Upload
steve-bacher
View
954
Download
3
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Should community colleges use search engine marketing (SEM) channels such as Google AdWords? Is it cost effective? This presentation begins with a brief explanation of SEM, using examples from Bucks County Community College's Paragon Award-winning SEM campaign to promote medical occupational programs, both credit and non-credit. It explains the steps the Director of e-Marketing went through in the creation of the campaign, and explores which elements can be outsourced. It also explores items to consider when selecting a vendor. Finally it presents ROI data from the pilot campaign referenced above. This was presented at the NCMPR national conference in Albuquerque, NM on 3/16/10.
Citation preview
Steve BacherDirector, e-MarketingBucks County Community [email protected] (215) 504-8543 NCMPR National Conference, March 16, 2010www.slideshare.net/SteveBacher
1
Overview1. What is SEM?
2. Why use SEM?
3. Steps to Create an SEM Campaign
4. Case Study:
Bucks County Community College’s 1st SEM Campaign
2
What is SEM?
Users search for Keywords on Search Engines such as Google
3
Search for Bucks County Community College and www.bucks.edu comes out on top.
4
Search for Dental Assistant training programs and there are 3,900,000 web pages.
Bucks isn’t on top.
5
How do we help people interested in Dental Assistant training programs find ours?
One answer is Search Engine Marketing (SEM).
Google and other Search Engines sell Sponsored Links, which appear at the top of the Search Results List, above
the normal (or “organic”) search results.
6
Here is an example of sponsored links above organic search results.
7
Sponsored Links are shown to users who search for related keywords and phrases…
Keywords and phrases in this example include:
dental assistant dental assistant career
dental assistant certificate dental assistant college
dental assistant jobs dental assistant programs dental assistant resume dental assistant school dental assistant schools dental assistant training
dental college dental hygiene colleges 8
Sponsored links are only shown to users in targeted zip codes who search for related keywords.
In the Bucks pilot SEM campaign, sponsored links were purchased for zip codes that had
at least five enrolled students last semester.
There are 75 such zip codes, including some in Mercer County, NJ & Philadelphia.
9
What happens when a potential student clicks on a sponsored link?
10
Sponsored links connect to special website pages called Landing Pages.
11
12
13
SEM combines the latest technology with old fashioned customer service:
When a potential student submits an online form from the landing page, a designated person from the program receives an email instantly.
14
15
She responds – usually immediately -- in no more than two business days.
The sooner the call, the more likely the enrollment, according to some studies.
Program staff follow up in a couple of weeks with those who filled out the form but haven’t yet enrolled.
16
Why use SEM?
* Measurable results
* Highly targeted
* Growing marketing channel
17
Why use SEM?
* Measurable results
* Highly targeted
* Growing marketing channel
18
What is measurable?
* Impressions* Click-throughs* Conversions (forms)* Enrollments* Revenue generated
19
Impressions
20
Click-throughs
21
Conversions
22
Enrollments & Revenue
Match conversion forms with new student database
Survey new students in targeted classes
23
Why use SEM?
* Measurable results
* Highly targeted
* Growing marketing channel
24
Why use SEM?
* Measurable results
* Highly targeted
* Growing marketing channel
25
Targeting SEM brings specific programs to the attention of people who are searching for the programs and don’t know that they are offered by your college.
26
Targeting Geographic: zip codes, city, county or state
Keyword/phrase
27
Why use SEM?
* Measurable results
* Highly targeted
* Growing marketing channel
28
Search is growing…
The U.S. core search market grew 16 percent overall in 2009, driven by a 6-percent gain in unique searchers and a 10-percent gain in searches per searcher.
—comScore 2009 Digital Year in Review
29
SEM is growing
In 2006, North American advertisers spent $9.4 billion on search engine marketing, a 62% increase over the prior year and a 750% increase over the 2002 year.
As of 2006, SEM was growing much faster than traditional advertising and even other channels of online marketing.[2]
--Wikipedia
And growing…
Year-to-date Internet advertising revenues through June 2008 totaled $11.5 billionup 15.2 percent from the $10 billion reported for the same six-month period in 2007. Search revenue accounted for 44 percent of 2008 second-quarter [internet advertising] revenues, up from the 40 percent reported in 2007.
—David Silverman, Partner, PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, 10/08Source: Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) www.iab.net
“Due to the unique efficiency and effectiveness of targeted and measurable campaigns,
internet advertising has shown strong growth in the first six months of 2008, compared to the same time period last year.
This growth has come in spite of an environment that has put significant pressure on the advertising industry in general.”
—David Silverman, Partner, PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, 10/08
Source: Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) www.iab.net
“While the overall advertising market has continued to be impacted by current economic conditions, marketers are allocating more of their dollars to digital media for its accountability and because consumers are spending more of their leisure time online.”
—David Silverman, Partner, PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, 10/09
Source: Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) www.iab.net
In the first half of 2009, compared with the same period in 2008:
Search advertising revenue went upDigital video advertising revenue went upAll other sectors of internet advertising went down
Search was 47% of all internet advertising revenueDigital video was 4% of all internet advertising revenue
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, 10/09Source: Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) www.iab.net
Internet Ad Revenues: 1st Half Year’09 vs. ‘08 ($ millions)
Source: Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB)/ PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, 10/09
Internet Ad Revenues 1st Half of ’09 ($ millions)
Source: Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB)/ PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, 10/09
Why focus on Google search?
37
What to Advertise with SEM
* new programs
* existing programs for which your college has many competitors
* online programs available to students nationwide
38
Steps to Create Your SEM Campaign
Choose the program to advertiseAsk:• Which program offers the best
potential return on investment – where are your empty seats?
• Can prospects find it easily without SEM?
39
Steps to Create Your SEM Campaign
Choose the program to advertiseAsk:• Which program offers you the most
reliable partner to:• Develop landing page(s)• Gather enrollment data• Survey students in class
40
Choose which services to purchase
vs.
in-house staff creation/implementation
Steps to Create Your SEM Campaign
41
Bucks SEM Pilot Program
Agency:Writes ad copy for sponsored links
Develops keyword and phrase lists
Manages sponsored link placement and daily word bidding
42
Bucks SEM Pilot Program
Bucks Marketing & IT Staff develop landing pages:
Work with program area to write copy
Design graphic look
Develop computer programming infrastructure
43
Bucks Marketing & IT Staff develop landing pages:
Work with program area to write copy
Design graphic look
44
45
Setting Up Your SEM Campaign
Choose an SEM Consultant/Agency
Ask:• Set-up fees vs. rates• Experience with higher education
clients• Experience with your program area
46
Setting Up Your SEM Campaign
Choose an SEM Consultant/Agency
Ask:
• Frequency of reports• College review of keywords • College review of ad copy• Campaign monitoring – frequency of
agency tweaking keyword groups and ad copy choices
47
Steps to Create Your SEM Campaign
Create landing page content:
* copy
* photos
* video
* data collection form 48
Steps to Create Your SEM Campaign
Create landing pages (IT)
Communicate expectations for department prospect follow-up
Track impressions and conversions
Calculate Return on Investment49
Bucks SEM Pilot Program
Goal:To test the effectiveness of SEM to increase income and fill
empty seats with a high return on investment.
Funding:$9,000 grant from the Bucks County Community College
Foundation.
Targeted Programs:Medical Occupational Programsin Business Studies and Continuing Education.
50
Bucks SEM Pilot Program: Dental Assistant Program, and:
51
Bucks SEM Pilot Program
Timeline:Two months: 12/24/08 – 2/24/09.
Cost:$4,500/month: $3,600 ad spend, $900 agency fee.
52
Pay Per Click -- Not Per Impression
Impressions (number of search results that showed a Bucks ad)
107,994
Clicks (number of times a Bucks ad was clicked on) 1,835
Conversions(number of landing page forms submitted) 129
Bucks SEM Campaign 12/24/08 – 3/3/0953
Bucks SEM Pilot Program
54
Bucks SEM Pilot Program
55
Bucks SEM Pilot Program
56
Enrollment Results
Conversions(number of landing page forms submitted) 129
New Student Enrollments from conversions 7
Bucks SEM Campaign 12/24/08 – 3/3/09
57
First Day of Class Survey:
Please check all that apply: I didn’t use Google to search for a class like this.I used Google but didn’t find Bucks.
If you remember which words you were searching for, please let us know: __________
I used Google, found Bucks, but didn’t click on the link.I used Google, clicked on the sponsored link at the top of the
page, viewed the page it linked me to, but didn’t fill out the form to request more information.
I used Google, clicked on the sponsored link at the top of the page, viewed the page it linked me to and filled out the form.
I used another search engine to search for a class like this (which one? ____________________)
58
First Day of Class Survey:
I used Google, clicked on the sponsored link at the top of the page, viewed the page it linked me to, but didn’t fill out the form to request more information.
59
First Day of Class Survey:
60
61
62
Enrollment Results: Spring ‘09 (1st Semester)
Conversions(number of landing page forms submitted) 129
New Student Enrollments from conversions 7
New Student Enrollments 11from students who viewed landing page and enrolled directly without submitting landing page form
Total SEM New Student Enrollments 18
Bucks SEM Campaign 12/24/08 – 3/3/0963
Bucks SEM Pilot Program: Results
12/24 – 1/21 Registration for Spring Credit Courses:
Phlebotomy Certificate Program: 2 students at 12 credits each Tuition & Fees income =
$3,050
Required for completion: Additional 4 credit externship
Additional income anticipated = $ 936
1 student at 3 credits income = $ 350
Required for completion: Additional 13 credits Additional income anticipated = $1,521
64
Bucks SEM Pilot Program: Results
12/24 – 3/3 Registration for Continuing Education Courses:
Dental Assisting Program7 @ $1,399
Pharmacy Technician Certificate Program3 @ $1,199
EKG Technician Certification2 @ 1,199
Nurse Aid Training 1 @ $659
Medical Billing & Coding Course2 @ $1,699
Total Income Generated to date: $19,845 65
Bucks SEM Pilot Program: Results
Income Summary Spring ‘09:
Continuing Education: $19,845
Credit Tuition & Tech. Fees: $ 3,159
Total: $23,004
Additional Tuition & Tech Fees Anticipated: $ 2,457
Conservative Anticipated Total Income: $25,461 66
Bucks SEM Pilot Program: Results
Possible Other Income:
Of the other 100+ conversions, how many will enroll in fall ‘09?
67
Enrollment Results: Fall ‘09 (2nd Semester)
One prospect who completed the form went on to enroll in Fall ‘09.
However, based on the in-class survey, an additional 17 new students who viewed the pilot campaign enrolled in fall ’09.
68
Return on Investment
Investment: $9,000
Income: $23,600 as of 3/09ROI = 164%
Income = $47,400 as of 10/09ROI = 427%
Total New Students = 3669
Enrollment Results: Spring ‘10 (3rd Semester)
One prospect who completed the form in February ’09 enrolled in Spring ‘10.
Based on the in-class survey, an additional 6 new students who viewed the pilot campaign enrolled in Spring ’10.
New students to date = 43
(Continuing Education surveys pending). 70
Return on Investment: Summer ‘09 Campaigns
New Applied Photography Credit Certificate
Investment: $5,000Fall ‘09 Income = $4,500New Students = 5
Total Income Fall ‘09 + Spring ‘10 = $6,800Spring ‘10 New Students = 1Returning Students = 3
ROI = 36%71
Return on Investment: Summer ‘09 Campaigns
IT Academy Programs
Investment: $5,000Fall ’09 Income = $5,655New Students = 3
Total Income Fall ‘09 + Spring ‘10 = $7,655New Students = 1
ROI = 53%72
Return on Investment: Summer ‘09 Campaigns
Historic Preservation Online Programs (national campaign)
Investment: $5,000Fall ’09 Income = $2,835New Students = 3
Total Income Fall ‘09 + Spring ‘10 = $5,654New Students = 1Returning Students = 1
ROI = 13%73
Bucks SEM Pilot Program: Results
Lessons Learned:
Put in writing the conditions for program area participation, such as:
Dissemination and collection of short survey in classes which might have people enrolled as a result of the campaign. Ideally for at least 3 semesters.
74
Bucks SEM Pilot Program:
Is there a commitment to follow-up timetable , mode and reporting. Will the staff person call same day?Who will verify enrollments?Is there a commitment to an in-class survey?
75
SEM Checklist:
Suitable program to promoteWilling academic/continuing education partner programIn-house or consultants to manage Google AdwordsIn-house IT or consultants to support landing pages and formsIn-house creative or consultants to create landing pages (photos, text, video)
76
Questions?
Steve BacherDirector, e-MarketingBucks County Community College
[email protected] (215) 504-8543
www.slideshare.net/SteveBacher 77
Why use facebook ads?
Social Networking Remains One of the Web’s Top Activities in 2009
Social networking continued to gain momentum in 2009 with nearly 4 out of 5 Internet users visiting a social networking site in December 2009. The activity now accounts for 11 percent of all time spent online in the U.S., making it one of the most engaging activities across the Web.
—comScore 2009 Digital Year in Review
78
Why use facebook ads?
Facebook surged to the #1 position among social networks for the first time in May and continued its strong growth trajectory throughout the year, finishing with 112 million visitors in December 2009, up 105 percent during the year.
—comScore 2009 Digital Year in Review
79
Do it Yourself? Facebook vs. Google
$50 each mini-campaigns, 2/9 – 3/9/10 promoting Historical Preservation nationally (no local targetting)
Facebook: Targeting users over 18 who like Historic PreservationResults: 171 click-throughs,
320,00 impressions
No enrollment data yet.
80
Do it Yourself? Facebook vs. Google
$50 each mini-campaigns, 2/9 – 3/9/10 promoting Historical Preservation nationally (no local targetting)
Google Adwords: Targeting searchers for one of 60 different keyword phrases generated by Google for me.Results: 60 click-throughs,
22,000 impressions
No enrollment data yet.
81
Steve BacherDirector, e-MarketingBucks County Community College
[email protected] (215) 504-8543
www.slideshare.net/SteveBacher
82