. 237 307). Lincoln 33. REMINDERNext session is ONLINE ONLYFind the resources for it in BlackboardEarworms and other creepy crawlies(Alex Lamont)