48
Un-publication: Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve) Colin Harrison, School of Education / Learning Sciences Research Institute, University of Nottingham

Un-publication: Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Un-publication: Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)Colin Harrison, School of Education / Learning Sciences Research Institute, University of Nottingham

Page 2: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

Page 3: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

Page 4: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

Page 5: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

Page 6: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

Page 7: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

Page 8: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

Page 9: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 10: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 11: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!DEStech publishes

23 journals, so one is

bound to be in

education!

Page 12: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!DEStech publishes

23 journals, so one is

bound to be in

education!

Page 13: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!DEStech publishes

23 journals, so one is

bound to be in

education!

Page 14: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 15: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 16: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 17: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 18: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 19: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 20: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 21: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 22: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 23: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 24: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 25: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 26: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 27: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 28: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Are our students now finding (and citing as authoritative) otherwise unpublishable research from rogue ‘peer-reviewed’ journals?

Page 29: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Are our students now finding (and citing as authoritative) otherwise unpublishable research from rogue ‘peer-reviewed’ journals?

Page 30: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Are our students now finding (and citing as authoritative) otherwise unpublishable research from rogue ‘peer-reviewed’ journals?

Page 31: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Are our students now finding (and citing as authoritative) otherwise unpublishable research from rogue ‘peer-reviewed’ journals?

Page 32: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 33: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 34: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 35: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

N=790 publishers

N=658 other stand-alone journals

Page 36: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Another opportunity!

scrip.org

Page 37: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Another opportunity!- especially for

Chinese authors….

Page 38: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 39: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 40: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

STOP PRESS!!

MORE good news!

Page 41: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 42: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 43: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

(plus another 17….)

Page 44: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 45: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 46: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 47: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Un-publication: the dark side of open-access publication (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)Colin Harrison, University of Nottingham/LSRI

Points to consider: -Are online ‘predatory publishers’ any more predatory than regular publishers?-Are ‘Scholarly’ Open-Access Publications (SOAPs) valuable?

- For the desperate- yes- And for crackpots- yes- For the naïve – potentially less reliable than Wikipedia- SOAPs do greatly extend the possibilities for publishing

online for academics in non-OECD nations-Take-home message: CAVEAT LECTOR

Page 48: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Un-publication: the dark side of open-access publication (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)Colin Harrison, University of Nottingham/LSRI