161
ɮɨɧɞ ɩɨɞɞɟɪɠɤɢ ɢɧɬɟɪɧɟɬ

User identification analysis

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: User identification analysis

ɮɨɧɞ ɩɨɞɞɟɪɠɤɢɢɧɬɟɪɧɟɬ

Page 2: User identification analysis

ƶǘǛǔnjNJƲǑǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�mƹǚǘǛǙǏǔǜ}

2015

ƪƷƪƵƲƱ�ƺƪƱƵƲǁƷDžƿ�ƪƻƹƯƴƼƸƬ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�Ƭ�ƲƷƼƯƺƷƯƼƯ�

ƲbƺƯƴƸƶƯƷƮƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸbƺƯƭƽƵƲƺƸƬƪƷƲLj

Page 3: User identification analysis

ƪǗNJǕǒǑ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�NJǛǙǏǔǜǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ�ǒ�ǚǏ-ǔǘǖǏǗǎNJǠǒǒ� Ǚǘ� ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ� �� Ʋ�ɋƵǏnjǘnjNJ�� ƭ�ɋǂǝǔǕǒǗ�� ƴ�ɋƴNJǑNJ-ǚǦǩǗ�ǒ�ǎǚ��ȃ�ƶ���ƲǑǎ�njǘ�mƹǚǘǛǙǏǔǜ}��������ȃ�����Ǜ�

ƲǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǘ�NJǗNJǕǒǜǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǚNJNjǘǜNJ�njǥǙǘǕǗǏǗNJ�ǍǚǝǙǙǘǓbǧǔǛǙǏǚǜǘnj�ƲǗǛǜǒǜǝǜNJ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�

ǙǚǒbǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǘǓ�ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔǏ�mƾǘǗǎNJ�ǛǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǨ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ȊƾǘǗǎ�ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜȋ}

ƪnjǜǘǚǥ��Ʋ�ɋƵǏnjǘnjNJ��ƭ�ɋǂǝǔǕǒǗ��ƴ�ɋƴNJǑNJǚǦǩǗ��

Ʈ�ɋƬǒǗǗǒǔ��ƶ�ɋƴNJǛǏǗǘnjNJ�

Ζ6%1������������������

Ζ6%1������������������

ƽƮƴƫƫƴ

�������������������ƪ��

ƽƮƴƫƫƴ

�������������������

ƪ��

ƹǝNjǕǒǔǝǏǜǛǩ�Ǚǘǎ�ǕǒǠǏǗǑǒǏǓ�&UHDWLYH�&RPPRQV�$WWULEXWLRQ�6KDUH$OLNH�����8QSRUWHG�/LFHQVH�

Page 4: User identification analysis

ƸƭƵƪƬƵƯƷƲƯ

ƬƬƯƮƯƷƲƯ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� �7

ƭƵƪƬƪ�����ƷǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǜǏǘǚǏǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�NJǛǙǏǔǜǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ��

ƭƵƪƬƪ�����ƸǙǥǜ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�njbǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗNJǟbǖǒǚNJ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ���

LJǛǜǘǗǒǩ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ���ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƹǚNJnjǘnjǥǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjǥ�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǒbǖǏǚǥ�����������������������������������������������LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒbǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ��ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ���njbƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

ƻǂƪ�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ���ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�ǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�������������������������������������������������ƪǖǏǚǒǔNJǗǛǔNJǩ�ǛǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǩ�mƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǛǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�njbǔǒNjǏǚǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǛǜnjǏ}��167Ζ&������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǒbǖǏǚǥ�����������������������������������������������ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ����������������������������������������������������������LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒbǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ��ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ���njbƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǩ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ���ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƷǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjNJǩ�NjNJǑNJ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǒbǖǏǚǥ�����������������������������������������������ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒbǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ��ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ���njbƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ���ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƹǚNJnjǘnjǥǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjǥ�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƷǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjNJǩ�NjNJǑNJ�ǒbǖǏǚǥ���������������������������������������������������������������������������ƸǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǖǏǚǥ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǒbǖǏǚǥ�����������������������������������������������LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒbǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ��ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ���njbƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

Page 5: User identification analysis

ƴǒǜNJǓ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ���ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƹǚNJnjǘnjǥǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjǥ�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƷǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjNJǩ�NjNJǑNJ�ǒbǖǏǚǥ���������������������������������������������������������������������������ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǒbǖǏǚǥ�����������������������������������������������LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǔǘ�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩ������������������������������������������������������������������������ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒbǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ��ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ���njbƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǩ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ���ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƹǚNJnjǘnjǥǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjǥ�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƷǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjNJǩ�NjNJǑNJ�ǒbǖǏǚǥ���������������������������������������������������������������������������ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǒbǖǏǚǥ�����������������������������������������������LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒbǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ��ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ���njbƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

LjǐǗNJǩ�ƴǘǚǏǩ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ���ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƹǚNJnjǘnjǥǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjǥ�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǒbǖǏǚǥ�����������������������������������������������LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒbǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ��ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ���njbƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔNJǩ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǩ����������������������������������������������������������������������������� ���ƪǗNJǕǒǑ�ǜǏǔǝǣǏǍǘ�ǛǘǛǜǘǩǗǒǩ�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�njbƺƾ�������������������������������ƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ�njbǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ��������������������������������������������������������ƯǎǒǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒbNJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƯƻƲƪ��������������������������������ƹǘǚǜNJǕ�ǍǘǚǘǎǛǔǒǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ƶǘǛǔnjǥ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������

ƻǚNJnjǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǓ�NJǗNJǕǒǑ�ǙǘbǛǜǚNJǗNJǖ����������������������������������������������������� ����

ƭƵƪƬƪ�����ƼǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����

ƹǘǗǩǜǒǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�������������������������������������� ����

ƻǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ���������������� ����ƻǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǘnj�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��������������������������������������������������������������������� ����ƻǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǛǏǜǡNJǜǔǒ�ǍǕNJǑNJ�������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����ƻǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǚNJǎǝǐǗǘǓ�ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔǒ�ǍǕNJǑNJ���������������������������������������������������������� ����ƺNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ�ǍǏǘǖǏǜǚǒǒ�ǚǝǔǒ���������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����ƺNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ�ǡǏǚǜ�ǕǒǠNJ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����ƼǏǚǖǘǍǚNJǞǒǩ�ǕǒǠNJ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ ����

ƮǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ������������ ����ƺNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ�ǍǘǕǘǛNJ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����

4 ƸƭƵƪƬƵƯƷƲƯ

Page 6: User identification analysis

ƪǗNJǕǒǑ�ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǡǏǚǔNJ����������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����ƬǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����

ƴǘǖNjǒǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ��NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����

ƱNJǣǒǜNJ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��������������������������������������������������������� ����ƼǚNJǗǛǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǡǏǚǜ��������������������������������������������������������������� ����ƫǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����

ƴǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǥǏ�ǒǗǐǏǗǏǚǗǥǏ�ǒbǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǏ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǥ��ǗNJbNjNJǑǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ�������������������������������������������������� ����ƶǝǕǦǜǒNjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǘǔ�ǙNJǕǦǠNJ�ǕǒǠǘ�ǚNJǎǝǐǗNJǩ�ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔNJ�ǙNJǚǘǕǦ��ǘǜb%LR(QDEOH��7HFKQRORJLHV��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����

ƶǝǕǦǜǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��0%$6��������������������������� ����ƮǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�������������������������� ����ƷǏǗNJnjǩǑǡǒnjNJǩ�ǙǘnjǏǎǏǗǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǒbǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǖǝǕǦǜǒǖǘǎNJǕǦǗǘǓ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��$&7Ζ%Ζ2���������������������������������������������������� ����

ƽǕǝǡǢǏǗǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǎǕǩbǎnjǝǟǔǘǕǏǛǗǥǟ�ǜǚNJǗǛǙǘǚǜǗǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj������������������������������������������������������� ����

ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǗNJbǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǛǘǡǏǜNJǗǒǩ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔ�ǕǒǠNJ�ǒbǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔNJ�ǕNJǎǘǗǒ�������������� ����

ƹǚǘǍǚNJǖǖNJ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�mƪǔǜǒnjǗǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}�'$53$����������� ����

Ƭǥnjǘǎǥ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ ����

ƭƵƪƬƪ�����ƺǏǔǘǖǏǗǎNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǎǕǩbƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ���������������������������� ����

ƮǕǩbǛǞǏǚǥ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��������������������������������������������������������������� ����

ƮǕǩbǝǛǕǝǍ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒbƲƼ������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����

ƮǕǩbǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ������������������������������������������������������������������� ����

ƭƵƪƬƪ�����ƼǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�njbǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǒ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘnj�ǒbǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ�ǟǚNJǗǒǜǦ�ǒbǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǜǦ��ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ��ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǝǨ�ǎǕǩbǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ������������������������������������������������������������������ ����

ƼǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƻǂƪ�ǘbǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǒ��ǒbǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǒ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ����������������������������������������������������������� ����

ƭƵƪƬƪ�����ƹǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǏ�ǛǘǍǕNJǢǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǟ��ǒbǚǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǒǟ�Ζ7�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ������������������������������������������������������������ ����

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǘnj�ǜǏǕǏǔǘǖ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ�njbƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ ����

5

Page 7: User identification analysis

ƫƲƫƵƲƸƭƺƪƾƲlj������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� �144

ƷǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǥǏ�NJǔǜǥ����������������������������������������������������������������� ����

ƹƺƲƵƸưƯƷƲlj����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� �148

ƹǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ����ƼǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǥ�ǝǙǚǘǣǏǗǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�ǙǕNJǜǏǐNJ�ǒbǒǗǥǟ��ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗǥǟ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜǘnj���������������������������������������������������������������������� ����ƹǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǛǘǜǘnjǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ��������� ����ƹǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ��ǚNJǗǏǏ�njǥǎNJǗǗǘǓ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǝ�ǒǗǘǓ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǘǓ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǏǓ������������������������������������� ����

ƹǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ��ǔbǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ��ƯǎǒǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒbNJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƯƻƲƪ���ƭƲƻ�ƭƶƹ������������������������������������������������������������������ ����

ƹǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǥ�ǝǙǚǘǣǏǗǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�njbǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǒ�ǔbǠǏǕǩǖ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǩ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ ����

ƹǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ����ƬǒǎǏǘǗNJNjǕǨǎǏǗǒǏ�ǗNJbnjǥNjǘǚNJǟ�ƹǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ��ƺǘǛǛǒǒ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����ƹǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǚǘǛǖǘǜǚNJ�ǙǚǩǖǘǓ�ǜǚNJǗǛǕǩǠǒǒ�ǛbnjǥNjǘǚǘnj�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����

ƹǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ����ƹǘǕǒǜǒǔǒ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗǒǩ�ǔǘǚǙǘǚNJǜǒnjǗǥǟ�NJǎǚǏǛǘnj�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�Ζ7�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����*RRJOH������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ ����0LFURVRIW������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����<DQGH[����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����&LVFR��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����ƬƴǘǗǜNJǔǜǏ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����0DLO�UX������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ ����)DFHERRN������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ����

6

Page 8: User identification analysis

ƬƬƯƮƯƷƲƯ

ƬƸƹƺƸƻ� Ƹƫ� ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ� ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ� ǛǏǜǒ� ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�� njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠǏnj�ǚǏǛǝǚǛǘnj� nj� ǛǏǜǒ� ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ� nj� ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǏ� njǚǏǖǩ� ǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǛǩ� njǛǪ� NjǘǕǏǏ�NJǔǜǝNJǕǦǗǥǖ�� Ƭ� ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ� ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ� ǑNJ� ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǒǏ� ǎnjNJ� ǍǘǎNJ� NjǥǕǘ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜǘ� ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjǘ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǙǚǘǏǔǜǘnj�� ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǗǥǟ� ǗNJ� ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJ-ǗǒǏ� ǜǏǟ�ǒǕǒ�ǒǗǥǟ� NJǛǙǏǔǜǘnj� ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ� nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��ƹNJǚNJǕǕǏǕǦǗǘ�njǛǪ�ǡNJǣǏ��ǔNJǔ�ǖǒǗǒǖǝǖ�ǗNJǡǒǗNJǩ�Ǜ�����bǍǘǎNJ��ǑnjǝǡNJǜ�ǒǗǒǠǒNJǜǒnjǥ��ǗNJ-ǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǗǥǏ�ǗNJ�ǑNJǙǚǏǜ�NJǗǘǗǒǖǗǘǛǜǒ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ1��ƹǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǘǡǏnjǒǎǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖNJ�ǘǛǜNJǪǜǛǩ�ǗǏǙǚǘǚNJNjǘǜNJǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǔ� Ǜ� ǜǏǘǚǏǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ��ǜǏǘǚǏǜǒǔǘ�ǞǒǕǘǛǘǞǛǔǒǏ�ǒ�ǜǏǚǖǒǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�NJǛǙǏǔǜǥ���ǜNJǔ�ǒ�Ǜ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǘǓ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔǒ�ǒ�ǙǚNJǔǜǒǔǒ�ǏǪ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJǟ��ƷǏ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǔǘǖǙǕǏǔǛǗǘǍǘ�NJǗNJǕǒǑNJ�ǜǏǟǗǘ-ǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�� ǔNJǔ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǨǣǒǟ�ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǝǨ�NJǗǘ-ǗǒǖǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ƻǏǜǒ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǣǒǟ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒǟ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƷNJǚǩǎǝ�Ǜ�ǧǜǒǖ�nj�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗNJǟ�ǝǐǏ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǙǚǘǎǘǕǐǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�njǏǎǪǜǛǩ�ǚNJNjǘǜNJ�ǙǘbǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔǏ�ǒ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǨ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�Ǜ�ǙǏǚǛǙǏǔǜǒnjǘǓ�ǒǟ�ǍǕǘNjNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ƸǛǘNjǏǗǗǘ�NJǔǜǝNJǕǦǗǘǓ�nj�ǧǜǘǖ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǒ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǙǚǒǗǩǜNJǩ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘǖ�ƻǂƪ�ƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗNJǩ� ƻǜǚNJ-ǜǏǍǒǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj� ǔǒNjǏǚǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǛǜnjǏ� �7KH�1DWLRQDO� 6WUDWHJ\� IRU�7UXVWHG� ΖGHQWLWLHV� LQ�&\EHUVSDFH� �167Ζ&����ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�ƻǘǏǎǒǗǏǗǗǥǏ�ǂǜNJǜǥ�ǗǏ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǏǎǒǗǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�ǛǜǚNJǗǘǓ��nj�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ�njǘǙǚǘǛ�ǘNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ�ǙǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗ�nj�ǛǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǖ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǖ�ǖNJǛǢǜNJNjǏ��ƻǚǏǎǒ�ǎǚǝ-Ǎǒǟbȃ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǩ��ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǩ��ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚ��LjǐǗNJǩ�ƴǘǚǏǩ�ǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǏ�

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ� ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ� ǎǕǩ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ� ǒǗ-ǜǏǚǏǛ�ǒ�Ǜ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��ǒ�Ǜ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ�ǘǙǜǒǖǒǑNJǠǒǒ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǔNJǔ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ�Ǜ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗNJǖǒ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǛǘNjǘǓ�ǒ�Ǜ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ�ǕǒǠNJǖǒ��Ƭ�ǎNJǗǗǘǓ�ǚNJNjǘǜǏ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǝǏǜǛǩ�ǘǙǥǜ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ� ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ� ǙǚǘǏǔǜǘnj� Ǚǘb ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǛǏǜǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�nj�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǖ�ǖNJǛǢǜNJNjǏ��Ƭ�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJ�ǒǛǛǕǏ-ǎǘnjNJǗǒǩ�njǥNjǚNJǗǥ�ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǩ��ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǩ��ƴǒǜNJǓ��ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚ��ƻǂƪ��

1 KWWS���ULD�UX�VRFLHW\��������������������KWPO�� KWWS���ZZZ�YHGRPRVWL�UX�WHFK�QHZV��������� UXQHWBQHBEXGHWBDQRQLPQ\P��KWWS���ZZZ�YHVWL�UX�GRF�KWPO"LG ������

7

Page 9: User identification analysis

LJǛǜǘǗǒǩ�ǒ�LjǐǗNJǩ�ƴǘǚǏǩ��ƷNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǛǚNJnjǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǍǘ�NJǗNJǕǒǑNJ�ǘǙǥ-ǜNJ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnj��ƭǕNJnjNJ����ǛǞǘǚǖǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǥ�ǚǏǔǘǖǏǗǎNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǚǏ-ǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ� ǎNJǗǗǘǓ� ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ� ǎǕǩ� ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ� ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ� �ƭǕNJnjNJ� ����ƼNJǖbǐǏ�ǙǚǘNJǗNJǕǒǑǒǚǘnjNJǗ�njNJǐǗǥǓ�ǘǙǥǜ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǘnj�ǙǘbǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǛNJǖǘǓ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ��ƯƻƲƪ��ǙǘǚǜNJǕ�ƭǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ�ǒ�ǎǚ����ƹǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ���ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ�ǘǙǒǛNJǗǒǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǟ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǥǟ�nj�ƺƾ�ǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚ�ǝǙǚǘǣǏǗǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�ǙǕNJǜǏǐNJ��nj�ƹǚǒǕǘ-ǐǏǗǒǒ���ǎNJǗǘ�ǘǙǒǛNJǗǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗ-ǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�njǒǎǏǘǗNJNjǕǨǎǏǗǒǩ�ǗNJ�njǥNjǘǚNJǟ��ƭǕNJnjNJ���ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ�NJǗNJǕǒǑ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǖǏǜǘǎǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǔNJǔ�ǗNJǒNjǘǕǏǏ�ǙǏǚǛǙǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǍǘ�ǒ�ǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǗǘ�ǚNJǑnjǒnjNJǨǣǏǍǘǛǩ�ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�nj�ǛǞǏǚǏ�

ƸǜǎǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǒ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�NJǔǜǝNJǕǦǗǥǖ�nj�ǛnjǏǜǏ�ǖǏǗǩǨǣǏǍǘǛǩ�ǚǘǛǛǒǓ-ǛǔǘǍǘ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ� nj� ǛǞǏǚǏ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� njǘ-ǙǚǘǛ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǔNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǏ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎǩǜ�ǔ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩǖ�ǔ�ǟǘǛǜǒǗǍ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJǖ�ǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǩǖ�ǙǘbǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǨ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥǟ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǟ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��LJǜǘǜ�njǘǙǚǘǛ�ǘǛnjǏǣǪǗ�nj�ƭǕNJnjǏ���

ƼNJǔǐǏ�ǎǕǩ�ǜǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǛǜǚNJǗǘnjǘǖ�ǖNJǛǢǜNJNjǏ�ǗǏǖNJǕǘnjNJǐ-Ǘǥǖ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǜǘ��ǔNJǔǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǥ�ǜǚǏNjǝǨǜ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǏ�ǔǚǝǙǗǥǏ�Ζ7�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�Ǚǚǒ�ǑNJǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǒ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǘnj�Ǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǖǒ�ǒǕǒ�ǚǏǍǒ-ǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ��ƭǕNJnjNJ�����ƴǚǘǖǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��nj�ƹǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǒ���ǙǚǒnjǏǎǏǗ�NJǗNJǕǒǑ�ǙǘǕǒ-ǜǒǔ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗǒǩ�ǔǘǚǙǘǚNJǜǒnjǗǥǟ�NJǎǚǏǛǘnj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǡǜǥ�ǔNJǔ�Ǚǚǒ-ǖǏǚ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǔNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǝǨǣǒǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�NjǥǜǦ�mǑNJǢǒǜǥ}�nj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǥ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�

8

Page 10: User identification analysis

ƭƵƪƬƪ��

ƷǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǜǏǘǚǏǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�NJǛǙǏǔǜǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ

Ƭ�ƮƪƷƷƸƳ�ƺƪƫƸƼƯ�ƲƻƹƸƵdžƱƽLjƼƻlj�ǙǚǒǗǩǜǥǏ�nj�ǕǒǜǏǚNJǜǝǚǏ�ǜǏǚǖǒǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏ-ǛǔǒǏ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǒǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǙǘǗǩǜǒǩǖǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔǠǒǒ��

Ƭ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǟ�Ǚǘǎ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǏǓ�ǘNjǥǡǗǘ�ǙǘǗǒ-ǖNJǨǜ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗǒǩ�ǔNJǔ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜNJǖ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJǖ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ� ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǪǗǗǥǟ� ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘnj� ǒ� ǒǟ� ǛǚNJnjǗǏǗǒǏ� Ǜ�ǙǏǚǏǡǗǏǖ� ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗǗǥǟ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘnj�� ƮǕǩ� njǥǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ� ǕǒǠNJ�� ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǣǏǍǘ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ��ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǍǘnjǘǚǒǜǦ�ǗǏ�ǛǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǘNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǘNj�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǜNJǔǘǍǘ�ǕǒǠNJ��ƲǖǏǗǗǘ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǦ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǏ�ǗNJǑnjNJǗ-Ǘǘǖǝ�ǒǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǝ�� ƼNJǔ�� nj� ǘǞǞǕNJǓǗǘnjǥǟ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǩǟ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ�ǙǘbǞǘǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǒ�nj�ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǩǏǖǘǖ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǏ��NJ�ǒǗǘǍǎNJ�ǙǘbǎǚǝǍǒǖ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǖ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǔNJǖ��njǔǕǨǡNJǩ�ǎNJǔǜǒǕǘǛǔǘ-ǙǒǡǏǛǔǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�

ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��Ǚǚǒ�ǛǘNjǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦ�ǒǗ-ǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�mǗNJǑǥnjNJǏǜ�ǛǏNjǩ}�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ��ǙǘǎǔǕǨǡǪǗǗǘǓ�ǔ�ƻǏǜǒ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǙǝǜǪǖ�ǝǔNJǑNJǗǒǩ�ǛnjǘǏǓ�ǝǡǪǜǗǘǓ�ǑNJǙǒǛǒ�ǗNJ�ǜǘǖ�ǒǕǒ�ǒǗǘǖ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǖ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛǏ��ƹǚǒ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ� Ǜǘ-ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǏ�ǕǒǠNJ�ǗNJǑnjNJǗǗǘǖǝ�ǒǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǝ��ƼNJǔNJǩ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�ǖǘ-ǐǏǜ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦǛǩ�ǔNJǔ�ǙǝǜǪǖ�njnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǙNJǚǘǕǩ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǛǏǚ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǜNJ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǒǗǥǖǒ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjNJǖǒ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJǖǒ��ǔNJǔ�ǛǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ�

ƹǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ� nj� ǖǒǚǏ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǝǏǖǘǏ��NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǝǏǖǘǏ�� ǕǒǠǘ�� ǔNJǔ� ǙǚNJnjǒǕǘ�� ǘǜǎǏǕǏǗǘ� ǘǜ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� Ǚǚǘ-ǛǜǚNJǗǛǜnjǘǖ��ǒǛǔǕǨǡNJǨǣǒǖ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǗǏǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǔǘǗǜNJǔǜNJ��ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ�njǏǛǜǒ�ǚǏǡǦ�ǗǏ�ǘ�ǕǒǠNJǟ��NJ�ǘNj�ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJǟ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǩnjǕǩǜǦǛǩ�ǚǏǙǚǏǑǏǗǜNJǜǒnjNJǖǒ�ǔNJǔ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnj��njǔǕǨǡNJǩ�Ǚǚǘ-ǍǚNJǖǖǗǥǏ�ǖǘǎǝǕǒ���ǎǕǩ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǗǏ�ǎǏǕNJǏǜ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǒǓ�

�� ƹǘǎǚǘNjǗǏǏ� ǘ� ǜǏǚǖǒǗǘǕǘǍǒǒb Ǜǖ��� ƶ�ɊljǔǝǢǏnj�� ƶǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǘ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ� ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ����ƲǗǎǏǔǛ�ƫǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��ȟɋ��������������

9

Page 11: User identification analysis

ƮǕǩ� ǜǘǍǘ� ǡǜǘNjǥ� ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� �NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔǠǒǒ�� Ǜǘ-ǛǜǘǩǕNJǛǦ�� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖNJ� ǙǚǏǎnjNJǚǒǜǏǕǦǗNJǩ� ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǩ� ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJ� nj� Ǜǒ-ǛǜǏǖǏbȃ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗǒǏ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜǝ�ǒǖǏǗǒ��Ƭǘ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǝǏǜ�ǚǩǎ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǔǘnj�ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǙNJǚǘǕǦ�ǒǕǒ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǘǔ�ǙNJǕǦǠNJ���Ǜ�ǜǏǖ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�njǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǒ�Ǚǘbǧǜǒǖ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǔNJǖ�ǙǚǘnjǘǎǒǜǦ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�

ƻǟǏǖNJ����ƺǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǩ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJ�nj�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ

Ƭ�ǜǘǖbǐǏ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ��ǔǘǍǎNJ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��mǑNJǕǘǍǒǗǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ}�ǗNJ�ǗǏǔǘǖ�ǛNJǓǜǏ��ǙǚǘǒǛǟǘǎǒǜ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǏǏ������ǘNjǤǏǔǜ�ǗNJǑǥnjNJǏǜ�ǛǏNjǩ�Ǜǒ-ǛǜǏǖǏ� �ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ��� ���� ǑNJǜǏǖ� ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǩǏǜ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ� ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǔǒ��ǛǘNjǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ���ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǡǏǍǘ�����ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǗNJǎǏǕǩǏǜ� ǘNjǤǏǔǜ� ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǪǗǗǥǖǒ�ǙǚNJnjNJǖǒ�ǗNJ� ǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǒǏ� ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǓ��NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǩ���ǀǏǕǒǔǘǖ�ǜNJǔǝǨ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǝ�ǒ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜǘ�ǗNJǑǥnjNJǜǦ�NJǝǜǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǏǓ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǜǏǚǖǒǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǗǏǙǚǘǜǒnjǘǚǏǡǒnjǘǛǜǒ�nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǎNJǗǗǘǓ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�ǎǕǩ�ǗǏǪ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗ�ǜǏǚǖǒǗ�mǚNJǛǢǒ-ǚǏǗǗǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}�

ƻǟǏǖNJ����ƻǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǗNJǩ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�ǚNJǛǢǒǚǏǗǗǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ

ƮǘnjǘǕǦǗǘ�ǡNJǛǜǘ�njǘǑǗǒǔNJǏǜ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǦ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǝǐǏ�ǛǝǣǏ-ǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǏ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǥ�� ǗNJǑǗNJǡǏǗǗǥǏ� ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJǖ� ǎǚǝǍǒǖǒ� ǛǒǛǜǏ-ǖNJǖǒ��ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǒǜǦ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�nj� ƯƻƲƪ�ǒ� ǎǚ���� ƴǚǘǖǏ� ǜǘǍǘ�� ǜNJǔǘǏ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ� ǝǖǏǗǦǢNJǏǜ� ǑNJǜǚNJǜǥ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJ�ǗNJ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǝ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�Ǜnjǘǒǟ�NJǔǔNJǝǗǜǘnj�nj�ǚNJǑǕǒǡ-

10 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƯ�ƼƯƸƺƯƼƲǁƯƻƴƲƯ�ƪƻƹƯƴƼDž�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ

Page 12: User identification analysis

Ǘǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǟ��ƮǕǩ�ǜǘǍǘ�ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘnj�ǘǎǗǒǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ǖǘǍǕǘ�NjǥǜǦ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǘ�nj�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ��ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǙǚǏǎnjNJǚǒǜǏǕǦ-ǗǘǏ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǚǏǐǒǖNJ�ǎǘnjǏǚǒǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖǒ�

ƻǟǏǖNJ����ƽǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǎǘnjǏǚǒǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖǒ

ƹǚǒ� ǝǛǕǘnjǒǒ�� ǡǜǘ� ǘNjǤǏǔǜ� NjǥǕ� ǑNJǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǗ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǘǓ� ��� NJ� ǘNj-ǣNJǏǜǛǩ� Ǜ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǘǓ� ��� ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ� ǚNJǛǢǒǚǏǗǗǘǓ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǑNJ-ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǏǜ� ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ�ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǢNJǍǒ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǢNJǍNJǖǒ� ����ǒ� ������� ��ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǘǓ���ǘǜ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJ��ǙǘbǏǍǘ�ǙǘǚǝǡǏǗǒǨ��ǙǏǚǏǎ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǘǓ���ǒ��� ��NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǘǓ���ǙǘbǙǘǚǝ-ǡǏǗǒǨ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ���

ƻǟǏǖNJ����ƺNJǛǢǒǚǏǗǗNJǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�Ǜ�ǝǡNJǛǜǒǏǖ�mǜǚǏǜǦǏǓ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ}

ƻǜǏǙǏǗǦ�ǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǗǘǛǜǒ� �ǗNJǎǪǐǗǘǛǜǒ��ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǟ��ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǝ-Ǩǣǒǟ�� ǙǚǒǑǗNJǔǘnj�� ǜǚǏNjǝǏǖǥǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǘǓ� Ǚǚǒ� ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ� ǒǕǒ� NJǝǜǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǘNjǚNJǜǗǘ�ǙǚǘǙǘǚǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗNJ�ǝǚǘnjǗǨ�ǑNJǕǘǐǏǗǗǥǟ�nj�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ�ǚǒǛǔǘnj�ǘǜ�ǗǏǗNJǎǕǏǐNJǣǏǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǒ��ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ��ǝǚǘnjǗǨ�ǎǘǙǝǛǜǒǖǘǓ�NJǗǘǗǒǖǗǘǛǜǒ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJ��

�� ƹǘǎǚǘNjǗǏǏ� ǘNj� NJǗǘǗǒǖǗǘǛǜǒb Ǜǖ��� ƶ�ɊljǔǝǢǏnj�� ƶǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǘ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ� ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ����ƲǗǎǏǔǛ�ƫǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��ȟɋ��������������

11

Page 13: User identification analysis

ƭƵƪƬƪ��

ƸǙǥǜ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�njbǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗNJǟ�ǖǒǚNJ

LJǛǜǘǗǒǩ

ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJƷƪƻƯƵƯƷƲƯ�LJƻƼƸƷƲƲ�ƷƯƬƯƵƲƴƸbȃ�ǙǚǒǖǏǚǗǘ�����ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗNJ�ǐǒǜǏǕǏǓ��ƫǕNJǍǘ-ǎNJǚǩ�ǒǗǗǘnjNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔǏ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�nj�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�ǒǗ-ǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ�� ǜǏǕǏǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ� ǛǏǔǜǘǚ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�ǙǚǏnjǚNJǜǒǕǛǩ�nj�ǛNJǖǥǓ�NjǥǛǜǚǘ�ǚNJǛǜǝǣǒǓ�nj�ǛǜǚNJǗǏ��ƲǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǏ��ǙǚǘnjǏ-ǎǏǗǗǘǏ�Ǚǘǎ�ǧǍǒǎǘǓ�ƶǒǚǘnjǘǍǘ�LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ƾǘǚǝǖNJ��ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǏǗ-ǗǘǏ�nj�����ǛǜǚNJǗNJǟ�ǖǒǚNJ��ǘǜnjǘǎǒǜ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�ǙǘǑǒǠǒǨ�ǕǒǎǏǚNJ�ǙǘbǘNjǣǏǓ�ǒǗǞǘǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǍǘǜǘnjǗǘǛǜǒ�ǛǚǏǎǒ�ǛǜǚNJǗ�ǀǏǗǜǚNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒ�ƬǘǛǜǘǡ-ǗǘǓ�ƯnjǚǘǙǥ�ǒ����Ǐ�ǖǏǛǜǘ�nj�ǘNjǣǏǖ�ǛǙǒǛǔǏ��

ƻǜǘǕǦ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǗǘǏ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘ�ǐǒǜǏǕǏǓ��ǔǘǖǙNJǔǜǗNJǩ�ǜǏǚǚǒǜǘǚǒǩ�ǒ� ǚNJǑnjǒǜNJǩ� ǜǏǕǏǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗNJǩ� ǒǗǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚNJ� ǙǘǑnjǘǕǒǕNJ� njǕNJ-Ǜǜǩǖ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑǘnjNJǜǦ� NJǖNjǒǠǒǘǑǗǥǓ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒ-ǘǗǗǘǓ� ǔNJǚǜǥ�� LJǛǜǘǗǒǩ� ǑNJǙǝǛǜǒǕNJ� ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǝ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ� Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ� nj�ǞǏnjǚNJǕǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ��ǔǘǍǎNJ�ƹNJǚǕNJǖǏǗǜ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�ǙǚǒǗǩǕ�ƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘNj�LJǕǏǔ-ǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǠǒǒ��ƱNJǔǘǗ�njǛǜǝǙǒǕ�nj�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏ���ǩǗnjNJǚǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ��ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǧǜǘǖǝ�ǑNJǔǘǗǝ�NjǥǕNJ�ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗNJ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǎǘǚǘǐǗNJǩ�ǔNJǚ-ǜNJ�ǎǕǩ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǎǕǩ�njǛǏǟ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ��Ʈǘ�ǧǜǘǍǘ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜNJ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǩ�ǗǏ�ǘNjǕNJǎNJǕNJ�ǕǒǡǗǥǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒ-ǘǗǗǥǖ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘǖ�njǘǘNjǣǏ��Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜNJ�NjǥǕNJ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗNJ�nj�ǎnjǝǟ�ǠǏǕǩǟ�����ǔNJǔ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜ��ǞNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǑNJǖǏǗǩǨǣǒǓ�ǘNjǣǏǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǒǓ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜ�� ��� ǔNJǔ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜ�

ƴNJǚǜNJ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǙǏǚnjǒǡǗǥǖ� ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǏǖ� ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ� ǒ� ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒ-ǜǏǕǦǗNJ�nj�ǙǚǏǎǏǕNJǟ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ��ǘǗNJ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǗNJ�njǛǏǖǒ�ǡǕǏǗNJǖǒ�ƯnjǚǘǛǘǨǑNJ�

�� 7KH�*OREDO�ΖQIRUPDWLRQ�7HFKQRORJ\�5HSRUW�����Ȃ����bȃ�7KH�1HWZRUN�5HDGLQHVV�RI�1DWLRQV����KWWS���XQFWDG�RUJ�VHFWLRQV�ZFPX�GRFV�F�HP��S���BHQ�SGI

12 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 14: User identification analysis

ǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJǖǒ�ǡǕǏǗNJǖǒ�ǂǏǗǍǏǗǛǔǘǍǘ�ǛǘǍǕNJǢǏǗǒǩ��ǗǏ�njǟǘǎǩǣǒǖǒ�nj�ƯnjǚǘǙǏǓǛǔǒǓ�ƻǘǨǑ�� nj� ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǘǞǒǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ� ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ�ǎǕǩ�Ǚǝ-ǜǏǢǏǛǜnjǝǨǣǏǍǘ�ǕǒǠNJ��ƮǕǩ�ǙǘǏǑǎǘǔ�ǑNJ�ǙǚǏǎǏǕǥ�ƯnjǚǘǛǘǨǑNJ��ǔǚǘǖǏ�Ʒǘǚ-njǏǍǒǒ��ƲǛǕNJǗǎǒǒ�ǒ�ǂnjǏǓǠNJǚǒǒ��ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗNJǖ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖ�ǧǛǜǘǗ-ǛǔǒǓ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜ�

ƹǚNJnjǘnjǥǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjǥƿƪƺƪƴƼƯƺƷƸƳ� ƸƻƸƫƯƷƷƸƻƼdžLj� ƲƷƷƸƬƪǀƲƲ� Ǚǘb njnjǏǎǏǗǒǨ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗ-ǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǜǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǘǚǒǏǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǗNJ�ǗǏ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǗNJ�ǍǚNJǐ-ǎNJǗ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�ǒ�ǏǪ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǘnj��Ǘǘ��nj�ǙǏǚǛǙǏǔǜǒnjǏbȃ�ǒ�ǗNJ�ǗǏ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǘnj��ƬǒǠǏ�ǔNJǗǠǕǏǚ�ǙǘbǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǒǗǞǘǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚ-ǛǜnjNJ� ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǔǒ� ǒ� ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǓ� ƼNJNJnjǒ� ƴǘǜǔNJ� njǖǏǛǜǏ� Ǜ� ǑNJnjǏǎǝǨǣǏǓ�ǘǜǎǏǕǘǖ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔǒ�ǖǒǍǚNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǙǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǗǘǓ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔǒ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjNJ�njǗǝǜǚǏǗǗǒǟ�ǎǏǕ�ƺǝǜ�ƪǗǗǝǛ�ǒ�ǛǘnjǏǜǗǒǔǘǖ�ǙǘbnjǘǙǚǘǛNJǖ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗ-ǗǘǍǘ� ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjNJ� ǛǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ� NjǨǚǘ� ƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ� ǔNJǗǠǏǕǩǚǒǒ�ƻǒǓǖǘǖ� ƻǒǔǔǝǜǘǖ�� ǝǡNJǛǜnjǝǩ� nj� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǖ� LJǛǜǘǗǛǔǒǖ� ǞǘǗǎǘǖ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�ǔǘǗǔǝǚǛǏ��ǙǚǏǎǕǘǐǒǕǒ�ǒǎǏǨ��nj�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�njǘǙǕǘǣǏǗǒǩ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ�ǔ� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ� ��� ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗǘnj� ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ�� ǛǜNJnj� ǘNjǕNJǎNJǜǏǕǩǖǒ� Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ� ǗǏ-ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ��ǛǖǘǍǝǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǧǛǜǘǗǛǔǒǖǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǖǒ�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǖǒ��Ƭǘǜ� ǡǜǘ� ǑNJǩnjǒǕ� ǘNj� ǧǜǒǟ� ǙǕNJǗNJǟ� ƼNJnjnjǒ� ƴǘǜǔNJ�� m��� ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗǘnj� ǧ�ǚǏǑǒ�ǎǏǗ�ǜǘnjbȃ�njǘǜ�ǠǏǕǦ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�Ǎǘnjǘǚǒǜ�ǘ�ǗNJǢǒǟ�NJǖNjǒǠǒǩǟ��ƷNJǢǏ�ǙǚǏǎ-ǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ� ǛnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ� ǔ� ǜǘǖǝ�� ǡǜǘNjǥ� ǛǘǑǎNJǜǦ� ǒǗǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǝ�� ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǒǜ� ǙǚǏǎǙǚǒǩǜǒǩǖ�� ǙǚǒǡǏǖ� ǗǏ� ǜǘǕǦǔǘ� ǧǛǜǘǗǛǔǒǖ�� ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǚNJǑǎnjǒǗǝǜǦ� ǍǚNJǗǒǠǥ� ǛǜǚNJǗǥ��ƻǏǓǡNJǛ� nj�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ��������ǙǚǏǎǙǚǒǩǜǒǓ��ǏǛǕǒ�ǑNJ�ǛǡǏǜbǜ�ɋǗ��ǧ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǘnj�ǖǥ�ǛǖǘǐǏǖ�ǝǎnjǘǒǜǦ�ǧǜǘ�ǡǒǛǕǘ��ǧǜǘ�Njǝ-ǎǏǜ� Ǒǎǘǚǘnjǘ}��� ƹǘb ǛǕǘnjNJǖ� ƴǘǜǔNJ�� ǚǏǡǦ� ǒǎǏǜ� ǘ� ǙǚǏǒǖǝǣǏǛǜnjǏ�� NJ� ǗǏ� ǘ�ǙǚNJnjǏ�� nj� ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�� ǏǛǕǒ�NjǒǑǗǏǛ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǗNJ�ǗǏǧǜǒǡǗǘǓ��ǜǘ�ǧǛǜǘǗǛǔǘǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǘ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǕǒǢǒǜǦ�ǏǍǘ�ǙǚǏǎǘ-ǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǗǘǍǘ� ǙǚǏǒǖǝǣǏǛǜnjNJ�� ƹǘb ǘǠǏǗǔǏ� ƴǘǜǔNJ�� LJǛǜǘǗǒǩ� ǚNJǛǛǡǒǜǥnjNJ-Ǐǜ� ǝnjǏǕǒǡǒǜǦ� ǙǚǒnjǕǏǔNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ� ǎǕǩ� ǙǚǏǎǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǜǏǕǏǓ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǖ�ǗǝǐǏǗ� ǒǗnjǏǛǜǒǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ� ǛǡǏǜ�� NjǕNJǍǘǎNJǚǩ� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǖ� ǝ� ǧǛǜǘǗǛǔǒǟ� Ǟǒǚǖ�ǙǚǒNjNJnjǒǜǛǩ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj�� NJ� ǜNJǔǐǏ� ǝnjǏǕǒǡǒǜǛǩ� ǔNJǙǒǜNJǕ� ǛǜǚNJǗǥ�� ƫǝǎǝǣǒǟ�ǧ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǘnj�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǙǚǒnjǕǏǡǦ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǝǡǚǏǎǒǜǦ�nj�ǜǏǡǏǗǒǏ�ǘǎǗǘ-Ǎǘ� ǎǗǩ�Ǟǒǚǖǝ�� ǘǜǔǚǥǜǦ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǒǓ� ǛǡǏǜ� nj� LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�� njǘǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǙǘǕǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǘǓ�ǗNJǕǘǍǘnjǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǘǓ�ǒ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǥǖǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥ-ǖǒ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǒǖǒ�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǖǒ�

�� KWWS���UXV�SRVWLPHHV�HH���������X�LQRVWUDQFHY�SRMDYLWVMD�YR]PR]KQRVW�KRGDWDMVWYRYDW� RE�LG�NDUWH�QHUH]LGHQWD

13LJƻƼƸƷƲlj

Page 15: User identification analysis

ƴNJǔ�ǘǜǖǏǜǒǕ�ƴǘǜǔNJ��ǎǕǩ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǦ�ǛǡǏǜ�nj�NjNJǗǔǏ��ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ�ǎǘǕǐǏǗ�ǘNjǚNJǜǒǜǦǛǩ�ǔ�ǝǙǘǕǗǘǖǘǡǏǗǗǘǖǝ�ǚNJNjǘǜǗǒǔǝ�NjNJǗǔNJbȃbǜ�ɋǗ��mǜǏǕ-ǕǏǚǝ}��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǦ�ǏǍǘ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ��ƴNJǔ�ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǏǜ�ƴǘǜǔNJ��ǏǛǕǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�ǝǐǏ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗNJ�nj�ǧǛǜǘǗǛǔǘǖ�ǙǘǛǘǕǦ-ǛǜnjǏ�ǒǕǒ�ǔǘǗǛǝǕǦǛǜnjǏ�ǒ�Ǐǖǝ�njǥǎNJǗNJ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜNJ�ǗǏǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ��ǜǘ�ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒ-ǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǒ�ǗǏ�ǜǚǏNjǝǨǜǛǩ�

ƱNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ� LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ� njǔǕǨǡNJǏǜ� nj� ǛǏNjǩ� NjǘǕǦǢǘǏ� ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘnj�ǒ�ǙǘǎǑNJǔǘǗǗǥǟ�NJǔǜǘnj�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚNJnjNJ��ƹǏǚǏǡǒǛǕǒǖ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ�ǒǟ�Ǘǒǟ��ǒǖǏǨǣǒǏ�ǗǏǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǏ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǏ�ǔ�ǜǏǖǏ�ǒǛ-ǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǩ�

��� mƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘNj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǩǟ}�������Ǎ���� mƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘNj�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǟ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjNJ}������bǍ���� mƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘ�NjNJǑNJǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ}�����bǍ���� mƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘ�ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ}�����bǍ���� ƹǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ� mƸ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ� ǖǏǚ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗ-

Ǘǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ}���� ƹǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�mƸ�ǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩǟ�ǎǕǩ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒ-

ǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�ǒ�ǛǏǜǏǓ}�����bǍ�ƷNJǒNjǘǕǏǏ�ǞǝǗǎNJǖǏǗǜNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚ��ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǩǨǣǒǓ�ǙǚǏǎǖǏǜ�ǗNJ-

ǛǜǘǩǣǏǍǘ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ǗǘǛǒǜ�mƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘNj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒ-ǩǟ}��ƸǗ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ�nj�ǩnjǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǏ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǛǝǍǝNjǘ�ǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǙǘǗǩǜǒǓ��ǔNJǔ�� Ζ'�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ� ƶǘǎǝǕǦ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜNJ Ζ'�Ǜǘǜǥ��ǔǘǚǘǜǔǒǓ�ǔǘǎ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ��ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�ǔǘǎ�ǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǏ��ƹǏǚ-njǥǏ�ǎnjNJ�ǔǕǨǡǏnjǥǟ�ǙǘǗǩǜǒǩ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�

Ζ'� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩb ȃ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�� ǙǚǏǎǗNJǑǗNJǡǏǗǗǥǓ� NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǝ�ǎǕǩ�ǠǏǕǏǓ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǝ�ǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǏǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ�

ƶǘǎǝǕǦ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜNJbȃ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ��ǍNJǚNJǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘ�Ǚǘ-ǑnjǘǕǩǨǣǒǏ� NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǝ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖǒ� ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǓ� ǒ� ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǏ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ�nj�ǜǘǡǔNJǟ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǖ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǛǏǜǩǖ�

i��Ȃ��� mƱNJǔǘǗNJ� ǘNj� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ� ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǩǟ}� nj� ǡǪǜǔǘǓ� ǞǘǚǖǏ�ǙǚǘǙǒǛǥnjNJǏǜ� ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǗǒǏ� ǔ� ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩǖ� Ǚǘb NjǥǛǜǚǘǓ� NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǩǏǜ� ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ǎǕǩ� ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ�� ǛǙǘǛǘNjǗǥǟ� ǍNJǚNJǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ� Njǥ-ǛǜǚǝǨ� NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǨ�� ǗNJǎǏǕǩǩ� ƽǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ� Ǚǘb ƼǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǘǖǝ� ǗNJǎǑǘǚǝ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥǖǒ� ǙǘǕǗǘǖǘǡǒǩǖǒ� ǒ� ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǦǨ�� ƼNJǔǐǏ� ǑNJǔǘǗ� ǛǘǎǏǚ-

�� KWWS���ZZZ�OHJDOWH[W�HH�HQ�DQGPHEDDV�WHNVW�DVS"ORF WH[WGRN ;�����.�NHHO HQSJ � SW\\S 57W\\S ;TXHU\ FRPPXQLFDWLRQV�� KWWS���]DNRQ���HH�]DNRQ�RE�XVOXJDK�LQIRUPDFLRQQRJR�REVKKHVWYD

14 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 16: User identification analysis

ǐǒǜ� ǘǙǒǛNJǗǒǏ� ǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǒ� ǙǚǒǔǕNJǎǗǥǟ� ǖNJǜǏǖNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJ-ǗǒǓ�ǙǘbǚǏǑǏǚnjǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǗǥǟ�ǗǘǖǏǚǘnj��Ζ'�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��6Ζ0�ǖǘǎǝǕǏǓ��ǗǘǖǏǚǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ��NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǘnj�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗǒǩ�ǗǘǖǏǚǘnj�ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJǖ�ǒb ǜ�ɋǙ�b mƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘNj�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǟ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǘNjǣǏ-ǛǜnjNJ}�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǩǏǜ�ǝǛǕǝǍǝ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjNJ��ǔNJǔ�ǝǛǕǝǍǝ��ǘǔNJǑǥ-njNJǏǖǝǨ�nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǟǘǑǩǓǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǚǘǞǏǛǛǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǘbǙǚǩǖǘǖǝ�ǟǘǎNJǜNJǓǛǜnjǝ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��Ǚǚǒ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǘNj-ǚNJNjNJǜǥnjNJǨǜǛǩ��ǛǘǟǚNJǗǩǨǜǛǩ�ǒ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǨǜǛǩ�nj�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǘǖ�njǒǎǏ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ� ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj��ǙǚǏǎǗNJǑǗNJǡǏǗǗǥǟ�ǎǕǩ�ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ�ǒ� ǛǘǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǙǚǒǡǏǖ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ�ǗǏ�ǗNJǟǘǎǩǜǛǩ�ǘǎǗǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǘ�nj�ǘǎǗǘǖ�ǒ�ǜǘǖbǐǏ�ǖǏǛǜǏ��ƽǛǕǝǍNJ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjNJ�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�NjǥǜǦ�ǙǘǕǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǙǏ-ǚǏǎNJǗNJ�ǒ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜNJ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�ǛnjǩǑǒ��ƽǛǕǝǍǘǓ�ǒǗ-ǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjNJ�ǗǏ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǝǛǕǝǍNJ��ǙǏǚǏǎNJǗǗNJǩ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǞNJǔǛNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǑnjǘǗǔNJ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǜǏǕǏǚNJǎǒǘnjǏǣNJǗǒǏ�ǙǘbǛǖǥǛǕǝ�ƱNJǔǘǗNJ�ǘ�ǜǏǕǏǚNJǎǒǘnjǏǣNJǗǒǒ��ƱNJǔǘǗ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ�ǘǙǒǛNJǗǒǏ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ǔ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǒ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǖ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǖ�

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǖǏǚǥƬ�ƷƪƻƼƸljǃƲƳ�ƶƸƶƯƷƼ�Ƭ�LJƻƼƸƷƲƲ�ǏǛǜǦ���ǛǙǘǛǘNjNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘ-Ǜǜǒ�nj�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��ǧǜǘ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜNJ��ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�Digi-ID�ǒ�Mobil-ID���ƷNJǒNjǘǕǏǏ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǪǗǗǥǖ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǘǏ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�Ǖǒǡ-ǗǘǛǜǒb ȃ� Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜNJ�� ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ� ǘNjǕNJǎNJǏǜ� ǎnjǝǖǩ� ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǖǒ� ǞǝǗǔǠǒǩǖǒ��Ƭǘ�ǙǏǚnjǥǟ�bȃ� ǧǜǘ� ǘNjǥǡǗǥǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�ǛǗNJNjǐǏǗ�ǙǘǕǝǜǘǚNJ�ǎǏǛǩǜǔNJǖǒ�ǧǕǏǖǏǗǜǘnj�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ� �ǖǒǔǚǘǙǏǡNJǜǦ��ǍǘǕǘǍǚNJǖǖNJ� ǒb ǜ�ɋǎ���� ǎǏǕNJǨǣǒǖǒ� Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǝ� ǙǘǕǗǘǠǏǗǗǥǖ� ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�nj�ǚǏNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǐǒǑǗǒ��Ƭǘ�njǜǘǚǥǟ��nj�ǗǏǏ�njǛǜǚǘǏǗ�ǡǒǙ��ǗNJ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǥ�ǎnjNJ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩbȃ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǏ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�Ǜ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǖ�3Ζ1�ǔǘǎǘǖ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗ-ǗǘǓ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ�� ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǘNjǕNJǎNJǨǣǏǏ� Ǜnjǘǒǖ�3Ζ1�ǔǘǎǘǖ��ƮǕǒǗNJ�ǧǜǒǟ�3Ζ1�ǔǘǎǘnj�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗNJ�

mƱNJǔǘǗ� ǘNj� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ� ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǩǟ}� ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǏǜ�� ǡǜǘ� ǗNJǠǒǘ-ǗNJǕǦǗNJǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗNJǩ� ǔNJǚǜNJ� ǎǘǕǐǗNJ� ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǜǦ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ� ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǜ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗNJǖ� ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǏ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǒ�� nj� ǡNJǛǜǗǘǛǜǒ� ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜ�� ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǣǒǓ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǒǜǦ� ǧǕǏǔ-ǜǚǘǗǗǝǨ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǝǨ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦ��LJǛǜǘǗǒǩ�njǥǙǝǛǜǒǕNJ�ǙǏǚnjǝǨ� ǛǏǚǒǨ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǔNJǚǜǘǡǏǔ� nj� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ�

�� mH�(VWRQLD�}�(VWRQLD�HX��Q�G���KWWS���HVWRQLD�HX�DERXW�HVWRQLD�HFRQRP\�D�LW�H�HVWRQLD�KWPO��DF-FHVVHG�$XJXVW�����������

15LJƻƼƸƷƲlj

Page 17: User identification analysis

ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘǖ�nj�����ǜǥǛǩǡ�Ǣǜǝǔ��ƴ�����bǍǘǎǝ�NjǘǕǏǏ���Ɍ��ǙǚǘǠǏǗǜǘnj�ǐǒ-ǜǏǕǏǓ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�ǘNjǕNJǎNJǕǒ�ǜNJǔǒǖǒ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔNJǖǒ��ƽǡǒǜǥnjNJǩ��ǡǜǘ�ǗNJǛǏǕǏǗǒǏ�ǛǜǚNJǗǥ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǙǚǒǖǏǚǗǘ�����ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗNJ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ��ǧǜǘ�ǘǑǗNJǡNJǏǜ��ǡǜǘ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǒ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǕǒ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗNJ��ƻǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�nj�njǒǎǝ��ǡǜǘ�ǒǗǘ-ǛǜǚNJǗǗǥǏ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǥ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǒǖǏǨǜ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǜNJǔǝǨ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǝ�

ƴNJǚǜǘǡǔNJ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ�ǗNJ�ǕǒǠǏnjǘǓ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǏ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�• ǒǖǩ�• ǞǘǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǩ�• ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦ�• ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�• ǎNJǜNJ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǩ�• ǙǘǕ�• ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǒǓ�ǛǜNJǜǝǛ�• ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�• ǎNJǜNJ�njǥǙǝǛǔNJ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ƸNjǚNJǜǗNJǩ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�• ǖǏǛǜǘ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǩ�• ǎNJǜNJ�njǥǙǝǛǔNJ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�• ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘ�ǖǏǛǜǏ�ǙǚǘǐǒnjNJǗǒǩ�Ǚǚǒ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ƼNJǔǐǏ�ǔNJǚǜNJ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ�ǗǏǍǚNJǞǒǡǏǛǔǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ��ǜ�ɋǏ��ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǗǏ�

ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǜ�ǞǘǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǨ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦ�njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠNJ��nj�mǖNJǢǒǗǗǘǖ}�ǞǘǚǖNJ-ǜǏ��ǁǒǙ�ǗNJ�ǔNJǚǜǏ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ�ǎnjNJ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜNJ��ǘǎǒǗ�ǎǕǩ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�NJǝ-ǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǘǎǒǗ�ǎǕǩ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ��LJǛǜǘǗǒǩ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǘǎ-ǗǘǓ�ǒǑ�ǗǏǖǗǘǍǒǟ�ǏnjǚǘǙǏǓǛǔǒǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗ��nj�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗNJǩ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦ�ǗǏ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǗǏǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�� ƻǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǥ� ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǜ� ǒǖǩ� ǎǏǚǐNJǜǏǕǩ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǒ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǗǘǖǏǚ� Ζ'�� ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ� ǘǞǒǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǓ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ� ǙǘǡǜǘnjǥǓ� NJǎǚǏǛ�� ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǎǕǩ�ǔNJǐǎǘǍǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ƹǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǏ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǗǘǛǒǜ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǓ�ǟNJ-ǚNJǔǜǏǚ�ǎǕǩ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ��ǗNJǡǒǗNJǩ�Ǜ�njǘǑǚNJǛǜNJ�nj���bǕǏǜ�

LJǛǜǘǗǒǩ�ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǒnjNJǏǜ�H�PDLO�ǎǕǩ�ǔNJǐǎǘǍǘ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ��ƹǘǡǜǘnjǥǓ�NJǎǚǏǛ�nj�ǙǏǚnjǝǨ�ǘǡǏǚǏǎǦ�ǙǚǏǎǗNJǑǗNJǡǏǗ�ǎǕǩ�ǘǞǒǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǙǏǚǏǙǒǛǔǒ�Ǜ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�njǕNJǛǜǒ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗ�ǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǓ�ǙǏǚǏǙǒǛǔǒ��ƻǜǚǝǔǜǝǚNJ�NJǎǚǏǛNJ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǡǜǥ�njǥǚNJǐNJ-ǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǞǘǚǖNJǜǏ�mǒǖǩBǞNJǖǒǕǒǩB1111#HHVWL�HH}��nj�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ�1111�ǙǚǏǎ-ǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǛǕǝǡNJǓǗǝǨ�ǙǏǚǏǛǜNJǗǘnjǔǝ�ǒǑ�ǡǏǜǥǚǏǟ�ǠǒǞǚ��ƼNJǔǐǏ�ǕǨNjǘǓ�njǕNJ-ǎǏǕǏǠ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�Ǚǘǡǜǝ�ǙǘbNJǎǚǏǛǝ�mΖ'B&2'(#HHVWL�HH}��ǍǎǏ�mΖ'B&2'(}�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ� ǛǘNjǘǓ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǗǘǖǏǚ� Ζ'� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ��ƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǘ� ǗǏ� ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǏǜ� ǙǘǕǗǘǠǏǗǗǘǍǘ� ǙǘǡǜǘnjǘǍǘ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJ� ǎǕǩ�

16 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 18: User identification analysis

Ǜnjǘǒǟ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ��NJǎǚǏǛ�ǘNjǥǡǗǘ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗǒǚǝǏǜ�ǔNJǔ�ǙǚǘǖǏǐǝǜǘǡǗǥǓ��ǜNJ-ǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǏ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǗNJǛǜǚǘǒǜǦ�ǙǏǚǏǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǙǒǛǏǖ�ǗNJ�Ǜnjǘǒ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ�ǙǘǡǜǘnjǥǏ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ��ƬǛǏ�NJǎǚǏǛNJ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǡǜǥ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǙǝNjǕǒǡǗǥǖǒ��ǜNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�ǒǟ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǘNjǗNJǚǝǐǒǜǦ�nj�LJǛǜǘǗ-ǛǔǘǓ�ƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ƹNJǕNJǜǏ�ƻǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�Ʋƻƹ�

LJǛǜǘǗǛǔǒǓ� ǙǚǘǏǔǜ� njǔǕǨǡNJǏǜ� ǔNJǔ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�� ǜNJǔ� ǒ� ǡNJǛǜǗǥǟ�ǙNJǚǜǗǏǚǘnj�� ƽǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǘǓ� ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�njǏǎǘǖǛǜnjǘǖbȃ�LJǛǜǘǗǛǔǒǖ�ǔǘǖǒǜǏǜǘǖ�ǙǘbǖǒǍǚNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǜnjǝ��ƼǏǟ-ǗǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ� ǒǗǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚNJ� ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ� ǀǏǗǜǚǘǖ� ƻǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǒǑnjǏǛǜǗǥǖ� ǔNJǔ� 6HUWLȴWVHHULPLVNHVNXV� �6.��� ǙNJǚǜǗǏǚǛǔǘǓ� ǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǘǓ��ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǗNJ�ǙNJǩǟ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǎnjǝǖǩ�NjNJǗǔNJǖǒ��m+DQVDSDQN}�ǒ�m(HVWL��KLVSDQN}�ǒ�ǎnjǝǖǩ�ǜǏǕǏǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖǒ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǩǖǒ��m(HVWL�7HOH-IRQ}� ǒ� m(07}�� 6.� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǝǨǣǒǖ� ǘǚǍNJǗǘǖ� ǎǕǩ� njǥǙǝǛǔNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ�ǒ�ǝǙǚNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖǒ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖǒ��ǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǥǖǒ�Ǜ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜNJǖǒ��ƼNJǔǐǏ�6.�ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǏǗ�ǑNJ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏ-ǗǒǏ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǏǔbȃ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǏ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǘNjǚNJǜǒǜǦǛǩ�nj�ǘǜǎǏǕǏǗǒǩ�ǝǔNJǑNJǗǗǥǟ�NjNJǗǔǘnj�ǒ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǝ�

ƴǚǘǖǏ� ǜǘǍǘ�� ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǩ� m75�%� %DOWLF� $6}�� ǩnjǕǩǨǣNJǩǛǩ� ǞǒǕǒNJǕǘǖ�ǢnjǏǓǠNJǚǛǔǘǓ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�m75�%�$*}��ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗNJ�ǑNJ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǨ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǏǔbȃ�ǔNJǔ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǝǨ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǝǨ�ǙǏǚǏǙǚǘǢǒnjǔǝ��6.�ǛǘǑ-ǎNJǕ�ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjǘ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǏǔ��ƸǎǗǘǓ�ǒǑ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�DigiDoc��ǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚNJ��ǔǘǜǘ-ǚNJǩ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǕǒǠNJǖ�ǛǘǑǎNJnjNJǜǦ�ǒ�njǏǚǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǥǏ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��'LJL'RF�ǛǘǛǜǘǒǜ�ǒǑ�ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjNJ�ǔǘǖǙǘǗǏǗ-ǜǘnj��ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǣǒǟ�ǛǘǑǎNJnjNJǜǦ��ǎǏǕǒǜǦǛǩ�ǒ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǩǜǦ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǥǏ�ǙǘǎǙǒ-Ǜǒ�� njǔǕǨǡNJǩ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜǛǔǘǏ� ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǘǏ� ǖǘǐǗǘ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǗNJ� ǚNJNjǘǡǏǖ� ǛǜǘǕǏ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ� ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚNJ�� ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕ�ǎǕǩ�njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǛǘnjǖǏǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�Ǜǘ� ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjǘǖ� ǙǘǎǙǒǛǏǓ�� ƼNJǔǐǏ� 'LJL'RF� njǔǕǨǡNJǏǜ� ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjǘ� Ǚǚǘ-ǍǚNJǖǖǒǚǝǏǖǥǟ� NjǒNjǕǒǘǜǏǔ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ� ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǜ� ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǡǒǔNJǖ� ǕǏǍǔǘ�njǔǕǨǡNJǜǦ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ� ǠǒǞǚǘnjǥǟ� ǙǘǎǙǒǛǏǓ� nj� ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǏ� ǙǚǒǕǘ-ǐǏǗǒǩ��'LJL'RF�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗ�ǗNJ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�;0/�$GYDQFHG�(OHFWURQLF�6LJQD-WXUHV��;DG(6��bȃ�ǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǘǖ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǏ��ǘǙǝNjǕǒǔǘnjNJǗǗǘǖ�ƲǗǛǜǒǜǝǜǘǖ�ƯnjǚǘǙǏǓǛǔǒǟ�ƼǏǕǏǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ƻǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǘnj��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǩ-Ǐǜ�Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǝ�ǞǘǚǖNJǜNJ�ǎǕǩ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǙǘǎǙǒǛNJǗǗǥǟ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦǨ� ǒ� NJǜǚǒNjǝǜǘnj� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�� 'LJL'RF� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǒ-ǑǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǓ�ǞǘǚǖNJǜ�ǎǕǩ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�Ǜ�ǎǚǝǍǒǖǒ�Ǚǚǘ-ǍǚNJǖǖǗǥǖǒ�ǙǚǘǎǝǔǜNJǖǒ�

17LJƻƼƸƷƲlj

Page 19: User identification analysis

ƴNJǚǜNJ�'LJL�Ζ'�ǗNJǡNJǕNJ�njǥǙǝǛǔNJǜǦǛǩ�Ǜ�����bǍǘǎNJ��ǙǘbǛǝǜǒ�ǛnjǘǏǓ�ǩnjǕǩ-ǏǜǛǩ�ǡǒǙǘǖ��ǗǏ�ǘNjǕNJǎNJǨǣǏǓ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJǖǒ�njǒǑǝNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǧǕǏǖǏǗǜǘnj�njǒǑǝNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ��ƷNJ�ǔNJǚǜǏ�ǝǔNJǑNJǗǥ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǒǖǩ�ǒ�ǞNJ-ǖǒǕǒǩ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ��ƿNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǡǒǙbǗNJ�'LJL�Ζ'�ǘNjǕNJǎNJǏǜ�ǚǘnjǗǘ�ǜǘǓbǐǏ�ǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǘǓ��ǡǜǘ�ǒ�ǗNJ�ǘNjǥǡǗǘǓ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǏ��ƶǘǐǗǘ�ǛǔNJǑNJǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�'LJL�Ζ'�ǩnj-ǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǝǙǚǘǣǪǗǗǥǖ�njNJǚǒNJǗǜǘǖ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ��ǎNJǨǣǏǓ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǏǪ�njǕNJǎǏǕǦ-Ǡǝ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�ǖǗǘǍǒǖ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ��ƷNJ�ǎNJǗǗǥǓ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ�ǜǚǒ�ǡǏǜnjǏǚǜǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�nj�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǒǗǜǏǚ-ǗǏǜNJ��ǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ�ǗNJǡǒǗNJǏǜ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�ǔǚǒǜǒ-ǡǏǛǔǘǏ� ǑǗNJǡǏǗǒǏ�� ƽǜǏǚǩ�ǒǕǒ�Ǚǚǒǟǘǎ� nj� ǗǏǍǘǎǗǘǛǜǦ� ǘNjǥǡǗǘǓ� Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǕǒǢNJǏǜ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�ǗNJ���ǗǏǎǏǕǒ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǖ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦ-ǔǝ�ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǛǜnjǘ�ǧǜǘǍǘ�njǥǛǘǔǘǑNJǣǒǣǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJ�ǑNJǗǒǖNJǏǜ�ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǏ�njǚǏǖǩ��ƴNJǚǜǝ�'LJL�Ζ'�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�nj�ǕǨNjǘǖ�ǎǏǙNJǚǜNJǖǏǗǜǏ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǜnjNJ�ǒ�ǖǒǍǚNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǜǏǡǏǗǒǏ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǛNJ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǙǏǡNJǜNJǨǜǛǩ�ǒ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗǒǞǒǠǒǚǝǨǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǖǏǛǜǏ�

ƼǚǏǜǒǓ� ǛǙǘǛǘNj� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒb ȃ� ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗNJǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ��Mobil-ID�� ƬǙǏǚnjǥǏ� ǧǜǘǜ� ǛǙǘǛǘNj� NjǥǕ� njǗǏǎǚǪǗ� ǘǎǗǒǖ� ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǘǖ� ǖǘ-NjǒǕǦǗǘǓ� ǛnjǩǑǒ� (07� nj� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ�� ƸǛǜNJǕǦǗǥǏ� ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǥ�� ǘNjǗNJǚǝǐǒnj�ǝǛǙǏǢǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ��ǛǜNJǕǒ�njǗǏǎǚǩǜǦ�ǏǍǘ�ǝ�ǛǏNjǩ�ǛǙǝǛǜǩ�ǎnjNJ�ǍǘǎNJ��ƻǝǜǦ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�0RELO�Ζ'� ǑNJǔǕǨǡNJǏǜǛǩ� nj� ǜǘǖ�� ǡǜǘ� nj� 6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜǝ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJ�ǑNJǙǒǛǥnjNJǨǜǛǩ�ǜǏbǐǏ�ǛNJǖǥǏ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩbȃ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒ-ǘǗǗǘǏ� ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ� ǒ� LJǀƹ�� ƵǒNjǘ� ǙǏǡNJǜNJǏǜǛǩ� ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗNJǩ� ǔNJǚǜNJ�� ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦ�0RELO�Ζ'�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǛǏNjǩ�Ǜ�Ǚǘ-ǖǘǣǦǨ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�ǎǕǩ�ǧǜǘǍǘ�Ǐǖǝ�ǗǏ�ǗǝǐǗǘ�Ǜǡǒǜǥ-njNJǨǣǏǏ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjǘ�ǎǕǩ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ��LJǜǘ�ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�ǑǗNJǡǏǗǒǏ��ǔǘǍǎNJ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦ�ǗNJǟǘǎǒǜǛǩ�ǑNJ�ǙǚǏǎǏǕNJǖǒ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ��ǁǏǚǏǑ�0RELO�Ζ'�ǙǏǚǏ-ǎNJǨǜǛǩ�ǘǛǘNjǥǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�ǑNJǢǒǞǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ�606�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǩ�nj�mǔǘǗǜǏǓ-ǗǏǚNJǟ}�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ� ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚ� ǛǜǚNJǗǥ� ǙǚǏNjǥnjNJǗǒǩ� ǙǏǚǏǎNJǪǜ� ǧǛǜǘǗǛǔǘǖǝ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǝ��ǜǘǜ��nj�ǛnjǘǨ�ǘǡǏǚǏǎǦ�bȃ�nj�ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǩǨǣǒǓ�ǠǏǗǜǚ��NJ�ǑNJǜǏǖ�ǙǘbǜǘǓbǐǏ�ǛNJǖǘǓ�ǠǏǙǘǡǔǏ�njǛǪ�njǘǑnjǚNJǣNJǏǜǛǩ�ǘNjǚNJǜǗǘ�

ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ǗǏ�ǗNJǕNJǍNJǏǜ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǒǓ�ǗNJ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ�nj�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǖ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚǏ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙǏǗ� ǕǨNjǘǖǝ� njǗǏǢǗǏǖǝ� ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǡǒǔǝ�� ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǕǨNjNJǩ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǙǘǛǜǚǘǒǜǦ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǏ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�Ζ'�ǎǕǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��Ƭ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǒǓ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǜ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǔNJǚǜ� nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ� NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǒǟ� ǜǚNJǗǑNJǔǠǒǓ�nj�ǚǏǐǒǖǏ�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ��ǎǕǩ�ǙǚǘǙǒǛǥnjNJǗǒǩ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǘnj�ǒ�ǗNJǕǘǍǘnjǥǟ�ǎǏǔǕNJǚNJ-

18 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 20: User identification analysis

ǠǒǓ��ǎǕǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�NjǏǛǙǚǘnjǘǎǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǩǟ��ǎǕǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�nj�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�NjNJǑǥ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�nj�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǙǚǘǙǝǛǔǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǒ�ǎǕǩ�NJnjǜǘǖNJ-ǜǒǑǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�nj�ǘǟǚNJǗǩǏǖǥǏ�ǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǙǘǖǏǣǏǗǒǩ�

ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗNJǖ� ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjNJǜǦ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ��ƹǘǡǜǒ�ǡǏǜnjǏǚǜǦ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�ǙǚǘǍǘǕǘǛǘnjNJǕNJ�ǗNJ�ǙNJǚǕNJǖǏǗǜǛǔǒǟ�njǥNjǘǚNJǟ�nj�ǖNJǚǜǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǩ�ǛnjǘǓ�Ζ'�ǗǘǖǏǚ��ƫǘǕǏǏ�ǜǘǍǘ����Ɍ��njǕNJǎǏǕǦ-ǠǏnj�ǔNJǚǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜ�Ǜnjǘǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǎǕǩ�ǘǙǕNJǜǥ�ǘNj-ǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ� ǜǚNJǗǛǙǘǚǜNJ�ǒ���Ɍ��ǎǕǩ� ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�ǠǒǞ-ǚǘnjǥǖǒ� ǙǘǎǙǒǛǩǖǒ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�� ��Ɍ�� ǙǕNJǜǏǕǦǣǒǔǘnj� ǗNJǕǘǍǘnj� ǑNJǙǘǕǗǩǨǜ�ǗNJǕǘǍǘnjǥǏ�ǎǏǔǕNJǚNJǠǒǒ�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǩ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�ƲǗǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǥ�ǘǜ-ǔǚǥǜǘǍǘ�ǔǘǎNJ�3.Ζ���ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǒnjNJǏǖǥǓ�NjNJǗǔNJǖǒ��NJ�ǗǏ�Ζ'��ƹǚǒǡǒǗNJ�ǧǜǘǍǘ�ǑNJǔǕǨǡNJǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǘnj�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��ǛǘǑǎNJǗǗNJǩ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ� NjNJǗǔNJǖǒ�� ǙǘǩnjǒǕNJǛǦ� ǚNJǗǏǏ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ� ǔNJǚǜǥ�� ƴǚǘǖǏ� ǜǘǍǘ�� LJǛǜǘǗǒǩ� ǑNJǙǝǛǜǒǕNJ� ǙǚǘǏǔǜ� mƶǘNjǒǕǦ-ǗǥǓbȃ�Ζ'}�ǎǕǩ�Ǜǘǜǘnjǥǟ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǘnj��ƹǘǎǘNjǗǘ�ǔNJǚǜǏ��ǧǜǘǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�ǛǘǎǏǚ-ǐǒǜ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǥ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǜ�ǕǒǠNJǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǛǏNjǩ�ǒ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǥnjNJǜǦ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǥ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǥǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ƻǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǥ�ǒǗǛǜNJǕ-ǕǒǚǝǨǜǛǩ�nj�6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜǝ��ƫǘǕǦǢǘǏ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǕǒǠNJǖ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�mƶǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǓ�Ζ'}�njǖǏǛǜǘ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�

ƷǏ� ǝǎǒnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�� ǡǜǘ� nj� ǛǜǚNJǗǏ� NjǏǛǙǚǘnjǘǎǗǘǓ� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǙǘnjǛǏǖǏǛǜǗǘ� ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǗǥǖ� ǒ� Ǚǘǡǜǒ� njǏǑǎǏ� ǛnjǘNjǘǎǗǥǖ�� Ƽǘǡǔǒ�NjǏǛǙǚǘnjǘǎǗǘǍǘ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�:L�)L� ǖǘǍǝǜ� NjǥǜǦ� ǘNjǗNJǚǝǐǏǗǥ� njǘ� ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjǏ�ǖǏǛǜ��ǙNJǚǔNJǟ��ǙǕǘǣNJǎǩǟ��ǙNJNjNJǟ��ǔNJǞǏ��ǚǏǛǜǘǚNJǗNJǟ��NJǧǚǘǙǘǚǜNJǟ��ǙǘǏǑǎNJǟ��NJnjǜǘnjǘǔǑNJǕNJǟ�ǒ�ǎNJǐǏ�ǝǎNJǕǏǗǗǥǟ�ǖǏǛǜNJǟ�ǜǒǙNJ�ǙǕǩǐNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǎNJǐǏ�nj�ǕǏǛǝ��ƫǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǘ� ǍǘǛǜǒǗǒǠ� ǒ� ǟǘǛǜǏǕǘnj� ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ� ǛnjǘNjǘǎǗǥǓ� ǒǗǜǏǚ-ǗǏǜ�nj�ǔǘǖǗNJǜNJǟ�ǒǕǒ�ǟǘǕǕNJǟ��ǁǜǘNjǥ�ǙǘǎǔǕǨǡǒǜǦǛǩ�ǔ�ǛǏǜǒ��ǗǏ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�bȃ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�njǔǕǨǡǒǜǦ�ǛnjǘǏ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǏ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjǘ��ǗNJǓǜǒ�ǙǘǎǟǘǎǩǣǝǨ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǝǨ�ǛǏǜǦ�ǒ�ǙǘǎǔǕǨǡǒǜǦǛǩ�ǔ�ǗǏǓ�

ƼNJǕǕǒǗǗ� ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǏǜ� ǛnjǘNjǘǎǗǥǓ� NjǏǛǙǚǘnjǘǎǗǘǓ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙ� nj� ǒǗǜǏǚ-ǗǏǜ�ǎǕǩ�ǍǘǚǘǐNJǗ�ǒ�ǍǘǛǜǏǓ�ǍǘǚǘǎNJ�nj����ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǟǘǜǛǙǘǜNJǟ�nj�ǍǘǚǘǎǏ��nj�ǧǜǘ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘ�ǗǏ�njǔǕǨǡǏǗǥ�ǢǔǘǕǥ�ǒ�NjǒNjǕǒǘǜǏǔǒ���ƸǗǒ�NjǥǕǒ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnj-ǕǏǗǥ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ��ƻǔǘǚǘǛǜǦ�ǑNJǍǚǝǑǔǒ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ����ǖǏǍNJNjǒǜ�nj�ǛǏǔǝǗǎǝ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ� ǚNJǛǙǚǏǎǏǕǩǨǜǛǩ� ǖǏǐǎǝ� njǛǏǖǒ� ǙǘǎǔǕǨǡǪǗǗǥǖǒ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏ-Ǖǩǖǒ��ƫǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǘ�ǟǘǛǜǙǘǜǘnj�ǙǘǔǚǥnjNJǏǜ�ǙǘǙǝǕǩǚǗǥǏ�ǚNJǓǘǗǥ�ƻǜNJǚǘ-Ǎǘ�ƭǘǚǘǎNJ��ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǙNJǚǔǒ�ǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǏ�ǙǚǒnjǕǏǔNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǎǕǩ�ǜǝǚǒǛǜǘnj�ǖǏǛǜNJ��ƼNJǔǐǏ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǜ�nj�NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǏ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦ-

�� KWWSV���ZZZ�ULD�HH�SXEOLF�NH\�LQIUDVWUXFWXUH�

19LJƻƼƸƷƲlj

Page 21: User identification analysis

Ǘǥǟ�ǝǡǚǏǐǎǏǗǒǓ��ƹǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǨ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǙǘǎǔǕǨǡǒǜǦǛǩ�ǔ�NjǏǛǙǚǘ-njǘǎǗǘǓ� ǛǏǜǒ� Ǚǘǎ� ǗNJǑnjNJǗǒǏǖ� 7DOOLQQ:Ζ)Ζ� NjǏǑ� njǛǩǔǒǟ� ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǓ�ǙǘbNJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�

Ƭ� ǎǘǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǏ� ǔ� ǛnjǘNjǘǎǗǘǖǝ�NjǏǛǙǚǘnjǘǎǗǘǖǝ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǝ� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝ-Ǐǜ�ǛǏǜǦ�NjǘǕǏǏ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǥǟ��ǑNJǔǚǥǜǥǟ�NjǏǛǙǚǘnjǘǎǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǏǓ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǗNJ�NJnjǜǘǑNJǙǚNJnjǔNJǟ��Ʋǖǒ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�njǘǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ��ǙǚǒǘNjǚǏǜǩ�NjǒǕǏǜ�ǗNJ�Ǜǝǜǔǒ�ǕǒNjǘ�ǗNJ�ǡNJǛ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ��ƮǕǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǎǘ-ǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǘǜǙǚNJnjǒǜǦ�606�ǙǘbNJǎǚǏǛNJǖ��ǝǔNJǑNJǗǗǥǖ�ǗNJ�NJnjǜǘǑNJǙǚNJnjǔNJǟ��Ƹǜ-njǏǜǗǥǖ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǏǖ�njǥǛǥǕNJǏǜǛǩ�ǒǖǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǒ�ǙNJǚǘǕǦ���

Ƭ�ƼNJǕǕǒǗǗǏ�� ƼNJǚǜǝ�ǒ�ƿNJǚǦǨǖNJNJ�njǕNJǛǜǒ�njnjǏǕǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǏ�NjǒǕǏǜǥ�ǎǕǩ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǜǚNJǗǛǙǘǚǜNJ��ǙǚǒnjǩǑNJǗǗǥǏ�ǔ�ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎǝNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǏ��ƹNJǛǛNJǐǒǚǥ�ǒǖǏǨǜ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǘǙǕNJǜǒǜǦ�ǙǚǘǏǑǎ�nj�ǔǒǘǛǔNJǟ��ǙǘbǒǗǜǏǚ-ǗǏǜǝ��Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ�ǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǛnjǘǨ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǝ�nj�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǙǚǘǏǑǎǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJ�bǜ�ɋǏ��ǞNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒbȃ�njǖǏǛǜǘ�NjǒǕǏǜNJ�

Ƭǘǜ�ǔNJǔ�ǘǙǒǛǥnjNJǏǜ�ǘǎǒǗ�ǒǑ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǙǘnjǛǏǎǗǏnjǗǥǓ�ǘǙǥǜ�ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ�nj�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǖ�ǜǚNJǗǛǙǘǚǜǏ��mƬǜǘǚǘǏ�ǡNJǛǜǘ�ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǘǏ�ǖǗǘǓ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǏ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥbȃ�ǙǘǔǝǙǔNJ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�Njǒ-ǕǏǜNJ�ǗNJ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǓ�ǜǚNJǗǛǙǘǚǜ��ƱNJǟǘǎǒǖ�ǗNJ�SLOHW�HH�� NJnjǜǘǚǒǑǝǏǖǛǩ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǒǕǒ�0RELOH�Ζ'��njǥNjǒǚNJǏǖ�ǗǝǐǗǥǓ�ǜǒǙ�Njǒ-ǕǏǜNJ��ǖǏǛǩǡǗǥǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǡNJǛǘnjǘǓ��ǒ�ǘǙǕNJǡǒnjNJǏǖ�ǏǍǘ��ƴǘǍǎNJ�nj�NJnjǜǘNjǝǛ�ǑNJǟǘ-ǎǩǜ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǪǚǥ��ǩ�ǙǚǘǛǜǘ�ǎNJǨ�ǛnjǘǨ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǝ��ǒ�ǙǘbǗǏǓ�Ǜ�NjǏǛǙǚǘnjǘǎǗǘǍǘ�ǚǒǎǏǚNJ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǩǏǜǛǩ�ǗNJǕǒǡǒǏ�ǝ�ǖǏǗǩ�NjǒǕǏǜNJ��ƯǣǪ�Ζ'�NjǒǕǏǜ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǔǝ-ǙǒǜǦ�Ǚǚǩǖǘ�Ǜ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ��ǙǘǑnjǘǗǒnj�ǗNJ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǪǗǗǥǓ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǒ�ǝǔNJǑNJnj�ǛnjǘǓ�ǕǒǡǗǥǓ�ǔǘǎ��ƻ�ǗNJǛǜǝǙǕǏǗǒǏǖ�ǔǚǒǑǒǛNJ�ǩ�ǛǜNJǕ�ǗǏǖǗǘǍǘ�ǡǒǜǏǚǒǜǦ11��ǙǘǔǝǙNJǩ�NjǒǕǏǜ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǔǘǍǎNJ�njǒǐǝ��ǡǜǘ�NJnjǜǘNjǝǛ�ǛǘNjǒǚNJǨǜǛǩ�ǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǦ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǪǚǥ��ƱnjǘǗǘǔ�NJǔǜǒnjNJǠǒǩ�NjǒǕǏǜNJ�ǑNJǗǒǖNJǨǜ���ǛǏǔǝǗǎ�ǒ�ǗǏ�ǗNJǎǘ�njǛǜNJnjNJǜǦ��ǛǝǎǘǚǘǐǗǘ�ǒǛǔNJǜǦ�ǔǘǖǙǘǛǜǏǚ�ǒ�ǙǚǘNjǒnjNJǜǦ�ǜNJǕǘǗǡǒǔ��ǁNJǛǘnjǘǓ�NjǒǕǏǜ�Ǜǜǘǒǜ����ǚǝNjǕǏǓ}���

ƻ�����bǍǘǎNJ�njǛǏ�ǧǛǜǘǗǛǔǒǏ�ǢǔǘǕǥ�ǒǖǏǨǜ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǚǏǎǘǓ�ǘNjǣǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǢǔǘǕǘǓ�ǒ�ǎǘǖǘǖ�E-kool��ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗNJǩ�ǢǔǘǕNJ���ǠǏǕǦ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓbȃ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǏ�ǝǡNJǛǜǒǏ�ǚǘǎǒǜǏǕǏǓ�nj�ǝǡǏNjǗǘǖ�Ǚǚǘ-ǠǏǛǛǏ�ǚǏNjǏǗǔNJ��NjǘǕǏǏ�ǙǚǘǛǜǘǓ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǚǘǎǒǜǏǕǏǓ�ǒ�ǝǡǏǗǒǔǘnj�ǔ�ǝǡǏNjǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǘNjǕǏǍǡǏǗǒǏ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�ǝǡǒǜǏǕǏǓ�ǒ�ǚǝǔǘnjǘǎǛǜnjNJ�ǢǔǘǕǥ��ƷNJ-ǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�(�NRRO�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǗNJNjǕǨǎNJǜǦ�ǑNJ�ǘǠǏǗǔNJǖǒ�ǝǡǏǗǒǔǘnj��ǙǚǘǙǝǣǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǝǚǘǔNJǖǒ��ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǗǒǏǖ�ǝǚǘǔǘnj��ǎǘǖNJǢǗǒǖǒ�ǑNJǎNJǗǒǩ-

�� KWWS���ZZZ�YLVLWHVWRQLD�FRP�HQ�WKLQJV�WR�NQRZ�DERXW�HVWRQLD�IDFWV�DERXW�HVWRQLD�ZLȴ�LQ�HVWRQLD11 ƸNjǖNJǗǥnjNJǜǦ��ǛǕǏǗǍ���� KWWS���KDEUDKDEU�UX�SRVW�������

20 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 22: User identification analysis

ǖǒ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǑNJ�ǜǏǖ��ǔNJǔ�ǝǡǒǜǏǕǩ�ǘǠǏǗǒnjNJǨǜ�ǝǡǏǗǒǔǘnj�nj�ǔǘǗǠǏ�ǔNJǐǎǘ-Ǎǘ�ǝǡǏNjǗǘǍǘ�ǙǏǚǒǘǎNJ��ƽǐǏ�ǔ�����bǍǘǎǝ�ǔ�(�NRRO�ǙǚǒǛǘǏǎǒǗǒǕǒǛǦ�ǛnjǥǢǏ����bǢǔǘǕ�ǙǘbnjǛǏǓ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ����Ɍ��njǛǏǟ�ǢǔǘǕ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ��

ƲǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘ�ǔNJǐǎǘǖ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗǏ�ǟǚNJǗǒǜǛǩ�nj�ǘNjǣǏǓ�NjNJǑǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ƷNJǑǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ�ǘǗNJ�;�5RDG�ǒ�nj�ǗǏǓ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǙǘǛǖǘǜǚǏǜǦ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǘ�ǛnjǘǏǓ�ǗǏ-ǎnjǒǐǒǖǘǛǜǒ��ǜǚNJǗǛǙǘǚǜǗǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJǟ��ǖǏǛǜǏ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ��ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjǔǏ��ǔǚǏǎǒ-ǜNJǟ��ǝǡǏNjǗǥǟ�ǑNJnjǏǎǏǗǒǩǟ�ǒ�ǎǒǙǕǘǖNJǟ��ǎNJǐǏ�ǘǠǏǗǔǒ�ǑNJ� ǍǘǛǧǔǑNJǖǏǗǥ�nj�ǢǔǘǕǏ�

ƻǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕ�RSHQLG�HH��LJǜǘ�ǗNJNjǘǚ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�Ǚǘ-ǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǎǏǕNJǜǦ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǨ�ǗNJ�ǛnjǘǪǖ�ǛNJǓǜǏ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�2SHQΖ'��LJǜǘǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�ǙǚǒnjǩǑNJǗ�ǔ�ǔ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǏ�ǒǕǒ�0RELOH�Ζ'��ƪnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘbΖ'�ǔNJǚǜǏ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǘǛǝ-ǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǘǙǕNJǜǥ�ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ǛǡǏǜǘnj�ǑNJ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǓ��ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ��ǜǏǕǏnjǒǎǏǗǒǏ�� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǒǡǏǛǜnjǘ�� ǍNJǑ�� njǘǎǝ�� ƯǛǜǦ� ǎNJǐǏ� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǖNJǍNJǑǒǗ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǒǔǒ��ǔǝǎNJ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�njǘǓǜǒ�Ǜ�ǏǪ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ��ƷNJ�ǛNJǓǜǏ�ǖǏǛǜǗǘǓ�ǍNJǑǏ-ǜǥ�(HVWL�3¦HYDOHKW�ǎǕǩ�ǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǔǘǖǖǏǗǜNJǚǒǩ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�NjǥǕǘ�ǜǘǐǏ�ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǝ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ��ǙǘǑǎǗǏǏ��ǧǜNJ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�NjǥǕNJ�ǑNJǔǚǥǜNJ�

Ƭ�ǛǞǏǚǏ�ǖǏǎǒǠǒǗǥ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǒǜǦ��ǔNJǔǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�ǑNJǙǚNJǢǒnjNJǕ�ǘ�ǗǏǖ�njǚNJǡ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘ-Ǎǘ�ǑǎǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǙǚǒnjǩǑNJǗNJ�ǔ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǏ��LJǜǘ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�NjǥǕǘ�ǛǎǏǕNJǜǦ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��nj�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�NJnjǜǘǔNJǜNJǛǜǚǘǞǥ��ǔǘǍǎNJ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ�ǗNJǟǘǎǒǜǛǩ�NjǏǑ�ǛǘǑǗNJǗǒǩ��ǘǗ�ǗǏ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǛǘǘNjǣǒǜǦ�ǘ�ǛǏNjǏ�ǖǏǎǒǔNJǖ�njǛǨ�ǗǏ-ǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ��ƼǏǖ�ǗǏ�ǖǏǗǏǏ��nj�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�ǘǛǜNJǨǜǛǩ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǘ�ǜǘǖ��ǔNJǔǝǨ�ǒǖǏǗǗǘ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�njǚNJǡǒ�ǑNJǙǚNJǢǒnjNJǕǒ�ǘ�ǙNJǠǒǏǗǜǏ�

Ƭ�ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛǞǏǚǏ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ��ǏǛǕǒ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ�ǗNJǟǘǎǒǜǛǩ�Ǚǘǎ�ǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǏǖ�ǒ�Ǚǚǘǜǒnj�ǗǏǍǘ� njǘǑNjǝǐǎǏǗǘ� ǝǍǘǕǘnjǗǘǏ� ǎǏǕǘ�� ǘǗ� njǘ� njǚǏǖǩ�ǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩ�ǝǐǏ�ǗǏ�ǛǖǘǐǏǜ�ǘǜǛǕǏǐǒnjNJǜǦ��ǔǜǘ�ǒ�ǔNJǔǒǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǘ�ǗǏǖ�ǑNJǙǚNJ-ǢǒnjNJǕ��Ʒǘ�ǔNJǔ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǘNjnjǒǗǏǗǒǩ�ǛǗǒǖNJǨǜǛǩ��ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�Ǜnjǘǒǖ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖ�ǝ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ�njǗǘnjǦ�ǘǜǔǚǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ�

LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǝǨ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǝ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�Ǜǘ-ǔǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�ǚNJǛǟǘǎǘnj�ǒ�ǝǕǝǡǢǏǗǒǩ�ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�Ǎǘ-ǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǏ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�ǖǏǎǒǠǒǗǛǔǘǖǝ�ǘNjǛǕǝǐǒnjNJǗǒǨ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǩ�Ǜnjǘǒ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�njǖǏǛǜǘ�ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǏǔ�ǛǜǚNJ-ǟǘnjǘǍǘ�ǖǏǎǒǠǒǗǛǔǘǍǘ�ǘNjǛǕǝǐǒnjNJǗǒǩ��ƹǘǕǒǠǒǩ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�ǒǗǜǏǍǚǒǚǘnjNJǕNJ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǏǔ�nj�ǛnjǘǨ�NjNJǑǝ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǜNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǘǕǒǠǏǓǛǔǒǏ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǒǟ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǒ�ǛǜNJǜǝǛNJ�njǘǎǒǜǏǕǏǓ�NJnjǜǘǖǘNjǒǕǏǓ��ǒǑNjNJnjǕǩǩ�njǘǎǒǜǏǕǏǓ�ǘǜ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǗǘǛǒǜǦ�Ǜ�ǛǘNjǘǓ�njǘǎǒǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǏ�

21LJƻƼƸƷƲlj

Page 23: User identification analysis

ǙǚNJnjNJ�� ƹNJǛǛNJǐǒǚǥ�� ǘNjǕNJǎNJǨǣǒǏ� ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǖǒ� ǕǦǍǘǜNJǖǒ� ǗNJ� ǙǚǘǏǑǎ��ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǖǘǍǝǜ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ� ǜNJǔǝǨ� ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǝ� njǖǏǛǜǘ� NjǒǕǏǜNJ� NjǏǑ� ǎǘǙǘǕ-ǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǓ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�nj�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǏ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǜǛǩ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǘNj�ǒǟ�ǛǜNJǜǝǛǏ�ǗNJ�ǘNjǕNJǎNJǗǒǏ�ǕǦǍǘǜNJǖǒ��ƫǘǕǏǏ�����ǜǥǛǩǡ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǝǨ� ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǝ� ǙǘǛǜǘǩǗǗǘ�� ƹǘǛǕǏ� ǎnjNJǎǠNJǜǒ� ǖǏǛǩǠǏnj�ǙǘǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ� ǧǜǘǓ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ� ǘǔǘǕǘ� ��Ɍ�� ǎǘǟǘǎǘnj� ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǚNJǗǛǙǘǚǜNJ�nj�ǧǜǒǟ�ǍǘǚǘǎNJǟ�ǛǜNJǕǒ�ǙǘǛǜǝǙNJǜǦ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǧǜǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�

LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ� ǧǞǞǏǔǜ� ǘǜ� ǎNJǗǗǘǓ� ǒǗǗǘnjNJǠǒǒ� ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ� ǙǚǒǑǗNJǜǦ�ǘǡǏǗǦ�ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǝǐǏ�ǔ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǖǝ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜǝ��Ƭ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJ-ǗǏǗǒǩ�ǎNJǗǗǘǓ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�ǗNJ�ǗǏ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǘnj�nj�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǑNJ�ǙǚǏǎǏǕǥ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ��ǎNJǗǗNJǩ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǩ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�njǛǏ�ǢNJǗǛǥ�ǛǜNJǜǦ�ǙǘǕǗǘ-ǠǏǗǗǘǓ�ǙǏǚǏǎǘnjǘǓ�ǘǜǚNJǛǕǦǨ�ǧǛǜǘǗǛǔǘǓ�ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǔǒ�

ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒ�ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ��ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ��nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒLJƻƼƸƷƻƴƲƳ� ƸƹDžƼ� ƮƸƻƼƸƯƷ� ǛNJǖǘǍǘ� ǙǚǒǛǜNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ� njǗǒǖNJǗǒǩ� nj� ǙǕNJǗǏ� ǑNJ-ǒǖǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǒ� ǙǚNJnjǘnjǥǟ� ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖǘnj� ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǏǎǒǗǘǓ�ǙǕNJǜǞǘǚǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ� ǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǥǟ� Ǜ�Ǘǒǖ� Ǎǘ-ǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ƹǚǏǎnjNJǚǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǙǏǚǏ-ǡǒǛǕǒǜǦ�ǏǍǘ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�

��� ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩ-Ǐǜ� nj� ǚNJǖǔNJǟ� ǘǎǗǘǓ� ǙǕNJǜǞǘǚǖǥ� ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�ǔNJǔ� ǜǒǙNJ� ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ��bȃ� ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ� ǜǘǐǎǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǗǏǒǑnjǏǛǜǗǘǍǘ� ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJ�� ǒǑnjǏǛǜǗǘǖǝ� ǗNJ� ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǒ� ǛǘnjǙNJǎǏǗǒǩ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǔǘnj��ǘǙǘǑǗNJǗǒǏ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ��bȃ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗǒǏ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJǖ�ǒ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜNJǖ� >nj�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǟ@�ǘǙǚǏǎǏ-ǕǪǗǗǥǟ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘnj� ǒ� �ǒǕǒ�� ǛǚNJnjǗǏǗǒǏ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚNJ�Ǜ� ǙǏǚǏǡǗǏǖ� ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗǗǥǟ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘnj�� LJǜǘ� ǘNjǤǩǛǗǩǏǜǛǩ�ǜǏǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗNJǩ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔNJ�ǒǍǚNJǏǜ�ǔNJǔ�ǚǘǕǦ�ǘNjǣǏ-ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǘǍǘ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�mǗNJǑǥnjNJǗǒǩ}�ǕǒǠNJ�nj�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒ-ǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�

��� LJǛǜǘǗǛǔǒǓ�ǘǙǥǜ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦ�NjǥǛǜǚǝǨ�ǒ�ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnj-ǗǝǨ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�� NjǕNJǍǘǎNJǚǩ� ǜǘǖǝ�� ǡǜǘ� ǘǗNJ� ǙǚǒnjǩǑNJǗNJ� ǔ�ǛǜǚǘǍǒǖ��ǛǔnjǘǑǗǥǖ�ǒ�ǜǚNJǗǛǙNJǚǏǗǜǗǥǖ�nj�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǖNJǛ-ǢǜNJNjNJǟ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚNJǖ�nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ���

��� LJǛǜǘǗǛǔǒǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǒ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ��ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝ-ǨǣǒǏ� ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ� mƱNJǔǘǗǝ� ǘNj� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ� ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǩǟ}� ǒ�

22 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 24: User identification analysis

mƱNJǔǘǗǝ� ǘNj� ǝǛǕǝǍNJǟ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ� ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjNJ}�� ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǜ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǨ��ǘǛǗǘnjǥnjNJǩǛǦ�ǗNJ�ǜǏǟ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜNJǟ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǟǚNJǗǩǜǛǩ�nj�ǖǘǎǝǕǩǟ�6Ζ0�nj�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǏ��'LJL�Ζ'�ǒ�0RELO�Ζ'�

��� LJǛǜǘǗǒǩ� ǙǚǘǎǘǕǐNJǏǜ� ǘǛǜNJnjNJǜǦǛǩ� ǛǜǚNJǗǘǓ� Ǜ� njǥǛǘǔǒǖ� ǝǚǘnjǗǏǖ�ǛnjǘNjǘǎ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��ƹǝNjǕǒǡǗǥǏ�NjǏǛǙǚǘnjǘǎǗǥǏ�ǛǏǜǒ�ǗǏ�ǜǚǏNjǝ-Ǩǜ�ǔNJǔǘǓ�Njǥ�ǜǘ�Ǘǒ�NjǥǕǘ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƬǙǚǘǡǏǖ��ǧǜNJ�ǘǛǘNjǏǗ-ǗǘǛǜǦ� ǔǘǖǙǏǗǛǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ� ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǒǏǖ� 0RELO�Ζ'�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ��njǏǚǘǩǜǗǘ��ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǛǕǝǐǒǜǦ�ǠǏǕǩǖ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǗNJǎǑǘǚNJ�

ƸǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ� ǙǏǚǏǗǩǜǒǩ� ǘǙǥǜNJ� LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ� ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnj-ǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǠǏǗǗǘǓ� ǜǘǡǔNJ� ǑǚǏǗǒǩ� ǎǒǚǏǔǜǘǚNJ� ǧǛǜǘǗǛǔǘǍǘ�ǀǏǗǜǚNJ� ǛǜǚNJǜǏǍǒ-ǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�m(OLRQ�(WWHYRWWHG}�ƸǕǏǍNJ�ǂnjNJǓǔǘnjǛǔǘǍǘ��mlj�ǑǗNJǔǘǖ�Ǜ�ǖǗǏǗǒǩǖǒ�ǜǏǟ��ǔǜǘ�ǘǙNJǛNJǏǜǛǩ�njnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ƽLJƴ�nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ��ƻNJǖǘǏ�ǒǗǜǏǚǏǛ-ǗǘǏ�� ǡǜǘ� ƽLJƴ�� ǔNJǔ� ǚNJǑ� ǗNJǘNjǘǚǘǜ�� ǛǙǘǛǘNjǛǜnjǝǏǜ� ǜǘǖǝ�� ǡǜǘ�� njǖǏǛǜǘ� ǠǏǗ-ǜǚNJǕǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�mǛǝǙǏǚNjNJǑǥ}��ǖǘǐǗǘ�NjǥǕǘ�njǥǛǜǚǘǒǜǦ�ǚNJǛǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǝǨ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ��ƷNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��nj�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�ǒǖǏǗǗǘ�ǧǜNJ�ǛǒǜǝNJǠǒǩ��ƽ�ǗNJǛ�ǗǏ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝ-Ǐǜ� ǔNJǔǘǓ�ǜǘ�ǏǎǒǗǘǓ�NjNJǑǥ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ƷNJǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǖǗǏ�ǒǑnjǏǛǜǗǘ�� nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ǜǘǐǏ�ǙǘǢǕǒ�ǙǘbǜǘǖǝbǐǏ�Ǚǝǜǒ��ƯǛǜǦ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǘǏ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘ�ǚǏǏǛǜǚǘnj�ǒ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗNJǩ� ǛǟǏǖNJ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�Ǘǒǖǒ�� ƼNJǔ��ǖǘǒ�ǞNJǖǒ-Ǖǒǩ��ǒǖǩ�ǒ�ǘǜǡǏǛǜnjǘ�NjǏǚǝǜǛǩ�ǒǑ�ǘǎǗǘǍǘ�ǚǏǏǛǜǚNJ��ǖǘǓ�NJǎǚǏǛbȃ�ǒǑ�ǎǚǝǍǘǍǘ�ǚǏǏǛǜǚNJ��NJ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǖǘǏǓ�ǖNJǢǒǗǥbȃ�ǒǑ�ǜǚǏǜǦǏǍǘ�ǚǏǏǛǜǚNJ��ƽ�ǔNJǐǎǘǍǘ�ǒǑ�ǧǜǒǟ�ǚǏǏǛǜǚǘnj�ǒǖǏǨǜǛǩ�Ǜnjǘǒ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ��ƴǚǘǖǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��nj�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǘǡǏǗǦ�ǛǒǕǦǗǥǓ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǩ�Ǜǘ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǘ-Ǎǘ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjNJ��ƽ�ǗNJǛ��ǔNJǔ�ǩ�ǝǐǏ�ǍǘnjǘǚǒǕ��ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǏǜ�NJǗNJǕǘǍ�ƻƶLJƬ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�ǗNJǑǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ�[�5RDG��LJǜǘ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕ��ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǔǘǜǘ-ǚǥǖ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚ�ǘNjǣNJǨǜǛǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǛǘNjǘǓ��ƸNjǣǏǗǒǏ�ǧǜǘ�ǙǚǘǒǛǟǘǎǒǜ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǘǛǘNjǥǟ�ǑNJǢǒǞǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�;0/�62$�ǔǘǗnjǏǚǜǘnj��ƴNJǐǎǥǓ�ǜNJǔǘǓ�ǔǘǗnjǏǚǜ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ�ǙǘǎǚǘNjǗǥǏ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǘ�ǜǘǖ��ǔǜǘ�ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǘ�ǧǜǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǑNJǙǚǘǛǒǕ��ƹǘ-ǧǜǘǖǝ�njǛǏ�ǐǒǜǏǕǒ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�nj�ǘǗǕNJǓǗǏ�ǙǚǘǛǕǏǎǒǜǦ��ǔNJǔǒǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǒ� ǔǘǍǎNJ� ǘ� ǗǏǖ� ǑNJǙǚNJǢǒnjNJǕǒǛǦ�� ǒ� ǔǜǘ� ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǘ� ǒǟ� ǑNJǙǚNJǢǒnjNJǕ�� ƷNJ�ǧǛǜǘǗǛǔǘǖ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕǏ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ�ǏǛǜǦ�ǖǏǛǜǘ��ǍǎǏ�ǔNJǐǎǥǓ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǝnjǒǎǏǜǦ�ǧǜǝ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ��Ǘǘ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǘ�ǛǏNjǏ��ƯǛǕǒ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗ�njǒǎǒǜ��ǡǜǘ�ǔǜǘ�ǜǘ�ǑNJǙǚNJǢǒnjNJǕ�ǘ�ǗǏǖ�ǜǝ�ǒǕǒ�ǒǗǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ��ǘǗ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�ǙǘǕǗǘǏ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǑNJǩnjǒǜǦ�ǘNj�ǧǜǘǖ�nj�mƲǗǛǙǏǔǠǒǨ�ǙǘbǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ}��NJ�ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔǒ�ǧǜǘǓ�Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǥ�ǙǚǘnjǏǎǝǜ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǝbȃ�ǙǚNJnjǘǖǘǡǗǥǖ�ǒǕǒ�ǗǏǜ�NjǥǕ�ǜNJǔǘǓ�ǑNJǙǚǘǛ}���

�� KWWS���H�JRY�E\�WKHPHV�HNVSHUW�LG�NDUWD�GLJL�LG�L�PRELO�LG�QRY\M�HOHNWURQQ\M�SDVSRUW�HVWRQFD

23LJƻƼƸƷƲlj

Page 25: User identification analysis

ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǛǎǏǕNJǜǦ�njǥnjǘǎ��ǡǜǘ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�� ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǨǣǏǓ� ǗNJǕǒǡǒǏ� ǝ� ǔNJǐǎǘǍǘ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ� Ǚǘǖǒǖǘ�ǘNjǣǏǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǘǍǘ� ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ� ǒǕǒ� ǎNJǐǏ� njǖǏǛǜǘ� ǗǏǍǘ� ǏǎǒǗǘǓ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǕǒNjǘ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�NJǕǦǜǏǚǗNJǜǒnjǗǥǏ�njNJ-ǚǒNJǗǜǥ� ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎǝNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǔNJǚǜǘǡǏǔ� ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǥǖ��ƹǘǎǘNjǗǥǏ� ǔNJǚǜǥ� ǎǘǕǐǗǥ� ǘNjǕNJǎNJǜǦ� ǝǗǒnjǏǚǛNJǕǦǗǥǖ� ǖǘǎǝǕǏǖ� ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�� ǏǎǒǗǥǖ� ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖǘǖ� NJǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� Ǘǘ� ǚNJǑ-ǕǒǡǗǥǖǒ� ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜNJǖǒ� NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ� ǎǕǩ� ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj��ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘ�ǒǗǛǙǒǚǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǔǘǗǔǝǚǏǗǠǒǒ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǚǩǎǘǖ� Ǎǘ-ǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�njǏǎǘǖǛǜnj��NjNJǗǔǘnj��Ǜǘǜǘnjǥǟ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǘnj�ǒ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘnj�ǙǘbǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǨ�NJǕǦǜǏǚǗNJǜǒnjǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ�ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǔǕǨǡǏnjǥǖ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ��Ǜǘ-ǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ��ǙǏǗǛǒǘǗǗǘǏ��ǖǏǎǒǠǒǗǛǔǘǏ�ǘNjǛǕǝǐǒnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒbǜ�ɋǙ����ǎǘ-ǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǖ�ǙǘbǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗǒǨ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��ǘǙǕNJǜNJ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǏǓ��ǢǜǚNJǞǘnj�ǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘǢǕǒǗ��ǘǟǚNJ-Ǘǥ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǚǩǎǔNJ�ǒbǜ�ɋǙ�b

ƻǂƪ

ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�ǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ14

Ƭ������ƭƸƮƽ�Ƭ�ƻǂƪ�ƫDžƵ�ƺƪƱƺƪƫƸƼƪƷ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ�ǙǘbNJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǛǘǛǜǘ-ǩǣǒǓ�ǒǑ�ǜǚǏǟ�ǡNJǛǜǏǓ��ǘNjǣǒǓ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǛǒǖǖǏǜǚǒǡǗǘǓ�ǒ�NJǛǛǒǖǏǜǚǒǡǗǘǓ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǒ���ƼǚǏǜǦǩ�ǡNJǛǜǦ�ǎNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJ�NjǥǕNJ�ǙǏǚǏǛǖǘǜǚǏǗNJ�nj�����Ȃ����bǍǘǎNJǟ��ƻǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ�ǙǘǛnjǩǣǏǗ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜǘnj�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖNJ�Ǜ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǖ�ǔǕǨǡǘǖ��Ƭ�ǛǜNJǗ-ǎNJǚǜǏ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǥ�ǙǩǜǦ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǘnj�ǎǕǩ�ǘǎǗǘǛǜǘǚǘǗǗǏǓ�ǒ�ǎnjǝǛǜǘǚǘǗǗǏǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǘnj�Ǜ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǖ�ǔǕǨǡǘǖ��Ƭ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǏ�ǙǚǒnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ�ǘǎǗǘ�ǒǑ�ǙǏǚ-njǥǟ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǓ�ǙǘǗǩǜǒǩ�mǛǜǚǘǍǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǚNJǛǛǖǘǜǚǏǗNJ�ǗǒǐǏ��ƻǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ�NjǥǕ�njnjǏǎǏǗ�nj�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏ�������������ǑNJǖǏ-ǗǪǗ������������ǗNJ�Ζ62�Ζ(&�����Ȃ�������

Ƭ�ǜǘǖbǐǏ�����bǍǘǎǝ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ�mƪǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜNJ�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘ-njNJǗǒǏǖ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǒ�Ǜ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǖ�ǔǕǨǡǘǖ}�NjǥǕ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǗ�1Ζ67��NJǖǏ-ǚǒǔNJǗǛǔǒǖ�ƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǒǗǛǜǒǜǝǜǘǖ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǘnj�ǒ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ��� Ǘǘ�NjǥǕ�ǘǙǝNjǕǒǔǘnjNJǗ�ǡǏǜǥǚǏ�ǍǘǎNJ�ǛǙǝǛǜǩ�����ǞǏnjǚNJǕǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ��ƮNJǗǗǥǓ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǩǏǜ�ǎnjNJ�ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜǘnj�nj�ǔǘǖ-

�� ƺNJǑǎǏǕ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗ�ǗNJ�ǛǜNJǜǦǏ�ƪ�Ɍƭ�ɊƻNJNjNJǗǘnjNJbȃ�mƸNjǑǘǚ�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǘǓ�ǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘǓ�NjNJǑǥ�ǙǘbǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}b���mƱNJǣǒǜNJ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��Ζ16Ζ'(}�ȟɋ���ǒǨǕǦ�NJnjǍǝǛǜ�������

24 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 26: User identification analysis

ǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǘǜǔǕǒǔNJ�ǒ�ǘǜǑǥnjNJ��ǘǎǒǗbȃ�ǎǕǩ�ǘǎǗǘǛǜǘ-ǚǘǗǗǏǓ��ǎǚǝǍǘǓbȃ�ǎǕǩ�ǎnjǝǟǛǜǘǚǘǗǗǏǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��LJǜǘǜ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ�ǚǏǔǘǖǏǗǎǝǏǜǛǩ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǜǦ�njǘ�njǛǏǟ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�njǏǎǘǖǛǜnjNJǟ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦ-ǑǝǨǣǒǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǗNJ� ǘǛǗǘnjǏ� ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǟ� ǔǕǨǡǏǓ� ǎǕǩ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǗǏǛǏǔǚǏǜǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�nj� ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǟ�ǒ�ǠǒǞ-ǚǘnjǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǟ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǛnjǩǑǒ��ǗǏ�ǙǘǎǙNJǎNJǨǣǒǟ�Ǚǘǎ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏ�ǛǏǔǠǒǒ������ǚNJǑǎǏǕNJ����ǒǕǒ�ǛǏǔǠǒǒ����������ǚNJǑǎǏǕNJ����ƴǘǎǏǔǛNJ�ƻǂƪ��ƮNJǗǗǥǓ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǒ�ǗǏǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�

ƸǎǗǒǖ�ǒǑ�ǔǘǚǘǜǔǒǟ��Ǘǘ�ǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǗǥǟ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��ǘǛǗǘnjǥnjNJǨǣǒǟǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜǘǖ�81&Ζ75$/�ǖǘǎǏǕǦǗǘǖ�ǑNJǔǘǗǏ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔǘǖ-ǖǏǚǠǒǒ�nj�ǖǒǚǏ��ǙǚǒǗǩǜǘǖ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ�nj�ƸǜǜNJnjǏ��ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǔNJǩ�ǎǏǔǕNJǚNJǠǒǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǠǒǒ��nj�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǖǗǘ-Ǎǘ� njǗǒǖNJǗǒǩ� ǝǎǏǕǏǗǘ� njǘǙǚǘǛNJǖ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� Ƭ� ǧǜǘǖ� ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǏ��ǝǡǒǜǥnjNJǩ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǦ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ� ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǠǒǒ��ǙǚǒǑǗNJǏǜǛǩ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǦ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�njǗǝǜǚǒ�ǛǜǚNJǗ�ǗǏǎǒǛǔǚǒǖǒǗNJ-ǠǒǘǗǗǥǖǒ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJǖǒ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǒǗǜǏǚǘǙǏǚNJNjǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝ-ǗNJǚǘǎǗǘǓ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǠǒǒ�

Ƭ�NJnjǍǝǛǜǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ�NjǥǕǒ�ǘǙǝNjǕǒǔǘnjNJǗǥ�ǚǏǔǘǖǏǗǎNJǠǒǒ��nj�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� 6$6/� �6LPSOH� $XWKHQWLFDWLRQ�DQG� 6HFXULW\� /D\HU�� ǙǚǘǛǜǘǓ� ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǒ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘ-Ǜǜǒ��� ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǗǥǓ�ǗNJ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJǟ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜNJ�� ƺǏǔǘǖǏǗ-ǎNJǠǒǒ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǎǘǚNJNjǘǜǔǘǓ�ǙǘǎǍǘǜǘnjǕǏǗǗǘǍǘ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǏǓ�1HWVFDSH�5)&�������ƶǏǟNJǗǒǑǖ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜNJ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǏǜ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ� Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ� ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘnj�ǞǘǚǖNJǜNJ� ƿ������ Ǘǘ�ǗǏ� ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǏǜ� ǠǏǕǘǛǜǗǘǛǜǦ� ǒ� ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�� ƸǗ� ǖǘǐǏǜ� ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�nj�ǜǏǟ�ǛǕǝǡNJǩǟ��ǔǘǍǎNJ�ǠǏǕǘǛǜǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒ�ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǨǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�

ƷNJ� ǘǛǗǘnjǏ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJ� nj� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ� NJǎǖǒǗǒǛǜǚNJǜǒnjǗǘ�NjǨǎǐǏǜǗǘǏ�ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ� �ƪƫƽ�� Ǚǚǒ� ƹǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǏ� ƻǂƪ� ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǕǘ� ǚǝǔǘnjǘǎǛǜnjǘ�ǙǘbǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǨ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗ-Ǘǥǖ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǏ�NjǥǕǘ�ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǏǗǘ�ƮǒǚǏǔǜǒnjǘǓ�����ǙǘǎǙǒǛNJǗ-ǗǘǓ� ƹǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǘǖ� nj� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ�� Ƭ� ƮǒǚǏǔǜǒnjǏ� ǗNJ� ǘǛǗǘnjǏ� ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǩ�ǛǜǏǙǏǗǒ� ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ� ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛNJ� ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ�ǒ�ǛǜǏǙǏǗǒ�ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ��Ǜ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ�ǍǚNJǐ-ǎNJǗǒǗ�ǎǘǕǐǏǗ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǒ�ǟǚNJǗǒǜǦ�ǒǑǎNJǗǗǘǏ�ǎǕǩ�ǗǏǍǘ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǏ�ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǏ� ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�� NjǥǕǘ� njǙǏǚnjǥǏ� njnjǏǎǏǗǘ� ǙǘǗǩǜǒǏ� ǍNJǚNJǗǜǒǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǜǚNJǗǑNJǔǠǒǓ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�

25ƻǂƪ

Page 27: User identification analysis

ƹǚǒ� ǧǜǘǖ� ǍNJǚNJǗǜǒǒ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� NjǥǕǒ� ǚNJǑǎǏǕǏǗǥ� ǗNJ� ǡǏǜǥǚǏ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�

��� ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǒǏ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗ-Ǘǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�

��� ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�

��� njǥǛǘǔǒǓ�ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�

��� ǘǡǏǗǦ�njǥǛǘǔǒǓ�ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�

ƮǒǚǏǔǜǒnjNJ�ǛǥǍǚNJǕNJ�ǚǘǕǦ�nj�ǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǒ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǘnj� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǒ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� nj� ƻǂƪ�� ƴNJǗNJǎǏ�� ƪnj-ǛǜǚNJǕǒǒ�ǒ�ǎǚ�

ǁǏǚǏǑ�ǎnjNJ�ǍǘǎNJ�nj�ƻǂƪ�NjǥǕ�njǥǙǝǣǏǗ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ��ǙǘǎǍǘǜǘnjǕǏǗǗǥǓ�1Ζ67�njǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǏ�ƮǒǚǏǔǜǒnjǥ��Ƭ�ǘǜǕǒǡǒǏ�ǘǜ�ǙǚǏǎǥǎǝǣǒǟ�ǚǝǔǘnjǘǎǩǣǒǟ�ǎǘ-ǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�njǖǏǛǜǘ�Ʋƪ�nj�ǧǜǘǖ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǏ�njǙǏǚnjǥǏ�njnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ�ǙǘǗǩǜǒǏ�3Ζ9��3HUVRQDO� ΖGHQWLW\� 9HULȴFDWLRQbȃ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔNJ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ���ƴ�ǧǜǘǖǝ�njǚǏǖǏǗǒ� �����bǍǘǎ��ǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗNJǩ�NjNJǑNJ�ƻǂƪ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǚNJǑnjǒǕNJǛǦ��nj�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǛǜǒ��ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�Ʋƪ�ǝǐǏ�ǛǜǚǘǒǕǒǛǦ���NJ�ǎǕǩ�njǥǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǩ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǓ�ƮǒǚǏǔǜǒnjǥ�ǘǛǜNJǕǘǛǦ�ǗǏ�ǜNJǔ�ǖǗǘǍǘbȃ�ǎǘǛǜǚǘǒǜǦ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ�ǍNJǚNJǗǜǒǓ�Ʋƪ��ƮǕǩ�ǧǜǘǍǘ�ǛǗNJǡNJǕNJ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǒ�ǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǎǘ-ǛǜǝǙ� ǚNJǑǎǏǕǩǨǜǛǩ� Ǚǘb ǚNJǑǗǥǖ� ǔǘǗǜǝǚNJǖ�� ǙǚǒǡǪǖ� ǔǘǗǜǝǚ� ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǖ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǘǖ�ǒǗǜǏǍǚǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ�Ǜǘ�ƻƴƽƮbȃ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǘǓ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǩ�ǒ�ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǘǖ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǛǖNJǚǜ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�Ǜ�5)Ζ'� �5DGLR�)UHTXHQF\�ΖGHQWLȴFDWLRQ�'HYLFHbȃ� ǚNJǎǒǘǖǏǜǔǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��� ƮǕǩ� ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǖ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǘǖ�njnjǘǎǩǜǛǩ�ǡǏǜǥǚǏ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�ǎǘnjǏǚǒǩ��ǍNJǚNJǗǜǒǓ��NJǝ-ǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƹǘǛǕǏ�ǘǠǏǗǔǒ�ǚǒǛǔǘnj�ǒ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǩ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǖǘǍǘ�ǝǚǘnj-Ǘǩ�ǛǜǚǘǍǘǛǜǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�NJǍǏǗǜǛǜnjNJ�ǒ�njǏǎǘǖǛǜnjNJ��ǖǘǍǝǜ� njǥNjǒǚNJǜǦ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǨ�� ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǏǜ�njǥǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǏ�ǎǕǩ�ǎNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�ǛǜǚǘǍǘǛǜǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǟǘǜǩbNjǥ�ǖǒǗǒǖNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǜǏǟ-ǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ǔ�

• NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚNJǖ��ǜǘǔǏǗNJǖ��• ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǨ� ǙǘǎǕǒǗǗǘǛǜǒ�� ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ� ǒ� ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǏ� ǧǕǏǔ-

ǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǓ��ǙǚǒnjǩǑǥnjNJǨǣǒǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǔ�NJǝǜǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǝ�

• ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖNJǖ� ǝǎNJǕǪǗǗǘǓ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǣǒǖ� Ǜǘ-NjǘǓ� ǔǘǖNjǒǗNJǠǒǨ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ� ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǓ�� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘ-ǚǘnj�ǒ�ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǘnj�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

26 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 28: User identification analysis

• ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖNJǖ� ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǩ�� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǖ� ǎǕǩ� ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǒ� ǚǏ-ǑǝǕǦǜNJǜǘnj�ǝǎNJǕǪǗǗǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǖ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJǖ�

ƸǛǘNjǘǏ�ǖǏǛǜǘ�nj�ǚNJǛǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǏǖǥǟ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǟ�ǑNJǗǒǖNJǏǜ�ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǛǜnjǘ�Ǚǘ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� 1Ζ6763� �������� ǜNJǔǐǏ� ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǗǗǘǏ�ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ƮǒǚǏǔǜǒnjǏ�ǒ�ǎǘǙǘǕǗǩǨǣǏǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ�ǜǏǘǚǏǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏ-Ǘǒǩ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJ��Ƭ�ǙǚǏNJǖNjǝǕǏ�ǎNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǚǝǔǘnjǘǎǛǜnjNJ�ǛǔNJǑNJǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǚǏǔǘǖǏǗ-ǎNJǠǒǒ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǜ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩǖ�ǚNJǑǎǏǕNJ��E� ����ǠǒǚǔǝǕǩǚNJ��ƺǏǔǘǖǏǗ-ǎNJǠǒǒ� ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ� ǎǘǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǏǖ� ǔ� ǚǏǔǘǖǏǗǎNJǠǒǩǖ� ƪƫƽ� Ǚǘb ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�njǏǎǘǖǛǜnj��nj�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǑNJǎNJǗǥ�ǡǏǜǥǚǏ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǘǜ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǓ�ǘǢǒNjǘǔ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǗǏǗNJǎǕǏǐNJǣǏǍǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǓ�

ƺǘnjǗǘ�ǡǏǚǏǑ��bǕǏǜ�ǙǘǛǕǏ�njǥǟǘǎNJ�ǙǏǚnjǘǓ�njǏǚǛǒǒ�)Ζ3638%�������NjǥǕ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǗ�ǒ�ǘǙǝNjǕǒǔǘnjNJǗ�ǝǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǗǥǓ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ�Ǚǘǎ�ǜǏǖbǐǏ�ǗNJǑnjNJǗǒǏǖ��Ƭ�njǏǚǛǒǒ�������ǝǡǜǏǗǥ�ǘǜǑǥnjǥ�ǒ�ǙǚNJnjǔǒ��ǙǘǛǜǝǙǒnjǢǒǏ�ǑNJ�Ǚǩ-ǜǒǕǏǜǒǏ�ǘǜ�njǏǎǘǖǛǜnj��ƹǚǒnjǏǎǪǖ�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǘǜǕǒǡǒǩ��ƬnjǏǎǏǗǘ�ǙǘǗǩǜǒǏ�mǠǏǙǘǡǔǒ�ǎǘnjǏǚǒǩ}��ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǒnjNJǏǖǘǓ�ǒǑǎNJǜǏǕǏǖ�ǛǖNJǚǜ�ǔNJǚǜǥbȃ�ǝǎǘ-ǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ��mǀǏǙǘǡǔNJ�ǎǘnjǏǚǒǩ}�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠǝ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǗǘnjǝǨ�ǔNJǚǜǝ�njǑNJǖǏǗ�ǛǔǘǖǙǚǘǖǏǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ��ǙǘǜǏǚǩǗǗǘǓ��ǝǔǚNJǎǏǗǗǘǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǘnjǚǏǐǎǪǗǗǘǓ��ǙǚǘǓǎǩ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǝǨ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ��ƶNJǔǛǒ-ǖNJǕǦǗǥǓ�Ǜǚǘǔ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǛǖNJǚǜ�ǔNJǚǜǥbȃ�ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ�ǙǚǘǎǕǏǗ�Ǜ���ǎǘ��bǕǏǜ��ƪǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�NJǛǒǖǖǏǜǚǒǡǗǥǟ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǘnj�ǛǎǏǕNJǗNJ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ��NJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǔNJǚ-ǜǥ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǛǒǖǖǏǜǚǒǡǗǥǟ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǘnjbȃ�ǗǏǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ��Ƭ�ǔNJǡǏ-ǛǜnjǏ�ǗǏǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJ�NJǔǜǒnjNJǠǒǒ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǒ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǘNjNJnjǕǏǗǘ�ǛǚNJnjǗǏǗǒǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǙNJǚNJǖǏǜǚǘnj�ǗNJ�ǔNJǚǜǏ�

ƪǖǏǚǒǔNJǗǛǔNJǩ�ǛǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǩ�mƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǛǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǔǒNjǏǚǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǛǜnjǏ}��167Ζ&�Ƭ�LJƹƸƿƽ�ƾƲǂƲƷƭƪ��ƿƪƴƯƺƻƼƬƪ��ǔǚNJǐǒ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǔǒ-NjǏǚǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǕǏǗǒǓ�ǘǜnjǏǜ�ǗNJ�ǎnjNJ�ǙǚǘǛǜǥǟ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJ��NJ�ǒǖǏǗǗǘ��mƴǜǘ�njǥ"}�ǒ�mƴNJǔ�njǥ�ǖǘǐǏǜǏ�ǧǜǘ�ǎǘǔNJǑNJǜǦ"}��ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǔǕǨǡǏnjǥǖ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǚǏǎǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǘǓ� ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ� nj� ǚǏǐǒǖǏ� mǘǗǕNJǓǗ}�� ƺǏǢǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǥ�Ǜ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǏǓ�ǕǒǠ�ǛǜNJǕǘ�ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘ�NJǔǜǝNJǕǦǗǥǖ�nj�Ǜnjǩ-Ǒǒ�Ǜ�ǚNJǛǢǒǚǏǗǒǏǖ�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǠǒǒ��ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖ�mǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚNJ-njǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ}�� ǜǚNJǗǛǙǘǚǜǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǒbǜ�ɋǎ��b ǜ�ɋǏ��ǚNJǛǢǒǚǏǗǒǏǖ�ǜǚNJǗǛǍǚNJ-ǗǒǡǗǘǍǘ� ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǡǏǛǜnjNJ� ǖǏǐǎǝ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǖǒ�� ƺǏǢǏǗǒǏ� njǘǙǚǘǛǘnj�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�njǏǎǏǗǒǩ�NjǒǑǗǏǛNJ�� ǑNJǣǒǜNJ� ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒ�ǙǚǘǡǏǏ� ǛnjǩǑǥnjNJǨǜǛǩ�� nj� ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�� Ǜ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏ-

27ƻǂƪ

Page 29: User identification analysis

ǖNJǜǒǔǘǓ� ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǖǒ� ǙNJǚǘǕǩǖǒ�� ƻǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǏ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎǥ�njǥǎNJǡǒ�ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǥǖ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜNJǖ�ǕǒǠNJǖ�ǙNJǚǘǕǏǓ�ǒ�ǕǘǍǒǗǘnj�nj�ǛǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǟ� ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩǟ�ǘǔNJǑǥnjNJǨǜǛǩ�ǗǏ� ǛǘnjǛǏǖ�NJǎǏǔnjNJǜǗǥǖǒ�ǒ�Ǚǚǒ-ǏǖǕǏǖǥǖǒ�

ƸǛǗǘnjǥ�ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒƷƯƻƶƸƼƺlj�Ʒƪ�ƼƸ��ǁƼƸ�ƼƯƺƶƲƷ�mƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲlj}�ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǗǘnjǥǓ��ǔǘǗ-ǠǏǙǜǝNJǕǦǗǥǏ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎǥ�ǙǘǩnjǒǕǒǛǦ�ǎNJnjǗǘ�nj�ǚǏǐǒǖǏ�mǘǞǞǕNJǓǗ}��ƹNJǛǙǘǚ-ǜNJ��njǘǎǒǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǏ�ǙǚNJnjNJ��ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ�ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔǘnj�ǒ�Ǚǚǘǡ�bȃ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜ-Ǜǩ�ǡNJǛǜǦǨ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ� ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛ� ǘǜnjǏǡNJǏǜ� ǗNJ� njǘǙǚǘǛ� mƴǜǘ� ǜǥ"}� LJǜǘ�njǥǙǘǕǗǩǏǜǛǩ�ǕǒǠǘǖ��ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǨǣǒǖ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJ��ǒ�ǑNJǔǕǨǡNJǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǛǚNJnjǗǏǗǒǒ�ǘǎǗǘǍǘ�ǒǕǒ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǒǟ�ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�NJǜǚǒNjǝǜǘnj��ǒǖǩ��NJǎǚǏǛ��ǚǘǛǜ��661��ǖǏǛǜǘ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�ǒbǜ�ɋǙ���Ǜ�ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǥǖ�ǕǒǠǘǖ��Ƭ�ǔǘǗǠǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛNJ��ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǘ�ǕǒǠǏ�ǡNJǣǏ�njǛǏǍǘ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǥ�nj�NjǝǖNJǐǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ�ǒǕǒ�nj�ǞǘǚǖǏ�ǧǕǏǔ-ǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ� ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJ�� njǥǙǝǣǏǗǗǘǍǘ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ� ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏ-ǚǘǖ��ǜNJǔ�ǗNJǑǥnjNJǏǖǥǏ�mǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǥ}�

ƴǘǍǎNJ�ǕǒǠǘ�ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǩǏǜ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜ�ǒ�ǛǘNjǒǚNJ-ǏǜǛǩ�ǛǘnjǏǚǢǒǜǦ�ǔNJǔǒǏ�ǕǒNjǘ�ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǥǏ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǑNJNjǚǘǗǒ-ǚǘnjNJǜǦ�NjǒǕǏǜ��ǑNJǓǜǒ�nj�ǔǘǚǙǘǚNJǜǒnjǗǝǨ�ǛǏǜǦ�ǒ�Ǚǚǘǡ����ǜǘ�ǘǗ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��Ǜ�ǜǏǖ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǛnjǘǨ�Ǖǒǡ-ǗǘǛǜǦ��ƴNJǔ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǕǒǠǘ�Ǚǚǘǟǘǎǒǜ�ǝǛǙǏǢǗǝǨ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ��ǘǚǍNJǗǒ-ǑNJǠǒǩ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǏǜ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ��5HO\LQJ�3DUW\��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǩ�mǘNjǤǏǖNJ�njǘǑǖǘǐ-ǗǘǛǜǏǓ}�ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǘǍǘ�ǕǒǠNJ��ǒ�ǧǜǘ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǏǖ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJ�mǁǜǘ�njǥ�ǖǘǐǏǜǏ�ǛǎǏǕNJǜǦ"}�

ƮǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ� ǙǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ� ǙǚǒǖǏǚǘǖ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǩ� Ǜ� NjNJǗ-ǔǘǖNJǜǘǖ��ǔǘǍǎNJ�ǕǒǠǘ��ǒǖǏǨǣǏǏ�ǛǡǏǜ�nj�ƫNJǗǔǏ�ƪ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǥ��njǥǙǝǣǏǗǗǥǏ�ǧǜǒǖ�NjNJǗǔǘǖ� �ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗNJǩ�ǔNJǚǜNJ���ǡǜǘNjǥ� ǛǗǩǜǦ� ǗNJǕǒǡǗǥǏ� Ǜ� NjNJǗǔǘǖNJǜNJ�� ǗNJǟǘǎǩǣǏǍǘǛǩ� nj� ƫNJǗǔǏɊƬ�ɊǁǏǚǏǑ�ǛǏǜǦ�ƫNJǗǔ�Ƭ�ǛnjǩǑǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ�Ǜ�ƫNJǗǔǘǖ�ƪ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǒǜǦ�ǙǘǎǕǒǗǗǘǛǜǦ�ǕǒǠNJ�bǜ�ɋǏ��ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ��nj�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǛǜǒ��njnjǏǎǏǗbǕǒ�njǏǚ-ǗǥǓ�ƹƲƷ�ǔǘǎ���ǒ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǪǗǗǝǨ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚ-ǖNJǠǒǨ��ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘbǕǒ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�ǗNJ�ǛǡǪǜǏ�ǎǕǩ�ǛǤǪǖNJ�ǗNJǕǒǡǗǥǟ��njǒǎ�njNJ-ǕǨǜǗǘǓ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�Ǚǚǘǡ���

ƽǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǘǖ�njǔǕǨǡNJǏǜ�nj�ǛǏNjǩ�ǎnjNJ�ǔǕǨǡǏnjǥǟ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛNJ�

28 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 30: User identification analysis

• ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛ�njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�NJǜǚǒ-Njǝǜǘnj�ǘ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜǏ�ǒ�njǥǙǝǛǔ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��ǠǒǞ-ǚǘnjǥǟ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj���ǘǜǚNJǐNJǨǣǒǟ�NJǜǚǒNjǝǜǥ�

• ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛ� ǎNJǕǦǗǏǓǢǏǓ� njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǘǍǘ� ǕǒǠNJ�� ǙǚǏǎ-ǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǣǏǍǘ� ǎNJǗǗǥǏ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ� ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǥ� �ǠǒǞǚǘ-njǥǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǥ��ǒ�ǑNJǩnjǕǩǨǣǏǍǘ�ǘ�ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǒǖǏǗǗǘ�ǘǗ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǖ�ǕǒǠǘǖ��NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǩ��

ƻǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥƬƪưƷDžƶ�ƸƫǃƯƹƺƲƷljƼDžƶ�ƪƻƹƯƴƼƸƶ�ƻƸƱƮƪƷƲlj�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔNJ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ� ǜǘǚǍǘnjǕǒ� ǒ� ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǏ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�� ƷǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ� ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnj�� ǖǏǐǙǚNJnjǒ-ǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�Ǟǘǚǝǖǘnj�ǒ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǟ�ǍǚǝǙǙ�ǝǐǏ�ǚNJNjǘǜNJǨǜ�ǗNJǎ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǏǖ�ǎNJǗǗǘǍǘ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJ�

ƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗNJǩ� ǛǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǩ� ƻǂƪ� ǙǥǜNJǏǜǛǩ� ǗNJǓǜǒ� ǙǝǜǦ� njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓ-Ǜǜnjǒǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǖ�ǒ�ǙǝNjǕǒǡǗǥǖ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚNJǖǒ�nj�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǒ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǥ�ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǘǓ�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��Ƭ�ǘǜǕǒǡǒǏ�ǘǜ�Ưƻ��ǛǜǚNJǜǏ-Ǎǒǩ�ǒǛǟǘǎǒǜ�ǒǑ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǗǏ�ǙǕNJǗǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ��NJ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔNJ�ǎǘNjǚǘnjǘǕǦǗǘǓ�njǑNJǒǖǘǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǧǔǘǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��Ƭ�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP�ǛǝNjǤǏǔ-ǜǥ�Njǝǎǝǜ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�njǥNjǘǚ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�ǘǜ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǟ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘnj��ƹǘǧǜǘǖǝ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǔǘǜǘ-ǚNJǩ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗNJ� �ǘǜ�ǞNJǕǦǛǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� ǟNJǔǏǚǛǜnjNJ�ǒ�Ǚǚǘǡ���� ǘNjǕNJǎNJǏǜ�njǑNJ-ǒǖǘǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǘǛǜǦǨ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj� �ǘǎǒǗ� ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜ�ǖǘǐǏǜ� NjǥǜǦ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗ� ǖǗǘǍǒǖǒ� ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǥǖǒ� ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJǖǒ��� ǎǘNjǚǘ-njǘǕǦǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǝǡNJǛǜǒǩ��ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ�ǑNJ�ǚNJǑǝǖǗǝǨ�ǠǏǗǝ�ǒ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǗNJǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�njǛǏǖǒ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜNJǖǒ�

ƮǕǩ� ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ� ǙǘǎǘNjǗǘǓ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ� ǘNjǚNJǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ� ǎǘnjǏ-ǚǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ� Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǥ�� njǔǕǨǡNJǨǣǏǓ� ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ�ǔǘǖǙǘǗǏǗǜǥ�

• ƼǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǛǙǏǠǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ��ǙǚNJnjǒǕNJ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�ǒ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ǔǘǜǘ-ǚǥǏ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥ�ǎǕǩ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ�ǚNJNjǘǜǘǛǙǘǛǘNjǗǘǛǜǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��LJǜǘ�njǔǕǨǡNJǏǜ�nj�ǛǏNjǩ�ǒ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǔ�ǚNJNjǘǜǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��ǒ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏ-ǗǒǏ�ǚǘǕǏǓ�ǒ�ǘNjǩǑNJǗǗǘǛǜǏǓ�ǝǡNJǛǜǗǒǔǘnj��ǒ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǍNJǚNJǗ-ǜǒǓ� ǑNJǣǒǜǥ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�� NjǏǛǙǏǚǏNjǘǓǗǘǓ� ǒ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛ-ǗǘǓ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�

29ƻǂƪ

Page 31: User identification analysis

• Ʒǘǚǖǥ�ǙǚNJnjNJ��ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǩǨǣǒǏ�ǙǚNJnjNJ�ǒ�ǘNjǩǑNJǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜǘnj�ǒ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǨǣǒǏ�ǙǚǒǗǝǎǒǜǏǕǦǗǝǨ�ǑNJǣǒǜǝ�Ǚǚǒ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ��LJǜǘ�njǔǕǨǡNJǏǜ�nj�ǛǏNjǩ�ǔNJǔ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǏ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǏ�ǝǛǜNJ-ǗNJnjǕǒnjNJǏǜ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǘ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǓ�ǞǘǚǖNJǜ�ǚǏǍǝ-ǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�bǜ�ɋǏ��mǛnjǘNjǘǎǝ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǘnj}�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜǘnj�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǓ�

ƸǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǥƹƺƸƯƴƼ��ƷƪƱƬƪƷƷDžƳ�mƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǛǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǔǒNjǏǚ-ǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǛǜnjǏ}�� NjǥǕ� ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǗ� ƪǎǖǒǗǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǏǓ� ƹǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ� ƻǂƪ� Ǜ�ǙǚǒnjǕǏǡǏǗǒǏǖ� njǛǏǟ� ǑNJǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ� ǛǜǘǚǘǗ�� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǘǍǘ� ǘNjǣǏ-ǛǜnjNJ��ǗNJǝǡǗǘǍǘ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǛǜnjNJ��ǡNJǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚNJ�ǒ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ��ƻǜǚNJǜǏ-Ǎǒǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǗǏǘǞǒǠǒNJǕǦǗǘ�ǗNJǑnjNJǗǗNJǩ�m2EDPD1HW}��NjǥǕNJ�ǚNJǛ-ǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗNJ�nj�ǒǨǗǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǎǕǩ�ǢǒǚǘǔǘǍǘ�ǘNjǛǝǐǎǏǗǒǩ����Ƭ�NJǙǚǏǕǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ�NjǥǕNJ�ǘǙǝNjǕǒǔǘnjNJǗNJ�ǘǔǘǗǡNJǜǏǕǦǗNJǩ�ǚǏǎNJǔǠǒǩ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJ��ǗNJ-ǑnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ�mƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǛǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǔǒNjǏǚǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗ-ǛǜnjǏ�� ƺNJǛǢǒǚǏǗǒǏ� ǛǏǜǏnjǘǍǘ� njǥNjǘǚNJ�� ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ�� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ� ǒ�ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ}� �1DWLRQDO� 6WUDWHJ\� IRU� 7UXVWHG� ΖGHQWLWLHV� LQ�&\EHU-VSDFH� (QKDQFLQJ�2QOLQH�&KRLFH��(ɝFLHQF\��6HFXULW\��DQG�3ULYDF\� 167Ζ&���ǎNJ-ǕǏǏbȃ�mΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP}�ǒǕǒ�mƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}���

ƹǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǧǜǘ�ǎǘnjǘǕǦǗǘ�ǘNjǤǏǖǗǥǓ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜ��ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǠǏǕǏ-ǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǥǖ�ǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǦǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǔǕǨǡǏnjǥǟ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǩǟ�ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǒ�ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

��� ƸǛǗǘnjǗNJǩ� ǑNJǎNJǡNJ� ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǛǘǛǜǘǒǜ� nj� ǔNJǚǎǒ-ǗNJǕǦǗǘǖ�ǙǘnjǥǢǏǗǒǒ�ǗNJǎǏǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǝǔǚǏǙǕǏǗǒǒ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǣǏǓ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǦ�ǚǏNJǕǦǗǝǨ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�

��� ƴǒNjǏǚǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǛǜnjǘ�ǚNJǛǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǘǎǗǘǓ�ǒǑ�njNJǐǗǏǓ-Ǣǒǟ�ǧǕǏǖǏǗǜǘnj�ǐǒǑǗǏǗǗǘ�njNJǐǗǘǓ�� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝ-ǚǥ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ��ƴǒNjǏǚǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǛǜnjǘ�ǗǝǐǎNJǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǜNJǔǘǓbǐǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��ǔNJǔ�ǒ�ǕǨNjNJǩ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗNJǩ��ǐǒǑǗǏǗǗǘ�njNJǐǗNJǩ�ǒǗ-ǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚNJ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ��ǒ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǔǒNjǏǚNjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘ-Ǜǜǒ�ƻǘǏǎǒǗǏǗǗǥǏ�ǂǜNJǜǥ�ǛǡǒǜNJǨǜ�mǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǙǚǒǘǚǒǜǏǜǘǖ}�

��� ƴǒNjǏǚ�NJǜNJǔǒ��ǔǒNjǏǚ�ǔǚNJǐǒ��ǎǒǞǞNJǖNJǠǒǩ��ǔǒNjǏǚ�ǖǘǢǏǗǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǒ�nj�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǘǓ�ǛǞǏǚǏ��ǚǘǑǗǒǡǗǘǓ�ǜǘǚǍǘnjǕǏ�ǒ�Ǚǚǘǡ���ǔNJǔ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕǘ��ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǟǒǣǏǗǒǩ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�

�� ƹǚǘǏǔǜɊǛǖ��KWWS���ZZZ�GKV�JRY�[OLEUDU\�DVVHWV�QVBWLF�SGI�� ƻǖ�� KWWS���ZKDWLV�WHFKWDUJHW�FRP�GHȴQLWLRQ�LGHQWLW\�HFRV\VWHP�KWPO�� NJ� ǜNJǔǐǏ� KWWS���ZZZ�ZKLWHKRXVH�JRY�VLWHV�GHIDXOW�ȴOHV�UVVBYLHZHU�167Ζ&VWUDWHJ\B�������SGI�� ƻ�ɊƹǘǙǛǝǕǒǗ� KWWS���SG�UVRF�UX�SUHVV�VHUYLFH�VXEMHFW��QHZV����KWP

30 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 32: User identification analysis

ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǗǏ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǒǚǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǛNJ-ǖǒǖǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǖǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�nj�ǛǒǕǝ�ǛǕNJNjǘǓ�ǑNJǣǒǣǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǜNJǔǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǗǥǟ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǏǓ�ǛNJǖǒǟ�ǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�

��� ƹǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜ�ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǏ�ǡǒǛǕǘ� ǝǡǏǜǗǥǟ� ǑNJǙǒǛǏǓ�� ǙNJǚǘǕǏǓ�� ǒǗǥǟ� ǕǒǡǗǥǟ� NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǓ��ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥǟ� ǎǕǩ� ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ� ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ� ǝǛǕǝǍ� nj� ǚǏǐǒǖǏ� ǘǗ-ǕNJǓǗ�ǘǜ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ��ǙǚǏǎǕǘǐǏǗǘ�ǛǘǑǎNJǜǦ�mƻǒǛǜǏǖǝ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}��mΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP}����

��� ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǏǜ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǏǎǒǗǥǟ�ǙNJ-ǚNJǖǏǜǚǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǒ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩ-Ǐǜ�� Ǜ�ǘǎǗǘǓ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ��ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�mǙǘǎǕǒǗǗǘǛǜǦ}�ǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǘǏ�ǒǕǒ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǘǏ�ǕǒǠǘ��nj�ƻǏǜǒ��Ǜ�ǎǚǝǍǘǓ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ��ǙǘnjǥǛǒǜǦ�ǛNJǖǘ�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǘ�ǗNJǎǏǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj� ǔǒNjǏǚǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǛǜnjǏ� Ǜ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦǨ� ǛǘǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ� NJǗǘǗǒǖǗǘ-Ǜǜǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�

��� ƸǛǗǘnjǘǓ� ǞǘǚǖǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ΖGHQWLW\� (FRV\VWHP� ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ� ǛǕǏǎǝǨ-ǣǒǏ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǗNJǡNJǕNJ�

• ǎǘNjǚǘnjǘǕǦǗǘǏ� ǝǡNJǛǜǒǏ� ǕǨNjǘǍǘ� ǑNJǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ� ǕǒǠNJ� nj� ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǒ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ� �ǝǡǏǜǗǥǟ�� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� ǎǕǩ� ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ�mǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}���ƱNJǖǏǜǒǖ��ǡǜǘ�nj�ǟǘǎǏ�ǘNjǛǝǐǎǏ-Ǘǒǩ�ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP�ǙǘǩnjǒǕǛǩ�ǜǏǚǖǒǗ�mǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜ}����

• ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ� ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖǘnj� ǝǛǒǕǏǗǒǩ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ� ǙǏǚǛǘ-ǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ��ǝǡǏǜǗǥǟ��ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǒǗ-ǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�

• ǛǘnjǖǏǛǜǒǖǘǛǜǦ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ� �ǝǡǏǜǗǥǟ�� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏ-ǖǥǟ�Ǚǚǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

• ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�NjǥǜǦ�ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǓ��ǙǚǘǛǜǘǓ�nj�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǒ�ǕǏǍǔǘǎǘǛǜǝǙǗǘǓ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǘǛǜNJnjǣǒǔǘnj�ǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�

��� ƲǛǟǘǎǗǥǖ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǜǘ�� ǡǜǘ� ΖGHQWLW\� (FRV\VWHP� njǔǕǨǡNJǏǜ� ǜǚǒ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�� NJ� ǒǖǏǗǗǘ�� ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ� ǚǝǔǘnjǘǎǛǜnjNJ� �*RYHUQDQFH� /D\HU��� ǗNJ�

�� Ƭ� ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔǏ� ΖGHQWLW\� (FRV\VWHP�� Ǚǘǖǒǖǘ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjNJ� ǜǘǚǍǘnjǕǒ�� ǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǏǜ� ǝǡNJǛǜǒǏ�ƻǜǧǗǞǘǚǎǛǔǒǓ�ǝǗǒnjǏǚǛǒǜǏǜ��� Ƭ�ǟǘǎǏ�ǘNjǛǝǐǎǏǗǒǩ�ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP�ǙǘǩnjǒǕǛǩ�ǜǏǚǖǒǗ�mǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜ}��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��Ǜǖ��KWWS���KDEUDKDEU�UX�EORJV�LQIRVHFXULW\����������ƴǘǗǠǏǙǠǒǩ�mǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ}��ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP��ǔNJǐǏǜǛǩ�ǙǚǒnjǕǏǔNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǚǏǡǦ�ǒǎǏǜ�ǘ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǒ�ǏǎǒǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�ǛǖǘǍǝǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗǥ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǎǕǩ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǍǘ�ǒǕǒ�NJǗǘǗǒǖǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛNJǓǜNJǖ�NjǏǑ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǑNJǙǘǖǒǗNJǜǦ�NjǘǕǦǢǘǏ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘ�ǕǘǍǒǗǘnj�ǒǕǒ�ǙNJǚǘǕǏǓ��ƷǏǛǖǘǜǚǩ�ǗNJ�ǜǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǎNJǗǗNJǩ�ǔǘǗǠǏǙǠǒǩ�ǔNJǐǏǜǛǩ�ǗǏǛǕǘǐǗǘǓ��njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǏ�ǏǏ�ǗNJ�ǙǚNJǔǜǒǔǏ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǘǜǗǨǎǦ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǘǛǜǘǓ�ǑNJǎNJǡǏǓ�

31ƻǂƪ

Page 33: User identification analysis

ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖ� ǝǛǜNJǗNJnjǕǒnjNJǨǜǛǩ� ǙǚNJnjǒǕNJ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ�ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ� �0DQDJHPHQW� /D\HU���ǒ�ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǩ� �([HFX-WLRQ�/D\HU���ǗNJ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖ�nj�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ�Ǜ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕNJǖǒ��ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩ-ǨǜǛǩ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǕǒǠ�

��� ƹǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǏ� ΖGHQWLW\� (FRV\VWHP�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǒǜ� ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜNJǖ� ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒ-ǔNJǠǒǓ� ǘNjǖǏǗǒnjNJǜǦǛǩ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǏǓ� nj� ǙǚǏǎǏǕNJǟ�� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥǟ�nj� ǎNJǗǗǘǖ� ǔǘǗǜNJǔǜǏ� NjǏǑ� ǙǘǕǗǘǓ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏ-ǕǏǓ�bǜ�ɋǏ��Ǜ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǛǘǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�NJǗǘǗǒǖǗǘǛǜǒ��ƻǚǏǎǛǜnjNJ��ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǝǨǣǒǏ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�Njǝǎǝǜ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǘnjNJǜǦ�nj�ǞǘǚǖNJǜNJǟ�ǛǖNJǚǜ�ǔNJǚǜ�� ǡǒǙǘnj� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�� njǛǜǚǘǏǗǗǥǟ� nj� ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǥ��ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǟ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǘnj��ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǗǘǍǘ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǜǘnj��86%�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ�ǒ�Ǚǚǘǡ�

��� Ƭ�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜǘnj�ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP�njǥǛǜǝǙNJǨǜ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǕǒǠNJ��ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǕǒǠNJ��ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ��ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ���ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦ-ǗǘǛǜǦ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǘǟnjNJǜǥnjNJǏǜ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǞǘǚǖNJǜ�mǘǗǕNJǓǗ}�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ���ƹǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǜǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘ�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJ-ǍNJǏǜ� ǔǘǚǚǏǕǩǠǒǨ� Ǜ� ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǩǖǒ�� ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǖǥǖǒ� nj� ǚǏǐǒǖǏ�mǘǞǞǕNJǓǗ}��

���� ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��3HUVRQDOO\�ΖGHQWLȴDEOH�ΖQ-IRUPDWLRQ��nj�ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP�ǑǒǐǎǏǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ƹǚǒǗǠǒǙNJǟ�ǎǘNjǚǘǛǘ-njǏǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��m)DLU�ΖQIRUPDWLRQ�3UDFWLFH�3ULQFLSOHV}��

���� ƶǘǗǒǜǘǚǒǗǍ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩ-ǏǜǛǩ� ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǖ� ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǖ� ƪǍǏǗǜǛǜnjǘǖ� ƻǂƪ� nj� ǕǒǠǏ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjNJ� ǜǘǚǍǘnjǕǒ�� �ƹǏǚnjǘǗNJǡNJǕǦǗǘ� ǙǚǏǎǕNJǍNJǕǘǛǦ�� ǡǜǘ� nj�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ� ǜNJǔǘǍǘ� ǘǚǍNJǗNJ� NjǝǎǏǜ� njǥǛǜǝǙNJǜǦ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjǘ� ǗNJǠǒǘ-ǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��

ƹǚNJnjǘnjǥǏ�ǔǘǗǠǏǙǠǒǒ�nj�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�176Ζ&ƻƼƺƪƼƯƭƲlj� ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ� ƲƻƿƸƮƲƼ� ƲƱ� ƼƸƭƸ�� ǡǜǘ� ƹǚǒǗǠǒǙǥ� ǎǘNjǚǘǛǘ-njǏǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ� �m)DLU� ΖQIRUPDWLRQ� 3UDFWLFH� 3ULQ-FLSOHV}��� ǎNJǕǏǏbȃ� mƹǚǒǗǠǒǙǥ� )Ζ33}�� ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ� ǘǛǗǘnjǘǙǘǕNJǍNJǨǣǒǖǒ� nj�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔǏ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǘnj� ǗNJǎǏǐǗǥǟ� ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖǘnj� ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ� Ǚǘǎ-ǕǒǗǗǘǛǜǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ� ǗǏǘǜǤǏǖǕǏǖǘǓ� ǡNJǛǜǦǨ� ƻǜǚNJǜǏ-Ǎǒǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��� ǒ� ǘǛǗǘnjǘǓ� ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ΖGHQWLW\� (FRV\V-WHP�� Ƭb ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǘǜǖǏǡNJǏǜǛǩ�� ǡǜǘ� ƹǚǒǗǠǒǙǥ� )Ζ33�

�� ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� ƹǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ� ƪ� �$SSHQGL[� $�� KWWS���ZZZ�ZKLWHKRXVH�JRY� VLWHV�GHIDXOW�ȴOHV�UVVBYLHZHU�167Ζ&VWUDWHJ\B�������SGI�

32 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 34: User identification analysis

ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ� ǘNjǣǏǙǚǒǑǗNJǗǗǘǓ� NjNJǑǘǓ� ǎǕǩ� ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ� ǖǏǜǘǎǘnj�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǎǕǩ�NJǗNJǕǒǑNJ�ǒ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ��ǙǚǘǠǏǛ-Ǜǘnj�ǒǕǒ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖ��njǕǒǩǨǣǒǟ�ǗNJ�ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ƹǚǒǗǠǒǙǥ�)Ζ33�ǙǚǒǑnjNJǗǥ�ǑNJǣǒǣNJǜǦ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�Ǚǚǒ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǏǗǒǒ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ�nj�ǚǏǐǒǖǏ�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ��ƽǗǒnjǏǚǛNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏ-ǗǏǗǒǩ�ƹǚǒǗǠǒǙǘnj� )Ζ33�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǏǜ� ǘǛǗǘnjǝ� ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ�ǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǗǘǛǜǒ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ��ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǖǥǟ�nj�ǘǗǕNJǓǗǘnjǘǖ�ǞǘǚǖNJǜǏ�

ƲǛǜǘǚǒǡǏǛǔǒ� ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǏǗǒǏ� ƹǚǒǗǠǒǙǘnj� )Ζ33� ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǛǩ� ǔ� ����b Ǎ���ǔǘǍǎNJ� ǘǗǒ� ǙǘǕǝǡǒǕǒ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǗǘǏ� ǒǑǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ� nj� ǎǘǔǕNJǎǏ� ƮǏǙNJǚǜNJǖǏǗ-ǜNJ� ǑǎǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ��ǘNjǚNJǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒ� ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ�ƻǂƪ��ǗNJǑnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ�mƲǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ��ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǥ�ǒ�ǙǚNJnjNJ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ}����ƹǘǑǎǗǏǏ�)Ζ33� ǙǘǛǕǝǐǒǕǒ�ǘǛǗǘnjǘǓ� ƱNJǔǘǗNJ�ƻǂƪ� mƸ� ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǎNJǗ-Ǘǥǟ}� ����b ǍǘǎNJ��� ǒ� NjǥǕǒ� ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǏǗǥ� nj� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ� NJǔǜNJǟ� ǚǩǎNJ�ǢǜNJǜǘnj�ƻǂƪ��ƹǚǒǗǠǒǙǥ�)Ζ33�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǗNJǢǕǒ�ǘǜǚNJǐǏǗǒǏ�nj�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǟ�ǗNJ-ǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǗǏǔǘǖ-ǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ��ƸǛǗǘnjǝ�ƹǚǒǗǠǒǙǘnj�)Ζ33� ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǜ�njǘǛǏǖǦ�ǘǛǗǘnjǘǙǘǕNJǍNJǨǣǒǟ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǘnj�

ƹǚǘǑǚNJǡǗǘǛǜǦ� �7UDQVSDUHQF\��� ƸǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ� ǎǘǕǐǗǥ� NjǥǜǦ� ǖNJǔǛǒ-ǖNJǕǦǗǘ�ǙǚǘǑǚNJǡǗǥǖǒ�ǒ�ǝnjǏǎǘǖǕǩǜǦ�ǕǒǠ�ǘ�ǛNjǘǚǏ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǒ��ǘNj-ǚNJNjǘǜǔǏ�ǒ� ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǒ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�Ǖǒǡ-ǗǘǛǜǒ�� ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ� �3HUVRQDOO\�ΖGHQWLȴDEOH�ΖQIRUPDWLRQ��3ΖΖ���ǎNJǕǏǏbȃ�mƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗNJǩ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦ-ǗNJǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ}�

ƵǒǡǗǘǏ�ǝǡNJǛǜǒǏ��ΖQGLYLGXDO�3DUWLFLSDWLRQ���ƸǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�Ǚǚǒ-njǕǏǔNJǜǦ� ǕǒǠ� ǔ� ǝǡNJǛǜǒǨ�nj�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǏ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗ-ǗǘǓ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǒ��nj�ǙǚǏǎǏǕNJǟ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǍǘ��ǑNJǙǚNJǢǒ-njNJǜǦ�ǒǟ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǏ�ǛǘǍǕNJǛǒǏ�ǗNJ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǏ��ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǝ��ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǝ�ǒ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǏ� ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�� ƸǚǍNJǗǒ-ǑNJǠǒǒ� ǜNJǔǐǏ� ǎǘǕǐǗǥ� ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǜǦ� ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖ� ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǏǍǘ� ǎǘ-ǛǜǝǙNJ�� ǔǘǚǚǏǔǜǒǚǘnjǔǒ� ǒ� ǙǏǚǏNJǎǚǏǛNJǠǒǒ� ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ� ǙǏǚǛǘ-ǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�

ƸǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǏ�ǠǏǕǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ� �3XUSRVH� 6SHFLȴFDWLRQ���ƸǚǍNJǗǒ-ǑNJǠǒǒ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�ǡǏǜǔǘ�ǛǞǘǚǖǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǙǘǕǗǘǖǘǡǒǩ��ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǔǘ-ǜǘǚǥǟ�ǚNJǑǚǏǢNJǏǜǛǩ� ǛNjǘǚ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚ-ǖNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘ�ǜǘǡǗǘ�ǝǔNJǑNJǜǦ�ǠǏǕǦ�ǒǕǒ�ǠǏǕǒ�ǏǪ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�

�� ƻǖ��KWWS���ZZZ�IWF�JRY�UHSRUWV�SULYDF\��IDLULQIR�VKWP�� ƻǖ�� ǘNj� ǧǜǘǖ� ǙǘǎǚǘNjǗǏǏ�� KWWS���ZZZ�GKV�JRY�[OLEUDU\�DVVHWV�SULYDF\�SULYDF\BSROLF\JXLGHB ����Ȃ���SGI

33ƻǂƪ

Page 35: User identification analysis

ƶǒǗǒǖNJǕǦǗǘǏ� ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ� �'DWD� 0LQLPL]DWLRQ��� ƸǚǍNJ-ǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�ǛǘNjǒǚNJǜǦ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǜNJǔǝǨ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǝǨ�ǙǏǚǛǘ-ǗNJǕǦǗǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�ǗǏǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǏ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖNJ�ǎǕǩ�njǥǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǩ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǘǓ�ǠǏǕǒ��ǠǏǕǏǓ���ǒ�ǛǘǟǚNJǗǩ-Ǩǜ�ǏǪ��ǙǘǔNJ�ǧǜǘ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥǖ�ǎǕǩ�njǥǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǗǘǓ��Ǘǥǟ��ǠǏǕǒ��ǠǏǕǏǓ��

ƸǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǒǏ�ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ��8VH�/LPLWDWLRQ���ƸǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ� ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǝǨ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǝǨ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ� ǒǛ-ǔǕǨǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ��ǘNjǘǑǗNJǡǏǗǗǥǟ�nj�ǝnjǏǎǘǖǕǏǗǒǒ�ǕǒǠNJ��ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnj-ǕǩǨǣǏǍǘ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ��ƸNjǖǏǗ�ǜNJǔǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǏǓ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ��ǛǘǘǜǗǘǛǒǖǥǟ�Ǜ�ǠǏǕǩǖǒ��ǎǕǩ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǘǗNJ�NjǥǕNJ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗNJ�

ƴNJǡǏǛǜnjǘ�ǒ�ǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ� �'DWD�4XDOLW\�DQG�ΖQWHJULW\�� ƸǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ� ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�� ǗNJǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘ�� ǛǕǏǎǒǜǦ� ǑNJ� ǜǏǖ�� ǡǜǘNjǥ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗNJǩ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�NjǥǕNJ�ǜǘǡǗǘǓ��ǘǜǗǘǛǩ-ǣǏǓǛǩ�ǔ�ǎǏǕǝ��NJǔǜǝNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒ�ǙǘǕǗǘǓ�

ƫǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǦ� �6HFXULW\���ƸǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�ǘǟǚNJǗǩǜǦ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǝǨ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ��ǗNJ�njǛǏǟ�ǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǩǟ��Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǟ�ǖǏǚ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�Ǚǚǘǜǒnj�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǚǒǛǔǘnj��ǔNJǔ�ǙǘǜǏǚǩ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǗǏǛNJǗǔǠǒǘǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǓ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ��ǝǗǒǡǜǘǐǏǗǒǏ��ǒǑǖǏ-ǗǏǗǒǏ��ǕǒNjǘ�ǗǏǙǚǏǎǗNJǖǏǚǏǗǗǘǏ�ǒǕǒ�ǗǏǙǘǎǘNjNJǨǣǏǏ�ǚNJǛǔǚǥǜǒǏ�

ƽǡǏǜ�ǒ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǦ��$FFRXQWDELOLW\�DQG�$XGLWLQJ���ƸǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�ǗǏǛǜǒ�ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǦ�ǑNJ�ǛǘNjǕǨǎǏǗǒǏ�ǧǜǒǟ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǘnj��ǙǚǘnjǘǎǒǜǦ�Ǜǘ-ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǏǏ�ǘNjǝǡǏǗǒǏ�njǛǏǟ�ǚNJNjǘǜǗǒǔǘnj�ǒ�Ǚǘǎǚǩǎǡǒǔǘnj��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝ-Ǩǣǒǟ� ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǝǨ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǝǨ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�� ǙǚǘnjǘǎǒǜǦ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǝ�ǏǪ�ǠǏǕǏnjǘǍǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǎǏǖǘǗǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǛǘNjǕǨǎǏǗǒǩ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǘnj�ǒ�njǛǏǟ�ǒǗǥǟ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�nj�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǒ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦ-ǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�

ƹǚǏǎǙǘǛǥǕǔǒ�ǙǘǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ��ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔNJ�ǒ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǒƬƯƮƽǃƽLj�ƺƸƵdž�Ƭ�ƺƯƪƵƲƱƪǀƲƲ�ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\V-WHP��ǗNJǡǒǗNJǩ�Ǜ�����bǍǘǎNJ��ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǓ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚ��Ƭ�����bǍǘǎǝ�NjǥǕNJ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘnjNJǗNJ�ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǩǣNJǩ�ƭǚǝǙǙNJ�ƻǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��Iden-

tity Ecosystem Steering Group, IDESG���ǎNJǕǏǏbȃ�mƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǩǣNJǩ�ǍǚǝǙǙNJ�Ζ'(6*}�� ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ� ǗǏ� ǩnjǕǩǕNJǛǦ� ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǖ� ǕǒǠǘǖ�� ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǕNJ� Ǜǘ-NjǘǓ� ǛNJǖǘǛǜǘǩǜǏǕǦǗǘ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǝǨ� ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǝǨ� Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǝ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚNJ��ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǗǝǨ�ǗNJ�ǛNJǖǘǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǒ��ǒ�ǑNJǗǒǖNJǨǣǝǨǛǩ�NJǗNJǕǒǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǒ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǘǓ�ǚNJNjǘǜǘǓ�nj�ǔǘǗǜǏǔǛǜǏ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǒ� ΖGHQWLW\� (FRV\VWHP�� Ƭ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǘǗǗǝǨ�

34 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 36: User identification analysis

Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǝ� ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǩǣǏǓ� ǍǚǝǙǙǥ� Ζ'(6*� njǟǘǎǒǕ� ƻǘnjǏǜ�� ƻǏǔǚǏǜNJǚǒNJǜ�� NJ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǕǘǛǦ�ǡǏǚǏǑ� ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ� ǔǘǖǒǜǏǜǘnj�ǒ�ǚNJ-Njǘǡǒǟ� ǍǚǝǙǙ�� ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ� ǒ� ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǟ� ǗNJ� ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǒ� ǡǕǏǗǛǜnjNJ�� ǙǘbǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩǖ�

ƼǏǔǝǣNJǩ�ǚNJNjǘǜNJ�NjǥǕNJ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑǘnjNJǗNJ�ǙǘbǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǝ�mǡǕǏǗǛǜnjNJ}��ǁǕǏ-ǗNJǖǒ�ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǩǣǏǓ�ǍǚǝǙǙǥ�Ζ'(6*�ǖǘǍǕǒ�NjǥǜǦ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǒ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏ-ǛǔǒǏ� ǕǒǠNJ�� ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǣǒǏ� njǛǏ� ǑNJǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ� ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ� �6WDNH-KROGHUV���ƮǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�ǔǘǖǒǜǏǜǘnj�ǒ�ǚNJNjǘǡǒǟ�ǍǚǝǙǙ�ǙǘbǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩǖ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ� ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǩǣǏǓ� ǍǚǝǙǙǥ� Ζ'(6*� ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǕNJǛǦ� ǜNJǔǐǏ� ǡǏ-ǚǏǑ� ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǚǩǎNJ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǟ�ǚNJNjǘǡǒǟ�ǍǚǝǙǙ��ǔǘǖǒǜǏǜǘnj�� ǝǡNJǛǜǗǒǔǒ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǖǘǍǕǒ�ǚNJNjǘǜNJǜǦ�ǎǒǛǜNJǗǠǒǘǗǗǘ��ƹǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǕǘǛǦ�� ǡǜǘ�ǚNJNjǘǡǒǏ� ǍǚǝǙǙǥ�ǒ� ǔǘǖǒǜǏǜǥ�ƺǝǔǘnjǘ-ǎǩǣǏǓ�ǍǚǝǙǙǥ�Ζ'(6*�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǍǚǝǙǙNJǖǒ�ǡǕǏǗǘnj��ǚNJNjǘǜNJǨǣǒǟ�nj�ǜǏǡǏ-ǗǒǏ�ǎǕǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǍǘ�njǚǏǖǏǗǒ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǎǕǩ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�ǜNJǔǘǍǘ�njǒǎNJ�ǚNJNjǘǡǒǟ�njǑNJǒǖǘǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǓ��ǡǕǏǗǛǜnjǘ�nj�ǧǜǒǟ�ǚNJNjǘǡǒǟ�ǍǚǝǙǙNJǟ�NjǥǕǘ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǖ��ǁǕǏǗǥ�ǚNJNjǘǡǒǟ�ǍǚǝǙǙ�ǒ�ǔǘǖǒǜǏǜǘnj�ǖǘǍǕǒ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǘnjNJǜǦ�nj�mǕǒǡǗǘǖ}�ǔNJ-ǡǏǛǜnjǏ�� NJ�ǗǏ�nj� ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǒǜǏǕǏǓ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ��ƺNJNjǘǡǒǏ� ǍǚǝǙǙǥ� ǒ� ǔǘǖǒǜǏǜǥ� ǚNJǑǚNJNjNJǜǥnjNJǕǒ� ǙǘǎǍǘǜǘnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ� ǎǘ-ǔǝǖǏǗǜǥ� ǒ� ǖNJǜǏǚǒNJǕǥ�� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥǏ� ǎǕǩ� ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǩǕǒ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǥ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ� ǒ� ǚǏǢNJǕǒ� ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǥ� ǛǘnjǖǏǛǜǒ-ǖǘǛǜǒ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǔǒNjǏǚǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǛǜnjǏ�

ƮǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǩǣǏǓ�ǍǚǝǙǙǥ�Ζ'(6*��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǦ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ� ΖGHQWLW\� (FRV\VWHP��ǙǚǒnjǏǕǒ�ǔ� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ� ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ� ǛNJǖǘǛǜǘǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒb ȃ� Ǩǚǒ-ǎǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ� ǕǒǠNJ�� ƻǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǏǏ� ǚǏǢǏǗǒǏ� NjǥǕǘ� ǙǚǒǗǩǜǘ� ƻǘnjǏǜǘǖ�Ǚǘb ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǨ� ǒ� NjǥǕǘ� ǘǎǘNjǚǏǗǘ� NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǘǖ� ǍǘǕǘǛǘnj� ǡǕǏǗǘnj����bǘǔǜǩNjǚǩ�����bǍ��NjǥǕǘ�ǘNjǤǩnjǕǏǗǘ�ǘ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǒ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǕǒǠNJbȃ�ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǩǣNJǩ�ǍǚǝǙǙNJ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ƲǗǔ�� �ΖGHQWLW\� (FRV\VWHP�6WHHULng�*URXS�ΖQGXVWU\�$VVRFLDWLRQɊΖQF����ǛǘǑǎNJǗǗǘǍǘ�nj�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ�Ǜ�ƱNJ-ǔǘǗǘǖ�ǘ�ǗǏǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǟ�ǢǜNJǜNJ�ƬǒǚǎǐǒǗǒǩ��ƻǂƪ� �9LU-JLQLD�1RQSURȴW�&RUSRUDWLRQ�$FW���nj�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǘǗǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǓ�ǞǘǚǖǏ�ǗǏ-ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǔǘǚǙǘǚNJǠǒǒ��1RQSURȴW�&RUSRUDWLRQ����

ƻǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜǘǖ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǜǘ�� ǡǜǘ� njǗǘnjǦ� ǛǘǑǎNJǗǗNJǩ� ǔǘǖ-ǙNJǗǒǩ�ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǩǣNJǩ�ǍǚǝǙǙNJ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ƲǗǔ���ΖGHQWLW\�(FR-V\VWHP�6WHHULQJ�GURXS�ΖQGXVWU\�$VVRFLDWLRQɊΖQF���ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǙǘǕǗǥǖ�ǙǚNJnjǘ-ǙǚǏǏǖǗǒǔǘǖ� ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǩǣǏǓ� ǍǚǝǙǙǥ� Ζ'(6*�� Ƭ� ǙǚNJnjǘǝǛǜNJǗNJnjǕǒnjNJǨǣǒǟ�

�� 85/��KWWS���ZZZ�LGHFRV\VWHP�RUJ�JURXS�OHDGHUVKLS�� 85/��KWWS���ZZZ�LGHFRV\VWHP�RUJ�SDJH�LQFRUSRUDWLRQ�GRFXPHQWV

35ƻǂƪ

Page 37: User identification analysis

ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǟ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǩǣǏǓ�ǍǚǝǙǙǥ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ƲǗǔ��ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǏǗǘ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ǘ�ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�Ǜ���ǩǗnjNJǚǩ�����bǍ��njǛǏ�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǘǍǘ� ǛǘǍǕNJǢǏǗǒǩ�� ǛǘǍǕNJǢǏǗǒǓ� Ǚǘb ǙǚNJnjNJǖ� ǒǗǜǏǕǕǏǔǜǝ-NJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛǘNjǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ��ƹǚNJnjǒǕNJ�ƪǛǛǘǠǒNJǠǒǒ��ǒǗǥǏ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǥ�ƺǝǔǘnjǘ-ǎǩǣǏǓ�ǍǚǝǙǙǥ�Ζ'(6*�bȃ�ǘǛǜNJǨǜǛǩ�ǗǏǒǑǖǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǒ�ǛǘǟǚNJǗǩǨǜ�ǛnjǘǏ�ǎǏǓ-ǛǜnjǒǏ��ƵǨNjNJǩ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ǒǕǒ�ǕǒǠǘ��ǐǏǕNJǨǣǒǏ�ǙǚǏǔǚNJǜǒǜǦ�ǡǕǏǗǛǜnjǘ��ǝǡNJǛǜǒǏ��nj�ǗǘnjǘǓ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǛǎǏǕNJǜǦ�ǧǜǘ�nj�ǕǨNjǘǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�

ƴǕǨǡǏnjǥǏ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǥ�ǒ�ǙǚǏǍǚNJǎǥ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒƹƸƴƪ� ƷƯ� ƻƸƬƻƯƶ� ljƻƷƸ�� ǔNJǔǒǖ� ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ� NjǝǎǏǜ� ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦǛǩ� ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦ-ǗǘǛǜǦ�ǗǘnjǘǓ�ǔǘǚǙǘǚNJǠǒǒbȃ�ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǩǣNJǩ�ǍǚǝǙǙNJ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǠǒǒ�ƲǗǔ�� �ΖGHQWLW\� (FRV\VWHP� 6WHHULng� *URXS� ΖQGXVWU\� $VVRFLDWLRQɊΖQF����ƬǖǏǛǜǏ�Ǜ�ǜǏǖ��njǘ�ǙǏǚnjǥǟ��ǘǡǏnjǒǎǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǨ�ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǩǣNJǩ�ǍǚǝǙ-ǙNJ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ƲǗǔ��� ǩnjǕǩǨǣǝǨǛǩ� ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǖ� ǕǒǠǘǖ�ǙǚNJnjNJ�ƻǂƪ� �ǢǜNJǜ�ƬǒǚǎǐǒǗǒǩ��� ǜNJǔ�ǒǕǒ�ǒǗNJǡǏ� ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǚNJǛǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǜǦ�nj� ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ� ǠǏǗǜǚNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ� ǑnjǏǗNJ� nj� ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ� ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP��Ƭǘ�njǜǘǚǥǟ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ƻǜǚNJǜǏ-Ǎǒǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ� ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP�ǛnjǩǑNJǗǥ�Ǜ� ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏǖ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǘnj� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ� ǔǒNjǏǚǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǛǜnjNJ� ǒ� Ǜǘ-njǖǏǛǜǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǙǘǛǜǘǕǦǔǝ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ��ǛǘǑǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǖ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚǘǖ��ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�NjǥǜǦ�ǛǘnjǖǏǛǜǒǖǥǖǒ��ǒǗǜǏǚǘǙǏǚNJNjǏǕǦǗǥǖǒ��Ǜ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖǒ�ǙǘbǝǚǘnjǗǨ�ǗNJ-ǎǏǐǗǘǛǜǒ��ǙǘbǔǚNJǓǗǏǓ�ǖǏǚǏ�Ǜ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖǒ�ƻǂƪ���ƷNJ�ǧǜǘ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǘNjǚNJǜǒǜǦ�ǘǛǘNjǘǏ�njǗǒǖNJǗǒǏ�nj�ǛnjǩǑǒ�Ǜ�ǜǏǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛ�ǏǪ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�njǟǘǎǒǜ�nj�ǔǘǖǙǏǜǏǗǠǒǨ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjNJ�ǜǘǚǍǘnjǕǒ�ƻǂƪ��Ƭ�ǛnjǘǨ�ǘǡǏǚǏǎǦ�ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǏ-ǗǒǏ� ǜNJǔǘǍǘ� ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�nj�ǙǏǚǛǙǏǔǜǒnjǏ�ǙǚǒnjǏǛǜǒ�ǕǒNjǘ�ǔ� ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǨ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǍǘ� ǙNJǚǜǗǏǚǛǜnjNJ�� ǕǒNjǘ� ǔ� ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǨ� mǎǘǍǘ-njǘǚǗǥǟ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǓ}�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǏǓ�ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǩǣNJǩ�ǍǚǝǙǙNJ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ƲǗǔ���Ǜ�ǘǎǗǘǓ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ��ǒ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjǘǖ�ǜǘǚǍǘnjǕǒ�ȃ�ǛbǎǚǝǍǘǓ��ǙǘbNJǗNJǕǘǍǒǒ�mǔǘǗǜǚNJǔǜǗǥǟ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǓ}�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǞǝǗǔ-ǠǒǓ�Ζ$1$��

ƸǛǜNJnjǕǩǩ�nj�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǏ�ǚNJǑǗǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǥǏ�NJǛǙǏǔǜǥ�ǎǒǛǔǝǛǛǒǒ�ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦ-Ǘǘ� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjNJ� ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǒ� ǙǏǚǛǙǏǔǜǒnj� ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗǒǚǘ-njNJǗǒǩ�ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP��ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǛǘǛǕNJǜǦǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǖǗǏǗǒǏ�ƬǒǗǜǘǗNJ�ƻǏǚǞNJ��9LQWRQ�&HUI�bȃ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǜǏǜǗǘǍǘ�ǧǔǛǙǏǚǜNJ��ǘǎǗǘǍǘ�ǒǑ�ǙǒǘǗǏǚǘnj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ��NjǥnjǢǏǍǘ�ƹǚǏǎǛǏǎNJǜǏǕǩ�ƹǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ƴǘǚǙǘǚNJǠǒǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǙǘbǚNJǛǙǚǏ-

36 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 38: User identification analysis

ǎǏǕǏǗǒǨ�ǒǖǏǗ�ǒ�ǗǘǖǏǚǘnj��7KH� ΖQWHUQHW�&RUSRUDWLRQ� IRU�$VVLJQHG�1DPHV�DQG�1XPEHUV�� Ζ&$11��� ljnjǕǩǩǛǦ�nj�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�njǒǠǏ�ǙǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǘǖ�ǒ� ǍǕNJnjǗǥǖ� mǏnjNJǗǍǏǕǒǛǜǘǖ� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ}� ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ� *RRJOH��ƬǒǗǜǘǗ� ƻǏǚǞ� ǙǘǕNJǍNJǏǜ�� ǡǜǘ� ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� mǛǘǑǎNJǏǜ� ǜǏǟ-ǗǒǡǏǛǔǝǨ�NjNJǑǝ�ǒ�ǐǒǑǗǏǛǙǘǛǘNjǗǝǨ�ǧǔǘǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ�ǔǘǗǔǝǚǒǚǝǨǣǒǟ��Ǘǘ�Ǜǘ-njǖǏǛǜǒǖǥǟ� �ǒǗǜǏǚǘǙǏǚNJNjǏǕǦǗǥǟ�� ǛǒǛǜǏǖ� ǒ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj� ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǎǕǒǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ��ƯǛǕǒ�ǙǚǏǎǕNJǍNJǏǖǥǏ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǥ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜ�ǙǚǒǖǏ-ǗǏǗǒǏ�ǑNJ�ǙǚǏǎǏǕNJǖǒ�ƻǂƪ��ǜǘ�ǧǜǘ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjǛǜnjǘnjNJǜǦ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�NjǒǑǗǏǛNJ�ǒ�nj�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǘǖ�ǖNJǛǢǜNJNjǏ}���

ƲǗǜǏǚǏǛǗǥǓ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎ�ǘǠǏǗǔǒ�ƻǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǚǏǎǕNJǍNJǨǜ�Ʈǐǒǖ�ƿǒǏǜNJǕNJ��Jim Hietala� ǒ�ljǗ�ƮǘNjǛǘǗ��Ian Dobson�� ǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǥǓ�Ǜ� ǜǏǖ��ǡǜǘ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǏ�ǗǏ� ǜǘǕǦǔǘ� ǔ� ǕǒǠNJǖ��Ǘǘ�ǒ�ǔ�mǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�njǏǣNJǖ}����ƹǘbǒǟ�ǖǗǏǗǒǨ�ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǜǚǏ-NjǝǏǜ� mǠǒǞǚǘnjǘǍǘ� ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ� ǔNJǔ� ǖǒǗǒǖǝǖ� Ǚǩǜǒ� ǜǒǙǘnj� ǘNjǤǏǔǜǘnj��NJ�ǒǖǏǗǗǘ��ǕǨǎǒ� �3HRSOH��� ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ� �'HYLFHV��� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ� �2UJDQL]D-WLRQV���ǔǘǎǘnjǥǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��&RGH��ǒ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǗǒǔǒ��$JHQWV���ƹǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜǘnj�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡNJǜǦǛǩ�nj�ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǘǜ�ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǥǟ�ǘNjǛǜǘǩǜǏǕǦǛǜnj�

ƼNJǔ�� ǏǛǕǒ� ǙǘǙǥǜNJǜǦǛǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ� ǜNJǔǘǏ� ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjǘ�� ǔNJǔ�ǗǘǝǜNjǝǔ�� ǜǘ� ǘǗ�ǖǘǐǏǜ� NjǥǜǦ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗ� nj� ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǘǜ� ǜǘǍǘ�ǙǚǒǗNJǎǕǏǐǒǜ�Ǖǒ�ǘǗ�ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǘǖǝ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǘǖǝ�ǕǒǠǝ�ǒǕǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ƯǛǕǒ� ǗǘǝǜNjǝǔ� ǙǚǒǗNJǎǕǏǐǒǜ� ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�� ǜǘ�� ǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǗǘ�� ǧǜǘ� NjǝǎǏǜ�mǔǘǚǙǘǚNJǜǒnjǗǥǓ�ǗǘǝǜNjǝǔ}�ǒ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�Ǜ�ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǘǓ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǏǓ��ƴǚǘǖǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǧǜǒǖ�ǗǘǝǜNjǝǔǘǖ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǔNJǔ�ǔǘǗ-ǔǚǏǜǗǘǏ�ǕǒǠǘ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǏǍǘ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǒǜǏǕǦ��$JHQW���ƹǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǒǜǏǕǦ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǘnjNJǜǦ�ǔNJǔ�ǘǜ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǝǙǘǕǗǘǖǘǡǒnjǢǏǍǘ�ǏǍǘ�ǕǒǠNJ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǘǜ�ǛǘNjǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǒǖǏǗǒ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��nj�ǛǕǝǡNJǩǟ��ǔǘǍǎNJ�ǙǘǖǘǣǗǒǔ�NjǚǘǗǒǚǝ-Ǐǜ�NjǒǕǏǜ�ǎǕǩ�NJnjǒNJǙǝǜǏǢǏǛǜnjǒǩ��LJǜǘǜ�ǙǚǒǖǏǚ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǛnjǒǎǏǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘǖ�njNJǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǜǏǑǒǛNJ�ǘ�ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�ǘǟnjNJǜǥnjNJǜǦ�njǛǏ�ǧǜǒ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜǥ� ǎǕǩ� ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ� ǗNJǎǏǐǗǘǛǜǒ� ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǏǗǒǩ� ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǜǚNJǗ-ǑNJǔǠǒǓ��ƷǏǖNJǕǘnjNJǐǗǥǖ�njǘǙǚǘǛǘǖ�ǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǛǩ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖNJǜǒǔNJ�ǛǘnjǖǏǛǜǒ-ǖǘǛǜǒ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘnj�� Ǜ� ǝǡǏǜǘǖ� ǜǚNJǗǛǍǚNJǗǒǡǗǘǍǘ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘ�ǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�

ƮǏǜNJǕǒ� ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ƻǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǗNJǟǘǎǩǜǛǩ� nj�ǛǜNJǎǒǒ�ǞǘǚǖǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǗNJ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǖ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ��ǒ�ǗNJ�ǒǗǛǜǒǜǝǠǒ-

�� 85/��KWWS���ZZZ�RVS�UX�RV������������������� -LP� +LHWDOD� DQG� ΖDQ� 'REVRQ�� (QWLWLHV� DQG� (QWLWOHPHQWb ȃ� 7KH� %LJJHU� 3LFWXUH� RI� ΖGHQWLW\�0DQDJHPHQW�bȃ�85/��KWWS���EORJ�RSHQJURXS�RUJ�WDJ�LGHQWLW\�HFRV\VWHP�

37ƻǂƪ

Page 39: User identification analysis

ǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǖ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ��ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjǥ�ǝǐǏ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǥ�ǒ�ǘǗǒ�ǛnjǩǑNJǗǥ��Ǜ�ǘǎǗǘǓ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ��ǙǘǒǛǔǘǖ�ǘǙǜǒǖNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǖǘǎǏǕǏǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� Ǜ� ǎǚǝǍǘǓ� ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ�ȃ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǒǗ-ǛǜǒǜǝǠǒǘǗNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǏǓ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ƻǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

ƬǘǙǚǘǛǥ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟƵLjƫƸƳ�ƹƺƸǀƯƻƻ�ƽƹƺƪƬƵƯƷƲlj�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�njǔǕǨǡNJǏǜ�ǛNjǘǚ��ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǒ�ǚNJǛǔǚǥǜǒǏ�5HO\LQJ�3DUW\��ǎǘnjǏǚǩǨǣNJǩ�Ǜǜǘ-ǚǘǗNJ� ǒǕǒ� ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJ�� ǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǨǣNJǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ� ǎNJǗǗǥǏ� ǕǒǠ��ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǘǓ�Ǜ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǖǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖǒ�ǘ�ǕǒǠǏ��ƽǡNJǛǜǒǏ�nj�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ�ǘǜ�ǕǒǠ�ǚNJǛǔǚǥǜǒǩ�Ǜnjǘǒǟ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦ-Ǘǥǟ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� ǒ�� ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�� ǙǘǎnjǏǚǍNJǨǜǛǩ� ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǘǖǝ� ǚǒǛǔǝ�ǚNJǛǔǚǥǜǒǩ�ǧǜǒǟ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ƹǘǧǜǘǖǝ�ǔǕǨǡǏnjǥǖ�njǘǙǚǘǛǘǖ�ǎǕǩ�ǕǨNjǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǑNJǣǒǜNJ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦ-Ǘǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�

Ƭ� ǧǜǘǓ� ǛnjǩǑǒ� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ� ǚǏǢǒǜǦ� ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ� njǘǙǚǘǛǥ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǗNJǟǘǎǩǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǙǘnjǏǛǜǔǏ�ǎǗǩ��ǔNJǔǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǛǘNjǒǚNJǜǦ�Ǚǚǘ-njNJǓǎǏǚ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ"�ƻǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǚNJǛ-ǔǚǥǜǦ�5HO\LQJ�3DUW\��ǎǘnjǏǚǩǨǣNJǩ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJ��ǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǨǣNJǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ� ǎNJǗǗǥǏ� ǕǒǠ�"� ƴNJǔǘǓ� ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ� ǗǏ-ǘNjǟǘǎǒǖ�ǎǕǩ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�Ǜ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǖǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖǒ"�ƴNJǔǒǏ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǒǩ�ǗǝǐǗǘ�ǗNJǕǘǐǒǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘǖ�ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǒ�5HO\LQJ�3DUW\"�Ƭ�ǒǎǏNJǕǏ�ǧǜǒ�njǘǙǚǘǛǥ�ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǚǏ-ǢNJǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ��ǒ�ǗNJ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǓ�ǙǚNJǔǜǒǔǒ��ǔǘǗǜǚNJǔǜǗǥǏ�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩ�ǎǘ-Ǎǘnjǘǚǘnj��

ƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǛǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�mǎǘǕǐǗNJ�ǙǚǏǎǕǘǐǒǜǦ�ǝǡNJ-ǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǖ�ǕǒǠNJǖ� ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJ� ǎǕǩ� ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǝǜǏǖ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǩ� ǡǏǜǔǒǟ� ǙǚNJnjǒǕ� ǒ� ǚǝǔǘnjǘǎǛǜnj�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ� ǑNJǜǚNJǍǒnjNJǨǜ� ǗǏ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��Ǘǘ�ǒ�njǒǎǥ�ǙǏǚ-ǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩ�ǒǟ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ}��ƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǛǜǚNJ-ǜǏǍǒǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜ� ǎǕǩ� ǎǘǛǜǒǐǏǗǒǩ� ǎNJǗǗǘǓ� ǠǏǕǒ� ǜNJǔ�ǗNJǑǥnjNJǏǖǥǓ�mǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǘ�ǘǚǒǏǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǓ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎ}��Ƭ�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǜNJǔǘǍǘ�ǔǘǗǠǏǙǜǝNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǎǟǘǎNJ�ǒǖǏǗǗǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǒǚǝǏǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��NJ�ǗǏ� ΖGHQWLW\� 6HUYLFH�3URYLGHU� �ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǥ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǘǛǜNJnjǣǒǔǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-ǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǝǛǕǝǍ�� ǒǕǒ�5HO\LQJ� 3DUW\� �ǎǘnjǏǚǩǨǣNJǩ� ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJ�ǒǕǒ� ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJ��ǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǨǣNJǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǕǒǠ��

38 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 40: User identification analysis

Ƭ�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP�ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǚǏǢǒǜǦ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ�njǘǙǚǘǛǥ�ǘǜ-njǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�

• ƴNJǔǘnjNJ� NjǝǎǏǜ� ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǦ� ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜNJ� ǑNJ� ǗNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǏ� ǘNjǩǑNJǗ-ǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǘbǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǙNJǚǘǕǩ��ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǍǘ�ǎǕǩ�NJǔǜǒnjNJǠǒǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǍǚNJǖǘǜ�ǒ�ǗNJǡNJǕNJ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��nj�Ǚǚǘ-ǠǏǛǛǏ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ�"

• ƴNJǔǘnjNJ� NjǝǎǏǜ� ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǦ� ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘnj�ǒǕǒ�ǙǘǛǜNJnjǣǒǔǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǑNJ�ǗNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǏ�Ǚǚǘ-ǠǏǎǝǚ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǙǚǒnjǏǎǢǏǏ�ǔ�ǘǢǒNjǔǏ"

• ƴNJǔǘnjNJ� NjǝǎǏǜ� ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǦ� ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǓ� ǙNJǚǜǒǒ� ǑNJ� ǙǚǒǗǩǜǒǏ�ǞNJǕǦǢǒnjǘǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǘǓ�nj�ǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜǏ�ǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǕǏǗǒǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚ-ǖNJǠǒǒ��ǑNJ�ǗǏǒǛǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǏ�ǘNjǩǑNJǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǘbǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ"

ƷǏǛǖǘǜǚǩ� ǗNJ� NjǘǕǦǢǘǏ� ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘ� ǜǏǘǚǏǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǒ� ǙǚNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǚNJNjǘǜ�ǙǘbǎNJǗǗǘǖǝ�njǘǙǚǘǛǝ��Ǚǘ�ǙǚǏǐǗǏǖǝ�njǘǙǚǘǛ� ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦ-Ǘǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǦ�ǑNJ�ǗNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǏ�ǙǕǘǟǘ�ǙǚǘǚNJNjǘǜNJǗ��ƫǏǑ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�njǘǙǚǘǛǘnj�ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǩ�ǔǚǝǍNJ�ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗ-Ǘǥǟ�ǕǒǠ��ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHP�ǞNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǗǏnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǘ�

ƹǘǧǜǘǖǝ� ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ� ǡNJǛǜǗǘǓ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ� ǚNJǛ-ǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǜǦ�ǔNJǔ�njǥǑǘnj��ǗNJ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜǘǒǜ�ǘǜǚǏNJǍǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ��Ƭ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJ-Ǘǒǒ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗNJ�ǡNJǛǜǗNJǩ�ǒǗǒǠǒ-NJǜǒnjNJ��ǙǘbNJǗNJǕǘǍǒǒ�Ǜ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗǥǖǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖǒ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�ǡNJǛǜǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǜNJǔǐǏ� ǗǝǐǎNJǏǜǛǩ� nj� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ� ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ� �ǑNJǔǘ-ǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǍǘ�� ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�� ƽǐǏ� ǏǛǜǦ� ǙǚǒǖǏǚǥ� ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǟ� ǛǏǜǏǓ� nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ� njǥǛǘǔǘ� ǚǒǛǔǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ� ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǏ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�� ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ�� ΖGHQ7UXVW�ǎǕǩ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǘǍǘ�ǚǥǗǔNJ�� 6$)(%LR3KDUPD�$VVRFLDWLRQ�ǎǕǩ�ǞNJǚǖNJǠǏnjǜǒ-ǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǛǞǏǚǥ��&HUWL3DWK�ǎǕǩ�ǛǞǏǚǥ�ǘNjǘǚǘǗǥ�ǒ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗNJǩ�ǖǘǎǏǕǦ�7UXVW�)UDPHZRUNƸƻƷƸƬƽ�75867�)5$0(:25.�ƻƸƻƼƪƬƵljƯƼ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖNJ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǏ��ǒǖǏǗǝǏǖǘǓ�ǎǘnjǏǚǩǨǣǏǓ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǘǓ��ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǓ�Ǜǜǘ-ǚǘǗǘǓ��ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǝǏǖǘǓ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǘǓbȃ�m5HO\LQJ�3DUW\}���ǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǨǣǏǓ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǝǨ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�� ǎǘnjǏǚǒǜǦǛǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘ-Ǜǜǒ��ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔǏ�ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ��ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǏǗǗǘǓ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǘǓ��ǔǘǜǘ-ǚNJǩ�njǥǙǘǕǗǩǏǜ�ǜNJǔǝǨ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ��ǒǖǏǗǝǏǖNJǩ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘǖ� ǒǕǒ� ǙǘǛǜNJnjǣǒǔǘǖ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǝǛǕǝǍb ȃ� mΖGHQWLW\�6HUYLFH�3URYLGHU}���ǒ�ǗNJǘNjǘǚǘǜ�

39ƻǂƪ

Page 41: User identification analysis

Ƭ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�7UXVW�)UDPHZRUN�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǗNJ�ƶǘǎǏǕǦ�m2SHQ�ΖGHQWLW\�7UXVW�)UDPHZRUN}��2Ζ7)����

ƵǒǠNJ��ǚNJNjǘǜNJǨǣǒǏ�nj�ǖǘǎǏǕǒ�m2SHQ�ΖGHQWLW\�7UXVW�)UDPHZRUN}��2Ζ7)��• 3ROLF\PDNHUb ȃ� ƺNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǡǒǔ� ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǠǒǒ� Ǚǘb ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

�SROLF\PDNHU��• ΖGHQWLW\�6HUYLFH�3URYLGHUbȃ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǘǛǜNJnj-

ǣǒǔ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�• 5HO\LQJ�3DUW\bȃ�ǎǘnjǏǚǩǨǣNJǩ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJ��ǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǨǣNJǩ�

ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǕǒǠ�ƵǒǠNJ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǨǜ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǒ�• ƹǝNjǕǒǔǝǨǜ�ǘǛǗǘnjǥ�7UXVW�)UDPHZRUN�bǜ�ɋǏ��ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǜ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥ�

ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒbǜ�ɋǎ��nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǙǝNjǕǒǡǗǘǍǘ�ǘNjǛǝǐǎǏǗǒǩ�• ƹǚǒǗǒǖNJǨǜ�ǒ�ǚNJǛǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǨǜ�ǙǚǏǎǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�ǘǜ� ǧǔǛǙǏǚǜǘnj�� ǔǘǜǘ-

ǚǥǏ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjNJǜǥnjNJǨǜ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥǏ�ǖǏǚǘǙǚǒǩǜǒǩ� nj� ǚNJǖǔNJǟ� 7UXVW�)UDPHZRUN�

• ƹǚǒǗǒǖNJǨǜ�ǒ�ǚNJǛǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǨǜ�ǙǚǏǎǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�ǘǜ�ΖGHQWLW\�6HUYLFH�3UR-YLGHU�b ǜ�ɋǏ�� ǘǜ� ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘnj� ǒǕǒ� ǙǘǛǜNJnjǣǒǔǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�

• ƹǚǒǗǒǖNJǨǜ�ǒ�ǚNJǛǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǨǜ�ǙǚǏǎǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�ǘǜ�5HO\LQJ�3DUW\�bǜ�ɋǏ��ǎǘnjǏǚǩǨǣǒǟ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗ��ǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǨǣǒǟ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒ-ǘǗǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǕǒǠ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǝǛǙǏǢǗǘ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǥ�ǔnjNJǕǒ-ǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǖǒ�ǘǠǏǗǣǒǔNJǖǒ�

�� KWWS���RSHQLGHQWLW\H[FKDQJH�RUJ�ZS�FRQWHQW�XSORDGV�WKH�RSHQ�LGHQWLW\�WUXVW�IUDPHZRUN�PRGHO���������SGI

40 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 42: User identification analysis

• ƹǝNjǕǒǔǝǨǜ�ǘNjǗǘnjǕǏǗǗǥǏ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǙǏǚǒǘǎǒǡǏǛǔǒ�NJǔǜǝNJǕǒǑǒǚǝ-Ǩǜ�njǥǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǥ�ǝǡNJǛǜǗǒǔNJǖ�nj�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ�Ǜ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJ-Ǘǒǩǖǒ��ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖǘǜǚǏǗǗǥǖǒ�7UXVW�)UDPHZRUN�

ƹǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJǖǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚNJǖǒ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ��ǙǚǏǎǘ-ǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǣǒǏ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ� ǎNJǗǗǥǏ� ǎǕǩ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj�� ǜNJǔǒǏ�� ǔNJǔ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǥǏ�NjǨǚǘ��ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǏ�ǝǡǚǏǐǎǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǜǏǕǏǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�

ƹǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJǖǒ� NJǜǚǒNjǝǜǒǔǒ� ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�� ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨ-ǣǒǏ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ� ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�� ƷNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ�� ǒǎǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ� ǎNJǗǗǥǏ� ǘǜ� ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǘǍǘ� ǝǡǚǏǐǎǏǗǒǩ� ǖǘǍǝǜ� ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�NJǜǚǒNjǝǜǒǔǝ� ǘǜ� ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǘǍǘ� NjǨǚǘ� ǒǕǒ� ǜǏǕǏǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ� ǔǘǖǙNJ-Ǘǒǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�nj�ǒǗǘǓ�ǠǏǕǒ��

ǁǜǘ� ǜNJǔǘǏ� NJǜǚǒNjǝǜ� �$WWULEXWH�"� ƶǘǐǗǘ� ǛǡǒǜNJǜǦ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ� ǛnjǘǏǘNjǚNJǑǗǥǖ� mǙǚǘǙǝǛǔǘǖ}�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ� ǎNJǏǜ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙ� ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜǝ� nj�mǑǎNJǗǒǏ}��Ʒǘ�ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�mǕǒǞǜNJǖ}��mǧǜNJǐNJǖ}�ǒ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǖ�mǘǞǒǛNJǖ}�nj�ǧǜǘǖ�mǑǎNJǗǒǒ}�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǗNJǕǒǡǒǏ�NJǜǚǒNjǝǜǘnj�ǔ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-ǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖ��ƯǛǜǦ�NJǜǚǒNjǝǜǥ��ǩnjǕǩǨǣǒǏǛǩ�ǘǛǗǘnjǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǗǏǒǑǖǏǗǩǏǖǥǏ��ǏǛǜǦ�ǚǏǎǔǘ�ǖǏǗǩǨǣǒǏǛǩ�ǕǒNjǘ�ǖǏǗǩǨǣǒǏǛǩ�ǙǘǛǜǘǩǗǗǘ�

ƴǕǨǡǏnjǥǏ�NJǜǚǒNjǝǜǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒbȃ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦ-Ǘǘ�ǙǘǕNJ�� ǎNJǜǥ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǩ��ǒǗNJǩ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�b ǜ�ɋǏ�bǒǗ-ǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǙǚNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǗǏ�ǙǘǎnjǏǚǐǏǗNJ�ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǨ���

ƷNJ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǏǖ��NjǘǕǏǏ�ǗǒǑǔǘǖ��ǝǚǘnjǗǏ�ǗNJǟǘǎǒǜǛǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ��ǖǏ-ǗǩǨǣNJǩǛǩ�ǗǏ�ǡNJǛǜǘ��ǜNJǔNJǩ��ǔNJǔ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ǖǏǛǜǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ��ǖǏǛǜǘ�ǙǚǘǐǒnjNJ-Ǘǒǩ��NJǎǚǏǛ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǡǜǥ��ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǒǟ�ǛǡǏǜNJǟ��NjNJǗ-ǔǘnjǛǔǒǟ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜNJǟ���ǖǏǎǒǠǒǗǛǔNJǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ��ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒ�Ǚǚǘǡ���

ƷNJ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǏǖ�mǗǒǛǟǘǎǩǣǏǖ}�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ�ǗNJǟǘǎǒǜǛǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ��ǖǏ-ǗǩǨǣNJǩǛǩ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǡNJǛǜǘ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚǘǞǏǛǛǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǔnjNJ-ǕǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǛǕǝǐǏNjǗǥǓ�ǔNJǚǦǏǚǗǥǓ�ǚǘǛǜ�ǒ�Ǚǚǘǡ�

ƷNJ� ǛNJǖǘǖ� ǗǒǑǔǘǖ� ǝǚǘnjǗǏ� ǗNJǟǘǎǒǜǛǩ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�� ǖǏǗǩǨǣNJǩǛǩ�ǙǘǛǜǘǩǗǗǘ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖNJǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�nj�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǛǏǜǒ�ǒ� ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǖNJǍNJǑǒǗǥ�� ƷNJ� ǧǜǘǖ� ǝǚǘnjǗǏ� NJǜǚǒNjǝǜǒǔNJ� ǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǛǩ� ǛǕǘǐ-ǗǏǏ�bǜ�ɋǔ��ǛNJǓǜǥ�ǙǚǏǎǕNJǍNJǨǜ�NJǜǚǒNjǝǜǒǔǝ�NjǏǛǙǕNJǜǗǘ�ǒǕǒ�ǑNJ�ǘǡǏǗǦ�ǗǒǑǔǝǨ�ǠǏǗǝ��Ǘǘ�Ǚǘǜǘǖ�ǙǚǘǎNJǨǜ�ǏǪ�ǒǗǥǖ�ǕǒǠNJǖ��ƷNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǕǒǠNJ�ǑNJǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒ-ǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ�nj�)DFHERRN�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǥnjNJǨǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�&RQ-QHFW�� ǘǎǗǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǘ� ǛǘǍǕNJǢNJǨǜǛǩ� ǗNJ� ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǝ� Ǜnjǘǒǟ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ��� ƸǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�Ζ'�FDUG�ǖNJǢǒǗbȃ�KWWS���ZZZ�DOSKDFDUG�FRP�LG�FDUG�PDNHU�LG�FDUG�PDFKLQHV��Ζ'� FDUG�ǖNJǢǒǗǥ�ǔǕNJǛǛǒǞǒǠǒǚǝǨǜǛǩ�Ǚǘb ǔNJǜǏǍǘǚǒǩǖ�nj� ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǘǜ� ǜǘǍǘ�� NjǝǎǝǜbǕǒ�ǘǗǒ�ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǒǜǦ�ǔǘǎǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ�ǒǕǒ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�NjǏǓǎǐǒ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝ-ǨǜǛǩbǕǒ�ǘǗǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǡǜǏǗǒǩ�ǔǘǎǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǗNJ�ǔNJǚǜNJǟ��

41ƻǂƪ

Page 43: User identification analysis

ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��Ʋ�NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǘ�ǕǨǎǏǓ�ǗǏ�ǙǘǗǒǖNJǨǜ��ǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǘǗǒ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǨǜ�ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�

ƽǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǗǥǏ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǥ��$GRSWHG�7UXVW�)UDPH-ZRUN� 3URYLGHUV��� ƻǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ� ǚǩǎ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ�� ǩnjǕǩǨǣǒǟǛǩ� mƽǜnjǏǚǐ-ǎǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJǖǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚNJǖǒ��$GRSWHG�7UXVW�)UDPHZRUN�3URYLGHUV���ƸǎǗǘǓ�ǒǑ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ƲǗǒǠǒNJǜǒnjNJ�.DQWDUD��.DQWDUD�ΖQLWLDWLYH�����ƲǗǒǠǒNJǜǒnjNJ�.DQWDUD��.DQWDUD�ΖQLWLDWLYH���bȃ�ǘNjǤǏǎǒ-ǗǏǗǒǏ� ǧǔǛǙǏǚǜǘnj� nj� ǛǞǏǚǏ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�� ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ�ǑNJǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗ�ǎǕǩ�ǍǕǘNjNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ��ǘǜǔǚǥǜǘǍǘ�ǒ�ǙǚǘǑǚNJǡ-ǗǘǍǘ�ǛǘnjǖǏǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖ�ǍNJǚǖǘǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǘǙǏǚNJNjǏǕǦ-ǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ǙǚǏǎǙǚǒǩǜǒǓ��njǏNj�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǓ������njǏNj�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǒ�Ǚǚǘǡ��ƻǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ƲǗǒǠǒNJǜǒnjǥ�.DQWDUD�NjǥǕǘ�ǒǗǒǠǒǒǚǘnjNJǗǘ�ǚǝǔǘnjǘǎǒǜǏǕǩǖǒ�ǞǘǗǎǘnj��ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ��NJǛǛǘǠǒNJǠǒǓ�ǒ�Ǚǚǘǡ���ǚNJNjǘǜNJǨ-ǣǒǟ�ǙǘbǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǖ�NJǛǙǏǔǜNJǖ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

ƲǗǒǠǒNJǜǒnjNJ� .DQWDUD� njǏǎǏǜ� ǛǙǒǛǘǔ�� njǘ�ǙǏǚnjǥǟ�� NJǔǔǚǏǎǒǜǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�ƲǗǒǠǒNJǜǒnjǘǓ� .DQWDUD� ǙǘǛǜNJnjǣǒǔǘnj� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǝǛǕǝǍ� �.DQ-WDUD� $SSURYHG� &UHGHQWLDO� 6HUYLFH� 3URYLGHUV�� &63V��� nj� ǡǒǛǕǏ� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�� ǗNJ-ǙǚǒǖǏǚ��9HUL]RQ��6\PDQWHF�ǒ�ǎǚ��Ƭǘ�njǜǘǚǥǟ��ǔǘǖǙǘǗǏǗǜǘnj�ǝǛǕǝǍ��6HUYLFH�&RPSRQHQWV��6&V���Ƭ�ǜǚǏǜǦǒǟ��NJǔǔǚǏǎǒǜǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�ǧǔǛǙǏǚǜǘnj��.DQWDUD�$F-FUHGLWHG�$VVHVVRUV����

ƲǗǒǠǒNJǜǒnjNJ� .DQWDUD� ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗǒǚǝǏǜ� ǔNJǔ� ǗǏǑNJnjǒǛǒǖNJǩ� ǗǏǔǘǖǖǏǚ-ǡǏǛǔNJǩ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩ�� ǛǘǑǎNJǗǗNJǩ� nj� ǚNJǖǔNJǟ� ƹǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥ� Ζ(((-Ζ672� �ZZZ�LHHH�LVWR�RUJ���ƮǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑǘnjNJǗNJ�ǙǘbǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǝ�ǡǕǏǗǛǜnjNJ��Ǚǘǎ-ǎǏǚǐǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ�ǡǕǏǗǛǔǒǖǒ�njǑǗǘǛNJǖǒ��NjǕNJǍǘǜnjǘǚǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖǒ�ǒ�ǒǗǥǖǒ�njǑǗǘ-ǛNJǖǒ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�ǒǗǛǜǒǜǝǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǝǨ�njǗǝǜǚǏǗǗǨǨ�Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǝ�ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ��ƼǏǔǝǣNJǩ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǛǘǑǎNJnjNJǏ-ǖǥǟ�ǚNJNjǘǡǒǟ�ǒ�ǎǒǛǔǝǛǛǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǍǚǝǙǙ�

ƹǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǏ� ǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǗǘǛǜǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ� ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖNJ� ǛǏǚ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��.DQWDUD�ΖGHQWLW\�$VVXUDQFH�$FFUHGLWDWLRQ�DQG�&HUWLȴFDWLRQ�3UR-JUDP�����Ƭ�����b Ǎ�� NjǥǕNJ� ǛǘǑǎNJǗNJ�ƺNJNjǘǡNJǩ� ǍǚǝǙǙNJ�ǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ� �ΖGHQWLW\�$VVXUDQFH�:RUN�*URXS�� Ζ$:*�����ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǨǣNJǩ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ƽǛǜNJnjNJ�nj�ǚǏǎNJǔǠǒǒ�����bǍ��ƸǎǗǒǖ�ǒǑ�NJǛǙǏǔ-ǜǘnj�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ƺNJNjǘǡǏǓ�ǍǚǝǙǙǥbȃ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǏ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǛǘǑ-

�� KWWS���ZZZ�LGPDQDJHPHQW�JRY�DGRSWHG�WUXVW�IUDPHZRUN�SURYLGHUV�� KWWSV���NDQWDUDLQLWLDWLYH�RUJ�DERXW�� $SSURYHV�&UHGHQWLDO�DQG�&RPSRQHQW�6HUYLFH�3URYLGHUV��&63V��DQG�$FFUHGLWV�$VVHVVRUV��� KWWS���NDQWDUDLQLWLDWLYH�RUJ�FRQȵXHQFH�GLVSOD\�LGDVVXUDQFH������Ζ$:*�&KDUWHU"VUF FRQWH[-WQDYFKLOGPRGH�� KWWS���NDQWDUDLQLWLDWLYH�RUJ�FRQȵXHQFH�GLVSOD\�LGDVVXUDQFH������Ζ$:*�&KDUWHU

42 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 44: User identification analysis

ǎNJǗǒǩ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙNJǚǜǗǪǚǛǜnjNJ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǏ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒǜ�ǎǘnjǏ-ǚǒǜǏǕǦǗǝǨ�Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǝ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚNJǖ��ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJǖ�NJǜǚǒNjǝǜǘnj��ǙǘǜǚǏNjǒǜǏǕǩǖ�ǒ�ǒǗǥǖ�5HO\LQJ�3DUW\��ǎǘnjǏǚǩǨ-ǣNJǩ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJ��ǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǨǣNJǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǕǒǠ��

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǖǏǚǥƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲlj� Ʒƪ� ƸƻƷƸƬƯ� ƴƺƲƹƼƸƭƺƪƾƲƲ� Ǜ� ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǖ� ǔǕǨǡǘǖ� ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǝǛǙǏǢǗǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�njǘ�ǖǗǘǍǒǟ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩǟ��nj�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǛǜǒ�nj�ǛǕǝ-ǡNJǩǟ��ǔǘǍǎNJ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǗǏ�ǒǖǏǨǜ�ǙǚǏǎnjNJǚǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǛnjǏ-ǎǏǗǒǓ�ǘ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǎǚǝǍ�ǎǚǝǍNJ��ƹǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǥ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��Ǚǚǒ-njǏǎǪǗǗǥǏ� nj� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǏ� mƪǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜNJ� Ǜ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǒ�Ǜ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǖ�ǔǕǨǡǘǖ}��ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǛǘnjǖǏǛǜǗǘ�Ǜ�ǎǚǝǍǒǖǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖǒ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǘǍǘ�ǔǕǨǡNJ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�nj�ǙǚǒǔǕNJǎǗǘǖ�ǒ�njǛǜǚǘǏǗǗǘǖ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǗǘǖ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǒ��nj�NJǙǙNJǚNJǜǗǘǖ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǒ�ǒ�nj�ǕǨNjǘǓ�ǒǟ�ǔǘǖNjǒǗNJǠǒǒ�

Ƭ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǏ� ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǥ� ǎnjNJ� ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕNJ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǛǝNjǤǏǔ-ǜǘnj��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǣǒǟ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǥ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǙǚǏǘNjǚNJǑǘnjNJǗǒǓ�Ǜ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǖ�ǔǕǨǡǘǖ�ǎǕǩ�ǞǘǚǖǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǒ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǎ-ǙǒǛǒ��ƸǎǒǗ� ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜ�ǖǘǐǏǜ� ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǎǒǜǦ� ǎǚǝǍǘǖǝ� ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜǝ� ǛnjǘǨ�Ǚǘǎ-ǕǒǗǗǘǛǜǦ�� ǙǘǎǙǒǛNJnj� ǛǕǝǡNJǓǗǥǓ� ǘǜǔǕǒǔ�� LJǜǘ� ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǏǜ� ǛǜǚǘǍǘǛǜǦ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� NjǏǑ� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ� ǗNJǕǒǡǒǩ� ǘNjǣǏǍǘ� ǛǏǔǚǏǜNJ�� ƯǛǕǒ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǒǓ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ� njǗǏǎǚǩǏǜǛǩ� nj� ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǟ�� ǍǏǗǏǚNJǠǒǩ�ǒ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔNJ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘǎǙǒ-ǛǏǓ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�njǥǙǘǕǗǩǜǦǛǩ�ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩǖ�)Ζ36��nj�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǛǜǒ��)Ζ3-638%�����mƻǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ}��

ƬǖǏǛǜǏ�Ǜ�ǜǏǖ��ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǍǘ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJ�ǛǞǘǚǖǝ-ǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǥ�ǗǏ�ǜNJǔ�ǛǜǚǘǍǘ��ǔNJǔ�NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǗǥǏ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǡǒǔNJǖ�njnjǘǎǒǜǦ�ǘǚǒǍǒǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǙǘǕǩ�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-ǜǘǚǘnj��NJ� ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǎǕǩ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǩ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǖǝ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǝ� ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ� ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǘnj� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� Ǜ� ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǖ� ǔǕǨ-ǡǘǖ��ǗǏ�ǙǘǎǙNJǎNJǨǣǒǟ�Ǚǘǎ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ��Ƭ�ǚNJǑǎǏǕǏ���ǙǚǒnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ�

• ǘNjǑǘǚ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǥǟ�ǚNJǛǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǏǖǥǟ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǘǖ�ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǘnj�• ǔǚǒǜǏǚǒǒ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǩ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǝ�• ǔǚNJǜǔǘǏ� ǘǙǒǛNJǗǒǏ� ǝǍǚǘǑ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǖ� ǙǚǘǜǒnjǘǛǜǘǩǜ� ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǥ� NJǝ-

ǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�• ǛǙǒǛǘǔ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǓ�ǒ�ǘNjǘǑǗNJǡǏǗǒǓ�

43ƻǂƪ

Page 45: User identification analysis

ƹǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǥ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǘǙǒǛNJǗǥ� nj� ǚNJǑǎǏǕǏ� ��� ƹǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ� ǔ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǝ�ǘǙǒǛǥnjNJǨǜ�ǗǏǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�ǞǘǚǖNJǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǔǘ-ǎǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�

Ƭ� ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕNJǟ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜǘnj�� ǒǑǕǘǐǏǗǗǥǟ� nj� ǚNJǛǛǖNJ-ǜǚǒnjNJǏǖǘǖ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǏ��ǎǕǩ�ǍǏǗǏǚNJǠǒǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘnj�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǨǜǛǩ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǥ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ��ƹǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǥ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǗǏ�ǑNJ-njǒǛǩǜ�ǘǜ�Ǚǚǒǚǘǎǥ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜNJ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǘǎǒǗ�ǒ�ǜǘǜbǐǏ�ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦ-ǑǝǏǜǛǩ�ǎǕǩ�njǑNJǒǖǗǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎnjǝǟ�ǕǨǎǏǓ��ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�ǒ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛ-ǛNJ�� NJ� ǜNJǔǐǏ� ǎnjǝǟ� ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǘnj��� ƪǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ� ǘNjǥǡǗǘ�ǚNJǑNjǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǎnjǏ�ǛǜNJǎǒǒ��ǗNJ�ǙǏǚnjǘǓbȃ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ�Ǚǚǘǟǘǎǒǜ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǠǒǨ�ǙǘbǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǨ�ǔ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǡǏǛǔǘǖǝ�ǖǘǎǝǕǨ��NJ�ǗNJ�njǜǘǚǘǓbȃ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǖǘǎǝǕǦ�njǥǙǘǕǗǩǏǜ�ǞǘǚǖǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚ-ǔǝ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ�ǘǜ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�

ƪǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜNJ�ǑNJnjǒǛǒǜ�ǘǜ�ǝǛǙǏǢǗǘǛǜǒ�njǥǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǩ�ǎnjǝǟ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǓ�

• ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǒ�ǙǚǒǗNJǎǕǏǐǗǘǛǜǒ�Ǐǖǝ�ǔǕǨǡǏnjǘǓ�ǙNJǚǥ�• ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǒ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ�Ǚǘǎ�ǘǜǔǕǒǔǘǖ�Ƭ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǏ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǩǨǣNJǩ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJ�ǍǏǗǏǚǒǚǝǏǜ�ǛǕǝ-

ǡNJǓǗǘǏ�ǡǒǛǕǘbȃ�ǘǜǔǕǒǔ�� ǛnjǩǑǥnjNJǏǜ�ǏǍǘ�Ǜ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘǖ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǩ-ǏǖǘǓ� ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ��ƱNJǜǏǖ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǩǏǖNJǩ� ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJ�ǞǘǚǖǒǚǝǏǜ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǝǨ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦ�ǘǜǔǕǒǔNJ��ƹǚǘnjǏǚǩǨǣNJǩ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJ�ǗNJǟǘǎǒǜ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǓ�ǔǕǨǡ�Ǚǚǘ-njǏǚǩǏǖǘǓ�ǙǘbǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǝ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǓ��Ƭ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǝǛǙǏǢǗǘǓ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚ-ǔǒ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǗNJǓǎǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǘǍǘ�ǔǕǨǡNJ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔNJ�ǛǡǒǜNJ-ǏǜǛǩ�ǙǚǘǓǎǏǗǗǘǓ�

ƮNJǗǗǥǓ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǏǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�Ǘǒ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǜǘnj�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǘǍǘ�ǔǕǨǡNJ��Ǘǒ�ǒǗǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǥ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǟ�ǔǕǨǡǏǓ��ƸǗ�ǗǏ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ�Ǘǒ�ǛǒǗǟǚǘǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǡNJǛǘnj��Ǘǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǢǜNJǖǙǘnj�njǚǏǖǏ-Ǘǒ��ƺNJǛǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǏǖǥǓ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǩǏǜ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ǔ�ǒǖǏǗǘ-njNJǗǒǨ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜǘnj��ƸǗ�ǕǒǢǦ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǟ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘnj�

Ƭ�NJǛǒǖǖǏǜǚǒǡǗǥǟ�ǛǟǏǖNJǟ��ǛǟǏǖNJǟ�Ǜ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǖ�ǔǕǨǡǘǖ��NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒ-ǚǝǏǖǥǓ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜ�ǛǗNJNjǐNJǏǜǛǩ�ǑNJǔǚǥǜǥǖ�ǔǕǨǡǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�Ǐǖǝ�ǑNJ-ǜǏǖ�ǙǚǘǟǘǎǒǜǦ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�ǙǘbǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǨ�ǔ�ǕǨNjǘǖǝ�ǛǏǚnjǏǚǝ��Ǚǘ-ǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǏǍǘ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǓ�ǔǕǨǡ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǏǗ�njǘ�njǛǏǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ��ƻǒǖǖǏǜǚǒǡǗǥǏ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖǥ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǜNJǔǒǏ�ǙNJǚǘǕǦǗǥǏ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖǥ��ǔNJǔ�&5$0-0'��� ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǣǒǓǛǩ� nj� 5)&������ ǗǏ� ǒǖǏǨǜ� ǙǘǎǘNjǗǘǍǘ� ǙǚǏǒǖǝǣǏǛǜnjNJ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǒǟ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ�ǙǚǏǎnjNJǚǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏ-Ǘǒǩ�ǘNjǣǏǍǘ�ǛǏǔǚǏǜNJ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJǖǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƹǘbǛǚNJnjǗǏǗǒǨ�Ǜ�7/6�ǘǙǒǛǥnjNJǏǖǥǓ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖ�ǘNjǕNJǎNJǏǜ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǖǒ�ǙǚǏǒǖǝǣǏǛǜnjNJǖǒ�

44 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 46: User identification analysis

• ǙǚǘǛǜǘǜǘǓ�� ǏǛǕǒ� ǜǚǏNjǝǨǜǛǩ� ǜǘǕǦǔǘ� ǞǝǗǔǠǒǒ�� ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǏǖǥǏ�6$6/� �NJ�ǗǏ�njǛǏ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǒ��ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǏǖǥǏ�7/6��� ǜǘ�6$6/�ǙǚǏǎǙǘ-ǡǜǒǜǏǕǦǗǏǏ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǘǗ�ǙǚǘǣǏ�

• ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔǘǓ� ǝǚǘnjǗǏǓ�� ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖ� 6$6/� ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǑǝǏǜǛǩ� ǕǝǡǢǏǓ�ǛǘnjǖǏǛǜǒǖǘǛǜǦǨ�Ǜ�NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǘǖ�ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǘnj��ǡǏǖ�7/6�

• ǙǚǘǔǛǒ�ǛǏǚnjǏǚNJǖǒ��nj�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�NJǚǟǒǜǏǔǜǝǚNJǟ�7/6�ǛǏNJǗǛǥ�ǗǏ�Ǜnjǩ-ǑǥnjNJǨǜ� ǔǘǗǏǡǗǥǏ� ǜǘǡǔǒ� ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǓbȃ� nj� ǜNJǔǒǟ� ǛǒǜǝNJǠǒǩǟ� ǎǕǩ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ� ǛǔnjǘǑǗǘǓ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǖǘǐǏǜ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�6$6/�

• ǙǘnjǥǢǏǗǒǏǖ� ǝǚǘnjǗǩ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� nj� ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ� ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏ-Ǘǒǩǟ� ǗNJ� ǖǘǖǏǗǜ� ǒǗǒǠǒǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ� 7/6�ǛǏNJǗǛNJ� ǏǣǪ� ǖǘǐǏǜ� NjǥǜǦ�ǗǏǒǑnjǏǛǜǏǗ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǖǥǓ�ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��NJǗǘǗǒǖǗǘǛǜǦ��NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� ǛǏǚnjǏǚNJ�� njǑNJǒǖǗNJǩ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ��� 6$6/b ǐǏ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�Ǜǘ�njǚǏǖǏǗǏǖ�ǙǘnjǥǢNJǜǦ�ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

ƶǏǟNJǗǒǑǖ�6$6/�ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǏǜ�ǎnjNJ�ǚǏǐǒǖNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�• ǘǎǗǘǛǜǘǚǘǗǗǨǨ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ�� ǔǕǒǏǗǜ� Ǟǘǚǖǒǚǝ-

Ǐǜ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǝǨ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦ�ǘǜǔǕǒǔNJ�ǘǜ� ǛǏǚnjǏǚNJ�ǒ� ǜǏǖ�ǛNJǖǥǖ�Ǚǘǎ-ǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǏǚǝ�ǛnjǘǨ�ǙǘǎǕǒǗǗǘǛǜǦ�

• njǑNJǒǖǗǝǨ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�� ǔǕǒǏǗǜ� ǞǘǚǖǒǚǝǏǜ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǝǨ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦ�ǘǜǔǕǒǔNJ�ǘǜ�ǛǏǚnjǏǚNJ��ǒ�ǛǏǚnjǏǚ�ǞǘǚǖǒǚǝǏǜ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǝǨ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦ�ǘǜǔǕǒǔNJ�ǘǜ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJbȃ�ǜNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǒ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜ��ǒ�ǛǏǚnjǏǚ�ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǨǜ�ǎǚǝǍ�ǎǚǝǍǝ�ǛnjǘǨ�ǙǘǎǕǒǗǗǘǛǜǦ�

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒƮǘǙǝǛǜǒǖǥ�ǔ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜǛǩ�njǛǏ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǏ�Njǒǘ-ǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ� ǖǏǜǘǎǥ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�b ȃ� ǔNJǔ� ǛǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ� ǖǏǜǘǎǥ��NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘbǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǝ�ǙNJǕǦǠNJ��NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘbǚNJǎǝǐǗǘǓ�ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔǏ� ǍǕNJǑNJ�� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� Ǚǘb ǛǏǜǡNJǜǔǏ� ǍǕNJǑNJ�� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘbǍǏǘǖǏǜǚǒǒ�ǚǝǔǒ��NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘbǍǏǘǖǏǜǚǒǒ�ǕǒǠNJ��NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǩ�ǙǘbǜǏǚǖǘǍǚNJǖǖǏ�ǕǒǠNJ���ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ��NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǩ�ǙǘbǍǘǕǘǛǝ��NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘbǚǝǔǘǙǒǛǗǘǖǝ�ǙǘǡǏǚǔǝ���NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǔǘǖ-NjǒǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

ƴǚǘǖǏ�ǧǜǘǍǘ��nj�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚǘnjǘǎǩǜǛǩ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǩ�nj�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƼNJǔ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ����ǞǏnjǚNJǕǩ�����b ǍǘǎNJ� ǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǗǘǏ� ǙǘǎǚNJǑǎǏǕǏǗǒǏ�ƸǞǒǛ� ǒǗǗǘnjNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǒǗǞǘǚ-ǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ��ΖQIRUPDWLRQ�LQQRYDWLRQ�RɝFH��NJǍǏǗǜǛǜnjNJ�'$53$�ǘNjǗNJǚǘǎǘnjNJǕNJ� njǜǘǚǝǨ� ǞNJǑǝ� ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ� mƪǔǜǒnjǗǘǓ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}� Ǜ�NjǨǎǐǏǜǘǖ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥ�ǘǔǘǕǘ���ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗǘnj�ǎǘǕǕNJǚǘnj�ƻǂƪ�

45ƻǂƪ

Page 47: User identification analysis

Ƭ�ǎNJǗǗǘǓ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǏ�ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǏǜǛǩ��ǡǜǘ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǏ�ǙNJǚǘǕǒ�ǗǏ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǙǘǎǕǒǗǗǘ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǥǖǒ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjNJǖǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƴǘǗǏǡ-ǗNJǩ� ǠǏǕǦ� ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥbȃ� ǛǘǑǎNJǜǦ� ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǗǥǓ� Ǚǚǘǎǝǔǜ�� ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǝǨ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǝǨ� ǙǕNJǜǞǘǚǖǝ� ǎǕǩ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ� nj�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǟ� ǛǏǜǩǟ� njǥǛǘǔǘǓ� ǑNJǣǒǣǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�� ƿNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǗNJǩ� ǘǛǘNjǏǗ-ǗǘǛǜǦ� ǙǕNJǜǞǘǚǖǥb ȃ� ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǒǏ� ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǛǏǗǛǘǚǘnj�� ƹǕNJǜǞǘǚǖNJ� ǎǘǕǐǗNJ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ� ǙǚǒnjǥǡǗǝǨ� ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǝ��ǖǥǢǦ�ǒ�njǏNjǔNJǖǏǚǝ��ƷNJǝǡǗǘǓ�ǘǛǗǘnjǘǓ�ǗǘnjǘǓ�ǙǕNJǜǞǘǚǖǥ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǎǘ-ǛǜǒǐǏǗǒǩ�ǔǘǍǗǒǜǒnjǗǥǟ�ǗNJǝǔ�ǒ�ǙǛǒǟǘǞǒǑǒǘǕǘǍǒǒ��ƷNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǙǘǎǘNjǗǘ�ǙǚǒnjǥǡǗǘǖǝ�ǙǘǡǏǚǔǝ��ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǙǘǡǏǚǔ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�ǗNJ�ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǏ�ǒ�ǎnjǒ-ǐǏǗǒǓ�ǖǥǢǦǨbȃ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǎǕǩ�ǔNJǐǎǘǍǘ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�ǙNJǜǜǏǚǗǥ�ǎnjǒǐǏ-ǗǒǓ� Ǜ� ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǗǥǖǒ� njǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǖǒ� ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔNJǖǒ� �ǑNJǎǏǚǐǔNJǖǒ� ǒ�ǙNJǝǑNJǖǒ���ƴǚǘǖǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǎǕǩ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǗǥ�ǛǜǒǕǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǒ�ǛǏ-ǖNJǗǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǩǑǥǔNJ��ƪǗNJǕǒǑ�ǧǜǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��nj�ǛǘnjǘǔǝǙǗǘǛǜǒ�Ǜ�ǘNjǥǡǗǥǖǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖǒ��ǞǒǔǛǒǚǝǏǖǥ-ǖǒ�njǒǎǏǘǔNJǖǏǚǘǓ��ǞǘǚǖNJ�ǕǒǠNJ��ǞǘǚǖNJ�ǛǏǜǡNJǜǔǒ��ǎnjǒǐǏǗǒǩ�ǍǕNJǑ�ǒbǜ�ɋǙ���ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǜ� ǛǘǑǎNJǜǦ� ǖǗǘǍǘǙNJǚNJǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǝǨ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǛnjǏǚǟnjǥǛǘǔǘǓ�ǑNJǣǒǣǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�

LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩƮƸƵlj�LJƵƯƴƼƺƸƷƷƸƳ�ƴƸƶƶƯƺǀƲƲ�nj�ƬƬƹ�ƻǂƪbȃ�����Ɍ���nj�ǜǘ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǔNJǔ��ǗNJ-ǙǚǒǖǏǚ�� nj� ƴǘǚǏǏbȃ� ����Ɍ��� LJǜǘ� ǘNjǝǛǕǘnjǕǏǗǘ� nj� ǙǏǚnjǝǨ� ǘǡǏǚǏǎǦ� Ǚǚǒ-ǛǜNJǕǦǗǥǖ�njǗǒǖNJǗǒǏǖ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ��NjǒǑǗǏǛNJ�ǒ�ǢǒǚǘǔǘǓ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ-Ǜǜǒ�ǔ�ǚǏǍǕNJǖǏǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��NJ� ǜNJǔǐǏ� ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔǘǓ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ� nj� ǎNJǗǗǘǓ� ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒbȃ� ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ� ǘ� ǚǏ-ǍǕNJǖǏǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǜNJǔǘǓ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǨǜǛǩ�nj�ǜǏǛǗǘǖ�Ǜǘǜǚǝǎ-ǗǒǡǏǛǜnjǏ� Ǜ� ǧǔǛǙǏǚǜǗǥǖ� ǛǘǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǘǖ� ǒ� ǗNJ� ǘǛǗǘnjǏ� njǛǏǛǜǘǚǘǗǗǒǟ� ǒǛ-ǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǚǏNJǕǒǓ�ǒ�ǙǏǚǛǙǏǔǜǒnj�ǒǟ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�

ƲǖǏǗǗǘ�ǜNJǔǘǍǘ�ǚǘǎNJ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǛǎǏǕNJǕǘ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǥǖ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǘ-njNJǗǒǏ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ��ǔNJǔ�H%D\��$PD]RQ��3D\3DO�ǒ�Ǚǚ�

ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒ�ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ��ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ��nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒƺƪƱƬƲƼƲƯ�Ʋ�ƽƼƸǁƷƯƷƲƯ�ƷƸƺƶƪƼƲƬƷƸ�ƹƺƪƬƸƬƸƳ�ƫƪƱDž��ǔNJǛNJǨǣǏǓǛǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǥǖ�ǒ�ǛǚǘǡǗǥǖ�ǢNJǍǘǖ� ǎǕǩ� ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�� ǁNJǛǜǒǡǗǘǏ� ǑNJǒǖǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǏ� ǘǙǥǜNJ�

46 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 48: User identification analysis

ƻǂƪ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǥǖ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǔNJǛNJǨǣǏǍǘ-Ǜǩ� ǙǘǚǩǎǔNJ� ǗǘǚǖǘǜnjǘǚǡǏǛǜnjNJ� nj� ǎNJǗǗǘǓ� ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�� ǘNjǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǗǘǛǜǦ� ǚǏ-ǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ�ǚǏNJǕǒǩǖǒ��ǙǚǒnjǕǏǡǏǗǒǏ�ǧǔǛǙǏǚǜǗǘǍǘ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǛǜnjNJ�ǒ�ǘǠǏǗǔNJ�ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǓ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǒ�Ǚǘ-ǑǒǜǒnjǗǥǟ��ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�njNJǐǗǥǖǒ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǣǒǖǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǒǖǘǍǘ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘ-njNJǗǒǩ�

ƹǘǟǘǐǏǓ� ǙǘǑǒǠǒǒ� ǙǚǒǎǏǚǐǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ� ǒ� ǔ�ǜ�ɋǗ�� ƪ�Ɍƭ�ɊƻNJNjNJǗǘnj� nj� ǛǜNJǜǦǏ�mƸNjǑǘǚ�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǘǓ�ǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘǓ�NjNJǑǥ�ǙǘbǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}��mƸǙǥǜ�ǙǏǚǏǟǘǎNJ�ǘǜ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǨǣǏǍǘ�ǎǘ�Ǜǒǟ�Ǚǘǚ�����ǎǏǔNJNjǚǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ��ȟɋ��ƾƱ�ǔ�ȟɋ���ƾ��ǙǘǔNJǑNJǕ��ǡǜǘ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǔ�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǨ�ǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǥǏ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǥ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕǦǗǏǏ�njǥǙǝǛǔNJǜǦ�ǙǘǛǕǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǔNJǔ�ǛǞǘǚ-ǖǒǚǘnjNJǗǥ�ǒ�ǘǜǚNJNjǘǜNJǗǥ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥǏ�ǔ�ǒǟ�ǙǘǩnjǕǏǗǒǨ�ǚǏǔǘǖǏǗǎNJǜǏǕǦ-ǗǥǏ�� ǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǥǏ�ǖǏǐǎǝ� ǛǘNjǘǓ�ǙǘbǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǝ� mǔǒǚǙǒǡǒǔ� ǔ� ǔǒǚǙǒǡǒǔǝ}��LJǜǘ�ǙǘǛǕǝǐǒǜ�ǞǝǗǎNJǖǏǗǜǘǖ�ǎǕǩ�ǛǜǚǘǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǔ�ǒǛǙǘǕ-ǗǏǗǒǨ�NjNJǑǥ��ƼǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǩ�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�mnjǥǑǚǏǜǦ}�ǎǘ�ǍǘǜǘnjǗǘǛǜǒ�ǔ�Ǣǒǚǘǔǘǖǝ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǨ��ƲǎǏNJǕǦǗǥǖ�njNJǚǒNJǗǜǘǖ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǩnjǒǜǦǛǩ�ǛǕǝǡNJǓ��ǔǘǍǎNJ�Ǘǘǚ-ǖNJǜǒnjǗNJǩ�NjNJǑNJ�ǗNJ�ǢNJǍ�ǘǙǏǚǏǐNJǏǜ�ǑǚǏǕǘǛǜǦ�ǚǥǗǔNJ��Ƭ�ǡNJǛǜǒ�ǗǘǚǖǒǚǘnjNJ-Ǘǒǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǝǡǒǜǥnjNJǜǦ�ǑNJǚǝNjǏǐǗǥǓ�ǘǙǥǜ��LJǜǘǖǝ�ǖǘ-ǐǏǜ�ǙǘǛǙǘǛǘNjǛǜnjǘnjNJǜǦ�ǒ�ǘNjǑǘǚ��ǙǚǒnjǏǎǏǗǗǥǓ�nj�ǎNJǗǗǘǓ�ǚNJNjǘǜǏ��ƼǘǕǦǔǘ�ǟǘǜǏǕǘǛǦbNjǥ�ǗǏ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǙǏǚǏnjǘǎNJ�Ǜ�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǘǍǘ�Ǎǘǜǘnjǥǟ�ǎǘ-ǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�� NJ�ǙǘǒǛǔNJ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǙǘǎǟǘǎǩǣǏǍǘ� ǛǙǘǛǘNjNJ�ǞǘǚǖǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�Ǘǘǚ-ǖNJǜǒnjǗǘǓ�NjNJǑǥ�ǗNJ�ǗNJǝǡǗǘǓ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ� Ǜ� ǝǡǪǜǘǖ�ǛǙǏǠǒǞǒǔǒ�ǚǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǍǘ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǥ}���

ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǩ

ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJƺƪƱƬƲƼƲƯ� ƻƲƻƼƯƶ� ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ� ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ� nj� ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ� njǘ� ǖǗǘǍǘǖ�ǛnjǩǑNJǗǘ� Ǜ� njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǏǖ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ� ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ǏǣǪ� nj�����bǍǘǎǝ��ǘǍǚǘǖǗǥǏ�ǚNJǑǖǏǚǥ��ǡǒǛǕǏǗǗǘǛǜǦ�ǗNJǛǏǕǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǗǒǑǔǒǓ�ǝǚǘ-njǏǗǦ�ǍǚNJǖǘǜǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǚǒnjǘǎǒǕǒ�ǔ�ǙǘǛǜǘǩǗǗǥǖ�ǛǕǝǡNJǩǖ�ǙǘǎǜNJǛǘnjǔǒ�Ǚǚǒ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjNJǗǒǒ��ǙǘǎǎǏǕǔNJ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�ǜNJǔǐǏ�NjǥǕNJ�ǒ�ǘǛǜNJǪǜǛǩ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗNJ�� ƴ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǖ�njǥNjǘǚNJǖ�����b ǍǘǎNJ�ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǩ�NjǥǕNJ�ǙǘǕǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǙǏǚǏnjǏǎǏǗNJ�ǗNJ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǏ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjNJǗǒǏ�

�� ƪ�Ɍƭ�ɊƻNJNjNJǗǘnjbȃ�mƸNjǑǘǚ�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǘǓ�ǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘǓ�NjNJǑǥ�ǙǘbǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}����mƱNJǣǒǜNJ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��Ζ16Ζ'(}�ȟɋ���ǒǨǕǦ�NJnjǍǝǛǜ�������

47ƫƺƪƱƲƵƲlj

Page 49: User identification analysis

ƹǏǚnjǥǏ�ǛNJǓǜǥ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ǙǘǩnjǒǕǒǛǦ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ��ƬNJǐǗǏǓǢǒǖ�ǧǜNJǙǘǖ�nj�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ�ǛǜNJǕǘ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�Ǜ������Ǚǘb����bǍǘǎ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�Ζ&3�%UDVLO��3.Ζ�%UD]LO�bȃ�ǒǗ-ǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǥ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǒ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ� Ǚǘ-ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǙǝNjǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǔǕǨǡǏǓ��ǠǒǞǚǘnjǥǟ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǏǓ��

ƷǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjNJǩ�NjNJǑNJƷƪ�ƱƪƴƸƷƸƮƪƼƯƵdžƷƸƶ�ƽƺƸƬƷƯ�Ǘǘǚǖǥ�Ζ&3�%UDVLO�NjǥǕǒ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜǥ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ��3URYLVLRQDO�0HDVXUH���������LJǜǒǖbǐǏ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǖ�ǝǛǜNJǗNJnjǕǒnjNJǕǘǛǦ�ǚNJnjǏǗ-Ǜǜnjǘ�ǖǏǐǎǝ� ǠǒǞǚǘnjǘǓ�ǒ� ǘNjǥǡǗǘǓ� ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦǨ� ǎǕǩ� ǕǨNjǥǟ� ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��ƻǘǠǒǘǕǘǍ�ƶNJǚǛǏǕǕǘ�ƫNJǚǚNJ�ǗNJǑnjNJǕ�ǧǜǝ�ǔǘǗǠǏǙǠǒǨ�mǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǖ�ǕǏnjǒ-NJǞNJǗǘǖ}��ǖNJǗǒǞǏǛǜNJǠǒǏǓ�ǗǘnjǘǓ�ǚǘǕǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ�nj�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǘǖ�ǖǒǚǏ��ƼNJǔǒǖ� ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�� ǍǕNJnjǗǥǖ� ǝǛǕǘnjǒǏǖ� ǚNJNjǘǜǥ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� NjǥǕNJ� ǍNJǚNJǗǜǒǩ�ǠǏǗǜǚNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǚǘǕǒ�ǛNJǖǘǍǘ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ�nj�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǒ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ�ǚNJǑǚǏǢǏǗǒǒ�ǔǘǗǞǕǒǔǜǘnj�ǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǘnj��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǖǒ�ǒǗǛǜǒǜǝǜNJǖǒ�ǒ�ǠǏǗǜǚNJǖǒ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǒ�ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔNJ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǟ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǓ�Ǚǚǒ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǒ�ǛǝnjǏǚǏǗǒǜǏǜNJ�

ƻǜǚǝǔǜǝǚNJ�Ζ&3�%UDVLO�ǛǘǛǜǘǒǜ�ǒǑ�ǠǏǙǘǡǔǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǟ�ǠǏǗǜǚǘnj�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��nj�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓbȃ�ǔǘǚǗǏnjǘǓ�ǠǏǗǜǚ�$&�5DL]��ǔǘ-ǜǘǚǘǖǝ�ǑNJǙǚǏǣǏǗǘ�njǥǎNJnjNJǜǦ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǥ�ǔǘǗǏǡǗǥǖ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǖ��ǒ�ǝǙǚNJnjǕǩǨǣǒǓ�ǔǘǖǒǜǏǜ��ǙǘǎǡǒǗǏǗǗǥǓ�ǍǕNJnjǏ�NJǎǖǒǗǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ƹǚǏǑǒ-ǎǏǗǜNJ�ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ��Ƭ�ǛǘǛǜNJnj�ǔǘǖǒǜǏǜNJ�njǟǘǎǩǜ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǒǜǏǕǒ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǘ-Ǎǘ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjNJ��NjǒǑǗǏǛNJ�ǒ�ǙǚǘǞǒǕǦǗǥǟ�ǖǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnj��ƹǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǗǥǏ�ǒ�ǜǏǟ-ǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�Ǘǘǚǖǥ�ǝǛǜNJǗNJnjǕǒnjNJǨǜǛǩ�ǔǘǖǒǜǏǜǘǖ��NJ�ǗǏ�ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǖ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ��ƪǎǖǒǗǒǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǔǘǚǗǏnjǘǍǘ�ǠǏǗǜǚNJ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǑNJǗǒǖNJǏǜǛǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗNJǩ�ǔǘǚǙǘǚNJǠǒǩ�6(5352� �ǜǏǟ-ǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǞǒǕǒNJǕ� ǗNJǕǘǍǘnjǘǍǘ� njǏǎǘǖǛǜnjNJ� ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ��� ƷNJ� ǜǏǔǝǣǒǓ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ�nj�ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ�ǑNJǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǗǘ����ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǠǏǗǜǚǘnj�ǙǏǚnjǘǍǘ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ��ƻ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǑNJ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǝ�ǘǎǘNjǚǏǗǒǩ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǡǏ-Ǜǔǒǟ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǘnj�ǒ�ǘNjǘǚǝǎǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǘǜnjǏǡNJǏǜ�ƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǒǗǛǜǒǜǝǜ�ǒǗ-ǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ��ƷNJ�ǜǏǔǝǣǒǓ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ�njǛǏ�ǘǎǘNjǚǏǗǗǥǏ�ǛǜNJǗ-ǎNJǚǜǥ�ǛǘnjǖǏǛǜǒǖǥ�Ǜ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǒǖǒ�njǏǚǛǒǩǖǒ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǟ��$(6b�����)Ζ36��������56$������ǒ�ǎǚ���

ƬǛǏ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ�ǚNJǑnjǒnjNJǨǜǛǩ�nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǙNJǚNJǎǒǍǖǥ�(�3Ζ1*��ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǨǣǏǓ�ǛǘnjǖǏǛǜǒǖǘǛǜǦ�ǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǘ-ǙǏǚNJNjǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�Ǜ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜǥǖǒ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǖǒ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJǖǒ��Ƭ�ǏǪ�ǘǛ-ǗǘnjǏ�ǕǏǐNJǜ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǘnj�

• ǙǚǏǎǙǘǡǜǏǗǒǏ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǟ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǘnj�

48 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 50: User identification analysis

• ǛnjǘNjǘǎǗǘǏ� ǒǕǒ� ǘǜǔǚǥǜǘǏ� ƹƸ�b ǙǚǘǑǚNJǡǗǘǛǜǦ� ǒ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙǗǘǛǜǦ� ǒǗ-ǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ

• ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǏ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�• ǙǚǏǎǙǘǡǜǏǗǒǏ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǟ�ǗNJ�ǚǥǗǔǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ�Ƭ�����b Ǎǘǎǝ�nj�ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ�NjǥǕ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜ�ǙNJǔǏǜ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘnj�0DUFR�&LYLO�GD�

ΖQWHUQHW��ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǝǨǣǒǓ�ǖǗǘǍǒǏ�NJǛǙǏǔǜǥ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǥǟ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǓ�nj�ǒǗ-ǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�njǘǙǚǘǛǥ�ǛNjǘǚNJ��ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦ-Ǘǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ƻǜǘǒǜ�ǘǜǖǏǜǒǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�nj�NjǚNJǑǒǕǦǛǔǘǓ�ǔǘǗǠǏǙǠǒǒ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǗNJ�ǑNJǣǒǜǝ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǥǖǒ��Ǘǘ�ǗǏ�ǚNJnjǗǘǑǗNJǡǗǥǖǒ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ� ǙǘǗǩǜǒǩǖǒ�� Ƭ� ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ� ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒ-NJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ� 0DUFR� &LYLO� ǎǘǙǘǕǗǩǏǜ� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǏ� ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ� ǘ� ǜNJǓǗǏ�ǙǏǚǏǙǒǛǔǒ�� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ� ǙǏǚǏǙǒǛǔǒ�� ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǗǥǟ� ǚNJǑǍǘnjǘǚǘnj� ǒ� NjNJǗ-ǔǘnjǛǔǘǓ� ǜNJǓǗǏ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ� ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǜǛǩ� nj� ǔǘǗǛǜǒǜǝǠǒǒ� ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ�� ƭǚNJǐ-ǎNJǗǛǔǘǖ� ǔǘǎǏǔǛǏ� ǒ� ǑNJǔǘǗǏ� ǘ� ǑNJǣǒǜǏ� ǙǚNJnj� ǙǘǜǚǏNjǒǜǏǕǏǓ� �0DUFR� &LYLO�njǘ�ǖǗǘǍǘǖ� ǝǜǘǡǗǩǏǜ� ǏǍǘ� ǡNJǛǜǒ�� ǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǥǏ� Ǜ� ǑNJǣǒǜǘǓ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��� Ƭ� ǑNJǔǘǗǏ�� ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�� ǗǏ� ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜǛǩ� ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǏ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦ-Ǘǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǒǛǟǘǎǩ�ǒǑ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǣǏǓ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǘǓ�ǙǚNJǔǜǒǔǒ��ǜNJǔǘnjǥǖǒ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǕǨNjǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ��ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǣǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�� ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǘǓ� ǔNJǜǏǍǘǚǒǒ� mǡǝnjǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ}� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� ǗǏ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ��ƹǘǎ�ǨǚǒǛǎǒǔǠǒǨ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�ǙǘǙNJǎNJǨǜ�njǛǏ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�� ǑNJǗǒ-ǖNJǨǣǒǏǛǩ� ǛNjǘǚǘǖ�� ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǏǖ� ǒǕǒ� ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǘǓ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� ǗNJ� ǜǏǚǚǒǜǘ-ǚǒǒ�ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ��ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǕǨNjǘǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�ǎǘǕǐǏǗ�ǙǘǕǝ-ǡNJǜǦ�ǛǘǍǕNJǛǒǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǗNJ�ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǝ�ǏǍǘ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ƼǚNJǗǛǍǚNJǗǒǡǗNJǩ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡNJ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǚNJǑǚǏǢǏǗNJ��ƷNJ�ǜǏǔǝǣǒǓ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ�nj�ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ�ǗǏ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǚǏǍǝǕǩǜǘǚNJ�ǙǘbǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǗǏ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǥ�ǒ�ǖǏǚǥ�Ǚǚǘǜǒnj�ǗNJǚǝǢǒǜǏǕǏǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ��ǎǕǩ�ǧǜǘǍǘ�ǙǘǜǚǏ-NjǝǏǜǛǩ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǙǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǛǔǒǓ�ǝǔNJǑ��ǙǚǒǗǩǜǒǏ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǍǘ�NjǥǕǘ�ǘǜ-ǕǘǐǏǗǘ�ǒǑ�ǑNJ�njǥNjǘǚǘnj�

ƭǚNJǐǎNJǗǏ�ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ�nj�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ�Ǜ�ƴǘǗǛǜǒǜǝǠǒǏǓ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǒǖǏ-Ǩǜ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�nj�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǘǖ�ǙǘǚǩǎǔǏ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǜǦ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�ǕǨNjǥǖ�ǔNJǛNJǨǣǒǖǛǩ�ǏǍǘ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǖ�� ǟǚNJǗǩǣǒǖǛǩ�nj�NJǚǟǒnjNJǟ�ǒ� ǝǡǚǏǐǎǏǗǒǩǟ�� nj� ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǛǕǝǐNjNJǟ��ǜNJǔ�ǗNJǑǥnjNJǏǖǥǓ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙ�+DEHDV�GDWD� �ƫǚNJǑǒ-Ǖǒǩ�ǙǏǚnjǘǓ�ǑNJǔǚǏǙǒǕNJ�ǙǘǎǘNjǗǘǏ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǗNJ�ǔǘǗǛǜǒǜǝǠǒǘǗǗǘǖ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ���Ƭ�ǜǘbǐǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǥ�ǘNjǩǑNJǗǥ�ǟǚNJǗǒǜǦ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǘ�ǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǟ�nj�ǜǏǡǏǗǒǏ�ǘǎǗǘǍǘ�ǍǘǎNJ��NJ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥbȃ�nj�ǜǏǡǏǗǒǏ�Ǚǘ-ǕǝǍǘǎNJ��ƮǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǘnj�njǘǑǖǘǐǏǗ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǙǘbǛǝǎǏNjǗǘǖǝ�ǘǚǎǏǚǝ��ǔǚǘǖǏ�ǜǘǍǘ�Ǚǘbǒǟ�ǑNJǙǚǘǛǝ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǝnjǏ-ǕǒǡǏǗ�Ǜǚǘǔ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ƹǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǒ�ǒǖǏǨǜ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǑNJǙǚǘǛǒǜǦ�

49ƫƺƪƱƲƵƲlj

Page 51: User identification analysis

ǝǎNJǕǏǗǒǏ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǒǑ�NjNJǑ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǑNJ�ǒǛǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǏǖ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǘǓ�ǒǛǜǘǚǒǒ��ǙǘbǘǔǘǗǡNJǗǒǒ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǗǥǟ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǓ�Ǜ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓ-ǎǏǚǘǖ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘǖ��ǑNJ�ǒǛǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǏǖ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǜǚǏNjǝǏǖǥǟ�ǔ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦ-Ǘǘǖǝ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǨ��

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǖǏǚǥƻ� ƼƯƿƷƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ� ƻƼƸƺƸƷDž�� njǛǏ� njǗǏǎǚǩǏǖǥǏ� ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ� ǎǘǕǐǗǥ� ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜ-ǛǜnjǘnjNJǜǦ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJǖ� ǚNJNjǘǜǥ� ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�� ǍǕNJnjǗǥǖ� ǛǙǘǛǘNjǘǖ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�NjǚNJǝǑǏǚǗǥǏ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ� �ǎǚǝǍǒǏ�ǒǗǜǏǚǞǏǓǛǥ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜǛǩ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�nj�ǔǚNJǓǗǏǖ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ���ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘ�ǖNJǛǢǜNJNjǒǚǘ-njNJǜǦǛǩ�ǔNJǔ�ǗNJ�ǕǘǔNJǕǦǗǘǖ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǗNJ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǖ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ��ƻ�ǛǏǖNJǗǜǒ-ǡǏǛǔǘǓ� ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ�� ǟǚNJǗǒǖNJǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑǘnjǥnjNJǜǦǛǩ� Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǘǗǜǘǕǘǍǒǓ��ǜNJǔǛǘǗǘǖǒǓ�ǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǖǏǜǘǎǘnj�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJ-Ǡǒǒ�ǒ� ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ��ƮǘǕǐǏǗ�NjǥǜǦ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗ� ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǥǓ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ� ǔ�ǒǗ-ǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǚǏǙǘǑǒǜǘǚǒǩǖ�ǎǕǩ�njǛǏǟ�ǑNJǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�ǕǒǠ�ǒ�njǘǑ-ǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�ǗNJǎ�ǒǟ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǏǖ�

Ƭ�����bǍǘǎǝ�ǗNJ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǖ�ǎǘǖǏǗǏ�JRY�EU�NjǥǕǘ�ǑNJǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒ-ǚǘnjNJǗǘ� ǘǔǘǕǘ� ��� ǜǥǛǩǡ� ǛNJǓǜǘnj�ǒ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�� ƻǚǏǎǒ� ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǟ�ǗNJǙǚNJnj-ǕǏǗǒǓbȃ�ǙǚǘǑǚNJǡǗǘǛǜǦ�NjǨǎǐǏǜǘnj�ǒ� ǍǘǛǑNJǔǝǙǘǔ�njǛǏǟ� ǝǚǘnjǗǏǓ�� ǑNJǙǚǘ-Ǜǥ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ��ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǏ�ǘNjǛǝǐǎǏǗǒǏ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒǗǒǠǒNJǜǒnj��ǑNJǣǒǜNJ�ǙǚNJnj�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ��ǁǏǚǏǑ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǗǥ�ǜNJǔǒǏ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍǒ��ǔNJǔ�ǎǏǔǕNJǚNJǠǒǩ� ǒ� ǘǙǕNJǜNJ� ǗNJǕǘǍǘnj� ǒ� ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔNJ� ǎǘǕǍǘnj�� ǑNJǔNJǑ� ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��ǙǘǒǛǔ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ��ǑNJǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ�nj�ǙǘǕǒǠǒǨ��ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǔǝǚǛǥ�ǒ�NjǒNjǕǒǘǜǏǔǒ�

ƻ�njǥNjǘǚǘnj�����bǍǘǎNJ�nj�ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘ�ǚNJǑnjǒnjNJǨǜǛǩ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒ-ǡǏǛǔǒǏ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� nj� ǘǛǗǘnjǗǘǖ� Ǜ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ� ǘǜ-ǙǏǡNJǜǔǘnj�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��ƲǑ�ǑNJ�njǥǛǘǔǘǍǘ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�NjǏǎǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ�ǗǒǑǔǘǍǘ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�ǍǚNJǖǘǜǗǘǛǜǒ�ǝ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�NjǘǕǦǢǘǍǘ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjNJ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǗǏǜ�njǘǘNjǣǏ�ǗǒǔNJǔǒǟ�ǘǞǒǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�� ǎNJǐǏ� ǛnjǒǎǏǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ǘ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǒ��Ƭ�ǜǘbǐǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�Ǣǒǚǘǔǘ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǘ�ǖǘǢǏǗǗǒǡǏǛǜnjǘ�Ǜ�ǙǘǛǘNjǒǩǖǒ��ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǥǖǒ�ǔNJǚǜNJǖǒ��Ǚǚǒ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjNJǗǒǒ��Ƭ�����bǍǘǎǝ�NjǥǕ�ǑNJǙǝǣǏǗ�njǜǘ-ǚǘǓ�ǧǜNJǙ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥbȃ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�NjǥǕNJ�njǗǏǎǚǏ-ǗNJ�nj����ǢǜNJǜNJǟ��ǒǑ������ƴ�njǥNjǘǚNJǖ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǘǓ�njǘǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǕǒǛǦ�NjǘǕǏǏ� ��� ǖǕǗ� ǒǑNjǒǚNJǜǏǕǏǓ�� ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ǚǏǑǔǘ�njǥǚǘǛǕǘ�nj� ǛnjǩǑǒ� Ǜ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜǒǏǖ�ǙǘnjǥǢǏǗǗǥǟ�ǖǏǚ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǏǚǏǎ�ǡǏǖǙǒǘǗNJǜǘǖ�ǖǒǚNJ�ǙǘbǞǝǜNjǘǕǝ������ǒ�ǘǕǒǖǙǒNJǎǘǓ�������nj�ǡNJǛǜ-ǗǘǛǜǒ��NjǥǕNJ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗNJ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ�ǕǒǠ�ǗNJ�ǜǚNJǗǛǙǘǚǜǏ�ǒ�ǛǜNJ-ǎǒǘǗNJǟ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǎǚǘǗǘnj��ǒ�NjNJǑNJ�ǙǚNJnjǘǗNJǚǝǢǒǜǏ-ǕǏǓ�����ǖǕǗ�ǑNJǙǒǛǏǓ��

50 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 52: User identification analysis

ƴNJǚǜǘǡǔNJ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ� ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ� �F«GXOD� GH� LGHQWLGDGH�� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�Ǜ� ǗNJǡNJǕNJ� ��b njǏǔNJ�� ǒ� njǛǏǍǎNJ� ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǕNJ� ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǒ� ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj� NjǕNJǍǘǎNJǚǩ�ǙǒǘǗǏǚǝ�ǎNJǔǜǒǕǘǛǔǘǙǒǒ�ƿǝNJǗǝ�ƬǝǡǏǜǒǡǝ��NjǕǒǑǔǘǖǝ�ǔ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗ-Ǘǥǖ� ǔǚǝǍNJǖ� ǛǜǚNJǗǥ� ǜǘǍǘ� njǚǏǖǏǗǒ�� ƻǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗNJǩ� ǔNJǚǜNJ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ�NjNJǚǔǘǎ��nj�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖ�ǛǔǘǙǒǚǘnjNJǗNJ�njǛǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ��ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJ-ǣNJǩǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǔNJǚǜǏ��ƴNJǚǜNJ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ�ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ�ǘǜǕǒǡNJǏǜǛǩ�ǕǒǢǦ�ǠnjǏǜǘǖ��ƻ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗNJǖ�njǥǎNJǨǜǛǩ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ��ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜ-ǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǏ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJǖ�Ζ&$2��ƹǚǒǗǠǒǙ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǗǘǖǏǚNJ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǑNJnjǒ-Ǜǒǜ�ǘǜ�ǢǜNJǜNJ�ǒ�ǗǏ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜǛǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ƮǕǩ�ǧǜǒǟ�ǠǏǕǏǓ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜǛǩ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�&3)��NJǗNJǕǘǍ�ƲƷƷ���njǙǚǘǡǏǖ��ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǑNJǙǒǛNJǗǗǥǓ�nj�ǔNJǚǜǏ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ��ƲǑ�ǑNJ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǡǜǘ�njǥǙǝǛǔ�ǔNJǚǜ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǙǚǏǚǘǍNJǜǒnjǘǓ�ǢǜNJǜǘnj��ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗ�njǙǘǕǗǏ�ǕǏǍNJǕǦǗǘ�ǖǘ-ǐǏǜ�ǒǖǏǜǦ����ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǓ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒbȃ�ǏǎǒǗǘǓ�NjNJǑǥ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�ǗǏ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ��ƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǒ�ǏǎǒǗǘǍǘ�ǞǘǚǖNJǜNJ�ǔNJǚǜ�NjǥǕ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜ�ǏǣǏ�nj� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ�� Ǜ� ����b ǍǘǎNJ� njǏǎǪǜǛǩ� ǜǏǛǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǗǘnjǘǍǘ�ǞǘǚǖNJǜNJ� ǔNJǚǜ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ�5Ζ&��5HJLVWUR�GH�ΖGHQWLGDGH�&LYLO��Ǜ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗNJǕǘǖ�ǛǖNJǚǜǔNJǚ-ǜǥ��ƴNJǚǜNJ�5Ζ&�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǘNjǤǏǎǒǗǒǜǦ�nj�ǛǏNjǏ�njǛǏ�ǒǖǏǨǣǒǏǛǩ�nj�ƫǚNJ-ǑǒǕǒǒ�Ǟǘǚǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǥ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�ǎǕǩ�ǏǍǘ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǩ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ǏǎǒǗǘǓ�NjNJǑǥ�ǒ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡNJ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǓ�njǥǙǝǛǔNJ�ǔNJǚǜ�ǘǜ�ǢǜNJǜǘnj�ǗNJ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ��Ƭ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǒǓ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ�ǗǘnjǥǏ�ǔNJǚ-ǜǥ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜǛǩ�ǕǒǢǦ�nj�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǒǟ�ǔǚǝǙǗǥǟ�ǍǘǚǘǎNJǟ��NJ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜ�ǘǞǒǠǒ-NJǕǦǗǘ�ǛǡǒǜNJǏǜǛǩ�ǑNJǖǘǚǘǐǏǗǗǥǖ�

&3)��&DGDVWUR�GH�3HVVRD�)¯VLFD���NjǚNJǑǒǕǦǛǔǒǓ�NJǗNJǕǘǍ�ƲƷƷ��ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǖ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ� ǗǘǖǏǚǘǖ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ� ǒ� ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǘnj� Ǎǘ-ǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ�����ǑǗNJǡǗǥǓ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�&3)�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǒ�ǙǏǚǖNJǗǏǗǜ-Ǘǥǖ��ƪǗNJǕǘǍǘǖ�ǎǕǩ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�&13-��ƷǏǛǖǘǜǚǩ�ǗNJ�ǜǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�&3)�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜǛǩ�nj�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǏ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ��ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗNJǩ� ǔNJǚǜNJ� &3)�� ǗǏǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗNJǩ� ǔ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǨ�� Ƭ� ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ� ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ� ǘNjǢǒǚǗǥǓ� ǚǥǗǘǔ� Ǚǘb ǙǚǘǎNJǐǏ� ǗǘǖǏǚǘnj� &3)�ǎǕǩ�ǖǘǢǏǗǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǠǏǕǏǓ��ƮǕǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�&3)�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ�ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǏ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�

ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒ�ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ��ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ��nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒƷƯƻƶƸƼƺlj� Ʒƪ� ƼƸ�� ǁƼƸ� ƫƺƪƱƲƵdžƻƴƸƯ� ƭƸƻƽƮƪƺƻƼƬƸ� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ� ǝǐǏ� Ǚǘǡǜǒ����bǕǏǜ��ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ�ǐǒǑǗǒ�ǖǗǘǍǒǟ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǛǜǚNJǗNJǖ�ǜǚǏǜǦǏ-Ǎǘ�ǖǒǚNJ��Ʒǘ�Ǚǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǎNJǐǏ�NjǏǎǗǘǜNJ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘ�ǘǛnjNJǒnjNJǏǜ�ǗǘnjǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘ-

51

Page 53: User identification analysis

ǕǘǍǒǒ�ǒ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǝǨ�ǔǝǕǦǜǝǚǝ��ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǩbȃ�ǘǎǒǗ�ǒǑ�ǙǒǘǗǏǚǘnj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗ-ǗǘǍǘ� ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�� ƷNJǕǘǍǘnjǥǏ� ǎǏǔǕNJǚNJǠǒǒ� ǙǘǎNJǨǜǛǩ� ǙǚNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǠǏǕǒǔǘǖ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ��ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǎǕǩ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǘǟnjNJ-ǜǥnjNJǏǜ�njǛǏ�ǜǏǚǚǒǜǘǚǒǒ��ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǘǏ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǘ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘ�njǕǒǩǏǜ�ǗNJ�Ǚǚǒ-ǗǩǜǒǏ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǙǚǘǏǔǜǘnj�ǙǝǜǏǖ�ǛǏǜǏnjǥǟ�ǘNjǛǝǐǎǏǗǒǓ�

ƷǏǛǖǘǜǚǩ�ǗNJ�ǙǚǘNjǏǕǥ�nj�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�NJǛǙǏǔǜNJǟ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ��0DU-FR�&LYLO� GD� ΖQWHUQHW� ǙǘǔNJǑǥnjNJǏǜ� ǙǚǏǒǖǝǣǏǛǜnjǘ� ǔǘǖǙǕǏǔǛǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǎǟǘǎNJ�ǔ�ǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǖǝ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǓ��ǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǥǟ�Ǜ�ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ�ǙǏǚǏǎ�ǙǘǙǥǜǔNJǖǒ�ǛǢǒǜǦ�mǕǘǛǔǝǜ-ǗǘǏ�ǘǎǏǩǕǘ}�ǒǑ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǙǘǙǚNJnjǘǔ�ǔ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJǖ��ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǝǨǣǒǖ�ǖǗǘǍǘ-ǡǒǛǕǏǗǗǥǏ� ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ� ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǔǒ� ǒ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǥǟ� ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǓ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǑNJǜǚNJǍǒnjNJǏǜ�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�

ƸNjǣNJǩ�ǒǎǏǘǕǘǍǒǩ�ǙNJǚNJǎǒǍǖǥ�(�3Ζ1*�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǘNjǚNJǑǠǘǖ�ǚNJǑǝǖǗǘ-Ǎǘ�ǙǘǎǟǘǎNJ�ǎǕǩ� ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ�� ƼǏǟǗǘ-ǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǖǏǚǥ�ǗǏ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǩǜǦǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǑNJ-ǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǖ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ��NJ�ǙǘǎǑNJǔǘǗǗǥǏ�NJǔǜǥ��nj�ǛnjǘǨ�ǘǡǏǚǏǎǦ��ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�ǙǏǚǒǘǎǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǘNjǗǘnjǕǩǜǦǛǩ��ǛǕǏǎǝǩ�ǒ�ǙǚǏǎnjǘǛǟǒǣNJǩ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǒ�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ��ƹǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǘǡǏnjǒǎǗǥ�ǙǚǏǒǖǝǣǏǛǜnjNJ�ǛǕǏǎǘnjNJ-Ǘǒǩ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǖ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǖ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJǖ�

ƴNJǔ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǝ� Ǜ� ǛǒǕǦǗǥǖǒ� ǛǘǠǒNJǕǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ� ǜǚNJǎǒǠǒǩǖǒ�� ǎǕǩ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ��njǏǚǘǩǜǗǘ��NjǝǎǏǜ�NjǕǒǑǘǔ�ǒ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎ�ǔ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖǝ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǝ�ǔNJǔ�ǔ�ǏǣǏ�ǘǎǗǘǓ�ǙǘǕǗǘǠǏǗǗǘǓ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǣǏǓ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ��ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǘ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǘǛǜǘ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ�ǒ�ǙǕNJǜǞǘǚǖǝ��Ǘǘ�ǍNJǚNJǗǜǒǚǝǏǜ�ǙǚNJnjNJ�ǒ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǦ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��Ǜǜǚǘǒǜ�ǒǗǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǝ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛ-ǕǏbȃ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǝǨ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��

ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚ

ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJƻ������ƭƸƮƪ�ƹƸƻƵƯ�ƹƺƲƷljƼƲlj�ƪǔǜNJ�ǘ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ��njǛǏ�ǚǏ-ǑǒǎǏǗǜǥ� ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ� ǛǜNJǚǢǏ� ��b ǕǏǜ� ǘNjǩǑNJǗǥ� ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ� ƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǝǨ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǘǗǗǝǨ�ǔNJǚǜǝ� �15Ζ&�bȃ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�ǎǘǔǝ-ǖǏǗǜ�ǧǜǘǍǘ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ��ƷǘǖǏǚNJǖ�15Ζ&�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǜ�ǛǡǏǜNJ�nj�ǀǏǗǜǚNJǕǦ-Ǘǘǖ� ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjǘǖ� ǞǘǗǎǏ� ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ� �ǙǏǗǛǒǘǗǗǥǓ� ǞǘǗǎ��� ƴNJǚǜǘǡǔNJ� 15Ζ&�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǘNjǚNJǑǏǠ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǘnj�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj�ǒ�Ǣǜǚǒǟǔǘǎ�ǎǕǩ�ǝǎǘNjǛǜnjNJ�ǛǡǒǜǥnjNJǗǒǩ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ƽǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjǘ�ǔNJǚǜ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǥǟ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǘnj�)Ζ1�NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǗǘ�ǒ�ǘǜǕǒǡNJǏǜǛǩ�ǕǒǢǦ�ǎǒǑNJǓǗǘǖ��ƴNJǚǜǥ�15Ζ&�)Ζ1�Ǣǒǚǘǔǘ�ǒǛ-

52 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 54: User identification analysis

ǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜǛǩ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǖǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǒ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒ-ǑNJǠǒǩǖǒ�ǎǕǩ�NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǝǡǏǜNJ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj�njǖǏǛǜǘ�ǛǘNjǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�

Ƭ�����b Ǎǘǎǝ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘǖ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ�NjǥǕNJ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜNJ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖNJ�ǙǘbǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǨ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�H�*RYHUQPHQW�$FWLRQ�3ODQ����nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ�njǛǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�NjǥǜǦ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ-Ǘǥ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ��ǔNJǔ�ǎǕǩ�ǐǒǜǏǕǏǓ�ǘǛǜǚǘnjǗǘǍǘ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ��ƸǎǗǘǓ�ǒǑ�ǍǕNJnjǗǥǟ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩ-Ǩǣǒǟ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥ�ǛǜNJǕNJ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�6LQJDSRUH�3HUVRQDO�$FFHVV��6LQJSDVV�bȃ� ǏǎǒǗǘǓ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǎǕǩ� ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ�� ǙǚǒǢǏǎ-ǢǏǓ�ǗNJ�ǛǖǏǗǝ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǗǘǖǏǚNJ�ǀǏǗǜǚNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjǘ-Ǎǘ�ǞǘǗǎNJ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ��Ƭ�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǧǜǘǓbǐǏ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥ�NjǥǕǒ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǥ� ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ� ǙǘǚǜNJǕǥ� ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ� ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJb ȃ� H&LWL]HQ� ǒ� *H%Ζ=��Ƭb����bǍǘǎǝ�NjǥǕNJ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜNJ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖNJ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�L*RY������nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǔǘ-ǜǘǚǘǓ�ǔ�����bǍǘǎǝ�NjǥǕNJ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗNJ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�8QLTXH�(QWLW\�1XPEHU��8(1�bȃ�NJǗNJǕǘǍ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�15Ζ&�6LQJSDVV�ǎǕǩ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ�

Ƭ�����bǍǘǎǝ�ǙǚǘǒǑǘǢǕNJ�ǝǜǏǡǔNJ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǘǔǘǕǘ�����ǜǥǛǩǡ�NJǔǔNJǝǗǜǘnj�6LQJSDVV� nj� ǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜǏ� njǑǕǘǖNJ�ǗǏǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��ƹǘ-ǛǕǏǎǘnjNJnjǢǒǓ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǓ�ǚǏǑǘǗNJǗǛ�njǥǗǝǎǒǕ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ǙǏǚǏ-ǛǖǘǜǚǏǜǦ� ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǝ� L*RY����� nj� ǛǜǘǚǘǗǝ� ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ� NjǘǕǦǢǏǓ� NjǏǑ-ǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�6LQJ3DVV�

ƹǚNJnjǘnjǥǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjǥƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǘ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚ� Ǜ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜNJ� ǛnjǘǏǍǘ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ� Ǜǘ-NjǘǓ�ǘǎǒǗ�ǒǑ�ǛNJǖǥǟ�ǝǛǙǏǢǗǥǟ�ǙǚǒǖǏǚǘnj�mǝǙǚNJnjǕǩǏǖǘǓ}�ǎǏǖǘǔǚNJǜǒǒ��ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǗNJ�ǍǕNJnjǏǗǛǜnjǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ�nj�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǐǒǑǗǒ�ǒ�ǖNJǔ-ǛǒǖNJǕǦǗǘǓ� ǛnjǘNjǘǎǏ�nj� ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� ǛǞǏǚǏ�� NJ� ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǗǏǙǚǒǖǒǚǒǖǘǓ�NjǘǚǦNjǏ�Ǜ�ǔǘǚǚǝǙǠǒǏǓ�

ƻǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǗNJNjǕǨǎǏǗǒǩbȃ�ǘǜ�njǏǑǎǏǛǝǣǒǟ�ǔNJǖǏǚ�ǎǘ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓ-ǎǏǚǘnjbȃ�ǙǚǒnjǥǡǗNJǩ�ǡNJǛǜǦ�ǐǒǑǗǒ�ǐǒǜǏǕǏǓ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ��ƹǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǒ-ǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǘǚǍNJǗǥ�ǒǖǏǨǜ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǜNJǔǒǖ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖ�ǙǏǚǏǙǒǛǔǒ��ǛǙǒ-ǛǔNJǖ�ǑnjǘǗǔǘnj��ǒǛǜǘǚǒǒ�ǙǘǛǏǣǏǗǒǓ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǒ�ǜ�ɋǎ��NjǏǑ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǘǍǘ�ǘǚǎǏǚNJ��ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ƪǔǜǝ�ǘ�ǔǒNjǏǚǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǗǘǛǜǒ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�ǛǘNjǒ-ǚNJǜǦ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǒ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǜǦ�ǒǟ�nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǚǘǑǥǛǔǗǘǓ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ��Ƭ�ǜǘbǐǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǏ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�ƽǍǘǕǘnjǗǘǍǘ�ǔǘǎǏǔǛNJ�ǗNJǙǒǛNJǗǥ�ǜNJǔǒǖ�ǩǑǥǔǘǖ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�Ǚǚǒ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ-Ǜǜǒ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜǦ�njǛǨ�ǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǝǨǣǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�NjǏǑ�ǕǒǢǗǒǟ�njǘǙǚǘǛǘnj��Ƭ�����bǍǘǎǝ�Ǚǚǘǜǒnj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�NjǥǕ�njǙǏǚnjǥǏ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǓ�Ǜ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘNj�ǧǔǛǜǚǏǖǒǑǖǏ��ƾǘǚǖǝǕǒǚǘnjǔǒ�ǑNJǔǘ-

53ƻƲƷƭƪƹƽƺ

Page 55: User identification analysis

ǗNJ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǜ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǜǦ�ǏǍǘ�Ǚǚǘǜǒnj�ǕǨNjǥǟ�ǙǚǘǩnjǕǏǗǒǓ�ǗǏǎǘnjǘǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘǖ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ��ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚbȃ�ǘǎǒǗ�ǒǑ�ǕǒǎǏǚǘnj�ǙǘbǔǘǕǒǡǏ-Ǜǜnjǝ�ǑNJǙǚǘǛǘnj�ǗNJ�ǚNJǛǔǚǥǜǒǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǔ�)DFHERRN�ǒ�*RRJOH�

ƷǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ� ǘǜǖǏǜǒǜǦ�� ǡǜǘ� ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǏ� ǐǒǜǏǕǏǓ� ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ� ǔ� Ǚǘ-ǎǘNjǗǥǖ�ǗNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǩǖ�ǙǚNJnjNJ�ǗNJ�ǡNJǛǜǗǝǨ�ǐǒǑǗǦ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǛǙǘǔǘǓǗǘǏ��ƹǘbǛǘǠǒǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǖ�ǘǙǚǘǛNJǖ��ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗNJǩ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnj-ǕǩǏǜǛǩ�NjǘǕǏǏ�njNJǐǗǥǖ�ǎǘǛǜǒǐǏǗǒǏǖ�

ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖ�LJǎnjNJǚǎNJ�ƻǗǘǝǎǏǗNJ��ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜ�ǧǕǏǔ-ǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�ǢǙǒǘǗNJǐ�ǗǏ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǑNJ�ǛǘNjǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǐǒǜǏǕǩǖǒ��Ǘǘ�ǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗ��ƶNJǕNJǓǑǒǒ��ƲǗǎǘǗǏǑǒǒ��ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǙǏǚǏǟnjNJǜ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǖNJǍǒǛǜǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǔNJNjǏǕǏǓ�

ƽǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǙǘbǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǨ�ǖǏǎǒNJ��0'$��ǘǜnjǏǡNJǏǜ�nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǑNJ�Ǚǘǎ-ǎǏǚǐNJǗǒǏ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�ǖǘǚNJǕǒ�nj�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJǟ�ǖǏǎǒNJǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǓ��ƹǚǘ-njNJǓǎǏǚǥ�ǘNjǩǑNJǗǥ�NjǕǘǔǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǛNJǓǜǥ�ǗNJǚǝǢǒǜǏǕǒ��ǔNJǔ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕǘ��ǙǘǚǗǘ-ǍǚNJǞǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǛNJǓǜǥ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǛNJǓǜǥ�ǑǗNJǔǘǖǛǜnj���ƻb����bǍǘǎNJ�ǙǘǛǕǏ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜǒǩ�ǗǘnjǘǍǘ�NJǗǜǒǙǒǚNJǜǛǔǘǍǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ��ǙǘǙǝǕǩǚǗǥǏ�ǜǚǏǔǏǚǥ�ǒ�ǞNJǓǕ�ǟǘǛǜǒǗǍǒ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǙǘǎǕǏǐNJǜ�NjǕǘǔǒǚǘnjǔǏ�

ưǒǜǏǕǒ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ�ǘNjǩǑNJǗǥ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǒ�NJǔǜǝNJǕǒǑǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǒǗ-ǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�ǘNj�NJǎǚǏǛǏ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǜNJǜǝǛǏ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ��ƷNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕ�ǚǏǍǒ-ǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǔNJǚNJǏǜǛǩ�ǢǜǚNJǞǘǖ�nj�ǚNJǑǖǏǚǏ�ǎǘ����ǜǥǛ��ǒǕǒ�ǜǨǚǏǖǗǥǖ�Ǜǚǘǔǘǖ�ǎǘ��bǕǏǜ��ƹǘǎǎǏǕǔNJ�15Ζ&�ǔNJǚNJǏǜǛǩ�ǢǜǚNJǞǘǖ�ǎǘ�����ǜǥǛ��ǒǕǒ�ǜǨǚǏǖǗǥǖ�Ǜǚǘǔǘǖ�ǎǘ���bǕǏǜ�

ƷǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjNJǩ�NjNJǑNJ�ǒ�ǖǏǚǥƬ� ����� ƭƸƮƽ� ƬƻƼƽƹƲƵ� Ƭ� ƻƲƵƽ� ƱNJǔǘǗ� ǘ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�� ƷǘnjǥǏ�ǖǏǚǥ� ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ǎǘǕǐǗǥ� ǙǘǖǘǡǦ� ǛǒǗǍNJǙǝǚǛǔǒǖ� ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǩǖ� Ǜǘ-ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǘnjNJǜǦ� ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩǖ� Ǚǘb ǑNJǣǒǜǏ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� Ǚǚǒ�ǜǚNJǗǛǍǚNJǗǒǡǗǘǓ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǏ��ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǩǏǖǥǖ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ�� ǛǜǚNJǗNJǖǒ�Ưƻ��ƷǘnjǘǏ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ�ǘǜ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜǦ�ǚNJǑǚǏǢǏǗǒǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǗNJ�ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǝ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǘNjǤǩǛǗǩǜǦ�ǒǖ��ǔNJǔ�Njǝǎǝǜ�ǘNjǚNJNjNJǜǥnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ��ƷǏ�ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǛǩ�ǔ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖ�ǒ�ǕǨNjNJǩ�ǔǘǗǜNJǔǜǗNJǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ��ǛnjǩǑNJǗǗNJǩ�Ǜ�NjǒǑǗǏǛǘǖ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǒǖǩ��ǎǘǕǐǗǘǛǜǦ��ǚNJNjǘǡNJǩ�ǙǘǡǜNJ�ǒ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗ��ƱNJ-ǔǘǗ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǎǚǝǐǏǕǨNjǗǥǖ�ǎǕǩ�NjǒǑǗǏǛNJ�ǒ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�� ƼNJǔ�ǘǗ�ǗǏ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ� Ǘǘǚǖ� ǘ� ǞǝǗǎNJǖǏǗǜNJǕǦǗǘǖ� ǙǚNJnjǏ� ǗNJ� ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ��ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǩǏǜǛǩ�ǒǛǔǕǨǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǗNJ�NjǒǑǗǏǛ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǩ����ƴǚǘǖǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��

�� Ƭ�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǙǚǒǖǏǚNJ�ǙǚNJnjǘǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�ǘ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǗNJ�ǘǞǒǠǒNJǕǦ-Ǘǘǖ�ǛNJǓǜǏ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ�ǙǚǒnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ�ǘǙǒǛNJǗǒǏ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǏǓ�ǛǒǜǝNJǠǒǒ��mƴNJǚǏǗ�

54 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 56: User identification analysis

ǎNJǗǗǥǏ� ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ� ǎǕǩ� ǠǏǕǏǓ�� mǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ� Njǝǎǝǜ� ǛǘǡǜǏǗǥ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎǩǣǒǖǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�ǚNJǑǝǖǗǘǍǘ�nj�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǘNjǛǜǘǩǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJǟ}��ǡǜǘ�ǘǜǔǚǥnjNJǏǜ�ǙǝǜǦ�ǎǕǩ�ǖǗǘǍǒǟ�ǛǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǟ�ǙǚNJǔǜǒǔ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǖNJǛ-Ǜǒnjǘnj�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǔ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǖ�ǏǛǜǦ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǥǏ�njǘǙǚǘǛǥ�ǝ�ǛǜǚNJǗ�Ưƻ��Ƹǚ-ǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǟǚNJǗǒǜǦ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��ǙǘǔNJ�ǧǜǘ� ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ� ǎǕǩ� ǠǏǕǏǓ�� ǑNJǩnjǕǏǗǗǥǟ� Ǚǚǒ� ǛNjǘǚǏ�� ƷNJǔǘǗǏǠ�� ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ� ǗǏ� ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǩǏǜǛǩ� ǗNJ� NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǘ� ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�NJǍǏǗǜǛǜnj�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ��ƮǕǩ�15Ζ&�nj�ǑNJǔǘǗǏ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗNJǩ�ǗǘǚǖNJ��ƼNJǔ�ǗǏ�ǚǏǔǘǖǏǗǎǝǏǜǛǩ�ǛǘNjǒǚNJǜǦ�ǒ�ǟǚNJǗǒǜǦ�15Ζ&��ǏǛǕǒ�ǧǜǘǍǘ�ǗǏ�ǜǚǏNjǝ-ǏǜǛǩ�ǗǏǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�ǎǕǩ�ǠǏǕǏǓ�NjǒǑǗǏǛNJ��ǒ�ǗNJǘNjǘǚǘǜ��ǏǛǕǒ�ǛNjǘǚ�15Ζ&�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖ�� ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ� ǛǘǔǚNJǜǒǜǦ� ǘNjǤǏǖ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ� ǛǘNjǒǚNJǏǖǥǟ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� ǎǘ�ǖǒǗǒǖǝǖNJ��ƺNJǑǍǕNJǢǏǗǒǏ�15Ζ&�ǒǕǒ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡNJ�ǒǟ�ǜǚǏǜǦǒǖ�ǕǒǠNJǖ�ǗǏ�ǑNJ-ǙǚǏǣǏǗNJ��ǏǛǕǒ�ǧǜǘ�ǙǚǘǒǛǟǘǎǒǜ�nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǑNJǩnjǕǏǗǗǥǟ�Ǚǚǒ�ǛNjǘǚǏ�ǠǏǕǏǓ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�ǙǘbnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǚǏǔǘǖǏǗǎǝǏǜǛǩ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǒǜǦǛǩ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǏǓ�ǕǒǢǦ���ǒǑ���ǚNJǑǚǩǎǘnj�ǗǘǖǏǚNJ�

ƸǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǖǏǚǥƻ������ƭƸƮƪ�ƺƯƱƲƮƯƷƼDž�ƻƲƷƭƪƹƽƺƪ�ǛǜNJǚǢǏ���bǕǏǜ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�6LQJ3DVV�Ζ'�ǎǕǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍNJǖ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��ƮǕǩ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ�6LQJ3DVV�ǗǏ-ǘNjǟǘǎǒǖ�ǘǎǒǗ�ǒǑ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǗǘǖǏǚǘnj��ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ��ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ��ǚNJNjǘǡǏǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǝǡǏNjǗǘǓ�njǒǑǥ��ƵǒǠNJ��ǙǘǕǝǡNJǨǣǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ��15Ζ&��)Ζ1�ǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǏ��ǙǘǕǝǡNJǨǜ�6LQJ3DVV�njǖǏǛǜǏ�Ǜ�ǙNJ-ǔǏǜǘǖ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��ƮǕǩ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǔNJǜǏǍǘǚǒǓ�ǕǒǠ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǏ�6LQJ3DVV�njǘǑ-ǖǘǐǗǘ�nj�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǒǕǒ�nj�ǠǏǗǜǚNJǟ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ��ƻ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ� ǕǒǠNJ� ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ� ǙǘǕǝǡNJǨǜ� ǝǗǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ� ǗǘǖǏǚNJ�8(1��ǘNjǤǏǎǒǗǩǨǣǒǏ�njǛǏ�ǜǒǙǥ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�Ǘǘ-ǖǏǚǘnj� �ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ƲƷƷ��ƫƲƴ�ƸƭƺƷ�ǒ� ǜ�ɋǎ�� ǘǎǗǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǘ��� ƱNJǚǝNjǏǐǗǥǏ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ��njǏǎǝǣǒǏ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǜǏǚǚǒǜǘǚǒǒ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ��ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǖǘ-Ǎǝǜ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�8(1��ƮǕǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǍǘǛǑNJǔǝǙǔNJǖ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜǛǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�($6<��H�6HUYLFHV�$XWKRUL-VDWLRQ�6\VWHP���nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�njǥǎNJǜǦ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦ-ǗǥǏ� ǔǘǎǥ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ� ǎǕǩ� ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔǘnj�� ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǣǒǏ� ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǒǜǦ� ǘǙǏ-

ǙǚǒǘNjǚǏǜNJǏǜ�ǑNJǚǝNjǏǐǗǥǓ�ǜǝǚ�ǝ�ǜǝǚǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�NJǍǏǗǜǛǜnjNJ�'()��ƮǕǩ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǒǜǦ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ǙǘbǔǘǗǜǚNJǔǜǝ� Ǜ�ƴNJǚǏǗǘǖ�� ǛǘnjǏǚǢǒǜǦ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥǏ�NjǚǘǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǘǜǏǕǏǓ��NJǍǏǗǜǛǜnjǝ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǜǦ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ƴNJǚǏǗNJ��ǜNJǔǒǏ��ǔNJǔ�ǒǖǩ��ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦ-ǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ��ǜǚNJǗǛǍǚNJǗǒǡǗǘ�nj�ǜǏ�ǘǜǏǕǒ��nj�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǘǗ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǘǛǜNJǗNJnjǕǒnjNJǜǦǛǩ�njǘ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǙǘǏǑǎǔǒ��Ƭ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǜNJǔNJǩ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡNJ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ƴNJǚǏǗNJ�ǜǝǚǒǛǜǒ-ǡǏǛǔǒǖ�NJǍǏǗǜǛǜnjǘǖ�'()�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǛǘǍǕNJǛǘnjǥnjNJǜǦǛǩ�Ǜ�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩǖǒ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǒǩ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǒ�ǙǏǚǛǘ-ǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��7UDQVIHU�/LPLWDWLRQ�2EOLJDWLRQ���ǔNJǔ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖNJǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǩ�ǘNjǩǑNJ-ǜǏǕǦǛǜnj�ǙǘbǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǝ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǜǝǚNJǍǏǗǜǛǜnjǘǖ�ǒ�ƴNJǚǏǗǘǖ�

55ƻƲƷƭƪƹƽƺ

Page 57: User identification analysis

ǚNJǠǒǒ�ǘǜ�ǕǒǠNJ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ�6LQJ3DVV��ƺǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǜǘǚ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǖǏǗNJ�6*�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ�6LQJ3DVV�ǎǕǩ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǒ�ǙǘǔǝǙNJǜǏǕǩ��ǎǘǖǏǗǥ�6*�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǗǥ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǚǏǑǒ-ǎǏǗǜNJǖ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ��

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǖǏǚǥƷƸƶƯƺƪ�15Ζ&�Ʋ� )Ζ1� ƻƸƮƯƺưƪƼ���ǛǒǖnjǘǕǘnj����NjǝǔnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǙǚǏǞǒǔǛNJ��ǝǔNJ-ǑǥnjNJǨǣǒǟ�ǗNJ�ǛǜNJǜǝǛ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ�ǒ�njǏǔ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǩ����ǠǒǞǚ��ǙǏǚnjǥǏ�ǎnjǏ�ǒǑ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟbȃ�Ǎǘǎ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǩ��ǘǛǜNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǙǚǒǛnjNJǒnjNJǨǜǛǩ�ǛǕǝǡNJǓǗǥǖ�ǘNj-ǚNJǑǘǖ��ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǦǗNJǩ�ǛǝǖǖNJ��6LQJ3DVV�Ζ'bȃ�ǧǜǘ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�15Ζ&�ǒǕǒ�)Ζ1��ǒǕǒ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǛǡǏǜNJ�nj�ǀǏǗǜǚNJǕǦǗǘǖ�ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjǘǖ�ǞǘǗǎǏ��ǛNJǖ�6LQJ3DVV�ǑNJǎNJǏǜǛǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǖ�ǒ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǘǜ���ǎǘ����ǛǒǖnjǘǕǘnj�ǎǕǒǗǘǓ��ǒ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǜǦ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǛǒǖnjǘǕǥ��ǙǚǘNjǏǕǥ��njǏǚǟǗǒǓ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚ��6LQJ3DVV�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǕǨNjǘǖ�ǛǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǘǖ�ǎǏǛǔǜǘǙǗǘǖ�ǒ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǖ�NjǚNJ-ǝǑǏǚǏ�� ƻǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ� njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǩ� 6LQJ3DVV� ǒ� nj� ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǏ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�ǙǘǔNJ�ǘǗNJ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑǘnjNJǗNJ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�nj�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǒ�ǀǏǗ-ǜǚNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjǘǍǘ�ǞǘǗǎNJ�

ƷǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥǏ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǗǥǏ� ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ� 6LQJ3DVV�� ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔNJ� FRRNLH�ǒ�-DYD6FULSW��ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕNJ�ǢǒǞǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�66/�njǏǚǛǒǒ������ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǧǔǛǙǏǚǜ-Ǘǘǖǝ�ǜǏǛǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ��ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�6LQJ3DVV�ǗǏ�NjǥǕNJ�ǙǘǎnjǏǚǐǏǗNJ�NJǜNJǔNJǖ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�+HDUWEOHHG��ƮǕǩ�NjǥǛǜǚǘǍǘ�ǛNjǚǘǛNJ�ǙNJǚǘǕǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǖ�ǚǏǔǘ-ǖǏǗǎǝǏǜǛǩ�ǙǚǒnjǩǑNJǜǦ�ǔ�NJǔǔNJǝǗǜǝ�6LQJ3DVV�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚǛǔǘǍǘ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJ�

Ƭ�ǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǓ�ǟNJǔǏǚǛǔǘǓ�NJǜNJǔǒ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NjǏǑ-ǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�6LQJ3DVV�ǗNJǟǘǎǒǜǛǩ�nj�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǏ�ǙǏǚǏǛǖǘǜǚNJ��ƻǚǏǎǒ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǕNJ-ǗǒǚǝǏǖǥǟ�ǔ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǨbȃ�ǎnjǝǟǞNJǔǜǘǚǗNJǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ� 606�� ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ� ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ� ǒǕǒ� ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ� ǜǘǔǏǗNJ�� NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖ�ǙǚǏǎǝǙǚǏǐǎǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǘ�ǗǏǘNjǥǡǗǘǓ�NJǔǜǒnj-ǗǘǛǜǒ��ǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǘǓ�Ǜ�ǒǟ�NJǔǔNJǝǗǜǘǖ�

ƸǎǒǗ� ǒǑ� ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�� ǎǘǛǜǝǙǗǥǟ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǖ� 6LQJ-3DVVbȃ�ǙǕNJǜǞǘǚǖNJ�2QHΖQER[��ǛǘNjǒǚNJǨǣNJǩ�njǛǨ�ǙǏǚǏǙǒǛǔǝ��ǘǜǗǘǛǩǣǝ-ǨǛǩ�ǔ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖ��ǔNJǔ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ��ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�ǍNJǚNJǗǜǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ�ǎǘǛǜNJnjǔNJ�njNJǐǗǘǓ�ǔǘǚǚǏǛǙǘǗǎǏǗǠǒǒ�nj�ǑNJǣǒǣǏǗǗǘǓ��ǢǒǞǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǛǚǏǎǏ��ǛnjǘNjǘǎǗǘǓ�ǘǜ�ǛǙNJǖNJ��ƴǘǚǚǏǛǙǘǗ-ǎǏǗǠǒǨ�ǒǑ�2QHΖQER[�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǙǏǚǏǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǩǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǘNjǥǡǗǥǏ�NJǎǚǏǛNJ�ǧǕǏǔ-ǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǡǜǥ��ǝnjǏǎǘǖǕǏǗǒǩ�ǘ�Ǘǘnjǥǟ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǩǟ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǜǦǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǘNjǥǡǗǝǨ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǝǨ�Ǚǘǡǜǝ�ǒǕǒ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǓ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗ�

56 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 58: User identification analysis

LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩưƲƼƯƵljƶ� ƻƲƷƭƪƹƽƺƪ� ƮƸƻƼƽƹƷƸ�ǘǔǘǕǘ������ ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�nj�ǒǗ-ǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ������ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ����Ɍ��ǐǒǜǏǕǏǓ�ǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜǛǩ�ǒǖǒ�ǟǘǜǩbNjǥ�ǚNJǑ�nj�Ǎǘǎ��ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚbȃ�ǘǎǒǗ�ǒǑ�ǕǒǎǏǚǘnj�nj�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚNJ-njǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ� nj� ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ� ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǟ� ǚǏǓǜǒǗǍNJǟ� ��� ǖǏǛǜǘ� nj� 81�H*RY�UDQNLQJ����ǖǏǛǜǘ�nj�ǚǏǓǜǒǗǍǏ�*Ζ75���ƹǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǖ�6LQJ3DVV��NjǘǕǏǏ����bǖǕǗ�ǐǒǜǏǕǏǓ��ǎǘǛǜǝǙǗǥ�����ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�ǘǜ����ǘǚ-ǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ��Ƭ�Ǎǘǎ�ǘǗǒ�njǥǙǘǕǗǩǨǜ�NjǘǕǏǏ����ǖǕǗ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘ-njNJǗǒǏǖ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��Ƭ�ǘǜǕǒǡǒǏ�ǘǜ�ǖǗǘǍǒǟ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗ��ǘǛǘNjǘǏ�njǗǒǖNJǗǒǏ�ǝǎǏǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ�NjǒǑǗǏǛǘǖ��ǔ�ǙǚǒǖǏǚǝ��ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ� ǖǘǍǝǜ� ǛǎNJǜǦ� ǘǜǡǏǜǗǘǛǜǦ� Ǚǘb ǚNJNjǘǜǗǒǔNJǖ� Ǜ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ��NJ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǘǙǝǕǩǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǥ�ǛǙǏ-ǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǠǏǗǜǚǥ�Ǚǘǖǘǣǒ�NjǒǑǗǏǛǝ��ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚ�ǛǜNJNjǒǕǦǗǘ�ǑNJǗǒǖNJǏǜ�ǙǏǚ-njǘǏ�ǖǏǛǜǘ�nj�ǚǏǓǜǒǗǍǏ�'RLQJ�%XVLQHVV�ƬǛǏǖǒǚǗǘǍǘ�NjNJǗǔNJ��ǒ�ǛǔǘǚǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǏ-ǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�njNJǐǗǘǓ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǣǏǓ�nj�ǧǜǘǖ�njǘǙǚǘǛǏ�

ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǛǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǒ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�H*RY�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘbȃ�ǧǜǘ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�Ǚǚǘ-njNJǓǎǏǚ�ǎǕǩ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǒ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ��ƮNJǗǗǥǓ�ǙǝǜǦ�NjǥǕ�njǥNjǚNJǗ�ǏǣǪ�nj�����b Ǎǘǎǝ�� ǎǘ�ǙǚǒǟǘǎNJ�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�nj�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚ�Ǚǚǒ�ǙǘǛǜǚǘǏǗǒǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǖǏǐnjǏǎǘǖǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ��ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǙǒǘǗǏǚǘǖ�ƪǑǒǒ�nj�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ��Ǚǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗNJ�ǗNJ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�ǡNJǛǜ-ǗǘǍǘ� ǙNJǚǜǗǏǚǛǜnjNJ�� ƹǘǕǗǘǛǜǦǨ� ǙǚǒnjNJǜǒǑǒǚǘnjNJǗǗNJǩ� ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǩ� &ULP-VRQ/RJLF��ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�6LQJ3DVV��ǒǑǗNJǡNJǕǦǗǘ�ǎǘǡǏǚǗǩǩ�ǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚNJ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjNJ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǙǘǛǜNJnjǣǒǔǘǖ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�nj�ǎǏǛǩǜǔǒ�ǛǜǚNJǗ�ǖǒǚNJ��ǘǜ�ƪnjǛǜǚNJǕǒǒ�ǒ�ƴNJǗNJǎǥ��ǎǘ�ƸƪLJ�ǒ�ƴǒǜNJǩ�

ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒ�ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ��ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ��nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒƸƹDžƼ�ƻƲƷƭƪƹƽƺƪ��ƴƪƴ�ƻƼƺƪƷDž�Ǜ�ǘǎǗǒǖ�ǒǑ�ǗNJǒNjǘǕǏǏ�njǥǛǘǔǒǟ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏǓ�ǚNJǑnjǒ-ǜǒǩ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ�nj�ǖǒǚǏ��ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǔǚNJǓǗǏ�njNJǐǗǥǖ��ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ��ǙǘǛǜǘǩǗǗǘ�ǘNjǗǘnjǕǩǏǖǥǏ�Ǜǒ-ǛǜǏǖǥ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǖǏǚǥbȃ�ǜǚǏNjǝǨǜ�ǙǚǒǛǜNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǒǑǝǡǏǗǒǩ�Ǜǘ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ�ǚǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǒǟ�njǏǎǘǖǛǜnj��ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗ-Ǘǥǟ� ǑNJ� njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǏ� ǒ� ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔǝ� ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǝǨǣǒǟ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�njnjǒǎǝ�ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǘǜǛǜNJnjNJǗǒǩ�ǙǘbǛǚNJnjǗǏǗǒǨ�Ǜ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚǘǖ�Ǚǘb ǝǚǘnjǗǨ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ� Ζ7�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ�nj�ǙǘnjǛǏǎǗǏnj-

57

Page 59: User identification analysis

Ǘǘǖ�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǖ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǒ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǏ�nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJ-Ǡǒǒ�NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǗǥǟ�ǖǏǚ�ǒ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǜǏǔǝǣǒǓ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ�ǛǕNJNjǘ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑǝǏǖǥǖ�

ƴǒǜNJǓ

ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJƬƹƵƸƼdž�ƮƸ������ƭƸƮƪ�ǘǜ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ƴƷƺ�ǗǏ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǕǘǛǦ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜǦ�ǒ�ǗǘǛǒǜǦ�Ǜ�ǛǘNjǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǝǨǣǒǓ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜ������NJǙǚǏǕǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ƹǘǛǜǘǩǗǗǥǓ� ǔǘǖǒǜǏǜ� ƬǛǏǔǒǜNJǓǛǔǘǍǘ� ǛǘNjǚNJǗǒǩ� ǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǟ� ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǒ-ǜǏǕǏǓ� �ƹƴb ƬƻƷƹ�� ǙǚǒǗǩǕ� mƹǚǏǎnjNJǚǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǓ� ƫǒǕǕǦ� ǘNj� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-ǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ� ǔNJǚǜǏ}� �ᷕ⋶Ṣ㮹ℙ⚥⯭㮹幓ấ孩孽埴㜉ἳ��� nj� ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖ�ǙǚǘǙǒ-ǛǥnjNJǕǒǛǦ�ǢNJǍǒ�ǙǘbǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǨ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ� ǗNJ� ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǒ� ǘǙǥǜNJ� ǚNJǑnjǒǜǥǟ� ǛǜǚNJǗ�� ƹǏǚnjǘǏ� ǙǘǔǘǕǏǗǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǕǘ�ǛǘNjǘǓ�ǘǎǗǘǛǜǘǚǘǗǗǨǨ�ǔNJǚǜǝ��ǛǎǏǕNJǗǗǝǨ�ǒǑ�ǙǚǏǛǛǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǙǘǕǒǧǞǒǚǗǘǓ�ǙǕǏǗǔǒ��ƻ������Ǚǘb����bǍǘǎǥ�ǘǙǥǜǗǘǏ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǒǛǙǥǜNJǗǒǏ�Ǘǘnjǥǟ�ǧǜǒǟ�ǔNJǚǜ�ǙǚǘnjǘǎǒǕǘǛǦ�nj�ƹǏ-ǔǒǗǏ��ǂNJǗǟNJǏ�ǒ�ƼǩǗǦǠǑǒǗǏ��ƹǏǚnjǥǖ�njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠǏǖ�ǜNJǔǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǒ�ǛǜNJǕ�ǂNJǗ�ƴǛǒǝǚǘǗ��ǘǙǏǚǗǥǓ�ǙǏnjǏǠ�ǒǑ�ƹǏǔǒǗNJ���

��ǛǏǗǜǩNjǚǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ƹǘǛǜǘǩǗǗǥǓ�ǔǘǖǒǜǏǜ����Ǎǘ�ǛǤǏǑǎNJ�ƬƻƷƹ�Ǚǚǒ-ǗǩǕ�mƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜNJǟ�ƴƷƺ}��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�ǙǚǏǎǙǒǛǥnjNJǕ�njǛǏǖ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗNJǖ��ǗNJǡǒǗNJǩ�Ǜ�njǘǑǚNJǛǜNJ���bǕǏǜ�ǘNjǚNJǣNJǜǦǛǩ�ǑNJ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǏǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ��ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjǘ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ƴƷƺ� ǛǘǑǎNJǕǘ� ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǓ� ǘǚǍNJǗ� ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�� ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǓ� ǑNJ� njǥ-ǙǝǛǔ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜ��&�����bǍǘǎNJ�NjǥǕǒ�njǥǙǝǣǏǗǥ���ǖǒǕǕǒNJǚǎ�����ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ�ǎǕǩ�����ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗǘnj�njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠǏnj��ƻǜǘǕǦ�NjǘǕǦ-ǢNJǩ�ǚNJǑǗǒǠNJ�nj�����ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗǘnj�ǔNJǚǜ�ǘNjǤǩǛǗǩǏǜǛǩ�ǗǏ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�njǥǙǝǛǔǘǖ�ǎǝNjǕǒǔNJǜǘnj�njǑNJǖǏǗ�ǝǜǏǚǩǗǗǥǟ��Ǘǘ�ǒ�ǜǏǖ�ǞNJǔǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�ǛǜNJǕǒ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǗǥ�ǎǕǩ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǒǕǘ�ǖǘǢǏǗǗǒǔNJǖ�ǗNJǕNJǎǒǜǦ�njǥǙǝǛǔ�ǙǘǎǎǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�

��ǒǨǗǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ƹƴbƬƻƷƹ�ǒǑǎNJǕǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�mƸNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǏ� ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ}���� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ� ǚNJǛǢǒǚǒǕ� ǎǒNJǙNJǑǘǗ� njǥǙǝǛǔNJǏǖǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǏǔ�� ǙǘǑnjǘǕǒnj� njǘǏǗǗǘǛǕǝǐNJǣǒǖ�ƷƸƪƴ� ǒ� ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔNJǖ� ǙǘǕǒǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜǦ� ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǒ��ƵǒǠNJ�ǖǘǕǘǐǏ�

�� KWWS���QHZV�UHGQHW�FQ�F��������������������KWP�� KWWS���ZZZ�WKHEHLMLQJQHZV�FRP�QHZV�UHIRUP�����������������#�������KWP�� KWWS���ZZZ�JRY�FQ�EDQVKL������������FRQWHQWB������KWP

58 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 60: User identification analysis

��bǕǏǜ��ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǧǜǘǖǝ�ǑNJǔǘǗǝ��ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǙǘbǛnjǘǏǓ�njǘǕǏ�ǒǖǏǨǜ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǗNJǙǒ-ǛNJǜǦ�ǑNJǩnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǘ�njǥǎNJǡǏ�ǒǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ��ƼNJǔǐǏ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ�ǙǚǏǎǙǒǛNJǗǒǏ�ǘ�njǥǙǝǛǔǏ�ǗǘnjǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�njǜǘǚǘǍǘ�ǙǘǔǘǕǏǗǒǩ��Ǜǘ-ǎǏǚǐNJǣǏǓ�NjǘǕǏǏ�njǥǛǘǔǒǏ� ǛǜǏǙǏǗǒ� ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǘǜ�ǙǘǎǎǏǕǔǒ�ǒ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨ-ǣǏǓ�ǛǡǒǜǥnjNJǜǦ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�ǘ�njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠǏ�ǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJǖǒ��LJǜǘ�ǘǜǔǚǥǕǘ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ�ǙNJǛǛNJǐǒǚNJ�Ǚǚǒ�ǙǚǒǘNjǚǏǜǏǗǒǒ�NjǒǕǏǜǘnj�nj�NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǔNJǛǛNJǟ�ǒ�ǜǘǖǝ�ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǟ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ��ǗǏǛǖǘǜǚǩ�ǗNJ�ǘǍǚǘǖǗǥǏ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǎǕǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǛNJǖǥǖ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǖ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ��ǗNJǡǒ-ǗNJǩ�ǘǜ�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ��ǑNJǔNJǗǡǒnjNJǩ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǖ�ǒ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǒǖ��ǙǘǎǘNjǗǘ�ǜǘǖǝ��ǔNJǔ�ǧǜǘ�NjǥǕǘ�ǛǎǏǕNJǗǘ�nj�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�ǒ�ƮNJǗǒǒ��ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ƴǒǜNJǩ�ǗǏ�ǙǘǢǕǘ�Ǚǘbǧǜǘǖǝ�Ǚǝǜǒ��ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǒnjǢǒǛǦ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǏǓ�njǗǝǜǚǒǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǘǍǘ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ�nj�ǖNJǢǒǗǗǘ�ǡǒǜNJǏǖǘǖ�ǞǘǚǖNJǜǏ�

Ƭ� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ�ƹǘǛǜǘǩǗǗǥǓ�ǔǘǖǒǜǏǜ�ƬǛǏǔǒǜNJǓǛǔǘǍǘ� ǛǘNjǚNJǗǒǩ�ǗNJǚǘǎ-Ǘǥǟ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǒǜǏǕǏǓ��ƹƴbƬƻƷƹ��ǙǚǒǗǩǕ�ǑNJǔǘǗ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�ǙǚǏǎǙǒǛǥnjNJǏǜ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗNJǖ�� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǣǒǖ� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ� ǛǏNjǩ� Ǚǚǒ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǔǏ� ǔ� njǏNj�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ� ǒ� ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǖ� ǝǛǕǝǍNJǖ�� ƸǎǗǒǖ� ǒǑ� ǖǘǜǒnjǘnj�ǙǚǒǗǩǜǒǩ�ǎNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�NjǥǕǘ�ǘNjnjǒǗǏǗǒǏ�mǎǒǛǔǝǛǛǒǓ}�nj�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǩǟ�nj�ǚNJǛǜǝǣǏǓ�mǗǏǛǜNJNjǒǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�nj�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǥǟ�ǚǏǍǒǘǗNJǟ}��ƱNJǔǘǗ�ǙǚǏǎǙǒǛǥnjNJǏǜ� mǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǨ�ǙǘbǚǏNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǒǖǏǗNJǖ}�� ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�mǛǎǏǕNJ-Ǐǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǛǏǜǒ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǘǛǜǚǘǐǗǥǖǒ�Ǚǚǒ�ǚNJǑǖǏǣǏǗǒǒ�ǔǘǖǖǏǗ-ǜNJǚǒǏnj�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ}��LJǜNJ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗNJǩ�ǒǗǒǠǒNJǜǒnjNJ�NjǥǕNJ�ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗNJ�ǗNJ�ǜǘ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǏ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǕǒ�Ǜnjǘǒ�ǚǏNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǒǖǏǗNJ�nj�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩ�ǗNJ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚNJnjNJ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǝ��ǝǛǕǝǍNJǖ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒ�ǔNJNjǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǏǓ�

ƹǚǘǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ� ƻƶƲ� ǚNJǑnjǏǚǗǝǕǒ� NJǍǒǜNJǠǒǘǗǗǝǨ� ǔNJǖǙNJ-ǗǒǨ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǘǛǗǘnjǥnjNJǕNJǛǦ�ǗNJ�ǜǏǑǒǛǏ��mƱNJǔǘǗ�ǎǘǕǐǏǗ�ǛǘǙǚǘnjǘǐǎNJǜǦ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǏ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǎǕǩ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǘnj�ǕǨǎǏǓ��ƼǘǕǦǔǘ�ǜNJǔǒǖ�ǘNj-ǚNJǑǘǖ�ǗNJǢ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǛǜNJǜǦ�NjǘǕǏǏ�Ǒǎǘǚǘnjǥǖ��NjǘǕǏǏ�ǔǝǕǦǜǝǚǗǥǖ�ǒ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǥǖ}�

ƻǏǚnjǒǛ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJǖ� ǙǚǏǎǙǒǛǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ� ǘNjǩǑNJǜǦ� Ǜnjǘǒǟ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ� Ǜnjǘǒ�ǚǏNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǒǖǏǗNJ�ǒ� ǎǚǝǍǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǥ�� Ǚǚǒ-njǩǑNJǗǗǥǏ� ǔ� ǚǏNJǕǦǗǥǖ� ǒǖǏǗNJǖ� Ǚǚǒ� ǔǘǖǖǏǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǒ� ǙǘǛǜǘnj� ǗNJ� Ǚǝ-NjǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǞǘǚǝǖNJǟ�ǒ�nj�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǩǟ��ƮǕǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǚǏǎǙǒ-ǛǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ� Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ƴǒǜNJǩ��Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǘǗǒbǖǘǍǕǒ�Njǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǛǏNjǩ�nj�ǛǏǜǒ�ǙǘbǗǘǖǏǚǝ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�

Ƶǒ�ƾǏǓ��ǑNJǖǏǛǜǒǜǏǕǦ�ǝǙǚNJnjǕǩǨǣǏǍǘ�ƴǘǖǒǜǏǜNJ�ǙǘbƱNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǝ�ǒ�ǡǕǏǗ�ƹƴbƬƻƷƹ�njǥǛǔNJǑNJǕǛǩ��ǡǜǘ�ǧǜǘ�mǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǎǕǩ�ǑǎǘǚǘnjǘǍǘ�ǚNJǑ-

59ƴƲƼƪƳ

Page 61: User identification analysis

njǒǜǒǩ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ}��ƼNJǔǐǏ�ǧǜǘǜ�ǡǒǗǘnjǗǒǔ�ǎǘNjNJnjǒǕ��mƴǘǗǛǜǒǜǝǠǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝ-ǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ�ǑNJǣǒǣNJǏǜ�ǙǚNJnjNJ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦ�ǗNJǎǑǘǚ�ǒ�ǔǚǒǜǒǔǘnjNJǜǦ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǘ�ǒ�ǙǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǡǒǗǘnjǗǒǔǘnj}����ƹǘǎ�ǧǜǒǖ�ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǏǖ�ǙǘǎǚNJǑǝǖǏnjNJǏǜǛǩ�� ǡǜǘ� ǔǒǜNJǓǛǔǘǏ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ǗNJǖǏ-ǚǏǗǘ�ǑNJǣǒǣNJǜǦ�ǡǏǛǜǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǘǜ�ǜǏǟ��ǔǜǘ�ǗNJǖǏǚǏǗ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǏǍǘ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�NJǗǜǒǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�Ǖǐǒ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�Ǚǘǡǜǘnjǥǟ�ǚNJǛǛǥǕǘǔ�ǒ�NJǗǘǗǒǖǗǥǟ�ǔǘǖǖǏǗǜNJǚǒǏnj�

ƹǚNJnjǘnjǥǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjǥƬ�ƴƲƼƪƳƻƴƸƳ�ƷƪƺƸƮƷƸƳ�ƺƯƻƹƽƫƵƲƴƯ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǘǎǗǘǙNJǚǜǒǓǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�Ǜ�ǛǘǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǏǖ�ǖǒǗǘǚǒǜNJǚǗǥǟ�ǙNJǚǜǒǓ��ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎǛǜnjǘ�ƴǘǖǖǝǗǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǙNJǚǜǒǒ�ƴǒǜNJǩ��ǘǛǘǑǗNJnjNJǩ��ǡǜǘ�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǏǪ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�NjǥǜǦ�Ǚǘǎ-njǏǚǍǗǝǜǥ�ǔǚǒǜǒǔǏ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�njǙǘǕǗǏ�ǛǙǚNJnjǏǎǕǒnjǘ�ǙǚǏǎǙǘ-ǕNJǍNJǩ��ǡǜǘ�njǒǚǜǝNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǜǚǒNjǝǗNJ�ǎǕǩ�ǎǒǛǛǒǎǏǗǜǘnj�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�ǛǏǚǦǏǑ-ǗǥǏ�ǗǏǍNJǜǒnjǗǥǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩ��ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǑNJNjǕNJǍǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǘ�ǑNJǎNJǕǘǛǦ�njǘǙǚǘǛǘǖ��ǔNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�ǒǑNjǏǐNJǜǦ�ǗǏǍNJǜǒnjǗǥǟ�ǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜǘnj�ǒ�ǛǕǏǎǝ-ǏǜbǕǒ�ǙǚǒNjǏǍNJǜǦ�ǔ�ǛǜǚǘǍǒǖ�ǑNJǙǚǏǜǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǖǏǚNJǖ��ƹǚǒǖǏǚǘǖ�Ǚǘǎǟǘ-ǎNJ��ǔǘǍǎNJ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�njǘ�njǛǏǖǒǚǗǝǨ�ǛǏǜǦ�ǑNJǔǚǥǜ�nj�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǖ�ǖNJǛǢǜNJNjǏ��ǏǛǜǦ�ǛǘnjǛǏǖ�ǗǏǎNJǕǏǔǘ�ǘǜ�ƴǒǜNJǩ��nj�ƴƷƮƺ��ƹǘbǛǕǘnjNJǖ�njǥǎNJǨǣǏǍǘǛǩ�ǚǘǛ-ǛǒǓǛǔǘǍǘ�ǔǘǚǏǏnjǏǎNJ�ƪ�ɌƷ�ɊƵNJǗǦǔǘnjNJ��mNjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǘ�ǎNJǐǏ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�ǔǘǚǏǓǠǏnj� ǙǚǘǛǜǘ� ǗǏ� ǙǘǎǘǑǚǏnjNJǨǜ� ǘ� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǒ� ƻǏǜǒ}���� ƮNJǐǏ� ǝ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǜǒ�ƴnjNJǗǖǪǗ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǗNJǙǘǕǗǏǗNJ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǗǏǓǜǚNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǜǏǟ-ǗǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǠǒǏǓ� ǒ� ǒǎǏǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ� ǛǜNJǜǦǩǖǒ� njǛǏǍǘ� ǘǔǘǕǘ���b ǜǥǛ�� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ���� ǡǜǘ� ǗǏ� ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ� ǒ� ǘǎǗǘǍǘ� ǙǚǘǠǏǗǜNJ�ǗNJǛǏ-ǕǏǗǒǩ��ƬǙǚǘǡǏǖ��ǚNJǑǗǒǠNJ�Ǚǝǜǒ�ƴƷƮƺ�ǒ�ƴƷƺ�ǘǡǏnjǒǎǗNJ��ǒ�ǕǒǎǏǚǥ�ǧǜǒǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗ�ǗǏ�ǚNJǑ�ǗNJǟǘǎǒǕǒ� ǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǗǘ�ǚNJǑǗǥǏ�ǘǜnjǏǜǥ�ǗNJ� ǘǎǗǒ�ǒ� ǜǏbǐǏ�njǘǙǚǘǛǥ��ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǙǘǕǗǘǍǘ�ǑNJǙǚǏǜNJ�ǎNJǏǜ�ǛNjǘǒ�ǎNJǐǏ�nj�ǙǚǏǎǏǕǦǗǘ�ǒǑǘ-ǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ƻǏnjǏǚǗǘǓ�ƴǘǚǏǏ��ǒ�ǝǐ�ǔǘǗǏǡǗǘ�ǜǚǝǎǗǘ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǒǖNJ�nj�ƴǒ-ǜNJǏbȃ�ǧǔǛǙǘǚǜǗǘ�ǘǚǒǏǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǛǜǚNJǗǏ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǕǒǎǏǚǘǖ�ǙǘbǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǛǜnjǝ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǒǔǒ�

ƬǏǛǦǖNJ�ǙǚǒǖǏǡNJǜǏǕǦǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǏǚnjǥǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǩǟ�ǙǘǩnjǒǕǛǩ�nj�ƴǒǜNJǏ�ǏǣǏ�nj�����bǍ���ǑNJ�ǜǚǒ�ǍǘǎNJ�ǎǘ�ǙǘǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǍǕǘNjNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛǏǜǒ�nj�ƴǒǜNJǏ��ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǜNJǕ�ǞNJǔǜǘǖ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǓ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�nj�ƴƷƺ���ǩǗnjNJǚǩ�����b Ǎ��ƶǏǗǏǏ�ǡǏǖ�ǑNJ� Ǎǘǎ�bȃ�ǔ�ǗǘǩNjǚǨ�����b Ǎ�� nj�ƴǒǜNJǏ�NjǥǕǘ�ǝǐǏ�����ǜǥǛǩǡ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǘnj��ǙǘǎǔǕǨǡǪǗǗǥǟ�ǔǘ�njǛǏǖǒǚǗǘǓ�ǛǏǜǒ��

�� KWWS���ZZZ�RFFXS\FRUSRUDWLVP�FRP�FKLQD�UHTXLUHV�XVHUV�WR�LGHQWLI\�WKHPVHOYHV�RQ�LQWHUQHW��� ƵNJǗǦǔǘnj��������� ƵNJǗǦǔǘnj�������

60 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 62: User identification analysis

���b ǜǥǛ�� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�� ����� ǑNJǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ� ǎǘǖǏǗǗǥǟ� ǒǖǪǗ�������njǏNj�ǛNJǓǜǘnj����ƻǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǘǜǖǏǜǒǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǞǒǕǦǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚ-ǗǏǜ�ǔǘǗǜǏǗǜNJ�mƱǘǕǘǜǘǓ�ǣǒǜ}��慹䚦ⶍ䦳��ǗNJǡNJǕNJ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjNJǜǥnjNJǜǦǛǩ�Ǚǘǡǜǒ�ǛǚNJǑǝ�bȃ�nj�����b Ǎ��� ǔǘǍǎNJ�njǛǏǖǒǚǗNJǩ�ǛǏǜǦ�ǏǣǏ�ǗǏ�ǩnjǕǩǕNJǛǦ�ǖNJǛǛǘnjǥǖ�ǩnjǕǏǗǒǏǖ�ǎǕǩ�ƴǒǜNJǩ�nj�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǏ��Ƭ�����bǍ���ǔǘǍǎNJ�ǛǒǜǝNJǠǒǩ�ǗNJǡNJǕNJ�ǖǏ-ǗǩǜǦǛǩ��mƱǘǕǘǜǘǓ�ǣǒǜ}�ǝǐǏ�NjǥǕ�Ǎǘǜǘnj�ǔ�ǚNJNjǘǜǏ��ƱNJǔǘǗǥ��ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǝǨǣǒǏ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǏ�NJǛǙǏǔǜǥ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘnj��ǗNJǡNJǕǒ�njǥ-ǟǘǎǒǜǦ�nj�����bǍ��ƪ�ǔ�����bǍ��ǗNJ�ǜǏǚǚǒǜǘǚǒǒ�ǛǜǚNJǗǥ�ǒǖǏǕNJǛǦ�ǝǐǏ�ǘǡǏǗǦ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜNJǩ�ǛǏǜǦ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔNJǞǏ��Ƭ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǙǘǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǗNJ�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ�ǜǏǚ-ǚǒǜǘǚǒǒ� ǗǏǔǒǟ� ǗǏǍNJǜǒnjǗǥǟ� ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǘnj��Ǜb ǜǘǡǔǒ� ǑǚǏǗǒǩ� ǘǞǒǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ� njǕNJǛǜǏǓ�� ǝǍǚǘǑǥ�� ǔǘǚǗǒ� ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǝǟǘǎǒǜǦ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�� ǜNJǔǘnjǘǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǗǏǖǏǎǕǏǗǗǘ�ǙǘǎnjǏǚǍNJǏǜǛǩ�ǡNJ-ǛǜǒǡǗǘǖǝ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǘǕǗǘǖǝ�ǘǜǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǨ��ƼNJǔ��ǗNJ�ǙǚǘǜǩǐǏǗǒǒ�Ǚǘǡǜǒ�ǙǘǕǝ-ǍǘǎNJ�ǗNJ����bǡNJǛǜǒ�ƴǒǜNJǩ��nj�ƻƽƪƺ��ƻǒǗǦǠǑǩǗ�ƽǓǍǝǚǛǔǒǓ�NJnjǜǘǗǘǖǗǥǓ�ǚNJǓ-ǘǗ���NjǥǕ�ǘǜǔǕǨǡǏǗ�ǕǨNjǘǓ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ��ƷǏ�njǙǘǕǗǏ�ǘNjǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǗǘǏ�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ǘǚǍNJǗǘnj� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǘǓ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǘ� ǛnjǩǑǒ�NJǗǜǒ-ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ� njǥǛǜǝǙǕǏǗǒǓ� Ǜ� ǙǘǕǒǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǦǨ� nj� Ǜǘ-ǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǩǟ�ǒ�NjǕǘǍNJǟ�ǒǖǏǕǘ�ǘǡǏǗǦ�ǛǔǘǚǥǏ�ǒ�ǐǏǛǜǔǒǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩ��ƹǚǒǚNJnjǗǒnjNJǗǒǏ�ǘǜǔNJǑNJ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�nj�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǏ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔ�ǗNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǨ�ǙǚNJnj�ǗNJ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ�ƸƸƷ�ǙǚǘǒǑǘǢǕǘ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�nj�����bǍ��>/D�5XH������@��Ǚǘǧǜǘ-ǖǝ�ǗNJ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ� ǑNJǙǚǏǜNJ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ƴƷƺ�ǗNJǙǚǩǖǝǨ�ǗǏ�ǢǕǘ�Ǚǚǘǜǒnj�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǟ�Ǘǘǚǖ��ƴǘǍǎNJ�ǙǘǩnjǒǕNJǛǦ�ǙǚǒǑǚNJǡǗNJǩ�ǝǍǚǘǑNJ�mưNJǛǖǒǗǘ-njǘǓ�ǚǏnjǘǕǨǠǒǒ}��ǔǒǜNJǓǛǔǒǏ�njǕNJǛǜǒ�ǑNJNjǕǘǔǒǚǘnjNJǕǒ�ǛǕǘnjǘ�mǐNJǛǖǒǗ}�nj�ǙǘǒǛǔǘnjǥǟ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕNJǟ��ƼǘǍǎNJǢǗǒǓ�ǙǚǏǎǛǏǎNJǜǏǕǦ�ƴƷƺ�ƿǝ�ǀǑǒǗǦǜNJǘ�Ǚǚǒ-ǑnjNJǕ� ǔ� njnjǏǎǏǗǒǨ�NjǘǕǏǏ� ǛǜǚǘǍǘǍǘ� ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǩ� nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ� Ǜ� ǜǏǖ�� ǡǜǘNjǥ�mǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǩǜǦ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǏ�ǖǗǏǗǒǏ}�ǒ�mǚǏǢNJǜǦ�ǛǏǚǦǏǑǗǥǏ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǥ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǙǘǎǘǚnjNJǜǦ�ǍNJǚǖǘǗǒǨ�ǒ�ǛǜNJNjǒǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjNJ}�����ƹǘǕ-ǗǘǍǘ� ǘǜǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǩ� ǝǐǏ� ǗǏ� ǙǚǘǒǛǟǘǎǒǜ�� ƹǏǚǒǘǎǒǡǏǛǔǒ�� njǗǏ� njǛǩǔǒǟ� Ǚǘ-ǕǒǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǙǚǘǒǛǢǏǛǜnjǒǓ��ǑNJǔǚǥnjNJǨǜǛǩ�ǗǏǕǏǍNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔNJǞǏ��ƲǗǘǍǎNJ�ǛǘǘNjǣNJǏǜǛǩ�ǘ�����ǜǥǛ��ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǑNJǔǚǥǜǥǟ�ǜǘǡǏǔ�ǑNJ�ǙǏǚǒǘǎ�Ǜ�����bǍ��Ǚǘb����bǍ����ƻǚǏǎǒ�ǙǚǒǡǒǗ�ǗNJǑǥnjNJǨǜ��Ǜ�ǘǎǗǘǓ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ��ǗNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǏ�ǗNJ-ǕǘǍǘnjǘǍǘ�ǒ�NJǎǖǒǗǒǛǜǚNJǜǒnjǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǚǩǎǔNJ��Ǜ�ǎǚǝǍǘǓbȃ�NjǚǏǢǦ�nj�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJ-ǠǒǘǗǗǘǖ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǏ�

ƮǕǩ�ǜǘǍǘ�ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǏ�ƴƷƺ�ǗǏ�ǙǘǙNJǕǒ�njǘ�njǚǏǎǗǥǓ�ǛǏǍǖǏǗǜ�ǒǗ-ǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ� ǚǩǎ� ǛNJǓǜǘnj�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�� nj� ǘǜǕǒǡǒǏ� ǘǜ� njǚǏǖǏǗǗǘǍǘ�

�� &11Ζ&��������� ƬƬƻ��������� .DQ�������

61ƴƲƼƪƳ

Page 63: User identification analysis

mǐNJǛǖǒǗNJ}�� ǑNJǔǚǥǜǥ� njǛǏǍǎNJ�� LJǜǘ� <RX7XEH�� 5X7XEH�� 7ZLWWHU�� )DFHERRN��%ORJSRVW� ǒ� ǚǩǎ� ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�� ƹǏǚnjǥǏ� ǎnjNJ� ǚǏǛǝǚǛNJ� ǖǘǐǗǘ� ǑNJǍǚǝǑǒǜǦ�� ǑNJ� ǒǛ-ǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǏǖ�ǛǘNjǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�njǒǎǏǘ�ǔǘǗǜǏǗǜNJ��ƮǕǩ�7ZLWWHU�ǏǛǜǦ�NJǗNJǕǘǍ�nj�ǕǒǠǏ�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛǏǜǒ�:HLER��ZZZ�ZHLER�FRP���ƷNJǎǘ�ǘǜǖǏǜǒǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�njǥǢǏǙǏ-ǚǏǡǒǛǕǏǗǗǥǏ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛǥ�ǗǏ�ǜNJǔ�ǒǑnjǏǛǜǗǥ�nj�ƴǒǜNJǏ��nj�ǘǜǕǒǡǒǏ�ǘǜ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ǒǕǒ�ƯnjǚǘǙǥ��Ƭ�ƴƷƺ�ǏǛǜǦ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǔǚǝǙǗǥǟ�ǛNJǓǜǘnj��ǍǎǏ�njǥǔǕNJǎǥnjNJǨǜǛǩ�njǒǎǏǘǚǘǕǒǔǒ��ljǚǔǒǓ�ǙǚǒǖǏǚ�ǛNJǖǘNjǥǜǗǘǛǜǒ��ǗǏ�ǑNJǙǚǏǣǏǗǗǥǓ�6N\SH�ǗǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜǛǩ�NjǘǕǦǢǒǖ�ǛǙǚǘǛǘǖ��njǖǏǛǜǘ�ǗǏǍǘ�nj�Ǣǒǚǘǔǘǖ�ǟǘǎǝ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǗǥǏ�nj�ƴǒǜNJǏ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ�44�ǒ�:H&KDW��ƬǙǕǘǜǦ�ǎǘ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǝ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǗǏ�NjǥǜǦ�NJǎǚǏǛNJ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǡǜǥ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǝǨ�Ǐǖǝ� ǑNJǖǏǗǩǏǜ�44��ƬǚǏ-ǖǩ�ǘǜ�njǚǏǖǏǗǒ�nj�ƴǒǜNJǏ�ǛǕǝǡNJǨǜǛǩ�ǘǜǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǩ�*RRJOH�ǒ�:LNLSHGLD�ǒǑ�ǑNJ�ǘǜǔNJǑNJ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǒǟ�ǙǘǎǡǒǗǩǜǦǛǩ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩǖ�ǞǒǕǦǜǚNJǠǒǒ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�ǔǒ-ǜNJǓǛǔNJǩ�ǙǘǒǛǔǘnjNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�%DLGX�ǧǜǘǜ�ǙǚǘNjǏǕ�njǘǛǙǘǕǗǩǏǜ��ǁǜǘ�ǔNJǛNJǏǜ-Ǜǩ�ǧǗǠǒǔǕǘǙǏǎǒǒ�:LNLSHGLD�� ǜǘ�ǏǏ�ǔǒǜNJǓǛǔǒǓ�ǛǏǍǖǏǗǜ�nj�ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛǜǏǙǏǗǒ�ǞǘǚǖǒǚǝǨǜ�NJnjǜǘǚǥ�Ǜ�ƼNJǓnjNJǗǩ��ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ��ƻǩǗǍNJǗNJ�ǒ�ƪǘǖǥǗǩ�

ǁǜǘbǐǏ�ǔNJǛNJǏǜǛǩ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�Ǜ�ǗNJǛǜǚǘǏǗǒǩǖǒ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǛǏǜǦ��ǜǘ�nj�ǙǚǘǜǒnjǘNjǘǚǛǜnjǘ�ǙǝNjǕǒǔNJǠǒǩǖ�ǚǏǡǏǓ�ƮNJǕNJǓ�ƵNJǖǥ��ƺNJNjǒǒ�ƴNJǎǥǚ��ǎǒǛ-ǛǒǎǏǗǜǘnj� ǒ� ǒǗǥǟ� NJǗǜǒǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ� ǗNJǛǜǚǘǏǗǗǥǟ� ǕǒǠ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǙǚǘǚnjNJǕǒǛǦ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǞǒǕǦǜǚǥ��ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜbǜ�ɋǗ��ƽǖNJǘǎNJǗ��Ḽ㮃ℂ���ƬǘǙǚǏ-ǔǒ�ǛǘǑnjǝǡǒǨ��ǔ�ƶNJǘ�ǀǑǏǎǝǗǝ�ǙǚǩǖǘǍǘ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǩ�ǗNJǑnjNJǗǒǏ�ǗǏ�ǒǖǏǏǜ��ƹǏǚǏnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ� mḼ㮃ℂ}� ǙǚǒǖǏǚǗǘ�� ǔNJǔ� mǙNJǚǜǒǩ� ǙǘǕǘnjǒǗǥ� ǨNJǗǩ}�� ƷNJ-ǑnjNJǗǒǏ� ǗǘǛǒǜ� ǗǏǘǞǒǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǓ� ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚ�� ǒ� ǛǒǖnjǘǕǒǑǒǚǝǏǜ� ǗNJǏǖǗǥǓ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǚǘǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�NjǕǘǍǍǏǚǘnj��Ʋǟ�ǡǒǛǕǏǗ-ǗǘǛǜǦ�njǏǛǦǖNJ�njǗǝǢǒǜǏǕǦǗNJ��ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǜ�ǘǠǏǗǔǒ�nj�����ǜǥǛ��ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǟ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǏǓ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǛǜNJǗǘnjǩǜǛǩ�ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǞNJǔǜǘǚǘǖ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǐǒǑǗǒ����Ƹ�ǛǜǏǙǏǗǒ�ǖNJǜǏǚǒNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǑNJǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǘnjNJǗǗǘǛǜǒ�nj�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǍǘnjǘǚǒǜǦ�ǛǕǘǐǗǘbȃ�ǏnjǚǘǙǏǓǛǔǒǏ�ǒ�NJǖǏǚǒǔNJǗǛǔǒǏ�ǒǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ǗǏǚǏǎǔǘ�NJǔǠǏǗǜǒǚǝǨǜ�ǗNJ�ǧǜǘǖ�njǗǒǖNJǗǒǏ��ǔǒǜNJǓǛǔǒǏbǐǏ�ǘǛǘ-NjǏǗǗǘ�ǗǏ�NJǞǒǢǒǚǝǨǜ��ƬǙǘǕǗǏ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕǘǐǒǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�ǖǗǘǍǒǏ�ǎǏǑNJ-njǝǒǚǝǨǜ�ǒǎǏǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǙǚǘǜǒnjǗǒǔǘnj�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ�njǙǘǕǗǏ�ǒǛǔǚǏǗǗǏ�ǒ�NjǏǑnjǘǑǖǏǑǎǗǘ�

ƷǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjNJǩ�NjNJǑNJ�ǒ�ǖǏǚǥƱƪƴƸƷƸƮƪƼƯƵdžƷDžƯ� ƪƴƼDž�� ƴƪƻƪLjǃƲƯƻlj� njǛǏǖǒǚǗǘǓ� ǛǏǜǒ��ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǚNJǑǎǏǕǒǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǜǚǒ�ǍǚǝǙǙǥ��LJǜǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗǥ�ǘNj�ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǒ�ǛǏǜǦǨ��ǑNJǔǘǗǥ�ǘNj�ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏ-Ǘǒǒ�ǎǘǖǏǗNJǖǒ�ǒ�ǑNJǔǘǗǥ�ǘ�ǛǏǜǏnjǘǓ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��ƴ�ǙǏǚnjǘǓ�ǔNJǜǏǍǘǚǒǒ�

�� )DUHHG������

62 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 64: User identification analysis

ǘǜǗǘǛǩǜǛǩ��ǗǏǙǘǕǗǥǓ�ǛǙǒǛǘǔ���mƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘNj�NJnjǜǘǚǛǔǘǖ�ǙǚNJnjǏ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ}��ǙǚǒǗǩǜ����ǖNJǩ�����bǍ���� mƹǚNJnjǒǕNJ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�njǥǎNJǡǒ� Ζ3�NJǎǚǏǛNJ}��ǙǚǒǗǩǜǥ����ǖNJǚǜNJ�����bǍ����mƹǚNJnjǒǕNJ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǗǏǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǖ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǖ}� �ǙǚǒǗǩǜǥ� ��� ǖNJǚǜNJ� ����b Ǎ���� mƹǚNJ-njǒǕNJ� ǙǚǏǛǏǡǏǗǒǩ� ǙǝNjǕǒǔNJǠǒǒ� nj� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ� NjǏǑǗǚNJnjǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ� ǖNJǜǏ-ǚǒNJǕǘnj}� �ǙǚǒǗǩǜǥ����ǒǨǗǩ�����bǍ����ƹǘǖǒǖǘ�ǧǜǒǟ��ǛǨǎNJbǐǏ�ǙǘǙNJǎNJǨǜ�mƺNJǑǤǩǛǗǏǗǒǩ�ǎǕǩ�ƬǏǚǟǘnjǗǘǍǘ�ǗNJǚǘǎǗǘǍǘ�ǛǝǎNJ�ǒ�ƬǏǚǟǘnjǗǘǓ�ǗNJǚǘǎǗǘǓ�ǙǚǘǔǝǚNJǜǝǚǥ�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�NJǛǙǏǔǜǘnj�ǙǚNJnjǒǕ�ǘ�njǏǎǏǗǒǒ�ǝǍǘǕǘnjǗǥǟ�ǎǏǕ�ǘ�ǜǘǚǍǘnjǕǏ�� ǔǘǙǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǒ� ǒǕǒ� ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǛǜnjǏ� NjǏǑǗǚNJnjǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ� Ǚǚǘǎǝǔ-Ǡǒǒ�Ǜ�ǙǚǒnjǕǏǡǏǗǒǏǖ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǒ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjǥǟ�ǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǏǓ}��mƴǒǜNJǓǛǔNJǩ�ǔǘǗnjǏǗǠǒǩ� ǘ� ǛNJǖǘǎǒǛǠǒǙǕǒǗǏ� nj� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ}�� mƴǘǗnjǏǗǠǒǩ� ǘ� ǛNJǖǘǎǒǛ-ǠǒǙǕǒǗǏ� nj� ǛǞǏǚǏ� NJnjǜǘǚǛǔǒǟ� ǙǚNJnj� nj� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ}� ǒ� ǚǩǎ� ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�� ǖǏǗǏǏ�njNJǐǗǥǟ�ǙǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǓ��ƴǘ�njǜǘǚǘǓ�ǔNJǜǏǍǘǚǒǒ�ǘǜǗǘǛǩǜǛǩ�mƬǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǏ�ǖǏǚǥ� Ǚǘb ǝǙǘǚǩǎǘǡǏǗǒǨ� njǥǎNJǡǒ� ǎǘǖǏǗǗǥǟ� ǒǖǏǗ� ǗNJ� ǜǏǚǚǒǜǘǚǒǒ� ƴǒ-ǜNJǩ}���bǒǨǗǩ�����bǍ����mƹǚNJnjǒǕNJ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǎǘǖǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒǖǏǗ�nj�ƴǒǜNJǏ}���� ǒǨǗǩ� ����b Ǎ���� mƹǚǏǎnjNJǚǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ� ǙǚNJnjǒǕNJ� ǚNJǑǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ� ǛǙǘǚǘnj� nj�njǘǙǚǘǛNJǟ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǎǘǖǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒǖǏǗ�ǗNJ�ǜǏǚǚǒǜǘǚǒǒ�ƴǒǜNJǩ}� ��bǗǘǩ-Njǚǩ� ����b Ǎ���� mƹǚǏǎnjNJǚǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ� ǖǏǚǥ�� ǔNJǛNJǨǣǒǏǛǩ� ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ� ǎǘ-ǖǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒǖǏǗ�ǗNJ� ǜǏǚǚǒǜǘǚǒǒ�ƴǒǜNJǩ}� ���ǗǘǩNjǚǩ�����b Ǎ���� mƲǗǛǜǚǝǔǠǒǒ�ǙǘbnjǏǎǏǗǒǨ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǟ�ǎǏǕ��ǔNJǛNJǨǣǒǓǛǩ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǎǘǖǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒǖǏǗ�ǒ�ǒǗǜǏǕǕǏǔǜǝNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛǘNjǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ}�����NJnjǍǝǛǜNJ�����bǍ����mƺNJǑǤǩǛǗǏǗǒǩ�ǎǕǩ�ƬǏǚǟǘnjǗǘǍǘ�ǗNJǚǘǎǗǘǍǘ�ǛǝǎNJ�ǙǘbnjǏǎǏǗǒǨ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǟ�ǎǏǕ��ǔNJǛNJǨǣǒǏ-Ǜǩ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǎǘǖǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒǖǏǗ�ǒ�ǒǗǜǏǕǕǏǔǜǝNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛǘNjǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ}�����ǒǨǕǩ�����bǍ����mƹǚNJnjǒǕNJ��ǔNJǛNJǨǣǒǏǛǩ�ǎǘǖǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒǖǏǗ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǗNJ�ǜǏǚǚǒǜǘǚǒǒ�ƴǒǜNJǩ}���bNJnjǍǝǛǜNJ�����bǍ���ǒ�mƹǚNJnjǒǕNJ��ǔNJǛNJǨǣǒǏǛǩ�ǎǘǖǏǗ-Ǘǥǟ�ǒǖǏǗ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǗNJ� ǜǏǚǚǒǜǘǚǒǒ�ƴǒǜNJǩ}� ǘǜ� ��� ǎǏǔNJNjǚǩ� ����b Ǎ��Ʋ��ǗNJǔǘǗǏǠ�� ǔ� ǜǚǏǜǦǏǓ� ǔNJǜǏǍǘǚǒǒ�ǘǜǗǘǛǩǜǛǩ�� mƹǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ǘ� ǑNJǣǒǜǏ� ǔǘǖ-ǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǟ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ƴƷƺ}�����ǞǏnjǚNJǕǩ��������mƹǚNJnjǒ-ǕNJ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ��ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǛǘNjǕǨǎǏǗǒǩ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�nj�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǟ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǩǟ�ǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ}� ����ǎǏǔNJNjǚǩ�����bǍ����mƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘNj�ǝǔǚǏǙǕǏǗǒǒ� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ}� ���� ǎǏǔNJNjǚǩ� ����b Ǎ���� mƹǚNJnjǒǕNJ�ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�nj�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǟ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǩǟ�ǒ�ǒǗ-ǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ}� ��b ǩǗnjNJǚǩ� ����b Ǎ���� mƹǚNJnjǒǕNJ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ}����NJǙǚǏǕǩ�����bǍ������ƹǘǛǕǏǎǗǒǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�nj�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǘǖ�ǙǘǛnjǩǣǏǗ�ǙǚNJ-njǒǕNJǖ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǗNJ�ǎǘǖ��ƼNJǖ�ǝǔNJǑǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǦ�ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗǒǩ� ǜǒǙǘnjǘǍǘ� ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚNJ� ǗNJ� ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǘǏ� ǕǒǠǘ� nj� ǎnjǝǟ� ǔǘǙǒǩǟ��

�� ƼǏǔǛǜǥ�ǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǥǟ�NJǔǜǘnj�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǗǥ�ǗNJ�ǛNJǓǜǏ�ZZZ�FKLQD�FRP

63ƴƲƼƪƳ

Page 65: User identification analysis

ǙǚNJnjNJ�ǒ�ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǦ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗ��ƷNJǎǘ�ǘǜǖǏǜǒǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�nj�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǘǖ�ǚǏǡǦ�ǒǎǏǜ�ǘ�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǣǏǓ��ƬNJǐǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�Ǚǚǒ�ǒǖǏǨǣǒǟǛǩ�ǑNJǙǚǏǜNJǟ�ǗNJ�ǛNJǓǜǥ��ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�ǞǒǕǦǜǚNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǙǘǒǛǔǘnjǥǟ�Ǜǒ-ǛǜǏǖNJǟ��ǗNJǕǒǡǒǒ�ǙǚǘǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǑNJ-ǎNJǡNJ�njǥǩǛǗǏǗǒǩ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�njǥǢǏǎǢǏǍǘ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǜǏǚǩǏǜ�ǙǏǚnjǘǛǜǏǙǏǗ-ǗǘǏ�ǑǗNJǡǏǗǒǏ��ƮǏǓǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǏ�nj�ǛǞǏǚǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǖǏǚǥ�ǙǚǘǛǜǥ�ǒ�ǙǘǗǩǜǗǥ��ƲǑǕǒǢǗǏ�ǝǛǕǘǐǗǩǜǦ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǝ�njǟǘǎNJ�nj�ǛǏǜǦ�njǚǏǎǗǘ�ǒ�Ǜ�Ǚǘ-ǑǒǠǒǓ�ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǔǒ�

Ƭ�ǛǞǏǚǏ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǜnjǘǚǡǏǛǜnjNJ��ǔNJǛNJǨǣǏǍǘǛǩ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǜǚǝǎǩǜǛǩ�ǠǏǕǥǏ�ǗNJǝǡǗǥǏ�ǠǏǗǜǚǥ��ƴǒǜNJǓǛǔǒǏ�ǝǡǏǗǥǏ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǝǨǜ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǝ�NJnjǜǘǚǛǔǘǍǘ�ǙǚNJnjNJ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��ǗNJ�ǧǜǝ�ǜǏǖǝ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǖǗǘǍǘ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡ-Ǘǥǟ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘnj� ǒ� ǙǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǓ�� ƴ� ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǏ� ǏǛǜǦ� ǘǎǗǘǑǗNJǡǗǥǓ�ǒǗǜǏ-ǚǏǛ��ǎNJǐǏ�ǔ�ǜǘǖǝ��ǔNJǔ�ǘǜǛǜǘǩǜǦ�NJnjǜǘǚǛǔǘǏ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǖǝǑǥǔNJǗǜǘnj����ƲǗǜǏǚǏǛ�ǔ�ǒǑǝǡǏǗǒǨ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǙǕNJǜǞǘǚǖǥ�ǎǕǩ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚ-ǗǏǜǏ� ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ� ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǖǒ� ǔǘǗǔǝǚǛNJǖǒ�� ƷNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ�� Ǜ� ǔǘǗǠNJ�ǛǏǗǜǩNjǚǩ�ǎǘ�ǔǘǗǠNJ�ǎǏǔNJNjǚǩ��ƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǏ�NjǨǚǘ�ǙǘbǎǏǕNJǖ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ��ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjǘ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ǀƴ�ǔǘǖǛǘǖǘǕNJ��ƾǏ-ǎǏǚNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘbǎǏǕNJǖ�ǐǏǗǣǒǗ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǛǘǜǗǒ�ǛNJǓǜǘnj�ǚǏǢǒǕǒ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǒǜǦ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǝ� mƱǏǕǏǗNJǩ� ǛǏǜǦ�� ǙǘǖǘǍNJǨǣNJǩ�ǕǏǜǩǣǏǓ�ǖǏǡǜǏ}�� ƻǝǜǦ�nj� ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǙǘǎǚǘǛǜǘǔ�ǖǘǍ�ǙǘǝǡNJǛǜnjǘnjNJǜǦ�ǒ�ǎNJǐǏ�ǙǘnjǕǒǩǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǏ�ǒǗ-ǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�� ƸǎǗǒǖ� ǒǑ� ǗNJǒNjǘǕǏǏ� ǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǗǥǟ� ǖǏǚǘǙǚǒǩǜǒǓ� ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥ�ǛǜNJǕ� mƶǘǕǘǎǏǐǗǥǓ� ǔǘǗǔǝǚǛ� ǙǚNJnjǘnjǥǟ� ǑǗNJǗǒǓ� ǘNj� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ}�� ƹǘb ǑNJ-ǖǥǛǕǝ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǜǘǚǘnj��ǧǜǘ�ǙǘǖǘǐǏǜ�ǖǘNjǒǕǒǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǧǗǜǝǑǒNJǑǖ�ǖǘǕǘǎǥǟ�ǕǨǎǏǓ��ǘǗǒ�ǛǖǘǍǝǜ�ǚNJǛǢǒǚǒǜǦ�Ǜnjǘǒ�ǑǗNJǗǒǩ�ǙǘbǛǜǘǕǦ�NjǕǒǑǔǘǓ�ǒǖ�ǜǏǖǏ��nj�ǒǜǘǍǏ�ǙǘnjǥǛǒǜǛǩ�ǛNJǖǘǎǒǛǠǒǙǕǒǗNJ��ǛNJǖǘǘNjǚNJǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǙǚǘǡǒǏ�ǙǘǕǘ-ǐǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ����

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǖǏǚǥǁƼƸƫDž�ƹƸƹƪƻƼdž�Ƭ�ƫƯƻƹƺƸƬƸƮƷƸƳ�ƲƷƼƯƺƷƯƼ��ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ��ǙǘǕǦǑǝǩǛǦ�ǔǒǜNJǓ-ǛǔǘǓ� Ǜǒǖ�ǔNJǚǜǘǓ� �Ǚǚǒ� ǙǚǒǘNjǚǏǜǏǗǒǒ� ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ� ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ� ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǒǜǦ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜ��� ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ� ǛǖǛ� Ǜ� ǔǘǎǘǖ�� Ƭ� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔNJǞǏ� ǎNJǗǗNJǩ� ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�ǙǚǘǒǛǟǘǎǒǜ�ǙǘǛǕǏ�ǙǘǔNJǑNJ�ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�ǛǕǝǐNJǣǏǖǝ��ǙǘǛǕǏ�ǡǏǍǘ�njǥǎNJǏǜǛǩ�ǙǒǗ�ǔǘǎ�ǒ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚ��ƯǛǕǒ�ǚǏǡǦ�ǒǎǏǜ�ǘNj� ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǠNJǟ�� ǜǘ� ǛǒǜǝNJǠǒǩ� ǗǏ� ǛǜǘǕǦ� ǘǎǗǘǑǗNJǡǗNJǩ�� Ƭ� ǘǎǗǒǟ�ǖǏǛǜNJǟ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�njǘǘNjǣǏ�ǗǏ�ǛǙǚǘǛǒǜǦ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��nj�ǎǚǝǍǒǟbȃ�ǘǜǔNJǑNJǜǦ�nj�ǘNjǛǕǝ-ǐǒnjNJǗǒǒ��ƹǘbǞǘǚǖNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǙǚǒǡǒǗNJǖ�ǧǜǘ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǘNjǘǛǗǘnjǥnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǘǜǛǝǜ-

�� ǁǧǗǦ�ƶǒǗ��������ƻ����Ȃ���� ƻǒǗǦǟǝNJ������

64 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 66: User identification analysis

ǛǜnjǒǏǖ�ǜǚNJǎǒǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǎǕǩ�ƴǒǜNJǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ��ǜǏǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǑNJǍǚNJǗǙNJǛǙǘǚǜ�ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗ�ǗǏ�nj�ƴǒǜNJǏ�ǒ�ǗǏ� ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ�ǙǏǚǏnjǘǎNJ�ǗNJ�ǔǒ-ǜNJǓǛǔǒǓ�ǩǑǥǔ��ƻǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǘǜǖǏǜǒǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�ǚǏNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǙǚNJnjǘǙǚǒǖǏǗǒǜǏǕǦǗNJǩ�ǙǚNJǔǜǒǔNJ�nj�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǚNJǓǘǗNJǟ�ƴǒǜNJǩ�njǏǛǦǖNJ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡNJǏǜ-Ǜǩ�Ǚǘb ǛǜǏǙǏǗǒ� ǛnjǘǏǓ� ǛǜǚǘǍǘǛǜǒ��ƷNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ� ǜǘ�� ǡǜǘ� nj�ƻǒǗǦǠǑǩǗ�ƽǓǍǝǚ-Ǜǔǘǖ� NJnjǜǘǗǘǖǗǘǖ� ǚNJǓǘǗǏ� ǒǕǒ� ƼǒNjǏǜǏ� njǥǙǘǕǗǩǏǜǛǩ� ǗǏǝǔǘǛǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ��njb ƹǏǔǒǗǏ�ǖǘǐǏǜ� ǘǛǜNJnjNJǜǦǛǩ� ǗNJ� ǝǛǖǘǜǚǏǗǒǏ� ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǘǍǘ� ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔNJ��ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ� ǑNJ� ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ� ǔ� ǔ� ǚǏǛǝǚǛNJǖ� njǛǏǖǒǚǗǘǓ�ǛǏǜǒ��LJǜǘ�ǔNJǛNJǏǜǛǩ�ǔNJǔ�NjǏǛǙǚǘnjǘǎǗǘǍǘ�ǛǘǏǎǒǗǏǗǒǩ�nj�ǚǏǛǜǘǚNJǗǏ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǒǑǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔNJǞǏ�

ƹǚǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǏ� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ� nj� ǎǘǖ� ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ� ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǝ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǕǒǠNJ�Ǜ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘǖ��ǙǘǎǚNJǑǝǖǏnjNJǨǣǏǍǘ�ǝǛǜNJ-ǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǙǘbǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǏ�ǍǚNJǐ-ǎNJǗǒǗNJ�ƴƷƺ�ǒǕǒ�ǑNJǍǚNJǗǒǡǗǘǍǘ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǠNJ�

ƫǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǙǘnjǛǏǎǗǏnjǗǘǖ�Ǜǘ-ǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǖ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǒ�nj�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǒǓ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǨǜǛǩ�

ƻ� ǜǘǡǔǒ� ǑǚǏǗǒǩ�ǨǚǒǛǙǚǝǎǏǗǠǒǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǗNJ�ǔǒǜNJǓǛǔNJǩ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘ�ǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj� ǎǕǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ��ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǏǖNJǩ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǗNJǎǑǘǚNJ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖǒ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�� ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ� ǗNJǑǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ�Ṣ倱㏄䳊�� ǡǜǘ� ǎǘǛǕǘnjǗǘ�ǘǑǗNJǡNJǏǜ�mǙǘǒǛǔ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǙǕǘǜǒ}��ƺǏǡǦ�ǒǎǏǜ�ǘ�ǎǏNJǗǘǗǒǖǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǕǒǠNJ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǏ�ǙǚǘǩnjǒǕǘ�ǗǏǝnjNJǐǏǗǒǏ�ǔ�ǎǚǝǍǒǖ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦ-Ǒǝǩ� ǜNJǔ� ǗNJǑǥnjNJǏǖǝǨ� ǚǒǜǘǚǒǔǝ� ǗǏǗNJnjǒǛǜǒ�� LJǜǘ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�NjǘǕǦǗǘǓ�ǜǏǖǘǓ�nj�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�ǐǒǑǗǒ�ƴǒǜNJǩ��Ƭ�ǔǒǜNJǓǛǔǘǖ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�ǖǏǛǜǘ�ǘǛǜǚNJǩ�ǙǘǕǏǖǒǔNJ�ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ�ǧǜǘǍǘ�ǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǍǚNJǗǒǠ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǙǝNjǕǒǡǗǘǓ�ǙǘǕǏǖǒǔǒ�nj�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǩǟ�ǒ�ǞǘǚǝǖNJǟ��ƻ�ǞǘǚǖNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǕǏǖǒǔNJ�ǙǚǘǒǛǜǏǔNJǏǜ�ǒǑ�ǔǘǗǞǕǒǔǜNJ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǔǘǗǛǜǒǜǝǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǙǚNJnjǘǖ�ǗNJ�ǗǏǙǚǒǔǘǛǗǘnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǦ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǓ�ǐǒǑǗǒ�ǒ�ǛnjǘNjǘǎǝ�ǛǕǘnjNJ��ǙǘǎǘNjǗǘ�ǜǘǖǝ�ǔNJǔ� ǧǜǘ� ǒǖǏǏǜ� ǖǏǛǜǘ� nj� ǑNJǙNJǎǗǥǟ� ǎǏǖǘǔǚNJǜǒǩǟ�� ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�� ǒǖǏǏǜ� ǖǏǛǜǘ�ǒ� ǔǘǗǞǕǒǔǜ� nj� ǛǞǏǚǏ� ǔǝǕǦǜǝǚǥ� ǒ� ǖǒǚǘnjǘǑǑǚǏǗǒǩ�� ƶǘǐǗǘ� ǗNJNjǕǨǎNJǜǦ�ǛǜǘǕǔǗǘnjǏǗǒǏ� ǕǒNjǏǚNJǕǦǗǘ�ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎǝNJǕǦǗǥǓ� ǔǝǕǦǜǝǚǥ�� njǘǙǕǘǣǪǗǗǘǓ�nj�ǙǚNJnjǏ�ǗNJ�ǡNJǛǜǗǝǨ�ǐǒǑǗǦ�ǒ�NJǗǘǗǒǖǗǘǛǜǦ��ǒ�ǜǚNJǎǒǠǒǘǗǗǘ�ǔǝǕǦǜǒnjǒ-ǚǝǏǖǘǍǘ�nj�ǔǒǜNJǓǛǔǘǓ�ǠǒnjǒǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǔǘǕǕǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǍǘ�ǗNJǡNJǕNJ��ƹǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǏ�ǜǚNJǎǒǠǒǘǗǗǘǏ�ǗNJǡNJǕǘ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�Ǜnjǘǒ�ǙǚǏnjǚNJǣǪǗǗǥǏ�Ǟǘǚǖǥ��ǏǣǪ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǝǛǒǕǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ�njnjǒǎǝ�ǛǏǜǏnjǘǓ�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǔǝǕǦǜǝǚǥ��ǔǘǜǘǚǝǨ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǗNJ-ǑnjNJǜǦ� mǔǒǜNJǓǛǔǘǓ� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔǝǕǦǜǝǚǘǓ}�� ƸǗNJ� njǘǙǕǘǣǏǗNJ� nj� ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ��ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǖNJǛǛǘnjǘ�ǙǘǎǏǚǐǒnjNJǨǣǒǟ�NJǚǍǝ-

65ƴƲƼƪƳ

Page 67: User identification analysis

ǖǏǗǜǥ�nj�ǙǘǕǦǑǝ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǗNJǡNJǜǦ�ǖNJǛǛǘnjǝǨ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǨ�ǙǘbǎǏNJǗǘǗǒ-ǖǒǑNJǠǒǒ��NjǕNJǍǘǎNJǚǩ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǗNJǔNJǑNJǜǦ�ǕǒǠ��ǡǦǒ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǘǛǔǘǚNjǒǕǒ�ǒǟ�ǗǚNJnjǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǡǝnjǛǜnjNJ��ƾǏǗǘǖǏǗǝ�ǛǏǜǏnjǘǓ�NJǗǘǗǒǖǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǘǛnjǩǣǏǗǘ�ǗǏǖNJǕǘ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǓ��ǛǜǚǏǖǩǣǒǟǛǩ�ǛǘǑǎNJǜǦ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǓ�ǖǏ-ǟNJǗǒǑǖ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ���

ƱNJ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǥǖ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǏǖ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�njǛǏǖǒǚǗǘǓ�ǛǏǜǒ�nj�ƴǒ-ǜNJǏ� Ǜǜǘǒǜ� ǘNjǢǒǚǗNJǩ�ǚNJNjǘǜNJ�ǗNJ� ǚNJǑǗǥǟ� ǝǚǘnjǗǩǟ�� ǗNJǝǡǗǥǏ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJ-Ǘǒǩ��ǒǎǏǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǙǘǎǍǘǜǘnjǔNJ��ǚNJNjǘǜNJ�Ǜ�ǖǘǕǘǎǏǐǦǨ�ǒ�NjǘǕǦǢǘǏ�njǗǒ-ǖNJǗǒǏ�Ǜǘ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ�ǙNJǚǜǒǒ�ǒ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǙǥǜNJǨǜǛǩ�ǗNJǓǜǒ�ǔǘǖǙǚǘǖǒǛǛ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǑNJǙǚǏǜNJǖǒ�njǘ�ǒǖǩ�ǛǘǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�ǚǏǐǒǖNJ�ǒ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ-Ǜǔǒǖǒ�ǛnjǘNjǘǎNJǖǒ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�ǛǜǚNJǗǥ�

LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǔǘ�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩƯƻƵƲ� ƭƸƬƸƺƲƼdž� Ƹ� ƻƸǀƲƪƵdžƷƸƳ� ƻƼƸƺƸƷƯ� njǘǙǚǘǛNJ�� ǜǘ� ǖǘǐǗǘ� ǛǎǏǕNJǜǦ� ǗǏ-ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ� njǥnjǘǎǥ�� Ƭǘ�ǙǏǚnjǥǟ�� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ� nj� ƴƷƺ� ǙǘǙNJǕ� nj� ǙǘǕǏ� ǑǚǏǗǒǩ�njǕNJǛǜǗǥǟ�Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚ�ǒ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǜnjǘǚǠǏnj�ǑNJǎǘǕǍǘ�ǎǘ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǔNJǔ�ǛǜNJǕ�ǖNJǛǛǘ-njǥǖ�ǩnjǕǏǗǒǏǖ��Ƭǘ�njǜǘǚǥǟ��ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǒ�ǒ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗǏǚǥ�ƴƹƴ�ǗǏ�ǛǜNJǕǒ�njǏǢNJǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǩǚǕǥǔ�ǚǝǙǘǚNJ�njǚNJǐǎǏNjǗǘǓ�ǙǚǘǙNJ-ǍNJǗǎǥ��ǕǒNjǘ�ǑNJǖNJǕǡǒnjNJǜǦ�ǞNJǔǜ�ǏǍǘ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ǔNJǔ�ǧǜǘ�ǛǎǏǕNJǕǒ�ǒǟ�ǛǘǛǏǎǒ�ǒ�ǔǘǕǕǏǍǒ�nj�ƴƷƮƺ��ǟǘǜǩ�ǜNJǔǘǓ�njNJǚǒNJǗǜ�ǛǘNjǥǜǒǓ�ǖǘǍbNjǥ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�ǖǏǛǜǘ��Ƭ�ǜǚǏǜǦǒǟ��ǕǒǎǏǚǥ�ƴǒǜNJǩ�ǛǘǡǕǒ�ǗNJǒǕǝǡǢǒǖ�njǥǟǘǎǘǖ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ǛǕǘǐǗǘǍǘ�ǞǒǕǦǜǚNJ�mƱǘǕǘǜǘǓ�ǣǒǜ}��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�nj�ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛǜǏǙǏǗǒ�ǘNjǛǕǝǐǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ� nj� ǚǏǐǒǖǏ� ǚǝǡǗǘǍǘ� ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�� ǙǏǚǒǘǎǒǡǏǛǔǒ� njnjǘ-ǎǩ� njǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǏ� ǑNJǙǚǏǜǥ� ǒ� ǔǘǚǚǏǔǜǒnjǥ�� ƹǘǙǝǜǗǘ� ǙǚǏǎǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǨǜǛǩ�ǢNJǍǒ� ǔ� ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǨ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� NJǍǒǜNJǠǒǒ� nj� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ� ǛǗǒǑǝ� �ǙNJǚNJǕǕǏǕǦ-Ǘǘ� Ǜ� ǝǐǏ� ǒǖǏǨǣǏǓǛǩ�� ǡǏǚǏǑ� ǒǗǛǜǒǜǝǜ� ǕǘǩǕǦǗǥǟ� njǕNJǛǜǩǖ� NjǕǘǍǍǏǚǘnj��Ƭ�ǡǏǜnjǏǚǜǥǟ��ǜǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǘǙNJǎNJǏǜ�Ǚǘǎ�njǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǘǕǗǥǓ�ǑNJǙǚǏǜ��ǗǏ-ǑNJǖǏǎǕǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǗNJǟǘǎǒǜ�ǛǏNjǏ�njǙǘǕǗǏ�ǚNJNjǘǜǘǛǙǘǛǘNjǗǝǨ�ǑNJǖǏǗǝ��ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�� ǖǘǐǗǘ� ǍǘnjǘǚǒǜǦ� ǘ� ǎNJǕǦǗǘnjǒǎǗǘǛǜǒ� NJǎǖǒǗǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ� ƴƷƺ� ǒ�ƴƹƴ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǘ�NjǘǕǦǢǘǖ�ǒǟ�ǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǏ�ǔ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǏ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǩ�ǗNJǎ�ǙǘǜǘǔNJ-ǖǒ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�njǘ�njǛǏǖǒǚǗǘǓ�ǛǏǜǒ�

LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǔNJ�ƴǒǜNJǩ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǑNJnjǩǑNJǗNJ�ǗNJ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��ǙǚǒǖǏǚǘǖ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǔNJǔ�ǘǗ�njNJǐǏǗ��ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǜǘ��ǡǜǘ�nj�ƻƽƪƺ�Ǚǚǒ�ǘǜǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǙǘnjǛǏǖǏǛǜǗǘ�nj�ǔǚǝǙǗǥǟ�ǧǔǛǙǘǚǜǗǥǟ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǩǟ�ǘǗ�NjǥǛǜǚǘ�njǘǑǘNjǗǘnjǒǕ�ǚNJNjǘǜǝ��ƽ�ǔǚǝǙǗǏǓǢǒǟ�ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�Ǟǘǚǝǖǘnj�ǒ�ǩǚǖNJǚǘǔ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ƭǝNJǗǡǐǘǝǛǔǘǓ�ljǚǖNJǚǔǒ��ǒǖǏǏǜǛǩ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǘǙǘnjǏǣǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǜǏǗ-

�� ƵǨ�ƿNJǗǦ��������ƻ���Ȃ��

66 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 68: User identification analysis

ǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj��ƻǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǜ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛǥ��njǚǘǎǏ�PDGH�LQ�FKLQD�FRP��ǍǎǏ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǗNJǓǜǒ�ǙǚNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǕǨNjǘǓ�ǜǘnjNJǚ��ǗNJǡǒǗNJǩ�ǘǜ�ǍnjǘǑǎǏǓ�ǒ�ǑNJǔNJǗǡǒnjNJǩ�NJnjǜǘǙǘǍǚǝǑǡǒǔNJǖǒ��ǒ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǒǜǦǛǩ�ǘ�ǏǍǘ�ǙǏǚǏ-njǘǑǔǏ� nj� ǎǚǝǍǘǏ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǘ�� ƼNJǔǒǟ� ǚǏǛǝǚǛǘnj� ǎǏǛǩǜǔǒ�� nj� Ǘǒǟ� ǏǛǜǦ� njǗǝ-ǜǚǏǗǗǩǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘ�ǚNJNjǘǜNJǏǜ�

ƬǛǏǖ�ǒǑnjǏǛǜǏǗ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�ƼNJǘNjNJǘ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�ǝǐǏ�Ǎǘǜǘnj�NjǘǚǘǜǦǛǩ�Ǜ�ǖǒǚǘ-njǥǖǒ�ǕǒǎǏǚNJǖǒ�njǚǘǎǏ�(ED\��Ƭ�����b Ǎǘǎǝ�ǘNjǘǚǘǜ� ǛǘǛǜNJnjǒǕ�������ǖǕǚǎ�ǨNJǗǏǓ��ǘǔǘǕǘ����ǖǕǚǎ�ǎǘǕǕNJǚǘnj�ƻǂƪ���Ǚǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǗNJ�ǎǘǕǨ�7DREDR�Ǚǚǒ-ǟǘǎǒǕǘǛǦ���Ɍ��ǛǎǏǕǘǔ�ǘǜ�njǛǏǍǘ�ǘNjǤǪǖNJ�ǙǚǘǎNJǐ�ǗNJ�ǔǒǜNJǓǛǔǘǖ�ǚǥǗǔǏ�ǒǗ-ǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǖNJǍNJǑǒǗǘnj����ƹǘbǛǘǛǜǘǩǗǒǨ�ǗNJ�����bǍǘǎ��ǗNJ�7DREDR�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘ�ǑNJǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǒǕǘ�����ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗǘnj��ƹǚǒǖǏ-ǡNJǜǏǕǦǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�ƼNJǘNjNJǘ�ǙǘǚǘǎǒǕ�ǑNJ�ǙǚǏǎǏǕNJǖǒ�ƴƷƺ�ǠǏǕǥǓ�ǚǩǎ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ� ǑNJǗǒǖNJǕǒǛǦ� ǙǘǛǚǏǎǗǒǡǏǛǜnjǘǖ�� ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�� ǎǕǩ� ǛnjǩǑǒ� ǔǒǜNJǓǛǔNJǩ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗNJ� ǗǏǚǏǎǔǘ� njǛǏ� ǏǣǏ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜ� ǜǚNJǎǒǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ� ǛnjǩǑǒ��njǚǘǎǏ�44��NjǕNJǍǘǎNJǚǩ�ǡǏǖǝ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǗǒǔǒ�ǔNJǔǘǏ�ǜǘ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǙǚǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǜ�

ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒ�ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ��ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ��nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒƷƯƻƶƸƼƺlj�Ʒƪ� ƿƸƺƸǂƲƯ�ƹƸƴƪƱƪƼƯƵƲ�ǚNJǛǙǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�nj�ƴǒǜNJǏ�ǒ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�� ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ� ǙǘǖǗǒǜǦ�� ǡǜǘ� ǧǜǘ� njǏǛǦǖNJ� ǛǙǏǠ-ǒǞǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ� ǛǜǚNJǗNJ�� ǒǛǜǘǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ� ǙǝǜǦ� ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ�� ǎNJǐǏ� ǏǛǕǒ� NjǚNJǜǦ� ǒǛ-ǔǕǨǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�njǜǘǚǝǨ�ǙǘǕǘnjǒǗǝ�;;bnj���ǘǡǏǗǦ�ǘǜǕǒǡǏǗ�ǘǜ�ǚǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǍǘ��ƹǚǒ� ǔNJǐǝǣǏǖǛǩ� ǛǟǘǎǛǜnjǏ� �ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ�� ǎǘǕǍǘǏ� ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ� Ǜǘ� ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǛǜǘnj���ǚNJǑǕǒǡǒǓ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�NjǘǕǦǢǏ��ƻǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�nj�njǒǎǝ��ǡǜǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǏ�ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǘǖ�nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�nj�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǘǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǘǜnjǏǜNJ�ǗNJ�ǝǐǏ�ǒǖǏǨ-ǣǒǓǛǩ�ǞNJǔǜ�ǖNJǛǛǘnjǘǍǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǩǖǒ�ǍǕǘNjNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛǏǜǒ��Ƭ�ǘǜǕǒǡǒǏ�ǘǜ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ��nj�ƴƷƺ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǏ�ǧǜǘǓ�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�ǗNJǡNJǕǘǛǦ�njǕNJǛǜǩ-ǖǒ�mǛnjǏǚǟǝ}�ǏǣǪ�ǎǘ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�njǛǏǖǒǚǗǘǓ�ǛǏǜǒ�njǗǝǜǚǒ�ǛǜǚNJǗǥ��ƬbƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǗǏǜ�ǜNJǔǘǓ�ǙǚǒnjǏǚǐǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǔ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔNJǞǏ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǎǘǕǍǘǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�NjǥǕǒ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǖ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjǘǖ�ǙǘǙNJǛǜǦ�nj�ǛǏǜǦ��Ǚǘ-ǙǝǜǗǘ�ǩnjǕǩǩǛǦ�ǔǕǝNjǘǖ�ǑǗNJǔǘǖǥǟ��ƸǡǏnjǒǎǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�nj�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǑNJnjǏǎǏǗǒǩǟ�ǚǏ-ǢǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǥ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǩ�ǑNJ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǗǒǏǖ�ǒ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǝǙǚǘǣǏǗǗǘǓ�ǑNJǎNJǡǏǓ��ƺǘǛǛǒǩ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǒǗǜǏǍǚǒǚǘnjNJǗNJ�nj�ǖǏǐǎǝ-ǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǏ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǥ��ǑǎǏǛǦ�ǙǘǙǝǕǩǚǗǥ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�njǘ�njǛǏǖ�

�� mƮǘǔǕNJǎ�ǘ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�nj�����bǍ�}�������

67ƴƲƼƪƳ

Page 69: User identification analysis

ǖǒǚǏ� �*RRJOH��)DFHERRN��<RXWXEH��7ZLWWHU��:LNLSHGLD���Ǚǘǧǜǘǖǝ�ǙǘǙǥǜǔNJ�ǑNJǔǚǥǜǦ�ǔ�Ǘǒǖ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ��ǎNJǐǏ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�ǏǍǘ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǒǜǦ��ǗNJǜǘǕǔǗǏǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǖNJǛǛǘnjǘǏ�ǗǏǙǚǒǩǜǒǏ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ��ƺǘǛǛǒǩ��ǩnjǕǩǨǣNJǩǛǩ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǒǜǏǕǦ-ǛǔǘǓ�ǎǏǖǘǔǚNJǜǒǏǓ��ǗǏ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǒǜǦ�ǛǏNjǏ�ǜǏǟ�ǍǒNjǔǒǟ�ǚǏǍǝǕǩǜǒnjǗǥǟ�ǖǏǚ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǩ�ǖNJǛǛǝ�ǙǘǎǑNJǔǘǗǗǥǟ�NJǔǜǘnj��ǡǜǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜ�ǘǎǗǘǙNJǚǜǒǓ-ǗǥǓ�ƴǒǜNJǓ��ƫǘǕǏǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǘǗǒ�NjǥǕǒbNjǥ�ǛnjǘǏnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǥ�ǒ�ǒǛǔǝǛǛǜnjǏǗǗǥ�

ƹǚǒǗǩǜNJǩ� nj� ƴƷƺ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ� ǛǖǛ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� Ǜ� ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�Ǜǒǖ�ǔNJǚǜǥ��ǙǚǒnjǩǑNJǗǗǘǓ�ǔ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǏ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJ-ǗǒǗNJ�ǒǕǒ� ǔ� ǑNJǍǚNJǗǒǡǗǘǖǝ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜǝ� ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǠNJ� njǙǘǕǗǏ� ǑNJǛǕǝǐǒnjNJǏǜ�njǗǒǖNJǗǒǩ��ƸǗNJ�ǙǚǘǛǜNJ�ǒ�ǘNjǣǏǎǘǛǜǝǙǗNJ��ǗǏ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ�NjǘǕǦǢǒǟ�njǚǏǖǏǗ-Ǘǥǟ�ǒǑǎǏǚǐǏǔ�Ǜ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ��ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ǙǘǎǘNj-ǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ǔNJǐǎǥǖ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘǖ�ǛǏǚnjǏ-ǚǘnj�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�� ǛǙǘǛǘNjǗǥǟ� ǍǏǗǏǚǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ� ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǕǘǍǒǗǥ�ǒ�ǙNJǚǘǕǒ�ǎǕǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�

ƶǘǐǗǘ�ǛǎǏǕNJǜǦ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ�njǥnjǘǎǥ���� ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�nj�ƴǒǜNJǏ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǎǘǛǜNJ-

ǜǘǡǗǘ�ǙǚǒǖǒǜǒnjǗǘǓ�ǙǘbǜǘǓ�ǙǚǒǡǒǗǏ��ǡǜǘ�njǘǙǚǘǛǥ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗ-Ǘǘ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� ǒ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ� ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒ-njNJǨǜǛǩ� ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJǖǒ�ǞǒǕǦǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǔǘǗǜǏǗǜNJ��ƮǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǝ�ǔ� NjǏǛǙǚǘnjǘǎǗǥǖ� ǛǏǜǩǖ� nj� ǖǏǛǜNJǟ� ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǘǍǘ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǗǥǖ�ǜǘǖǝ��ǔNJǔ�ǧǜǘ�ǎǏǕNJǏǜǛǩ�nj� ƲǜNJǕǒǒ� ǒ� ƲǛǙNJǗǒǒbȃ� ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ� ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ� ǍǏǗǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǕǘǍǒǗNJ� ǒ� ǙNJǚǘǕǩ� njǒǜǚǜǝNJǕǦǗǥǖ� ǛǏǚnjǏǚǘǖ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ� ǗNJ� ǝǚǘnjǗǏ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJ�� ǙǚǒnjǩǑNJǗǗǘǍǘ� ǔ� ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜǝ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ��ƶǏǐǎǝ�ǜǏǖ��ǛNJǖ�ǞNJǔǜ�ǗNJǕǒǡǒǩ�ǝ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ƴǒǜNJǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒ-ǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�njǜǘǚǘǍǘ�ǙǘǔǘǕǏǗǒǩ��ǛǘǎǏǚNJǐNJǣǏǓ�ǡǒǙ�Ǜ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖǒ��nj� ǙǚǒǗǒǠǙǏ� ǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ� ǗNJǛǥǣǏǗǒǩ� ǧǜǘǍǘ� ǠǒǞǚǘ-njǘǍǘ�ǖǘǎǝǕǩ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǖǒ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜNJǖǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡ-Ǘǥǖ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ�ǒ�ǚNJǛǢǒǚǏǗǒǩ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǏǓ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

��� ƱNJǒǖǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǏ� ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖNJ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ� Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ� Ǜǒǖ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�� ǙǚǒnjǩǑNJǗǗǘǓ� ǔ� ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǥǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǏǛ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǩ� ǒ� ǖǘǗǒǜǘǚǒǗǍNJ� ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǘnj� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǖNJǚǢǚǝǜǒǑNJǜǘǚǘnj�nj�ǖǏǛǜNJǟ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǚǒnjǏ-ǎǏǜ�ǔNJǔ�ǔ�ǚǘǛǜǝ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒǑǎǏǚǐǏǔ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǚǘǛǜǝ�ǒǑǎǏǚǐǏǔ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘnj��ǘNjǩǑNJǗǗǥǟ�njǗǏǎǚǩǜǦ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�Ǚǘǚ-ǜNJǕǥ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǎǕǩ�mǛǕǝǡNJǓǗǥǟ}�ǙǘǛǏǜǒǜǏǕǏǓ�NjǏǛǙǚnjǘǎǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǏǓ�

68 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 70: User identification analysis

��� ƬǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǏ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ� ǔNJǚǜǥ�� ǑNJǖǏǗǩǨǣǏǓ� ǘNjǣǏ-ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǒǓ� ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜ�� ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǣǏǓ� ǡǒǙ� Ǜ� ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǥǖ� ǘNjǤǏ-ǖǘǖ�ǙNJǖǩǜǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǑNJǙǒǛǒ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘnj�ǎǕǩ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�ǑNJǛǕǝǐǒnjNJǏǜ�ǛNJǖǘǍǘ�ǙǚǒǛǜNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�njǗǒǖNJǗǒǩ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǛǘǎǏǚ-ǐǒǜ�NjǘǕǦǢǘǓ�ǙǘǜǏǗǠǒNJǕ�ǎǕǩ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ� njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� nj� ǠǏǕǩǟ� ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�� ǘNjǣǏ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�

ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǩ

ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJƲƻƼƸƺƲlj� ƬƬƯƮƯƷƲlj� ƻƲƻƼƯƶ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�nj�ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǒ�ǗǘǛǒǜ� njǏǛǦǖNJ� ǑNJǙǝǜNJǗǗǥǓ� ǒ� ǒǗǜǚǒǍǝǨǣǒǓ� ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚ�� ƯǣǏ� nj� ǛǏǚǏǎǒǗǏ�;;bnjǏǔNJ�nj�ǗǝǐǎNJǟ�ǝǛǒǕǏǗǒǩ�ǔǘǗǜǚǚNJǑnjǏǎǥnjNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǒ�ǗNJǎǑǘǚǗǘǍǘ�ǚǏ-ǐǒǖNJ� nj� ǛǜǚNJǗǏ� ǗNJ� ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǘǏ� njǚǏǖǩ� njnjǘǎǒǕǒǛǦ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǒ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǕǒ�ǛǘNjǘǓ�ǞNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�NJǗNJǕǘǍ�njǗǝǜǚǒǍǚNJǐ-ǎNJǗǛǔǒǟ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜǘnj��ƽǚǘnjǏǗǦ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǒǟ�ǛnjǘNjǘǎ�nj�ǧǜǘǓ�ǛǜǚNJǗǏ�njǏǛǦǖNJ�njǥǛǘǔ��Ǚǘǧǜǘǖǝ�ǏǎǒǗǘǓ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǝǡǏǜNJ�ǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�nj�ǛǜǚNJǗǏ�ǎǘ�Ǜǒǟ�Ǚǘǚ�ǗǏ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ��ǙǘǙǥǜǔǒ�njnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǙǚǏǎǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǕǒǛǦ�ǗǏǘǎǗǘǔǚNJǜǗǘ��ƹǏǚnjǥǏ�ǙǘǙǥǜ-ǔǒ�ǙǚǘǎNJnjǒǜǦ� njnjǏǎǏǗǒǏ� Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ�NjǥǕǒ�ǙǚǏǎǙǚǒǗǩǜǥ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘǖ�ǔǘǗǛǏǚnjNJǜǘǚǘnj�� njǘǑǍǕNJnjǕǩǏǖǥǖ� ƮǐǘǗǘǖ� ƶǧǓǎǐǘǚǘǖ� Ǚǘǎ� ǗǏǙǘǛǚǏǎ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ� ǚǝǔǘnjǘǎǛǜnjǘǖ� ƶǒǗǒǛǜǚNJ� njǗǝǜǚǏǗǗǒǟ� ǎǏǕ� ƶNJǓǔǕNJ� ƭǘnjNJǚǎNJ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ��ǗNJ�ǔǘǗǞǏǚǏǗǠǒǒ�ǕǏǓNjǘǚǒǛǜǛǔǘǓ�ǙNJǚǜǒǒ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ�ƼǘǗǒ�ƫǕǧǚ�ǑNJǩnjǒǕ��ǡǜǘ�njǖǏǛǜǘ�ǜǚNJǜǥ�ǛǘǜǏǗ�ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗǘnj�ǞǝǗǜǘnj�ǗNJ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǒǟ�ǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǕǘbNjǥ�ǙǘǜǚNJǜǒǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǗǒǏ�ǜǥǛǩǡ�ǘǞǒǠǏǚǘnj�Ǚǘ-ǕǒǠǒǒ�ǗNJ�ǖǏǛǜNJǟ��ƷǏǛǖǘǜǚǩ�ǗNJ�ǜǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǧǜǘǜ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜ�NjǥǕ�njǔǕǨǡǏǗ�nj�ǜǏǔǛǜ�ǖNJǗǒǞǏǛǜNJ�ǔǘǗǛǏǚnjNJǜǒnjǗǘǓ�ǙNJǚǜǒǒ��ǙǘNjǏǎNJ�ǕǏǓNjǘǚǒǛǜǘnj�ǗNJ�njǥNjǘǚNJǟ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ�ǙǚǒnjǏǕNJ�ǔ�ǜǘǖǝ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜ�ǧǜǘǜ�NjǥǕ�ǑNJNjǕǘǔǒǚǘnjNJǗ�

ƹǚǏǎǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�njnjǏǛǜǒ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ�mǒǖǏǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ}��HQWLWOHPHQW�FDUGV��Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ�NjǥǕǘ�njǗǘnjǦ�ǙǘǎǗǩǜǘ�ǖǒǗǒǛǜǚǘǖ�ƶƬƮ�Ʈǧnjǒǎǘǖ�ƫǕNJǗǔǏǜ-ǜǘǖ�ǙǘǛǕǏ�ǜǏǚǚǘǚǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�NJǔǜNJ����ǛǏǗǜǩNjǚǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�ǧǜǘǜ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜ�njǥǑnjNJǕ�ǛǘǙǚǘǜǒnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǔǘǕǕǏǍ�ǒǑ�ƴNJNjǒǗǏǜNJ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǚǘnj��ƼǏǖ�ǗǏ�ǖǏǗǏǏ��njǘǑǚNJǛǜNJǨǣǏǏ�NjǏǛǙǘǔǘǓǛǜnjǘ�ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏnj�ǔǚǒǖǒǗNJǕǦ-Ǘǥǟ�ǙǘǎǖǏǗ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ��LGHQWLW\� WKHIW��ǒ�ǘǢǒNjǘǔ�nj�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǍǘǛǝ-ǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖǒ��ǙǚǒnjǏǕǘ�ǔ�ǜǘǖǝ��ǡǜǘ�nj�ǒǨǕǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ�nj�ǠǏ-Ǖǩǟ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�NjǥǕ�ǒǑǎNJǗ�ǔǘǗǛǝǕǦǜNJǜǒnjǗǥǓ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜ�

69ƬƯƵƲƴƸƫƺƲƼƪƷƲlj

Page 71: User identification analysis

mƲǖǏǗǗǥǏ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǒ�ǔǚNJǐNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ}����ƷNJǡNJǕǛǩ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛ�ǙǝNjǕǒǡǗǘ-Ǎǘ�ǘNjǛǝǐǎǏǗǒǩ��nj�ǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜǏ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǍǘ�ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjǘ�njǘnjǕǏǡǪǗǗǥǟ�nj�ǚǏNJ-ǕǒǑNJǠǒǨ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ��ǛǘǍǕNJǛǒǕǒǛǦ�ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǩǜǦ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�

Ƭ�����bǍǘǎǝ�ƫǕNJǗǔǏǜǜ�ǘNjǤǩnjǒǕ��ǡǜǘ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ǗNJǖǏǚǏǗǘ�njnjǏǛǜǒ�mNjǚǒǜNJǗǛǔǝǨ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǝǨ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǝǨ�ǔNJǚǜǝ}����ǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǝǨ�Ǜ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�NjNJǑǘǓ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǒǑnjǏǛǜǗǘǓ�ǔNJǔ�ƷNJ-ǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�ƺǏǏǛǜǚ��ƷƲƺ���ƹǚǏǎǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ǘ�njnjǏ-ǎǏǗǒǒ�ǔNJǚǜ�NjǥǕǘ�njǔǕǨǡǏǗǘ�nj�ǗǘǩNjǚǦǛǔǝǨ�ǚǏǡǦ�ƴǘǚǘǕǏnjǥ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ��ǗǏǛǖǘǜǚǩ� ǗNJ� ǛǔǏǙǜǒǠǒǑǖ� ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ� ǛǙǘǛǘNjǗǘǛǜǒ� ǗǘnjǘǓ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǘǔNJǑNJǜǦ� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǏ� ǙǚǘǜǒnjǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏ� ǜǏǚǚǘǚǒǑǖǝ�� ƸNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǏ�ǘNjǛǝǐǎǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚǒnjǏǕǘ�ǔ�ǜǘǖǝ��ǡǜǘ�NjǥǕǘ�ǞNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǜǏǚ-ǖǒǗ�mǒǖǏǗǗǥǏ�ǔNJǚǜǥ}�ǗǘǛǒǕ�njǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǓ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚ��ǞNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǩnjǕǩ-ǩǛǦ�ǧǞǏǖǒǑǖǘǖ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ�

Ƭ�NJnjǍǝǛǜǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǗNJ�ǑNJǛǏǎǏǗǒǒ�ƾNJNjǒNJǗǛǔǘǍǘ�ƸNjǣǏǛǜnjNJ�ǖǒǗǒǛǜǚ�ƼǘǗǒ�ƶNJǔ�ƷǝǕǦǜǒ�� ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǓ� ǑNJ� njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ�� ǑNJǩnjǒǕ�� ǡǜǘ�ǗǘnjǥǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǛǜNJǗǝǜ�mǑǘǕǘǜǥǖ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǘǖ}�nj�ǝǎǘ-ǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ���

ƱNJǔǘǗ�� ǝǡǚǏǐǎNJnjǢǒǓ� ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǑNJǖǏǗǩǕǒ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜ�njǗǝǜǚǒ�ƫǚǒǜNJǗǒǒ�ǒ�ǩnjǕǩǕǒǛǦbNjǥ�ǘǛ-ǗǘnjǗǥǖ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘǖ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǝǜǏǢǏǛǜnjǒǓ�nj�Ưƻ��NjǥǕ�ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗ�ƹNJǚǕNJǖǏǗ-ǜǘǖ�ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǒ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ�ǒ�ǒǑnjǏǛǜǏǗ��ǔNJǔ�mƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǔNJǚǜNJǟ}���� ƸǎǗǒǖ� ǒǑ� ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǟ� NJǚǍǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�� njǥǎnjǒǍNJǏǖǥǟ�ǙǝNjǕǒǡǗǘ�nj�ǙǘǕǦǑǝ�njnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǗǘnjǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��NjǥǕǘ�ǙǚǘǜǒnjǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏ�ǜǏǚǚǘǚǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ǘǍǚǘǖǗǥǟ�ǛǕǘǐǗǘ-ǛǜǏǓ�ǎǕǩ�ǞNJǕǦǛǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǜǏǚǚǘǚǒǛǜNJǖǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗ-ǜǘnj��ƮǚǝǍǒǖ�NJǚǍǝǖǏǗǜǘǖ�nj�ǙǘǕǦǑǝ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ�NjǥǕNJ�NjǘǚǦNjNJ�Ǜ�ǗǏǕǏǍNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǖǖǒǍǚNJǠǒǏǓ��ƴNJǔ�ǛǔNJǑNJǕ�ǙǚǏǖǦǏǚ�ǖǒǗǒǛǜǚ�ƼǘǗǒ�ƫǕǧǚ��nj�ǛǜǚNJǗǏ�Ǚǚǒ-ǖǏǚǗǘ�����ǜǥǛǩǡ�ǗǏǕǏǍNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǒǖǖǒǍǚNJǗǜǘnj�ǒ��mǏǛǕǒ�njǥ�ǟǘǜǒǜǏ�ǘǜǛǕǏ-ǐǒnjNJǜǦ�ǗǏǕǏǍNJǕǦǗǝǨ�ǒǖǖǒǍǚNJǠǒǨ�ǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǝǨ�ǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǗǘǛǜǦ�Ȑ�njNJǖ�ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ�njnjǏǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǔNJǚǜǥ��ƵǨNjǘǏ�ǎǚǝǍǘǏ�ǚǏǢǏ-ǗǒǏ�ǙǚǘǛǜǘ�ǗǏ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǚNJNjǘǜNJǜǦ}���

ƴNJǐǎNJǩ� Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜNJ� ǒ� ǙǚǒnjǩǑNJǗǗǥǓ� ǔ� ǗǏǓ� NJǔǔNJǝǗǜ� nj� ƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǖ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǖ�ƺǏǏǛǜǚǏ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�NjǥǕǒ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǜǦ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ��ǒǖǏǨǣǝǨ� ǑǗNJǡǏǗǒǏ� ǎǕǩ� njǘǙǚǘǛǘnj� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�� ǜNJǔǒǏ� ǔNJǔ� 3Ζ1�ǔǘǎ��

�� KWWS���ZZZ�KRPHRIILFH�JRY�XN�GRFXPHQWV�HQWLWOHPHQW�FDUGV�� KWWS���QHZV�EEF�FR�XN���KL�XN���������VWP�� KWWS���QHZV�EEF�FR�XN���KL�XNBQHZV�SROLWLFV���������VWP�� KWWS���ZZZ�RSVL�JRY�XN�$&76�DFWV������������E�KWP�VFK��� KWWS���ZZZ�JRYWHFK�FRP�VHFXULW\�*UHDW�%ULWDLQV�1DWLRQDO�Ζ'�&DUG�:KDW�KWPO

70 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 72: User identification analysis

ǙNJǚǘǕǦ� ǒ�ǒǕǒ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ� njǘǙǚǘǛǥ�� njǘǙǚǘǛǥ�� ǙǚǒǑnjNJǗǗǥǏ� ǘǙǚǏ-ǎǏǕǒǜǦ�njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠNJ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǒ�ǙǘǖǏǢNJǜǦ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǗǏNJnjǜǘǚǒǑnjNJǗǗǥǓ�ǎǘ-ǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ƴNJǐǎNJǩ�ǔNJǚǜNJ�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�NjǥǕNJ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�ǞǘǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǨ�njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠNJ��ƯǪ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�NjǥǕǘbNjǥ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�nj�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�njǘǎǒǜǏǕǦǛǔǘǍǘ�ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ��ǙǘǎǘNjǗǘ�ǜǘǖǝ��ǔNJǔ�ǧǜǘ�ǎǏǕNJǏǜǛǩ�nj�ƻǂƪ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�Ǚǘǖǒǖǘ�ǧǜǘǍǘ��ǔNJǚǜNJ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǛǡǒǜNJǗNJ�ǎǕǩ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�Ǜ�ƷƲƺ��ƼNJǔ�ǗNJǑǥnjNJǏǖNJǩ� ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗNJǩ� ƬǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗNJǩ� ƻǕǝǐNjNJ� ǎǘǕǐ-ǗNJ� NjǥǕNJ� ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǜǦ� NjNJǗǔNJǖ�� njǚNJǡNJǖ�� ƴǘǚǘǕǏnjǛǔǘǓ� ƹǘǡǜǘnjǘǓ� ƻǕǝǐNjǏ��ǝǗǒnjǏǚǛǒǜǏǜNJǖ�� ǙǚǘǔNJǜǡǒǔNJǖ� '9'�ǎǒǛǔǘnj� ǒ� ǚǘǑǗǒǡǗǥǖ� ǜǘǚǍǘnjǠNJǖ�njǛǏǟ�njǒǎǘnj�njǏǚǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠNJ�� njǙǕǘǜǦ�ǎǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǥǖ�ǔNJǜǏǍǘǚǒǩǖ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ƶƬƮ�ƬǏǕǒ-ǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǒ�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǕǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘǖ�ǛǖǘǍǝǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǕǨNjǥǏ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ��ǙǚǘǢǏǎǢǒǏ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǝǨ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǝ�NJǔ-ǔǚǏǎǒǜNJǠǒǒ��ƸǛǘNjNJǩ�ǗNJǎǏǐǎNJ�njǘǑǕNJǍNJǕNJǛǦ�ǗNJ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏb Njǥ� ǎǏǕNJǕǒb ǙǘǎǖǏǗǝ� ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ� nj� njǥǛǢǏǓ� ǛǜǏǙǏǗǒ� ǑNJǜǚǝǎǗǒ-ǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�ǔǚǒǜǒǔǒ�ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǕǒ��ǡǜǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǏǎǒǗǛǜnjǏǗ-ǗǘǍǘ�ǗǘǖǏǚNJ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǖǘǍǕǘbNjǥ�ǙǚǒnjǏǛǜǒ�ǔ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖNJǖ��ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǖǒ�ǜǏǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǒǖǏǕǒ�ǖǏǛǜǘ�nj�ƻǂƪ�Ǜ�ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎǝNJǕǦǗǥǖǒ�ǗǘǖǏǚNJǖǒ�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǕǒǛǦ�ǎǕǩ�ǔǚNJǐǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�

ƬNJǐǗǏǓǢǒǖ� ǧǕǏǖǏǗǜǘǖ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�NjǥǕ� ǝǙǘǖǩǗǝǜǥǓ�ƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�ƺǏǏǛǜǚ�bȃ�NjNJǑNJ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜ�� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǍǘ� ǒ� ǛǜNJǕǘ� ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǖ� NJǚǍǝǖǏǗǜǘǖ� ǙǚǘǜǒnjǗǒǔǘnj� ǗǘnjǘǓ� ǗNJǠǒǘ-ǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� ƱNJǔǘǗ� ǙǚǏǎǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǩǕ� ��� ǔNJǜǏǍǘ-ǚǒǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ƷƲƺ�nj�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǒ�ǔNJǐǎǘǍǘ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ�ǒ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ��njǔǕǨǡNJǩ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǒ�njǛǏǟ����ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��ǛǔNJǗ�ǕǒǠNJ�ǒ�ǚNJǎǝǐǗǘǓ�ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔǒ�ǍǕNJǑNJ��ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǒǏ�ǒ�njǛǏ�NjǥnjǢǒǏ�ǖǏǛǜNJ�ǐǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�nj�ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǒ��ǒǗǎǏǔǛǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǖǏǜǘǔ�ǕǒǗǔǘnj�ǗNJ�ǎǚǝǍǒǏ�njǏǎǘǖǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�NjNJǑǥ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��njǔǕǨǡNJǩ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjNJǗǒǩ���Ǜ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖ�ǧǜǒǟ�NjNJǑ��ƱNJǔǘǗ�ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǕ��nj�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ��ǝnjǏ-ǕǒǡǏǗǒǏ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjNJ�ǔNJǜǏǍǘǚǒǓ�ǒ��ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ��ǜǒǙǘnj�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�

ƬǛǏ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǏ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ� ǙǘǎNJǨǜ� ǗNJ� ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǏ� ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ�� ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�NjǥǕǒ�NjǥǜǦ�njǔǕǨǡǏǗǥ�nj�ƷƲƺ��ƫǚǒǜNJǗǛǔNJǩ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜǗNJǩ�ǛǕǝǐNjNJ�NjǥǕNJ�ǙǏ-ǚǏǒǖǏǗǘnjNJǗNJ�nj�ƻǕǝǐNjǝ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ƹNJǛǙǘǚǜǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ΖGHQWLW\�DQG�3DVVSRUW�6HUYLFH��

ƬǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǏ�ǗNJǡNJǕǘǛǦ�Ǜ�ǚǩǎNJ�ǙǒǕǘǜǗǥǟ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǘnj�• ƻǜǝǎǏǗǜǥ� ǒǑ� ǛǜǚNJǗ� ǑNJ� ǙǚǏǎǏǕNJǖǒ� Ưƻ� ǒ� ǕǒǠNJ�� njǛǜǝǙNJǨǣǒǏ� nj�

NjǚNJǔ�� njǔǕǨǡNJǩ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǒǓ��ƻ�ǗǘǩNjǚǩ� ����b ǍǘǎNJ� njǙǕǘǜǦ� ǎǘ� ǘǜ-ǖǏǗǥ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥ�ǕǒǠNJǖ��njǤǏǟNJnjǢǒǖ�nj�ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǨ�ǙǘbǛǜǝ-

71ƬƯƵƲƴƸƫƺƲƼƪƷƲlj

Page 73: User identification analysis

ǎǏǗǡǏǛǔǒǖ�njǒǑNJǖ�ǒ�njǒǑNJǖ��njǥǎNJǨǣǒǖǛǩ�ǎǕǩ�njǛǜǝǙNJǨǣǒǟ�nj�NjǚNJǔ�ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǩǕǘǛǦ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜǦ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ�

• ƪnjǒNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕ�� ƹǒǕǘǜǗNJǩ� ǛǟǏǖNJ�� ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJnjǢNJǩ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǝǨ�njǥǎNJǡǝ�ǔNJǚǜ��������ǕǒǠNJǖ��ǑNJǗǩǜǥǖ�nj�NJnjǒNJǠǒǘǗ-ǗǘǓ�ǘǜǚNJǛǕǒ��ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�NjǥǕNJ�NjǥǜǦ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗNJ�nj�NJǧǚǘǙǘǚǜNJǟ�ƶNJǗǡǏ-ǛǜǏǚNJ�ǒ�ƵǘǗǎǘǗNJ��Ǘǘ�Ǚǘǎ�ǎNJnjǕǏǗǒǏǖ�ǙǚǘǞǛǘǨǑǘnj�NjǥǕNJ�ǘǜǖǏǗǏǗNJ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ�

• ưǒǜǏǕǒ� ƫǘǕǦǢǘǍǘ� ƶNJǗǡǏǛǜǏǚNJ�� ƹǒǕǘǜǗǥǓ� ǙǚǘǏǔǜ�� ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖNJ-ǜǚǒnjNJnjǢǒǓ� njǥǎNJǡǝ� Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜ� ǗNJ� ǎǘNjǚǘnjǘǕǦǗǘǓ� ǘǛǗǘnjǏ� Ǜ� ǘǔǜǩNjǚǩ�����b ǍǘǎNJ�� ƱNJǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ� ǙǘǎNJǕǒ� ������ ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ� nj� ǘNjǣǏǓ� ǛǕǘǐǗǘ-Ǜǜǒ�� ƭNJǑǏǜNJ� mƶNJǗǡǏǛǜǏǚ� ǒnjǗǒǗǍ� ǗǦǨǑ}� ǚNJǛǔǘǙNJǕNJ� ǞNJǔǜǥ�� ǡǜǘ� nj�����bǍǘǎǝ�ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔǒ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ǚNJǛǛǥǕNJǕǒ�ǎǚǝǑǦǩǖ�ǒ�ǚǘǎ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗǒǔNJǖ� ǙǒǛǦǖNJ� Ǜ� ǙǚǘǛǦNjǘǓ� ǙǚǒǘNjǚǏǛǜǒ� ǔNJǚǜǥ�� ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǘǗǒ�NjǥǕǒ�ǘNjǏǛǙǘǔǘǏǗǥ�ǗǒǑǔǒǖ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘǖ�ǑNJǩnjǕǏǗǒǓ�

• ƫNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǒǏ�ǛǡǏǜNJ�ǎǕǩ�ǖǘǕǘǎǥǟ�ǕǨǎǏǓ��ƹǚǘǏǔǜ�ǗNJ�ǎǘNjǚǘnjǘǕǦǗǘǓ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ��ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJnjǢǒǓ�ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗǒǏ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜ�Ǚǚǒ�ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏ-Ǘǒǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘǍǘ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǘǍǘ�ǛǡǏǜNJ�

• ưǒǜǏǕǒ�ƵǘǗǎǘǗNJ��ƹǚǘǏǔǜ�ǗNJ�ǎǘNjǚǘnjǘǕǦǗǘǓ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ��ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖNJǜǚǒ-njNJnjǢǒǓ�njǥǎNJǡǝ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜ�ǎǕǩ�njǛǏǟ�ǐǏǕNJǨǣǒǟ�ǐǒǜǏǕǏǓ�ƵǘǗǎǘǗNJ�

ƹǚǘǜǒnj� ǑNJǔǘǗNJ� njǘǛǛǜNJǕǒ� ǙǚNJnjǘǑNJǣǒǜǗǒǔǒ�� ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǒǛǜǥ� Ǚǘb NjǏǑǘ-ǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��ǨǚǒǛǜǥ��ƲƼ�ǧǔǛǙǏǚǜǥ��ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔǒ��ƸǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ�ǙǚǏǜǏǗǑǒǒ�NjǥǕǒ��ǛǔǘǚǏǏ��ǔ�ǛNJǖǘǓ�NjNJǑǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǔ�ǏǪ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjNJǖ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǚNJǛ-ǙǘǚǩǐǏǗǒǩ�� ǗǏǐǏǕǒ� ǔ� ǛNJǖǒǖ� Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜNJǖ�� ƴǘNJǕǒǠǒǩ� ǔǘǗǛǏǚnjNJǜǘǚǘnj� ǒ�ǕǒNjǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎǏǖǘǔǚNJǜǘnj��ǛǞǘǚǖǒǚǘnjNJǗǗNJǩ�ǙǘǛǕǏ�njǥNjǘǚǘnj�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǘNjǤǩnjǒǕNJ��ǡǜǘ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ� Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǕǒǔnjǒǎǒǚǘnjNJǗNJ��Ƭ�����bǍǘǎǝ�Ǘǘ-njǥǓ� ǔNJNjǒǗǏǜ� ǖǒǗǒǛǜǚǘnj� ǘNjǤǩnjǒǕ�� ǡǜǘ� ǘǗ� ǗNJǖǏǚǏǗ� ǛnjǏǚǗǝǜǦ� ǙǚǘǏǔǜ��njǔǕǨǡNJǩ�ǕǒǔnjǒǎNJǠǒǨ�ƷƲƺ��njǔǕǨǡNJǩ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǏǏ�ǙǘǔǘǕǏǗǒǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒ-ǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜǘnj�ǒ�NjNJǑǝ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ƴǘǗǜNJǔǜ�ƹǘǒǗǜ��nj�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ�ǝǡǒǜǥnjNJ-ǕǒǛǦ� njǛǏ�ǐǒǜǏǕǒ�ǎǘ� ��b ǕǏǜ� nj� ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǙǚǏǎǘǜnjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ� ǧǔǛǙǕǝNJǜNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǗNJǛǒǕǒǩ�nj�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǒ�ǗǏǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǗǘǕǏǜǗǒǟ���ƸǞǒǠǒNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǞǘǚǖǝǕǒ-ǚǘnjǔNJ� ǑnjǝǡNJǕNJ� ǜNJǔ�� mǙǚǏǛǏǡǦ� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǏ� ǚNJǑǤǏǎNJǗǒǏ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǒǟ�ǛnjǘNjǘǎ}��ƷƲƺ�NjǥǕ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǝǗǒǡǜǘǐǏǗ����ǞǏnjǚNJǕǩ�����bǍǘǎǝ�ǙǝǜǪǖ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǙǏǚǏǖNJǕǥnjNJǗǒǩ�����ǐǏǛǜǔǒǟ�ǎǒǛǔǘnj�nj�ǙǚǘǖǥǢǕǏǗǗǘǓ�ǎǚǘNjǒǕǔǏ�nj�LJǛǛǏǔǛǏ�

ƱNJǔǘǗ�mƸNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜNJǟ}�NjǥǕ�ǑNJǖǏǗǏǗ�ƱNJǔǘǗǘǖ�mƸNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǟ}������ǩǗnjNJǚǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ��NJ�ǛNJǖǒ�njǥǎNJǗ-

�� KWWS���ZZZ�SXEOLFDWLRQV�SDUOLDPHQW�XN�SD�FP�������FPELOOV�������������SGI

72 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 74: User identification analysis

ǗǥǏ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�NjǥǕǒ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǗǥ�ǗǏǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖǒ�NjǏǑ�njǛǩǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǔǘǖǙǏǗ-ǛNJǠǒǓ�ǒǟ�njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠNJǖ��Ƹǜ�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǥǟ�ǕǒǠ�ǑNJ�ǙǚǏǎǏǕNJǖǒ�Ưƻ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ��ǜǚǏ-NjǝǨǜ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜǦ� Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�njǒǎNJ�ǗNJ�ǐǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩǖ�ƱNJǔǘǗNJ�ǘ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�ǍǚNJǗǒǠǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǒ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�mƸ�ƭǚNJǗǒǠNJǟ��ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǜnjǏ�ǒ�ǒǖǖǒǍǚNJǠǒǒ}�����bǍǘǎNJ�

ƼNJǔǒǖ� ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�� ǙǘǛǕǏ� ��� ǩǗnjNJǚǩ� ����b ǍǘǎNJ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�mǗǏ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǨǜ�ǎǕǩ�ǘǞǒǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǠǏǕǏǓ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǘǚ-ǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǒǖǏǨǜ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǜǦ�ǒǟ��ǔNJǔ�ǎǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ǜǘǐǎǏǛǜnjNJ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ���

Ƭ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǒǓ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ�njǘǎǒǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǏ�ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ��nj�ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�njǘǎǒǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǏ� ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ� Ǜ�ǞǘǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǏǓ�� njnjǏǎǏǗǗǥǏ�nj� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ�ǗNJǚNJnjǗǏ�Ǜ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJǖǒ��ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǗNJǒNjǘǕǏǏ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖǒ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǖǒ�nj�ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǒ��Ƭ�NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǏ�Ǚǘ-njǛǏǎǗǏnjǗǥǟ�ǛǒǜǝNJǠǒǓ�ǙǘǕǒǠǒǩ�ǎǘ�Ǜǒǟ�Ǚǘǚ�ǗǏ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜ�njǥNjǘǚǘǡ-ǗǝǨ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǝ�ǕǒǠ�

ƹǚNJnjǘnjǥǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjǥƬƯƵƲƴƸƫƺƲƼƪƷƲlj� ljƬƵljƯƼƻlj� ƭƸƻƽƮƪƺƻƼƬƸƶ� Ǜ� ǔǘǗǛǜǒǜǝǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ� ǖǘǗNJǚǟǒǏǓ�ǒ� ǙNJǚǕNJǖǏǗǜǛǔǘǓ� ǞǘǚǖǘǓ� ǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�� nj� ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ� ǙNJǚǕNJǖǏǗǜǛǔNJǩ� ǔǘ-NJǕǒǠǒǩ� ǞǘǚǖǒǚǝǏǜ� ǔNJNjǒǗǏǜ� ǖǒǗǒǛǜǚǘnj�� ƹǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ� ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǩ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǘǎǗǒǖ�ǒǑ�ǛǜNJǚǏǓǢǒǟ�ǎǏǖǘǔǚNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǑNJǙNJǎǗǥǟ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnj��ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǒǟ�ǛnjǘNjǘǎ�nj�ǛǜǚNJǗǏ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�njǥǛǘǔ�ǒ�njǛǩǔǒǏ�ǒǗǒ-ǠǒNJǜǒnjǥ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ�ǙǘbǝǛǒǕǏǗǒǨ�ǖǏǚ�ǗNJǎǑǘǚNJ�ǒ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǩ�njǥǑǥnjNJǨǜ�ǐǏǛǜǔǝǨ�ǗǏǍNJǜǒnjǗǝǨ�ǚǏNJǔǠǒǨ�NjǘǚǠǘnj�ǑNJ�ǛnjǘNjǘǎ�Ǜǘ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ-ǛǔǘǍǘ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjNJ��ƹǘbǧǜǘǓ�ǙǚǒǡǒǗǏ�ǒǗǒǠǒNJǜǒnjNJ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ƷƲƺ�nj�ǔǘǗǏǡ-Ǘǘǖ�ǛǡǏǜǏ�ǙǚǘnjNJǕǒǕNJǛǦ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�NjǥǕǘbNjǥ�ǗǏnjǏǚǗǘ�ǛǡǒǜNJǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǘNjǏǎNJ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǗǒǔǘnj�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǒǟ�ǛnjǘNjǘǎ�ǗǘǛǒǜ�ǘǔǘǗǡNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǓ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚ��Ƹǎ-Ǘǒǖ�ǒǑ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǟ�NJǚǍǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��njǥǎnjǒǍNJǏǖǥǟ�ǙǝNjǕǒǡǗǘ�nj�ǙǘǕǦǑǝ�njnjǏǎǏ-Ǘǒǩ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�mƸNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜNJǟ}��NjǥǕǘ�ǙǚǘǜǒnjǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏ�ǜǏǚǚǘǚǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ǘǍǚǘǖǗǥǟ�ǛǕǘǐǗǘ-ǛǜǏǓ�ǎǕǩ�ǞNJǕǦǛǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǜǏǚǚǘǚǒǛǜNJǖǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗ-ǜǘnj��ƮǚǝǍǒǖ�NJǚǍǝǖǏǗǜǘǖ�nj�ǙǘǕǦǑǝ� ǧǜǘǍǘ�NJǖNjǒǠǒǘǑǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ�NjǥǕNJ�NjǘǚǦNjNJ�Ǜ�ǗǏǕǏǍNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǖǖǒǍǚNJǠǒǏǓ�

ƻǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ� mƶǏǖǘǚNJǗǎǝǖ� ǘ� njǑNJǒǖǘǙǘǗǒǖNJǗǒǒ}���� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ� NjǥǕ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛNJǗ����ǞǏnjǚNJǕǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǏǓ�ǒ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǏǓ��

�� KWWSV���ZZZ�JRY�XN�LGHQWLW\�FDUGV�DQG�QHZ�LGHQWLW\�DQG�SDVVSRUW�VHUYLFH�VXSSOLHUV�� KWWSV���ZZZ�JRY�XN�JRYHUQPHQW�XSORDGV�V\VWHP�XSORDGV�DWWDFKPHQWBGDWD�ILOH��������0R8B8.B(VWRQLDBGLJLWDO�SGI

73ƬƯƵƲƴƸƫƺƲƼƪƷƲlj

Page 75: User identification analysis

ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǧǜǘǖǝ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǝ��ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ�Njǝǎǝǜ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦ�ǘNjǖǏǗ�ǘǙǥ-ǜǘǖ�ǒ�ǙǚǘnjǘǎǒǜǦ�ǛǘnjǖǏǛǜǗǥǏ�ǖǏǚǘǙǚǒǩǜǒǩ�ǒ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦ�ǛǘnjǖǏǛǜǗǥǏ�ǙǒǕǘǜǗǥǏ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǥ�ǙǘbǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǨ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǙǝNjǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�

ƷǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjNJǩ�NjNJǑNJ�ǒ�ǖǏǚǥƬ�ƷƪƻƼƸljǃƯƯ� ƬƺƯƶlj�ƸƻƷƸƬƷDžƶ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�NJǔǜǘǖ��ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǝǨǣǒǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�nj�ǛǏǜǒ�nj�ǙǝNjǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǗǝǐǎNJǟ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�mƸNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǟ}���ǘǜ���bǩǗnjNJǚǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǒ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�mƸ�ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ}�ǘǜ������Ǎ���

ƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�njǏǎǘǖǛǜnjǘǖ��ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǑNJ�NJǛǙǏǔǜǥ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗ-ǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗNJǩ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjNJǩ�ǛǕǝǐNjNJ��*R�YHUQPHQW�'LJLWDO�6HUYLFH��nj�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǏ�ƻǏǔǚǏǜNJǚǒNJǜNJ�ƴNJNjǒǗǏǜNJ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǚǘnj�ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǒ��Ƭ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǧǜǘ�njǏǎǘǖǛǜnjǘ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑǝǏǜ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜ�m*29�8.�9HULI\}���� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�� nj�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǘǖ� ǛǖǥǛǕǏ�� ǕǒNjǏǚNJǕǦ-ǗǘǓ�ǑNJǖǏǗǘǓ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ�ƷƲƺ��ƹǚǘǏǔǜ�NjǥǕ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǑNJǣǒǜǒǜǦ�ǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�Ǚǚǒ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǏ�ǔ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ��ƻǏǚnjǒǛǥ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ�ǗǘǛǩǜ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǓ�ǒ�ǗǏǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǓ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚ��ǔ�Ǘǒǖ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�Ǚǚǒ-ǛǘǏǎǒǗǒǜǦǛǩ�ǒ�ǗǏǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�

ƵǨNjǘǙǥǜǗǘ��Ǘǘ�ǜǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǗǏ�ǝǎNJǕǘǛǦ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑǘnjNJǜǦ�nj�ǙǘǕǗǘǓ�ǖǏǚǏ�Njǚǒ-ǜNJǗǛǔǘǖǝ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǝ� nj� ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ� njnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǔNJǚǜ��ǝǎNJǕǘǛǦ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǝ� ǧǛǜǘǗǛǔǘǖǝ�� ƫǚǒǜNJǗǛǔǘǏ� ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ� nj� ǧǛǜǘǗ-Ǜǔǘǖ�ǘǙǥǜǏ�ǙǚǒnjǕǏǔǕǒ�ǎnjǏ�ǔǕǨǡǏnjǥǏ�ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�

• ǗNJǕǒǡǒǏ� ƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ� ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJ� �ǒǖǏǗǝǏǖǘǍǘ� ƫNJǑǘǓ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ƷNJǛǏǕǏǗǒǩ���ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǨǣǏǍǘ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǎǕǩ�njǛǏǟ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǒ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǘnj�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ�

• ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǔNJǚǜǥ��ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǨǣǒǏ�ǕǏǍNJǕǦǗǝǨ�ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�ǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǏ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ�

Ƭ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�nj�ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǒ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜ�ǘǜǕǒǡǗǥǓ�ǘǜ�ǧǛǜǘǗ-ǛǔǘǍǘ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎ�ǔ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��LJǜǘǜ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎ�ǗǏ�ǙǘǎǚNJǑǝǖǏnjNJǏǜ�njǥǎNJǡǝ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜ��ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�NjǘǕǦǢǒǟ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�NjNJǑ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǜǘǚǘnj�njǛǏǘNjǣǏǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǥǏ�ǑNJǒǖǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǗNJǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǝǨǜ�

ƻǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔ�ƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǘǓ�ǛǕǝǐNjǥ��*RYHUQPHQW�'LJLWDO�6HUYLFH�� ƹǒǜǏǚ� ƿǏǚǕǒǟǒ� ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǏǜ�� mLJǛǜǘǗǒǩ� ǛǖǘǍǕNJ� ǎǘNjǒǜǦǛǩ� ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǝǛǙǏǟǘnj�ǙǘbǜǘǓ�ǙǚǒǡǒǗǏ��ǡǜǘ�ǘǗǒ��ǞNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ��ǛǘǑǎNJǕǒ�ǛnjǘǨ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ��� KWWS���ZZZ�SXEOLFDWLRQV�SDUOLDPHQW�XN�SD�FP�������FPELOOV�������������SGI�� KWWS���ZZZ�OHJLVODWLRQ�JRY�XN�XNSJD���������FRQWHQWV�� KWWSV���LGHQWLW\DVVXUDQFH�EORJ�JRY�XN������������KRZ�ZHUH�HPEHGGLQJ�WKH�LGHQWLW\�DVVXUDQFH�SULQFLSOHV�LQ�JRY�XN�YHULI\�

74 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 76: User identification analysis

Ǜ�ǗǝǕǩ��Ƭ�ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǒ�ǧǜǘ�ǗǏnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǘ�ǙǘbǖǗǘǍǒǖ�ǙǚǒǡǒǗNJǖ��Ǘǘ�ǗNJǖ�ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǘNjǚNJǜǒǜǦ�njǗǒǖNJǗǒǏ�ǗNJ�ǎnjǏ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǘǡǏǗǦ�njNJǐǗǥǏ�njǏǣǒ�� ��� ǛǘNjǒǚNJǗǒǏ�� ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ� ǒ� ǙǝNjǕǒǔNJǠǒǩ� ǎǏǜNJǕǏǓ� ǎNJǗ-Ǘǥǟ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǖǒ�ǘNjǕNJǎNJǏǜ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǘ��ǒ�nj�ǔNJǔǘǖ�ǞǘǚǖNJǜǏ��ǎǕǩ�ǔNJǐǎǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�����ǙǝNjǕǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǛǘǍǕNJǢǏǗǒǓ�ǘǜ-ǔǚǥǜǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǘnj�ǘǜǙǚNJnjǔǒ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ�ǒ�ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǘnj�ǎǕǩ�ǘNjǕǏǍǡǏǗǒǩ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖǒ��nj�ǜǏǟ�ǛǕǝǡNJǩǟ��ǔǘǍǎNJ�ǧǜǘ�ǝǖǏǛǜǗǘ�}���

ƴNJǔ� NjǥǕǘ� ǝǔNJǑNJǗǘ� njǥǢǏ�� nj� ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ� njǚǏǖǩ� njǛǩ� ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�Ǚǘb ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǨ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�nj�ǗǝǐǎNJǟ� ǍǘǛǝ-ǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ�m*29�8.�9HUL�I\}��ƹǚǘǏǔǜ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗ�ǗNJ�ǎǏnjǩǜǒ�ƹǚǒǗǠǒǙNJǟ� ǍNJǚNJǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ����ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǗǘǛǩǜ�ǏǣǪ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǕǒNjǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚ��ǗǏǐǏǕǒ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�mƸ�ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ}��LJǜǒ�ǎǏnjǩǜǦ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǘnj�ǒǑǕǘǐǏ-Ǘǥ�nj�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǏǓ�ǜNJNjǕǒǠǏ�

ƹǚǒǗǠǒǙǥ�ǍNJǚNJǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ

ƴǘǗǜǚǘǕǦ��ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǗǥǓ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǨ

��� ƹǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǓ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǦ

lj�ǒǖǏǨ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǘǜǚNJNjNJǜǥnjNJǜǦ�Ǟǘǚǖǥ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǩ�ǗNJǎ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖǒ��ǛǙǘǛǘNjǗǥǖǒ�ǙǘnjǕǒǩǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǖǏǗǩ��ǙǚǒǡǏǖ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�Ǜ�ǖǘǏǍǘ�ǛǘǍǕNJǛǒǩ

��� ƹǚǘǑǚNJǡǗǘǛǜǦ ƭNJǚNJǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǗNJǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗNJ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǜǏǖǒ�Ǚǝǜǩǖǒ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǩ�ǙǘǗǒǖNJǨ�ǒ�ǘ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǩ�ǙǘǕǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖǒǚǘnjNJǗ

��� ƶǗǘǐǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǦ lj�ǖǘǍǝ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǒ�njǥNjǒǚNJǜǦ�ǗNJǛǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǖǗǘǍǘ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘnj�ǒǕǒ�Ζ'�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘnj��ǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǙǘǐǏǕNJǨ

��� ƶǒǗǒǖǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ

ƶǘǒ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜ�ǖǒǗǒǖǝǖ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥǟ�ǎǕǩ�ǖǘǒǟ�ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǥǟ�Ǘǝǐǎ

��� ƴNJǡǏǛǜnjǘ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ lj�ǘNjǗǘnjǕǩǨ�Ǜnjǘǒ�ǑNJǙǒǛǒ�ǙǘbǛǘNjǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǖǝ�ǐǏǕNJǗǒǨ

��� ƻǏǚnjǒǛ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǒbǔǘǖǙNJǔǜǗǘǛǜǦ

lj�ǎǘǕǐǏǗ�NjǥǜǦ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗ�njǛǏǖǒ�ǔǘǙǒǩǖǒ�njǛǏǟ�ǖǘǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘbǖǘǏǖǝ�ǑNJǙǚǘǛǝ��ǩ�ǖǘǍǝ�ǙǏǚǏǗǘǛǒǜǦ�ǒ�ǝǎNJǕǩǜǦ�Ǜnjǘǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�njǛǩǔǒǓ�ǚNJǑ��ǔǘǍǎNJ�ǙǘǐǏǕNJǨ�ǧǜǘǍǘ

��� ƻǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ lj�ǖǘǍǝ�ǎǘnjǏǚǩǜǦ�ǖǘǏǖǝ�ƻǏǚnjǒǛǝ�ǍNJǚNJǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�njǛǏ�ǝǡNJǛǜǗǒǔǒ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǥ��ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǘNjǣǒǖ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩǖ

��� ƺNJǑǚǏǢǏǗǒǏ�ǛǙǘǚǘnj

ƯǛǕǒ�njǘǑǗǒǔǕNJ�ǛǙǘǚǗNJǩ�ǛǒǜǝNJǠǒǩ��ǩ�ǖǘǍǝ�ǘNjǚNJǜǒǜǛǩ�ǔ�ƼǚǏǜǦǏǓ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǏ�ǎǕǩ�ǚNJǑǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǛǙǘǚNJ

��� ƸǛǘNjǥǏ�ǘNjǛǜǘǩǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ

lj�ǑǗNJǨ��ǡǜǘ�njǛǩǔǘǏ�ǒǛǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǏ�ǎǘǕǐǗǘ�NjǥǜǦ�ǘǎǘNjǚǏǗǘ�ƹNJǚǕNJǖǏǗǜǘǖ�ǒ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǙǚǏǎǖǏǜǘǖ�ǗǏǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǍǘ�ǗNJǎǑǘǚNJ

�� +HUOLK\Ɋ3�Ɋ*RYHUQPHQW�DV�D�GDWD�PRGHOȇ��ZKDW�Ζ�OHDUQHG�LQ�(VWRQLD����85/��KWWSV���JGV�EORJ�JRY�XN������������JRYHUQPHQW�DV�D�GDWD�PRGHO�ZKDW�L�OHDUQHG�LQ�HVWRQLD��� KWWSV���ZZZ�JRY�XN�JRYHUQPHQW�XSORDGV�V\VWHP�XSORDGV�DWWDFKPHQWBGDWD�ILOH��������3&$*BΖ'$B3ULQFLSOHVB���BB�B�SGI

75ƬƯƵƲƴƸƫƺƲƼƪƷƲlj

Page 77: User identification analysis

Ƭ�ǘǙǒǛNJǗǒǒ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ�ǘǜǖǏǡNJǏǜǛǩ�� ǡǜǘ� ǔǘǗǠǏǙǠǒǩ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǍǘ�Ǚǚǘ-ǏǔǜNJ�ǙǘǎǘNjǗNJ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎǝ��ǙǚǒǗǩǜǘǖǝ�nj�ƻǂƪ��ǍǎǏ�ǔNJǐǎNJǩ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǩ�njǏǎǏǜ�ǛnjǘǨ�ǛǘNjǛǜnjǏǗǗǝǨ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔǝ�ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��Ǘǘ�Ǚǚǒ� ǧǜǘǖ� ǚǝǔǘnjǘǎǛǜnjǝǏǜǛǩ� ǘǜǚNJǛǕǏnjǥǖǒ� ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩǖǒ�� ƴNJǐǎNJǩ� ǔǘǖ-ǙNJǗǒǩ�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�ǙǚǘǎǏǖǘǗǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�ǘǗNJ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǚǝǔǘnjǘǎ-ǛǜnjǝǏǜǛǩ�ƹǚǒǗǠǒǙNJǖǒ�ƭNJǚNJǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJ-Ǡǒǒ�Ǜnjǘǒǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj��ƼNJǔǒǏ�Ǟǒǚǖǥ�ǘNjǩǑNJǗǥ�ǛǘǍǕNJǛǘnjNJǜǦ�Ǜnjǘǒ�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǒ�ǛnjǘǨ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔǝ�ǙǚNJǓnjǏǛǒ�Ǜ�ƻǏǔǚǏǜNJǚǒNJǜǘǖ�ǔNJ-NjǒǗǏǜNJ�ǖǒǗǒǛǜǚǘnj�ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǒ��ǙǚǏǐǎǏ�ǡǏǖ�ǘǗǒ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǘNjǚNJǜǒǜǦǛǩ�ǔ�ǝǡNJǛǜǒǨ�nj�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǏ�m*29�8.�9HULI\}�

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǖǏǚǥm*29�8.� 9(5Ζ)<}� ƷƯ� ljƬƵljƯƼƻlj� ƲƱƸƵƲƺƸƬƪƷƷDžƶ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘǖbȃ� ǧǜǘ� ǛǙǘǛǘNj��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǖ� ǕǨǎǒ� ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ� ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǎǒǜǦ� ǜǘǐǎǏǛǜnjǘ� ǛnjǘǏǓ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�� ǔǘǍǎNJ� ǘǗǒ� ǙǘǕǝǡNJǨǜ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙ� ǔ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ��ƫǏǜNJ�njǏǚǛǒǩ� ǑNJǙǝǣǏǗNJ� Ǜ�ǞǏnjǚNJǕǩ� ������ ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ� ǜǏǛǜǒǚǘnjNJǕNJǛǦ� Ǜ� Ǚǘ-ǖǘǣǦǨ�ǑNJǚNJǗǏǏ�ǘǜǘNjǚNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�nj�ǜǚǏǟ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǛǕǝǐNjNJǟ�

ƺNJNjǘǜNJ�njǏǕNJǛǦ�ǙǘbǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǖ�ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩǖ�• ƻǏǚnjǒǛ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǒ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�Ǜ�ǠǏǕǦǨ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǒǜǦ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒ-

ǘǗǗǥǖ�ƹǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJǖ��LGHQWLW\�SURYLGHUV��ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǩǜǦ�njǘǎǒǜǏǕǦ-ǛǔǘǏ�ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǒǕǒ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�

• ƫǥǕNJ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǗNJ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖNJ�ǙǚǏǎnjNJǚǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ�ǎNJǗ-Ǘǥǟ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǖ�njǥNjǚNJǜǦ�Ζ'�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJ�

• ƫǥǕNJ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗNJ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NJǔǔǚǏǎǒǜNJǠǒǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�Ǜǘ�njǛǏǖǒ�ǙǚNJ-njǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚNJǖǒ��ƹǚǘǏǔǜ�njǥǙǘǕǗǩǏǜ�njǛǏ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒ-ǖǥǏ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�njǛǏǟ�ǖǏǐnjǏǎǘǖǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�ǜNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǘǗǒ�Ǎǘǜǘnjǥ�ǔ�ǙǝNjǕǒǡǗǘǖǝ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǝ�

• ƫǥǕ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗ�ǙǏǚnjǥǓ� Ζ'�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚ��ǔNJǔ�ǝǎǘnjǕǏǜnjǘǚǩǨ-ǣǒǓ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJǖ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǕǨǎǏǓ���ƴ�ǔǘǗǠǝ�ǍǘǎNJ�ǑNJǙǕNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǘ���ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJ���ƿNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǔNJǐǎǥǓ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓ-ǎǏǚ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǛnjǘǓ�ǗNJNjǘǚ�ǖǏǜǘǎǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

ƮǕǩ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�NjǏǜNJ�njǏǚǛǒǒ�m*29�8.�9HULI\}�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗǝ�ǙǘǜǚǏ-NjǝǏǜǛǩ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜ�ǒǕǒ�njǘǎǒǜǏǕǦǛǔǘǏ�ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǏ�Ǜ�ǞǘǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǏǓ��NJbǜNJǔ-ǐǏ�ǙǚǘǩnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǘǓ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ�nj�ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǒ�nj�ǜǏǡǏǗǒǏ�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǘǍǘ�njǚǏǖǏǗǒ��ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǚNJǑnjǒnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǜNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǡǜǘ��nj�ǔǘǗǏǡǗǘǖ�ǛǡǏǜǏ��ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǛnjǘǨ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǛǖǘǍǝǜ�ǎNJǐǏ�ǜǏ��ǝ� ǔǘǍǘ� ǗǏǜ� ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ� ǒ� njǘǎǒǜǏǕǦǛǔǘǍǘ� ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ�� ƫǝǎǝǜ� njnjǏǎǏǗǥ�

76 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 78: User identification analysis

NJǕǦǜǏǚǗNJǜǒnjǗǥǏ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜǥ��ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NjǥǕNJ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗNJ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�Njǥ-Ǜǜǚǘbȃ�ǙǚǒǖǏǚǗǘ�ǑNJ�Ǎǘǎ���

ƴǕǨǡǏnjǥǖ� ǧǕǏǖǏǗǜǘǖ� ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǓ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�mƹǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǏ� ǒ� njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ}� �Ζ39��� ƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ� ǒ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǏ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǥ�ǔǘǚǚǏǕǒǚǝǨǜ��Ǘǘ�ǗǏ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��Ƭ�ǜNJNjǕǒǠǏ�ǗǒǐǏ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǘ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǏ�ǔ�Ǚǚǘǡǒǖ�Ζ39�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJǖ�

*3*��� 56'236 6725.���� 29115:2011 Ζ62������ 1Ζ67�������

1�$ /HYHO��� 1�$ 1�$ 1�$�1�$

/HYHO�� /HYHO�� 4$$�/HYHO�� /R$�� /R$�� /HYHO��

/HYHO�� /HYHO�� 4$$�/HYHO�� /R$�� /R$�� /HYHO��

/HYHO�� /HYHO�� 4$$�/HYHO�� /R$�� /R$�� /HYHO��

/HYHO�� 1�$ 4$$�/HYHO�� /R$�� /R$�� /HYHO��

ƸǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ�ǙǘǗǩǜǒǩ�Ζ39���• ƱNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǦb ȃ� ǜǘǜ�� ǔǜǘ� ǑNJǩnjǕǩǏǜ� ǘ� ǛnjǘǏǓ� ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ� Ǜ� ǠǏǕǦǨ� ǏǪ�

ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�• ƱNJǩnjǕǏǗǗNJǩ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦbȃ�ǗNJNjǘǚ�ǑNJǩnjǕǩǏǖǥǟ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘnj�• ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǥbȃ�ǒǖǩ�ǒ�ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjǘ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǛnjǘǓǛǜnj��ǛǙǘǛǘNj-

Ǘǥǟ�ǎǘǔNJǑNJǜǦ�ǜǘǐǎǏǛǜnjǘ�ƱNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǩ�ǒ�ƱNJǩnjǕǏǗǗǘǓ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�• ƬǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒbȃ� ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ� ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǩ� ǕǒǡǗǘ-

Ǜǜǒ�ǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�• ƲǎǏǗǜǒǡǗǘǛǜǦbȃ�ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǘǏ�ǒǖǩ��NJ�NjǘǕǏǏ�NJNjǛǜǚNJǔǜǗǘbȃ�ǖǗǘ-

ǐǏǛǜnjǘ�ǛǘǍǕNJǛǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�ǎǚǝǍ�Ǜ�ǎǚǝǍǘǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘnj��ƻǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�nj�njǒǎǝ��ǡǜǘ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǘNjǕNJǎNJǏǜ�ǎnjǝǖǩ�njNJǐǗǥǖǒ�ǛnjǘǓ-ǛǜnjNJǖǒ��ǘǗNJ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǞNJǕǦǛǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǝǔǚNJǎǏǗNJ�

• ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ� ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚb ȃ� ǞǒǚǖNJ�� ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗ-ǗNJǩ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǘǖ�� ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǨǣNJǩ� njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ� ǖǏǚǘ-Ǚǚǒǩǜǒǩ�ǙǘbǛǘǍǕNJǢǏǗǒǨ�Ǜ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǖǒ� �ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǒ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǖǒ�bȃ�njǏǎǘǖǛǜnjNJǖǒ��ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJǖǒ�ǒbǜ�ɋǙ�bƹǘǕǦǑǘ-

njNJǜǏǕǦbȃ� ǕǒǠǘ�� ǛǜǚǏǖǩǣǏǏǛǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ� ǛǏNjǩ� Ǜ� Ǚǘǖǘ-ǣǦǨ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�

• ƬǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�� ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǗNJǩ� ǗNJ� ǛǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǖ� ǑǗNJǗǒǒ�� �6WDWLF�.QRZOHGJH�%DVHG�9HULȴFDWLRQ���ƸǛǗǘnjNJǗNJ�ǗNJ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǛǏǔǚǏǜ-

�� KWWSV���LGHQWLW\DVVXUDQFH�EORJ�JRY�XN������������JRY�XN�YHULI\�SXEOLF�EHWD��� KWWSV���ZZZ�JRY�XN�JRYHUQPHQW�XSORDGV�V\VWHP�XSORDGV�DWWDFKPHQWBGDWD�ILOH��������*3*B��BLGHQWLW\BSURRILQJBY�B�B-XO\B�����SGI

77ƬƯƵƲƴƸƫƺƲƼƪƷƲlj

Page 79: User identification analysis

Ǘǥǟ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJǟ��ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǏǗǗǘǛǜǦ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǖ�ǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘǖ�

• ƬǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ��ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǗNJǩ�ǗNJ�ǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǖ�ǑǗNJǗǒǒ� (Dynamic

.QRZOHGJH�%DVHG�9HULȴFDWLRQ���ƸǛǗǘnjNJǗNJ�ǗNJ�ǛNjǘǚǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-ǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘǖ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏ-ǕǏ�ǒ�ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǏǪ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǨ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǒ��ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦ-Ǘǘb Ǖǒ� ǘǗ� ǏǓ� njǕNJǎǏǏǜ�� ƮǕǩ� ǧǜǒǟ� Ǘǝǐǎ�ǖǘǐǏǜ� NjǥǜǦ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗNJ�ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎNJ��Ƭ�ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǘǜ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ-Ǎǘ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�ǗNJǎǏǐǗǘǛǜǒ�njǥǎǏǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ�ǚNJǗǍǒ�

ȃ ��ƷǏnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǘǎǏǖǘǗǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǒǛǜǘǚǒǨ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ� ȃ ��ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ�ǗǏ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ� ȃ ��ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ�ǔNJǔ�ǖǒǗǒǖǝǖ�ǑNJ�����ǔNJǕǏǗǎNJǚǗǥǟ�ǎǗǏǓ� ȃ ��ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ�ǔNJǔ�ǖǒǗǒǖǝǖ�ǑNJ���������ǔNJǕǏǗǎNJǚǗǥǟ�ǎǗǏǓ�

ȃ ��ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ�ǔNJǔ�ǖǒǗǒǖǝǖ�ǑNJ����������ǔNJǕǏǗǎNJǚǗǥǟ�ǎǗǏǓ�

• ƾǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǘǏ�ǛǚNJnjǗǏǗǒǏ��ƸǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǘ�ǙǘǎǍǘǜǘnj-ǕǏǗǗǥǖǒ� ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔNJǖǒ� njǒǑǝNJǕǦǗǘ� Ǚǚǒ� ǕǒǡǗǘǓ� njǛǜǚǏǡǏ� ǕǒNjǘ�ǝǎNJǕǪǗǗǘ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�njǒǎǏǘǛnjǩǑǒ�

• ƫǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǏ� ǛǚNJnjǗǏǗǒǏ�� ƵǨNjǥǏ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ� ǙǘǔNJǑNJ-ǜǏǕǒ��ǑNJǙǒǛNJǗǗǥǏ�nj�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ�Ǜǘ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJǖǒ�Ζ&$2������ǒǕǒ�Ζ62�Ζ(&�������

• ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǥ��njǥNjǘǚǘǡǗǘ�� ȃ ƪǔǔNJǝǗǜ�ǗNJ�ǍǘǚǘǎǛǔǘǓ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗ ȃ ƪǔǔNJǝǗǜ�ǗNJ�ǛǗNJNjǐǏǗǒǏ�ǍNJǑǘǖ ȃ ƪǔǔNJǝǗǜ�ǗNJ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǛǗNJNjǐǏǗǒǏ ȃ ƹǘǕǒǠǏǓǛǔǘǏ�ǙǘǚǝǡǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ ȃ ƸǟǘǜǗǒǡǒǓ�NjǒǕǏǜ ȃ ƻnjǒǎǏǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ǘ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǒ ȃ ƻnjǒǎǏǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ǘNj�ǝǛǥǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǒ ȃ ƻǘǍǕNJǢǏǗǒǏ�ǘNj�NJǚǏǗǎǏ�ǐǒǕǘǓ�ǙǕǘǣNJǎǒ ȃ ƴNJǚǜǘǡǔNJ��ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǨǣNJǩ�njǘǑǚNJǛǜ ȃ ƹǘǕǒǠǏǓǛǔNJǩ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔNJ ȃ ƶǏǎǒǠǒǗǛǔNJǩ�ǔNJǚǜNJ ȃ ƻnjǒǎǏǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ǘ�njǛǜǝǙǕǏǗǒǒ�nj�NjǚNJǔ ȃ Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜNJ�njǘǏǗǗǘǛǕǝǐNJǣǏǍǘ ȃ ƴNJǚǜǘǡǔNJ�ǎǕǩ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjNJǗǒǩ�nj�ƻǏnjǏǚǗǘǓ�ƲǚǕNJǗǎǒǒ ȃ ƴNJǚǜǘǡǔNJ�ǡǕǏǗNJ�ǎǘNjǚǘnjǘǕǦǗǘǓ�ǙǘǐNJǚǗǘǓ�ǎǚǝǐǒǗǥ

78 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 80: User identification analysis

ȃ ƮǘǍǘnjǘǚǥ�ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjNJǗǒǩ ȃ ƫNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǒǏ�ǛǡǏǜNJ

ƹǚǘǠǏǛǛ�njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗ�ǗNJ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǟ�ǔǕǨǡǏnjǥǟ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙNJǟ�• ƹǚǘǠǏǛǛ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǘǕǐǏǗ�NjǥǜǦ�ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǏǗ�• ƲǗǎǒnjǒǎ�ǎǘǕǐǏǗ�ǑNJǩnjǒǜǦ�ǘ�ǛnjǘǏǓ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�nj�ǙǚǩǖǘǓ�ǒ�ǗǏǎnjǝǛ-

ǖǥǛǕǏǗǗǘǓ�ǞǘǚǖǏ�• ƸNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǏ�ǎǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJǖǒ�ǛnjǘǏǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǕǏǐǒǜ�ǗNJ�

ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎǏ�• ƮǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�NjǥǜǦ�ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘ�ǘǠǏǗǏǗǥ�ǗNJ�njNJǕǒǎǗǘǛǜǦ�

ǒ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǘǎǕǒǗǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒ�ǙǚǒǗNJǎǕǏǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǘǖǝ�ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎǝ�• ƷǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǘǡǗǥǏ�ǖǏǚǘǙǚǒǩǜǒǩ��ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǗǥǏ�ǗNJ�njǥ-

ǩǛǗǏǗǒǏ� ǜǘǍǘ�� ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘb Ǖǒ� ǘNjǤǏǔǜ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǛǝǣǏ-ǛǜnjǝǏǜ�nj�ǚǏNJǕǦǗǘǖ�ǖǒǚǏ�

• ƸNjǤǏǖ�ǒ�ǍǕǝNjǒǗNJ�ǎǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnj�ǒ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǘǡǗǥǟ�ǖǏǚǘǙǚǒǩǜǒǓ�ǑNJ-njǒǛǩǜ�ǘǜ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�ǝnjǏǚǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ��ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǍǘ�ǎǕǩ�ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǩ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǚǏNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�Ǚǚǒ-ǗNJǎǕǏǐǒǜ�ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎǝ�

ƻǜNJǎǒǒ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛNJ���� Ƹǜ� ǑNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǩ� ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ� ǑNJǩnjǒǜǦ� ǛnjǘǏ� ǒǖǩ�� ǎNJǜǝ� ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǩ� ǒ�

NJǎǚǏǛ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǘǗ�ǐǏǕNJǏǜ�ǝǔNJǑNJǜǦ�ǙǘbǛnjǘǏǖǝ�ǝǛǖǘǜǚǏǗǒǨ���� ƱNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǦ�ǎǘǕǐǏǗ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǒǜǦ�ƮǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ��ǡǜǘ�ƱNJǩnjǕǏǗ-

ǗNJǩ�ƵǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ��LJǜǘ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǛǎǏ-ǕNJǗǘ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǖ�ǒǕǒ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǖ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjǘǖ�

��� ƹǚǘnjǏǚǔNJ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǗǥǟ�ǎǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnj���� ƬǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ƱNJǩnjǕǏǗǗǘǓ�ƵǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ��ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘbǕǒ�ǘǗNJ�ǘǜ-

ǗǘǛǒǜǛǩ�ǔ�ƱNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǨ���� ƱNJǩnjǕǏǗǗNJǩ�ƵǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�NjǥǜǦ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǏǗNJ�ǗNJ�ǙǚǏǎǖǏǜ��Ǜǝ-

ǣǏǛǜnjǘnjNJǕNJbǕǒ�ǘǗNJ�nj�ǚǏNJǕǦǗǘǖ�ǖǒǚǏ�nj�ǑNJǩnjǕǏǗǗǥǓ�ǙǏǚǒǘǎ�njǚǏ-ǖǏǗǒ��ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�ƮǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ��

��� ƱNJǩnjǕǏǗǗNJǩ�ƵǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�NjǥǜǦ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǏǗNJ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǖǒ�NJǗ-ǜǒǖǘǢǏǗǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖǒ�ǗNJ�ǙǚǏǎǖǏǜ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǗǏ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩbǕǒ�ǧǜNJ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǞǒǔǜǒnjǗǘǓ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�Ǜ�ǠǏǕǦǨ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎǘnj��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ� ǛǜNJǕǒ� ǐǏǚǜnjǘǓ� ǔǚNJǐǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ƪǗǜǒǖǘǢǏǗǗǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ƹǚǘnjǏǚǔNJ��

��� Ƭ� ǔǘǗǠǏ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛNJ�ǙǚǘǒǛǟǘǎǒǜ�ƽǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǒǏ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�� ǔǘǜǘ-ǚǘǏ�ǘǙǒǛǥnjNJǏǜ�ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ�ǝnjǏǚǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǡǜǘ�ƱNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǦ�ǎǏǓ-ǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠǏǖ�ƱNJǩnjǕǏǗǗǘǓ�ƵǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ�ǡǜǘ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǗǘǛǒǜ�ǙǘǎǕǒǗǗǥǓ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚ�

79ƬƯƵƲƴƸƫƺƲƼƪƷƲlj

Page 81: User identification analysis

ƹǚǏǎǝǛǖǘǜǚǏǗǘ� �� ǝǚǘnjǗǩ� ǝnjǏǚǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�� ǡǜǘ� ƱNJǩnjǕǏǗǗNJǩ� ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ƱNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǨ�

��� ƷǏ� ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǩǏǜ� ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ� ǔ� ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ� ƱNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǩ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ� NjǥǜǦ� ǎǘǔNJǑNJǗǥ�� ƱNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǦ� ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ� ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǜǘǚ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ� ǖǘǐǏǜ� ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǒǜǦ� ǏǍǘ� nj� ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ� ƱNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǩ��ƸǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔNJ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǡǜǘ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǒ-ǚǝǏǜǛǩ�ƱNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǏǖ�

��� ƱNJǩnjǕǏǗǗNJǩ�ƵǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�Ǜ�ǎǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJǖǒ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǙǘǎǔǚǏǙǕǩ-Ǩǜ�ǚǏNJǕǦǗǘǏ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǘǏ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ��ƷǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖNJ�ǝnjǏǚǏǗǗǘǛǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǛǘǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǛǩ�Ǜ�ǚǏ-NJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǒ�ǡǜǘ�ƱNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǦ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠǏǖ�ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�� ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ� ǖǘǐǏǜ� NjǥǜǦ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗNJ� ǎǕǩ� ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔǒ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǥǟ�NJǔǜǘnj�

��� ƻǘǎǏǚǐNJǗǒǏ�NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǗǘ�ƽǚǘnjǗǨ����ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǠǒǚǝǏǜ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǎǕǩ�Ǘǝǐǎ� ǝǍǘǕǘnjǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛNJ�

��� ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ� ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ� ǛǙǏǠǒǞǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚ��njǔǕǨǡNJǩ�ƫǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǨ��ǎǕǩ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǘǜ�ǞNJNjǚǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǔǚNJǐǒ�ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ��ƮǕǩ�ǛǏǔǚǏǜǘǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǏǓ�ǒǕǒ�nj�ǛǒǜǝNJǠǒǩǟ��nj�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǖǘ-ǐǏǜ�njǘǑǗǒǔǗǝǜǦ�ǝǍǚǘǑNJ�ǐǒǑǗǒ�

LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩƲƻƻƵƯƮƸƬƪƷƲƯ�� ƹƺƸƬƯƮƯƷƷƸƯ�ƶƬƮ� ƬƯƵƲƴƸƫƺƲƼƪƷƲƲ�� ǍǕNJǛǒǕǘ�� ǡǜǘ� nj� ǡNJǛǜ-Ǘǘǖ�ǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǖ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚNJǟ�njnjǏǎǏǗǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ�ǙǚǒǗǏǛǏǜ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǖǝ�ǟǘǑǩǓǛǜnjǝ�ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǨ�nj�ǚNJǑǖǏǚǏ�ǘǜ����bǖǒǕ-ǕǒǘǗǘnj�ǎǘ�����ǖǒǕǕǒNJǚǎNJ�ǞǝǗǜǘnj�nj�Ǎǘǎ��ǗǏ�Ǎǘnjǘǚǩ�ǝǐǏ�ǘ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǜǚǝǎǗǘ�ǒǛǡǒǛǕǩǏǖǥǟ�njǥǍǘǎNJǟ�ǒ�njǘǘNjǣǏ�ǗǏǒǛǡǒǛǕǩǏǖǥǟ�NjǕNJǍNJǟ��ǔNJǔ�ǛǗǒǐǏǗǒǏ�ǛǜǏǙǏǗǒ�ǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǘǜ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǓ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ�ǜǏǚ-ǚǘǚǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǍǚǝǙǙ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑǘnjNJǗ�ǗǏ�NjǥǕ��ǧǜǒ� ǘǠǏǗǔǒ� ǘǛǜNJǕǒǛǦ� ǗǏǛNjǥnjǢǒǖǒǛǩ� ǙǚǘǍǗǘǑNJǖǒ�� Ƭ� ǕǨNjǘǖ� ǛǕǝǡNJǏ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǨ�ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǜǦ�ǛǔǚǘǖǗǘǓ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜ�ǛNJǖ�ǙǘbǛǏNjǏ�NjǥǕ� ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ� ǎǘǚǘǍǘǛǜǘǩǣǒǖ�� ǒ� nj� ǙǏǚnjǝǨ� ǘǡǏǚǏǎǦ� ǙǚǏǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǕ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǏ� njǘǙǚǘǛǘnj� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ� ǒ� ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��NJ�ǗǏ�ǠǏǕǒ�ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�njǥǍǘǎǥ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǗǘǛǒǕǒ�ǛǔǘǚǏǏ�NJǚǍǝǖǏǗǜNJ-ǜǒnjǗǥǓ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚ��LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǝǨ�njǥǍǘǎǝ�ǘǜ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǩ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ�m*29�8.�9HULI\}�ǘǠǏǗǒǜǦ�ǛǕǘǐǗǘ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜ�ǗNJ�ǎNJǗǗǘǓ�ǛǜNJǎǒǒ�ǙǚǏ-NjǥnjNJǏǜ�nj�NjǏǜNJ�njǏǚǛǒǒ�ǒ�ǐǎNJǜǦ�ǏǍǘ�ǙǘǕǗǘǠǏǗǗǘǓ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�Ǜǜǘǒǜ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ�

80 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 82: User identification analysis

ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒ�ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ��ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ��nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒƪƶƫƲǀƲƸƱƷDžƳ�� ƷƸ� ƼƸƺƹƯƮƲƺƸƬƪƷƷDžƳ� ƵƯƳƫƸƺƲƻƼƪƶƲ� NjǚǒǜNJǗǛǔǒǓ� ǙǚǘǏǔǜ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ƺǏǏǛǜǚNJ�ǒ�ǙǚǒnjǩǑNJǗ-Ǘǥǟ�ǔ�Ǘǒǖ�ǔNJǚǜ�ǑNJǛǕǝǐǒnjNJǏǜ�ǙǚǒǛǜNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�njǗǒǖNJǗǒǩ��ƻǝǎǩ�ǙǘbnjǛǏǖǝ��ǧǜǘ�NjǥǕ�ǏǎǒǗǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǓ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�NjǥǕ�ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗ�ǗNJ�ǔNJǚǎǒǗNJǕǦǗǘǏ�ǒ� ǔǘǖǙǕǏǔǛǗǘǏ� ǚǏǢǏǗǒǏ� njǘǙǚǘǛǘnj� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ� ǒ� ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��ƮǕǩ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ��ǛǜǚNJǗǥ��ǛǜNJǕǔǒnjNJǨǣǏǓǛǩ�Ǜ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖǒ�njǥǑǘnjNJǖǒ�nj�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��ǧǜǘǜ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜ��njǗǏ�njǛǩǔǘǍǘ�ǛǘǖǗǏǗǒǩ��ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�njǏǛǦǖNJ�ǙǚǒnjǕǏǔNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǒ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑǝǏǖǥǖ�Ǜ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ�ǘǜǏ�ǡǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǔǝǕǦǜǝǚǥ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�ǘǛǜǚǘǓ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ�nj�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǒ� ǐǏǛǜǔǘǓ� ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǙǏǚǏnjǘǎNJ� njǛǏǟ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ� ǗNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǔNJǚǜǘǡǔǒ��ǝǡǒǜǥnjNJǩ�ǛǙǏǠǒǞǒǔǝ�ǙǚǒǚǘǎǗǘ�ǍǏǘǍǚNJ-ǞǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǓ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ��ǗǏǜ��ƴNJǔ�ǘǜǖǏǡNJǨǜ�NjǚǒǜNJǗǛǔǒǏ�ǔǚǒǜǒǔǒ�ǧǛǜǘǗ-ǛǔǘǍǘ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ��ǘǗ�ǘǔNJǑNJǕǛǩ�ǝǛǙǏǢǗǥǖ�njǘ�ǖǗǘǍǘǖ�NjǕNJǍǘǎNJǚǩ�ǜǘǖǝ��ǡǜǘ�ǗNJǛǏǕǏǗǒǏ�LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ�ǔǚǘǟǘǜǗǘbȃ���ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ�ǒ�ǙǚǘǐǒnjNJǏǜ�ǘǡǏǗǦ�ǔǘǖǙNJǔǜǗǘ�nj�ǙǚǏǎǏǕNJǟ�ǎǘǛǩǍNJǏǖǘǛǜǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǓ��ƮNJǐǏ�nj�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩǟ�ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǒ�ǎNJǕǏǔǘ�ǗǏ�njǛǏ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǏ�ǒǖǏǕǒbNjǥ�njǘǑǖǘǐ-ǗǘǛǜǦ� ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ� ǠǒǞǚǘnjǥǖǒ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǩǖǒ� Ǘǘnjǥǟ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ��NjǘǕǏǏ�ǜǘǍǘbȃ�ǛǜǘǕǔǗǝǕǒǛǦbNjǥ�Ǜ�ǜǚǝǎǗǘǛǜǩǖǒ�njǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǏ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǘNjǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǙǚǘǙǒǛNJǗǗǥǟ�nj�ǗǏǓ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǜǘnj�ǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ƹǚǘǏǔǜ�m*29�8.�9HULI\}�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǑNJǛǕǝǐǒnjNJǨǣǒǖ�njǗǒ-ǖNJǗǒǩ�Ǜ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ�ǙǚǘǚNJNjǘǜNJǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��Ǘǘ�ǘǗ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǏǜ�njǥǙǝǛǔNJ�Ζ'�ǔNJǚǜ��ƹǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǥǖ�ǑNJǒǖǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǏ�NjǚǒǜNJǗǛǔǘǍǘ�ǘǙǥǜNJ�nj�ǡNJǛǜǒ�njǥǛǘǔǒǟ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�NjǏǑǘ-ǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǘbNJǗNJǕǘǍǒǒ�Ǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘǖ�Ζ39�nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ�m*29�8.�9HULI\}�

LjǐǗNJǩ�ƴǘǚǏǩ

ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJƷƯƻƶƸƼƺlj� Ʒƪ� ƮƯƴƵƪƺƲƺƽƯƶƽLj� ƹƺƲƬƯƺưƯƷƷƸƻƼdž� ǎǏǖǘǔǚNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǖ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒ-ǙNJǖ�� ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗNJǩ� ǡNJǛǜǦ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ� ƴǘǚǏǒ�� ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘ� nj� ǡNJǛǜǒ�ǙǚNJnjNJ�ǗNJ�ǛNJǖǘnjǥǚNJǐǏǗǒǏ��ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ƻƶƲ��ǒǑNjǒǚNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚNJnjNJ��ǗǘǛǒǜ�ǗNJ�ǛǏNjǏ�njǕǒǩǗǒǏ�ǙǚǏǎǥǎǝǣǏǓ��NJnjǜǘǚǒǜNJǚǗǘǓ��ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��ǛǕǘǐǒnj-ǢǏǓǛǩ�nj�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩǟ�ǙǘǛǜǘǩǗǗǘǓ�ǔǘǗǞǚǘǗǜNJǠǒǒ�Ǜ�ƴƷƮƺ��ƼNJǔ�nj������Ǎ��nj�ǚǏǛ�ǙǝNjǕǒǔǏ� ƴǘǚǏǩ� NjǥǕNJ� njnjǏǎǏǗNJ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�5HVLGHQW� 5HJLVWUDWLRQ�1XPEHU�

81LjưƷƪlj�ƴƸƺƯlj

Page 83: User identification analysis

�551�b ȃ� ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǓ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ� ǛǜǚNJǗǥ� ǒ� ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜ-ǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǓ�Ǐǖǝ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜ�nj�ǞǘǚǖǏ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�� ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǣǒǓ�ǏǍǘ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦ-ǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ��ǎNJǜNJ�ǒ�ǖǏǛǜǘ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǩ��ǙǘǕ���NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǒ�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ��ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ�551�NjǥǕNJ�njnjǏǎǏǗNJ�ƱNJǔǘǗǘǖ�ǘ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǍǚNJǐ-ǎNJǗ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ�ǙǘǛǕǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǔNJǔ�ǛǏnjǏǚǘǔǘǚǏǓǛǔǒǏ�ǎǒnjǏǚǛNJǗǜǥ�ǙǚǘnjǏǕǒ�ǝǛǙǏǢǗǘǏ�ǗNJǙNJǎǏǗǒǏ�ǗNJ�ǙǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǛǔǝǨ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǠǒǨ�nj�ƻǏǝǕǏ��Ǜ�ǠǏǕǦǨ�njǥǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǥǟ�NJǍǏǗǜǘnj�nj�NjǝǎǝǣǏǖ��ƹǘǎǎǏǕǔNJ�551�ǗNJǔNJǑǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ�ǜǨǚǏǖǗǥǖ�Ǜǚǘǔǘǖ�ǎǘ��bǕǏǜ�ǒǕǒ�ǢǜǚNJǞǘǖ�ǘǔǘǕǘ�����ǜǥǛ��ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�Ǚǘ-ǙǚNJnjǔNJǖ�ǘǜ�����bǍǘǎNJ�

Ƭ�ǔǘǗǠǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ��ǗǏ�ǎǘǐǒǎNJǩǛǦ�njnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǘǍǘ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚ-ǜNJ�ǢǒǞǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ�66/�����ELW��5)&��������nj�ƴǘǚǏǏ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǕǒ�ǛǘNjǛǜnjǏǗǗǝǨ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǨ�ǢǒǞǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�6(('��ǙǏǚnjǘǗNJǡNJǕǦǗǘ�ǗNJǠǏǕǏǗ-ǗǝǨ�ǗNJ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǦ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǏǓ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��ƼǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǔ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǚǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǏǓ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ�NjǥǕǘ�ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǏǗǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǘ��Ƭ�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǘǓ�Ǚǘǎ-ǙǒǛǒ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ�NjǥǕ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗ�ǏǍǘ�551��Ƭ� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ�NjǥǕǒ� ǜNJǔbǐǏ�ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǥ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnj�Ǚǚǒ�Ǚǘ-ǖǘǣǒ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ��ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ�6(('�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǏǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǥǟ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘnj��njǥǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǘǎǗǒǖ�ǒǑ�NJǔǔǚǏǎǒǜǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�NJǍǏǗǜǛǜnj��ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗǝ�ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǏ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜNJ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ�ǜǘǕǦ-ǔǘ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǘǔǝǙǘǔ�ǎǘǚǘǐǏ�����ǜǥǛ�njǘǗ���������ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�NjNJǗǔǒ�ǒ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗǥǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��ǔNJǔ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕǘ��ǜǚǏNjǝǨǜ�njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�Ǚǚǒ�ǕǨNjǘǓ�ǜǚNJǗǑNJǔǠǒǒ�

Ƭ�����bǍǘǎǝ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjǘ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ƴǘǚǏǒ�ǘNjǤǩnjǒǕǘ�ǘ�ǔǘǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǒ�Ǜ�ǔǚǝǙǗǏǓǢǒǖǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕNJǖǒ�ǛǜǚNJǗǥ��<DKRR�.RUHD��'DXP�&RPPXQLFDWLRQV��1+1��1HR:L]��ǎǕǩ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǚǏNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǒǖǏǗ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ� Ǜ� ǠǏǕǦǨ� NjǘǚǦNjǥ� Ǜ� ǔǒNjǏǚNjǝ-ǕǒǗǍǘǖ��ƷǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�Ǎǚǘǖǔǒǟ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏnj�ǛNJǖǘǝNjǒǓǛǜnj�ǎNJǕǒ�ǜǘǕǡǘǔ�ǎǕǩ�ǖNJǛ-ǢǜNJNjǗǘǓ�ǔNJǖǙNJǗǒǒ�nj�ǙǚǏǛǛǏ�nj�ǙǘǕǦǑǝ�ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǟ�ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǓ�

Ƭ� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ� nj� ǚNJǖǔNJǟ� ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǓ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ� ǘ� njǥNjǘǚNJǟ� ǘǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��ǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǣǒǟ�ǔǘǖǖǏǗǜNJǚǒǒ�ǔNJǛNJǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔǘnj�Ǚǘ-ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǕǒ� ǝǔNJǑǥnjNJǜǦ� Ǜnjǘǒ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǒǏ�ǒǖǏǗNJ�� ƴ� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ� ǧǜNJ� ǗǘǚǖNJ�ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǕNJǛǦ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǔ�Ǚǘǡǜǘnjǥǖ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ�ǒ�ǡNJǜNJǖ�ǟǚNJǗǒǜǦ�ǎǏ-ǜNJǕǦǗǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�ǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǟ��njǔǕǨǡNJǩ�ǒǖǩ��NJǎǚǏǛ��ǙǚǘǞǏǛ-ǛǒǨ�ǒ�551��Ƭ�����bǍǘǎǝ�ǧǜNJ�ǗǘǚǖNJ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǒǕNJǛǦ�ǗNJ�ǛNJǓǜǥ��ǙǘǑnjǘ-ǕǩǨǣǒǏ�ǑNJǍǚǝǐNJǜǦ�njǒǎǏǘ�ǒǕǒ�ǑnjǝǔǘnjǥǏ�ǞNJǓǕǥ�Ǜ�ǙǘǛǏǣNJǏǖǘǛǜǦǨ�NjǘǕǏǏ�����ǜǥǛǩǡ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǒ�ǗǘnjǘǛǜǗǥǏ�ǛNJǓǜǥ�Ǜ�ǙǘǛǏǣNJǏǖǘǛǜǦǨ�NjǘǕǏǏ������ǜǥǛǩǡ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��Ǚǘǎ�ǙǚǏǎǕǘǍǘǖ�NjǘǚǦNjǥ�Ǜ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǒ-Ǐǖ�ǕǘǐǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǔǕǏnjǏǜǥ��ǛǕǝǟǘnj�ǘ�ǑǗNJǖǏǗǒǜǘǛǜǩǟ�

82 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 84: User identification analysis

ƷNJǔǘǗǏǠ�� nj� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ� Ǚǘb ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǨ� .&&� �ǔǘǚǏǓǛǔǒǓ� ǚǏǍǝǕǩǜǘǚ�ǚǥǗǔNJ� ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǓ�� njǛǏ� Ǟǘǚǝǖǥ� ǒ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ� ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ� ǙǏǚǏǢǕǒ�ǗNJ� ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǨ� Ǚǘb ǚǏNJǕǦǗǘǖǝ� ǒǖǏǗǒ�� ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ� ǙǘǙǚNJnjǔNJǖ� ǔ� ǑNJǔǘǗǝ�ǘNj�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�njǛǏ�ǛNJǓǜǥ�Ǜ�ǙǘǛǏǣNJǏǖǘǛǜǦǨ�NjǘǕǏǏ�����ǜǥǛǩǡ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�nj�ǎǏǗǦ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�NjǥǕǒ�ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǜǦ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘ-njNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�551��LJǜǘ�njǥǑnjNJǕǘ�ǙǚǘǜǏǛǜ�ǖǗǘǍǒǟ�ǑNJǚǝNjǏǐǗǥǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj��ǜNJǔ�*RRJOH�ǘǜǔǕǨǡǒǕ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǑNJǍǚǝǑǔǒ�njǒǎǏǘ�ǒ�ǙǝNjǕǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǔǘǖ-ǖǏǗǜNJǚǒǏnj�ǗNJ�ǔǘǚǏǓǛǔǘǖ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕǏ�<RX7XEH��Ƭ�����bǍǘǎǝ�Ǚǘǎ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�ǙǘǎǙNJǎNJǕǒ����ǔǘǚǏǓǛǔǒǟ�ǛNJǓǜǘnj��nj������ȃ�����

Ƭ�����bǍǘǎǝ�NjǥǕǘ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜǘ�ǗǘnjǘǏ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ǘ�ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǎǏǜǏǓ��nj� ǚNJǖǔNJǟ� ǔǘǜǘǚǘǍǘ� NjǥǕǘ� njnjǏǎǏǗǘ� ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǏ�551� ǎǕǩ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ� ǔ� ǘǗ-ǕNJǓǗ�ǒǍǚNJǖ�nj�ǗǘǡǗǘǏ�njǚǏǖǩ��ǜNJǔ�ǗNJǑǥnjNJǏǖǥǓ�6KXWGRZQ�ODZ���ƮNJǗǗNJǩ�ǗǘǚǖNJ� ǙǘnjǕǏǔǕNJ� ǑNJ� ǛǘNjǘǓ� ǖNJǛǛǘnjǘǏ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ� ǡǝǐǒǟ� ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJ-ǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǗǘǖǏǚǘnj�ǒǍǚǘǔNJǖǒ�ǖǘǕǘǐǏ���bǕǏǜ��Ƭ�ǧǜǘǖbǐǏ�Ǎǘǎǝ��nj�ǚǏǑǝǕǦ-ǜNJǜǏ� ǟNJǔǏǚǛǔǘǓ� NJǜNJǔǒ� ǒǑ� ƴǒǜNJǩ�� ǙǚǘǒǑǘǢǕNJ� ǖNJǛǛǘnjNJǩ� ǝǜǏǡǔNJ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǔǚǝǙǗǏǓǢǏǓ� ǔǘǚǏǓǛǔǘǓ� ǜǏǕǏǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ� ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ� 6.� &RP-PXQLFDWLRQV��ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�&\ZRUOG���Ƭ�ǛǏǜǒ�ǘǔNJǑNJǕǒǛǦ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ��njǔǕǨǡNJǩ�551��ǙǚǒǖǏǚǗǘ���Ɍ��ǐǒǜǏǕǏǓ�LjǐǗǘǓ�ƴǘǚǏǒ��Ƭ�ǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǘnjNJnjǢǏǍǘ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǚǏǑǘǗNJǗǛNJ��nj�NJǙǚǏǕǏ�����b ǍǘǎNJ�.&&��ǔǘǖǒǛǛǒǩ�ǙǘbǞǒ-ǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǖ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ�ǒ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjǘ�njǗǝǜǚǏǗǗǒǟ�ǎǏǕ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǕǒ�Ǘǘ-njǥǏ� ǖǏǚǥ� ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�� ƻNJǓǜǥ� ǘNjǩǑNJǕǒ� ǛǜǏǚǏǜǦ� njǛǨ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�ǘNj�551�ǒ�nj�ǎNJǕǦǗǏǓǢǏǖ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǜǦ�ǏǪ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�nj�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǑNJǖǏǗǒǜǦ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǗNJ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǝǨ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦ�ǒǕǒ�L�3Ζ1��ǍǏǗǏǚǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ�NJǔǔǚǏǎǒǜǘnjNJǗǗǥǖǒ�NJǍǏǗǜǛǜnjNJǖǒ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǙǏǚǛǘ-ǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��

ƹǚNJnjǘnjǥǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjǥƮƯƳƻƼƬƽLjǃƲƳ�ƻƸ�ƬƺƯƶƯƷ�ƴƸƺƯƳƻƴƸƳ�ƬƸƳƷDž ƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�NjǏǑ-ǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǘǜ�����bǍǘǎNJ��ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǏǜ�ǜǨǚǏǖǗǘǏ�ǑNJǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǏ�Ǜǚǘǔǘǖ�ǎǘ��bǕǏǜ�ǑNJ�njǘǛǟnjNJǕǏǗǒǏ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǒǖǙNJǜǒǒ�ǔ�ƴƷƮƺ��Ƭ�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩǟ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒ-ǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjNJ�ǧǜǒ�Ǘǘǚǖǥ�ǛǔNJǜǥnjNJǨǜǛǩ�ǔ�ǙǚǏǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǨ�NjǕǘǍǏǚǘnj�ǑNJ�ǚǏǜnjǒǜ�����ǗǏǓǜǚNJǕǦǗǘ�ǙǘǕǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǗǘnjǘǛǜǒ�ǒǑ�ǛǏnjǏǚǘǔǘǚǏǓǛǔǒǟ�ǒǛǜǘǡǗǒǔǘnj��ƫǘǕǏǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��nj�����bǍǘǎǝ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjǘ�ǘNjǤǏǎǒǗǏǗǒǩ�ǚNJǑǤ-ǩǛǗǒǕǘ�� ǡǜǘ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǒ� ǎǘǕǐǗǥ� ǛǘǘNjǣNJǜǦ� ǘ� njǒǑǒǜNJǟ� ǗNJ� ǛǏnjǏǚǘ-ǔǘǚǏǓǛǔǒǏ�ǛNJǓǜǥ��ǒǗNJǡǏ�ǚǒǛǔǝǨǜ�ǢǜǚNJǞǘǖ�nj���ǖǕǗ�njǘǗ� �ǘǔǘǕǘ��������Ƭb����Ȃ����bǍǘǎNJǟ��ǑNJ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�NJǎǖǒǗǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǘǜ�ǔǘǗǛǏǚnjNJ-ǜǒnjǗǘǓ�ǙNJǚǜǒǒ��ƻǧǗǝǚǒ��ǚǏǑǔǘ�njǥǚǘǛǕǘ��ǎǘ�ǛǘǜǗǒ��ǡǒǛǕǘ�ǕǨǎǏǓ��ǘǛǝǐ-ǎǏǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘbǎNJǗǗǥǖ�ǛǜNJǜǦǩǖ�

83LjưƷƪlj�ƴƸƺƯlj

Page 85: User identification analysis

ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ� ǙǚǒǗǩǜǘǖǝ� nj� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ� ǘǛǗǘnjǗǘǖǝ� ƱNJǔǘǗǝ� ǘ� ǜǏǕǏǔǘǖ-ǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǖ� NjǒǑǗǏǛǏ�� ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJ� ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǗǏ� ǎǘǕǐǗǥ� ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǗNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǩ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǚǩǎǔNJ��ǖǘǚNJǕǒ�ǒ�ǜǚNJ-ǎǒǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǜǘǏnj��Ƭ�����b Ǎǘǎǝ�ƬǏǚǟǘnjǗǥǓ�Ǜǝǎ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǕ�ǙǘǕǗǘǖǘǡǒǩ�ǙǘbǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǨ�ǔNJǜǏǍǘǚǒǓ�ǑNJǙǚǏǣǏǗǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǘǜ�ƹǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ�ǔ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjǝ�ƻnjǩǑǒ��nj�����bǍǘǎǝ�ǙǘǙǚNJnjǔNJǖǒ�ǔ�ƱNJǔǘǗǝ�ǘNj�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJ-Ǡǒǒ�NjǥǕǘ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǘ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǏ�ǗNJǎǑǘǚǗǘǏ�njǏǎǘǖǛǜnjǘ��ƹǘbǧǜǘǖǝ�ǑNJǔǘǗǝ�ǙǘǕǒǠǒǩ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǜǦ�ǘǜ�ƴǘǖǒǛǛǒǒ�ǙǘbǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJǖ��.&6&��ǎǘǛǝǎǏNjǗǘǓ�NjǕǘǔǒǚǘnjǔǒ�ǛNJǓǜǘnj��ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǣǒǟ�ǗǏǑNJ-ǔǘǗǗǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ��ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǘǜǡǏǜNJǖ�njǏǎǘǖǛǜnjNJ�ǛǚǏǎǒ�ǙǘǙǝǕǩǚǗǥǟ�ǙǚǒǡǒǗ�NjǕǘǔǒǚǘnjǔǒ��ǔǚǘǖǏ�ǛǒǖǙNJǜǒǓ�ǔ�ƴƷƮƺ���ǗNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǏ�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗ-ǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǚǩǎǔNJ��ǗǏǙǚǒǛǜǘǓǗǘǏ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǗǒǏ��ǗNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚNJnj�ǗNJ�ǡNJǛǜǗǝǨ�ǐǒǑǗǦ�� ǙǚǘǙNJǍNJǗǎNJ�ǐǏǛǜǘǔǘǛǜǒ� ǒ� ǗNJǛǒǕǒǩ�� njǘǑNjǝǐǎǏǗǒǏ� njǚNJǐǎǥ�� Ǚǘ-ǘǣǚǏǗǒǏ�NJǑNJǚǜǗǥǟ�ǒǍǚ��.&6&�ǜNJǔbǐǏ�ǗǏǛǏǜ�ǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǛǜǦ�ǑNJ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏ-ǕǏǗǒǏ�ǔNJǜǏǍǘǚǒǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��njǚǏǎǗǘǓ�ǎǕǩ�ǎǏǜǏǓ��ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ƱNJǔǘǗǝ�ǘ�ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǎǏǜǏǓ�ǘǜ�����bǍǘǎNJ�

ƴǕǏnjǏǜNJ� nj� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǝǍǘǕǘnjǗǥǖ� ǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǕǏǗǒǏǖ� nj� ƺǏ-ǛǙǝNjǕǒǔǏ� ƴǘǚǏǩ� ǒ� ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ� ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǥǖǒ� ǙǘǙǚNJnjǔNJǖǒ� nj� ƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘNj�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�� Ƭ� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ�NjǥǕǘ�njǘǑNjǝǐǎǏǗǘ�NjǘǕǏǏ���� ǜǥǛǩǡ�ǎǏǕ�ǙǘbǔǕǏnjǏǜǏ��ǘǛǝǐǎǏǗǘ�NjǘǕǏǏ���ǜǥǛǩǡ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ƴǘǚǏǒ��ǒǑ�Ǘǒǟ�ǘǔǘǕǘ�ǜǥǛǩ-ǡǒbȃ�ǒǖǏǗǗǘ�ǑNJ�ǙǝNjǕǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��ƸǛǝǐǎǏǗǗǥǖ�ǍǚǘǑǒǜ�ǢǜǚNJǞ�ǎǘ����ǖǕǗ�njǘǗ��ǘǔǘǕǘ�����ǜǥǛǩǡ��ǒǕǒ�ǜǨǚǏǖǗǘǏ�ǑNJǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǏ�Ǜǚǘǔǘǖ�ǎǘ��bǕǏǜ��ǙǚǒǡǏǖ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǘǜǩǍǘǣNJǨǣǒǖ�ǘNj-ǛǜǘǩǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘǖ��ƷNJǒNjǘǕǏǏ�ǒǑnjǏǛǜǗǥǖ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏǖ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�ǛǜNJ-Ǖǘ�ǙǚǏǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǏ�NjǕǘǍǏǚNJ�ƶǒǗǏǚnjNJ��ǙǚǏǎǛǔNJǑNJnjǢǏǍǘ�ǔǚǒǑǒǛ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǒ�ǔǚǒǜǒǔǘnjNJnjǢǏǍǘ�ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǝǨ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔǝ�njǕNJǛǜǏǓ�

ƲǑNjǒǚNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǏ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ� ƺǏǛǙǝNjǕǒǔǒ� ƴǘǚǏǩ� ǚNJǑǚǏǢNJ-Ǐǜ� NJǍǒǜNJǠǒǨ�nj�ǙǘǕǦǑǝ� ǜǘǍǘ�ǒǕǒ�ǒǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔNJ� ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�njǘ� njǚǏǖǩ�ǒǑ-NjǒǚNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǔNJǖǙNJǗǒǒ��ƷNJǚǝǢǒǜǏǕǏǓ�ǐǎǏǜ�ǢǜǚNJǞ�nj�ǚNJǑǖǏǚǏ�ǎǘ���ǖǕǗ�njǘǗ��ǘǔǘǕǘ��������ǒǕǒ�ǜǨǚǏǖǗǘǏ�ǑNJǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǏ�Ǜǚǘǔǘǖ�ǎǘ�ǎnjǝǟ�ǕǏǜ��ǀǏǗ-ǜǚNJǕǦǗNJǩ� ǒǑNjǒǚNJǜǏǕǦǗNJǩ� ǔǘǖǒǛǛǒǩ� ǘNjǕNJǎNJǕNJ� ǙǚNJnjǘǖ�ǖǘǗǒǜǘǚǒǗǍNJ� ǒ�ǠǏǗǑǝǚǥ�ǛNJǓǜǘnj�ǒ�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǖǏǎǒNJ��ǔNJǐǎǥǓ�Ǎǘǎ�ǝǎNJǕǩǕǘǛǦ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǎǏǛǩǜǔǘnj�ǜǥǛǩǡ�ǙǝNjǕǒǔNJǠǒǓ�ǘ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔNJǟ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�ǧǜNJ�ǗǘǚǖNJ�NjǥǕNJ�Ǚǚǒ-ǑǗNJǗNJ�ǗǏǔǘǗǛǜǒǜǝǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ��njǖǏǛǜǏ�Ǜ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩǖǒ�ǘNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǛNJǓǜǘnj�

&�����bǍǘǎNJ�nj�ǛǜǚNJǗǏ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǐǏǛǜǔǘǏ�NJǗǜǒǙǒǚNJǜǛǔǘǏ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJ-ǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ��njǔǕǨǡNJǨǣǏǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ�mǜǚǏǟ�ǛǜǚNJǓǔǘnj}��ǘǜǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǏ�ǗNJǚǝǢǒ-ǜǏǕǏǓ�ǘǜ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǑNJ�ǜǚǒ�ǗNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǩ�NJnjǜǘǚǛǔǘǍǘ�ǒ�ǛǖǏǐǗǥǟ�ǙǚNJnj��ǗǏ�

84 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 86: User identification analysis

ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��Ǘǘ�ǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ��ǒ�ǢǜǚNJǞǥ�nj�ǚNJǑǖǏǚǏ�ǎǘ����ǖǕǗ�njǘǗ��ǘǔǘǕǘ�����ǜǥǛǩǡ���ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǝǡǒǜǥnjNJǩ�Ǚǘ-Ǖǒǜǒǔǝ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǚǏNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǒǖǏǗ��ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�njǥǗǝǐǎǏ-Ǘǥ�njǥǎNJnjNJǜǦ�Ǜnjǘǒǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��ƱNJ�Ǎǘǎǥ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǙǚǏǎǝǙǚǏǐǎǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǕǒ�NjǘǕǏǏ�����ǜǥǛǩǡ�ǗNJǚǝǢǒǜǏǕǏǓ�

ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ƱNJǔǘǗǝ�ǘ�ǜǏǕǏǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǖ�NjǒǑǗǏǛǏ��ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏ-ǚǥ�ǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�ǘNjǩǑNJǗǥ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǜǦ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�ǘ�ǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǟ�ǗNJ�ǑNJǙǚǘǛǥ�ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǘnj��ǙǚǘǔǝǚNJǜǝǚǥ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǝǎNJ��ƻ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘ�ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǜNJǓǗǥ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǓ��Ǜǘ-ǍǕNJǛǗǘ� ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖǝ� ǜǏǕǏǔǘǖǥ� ǒ� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ� ǘNjǩǑNJǗǥ� ǟǚNJǗǒǜǦ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǟ�nj�ǜǏǡǏǗǒǏ��ǔNJǔ�ǖǒǗǒǖǝǖ��ǜǚǏǟ�ǖǏǛǩǠǏnj�

Ƭ� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ� nj� ǙǚǏǛǛǏ�ǙǘǩnjǒǕNJǛǦ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘNj�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ƴǘǚǏǓǛǔǒǖ�NJǍǏǗǜǛǜnjǘǖ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǛǕǏǐǔǏ�ǑNJ�ǒǗǜǏǚ-ǗǏǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǖǒ�� ƻ� ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǏǖ� ǛǔNJǗǎNJǕNJ� ǛǜNJǕǘ� ǒǑnjǏǛǜǗǘ� ǒ� ǘ� ǎǚǝ-Ǎǒǟ� ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǟ�� ǘNjǕNJǎNJǨǣǒǟ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǩǖǒ�Ǚǘb ǙǏǚǏǟnjNJǜǝ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǘǓ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�� ǒ� ǘNj� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǏǓ�ǎǕǩ�NjǘǚǦNjǥ�Ǜ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ�ǙǚǘǜǒnjǗǒǔNJǖǒ�

Ƭ�NJnjǍǝǛǜǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ƴǘǗǛǜǒǜǝǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�Ǜǝǎ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǕ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�njǏǚǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ� ǗǏǔǘǗǛǜǒǜǝǠǒǘǗǗǥǖǒ�� ƹǏǚǏǟǘǎ� ǘǜ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘ-njNJǗǒǩ�551�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ�ǔ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǥǖ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǩǖ�ǒ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ� L�3Ζ1�NjǥǕ�ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗ�nj�ƱNJǔǘǗǏ�ǘ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǘǜ�����bǍǘǎNJ��ƹǚǒǗǩǜǥǏ�nj�ǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜǏ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǘǍǘ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǙǚNJnjǔǒ�nj�ƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘNj�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǘǜ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǝǛǜNJǗNJnjǕǒnjNJǨǜ�ǛǙǒǛǘǔ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏnj��ǔǘǍǎNJ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǥ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǜǦ�551��nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�njǥǎNJǡǒ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�NJǕǦǜǏǚǗNJǜǒnjǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�NJǔǔǚǏǎǒǜǘnjNJǗǗǥǖǒ�NJǍǏǗǜǛǜnjNJǖǒ��nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǙǚNJnjǘǙǚǒǖǏ-ǗǏǗǒǩ�ǔnjNJǕǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǖǒ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖǒ�ǒ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥ-ǖǒ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJǖǒ��nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�njǏǎǏǗǒǩ�NjǒǑǗǏǛNJ�Ǜ�ǝnjǏǎǘǖǕǏǗǒǏǖ�ƴǘ-ǖǒǛǛǒǒ� Ǚǘb ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǩǖ� ǔnjNJǕǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǖǒ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖǒ�ǒ� ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖǒ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚNJǖǒ�� ƴǚǘǖǏ� ǜǘǍǘ�� ǘǛǜNJǨǜǛǩ� nj�ǛǒǕǏ� Ǘǘǚǖǥ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ� ǘ� ǑNJǣǒǜǏ� ǎǏǜǏǓ�� ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǖ� ǚǩǎ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�ǎǘǕǐǏǗ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǜǦ�njnjǘǎ�njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǘǜǛǏǡǏǗǒǩ�ǗǏǛǘnjǏǚ-ǢǏǗǗǘǕǏǜǗǒǟ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�� NJ� ǜNJǔǐǏ� ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗNJǩ� njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� ǖǘ-NjǒǕǦǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��Ƭ�NJǙǚǏǕǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǙǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǛǔǒǖ�ǝǔNJǑǘǖ�NjǥǕNJ�ǝǙǚNJǑǎǗǏǗNJ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǏǓ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�6(('�

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǖǏǚǥƸƻƷƸƬƪ�ƻƲƻƼƯƶDž�ƬƯƺƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ȃ�ǗǘǖǏǚNJ�551��ǙǚǒǛnjNJǒnjNJ-ǨǜǛǩ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗNJǖ�ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǘǖǝ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǝ��ƷǘǖǏǚ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ�

85LjưƷƪlj�ƴƸƺƯlj

Page 87: User identification analysis

���ǠǒǞǚ��ǙǏǚnjǥǏ��bȃ�ǧǜǘ�ǎNJǜNJ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǩ��ƻǏǎǦǖNJǩ�ǠǒǞǚNJ�ǝǔNJǑǥnjNJǏǜ�ǗNJ�ǙǘǕ�ǒ�njǏǔ��nj�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖ�NjǥǕ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩbǕǒ�ǘǗ�ǍǚNJǐ-ǎNJǗǒǗǘǖ�ǒǕǒ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǘǖ�ƴǘǚǏǒ��ƻǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ���ǠǒǞǚǥ�ǝǔNJǑǥnjNJǨǜ�ǗNJ�ǖǏǛǜǘ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǩ��Ǚǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǎnjǏǗNJǎǠNJǜNJǩ�ǠǒǞǚNJbȃ�ǙǘǚǩǎǔǘnjǥǓ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǎǕǩ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǘǎǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǕNJ��ǚǘǎǒnjǢǒǟǛǩ�nj�ǘǎǗǘǖ�ǖǏǛǜǏ�nj�ǘǎǒǗ�ǎǏǗǦ��ƹǘ-ǛǕǏǎǗǩǩ�ǠǒǞǚNJ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǛǘNjǘǓ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǦǗǝǨ�Ǜǝǖǖǝ��njǥǡǒǛǕǩǏǖǝǨ�ǙǘbǞǘǚǖǝǕǏ

P� �>���ȫ�^���D����b����F����G����e����I����bJ����h����i����j����N����l��PRG���`@�PRG����

ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǑǗNJǩ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǥǓ�ǗNJNjǘǚ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ�� ǗǏǛǕǘǐǗǘ� ǙǘǎǎǏǕNJǜǦ� ǏǍǘ� 551�� ƼNJǔ� 551� NjǥnjǢǏǍǘ� ǙǚǏǑǒ-ǎǏǗǜNJ�ƴǘǚǏǒ�Ʒǘ�ƶǝ�ƿǪǗNJ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǕǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǛǘǜǗǩǟ�ǛNJǓǜǘnj�ǛǘǖǗǒǜǏǕǦ-ǗǘǍǘ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǗǒǩ��ƹǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǛǖǏǗǥ�551�nj�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǝǜǏǡǔǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�nj�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖǘǜǚǏǗNJ�

ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ� ǑNJǣǒǜǥ� ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǏǓ� 6(('� ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗNJ� ǗNJ� ǛǒǖǖǏǜǚǒǡ-Ǘǘǖ�NjǕǘǡǗǘǖ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘNJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǏ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ƻǏǜǒ�ƾǏǓǛǜǏǕǩ��ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǗ-Ǘǘǖ� ƴǘǚǏǓǛǔǒǖ� NJǍǏǗǜǛǜnjǘǖ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ� �.Ζ6$�� nj�����bǍǘǎǝ��Ƭ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǏ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜǛǩ�����NjǒǜǗǥǓ�NjǕǘǔ�ǒ�ǔǕǨǡ�ǎǕǒǗǘǓ�����Njǒǜ��ƪǍǏǗǜǛǜnjǘǖ�ǛǙǏǠǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǢǒǞǚNJ�6(('�nj�ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕNJǟ�7/6�ǒ�6�0Ζ0(��Ƭ�ǜǘbǐǏ�njǚǏǖǩ��NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖ�6(('�ǗǏ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑǘnjNJǗ�nj�NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǏ�ǛǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǟ�NjǚNJǝǑǏǚǘnj�ǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǓ��ǡǜǘ�ǑNJǜǚǝǎǗǩǏǜ�ǏǍǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�nj�ǎNJǗǗǘǓ�ǛǞǏǚǏ�njǗǏ�ǙǚǏǎǏǕǘnj�LjǐǗǘǓ�ƴǘǚǏǒ��ƼǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǩ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǒ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǥǟ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘnj�NjǥǕNJ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑǘ-njNJǗNJ�nj�njǒǎǏ�ǙǕNJǍǒǗǘnj�ǎǕǩ�1HWVFDSH�ǒ� ΖQWHUQHW�([SORUHU� Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJ-ǗǒǏǖ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�0LFURVRIW�$FWLYH;��ƹǚǒǡǒǗǘǓ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ�6(('�ǛǜNJǕNJ�ǑNJǎǏǚǐǔNJ� Ǜǘ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǒǑNJǠǒǏǓ� ����NjǒǜǗǘǍǘ� ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕNJ� 66/� ǒ� ǑNJǙǚǏǜ�ƻǂƪ�ǗNJ� ǧǔǛǙǘǚǜ� ǔǚǒǙǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ� ǧǜǘǍǘ� ǔǕNJǛǛNJ�� ǙǚǘǛǝ-ǣǏǛǜnjǘnjNJnjǢǒǓ�ǎǘ�ǔǘǗǠNJ�����bǍǘǎNJ��ƹǘǎǎǏǚǐǔNJ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJ�ǎǕǩ�NjǚNJǝǑǏǚNJ�1HWVFDSH�ǙǚǏǔǚNJǜǒǕNJǛǦ�njǖǏǛǜǏ�Ǜ�ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔǘǓ�ǛNJǖǘǍǘ�NjǚNJǝǑǏǚNJ��ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǙǕNJǜǏǐǒ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ�ǛǜNJǕǒ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǥ�ǒǛǔǕǨǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�Ǜ�Ǚǘ-ǖǘǣǦǨ�NjǚNJǝǑǏǚNJ�0LFURVRIW�ΖQWHUQHW�([SORUHU�

ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�L�3Ζ1��ǙǚǒǢǏǎǢNJǩ�ǗNJ�ǑNJǖǏ-Ǘǝ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǨ�551�nj�ǘǗǕNJǓǗǏ�ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ�ǙǩǜǦǨ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒ-ǩǖǒ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǠǏǗǜǚǘǖ�ǒ�ǗNJǠǒǘ-ǗNJǕǦǗǥǖǒ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǥǖǒ�NjǨǚǘ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǟǚNJǗǩǜ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǒ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǜ�$3Ζ�ǎǕǩ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǗǒǟ�ǛNJǓǜǘnj��ƮǕǩ�ǙǘǕǝ-ǡǏǗǒǩ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜNJ� L�3Ζ1�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ�njnjǘǎ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��njǔǕǨ-

86 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 88: User identification analysis

ǡNJǩ� 551�� NJ� ǜNJǔǐǏ� njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� ǘǎǗǒǖ� ǒǑ� ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǒnjNJǏǖǥǟ� ǛǙǘǛǘNjǘnj��ǠǒǞǚǘnjNJǩ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦ��606��ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗNJǩ�ǔNJǚǜNJ��ǕǒǡǗǥǓ�njǒǑǒǜ�nj�NJǍǏǗǜǛǜnjǘ���ƸǜǎǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǘǙǠǒǒ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǗǥ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǎǕǩ�ǧǔǛǙNJǜǘnj��ƻ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�L�3Ζ1�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǛǘNjǘǓ�ǗNJNjǘǚ�ǠǒǞǚ�ǒ�njǥNjǚNJǗǗǥǓ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJ-ǜǏǕǏǖ�ǙNJǚǘǕǦ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�njnjǏǛǜǒ�ǗNJ�ǧǜNJǙǏ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��Ƭ�ǜǘbǐǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǧǔǛǙǏǚǜǥ�ǙǘbNjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǝǔNJǑǥnjNJǨǜ�ǗNJ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǦ�njnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�ǎnjǝǟǧǜNJǙǗǘǓ�njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�L�3Ζ1�njǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǏ�ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjNJ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏnj�ǙǘǟǒǣǏǗǒǩ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��ƴǚǘǖǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǗǏǛǖǘǜǚǩ�ǗNJ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǥǓ�ǙǚǘǍǚǏǛǛ��ǘǛǗǘnjǗNJǩ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJ-Ǡǒǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�L�3Ζ1�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ�ǘǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�NjǚNJǝǑǏǚ�Ǜ�ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔǘǓ�$FWLYH;��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǎǕǩ�njǛǜǚǘǏǗǗǘǓ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǘǜ�ǢǙǒǘǗǛǔǒǟ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖ�

LJǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩƺƯƻƹƽƫƵƲƴƪ�ƴƸƺƯljbȃ�ǘǎǒǗ�ǒǑ�ǙǒǘǗǏǚǘnj�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ��ƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǛǏǜǦ�ƻǏǝǕǦǛǔǘǍǘ� ǝǗǒnjǏǚǛǒǜǏǜNJ�NjǥǕNJ�ǙǘǛǜǚǘǏǗNJ�ǒ�ǘNjǤǏǎǒǗǏǗNJ� Ǜ� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǘ-njNJnjǢǒǖǒ� ǜǘǍǎNJ� NJǔNJǎǏǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ� ǏnjǚǘǙǏǓǛǔǒǖǒ� ǒ� NJǖǏǚǒǔNJǗǛǔǒǖǒ�ǛǏǜǩǖǒ�ǏǣǪ�nj� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ�� NJ� ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǎǘǖǏǗ�NjǥǕ�ǎǏǕǏǍǒǚǘnjNJǗ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ��ƴǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǥ�ǙǘǩnjǒǕǒǛǦ�nj�������NJbǔ�����bǍǘǎǝ�ǙǘbǎǘǕǏ�ǂƹƮ��ǢǒǚǘǔǘǙǘǕǘǛǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ��ǛǜǚNJǗNJ�ǛǜNJǕNJ�ǕǒǎǏǚǘǖ�ǛǚǏǎǒ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǥǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗ��ƹǘbǎNJǗǗǥǖ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǒǟ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘ-njNJǗǒǓ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�$NDPDL�6WDWH�RI�WKH�ΖQWHUQHW��LjǐǗNJǩ�ƴǘǚǏǩ�ǘNjǕNJǎNJǏǜ�ǛNJǖǥǖ�NjǥǛǜǚǥǖ�ǢǒǚǘǔǘǙǘǕǘǛǗǥǖ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǘǖ�nj�ǖǒǚǏ��Ǜǘ�ǛǚǏǎǗǏǓ�Ǜǔǘ-ǚǘǛǜǦǨ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�NjǘǕǏǏ����ǖNjǒǜ�Ǜ�

ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ� ǘǜǡǪǜǝ� ǘǜǚNJǛǕǏnjǘǓ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ� ǙǚǏǎǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǜǏǕǏǓ� ƴǘ-ǚǏǒ��).Ζ���ǎǘǕǩ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǠǒǒ�nj�ƬƬƹ�ǛǜǚNJǗǥ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�����Ɍ���ǜǘǍǎNJ�ǔNJǔ�nj�ƻǂƪbȃ�����Ɍ���nj�ƴǒǜNJǏbȃ�����Ɍ���ƸǛǗǘnjǗǝǨ�njǒǗǝ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�njǘǑǕNJǍNJǨǜ�ǗNJ�ǎNJnjǗǘ�ǝǛǜNJǚǏnjǢǒǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��njǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǏ�ǡǏǍǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǒ�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǡǒǜNJǨǜ�ǙǘǔǝǙǔǒ�ǗNJ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǟ�ǛNJǓǜNJǟ��ǜNJǔǒǟ�� ǔNJǔ� H%D\� ǒ� $PD]RQ�� ƲǑ�ǑNJ� ��b ǕǏǜ� ǎǘǖǒǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�6(('� ǗNJNjǕǨǎNJǏǜǛǩ� ǔNJǜNJǛǜǚǘǞǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ� ǛǒǜǝNJǠǒǩ� ǗNJ� ǚǥǗǔǏ� ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖbȃ� nj� ƴǘǚǏǏ� ǗǏ� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ� Ǘǒ� ǘǎǗǘǍǘ� ǛǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǖǏǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJ�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǏǓ��ƬǛǏ�ǙǘǙǥǜǔǒ�ǛǘǑǎNJǜǦ�ǖǏǛǜǗǥǏ�NJǗNJǕǘǍǒ�3D\-3DO�NjǥǕǒ�ǑNJNjǕǘǔǒǚǘnjNJǗǥ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǘǓ�ǒǗǎǝǛǜǚǒǏǓ�

ƮǘǕǩ�NjǚNJǝǑǏǚNJ�0LFURVRIW�ΖQWHUQHW�([SORUHU�nj�LjǐǗǘǓ�ƴǘǚǏǏbȃ�NjǘǕǏǏ���Ɍ��� ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�� ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǡǒǔǒ� njǥǗǝǐǎǏǗǥ�ǘǚǒǏǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǝǛǜNJǚǏnjǢǒǏ� njǏǚǛǒǒ� NjǚNJǝǑǏǚǘnj�� ƽ� ǛǜNJǚǜNJǙǘnj� ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǝǏǜ� ǛǜǒǖǝǕ� ǔ� ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǨ�Ǘǘnjǥǟ�njǏNj�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ��NjǏǑ�ǡǏǍǘ�ǗǏnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǘ�ǙǘǛǜǚǘǒǜǦ�ǔǘǗǔǝǚǏǗǜǗǥǏ�njǏNj�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ�ǒ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ��ƴǘǚǏǩ�ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǘǜǛǜNJǏǜ�

87LjưƷƪlj�ƴƸƺƯlj

Page 89: User identification analysis

ǒ� nj� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǒ� ǛǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǟ� ǜǒǙǘnj� njǏNj�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj� �ǛǜǚǒǖǒǗǍ�� ǘNj-ǕNJǔNJ�ǒ�ǎǚ���Ƭ�ǜǘbǐǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǗNJǕǒǡǒǏ�NjǘǕǦǢǘǓ�ǎǘǕǒ�ǝǛǜNJǚǏnjǢǒǟ��ǗǏǙǘǎ-ǎǏǚǐǒnjNJǏǖǥǟ�NjǚNJǝǑǏǚǘnj�ǘǑǗNJǡNJǏǜ�NjǘǕǦǢǒǏ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǥ�Ǜ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒ-ǘǗǗǘǓ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��ǙǘbǘǠǏǗǔNJǖ�0F$IHH�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ�NjǥǕǒ�ǝǔǚNJǎǏǗǥ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�NjǘǕǏǏ����ǖǕǗ�ǔǘǚǏǓǠǏnj��ƸǞǒ-ǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǕǒǠNJ�ǘǠǏǗǒnjNJǨǜ�ǝǣǏǚNj�ǘǜ�ǔǒNjǏǚNJǜNJǔ�nj�����Ȃ����ǖǕǗ��ǑǗNJ-ǡǒǜǏǕǦǗNJǩ� ǎǘǕǩ� ǙǚǒǟǘǎǒǜǛǩ� ǗNJ� ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ� ǛǏnjǏǚǘǔǘǚǏǓǛǔǒǟ� ǟNJǔǏǚǘnj��Ƭ�ǜǘbǐǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�NjǥǕNJ�ǙǚǏǔǚNJǣǏǗNJ�ǚNJNjǘǜNJ�ǗNJǎ�Ǘǘnjǥǖǒ�ǔǘǗǠǏǙǠǒǩǖǒ�ǒ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǩǖǒ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�njǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǏ�ǗǏnjǘǑǖǘǐ-ǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǟ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǗNJ�ǙǚNJǔǜǒǔǏ�

ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǚǏNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǙǚǒnjǏǕNJ�ǔ� ǎǘǖǒǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ� ǑNJǚǝNjǏǐǗǥǟ� 8*&�ǚǏǛǝǚǛǘnj� ǒ� ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǖǏǎǒNJ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǕǒ�ǕǏǍǔǒǏ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjǥ�ǘNjǟǘǎNJ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǙǝǜǏǖ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǟ�njǏǚǛǒǓ�ǛNJǓǜǘnj��ƪNjǛǝǚǎǗǘǛǜǦ�ǛǒǜǝNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǎǡǪǚǔǒnjNJǨǜ� ǜNJǔǒǏ� ǙǚǒǖǏǚǥ�� ǔNJǔ� ǘǞǒǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǓ� ǔNJǗNJǕ� ƹǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ�ƴǘǚǏǒ�ǗNJ�<RX7XEH��ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǒnjNJǏǖǥǓ�ǒǖǏǗǗǘ�nj�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǘǓ�njǏǚǛǒǒ�

ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒ�ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ��ǙǚNJnjǘnjǘǍǘ��ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ��ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ��nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒƲƻƼƸƺƲlj� ƮƬƽƿ� ƻƲƻƼƯƶ� njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��6(('� ǒ� 551�� ǙǘǔNJǑǥnjNJǏǜ� ǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǦ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǍǘ� ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǏǗǒǩ�ǗǏǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǒ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ��ǗǏ�ǝǡǒǜǥnjNJǨǣǒǟ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǏ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ��ǛǙǘǛǘNjǘnj�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǓ�� ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔNJǩ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ� ƯƻƲƪ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� NjǘǕǏǏ� ǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗ-ǗǘǓ�ǔNJǔ�Ǜ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�Ǜ�ǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ��Ƭ�ǜǘbǐǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǛǜǒǖǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ƯƻƲƪ�ǎǕǩ�ǘNjǏ-ǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ� ǜǚNJǗǑNJǔǠǒǓ� ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǙǘǕǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǖǏǚǘǓ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�

ƹǘbǖǗǏǗǒǨ�ƴǘǗǛǜǒǜǝǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǛǝǎNJ�ƴǘǚǏǒ��ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǔ�ǛNJǓǜNJǖ�ǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǖ� ǎǘǕǐǗǥ� NjǥǜǦ� ǙǚǘǙǘǚǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥ� ǑNJǩnjǕǏǗǗǥǖ� ǠǏǕǩǖ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ� NJǔǜǘnj� ǒ� ǗǏ� ǎǒǛǔǚǒǖǒǗǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ� ǖǏǛǜǗǥǏ� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�� ƷǏǕǦǑǩ� ǚNJǛǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǜǦ� njǛǏǟ� ǙǘǛǏǜǒǜǏǕǏǓ� ǛNJǓǜǘnj�� ǔNJǔ� Ǚǘ-ǜǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǗNJǚǝǢǒǜǏǕǏǓ��ƷǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǝǡǒǜǥnjNJǜǦ�ǒ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǏ�Ǘǘǚǖǥ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ǜNJǔ�ǔNJǔ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǑNJǔǘǗǥ�mǎǕǩ�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ}�ǡNJǣǏ�njǛǏǍǘ�ǘǔNJǑǥnjNJǨǜǛǩ�ǒǑNjǥǜǘǡǗǥǖǒ�ǒ�ǗǏǛǝǜ�ǗǏǙǚǏǎnjǒǎǏǗǗǥǏ�Ǚǘ-ǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩ��ƼNJǔ��ǗNJ�ǙǚǒǖǏǚǏ�ƴǘǚǏǒ�njǒǎǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǎǕǩ�ǝǛǙǏǢǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚǏǛǏǡǏ-Ǘǒǩ�ǔǕǏnjǏǜǥ��ǘǙNJǛǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��NjǥǕǘ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�

88 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 90: User identification analysis

ǘǛǗǘnj��ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǟ�Ǜ�����bǍǘǎNJ� �ǜNJǔǒǟ��ǔNJǔ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡNJ�ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǒ-ǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ� ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ� ǘNj� Ζ3�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǟ��� ƷǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǘǜǖǏǜǒǜǦ�ǒ�ǜǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǘǜ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�551�ǘǜǔNJǑNJǕǒǛǦ�njǘ�ǖǗǘǍǘǖ�njǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǏ�ǗǏnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǗNJǓǜǒ�ǞNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǏ�ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǏ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ�ǙǚǏǎǘǜnjǚNJǜǒǜǦ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǒǏ�ǕǘǐǗǘǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǑNJǙǚǏǣǪǗǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚ-ǖNJǠǒǒ�bȃ�ǗNJǙǚǘǜǒnj��ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�551�ǒ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǘǚ-ǍNJǗǘnj�ǙǚǒnjǏǕǒ�nj�ǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜǏ�ǔ�ǖNJǛǛǘnjǘǖǝ�mǙǏǚǏǏǑǎǝ}�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǗNJ�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǥǏ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ�

ƷNJǔǘǗǏǠ��ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǒǛǔǕǨǡNJǕNJ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǖǏǛǜǗǥǟ�ǛNJǓǜǘnj�ǗǏ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗNJǖǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJǖǒ�ƴǘǚǏǒ���Ǘǘ�ǒ�ǧǜǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ�ǔǘǚǏǓǠNJǖǒ��ǙǚǘǐǒnjNJǨǣǒǖǒ�nj�ǧǜǒǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗNJǟ��ǒ�ǎǏǕNJǕNJ�ǗǏnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǥǖ�ǧǔǛǙǘǚǜ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj��ƯǛǕǒ�ǝǡǏǛǜǦ��ǡǜǘ��ǙǘbǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǖ�ǘǠǏǗǔNJǖ��ǚǝǛǛǔǒǓ�ǩǑǥǔ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�njǜǘǚǥǖ�ǙǘbǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJ-ǗǪǗǗǘǛǜǒ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǏ�ǖǏǚǥ�ǛǏǚǦǪǑǗǘ�ǝǎNJǚǒǕǒbNjǥ�ǙǘbǔǝǕǦ-ǜǝǚǗǘǖǝ�ǘNjǖǏǗǝ�nj�ǚǝǛǛǔǘǩǑǥǡǗǘǖ�ǖǒǚǏ�

ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔNJǩ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǩ

ƪǗNJǕǒǑ�ǜǏǔǝǣǏǍǘ�ǛǘǛǜǘǩǗǒǩ�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ƺƾ

Ƭ�ǛǞǏǚǏ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍƬ�ƻƸƸƼƬƯƼƻƼƬƲƲ�ƻ�ƹƸƮƹƽƷƴƼƸƶ���ǙǝǗǔǜNJ���ǛǜNJǜǦǒ���ƱNJǔǘǗNJ�ȟɋ����ƾƱ�ǘǚ-ǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǨǣǒǏ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǒ�Ǜ�ǎǏǗǏǐǗǥǖǒ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJǖǒ�ǒǕǒ�ǒǗǥǖ� ǒǖǝǣǏǛǜnjǘǖ�� ǘNjǩǑNJǗǥ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ�� ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǒ-ǜǏǕǩ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ�ǒ��ǒǕǒ��njǥǍǘǎǘǙǚǒǘNjǚǏǜNJǜǏǕǩ��ǑNJ�ǒǛǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǏǖ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏnj��ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǗǥǟ�Ǚ�bǙ�b���������ǒ�����ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǓ�ǛǜNJǜǦǒ��ǒ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǦ�nj�ǘǜ-ǗǘǢǏǗǒǒ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǨ��ǒǖǩ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǘǜǡǏǛǜnjǘ��ǏǛǕǒ�ǒǗǘǏ�ǗǏ�njǥǜǏǔNJǏǜ�ǒǑ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǘNjǥǡNJǩ���ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǜnjǘ��ǎNJǜǝ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǩ��ǚǏǔnjǒǑǒǜǥ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJ��ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǩǨǣǏǍǘ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ��ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǖǒǍǚNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ��ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJ��ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǨǣǏǍǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗ-ǗǘǍǘ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǕǒǠNJ�NjǏǑ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǜnjNJ�ǗNJ�ǙǚǏNjǥnjNJǗǒǏ��ǙǚǘǐǒnjNJ-ǗǒǏ��nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ��NJǎǚǏǛ�ǖǏǛǜNJ�ǐǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ��ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ��ǒǕǒ� ǖǏǛǜNJ� ǙǚǏNjǥnjNJǗǒǩ�� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ� ǗǘǖǏǚ� ǗNJǕǘǍǘǙǕNJǜǏǕǦ-ǣǒǔNJ��Ǚǚǒ�ǏǍǘ�ǗNJǕǒǡǒǒ��

ƹǘǎǙǝǗǔǜNJǖǒ����������ǒ�����ǛǜNJǜǦǒ���ƱNJǔǘǗNJ�ȟɋ����ƾƱ�ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖǘǜǚǏ-Ǘǥ�ǒǛǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ�Ǜ�ǎǏǗǏǐǗǥǖǒ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJǖǒ�nj�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǘǓ�njNJǕǨǜǏ�nj�ǛǝǖǖǏ��ǗǏ�ǙǚǏnjǥǢNJǨǣǏǓ��ǒǕǒ�ǧǔnjǒnjNJǕǏǗǜǗǘǓ��������bǚǝNj�

89ƺƸƻƻƲƳƻƴƪlj�ƾƯƮƯƺƪǀƲlj

Page 91: User identification analysis

ƴǚǘǖǏ� ǜǘǍǘ�� ǗNJ� ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǒ� ǙǝǗǔǜNJ� ���� ƹǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǕǒǠNJ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǙǚǘnjǘǎǒǜǦǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJ��ǝǎǘ-ǛǜǘnjǏǚǩǨǣǏǍǘ� ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ� ǗǏ� ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜ� njǛǏǟ� ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǓ�� ǜǚǏ-NjǝǏǖǥǟ� nj� ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ� Ǜǘ� ǛǜNJǜǦǏǓ� �� ƱNJǔǘǗNJ�ȟɋ����ƾƱ� ǒ� ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǒǖ�ƹǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏǖ� �ǝǙǚǘǣǏǗǗNJǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ� ǕǒǠNJ��� Ǚǚǒ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǏǗǒǒ�

• ǙǏǚǏnjǘǎǘnj�ǎǏǗǏǐǗǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�ǙǘbǙǘǚǝǡǏǗǒǨ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ�NjǏǑ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǒǩ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǒǟ�ǛǡǏǜǘnj�

• NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǒǟ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ�Ǜ�ǗNJǕǒǡǗǘǓ�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǘǓ�njNJǕǨǜǘǓ�ǒ�ǘǙǏ-ǚNJǠǒǓ�Ǜ�ǡǏǔNJǖǒ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǎǘǚǘǐǗǥǖǒ�ǡǏǔNJǖǒ���ǗǘǖǒǗNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǛǜǘǒǖǘǛǜǦ� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ� ǝǔNJǑNJǗNJ� nj� ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǘǓ� njNJǕǨǜǏ�� ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖǘ-ǜǚǏǗǗǥǟ�ƲǗǛǜǚǝǔǠǒǏǓ�ƫNJǗǔNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ����Ʋ�mƸ�Ǚǘ-ǚǩǎǔǏ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǏǗǒǩ� ǝǙǘǕǗǘǖǘǡǏǗǗǥǖǒ�NjNJǗǔNJǖǒ� �ǞǒǕǒNJǕNJǖǒ��ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǥǟ�njǒǎǘnj�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǒǟ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ�Ǜ�ǗNJǕǒǡǗǘǓ�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǘǓ�njNJǕǨǜǘǓ�ǒ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ�Ǜ�ǡǏǔNJǖǒ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǎǘǚǘǐǗǥǖǒ�ǡǏǔNJǖǒ���ǗǘǖǒǗNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǛǜǘǒǖǘǛǜǦ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǝǔNJǑNJǗNJ�nj�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǘǓ�njNJǕǨǜǏ��Ǜ�ǝǡNJǛǜǒǏǖ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ}�

ƼNJǔǒǖ� ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�� ǔǕǨǡǏnjǘǓ� ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔǘǓ� ǙǚNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� ǙǚǘǠǏ-ǎǝǚǥ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� nj� ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ� Ǜ� ǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǥǖǒ� ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǖǒ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǕǒǡǗǘǏ�ǙǚǒǛǝǜǛǜnjǒǏ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ�ǒ�ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǒǖ�ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔǝ��ǝǙǘǕǗǘǖǘǡǏǗǗǘǖǝ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǘǓ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǏǓ��ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ�ǒ?ǒǕǒ�ǒǗǥǟ�ǎǘ-ǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��ƽǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǘ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǏ�ǙǘbǚǏǔnjǒǑǒǜNJǖ�ǙǚǒǗNJǎǕǏ-ǐNJǣǏǓ�Ǐǖǝ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�� ǔǘǎNJǖ��ǙNJǚǘǕǩǖ�nj�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�nj�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ�mǛ�NjǝǔnjǘǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ}�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǏǓ�ǗǏ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�

ƿǘǜǩ� ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ǔ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj� nj� ƺǘǛǛǒǒ� ǘǛǜNJǨǜǛǩ�ǘǎǗǒǖǒ�ǒǑ� ǛNJǖǥǟ� ǛǜǚǘǍǒǟ�nj�ǖǒǚǏ��ǘǗǒ� ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǗǒǔNJǔ�ǗǏ� ǛǘǘǜǗǘǛǩǜǛǩ� Ǜ�ǖǘǎǏǚǗǒǑNJǠǒǏǓ� ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ� nj� ǒǗǥǟ� ǛǞǏǚNJǟ�� Ƭ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǛǜǒ��Ǜǒǖ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǎǘ�Ǜǒǟ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǗǥ�nj�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǝ-ǨǣǏǍǘ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜNJ��ǗǏǛǖǘǜǚǩ�ǗNJ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǏ�ǝǐǏǛǜǘǡǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕ�ǒǟ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�Ǜ���ǩǗnjNJǚǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ��ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǑNJǩnjǕǏǗǒǩǖ�ǖǒǗǒǛǜǚNJ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒ�ǖNJǛǛǘnjǥǟ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǓ��Ǜ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗNJǖ�Njǝǎǝǜ�njǥǎNJ-njNJǜǦǛǩ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ�nj�njǒǎǏ�ǙǕNJǛǜǒǔǘnjǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ��ƼǏǖ�ǗǏ�ǖǏǗǏǏ��ǙǘǔNJ�ǗǏ�ǚNJǑ-ǚǏǢǏǗ�njǘǙǚǘǛ��ǔNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǥǏ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�Njǝǎǝǜ�ǝǛǜNJǗNJnj-ǕǒnjNJǜǦ�ǖǏǛǜǘ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ�ǒ�ǚǩǎ�ǒǗǥǟ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǓ��ǒǖǏǨǣǒǟǛǩ�nj�NjǝǖNJǐǗǥǟ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJǟ��Ǘǘ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�Njǝǎǝǜ�ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǘnjNJǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǙǕNJǛǜǒǔǘnjǥǟ��ƬǘǙǚǏǔǒ� ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩǖ� ƾƪƼƾ� ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ� ǚǒǛǔǘǚǒǏǗǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǎǟǘǎNJ��ǗNJ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ǗǏ�ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǏǗǘ�ǙǘǗǩǜǒǩ�mǝǙǚǘ-ǣǏǗǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}�

90 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 92: User identification analysis

ƴǕǨǡǏnjǥǖ�ǞNJǔǜǘǚǘǖ�njǘnjǕǏǡǏǗǒǩ�ǖNJǛǛǘnjǥǟ�ǛǕǘǏnj�ǗNJǛǏǕǏǗǒǩ�nj�ǒǗ-ǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǝ�ǙǘǕǗǘǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǘǍǘ�ǘNjǛǕǝǐǒnjNJǗǒǩ�ǚǏ-ǍǝǕǩǜǘǚǥ�ǛǡǒǜNJǨǜ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǘǛǜǏǙǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǎnjǒǐǏǗǒǩ�ǘǜ�mǙǚǘǛǜǘǍǘ�ǔ�ǛǕǘǐǗǘǖǝ}��ǘǜ�mǖǒǔǚǘ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗǥǟ}�Ǚǚǘǎǝǔǜǘnj��ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǟ�Ǜǘ-ǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǓ� ǛǚǏǎǏ� �ƲǗǎǒǩ�� ǎǘ� ǙǩǜǒǝǚǘnjǗǏnjǘǓ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗǥǟ� ǛǡǏ-ǜǘnj��ǘǜ�mNJǗǘǗǒǖǗǘǍǘ}�ǡǏǚǏǑ�mǒǖǏǗǗǘǓ}�ǔ�ǙǘǕǗǘǠǏǗǗǘǖǝ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǘǖǝ��ƶǏǔǛǒǔNJ��

Ƭ�ƯnjǚǘǙǏ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��nj�ƾǒǗǕǩǗǎǒǒ��ǒ�nj�ƻǂƪ���ǜNJǔǐǏ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦ-ǑǝǏǜǛǩ�ǛǜǝǙǏǗǡNJǜǥǓ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎ�ǔ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǎǘ-ǙǝǛǔNJǏǜǛǩ�ǝǎNJǕǪǗǗNJǩ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔNJ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�Ǚǚǒ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǩǟ��ǗǏ�ǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǥǟ�Ǜ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǒǏǖ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǘǍǘ�ǛǡǏǜNJ�

Ƭ� ƯnjǚǘǙǏǓǛǔǘǖ� ƻǘǨǑǏ� ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǝǨǜ� Ǖǒǖǒǜǥ� ǗNJ� ǚNJǑǖǏǚ� ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ��ǛǘnjǏǚǢNJǏǖǥǟ� nj� ǜǏǡǏǗǒǏ� Ǜǝǜǘǔ�� Ƭ� ǡNJǛǜǗǘǛǜǒ�� ǏnjǚǘǙǏǓǛǔNJǩ� ƮǒǚǏǔǜǒnjNJ�ǘNj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎǏǗǦǍNJǟ�ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǏǜ��ǡǜǘ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǔǕǒǏǗ-ǜNJ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǘnjǘǎǒǜǦǛǩ��ǏǛǕǒ�ǖNJǔǛǒǖNJǕǦǗǥǓ�NjNJǕNJǗǛ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǏnjǥǢNJǏǜ����bǏnjǚǘ��ǏǛǕǒ�ǙǘǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǏ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜNJ�ǗǏnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǘ�����ƯǛǕǒ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐ-ǗǥǓ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǙǘǙǘǕǗǩǜǦ��ǜǘ�ǘNjǣǒǓ�ǘNjǤǪǖ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǏǓ�nj�ǜǏǡǏ-ǗǒǏ�ǔNJǕǏǗǎNJǚǗǘǍǘ�ǍǘǎNJ�ǗǏ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǙǚǏnjǥǢNJǜǦ�������Ǐnjǚǘ��NJ�ǘNjǤǪǖ�njǥnjǘ-ǎNJ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjbȃ�������Ǐnjǚǘ��ƷǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǙǘǎǡǏǚǔǗǝǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�Ǘǘǚǖǥ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǨǜ�ǒ�njǘ�ƾǚNJǗǠǒǒ��ǒ�nj�ƭǏǚǖNJǗǒǒbȃ�ǛǜǚNJǗNJǟ�Ǜ�ǗNJǒNjǘǕǏǏ�ǐǪǛǜǔǒǖ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�

Ƭ�ƻǘǏǎǒǗǪǗǗǥǟ�ǂǜNJǜNJǟ�ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǝǨǜ�ǙǚǩǖǥǏ�Ǖǒǖǒǜǥ�ǗNJ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJ-ǗǒǏ�ǙǚǏǎǘǙǕNJǡǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��ƮǕǩ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ�ǙǚǏǎǘǙǕNJǡǏǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ��ǙǘǜǚǏNjǒǜǏǕǨ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǝǔNJǑNJǜǦ�ǛnjǘǏ�ǒǖǩ��ǎNJǜǝ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�ǘǛǝ-ǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǝǎNJǕǪǗǗǘ�

Ƭ� ƫǏǕNJǚǝǛǒ�� ǡǕǏǗǏ� ƼNJǖǘǐǏǗǗǘǍǘ� ǛǘǨǑNJ�� ǚNJǑǖǏǚ� ǖNJǔǛǒǖNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǘǛǜNJǜǔNJ�ǗNJ�ǗǏǙǏǚǛǘǗǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǖ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǏ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐNJ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǎǘǛǜǒ-ǍNJǜǦ���������ǚǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǒǟ�ǚǝNjǕǏǓ��NJ�ǏǐǏǎǗǏnjǗǥǓ�Ǖǒǖǒǜ�ǙǏǚǏnjǘǎǘnj�ǝǛǜNJ-ǗǘnjǕǏǗ�ǗNJ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ��������ǚǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǒǟ�ǚǝNjǕǏǓ�

ƶǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǓ� ǘǙǥǜ� ǙǘǔNJǑǥnjNJǏǜ�� ǡǜǘ� ǝǐǏǛǜǘǡǏǗǒǏ� ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�Ǚǘb ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ� ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǥǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖ� ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǗǏǍNJǜǒnjǗǥǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǩ��Ƭ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǛǜǒ��ǙǘǛǕǏ�ǑNJ-ǙǚǏǜNJ�ǗNJ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǨ�ǙǚǏǎǘǙǕNJǡǏǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ�nj�ƭǏǚǖNJǗǒǒ��ǚǥǗǘǔ�ǧǕǏǔ-ǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎǏǗǏǍ�nj�ǧǜǘǓ�ǛǜǚNJǗǏ�ǛǘǔǚNJǜǒǕǛǩ�ǗNJ���Ɍ��

�� %DQN�6HFUHF\�$FW� ��$QWL�0RQH\�/DXQGHULQJ�([DPLQDWLRQ�0DQXDO� ���)HGHUDO�)LQDQFLDO� ΖQVWLWX-WLRQV�([DPLQDWLRQ�&RXQFLO��������3S����Ȃ����� KWWS���EDVH�FRQVXOWDQW�UX�FRQV�FJL�RQOLQH�FJL"UHT GRF�EDVH Ζ17�Q �������IUDPH ���

91ƺƸƻƻƲƳƻƴƪlj�ƾƯƮƯƺƪǀƲlj

Page 93: User identification analysis

Ƭ�ǖǒǚǘnjǘǓ�ǙǚNJǔǜǒǔǏ� njǏǎǝǣǒǟ� ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǔ�ƻǂƪ�ǒ� Ưƻ�ǗǏ� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǚNJǑǎǏǕǏǗǒǩ�ǗNJ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǒ�ǜǚNJǗǛǍǚNJǗǒǡǗǥǏ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǒ�Ǜ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏ-Ǘǒǩ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ�

Ƭ�ǛǞǏǚǏ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒ�ƲƼƹƽƷƴƼƸƶ���ƻƼƪƼdžƲ����ƱNJǔǘǗNJ�mƸ�ǛnjǩǑǒ}�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�Ǚǘǚǩǎǘǔ�ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǖǒ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǙǘbǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǙǚǏ-ǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǨ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘ�ǜǏǕǏǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛǏǜǒ�mƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ}� ǒ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǘǍǘ� ǒǖǒ� ǘǔǘǗǏǡǗǘǍǘ� ǘNjǘǚǝǎǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ǚǏǍǕNJ-ǖǏǗǜǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕNJǖǒ�ǘǔNJǑNJǗǒǩ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǏǖǥǖǒ�ƹǚNJnjǒ-ǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘǖ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�

ƹǘǚǩǎǘǔ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�Ǚǚǒ�ǑNJǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǒ�ǛǚǘǡǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚNJ� ǘNj� ǘǔNJǑNJǗǒǒ� ǚNJǑǘnjǥǟ� ǝǛǕǝǍ� Ǚǘb ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǏ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� ǒ� ǙǚǏǎǘ-ǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǨ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ� ǔ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘ�ǜǏǕǏǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ� ǛǏǜǒ�mƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ}�nj�ǙǝǗǔǜNJǟ�ǔǘǕǕǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ�ƹǚNJnjǒǕNJǖǒ�ǘǔNJǑNJǗǒǩ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǙǘbǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎǪǗǗǥǖǒ�ƹǘǛǜNJǗǘnj-ǕǏǗǒǏǖ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƺƾ�ǘǜ����ǩǗnjNJǚǩ�����b Ǎ��ȟɋ���nj�ǚǏǎNJǔǠǒǒ�Ǚǘ-ǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǓ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǘǜ����ǒǨǕǩ�����bǍ��ȟɋ����ǒ�ǘǜ����NJnjǍǝǛǜNJ�����bǍ��ȟɋ�����ǎNJǕǏǏ�ƹǚNJnjǒǕNJ��

ƸǎǗǒǖ�ǒǑ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǖǒ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖǘǜǚǏǗǗǘǍǘ� ƹǚNJnjǒǕNJǖǒ�� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǗǘǏ� ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǛǔǘǍǘ�ǗǘǖǏǚNJ�� ǗNJǑǗNJǡǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǨ�nj� ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ� Ǜ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǘǖ�ǘNj�ǘǔNJǑNJǗǒǒ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǙǘǎnjǒǐǗǘǓ�ǚNJǎǒǘǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��ǑNJ-ǔǕǨǡǏǗǗǥǖ�Ǜ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǘǖ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�

Ƭ� ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǨǣǏǓ�ǚǏǎNJǔǠǒǒ�ƹǚNJnjǒǕ�Ǚǘǚǩǎǘǔ� ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǒ� ǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǗǘ-Ǜǜǒ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǛǔǘǍǘ�ǗǘǖǏǚNJ��ǗNJǑǗNJǡǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǨ�nj�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ�Ǜ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǘǖ�ǘNj�ǘǔNJǑNJǗǒǒ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǙǘǎnjǒǐǗǘǓ�ǚNJǎǒǘǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��ǗǏ�ǝǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗ�

Ƭ�ǛǞǏǚǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍƬ� ƷƪƻƼƸljǃƲƳ�ƶƸƶƯƷƼ� ƯƻƲƪ� ǝǛǙǏǢǗǘ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǠǏǕǘǖ�ǚǩǎǏ�ǍǘǛǝ-ǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ��ǏǪ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘ�ǗNJǕǘǖ�ǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜǛǩ�ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗǥ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�� ƼǏǖ�ǗǏ�ǖǏǗǏǏ�� ǎǘǛǜǝǙ� ǔ� ƯƻƲƪ�ǘǛǜNJǪǜǛǩ� ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗ� ǚNJǖǔNJǖǒ� njǏǎǘǖǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ� ǒ� ǖǏǐnjǏǎǘǖǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ��ƮǘǛǜǝǙ�nj�ǗǏǪ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǏǎǝ�ǛǖǘǜǚǏǗ� ǎNJǐǏ� nj� ǜǏǟ� ǛǕǝǡNJǩǟ�� ǔǘǍǎNJ� ǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǥ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ� ǒ� ǡNJǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚNJ�Ǚǚǩǖǘ�ǛǘnjǙNJǎNJǨǜ�

92 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 94: User identification analysis

ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ƯƻƲƪ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǥ�ǎǕǩ�njǥ-ǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǩ� ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǖǒ� ǘNjǩǑNJǗǗǘǛǜǏǓ� Ǚǘb ǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj� ǒ� njǥǍǘǎǘǙǚǒǘNjǚǏǜNJǜǏǕǏǓ� nj� ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ� Ǜ� ƾǏ-ǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǖ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǖ� ǘǜ� ����������� ȟɋ����ƾƱ� mƸ� ǙǚǘǜǒnjǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǒ�ǕǏǍNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ� �ǘǜǖǥnjNJǗǒǨ�� ǎǘǟǘǎǘnj�� ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǥǟ� ǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǗǥǖ� ǙǝǜǏǖ��ǒ� ǞǒǗNJǗǛǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ� ǜǏǚǚǘǚǒǑǖNJ}�� ƯǎǒǗNJǩ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�njǥǙǘǕǗǩǜǦ�ǚǘǕǦ�mǗNJǎǏǐǗǘǓ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ}�ǎǕǩ�ǝǎNJ-ǕǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǒ�ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǏǗǗǘǍǘ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�Ǜ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǒǖǒ�ǒ�ǒǗǥǖǒ� ǝǡǚǏǐǎǏǗǒǩǖǒ�� ƱNJǎǏǓǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ƯƻƲƪ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǒǜ� ǔNJǚǎǒǗNJǕǦǗǘ�ǙǘnjǥǛǒǜǦ� ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǦ� ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj� ǒ� ǖǏǚ�ǙǘbǙǚǘǜǒnjǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǨ�ǘǜǖǥnjNJǗǒǨ�ǎǏǗǏǍ�ǒ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǜǏǚǚǘǚǒǑ-ǖNJ�nj�ǠǏǕǘǖ�

ƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ67

ƹƸƺƼƪƵ� ƭƸƻƽƮƪƺƻƼƬƯƷƷDžƿ� ƽƻƵƽƭ� ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ� ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ� �mLJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǏ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ}�b ȃ� ǛǙǚNJnjǘǡǗǘ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ� ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕ��ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǗǥǓ� ǗNJ� ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǏ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ� ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǒ� ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ�ǔ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩǖ�ǘ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǟ�nj�ƺǘǛ-ǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ��ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǩǟ�ǙǘbǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǨ�ǒ�ǗNJǎǑǘ-ǚǝ��ǘNj�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǟ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǡǚǏǐǎǏǗǒǓ��ǘNj�ǝǛ-ǕǝǍNJǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ��ǝǡNJǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǟ�nj�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǞǘǚǖǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�

ƬǛǏ� ǝǛǕǝǍǒ�� ǚNJǑǖǏǣǪǗǗǥǏ� ǗNJ� ǙǘǚǜNJǕǏ�� ǛǘǘǜǗǏǛǏǗǥ� Ǜ� ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǥǖ�ǚǏǍǒǘǗǘǖ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ��ǖǏǛǜǘ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǩǏǜ�ǔNJǔ�ǗNJǕǒǡǒǏ�ǛNJǖǘǓ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩ�ǏǪ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�

ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�ǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ�njbƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒƹƺƯƮǂƯƻƼƬƯƷƷƲƴƸƶ�ƲƷƼƯƺƷƯƼ�ƹƸƺƼƪƵƪ�*RVXVOXJL�UX�NjǥǕ�ǛNJǓǜ�RJLF�UX��ǚNJǑ-ǚNJNjǘǜNJǗǗǥǓ�ƾƭƽƹ�ƷƲƲ�mƬǘǛǟǘǎ}��ƹǘǛǕǏ�ǛǖǏǗǥ�ǚǝǔǘnjǘǎǛǜnjNJ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚ-ǛǜnjNJ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�NjǥǕǘ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜǘ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǏ�ǘ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔǏ�ǗǘnjǘǍǘ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕNJ�

Ƭ�NJnjǍǝǛǜǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǒǕǘ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǨ�mƺǘǛǜǏǕǏǔǘǖ}� nj� ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ� ǏǎǒǗǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ� ǒǛǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǩ� ǖǏǚǘǙǚǒǩǜǒǓ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥ�mLJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗNJǩ�ƺǘǛǛǒǩ}�nj�ǡNJǛǜǒ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ǒǗǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǥ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ��nj�ǡǒǛǕǘ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǖǏǚǘ-

�� ƺNJǑǎǏǕ�ǗNJǙǒǛNJǗ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ� ǛǜNJǜǦǒ�:LNLSHGLD�UX� mƹǘǚǜNJǕ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓ-ǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ}�

93ƺƸƻƻƲƳƻƴƪlj�ƾƯƮƯƺƪǀƲlj

Page 95: User identification analysis

ǙǚǒǩǜǒǓ�NjǥǕǘ�njǔǕǨǡǏǗǘ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ�����ǘǔǜǩNjǚǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦ-Ǜǜnjǘ� ǝǜnjǏǚǎǒǕǘ� ǙǕNJǗ� ǙǏǚǏǟǘǎNJ� ǗNJ� ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǓ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ�ǞǏ-ǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǖǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�njǕNJǛǜǒ��ƺǏǍǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒ-ǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ�ǙǘǎǕǏǐNJǕǒ�ǙǏǚǏnjǘǎǝ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�njǒǎ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǘnj��ǑNJǔǕǨǡNJǏǖǥǟ�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖǒ�njǕNJǛǜǒ�ǚǏǍǒǘ-Ǘǘnj�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖǒ�ǖǏǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǛNJǖǘǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�

ƱNJǔNJǑǡǒǔǘǖ� ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ� Ǚǘb ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǨ� ǙǘǚǜNJǕNJ� *RVXVOXJL�UX� njǥǛǜǝǙǒǕ�mƺǘǛǜǏǕǏǔǘǖ}��ǗǏǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǏǖ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJbȃ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǩ�mLJǗnjǒǐǗ� ƭǚǝǙ}�� ��� ǗǘǩNjǚǩ� ����b ǍǘǎNJ�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗ-Ǘǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǑNJǚNJNjǘǜNJǕ�nj�ǜǏǛǜǘnjǘǖ�ǚǏǐǒǖǏ��ƸǞǒǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǏ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǒǏ�Ǚǘǚ-ǜNJǕNJ� ǛǘǛǜǘǩǕǘǛǦ����ǎǏǔNJNjǚǩ�����b ǍǘǎNJ� �Ǚǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǑNJǙǝǛǔ� ǛNJǓǜNJ� ǛǘǙǚǘ-njǘǐǎNJǕǛǩ�ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖǒ�ǜǚǝǎǗǘǛǜǩǖǒ���ƷNJ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕǏ�NjǥǕNJ�ǚNJǑǖǏǣǏǗNJ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘ�����ǝǛǕǝǍNJǟ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�ǒ�NjǘǕǏǏ����bȃ�ǚǏǍǒǘ-ǗNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�

��NJǙǚǏǕǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǗNJ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕǏ�ǗNJǡNJǕ�ǚNJNjǘǜNJǜǦ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ��mǕǒǡǗǥǓ� ǔNJNjǒǗǏǜ}��� ǡǜǘ� ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǒǕǘ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǖ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǗNJ� ǛNJǓǜǏ�ǒ� ǘǜǙǚNJnjǕǩǜǦ� ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǥ�ǗNJ�ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗǒǏ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ� ǝǛǕǝǍ� �ǎǘ� ǧǜǘǍǘ� ǖǘǖǏǗǜNJ� ǗNJ� ǙǘǚǜNJǕǏ� ǖǘǐǗǘ� NjǥǕǘ� ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǗNJǓǜǒ�ǛǙǚNJnjǘǡǗǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ��

ƴ�ǒǨǕǨ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǗNJ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕǏ�ǑNJǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǕǒǛǦ�NjǘǕǏǏ�����ǜǥǛ��ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��ǒǑ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǨ�ǙǚǘǢǕǒ�NjǘǕǏǏ����ǜǥǛ��ƪnjǜǘǚǒ-ǑǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǒ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǕǒ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜǦ�ǛǙǚNJnjǘǡǗǝǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�ǘ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�njǕNJǛǜǒ�Njǘ-ǕǏǏ�����ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǩǜǦ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǏ�ǑNJǩnjǕǏǗǒǩbȃ�Ǚǘb��bǝǛǕǝǍNJǖ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǙǘǎNJǡNJ�ǗNJǕǘǍǘnjǥǟ�ǎǏǔǕNJǚNJǠǒǓ��ǕǒǠǏǗǑǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǥǟ�njǒǎǘnj�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ��

ƷNJǡǒǗNJǩ�Ǜ�ǎǏǔNJNjǚǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ�nj�ƶǘǛǔnjǏ�ǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǗNJǛǏǕǪǗǗǥǟ�ǙǝǗ-ǔǜNJǟ�ǛǜNJǕǒ�ǝǛǜNJǗNJnjǕǒnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǒǗǞǘǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǜǏǚǖǒǗNJǕǥ��mǒǗ-ǞǘǖNJǜǥ}��ǎǕǩ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�Ǜ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕǘǖ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ��ƼǏǚǖǒǗNJǕ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜǦ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǗǥǏ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǝǛ-ǕǝǍǒ�ǕǒǠNJǖ��ǗǏ�ǒǖǏǨǣǒǖ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�nj�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�

Ƭ�ǛǏǗǜǩNjǚǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǡǒǛǕǘ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǙǘǚǜNJ-ǕNJ�ǙǚǏnjǥǛǒǕǘ���ǖǕǗ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ�����ǗǘǩNjǚǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕ�NjǥǕ�ǝǎǘǛǜǘǏǗ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǗNJǍǚNJǎǥ�ǗNJ�ǠǏǚǏǖǘǗǒǒ�njǚǝǡǏǗǒǩ�ƹǚǏǖǒǒ�ƺǝǗǏǜNJ�

ƴ�ǔǘǗǠǝ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǗNJ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕǏ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ�NjǥǕǘ�ǚNJǑǖǏǣǏǗǘ��������ǝǛ-ǕǝǍ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�����ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ���������ǚǏǍǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ���������ǖǝǗǒ-

94 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 96: User identification analysis

ǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǒ����Ǚǚǘǡǒǟ��Ƭ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǕǒǛǦ����bǝǛ-ǕǝǍ��ǒǑ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ����bȃ�ǚǏǍǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǒ����bȃ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǏ��ƻǚǏǎǗǩǩ�ǙǘǛǏǣNJǏǖǘǛǜǦ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕNJ� ǛǘǛǜNJnjǒǕNJ�NjǘǕǏǏ� ��ǖǕǗ�ǙǘǛǏǜǒǜǏǕǏǓ�nj�ǖǏǛǩǠ��ǡǒǛǕǘ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǒǕǘ�����������ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ�

Ƭ� ǞǏnjǚNJǕǏ� ����b ǍǘǎNJ� NjǥǕNJ� ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǏǗNJ� ǗǘnjNJǩ� njǏǚǛǒǩ� ǙǘǚǜNJǕNJ����bNJǙǚǏǕǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǡǒǛǕǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕNJ�ǙǚǏnjǥǛǒǕǘ���ǖǕǗ�

���ǘǔǜǩNjǚǩ������ǡǒǛǕǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǙǚǏnjǥǛǒǕǘ���ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗNJ�ǡǏ-ǕǘnjǏǔ��ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩbȃ�ǘǔǘǕǘ�����ǜǥǛǩǡ�ǡǏ-ǕǘnjǏǔ�

Ƭ�ǖNJǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǝ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǙǘǩnjǒǕNJǛǦ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�njǟǘǎNJ�ǗNJ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕ�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǝǗǒnjǏǚǛNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�

��ǒǨǗǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǒǑǖǏǗǒǕNJǛǦ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏ-ǕǏǓ�

��� ǒǨǕǩ� ����b ǍǘǎNJ� ǑNJǙǝǣǏǗNJ� NjǏǜNJ�njǏǚǛǒǩ� ǘNjǗǘnjǕǏǗǗǘǍǘ� ǙǘǚǜNJǕNJ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ��ƫǏǜNJ�njǏǚǛǒǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǗNJ�ǙǘbNJǎǚǏǛǝ�EHWD�JRVXVOXJL�UX��ƷNJ�ǎNJǗǗǘǖ�ǧǜNJǙǏ�njǏǚǛǒǩ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǛǘNjǘǓ�ǎǘǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǏ�ǔ�ǜǏǔǝǣǏǖǝ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕǝ�

ƻǏǓǡNJǛ�ǗNJ�NjǏǜNJ�njǏǚǛǒǒ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǥ� ǜǚǒ� ǝǛǕǝǍǒ�� ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔNJ�ǢǜǚNJ-Ǟǘnj�ƭƲƫƮƮ� �Ǜ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǘǗǕNJǓǗ�ǘǙǕNJǜǥ��� ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔNJ�ǗNJǕǘǍǘnjǘǓ�ǒ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǘǓ� ǑNJǎǘǕǐǏǗǗǘǛǜǏǓ�� ƹǚǘnjǏǚǔNJ� ǗNJǕǘǍǘnjǘǓ� ǑNJǎǘǕǐǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ� ǎǘ-ǙǘǕǗǏǗNJ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘǖ� Ǚǘb ǝǜǘǡǗǏǗǒǨ� ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎǝNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ� ǗǘǖǏǚNJ� ǗNJǕǘǍǘ-ǙǕNJǜǏǕǦǣǒǔNJ��ƲƷƷ��

ƹǚNJnjǘnjǘǏ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏƾƽƷƴǀƲƸƷƲƺƸƬƪƷƲƯ�ƹƸƺƼƪƵƪ�*2686/8*Ζ�58�ǔNJǔ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�njǏNj�ǛNJǓǜNJ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJ-Ǡǒǒ� ǘǜ� ��� ǒǨǕǩ� ����b Ǎ��ȟɋ����ƾƱ� mƸNj� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ� ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ� ǒ� ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǝǛǕǝǍ}� ǒ� ƹǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǩ� ƹǚNJnjǒ-ǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ǘǜ����ǘǔǜǩNjǚǩ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ȟɋ�����NjǥǕǘ�ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǘ�ƹǘ-ǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ǘ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǓ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�mƯǎǒǗǥǓ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǞǝǗǔǠǒǓ�}�

ƺǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǩ�ǗNJ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍƺƯƭƲƻƼƺƪǀƲlj� Ʒƪ� ƹƸƺƼƪƵƯ� ƹƺƸƿƸƮƲƼ� Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ƯǎǒǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƯƻƲƪ���ƺǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǩ�njǔǕǨǡNJǏǜ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǧǜNJǙǘnj�Ǜ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǙǚǒnjǩǑǔǘǓ�ǒ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǘǓ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�NJǎǚǏǛNJ��ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ��NJ� ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǏǖ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJ-ǜǏǕǩ� �ǔǘǎ�ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǩ�njǥǛǥǕNJǏǜǛǩ�ǙǘǡǜǘǓ�ǕǒNjǘ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǪǜǛǩ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�

95ƺƸƻƻƲƳƻƴƪlj�ƾƯƮƯƺƪǀƲlj

Page 97: User identification analysis

ǘǞǒǛ�ƸƪƸbmƺǘǛǜǏǕǏǔǘǖ}���ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǙǏǚnjǒǡǗNJǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ�ǙǘbǙNJǛǙǘǚǜǝ�nj�ǚǏǐǒǖǏ�ǗǏǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǔǘǗǜNJǔǜNJ�Ǜǘ-ǜǚǝǎǗǒǔǘǖ� ǝǙǘǕǗǘǖǘǡǏǗǗǘǓ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ� �ƸƪƸb mƺǘǛǜǏǕǏǔǘǖ}� ǒǕǒ�ƾƭƽƹ�mƹǘǡǜNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ}��

ƪnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ǙǚǘǒǛǟǘǎǒǜ�ǙǘbǛǜǚNJǟǘnjǘǖǝ�ǗǘǖǏǚǝ�ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎǝNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǕǒǠǏnjǘǍǘ�ǛǡǪǜNJ�ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjǘǍǘ�ǛnjǒǎǏǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǙǏǗǛǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ƻƷƲƵƻ��

ƹǘǛǕǏ� ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ� ǙǏǚǏǡǏǗǦ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǗǥǟ� ǞǝǗǔǠǒǓ� ǙǘǚǜNJǕNJ� ǚNJǛ-ǢǒǚǩǏǜǛǩ�� ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ�� ǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǛǩ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǥǖ� nj� ǎnjNJ� ǔǕǒǔNJ� ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǘ�ǛǘǛǜǘǩǗǒǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘǍǘ�ǕǒǠǏnjǘǍǘ�ǛǡǪǜNJ�ǒǑ�ƹǏǗǛǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǞǘǗǎNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǘǎNJǜǦ�ǑNJǩnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǗNJ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǏ�ǑNJǍǚNJǗǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ�ǗǘnjǘǍǘ�ǙǘǔǘǕǏ-Ǘǒǩ��ǑNJǙǘǕǗǒnj�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǝǨ�Ǟǘǚǖǝ�ǗNJ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕǏ�

ƯǎǒǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƯƻƲƪ�ƯƮƲƷƪlj�ƻƲƻƼƯƶƪ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒbȃ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ� nj� ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ� ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�� ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǨǣNJǩ� ǛNJǗǔǠǒǘǗǒǚǘ-njNJǗǗǥǓ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǝǡNJǛǜǗǒǔǘnj�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ��ǍǚNJǐ-ǎNJǗ�ǑNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǏǓ�ǒ�ǎǘǕǐǗǘǛǜǗǥǟ�ǕǒǠ�ǘǚǍNJǗǘnj�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�njǕNJǛǜǒ��ǔ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�� ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǣǏǓǛǩ� nj� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǟ�ǒ�ǒǗǥǟ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǟ�

ƴ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǖ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǖ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǩǖ�ƯƻƲƪ�ǘǜǗǘǛǩǜǛǩ�• ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�• ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖǒ�• NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǩ� ǝǙǘǕǗǘǖǘǡǏǗǗǥǟ� ǕǒǠ� ǘǚǍNJǗǘnj� ǒǛǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�

njǕNJǛǜǒ�Ǚǚǒ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǏ�ǔ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǩǖ�ƯƻƲƪ�• njǏǎǏǗǒǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǘ�ǙǘǕǗǘǖǘǡǒǩǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�nj�ǘǜǗǘǢǏ-

Ǘǒǒ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ƱNJ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ƯƻƲƪ�ǘǜnjǏǡNJǏǜ�ƸƪƸbmƺǘǛǜǏǕǏǔǘǖ}�ƯƻƲƪ�ǙǚǏǎǗNJǑǗNJǡǏǗNJ�ǎǕǩ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ�• ƮǘǛǜǝǙNJ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ� ǔ� ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǖ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ� Ǜǒ-

ǛǜǏǖNJǖ� NjǏǑ� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ� ǙǘnjǜǘǚǗǘǓ� ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ� ǗNJ� ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǏǎǒǗǥǟ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǙNJǚNJǖǏǜǚǘnj� Ǜ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ� ǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǏǓ�� ƻƷƲƵƻ�ǒ� ǙNJǚǘǕǦ�� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗNJǩ� ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦ��6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǖNJǚǜ�ǔNJǚǜNJ�

• ƮǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǎǘǕǐǗǘǛǜǗǥǟ�ǕǒǠ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ�ǔ�NjNJǑǘ-njǥǖ� ǚǏǛǝǚǛNJǖ�� ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǏǗǒǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǒ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ�ǎǘǕǐǗǘǛǜǗǥǟ�ǕǒǠ�ǘǚǍNJǗǘnj�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�njǕNJǛǜǒ�Ǚǚǒ�ǖǏǐ-njǏǎǘǖǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǖ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǒ�

96 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 98: User identification analysis

• ƬǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�� ǜǘ�ǏǛǜǦ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗ-Ǘǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�Ǚǚǒ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǒ�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ƻƶLJƬ�

ƮǕǩ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ǝǡǪǜǗǘǓ�ǑNJǙǒǛǒ�nj�ƯƻƲƪ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ�ǎNJǗ-ǗǥǏ�ǕǒǠNJ�

• ƾƲƸ�• ƷǘǖǏǚ�ƻƷƲƵƻ��ƲƷƷ��• ƷǘǖǏǚ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ�• ƪǎǚǏǛ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǡǜǥ�

ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�����ƭ��ȃ�ƻƸƱƮƪƷƲƯ�ƻƲƻƼƯƶDž��ƹǏǚnjǘǗNJǡNJǕǦǗǘ�ƯƻƲƪ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǕNJ�njǘǑ-ǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ�ǗNJ�ƹǘǚǜNJǕǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ƹƭƽ���ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�Ǚǚǒ�ǎǘ-ǛǜǝǙǏ�ǔ�ƹƭƽ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǕNJǛǦ�ǙǘbǙNJǚǘǕǨ�

����bǍ�bȃ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��ƸNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǗǏ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǔ�ƹƭƽ��Ǘǘ�ǒ�ǔ�ǚǏǍǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕNJǖ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ZHE�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩǖ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ� ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ��ƸNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗNJ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ� ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǗǏ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ��Ǘǘ�ǒ�ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎǝNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǙǚǏǎǙǚǒǗǒǖNJǜǏǕǏǓ��ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǕǒǠ� ǒ� ǎǘǕǐǗǘǛǜǗǥǟ� ǕǒǠ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǕǒǠ�� ƹǘǎǎǏǚǐǔNJ�ǗǘnjǘǍǘ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒbȃ�ǙǘbǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ�

����bǍ�bȃ�ǎNJǕǦǗǏǓǢǏǏ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��ƺNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǗNJ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�njǏ-ǎǏǗǒǩ�ǚǏǏǛǜǚǘnj�ǎǘǕǐǗǘǛǜǗǥǟ�ǕǒǠ�ǘǚǍNJǗǘnj�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�njǕNJǛǜǒ�ǒ�ǒǟ� ǙǘǕǗǘǖǘǡǒǓ�� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖ� ǘǚǍNJǗǘnj� ǒǛǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�njǕNJǛǜǒ��ƸNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗNJ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�Ǚǚǒ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǏ�ǔ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖ�ǝǡNJǛǜǗǒǔǘnj�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�Ǜ�ƯƻƲƪ�

����bǍ�bȃ�ƹǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏǖ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǘǜ����ǩǗnjNJǚǩ�����bǍ��ȟɋ���mƸNj�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǙǚǘǛǜǘǓ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǎ-ǙǒǛǒ�Ǚǚǒ�ǘǔNJǑNJǗǒǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ}�ǙǚǏǎǝǛ-ǖǘǜǚǏǗǘ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�nj�ƯƻƲƪ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJ�ǘǚǍNJǗǘnj�ǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ��ǒǖǏǨǣǒǟ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ��ǑNJǖǏǗǥ��ǒ�njǥǎNJǡǒ�ǔǕǨǡNJ�ǙǚǘǛǜǘǓ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒ-Ǜǒ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǘǔNJǑNJǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘ�ǛǚǘǔNJǟ�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǩ�ǎNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǙǘǩnjǕǏǗǒǒ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǟ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǏǓ�nj�ƯƻƲƪ�ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǝǏǜ�

Ƭ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�ƸƪƸbmƺǘǛǜǏǕǏǔǘǖ}�Ǚǚǘnjǘǎǒǜ�ǚNJNjǘǜǝ�ǙǘbǎǒǞǞǏ-ǚǏǗǠǒNJǠǒǒ� ǒ� ǚNJǛǢǒǚǏǗǒǨ� ǛǙǘǛǘNjǘnj� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�

97ƺƸƻƻƲƳƻƴƪlj�ƾƯƮƯƺƪǀƲlj

Page 99: User identification analysis

Ǚǚǒ�Ǚǘǖǘǣǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��ƹǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǏǜǛǩ�ǡǜǘ�ƯƻƲƪ�ǛǖǘǐǏǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ-Ǜǩ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǖ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚǘǖ��ƸǛǗǘnjNJ�ǎNJǗǗǘǓ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�NjǥǕNJ�ǑNJǕǘ-ǐǏǗNJ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǖ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǘǜ���ǖNJǩ�����bǍ��ȟɋ����ƾƱ�mƸ�njǗǏǛǏǗǒǒ�ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǓ�nj�ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�NJǔǜǥ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ}��nj�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖ�ǙǘǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǙǘǗǩǜǒǏ�mǝǙǚǘǣǪǗǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}�

ƬǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�Ǜ�ƯƻƲƪƬƱƪƲƶƸƮƯƳƻƼƬƲƯ�ƲƷƾƸƺƶƪǀƲƸƷƷDžƿ�ƻƲƻƼƯƶ�Ǜ�ƯƻƲƪ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎ-Ǜǜnjǘǖ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ��ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�ǗNJ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǏ�6$0/�����

ƻǠǏǗNJǚǒǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�njǥǍǕǩǎǒǜ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�

��� ƹǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦ� ǘNjǚNJǣNJǏǜǛǩ� ǔ� ǑNJǣǒǣǪǗǗǘǖǝ� ǚǏǛǝǚǛǝ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJ-ǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��njǏǎǘǖǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǖǝ�ǒǕǒ�ǚǏǍǒǘǗNJǕǦ-Ǘǘǖǝ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕǝ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��

��� ƲǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǩǏǜ�nj�ƯƻƲƪ�ǑNJǙǚǘǛ�ǗNJ�NJǝǜǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�

��� ƯƻƲƪ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǩǏǜ�ǗNJǕǒǡǒǏ�ǝ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǘǓ�ǛǏǛǛǒǒ�ǒ��ǏǛǕǒ�NJǔǜǒnjǗNJǩ�ǛǏǛǛǒǩ�ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǝǏǜ��Ǚǚǘnjǘǎǒǜ�ǏǍǘ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ��ƮǕǩ�ǧǜǘǍǘ�ƯƻƲƪ�ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǗNJ�njǏNj�ǛǜǚNJǗǒǠǝ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ƯƻƲƪ��ƱNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǦ�Ǚǚǘǟǘǎǒǜ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǗǥǓ�Ǐǖǝ�ǖǏǜǘǎ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

��� ƯǛǕǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦ�ǝǛǙǏǢǗǘ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗ��ǜǘ�ƯƻƲƪ�ǙǏǚǏ-ǎNJǪǜ�nj�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǝǨ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ�ǗNJNjǘǚ�ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǓ��ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJ-ǣǒǟ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�ǘ�ǔǘǗǜǏǔǛǜǏ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǘNj�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ�ǎǘ-ǛǜǘnjǏǚǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

��� ƷNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǘǓ�ǒǑ�ƯƻƲƪ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒ-ǘǗǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑǝǏǜ�ǑNJǩnjǒǜǏǕǩ�ǗNJ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�ǑNJǣǒǣNJǏǖǘǖǝ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛǝ�

ƹǏǚǛǙǏǔǜǒnjǥ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�ƯƻƲƪƬƸƻƼƺƯƫƸƬƪƷƷƸƻƼdž� ƯƻƲƪ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǛnjǩǑNJǗNJ�Ǜǘ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǖǒ�ǗNJǙǚNJnj-ǕǏǗǒǩǖǒ�

��� ƻǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǒǏ�nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ƴNJǚǜǥ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚNJ-njǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ��ǗNJǚǩǎǝ�Ǜ�ƯƻƲƪ��ǛǜNJǗǏǜ�ǧǕǏǖǏǗǜǘǖ�ǝǗǒnjǏǚ-ǛNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǒǗNJ��ƼNJǔ��nj�ǛǏǗǜǩNjǚǏ�����bǍ��NjǥǕǘ�ǘNjǤǩnjǕǏǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�NjNJǗǔ�ƬƼƫ����ǗNJǖǏǚǏǗ�Ǜ�

98 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 100: User identification analysis

�bǩǗnjNJǚǩ�����bǍ��njǥǎNJnjNJǜǦ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�mLJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǏ�ǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ}�Ǜ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ƯƻƲƪ��ƸǙǏǚNJǜǘǚ�ƯƻƲƪbȃ�ƸƪƸbmƺǘǛǜǏǕǏǔǘǖ}bȃ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǒǕ�NjNJǗǔNJǖ�ǎǘ-ǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�ǗǏǓ��ǜNJǔ�ǡǜǘ�ǧǖǒǜǏǗǜǥ�ǡǒǙǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ�Ǚǚǒ�ǐǏǕNJǗǒǒ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǑNJǙǒǛǥnjNJǜǦ�ǗNJ�Ǘǒǟ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�Ǜ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍNJǖǒ�

��� ƺNJǑnjǒǜǒǏ�ǘNjǕNJǡǗǥǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ��ƮǕǩ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�Ǘǒǖ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ƯƻƲƪ��ƹǘǛǕǏ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJ-ǜǏǕǨ�ǜǚNJǗǛǕǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǥǓ�ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ�ǎǘnjǏǚǒǩ��nj�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜ-Ǜǜnjǒǒ�Ǜ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǖ�ǘǗ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǏǜ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǖ�ǧǜǘǖǝ�ǝǚǘnjǗǨ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ��mƺǘǛǜǏǕǏǔǘǖ}�ǔ�����bǍ��ǛǘǑǎNJǕ�ǙǕNJǜǞǘǚǖǝ�ǎǕǩ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�ǒ�ǗNJǡNJǕ�ǗNJNjǒǚNJǜǦ�ǙǘǛǜNJnjǣǒǔǘnj�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ƹǘbǘǠǏǗǔNJǖ�ǧǔǛǙǏǚǜǘnj��ǜNJǔǒǏ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǥ�ǙǘǩnjǩǜǛǩ�nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǎnjNJ�ǜǚǒ�ǍǘǎNJ�

ƲǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘ�ǙǕNJǗǒǚǝǏǖǥǟ�ǝǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǩǟ�ƯƻƲƪ��ǙǘǩnjǕǏ-Ǘǒǒ�ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǓ�ǔǚNJǓǗǏ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗNJ��ƼNJǔ��ǒǖǏǨǜǛǩ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ��ǡǜǘ� nj� ǙǏǚǛǙǏǔǜǒnjǏ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘ� njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǏ� NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ� ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜǗǥǟ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ� ƺƾ� Ǜ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ� njǏNj�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǖǒǍǚNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛǕǝǐNjǥ�

ƷǏ�ǒǛǔǕǨǡǏǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǘǩnjǒǜǛǩ�ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJ-ǜǏǕǏǓ�Ǚǚǒ�Ǚǘǖǘǣǒ�ǔnjNJǕǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǖǘ-NjǒǕǦǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��ƻǙǘǛǘNjǛǜnjǘnjNJǜǦ�ǧǜǘǖǝ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏ-ǗǒǏ�VLP�ǔNJǚǜ�Ǜ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦǨ��LJǀƹ��ǎǕǩ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnj��Ƭ�����bǍ��ǛǘǍǕNJǢǏǗǒǏ�ǘ�ǙǚǘǎNJǐǏ�6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜ�Ǜ�LJǀƹ�Ǜ�mƺǘǛǜǏǕǏ-ǔǘǖǘǖ}�ǑNJǔǕǨǡǒǕ�mƶǏǍNJǞǘǗ}�

ƹǘǚǜNJǕ�ǍǘǚǘǎǛǔǒǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ƶǘǛǔnjǥƹƸƺƼƪƵ�ƭƸƺƸƮƻƴƲƿ�ƽƻƵƽƭ�ǍǘǚǘǎNJ�ƶǘǛǔnjǥbȃ�ǛǙǚNJnjǘǡǗǘ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕ��ƹǘǚǜNJǕ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǏǜ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǒ�Ǩǚǒǎǒ-ǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ�ǔ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǘNj�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǘnj�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�njǕNJǛǜǒ�ǍǘǚǘǎNJ�ƶǘǛǔnjǥ�ǒ�ǍǘǚǘǎǛǔǒǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜǦ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖnjǒǎǏ�ǒǕǒ�nj�ǖǗǘǍǘǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǠǏǗǜǚNJǟ�ǍǘǚǘǎNJ��ƻǘǔǚNJǣǏǗǗǥǏ�ǗNJǑnjNJǗǒǩ��ƹƭƽ��ƶƹƭƽ��3*8��ƹǘǚǜNJǕ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ��ǎǘǖǏǗǗǘǏ�ǒǖǩ�3*8�026�58�

ƹǘǚǜNJǕ� ǍǘǚǘǎǛǔǒǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ� ǍǘǚǘǎNJ�ƶǘǛǔnjǥ�NjǥǕ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǗ�nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ� ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥ� ǍǘǚǘǎNJ� ƶǘǛǔnjǥ� mƲǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�Ǎǘǚǘǎ}����ƹǘǚǜNJǕ�NjǥǕ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǗ�ǒ�ǑNJǙǝǣǏǗ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ�ƮǏǙNJǚǜNJǖǏǗ-ǜǘǖ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ�ǍǘǚǘǎNJ�ƶǘǛǔnjǥ�

�� KWWS���ZZZ�PRV�UX�DERXW�JSURJUDPV�LQIRFLW\�

99ƺƸƻƻƲƳƻƴƪlj�ƾƯƮƯƺƪǀƲlj

Page 101: User identification analysis

ƮǕǩ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�ǗNJ�ƶǘǛǔǘnjǛǔǘǖ�ƹǘǚǜNJǕǏ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ� ǝǛǕǝǍ� ǍǚNJǐ-ǎNJǗNJǖ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǙǚǘǓǜǒ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǝ�ǝǙǚǘǣǪǗǗǘǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǘǕǗǘǓ�ǚǏǍǒ-ǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�

ƽǙǚǘǣǪǗǗNJǩ� ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǩ� ǙǚǘnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ� ǎǒǛǜNJǗǠǒǘǗǗǘb ȃ� ǗNJ� ǛNJǓǜǏ�SJX�PRV�UX��ƸǗNJ�ǛǘǛǜǘǒǜ�ǒǑ�ǎnjǝǟ�ǧǜNJǙǘnj�

• njnjǘǎǩǜǛǩ� ǕǒǡǗǥǏ� ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�� ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�� ǒǖǩ�� ǘǜǡǏǛǜnjǘ� ǒ� ǗǘǖǏǚ�ƻƷƲƵƻ�

• ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǏǜǛǩ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǡǜǥ�ǒ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ�

ƹǘǕǗNJǩ� ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǩ� ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ� ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ� ǛǜNJǜǝǛ� mǙǚǘnjǏǚǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ}�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ� ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ� ǔ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒ� ǑǗNJǡǒ-ǖǥǖ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ��ǁǜǘNjǥ�ǏǪ�ǙǚǘǓǜǒ��ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǕǒǡǗǘ�ǙǘǛǏǜǒǜǦ�ǕǨNjǘǓ�ǒǑ� ǛǜǘǕǒǡǗǥǟ� ǖǗǘǍǘǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǠǏǗǜǚǘnj� ǒǕǒ� ǚNJǓǘǗǗǥǟ� ǒǗǐǏ-ǗǏǚǗǥǟ� ǛǕǝǐNj� �ƭƽ� Ʋƻ�� Ǜ� ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜǘǖ� ǒ� ǛnjǒǎǏǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘǖ� ǙǏǗǛǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjNJǗǒǩ�

ƹǘǕǗNJǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕNJ�ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ�Ǜ�Ǚǘ-ǖǘǣǦǨ�ƻǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǘǖ�ǔ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛNJǖ�ǍǘǚǘǎNJ�ƶǘǛǔnjǥ��ƻƽƮƲƺ���ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗǒǚǝǨǣǏǓ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗ-ǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǖǗǘǍǘǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǠǏǗǜǚNJ�ƪƲƻ�ƶƾǀ�ƻƹƸ��ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘ-ǜNJǗǗǘǓ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǏǓ�mƵNJǗǒǜ}�ǙǘbǑNJǔNJǑǝ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjNJ�ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�� ƽǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘǖ�NJǔ-ǔNJǝǗǜNJ�nj�ƻƽƮƲƺ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ƻƷƲƵƻ��NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǗǘ�ƯƻƲƪ�

ƺǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǩ�ǗNJ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǖ�ƹǘǚǜNJǕǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��Ǜ�Ǚǘ-ǖǘǣǦǨ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ƯƻƲƪ��ǎNJǪǜ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǘǟǘǎǒǜǦ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǨ�ǗNJ�Ǚǘǚ-ǜNJǕǏ�ǍǘǚǘǎǛǔǒǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǙǘnjǜǘǚǗǘ��NJ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǝǡǏǜǗǝǨ�ǑNJǙǒǛǦ�ƯƻƲƪ�

ƻǚNJnjǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǓ�NJǗNJǕǒǑ� ǙǘbǛǜǚNJǗNJǖ

ƻƺƪƬƷƲƼƯƵdžƷDžƳ�ƪƷƪƵƲƱ�ǜǏǔǝǣǏǍǘ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�ǎǏǕ�nj�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ� ǕǒǠ� nj� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ�� NJ� ǜNJǔǐǏ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ� ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǒ� ǏǍǘ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǏǗ�nj�ǜNJNjǕǒǠǏ�

ƻǚǏǎǒ� ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǟ� njǥnjǘǎǘnj� ǛǚNJnjǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǍǘ� NJǗNJǕǒǑNJ� ǖǘǐǗǘ� njǥǎǏ-ǕǒǜǦ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ�

• Ƭǘ�njǛǏǟ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǝǏǖǥǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗNJǟ�ǙǚǒǛǝǜǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǘǡǏǗǦ�ǟǘǚǘǢǘ�Ǚǚǘ-ǚNJNjǘǜNJǗǗNJǩ� ǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjNJǩ� NjNJǑNJ� ǎǕǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ� ȟȟ

ƹNJǚ

NJǖǏǜ

ǚLJǛ

ǜǘǗǒ

ǩƻǂ

ƪƻǒ

ǗǍNJǙ

ǝǚƴǒ

ǜNJǓ

LjǐǗNJ

ǩ�ƴǘ

ǚǏǩ

ƫǚNJǑ

ǒǕǒ

ǩƬǏ

Ǖǒǔǘ

NjǚǒǜNJ

Ǘǒǩ

1ƾǘǚ

ǖNJ�Ǚǚ

NJnjǕǏ

Ǘǒǩ

ƹNJǚ

ǕNJǖǏǗ

ǜǛǔNJǩ�

ǚǏǛǙǝNjǕǒ

ǔNJƹǚǏ

ǑǒǎǏǗǜǛǔNJǩ�

ǚǏǛǙǝNjǕǒ

ǔNJƹNJǚ

ǕNJǖǏǗ

ǜǛǔNJǩ�

ǚǏǛǙǝNjǕǒ

ǔNJ�

Ǜbǎǘ

ǖǒǗ

ǒǚǝǨ

ǣǏǓ

�ǙNJ

ǚǜǒǏ

Ǔ

ƸǎǗ

ǘǙNJǚ

ǜǒǓǗ

NJǩ�

ǛǘǠǒ

NJǕǒǛǜǒǡǏ

ǛǔNJǩ�

ǚǏǛǙǝNjǕǒ

ǔNJ

ƹǚǏ

ǑǒǎǏǗǜǛǔNJǩ�

ǚǏǛǙǝNjǕǒ

ǔNJƹǚǏ

ǑǒǎǏǗǜǛǔNJǩ�

ǚǏǛǙǝNjǕǒ

ǔNJƹNJǚ

ǕNJǖǏǗ

ǜNJǚǗ

NJǩ�

ǖǘǗ

NJǚǟǒ

ǩ

�ƹǚǘ

ǚNJNjǘ

ǜNJǗǗ

ǘǛǜǦ

�Ǘǘ

ǚǖNJǜ

ǒnjǗ

ǘ�Ǚǚ

NJnjǘnj

ǘǓ�NjNJǑ

ǥ

ƸǡǏ

ǗǦ�njǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƸǡǏ

ǗǦ�njǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

�ƷNJǕ

ǒǡǒ

Ǐ�ǗNJ

ǠǒǘǗ

NJǕǦǗ

ǘǓ�

ǛǜǚNJ

ǜǏǍǒ

ǒ�

ǒbǙǘǕ

ǒǜǒ

ǔǒ

ƷNJǕǒǡ

ǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ

ƷNJǕǒǡ

ǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ

ƷNJǕǒǡ

ǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ

ƬbǩnjǗǘ

ǖ�njǒǎ

Ǐ�ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǝǏǜ

ƸǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǝǏǜ

ƷNJǕǒǡ

ǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ

ƷNJǕǒǡ

ǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ

�ƹǚǒ

ǖǏǗ

ǩǏǖǥǏ�

ǜǏǟǗ

ǘǕǘǍǒǡǏ

ǛǔǒǏ�

ǚǏǢǏǗ

ǒǩ

Ζ'�ǔNJǚ

ǜNJ���ǖǘǎ

ǝǕǦ�

njbǛǘǜǘnjǘ

ǖ�

ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗ

Ǐb��

ǝǙǚǘ

ǣǪǗ

ǗNJǩ�

ǔNJǚǜNJ�

ǛbNJǗ

NJǕǘǍǒǡ

Ǘǥǖ�

ǖǘǎ

ǝǕǏǖ

ƬǑNJǒ

ǖǗNJ

ǩ�LJǀ

ƹ�

NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞ

ǒǔNJǠ

ǒǩ�

��ǛǜNJǜǒǡ

ǏǛǔǒ

Ǐ�ǒbǎǒ

ǗNJǖǒǡ

ǏǛǔǒ

Ǐ�Njǒ

ǘǖǏǜǚǒ

ǡǏǛǔǒǏ

�ǖǏǜǘǎ

ǥ

ƮnjǝǟǧǜNJǙǗ

NJǩ�

NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞ

ǒǔNJǠ

ǒǩ��

ǝǗǒǔ

NJǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǒǎǏǗ

ǜǒǞǒǔ

NJǜǘǚ

�ǒbǙNJ

ǚǘǕǦ

���

ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐ

ǎǏǗǒ

Ǐ�ǡǏ

ǚǏǑ�60

6��

ǖǘNj

ǒǕǦǗ

ǘǏ�

ǙǚǒǕ

ǘǐǏǗ

ǒǏ��

ǞǒǑǒǡ

ǏǛǔǒ

Ǔ�ǜǘǔǏǗ

ƹNJǛǙǘ

ǚǜǗǥ

Ǐ�ǎNJǗǗ

ǥǏ���60

6�Ǚǘ

ǎǜnjǏǚǐ

ǎǏǗǒ

Ǐ

ƻǏǚǜǒǞ

ǒǔNJǜ�LJǀƹ�

��ǝǗǒǔ

NJǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǒǎǏǗ

ǜǒǞǒǔ

NJǜǘǚ

�ǒbǙNJ

ǚǘǕǦ

ƻǏǚǜǒǞ

ǒǔNJǜ�LJǀƹ�

�bǝǗǒǔ

NJǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǒǎǏǗ

ǜǒǞǒǔ

NJǜǘǚ

��Njǒ

ǘǖǏǜǚǒ

ǡǏǛǔNJǩ�

ǒǎǏǗ

ǜǒǞǒǔ

NJǠǒǩ

��ǞǒǑǒǡ

ǏǛǔǒ

Ǔ�ǜǘǔǏǗ

Ζ39���ǝǗǒǔ

NJǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǒǎǏǗ

ǜǒǞǒǔ

NJǜǘǚ

��ǛǜNJǜǒǡ

ǏǛǔǒ

Ǐ�ǒbǎǒ

ǗNJǖǒǡ

ǏǛǔǒ

Ǐ�Njǒ

ǘǖǏǜǚǒ

ǡǏǛǔǒǏ

�ǖǏǜǘǎ

ǥ

�ƶǘNj

ǒǕǦ

ǗNJǩ�

ǔǘǖǙǘ

ǗǏǗǜ

NJ��ǑNJǎ

ǏǓǛǜnjǘ

njNJǗǒ

Ǐ�ǜǏ

ǕǏǔǘ

ǖ�

ǘǙǏǚ

NJǜǘǚ

ǘnj��

ƮNJ

ƷǏǜ

ƮNJ

ƮNJ

ƮNJ

ƷǏǜ

ƷǏǜ

�LJǔ

ǘǗǘǖ

ǒǡǏ

ǛǔǒǓ�

ǧǞǞǏǔ

ǜƹǘǕ

ǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǛǒǕǦ

ǗǥǓ

ƹǘǕ

ǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǛǚǏǎǗǒ

ǓƹǘǕ

ǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǛǒǕǦ

ǗǥǓ

ƹǘǕ

ǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǛǒǕǦ

ǗǥǓ

ƷǏǍNJǜǒnj

ǗǥǓ�

ǛǒǕǦ

ǗǥǓ

ƹǘǕ

ǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǛǚǏǎǗǒ

ǓƹǘǕ

ǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǛǒǕǦ

ǗǥǓ

�ƭǘ

ǛǝǎNJ

ǚǛǜnj

ǏǗǗǘ

�ǡNJ

ǛǜǗǘ

Ǐ�ǙNJ

ǚǜǗǏ

ǚǛǜnj

ǘ

ƮNJ

ƮNJ

ƮNJ

ƷǏǜ

ƮNJ

ƮNJ

ƮNJ

�Ƭǘ

Ǒǖǘǐ

ǗǘǛǜǦ�

ǙǚǒǖǏǗ

ǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ

�njbƺƾ

ƻǚǏǎǗǩ

ǩƷǒǑǔNJǩ

ƻǚǏǎǗǩ

ǩƻǚ

ǏǎǗǩ

ǩƬǥ

ǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

�ǀǏǕ

ǏǛǘǘ

NjǚNJǑ

ǗǘǛǜǦ�

ǙǚǒǖǏǗ

ǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ

�njbƺƾ

ƻǚǏǎǗǩ

ǩƬǥ

ǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƻǚǏǎǗǩ

ǩƷǒǑǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

100 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƸƹDžƼ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƬbƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�ƻƼƺƪƷƪƿ�ƶƲƺƪ

Page 102: User identification analysis

ƮǕǩ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�ǗNJ�ƶǘǛǔǘnjǛǔǘǖ�ƹǘǚǜNJǕǏ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ� ǝǛǕǝǍ� ǍǚNJǐ-ǎNJǗNJǖ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǙǚǘǓǜǒ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǝ�ǝǙǚǘǣǪǗǗǘǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǘǕǗǘǓ�ǚǏǍǒ-ǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�

ƽǙǚǘǣǪǗǗNJǩ� ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǩ� ǙǚǘnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ� ǎǒǛǜNJǗǠǒǘǗǗǘb ȃ� ǗNJ� ǛNJǓǜǏ�SJX�PRV�UX��ƸǗNJ�ǛǘǛǜǘǒǜ�ǒǑ�ǎnjǝǟ�ǧǜNJǙǘnj�

• njnjǘǎǩǜǛǩ� ǕǒǡǗǥǏ� ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�� ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�� ǒǖǩ�� ǘǜǡǏǛǜnjǘ� ǒ� ǗǘǖǏǚ�ƻƷƲƵƻ�

• ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǏǜǛǩ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǡǜǥ�ǒ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ�

ƹǘǕǗNJǩ� ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǩ� ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ� ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ� ǛǜNJǜǝǛ� mǙǚǘnjǏǚǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ}�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ� ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ� ǔ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒ� ǑǗNJǡǒ-ǖǥǖ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ��ǁǜǘNjǥ�ǏǪ�ǙǚǘǓǜǒ��ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǕǒǡǗǘ�ǙǘǛǏǜǒǜǦ�ǕǨNjǘǓ�ǒǑ� ǛǜǘǕǒǡǗǥǟ� ǖǗǘǍǘǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǠǏǗǜǚǘnj� ǒǕǒ� ǚNJǓǘǗǗǥǟ� ǒǗǐǏ-ǗǏǚǗǥǟ� ǛǕǝǐNj� �ƭƽ� Ʋƻ�� Ǜ� ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜǘǖ� ǒ� ǛnjǒǎǏǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘǖ� ǙǏǗǛǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjNJǗǒǩ�

ƹǘǕǗNJǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕNJ�ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ�Ǜ�Ǚǘ-ǖǘǣǦǨ�ƻǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǘǖ�ǔ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛNJǖ�ǍǘǚǘǎNJ�ƶǘǛǔnjǥ��ƻƽƮƲƺ���ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗǒǚǝǨǣǏǓ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗ-ǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǖǗǘǍǘǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǠǏǗǜǚNJ�ƪƲƻ�ƶƾǀ�ƻƹƸ��ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘ-ǜNJǗǗǘǓ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǏǓ�mƵNJǗǒǜ}�ǙǘbǑNJǔNJǑǝ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjNJ�ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�� ƽǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘǖ�NJǔ-ǔNJǝǗǜNJ�nj�ƻƽƮƲƺ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ƻƷƲƵƻ��NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǗǘ�ƯƻƲƪ�

ƺǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǩ�ǗNJ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǖ�ƹǘǚǜNJǕǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��Ǜ�Ǚǘ-ǖǘǣǦǨ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ƯƻƲƪ��ǎNJǪǜ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǘǟǘǎǒǜǦ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǨ�ǗNJ�Ǚǘǚ-ǜNJǕǏ�ǍǘǚǘǎǛǔǒǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǙǘnjǜǘǚǗǘ��NJ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǝǡǏǜǗǝǨ�ǑNJǙǒǛǦ�ƯƻƲƪ�

ƻǚNJnjǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǓ�NJǗNJǕǒǑ� ǙǘbǛǜǚNJǗNJǖ

ƻƺƪƬƷƲƼƯƵdžƷDžƳ�ƪƷƪƵƲƱ�ǜǏǔǝǣǏǍǘ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�ǎǏǕ�nj�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ� ǕǒǠ� nj� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ�� NJ� ǜNJǔǐǏ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ� ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǒ� ǏǍǘ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǏǗ�nj�ǜNJNjǕǒǠǏ�

ƻǚǏǎǒ� ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǟ� njǥnjǘǎǘnj� ǛǚNJnjǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǍǘ� NJǗNJǕǒǑNJ� ǖǘǐǗǘ� njǥǎǏ-ǕǒǜǦ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ�

• Ƭǘ�njǛǏǟ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǝǏǖǥǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗNJǟ�ǙǚǒǛǝǜǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǘǡǏǗǦ�ǟǘǚǘǢǘ�Ǚǚǘ-ǚNJNjǘǜNJǗǗNJǩ� ǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjNJǩ� NjNJǑNJ� ǎǕǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ� ȟ

ȟƹNJǚ

NJǖǏǜ

ǚLJǛ

ǜǘǗǒ

ǩƻǂ

ƪƻǒ

ǗǍNJǙ

ǝǚƴǒ

ǜNJǓ

LjǐǗNJ

ǩ�ƴǘ

ǚǏǩ

ƫǚNJǑ

ǒǕǒ

ǩƬǏ

Ǖǒǔǘ

NjǚǒǜNJ

Ǘǒǩ

1ƾǘǚ

ǖNJ�Ǚǚ

NJnjǕǏ

Ǘǒǩ

ƹNJǚ

ǕNJǖǏǗ

ǜǛǔNJǩ�

ǚǏǛǙǝNjǕǒ

ǔNJƹǚǏ

ǑǒǎǏǗǜǛǔNJǩ�

ǚǏǛǙǝNjǕǒ

ǔNJƹNJǚ

ǕNJǖǏǗ

ǜǛǔNJǩ�

ǚǏǛǙǝNjǕǒ

ǔNJ�

Ǜbǎǘ

ǖǒǗ

ǒǚǝǨ

ǣǏǓ

�ǙNJ

ǚǜǒǏ

Ǔ

ƸǎǗ

ǘǙNJǚ

ǜǒǓǗ

NJǩ�

ǛǘǠǒ

NJǕǒǛǜǒǡǏ

ǛǔNJǩ�

ǚǏǛǙǝNjǕǒ

ǔNJ

ƹǚǏ

ǑǒǎǏǗǜǛǔNJǩ�

ǚǏǛǙǝNjǕǒ

ǔNJƹǚǏ

ǑǒǎǏǗǜǛǔNJǩ�

ǚǏǛǙǝNjǕǒ

ǔNJƹNJǚ

ǕNJǖǏǗ

ǜNJǚǗ

NJǩ�

ǖǘǗ

NJǚǟǒ

ǩ

�ƹǚǘ

ǚNJNjǘ

ǜNJǗǗ

ǘǛǜǦ

�Ǘǘ

ǚǖNJǜ

ǒnjǗ

ǘ�Ǚǚ

NJnjǘnj

ǘǓ�NjNJǑ

ǥ

ƸǡǏ

ǗǦ�njǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƸǡǏ

ǗǦ�njǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

�ƷNJǕ

ǒǡǒ

Ǐ�ǗNJ

ǠǒǘǗ

NJǕǦǗ

ǘǓ�

ǛǜǚNJ

ǜǏǍǒ

ǒ�

ǒbǙǘǕ

ǒǜǒ

ǔǒ

ƷNJǕǒǡ

ǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ

ƷNJǕǒǡ

ǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ

ƷNJǕǒǡ

ǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ

ƬbǩnjǗǘ

ǖ�njǒǎ

Ǐ�ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǝǏǜ

ƸǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǝǏǜ

ƷNJǕǒǡ

ǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ

ƷNJǕǒǡ

ǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ

�ƹǚǒ

ǖǏǗ

ǩǏǖǥǏ�

ǜǏǟǗ

ǘǕǘǍǒǡǏ

ǛǔǒǏ�

ǚǏǢǏǗ

ǒǩ

Ζ'�ǔNJǚ

ǜNJ���ǖǘǎ

ǝǕǦ�

njbǛǘǜǘnjǘ

ǖ�

ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗ

Ǐb��

ǝǙǚǘ

ǣǪǗ

ǗNJǩ�

ǔNJǚǜNJ�

ǛbNJǗ

NJǕǘǍǒǡ

Ǘǥǖ�

ǖǘǎ

ǝǕǏǖ

ƬǑNJǒ

ǖǗNJ

ǩ�LJǀ

ƹ�

NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞ

ǒǔNJǠ

ǒǩ�

��ǛǜNJǜǒǡ

ǏǛǔǒ

Ǐ�ǒbǎǒ

ǗNJǖǒǡ

ǏǛǔǒ

Ǐ�Njǒ

ǘǖǏǜǚǒ

ǡǏǛǔǒǏ

�ǖǏǜǘǎ

ǥ

ƮnjǝǟǧǜNJǙǗ

NJǩ�

NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞ

ǒǔNJǠ

ǒǩ��

ǝǗǒǔ

NJǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǒǎǏǗ

ǜǒǞǒǔ

NJǜǘǚ

�ǒbǙNJ

ǚǘǕǦ

���

ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐ

ǎǏǗǒ

Ǐ�ǡǏ

ǚǏǑ�60

6��

ǖǘNj

ǒǕǦǗ

ǘǏ�

ǙǚǒǕ

ǘǐǏǗ

ǒǏ��

ǞǒǑǒǡ

ǏǛǔǒ

Ǔ�ǜǘǔǏǗ

ƹNJǛǙǘ

ǚǜǗǥ

Ǐ�ǎNJǗǗ

ǥǏ���60

6�Ǚǘ

ǎǜnjǏǚǐ

ǎǏǗǒ

Ǐ

ƻǏǚǜǒǞ

ǒǔNJǜ�LJǀƹ�

��ǝǗǒǔ

NJǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǒǎǏǗ

ǜǒǞǒǔ

NJǜǘǚ

�ǒbǙNJ

ǚǘǕǦ

ƻǏǚǜǒǞ

ǒǔNJǜ�LJǀƹ�

�bǝǗǒǔ

NJǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǒǎǏǗ

ǜǒǞǒǔ

NJǜǘǚ

��Njǒ

ǘǖǏǜǚǒ

ǡǏǛǔNJǩ�

ǒǎǏǗ

ǜǒǞǒǔ

NJǠǒǩ

��ǞǒǑǒǡ

ǏǛǔǒ

Ǔ�ǜǘǔǏǗ

Ζ39���ǝǗǒǔ

NJǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǒǎǏǗ

ǜǒǞǒǔ

NJǜǘǚ

��ǛǜNJǜǒǡ

ǏǛǔǒ

Ǐ�ǒbǎǒ

ǗNJǖǒǡ

ǏǛǔǒ

Ǐ�Njǒ

ǘǖǏǜǚǒ

ǡǏǛǔǒǏ

�ǖǏǜǘǎ

ǥ

�ƶǘNj

ǒǕǦ

ǗNJǩ�

ǔǘǖǙǘ

ǗǏǗǜ

NJ��ǑNJǎ

ǏǓǛǜnjǘ

njNJǗǒ

Ǐ�ǜǏ

ǕǏǔǘ

ǖ�

ǘǙǏǚ

NJǜǘǚ

ǘnj��

ƮNJ

ƷǏǜ

ƮNJ

ƮNJ

ƮNJ

ƷǏǜ

ƷǏǜ

�LJǔ

ǘǗǘǖ

ǒǡǏ

ǛǔǒǓ�

ǧǞǞǏǔ

ǜƹǘǕ

ǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǛǒǕǦ

ǗǥǓ

ƹǘǕ

ǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǛǚǏǎǗǒ

ǓƹǘǕ

ǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǛǒǕǦ

ǗǥǓ

ƹǘǕ

ǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǛǒǕǦ

ǗǥǓ

ƷǏǍNJǜǒnj

ǗǥǓ�

ǛǒǕǦ

ǗǥǓ

ƹǘǕ

ǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǛǚǏǎǗǒ

ǓƹǘǕ

ǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗ

ǥǓ�

ǛǒǕǦ

ǗǥǓ

�ƭǘ

ǛǝǎNJ

ǚǛǜnj

ǏǗǗǘ

�ǡNJ

ǛǜǗǘ

Ǐ�ǙNJ

ǚǜǗǏ

ǚǛǜnj

ǘ

ƮNJ

ƮNJ

ƮNJ

ƷǏǜ

ƮNJ

ƮNJ

ƮNJ

�Ƭǘ

Ǒǖǘǐ

ǗǘǛǜǦ�

ǙǚǒǖǏǗ

ǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ

�njbƺƾ

ƻǚǏǎǗǩ

ǩƷǒǑǔNJǩ

ƻǚǏǎǗǩ

ǩƻǚ

ǏǎǗǩ

ǩƬǥ

ǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

�ǀǏǕ

ǏǛǘǘ

NjǚNJǑ

ǗǘǛǜǦ�

ǙǚǒǖǏǗ

ǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǚ

�njbƺƾ

ƻǚǏǎǗǩ

ǩƬǥ

ǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƻǚǏǎǗǩ

ǩƷǒǑǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

ƬǥǛǘǔNJǩ

101ƺƸƻƻƲƳƻƴƪlj�ƾƯƮƯƺƪǀƲlj

Page 103: User identification analysis

• ƹǚNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�njǘ�njǛǏǟ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǝǏǖǥǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗNJǟ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǗ�njǥǛǘǔǘ-ǝǚǘnjǗǏnjǥǓ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜ� ǜǒǙNJ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ� ǛǜǚNJǜǏǍǒǒ�� ǘǙǚǏ-ǎǏǕǩǨǣǒǓ� ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ� ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔǒ� nj� ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�

• ƺǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǘnj�ǙǘbǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǗǏ�ǑNJnjǒ-Ǜǒǜ�ǘǜ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�ǎǏǖǘǔǚNJǜǒǒ�ǒ�Ǟǘǚǖǥ�ǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ�

• ƱNJǎǏǓǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǓ� ǔǘǖǙǘǗǏǗǜǥ� ǗǏ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǘNjǩ-ǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǏǖ�ǝǛǙǏǢǗǘǍǘ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǩ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǘnj�ǙǘbǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

• ƹǘǡǜǒ�njǘ�njǛǏǟ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǝǏǖǥǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗNJǟ�ǘNjǗNJǚǝǐǏǗ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǛǒǕǦ-ǗǥǓ�ǙǘǕǘǐǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǓ� ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ� ǧǞǞǏǔǜ� ǘǜ� ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǘnj�ǙǘbǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��ƲǛǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǏ�ǛǘǛǜNJnj-ǕǩǏǜ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜ�LjǐǗǘǓ�ƴǘǚǏǒ��ǒǖǏǨǣǒǓ�ǔǘǗǠǏǙǜǝNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǗǏǎǘǛǜNJǜǔǒ�

• ƹǘǡǜǒ�ǎǕǩ�njǛǏǟ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǘnj�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǗǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǙNJǚǜǗǏǚǛǜnjNJ�Ǚǚǒ�ǒǟ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�

• ƷNJǒNjǘǕǏǏ� ǑǗNJǡǒǖǥǖ� ǎǕǩ� ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ� Ǚǘb ǛǘǘǜǗǘǢǏ-ǗǒǨ�mnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǗǥǟ�ǖǏǚ}�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǘǙǥǜ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ��ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ�ǒ�ƬǏǕǒǔǘNjǚǒǜNJǗǒǒ�

• ƻǚǏǎǒ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ�ǜǒǙǒǡǗǥǖ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǛǘǡǏǜNJǗǒǏ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜǘnj��Ǣǒǚǘǔǘ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǎǘǚNJ-NjǘǜǔNJ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖNJ�LJǀƹ�

102

Page 104: User identification analysis

ƭƵƪƬƪ��

ƼǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ

ƹǘǗǩǜǒǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ

ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƪlj�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲljbȃ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǏ-ǗǒǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǖ�ǛnjǘǏǍǘ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǘNjǚNJǑNJ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǘǜǙǏ-ǡNJǜǔNJ�ǙNJǕǦǠNJ��ƫǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǘNjǚNJǑǥ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǝǨǜǛǩ�nj�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ�Ǜ� ǑNJǚNJǗǏǏ� ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǪǗǗǥǖ�ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǘǖ�ǒ� ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ� ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǖǒ�� ǡǜǘ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǏǜ�NjǘǕǦǢǝǨ�ǗNJǎǪǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�

ƻǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�nj�njǒǎǝ��ǡǜǘ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ�ǘǜǕǒǡNJǨǜǛǩ�ǘǜ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�Ǜ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǏǓ��ƺNJǑǗǒ-ǠNJ�ǑNJǔǕǨǡNJǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǚNJNjǘǜNJǨǜ�nj� NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǖ�ǚǏǐǒǖǏ�� ǙǚNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�njǛǏǍǎNJ�ǙǘǎǚNJǑǝǖǏnjNJǩ� NJnj-ǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǨ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�� ƫǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǚNJNjǘǜNJǜǦ�nj�ǙNJǛǛǒnjǗǘǖ�ǚǏǐǒǖǏ�nj�ǗǝǐǎNJǟ�ǙǘǕǒǠǏǓǛǔǘǍǘ�ǗNJǎǑǘǚNJ��ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǚNJǑnjǏǎǔǒ�

ƶǏǜǘǎǥ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǏǕǩǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǎnjNJ�ǔǕNJǛǛNJ�• ƻǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǥ�ǗNJ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǒ�ǞǒǑǒǘǕǘǍǒ-

ǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǗNJǟǘǎǩǜǛǩ�Ǚǚǒ�ǗǪǖ�ǘǜ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǩ�ǎǘ�ǛǖǏǚǜǒ��ƴ�ǛǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǖ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJǖ�ǘǜǗǘǛǩǜ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǠǒǨ�ǙǘbǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔNJǖ�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��ǚǒǛǝǗǔǝ�ǛǏǜǡNJǜǔǒ�ǍǕNJǑNJ��ǘǛǘNjǏǗ-ǗǘǛǜǩǖ�ǚNJǎǝǐǗǘǓ�ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔǒ�ǍǕNJǑNJ��ǍǏǘǖǏǜǚǒǒ�ǔǒǛǜǒ�ǚǝǔǒ��ǍǏǘǖǏ-ǜǚǒǒ�ǕǒǠNJ��ǜǏǚǖǘǍǚNJǖǖǏ�ǕǒǠNJ��ǞǚNJǍǖǏǗǜǝ�ǍǏǗǏǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǔǘǎNJ�

• ƮǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ� ǖǏǜǘǎǥ� ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǥ�ǗNJ�NJǗNJǕǒǑǏ�ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘǛǜǏǓ�Ǚǘ-njǏǎǏǗǒǩ��ǜǘ�ǏǛǜǦ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǗǥǟ�ǡǏǚǜ��ǙǘǎǛǘǑǗNJǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǎǏǖǘǗǛǜǚǒ-ǚǝǏǖǥǟ� ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔǘǖ� nj� ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǏ� njǘǛǙǚǘǒǑnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ� ǔNJǔǘǍǘ�ǕǒNjǘ�ǘNjǥǎǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ��ƴ�ǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǖ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJǖ�ǘǜǗǘǛǩǜ�NJǝǜǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�ǙǘbǍǘǕǘǛǝ��ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǗǘǖǝ�ǙǘǡǏǚǔǝ��ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ�ǒ�ǎǚ�

103

Page 105: User identification analysis

ƹǚǒǖǏǚǥ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǏǖǥǟ�njbǙǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǟ��NJ�ȃ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖNJ�86�9Ζ6Ζ7��

ǞǒǔǛǒǚǝǨǣNJǩ�ǞNJǔǜ�ǙǏǚǏǛǏǡǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǍǚNJǗǒǠ��ǑNJǙǒǛǥnjNJǏǜ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǒ�njǛǏǟ�ǎǏǛǩǜǒ�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj�ǙǘǎNJǜǏǕǩ�ǑNJǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǗNJ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǏ�njǒǑǥ��Nj�ȃ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǒǟ�ǛǘǛǜǘǩǗǒǓ�$DGKDDU��ƲǗǎǒǩ���Ǚǘǖǒǖǘ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǘnj�

��bǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��ǛǘǟǚNJǗǩǏǜ�ǛǗǒǖǔǒ�ǚNJǎǝǐǗǘǓ�ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔǒ�ǍǕNJǑNJ�ǒ�ǕǒǠNJ��nj�ȃ�nj�ǠǏǗǜǚǏ�ǘǜǎǥǟNJ�'LVQH\�:RUOG�nj�ƸǚǕNJǗǎǘ��ǢǜNJǜ�ƾǕǘǚǒǎNJ��ǎǕǩ�ǙǚǏǎǘǜnjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǎǎǏǕǔǒ�

NjǒǕǏǜǘnj�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜǛǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǘnj�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��Ǎ�ȃ�njǘ�ǖǗǘǍǒǟ�NjNJǗǔNJǟ�ljǙǘǗǒǒ�ǒ�ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǒ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǨǜǛǩ�NjNJǗǔǘǖNJǜǥ��

ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǝǨǣǒǏ�ǚǒǛǝǗǘǔ�njǏǗ�ǕNJǎǘǗǒ

ƷNJ�ǖǒǚǘnjǘǖ�ǚǥǗǔǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�nj�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǘǖ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnj-ǕǏǗǥ�ǛǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ��ƼNJǔ��ǛǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǘǜǡǏǜǝ�ΖQWHUQDWLRQDO�%LRPHWULF�*URXS� �ZZZ�ELRPHWULFJURXS�FRP��� nj� ����b Ǎǘǎǝ� ��Ɍ�� ǚǥǗǔNJ� ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǕǒ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚǥ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǘnj�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��ǗNJ�ǘǛǜNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǛǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�Ǚǚǒ-ǟǘǎǒǕǘǛǦ�nj�ǛǝǖǖǏ���Ɍ���ǒ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ���Ɍ��ǚǥǗǔNJ�ǑNJǗǒǖNJǕǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǎǒǗNJ-ǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǔǘǖNjǒǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�nj�Ǚǘ-ǛǕǏǎǗǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘ�ǚNJǑnjǒnjNJǨǜǛǩ��ƻ� ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ�ǛǏǜǏnjǥǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ�ǘǛǘNjǥǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǏǛ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǜ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�NJǝ-ǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ�ǒ�ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǗǘǖǝ�ǙǘǡǏǚǔǝ�

Ƭ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘ�ǚNJǑnjǒnjNJ-ǨǜǛǩ�� Ǚǘǧǜǘǖǝ� ǘǡǏǗǦ� NJǔǜǝNJǕǦǗǘǓ� ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǘǓ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǘnj� ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjNJ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj� ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�� ƻǚǏǎǒ� ǛǙǏǠǒ-NJǕǒǛǜǘnj�NjǘǕǦǢǘǏ�ǑǗNJǡǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚǒǎNJǏǜǛǩ�ǛǏǚǜǒǞǒǔNJǜNJǖ�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjNJ��njǥǎNJǗ-Ǘǥǖ� ƶǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǘǓ� NJǛǛǘǠǒNJǠǒǏǓ� Ǚǘb ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǘǓ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��ΖQWHUQDWLRQDO�&RPSXWHU�6HFXULW\�$VVRFLDWLRQ��Ζ&6$��

104 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƲ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ

Page 106: User identification analysis

ƻǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ

ƻǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǘnj�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnjƻƴƪƷƲƺƸƬƪƷƲƯ�ƸƼƹƯǁƪƼƴƸƬ�ƹƪƵdžǀƯƬ��ǎNJǔǜǒǕǘǛǔǘǙǒǩ�bȃ�ǛNJǖNJǩ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJ-ǗǪǗǗNJǩ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǩ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� Ƭ� ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ� ǧǜǘǜ� ǖǏǜǘǎ� NJǔǜǒnjǗǘ� ǙǚǘǙNJǍNJǗǎǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ� ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖǒ� ǒǑ�ǑNJ� ǔǚǝǙǗǥǟ� NJǛǛǒǍǗǘnjNJǗǒǓ� nj� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǏ� NJǚǟǒnjǥ� ǘǜǙǏ-ǡNJǜǔǘnj�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��ƯǍǘ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ�ǙǚǏǒǖǝǣǏǛǜnjNJbȃ�ǧǜǘ�ǕǪǍǔǘǛǜǦ�nj�ǒǛǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǒ� ǝǗǒnjǏǚǛNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�� ƻǔNJǗǏǚǥ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǘnj� ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj� ǗǏnjǏǕǒǔǒ�ǙǘbǚNJǑǖǏǚNJǖ�ǒ�ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǗǏǎǘǚǘǍǒ��ƴ�ǜǘǖǝbǐǏ�ǜNJǔNJǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǩ�ǙǚǘǒǛǟǘǎǒǜ�NjǥǛǜǚǘ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǗǏ�ǗǝǐǗǘ�ǛǚNJnjǗǒnjNJǜǦ�Ǜ�NjNJǑǘǓ�ǎNJǗ-Ǘǥǟ� ǔNJǐǎǝǨ� ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǝǨ� ǕǒǗǒǨ� ǝǑǘǚNJ�� ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ� ǗNJǓǜǒ� ǛǘnjǙNJǎǏǗǒǏ�nj�ǔǚǝǙǗǥǟ�NjǕǘǔNJǟ��NJ�Ǚǘǜǘǖ�ǙǚǘNJǗNJǕǒǑǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǜNJǔ�ǗNJǑǥnjNJǏǖǥǏ�ǖǒǗǝ-Ǡǒǒbȃ�ǘǔǘǗǡNJǗǒǩ�ǕǒǗǒǓ� �ǚNJǑǚǥnjǥ��ǚNJǑǎnjǘǏǗǒǩ�ǒbǜ�ɋǎ����ƬǛǏ�ǧǜǒ�ǔNJǡǏ-ǛǜnjNJ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚǥ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǘnj�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj�ǗǏ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�nj�ǔǚǒǖǒǗNJǕǒǛǜǒǔǏ��Ǘǘ�ǒ�nj�NjǒǑǗǏǛǏ�ǒ�ǎNJǐǏ�nj�Njǥǜǝ��Ʋǟ�njǛǜǚNJǒnjNJǨǜ�nj�ǗǏ-ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǗǘǝǜNjǝǔǒ��ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǏ�ǖǥǢǒ��ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǥ��ǞǕǏǢ�ǔNJǚǜǥ��NJ�Ǜ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜNJ�njǥǟǘǎNJ�Ζ3KRQH��6bȃ�ǒ�nj�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǥ�

ƻǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ� Ǚǘb ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔNJǖ� ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj� ǎǏǖǘǗǛǜǚǒǚǝǨǜ�njǥǛǘǔǒǏ�ǙǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǒ�ǜǘǡǗǘǛǜǒ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǒ�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj�ǝ�ǕǨǎǏǓ�ǙǘnjǜǘǚǩǨǜǛǩ� Ǜ� ǗǒǡǜǘǐǗǘǓ� njǏǚǘǩǜǗǘǛǜǦǨ� ��Ȃ��Ɍ��� Ǚǚǒ� ǧǜǘǖ� ǒǟ� ǗǏnjǘǑ-ǖǘǐǗǘ�njǒǎǘǒǑǖǏǗǒǜǦ��Ʒǒ�ǙǘǚǏǑǥ��Ǘǒ�ǘǐǘǍǒ��Ǘǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǏ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙǘnjǚǏǐǎǏǗǒǩ� ǔǘǐǒ� ǗǏ� ǒǖǏǨǜ� ǑǗNJǡǏǗǒǩ�� ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ� ǝǛǜǘǓǡǒnjǘǛǜǦ� ǙNJ-ǙǒǕǕǩǚǗǘǍǘ�ǝǑǘǚNJ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ�ǚǏǍǏǗǏǚNJǜǒnjǗǘǓ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǘǛ-ǗǘnjǗǘǍǘ�ǛǕǘǩ�ǧǙǒǎǏǚǖǒǛNJ�ǔǘǐǒ��ƹǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǒǜǏǕǒ�ǘNjǥǡǗǘ�ǑNJǩnjǕǩǨǜ��ǡǜǘ�njǏǚǘǩǜǗǘǛǜǦ�ǘǢǒNjǘǡǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǜNJǔǒǖǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖǒ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǎǕǩ�ǗǏNJnjǜǘǚǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ������Ɍ���njǏǚǘǩǜǗǘǛǜǦ�ǘǢǒNjǘǡǗǘǍǘ� ǘǜǔNJǑNJ� nj� ǎǘǛǜǝǙǏ� �ǜNJǔ� ǗNJǑǥnjNJǏǖǘǓ� ǘǢǒNjǔǒ� ǗǏǙǚǒǑǗNJ-Ǘǒǩ�bȃ�����Ɍ���Ƭ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�njǜǘǚNJǩ�njǏǕǒǡǒǗNJ�ǝ�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�Ǜǒ-ǛǜǏǖ�ǗNJ�Ǚǘǚǩǎǘǔ�njǥǢǏ��ƹǚǒǡǒǗNJ�ǛǘǛǜǘǒǜ�nj�ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǚǒǛǝǗǘǔ�ǙNJǙǒǕǕǩǚ-Ǘǥǟ�ǕǒǗǒǓ�ǘǡǏǗǦ�ǖǏǕǔǒǓ��ǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǏǍǘ�NJǗNJǕǒǑNJ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜǛǩ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǛǕǘǐǗǥǏ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǥ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǙǘǎnjǏǚǐǏǗǥ�ǛNjǘǩǖ�Ǚǚǒ�ǙǕǘǟǘǖ�ǔǘǗǜNJǔǜǏ�ǙNJǕǦǠNJ� Ǜǘ� ǛǔNJǗǏǚǘǖ�� ƫǘǕǏǏ� ǛǏǚǦǏǑǗǥǓ�ǖǒǗǝǛ� ǧǜǘǓ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒbȃ� ǜǘ��ǡǜǘ� NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǘ� ǛǔNJǗǏǚǘnj� ǖǘǐǗǘ� ǘNjǖNJǗǝǜǦ� Ǚǚǒ� Ǚǘǖǘǣǒ� ǖǏǚǜnjǘǍǘ�ǙNJǕǦǠNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǖǝǕǩǐNJ�

ƹǘbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǖ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǖ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙNJǖ�njǛǏ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚǥ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǚNJǑ-ǎǏǕǒǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǜǚǒ�NjǘǕǦǢǒǟ�ǍǚǝǙǙǥ�

105ƻƼƪƼƲǁƯƻƴƲƯ�ƶƯƼƸƮDž�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ

Page 107: User identification analysis

• ƸǙǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ ǛǔNJǗǏǚǥ��ǚNJNjǘǜNJǨǣǒǏ�ǗNJ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǏ�ǘǜǚNJǐǏǗǒǩ�ǒǕǒ�ǗNJ�ǙǚǘǛnjǏǜ��ƸǙǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǖǏǜǘǎ�ǎǏǢǏnjǕǏ�ǒ�ǙǚǘǣǏ�nj�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ǡǏǖ�ǎǚǝǍǒǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�ǛǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ��Ǚǘǧǜǘǖǝ�ǘǗ�ǗNJǒNjǘǕǏǏ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘ-ǛǜǚNJǗǪǗ��ǟǘǜǩ�ǗǏ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJǜǦ�ǖǝǕǩǐ�

• ƹǘǕǝǙǚǘnjǘǎǗǒǔǘnjǥǏ� ǛǔNJǗǏǚǥ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ� nj� ǛnjǘǨ� ǘǡǏǚǏǎǦ� ǙǘǎǚNJǑ-ǎǏǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǪǖǔǘǛǜǗǥǏ��ǚNJǎǒǘǡNJǛǜǘǜǗǥǏ��ǡǝnjǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǔ�ǎNJnj-ǕǏǗǒǨ� ǒ� ǜǏǚǖǘǡǝnjǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�� ƸǗǒ� ǘNjǕNJǎNJǨǜ� ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǘǓ� ǛǜǏ-ǙǏǗǦǨ�ǗNJǎǪǐǗǘǛǜǒ��nj�ǠǏǕǘǖ�NjǘǕǏǏ�njǥǛǘǔǘǓ��ǡǏǖ�ǝ�ǙǚǏǎǥǎǝǣǏǓ�ǍǚǝǙǙǥ��ƵǝǡǢǏ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǑNJǣǒǣǏǗǥ�ǘǜ�ǖǝǕǩǐǏǓ�ǚNJǎǒǘǡNJǛǜǘǜǗǥǏ�ǒ�ǜǏǙǕǘnjǥǏ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚǥ�

• ƽǕǦǜǚNJǑnjǝǔǘnjǥǏ� ǛǔNJǗǏǚǥ�� LJǜǘ� ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ� ǎǘǚǘǍǒǏ� ǒ� ǛǕǘǐǗǥǏ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ�� ǎNJǨǣǒǏ� ǒǑǘNjǚNJǐǏǗǒǏ�� nj� ǎǏǛǩǜǔǒ� ǚNJǑ� NjǘǕǏǏ� ǔNJǡǏ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǏ��ǡǏǖ�ǎǚǝǍǒǏ�ǜǒǙǥ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚǘnj��Ʋǟ�Ǚǘǡǜǒ�ǗǏnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǘ�ǘNj-ǖNJǗǝǜǦ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǎNJǗǗǥǓ�ǖǏǜǘǎ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǗǏ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǒ�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��Ǘǘ�ǒ�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǎǚǝǍǒǏ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒ-ǔǒ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǡNJǛǜǘǜǝ�ǙǝǕǦǛNJ�

ƻǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǛǏǜǡNJǜǔǒ�ǍǕNJǑNJƶƯƼƸƮ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸ�ƻƯƼǁƪƼƴƯ�ƭƵƪƱƪ�ǗNJǡNJǕ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǜǦǛǩ�ǙǚǒǖǏǚǗǘ�nj�ǛǏǚǏǎǒǗǏ����ǟ�Ǎǘǎǘnj�ǙǚǘǢǕǘǍǘ�njǏǔNJ��ƲǖǏǗǗǘ�ǜǘǍǎNJ�NjǥǕNJ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏ-ǗNJ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�ǚǒǛǝǗǔNJ�ǔǚǘnjǏǗǘǛǗǥǟ�ǛǘǛǝǎǘnj� ǍǕNJǑǗǘǍǘ�ǎǗNJ� �ǎNJǐǏ�ǝ�NjǕǒǑǗǏǠǘnj�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǚǒǛǝǗǔǒ�ǗǏ�ǛǘnjǙNJǎNJǨǜ���ƹǚNJnjǎNJ��ǛǔNJǗǏǚǥ�ǛǏǜǡNJǜǔǒ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǍǚǘǖǘǑǎǔǒ�ǒ�ǎǘǚǘǍǒ��Ǘǘ�ǧǜǒ�ǗǏǎǘǛǜNJǜǔǒ�ǔǘǖǙǏǗǛǒǚǝǨǜǛǩ�ǒǟ�njǥǛǘǔǘǓ�ǗNJǎǪǐǗǘǛǜǦǨ��ƬǏǚǘǩǜǗǘǛǜǦ�ǘNjǖNJǗNJ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǙǘǎǎǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛǏǜǡNJǜǔǒ�ǛǜǚǏǖǒǜǛǩ�ǔ�ǗǝǕǨ��Ǚǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǡNJǛǜǘǜNJ�ǘǢǒNjǘǔ�ǗǏǙǚǒǑǗNJǗǒǩbȃ�ǙǚǒǖǏǚǗǘ�ǘǎǒǗ�ǗNJ�ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗ��ƹǚǏǙǩǜǛǜnjǘnjNJǜǦ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǎNJǗǗǘ-Ǎǘ� ǖǏǜǘǎNJ� ǖǘǐǏǜ� ǗNJǕǒǡǒǏ� ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ� ǑNJNjǘǕǏnjNJǗǒǓ� ǍǕNJǑ� �ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǔNJǜNJǚNJǔǜǥ��� Ǘǘ� ǧǜǘǜ� ǛǕǝǡNJǓ� ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ� ǙǚǒǑǗNJǜǦ� ǒǛǔǕǨǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ� ǒ� ǗǏ�ǒǖǏǨǣǒǖ�NjǘǕǦǢǘǍǘ�ǑǗNJǡǏǗǒǩ��Ƭ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚǥ�ǛǏǜǡNJǜǔǒ�Ǣǒǚǘǔǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜǛǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǛnjǏǚǟǛǏǔǚǏǜǗǥǟ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜǘnj��ǡNJǛǜǗǥǟ�ǔNJNjǒǗǏǜǘnj�ǒ�ǟǚNJǗǒǕǒǣ�

ƮǕǩ� ǛǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ǛǏǜǡNJǜǔǒ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜǛǩ� ǒǗǞǚNJǔǚNJǛǗǘǏ� ǒǑǕǝǡǏ-ǗǒǏ�ǗǒǑǔǘǓ�ǒǗǜǏǗǛǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ��ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǗǘǏ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǑǚNJǡǘǔ�ǔ�ǛǘǛǝǎNJǖ�ǗNJ�ǑNJǎǗǏǓ� ǛǜǏǗǔǏ� ǍǕNJǑNJ��ƲǑ�ǘǜǚNJǐǏǗǗǘǍǘ� ǛǒǍǗNJǕNJ� njǥǎǏǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǛǘǜǏǗ�ǘǛǘNjǥǟ�ǜǘǡǏǔ��ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǛǘǟǚNJǗǩǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǢNJNjǕǘǗǏ��Ƭ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǒǟ�ǖǘǎǏǕǩǟ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚǘnj�njǖǏǛǜǘ�ǒǗǞǚNJǔǚNJǛǗǘǍǘ�ǛnjǏǜNJ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦ-ǑǝǏǜǛǩ� ǕNJǑǏǚ� ǖǩǍǔǘǍǘ� ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�� ǁǏǕǘnjǏǔ� ǎǘǕǐǏǗ� ǙǚǒNjǕǒǑǒǜǦ� ǕǒǠǘ� ǔ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚǝ��ǑNJǞǒǔǛǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǏǍǘ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǗNJǙǚNJnjǒǜǦ�njǑǍǕǩǎ�ǗNJ�ǛǙǏǠǒ-

106 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƲ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ

Page 108: User identification analysis

NJǕǦǗǝǨ� ǖǏǜǔǝ� ǗNJ� ǎǒǛǙǕǏǏ� ǛǔNJǗǏǚNJ�� Ƭ� ǜNJǔǘǖ� ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǒ� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǘǛǜNJnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǙǚǘǎǘǕǐǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǏ�njǚǏǖǩ��ƻNJǖǥǏ�ǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǗǥǏ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚǥ�ǛǏǜǡNJǜǔǒ��ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǏ�ǗNJ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǒǓ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ��ǑNJǜǚNJǡǒnjNJǨǜ�ǘǔǘǕǘ�ǖǒǗǝǜǥ�ǗNJ�ǛǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǏǣǏ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǛǏǔǝǗǎ�ǗNJ�ǛǚNJnjǗǏǗǒǏ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗNJ�Ǜ�ǘNjǚNJǑǠǘǖ��LJǜǘ�ǏǎǒǗǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǓ�ǛǏǚǦǏǑǗǥǓ�ǗǏ-ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǔ�ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ��ƮǕǩ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǔǒ�ǗNJ�ǙǚǘǟǘǎǗǥǟ�ǙǚǏǎǙǚǒǩǜǒǓ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǘǗǒ�ǗǏ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎǩǜbȃ�Njǝǎǝǜ�ǑNJǎǏǚǐǒnjNJǜǦ�ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǓ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛ��ƼNJǔǐǏ�ǛǚǏǎǒ�ǗǏǎǘǛǜNJǜǔǘnj�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǝǙǘǖǩǗǝǜǦ�ǙǛǒǟǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǎǒǛǔǘǖǞǘǚǜ�ǘǜ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǎǘǕǍǘ�ǞǒǔǛǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�njǑǍǕǩǎ�ǒ�ǛǖǘǜǚǏǜǦ�ǗNJ� njǛǙǥǢǔǝ� ǛnjǏǜNJ�� ǜǏǖ� NjǘǕǏǏ� ǗǏǙǚǒǩǜǗǝǨ�� ǡǜǘ� Ǚǚǒ� ǛǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǍǕNJǑ�ǎǘǕǐǏǗ�ǗNJǟǘǎǒǜǦǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǚNJǛǛǜǘǩǗǒǒ�ǗǏ�NjǘǕǦǢǏ�����ǛNJǗǜǒǖǏǜǚNJ�ǘǜ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ�

ƻǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǚNJǎǝǐǗǘǓ�ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔǒ�ǍǕNJǑNJƮƪƷƷƪlj� ƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲlj� ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜ� ǝǗǒ-ǔNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ� ǙǚǒǑǗNJǔǘnj� ǚNJǎǝǐǗǘǓ� ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔǒ� ǍǕNJǑNJ�� ƺNJǎǝǐǗNJǩ� ǘNjǘǕǘǡ-ǔNJbȃ�ǜǘǗǔNJǩ�ǙǘǎnjǒǐǗNJǩ�ǎǒNJǞǚNJǍǖNJ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǙǏǚǏǎǗǏǓ�ǒ�ǑNJǎǗǏǓ�ǔNJǖǏǚNJ-ǖǒ�ǍǕNJǑNJbȃ�ǝ�ǕǨǎǏǓ�ǡNJǣǏ�njǛǏǍǘ�ǘǔǚNJǢǏǗNJ�nj�ǍǘǕǝNjǘǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǔǘǚǒǡǗǏnjǥǓ�ǠnjǏǜ��ǒ�ǗNJ�ǗǏǓ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǝnjǒǎǏǜǦ�ǛǕǘǐǗǥǓ�ǚǒǛǝǗǘǔ��ǗNJǙǘǖǒǗNJǨǣǒǓ�ǛǏǜǦ��LJǜǘǜ�ǚǒǛǝǗǘǔ�ǞǘǚǖǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ�ǏǣǪ�ǎǘ�ǚǘǐǎǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�Ǚǘǡǜǒ�ǗǏ�ǖǏǗǩǏǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǙǚǘǜǩǐǏǗǒǒ�njǛǏǓ�ǐǒǑǗǒ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ��Ƽǘǜ�ǞNJǔǜ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǚNJnjǥǓ�ǒ�ǕǏnjǥǓ�ǍǕNJǑ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�ǘǜǕǒǡNJǨǜǛǩ�ǎǚǝǍ�ǘǜ�ǎǚǝǍNJ��ǎǏǕNJǏǜ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǨ�ǛǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǚNJǎǝǐǗǘǓ�ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔǒ�ǘǎǗǒǖ�ǒǑ�ǛNJǖǥǟ�ǗNJǎǏǐǗǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ��ǁNJǛǜǘǜNJ�ǕǘǐǗǘǍǘ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ�nj�ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǟ�ǚNJnjǗNJ���ǔ�����ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗNJǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǟǝǐǏ��ǡǏǖ�Ǚǚǒ�ǛǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǛǏǜǡNJǜǔǒ��Ǘǘ�ǗNJǖǗǘǍǘ�ǕǝǡǢǏ��ǡǏǖ�ǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜǥ��ǎǏǖǘǗǛǜǚǒǚǝǏǖǥǏ�ǛNJǖǥǖǒ�ǗNJǎǪǐ-Ǘǥǖǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔNJǖ�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��ǁǜǘ�ǔNJǛNJǏǜ-Ǜǩ�ǘǢǒNjǘǔ�ǗǏǙǚǒǑǗNJǗǒǩ��ǖǗǏǗǒǩ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǛǒǕǦǗǘ�ǚNJǛǟǘǎǩǜǛǩ��ƸǎǗǒ�ǛǡǒǜNJǨǜ��ǡǜǘ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǖǝ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǨ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǘǜǔNJ-ǑNJǗǘ�nj�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǏ�ǙǘbǢǒǚǘǔǘǖǝ�ǛǙǏǔǜǚǝ�ǙǚǒǡǒǗ��ǗNJǡǒǗNJǩ�Ǜ�ǔǘǗǤǨǗǔǜǒ-njǒǜNJ��ǎǚǝǍǒǏ�ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǨǜ��ǡǜǘ�ǗNJ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǏ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǗǒǔNJǔ�ǗǏ�ǘǜǚNJǐNJǏǜǛǩ�ǎNJǐǏ�ǗNJǕǒǡǒǏ�ǠnjǏǜǗǥǟ�ǔǘǗǜNJǔǜǗǥǟ�ǕǒǗǑ�

ƻǜǚǘǍǘ�Ǎǘnjǘǚǩ��ǗNJǑǥnjNJǜǦ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚNJǖǒ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ��ǛǡǒǜǥnjNJǨǣǒǏ�ǚǒǛǝ-Ǘǘǔ�ǚNJǎǝǐǗǘǓ�ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔǒ��ǗǏnjǏǚǗǘ��ǜNJǔ�ǔNJǔ�nj�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǑǘNjǚNJ-ǐǏǗǒǏ� ǙǘǕǝǡNJǏǜǛǩ� ǙǝǜǏǖ� ǘNjǥǡǗǘǍǘ� ǞǘǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�� ƻǕNJNjǥǓ� ǛnjǏǜ�ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǗNJ� ǚNJǎǝǐǗǝǨ� ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔǝ�� NJ� ǡǏǚǗǘ�NjǏǕNJǩ� ǔNJǖǏǚNJ� ǎǏǕNJǏǜ���bǑNJǙǒǛǏǓ�nj�ǛǏǔǝǗǎǝ��ƸǎǗNJ�ǒǑ�ǑNJǙǒǛǏǓ�ǑNJǜǏǖ�ǘǠǒǞǚǘnjǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ�ǒ�ǙǚǏ-ǘNjǚNJǑǝǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǝǙǚǘǣǏǗǗǝǨ�Ǟǘǚǖǝbȃ�ǘǜNjǒǚNJǨǜǛǩ�ǙǘǚǩǎǔNJ�����ǜǘǡǏǔ��ǒǗ-

107ƻƼƪƼƲǁƯƻƴƲƯ�ƶƯƼƸƮDž�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ

Page 109: User identification analysis

ǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǛǘǟǚNJǗǩǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǢNJNjǕǘǗǏ��ǎǕǩ�ǛǚNJnjǗǏǗǒǩ��ǢNJNjǕǘǗ�ǘǜ-ǙǏǡNJǜǔNJ�ǙNJǕǦǠNJ�ǛǜǚǘǒǜǛǩ�ǗǏ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǡǏǖ�Ǚǘb��Ȃ���ǜǘǡǔNJǖ���ƷǏǖNJǕǘnjNJǐǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�njǛǩ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�ǑNJǗǒǖNJǏǜ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǛǏǔǝǗǎ�ǒ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǙǘǕǗǘǛǜǦǨ�NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǑǒǚǘnjNJǗNJ��ƴNJǖǏǚNJ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗNJ�ǗNJ�ǚNJǛǛǜǘǩǗǒǒ�ǘǜ���bǛǖ�ǎǘ���ǖǏǜǚNJ��nj�ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǘǜ�ǛǔNJǗǒǚǝǨǣǏǍǘ�ǘNjǘǚǝǎǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ƮǕǩ�ǙǚǏǎǘǜnjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǙǘǎǎǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǍǕNJǑ�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǖǘǎǏǕǒ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚǘnj�ǒǑǖǏǗǩǨǜ�Ǚǘǜǘǔ�ǛnjǏǜNJ��ǒǎǝǣǒǓ�nj�ǍǕNJǑ��ǒ�ǘǜǛǕǏǐǒnjNJǨǜ�ǚNJǑǖǏǚ�ǑǚNJǡǔNJbȃ�ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǒǏ�ǚǏNJǔǠǒǒ�ǛnjǒǎǏǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǘ�ǙǘǎǎǏǕǔǏ�

ƻǔNJǗǏǚǥ� ǚNJǎǝǐǗǘǓ� ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔǒ� ǙǚǏǔǚNJǛǗǘ� ǑNJǚǏǔǘǖǏǗǎǘnjNJǕǒ� ǛǏNjǩ�Ǚǚǒ� ǧǔǛǙǏǚǒǖǏǗǜNJǕǦǗǘǖ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǒ� Ǜ� NjNJǗǔǘǖNJǜNJǖǒ� nj� ƪǗǍǕǒǒ��ƻǂƪ��ljǙǘǗǒǒ�ǒ�ƭǏǚǖNJǗǒǒ��ǗNJǡǒǗNJǩ�Ǜ�����bǍǘǎNJ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�nj�NJǧǚǘǙǘǚǜNJǟ��ǍǎǏ�ǘǗǒ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǕǒǛǦ�ǎǕǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǚNJNjǘǜǗǒǔǘnj�Ǚǚǒ�ǙǚǘǟǘǐǎǏ-Ǘǒǒ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǑǘǗǥ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǝǛǔǘǚǏǗǒǩ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜǗǘǍǘ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǩ�ǙNJǛǛNJǐǒǚǘnj��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǗNJǒNjǘǕǏǏ�ǡNJǛǜǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜǛǩ�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǖǒ�NJnjǒNJǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ��ǀǏǗNJ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚǘnj�njǛǏ�ǏǣǪ�njǥǛǘǔNJ��Ǘǘ�Ǜǘ�njǚǏǖǏǗǏǖ�ǘǗǒ�ǛǜNJǗǘnjǩǜǛǩ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǗǥǖǒ��ƻǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǜ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǥ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJ-Ǘǒǩ�ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�nj�ǘǗǕNJǓǗǘnjǥǟ�ǖNJǍNJǑǒǗNJǟ��ǘǗǕNJǓǗǘnjǘǖ�NjNJǗǔǘnj-Ǜǔǘǖ�ǘNjǛǕǝǐǒnjNJǗǒǒ��ǘǗǕNJǓǗǘnjǘǖ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǒ�ǘǗǕNJǓǗǘnjǘǓ�ǜǘǚǍǘnjǕǏ�NJǔǠǒǩǖǒ�

ƺNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ�ǍǏǘǖǏǜǚǒǒ�ǚǝǔǒƶƯƼƸƮ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸ�ƭƯƸƶƯƼƺƲƲ�ǚǝǔǒ�ǛǘǛǜǘǒǜ�nj�ǒǑǖǏǚǏǗǒǒ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡ-Ǘǥǟ�ǙNJǚNJǖǏǜǚǘnj�ǔǒǛǜǒ�ǚǝǔǒ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ��ǒǑǍǒNjǘnj�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��ǒǟ�ǜǘǕǣǒǗǥ�ǒ�ǎǕǒǗǥ��ǜǘǕǣǒǗǥ�ǒ�ǢǒǚǒǗǥ�ǜǥǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ�ǚǝǔǒ��ǚNJǛǛǜǘǩǗǒǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǛǝǛǜNJnjNJǖǒ�ǒ�ǘNjǣǏǓ�Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǥ�ǔǘǛǜǒ��ƹǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǚǝǔǒ�ǗǏ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǝǗǒ-ǔNJǕǦǗǥǖǒ��ǎǕǩ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ�ǗNJǎǏǐǗǘǛǜǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǔǘǖNjǒǗǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔ��ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒ-ǚǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǖǏǕǔǒǏ�ǎǏǜNJǕǒ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǖǘǚǣǒǗǥ�ǗNJ�ǔǘǐǏ���ƻǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǘǜǖǏǜǒǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǗǏǕǦǑǩ�ǛǡǒǜNJǜǦ�ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘ�ǗNJǎǪǐǗǥ-ǖǒ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ��ǟǘǜǩ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǚǝǔNJ�ǘNjǕNJǎNJǏǜ�ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǙǘǛǜǘ-ǩǗǗǘǓ�ǞǘǚǖǘǓ�� ǝǢǒNjǥ�ǒǕǒ� ǑNJNjǘǕǏnjNJǗǒǩ�� ǙǚǒnjǘǎǩǣǒǏ� ǔ� ǚNJǛǙǝǟNJǗǒǨ�ǜǔNJǗǏǓ� �ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ�� NJǚǜǚǒǜ��� ǖǘǍǝǜ� ǒǛǔNJǑǒǜǦ� ǏǏ� ǒǛǟǘǎǗǝǨ� Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǝ� ǒ�njǥǑnjNJǜǦ�ǘǢǒNjǔǝ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƹǘbǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǖ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖ��ǎǘǕǩ�ǘǢǒ-Njǘǔ�Ǚǚǒ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǒ�ǍǏǘǖǏǜǚǒǒ�ǚǝǔǒbȃ�ǙǘǚǩǎǔNJ����Ɍ���ǡǜǘ�ǎǘnjǘǕǦǗǘ�ǖǗǘǍǘ��ƹǘǧǜǘǖǝ�ǎNJǗǗǥǓ�ǖǏǜǘǎ�ǗǏ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎǒǜ�ǎǕǩ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜǘnj� Ǜ� njǥǛǘǔǒǖ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏǖ� ǛǏǔǚǏǜǗǘǛǜǒ��ƬǛǪbǐǏ�ǘǗ�ǎǘnjǘǕǦǗǘ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǪǗ�� ǡǜǘ� ǎǘǔNJ-ǑǥnjNJǏǜ�ǏǍǘ�ǝǎǘNjǛǜnjǘ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��Ƽǘǖǝ�ǏǛǜǦ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǙǚǒǡǒǗ��Ƭǘ�ǙǏǚnjǥǟ��ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǑNJǗǒǖNJǏǜ�njǛǏǍǘ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǛǏ-

108 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƲ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ

Page 110: User identification analysis

ǔǝǗǎ�ǒ�ǗǏ�ǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǎǒǛǔǘǖǞǘǚǜNJ��Ƭǘ�njǜǘǚǥǟ��ǗNJ�ǏǪ�ǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜ�ǗǏ�njǕǒ-ǩǨǜ�Ǘǒ�ǜǏǖǙǏǚNJǜǝǚNJ��Ǘǒ�njǕNJǐǗǘǛǜǦ��Ǘǒ�ǑNJǍǚǩǑǗǪǗǗǘǛǜǦ��Ƭ�ǜǚǏǜǦǒǟ��ǎǕǩ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎǒǜ�ǒǑǘNjǚNJǐǏǗǒǏ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǗǒǑǔǘǍǘ�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjNJ��ǚNJǑǖǏǚ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗNJ�ǘǡǏǗǦ�ǖNJǕ� �njǛǏǍǘ� �� NjNJǓǜ��� NJ� ǙǘǎǛǡǪǜǥ��ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǒǖǥǏ�Ǚǚǒ�ǏǍǘ�ǛǚNJnjǗǏǗǒǒ�Ǜ�ǧǜNJǕǘǗǘǖ��ǘǡǏǗǦ�ǙǚǘǛǜǥ�ǒ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǕǏǍǔǘ�NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǑǒǚǘnjNJǗǥ�

ƮǕǩ�ǛǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǚǝǔNJ�ǙǘǖǏǣNJǏǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǚǘnjǗǝǨ�ǙǘnjǏǚǟǗǘǛǜǦ�ǒ�Ǟǒǔ-ǛǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ� Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǢǜǒǞǜǘnj�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǙǘǖǘǍNJǨǜ�ǙǚNJ-njǒǕǦǗǘ� ǚNJǛǙǘǕǘǐǒǜǦ� ǚǝǔǝ� nj� ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǒ� ǞǘǜǘǔNJǖǏǚ�� ƷǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ� ǛnjǏ-ǜǘǎǒǘǎǘnj��ǚNJǛǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘbǛǜǘǚǘǗNJǖ��njǔǕǨǡNJǨǜǛǩ�ǙǘbǘǡǏǚǏǎǒ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǏ�ǙǚǘǏǔǠǒǒ�ǚǝǔǒ��ƷǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ�ǛǔNJǗǒǚǝǨǜ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǎnjNJ�ǙNJǕǦǠNJ��ǎǚǝǍǒǏbȃ�ǙǘǕǗǘǛǜǦǨ�njǛǨ�ǔǒǛǜǦ��ƱNJǜǏǖ�ǛǜǚǘǒǜǛǩ�ǜǚǏǟǖǏǚǗǥǓ�ǘNjǚNJǑ�ǚǝǔǒ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�ǛǚNJnjǗǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ�Ǜ�ǧǜNJǕǘǗǘǖ�

ƻǒǛǜǏǖǥ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ�ǗNJ�ǍǏǘǖǏǜǚǒǒ�ǚǝǔǒ��ǗNJǡNJǕǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�nj�ǖǒǚǏ�nj�ǗNJǡNJǕǏ����ǟ�Ǎǘǎǘnj�ǙǚǘǢǕǘǍǘ�ǛǜǘǕǏǜǒǩ��Ƭ�ǗNJ-ǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�nj�ƻǂƪ�ǒǖǒ�ǘNjǘǚǝǎǘnjNJǗǥ�NjǘǕǏǏ���ǜǥǛ��ǘNjǤǏǔǜǘnj��nj�ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǖǗǘǍǒǏ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǏ�NJǧǚǘǙǘǚǜǥ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǙNJǛǛNJǐǒǚNJǖ�NjǥǛǜǚǘ�ǙǚǘǟǘǎǒǜǦ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǝ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǩ��ƼNJǔǐǏ�NjǕNJǍǘǎNJǚǩ�ǛnjǘǏǓ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ-ǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒ�ǙǚǘǛǜǘǜǏ�nj�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǘǗǒ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǜǦǛǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǝǡǪǜNJ�ǚNJNjǘǡǏǍǘ�njǚǏǖǏǗǒ�ǗNJ�ǙǚǏǎǙǚǒǩǜǒǩǟ��ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǙǚǏǎǝǙǚǏǐǎǏ-Ǘǒǩ�ǘNjǖNJǗǗǥǟ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǓ�� ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ�� mǘǜǖǏǜǘǔ� ǎǚǝǍǘǖ}� njǚǏǖǏǗǒ�Ǚǚǒ-ǟǘǎNJ�ǝǟǘǎNJ�ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔNJ�

ƼNJǔǐǏ� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ� ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ� ǗǘnjǥǓ� ǖǏǜǘǎ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǚǒǛǝǗǔǝ�njǏǗ�ǚǝǔǒ��ƼǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǩ�ǜNJǔǘnjNJ��ǒǗǞǚNJǔǚNJǛǗNJǩ�ǔNJǖǏǚNJ�ǎǏǕNJ-Ǐǜ� ǛǗǒǖǔǒ� njǗǏǢǗǏǓ� ǒǕǒ� njǗǝǜǚǏǗǗǏǓ� ǛǜǘǚǘǗǥ� ǚǝǔǒ�� ǒ� ǒǑǘNjǚNJǐǏǗǒǏ�njǏǗ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǏǜǛǩ�NjǕNJǍǘǎNJǚǩ�ǜǘǖǝ��ǡǜǘ�ǍǏǖǘǍǕǘNjǒǗ�ǔǚǘnjǒ�ǙǘǍǕǘǣNJǏǜ�Ʋƴ�ǒǑǕǝǡǏǗǒǏ��ƹǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǒ�ǗNJǎǏǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJ�ǙǘǔNJ�ǗǏǒǑnjǏǛǜǗǥ�

ƺNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ�ǡǏǚǜ�ǕǒǠNJƺƪƻƹƸƱƷƪƬƪƷƲƯ� ƹƸ� ƭƯƸƶƯƼƺƲƲ� ƵƲǀƪ� ǙǚǒǡǒǛǕǩǨǜ� ǔ� mǜǚǪǖ� NjǘǕǦǢǒǖ�Njǒǘ-ǖǏǜǚǒǔNJǖ}� njǖǏǛǜǏ� Ǜ� ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏǖ� Ǚǘb ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔNJǖ� ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj� ǒ� ǚNJ-ǎǝǐǗǘǓ� ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔǏ�� LJǜǘǜ� ǖǏǜǘǎ� ǚNJǛǙNJǎNJǏǜǛǩ� ǗNJ� ǎnjNJ� ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ���'�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ� ǒ� �'�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ�� �'�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ� ǕǒǠNJ� Ǚǘ-ǩnjǒǕǘǛǦ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǎNJnjǗǘ�ǒ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǕǘǛǦ��nj�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǘǖ��nj�ǔǚǒǖǒǗNJǕǒ-ǛǜǒǔǏ��Ƭ�ǔǘǗǠǏ�ǙǚǘǢǕǘǍǘ�njǏǔNJ�ǙǘǩnjǒǕǒǛǦ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǏ�ǒǗǜǏǚǙǚǏǜNJ-Ǡǒǒ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJ��nj�ǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜǏ�ǡǏǍǘ�ǘǗ�ǛǜNJǕ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǗNJǎǪǐǗǥǖ��Ǘǘ��NjǏǑǝǛǕǘnjǗǘ��ǝǐǏ�ǜǘǍǎNJ�ǝǛǜǝǙNJǕ�ǒ�Ǜ�ǔNJǐǎǥǖ�Ǎǘǎǘǖ�njǛǪ�NjǘǕǦǢǏ�ǝǛǜǝǙNJǏǜ�ǎǚǝǍǒǖ�Njǒǘ-ǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǖ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƹǘbǚNJǑǗǥǖ�

109ƻƼƪƼƲǁƯƻƴƲƯ�ƶƯƼƸƮDž�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ

Page 111: User identification analysis

ǘǠǏǗǔNJǖ�� ǎǘǕǩ� ǕǘǐǗǥǟ� ǛǚNJNjNJǜǥnjNJǗǒǓ� ǎǕǩ� ǧǜǘǍǘ� ǖǏǜǘǎNJ� ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ����Ȃ�Ɍ���NJ�ǡNJǛǜǘǜNJ�ǘǢǒNjǘǔ�ǗǏǙǚǒǑǗNJǗǒǩ�ǏǣǪ�ǗNJ�Ǚǘǚǩǎǘǔ�njǥǢǏ��Ƭ�ǔNJ-ǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǙǚǒǖǏǚNJ�ǗǏǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ��'�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ�ǕǒǠ�ǙǚǒnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ�ǜNJǔǘǓ�ǛǕǝǡNJǓ��nj�ǘǎǗǘǖ�ǒǑ�NJǧǚǘǙǘǚǜǘnj�ƻǂƪ��ǍǎǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏ�ǛǘNjǥǜǒǓ���bǛǏǗ-ǜǩNjǚǩ� NjǥǕǒ� ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǥ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǕǒǠ�� ǛǕǝǐNJǣǒǏ�NJǧǚǘǙǘǚǜNJ�� ǑNJǖNJǛǔǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ�Ǚǚǒ�Ǚǘǖǘǣǒ�ǙNJǚǒǔǘnj��ǗNJǔǕNJǎǗǥǟ�ǝǛǘnj��NjǘǕǦǢǒǟ�ǢǕǩǙ��ǘǡǔǘnj�ǒ�ǍǚǒǖNJ��NjǥǕǒ�ǘǙǘǑǗNJǗǥ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�nj�ǘǎǗǘǖ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǒǑ�ǜǚǏǟ���'�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�Ǘǘnjǥǖ�ǖǏǜǘǎǘǖ�ǒ�ǗNJǎǏǐǗǥǏ�ǘǠǏǗǔǒ�ǡNJǛǜǘǜǥ�ǘǢǒNjǘǔ�ǎǕǩ�ǗǏǍǘ�ǙǘǔNJ�ǗǏ�ǛǎǏǕNJǗǥ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�ǗNJ�ǗǏǍǘ�njǘǑǕNJǍNJǨǜǛǩ�NjǘǕǦǢǒǏ�ǗNJǎǏǐǎǥ��ƻǡǒǜNJǏǜǛǩ��ǡǜǘ�ǏǍǘ�ǛǜNJǜǒǛǜǒ-ǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǗNJǎǪǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǛǚNJnjǗǒǖNJ�Ǜ�ǗNJǎǪǐǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJ�ǛǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǘǜ-ǙǏǡNJǜǔǘnj�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj�

Ƭ�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ��'�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ�ǕǒǠ�ǙǚǘǍǚǏǛǛ��Ǚǘ�njǒǎǒǖǘǖǝ��ǑNJǢǏǕ�nj�ǜǝǙǒǔ��ƸǛǗǘnjǗǥǖ�ǙǚǏǎǖǏǜǘǖ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǗǘǏ�ǘNjǏ-ǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǏ��ǜNJǔ�ǔNJǔ�ǘNjǥǡǗǥǏ�ǔNJǖǏǚǥ�ǘǜǕǒǡǗǘ�ǛǙǚNJnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�Ǜ�ǑNJǟnjNJǜǘǖ�ǒǑǘNjǚNJǐǏǗǒǩ�ǕǒǠNJ��Ʒǘ�ǝǐǏ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǕǏǜ�ǗǏ�ǙǘǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǘnj��ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ� ǘǜǕǒǡNJǨǣǒǟǛǩ� Ǚǘb ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ� ǘǜ� ǙǚǏǎǥǎǝǣǒǟ�� ǒ�ǖǗǘǍǒǏ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǡǒǔǒ�ǝǟǘǎǩǜ�Ǜ�ǚǥǗǔNJ��ƺNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ��'�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ�ǕǒǠ�nj�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǑNJǗǒǖNJǏǜǛǩ�ǘǔǘǕǘ�ǎǏǛǩǜǔNJ�Ǟǒǚǖ�� nj� ǜǘǖ� ǡǒǛǕǏ� ǒǑ� ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�� Ƭ� ǘǛǗǘnjǗǘǖ�� ǘǗǒ� ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǩǜ� ǍǘǜǘnjǥǏ�Ǚǚǘǎǝǔǜǥ��ǛǘǛǜǘǩǣǒǏ�ǒǑ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚNJ�ǒ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǗǘǍǘ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ�ǔ�ǗǏǖǝ��ǟǘǜǩ� ǏǛǜǦ� ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�� ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǩǣǒǏ� ǜǘǕǦǔǘ� ǛǔNJǗǏǚǥ�� LJǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǦ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǘnj��'�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡNJǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǘǜ� ǝǛǕǘnjǒǓ�ǒǟ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ��ƮǏǕǘ�nj� ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘ� ǑNJǎNJǡNJ�ǔǚNJǓǗǏ� ǛǕǘǐǗNJ� Ǜ�ǖNJǜǏǖNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ��ƻǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǑNJǗǒǖNJǏǜ���Ȃ���ǛǏǔǝǗǎ��Ǚǚǒ� ǧǜǘǖ� ǕǒǠǘ�ǖǘǐǏǜ� ǛǎnjǒǍNJǜǦǛǩ� ǒǕǒ�ǙǘnjǘǚNJǡǒnjNJǜǦǛǩ� ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǔNJǖǏǚǥ��ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�ǔǘǖǙǏǗǛǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǧǜǒ�ǎnjǒǐǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǙǘǛǜǚǘǒǜǦ�ǙǚǘǏǔǠǒǒ� ǕǒǠNJ�� ǗNJ� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ� ǗǝǐǗǘ� njǥǎǏǕǒǜǦ� ǔǘǗǜǝǚǥ� ǍǕNJǑ�� NjǚǘnjǏǓ��ǍǝNj�� ǗǘǛNJ� ǒ� ǎǚǝǍǒǟ� ǡǏǚǜ� ǕǒǠNJ�� NJ� ǑNJǜǏǖ� njǥǡǒǛǕǒǜǦ� ǚNJǛǛǜǘǩǗǒǩ� ǖǏǐǎǝ�Ǘǒǖǒ��ƮǕǩ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǚǏǟǖǏǚǗǘǍǘ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗNJ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǒǜǦ�ǘǜ����ǎǘ����ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǗǥǟ�ǧǕǏǖǏǗǜǘnj�� ǔNJǐǎǥǓ�ǒǑ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjǘ�njNJǚǒNJǠǒǓ��ǁǜǘNjǥ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�NjǥǕǘ�ǛǙǚNJnjǒǜǦǛǩ�Ǜǘ�ǛǕǝǡNJ-ǩǖǒ�ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�njǥǚNJǐǏǗǒǩ�ǕǒǠNJ��ǗNJǕǒǡǒǩ�ǘǡǔǘnj��ǢǕǩǙǥ�ǒǕǒ�Njǘǚǘǎǥ��ǢNJNjǕǘǗ�ǎǘǕǐǏǗ�ǛǜǚǘǒǜǦǛǩ�nj�ǙǏǚnjǝǨ�ǘǡǏǚǏǎǦ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǗǏǒǑǖǏǗǗǥǟ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔ��ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǔNJǔ�ǞǘǚǖNJ�ǡǏǚǏǙNJ��njǥǛǘǜNJ�ǒ�ǢǒǚǒǗNJ�ǛǔǝǕ��ǞǘǚǖNJ�ǗNJǎNjǚǘnjǗǥǟ�ǎǝǍ��ǍǕǝNjǒǗNJ�ǍǕNJǑǗǥǟ�njǙNJǎǒǗ�ǒbǜ�ɋǎ�

Ƭ� ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǏ� njǚǏǖǩ�ƶǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǓ� ǙǘǎǔǘǖǒǜǏǜ� Ǚǘb ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǒǑNJ-Ǡǒǒ�nj�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǒ��Ζ62�Ζ(&�-7&��6&���%LRPHWULFV��ǚNJǑǚNJNjNJǜǥnjNJ-

110 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƲ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ

Page 112: User identification analysis

Ǐǜ�ǏǎǒǗǥǓ�ǞǘǚǖNJǜ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǎǕǩ�NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ�ǕǒǠ��njǔǕǨǡNJǨǣǒǓ��'��ǒ��'�ǒǑǘNjǚNJǐǏǗǒǩ��ƬǏǚǘǩǜǗǏǏ�njǛǏǍǘ��njǛǔǘǚǏ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑ-ǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ�ǕǒǠNJ�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǘNjǘǒǟ�ǒǛǜǘǡǗǒǔǘnj�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǚNJǛǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǔNJǔ�ǘǎǒǗ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǖǏǜǘǎ�

ƼǏǚǖǘǍǚNJǞǒǩ�ǕǒǠNJƻƺƯƮƲ� ƹƺƲƱƷƪƴƸƬ� ƵƲǀƪ�� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǟ� ǎǕǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ��ǗNJǒNjǘǕǏǏ�ǝǛǜǘǓǡǒnjǥǖǒ�ǒ�ǜǚǝǎǗǘ�ǒǑǖǏǗǩǏǖǥǖǒ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�Ǚǚǒ-ǑǗNJǔǒ� ǒǑǘNjǚNJǐǏǗǒǩ� ǏǍǘ� ǔǚǘnjǏǗǘǛǗǥǟ� ǛǘǛǝǎǘnj�� ƹǝǜǏǖ� ǛǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǕǒǠNJ�nj�ǒǗǞǚNJǔǚNJǛǗǘǖ�ǛnjǏǜǏ�ǛǘǑǎNJǏǜǛǩ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǜǏǖǙǏǚNJǜǝǚǗNJǩ�ǔNJǚ-ǜNJbȃ�ǜǏǚǖǘǍǚNJǖǖNJ��ƪǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘbǜǏǚǖǘǍǚNJǖǖǏ�ǕǒǠNJ�ǙǘbǗNJǎǏǐ-ǗǘǛǜǒ�ǛǚNJnjǗǒǖNJ�Ǜ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǏǓ�ǙǘbǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔNJǖ�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��Ƭ�ǘǜǕǒǡǒǏ�ǘǜ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǍǏǘǖǏǜǚǒǒ�ǕǒǠNJ��ǎNJǗǗǥǓ�ǖǏǜǘǎ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡNJǏǜ�NjǕǒǑ-ǗǏǠǘnj��ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǖNJǛǘǔ��ǙǚǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǏ�ǙǕNJǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ��ǛǜNJǚǏǗǒǏ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑǖNJ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ��ǜǏǖǙǏǚNJǜǝǚNJ�ǜǏǕNJ��ǘǟǕNJǐǎǏ-ǗǒǏ�ǔǘǐǒ�ǕǒǠNJ�nj�ǖǘǚǘǑǗǝǨ�ǙǘǍǘǎǝ�ǗǏ�njǕǒǩǨǜ�ǗNJ�ǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǠǒǒ��ƷǏǛǘǖǗǏǗǗǥǖ�ǙǕǨǛǘǖ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǜǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǛǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJ-ǗǒǏ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǙǚǘnjǘǎǒǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǚNJǛǛǜǘǩǗǒǒ�ǎǘ����ǖǏǜǚǘnj��ƹǚNJnjǎNJ��ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǘ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǏǖǘǍǘ�ǒǑǘNjǚNJǐǏǗǒǩ�ǗǏnjǥǛǘǔǘ��ǒ�nj�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǘǖ�ǒǑ�ǑNJ�ǧǜǘǍǘ�ǜǏǚǖǘ-ǍǚNJǞǒǩ�ǕǒǠ�ǗNJ�ǎNJǗǗǥǓ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ�ǗǏ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�ǢǒǚǘǔǘǍǘ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�

ƮǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ

ƺNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ�ǍǘǕǘǛNJƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƲƳ� ƶƯƼƸƮ� ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ� Ǚǘb ǍǘǕǘǛǝ� ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǑǝǏǜǛǩ�� nj�ǙǏǚnjǝǨ�ǘǡǏǚǏǎǦ��ǙǚǘǛǜǘǜǘǓ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ƸǗ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǘǎǗǘǍǘ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǖǒǔǚǘ-ǞǘǗNJ��ǙǘǎǔǕǨǡǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǔ�ǑNJǙǒǛǥnjNJǨǣǏǖǝ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjǝ��LJǜǘ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�ǑǗNJǡǏǗǒǏ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��Ǚǚǒ� ǛǝǎǏNjǗǘǖ�ǚNJǑNjǒǚNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǏ�� ǍǎǏ� ǏǎǒǗǛǜnjǏǗ-Ǘǥǖ�ǎǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘǖ�njǒǗǥ�ǙǘǎǘǑǚǏnjNJǏǖǘǍǘ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǑNJǙǒǛǦ�ǏǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏ-ǞǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǚNJǑǍǘnjǘǚNJ��ƮǚǝǍǒǖ�ǙǚǏǒǖǝǣǏǛǜnjǘǖ�ǎNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǏǍǘ�ǝǎǘNjǛǜnjǘbȃ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǨ�ǗǏ�ǗǝǐǗǘ�ǛǘnjǏǚǢNJǜǦ�ǗǒǔNJǔǒǟ�ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒ-ǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǓ��ƷNJǔǘǗǏǠ��NjǘǕǦǢǒǖ�ǙǕǨǛǘǖ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǛǔǚǥǜǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒbȃ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǎNJǐǏ�ǗǏ�nj�ǔǝǚǛǏ��ǡǜǘ�njǔǕǨǡǏǗNJ�ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗNJǩ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔNJ�� NJ� ǑǗNJǡǒǜ�� ǘNj� ǧǜǘǖ� ǛǕǘǐǗǏǏ�

111ƮƲƷƪƶƲǁƯƻƴƲƯ�ƶƯƼƸƮDž�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ

Page 113: User identification analysis

NjǝǎǏǜ�ǝǑǗNJǜǦ�ǑǕǘǝǖǥǢǕǏǗǗǒǔǝ��ƻǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǎǘnjǘǕǦǗǘ�ǖǗǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏ-ǚǒǛǜǒǔ�ǍǘǕǘǛNJ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǘǛǜǚǘǏǗǒǩ�ǒǗǎǒnjǒ-ǎǝNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗNJ��njǥǛǘǜNJ�ǜǘǗNJ��ǖǘǎǝǕǩǠǒǩ��ǒǗǜǘǗNJǠǒǩ��ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǚǘǒǑǗǘǢǏǗǒǩ�ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǥǟ�Ǒnjǝǔǘnj�ǚǏǡǒ�ǒbǜ�ɋǙ�bƯǛǕǒ�njǛǏ�ǘǗǒ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ� NJǗNJǕǒǑǒǚǝǨǜǛǩ�� njǏǚǘǩǜǗǘǛǜǦ� ǙǚǒǗǩǜǦ� ǑNJ� NJnjǜǘǚǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǙǘǛǜǘǚǘǗǗǏǏ�ǕǒǠǘ�ǙǚNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǗǝǕǏnjNJǩ��ƸǛǗǘnjǗǘǓ�Ǚǚǘ-NjǕǏǖǘǓ� ǎǕǩ� ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖ� ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǜǘ�� ǡǜǘ� ǍǘǕǘǛ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǛǒǕǦǗǘ�ǖǏǗǩǜǦǛǩ�nj�ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǘǜ�ǛǘǛǜǘ-ǩǗǒǩ� ǙǛǒǟǒǔǒ�� ǗNJǕǒǡǒǩ� ǙǚǘǛǜǝǎǗǥǟ� ǒ� ǎǚǝǍǒǟ� ǑNJNjǘǕǏnjNJǗǒǓ�� njǘǑǚNJǛǜNJ�ǒb ǜ�ɋǎ��ƸǜǔNJǑ� nj� ǎǘǛǜǝǙǏ� ǎǕǩ� NJnjǜǘǚǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ� ǙǚǘǒǛǟǘ-ǎǒǜ��ǙǘbǚNJǑǗǥǖ�ǘǠǏǗǔNJǖ��nj��Ȃ�Ɍ��ǛǕǝǡNJǏnj��ǡǜǘ�ǎǘnjǘǕǦǗǘ�ǖǗǘǍǘ��ƹǘǧǜǘ-ǖǝ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� Ǚǘb ǍǘǕǘǛǝ� ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǏǜǛǩ� nj� ǘǛǗǘnjǗǘǖ�ǗNJ� ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJǟ�ǛǚǏǎǗǏǍǘ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��ǜNJǔǒǏ�ǔNJǔ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǏ�ǔǕNJǛǛǥ��ǕNJNjǘ-ǚNJǜǘǚǒǒ�ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ��NjǒǑǗǏǛ�ǠǏǗǜǚǥ�ǒbǜ�ɋǎ��ƯǣǪ�ǘǎǗNJ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖNJ�ǛǘǛǜǘǒǜ�nj�ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�ǘǜǎǏǕǒǜǦ�ǍǘǕǘǛ�ǘǜ�ǢǝǖNJ�

ƼǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǩ� ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ� ǍǘǕǘǛNJ� ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘ� ǙǏǚǛǙǏǔǜǒnjǗNJ� Ǚǘǜǘ-ǖǝ��ǡǜǘ�ǘǗNJ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǜǦǛǩ�ǗǏ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǔNJǔ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��Ǘǘ�ǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjǘǍǘ�njnjǘǎNJ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ƸǡǏnjǒǎǗǘ��ǡǜǘ� ǎǒǔǜǘnjNJǜǦ� ǜǏǔǛǜ� ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǝ� ǗNJǖǗǘǍǘ� ǝǎǘNjǗǏǏ� ǒ� nj� NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǏ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏnj�NjǥǛǜǚǏǏ��ǡǏǖ�njnjǘǎǒǜǦ�ǏǍǘ�Ǜ�ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǥ��ƭǘǕǘǛǘnjǥǏ�ǔǘǖNJǗǎǥ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǝǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǎǕǩ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǒǩ�Ǚǚǘ-ǍǚNJǖǖǗǥǟ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǓ��ǚNJǑnjǏǚǜǥnjNJǗǒǩ�ǖǏǗǨ�ǒǕǒ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�Ǜ�ǞNJǓǕǘnjǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǘǓ��ƻǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ�ǍǘǕǘǛNJ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjǗǥ�ǚNJǛ-ǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǜǦ�ǚǏǡǦ� Ǜǘ� ǛǔǘǚǘǛǜǦǨ�ǎǘ����� ǛǕǘnj�nj�ǖǒǗǝǜǝ��ǙǚNJnjǎNJ��ǙǘǔNJ� Ǜǘ�ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘǖ�ǘǢǒNjǘǔ��ƮǕǩ�mǘNjǝǡǏǗǒǩ}�ǖNJǢǒǗǥ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑ-ǗNJnjNJǜǦ� ǒǗǜǘǗNJǠǒǒ� ǒ� ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ� ǙǚǘǒǑǗǘǢǏǗǒǩ� ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǘǍǘ� ǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜǛǩ� ǜNJǔ� ǗNJǑǥnjNJǏǖǥǏ�ǗǏǓǚǘǗǗǥǏ� ǛǏǜǒ��ƸǗǒ� ǙǚǏǎ-ǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǜ�ǛǘNjǘǓ�ǒǛǔǝǛǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�NJǗNJǕǘǍǒ�ǛǏǜǒ�ǗǏǚnjǗǥǟ�ǔǕǏǜǘǔ�ǐǒnjǘǍǘ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑǖNJ��ƻǝǜǦ�ǧǜǘǓ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒbȃ�ǙNJǚNJǕǕǏǕǦǗǥǏ�njǥǡǒǛǕǏǗǒǩ��ƲǛǔǝǛ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗNJǩ�ǗǏǓǚǘǗǗNJǩ� ǛǏǜǦbȃ� ǧǜǘ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǟ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǛǘNjǘǓ�ǙǚǘǛǜǥǟ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǘǚǘnj��ǔNJǐǎǥǓ�ǒǑ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǘNjǚNJNjNJǜǥnjNJǏǜ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǛǒǍǗNJǕǥ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǘǗ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǏǜ�ǘǜ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǘǚǘnj��ǒ�ǛǒǍǗNJǕǥ��ǔǘ-ǜǘǚǥǏ�ǘǗ�ǙǘǛǥǕNJǏǜ�ǎǚǝǍǒǖ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǘǚNJǖ��ƸǔNJǑǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ��ǡǜǘ�ǜNJǔǒǏ�Ǚǚǘ-ǛǜǥǏ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǘǚǥ��Njǝǎǝǡǒ�ǛǘǏǎǒǗǪǗǗǥǖǒ�nj�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�NjǘǕǦǢǝǨ�ǛǏǜǦ�Ǜ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦǨ� ǔNJǕǒNjǚǘnjǔǒ� ǒǟ� njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�� njǖǏǛǜǏ� ǛǙǘǛǘNjǗǥ�njǥǙǘǕǗǩǜǦ�ǎǘnjǘǕǦǗǘ�ǛǕǘǐǗǥǏ�ǑNJǎNJǡǒ��ƹǘǖǒǖǘ�ǒǑǝǡǏǗǒǩ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǔNJǔ�njǥ�ǙǚǘǒǑǗǘǛǒǜǏ�ǛǕǘnjNJ��ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ�ǍǘǕǘǛNJ�NJǗNJǕǒǑǒǚǝǨǜ�ǍǚNJǖ-ǖNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǔǘǗǜǏǔǛǜ�ǒ�ǡNJǛǜǘǜǝ�ǝǙǘǜǚǏNjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǛǕǘnj�ǎǕǩ�ǜǘǍǘ��

112 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƲ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ

Page 114: User identification analysis

ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǙǚǏǎǛǔNJǑNJǜǦ��ǔNJǔǘǏ�ǛǕǘnjǘ�njǥ�ǐǏǕNJǏǜǏ�njnjǏǛǜǒ��ƼNJǔǒǏ�ǖǘǣǗǥǏ�ǛǜNJ-ǜǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǜ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǏ�ǗNJǓǜǒ�nj�ǘNjǢǒǚǗǘǓ�ǩǑǥǔǘ-njǘǓ�NjNJǑǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒǖǏǗǗǘ�ǜǘ�ǛǕǘnjǘ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǏ�njǥ�ǙǚǘǒǑǗǏǛǕǒ��ǎNJǐǏ�ǏǛǕǒ�ǞǘǗǏǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǘNjǚNJǑ�NjǥǕ�ǗǏǘǎǗǘǑǗNJǡǗǥǖ�

ƪǗNJǕǒǑ�ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǡǏǚǔNJƪƷƪƵƲƱ�ƴƵƪƬƲƪƼƽƺƷƸƭƸ�ƹƸǁƯƺƴƪ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǛǘNjǘǓ�ǘǎǒǗ�ǒǑ�ǛNJǖǥǟ�ǙǏǚ-ǛǙǏǔǜǒnjǗǥǟ� ǗNJ� ǛǏǍǘǎǗǩ� ǖǏǜǘǎǘnj� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƴǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǗǥǓ� ǙǘǡǏǚǔbȃ�ǙǘnjǏǎǏǗǡǏǛǔNJǩ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ� ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒ-ǛǜǒǔNJ��ǔǘǜǘǚǝǨ�ǘǙǒǛǥnjNJǨǜ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ�ǙNJǚNJǖǏǜǚǥ��ǛǔǘǚǘǛǜǦ�njnjǘǎNJ��ǒǗ-ǜǏǚnjNJǕǥ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǗNJǐNJǜǒǩǖǒ�ǔǕNJnjǒǢ��njǚǏǖǩ�ǝǎǏǚǐNJǗǒǩ�ǔǕNJnjǒǢ��ǡǒǛǕǘ�ǙǏǚǏǔǚǥǜǒǓ� ǖǏǐǎǝ� ǔǕNJnjǒǢNJǖǒ�� ǛǜǏǙǏǗǦ� NJǚǒǜǖǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ� Ǚǚǒ� ǗNJNjǘǚǏ��ǡNJǛǜǘǜNJ�njǘǑǗǒǔǗǘnjǏǗǒǩ�ǘǢǒNjǘǔ�Ǚǚǒ�njnjǘǎǏ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘ-ǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǔǕNJnjǒǢ��LJǜNJ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǩ� ǝǗǒnjǏǚǛNJǕǦǗNJ��Ǘǘ�ǕǝǡǢǏ�njǛǏǍǘ�ǘǗNJ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎǒǜ�ǎǕǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�Ǜ�ǝǎNJǕǏǗǗǥǖ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǘǖ�ǔ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ƻǏǍǘǎǗǩ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔNJ�ǒ�ǘǙǜǒǖǒǑNJǠǒǩ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǘnj�� ǘǛǝ-ǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǨǣǒǟ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǦ�ǑNJ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǘǖ�ǔ�ǛǏǜǏnjǥǖ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛNJǖ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�NJǗNJǕǒǑNJ�ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǡǏǚǔNJ��ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǘǎǗǒǖ�ǒǑ�ǙǚǒǘǚǒǜǏǜǗǥǟ�ǗNJ-ǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǓ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǩ�nj�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ�ǔNJǔ�nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǑNJ�ǚǝNjǏǐǘǖ�

ƻǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǜ�ǎnjNJ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǙǘbǔǕNJnjǒ-NJǜǝǚǗǘǖǝ�ǙǘǡǏǚǔǝ��Ǚǘbnjnjǘǎǝ�ǒǑnjǏǛǜǗǘǓ�ǞǚNJǑǥ��ǙNJǚǘǕǩ��ǒ�Ǚǘbnjnjǘǎǝ�ǗǏ-ǒǑnjǏǛǜǗǘǓ�ǞǚNJǑǥ��ǍǏǗǏǚǒǚǝǏǖǘǓ�ǛǕǝǡNJǓǗǘ��ƸNjNJ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjNJ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�njǔǕǨ-ǡNJǜǦ� nj� ǛǏNjǩ� ǚǏǐǒǖ� ǘNjǝǡǏǗǒǩ� ǒ� ǛǘNjǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ� ǚǏǐǒǖ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƬbǚǏǐǒǖǏ�ǘNjǝǡǏǗǒǩ�ǙǝǜǪǖ�ǖǗǘǍǘǔǚNJǜǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘnjǜǘǚǏǗǒǩ�njnjǘǎNJ�ǚNJǛǛǡǒǜǥ-njNJǨǜǛǩ�ǧǜNJǕǘǗǗǥǏ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔǒ�ǗNJNjǘǚNJ�ǜǏǔǛǜNJ��ƴNJǔ�ǙǘǔNJǑNJǕ�ǚǩǎ�ǧǔǛ-ǙǏǚǒǖǏǗǜǘnj��ǎǕǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�nj�NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǏ�ǛǕǝǡNJ-Ǐnj�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǚNJǛǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǜǦ�njǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǏ�ǒǗǜǏǚnjNJǕǥ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǗNJǐNJǜǒǏǖ�ǔǕNJnjǒǢ�ǒ�njǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǏ�ǒǗǜǏǚnjNJǕǥ�ǝǎǏǚǐNJǗǒǩ�ǔǕNJnjǒǢ��ƪǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǜǏǖ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǗNJǎǪǐǗNJ��ǡǏǖ�ǎǕǒǗǗǏǏ�ǗNJNjǒǚNJǏǖNJǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǖ�ǞǚNJǑNJ�

ƹǕǨǛǥ� ǒ� ǖǒǗǝǛǥ� ǖǏǜǘǎNJ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� Ǚǘb ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǗǘǖǝ� Ǚǘ-ǡǏǚǔǝ� NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǗǥ� ǜǏǖ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�NjǥǕǒ�ǘǜǖǏǡǏǗǥ�ǎǕǩ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJ� ǚNJǛǙǘǑ-ǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ� ǍǘǕǘǛNJ��ƹǕǨǛǥ�� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�NjǏǑ� ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǘNjǘǚǝǎǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ǝǎǘNjǛǜnjǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǛǔǚǥǜǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� ƭǕNJnjǗǥǓ� ǖǒǗǝǛ�� ǖǘǜǘǚǗǥǏ� ǙNJǜǜǏǚǗǥ� ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ� ǑNJnjǒǛǩǜ�ǘǜ�ǛǘǛǜǘǩǗǒǩ�ǏǍǘ�ǑǎǘǚǘnjǦǩ��njǘǑǚNJǛǜNJ�ǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǙǘǛǜǘǚǘǗǗǒǟ�ǞNJǔǜǘǚǘnj�ǎNJǐǏ�ǛǒǕǦǗǏǏ��ǡǏǖ�ǍǘǕǘǛ��ƯǛǕǒ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖNJ�ǗǏǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǜǘǡǗǘ�ǗNJǛǜǚǘ-ǏǗNJ�� ǙǚǒǡǒǗǘǓ� ǘǜǔNJǑNJ� nj� ǎǘǛǜǝǙǏ� ǎǕǩ� NJnjǜǘǚǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�

113ƮƲƷƪƶƲǁƯƻƴƲƯ�ƶƯƼƸƮDž�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ

Page 115: User identification analysis

ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǛǜNJǜǦ�ǙǚǘǛǜNJǩ�ǝǛǜNJǕǘǛǜǦ��ƮǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗNJǩ�ǜǚǝǎǗǘǛǜǦ�ǛǘǛǜǘǒǜ�nj�ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǗǥǓ�ǙǘǡǏǚǔ�ǖǏǗǩǏǜǛǩ�Ǚǚǒ�ǙǏǚǏǟǘǎǏ�Ǜ�ǘǎǗǘǓ�ǔǕNJnjǒ-NJǜǝǚǥ�ǗNJ�ǎǚǝǍǝǨ��Ƭ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǛǜǒ��ǎǕǩ�ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǥ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǝ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ�ǙǚǒǎǏǜǛǩ�ǗNJǛǜǚNJǒnjNJǜǦ�ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǘ��ƴNJǔ�ǙǘǔNJ-ǑNJǕǒ�ǗǏǎNJnjǗǒǏ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ǙǘnjǥǛǒǜǦ�ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǦ�ǧǜǘǍǘ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǒǛǔǝǛǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǏ�ǎǘNjNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǚǒǜǖNJ��ƹǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏ-ǕǨ�ǙǚǏǎǕNJǍNJǏǜǛǩ�ǗNJNjǒǚNJǜǦ�ǙNJǚǘǕǦ�Ǜ� ǑNJǚNJǗǏǏ�ǒǑnjǏǛǜǗǥǖ�ǚǒǜǖǘǖ� �ǗNJ-ǙǚǒǖǏǚ��Ǚǘǎ�ǔNJǔǝǨ�ǗǒNjǝǎǦ�ǖǏǕǘǎǒǨ���ƺǒǜǖǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ�ǗNJNjǘǚNJ�ǙǘnjǥǢNJǏǜ�ǝǛǜǘǓǡǒnjǘǛǜǦ�ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǡǏǚǔNJ��ǔǚǘǖǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��nj�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� njǗǘǛǒǜǛǩ� ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗNJǩ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ� ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔNJ��ǝǔǚNJǛǜǦ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǔǘǙǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǔǘǜǘǚǝǨ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǗǏnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǥǖ�

ƬǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒƬ� ƹƸƻƵƯƮƷƯƯ� ƬƺƯƶlj� ƴ� ƶƯƼƸƮƽ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǙǘǎ-ǙǒǛǒ�ǙǚǘǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�NjǘǕǦǢǘǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǏǛ��njǏǚǘǩǜǗǘ��nj�ǛnjǩǑǒ�Ǜ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏ-ǗǒǏǖ�nj�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnj�Ǜ�ǛǏǗǛǘǚǗǥǖǒ�ǧǔǚNJǗNJǖǒ��ƮǕǩ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǜǘǡǗǘǓ�njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǛnjǏ-ǜǘnjǥǏ�ǙǏǚǦǩ��Ƭ�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǑNJǚǝNjǏǐǗǥǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗNJǟ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǏ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗ-ǜǥ��ǛǗNJNjǐǏǗǗǥǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦǨ��ǒǖǏǨǜ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǝǨ�ǛǒǕǝ��ǡǜǘ� ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ� ǙǏǚǏnjǘǎǒǜǦ� ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǝǨ� ǡNJǛǜǦ� ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘǘNjǘǚǘǜNJ� nj�ǛǏǜǏnjǝǨ�ǛǞǏǚǝ��ƴ�ǛǘǐNJǕǏǗǒǨ��nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ǙǘǔNJ�ǎǘnjǏǚǩǨǜ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǙǘǎǙǒ-ǛNJǗǗǘǖǝ�NjǝǖNJǐǗǘǖǝ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǝ�ǕǒNjǘ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖǝ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǝ�Ǜ�ǘǞǒǠǒ-NJǕǦǗǘ�ǑNJǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�LJǀƹ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǗǏǎǘǛǜNJǜǔǘǖ�LJǀƹ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǜǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǘǗNJ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǗNJ�ǎǚǝǍǘǖǝ�ǕǒǠǝ��ǜǘǍǎNJ�ǔNJǔ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǗǏǘǜǡǝǐǎNJǏǖǘǓ�ǘǜ�njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠNJ�

ƫǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�Ǚǘb ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ�ǖǘǐǏǜ� ǙǚǘnjǘǎǒǜǦǛǩ�ǎnjǝǖǩ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjNJǖǒ�

• ƻ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�NJǗNJǕǒǑNJ�njǒǑǝNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔ�ǛNJǖǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ��LJǜǘ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǎǏǕNJǜǦ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ�ǒǕǒ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚbȃ�njǘ�njǜǘǚǘǖ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�NJǗNJǕǒǑǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ�ǙǚǘǛǜǘ�ǛǜǏǙǏǗǦ�ǛǘnjǙNJǎǏǗǒǩ�ǎnjǝǟ�ǒǑǘNjǚNJǐǏǗǒǓ�

• ƴǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǓ�NJǗNJǕǒǑ�ǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔ�ǗNJǙǒǛNJǗǒǩ��ƮNJǗǗǥǏ�� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǎǕǩ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� njǔǕǨǡNJǨǜ�ǒǗǞǘǚ-ǖNJǠǒǨ�ǘ�ǛNJǖǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǘ�njǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǛǜNJǜǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔNJǟ�ǏǪ�ǗNJǙǒǛNJǗǒǩ�

ǂNJNjǕǘǗ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ�ǛǘǑǎNJǪǜǛǩ�nj�ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǘǜ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǍǘ�ǝǚǘnj-Ǘǩ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ��ƼNJǔ�ǔNJǔ�njǛǏ�ǙǕNJǗǢǏǜǥ�ǘǙǚNJǢǒnjNJǨǜǛǩ�Ǜ�ǔǘǗǏǡǗǘǓ�ǡNJǛǜǘǜǘǓ��NJ� ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛ� ǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ� ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔǘǖ� ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ� ǑNJǗǒǖNJǏǜ� ǘNjǥǡǗǘ� ǘǔǘǕǘ��Ȃ�bǛǏǔǝǗǎ��ǜǘ�ǗNJ�ǘǎǗǝ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǦ�ǙǚǒǟǘǎǒǜǛǩ�njǛǏǍǘ����Ȃ����ǜǘǡǏǔ��Ǚǘbǔǘ-

114 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƲ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ

Page 116: User identification analysis

ǜǘǚǥǖ�ǏǪ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�NJǗNJǕǒǑǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ��Ʒǘ�ǏǛǕǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦ�ǚNJǛǙǒǛǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ�ǛnjǏǜǘnjǥǖ�ǙǏǚǘǖ��ǔǘǎǒǚǝǨǜǛǩ�ǗǏ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǔǘǘǚǎǒǗNJǜǥ�ǔǘǗǡǒǔNJ�ǙǏǚNJ��Ǘǘ�ǒ�ǛǒǕNJ�ǗNJǐNJǜǒǩ��ǎNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ��ǙǏǚNJ�ǗNJ�ǙǕNJǗǢǏǜ��ǝǍǘǕ�ǗNJǔǕǘǗNJ�ǙǏǚNJ�ǘǜǗǘ-ǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǙǕNJǗǢǏǜNJ�ǒ�ǝǍǘǕ�ǙǏǚNJ�ǙǘbǡNJǛǘnjǘǓ�ǛǜǚǏǕǔǏ��ƷNJǒNjǘǕǏǏ�ǑǗNJǡǒ-ǜǏǕǦǗǝǨ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǝ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ��ǔNJǔ�ǒ�nj�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ�ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǡǏǚǔNJ��ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǒǑǖǏǗǡǒnjǘǛǜǦ�ǖǘ-ǜǘǚǗǥǟ�ǙNJǜǜǏǚǗǘnj�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�nj�ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǘǜ�ǙǛǒǟǘǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǛǘǛǜǘ-ǩǗǒǩ��Ƭ�ǠǏǕǘǖ��Ǚǚǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǒ�mǘNjǝǡNJǨǣǒǟǛǩ}�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǘnj�ǔǘǕǒ-ǡǏǛǜnjǘ�ǘǢǒNjǘǔ�ǛǒǕǦǗǘ�ǑNJnjǒǛǒǜ�ǘǜ�ǙǚǘǎǘǕǐǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǞNJǑǥ�ǘNjǝǡǏǗǒǩ�

ƴǘǖNjǒǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ

ƴǘǖNjǒǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗNJǩ� �ǖǝǕǦǜǒǖǘǎNJǕǦǗNJǩ�� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǛǘNjǘǓ�ǛǘǡǏǜNJǗǒǏ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǒǟ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒ-ǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ� nj� ǘǎǗǘǖ� ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjǏ�� ƴǘǖNjǒǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ� NjǘǕǏǏ� ǗNJǎǪǐǗǥǖǒ� Ǜ� ǜǘǡǔǒ� ǑǚǏǗǒǩ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ� ǒǖǒǜNJǠǒǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�� ǜNJǔ�ǔNJǔ�ǜǚǝǎǗǏǏ�ǙǘǎǎǏǕNJǜǦ�ǠǏǕǥǓ�ǚǩǎ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔ��ǡǏǖ�ǞNJǕǦǛǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǘǎǒǗ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǔ��ƷNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��NjǘǕǦǢǘǓ�ǗNJǎǪǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǘǐǒǎNJǜǦ�ǘǜ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ǜǒǙNJ�mǙNJǕǏǠ���ǚǝǔNJ}�ǒǕǒ�mǙNJǕǏǠ���ǚNJǎǝǐǗNJǩ�ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔNJ�ǍǕNJǑNJ}�

Ƭ� ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǏ� njǚǏǖǩ� NjǘǕǦǢǘǓ� ǒǗǜǏǚǏǛ� ǙǚǘǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǔ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖ�ǜǒǙNJ�mǕǒǠǘ��� ǍǘǕǘǛ}��ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǏ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǛnjǩǑNJǗǘ�Ǜ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǒǏǖ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǛǘnjǖǏǣNJǨǣǒǟ�nj�ǛǏNjǏ�njǒǑǝNJǕǦǗǝǨ�ǒ�NJǝǎǒNJǕǦ-ǗǝǨ�ǖǘǎNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�� Ǜǘǜǘnjǥǟ� ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǘnj� Ǜǘ�njǛǜǚǘǏǗǗǘǓ�njǒǎǏǘǔNJǖǏǚǘǓ��ǗǘǝǜNjǝǔǘnj�ǒbǜ�ɋǎ��ƮǕǩ�ǎǏǖǘǗǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǜNJǔǒǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǎNJǨǜ�ǑǗNJ-ǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǓ�ǙǚǒǚǘǛǜ�ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǘbǛǚNJnjǗǏǗǒǨ�Ǜ�ǔNJǐǎǘǓ�ǒǑ�ǖǘǗǘ-ǖǘǎNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�nj�ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ��ǡNJǛǜǘ�ǙǚǒnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǓ�Ǚǚǒ-ǖǏǚ��ƹǏǚǏǎ�ǛǕǝǐNjǘǓ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǘǎǗǘǍǘ�ǒǑ�NjNJǗǔǘnj�NjǥǕNJ�ǙǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗNJ�ǑNJǎNJǡNJ�ǛǘǔǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�ǞǚǘǎNJ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǛǗǩǜǒǩ�ǎǏǗǏǍ�ǙǘbǙǘǎǕǘǐǗǥǖ�ǎǘ-ǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǖ���ƮǕǩ�ǧǜǘǍǘ�ǗNJǡNJǕNJ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǕǒǠǝ��Ǘǘ�ǒǑ�ǑNJ�ǗǏnjǥǛǘǔǘǍǘ�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjNJ�ǔNJǖǏǚ�ǡNJǛǜǘǜNJ�ǘǢǒNjǘǔ�ǗǏǙǚǒ-ǑǗNJǗǒǩ�ǘǔNJǑNJǕNJǛǦ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�NjǘǕǦǢǘǓ���Ɍ����ƼǘǍǎNJ�NjǥǕǘ�ǙǚǏǎǕǘǐǏǗǘ�ǛǘnjǖǏǛǜǒǜǦ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ�ǙǘbǕǒǠǝ�ǒ�ǍǘǕǘǛǝ��ƸǜǎǏǕǦǗǘ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjNJǩ�NJǝ-ǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǎNJnjNJǕNJ�njǥǛǘǔǒǓ�ǙǚǘǠǏǗǜ�ǘǢǒNjǔǒ���Ɍ���ǑNJ�ǛǡǏǜ�Ǟǘ-Ǘǘnjǥǟ�Ǣǝǖǘnj��Ǘǘ�Ǚǚǒ�ǛǘnjǖǏǣǏǗǒǒ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǎǘǛǜǒǍǕNJ�Ǚǘǡǜǒ�ǛǜǘǙǚǘǠǏǗǜǗǘǓ�ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ�

115ƴƸƶƫƲƷƲƺƸƬƪƷƷDžƯ�ƻƲƻƼƯƶDž�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ

Page 117: User identification analysis

ƮǕǩ�ǘǙǜǒǖǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǩ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjNJ�ǘǢǒNjǘǔ�ǔǘ�njǚǏǖǏǗǒ��ǜǚǏ-NjǝǏǖǘǖǝ� ǗNJ� ǘǎǗǝ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�� ǖǘǐǗǘ� njNJǚǦǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ� ǛǙǘǛǘNjǥ� Ǜǘ-ǏǎǒǗǏǗǒǩ� ǎnjǝǟ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�� ƻǒǛǜǏǖǥ� Ǜ� njǥǛǘǔǒǖ� NjǥǛǜǚǘ-ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏǖ�ǒ�ǗǏ�ǘǡǏǗǦ�NjǘǕǦǢǘǓ�ǗNJǎǪǐǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǒǖǏǏǜ�ǛǖǥǛǕ�ǛǘǏǎǒǗǩǜǦ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǗǘ�� NjǘǕǏǏ� ǗNJǎǪǐǗǥǏ� ǒ� ǖǏǎǕǏǗǗǥǏ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥbȃ� ǙNJǚNJǕ-ǕǏǕǦǗǘ�� ƻǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ� ǜNJǔǐǏ� ǒǏǚNJǚǟǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ� njNJǚǒNJǗǜ�� ǔǘǍǎNJ� NjǘǕǏǏ� Njǥ-ǛǜǚNJǩ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ� �ǛǔNJǐǏǖ�� ǛǔNJǗǏǚ� ǕǒǠ�� ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǗǥǓ�ǗNJ� njǟǘǎǏ� nj� NjNJǗǔ��ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜ� ǙǚǏǎnjNJǚǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǓ� ǘǜNjǘǚ� ǑNJǙǒǛǏǓ�� Ǜ� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǖǒ� NjǘǕǏǏ�ǖǏǎǕǏǗǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ��ǛǔNJǐǏǖ��ǛǔNJǗǏǚ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔNJ�ǙNJǕǦǠNJ��ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǗǥǓ�ǝ�NjNJǗǔǘǖNJǜNJ��NjǝǎǏǜ�ǛǚNJnjǗǒnjNJǜǦ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�

ƴǚǘǖǏ� ǔǘǖNjǒǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǜ�ǖǗǘǍǘǞNJǔǜǘǚǗǥǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��ǍǎǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜǛǩ�njǖǏǛǜǏ�Ǜ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǏǓ�ǙǘbǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖǝ�ǔǕǨǡǝ�ǒǕǒ� ǙNJǚǘǕǨ��ƶǏǜǘǎNJǖ�ǖǗǘǍǘǞNJǔǜǘǚǗǘǓ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǛǏǍǘǎǗǩ� ǎǘ-njǏǚǩǏǜ� NjǘǕǦǢǘǏ� ǡǒǛǕǘ� ǑNJǚǝNjǏǐǗǥǟ� ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ�� ǛǚǏǎǒ� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ� ǘǚǍNJ-ǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǘǍǘ� ǒ� ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjǘǍǘ� ǛǏǔǜǘǚǘnj� ǚǥǗǔNJ�� ǚǥǗǔNJ� njǥǛǘǔǒǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ��ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǙǚǏǎǙǚǒǩǜǒǩ��ǗǏǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǥǏ�ǧǔǛǙǏǚǜǗǥǏ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǏ�Ǟǒǚǖǥ�

ƱNJǣǒǜNJ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ

ƴƪƴ�Ʋ�Ƭƻljƴƪlj�ƲƷƾƸƺƶƪǀƲƸƷƷƪlj�ƻƲƻƼƯƶƪ��NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NJǝǜǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǖǘǐǏǜ� ǙǘǎnjǏǚǍǗǝǜǦǛǩ� NJǜNJǔǏ� ǑǕǘǝǖǥǢǕǏǗǗǒǔǘnj�� ƹǘǧǜǘǖǝ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǏ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǥ� nj� ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ�ǗNJǡǒǗNJǩ� Ǜ� ����b ǍǘǎNJ� �ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ� Ζ62�Ζ(&� ������������ ǚǏǍǕNJǖǏǗǜǒǚǝǨǜ�ǖǏǚǥ�ǙǘbǑNJǣǒǜǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��Ƭ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǗǥǏ�ǛǜNJǗ-ǎNJǚǜǥ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǥ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǖ�mƸ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ}��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�njǛǜǝǙǒǕ�nj�ǛǒǕǝ�nj�ǩǗnjNJǚǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ǒ�NjǥǕ�ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗ�nj�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǒǓ�ǚNJǑ�nj�ǒǨǕǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ�

ƸǎǗǘ�ǒǑ�ǛNJǖǥǟ�NJǔǜǝNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǓ�nj�ǛǞǏǚǏ�ǛǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǟ�Njǒǘ-ǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓbȃ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔNJ� ǛǟǏǖ� ǑNJǣǒǜǥ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗǘnj��ǟǚNJǗǩǣǒǟǛǩ�nj�NjNJǑǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��ƻǏǍǘǎǗǩ�mǔǚNJǐNJ�ǕǒǡǗǘ-Ǜǜǒ}bȃ�ǘǎǗǘ�ǒǑ�ǛNJǖǥǟ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǗǥǟ�ǔǒNjǏǚǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǕǏǗǒǓ�njǘ�ǖǗǘǍǒǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗNJǟ�ǖǒǚNJ��ƽǜǏǡǔNJ�ǒǑ�NjNJǑǥ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗǘnj�ǙǘnjǥǢNJǏǜ�ǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǦ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǙǚǏ-ǛǜǝǙǕǏǗǒǓ�� ǜNJǔ� ǔNJǔ� ǑǕǘǝǖǥǢǕǏǗǗǒǔǝ� ǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǛǩ� ǙǚǘǣǏ� njǘǛǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǦ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǙǝǜǏǖ�ǘNjǚNJǜǗǘǍǘ�ǒǗǐǒǗǒǚǒǗǍNJ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗNJ��ƹǚǒ-ǡǪǖ�ǝǔǚNJǎǏǗǗǥǓ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗ��nj�ǘǜǕǒǡǒǏ�ǘǜ�ǙNJǚǘǕǩ��ǗǏǕǦǑǩ�ǑNJǖǏǗǒǜǦ�Ǘǘnjǥǖ��

116 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƲ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ

Page 118: User identification analysis

ǏǣǏ� ǗǏ� ǛǔǘǖǙǚǘǖǏǜǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǖ�� ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ� ǙǚǒǑǗNJǔǒ�ǗǏǘǜǡǝǐǎNJǏǖǥ�ǘǜ�ǛnjǘǏǍǘ�ǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǩ��ƴǚNJǐNJ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗǘnj�ǘǙNJǛǗNJ�ǗǏ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǘǖ�ǑǕǘǝǖǥǢǕǏǗǗǒǔNJ�nj�ǑNJǣǒǣǪǗǗǥǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��Ǘǘ�ǒ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǜNJǓǗǘǓ�ǛǕǏǐǔǒ�ǑNJ�ǕǨǎǦǖǒ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ�ǙǚǒnjNJǜǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǘ�Ǘǒǟ�

ƹǚǒǖǏǚ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǡǏǚǜǥ�ǖǏǜǘǎǘǖ�ǘNjǚNJǜǗǘǓ�ǒǗǐǏǗǏǚǒǒ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǏǍǘ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗNJ��NJ�ȃ�ǘǚǒǍǒǗNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǛǗǒǖǘǔ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔNJ��Nj�ȃ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘ�ǕǒǗǒǩǟ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗNJ��ǒǑnjǕǏǡǏǗǗNJǩ�ǒǑ�ǛǗǒǖǔNJ�

ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔNJ��nj�ȃ�ǘNjǚNJǑ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔNJ��ǚǏǔǘǗǛǜǚǝǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǓ�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǘ�ǕǒǗǒǩǟ

ƻǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǜ�ǜǚǒ�ǘNjǣǒǟ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǔ�ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǢNJ-NjǕǘǗǘnj�

• ƷǏǘNjǚNJǜǒǖǘǛǜǦ��ƱǕǘǝǖǥǢǕǏǗǗǒǔǝ�ǎǘǕǐǗǘ�NjǥǜǦ�ǑNJǜǚǝǎǗǒǜǏǕǦ-Ǘǘ�njǥǡǒǛǕǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǙǝǜǏǖ�njǘǛǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǦ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǡǏǚǜǥ�ǒǑ� ǛǘǟǚNJǗǪǗǗǘǍǘ� ǢNJNjǕǘǗNJ� ǕǒNjǘ� ǛǘǑǎNJǜǦ� ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ� ǙǘǎǎǏǕǔǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǔNJ�

• ƺNJǑǕǒǡǒǖǘǛǜǦ��ƻǟǏǖNJ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗNJ�ǗǏ�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�ǝǟǝǎǢNJǜǦ�ǜǘǡ-ǗǘǛǜǦ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǘǓ�

• ƸǜǖǏǗǩǏǖǘǛǜǦ�� ƮǘǕǐǗNJ� NjǥǜǦ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ� ǒǑ� ǘǎǗǒǟ� ǒ� ǜǏǟb ǐǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� ǛǘǑǎNJǜǦ� ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ� ǑNJǣǒǣǪǗǗǥǟ�ǢNJNj�ǕǘǗǘnj��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǗǏǕǦǑǩ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǛnjǩǑNJǜǦ�Ǜ�ǧǜǒǖǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖǒ��LJǜǘ�ǛnjǘǓ-Ǜǜnjǘ�ǗǏ� ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�ǘǜǑǥnjNJǜǦ�ǒ�njǥǎNJnjNJǜǦ�ǗǘnjǥǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗǥ�nj�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǔǘǖǙǚǘǖǏ-ǜNJǠǒǒ�NjNJǑǥ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��Ǘǘ�ǒ�ǙǚǏǎǘǜnjǚNJǣNJǏǜ�ǙǏǚǏǔǚǏǛǜǗǘǏ�ǛǘǙǘǛǜNJnj-ǕǏǗǒǏ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�NjNJǑNJǖǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�� ǑNJ�ǛǡǪǜ�ǡǏǍǘ�ǛǘǟǚNJǗǩǏǜǛǩ�ǙǚǒnjNJǜ-ǗǘǛǜǦ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏ�

ƹǚǒ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǒ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗNJǩ�ǑNJǎNJǡNJ�ǛǘǛǜǘǒǜ�nj�ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǗNJǓǜǒ�ǙǚǒǏǖǕǏǖǥǓ�ǔǘǖǙǚǘǖǒǛǛ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǧǜǒǖǒ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩǖǒ�

ƲǖǏǨǜǛǩ�ǎnjNJ�ǘNjǣǒǟ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙNJ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗǘnj��ǜǚNJǗǛǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǡǏǚǜ� ǒ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ� ǔǚǒǙǜǘǛǒ-ǛǜǏǖǥ�

117ƱƪǃƲƼƪ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƲƿ�ƮƪƷƷDžƿ

Page 119: User identification analysis

ƼǚNJǗǛǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǡǏǚǜƼƺƪƷƻƾƸƺƶƪǀƲlj� ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƲƿ� ǁƯƺƼ�ȃ�ǧǜǘ�ǖǏǜǘǎ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗNJ�Ǚǝ-ǜǪǖ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǔ�ǗǏǖǝ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǒ�ǜǚNJǗǛǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ƾǝǗǔǠǒǩ�ǜǚNJǗǛǞǘǚ-ǖNJǠǒǒ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ� ǛǘNjǘǓ� ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǗǥǓ�ǖǏǜǘǎ�ǢǒǞǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ǒ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǕǨNjǘǓ��ǏǛǕǒ�njǥǙǘǕǗǩǨǜǛǩ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩ�

• ƷǏǘNjǚNJǜǒǖǘǛǜǦbȃ�ǗǏnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǘ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǒǑ� ǜǚNJǗǛǞǘǚǖǒǚǘnjNJǗ-Ǘǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒǛǟǘǎǗǥǏ��ǗǏ�ǑǗNJǩ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǒ�ǜǚNJǗǛǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�

• ƻnjǘNjǘǎNJ�ǘǜ�ǔǘǕǕǒǑǒǓbȃ�ǗǏ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǘǎǒǗNJǔǘnjǘǍǘ�ǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜNJ�ǎǕǩ�ǎnjǝǟ�ǚNJǑǗǥǟ�ǒǛǟǘǎǗǥǟ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ�

• ƼǏǚǙǒǖǘǛǜǦ�ǔ�ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǨ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǡǏǚǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�Ǜǘ�njǚǏǖǏǗǏǖ�

ƸNjǥǡǗǘ� ǞǝǗǔǠǒǩ� ǜǚNJǗǛǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ� ǘǛǗǘnjǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ� ǗNJ� ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎǝNJǕǦ-Ǘǥǟ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔNJǟ�ǛNJǖǘǍǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��Ƭ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǏ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǩǏǜ� ǜǝbǐǏ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǨ�ǜǚNJǗǛǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǔ� ǑNJǙǚǘǛǝ��ǒ�ǛǘǙǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ� ǙǚǘǒǛǟǘǎǒǜ� ǝǐǏ� ǎǕǩ� ǜǚNJǗǛǞǘǚǖǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ� ǘNjǚNJǑǠNJ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�ǗNJǓǜǒ�ǝǎNJǡǗǝǨ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǨ�ǜǚNJǗǛǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�NjǥnjNJǏǜ�ǛǕǘǐǗǘ�

ƫǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘǛǒǛǜǏǖǥƻƸƭƵƪƻƷƸ� ƹƸƻƵƯƮƷƲƶ� ƲƱƶƯƷƯƷƲljƶ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�� ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚ� Njǒǘ-ǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ� ǗǏ� ǖǘǐǏǜ� ǛnjǘǏnjǘǕǦǗǘ� ǖǏǗǩǜǦ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ� ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ� NjǏǑ� ǏǍǘ� ǙǚǒǛǝǜǛǜnjǒǩ�� ƹǘǧǜǘǖǝ� ǏǎǒǗǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ� Ǚǚǒ-ǏǖǕǏǖǥǖ�njNJǚǒNJǗǜǘǖ�ǛǜNJǗǘnjǩǜǛǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��nj�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǟǚNJǗǩǜǛǩ�nj�ǑNJǢǒǞǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ��ƻǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǜ�ǎnjNJ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJ�ǜNJ-ǔǘǍǘ�ǢǒǞǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ǢǒǞǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǘNjǥǡǗǘǍǘ�ǔǕǨǡNJ�ǒ�ǢǒǞǚǘ-njNJǗǒǏ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǖ�ǔǕǨǡǘǖ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�Ǘǒǖ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�NjǥǕǘ�ǙǘǕǝ-ǡǒǜǦ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�nj�ǙǚǒǛǝǜǛǜnjǒǒ�ǒǟ�njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠNJ���ƹǚǒ�ǘNjǥǡǗǘǓ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǒ�ǑNJǢǒǞǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǓ� ǢNJNjǕǘǗ� ǒ� ǔǕǨǡ� ǚNJǛǢǒǞǚǘnjǔǒb ȃ� ǧǜǘ� ǎnjǏ� ǚNJǑǗǥǏ�ǏǎǒǗǒǠǥ��ǒ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗ�ǑNJǣǒǣǏǗ��ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǏǛǕǒ�ǑNJǣǒǣǏǗ�ǒ�ǔǕǨǡ��Ƭ�NjǒǘǖǏ-ǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǖ�ǔǕǨǡǏ�ǒǗǔNJǙǛǝǕǒǚǝǨǜǛǩ�ǘǎǗǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǘ�ǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗ��ǒ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǔǕǨǡ��ƹǚǒ�ǜNJǔǘǖ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjǏ�ǢǒǞǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�nj�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�ǟǚNJǗǒǜǛǩ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǡNJǛǜǦ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǙǘǕǝ-ǡǏǗǗǘǓ� ǒǑ� ǢNJNjǕǘǗNJ�� ƸǗNJ� ǗNJǑǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ� ǑNJǣǒǣǪǗǗǥǖ� ǧǛǔǒǑǘǖ� �VHFXUH�VNHWFK��� ƸǚǒǍǒǗNJǕǦǗǥǓ� ǢNJNjǕǘǗ� njǘǛǛǜNJǗNJnjǕǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ� ǗNJ� ǘǛǗǘnjǏ� ǑNJǣǒ-ǣǪǗǗǘǍǘ�ǧǛǔǒǑNJ�Ǚǚǒ�ǗNJǕǒǡǒǒ�ǎǚǝǍǘǍǘ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǘNjǚNJǑǠNJ��Ǚǘ-ǟǘǐǏǍǘ�ǗNJ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǥǓ�Ǚǚǒ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ��ƲǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǒ�ǙǚǏǎǕǘǐǒǕǒ�ǎnjNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǟ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJ�ǍǏǗǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǑNJǣǒǣǪǗǗǘǍǘ�ǧǛǔǒǑNJ��ǗǏǡǪǜǔǘǏ�ǘNjǩ-ǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ� �IX]]\� FRPPLWPHQW�� ǒ�ǗǏǡǪǜǔǒǓ� ǛǏǓǞ� �IX]]\� YDXOW���ƹǏǚnjǥǓ�ǖǘǐǗǘ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ� ǎǕǩ� ǑNJǣǒǜǥ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǢNJNjǕǘǗǘnj�� ǙǚǏǎ-

118 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƲ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ

Page 120: User identification analysis

ǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǗǥǟ�nj�njǒǎǏ�ǎnjǘǒǡǗǥǟ�Ǜǜǚǘǔ�ǞǒǔǛǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǎǕǒǗǥ��ƬǜǘǚǘǓ�Ǚǘ-ǕǏǑǏǗ�ǎǕǩ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗǘnj��ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǗǥǟ�nj�njǒǎǏ�ǗNJNjǘǚǘnj�ǜǘǡǏǔ�

ƲǗǜǏǍǚNJǠǒǩ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǒ� ǔǚǒǙǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ� ǘǜ-ǔǚǥnjNJǏǜ� ǗǘnjǥǏ� ǙǏǚǛǙǏǔǜǒnjǥ� nj� ǛǞǏǚǏ� ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��Ƭ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǛǜǒ��ǘNjǤǏǎǒǗǏǗǒǏ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǓ��ǔNJǔ�ǖǗǘǍǘ-ǞNJǔǜǘǚǗNJǩ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǩ��ǙǘǚǘǍǘnjNJǩ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǩ�Ǜ�ǚNJǑǎǏǕǏǗǒǏǖ�ǛǏǔǚǏǜNJ�ǒ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�ǙǚǏǘNjǚNJǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǗǏǡǏǜǔǒǟ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǙNJǚNJǖǏǜǚǘnj�nj�ǔǕǨ-ǡǏnjǥǏ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ��ǘNjǚNJǑǝǏǜ�ǗǘnjǘǏ�ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ�nj�ǛǞǏǚǏ�ǑNJǣǒ-ǜǥ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒbȃ�ǖǗǘǍǘǞNJǔǜǘǚǗǝǨ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǝǨ�ǔǚǒǙǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǨ�

ƴǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǥǏ�ǒǗǐǏǗǏǚǗǥǏ�ǒbǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǏ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǥ�ǗNJ�NjNJǑǏ�

NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ

ƶǝǕǦǜǒNjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ69��ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǘǔ�ǙNJǕǦǠNJ�ǕǒǠǘ�ǚNJǎǝǐǗNJǩ�ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔNJ�ǙNJǚǘǕǦ��ǘǜ�%LR(QDEOH�7HFKQRORJLHVƬ� ƺƪƶƴƪƿ� ƹƺƸƯƴƼƪ� ƻƸƱƮƪƷƸ�ǒ�ǚNJǑnjǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǗǘǏ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǏ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�� njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ƸǛǘNjǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�

• mƮnjǒǐǘǔ}�NJǗNJǕǒǑNJ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǘnj�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj�ǛǙǘǛǘNjǏǗ�ǘNjǚNJNjNJǜǥnjNJǜǦ����b ǜǥǛǩǡ� ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǘnj� nj� ǛǏǔǗǝǎǝ�� �� ǖǕǗ� ���� ǜǥǛ�� ǕǒǠ� nj� ǛǏǔǝǗǎǝ�ǒǒǕǒ��bǖǕǗ�����ǜǥǛ��ǚNJǎǝǐǗǥǟ�ǘNjǘǕǘǡǏǔ�

• ƹǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǚNJNjǘǜNJǜǦ�nj�ǞǘǗǘnjǘǖ�ǚǏǐǒǖǏ��ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǩ�ǔǘǖ-ǙǦǨǜǏǚǝ�njǥǙǘǕǗǩǜǦ�ǙǘǛǜǘǚǘǗǗǒǏ�ǑNJǎNJǡǒ�

• ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ� ǖǘǐǏǜ� NjǥǜǦ� ǗNJǛǜǚǘǏǗNJ� ǜNJǔǒǖ� ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�� ǡǜǘ� njǘǑǖǘǐǏǗ�njǥNjǘǚ�ǔǘǖNjǒǗNJǠǒǓ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǙǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǏǓ�

ƶǝǕǦǜǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��0%$6�70

ƹƺƸƯƴƼ�0%$6��0XOWL�%LRPHWULF�$XWKHQWLFDWLRQ�6\VWHP��ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗ�ǗNJ�ǚNJǑ-njǒǜǒǏ�ǗNJǎǏǐǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦ-ǔǒǟ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔ��ƾǒǗNJǗǛǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ� ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǏǓ�ƮǐǏ-ǗǏǚNJǕ�ƶǘǜǘǚǛ�ǒ�ƷNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǒǗǛǜǒǜǝǜǘǖ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǘnj�ǒ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ��� KWWS���ZZZ�ELRHQDEOHWHFK�FRP�JRYHUQPHQW�QDWLRQDO�LG�PXOWLELRPHWULF�DXWKHQWLFDWLRQ�V\VWHP�ILQJHUSULQW�IDFH�LULV�SDVVZRUG�� KWWSV���ZZZ�F\ODE�FPX�HGX�UHVHDUFK�SURMHFWV������PXOWLELRPHWULF�DXWKHQWLFDWLRQ�KWPO� VWKDVK�83��]5�O�GSXI

119ƴƸƷƴƺƯƼƷDžƯ�ƲƷưƯƷƯƺƷDžƯ�ƲbƲƻƻƵƯƮƸƬƪƼƯƵdžƻƴƲƯ�ƹƺƸƯƴƼDž�Ʒƪ�ƫƪƱƯ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƲƿbƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƳ

Page 121: User identification analysis

ƻǂƪ�1Ζ67��Ƭ�NJǗǗǘǜNJǠǒǒ�ǔ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǝ�ǝǔNJǑǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ��ǡǜǘ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǜNJǔǘǓ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǙǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǦ�� ǔNJǔ�ǘNjǚNJǑ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǕǒǠNJ�� ǑNJnjǒǛǒǜ�ǘǜ� ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjNJ� ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǞNJǔǜǘǚǘnj�� ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ� ǘǛnjǏǣǏǗǒǩ�� ǖǒǖǒǡǏ-ǛǔǘǍǘ� njǥǚNJǐǏǗǒǩ�ǒ� ǝǍǕNJ�ǙǘnjǘǚǘǜNJ�ǙǘbǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǨ�ǔ� ǔNJǖǏǚǏ��ƹǘb ǧǜǘǓ�ǙǚǒǡǒǗǏ�ǗNJǎǪǐǗNJǩ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǡǏǖ�ǘǎǒǗ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǙǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǦ�

ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ� ǑNJǩnjǕǏǗǒǨ�NJnjǜǘǚǘnj�� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǙNJǚǘǕǩ��ǗNJ� ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ� ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗ� ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǦ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ� ǔ� NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǝ� ǛǘnjǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǟ�ǑNJǣǒǣǪǗǗǥǟ� ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǓ�� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǗǏǗNJǎǪǐǗǥǖ� ǖǏǜǘǎǘǖ�� ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦ-ǔǝ�ǙNJǚǘǕǦ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǑNJNjǥǜ�ǒǕǒ�ǝǔǚNJǎǏǗ��ƭǘǚNJǑǎǘ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǗǥ�NjǒǘǖǏǜ�ǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǜNJǔǒǏ�ǔNJǔ�ǛǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǘǜǙǏ-ǡNJǜǔǘnj�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��ǕǒǠǝ��ǚNJǎǝǐǗǘǓ�ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔǒ�ǍǕNJǑNJ��ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ�ǍǘǕǘǛNJ�ǒbǜ�ɋǎ��ƹǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗNJǩ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖNJ�Ǚǚǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏ-Ǜǔǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟbȃ�ǒǟ�ǗǘǚǖNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǒǑǖǏǗǡǒnjǘǛǜǦ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǕǒǠǘ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�njǥǍǕǩǎǏǜǦ�Ǚǘ�ǚNJǑǗǘǖǝ�Ǚǚǒ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǘǓ�ǙǘǎǛnjǏǜǔǏ��ǚNJǑǗǘǖ�njǥǚNJǐǏ-Ǘǒǒ�ǒǕǒ�ǚNJǑǗǘǓ�ǘǚǒǏǗǜNJǠǒǒ�ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǔNJǖǏǚǥ���NJǔǜǝNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǑNJǎNJǡǏǓ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ǔǘǖNjǒǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�Ǜ�ǍǒNjǔǘǓ�ǗNJǛǜǚǘǓǔǘǓ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǕNJbNjǥ�ǎǘǛǜǒǡǦ�ǘǙǜǒǖNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǔǘǖǙǚǘǖǒǛǛNJ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǗNJǎǪǐǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǒ�ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǦǨ��ƿǘǜǩ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǘǏ�njǗǒǖNJǗǒǏ�nj�ǧǜǘǖ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǏ�ǛǘǛǚǏǎǘǜǘǡǏǗǘ�ǗNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��NjǘǕǦǢNJǩ�ǡNJǛǜǦ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ�njǙǘǕǗǏ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎǒǜ�ǎǕǩ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

Ƭ� ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǏ� njǚǏǖǩ� Ǚǚǒ� ǚNJNjǘǜǏ� Ǜ� NjNJǑǘǓ� ǒǑǘNjǚNJǐǏǗǒǓ� ǕǒǠ�� ǛǘǛǜǘ-ǩǣǏǓ�ǒǑ�ǞǘǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǓ����ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ�Ǜ����ǚNJǑǗǥǖǒ�njǥǚNJǐǏǗǒǩǖǒ�ǕǒǠNJ�ǝ�ǔNJǐǎǘǍǘ�� 0%$6� ǎǘǛǜǒǍǕNJ� ǛǜNJNjǒǕǦǗǘǓ� ǡNJǛǜǘǜǥ� ǘǢǒNjǘǔ� ǘǔǘǕǘ� ����Ɍ���njbǎNJǗǗǘǖ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǘǢǒNjǘǡǗǘǏ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǒ�ǘǢǒNjǘǡǗǥǓ�ǘǜǔNJǑ�nj�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǏ�ǗǏ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡNJǨǜǛǩ���ƹǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǎǕǩ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǕǒǛǦ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǜǚǒ�ǒǑǘNjǚNJǐǏǗǒǩ�Ǜ�ǔNJǐǎǘǍǘ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ��ƺNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǡǒǔǒ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǎǘNjǒǕǒǛǦ�ǗǝǕǏnjǘǍǘ�ǙǚǘǠǏǗǜNJ�ǘǢǒNjǘǔ�Ǚǚǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǕǒǠ�Ǜ�ǚNJǑǗǥǖ�ǘǛnjǏǣǏǗǒǏǖ��ƷNJǛǜǘǕǦǔǘbǐǏ�njǥǛǘǔǘǓ�ǘǔNJǑNJǕNJǛǦ�ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǦ�0%$6�Ǚǚǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔNJǖ�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��Ƭ�NjǕǒǐNJǓǢǏǖ�Njǝ-ǎǝǣǏǖ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǜǏǛǜǒǚǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǑNJǎNJǡNJǟ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ�ǍǘǕǘǛNJ�ǒ�ǚNJǎǝǐǗǘǓ�ǘNjǘǕǘǡǔǒ�ǍǕNJǑNJ��Ƭ�ǙǕNJǗNJǟ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǡǒǔǘnj�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǝǕǝǡǢǏǗǒǏ�NjǥǛǜǚǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǘnj�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǒǗǜǏǍǚNJǠǒǒ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�Ǜ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥ-ǖǒ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǖǒ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJǖǒ�

ƮǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒƼƽƺƯǀƴƲƳ� ƲƻƻƵƯƮƸƬƪƼƯƵdžƻƴƲƳ� ƹƺƸƯƴƼ� ƭ�ɊƪǗNJǗǜNJǔǚǒǢǗNJǗNJ�� ƿ�ɊưǒNjǏ-ǔǕǒǘ��ƪ�ɊƵǘǙǏǛNJ�ǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��ǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜǥ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǍǘ�NjǥǕǒ�

120 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƲ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ

Page 122: User identification analysis

ǘǙǝNjǕǒǔǘnjNJǗǥ� nj� ǛǜNJǜǦǏ� mƮǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}����ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗ�ǗNJ�NJǗNJǕǒǑǏ�NJǗǜǚǘǙǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǙǘǔNJǑNJ-ǜǏǕǏǓ�� ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎǝNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǖǘǎNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǏǓ� ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǓ� ǜǏǕNJ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǙǏǚǏǎ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǘǖ��ǖǒǖǒǔǒ�ǕǒǠNJ��NJǗNJǕǒǑNJ�ǚǏǡǒ��NJbǜNJǔ-ǐǏ�ǙNJǜǜǏǚǗǘnj�ǑNJǟnjNJǜNJ�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�Njǥǜǘnjǥǟ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜǘnj��ǚNJǑǖǏǣǏǗǗǥǟ�ǙǏǚǏǎ� ǔNJǖǏǚǘǓ��ƲǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǙǚǘnjǘǎǩǜǛǩ� Ǜ� ǠǏǕǦǨ�ǞǘǚǖNJǕǒǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǒ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǒǑǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�NJǗNJǕǒǑ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǟ�ǙNJǜǜǏǚǗǘnj�ǒ�ǖǘǎNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǏǓ�

• ƹNJǜǜǏǚǗǥ�ǖNJǗǒǙǝǕǩǠǒǒ�ǖǥǢǦǨ��ǒǍǚNJ�nj�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǝǨ�ǒǍǚǝ��• ƶNJǗǏǚNJ�ǚNJǑǍǘnjǘǚNJ�ǙǘbǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǝ��ǚǏNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǎǒNJǕǘǍǒ�Ǜ�ǔǘǕǕǏǍNJǖǒ��• ƶNJǗǏǚNJ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�ǗNJ�ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǏ��ǘǜnjǏǜǥ�ǗNJ�njǘǙǚǘǛǥ�nj�ǙǒǛǦǖǏǗǗǘǓ�

ǞǘǚǖǏ��• ƹǘǡǏǚǔ��ǑNJǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǏ�NJǗǔǏǜǥ��• ƶNJǗǏǚNJ�ǙǒǜǦǩ�ǗNJǙǒǜǔǘnj� �ǎnjǒǐǏǗǒǩ��ǔNJǔ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ�NjǏǚǪǜ�ǡNJǢǔǝ�ǒ�

ǛǜNJnjǒǜ�ǏǪ�ǗNJ�ǖǏǛǜǘ��• ƶNJǗǏǚNJ�ǡǜǏǗǒǩ�ǛǙǏǠǒǞǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǜǏǔǛǜǘnj�ǗNJ�ǧǔǚNJǗǏ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚNJ�

ƷǏǗNJnjǩǑǡǒnjNJǩ�ǙǘnjǏǎǏǗǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǒ�ǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǖǝǕǦǜǒǖǘǎNJǕǦǗǘǓ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��$&7Ζ%Ζ2�ƹƺƸƯƴƼ�$&7Ζ%Ζ2��$&7ΖYLW\�5HODWHG�DQG�6RIW�%Ζ2PHWULFV��ǚNJǑnjǒnjNJǏǜ��Ǚǘbǝǜ-njǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǨ�NJnjǜǘǚǘnj��ǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǗǘ�ǗǘnjǥǓ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎ�ǔ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝ-ǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��$&7Ζ%Ζ2�ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǛǩ�ǔ�ƻǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǖ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJǖ�ƯnjǚǘǙǏǓǛǔǘǍǘ�ƻǘǨǑNJ��675(3���ƲǎǏǩ�ǛǘǛǜǘǒǜ�nj�ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǗǘ�ǗǏǑNJǖǏǜǏǗ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǒ�ǗǏǘǜǎǏ-Ǖǒǖ�ǘǜ�ǏǍǘ�ǏǐǏǎǗǏnjǗǘǓ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ�ǗNJ�ǚNJNjǘǡǏǖ�ǖǏǛǜǏ��ƹǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǛǒǛǜǏ-ǖNJ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǛǘǡǏǜNJǜǦ�nj�ǛǏNjǏ�ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǕǦǗǘǏ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘ�ǖǘǎNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǏǓ�ǒ�ǙǚǘnjǘǎǒǜǦ� ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ� ǙǚNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ� nj� ǚǏNJǕǦǗǘǖ� njǚǏǖǏǗǒ�� ǀǏǕǦ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJbȃ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�mǖǘǎǝǕǦǗǘǓ��ǖǝǕǦǜǒǖǘǎNJǕǦǗǘǓ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǖǘǗǒǜǘǚǒǗǍNJ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�NjǒǘǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǙǛǒǟǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǙǚǘǞǒǕǦ��ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǎǕǩ�ǔNJǐǎǘ-Ǎǘ�ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎNJ��ǙǘnjǏǎǏǗǡǏǛǔǝǨ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǨ�� ǜNJǔǝǨ�ǔNJǔ�ǙǘǟǘǎǔNJ�ǒ�ǖNJǗǏ-ǚNJ� ǛǒǎǏǜǦ��ƹǚǘǏǔǜ�ǎǘǕǐǏǗ�ǝǛǜǚNJǗǒǜǦ�ǗǏǎǘǛǜNJǜǔǒ� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǟ�Njǒǘ-ǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ��ǙǚǒnjǏǛǜǒ�ǔ�ǝǕǝǡǢǏǗǒǨ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǟ�ǛǏǗǛǘǚǘnj��ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǜǦ�ǗǘnjǥǏ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǥ��ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�Ǜ�ǠǏǕǦǨ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�Ǘǘnjǥǟ��ǗǏǗNJnjǩǑǡǒnjǥǟ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǡǝnjǛǜnjǒ-

�� 'URVRX��$���ΖRDQQLGLV��'���0RXVWDNDV��.���DQG�7]RYDUDV��'���������8QREWUXVLYH�EHKDYLRUDO�DQG�DFWLYLW\�UHODWHG�PXOWLPRGDO�ELRPHWULFV��WKH�$&7Ζ%Ζ2�DXWKHQWLFDWLRQ�FRQFHSW����85/��KWWS���ZZZ�FPSH�ERXQ�HGX�WU�aVDODK�DQDQWKDNULVKQDQ��HQWHUIDFH�SGI

121ƴƸƷƴƺƯƼƷDžƯ�ƲƷưƯƷƯƺƷDžƯ�ƲbƲƻƻƵƯƮƸƬƪƼƯƵdžƻƴƲƯ�ƹƺƸƯƴƼDž�Ʒƪ�ƫƪƱƯ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƲƿbƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƳ

Page 123: User identification analysis

ǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǔ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJǖ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǗǜǏǕǕǏǔǜǝNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛǚǏǎǏ��ǡǝnjǛǜnjǒ-ǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǔ�ǙǚǒǛǝǜǛǜnjǒǨ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ��$PELHQW�ΖQWHOOLJHQFH�HQYLURQPHQWV�}���

ƽǕǝǡǢǏǗǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǕǩbǎnjǝǟǔǘǕǏǛǗǥǟ�ǜǚNJǗǛǙǘǚǜǗǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj73

LJƼƸƼ�ƹƺƸƯƴƼ�ljƬƵljƯƼƻlj�ƺƪƱƺƪƫƸƼƴƸƳ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǎnjǝǟǔǘǕǪǛǗǥǟ�ǜǚNJǗǛǙǘǚǜǗǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǖǘ-ǐǏǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǟ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǘǜ�ǔǚNJǐǒ��Ƭ� ǧǜǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǘnj�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǒ�ǔNJǔ�ǒǛǜǘǡǗǒǔ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǑNJǙǝǛǔNJ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��ƴNJǔ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǛǔNJǗǏǚ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǜǦ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜ-ǔǒ�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj��ǒǑǘNjǚNJǐǏǗǒǩ�Njǝǎǝǜ�ǘǜǙǚNJnjǕǩǜǦǛǩ�nj�NjNJǑǝ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǛǚNJnjǗǒ-njNJǜǦǛǩ�Ǜ�ǛǘǟǚNJǗǪǗǗǥǖǒ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔNJǖǒ�njǕNJǎǏǕǦǠNJ��ƱNJǖǘǔ�ǗNJ�ǜǚNJǗǛǙǘǚǜ-Ǘǘǖ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǏ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǘǜǔǚǥnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǜǘǍǎNJ��ǔǘǍǎNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǚǘǢǕNJ�ǝǛǙǏǢǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǝǛǜǚNJǗǩǏǜ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǦ�nj�ǔNJǔǒǟ�ǕǒNjǘ�ǔǕǨǡNJǟ�ǒǕǒ�ǔǘǎNJǟ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǝǔǚNJǎǏǗǥ�ǑǕǘǝǖǥǢǕǏǗǗǒǔǘǖ�

ƻǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǛǘǡǏǜNJǗǒǩ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔ�ǕǒǠNJ�ǒ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔNJ�ǕNJǎǘǗǒ74

LJƼƪ�ƻƲƻƼƯƶƪ�ƺƪƱƺƪƫƪƼDžƬƪƯƼƻlj�ǎǕǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏ-ǕǏǓ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǛǘǡǏǜNJǗǒǩ�ǖǏǜǘǎǘnj�ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ�ǡǏǚǜ�ǕǒǠNJ�ǒ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜ-ǔNJ� ǕNJǎǘǗǒ�� ƺNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ� Ǚǘb ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǝ� ǕNJǎǘǗǒ� ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ� ǛǘNjǘǓ�NJǗNJǕǘǍ� ǚNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǩ� Ǚǘb ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǝ� ǙNJǕǦǠNJ� Ǜ� ǜǘǓ� ǜǘǕǦǔǘ� ǚNJǑǗǒǠǏǓ��ǡǜǘ�nj�ǛǒǕǝ�ǗǏnjǥǛǘǔǒǟ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ǔ�ǜǘǡǗǘǛǜǒ�ǛǔNJǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǔǘǖNjǒǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǘǔ�ǕNJǎǘǗǒ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ� ǘNjǥǡǗǘǍǘ� ǘǞǒǛǗǘǍǘ� ǛǔNJǗǏǚNJ�� ƺNJǛǙǘǑǗNJnjNJǗǒǏ� Ǚǘb ǕǒǠǝ� ǘǛǝ-ǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�njǏNj�ǔNJǖǏǚǥ��ƹǚǘǠǏǛǛǥ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�Ǚǚǘ-ǍǚNJǖǖǘǓ�ǙNJǚNJǕǕǏǕǦǗǘ��ǒ�ǙǘbǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜNJǖ�ǔNJǐǎǘǍǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǨ�Ǚǚǒ-ǛnjNJǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǪǗǗǘǏ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘ�mǘǡǔǘnj�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǗǒǩ}��ƹǘbǛǝǖǖǏ�ǧǜǒǟ�ǘǡǔǘnj�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖNJ�nj�ǒǜǘǍǏ�ǎǏǕNJǏǜ�njǥnjǘǎ�ǘ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǗǒǒ�ǒǕǒ�ǗǏǙǚǒ-ǑǗNJǗǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ƸǛǘNjǏǗǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǏǍǘ�ǘǚǒǏǗǜǒǚǘ-njNJǗǗǘǛǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǛǏǜǏnjǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǒ�

ƹǚǘǍǚNJǖǖNJ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�mƪǔǜǒnjǗǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}�'$53$��ƾƯƬƺƪƵlj������ƭƸƮƪ�ǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǗǘǏ�ǙǘǎǚNJǑǎǏǕǏǗǒǏ�ƸǞǒǛ�ǒǗǗǘnjNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ��ΖQIRUPDWLRQ�LQQRYDWLRQ�RɝFH��NJǍǏǗǜǛǜnjNJ�

�� KWWS���ZZZ�LWL�JU�aPRXVWDN�6:-B8QREWUXVLYHBFRQFHSW�SGI�� KWWS���ZZZ�LMHVLW�FRP�9ROXPH�����ΖVVXH�����Ζ-(6Ζ7������B���SGI�� KWWS���ZZZ�]HPULV�IHU�KU�SURMHFWV�%LRPHWULFV�HQJOLVK�UHVXOWV�VKWPO

122 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƲ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ

Page 124: User identification analysis

'$53$� ǘNjǗNJǚǘǎǘnjNJǕNJ� njǜǘǚǝǨ� ǞNJǑǝ� ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ� mƪǔǜǒnjǗǘǓ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ}�� ƶǏǗǏǎǐǏǚ� ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥ�� ƺǒǡNJǚǎ� ƭǝǎǘǚǒǠǠǒ� �5LFKDUG� *XLGRUL]]L���ƫǨǎǐǏǜ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥbȃ�ǙǚǒǖǏǚǗǘ���ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗǘnj�ǎǘǕǕNJǚǘnj�ƻǂƪ�

Ƭ� ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǏ� ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎNJǏǜǛǩ�� ǡǜǘ� ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǏ� ǙNJǚǘǕǒ� ǗǏ� ǩnjǕǩ-ǨǜǛǩ� ǙǘǎǕǒǗǗǘ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǥǖǒ� ǛǙǘǛǘNjNJǖǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� ƴǘǗǏǡǗNJǩ�ǠǏǕǦ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥbȃ�ǛǘǑǎNJǜǦ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǗǥǓ�Ǚǚǘǎǝǔǜ��ƶǘNjǒǕǦǗǝǨ�Njǒǘ-ǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǝǨ�ǙǕNJǜǞǘǚǖǝ�ǎǕǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�nj�ǔǘǖ-ǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǟ� ǛǏǜǩǟ� njǥǛǘǔǘǓ� ǑNJǣǒǣǪǗǗǘǛǜǒ�� ƿNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǗNJǩ� ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǕNJǜǞǘǚǖǥbȃ�ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǒǏ�ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǛǏǗǛǘǚǘnj��ƹǕNJǜǞǘǚǖNJ� ǎǘǕǐǗNJ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ� ǙǚǒnjǥǡǗǝǨ� ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǝ�� ǖǥǢǦ� ǒ�njǏNjǔNJǖǏǚǝ��ƷNJǝǡǗǘǓ�ǘǛǗǘnjǘǓ�ǗǘnjǘǓ�ǙǕNJǜǞǘǚǖǥ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǎǘǛǜǒǐǏǗǒǩ�ǔǘǍǗǒǜǒnjǗǥǟ�ǗNJǝǔ�ǒ�ǙǛǒǟǘǞǒǑǒǘǕǘǍǒǒ��ƮǏǕǘ�nj�ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǘǎǘNjǗǘ�Ǚǚǒ-njǥǡǗǘǖǝ�ǙǘǡǏǚǔǝ��ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǙǘǡǏǚǔ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�ǗNJ�ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǏ�ǒ�ǎnjǒǐǏ-ǗǒǓ�ǖǥǢǦǨbȃ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǎǕǩ�ǔNJǐǎǘǍǘ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�ǙNJǜǜǏǚǗǥ�ǎnjǒǐǏǗǒǓ�Ǜ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǗǥǖǒ�njǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǒǛǜǒǔNJǖǒ��ǑNJǎǏǚǐǔNJǖǒ�ǒ�ǙNJǝǑNJ-ǖǒ���ƴǚǘǖǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǎǕǩ�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔNJ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǗǥ�ǛǜǒǕǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǒ�ǛǏǖNJǗǜǒ-ǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǩǑǥǔNJ��ƪǗNJǕǒǑ�ǧǜǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��nj�Ǜǘ-njǘǔǝǙǗǘǛǜǒ�Ǜ�ǘNjǥǡǗǥǖǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǖǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖǒ��ǞǒǔǛǒǚǝǏǖǥǖǒ�njǒǎǏǘǔNJǖǏǚǘǓ� �ǞǘǚǖNJ� ǕǒǠNJ�� ǞǘǚǖNJ� ǛǏǜǡNJǜǔǒ�� ǎnjǒǐǏǗǒǩ� ǍǕNJǑ� ǒb ǜ�ɋǙ���ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǜ� ǛǘǑǎNJǜǦ� ǖǗǘǍǘǙNJǚNJǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǝǨ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǛnjǏǚǟnjǥǛǘǔǘǓ�ǑNJǣǒǣǪǗǗǘǛǜǒ�

ƺǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǩ� ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ� ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǏǜ� ǜǚǒ� ǧǜNJǙNJ�� ƸǙǒǛNJǗǒǏ� ǙǏǚnjǘǍǘ�ǧǜNJǙNJ�ǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ�Ǚǘǎǚǩǎǡǒǔǘnj�ǛǘǎǏǚǐǒǜǛǩ�nj�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǏǓ�ǜNJNjǕǒǠǏ�

ƹǘǎǚǩǎǡǒǔ ƸǙǒǛNJǗǒǏ�ǚNJNjǘǜ

ƲǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǗǏǓǚǘǔǘǍǗǒǜǒnjǗǥǟ�ǙNJǜǜǏǚǗǘnjbȃ�ƪǛǙǒǚNJǗǜǝǚNJ�Ƭƶƾ�ƻǂƪ

ƺNJǑnjǒǜǒǏ�ǠǒǞǚǘnjǥǟ�mǔǘǍǗǒǜǒnjǗǥǟ�ǘǜǙǏǡNJǜǔǘnj�ǙNJǕǦǠǏnj}�ǛbǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛǘnj��ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǙǘnjǏǎǏǗǡǏǛǔǒǟ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ƮǘǕǐǗǥ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǜǦ�ǔǚǒǖǒǗNJǕǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�NJǗNJǕǒǑ�ǙǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǎǏǜǏǔǠǒǒ�ǛǎnjǒǍǘnj�nj�ǖǥǢǕǏǗǒǒ��ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǥ�ǝNjǏǐǎǏǗǒǓ�ǒbǜ�ɋǙ�

ƹNJǜǜǏǚǗǥ�ǙǘǒǛǔNJ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓbȃ�$OOXUH�6HFXULW\�7HFKQRORJ\��ΖQF�

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǙNJǜǜǏǚǗǘnj�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǘǒǛǔNJ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǗNJ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǏ��njǏǚǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ�njǥǛǘǔǒǖǒ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩǖǒ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǕǘǐǗǥǖ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜNJǖ��ǚNJǑǖǏǣǏǗǗǥǖ�njbǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ

ƮǒǗNJǖǒǔNJ�ǝǎNJǚǘnj�ǙǘbǔǕNJnjǒǢNJǖ�ǒ�ǎǒǗNJǖǒǔNJ�ǎnjǒǐǏǗǒǓ�ǖǥǢǦǨbȃ�%HKDYLR6HF

ƲǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǎǒǗNJǖǒǔǒ�ǚNJNjǘǜǥ�ǗNJ�ǔǕNJnjǒNJǜǝǚǏ�ǒbǎǒǗNJǖǒǔǒ�ǎnjǒǐǏǗǒǩ�ǖǥǢǦǨ�nj�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩǟ

ƹǘnjǏǎǏǗǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙNJǜǜǏǚǗǥ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ǔNJǔ�ǘǗǒ�njǒǎǗǥ�ǒǑ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥbȃ�&RYHURV

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǜǚNJǎǒǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�Ζ'6�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǘnj�ǎǕǩ�NJǗNJǕǒǑNJ�ǙǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ǎǕǩ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǙǥǜǔǒ�ǗǏNJnjǜǘǚǒǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�njǘǓǜǒ�njbǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ

123ƴƸƷƴƺƯƼƷDžƯ�ƲƷưƯƷƯƺƷDžƯ�ƲbƲƻƻƵƯƮƸƬƪƼƯƵdžƻƴƲƯ�ƹƺƸƯƴƼDž�Ʒƪ�ƫƪƱƯ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƲƿbƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƳ

Page 125: User identification analysis

ƹǘǎǚǩǎǡǒǔ ƸǙǒǛNJǗǒǏ�ǚNJNjǘǜ

ƻǜNJǜǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǛǜǒǕǒǛǜǒǔNJbȃ�ƽǗǒnjǏǚǛǒǜǏǜ�ƮǚǏǔǛǏǕNJ��'UH[HO�8QLYHUVLW\�

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǛǜNJǜǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǛǜǒǕǒǛǜǒǔǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�Ǚǘbǜǘǖǝ��ǡǜǘ�ǘǗ�ǙǏǡNJǜNJǏǜ��ƼNJǔǐǏ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǎǘǕǐǗǘ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜNJǜǦ�ǖǏǜǘǎǒǔǝ�njǥǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǕǒǠ��ǙǥǜNJǨǣǒǟǛǩ�ǒǖǒǜǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǖNJǗǏǚǝ�ǙǒǛǦǖNJ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǕǨǎǏǓ

ƻǜNJǜǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǛǜǒǕǒǛǜǒǔNJ��ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǗNJǩ�ǗNJ�njǚǏǖǏǗǗǘǖ�NJǗNJǕǒǑǏ�ǔǘǍǗǒǜǒnjǗǥǟ�ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘǛǜǏǓ�bȃ�ƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǓ�ǝǗǒnjǏǚǛǒǜǏǜ�ƵǘnjNJ��ΖRZD�6WDWH�8QLYHUVLW\�

ƷǏǜ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ

ƻǜNJǜǒǛǜǒǡǏǛǔNJǩ�ǛǜǒǕǒǛǜǒǔNJ��ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǗNJǩ�ǗNJ�NJǗNJǕǒǑǏ�ƴǘǍǗǒǜǒnjǗǥǟ�ǚǒǜǖǘnjbȃ�1<Ζ7

ƪǗNJǕǒǑ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǗǒǩ�ǜǏǔǛǜNJ�ǒ�ǙNJǝǑ�nj�ǗNJNjǘǚǏ�ǜǏǔǛǜNJ�ǎǕǩ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��njǔǕǨǡNJǩ�ǔǘǗǜǏǗǜ�ǒ�ǩǑǥǔ�

ƻǔǚǥǜǥǏ�ƲǍǚǥ�LjǐǗǘ�njǘǛǜǘǡǗǥǓ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǓ�ƽǗǒnjǏǚǛǒǜǏǜ�6RXWKZHVW�5HVHDUFK�ΖQVWLWXWH

ƸǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǏ�ǙǘnjǏǎǏǗǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǙNJǜǜǏǚǗǘnj�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�Ǜ�ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�njǥǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǑNJNjǕǝǐǎǏǗǒǓ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǔǘǚǚǏǔǜǗǘǍǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǘǗ�ǒǗǜǝǒǜǒnjǗǘ�njǥǝǡǒǕ��ǒǗǥǖǒ�ǛǕǘnjNJǖǒbȃ�NJǗNJǕǒǑ�Ǜǔǚǥǜǥǟ�mǒǍǚ}�Ǜ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǥǖ�ǒǗǜǏǚǞǏǛǘǖ

ƻǔǚǒǗǢǘǜǥ�ǒǗǜǏǚǞǏǓǛNJbȃ�ƽǗǒnjǏǚǛǒǜǏǜ�ƶǧǚǒǕǧǗǎNJ�8QLYHUVLW\�RI�0DU\ODQG

ƹǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǏ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�njǚǏǖǏǗǗǥǟ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjǘnj�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒǗǜǏǚǞǏǓǛNJ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǚNJǑǖǏǣǏǗǒǩ�ǒǔǘǗǘǔ�ǗNJ�ǚNJNjǘǡǏǖ�ǛǜǘǕǏ

ƹǘnjǏǎǏǗǡǏǛǔNJǩ�njǏNj�NJǗNJǕǒǜǒǔNJ�ƲǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǏ�ǕNJNjǘǚNJǜǘǚǒǒ�Ƭƶƾ�ƻǂƪ��ǞǒǗNJǗǛǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�15/�

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�njǏNj�NjǚNJǝǑǏǚǥ�ǎǕǩ�ǗNJNjǘǚNJ�ǛǏǖNJǗǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǔNJǔǒǏ�ǜǒǙǥ�ǛǜǚNJǗǒǠ�ǙǘǛǏǣNJǏǜ��ǒ�ǛǒǗǜNJǔǛǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘǛǜǏǓ�nj�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǩǟ�ǒ�ǡNJǜNJǟ

ƬǜǘǚǘǓ�ǒ�ǜǚǏǜǒǓ�ǧǜNJǙǥ�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǨǜ�ǙǚǘǎǘǕǐǏǗǒǏ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǩ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǖǘǎNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǏǓ�� ǗNJ� ǘǛǗǘnjǏ� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ� ǚNJǛǛǡǒǜǥnjNJǨǜǛǩ�ǙNJǜǜǏǚǗǥ��ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǏ�ƫǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ƹǕNJǜǞǘǚǖǥ�ƺNJNjǘǡǏ-Ǎǘ�ǛǜǘǕNJ��nj�ǔǘǜǘǚǝǨ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǖǘǎNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�Njǝǎǝǜ�ǒǗǜǏǍǚǒǚǘnjNJǗǥ��ƬbǙǏǚ-ǛǙǏǔǜǒnjǏ�ǎNJǗǗNJǩ�ǙǕNJǜǞǘǚǖNJ�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�NjǥǜǦ�ǒǗǜǏǍǚǒ-ǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�nj�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǏ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ�NjǏǑ�ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǖǘǎǝǕǏǓ�ǗNJ�mǐǏǕǏǑǗǘǖ}�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ�

Ƭǥnjǘǎǥ

Ƭ� ƷƪƻƼƸljǃƲƳ� ƶƸƶƯƷƼ� ƷƪƫƵLjƮƪƯƼƻlj� njǑǚǥnjǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǥǓ� ǚǘǛǜ� ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjNJ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǟ� ǙǚǘǏǔǜǘnj� Ǚǘb ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǨ� ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǥǟ� NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǘnj�ǞǘǚǖNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǒǗǐǏǗǏǚǗǥǟ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǘnj��ǗNJ-ǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǗǥǟ� ǗNJ� ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖ� NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� nj�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǗǝǐǎNJǟ��ƻǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�nj�njǒǎǝ��ǡǜǘ�

124 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƲ�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƸƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ

Page 126: User identification analysis

• ƮǕǩ�Ǘǝǐǎ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǏǓ�njǥǛǘǔǘǓ�ǑNJǣǒǣǪǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǛǘǑǎNJǜǦ�ǘǜǏǡǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǝǨ�ǔǘǖNjǒǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǝǨ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏ-ǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǣǝǨ�ǔNJǔ�ǛǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǎǒ-ǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ��ƼNJǔNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�nj�ǒǎǏNJǕǏ�ǎǘǕǐǗNJ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǜǦ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǗǘǏ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǏ�ǘǜǏǡǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ��njǙǚǘǡǏǖ��ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗNJ�ǗNJ�ǑNJǒǖǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖNJǟ�ǒ�ǖǏǜǘǎNJǟ��ǛǏǗǛǘǚǥ�ǘǜǏǡǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǒǑǍǘǜǘnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǒ��njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘ��NJǙǙNJǚNJǜǗǥǏ�ǖǘǎǝǕǒ�Ǜǘ�njǛǜǚǘǏǗǗǥǖǒ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖNJǖǒ�NJǗNJǕǒǑNJ�Njǒǘ-ǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖNJǖǒ�ǢǒǞǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ��ƸǛǘNjǥǓ�ǒǗǜǏ-ǚǏǛ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǜ�ǙǘnjǏǎǏǗǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǔǘǜǘ-ǚǥǏ��nj�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǒǟ�ǝǛǙǏǢǗǘǍǘ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǩ��ǘNjǕNJǎNJǨǜ�ǗNJǒNjǘǕǦǢǒǖ�ǙǘǜǏǗǠǒNJǕǘǖ�ǑNJǣǒǣǪǗǗǘǛǜǒ�

• ƻǎǏǕNJǜǦ�ǘǎǗǘǑǗNJǡǗǥǓ�njǥnjǘǎ��ǔNJǔǘǓ�ǒǑ�ǖǏǜǘǎǘnj�NjǒǘǖǏǜǚǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǕǒNjǘ�ǔǘǖNjǒǗNJǠǒǩ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǖǏǜǘǎǘnj�ǎǕǩ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏ-Ǜǔǒǟ�Ǘǝǐǎ�ǘǔNJǐǝǜǛǩ�ǗNJǒNjǘǕǏǏ�ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǥǖǒ�Ǜ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ�Ǜǘ-ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǩ� ǞǝǗǔǠǒǒ� ǠǏǗNJ�ǗNJǎǪǐǗǘǛǜǦ�� nj� ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǒǓ� ǖǘǖǏǗǜ� ǗǏ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǥǖ��ƸǡǏnjǒǎǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǎǕǩ�NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjNJ�ǔǘǖ-ǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǠǏǕǏǓ�ǗǏǜ�ǛǖǥǛǕNJ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǘǡǏǗǦ�ǛǕǘǐǗǥǏ�ǔǘǖNjǒ-ǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǣǒǏ�ǛǘǡǏǜNJǗǒǏ�njǛǏǟ�ǔǕNJǛǛǘnj�ǖǏǜǘǎǘnj��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�� ǧǜǘ�ǗǏ�ǘǑǗNJǡNJǏǜ��ǡǜǘ�ǔǘǖNjǒǗǒǚǘ-njNJǗǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǘǔNJǐǏǜǛǩ�ǗǏnjǘǛǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ��ƯǛǜǦ�ǛǖǥǛǕ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǣǒǟ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǏ�ǖǏǜǘǎǥ�Ǜ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǒǟ�NJǔ-ǜǒnjNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǘǜ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǖǘǍǘ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�

125

Page 127: User identification analysis

ƭƵƪƬƪ��

ƺǏǔǘǖǏǗǎNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǎǕǩbƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ

ƶǏǚǥ��ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǗǥǏ�ǗNJ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏ-ǕǏǓ� ǛǏǜǒ�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�� ǝǛǕǘnjǗǘ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǚNJǑǎǏǕǒǜǦ�ǗNJ� ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ�ǘǛǗǘnj-ǗǥǏ�ǜǒǙǥ�

��� ƼǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ��ǖǘǍǝǜ�NjǥǜǦ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗǥ�ǔNJǔ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚNJǖǒ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǖ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚǘǖ�

��� ƱNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǖǏǚǥ��ǖǘǍǝǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǥ�ǗNJ�njnjǏǎǏǗǒǏ�ǘNjǩǑNJǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚNJ�njǗǏǎǚǒǜǦ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǪǗǗǥǏ�ǜǏǟ-ǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǕǒNjǘ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǖǏǚǥ�ǙǘbǒǎǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� Ǜnjǘǒǟ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj�� NJ� ǜNJǔǐǏ� ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǩǨǣǒǏ� ǕǒNjǘ�ǙǚǏǎǙǒǛǥnjNJǨǣǒǏ� Ǚǘǚǩǎǘǔ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ� nj� ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǒǜǦǛǩ�nj�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǟ�ǠǏǕǩǟ�

��� ƸǙǜǒǖǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘǘNjǘǚǘǜNJ���� ƵǏǍǒǜǒǖǒǑNJǠǒǩ� ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǓ� Ǜ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ� ǛǏǜǒ�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�� nj�

ǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǟ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ���� ƹǚǏǎǘǜnjǚNJǣǏǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǚNJǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǔǒNjǏǚǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǕǏǗǒǓ���� ƽǛǔǘǚǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗ-

Ǘǘǖ�njǒǎǏ�ǗNJǛǏǕǏǗǒǨ���� ƽǙǚǘǣǏǗǒǏ� njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǓ� ǔNJǔ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗ-

Ǘǥǟ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǔǘǖǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǟ�Ʋ�ǎǚ�ƶǏǚǥ�� ǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǗǥǏ� ǗNJ� ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�� ǜNJǔǐǏ�

ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǙǘǎǏǕǒǜǦ�ǙǘbǛǞǏǚNJǖ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǝǛǕǝǍ���� ƾǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǏ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ���� ƽǛǕǝǍǒ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒ�ƲƼ���� ƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ�

126

Page 128: User identification analysis

ƮNJǗǗǘǏ�ǎǏǕǏǗǒǏ�ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜǦ�ǑNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǝ�Ǚǚǒ�ǔǕNJǛǛǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǚǏ-ǔǘǖǏǗǎNJǠǒǓ�ǙǘbǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

ƽǔNJǑNJǗǗǥǏ� ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ� ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǝǨǜǛǩ� ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǖǒ� ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǖǒ� Ǘǘǚ-ǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǥǖǒ�NJǔǜNJǖǒ�

ƾǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǏ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ� ȃ ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ����ƾƱ��ǚǏǎ��ǘǜ�������������mƸ�ǙǚǘǜǒnjǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǒ�ǕǏǍNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ǘǜǖǥnjNJǗǒǨ��ǎǘǟǘǎǘnj��ǙǘǕǝ-ǡǏǗǗǥǟ�ǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǗǥǖ�ǙǝǜǏǖ��ǒ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǜǏǚǚǘǚǒǑǖNJ}�

ȃ ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ����ƾƱ��ǚǏǎ��ǘǜ�������������mƸ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ}�

ȃ ƹǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ƫNJǗǔNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ����ƹ�mƸNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǥǖǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǖǒ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj�ǒ�njǥǍǘǎǘǙǚǒǘNjǚǏǜNJǜǏ-ǕǏǓ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǙǚǘǜǒnjǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǕǏǍNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ǘǜǖǥnjNJǗǒǨ��ǎǘǟǘǎǘnj��ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǥǟ�ǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǗǥǖ�ǙǝǜǏǖ��ǒ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǜǏǚǚǘǚǒǑǖNJ}�

ȃ ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ������ �ǚǏǎ��ǘǜ�������������mƸ�NjNJǗǔNJǟ�ǒ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǘǓ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ}�

ƽǛǕǝǍǒ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒ�ƲƼ� ȃ ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ����ƾƱ��ǚǏǎ��ǘǜ�������������mƸ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ}�

ȃ ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ����ƾƱ��ǚǏǎ��ǘǜ�������������mƸNj� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǩǟ� ǒ� ǘ� ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ}�

ȃ ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ����ƾƱ��ǚǏǎ��ǘǜ�������������mƸ�ǛnjǩǑǒ}��Ǜ�ǒǑǖ��ǒ�ǎǘǙ���njǛǜǝǙ��nj�ǛǒǕǝ�Ǜ�������������

ȃ ƹǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƺƾ�ǘǜ����ǩǗnjNJǚǩ�����bǍ��ȟɋ���nj�ǚǏǎNJǔǠǒǒ� ǙǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǓ� ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ� ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ� ƾǏǎǏǚNJ-Ǡǒǒ�ǘǜ����ǒǨǕǩ�����bǍ��ȟɋ����ǒ�ǘǜ����NJnjǍǝǛǜNJ�����bǍ��ȟɋ����

ƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ� ȃ ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ����ƾƱ��ǚǏǎ��ǘǜ�������������mƸ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ}�

ȃ ƹǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ� ǘǜ� �� ǒǨǗǩ� ����b Ǎ�� ȟɋ���� mƸNj� ǒǗǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǏ��ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǨǣǏǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǏ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓ-ǛǜnjǒǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǟ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏ-Ǘǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝ-ǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǓ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǞǘǚǖǏ}�

ȃ ƺNJǛǙǘǚǩǐǏǗǒǏ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƺƾ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ�����ǚ�mƸNj�ǝǜ-njǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǒ�ƴǘǗǠǏǙǠǒǒ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖǘnj�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ}�

127

Page 129: User identification analysis

ƷNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǛǜǚNJǗǘnjǘǍǘ�ǘǙǥǜNJ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǛǞǘǚǖǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ�ǚǏǔǘǖǏǗǎNJǠǒǒ� ǘNjǣǏǍǘ� ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ� ǙǘbǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�nj�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǛǏǜǒ�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǎǕǩ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�

��� ƺNJǑǍǚNJǗǒǡǒǜǦ� ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏ� ǡNJǛǜǗǘǍǘ� ǒ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚǘnj�� Ƭ� ǡNJǛǜǒ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖNJ�ǡǪǜǔNJǩ�ǚǏǍǕNJǖǏǗǜNJǠǒǩ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚ�ǛNjǘǚNJ��ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ��ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǝǨǣǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ƮǕǩ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚNJ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǚNJǖǘǡǗǥǟ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJ-ǗǒǓ��ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�ǗNJ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǟ�ǛǘǍǕNJǢǏǗǒǩǟ�

��� Ƭ� ǛǞǏǚǏ� ǡNJǛǜǗǘǍǘ� ǛǏǔǜǘǚNJ� ǛǜǒǖǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ� ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǏ� ǜǏǟǗǘ-ǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�Ǚǚǒ�ǘǎǗǘ-njǚǏǖǏǗǗǘǖ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǖ� ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǏǗǒǒ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǖǏǚ�� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥǟ�ǎǕǩ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ� ǝǐǏ� ǝǛǙǏǢǗǘ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑǘnjNJǗ-Ǘǥǟ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ��ƸǙǒǛNJǗǒǏ�nj�ǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǥǟ�ǎǘ-ǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǟ� ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ� ǒǑǕǒǢǗǏ�� NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǘ�ǙǚǘNJǗNJǕǒǑǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ�ǛǜǚNJǗ�ǝǐǏ�ǘǜǔNJǑNJǕǒǛǦ�ǘǜ�ǜNJǔǘǍǘ�Ǚǝǜǒ�Ǘǘǚ-ǖǘǜnjǘǚǡǏǛǜnjNJ�nj�ǛnjǩǑǒ�Ǜ�ǏǍǘ�ǗǏǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǦǨ��ƼǏǖ�ǗǏ�ǖǏǗǏǏ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǏ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǘ-njNJǜǦ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǖ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜNJǖ�

��� ƬnjǏǛǜǒ�ǍǚNJǎNJǠǒǒ�ǜǒǙǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǛǜǒ�ǘǜ�ǝǚǘnj-Ǘǩ�ǚǒǛǔNJ�ǒ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ� �nj�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�Ǎǘ-ǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚNJ��ǒǕǒ�ǚǏǔǘǖǏǗǎNJǠǒǓ��nj�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǛǏǔǜǘǚNJ��ǔ�ǚNJǑǗǥǖ�ǜǒǙNJǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

��� ƻǘǑǎNJǜǦ�ǒ�ǛǜǒǖǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǏ�ǚǥǗǔNJ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǏǗǒǏ�ǑNJ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǘǖ�ǚǘǕǒ�ǘǎǗǘǍǘ�ǒǑ�ǔǚǝǙǗǥǟ�ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǩ-Ǩǣǒǟ�ǠǏǗǜǚǘnj�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǙNJǚǜǗǏǚǛǜnjNJ�

��� ƻǘǑǎNJǜǦ�ǒ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑǘnjNJǜǦ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǎǕǩ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǚNJǑ-ǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǟ�ǒ�njǗǘnjǦ�ǛǘǑǎNJnjNJǏǖǥǟ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǚǏǏǛǜǚǘnj� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ� �Ǐǎǒ-ǗǥǓ�ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕ�ǘNjǖǏǗNJ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖǒ��NJǗNJǕǘǍ�;�5RDG��

��� ƻNjNJǕNJǗǛǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǘNjǤǪǖ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǖǥǟ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǓ�Ǚǚǒ�ǙǚǘnjǏ-ǎǏǗǒǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�Ǜ�ǘNjǤǪǖǘǖ��ǜǚǏNjǝǏǖǥǖ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǚǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǓ��ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǟ�ǜǚNJǗǑNJǔǠǒǓ�

ƸǜǎǏǕǦǗǘ� ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ� ǘNjǚNJǜǒǜǦ� njǗǒǖNJǗǒǏ� ǗNJ�ǗǏǍNJǜǒnjǗǥǓ� ǘǙǥǜ� ǚǩǎNJ�ǛǜǚNJǗ� �nj� ǡNJǛǜǗǘǛǜǒ�� LjǐǗǘǓ� ƴǘǚǏǒ��� ǗNJ� ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǒ� ǔǘǜǘǚǘǍǘ� ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǛǞǘǚǖǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǙǏǚǏǡǏǗǦ�ǖǏǚ��ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǗNJ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ�ǍǘǛǝ-ǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǗǏ�ǚǏǔǘǖǏǗǎǝǏǜǛǩ�

128 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƺƯƴƸƶƯƷƮƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸbƺƯƭƽƵƲƺƸƬƪƷƲLj�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƮƵljbƺƸƻƻƲƳƻƴƸƳ�ƾƯƮƯƺƪǀƲƲ

Page 130: User identification analysis

��� ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǗǏǛǘnjǖǏǛǜǒǖǥǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǘnj���� ƱNJǔǚǏǙǕǏǗǒǏ�ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǥǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǜNJǗ-

ǎNJǚǜǘnj�ǗNJ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǖ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ���� ƽǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦ-

ǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǗǏǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǔǚǝǍNJ�ǛNJǓǜǘnj�ǒǕǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒ-Ǜǘnj��ǎǘǙǝǛǔNJǏǜǛǩ�ǗNJǕǒǡǒǏ�ǜNJǔǘǍǘ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǝ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǔǚǝǍNJ�ǛNJǓǜǘnj�ǒǕǒ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ƻƶƲ��

��� ƼǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǏ� ǙǚǒnjǩǑǥnjNJǜǦ� ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjǘ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ� ǒ� ǔǘǖ-ǖǏǚǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�ǔ�ǘǎǗǘǖǝ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǨ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǝ��nj�ǘǛǘNjǏǗ-ǗǘǛǜǒ�Ǚǚǒ�ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǒǒ�ǎnjǝǟǞNJǔǜǘǚǗǘǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��njǘǑǖǘǐ-ǗǘǛǜǒ�ǛǖǏǗǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚNJ��mƴǕNJǜǦ�njǛǏ�ǩǓǠNJ�nj�ǘǎǗǝ�ǔǘǚǑǒǗǝ}��

��� ƬǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǏ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ǗNJ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǖ�ǚǏǍǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǖ�ǝǚǘnjǗǏ��njǥǙǘǕǗǩǨǣǒǟ�ǛǟǘǎǗǥǏ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǠǏǕǏǓ�

��� ƸǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǒǏ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǗǘǍǘ�ǒ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�NJǝǎǒǜNJ�ǒ�NJǔǜǝNJǕǒ-ǑNJǠǒǒ�ǑNJǕǘǐǏǗǗǥǟ�nj�ǑNJǔǘǗNJǟ�Ǘǘǚǖ�

��� ƬnjǏǎǏǗǒǏ�ǒǑNjǥǜǘǡǗǥǟ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ǙǘbǕǘǔNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǨ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�

��� ƸǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǒǏ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ� ǚNJNjǘǜǥ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��ǛǒǛǜǏǖ��ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǎǕǩ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǘnj�ǍǘǛǝ-ǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ�

ƷNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǒǛǛǕǏǎǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǛǜǚNJǗǘnjǘǍǘ�ǘǙǥǜNJ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǛǞǘǚǖǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ�ǚǏǔǘǖǏǗǎNJǠǒǒ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ�ǙǘbǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�nj�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǛǏǜǒ�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǎǕǩ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓ-ǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�

ƮǕǩ�ǛǞǏǚǥ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ

��� ƶǘǎǏǚǗǒǑNJǠǒǩ� ǜǏǚǖǒǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ� NJǙǙNJǚNJǜNJ� ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�ȟɋ����ƾƱ��nj�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǛǜǒbȃ�njnjǏǎǏǗǒǏ�ǙǘǗǩǜǒǩ�mǖǏǚ�ǙǘbǗNJǎ-ǕǏǐNJǣǏǖǝ�ǒǑǝǡǏǗǒǨ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ}�ǔNJǔ�ǒǗǛǜǒǜǝǜNJ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǒ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ƹƸƮ�ƾƼ��njǔǕǨǡNJǨǣǏǍǘ�nj�ǛǏNjǩ�mǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ}��mNJǝǜǏǗ-ǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ}��mnjǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ}�nj�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚ�

��� ƽǜǘǡǗǏǗǒǏ� ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚ� mǝǙǚǘǣǏǗǗǘǓ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}�� ǚNJǑǍǚNJ-ǗǒǡǏǗǒǏ� ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǓ� mǝǙǚǘǣǏǗǗǘǓ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}� nj� ǚNJǑ-ǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�NJǔǜNJǟ��Ǜ�ǠǏǕǦǨ�ǒǛǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǩ�njǘǑǖǘǐ-ǗǘǛǜǏǓ� ǎnjǘǓǗǘǍǘ� ǜǘǕǔǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǟ� ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǓ��nj� ǛnjǩǑǒ� Ǜ� ǗǏǘǎǗǘǑǗNJǡǗǥǖ� ǘǙǒǛNJǗǒǏǖ� ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǥǟ� ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚ�

129ƮƵlj�ƻƾƯƺDž�ƾƲƷƪƷƻƸƬDžƿ�ƽƻƵƽƭ

Page 131: User identification analysis

ǝǙǚǘǣǏǗǗǘǓ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǒ� ǛǕǝǡNJǏnj�� ǔǘǍǎNJ� ǏǏ� ǙǚǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǏ�ǎǘǙǝǛǜǒǖǘ�

��� ƬnjǏǎǏǗǒǏ�ǑNJǙǚǏǜNJ�ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘ�ǗNJ�ǙǏǚǏǎǘnjǏǚǒǏ�ǙǚNJnjNJ�Ǚǚǘ-njǘǎǒǜǦ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ� ǒǕǒ� ǝǙǚǘǣǪǗǗǝǨ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ� ǒ�ǑNJǙǚǏǜNJ�ǎǕǩ�njǛǏǟ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜǘnj�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�ȟɋ����ƾƱ�ǗNJ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǎǏǕǘnjǥǟ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǓ�Ǜ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘǖ�nj�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǗǏǙǚǏǎ-ǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘǖ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� �ǎǕǩ� ǠǏǕǏǓ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǟ�ǜǚNJǗǑNJǔǠǒǓ��

��� ƺǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǩ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǚǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǝǜǏǖ� ȃ ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ� ǘǜ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ� ǚǏǔnjǒǑǒǜǘnj� ǙǚǒǗNJǎǕǏǐNJǣǏǍǘ� Ǐǖǝ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ� ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJ� ǙǕNJǜǏǐNJ��LJƻƹ���ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔǒ�ǒǟ�ǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǗǘǛǜǒ��NJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǙǚǒǗNJǎǕǏǐǗǘǛǜǒ�LJƻƹ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǝ�

ȃ ǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǒǩ�ǙǏǚǏnjǘǎNJ�ǎǏǗǏǐǗǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐ-ǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��ǏǛǕǒ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜ�NjǥǕ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗ�ǝǡNJǛǜǗǒ-ǔǘǖ�ǧǜǘǓ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�

ȃ ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǩ� NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǘǎǗǘǚNJǑǘnjǥǖ� ǙNJǚǘǕǏǖ��ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǥǖ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘǖ�ǙǘbNJǕǦǜǏǚǗNJǜǒnjǗǘǖǝ�ǔNJǗNJǕǝ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�

��� ƱNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǏ� ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǏǗǒǏ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǚǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�Ǚǚǘ-ǠǏǎǝǚǥ� ǎǒǛǜNJǗǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ� ǑNJǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǩ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJǖǒ� ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǘnj� Ǜ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǖǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǖǒ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ�

��� ƬnjǏǎǏǗǒǏ�ǍǚNJǎNJǠǒǒ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǟ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ�ǙǘbǝǚǘnjǗǨ�ǚǒǛǔNJ��ǑNJ-ǔǚǏǙǕǏǗǒǏ�nj�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǖ�ǑNJǔǘǗǏ�ȟɋ����ƾƱ�ǒ�Ʒƹƪ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦ-ǛǜnjNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�ƫNJǗǔNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ƹǏǚǏǡǗǩ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ�ǙǘǗǒǐǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�ǚǒǛǔNJ�ǒ�ǍǚNJǎNJǠǒǒ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǟ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ�ǙǘbǝǚǘnjǗǨ�ǚǒǛǔNJ�

ƮǕǩ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒ�ƲƼ

��� ƺNJǛǢǒǚǏǗǒǏ� ǙǏǚǏǡǗǩ� ǛǙǘǛǘNjǘnj� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǘǖ� ǛnjǩǑǒ� nj� ǙǝǗǔǜNJǟ� ǔǘǕǕǏǔǜǒnjǗǘǍǘ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ� �ƹǘǛǜNJ-ǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƺƾ�ǘǜ����ǩǗnjNJǚǩ�����bǍ��ȟɋ���nj�ǚǏǎNJǔ-Ǡǒǒ�ǙǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǓ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ� ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǘǜ���bǒǨǕǩ�����bǍ��ȟɋ����ǒ�ǘǜ����NJnjǍǝǛǜNJ�����bǍ��ȟɋ������

��� ƽǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǒǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�Ǚǚǒ�ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǏ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�nj�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝ-ǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǟ�ǒ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǎNJǗǗǘǓ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�

130 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƺƯƴƸƶƯƷƮƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸbƺƯƭƽƵƲƺƸƬƪƷƲLj�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵƯƳ�ƮƵljbƺƸƻƻƲƳƻƴƸƳ�ƾƯƮƯƺƪǀƲƲ

Page 132: User identification analysis

nj� ǡNJǛǜǗǥǟ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǟ�� ǀǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘ� ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǦ�� ǡǜǘ� ǎǕǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ� ǒ� ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǙǘbǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǨ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘ-Ǜǜǒ�ǝǛǜNJǗNJnjǕǒnjNJǨǜǛǩ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘǖ�ƺƾ��ƸǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǥ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǖǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǖǒ��ǎǘǕǐǗǥ�njǥǙǘǕǗǩǜǦ�ǜǚǏNjǘ-njNJǗǒǩ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǔ�ǒǗǥǖ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒ-ǩǖ�ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ��ǏǛǕǒ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǜNJǔǒǖǒ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩǖǒ��Ƭ�ǙǚǘǜǒnjǗǘǖ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚbȃ�ǡNJǛǜǗNJǩ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩ�njǙǚNJnjǏ�ǙǚǒǛǘǏǎǒǗǒǜǦǛǩ�ǔ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘ-ǖǝ�ǒǕǒ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǘǖǝ�ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǝ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǩ�NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�� ǕǒNjǘ� ǙǚǒǗǩǜǦ� ǛǘNjǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǓ� ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜ��ƸNjǏǛǙǏǡǏǗǒǏ� NjǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ� ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǓ� ǔǘǗǞǒǎǏǗǠǒNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ�� ǗǏ� ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǨǣǒǟ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǝǨ� ǜNJǓǗǝ� �ǜNJǓǗǥ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǓ�ǘNj�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜNJǟ��NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǘǓ�ǜNJǓǗǥ�ǒbǜ�ɋǙ����nj�ǗǏ-ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǟ� ǠǏǕǏǛǘǘNjǚNJǑǗǘ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǚǏǔǘǖǏǗǎNJǠǒǓ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǗNJ-ǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ��ǘǜǚNJǛǕǏnjǥǟ��ǛǜNJǗǎNJǚǜǘnj�

ƮǕǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ

��� ƺNJǛǢǒǚǏǗǒǏ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǏǓ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ƯƻƲƪ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǖ�ǛǏǔ-ǜǘǚǘǖ�ǎǕǩ�Ǜnjǘǒǟ�ǠǏǕǏǓ�ǗNJ�ǙǕNJǜǗǘǓ�ǒǕǒ�NjǏǛǙǕNJǜǗǘǓ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�

��� ƺNJǛǢǒǚǏǗǒǏ� njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǕǒǠ�Ǚǚǒ�Ǚǘǖǘǣǒ�ƯƻƲƪ��Ǜǖ��ƸǙǥǜ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ��

��� ƬnjǏǎǏǗǒǏ� ǍǚNJǎNJǠǒǒ� ǜǒǙǘnj� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� nj� ǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘǛǜǒ� ǘǜ�ǝǚǘnjǗǩ�ǚǒǛǔNJ�ǒ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ǔ�ǚNJǑǗǥǖ�ǜǒǙNJǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

131

Page 133: User identification analysis

ƭƵƪƬƪ��

ƼǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�nj�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǒ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘnj�ǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ�ǟǚNJǗǒǜǦ�ǒ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǜǦ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ��ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǝǨ�ǎǕǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ

ƼǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ� ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖ� nj� ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǒ�ǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘnj�ǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ�ǟǚNJǗǒǜǦ�ǒ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǜǦ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǨ�� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǝǨ� ǎǕǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� Ǖǒǡ-ǗǘǛǜǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǥ�nj�njǒǎǏ�ǜNJNjǕǒǠǥ�

ȟ ƻǜǚNJǗNJ

ƷNJǕ

ǒǡǒ

Ǐ�ǜǚ

ǏNjǘnj

NJǗǒǩ�

ǟǚNJǗ

ǒǜǦ

�ǒ�ǙǚǏ

ǎǘǛǜNJnj

ǕǩǜǦ

�ǒǗǞ

ǘǚǖNJǠ

ǒǨ

ƸNjǤǪǖ�ǟǚNJǗǒǖǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒƻǚ

ǘǔǒ�ǟǚNJ

ǗǏǗǒ

ǩƼǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǔbǟǚNJǗǒǕǒǣǝ

�� LJǛǜǘǗǒǩ ƯǛǜǦ • ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ǒǖǩ�ǒ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǡǒǔNJ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖǝ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ

• ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǏǖǘǍǘ�NJǎǚǏǛNJǜNJ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǒǖǩ�ǒ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǡǒǔNJ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖǝ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�NJǎǚǏǛNJǜNJ

• ƬǚǏǖǩ�ǗNJǡNJǕNJ�ǒ�ǑNJnjǏǚǢǏǗǒǩ�ǛǏNJǗǛNJ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ��njǚǏǖǏǗǗNJǩ�ǑǘǗNJ��Ζ3�NJǎǚǏǛ��ǜǒǙ�Ζ3�NJǎǚǏǛNJ��ǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�

• ƼǒǙ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǕǝǐNjǥ• ƼǒǙ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǛǔǘǍǘ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ��'6/�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǒǕǒ�

ǎǚǝǍǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ• ƭǏǘǎNJǗǗǥǏ

Ƹǜ���ǖǏ-ǛǩǠǏnj�ǎǘ��bǕǏǜ

ƱNJǣǒǜNJ�ǘǜ�ǗǏǛNJǗǔǠǒǘ-ǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ��ǙǚǏ-ǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǗǏǖǏǎǕǏǗ-ǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJ-ǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖ

�� ƫǚNJǑǒǕǒǩ ƯǛǜǦ • ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ǒǖǩ�ǒ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǡǒǔNJ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖǝ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ

• ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǏǖǘǍǘ�NJǎǚǏǛNJǜNJ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǒǖǩ�ǒ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǡǒǔNJ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖǝ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�NJǎǚǏǛNJǜNJ

• ƬǚǏǖǩ�ǗNJǡNJǕNJ�ǒ�ǑNJnjǏǚǢǏǗǒǩ�ǛǏNJǗǛNJ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ��njǚǏǖǏǗǗNJǩ�ǑǘǗNJ��Ζ3�NJǎǚǏǛ��ǜǒǙ�Ζ3�NJǎǚǏǛNJ��ǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�

• ƼǒǙ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǕǝǐNjǥ• ƼǒǙ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǛǔǘǍǘ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ��'6/�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǒǕǒ�

ǎǚǝǍǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ• ƭǏǘǎNJǗǗǥǏ

Ƹǜ���ǖǏ-ǛǩǠǏnj�ǎǘ��bǍǘǎNJ

ƱNJǣǒǜNJ�ǘǜ�ǗǏǛNJǗǔǠǒǘ-ǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ��ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏ-ǗǒǏ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǙǘbǛǝǎǏNjǗǘǖǝ�ǘǚǎǏǚǝ

132

Page 134: User identification analysis

ȟ ƻǜǚNJǗNJƷNJǕ

ǒǡǒ

Ǐ�ǜǚ

ǏNjǘnj

NJǗǒǩ�

ǟǚNJǗ

ǒǜǦ

�ǒ�ǙǚǏ

ǎǘǛǜNJnj

ǕǩǜǦ

�ǒǗǞ

ǘǚǖNJǠ

ǒǨ

ƸNjǤǪǖ�ǟǚNJǗǒǖǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ

ƻǚǘǔ

ǒ�ǟǚNJ

ǗǏǗǒ

ǩ

ƼǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǔbǟǚNJǗǒǕǒǣǝ

�� ƬǏǕǒǔǘ-NjǚǒǜNJǗǒǩ

ƯǛǜǦ • ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ǒǖǩ�ǒ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǡǒǔNJ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖǝ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ

• ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǏǖǘǍǘ�NJǎǚǏǛNJǜNJ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǒǖǩ�ǒ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǡǒǔNJ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖǝ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�NJǎǚǏǛNJǜNJ

• ƬǚǏǖǩ�ǗNJǡNJǕNJ�ǒ�ǑNJnjǏǚǢǏǗǒǩ�ǛǏNJǗǛNJ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ��njǚǏǖǏǗǗNJǩ�ǑǘǗNJ��Ζ3�NJǎǚǏǛ��ǜǒǙ�Ζ3�NJǎǚǏǛNJ��ǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�

• ƼǒǙ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǕǝǐNjǥ�• ƼǒǙ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǛǔǘǍǘ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ��'6/�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǒǕǒ�

ǎǚǝǍǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ• ƭǏǘǎNJǗǗǥǏ

Ƹǜ���ǎǘ��bǕǏǜ

ƱNJǣǒǜNJ�ǘǜ�ǗǏǛNJǗǔǠǒǘ-ǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ��ǙǚǏ-ǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǗǏǖǏǎǕǏǗ-ǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJ-ǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖ

�� LjǐǗNJǩ�ƴǘǚǏǩ

ƯǛǜǦ • ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ǒǖǩ�ǒ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǡǒǔNJ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖǝ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ

• ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǏǖǘǍǘ�NJǎǚǏǛNJǜNJ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǒǖǩ�ǒ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǡǒǔNJ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖǝ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�NJǎǚǏǛNJǜNJ

• ƬǚǏǖǩ�ǗNJǡNJǕNJ�ǒ�ǑNJnjǏǚǢǏǗǒǩ�ǛǏNJǗǛNJ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ��njǚǏǖǏǗǗNJǩ�ǑǘǗNJ��Ζ3�NJǎǚǏǛ��ǜǒǙ�Ζ3�NJǎǚǏǛNJ��ǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�

• ƼǒǙ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǕǝǐNjǥ• ƼǒǙ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǛǔǘǍǘ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ��'6/�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǒǕǒ�

ǎǚǝǍǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ• ƭǏǘǎNJǗǗǥǏ• ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�ǙǘǛǏǣǏǗǒǓ

Ƹǜ���bǎǗǏǓ

ƱNJǣǒǜNJ�ǘǜ�ǗǏǛNJǗǔǠǒǘ-ǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ��ǙǚǏ-ǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǗǏǖǏǎǕǏǗ-ǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJ-ǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖ

�� ƻǂƪ ƷǏǜ ȫ ȫ ȫ

�� ƴǒǜNJǓ ƯǛǜǦ • Ζ'�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ• ƬǚǏǖǩ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJ• ƹǘǛǏǣǪǗǗǥǏ�ǛǜǚNJǗǒǠǥ• ƪNjǘǗǏǗǜǛǔǒǓ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��Ǜ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǍǘ�

ǙǚǘǒǑnjǏǎǏǗ�njǥǟǘǎ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ

���ǎǗǏǓ ƱNJǣǒǜNJ�ǘǜ�ǗǏǛNJǗǔǠǒǘ-ǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ

�� ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚ ƯǛǜǦ • ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ǒǖǩ�ǒ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǡǒǔNJ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖǝ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ

• ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǚǏǎǙǘǕNJǍNJǏǖǘǍǘ�NJǎǚǏǛNJǜNJ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ǒǖǩ�ǒ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǡǒǔNJ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖǝ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�NJǎǚǏǛNJǜNJ

• ƬǚǏǖǩ�ǗNJǡNJǕNJ�ǒ�ǑNJnjǏǚǢǏǗǒǩ�ǛǏNJǗǛNJ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ��njǚǏǖǏǗǗNJǩ�ǑǘǗNJ��Ζ3�NJǎǚǏǛ��ǜǒǙ�Ζ3�NJǎǚǏǛNJ��ǎǒǗNJǖǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǜNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǓ�

• ƼǒǙ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǕǝǐNjǥ• ƼǒǙ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǛǔǘǍǘ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ��'6/�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǒǕǒ�ǎǚǝǍǘǓ�

ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ• ƭǏǘǎNJǗǗǥǏ• ƲǛǜǘǚǒǩ�ǙǘǛǏǣǏǗǒǓ• ƸǜǙǚNJnjǕǩǏǖNJǩ�ǒ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǏǖNJǩ�ǔǘǚǚǏǛǙǘǗǎǏǗǠǒǩ• ƻnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǘ�9RΖ3�ǛǘǏǎǒǗǏǗǒǩǟ

ȫ ƱNJǣǒǜNJ�ǘǜ�ǗǏǛNJǗǔǠǒǘ-ǗǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ��ǙǚǏ-ǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǗǏǖǏǎǕǏǗ-ǗǘǍǘ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJ-ǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖ��ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǏ�ǗNJ�ǜǏǚǚǒǜǘǚǒǒ�ƻǒǗǍNJǙǝǚNJ

133

Page 135: User identification analysis

ȟ ƻǜǚNJǗNJƷNJǕ

ǒǡǒ

Ǐ�ǜǚ

ǏNjǘnj

NJǗǒǩ�

ǟǚNJǗ

ǒǜǦ

�ǒ�ǙǚǏ

ǎǘǛǜNJnj

ǕǩǜǦ

�ǒǗǞ

ǘǚǖNJǠ

ǒǨ

ƸNjǤǪǖ�ǟǚNJǗǒǖǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ

ƻǚǘǔ

ǒ�ǟǚNJ

ǗǏǗǒ

ǩ

ƼǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǔbǟǚNJǗǒǕǒǣǝ

�� ƺǘǛǛǒǓ-ǛǔNJǩ�ƾǏ-ǎǏǚNJǠǒǩ

ƯǛǜǦ • ƻnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǘbǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏ��njbǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�njbǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǖ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǏ

• ƲǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘbǛǏǜǏnjǘǖ�NJǎǚǏǛǏ��ǛbǔǘǜǘǚǘǍǘ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǏǗNJ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ǛbǝǔNJǑNJǗǒǏǖ�ǜǘǡǗǘǍǘ�njǚǏǖǏǗǒ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ��ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ��njǗǏǛǏǗǗNJǩ�njbǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǖ�ǒǕǒbǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǜǘǚǘǖ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�njbǛǏǜǒ�mƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ}�ǙǚǒbǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ��NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJnjNJǏǖNJǩ�njbǟǘǎǏ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǖǝ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǝ�njbǛǒǕǝ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǟ�ǛǏǜǏnjǥǟ�ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǘnj�ǛbǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǗǥǟ�ǗNJbǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖ�ǎǕǩbǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�njǥǡǒǛǕǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǖNJǢǒǗ��ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ��ǞNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǞǒǔǛǒǚǝǏǖNJǩ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘǖ�ǙǚǒbǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǒǗǥǟ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj

• ƲǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘbǞNJǔǜNJǟ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǛbǝǔNJǑNJǗǒǏǖ�ǏǍǘ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚNJ�njbǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǖ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǏ��ǜǘǡǗǘǍǘ�njǚǏǖǏǗǒ�ǒbǛǏǜǏnjǥǟ�NJǎǚǏǛǘnj��Ǜbǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǕNJǛǦ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǩ��ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ��ǞNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǞǒǔǛǒǚǝǏǖNJǩ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘǖ�ǙǚǒbNJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ�njbǒǗǥǟ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǟ��ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ��NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJnjNJǏǖNJǩ�njbǟǘǎǏ�NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǖǝ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǝ�njbǛǒǕǝ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǟ�ǛǏǜǏnjǥǟ�ǙǚǘǜǘǔǘǕǘnj�ǛbǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǗǥǟ�ǗNJbǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖ�ǎǕǩbǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�njǥǡǒǛǕǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǖNJǢǒǗ

• ƲǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘNjbǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǩǟ�ǕǒNjǘ�ǘbǎǘǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǖ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǘbǗǘǖǏǚǏ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ�ǒǕǒbNJǎǚǏǛǏ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǡǜǥ��NJbǜNJǔǐǏ�ǒǗǥǟ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǓ��ǝǔNJǑNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒǖ�ǙǚǒbǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ

• ƲǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘNjbǘǔNJǑNJǗǗǥǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǜǘǚǘǖ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�njbǛǏǜǒ�mƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ}�ǙǕNJǜǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǨ�ǛbǝǔNJǑNJǗǒǏǖ�ǜǘǡǗǘǍǘ�njǚǏǖǏǗǒ�ǒǟbǘǔNJǑNJǗǒǩ��ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ǘǔNJǑǥnjNJǨǣǏǓ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǝǨ�ǝǛǕǝǍǝ��NJbǜNJǔǐǏ�ǞNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǞǒǔǛǒǚǝǏǖǘǓ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘǖ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǘNjbǘǙǕNJǜǏ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��njNJǕǨǜNJ��ǛǝǖǖNJ��ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǜǚNJǗǑNJǔǠǒǒ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǗNJǩ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǒbǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǥ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�

• ƲǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘbǞNJǔǜǏ�ǙǚǏǔǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�njbǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǖ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǏ�ǛbǝǔNJǑNJǗǒǏǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚNJ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�njbǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǖ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǏ��ǜǘǡǗǘǍǘ�njǚǏǖǏǗǒ�ǒbǛǏǜǏnjǥǟ�NJǎǚǏǛǘnj��Ǜbǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǕǘǛǦ�ǙǚǏǔǚNJǣǏǗǒǏ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ

ƷǏ�ǖǏǗǏǏ��bǖǏǛǩ-ǠǏnj

ƿǚNJǗǏǗǒǏ�ǗNJ�ǜǏǚǚǒǜǘǚǒǒ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ��ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǏ-ǗǒǏ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJ-ǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖ

134 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƼƺƯƫƸƬƪƷƲlj�ƷƪǀƲƸƷƪƵdžƷDžƿ�ƱƪƴƸƷƸƮƪƼƯƵdžƷDžƿ�ƻƲƻƼƯƶ�Ƭ�ƸƼƷƸǂƯƷƲƲ�ƸƫljƱƪƼƯƵdžƻƼƬ�ƲƷƼƯƺƷƯƼ�ƹƺƸƬƪƳƮƯƺƸƬ�Ʋ�ƲƷƼƯƺƷƯƼ�ƴƸƶƹƪƷƲƳ�ƿƺƪƷƲƼdž�Ʋ�ƹƺƯƮƸƻƼƪƬƵljƼdž�ƲƷƾƸƺƶƪǀƲLj��ƷƯƸƫƿƸƮƲƶƽLj�ƮƵlj�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƵƲǁƷƸƻƼƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵlj

Page 136: User identification analysis

ȟ ƻǜǚNJǗNJƷNJǕ

ǒǡǒ

Ǐ�ǜǚ

ǏNjǘnj

NJǗǒǩ�

ǟǚNJǗ

ǒǜǦ

�ǒ�ǙǚǏ

ǎǘǛǜNJnj

ǕǩǜǦ

�ǒǗǞ

ǘǚǖNJǠ

ǒǨ

ƸNjǤǪǖ�ǟǚNJǗǒǖǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ

ƻǚǘǔ

ǒ�ǟǚNJ

ǗǏǗǒ

ǩ

ƼǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǔbǟǚNJǗǒǕǒǣǝ

• ƾNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǞǒǔǛǒǚǝǏǖNJǩ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘǖ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘbǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǟ�njbǛǕǝǡNJǏ��ǏǛǕǒ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǓ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒǪǖNJ��ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǒ�ǒb�ǒǕǒ��ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǙǒǛǦǖǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǔǛǜNJ��ǒǑǘNjǚNJǐǏǗǒǓ��Ǒnjǝǔǘnj�ǒǕǒbǒǗǥǟ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǖ�ǛǏǜǒ�mƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ}�NjǏǑbǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǒbNJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ

• ƻnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǘbǞNJǔǜNJǟ�ǙǚǒǏǖNJ��ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǒ�ǒb�ǒǕǒ��ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǙǒǛǦǖǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǔǛǜNJ��ǒǑǘNjǚNJǐǏǗǒǓ��Ǒnjǝǔǘnj�ǒǕǒbǒǗǥǟ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǛǏǜǒ�mƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ}��ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘbǜǘǡǗǘǖ�njǚǏǖǏǗǒ�ǙǚǒǪǖNJ��ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǒ��ǎǘǛǜNJnjǔǒ�ǒb�ǒǕǒ��ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ�ǛbǝǔNJǑNJǗǒǏǖ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǘNjbNJǎǚǏǛNJǜNJǟ�ǧǜǒǟ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ��njbǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǎǕǩbǗǏǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǔǚǝǍNJ�ǕǒǠ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǛǏǜǒ�mƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ}�

• ƾNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǞǒǔǛǒǚǝǏǖNJǩ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘǖ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘNjbǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǙǚǒǪǖNJ��ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǒ��ǎǘǛǜNJnjǔǒ�ǒb�ǒǕǒ��ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ��ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǖǥǟ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǓ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ��njbǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘbǙǚǘǒǑnjǏǎǏǗǗǥǟ�ǎǏǗǏǐǗǥǟ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǩǟ��ǛbǝǔNJǑNJǗǒǏǖ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǘbǔǘǚǚǏǛǙǘǗǎǏǗǜǏbȃ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǏ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��njNJǕǨǜǥ��Ǜǝǖǖǥ��ǘǙǕNJǡǒnjNJǏǖǘǓ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ�ǒǕǒbǜǘnjNJǚǘnj��ǙǚǒbǗNJǕǒǡǒǒ���ǘNjbǒǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǝǔNJǑNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǚǒbǙǚǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǒ�ǎǏǗǏǐǗǘǓ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǒ���ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǪǗǗǥǟ�ǜǚNJǗǑNJǔǠǒǩǟ��ǛbǝǔNJǑNJǗǒǏǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚNJ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ��mǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǔǘǢǏǕǦǔNJ}���Ǜǝǖǖǥ�ǙǚǒǟǘǎNJ�ǕǒNjǘ�ǚNJǛǟǘǎNJ��ǒǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǝǔNJǑNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǚǒbǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǏǗǒǒ�ǜǚNJǗǑNJǔǠǒǒ�

ƼǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJbƻǂƪ�ǘ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǒ�ǒ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǒ�

ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒƹƸƵƸưƯƷƲlj�ƱƪƴƸƷƪ�Ƹ�ƱƪǃƲƼƯ�ƲƷƾƸƺƶƪǀƲƲ��(&3$��nj�ǡNJǛǜǒ�ǙǘǒǛǔNJ�ǒ�ǒǑǤǩǜǒǩ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒǑ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǏǓ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǕǒ�ǗNJǑnjNJǗǒǏ�mƱNJǔǘǗ�ȊƸbǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǒ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓȋ}��6&$���Ƭ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǑNJǔǘǗǏ�NjǥǕǘ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǘ�ǎnjNJ�ǙǘǎǟǘǎNJ�ǔ�ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǛǏǜǏnjǥǟ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǘnj��ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǧǜǘǖǝ�ǑNJǔǘǗǝ��ǛǏǜǏnjǥǏ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǥ� ǝǛǕǝǍ� ǎǏǕǩǜǛǩ� ǗNJ� ǎnjNJ� njǒǎNJ�� ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǥ� ǝǛǕǝǍ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗ-ǗǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��(&6��ǒ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǥ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǎǒǛǜNJǗǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�

135ƼƺƯƫƸƬƪƷƲlj�ƱƪƴƸƷƸƮƪƼƯƵdžƻƼƬƪbƻǂƪ�Ƹ�ƿƺƪƷƯƷƲƲ�Ʋ�ƹƺƯƮƸƻƼƪƬƵƯƷƲƲ�ƲƷƾƸƺƶƪǀƲƲ

Page 137: User identification analysis

�5&6���ƴ�ǝǛǕǝǍNJǖ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǘǜǗǘǛǩǜǛǩ�mǕǨNjǥǏ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ��ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJ-ǜǏǕǩǖ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦ�ǘǜǙǚNJnjǔǝ�ǒ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǏ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǙǚǘnjǘǎǗǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ}����ƹǘǎ�mǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǖ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǏǖ}�ǙǘǗǒǖNJǏǜǛǩ�mǕǨNjǘǏ�njǚǏǖǏǗ-ǗǘǏ�ǙǚǘǖǏǐǝǜǘǡǗǘǏ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǏ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ��ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚǗǘǏ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǒ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǙǚǘnjǘǎǗǘǓ�ǒǕǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ}�ǒǕǒ�mǕǨ-NjǘǏ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǏ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ�ǙǚǘnjNJǓǎǏǚǘǖ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ǜnjǩ-Ǒǒ� �(&6��nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǚǏǑǏǚnjǗǘǓ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ}����mƽǛǕǝǍNJ�ǎǒǛ-ǜNJǗǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ� ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ}� ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǔNJǔ� mǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǗNJǛǏǕǏǗǒǨ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǙǘbǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗǘǖǝ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǨ�ǒǕǒ�ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ}���

ƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘ�ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǗǏ�NjǥǕ�ǚNJǛǛǡǒǜNJǗ�ǗNJ�ǛǜǘǕǦ�NjǥǛǜǚǘǏ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǒǏ� ǘNjǕNJǡǗǥǟ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖ� ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ� Ǚǘ-ǑnjǘǕǩǨǜ�ǚNJǑǖǏǣNJǜǦ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǗNJ�ǗNJǎǏǐǗǥǟ�ǛǏǚnjǏǚNJǟ�njǗǏǢǗǒǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒ-ǑNJǠǒǓ��ƯǛǕǒbNjǥ�ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǏ�ǖNJǜǏǚǒNJǕǥ�ǚNJǑǖǏǣNJǕǒǛǦ�ǗNJ�ǐǪǛǜǔǘǖ�ǎǒǛǔǏ��ǔǘǖǙNJǔǜ�ǎǒǛǔǏ�ǒǕǒ�nj�ǛǏǓǞǏ��ǜǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖ�NjǥǕǘbNjǥ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǑNJǙǚǘǛǒǜǦ�ǘNjǥǡǗǥǓ�ǘǚǎǏǚ����ƸǎǗNJǔǘ��nj�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ�Ǜ�ƱNJ-ǔǘǗǘǖ� ǘ� ǑNJǣǒǜǏ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ� �(&3$��� nj� ǜǏǡǏǗǒǏ� ǛnjǘǏǍǘ� ǠǒǔǕNJ� ǛǝǣǏ-ǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǡǜǥ�ǒǕǒ�ǒǗǥǏ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǥ�ǙǘǎǕǏǐNJǜ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǨ�ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjNJ�ǚNJǑǗǥǟ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǥǟ�Ǘǘǚǖ��ƻǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǏ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǘǜǗǏǛǏǗǘ�ǔ�ǘǎǗǘǓ�ǒǑ�ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǟ�ǎnjǝǟ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǥǟ�ǔNJǜǏǍǘǚǒǓ�

��� ƻǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǏ�� ǗNJǟǘǎǩǣǏǏǛǩ� ǗNJ� mǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ� ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǒ}� ǝ� Ǚǚǘ-njNJǓǎǏǚNJ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��(&6��nj�ǜǏǡǏǗǒǏ�ǖǏǗǏǏ����bǎǗǩ��ǎǕǩ� ǜǘǍǘ�ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǎǘNjǒǜǦǛǩ�ǚNJǛǔǚǥǜǒǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJ-ǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ� ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖ� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ� ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ� ǙǚǘǛǜǘǓ� ǘǚǎǏǚ� ǗNJ�ǘNjǥǛǔ�nj�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ�Ǜ���Ǔ�ǙǘǙǚNJnjǔǘǓ�

��� ƻǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǏ��ǗNJǟǘǎǩǣǏǏǛǩ�ǗNJ�mǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǒ}�ǝ�ǘǙǏǚNJ-ǜǘǚNJ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��(&6��nj�ǜǏǡǏǗǒǏ�����ǒ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǎǗǏǓ��ǎǕǩ�ǜǘǍǘ�ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǎǘNjǒǜǦǛǩ�ǚNJǛǔǚǥǜǒǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǒ-ǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǘǚǎǏǚ��NJǎǖǒǗǒǛǜǚNJǜǒnj-ǗǥǓ�ǑNJǙǚǘǛ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǓ�ǙǚǒǔNJǑ����ƮǕǩ�ǧǜǘǍǘ�ǗǏ�ǗǝǐǗǘ�ǙǚǏǎǤ-ǩnjǕǩǜǦ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǏbȃ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǕǒǢǦ�ǝǔNJǑNJǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǜǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǑNJǙǚNJǢǒnjNJǏǖǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǛǕǝǐǒǜǦ�ǎǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘǖ�

�� Ʈǐ��ƫǏǔnjǒǜ�ƫǏǚǚ��ƱNJǔǘǗ�mƸ�ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǙǏǚǏǎNJnjNJǏǖǘǓ�Ǚǚǒ�Ǚǘǖǘǣǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗ-Ǘǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ�ǛnjǩǑǒ}�������ƸǛǗǘnjǥ�ǎǕǩ�njǗǏǛǏǗǒǩ�ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǓ��Ǚ�b�� ������� ���85/��KWWS���ZZZ�GLJLWDOGXHSURFHVV�RUJ�ILOHV�''3B%XUUB0HPR�SGI��� ƻnjǘǎ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘnj�ƻǂƪ��ǁNJǛǜǦ�����i������������� ƻnjǘǎ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘnj�ƻǂƪ��ǁNJǛǜǦ�����i������������� ƻnjǘǎ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘnj�ƻǂƪ��ǁNJǛǜǦ�����i������������ ƻnjǘǎ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘnj�ƻǂƪ��ǁNJǛǜǦ�����i�������D��

136 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƼƺƯƫƸƬƪƷƲlj�ƷƪǀƲƸƷƪƵdžƷDžƿ�ƱƪƴƸƷƸƮƪƼƯƵdžƷDžƿ�ƻƲƻƼƯƶ�Ƭ�ƸƼƷƸǂƯƷƲƲ�ƸƫljƱƪƼƯƵdžƻƼƬ�ƲƷƼƯƺƷƯƼ�ƹƺƸƬƪƳƮƯƺƸƬ�Ʋ�ƲƷƼƯƺƷƯƼ�ƴƸƶƹƪƷƲƳ�ƿƺƪƷƲƼdž�Ʋ�ƹƺƯƮƸƻƼƪƬƵljƼdž�ƲƷƾƸƺƶƪǀƲLj��ƷƯƸƫƿƸƮƲƶƽLj�ƮƵlj�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƵƲǁƷƸƻƼƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵlj

Page 138: User identification analysis

ǒǕǒ�ǒǖǏǨǜ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǏ�ǔ�ǎǏǕǝ��ƴǚǘǖǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǑNJǙǚǘǛǥ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�NjǥǜǦ�njǥǙǒǛNJǗǥ�Ǚǚǘǔǝǚǘǚǘǖ�ǒǕǒ� ǛǏǔǚǏǜNJǚǏǖ� ǛǝǎNJ�� ƫǘǕǏǏ� ǜǘǍǘ�� ǍǘǛǝ-ǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǘǚǍNJǗǥ�ǒǖǏǨǜ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǘǜǛǚǘǡǒǜǦ�ǝnjǏǎǘǖǕǏǗǒǏ�ǕǒǠNJ��ǡǦǒ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǩ�ǘǜǛǕǏǐǒnjNJǨǜǛǩ��ǗNJ�Ǜǚǘǔ�ǎǘ�ǎǏnjǩǗǘǛǜNJ�ǎǗǏǓ���

ƺNJǛǔǚǥǜǒǏ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ��ǗNJǟǘǎǩǣǒǏǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǒ�ǝ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJ�ǝǛ-ǕǝǍ�ǎǒǛǜNJǗǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��5&6���ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǏǗǘ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǘǚǎǏǚNJ��NJǎǖǒǗǒǛǜǚNJǜǒnjǗǘǍǘ�ǑNJǙǚǘǛNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǘǍǘ�Ǚǚǒ-ǔNJǑNJ��ǙǚǒǡǏǖ�ǗǏǑNJnjǒǛǒǖǘ�ǘǜ�njǚǏǖǏǗǒ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ���

ƱNJǔǘǗǘǖ�ǘ�ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��(&3$��ǗǏ�NjǥǕǘ�ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖǘǜǚǏǗǘ�Ǚǘ-ǩnjǕǏǗǒǏ� ǜNJǔǒǟ� ǘǗǕNJǓǗ� Ǚǘǡǜǘnjǥǟ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj�� ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǟ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛǝ�*PDLO��NjǕNJǍǘǎNJǚǩ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǖ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǒ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǜǦ�ǔNJǔ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǏ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǑNJǔǚǥǜǥǏ�ǙǒǛǦǖNJ�ǗNJ�ǛǏǚnjǏǚNJǟ��ƬǛǜNJǪǜ�njǘǙǚǘǛ��ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜbǕǒ�ǛǡǒǜNJǜǦ�ǜNJǔǒǏ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǩ�mǛǘǟǚNJǗǪǗǗǥǖǒ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ}"�ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ƺǝǔǘnjǘǎ-Ǜǜnjǝ�ǙǘbǙǘǒǛǔǝ�ǒ�ǒǑǤǩǜǒǨ�ǎǘǔNJǑNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnj� nj� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ�ƶǒǗǒ-ǛǜǏǚǛǜnjNJ�ǨǛǜǒǠǒǒ�ƻǂƪ��ǜNJǔǒǏ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǩ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǨǜǛǩ�ǛǘǟǚNJǗǪǗǗǥ-ǖǒ� nj� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ� njǒǎǏ�� ƯǛǕǒ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǒ� ǑNJǍǚǝǐNJǨǜ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǏ�ǙǒǛǦǖNJ� ǗNJ� Ǜnjǘǒ� ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǥ� ǒǕǒ� ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǏ� ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ�� ǛǡǒǜNJǏǜǛǩ��ǡǜǘ�ǔǘǙǒǒ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�ǙǒǛǏǖ��ǛǘǟǚNJǗǩǨǣǒǟǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǝǎNJǕǪǗǗǘǖ�ǛǏǚnjǏǚǏ��ǩnjǕǩ-ǨǜǛǩ�ǚǏǑǏǚnjǗǥǖǒ� ǔǘǙǒǩǖǒ��ƸǎǗNJǔǘ�� nj� ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǘNjǕNJǡǗǥǟ�njǥǡǒǛǕǏǗǒǓ�ǛǒǜǝNJǠǒǩ�ǘNjǛǜǘǒǜ�ǒǗNJǡǏ��ǝǎNJǕǪǗǗǥǓ�ǛǏǚnjǏǚ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǏǎǒǗǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǖǏǛǜǘǖ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǖ��ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǘǔǚǝǐǗǘǓ�Ǜǝǎ�ǀǏǗǜǚNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǘǔǚǝǍNJ�ǢǜNJǜNJ�ƲǕǕǒǗǘǓǛ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǕ�ǜNJǔǘǏ�ǘNjǛǜǘǩǜǏǕǦ-Ǜǜnjǘ�nj�ǎǏǕǏ�mƻǂƪ�Ǚǚǘǜǒnj�:HDYHU}���ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ��Ƭ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�Ǜǝǎ�ǛǜǘǩǕ�ǙǏǚǏǎ�njǥNjǘǚǘǖ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǩ�ǙǚǒǗNJǎǕǏǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJ�Ǚǘǡǜǘ-njǘǍǘ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJ�+RWPDLO�ǔ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJǖ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��(&6��ǒǕǒ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJǖ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǎǒǛǜNJǗǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��5&6���ƻǝǎ�ǙǘǛǡǒ-ǜNJǕ�� ǡǜǘ�+RWPDLO� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�5&6�� ǜNJǔ� ǔNJǔ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǒ� ǟǚNJǗǩǜ� Ǜnjǘǒ� Ǜǘ-ǘNjǣǏǗǒǩ�nj�ǝǎNJǕǪǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJ�

ƹǘǩnjǕǏǗǒǏ� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǓ� ǎǕǩ� Ǚǘǡǜǘnjǥǟ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj� ǏǣǪ�NjǘǕǦǢǏ� ǝǛǕǘǐǗǒǕǘ� ǚǏǢǏǗǒǏ� ǧǜǒǟ� ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖ�� ƭǘǚNJǑǎǘ� ǜǚǝǎǗǏǏ� ǘǙǚǏ-ǎǏǕǒǜǦ�� ǔNJǔ� ǛǏNjǩ� njǏǛǜǒ� Ǜ� ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǖǒ� nj� *RRJOH� 'RFV�� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦ�ǘNjǥǡǗǘ�ǗǏ�ǛǘNjǒǚNJǏǜǛǩ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJnjNJǜǦ�ǎǚǝǍǒǖ�ǕǒǠNJǖ�ǜNJǔǒǏ�ǜǏǔǛǜǘnjǥǏ�ǎǘ-ǔǝǖǏǗǜǥ��NJ�ǙǚǘǛǜǘ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǒǑ�ǛǘǘNjǚNJǐǏǗǒǓ�ǧǔǘǗǘǖǒǒ�ǎǒǛǔǘnjǘǍǘ�Ǚǚǘ-ǛǜǚNJǗǛǜnjNJ��ƶǒǗǨǛǜ�ƻǂƪ�ǙǘǛǡǒǜNJǕ�ƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘ�ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��(&3$��njǙǘǕǗǏ�ǝǖǏǛǜǗǥǖ�ǎǕǩ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǩ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�njǘǙǚǘǛǘnj��ǜNJǔ�ǔNJǔ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǏ�Ǚǘ-

�� ƻnjǘǎ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘnj�ƻǂƪ��ǁNJǛǜǦ�����ii�������D�Ȃ�E��� ƻnjǘǎ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘnj�ƻǂƪ��ǁNJǛǜǦ�����i�������D���� ƼNJǖbǐǏ��Ǚ�b�����

137ƼƺƯƫƸƬƪƷƲlj�ƱƪƴƸƷƸƮƪƼƯƵdžƻƼƬƪbƻǂƪ�Ƹ�ƿƺƪƷƯƷƲƲ�Ʋ�ƹƺƯƮƸƻƼƪƬƵƯƷƲƲ�ƲƷƾƸƺƶƪǀƲƲ

Page 139: User identification analysis

ǎǘNjǗǥǟ�ǞNJǓǕǘnj�nj�mǘNjǕNJǔǏ}��Ƭ�����bǍǘǎǝ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǏ�NjǘǕǦǢǏǓ�ǡNJǛǜǒ�ǎNJǗ-Ǘǥǟ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǕǘǛǦ�ǗǏ�ǗNJ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚNJǟ��ƻ�ǙǘǩnjǕǏǗǒǏǖ�NjǘǕǦǢǒǟ� ǘNjǤǪǖǘnj� ǙNJǖǩǜǒ� ǝǎNJǕǪǗǗǘǏ� ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǏ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� ǛǜNJǕǘ�ǖǏǗǏǏ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǪǗǗǥǖ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�ǛǏǍǘǎǗǩ�ǖNJǩǜǗǒǔ�ǛǗǘnjNJ�ǔNJǡǗǝǕǛǩ�nj�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǝ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� ǗNJ� njǗǏǢǗǒǟ� ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJǟ�� ƼNJǔǒǖ� ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǘǚǍNJǗǥ�ǒǖǏǨǜ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǗNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǒ�ǙǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǛǝǎNJ�ǒǕǒ�NJǎǖǒǗǒǛǜǚNJǜǒnjǗǘǍǘ�ǑNJǙǚǘǛNJ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�NjǘǕǦǢǏǓ�ǡNJǛǜǒ�ǒǗǞǘǚ-ǖNJǠǒǒ��ǔǘǜǘǚNJǩ�ǗǘǖǒǗNJǕǦǗǘ�ǗNJǟǘǎǒǜǛǩ�Ǚǘǎ�ǑNJǣǒǜǘǓ���Ǔ�ǙǘǙǚNJnjǔǒ�

Ƭ� ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ� *RRJOH� ǙǚǒǎǏǚǐǒnjNJǨǜǛǩ� ǙǚǘǜǒnjǘǙǘǕǘǐǗǘǍǘ� ǖǗǏǗǒǩ�ǒ� ǙǘǕNJǍNJǨǜ�� ǡǜǘ� ǘNjǕNJǡǗǥǏ� njǥǡǒǛǕǏǗǒǩ� ǛǕǏǎǝǏǜ� ǘǜǗǘǛǒǜǦ� ǔ� ǝǛǕǝǍNJǖ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��(&6��bǜ�ɋǏ��ǎǕǩ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǜNJǔǒǖ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖ�ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ� ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖ� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ� ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ� ǘǚǎǏǚ���� ƴǘNJ-ǕǒǠǒǩ�'LJLWDO�'XH�3URFHVV��nj�ǛǘǛǜNJnj�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǓ�njǘǢǕǒ�ǚNJǑǗǥǏ�ǙǘbǛnjǘǏǖǝ�ǙǚǘǞǒǕǨ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ƪǖǏǚǒǔNJǗǛǔǒǓ�ǛǘǨǑ�ǙǘbNjǘǚǦNjǏ�ǑNJ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗǛǔǒǏ�ǛnjǘNjǘǎǥ��ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǩ�0LFURVRIW��ǒ�mƪǖǏǚǒǔNJǗǠǥ�ǑNJ�ǗNJǕǘǍǘnjǝǨ�ǚǏǞǘǚǖǝ}��ǙǚǒǑǥnjNJǏǜ�ǒǑǖǏǗǒǜǦ�ƱNJǔǘǗ�ǘ�ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎ-ǗǒǓ��Ǚǘbǒǟ�ǖǗǏǗǒǨ��ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�mǛnjǘǎǘǖ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǥǟ�Ǘǘǚǖ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǛNjǒnjNJ-Ǩǜ�Ǜ�ǜǘǕǔǝ�ǒ�ǒǛǜǘǕǔǘnjǥnjNJǨǜǛǩ�ǛǝǎNJǖǒ�ǗǏǘǎǗǘǑǗNJǡǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǎǏǕNJǏǜ�ǝǛǕǘ-njǒǩ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�ǗǏǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǪǗǗǥǖǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǘǛǜNJnjǣǒǔǘnj�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǒ�ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǘnj}���

ƻǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǟǚNJǗǩǣǏǓǛǩ�nj�ǘNjǕNJǔǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJ-Ǡǒǒ� Ǜ� ǙǘǖǘǣǦǨ� ��Ǔ� ǙǘǙǚNJnjǔǒ� ǔ� ƴǘǗǛǜǒǜǝǠǒǒ� ƻǂƪ� �����b Ǎ���� ƻ� ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ�ǧǜǘǓ�ǙǘǙǚNJnjǔǒ��ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǖ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�Ǚǘ-ǕǝǡǏǗǒǏ�ǘNjǥǡǗǘǍǘ�ǘǚǎǏǚNJ�ǎǕǩ�NJǗNJǕǒǑNJ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǚNJǑǖǏǣǪǗǗǘǓ�nj�ǘNjǕNJǔǏ�

ƪǗNJǕǒǑ�ǙǘǔNJǑNJǕ��ǡǜǘ���ǩ�ǙǘǙǚNJnjǔNJ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǒǖNJ�ǔNJǔ�ǗǏǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǏǗ-Ǘǘ� ǔ� ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǝ���� ǜNJǔ� ǒ� ǔ� ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǥǖ� ǛǏǔǠǒǩǖ� ǐǏǛǜǔǘǍǘ� ǎǒǛǔNJ�� ǒǕǒ�mǜNJǚǏǕǔNJǖ}����ƸǚǍNJǗǥ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǘǓ�njǕNJǛǜǒ�ǒǗǜǏǚǙǚǏǜǒǚǝǨǜ�ǚNJǑǗǥǏ�ǝǚǘnj-Ǘǒ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��nj�ǙNJǙǔNJǟ��nj�ǞNJǓǕNJǟ�ǒbǜ�ɋǎ�����ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǥ-

�� LJǖǖǒɊLJ�ɊƫǒnjǒǗǛ��ƹǚNJǓnjǏǛǒ��ƻǜNJǜǝǛ�ǘNjǕNJǡǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�Ǚǘb(&3$�ǜǘǡǗǘ�ǗǏ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗ��ƹǚǘ-ǔǝǚNJǜǝǚNJ�ǑNJǩnjǕǩǏǜ�ǘ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ�njǗǏǛǏǗǒǩ�ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǓ�nj�ǑNJǔǘǗ��ƷǘnjǘǛǜǒ�ƫǨǚǘ�njǗǝǜǚǏǗ-Ǘǒǟ�ǎǏǕ�ǙǘbǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǖ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǩǖ�����ǒǨǗǩ�������� ƼNJǖbǐǏ��� ƻǂƪ�Ǚǚǘǜǒnj�ƹǏǚǚǒǗ��������ǩ�ǛǏǚǒǩ�ǛNjǘǚǗǒǔNJ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǟ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�NJǙǏǕǕǩ-ǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�Ǜǝǎǘnj�ƻǂƪ����������������Ǔ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǓ�ǘǔǚǝǍ���������njǥǗǏǛǏǗǘ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǏ�ǘ�ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǞNJǔǜ�ǙǘǎǛǘǏǎǒǗǏǗǒǩ�ǔ�ǛǏǜǒ�ǘNjǖǏǗNJ�ǞNJǓǕNJǖǒ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǖǒ��ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǣǒǓ�njǛǏǖ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩǖ�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜNJ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�ǜNJǔǒǖ�ǞNJǓǕNJǖ��ǗǏǓǜǚNJǕǒǑǝǏǜ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡ-ǗǘǏ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǘǐǒǎNJǜǦ�ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǍNJǚNJǗǜǒǓ�ǑNJǣǒǜǥ�ǙǚNJǓnjǏǛǒ���� ƻǖ��ƻǂƪ�Ǚǚǘǜǒnj�ƪǗǎǚǝǛ���������ǩ�ǛǏǚǒǩ�ǛNjǘǚǗǒǔNJ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǟ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�NJǙǏǕ-ǕǩǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�Ǜǝǎǘnj�ƻǂƪ���������Ȃ�������Ǔ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǓ�ǘǔǚǝǍ���������� ƻǂƪ�Ǚǚǘǜǒnj�ƴǚNJǓǛǜ��������ǩ�ǛǏǚǒǩ�ƻNjǘǚǗǒǔNJ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǟ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǘǔǚǝǐ-Ǘǥǟ�Ǜǝǎǘnj�ǒ�ǙǚǏǜǏǗǑǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǛǝǎNJ�ƻǂƪ������������ƻǚǏǎǗǒǓ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǓ�ǘǔǚǝǍ��

138 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƼƺƯƫƸƬƪƷƲlj�ƷƪǀƲƸƷƪƵdžƷDžƿ�ƱƪƴƸƷƸƮƪƼƯƵdžƷDžƿ�ƻƲƻƼƯƶ�Ƭ�ƸƼƷƸǂƯƷƲƲ�ƸƫljƱƪƼƯƵdžƻƼƬ�ƲƷƼƯƺƷƯƼ�ƹƺƸƬƪƳƮƯƺƸƬ�Ʋ�ƲƷƼƯƺƷƯƼ�ƴƸƶƹƪƷƲƳ�ƿƺƪƷƲƼdž�Ʋ�ƹƺƯƮƸƻƼƪƬƵljƼdž�ƲƷƾƸƺƶƪǀƲLj��ƷƯƸƫƿƸƮƲƶƽLj�ƮƵlj�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƵƲǁƷƸƻƼƲ�ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵlj

Page 140: User identification analysis

ǖǒ�mnjǒǚǜǝNJǕǦǗǥǖǒ�ǟǚNJǗǒǕǒǣNJǖǒ}�njǗǝǜǚǒ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǔǚǝǙǗǘǍǘ�ǟǚNJǗǒǕǒǣNJ�ǐǪǛǜǔǘǍǘ�ǎǒǛǔNJ��ƴǚǘǖǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǘǚǍNJǗǥ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǘǓ�njǕNJǛǜǒ�ǛǡǒǜNJǨǜ�ǑNJǣǒǜǝ�ǙNJǚǘǕǏǖ�ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘǓ�ǖǏǚǘǓ�ǙǘbǛǔǚǥǜǒǨ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ���

ƻǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǛǏǜǒ��ǙǘǎǘNjǗǥǏ�ǛǏǜǒ�)DFHERRN��ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǨǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏ-Ǖǩǖ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦ�ǔǘǕǕǏǔǜǒnjǗǥǓ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�ǞNJǓǕNJǖ��ǟǚNJǗǩǣǒǖǛǩ�nj�ǚNJǑ-Ǘǥǟ�ǞǘǚǖNJǜNJǟ��ǘǜǙǚNJnjǕǩǜǦ�ǒ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜǦ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǩ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǑNJǣǒǣǪǗǗǝǨ�ǙNJǚǘǕǏǖ�ǝǡǪǜǗǝǨ�ǑNJǙǒǛǦ��)DFHERRN�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǩ�ǑNJ�ǛǘNjǕǨǎǏǗǒǏǖ�ǙǚNJǓnjǏǛǒ��NjǕNJǍǘǎNJǚǩ�ǔǘǜǘǚǥǖ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦ�ǛNJǖǘǛǜǘ-ǩǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǩǏǜ�ǔǚǝǍ�ǕǒǠ�Ǜ�ǙǚNJnjǘǖ�ǙǚǘǛǖǘǜǚNJ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��Ƭ�ǙǚǒǗǠǒ-ǙǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǙǘǕǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǑNJNjǕǘǔǒǚǘnjNJǜǦ�ǛǙǒǛǘǔ�njǛǏǟ�Ǜnjǘǒǟ�ǎǚǝǑǏǓ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǜǏ�ǗǏ�ǛǖǘǍǕǒ�ǙǚǘǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǜǦ�ǏǍǘ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ��ǛǘǟǚNJǗǩǜǦ�ǜǏǔ-ǛǜǘnjǥǏ�ǞNJǓǕǥ�nj�njǒǎǏ�ǡǏǚǗǘnjǒǔǘnj�ǒ�Ǘǒǔǘǖǝ�ǒǟ�ǗǏ�ǘǜǙǚNJnjǕǩǜǦ�bǜ�ɋǏ��ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�)DFHERRN�nj�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ�ǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǗNJ�NjNJǑǏ�ǘNjǕNJǔNJ�� )DFHERRN�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǛǘNjǘǓ�ǗǏ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�Ǟǘǚǝǖ�ǎǕǩ�ǘNjǣǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ��Ǘǘ�ǒ�ǖǏǛǜǘ�ǚNJǑǖǏǣǏǗǒǩ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜǘnj��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǏ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǏ�ǘǚǍNJǗǥ�ǘǜǗǘǛǩǜ�ǔ�mǘNjǤǏǔǜNJǖ�ǛǝǍǝNjǘ�ǕǒǡǗǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJbȃ�ǞǘǜǘǍǚNJǞǒǒ��ǙǒǛǦǖNJ��ǕǒǡǗǥǏ�ǎǗǏnjǗǒǔǒ}�

ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǛǎǏǕNJǜǦ�njǥnjǘǎ��ǡǜǘ�ǚNJǑǖǏǣǏǗǒǏ�ǘNjǤǏǔǜǘnj�ǒǕǒ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘǍǘ�ǟNJǚNJǔǜǏǚNJ�nj�ǘNjǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǖ�ǖǏǛǜǏ�ǗǏ�Ǚǚǒnjǘ-ǎǒǜ�ǔ�ǗǏǓǜǚNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǙǚNJnjNJ�ǗNJ�ǑNJǣǒǜǝ�ǙǚNJǓnjǏǛǒ����ƺǏǢǏǗǒǏ�njǘǙǚǘǛNJ�ǘ�ǜǘǖ��ǗǏǓǜǚNJǕǒǑǝǏǜǛǩbǕǒ�ǙǚNJnjǘ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǗNJ�ǛǘNjǕǨǎǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚNJǓnjǏǛǒ�nj�ǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔ�ǏǍǘ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǜǚǏǜǦǒǖǒ�ǕǒǠNJǖǒ��ǝǛǕǘǐǗǩǏǜǛǩ�ǎǕǩ�NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjNJ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǘnj�ǘNjǕNJǡǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ��NjǘǕǏǏ�ǛnjǘNjǘǎǗǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨ-ǣǒǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓbȃ�ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��*PDLO��ƼNJǔ��ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǩ�*RRJOH�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�ǙǘǒǛǔǘnjǥǖ�ǑNJǙǚǘǛNJǖ�ǒ�ǔǘǗǜǏǗǜǝ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ�ǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǎǕǩ�ǗNJǛǜǚǘǓǔǒ� ǜǏǖNJǜǒǔǒ�ǚǏǔǕNJǖǗǥǟ�ǘNjǤǩnjǕǏǗǒǓ�Ǚǘǎ� ǔǘǗ-ǔǚǏǜǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�

ƶǘǐǗǘ�ǙǚǒǓǜǒ�ǔ�njǥnjǘǎǝ��ǡǜǘ�NjǏǑ�njǗǏǛǏǗǒǩ�ǑǗNJǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǒǑǖǏǗǏ-ǗǒǓ� nj� ǛǝǎǏNjǗǘǏ� ǜǘǕǔǘnjNJǗǒǏ� mǎǘǔǜǚǒǗǥ� ǚNJǛǔǚǥǜǒǩ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ� ǜǚǏ-ǜǦǏǓ�ǛǜǘǚǘǗǏ}�ǙǘǎNJnjǕǩǨǣNJǩ�ǡNJǛǜǦ�ǙǘǕǗǘǖǘǡǒǓ�ǙǘbǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǨ�ǍǚNJ-ǗǒǠ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǘnj�ǔ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǘǛǜNJǗǏǜǛǩ�ǑNJ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJǖǒ�ǘNjǕNJǡǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ƻNjǘǚǗǒǔ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǟ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ�ǢǜNJǜNJ�ƹǏǗǛǒǕǦnjNJǗǒǩ����������ƷNJǚǘǎ�Ǚǚǘǜǒnj�LJǖǏǚǛǘǗ�������Ƭǜǘ-ǚNJǩ�ǛǏǚǒǩ�ǛNjǘǚǗǒǔNJ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǟ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ�ǢǜNJǜNJ�ƷǦǨ�Ƴǘǚǔ������������ƻNjǘǚǗǒǔ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ�ƬǏǚ-ǟǘnjǗǘǍǘ�ǛǝǎNJ�ƻǂƪ��������� ƻǖ��ƻǂƪ�Ǚǚǘǜǒnj�ƫNJǚǜ��������ǩ�ǛǏǚǒǩ�ƻNjǘǚǗǒǔNJ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǟ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǘǔǚǝǐ-Ǘǥǟ�Ǜǝǎǘnj�ǒ�ǙǚǏǜǏǗǑǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǛǝǎNJ�ƻǂƪ������������ƱNJǙNJǎǗǥǓ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǓ�ǘǔǚǝǍ��ƻNjǘǚǗǒǔ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǟ�ǚǏǢǏǗǒǓ�ǢǜNJǜNJ�ƼǏǟNJǛ���������� ƮǏǕǘ�mƮǘǝ�Ǚǚǘǜǒnj�ǢǔǘǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǘǔǚǝǍNJ�ƵǒǜǜǕ�ƺǘǔ}���������ǩ�ǛǏǚǒǩ�ǛNjǘǚǗǒǔNJ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǟ�ǚǏ-ǢǏǗǒǓ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǟ�NJǙǏǕǕǩǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�Ǜǝǎǘnj�ƻǂƪ�������������������Ǔ�ǛǝǎǏNjǗǥǓ�ǘǔǚǝǍ���������ǛǛǥǕǔNJ�ǗNJ�ǎǏǕǘ�mǢǜNJǜ�ƷǦǨ�ƮǐǏǚǛǒ�Ǚǚǘǜǒnj�7�Ɍ/�Ɋ2�}������8�Ɋ6�������������������

139ƼƺƯƫƸƬƪƷƲlj�ƱƪƴƸƷƸƮƪƼƯƵdžƻƼƬƪbƻǂƪ�Ƹ�ƿƺƪƷƯƷƲƲ�Ʋ�ƹƺƯƮƸƻƼƪƬƵƯƷƲƲ�ƲƷƾƸƺƶƪǀƲƲ

Page 141: User identification analysis

ƴǚǘǖǏ�ǘNjǥǡǗǥǟ�ǘǚǎǏǚǘnj�ǗNJ�ǘNjǥǛǔ�ǒ�ǑNJǙǚǘǛǘnj��ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǘnj�ƻǂƪ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǑNJǙǚNJǢǒnjNJǜǦ�njǥǎNJǡǝ�ǘǚǎǏǚǘnj�ǙǘbƱNJǔǘǗǝ�mƸ�ǗNJǎǑǘǚǏ�ǑNJ�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǘǓ�ǚNJǑnjǏǎǔǘǓ}� �)Ζ6$�����ƹǚǒǖǏǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǔ�ǘNj-ǕNJǡǗǥǖ� njǥǡǒǛǕǏǗǒǩǖ� ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ� ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ� ǒ� ǙǚǒǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ� ǘǚǎǏǚǘnj�Ǚǘb ƱNJǔǘǗǝ� mƸ� ǗNJǎǑǘǚǏ� ǑNJ� ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǘǓ� ǚNJǑnjǏǎǔǘǓ}� �)Ζ6$�� ǝǛǕǘǐǗǩǏǜ-Ǜǩ�b ǜ�ɋǔ��ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ��ǛǘǑǎNJǗǗNJǩ�ǑNJ�ǚǝNjǏǐǘǖ��ǖǘǐǏǜ�nj�ǔǘǗǏǡǗǘǖ�ǒǜǘǍǏ�ǙǘǙNJǛǜǦ�ǗNJ�ǛǏǚnjǏǚǥ�ǗNJ�ǜǏǚǚǒǜǘǚǒǒ�ƻǂƪ��ǒ�ǗNJǘNjǘǚǘǜ��ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǙǏ-ǚǏǖǏǣNJǜǦǛǩ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ�ǛǏǚnjǏǚǘnj��ǚNJǑǖǏǣǪǗǗǥǟ�nj�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǥǟ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJǟ�ǒ�nj�ƻǂƪ��ǙǚǏǐǎǏ�ǡǏǖ�ǘǗǒ�ǎǘǛǜǒǍǗǝǜ�ǙǝǗǔǜNJ�ǗNJǑǗNJǡǏǗǒǩ��ƹǘǛǕǏ�ǙǚǒǗǩǜǒǩ�ǙǘǙǚNJnjǘǔ��nj�ƱNJǔǘǗǏ�mƸ�ǗNJǎǑǘǚǏ�ǑNJ�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǘǓ�ǚNJǑnjǏǎ-ǔǘǓ}�ǙǚǘnjǘǎǩǜǛǩ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǒǩ�ǙǘbǖǏǛǜǝ�ǙǚǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ǗNJǎǑǘǚNJ��ǑNJ�ǙǚǏǎǏǕNJǖǒ�ƻǂƪ�ǒǕǒ�ǗNJ�ǜǏǚǚǒǜǘǚǒǒ�ƻǂƪ��ƺNJǑǖǥǜǘǛǜǦ�ǍǏǘǍǚNJǞǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǍǚNJǗǒǠ��Ǚǚǒ-ǛǝǣNJǩ�ǘNjǕNJǡǗǥǖ�njǥǡǒǛǕǏǗǒǩǖ��ǑNJǜǚǝǎǗǩǏǜ�ǙǘǎǘNjǗǘǏ�ǚNJǑǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǒǏ�

�� 85/��KWWS���XVFRGH�KRXVH�JRY�GRZQORDG�SOV���&���W[W

140

Page 142: User identification analysis

ƭƵƪƬƪ��

ƹǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǏ�ǛǘǍǕNJǢǏǗǒǩ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǚǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǒǟ�Ζ7�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ

ƻƺƪƬƷƲƼƯƵdžƷDžƳ� ƪƷƪƵƲƱ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦǛǔǒǟ� ǛǘǍǕNJǢǏǗǒǓ� ǚǩǎNJ� ǔǚǝǙǗǥǟ�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǚǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǒǟ�Ζ7�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ�Ǜ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�ǑǚǏǗǒǩ�ǑNJǔǚǏǙǕǪǗ-Ǘǥǟ�nj�Ǘǒǟ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǓ��ǔNJǛNJǨǣǒǟǛǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��NJnjǜǘǚǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝ-ǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǏǗ�nj�ǜNJNjǕǒǠǏ�

ȟ ƹNJǚNJǖǏǜǚ 0LFURVRIW *RRJOH ljǗǎǏǔǛ ƬƴǘǗǜNJǔǜǏ )DFHERRN

1 ƮNJǗǗǥǏ�NJǗǔǏǜǥ�ǒ�ǗNJNjǘǚǥ�ǙNJǚNJǖǏǜǚǘnj�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏ-ǕǏǓ

• Ʋǖǩ• ƾNJǖǒǕǒǩ• LJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�NJǎǚǏǛ

• ƻǜǚNJǗNJ

ƸNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ• Ʋǖǩ• ƾNJǖǒǕǒǩ• LJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�NJǎǚǏǛ

• ƻǜǚNJǗNJ• ƹǘǕ• ƮNJǜNJ�ǚǘǐǎǏ-Ǘǒǩ

ƷǏǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦ-ǗǥǏ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ• ƾǘǜǘ• ƷǘǖǏǚ�ǖǘ-NjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ

• ƶǏǛǜǘ�ǚNJ-Njǘǜǥ

• ƶǏǛǜǘ�ǝǡǪNjǥ• ƭǘǚǘǎ

ƸNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ• ƾNJǖǒǕǒǩ• Ʋǖǩ• ƷǘǖǏǚ�ǖǘ-NjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ

• ǒǕǒ�ǔǘǗ-ǜǚǘǕǦǗǥǓ�njǘǙǚǘǛ

ƷǏǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦ-ǗǥǏ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ• ƼǏǕǏǞǘǗ�ǒǕǒ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǦǗǥǓ�njǘǙǚǘǛ

ƸNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ• ƾNJǖǒǕǒǩ• Ʋǖǩ• ƷǘǖǏǚ�ǖǘ-NjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ

• (�PDLOƷǏǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦ-ǗǥǏ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ• ƬǛǏ�ǘǛǜNJǕǦ-ǗǥǏ

ƸNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ• ƾNJǖǒǕǒǩ• Ʋǖǩ• (�PDLOƷǏǘNjǩǑNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǛnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ• ƬǛǏ�ǘǛǜNJǕǦǗǥǏ

� ƻǙǘǛǘNj�njǏ-ǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�NJǗǔǏǜǥ�ǘNjǚNJǜǗNJǩ�ǛnjǩǑǦ

LJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ƻǕǝǐNjNJ�ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ

ƭǏǘǕǘǔNJǠǒǩ��ǒǗǜǏǍǚNJǠǒǩ�Ǜ�NjNJǑNJǖǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒǗǥǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�*RRJOH��ǙNJǚ-ǜǗǪǚǘnj�ƻǕǝǐNjNJ�ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ

ƭǏǘǕǘǔNJǠǒǩ��ǒǗǜǏǍǚNJǠǒǩ�Ǜ�NjNJǑNJǖǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǒǗǥǟ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǘnj�ljǗǎǏǔǛ��ǙNJǚ-ǜǗǪǚǘnj�ƻǕǝǐNjNJ�ǙǘǎǎǏǚǐǔǒ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǓ

ƭǏǘǕǘǔNJǠǒǩ��ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏ-ǗǒǏ�ǗǘǖǏǚNJ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ��H�PDLO

ƭǏǘǕǘǔNJǠǒǩ��ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǏ�H�PDLO

141

Page 143: User identification analysis

ȟ ƹNJǚNJǖǏǜǚ 0LFURVRIW *RRJOH ljǗǎǏǔǛ ƬƴǘǗǜNJǔǜǏ )DFHERRN

� ƭǏǘǕǘǔNJǠǒǩ�ǒ�ǖǏǜǔǒ

$3Ζ�ǍǏǘǍǚNJ-ǞǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�njǏNj�ǙǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǩǖ�ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜǦ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǘ�Ǚǘ-ǕǘǐǏǗǒǒ�ǔǘǖ-ǙǦǨǜǏǚNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ��ǗNJ�ǔǘǜǘǚǘǖ�ǑNJǙǝ-ǣǏǗ�:LQGRZV�ΖQWHUQHW�([SORUHU���ǒǕǒ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǙǘǑǎǗǩǩ�njǏǚǛǒǩ�ΖQWHUQHW�([SORUHU�ƭǏǘǍǚNJǞǒǡǏ-ǛǔǘǏ�ǙǘǕǘǐǏ-ǗǒǏ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏ-ǕǩǏǜ�Ǣǒǚǘǜǝ�ǒ�ǎǘǕǍǘǜǝ�ǚNJǛǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚNJ

ƼǘǡǗǘ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏ-ǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǖǏǛǜǘ�ǑNJǙǝǛǔNJ�NjǚNJ-ǝǑǏǚNJ�*RRJOH�&KURPH��ǜǘǡǔNJ�njǟǘǎNJ�nj�Ǚǘ-ǡǜǘnjǥǓ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛ�*PDLO��ǖǏǛǜǘ-ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�Ǚǚǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘ-njNJǗǒǒ�*RRJOH�0DSV�ƸǙǚǏǎǏǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓ-Ǜǜnjǘ��Ǜ�ǔǘǜǘ-ǚǘǍǘ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜ-njǕǪǗ�ǑNJǙǝǛǔ�ǙǚǘǎǝǔǜNJ

ƼǘǡǗǘ�ǘǙǚǏ-ǎǏǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǖǏ-ǛǜǘǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǒ�Ζ3�njǟǘǎNJ

ƼǘǡǗǘ�ǘǙǚǏ-ǎǏǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǖǏ-ǛǜǘǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǒ�Ζ3�njǟǘǎNJ��ƬbǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǏǛǕǒ�njǟǘǎ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜ-njǕǩǏǜǛǩ�Ǜ�ǗǘnjǘǍǘ�ǖǏǛǜNJ��ǑNJǙǚNJǢǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ�ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏ-ǗǒǏ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗ-ǗǘǍǘ�ǗǘǖǏǚNJ

ƼǘǡǗǘ�ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǩ-ǏǜǛǩ�ǖǏǛǜǘǙǘǕǘ-ǐǏǗǒǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJ-ǜǏǕǩ�ǒ�Ζ3�njǟǘǎNJ

� ƹǏǚǏǔǚǪǛǜ-ǗǥǏ�ǛǛǥǕǔǒ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�NJǔ�ǔNJǝǗǜNJǖǒ

)DFHERRN7ZLWWHU/LQNHGΖQ

$SSOH ƬǗǝǜǚǒ�ǛǏǚnjǒ-Ǜǘnj�ljǗǎǏǔǛ

ƷǏǜ ƮNJ

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǘnj�ǜǏǕǏǔǘǖ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ�nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ

Ƭ�ƼƪƫƵƲǀƯ�ƷƲưƯ�ƹƺƯƮƻƼƪƬƵƯƷDž�ǘǙǒǛNJǗǒǩ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǚǩǎNJ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǓ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚNJ�Ǜ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜNJǖǒ��ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJ-ǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ǒ�ǘǜǎǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǏǓ�ǚǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǒǟ�ǘǙǏ-ǚNJǜǘǚǘnj�ǛnjǩǑǒ�

ȟ ƹNJǚNJǖǏǜǚ ƺǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǩ

1 ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǚǒbǙǘǔǝǙǔǏ�Ǜǒǖ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚ�ǘNjbǘǔNJǑNJǗǒǒ�ǝǛǕǝǍ

ƱNJǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǏ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚNJ�ǙǚǒbǝǛǕǘnjǒǒ�ǕǒǡǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚǒǛǝǜǛǜnjǒǩ�ǒbǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJ��ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǩǨǣǏǍǘ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ��ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜ��ǑNJǍǚNJǗǙNJǛǙǘǚǜ��njǘǏǗǗǥǓ�NjǒǕǏǜ�ǒbǎǚ���ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǗǥǏ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘǖ���ǛbnjǗǏǛǏǗǒǏǖ�njǛǏǟ�ǙNJǚNJǖǏǜǚǘnj�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJ��ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǩǨǣǏǍǘ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ��ƹǚǒbǑNJǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǒ�ǎǘǍǘnjǘǚNJ�ǘNjbǘǔNJǑNJǗǒǒ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ƻƹƻ�njbǎǘǍǘnjǘǚǏ�ǝǔNJǑǥnjNJǏǜǛǩ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǛǔǒǓ�ǗǘǖǏǚ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǓ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǖ��ƷǘǖǏǚ�njǥǎǏǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǒǑbǚǏǛǝǚǛNJ�ǗǝǖǏǚNJǠǒǒ��njǥǎǏǕǏǗǗǘǓ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǝ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�njbǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǗǘǖ�ǙǘǚǩǎǔǏ��ǗǘǖǏǚNJ�ǗǏbǙǘnjǜǘǚǩǨǜǛǩ��Ǚǘǧǜǘǖǝ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǖǒ��ƹǚǒǛnjNJǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ�ǒǗǎǒnjǒǎǝNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǗǏǙǘnjǜǘǚǩǏǖǥǓ�ǗǘǖǏǚ�ǔNJǐǎǘǖǝ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǝ

142 ƭƵƪƬƪ����ƹƸƵdžƱƸƬƪƼƯƵdžƻƴƲƯ�ƻƸƭƵƪǂƯƷƲlj�ƶƯưƮƽƷƪƺƸƮƷDžƿ�Ʋ�ƺƸƻƻƲƳƻƴƲƿ�Ζ7�ƴƸƶƹƪƷƲƳ

Page 144: User identification analysis

ȟ ƹNJǚNJǖǏǜǚ ƺǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǩ

� ƲǗǜǏǍǚNJǠǒǩ�ǛbǒǗǥǖǒ�NjNJǑNJǖǒ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ

ƯǛǜǦ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJnjNJǜǦ�njǛǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǑNJǒǗǜǏǚǏǛǘnjNJǗǗǥǖ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǖ��njbǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ�ǛbƾƱ�ǒbǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǥǖǒ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǖǒ�ƺƾ�ƬbǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǏǛǜǦ�ƹƹbƺƾ�ǘǜb���ǗǘǩNjǚǩ�����bǍ��ȟ�����ƸbƾƯƮƯƺƪƵdžƷƸƳ�ƭƸƻƽƮƪƺƻƼƬƯƷƷƸƳ�ƲƷƾƸƺƶƪǀƲƸƷƷƸƳ�ƻƲƻƼƯƶƯ�mƯƮƲƷƪlj�ƻƲƻƼƯƶƪ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƲbƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƬbƲƷƾƺƪƻƼƺƽƴƼƽƺƯ��ƸƫƯƻƹƯǁƲƬƪLjǃƯƳ�ƲƷƾƸƺƶƪǀƲƸƷƷƸ�ƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲǁƯƻƴƸƯ�ƬƱƪƲƶƸƮƯƳƻƼƬƲƯ�ƲƷƾƸƺƶƪǀƲƸƷƷDžƿ�ƻƲƻƼƯƶ��ƲƻƹƸƵdžƱƽƯƶDžƿ�ƮƵljbƹƺƯƮƸƻƼƪƬƵƯƷƲlj�ƭƸƻƽƮƪƺƻƼƬƯƷƷDžƿ�ƲbƶƽƷƲǀƲƹƪƵdžƷDžƿ�ƽƻƵƽƭ�ƬbLJƵƯƴƼƺƸƷƷƸƳ�ƾƸƺƶƯ}��ǍǘǛ��ǝǛǕǝǍǒ���ǗǘbnjbǜǏǔǝǣǒǓ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ�njǚǏǖǏǗǒ�ǗǏǙǘǗǩǜǗǘ��ǔNJǔbNjǝǎǏǜ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑǘnjNJǗǘ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJǖǒ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒbǧǜǘǓ�NjNJǑǘǓ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ǗǏǛǖǘǜǚǩ�ǗNJbǜǘ��ǡǜǘbƹƹbƺƾ�ǘbnjǗǏǛǏǗǒǒ�ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǓ�njbƹǚNJnjǒǕNJ�ǘǔNJǑNJǗǒǩ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ƹƮbǒbƼƶ�ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖNJǜǚǒnjNJǏǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJǖǒ�ǎNJǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�njbǠǏǕǩǟ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǘnj��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��njbǛǕǝǡNJǩǟ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǘǜǔǚǥǜǥǏ�ǜǘǡǔǒ�:L)L�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ

� ƸǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǏ�ǖǏǛǜǘǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�Ǜǒǖ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�Ζ0(Ζ

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�Ζ0(Ζ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�ǙǘǖǘǡǦ�njbǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǏǗǒǒ�ǖǏǛǜNJ�ǗNJǟǘǐǎǏǗǒǩ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜNJ��ǗǘbǗǏbǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǜǦ�ǏǍǘ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǜNJǔǘǍǘ�ǙNJǚNJǖǏǜǚNJ�ǗǏbǝǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǘ�ǗǘǚǖNJǖǒ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǝǨǣǏǍǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ

� ƼǚNJǗǛǍǚNJǗǒǡǗNJǩ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡNJ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǘbǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏ

ƯǛǜǦ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǚǒbǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ��njbǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ�Ǜb����ƾƱ��ǔǘǜǘǚǥǖ�njǗǏǛǏǗǥ�ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�njbƾƱ�ƸNjbǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǒbƸNjbǘNjǚNJNjǘǜǔǏ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ

� ƸǛǘNjǥǏ�ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩ ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ�ǙǚǘnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ�njbǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ�ǛbƾƱb������ƾƱ�����njǗǏǛǏǗǥ�ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�njbƾƱ������ǛNJǖǘǛǜǘǩǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǝǔNJǑǥnjNJǜǦ�ǗǏǜ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǛǜǒ��ƹǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏǖ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƺƾ�����ǘǜb��������

143

Page 145: User identification analysis

ƫƲƫƵƲƸƭƺƪƾƲlj

• ƪ�ɌƷ�ɊƵNJǗǦǔǘnj��mƸǛǜNJǪǜǛǩ�ǙǚǘǓǜǒ�ǡǏǜǥǚǏ�ǡǏǜnjǏǚǜǒ�Ǚǝǜǒ}Ȑ�ƸǙǝNjǕǒǔǘnjNJǗǘ����������������>LJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ� ǚǏǛǝǚǛ@�� 85/�� KWWS���WWWNNN�OLYHMRXUQDO�FRP��������KWPO� �ƮNJǜNJ� ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǍǘ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�������������

• ƪ�ɌƷ�ɊƵNJǗǦǔǘnj�� ƽ� ǖǏǗǩ� ǑNJǑnjǘǗǒǕ� ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗ�� ƸǙǝNjǕǒǔǘnjNJǗǘ�� ������������ >LJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛ@�� 85/�� KWWS���WWWNNN�OLYHMRXUQDO�FRP��������KWPO� �ƮNJǜNJ� ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǍǘ� ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�������������

• ƪ�Ɍƭ�ɊƻNJNjNJǗǘnjbȃ�mƸNjǑǘǚ�ǒǗǘǛǜǚNJǗǗǘǓ�ǗǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘǓ�NjNJǑǥ�ǙǘbǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ}����mƱNJǣǒǜNJ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��Ζ16Ζ'(}�ȟɋ���ǒǨǕǦ�NJnjǍǝǛǜ�������

• ƫ�ɊƴǚǘǛǛǏǜ� �ǔǘǘǚǎǒǗNJǜǘǚ���ƷNJǚǘǎǘǗNJǛǏǕǏǗǒǏ�ǖǒǚNJ�nj�����b Ǎǘǎǝ� �ǎǘǔǕNJǎ�ƸǜǎǏǕNJ�ǒǗǞǘǚ-ǖNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�njǗǏǢǗǒǟ�ǛnjǩǑǏǓ�ƾǘǗǎNJ�ƸǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ƸNjǤǏǎǒǗǪǗǗǥǟ�ƷNJǠǒǓ�nj�ǘNjǕNJǛǜǒ�ǗNJǚǘ-ǎǘǗNJǛǏǕǏǗǒǩ���ƷǦǨ�Ƴǘǚǔ������������Ǜ��>LJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛ@��85/��KWWS���ZZZ�XQ�RUJ�UX�GHYHORSPHQW�VXUYH\V�GRFV�SRSXODWLRQ�����SGI��ƮNJǜNJ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǍǘ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�������������

• ƬƬƻ� �ǚǝǛǛǔNJǩ� ǛǕǝǐNjNJ��� Ƭ� ƴǒǜNJǏ� mǐNJǛǖǒǗǘnjNJǩ� ǚǏnjǘǕǨǠǒǩ}� ǗǏ� ǝǎNJǕNJǛǦ�� ƸǙǝNjǕǒǔǘnjNJ-Ǘǘ�� ������������ >LJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ� ǚǏǛǝǚǛ@�� 85/�� KWWS���ZZZ�EEF�FR�XN�UXVVLDQ�LQWHUQDWLRQDO� ��������������BFKLQDBSURWHVW�VKWPO��ƮNJǜNJ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǍǘ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�������������

• ƱNJǔǘǗ�ƻǂƪ�mƸ�ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ}�����bǍ�bȃ�85/��KWWS���ZZZ�GKV�JRY�[OLEUDU\�DVVHWV�SULYDF\�SULYDF\BSROLF\JXLGHB�������SGI

• ƵǨ�ƿNJǗǦ��ǁNJǛǜǗNJǩ�ǐǒǑǗǦ�� ǛnjǘNjǘǎNJ� ǛǕǘnjNJ�ǒ� ǔǒǜNJǓǛǔNJǩ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�ǔǝǕǦǜǝǚNJ�� ǙǘǒǛǔ�ǙǝǜǏǓ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǎǏNJǗǘǗǒǖǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ƹǏǔǒǗ��������ƻ���Ȃ����⇀㗿/!昸䥩㛫ˣ妨孢冒䓙ᶶᷕ⚥仹㮹

㔯⊾烉Ṣ倱㏄䳊䘬奬⇞⚘⠫/!⊿Ṕ���������>LJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛ@��85/��KWWS���ZZZ�SNXQHWODZ�FQ�XSORDGȴOH��G�HD�����G�H���������H�FE�G�D�����SGI� �ƮNJǜNJ� ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǍǘ� ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�������������

• ƶ�ɌƬ�ɊljǔǝǢǏnj��ƶǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǘ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ� ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� nj� ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ� ���ƲǗǎǏǔǛ�ƫǏǑǘǙNJǛǗǘǛǜǒ��ȟɋ��������������

• ƸNjǑǘǚ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘnj�ǘNj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��Ḻ俼仹䭉䎮㱽⼳㱽奬ᶨ奰���>LJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛ@��85/��KWWS���ZZZ�FKLQD�FRP�FQ�FKLQHVH�]KXDQWL��������KWP��ƮNJǜNJ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǍǘ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�������������

• ƹǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ� ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ� ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ� ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ� ǘǜ� ��� ǗǘǩNjǚǩ� ����b Ǎ�� ȟɋ����mƸbǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�mƯǎǒǗNJǩ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒ-ǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǒǗǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǏ��ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǨǣǏǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘ�ǜǏǟ-ǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǏ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǟ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnj-ǕǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǞǘǚǖǏ}}bȃ�85/��KWWS���ZZZ�JDUDQW�UX�SURGXFWV�LSR�SULPH�GRF����������

• ƹǚǒǗǠǒǙǥ� ǎǘNjǚǘǛǘnjǏǛǜǗǘǍǘ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ� �m)DLU� ΖQIRUPDWLRQ� 3UDFWLFH�3ULQFLSOHV}�bȃ�85/��KWWS���ZZZ�ZKLWHKRXVH�JRY�VLWHV�GHIDXOW�ȴOHV�UVVBYLHZHU�167Ζ&VWUDWHJ\B �������SGI�

144

Page 146: User identification analysis

• ƻ�Ɍƻ�ɊƬNJǚǒnjǘǎNJ��ƻǏnjǏǚǗNJǩ�ƴǘǚǏǩ��mǔǚNJǛǗǥǓ}�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�Ǜ�ǎǝǢǔǘǖ�ǔNJǙǒǜNJǕǒǑǖNJ��ƸǙǝNjǕǒǔǘ-njNJǗǘ��������������>LJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛ@��85/��KWWS���ROG�UXVV�UX�QHWFXOW�JOREXV����������KWPO��ƮNJǜNJ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǍǘ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�������������

• ƻƯƺƲƴƸƬ�Ʋ�ɊƬ���ƷƲƴƲƼǁƯƷƴƸ�Lj�ɊƲ���ƬƪƿƺƸƶƯƯƬ�ƪ�Ɍƪ�ɊƻƸƻƼƸljƷƲƯ�Ʋ�ƹƯƺƻƹƯƴƼƲƬDž�ƺƪƱ-ƬƲƼƲlj�ƫƲƸƶƯƼƺƲǁƯƻƴƲƿ�ƼƯƿƷƸƵƸƭƲƳ�ƪƽƼƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ����Ƽǚǝǎǥ�ƶǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǘǍǘ�ǛǒǖǙǘǑǒǝǖNJ� mƷNJǎǏǐǗǘǛǜǦ� ǒ� ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǘ}�� ������ ȟɋ��� 85/�� KWWS���F\EHUOHQLQND�UX�DUWLFOH�Q�VRVWR\DQLH�L�SHUVSHNWLY\�UD]YLWL\D�ELRPHWULFKHVNLK�WHKQRORJL\�DXWHQWLȴNDWVLL� �ƮNJǜNJ� ǘNjǚNJǣǏ-Ǘǒǩ��������������

• $QMD�0LKU��3XEOLF�3ULYDF\��+XPDQ�5LJKWV�LQ�&\EHUVSDFH��6Ζ0�:RUNLQJ�3DSHU��8WUHFKW�8QLYHU-VLW\��'HFHPEHU������

• $UXQ�1DQGD��ΖGHQWLW\�6HOHFWRU�ΖQWHURSHUDELOLW\�3URȴOH��$SULO������

• %\ODZV� ΖGHQWLW\� (FRV\VWHP� 6WHHULQJ� *URXS� ΖQGXVWU\� $VVRFLDWLRQɊΖQF��b ȃ� 85/�� KWWS���ZZZ�LGHFRV\VWHP�RUJ�SDJH�LQFRUSRUDWLRQ�GRFXPHQWV

• &DPHURQ�� .LP�� m7KH� /DZV� RI� ΖGHQWLW\}�� 0D\� ������ KWWS���PVGQ�PLFURVRIW�FRP�ZLQI[�UHIHU-HQFH�LQIRFDUG�GHIDXOW�DVS["SXOO �OLEUDU\�HQ�XV�GQZHEVUY�KWPO�ODZVRȴGHQWLW\�DVS

• ƬǒǗǜǘǗ� ƻǏǚǞ��ǂNJǍ� ǔ� ǗNJǎǪǐǗǘǓ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒbȃ� 85/�� KWWS���ZZZ�RVS�UX�RV��������� ���������

• &11Ζ&� �&KLQD� ΖQWHUQHW� 1HWZRUN� ΖQIRUPDWLRQ� &HQWHU��� 7KH� ΖQWHUQHW� 7LPHOLQH� RI� &KLQD�����a������ 85/�� KWWS���ZZZ�ZHEFLWDWLRQ�RUJ���2�MH�0�� �ƮNJǜNJ� ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǍǘ� ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�������������

• 'DIW�1DWLRQDO�6WUDWHJ\� IRU�7UXVWHG� ΖGHQWLWLHV� LQ�&\EHUVSDFH��(QKDQFLQJ�2QOLQH�&KRLFH��(ɝ-FLHQF\��6HFXULW\��DQG�3ULYDF\��167Ζ&�ǙǚǘǏǔǜ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJbȃ�85/��KWWS���ZZZ�GKV�JRY�[OLEUDU\�DVVHWV�QVBWLF�SGI

• '$53$ȇV�$FWLYH�$XWKHQWLFDWLRQ�3KDVH����'$53$��Ζ�2��3URJUDP�2YHUYLHZ��)HEUXDU\��������bȃ�ZZZ�IER�JRY

• )HGHUDO�7UDGH�&RPPLVVLRQ��m&RQVXPHU�)UDXG�DQG�ΖGHQWLW\�7KHIW�&RPSODLQW�'DWD��-DQXDU\bȃ�'HFHPEHU�����}��-DQXDU\������

• )LW]SDWULFN��%UDG��2SHQΖ'�6SHFLȴFDWLRQV��KWWS���ZZZ�RSHQLG�QHW�VSHFV�EPO

• )UDQN�/DɊ5XH��5HSRUW�RI�WKH�6SHFLDO�5DSSRUWHXU�RQ�WKH�SURPRWLRQ�DQG�SURWHFWLRQ�RI�WKH�ULJKW�WR�IUHHGRP�RI�RSLQLRQ�DQG�H[SUHVVLRQ��ƷǦǨ�Ƴǘǚǔ�����������Ǜ��>LJǕ��ǚǏǛǝǚǛ@��85/��KWWS���ZZZ��RKFKU�RUJ�HQJOLVK�ERGLHV�KUFRXQFLO�GRFV���VHVVLRQ�$�Ɋ+5&������BHQ�SGI� �ƮNJǜNJ� ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǍǘ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�������������

• *UHJJ�.UHL]PDQ��5D\�:DJQHU��HW�DO����������������m)LQGLQJV��ΖGHQWLW\�����ΖV�7RR�ΖOO�'HȴQHG�IRU�ΖPPLQHQW�'HSOR\PHQW}��*DUWQHU�

• +HUOLK\Ɋ3�Ɋ*RYHUQPHQW�DV�D�GDWD�PRGHOȇ��ZKDW� Ζ� OHDUQHG� LQ�(VWRQLD����85/��KWWSV���JGV�EORJ�JRY�XN������������JRYHUQPHQW�DV�D�GDWD�PRGHO�ZKDW�L�OHDUQHG�LQ�HVWRQLD�

• +LHWDODɊ-�� DQG�'REVRQɊΖ�Ɋ(QWLWLHV�DQG�(QWLWOHPHQWbȃ�7KH�%LJJHU�3LFWXUH�RI� ΖGHQWLW\�0DQDJH-PHQW�bȃ�85/��KWWS���EORJ�RSHQJURXS�RUJ�WDJ�LGHQWLW\�HFRV\VWHP�

• ΖGHQWLW\�(FRV\VWHPbȃ�85/��KWWS���ZZZ�LGHFRV\VWHP�RUJ�

• /HPOH\Ɋ0���/HVVLJɊ/�Ɋ7KH�(QG�RI�(QG�WR�(QG��3UHVHUYLQJ�WKH�$UFKLWHFWXUH�RI�WKH�ΖQWHUQHW�LQ�WKH�%URDGEDQGɊ(UD��������8&/$�/�Ɋ5HY�������������

• /HVVLJɊ/�Ɋ7KH�$UFKLWHFWXUH�RI�ΖQQRYDWLRQ�����'XNHɊ/�Ɍ-���������������'DYLGɊ3�Ɍ$�Ɋ7KH�%HJLQQLQJV�DQG�3URVSHFWLYH�(QGLQJ�RI�m(QG�WR�(QG}��$Q�(YROXWLRQDU\�3HUVSHFWLYH�RQ� WKH� ΖQWHUQHWȇV�$U-

145

Page 147: User identification analysis

FKLWHFWXUH�����6WDQIRUG�(FRQ��'HSW���:RUNLQJ�3DSHUɊ1R����Ȃ�����������85/��KWWS���ZZZHFRQ�VWDQIRUG�HGX�IDFXOW\�ZRUNS�VZS������SGI

• 0DOLN�)DUHHG��&KLQD�MRLQV�D�WXUI�ZDU��ƸǙǝNjǕǒǔǘnjNJǗǘ�������������>LJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛ@��85/��KWWS���ZZZ�WKHJXDUGLDQ�FRP�PHGLD������VHS����FKLQDWKHPHGLD�PDUNHWLQJDQGSU� �ƮNJǜNJ� Ǚǘ-ǛǕǏǎǗǏǍǘ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�������������

• 0LFKDHOɊ.DQ��&KLQD�6KXWWHUV���������ΖQWHUQHW�&DIHV�DV�ΖW�6HHNV�0RUH�&RQWURO��ƸǙǝNjǕǒǔǘnjNJ-Ǘǘ��������������>LJǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�ǚǏǛǝǚǛ@��85/��KWWS���ZZZ�SFZRUOG�FRP�DUWLFOH��������FKLQDB VKXWVBQHWBFDIHV�KWPO�WN�UVVBQHZV��ƮNJǜNJ�ǙǘǛǕǏǎǗǏǍǘ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�������������

• 0LFURVRIWȇV�9LVLRQ�IRU�DQ�ΖGHQWLW\�0HWDV\VWHP��0D\�������KWWS���PVGQ�PLFURVRIW�FRP�ZLQI[�UHIHUHQFH�LQIRFDUG�GHIDXOW�DVS["SXOO �OLEUDU\�HQ�XV�GQZHEVUY�KWPO�LGHQWLW\PHWDV\VWHP�DVS

• 1DWLRQDO�6WUDWHJ\�IRU�7UXVWHG�ΖGHQWLWLHV�LQ�&\EHUVSDFH��(QKDQFLQJ�2QOLQH�&KRLFH��(ɝFLHQF\��6HFXULW\��DQG�3ULYDF\��167Ζ&bȃ�85/��KWWS���ZZZ�ZKLWHKRXVH�JRY�VLWHV�GHIDXOW�ȴOHV�UVVBYLHZ-HU�167Ζ&VWUDWHJ\B�������SGI

• 5RQDOGɊ-�Ɋ'HLEHUW�DQG�0DVDVKL�&UHWH�1LVKLKDWD��������*OREDO�*RYHUQDQFH�DQG�WKH�6SUHDG�RI�&\EHUVSDFH�&RQWUROV��*OREDO�*RYHUQDQFH��$�5HYLHZ�RI�0XOWLODWHUDOLVP�DQG�ΖQWHUQDWLRQDO�2U-JDQL]DWLRQV��-XO\�6HSWHPEHU��9RO������1R�����SS�����Ȃ����

• 7KUHH�+XQGUHG�0LOOLRQ�5HDVRQV�WR�)HGHUDWH�ΖGHQWLW\��DQ�Ζ56�&DVH�6WXG\bȃ�85/��KWWS���QVWLF�EORJV�JRYGHOLYHU\�FRP������������WKUHH�KXQGUHG�PLOOLRQ�UHDVRQV�WR�IHGHUDWH�LGHQWLW\� DQ�LUV�FDVH�VWXG\�

• 85/��KWWS���KDEUDKDEU�UX�EORJV�LQIRVHFXULW\�������

• 85/��KWWS���ZZZ�LGHFRV\VWHP�RUJ�

• 85/��KWWS���ZZZ�LGHFRV\VWHP�RUJ��SDJH�DERXW�LGHQWLW\�HFRV\VWHP�VWHHULQJ�JURXS

• 85/��KWWS���ZZZ�LGHFRV\VWHP�RUJ�JURXS�OHDGHUVKLS

• 85/��KWWS���ZZZ�LGHFRV\VWHP�RUJ�SDJH�LQFRUSRUDWLRQ�GRFXPHQWV

• 85/��KWWS���ZZZ�RVS�UX�RV������������������

• 85/�� KWWS���ZZZ�VPDUWFDUGDOOLDQFH�RUJ�SXEOLFDWLRQV�VPDUW�FDUG�DOOLDQFH�HQGRUVHV�WKH�QVWLF� IUDPHZRUN�

• 85/��KWWS���HQ�ZLNLSHGLD�RUJ�ZLNL�ΖGHQWLW\B���

• 85/�� KWWSV���ZZZ�JRY�XN�JRYHUQPHQW�XSORDGV�V\VWHP�XSORDGV�DWWDFKPHQWBGDWD�ȴOH��������*3*B��BLGHQWLW\BSURRȴQJBY�B�B-XO\B�����SGI

• 85/�� KWWSV���ZZZ�JRY�XN�JRYHUQPHQW�XSORDGV�V\VWHP�XSORDGV�DWWDFKPHQWBGDWD�ȴOH��������3&$*BΖ'$B3ULQFLSOHVB���BB�B�SGI

• 85/��KWWS���ZZZ�OHJLVODWLRQ�JRY�XN�XNSJD���������FRQWHQWV

• 85/��KWWS���ZZZ�SXEOLFDWLRQV�SDUOLDPHQW�XN�SD�FP�������FPELOOV�������������SGI

• 85/�� KWWSV���ZZZ�JRY�XN�JRYHUQPHQW�XSORDGV�V\VWHP�XSORDGV�DWWDFKPHQWBGDWD�ȴOH�������� 0R8B8.B(VWRQLDBGLJLWDO�SGI

• 85/��KWWSV���ZZZ�JRY�XN�JRYHUQPHQW�SXEOLFDWLRQV�JRYXN�YHULI\�LSY�RSHUDWLRQV�PDQXDO�UHGDFWHG

• :LOO�7VXL��'LJLWDO�ΖGHQWLW\�0DQDJHPHQW�RQ�WKH�ΖQWHUQHW��$SULO����������

• :LQGOH\��3KLO��'LJLWDO�ΖGHQWLW\��2ȇ5HLOO\�0HGLD��ΖQF���$XJXVW������

• <HK�� -RKQQ\�� mΖGHQWLW\� 7KHIW�� &RQJUHVVLRQDO� ΖQLWLDWLYHV� DQG� /HJLVODWLYH� )DLOXUHV}�� 'HFHPEHU������

146 ƫƲƫƵƲƸƭƺƪƾƲlj

Page 148: User identification analysis

ƷǘǚǖNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǥǏ�NJǔǜǥ

• ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ����ƾƱ��ǚǏǎ��ǘǜ�������������mƸ�ǙǚǘǜǒnjǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǒ�ǕǏ-ǍNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ� �ǘǜǖǥnjNJǗǒǨ��ǎǘǟǘǎǘnj��ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǥǟ�ǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǗǥǖ�ǙǝǜǏǖ��ǒ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǜǏǚǚǘǚǒǑǖNJ}�

• ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ����ƾƱ��ǚǏǎ��ǘǜ�������������mƸ�ǗNJǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǙǕNJ-ǜǪǐǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ}�

• ƹǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ƫNJǗǔNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ����ƹ�mƸNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǥǖǒ�ǘǚǍNJ-ǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǖǒ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj�ǒ�njǥǍǘǎǘǙǚǒǘNjǚǏǜNJǜǏǕǏǓ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǙǚǘǜǒnjǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǕǏǍNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ǘǜǖǥnjNJǗǒǨ��ǎǘǟǘǎǘnj��ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǥǟ�ǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǗǥǖ�ǙǝǜǏǖ��ǒ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǜǏǚǚǘǚǒǑǖNJ}�

• ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ�������ǚǏǎ��ǘǜ�������������mƸ�NjNJǗǔNJǟ�ǒ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǘǓ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ}�

• ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ����ƾƱ��ǚǏǎ��ǘǜ�������������mƸ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ}�

• ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ����ƾƱ��ǚǏǎ��ǘǜ�������������mƸNj�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ��ǒǗ-ǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǩǟ�ǒ�ǘ�ǑNJǣǒǜǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ}�

• ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǑNJǔǘǗ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ����ƾƱ��ǚǏǎ��ǘǜ�������������mƸ�ǛnjǩǑǒ}��Ǜ�ǒǑǖ��ǒ�ǎǘǙ���njǛǜǝǙ��nj�ǛǒǕǝ�Ǜ�������������

• ƹǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƺƾ�ǘǜ����ǩǗnjNJǚǩ�����bǍ��ȟɋ���nj�ǚǏǎNJǔǠǒǒ�ǙǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǓ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǘǜ����ǒǨǕǩ�����bǍ��ȟɋ����ǒ�ǘǜ����NJnjǍǝǛǜNJ�����bǍ��ȟɋ����

• ƹǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǘǜ���ǒǨǗǩ�����bǍ��ȟɋ����mƸNj�ǒǗǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǏ��ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒnjNJǨǣǏǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚ-ǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǘ�ǜǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǘǏ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖ��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǟ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǓ�nj�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǞǘǚǖǏ}�

• ƺNJǛǙǘǚǩǐǏǗǒǏ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƺƾ�ǘǜ������������ȟɋ�����ǚ�mƸNj�ǝǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǒ�ƴǘǗǠǏǙǠǒǒ�ǚNJǑnjǒǜǒǩ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖǘnj�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�nj�ǧǕǏǔ-ǜǚǘǗǗǘǖ�njǒǎǏ}�

147

Page 149: User identification analysis

ƹƺƲƵƸưƯƷƲlj

ƹǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ����ƼǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǏ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǥ�ǝǙǚǘǣǏǗǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�ǙǕNJǜǏǐNJ�ǒ�ǒǗǥǟ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗǥǟ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜǘnj

Ƭ� ƻƬƯƼƯ� ƹƸƬDžǂƯƷƲlj� ƼƺƯƫƸƬƪƷƲƳ� ǔ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘ� njNJǐǗǥǖ�ǛǜNJǗǘnjǒǜǛǩ� ǗNJǕǒǡǒǏ� ǝǎǘNjǗǥǟ�� NjǥǛǜǚǥǟ� ǒ�ǖNJǛǛǘnjǥǟ� ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜǘnj� ǏǪ�ǙǚǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ��Ƭ�ǜǘbǐǏ�njǚǏǖǩ��ǑNJǡNJǛǜǝǨ�ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǙǘǗǒǖNJǗǒǏ�ǚǏNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǠǏǕǏǓ�ǒ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǏǓ�ǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

ƸǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ�ǠǏǕǒ�ǝǙǚǘǣǪǗǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�• NjǥǛǜǚǘǏ� njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǏ� ǝǗǒnjǏǚǛNJǕǦǗǘǓ� ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ� ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗ-

Ǘǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�ǙǕNJǜǏǐNJ��njǔǕǨǡNJǩ�LJƻƹ��ǝǐǏ�ǒǖǏǨǣǒǏǛǩ�ǝ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj�• ǙǚǒǘǚǒǜǏǜ� ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ� ǘ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜǏ� �ǏǍǘ� Ǜnjǩ-

Ǒǒ��NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǦ�nj�ƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��ǖǏǛǜǘǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ��ǗNJǎ�ǞǘǚǖNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǏǓ�

• njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ� ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǩ� njǑNJǒǖǘǛnjǩǑǒ� ǖǏǐǎǝ� ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǓ� ǒ�ǒǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǏǓ�ǘ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǏ�

• ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ� ǏǎǒǗǘǓ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ� Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǥ� ǎǕǩ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJ-Ǡǒǒ�Ǜ�njǘnjǕǏǡǏǗǒǏǖ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǟ�ǙNJǚǜǗǏǚǘnj��ƼǏǖ�ǛNJǖǥǖ�ǑNJǖǏǜǗǘ�Ǜǘ-ǔǚNJǣNJǨǜǛǩ�Ǜǚǘǔǒ�ǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǚNJǛǟǘǎǥ�ǗNJ�ǏǪ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǏ��ƴ�ǛǘǐNJǕǏǗǒǨ��ǙǘǙǥǜǔǒ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚ�ǗNJ�ǒǛǔǕǨǡǒǜǏǕǦ-Ǘǘ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ� �ƽLJƴ�� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǔnjNJǕǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ��ǗǏ�ǘǙǚNJnjǎǥnjNJǨǜ�ǘǐǒǎNJǗǒǩ�

• ǝǎǘNjǛǜnjǘ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ƽǎǘNjǛǜnjǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�LJƻƹ�ǎǘǕǐ-Ǘǘ�NjǥǜǦ�ǛǚNJnjǗǒǖǘ�F�ǗNJǕǒǡǗǥǖǒ��ǒǗNJǡǏ�ǙǚǘǒǑǘǓǎǏǜ�ǗNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǏ�ǏǛǜǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛNJ��ǙǘǎǜNJǕǔǒnjNJǨǣǏǍǘ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǔ�ǙǏǚǏǟǘǎǝ�ǘǜ�ǗNJǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǏǓ�ǔ�NjǏǑǗNJǕǒǡǗǥǖ�

• ǚǏǢǏǗǒǏ� ǚǩǎNJ� ǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǥǟ� ǑNJǎNJǡ�� ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ�� ǗǏǎǘǙǝǣǏǗǒǏ� NJnj-ǜǘǖNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� ǍǏǗǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjNJ�LJƻƹ� Ǜ�ǠǏǕǦǨ�ǚNJǑNjǒǏǗǒǩ�ǒ�NJǍǚǏǍNJǠǒǒ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǏǓ�

ƸǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ�ǖǏǟNJǗǒǑǖǥ�ǝǙǚǘǣǪǗǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒbȃ�ǧǜǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜǘnj�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǘnj�ǛǘǜǘnjǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǥǟ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒ-ǑNJǠǒǓ��ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚ��ǜǒǙNJ�ƭƲƻ�ƭƶƹ��

148

Page 150: User identification analysis

ƹǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǛǘǜǘnjǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJƬ� ƫƸƵdžǂƲƷƻƼƬƯ� ƻƵƽǁƪƯƬ� ǗNJ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǓ� ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗ� ǝǛǜNJǗNJnjǕǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ� Ǚǚǘ-ǍǚNJǖǖNJ�ǔǘǢǏǕǪǔ��ƹǚǒ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜ�ǝǔNJǑǥnjNJǏǜ�ǛnjǘǓ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜ-ǛǔǒǓ�ǗǘǖǏǚ��ƸǙǏǚNJǜǘǚ�ǙǚǒǛǥǕNJǏǜ�ǗNJ�ǗǏǍǘ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǘǡǗǘǏ�606�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǏ�Ǜǘ�ǛǕǝǡNJǓǗǥǖ�ǔǕǨǡǘǖ��ǧǜǘǜ�ǔǕǨǡ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜ�njnjǘǎǒǜ�nj�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǝ��ǎǘǔNJǑǥ-njNJǩ�ǜǏǖ�ǛNJǖǥǖ��ǡǜǘ�6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜNJ�ǗNJǟǘǎǒǜǛǩ�ǝ�ǗǏǍǘ�ǗNJ�ǚǝǔNJǟ��nj�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǏ���ƹǚǘǍǚNJǖǖNJ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǑNJǍǚǝǐNJǏǜ�nj�ǟǚNJǗǒǕǒǣǏ�nj�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǏ�ǔǕǨǡ��ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜ-njǕǩǨǣǒǓ�ǙǚǒnjǩǑǔǝ�ǔǘǢǏǕǦǔNJ�ǔ�ǔǘǗǔǚǏǜǗǘǖǝ�NJǙǙNJǚNJǜǝ��ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��ǘNjǚNJǑǝǏǜǛǩ�ǛnjǩǑǔNJ�ǒǑ�ǜǚǏǟ�ǧǕǏǖǏǗǜǘnj��ǔǘǢǏǕǏǔ�ȃ�NJNjǘǗǏǗǜǛǔǒǓ�ǗǘǖǏǚ��6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜNJ�bȃ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗ��ǒ�Ǚǚǒ�ǛǖǏǗǏ�ǝǛǜǚǘǓǛǜnjNJ�ǒǕǒ�6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜǥ�LJƻƹ�NjǕǘ-ǔǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ�ǎǘ�ǙǘnjǜǘǚǏǗǒǩ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�

ƼǏǟǗǘǕǘǍǒǡǏǛǔǒ� ǜNJǔNJǩ� ǙǚǒnjǩǑǔNJ� ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ� ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜǦ� ǘǜ� ǛǘǜǘnjǘǍǘ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJ�ǔNJǔ�ǗNJNjǘǚ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǜǏǔǝǣǒǏ�ǙNJǚNJǖǏǜǚǥbȃ�NJǙǙNJǚNJǜǗǥǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ��ǏǍǘ�ǍǏǘǍǚNJǞǒǡǏ-ǛǔǘǏ�ǗNJǟǘǐǎǏǗǒǏ��ƮNJǗǗNJǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ��ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǘ�nj�ǛnjǩǑǔǏ�Ǜ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǒnj-ǗǘǓ�ǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔǘǓ�ǗǘǖǏǚNJ�ǙǘbǍǘǕǘǛǘnjǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒ�ǜǏǔǛǜǘnjǥǖ�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǩǖ�ǙǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǍǘǚNJǑǎǘ� NjǘǕǏǏ� ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ� ǎǕǩ� ǘǙǏǚNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǚǘ-ǑǥǛǔǗǘǓ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ��ƸƺƮ���ǡǏǖ�ǞǘǚǖNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ��ǙǚǘǒǑ-njǏǎǪǗǗNJǩ�ǎǕǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǗNJǑNJǎ�

Ƭ� ǎǘǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǏ�� ǘǜǛǥǕǔNJ� ǙǚǘnjǏǚǘǡǗǘǓ� 606� ǖǘǐǏǜ� ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǒǜǦǛǩ�Ǚǚǒ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǏǗǒǒ�ǔNJǐǎǘǍǘ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐNJ��ƹǚǒ�ǧǜǘǖ�ǙǚǒnjǩǑǔNJ��ǒ�ǙǏǚǏǡǒǛ-ǕǏǗǗǥǏ�ǙNJǚNJǖǏǜǚǥ��NJǔǜǝNJǕǒǑǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ�ǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǒǩ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐNJ�

ƸǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ�ǙǚǏǒǖǝǣǏǛǜnjNJ�• ǙǘǕǗNJǩ�ǞǘǚǖNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǔNJǔ�nj�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ��

ǜNJǔ�ǒ�Ǚǚǒ�ǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǒǒ�ǔNJǐǎǘǍǘ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐNJ�• ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǏ� ǛǘnjǘǔǝǙǗǘǛǜǒ� ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ� ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ� �NJǙǙNJ-

ǚNJǜǗǥǓ�ǒ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǗǥǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚ� ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ�� ǍǏǘǍǚNJǞǒǡǏ-ǛǔǘǏ�ǚNJǛǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ�ǒ�ǜNJǔ�ǎNJǕǏǏ��

• ǙǘnjǛǏǖǏǛǜǗNJǩ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǪǗǗǘǛǜǦ�Ǜǘǜǘnjǥǟ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǘnj�• ǙǚNJǔǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǘǜǛǝǜǛǜnjǒǏ�ǑNJǜǚNJǜ�ǗNJ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǨ�• ǗǏnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ� NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� ǍǏǗǏǚNJǠǒǒ� NjǘǕǦǢǘǍǘ� ǔǘǕǒǡǏ-

ǛǜnjNJ�LJƻƹ��ǘǎǗNJ�6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜNJbȃ�ǘǎǒǗ�ǔǘǢǏǕǏǔ��

149ƹƺƲƵƸưƯƷƲƯ����ƼƯƿƷƲǁƯƻƴƲƯ�ƹƺƸǀƯƮƽƺDž�ƽƹƺƸǃƯƷƷƸƳ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�LJƵƯƴƼƺƸƷƷDžƿ�ƻƺƯƮƻƼƬ�ƹƵƪƼƯưƪ�Ʋ�ƲƷDžƿ�ƹƵƪƼƯưƷDžƿ�ƲƷƻƼƺƽƶƯƷƼƸƬ

Page 151: User identification analysis

ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǥǏ�ǚǒǛǔǒ�

ƻǝǜǦ�ǚǒǛǔNJ ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǥǏ�ǖǏǚǥ�ǙǘbǖǒǗǒǖǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǚǒǛǔNJ

ƹǚǘǎNJǐNJ�6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜǥ�NjǏǑbǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǗNJǎǕǏǐNJǣǒǟ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǘnj

ƽǐǏǛǜǘǡǏǗǒǏ�NJǎǖǒǗǒǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǩ�Ǜǘǜǘnjǥǟ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǘnj�njbǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǜǏǔǝǣǏǍǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗǘǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ǚNJǛǛǖǘǜǚǏǗǒǏ�ǙǘǎǘNjǗǘǓ�ǙǚNJǔǜǒǔǒ�ǗǏbǜǘǕǦǔǘ�njbǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǗNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǩ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�mƸbǛnjǩǑǒ}��ǗǘbǒbƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�mƸbǙǚǘǜǒnjǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǒ�ǕǏǍNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ǘǜǖǥnjNJǗǒǨ��ǎǘǟǘǎǘnj��ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǥǟ�ǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǗǥǖ�ǙǝǜǏǖ��ǒbǞǒǗNJǗǛǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǜǏǚǚǘǚǒǑǖNJ}

ƹǚǘǎNJǐNJ�ǔǘǚǙǘǚNJǜǒnjǗǥǟ�6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǖ�ǕǒǠNJǖ��ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗǗǥǟ�ǗNJbǞǒǔǜǒnjǗǥǏ�Ǟǒǚǖǥ��njbǜǘǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ��njbNjǘǕǦǢǘǖ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǏ

ƪǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǗǘ

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǙǚǏǎǘǙǕNJǡǏǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ�ǑNJǚǝNjǏǐǗǥǟ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǘnj�ǛǘǜǘnjǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗǗǥǟ�NjǏǑbǜǚǏNjǝǏǖǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ

ƱNJǙǚǏǜ�ǗNJbǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǙǚǏǎǘǙǕNJǡǏǗǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ�ǑNJǚǝNjǏǐǗǥǟ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǘnj�ǛǘǜǘnjǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ

ƹǏǚǏǎNJǡNJ�6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǜǚǏǜǦǏǖǝ�ǕǒǠǝ

ƺǒǛǔ�ǙǘǕǗǘǛǜǦǨ�NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǏǗ�ǚǒǛǔǝ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǒ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǒǕǒbǔǕǨǡǏǓ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǔbǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ�NjNJǗǔǝ��ƬǖǏǛǜǏ�ǛbǜǏǖ��ǚǏNJǕǦǗNJǩ�ǛǜǏǙǏǗǦ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǩ�ǙǚǒbǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ�njǥǢǏ�ǒǑ�ǑNJbNjǘǕǦǢǘǓ�ǛǘnjǘǔǝǙǗǘǛǜǒ�NJǗNJǕǒǑǒǚǝǏǖǥǟ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ

ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǚNJǗǏǏ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǥǟ�6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜ��njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘ��ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗǗǥǟ�ǛbǗNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǏǖ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�mƸbǛnjǩǑǒ}

ƽǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǔbǛǘǜǘnjǥǖ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJǖ�njbǜǏǡǏǗǒǏ���ǖǏǛǩǠǏnj�ǙǚǘnjǏǛǜǒ�ǙǏǚǏǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗǒǏ�6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜ��ǒǕǒbnjbNjǘǕǏǏ�ǖǩǍǔǘǖ�njNJǚǒNJǗǜǏbȃ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǒǏ�ǔǚǝǍNJ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ�ǙǘbLJƻƹ��ǙǚǒnjǩǑNJǗǗǥǖ�ǔbǜNJǔǒǖ�6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜNJǖ��ǔNJǔbǡNJǛǜǦ�ǙǚǘǍǚNJǖǖǥ�njǗǝǜǚǏǗǗǏǍǘ�ǔǘǗǜǚǘǕǩ�NjNJǗǔNJbȃ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJ�LJƻƹ�

Ƭ�ǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�ǘǙǒǛNJǗǗNJǩ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�ǙǚǒnjǩǑǔǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnjNJ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐNJ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑǘnjNJǗNJ�ƴǒnjǒ�ƫNJǗǔǘǖ��ƱƪƸ��nj�ǚNJǖǔNJǟ�ǙǚǏǎǘǛǜNJnj-ǕǏǗǒǩ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJ�4LZL�9LVD�:DOOHW��ƷǘǖǏǚ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǝǗǒnjǏǚǛNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘǖ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǕǒǠNJ��ƹǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǏ�Ǜ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ� 606�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǓ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜǛǩ� ǗǏ� ǜǘǕǦǔǘ� Ǚǚǒ� ǛǘǑ-ǎNJǗǒǒ�ǛnjǩǑǔǒ�mǜǏǕǏǞǘǗ�LJƻƹ}��Ǘǘ�ǒ�Ǚǚǒ�ǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǒǒ�ǔNJǐǎǘǍǘ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐNJ��ƬǖǏǛǜǏ�Ǜ�ǜǏǖ��ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǖǥǏ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǘǓ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǏǓ�ǖǏǚǥ�ǗNJ�ǎNJǗ-ǗǥǓ�ǖǘǖǏǗǜ�nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ǞǘǚǖNJǕǦǗǘ�ǗǏ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǨǜǛǩ�nj�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒ-ǔNJǠǒǒ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǕǒǠNJ��ƻǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǘǜǖǏǜǒǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�nj�NjǘǕǦǢǒǗǛǜnjǏ�ǛǜǚNJǗ�ǙǚǘnjǏǚǔNJ�ǎǘǖNJǢǗǏǍǘ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǘǜǘnjǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ��ǏǛǕǒ�ǕǘǔNJǕǦǗǥǓ�NJǗNJǕǘǍ�ƱNJǔǘǗNJ�ǘ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�VLP�ǔNJǚǜ��ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗ-Ǘǥǖ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǖ�ǙǚǒǑǗNJǔǘǖ�

150 ƹƺƲƵƸưƯƷƲlj

Page 152: User identification analysis

ƹǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ��ǚNJǗǏǏ�njǥǎNJǗǗǘǓ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǝ�ǒǗǘǓ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǘǓ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǏǓƹƸƻƵƯ� ƬƬƸƮƪ� ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲǀƲƺƽƯƶDžƶ� ƵƲǀƸƶ� ǗNJ� ǛNJǓǜǏ� ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJ� LJƻƹ� �ǒǕǒ�ǒǗǥǖ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjǘǖ��ǚǏǔnjǒǑǒǜǘnj�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ��ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜ�NjǕǘǔǒǚǘnjǔǝ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�ǗNJ�ǛǕǝǡNJǓǗǝǨ�Ǜǝǖǖǝ�ǕǒNjǘ�Ǜ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǥǖ�ǙǚǒǖǏǡNJ-ǗǒǏǖ��ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǣǒǖ�ǘǎǗǘǚNJǑǘnjǥǓ�ǙNJǚǘǕǦ�ǒǕǒ�ǔǘǎ�

ƮǕǩ�ǜǘǍǘ�ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǝǑǗNJǜǦ�ǧǜǝ�Ǜǝǖǖǝ��ǒǕǒ�ǙǚǒǖǏǡNJǗǒǏ��ǒ�njǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǒ�ǝǔNJǑNJǜǦ�ǏǪ�ǗNJ�ǛNJǓǜǏ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJ��ǘNjǕNJǎNJǗǒǩ�ǛNJǖǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǘǓ�ǗǏǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ��ƵǒǠǘ�ǎǘǕǐǗǘ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�nj�NjNJǗǔǏ�ǧǖǒǜǏǗǜǏ�ǙǘbǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗ-ǗǘǓ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǘǓ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǏǓ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǏ��ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜ��ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǓ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗ�ǒǕǒ�nj�ǕǒǡǗǘǖ�ǙǚǒǛǝǜǛǜnjǒǒ���ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�njǥǙǒǛǔǝ�ǙǘbǛǡǪǜǝ�ǒ�ǗǏ-ǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǒǑ�ǗǏǪ��Ƭ�ǚǩǎǏ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏnj��ǝǔNJǑNJǗǗNJǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǖǘ-ǐǏǜ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǜǦǛǩ�nj�606�ǛǘǘNjǣǏǗǒǩǟ��ǙǚǒǛǥǕNJǏǖǥǟ�NjNJǗǔǘǖ�ǧǖǒǜǏǗǜǘǖ�

ƼNJǔǒǖ� ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�� ǗNJǎǪǐǗǘǛǜǦ� ǎNJǗǗǘǍǘ� ǖǏǜǘǎNJ� ǚNJnjǗǘǑǗNJǡǗNJ� ǘǙǕNJǜǏ�ǛǡǏǜǘnj�ǒ�ǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǒǨ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǓ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǎǒǛǜNJǗǠǒǘǗǗǘ-Ǎǘ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǘǍǘ�ǘNjǛǕǝǐǒnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒǕǒ�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�

ƻǕǏǎǝǏǜ�ǘǛǘNjǘ�ǘǜǖǏǜǒǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�ǙǚǏǎǕNJǍNJǏǖǥǓ�ǖǏǜǘǎ�ǗǏ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�Ǘǘ-njNJǠǒǏǓ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�Ǚǚǩǖǘ�njǥǜǏǔNJǏǜ�ǒǑ�Ǚ�b����ƹǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǩ�ƫNJǗǔNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ǘǜ����NJnjǍǝǛǜNJ�����bǍ��ȟɋ����ƹ�mƸNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǥǖǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒ-ǑNJǠǒǩǖǒ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj�ǒ�njǥǍǘǎǘǙǚǒǘNjǚǏǜNJǜǏǕǏǓ�nj�ǠǏǕǩǟ�ǙǚǘǜǒnjǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǕǏǍNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ǘǜǖǥnjNJǗǒǨ��ǎǘǟǘǎǘnj��ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǥǟ�ǙǚǏǛǜǝǙǗǥǖ�ǙǝǜǏǖ��ǒ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ�ǜǏǚǚǘǚǒǑǖNJ}��ǍǎǏ�ǝǔNJǑNJǗǘ��ǡǜǘ�mǙǚǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǒ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǒǟ� �ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǥǟ�� ǔNJǚǜ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ� ǙǚǘǒǑnjǘǎǒǜǛǩ� ǙǝǜǪǖ�ǙǚǏǎǤǩnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǚǏǔnjǒǑǒǜǘnj�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǒ�ǔǘǎǘnj��ǙNJǚǘǕǏǓ�}�

ƸǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ�ǙǚǏǒǖǝǣǏǛǜnjNJ�• ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�njǥǛǘǔNJǩ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǪǗǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ�• njǥǛǘǔNJǩ�ǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǗǘǛǜǦ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǏǚǐNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǥǟ�

ǔNJǚǜ�• ǗǏnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ� NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ� ǍǏǗǏǚNJǠǒǒ� NjǘǕǦǢǘǍǘ� ǔǘǕǒǡǏ-

ǛǜnjNJ�LJƻƹ�Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǘǎǗǘǓ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ƸǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ�ǚǒǛǔǒ�ǗǒǑǔǒ�ǒ�NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǗǥ�ǜǏǖ��ǡǜǘ�NJǔǜǝNJǕǦǗǥ�ǎǕǩ�ǛǜNJǗ-

ǎNJǚǜǗǘǓ� ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǥ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ� ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǘǓ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJ-ǠǒǏǓ��Ƭ�ǡNJǛǜǗǘǛǜǒ��ǘǗǒ�ǛǘǛǜǘǩǜ�nj�ǗǏǗNJǖǏǚǏǗǗǘǓ�ǔǘǖǙǚǘǖǏǜNJǠǒǒ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǡǏ� ǜǚǏǜǦǏǖǝ�ǕǒǠǝ� ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǒ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ� ǔ� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�ǎǒǛǜNJǗǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǘǍǘ�ǘNjǛǕǝǐǒnjNJǗǒǩ�

ƹǚǒnjǏǎǏǗǗNJǩ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�Ǣǒǚǘǔǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜǛǩ�nj�ǑNJǚǝNjǏǐǗǥǟ�ǛǜǚNJ-ǗNJǟ� ǒ� ǙǚǒǚNJnjǗǒnjNJǏǜǛǩ� ǔ� ǙǘǕǗǘǓ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ� ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ� ǕǒǠNJ��ƬbǡNJǛǜǗǘǛǜǒ��njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑǘnjNJǗNJ�nj�ǖǏǐǎǝ-

151ƹƺƲƵƸưƯƷƲƯ����ƼƯƿƷƲǁƯƻƴƲƯ�ƹƺƸǀƯƮƽƺDž�ƽƹƺƸǃƯƷƷƸƳ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�LJƵƯƴƼƺƸƷƷDžƿ�ƻƺƯƮƻƼƬ�ƹƵƪƼƯưƪ�Ʋ�ƲƷDžƿ�ƹƵƪƼƯưƷDžƿ�ƲƷƻƼƺƽƶƯƷƼƸƬ

Page 153: User identification analysis

ǗNJǚǘǎǗǘǖ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǖ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛǏ�3D\3DO��ƴǕǒǏǗǜǥ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�nj�ƯnjǚǘǙǏ��ǘǛǝ-ǣǏǛǜnjǒnjǢǒǏ� ǙǚǒnjǩǑǔǝ� NjNJǗǔǘnjǛǔǘǓ� ǔNJǚǜǥ�� ǖǘǍǝǜ� ǙǚǘnjǘǎǒǜǦ� ǙǕNJǜǏǐǒ�NjǏǑ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǒǓ�ǙǘbǛǝǖǖǏ�ǒǕǒ�ǡNJǛǜǘǜǏ�

ƹǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�ǔbǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJǖ��ƯǎǒǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǒ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƯƻƲƪ���ƭƲƻ�ƭƶƹ�ƹƺƸǀƯƮƽƺƪ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�ƸƻƽǃƯƻƼƬƵljƯƼƻlj�ǙǝǜǪǖ�ǙǏǚǏǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�Ǜ�ǛNJǓǜNJ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚNJ�LJƻƹ�ǗNJ�ǛNJǓǜ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJ��ǗNJ-ǙǚǒǖǏǚ�� ǛNJǓǜ� ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ��� ǍǎǏ�ǘǗ�Ǚǚǘǟǘǎǒǜ�ǙǚǏǎǝǛǖǘǜǚǏǗǗǥǏ�ǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǝ-Ǩǣǒǖǒ�ǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜNJǖǒ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǥ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��Ǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǥǟ�ǚNJǗǏǏ�ǕǒǡǗǘ�ǗNJ�ǚǝǔǒ�LJǀƹ��ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǜǘǔǏǗNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǚǏǔnjǒǑǒǜǘnj��

ƭǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǓ� ǛNJǓǜ�� ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǒnj� njǏǚǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ǙǏǚǏǎNJǪǜ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǝ�LJƻƹ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǑǗNJǡǒǖǘǏ�ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǐǎǏǗǒǏ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǡǜǘ�ǎNJǗǗǥǓ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǦbȃ�njǕNJǎǏǕǏǠ� ǜǘǍǘ�ǒǕǒ�ǒǗǘǍǘ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗ-ǗǘǍǘ� ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚNJ� �ǡNJǣǏ� njǛǏǍǘ�� ǧǜǘ� ƻƷƲƵƻ�� Ǘǘ� ǖǘǍǝǜ� NjǥǜǦ� ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ�ǒbǜ�ɋǙ����ƮǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ��Ǚǚǒ�ǗNJǕǒǡǒǒ�ǛǘǍǕNJǛǒǩ�ǙǘǕǦ-ǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�ǒ�ǙǚNJnjǘnjǥǟ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǓ��ƸǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǝ�LJƻƹ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǙǏǚǏǎNJǗǥ�ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǘǗǗǥǏ�ǎNJǗǗǥǏ�

ƹǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǗǏǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�ǖǏǐ-ǎǝ� ǛǏǚnjǏǚNJǖǒ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ� ǛǏǚnjǒǛNJ� ǒ� ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǘǓ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�Ǚǘb ǑNJǣǒǣǪǗǗǥǖ� ǔNJǗNJǕNJǖ� ǛnjǩǑǒ�� ǙǏǚǏǟnjNJǜ� ǒ� ǙǘǎǖǏǗNJ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� ǛNJǖǒǖ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǏǖ�ǒǕǒ�ǜǚǏǜǦǒǖǒ�ǕǒǠNJǖǒ�ǗǏnjǘǑǖǘǐǗǥ�

ƹǘb ǙǚǒnjǏǎǪǗǗǘǓ� ǛǟǏǖǏ� nj� ƺǘǛǛǒǒ� ǝǐǏ� ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǖǏǐnjǏǎǘǖ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǏ� njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǏ�� ƷNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ�� ǖǘǛǔǘnjǛǔǒǓ� ǒ� ǚǏǍǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕǥ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ�ǎǕǩ�ǠǏǕǏǓ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǏǚǏǗNJǙǚNJnjǕǩǨǜ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘ-njNJǜǏǕǩ�ǗNJ�ǞǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ�ǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ�ƯƻƲƪ��ƼNJǔǒǖ� ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�� ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǩ� ǛǟǏǖǥ� ǗǏ� ǙǘǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ� ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǚNJǛǟǘǎǘnj� NjǨǎǐǏǜǗǥǟ� ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�� ƯǎǒǗǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ� ǙǚǏǙǩǜǛǜnjǒǏǖ� ǎǕǩ� ǒǛ-ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ� ƯƻƲƪ� ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǖǒ�ǛǝNjǤǏǔǜNJǖǒ� ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ� ǑNJǔǘ-ǗNJ�ȟɋ����ƾƱ� ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ� ǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ� ǙǘǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǩ� ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ� ƺƾ�ȟɋ����ǘǜ�������������ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǒnjNJǨǣǏǏ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǔ�ƯƻƲƪ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥ-ǖǒ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǖǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖǒ�

ƸǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ�ǙǚǏǒǖǝǣǏǛǜnjNJ�• njǥǛǘǔNJǩ�ǛǜǏǙǏǗǦ�ǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǗǘǛǜǒ�• ǒǗǜǏǍǚNJǠǒǩ�Ǜ�ǒǗǛǜǒǜǝǜNJǖǒ��ǛǘǑǎNJǗǗǥǖǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǘǖ�

152 ƹƺƲƵƸưƯƷƲlj

Page 154: User identification analysis

ƷǏǎǘǛǜNJǜǔǘǖ�ǙǘǎǟǘǎNJ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǗǏNjǘǕǦǢǘǏ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjǘ�ǑNJǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒ-ǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǟ� nj� ǛǒǛǜǏǖǏ� ƯƻƲƪ� ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ� ǕǒǠ� njǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǏ� ǎǘǛǜNJǜǘǡǗǘ�ǛǕǘǐǗǘǓ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǥ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�ǒ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjNJ�ǜǘǡǏǔ�ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗǒǩ�LJǀƹ�

ƸǛǗǘnjǗǥǏ�ǚǒǛǔǒ�ǛǘǛǜǘǩǜ�nj�ǗǏǗNJǖǏǚǏǗǗǘǓ�ǔǘǖǙǚǘǖǏǜNJǠǒǒ�ǒǕǒ�ǙǏ-ǚǏǎNJǡǏ�ǚǏǔnjǒǑǒǜǘnj�ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ�nj�ƯƻƲƪ�ǒǗǘǖǝ�ǕǒǠǝ�

ƱNJǎǏǓǛǜnjǘnjNJǗǒǏ� ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ� NjNJǑ� ǎNJǗǗǥǟ� ǒ� ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǗǥǟ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǘǖ�ǛǙǘǛǘNjǘnj�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǕǒǠ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJ-ǗǏǗǘ�nj�ǖǏǐǎǝǗNJǚǘǎǗǘǓ�ǙǚNJǔǜǒǔǏ��Ƭ�ƷǒǎǏǚǕNJǗǎNJǟ�'LJΖG��njǔǕǨǡNJǨǣǒǓ�ǒǖǩ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�� ǙNJǚǘǕǦ� ǒ� ǘǎǗǘǚNJǑǘnjǥǏ� ǔǘǎǥ� Ǚǘb 606�� ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖ�ǎǕǩ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǔNJǔ�Ǜ�ǘǛǗǘnjǗǥǖǒ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚNJǖǒ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�Ǜ�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǖǒ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǖǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǩǖǒ��ƸǎǗǒ�ǒ�ǜǏbǐǏ�ǚǏǔnjǒǑǒ-ǜǥ��ǙǘǎǔǚǏǙǕǪǗǗǥǏ�ǘǎǗǘǚNJǑǘnjǥǖ�ǙNJǚǘǕǏǖ��ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦǛǩ�ǎǕǩ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǂnjǏǠǒǒ��ǁǏǟǒǒ��ƮNJǗǒǒ��LJǛǜǘǗǒǒ��ƵǒǜnjǏ��ƷǘǚnjǏǍǒǒ�Ǚǚǒ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǒ�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǓ�Ǜ�Ǣǒǚǘǔǒǖ�ǔǚǝǍǘǖ�ǝǡǚǏǐǎǏǗǒǓ�

Ƭ�ƷǘnjǘǓ�ƱǏǕNJǗǎǒǒ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗNJ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǛǙǏǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǓ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕ��ƸǎǗǘǔǚNJǜǗǘ�ǙǚǘǢǏǎǢǒǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǨ�ǕǒǠNJ�ǖǘǍǝǜ� ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ� ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǥǏ� ǚǏǔnjǒǑǒǜǥ� ǎǘǛǜǝǙNJ� ǎǕǩ� ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǥǟ� ǝǛǕǝǍ�� ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗǒǩ� ǛǜǚNJǟǘnjǘǔ�ǒ�nj�ǒǗǥǟ� ǛǕǝǡNJǩǟ��ƻǟǘǐNJǩ�ǛǟǏǖNJ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑǘnjNJǗNJ�nj�ƲǗǎǒǒ��nj�ǞǘǚǖǏ�mǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ}��

ƹǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǥ�ǝǙǚǘǣǏǗǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǘǜǗǘǢǏǗǒǒ�ǔ�ǠǏǕǩǖ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǩ

ƻǙǘǛǘNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǀǏǕǒ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�

ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�

ǔbǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�NjNJǑNJǖ�

ǎNJǗǗǥǖ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ

��� ƫǥǛǜǚǘǏ�ǒbǖNJǛǛǘnjǘǏ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǏ�ǝǗǒnjǏǚǛNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǙǏǚǛǘǗNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj�ǙǕNJǜǏǐNJ��njǔǕǨǡNJǩ�LJƻƹ��ǝǐǏ�ǒǖǏǨǣǒǏǛǩ�ǝbǔǕǒǏǗǜǘnj

ƽǚǘnjǏǗǦ�ǙǚǘǗǒǔǗǘnjǏǗǒǩ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�njbƺǘǛǛǒǒ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǘǎǗǒǖ�ǒǑbǛNJǖǥǟ�njǥǛǘǔǒǟ�njbǖǒǚǏ��ǧǞǞǏǔǜǒnjǗǥǓ�ǝǚǘnjǏǗǦ�ǙǚǘǗǒǔǗǘnjǏǗǒǩ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜ�ǘǔǘǕǘ���Ɍ��

ƬbǗNJǛǜǘǩǣǏǏ�njǚǏǖǩ�njbƺǘǛǛǒǒ��ǙǘbǎNJǗǗǥǖ�ƫNJǗǔNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ��njǥǙǝǣǏǗǘ�NjǘǕǏǏ�������ǖǕǗ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ��njǛǏ�ǒǑbǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�njǥǎNJǗǥ�ǛbǙǚǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǏǖ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚǥ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ

ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǎNJǗǗǥǖ�ƶǒǗǔǘǖǛnjǩǑǒ��ǗNJbƯǎǒǗǘǖ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕǏ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǗNJbǗNJǡNJǕǘ�����bǍǘǎNJ�NjǥǕǘ�ǑNJǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǗǘ�NjǘǕǏǏ���ǖǒǕǕǒǘǗǘnj�ǡǏǕǘnjǏǔ��ƻb����bǍǘǎNJ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�ǘbnjǛǏǟ�ǎǏǚǐNJǜǏǕǩǟ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ�NjǝǎǏǜ�NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǒ�njǗǘǛǒǜǦǛǩ�njbƯƻƲƪ

153ƹƺƲƵƸưƯƷƲƯ����ƼƯƿƷƲǁƯƻƴƲƯ�ƹƺƸǀƯƮƽƺDž�ƽƹƺƸǃƯƷƷƸƳ�ƲƮƯƷƼƲƾƲƴƪǀƲƲ�LJƵƯƴƼƺƸƷƷDžƿ�ƻƺƯƮƻƼƬ�ƹƵƪƼƯưƪ�Ʋ�ƲƷDžƿ�ƹƵƪƼƯưƷDžƿ�ƲƷƻƼƺƽƶƯƷƼƸƬ

Page 155: User identification analysis

ƻǙǘǛǘNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǀǏǕǒ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�

ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�

ǔbǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�NjNJǑNJǖ�

ǎNJǗǗǥǖ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ

��� ƹǚǒǘǚǒǜǏǜ�ǛǘǎǏǚǐNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǘbǔǕǒǏǗǜǏ��ǏǍǘ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǦ�njbƲǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ��ǖǏǛǜǘǙǘǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ��ǗNJǎbǞǘǚǖNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǏǓ

ƻnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ��ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǥǏ�ǛbǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ�ǝǐǏ�ǛǏǓǡNJǛ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǨǜǛǩ�njbǟǘǎǏ�ǙǚǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǩ�ƸƺƮ��ƴǚǏǎǒǜǗǥǏ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ�ǒbǛǘǜǘnjǥǏ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǘǚǥ�ǒǖǏǨǜ�ǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǝǨ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǎǕǩbǟǚNJǗǏǗǒǩ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣǏǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ

ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ�ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ�ǘbǔǕǒǏǗǜǏ�ǙǘbǏǍǘ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǏ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǘ��ƼǏǖbǗǏbǖǏǗǏǏ��NjNJǗǔ�ǧǖǒǜǏǗǜ�Ǚǚǘnjǘǎǒǜ�ǛNJǖǘǛǜǘǩǜǏǕǦǗǥǓ�ǖǘǗǒǜǘǚǒǗǍ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗǘǓ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ�ǙǘbǔNJǚǜǏ

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǝǜǪǖ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�ǔbǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�NjNJǑNJǖ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ��ƯƻƲƪ�njbǠǏǕǘǖ�NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǗǘ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǎǘǔǝǖǏǗǜǝ��ǝǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǩǨǣǏǖǝ�ǕǒǡǗǘǛǜǦ

��� ƬǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǩ�njǑNJǒǖǘǛnjǩǑǒ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗǘǓ�ǒbǒǗǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǏǓ�ǘbǔǕǒǏǗǜǏ

ƺǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǖǝ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗǝ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǝǛǜNJǗNJnjǕǒnjNJǜǦ�ǎǘǛǜǘnjǏǚǗǝǨ�ǛnjǩǑǦ�ǖǏǐǎǝ�ǞǒǗNJǗǛǘnjǘǓ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ��ǏǍǘ�ǙǏǚǏǖǏǣǏǗǒǩǖǒ��NJbǙǚǒbǗNJǕǒǡǒǒ�ǑNJǔǘǗǗǥǟ�ǘǛǗǘnjNJǗǒǓbȃ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjǘǓ�ǒbǜǏǔǛǜǘnjǘǓ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǒ

ƹǚǒbǙǚǘnjǏǎǏǗǒǏ�ǘǙǏǚNJǜǒnjǗǘ�ǚǘǑǥǛǔǗǘǓ�ǎǏǩǜǏǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ��ǙǚNJnjǘǘǟǚNJǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ�ǘǚǍNJǗǥ�ǛǖǘǍǝǜ�ǙǘǕǝǡǒǜǦ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙ�ǗǏbǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǔbǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǩǖ�ǙǘbǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǏ��ǗǘbǒbǔbǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǩǖ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǙǚǒnjǩǑNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǔbǗǏǓ�LJƻƹ��njbǘNjǘǒǟ�ǛǕǝǡNJǩǟ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǒǏ�ǗǏbǜǘǕǦǔǘ�Ǜǝǖǖǥ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǒ��ǗǘbǒbǖǏǛǜNJ��NJbǜNJǔǐǏ�ǘNjǛǜǘǩǜǏǕǦǛǜnj�ǛǘnjǏǚǢǏǗǒǩ�ǙǏǚǏnjǘǎNJ�ǎǏǗǏǐǗǥǟ�ǛǚǏǎǛǜnj��

ƹǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�ǔǕǒǏǗǜǥ�ǙǘbǚǏǑǝǕǦǜNJǜNJǖ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǗNJbǙǘǚǜNJǕǏ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ�njǙǘǛǕǏǎǛǜnjǒǒ�ǛǘnjǏǚǢNJǨǜ�ǚǩǎ�ǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒ�ǑǗNJǡǒǖǥǏ�ǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ��ǗNJǙǚ���ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗǒǏ�ǙNJǛǙǘǚǜNJ��ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǩ�njbǗNJǕǘǍǘnjǘǖ�ǘǚǍNJǗǏ�ǒbǙǚ����ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǝǨǣNJǩ�ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗNJǩ�ǒǗǞǘǚǖNJǠǒǩ�NjǝǎǏǜ�ǎǘǛǜǝǙǗNJ�ǎǕǩbǠǏǕǏǓ�ǖǘǗǒǜǘǚǒǗǍNJ�NJǔǜǒnjǗǘǛǜǒ�ǞǒǑǒǡǏǛǔǘǍǘ�ǕǒǠNJ

��� ƻǘǑǎNJǗǒǏ�ǏǎǒǗǘǓ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǥ�ǎǕǩbǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǛbnjǘnjǕǏǡǏǗǒǏǖ�ǡNJǛǜǗǥǟ�ǙNJǚǜǗǏǚǘnj��ƼǏǖbǛNJǖǥǖ�ǑNJǖǏǜǗǘ�ǛǘǔǚNJǣNJǨǜǛǩ�Ǜǚǘǔǒ�ǒbǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǚNJǛǟǘǎǥ�ǗNJbǏǪ�njǗǏǎǚǏǗǒǏ��ƴbǛǘǐNJǕǏǗǒǨ��ǙǘǙǥǜǔǒ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�Ǜǜǚǝǔǜǝǚ�ǗNJbǒǛǔǕǨǡǒǜǏǕǦǗǘ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǓ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ��ƽLJƴ��ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǔnjNJǕǒǞǒǠǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ��ǗǏbǘǙǚNJnjǎǥnjNJǨǜ�ǘǐǒǎNJǗǒǩ

ƬbǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ��ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǘnj�ǛbǝǡNJǛǜǒǏǖ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ�ǗǏbǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ

ƬbǛǕǝǡNJǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ��ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜǘnj�ǛbǝǡNJǛǜǒǏǖ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjNJ�ǗǏbǜǚǏNjǝǏǜǛǩ�

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�ǔbǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�NjNJǑNJǖ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ�ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǡǏǛǜnjNJ�ǛbǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖǒ�ǘǚǍNJǗNJǖǒ��ƺǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǩ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǒǜ�ǙǘnjǥǛǒǜǦ�ǎǘNjNJnjǕǏǗǗǝǨ�ǠǏǗǗǘǛǜǦ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�njǑNJǒǖǘǎǏǓǛǜnjǒǩ�ǎǕǩbǞǒǑǕǒǠNJ��ǙǘǘǣǚǒǜǦ�ǙǘǜǚǏNjǒǜǏǕǏǓ�ǔbǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�ǗNJbǛNJǓǜǏ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ��ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǨ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǓ�ǙǘǎǙǒǛǒ

154 ƹƺƲƵƸưƯƷƲlj

Page 156: User identification analysis

ƻǙǘǛǘNj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǀǏǕǒ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǒ

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�

ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�

ǔbǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�NjNJǑNJǖ�

ǎNJǗǗǥǖ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖNJǖ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ

��� ƽǎǘNjǛǜnjǘ�ǎǕǩbǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ��ƽǎǘNjǛǜnjǘ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�LJƻƹ�ǎǘǕǐǗǘ�NjǥǜǦ�ǛǚNJnjǗǒǖǘ�F�ǗNJǕǒǡǗǥǖǒ��ǒǗNJǡǏ�ǙǚǘǒǑǘǓǎǏǜ�ǗNJǚǝǢǏǗǒǏ�ǏǛǜǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚǘǠǏǛǛNJ��ǙǘǎǜNJǕǔǒnjNJǨǣǏǍǘ�ǍǚNJǐǎNJǗ�ǔbǙǏǚǏǟǘǎǝ�ǘǜbǗNJǕǒǡǗǥǟ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǏǓ�ǔbNjǏǑǗNJǕǒǡǗǥǖ

ƬbǛǒǕǝ�ǢǒǚǘǔǘǓ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǪǗǗǘǛǜǒ�ǛǘǜǘnjǘǓ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǥǓ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗ�ǛǜNJǕ�ǎǕǩbǙǘǜǚǏNjǒǜǏǕǩ�ǙǚǒnjǥǡǗǥǖ�ǒbǙǘǗǩǜǗǥǖ�ǙǘnjǛǏǎǗǏnjǗǥǖ�ǒǗǛǜǚǝǖǏǗǜǘǖ��606�ǞǝǗǔǠǒǘǗNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǦ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�ǝǗǒnjǏǚǛNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ǝǛǕǝǍǘǓ

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ�ǘǜbǔǕǒǏǗǜNJ�ǎǘǙǘǕǗǒǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǛǒǕǒǓ��ƬǖǏǛǜǏ�ǛbǜǏǖ��ǎNJǗǗNJǩ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�ǙǚǒnjǕǏǔNJǜǏǕǦǗNJ�ǎǕǩbǖNJǛǛǘnjǘǍǘ�ǙǘǜǚǏNjǒǜǏǕǩ��ǙǘǛǔǘǕǦǔǝ�njbǙǘǎNJnjǕǩǨǣǏǖ�ǡǒǛǕǏ�ǛǕǝǡNJǏnj�ǗǏbǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ�ǕǒǡǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚǒǛǝǜǛǜnjǒǩ�njbǘǞǒǛǏ�NjNJǗǔNJ

ƭǚNJǐǎNJǗǏ��ǝǐǏ�ǑNJǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ�ǗNJbǙǘǚǜNJǕǏ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ��ǗǏbǛǜǘǕǔǗǝǜǛǩ�ǛbǛǘbǛǕǘǐǗǘǛǜǩǖǒ�njbǙǚǘǠǏǛǛǏ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ��ƹǚǏǎǛǜNJnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ��ǡǜǘbnjǘǛǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǗǘǛǜǦ�ǎNJǗǗǘǓ�ǝǛǕǝǍǒ�ǛǜNJǗǏǜ�ǛǜǒǖǝǕǘǖ�ǔbǚNJǑǚNJNjǘǜǔǏ�NjǘǕǏǏ�ǎǚǝǐǏǕǨNjǗǘǍǘ�ǒǗǜǏǚǞǏǓǛNJ�ǒbǕǘǍǒǔǒ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕNJ�ǍǘǛǝǛǕǝǍ

��� ƺǏǢǏǗǒǏ�ǚǩǎNJ�ǛnjǩǑNJǗǗǥǟ�ǑNJǎNJǡ��ǗNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ��ǗǏǎǘǙǝǣǏǗǒǏ�NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǍǏǗǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjNJ�LJƻƹ�ǛbǠǏǕǦǨ�ǚNJǑNjǒǏǗǒǩ�ǒbNJǍǚǏǍNJǠǒǒ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǏǓ

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǖǘNjǒǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǜǏǕǏǞǘǗNJ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǙǘǕǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǒǛǔǕǨǡǒǜǦ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǑǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�LJƻƹ�ǝbǘǎǗǘǓ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǘǓ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ƹǘǔǝǙǔNJ�ǒbǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǩ�ǖǗǘǐǏǛǜnjNJ�6Ζ0�ǔNJǚǜ�ǖǘǐǏǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗNJ�ǔNJǔbǨǚǒǎǒǡǏǛǔǒ��ǜNJǔ�ǒbǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǒ��Ǜǖ��ǚNJǑǎǏǕ�Ζ�

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǛbǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏǖ�ǙǕNJǜǏǐǗǘǓ�ǔNJǚǜǥ�ǙǘǑnjǘǕǩǏǜ�ǙǘǕǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǒǛǔǕǨǡǒǜǦ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǦ�NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǑǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǘǓ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǒ�LJƻƹ�ǝbǘǎǗǘǓ�ǔǚǏǎǒǜǗǘǓ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǒ��ƸNjǟǘǎ�ǎNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ��njbǛnjǘǨ�ǘǡǏǚǏǎǦ��ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǒǩ�ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǒǟ�ǙǕNJǜǪǐǗǥǟ�ǔNJǚǜ

ƲǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǩ�ǙǘǛǚǏǎǛǜnjǘǖ�ǘNjǚNJǣǏǗǒǩ�ǔbǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�NjNJǑNJǖ�ǎNJǗǗǥǟ�ǙǘǕǗǘǛǜǦǨ�ǚǏǢNJǏǜ�ǙǚǘNjǕǏǖǝ�NJnjǜǘǖNJǜǒǡǏǛǔǘǓ�ǍǏǗǏǚNJǠǒǒ�LJƻƹ

ƹǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ����ƬǒǎǏǘǗNJNjǕǨǎǏǗǒǏ�ǗNJbnjǥNjǘǚNJǟ�ƹǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ��

��ƶƪƺƼƪ������ƭƸƮƪ�nj�ƺǘǛǛǒǓǛǔǘǓ�ƾǏǎǏǚNJǠǒǒ�ǙǚǘǢǕǒ�ǙǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜǛǔǒǏ�njǥ-Njǘǚǥ��Ƭ�ǎǏǔNJNjǚǏ�����bǍǘǎNJ�ƹǚǏǎǛǏǎNJǜǏǕǦ�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjNJ�ƺƾ�ƬǕNJǎǒǖǒǚ�ƹǝǜǒǗ�ǙǚǏǎǕǘǐǒǕ�ǀǏǗǜǚNJǕǦǗǘǓ�ƲǑNjǒǚNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǓ�ƴǘǖǒǛǛǒǒ�ƺƾ��ǀƲƴ��ǒ�ƶǒǗǒǛǜǏǚǛǜnjǝ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒ�ǖNJǛǛǘnjǥǟ�ǔǘǖǖǝǗǒǔNJǠǒǓ�ƺƾ�ǘNjǏǛǙǏǡǒǜǦ�njǒǎǏǘ-ǗNJNjǕǨǎǏǗǒǏ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒ�ǙǘǎǛǡǪǜNJ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnj�ǒǑNjǒǚNJǜǏǕǏǓ�ǗNJ�njǥNjǘǚNJǟ�ƹǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ�ƺƾ�

ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ�ǙǝǗǔǜǝ����ǡNJǛǜǒ���ǛǜNJǜǦǒ����ƾǏǎǏǚNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǑNJǔǘǗNJ�mƸ�ǚNJǑ-ǖǏǣǏǗǒǒ�ǑNJǔNJǑǘnj�ǗNJ�ǙǘǛǜNJnjǔǒ�ǜǘnjNJǚǘnj��njǥǙǘǕǗǏǗǒǏ�ǚNJNjǘǜ��ǘǔNJǑNJǗǒǏ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�ǎǕǩ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǟ�ǒ�ǖǝǗǒǠǒǙNJǕǦǗǥǟ�Ǘǝǐǎ}�ƹǚNJnjǒǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�ƺƾ�

�� ƷNJ�ǘǛǗǘnjǏ�ǛǜNJǜǦǒ�:LNLSHGLD�UX�mƬǒǎǏǘǗNJNjǕǨǎǏǗǒǏ�ǗNJ�njǥNjǘǚNJǟ�ƹǚǏǑǒǎǏǗǜNJ�ƺǘǛǛǒǒ}�

155ƹƺƲƵƸưƯƷƲƯ����ƬƲƮƯƸƷƪƫƵLjƮƯƷƲƯ�ƷƪbƬDžƫƸƺƪƿ�ƹƺƯƱƲƮƯƷƼƪ�ƺƸƻƻƲƲ

Page 157: User identification analysis

ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǒǕǘ�ƸƪƸbmƺǘǛǜǏǕǏǔǘǖ}�ǏǎǒǗǛǜnjǏǗǗǥǖ�ǙǘǛǜNJnjǣǒǔǘǖ�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜ-ǛǜnjǝǨǣǒǟ�ǝǛǕǝǍ�

ƺNJǗǏǏ� mƺǘǛǜǏǕǏǔǘǖ}� NjǥǕ� njǥNjǚNJǗ� ǀƲƴ� ǗNJ� ǔǘǗǔǝǚǛǗǘǓ� ǘǛǗǘnjǏ� ǎǕǩ�ǛǘǑǎNJǗǒǩ�ǒ� ǘNjǛǕǝǐǒnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒǗǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚǥ� ƭƪƻ� mƬǥNjǘǚǥ}�� ǒ� ǒǖǏǗǗǘ�Ǜ� mƺǘǛǜǏǕǏǔǘǖǘǖ}� ǀƲƴ� ǚǏNJǕǒǑǘnjNJǕ� ǙǒǕǘǜǗǥǏ� ǙǚǘǏǔǜǥ� Ǚǘb ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǔǏ�ǔNJǖǏǚ�ǗNJNjǕǨǎǏǗǒǩ�ǗNJ�ǒǑNjǒǚNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǟ�ǝǡNJǛǜǔNJǟ�ƿƶƪƸ�ǒ�ƺǘǛǜǘnjǛǔǘǓ�ǘNj-ǕNJǛǜǒ�

ƷNJ�ǚǏNJǕǒǑNJǠǒǨ�ǎNJǗǗǘǍǘ�ǙǚǘǏǔǜNJ�NjǥǕǘ�njǥǎǏǕǏǗǘ�ǘǔǘǕǘ����ǖǕǚǎ�ǚǝ-NjǕǏǓ��ƲǑ�Ǘǒǟ����ǖǕǚǎ�ǚǝNjǕǏǓ�njǥǎǏǕǏǗǘ�ǍǘǛǝǎNJǚǛǜnjǘǖ�ǒ�njǥǙǕNJǡǏǗǘ�nj�����bǍǘǎǝ��ǒ�ǏǣǏ���ǖǕǚǎ�ǚǝNjǕǏǓ�njǕǘǐǏǗǘ�ƺǘǛǜǏǕǏǔǘǖǘǖ��ƹǕNJǗǒǚǝǏǜǛǩ��ǡǜǘ�ǧǜǒ�ǑNJǜǚNJǜǥ�ǘǔǝǙǩǜǛǩ�nj�ǜǏǡǏǗǒǏ��Ȃ�bǕǏǜ��ƲǑ�Ǘǒǟ�ǗNJ�ǘNjǘǚǝǎǘnjNJǗǒǏ�NjǥǕǘ�ǙǘǜǚNJǡǏǗǘ���ǖǒǕǕǒNJǚǎǘnj�ǚǝNjǕǏǓ��NJ�ǘǛǜNJǕǦǗǥǏ�ǑNJǜǚNJǜǥ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǕǩ-Ǩǜ�ǕǒǗǒǒ�ǛnjǩǑǒ�ǒ�ǒǗǞǚNJǛǜǚǝǔǜǝǚNJ�

ƻǘǍǕNJǛǗǘ� ǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǘǖǝ� ǑNJǎNJǗǒǨ�� ǔǘǜǘǚǘǏ� ǘǙǚǏǎǏǕǒǕ� ǀƲƴ�� ǛǒǛǜǏ-ǖǘǓ�njǒǎǏǘǖǘǗǒǜǘǚǒǗǍNJ�NjǥǕǘ�ǘǟnjNJǡǏǗǘ��������ǝǡNJǛǜǔǘnjǥǟ�ǒǑNjǒǚNJǜǏǕǦ-Ǘǥǟ�ǔǘǖǒǛǛǒǓ��ƷNJ�ǔNJǐǎǘǖ�ǒǑNjǒǚNJǜǏǕǦǗǘǖ�ǝǡNJǛǜǔǏ�NjǥǕǘ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǘ�Ǚǘb ǎnjǏ� ǔNJǖǏǚǥ�� ƸǎǗNJ� ǙǏǚǏǎNJnjNJǕNJ� ǘNjǣǒǓ� ǙǕNJǗ�� njǜǘǚNJǩbȃ� ǗǏǙǘǛǚǏǎ-ǛǜnjǏǗǗǘ�ǝǚǗǝ�ǎǕǩ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjNJǗǒǩ�

ƼNJǔǒǖ�ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ��NjǥǕǘ�ǝǛǜNJǗǘnjǕǏǗǘ���������ǔNJǖǏǚ��ƱNJǙǒǛǦ�njǒǎǏǘ�njǏ-ǕNJǛǦ�Ǜ�ǚNJǑǚǏǢǏǗǒǏǖ����������NJ�ǜǚNJǗǛǕǩǠǒǩ�ǗNJ�ǛNJǓǜǏbȃ����������ƮǏǕNJ-ǕǘǛǦ�ǧǜǘ�ǎǕǩ�ǜǘǍǘ��ǡǜǘNjǥ�ǝǖǏǗǦǢǒǜǦ�ǗNJǍǚǝǑǔǝ�ǗNJ�ǕǒǗǒǒ�ǛnjǩǑǒ��ƸNjǛǕǝ-ǐǒnjNJǕǒ�ǎNJǗǗǝǨ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǝ���ǎNJǜNJ�ǠǏǗǜǚǘnj����ǖNJǚǜNJ�nj�ǛǘnjǘǔǝǙǗǘǛǜǒ�NjǥǕǘ�ǑNJǙǒǛNJǗǘ����bǕǏǜ�njǒǎǏǘ��ǔǘǜǘǚǘǏ�ǑNJǗǩǕǘ����ƹǏǜNJNjNJǓǜNJ���� �����ƼǏǚNJ-NjNJǓǜNJ� ��� ���� �����ƭǒǍNJNjNJǓǜNJ��

Ƭ�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǘǙǏǚNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǓ�ǛǒǛǜǏǖǥ�ǎǕǩ�ǗNJǛǜǘǕǦǗǥǟ�ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǘnj�ǒ�ǗǘǝǜNjǝǔǘnj�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǕǛǩ�/LQX[�ǎǒǛǜǚǒNjǝǜǒnj�ǗNJ�NjNJǑǏ�'HELDQ�

ƹǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�ǎǕǩ�ǙǚǘǛǖǘǜǚNJ�ǙǚǩǖǘǓ�ǜǚNJǗǛǕǩǠǒǒ�ǛbnjǥNjǘǚǘnj�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜƸƫǃƯƻƼƬƯƷƷDžƳ� ƮƸƻƼƽƹ� ƮƵlj� ƷƪƫƵLjƮƯƷƲlj� ǑNJ� njǥNjǘǚNJǖǒ�ǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǕǩǕǛǩ�ǗNJ�ǛNJǓǜǏ�ƬǏNj�njǥNjǘǚǥ�������ƮǕǩ�ǙǚǘǛǖǘǜǚNJ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǒ�Ǚǘǎ-ǛǡǪǜNJ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnj�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘǓ�ǩnjǕǩǕNJǛǦ�ǙǚǘǠǏǎǝǚNJ�NJǝǜǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�Ǚǚǒ�Ǚǘǖǘǣǒ�ǙǘǙǝǕǩǚǗǥǟ�ǛǘǠǒNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǛǏǜǏǓ��ǙǘǒǛǔǘnjǥǟ�ǒǕǒ�Ǚǘǡǜǘnjǥǟ�ǚǏ-ǛǝǚǛǘnj�ǕǒNjǘ�ǗǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�NjǥǕǘ�ǝǔNJǑNJǜǦ�ǕǨNjǘǓ�ǛnjǘǓ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǓ�NJǎǚǏǛ�ǒ�ǙǘǎǜnjǏǚǎǒǜǦ�ǚǏǍǒǛǜǚNJǠǒǨ�ǙǘbǛǛǥǕǔǏ�nj�ǙǘǕǝǡǏǗǗǘǖ�ǙǒǛǦǖǏ�

ƱNJǚǏǍǒǛǜǚǒǚǘnjNJǗǗǥǏ�ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǒ�ǙǘǚǜNJǕNJ�ǖǘǍǕǒ�njǥNjǒǚNJǜǦ�ǜǏ�ǒǑ-NjǒǚNJǜǏǕǦǗǥǏ� ǝǡNJǛǜǔǒ�� ǜǚNJǗǛǕǩǠǒǒ� Ǜ� ǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ� ǘǗǒ� ǟǘǜǏǕǒ� ǙǘǕǝǡNJǜǦ� nj�ǎǏǗǦ�ǍǘǕǘǛǘnjNJǗǒǩ�

156 ƹƺƲƵƸưƯƷƲlj

Page 158: User identification analysis

ƹǚǒǕǘǐǏǗǒǏ����ƹǘǕǒǜǒǔǒ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗǒǩ�ǔǘǚǙǘǚNJǜǒnjǗǥǟ�NJǎǚǏǛǘnj�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�

Ζ7�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǓ��

ƷƪƲƫƸƵƯƯ� ƺƪƻƹƺƸƻƼƺƪƷƜƷƷDžƶ� ǂƪƫƵƸƷƸƶ� ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗǒǩ� NJǎǚǏǛǘnj� ǔǘǚǙǘǚNJ-ǜǒnjǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǡǜǥ�ǩnjǕǩǏǜǛǩ�>ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǒǖǏǗǒ���ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ@��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�ǚNJǑ-ǗǥǏ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ��njǘ�ǙǏǚnjǥǟ��ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǎǘǙǝǛǔNJǜǦ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǏ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǥ�ǗNJ-ǚǩǎǝ�Ǜ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǘǖ�ǙǘbǝǖǘǕǡNJǗǒǨ��NJ�njǘ�njǜǘǚǥǟ��ǖǘǍǝǜ�nj�ǙǚǒǗǠǒǙǏ�ǗǏ�ǒǖǏǜǦ�ǘǛǘNjǥǟ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǓ��ƻǚǏǎǒ�ǝǗǒnjǏǚǛNJǕǦǗǥǟ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǘǜǖǏ-ǜǒǜǦ�ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǝǗǒǔNJǕǦǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǖǏǗǗǘǓ�ǡNJǛǜǒ�NJǎǚǏǛNJ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�ǧǜǘ�ǜǚǏNjǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǛǔǘǚǏǏ�ǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǘǏ��ǡǏǖ�ǘǚǍNJǗǒǑNJǠǒǘǗǗǘǏ�

ƷǏǘNjǟǘǎǒǖǘ�ǜNJǔǐǏ�ǘǜǖǏǜǒǜǦ��ǡǜǘ�njnjǒǎǝ�ǧnjǘǕǨǠǒǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǒǑǖǏǗǏǗǒǩ�ǙǘǕǒǜǒǔ�nj�ǗǏǔǘǜǘǚǥǟ�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǩǟ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�ǛǘǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǘnjNJǜǦ�mǛǜNJǚǥǏ}�ǒ�mǗǘ-njǥǏ}�NJǎǚǏǛNJ��ǡǜǘ�ǛǗǒǐNJǏǜ�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǘǛǜǒ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǩ�ǜNJǔǒǟ�NJǎǚǏǛǘnj�nj�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�njǗǏǢǗǒǟ�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǜǘǚǘnj�

*RRJOHƬ� ƴƸƶƹƪƷƲƲ�*22*/(� ǘǛǘNjǏǗǗǥǏ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕNJ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗǒǩ�NJǎǚǏǛǘnj�ǗǏ�Ǟǘǚ-ǖNJǕǒǑǘnjNJǗǥ��ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�ǡNJǣǏ�ǎǚǝǍǒǟ�ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔNJǖ�ǙǚǏǎǕNJǍNJǨǜǛǩ�njNJǚǒNJǗǜǥ�>ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǒǖǏǗǒ���ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ@�ǒǕǒ� >ǒǖǩ���ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǒ@��ƸNjǚNJǣNJǏǜ�ǗNJ�ǛǏNjǩ�njǗǒǖNJǗǒǏ�ǎǘǙǝǣǏǗǒǏ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǦ�ǎǘǖǏǗǗǝǨ�ǡNJǛǜǦ�nj�njǒǎǏ�JRRJOH�FRP��ƷNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ�

• QJDOLFK#JRRJOH�FRP���ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǒ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�• QDGH]KGD#JRRJOH�FRP���ǒǖǩ�• HSLIDQRY#JRRJOH�FRP���ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�• DOODVK#JRRJOH�FRP���ǒǖǩ�ǒ�ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǒ�

0LFURVRIWƴƸƶƹƪƷƲlj�ƼƺƯƫƽƯƼ�ǗNJǕǒǡǒǩ�nj�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǕǨNjǘǍǘ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjNJ�Njǝǔnj��ǘǜǕǒǡǗǘǍǘ�ǘǜ�ǗǝǕǩ���ǔNJǔ�ǒǖǏǗǒ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǒ�ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔNJ�nj�ǕǨNjǘǓ�ǔǘǖNjǒǗNJǠǒǒ��Ǘǘ�nj�ǠǏǕǘǖ�ǗǏ�ǖǏǗǏǏ���ǒ�ǗǏ�NjǘǕǏǏ���ǛǒǖnjǘǕǘnj��ǟǘǜǩ�ǛǚǏǎǒ�NJǎǚǏǛǘnj�ǖǘǍǝǜ�njǛǜǚǏǡNJǜǦǛǩ�ǒ�mǝǛǜNJǚǏnjǢǒǏ}�ǗNJǡǏǚǜNJǗǒǩ�nj�ǛǘǘǜnjǏǜǛǜnjǒǒ�Ǜ�NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǘǖ�>ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǒǖǏǗǒ���ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ@�

• RX]KDV#PLFURVRIW�FRP���ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǒ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�

�� ƬǛǏ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǥǏ�NJǎǚǏǛNJ�ǩnjǕǩǨǜǛǩ�njǥǖǥǢǕǏǗǗǥǖǒ��ƵǨNjǥǏ�ǛǘnjǙNJǎǏǗǒǩ�ǛǕǝǡNJǓǗǥ�

157ƹƺƲƵƸưƯƷƲƯ����ƹƸƵƲƼƲƴƲ�ƹƺƲƻƬƸƯƷƲlj�ƴƸƺƹƸƺƪƼƲƬƷDžƿ�ƪƮƺƯƻƸƬ�ƷƯƴƸƼƸƺDžƿ�Ζ7�ƴƸƶƹƪƷƲƳ

Page 159: User identification analysis

• HOHQD]#PLFURVRIW�FRP���ǒǖǩ�ǒ�ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǒ�• NDWHULQG#PLFURVRIW�FRP���ǝǛǏǡǏǗǗǘǏ�ǒǖǩ�ǒ�ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǒ�

<DQGH[ƴƸƶƹƪƷƲlj� ljƷƮƯƴƻ� ǗǏ� ǗNJǔǕNJǎǥnjNJǏǜ� ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǒǓ� ǗNJ� ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔǘnj� Ǚǚǒ�njǥNjǘǚǏ� ǒǖǏǗǒ� ǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǜǏǕǩ�� ǑNJ� ǒǛǔǕǨǡǏǗǒǏǖ� ǘǎǗǘǍǘ� ǝǛǕǘnjǒǩ�� ǒǖǩ�ǗǏ� ǎǘǕǐǗǘ� NjǥǜǦ� ǔǘǚǘǡǏ� �� ǛǒǖnjǘǕǘnj�� ƼNJǔǒǖ� ǘNjǚNJǑǘǖ�� nj� ǎǘǖǏǗǏ� \DQ-GH[�WHDP�UX�njǘǑǖǘǐǗǥ�ǜNJǔǒǏ�NJǎǚǏǛNJ��ǔNJǔ

• OL]DYHWD#\DQGH[�WHDP�UX���ǒǖǩ��ǗǏǙǘǕǗǘǏ��• PDULQD�LYDQRYD#\DQGH[�WHDP�UX���ǒǖǩ�ǒ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǚNJǑǎǏǕǒ-

ǜǏǕǦbȃ�ǎǏǞǒǛ�• DNRUNXPRYD#\DQGH[�WHDP�UX���ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǒ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�• WPRQ#\DQGH[�WHDP�UX���ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǒ�ǙǏǚnjǥǏ�ǜǚǒ�Njǝǔnjǥ�

ǞNJǖǒǕǒǒ�

&LVFRƪƵƭƸƺƲƼƶ� LJƼƸƳ� ƴƸƶƹƪƷƲƲ� NJǗNJǕǘǍǒǡǏǗ� NJǕǍǘǚǒǜǖǝ� 0LFURVRIW� �ǗǏ� NjǘǕǏǏ��bǛǒǖnjǘǕǘnj��ǗNJǕǒǡǒǏ�Njǝǔnj�ǔNJǔ�ǒǖǏǗǒ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǒ���ǙǘbǝǖǘǕǡNJǗǒǨ�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǩ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗ�>ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǒ�ǗǏ�NjǘǕǏǏ���ǙǏǚnjǥǟ�Njǝǔnj�ǞNJ-ǖǒǕǒǒ@�

• LUXNDWVN#FLVFR�FRP���ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǒ�ǝǛǏǡǏǗǗNJǩ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�• RQDU\VKN#FLVFR�FRP���ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǒ�ǝǛǏǡǏǗǗNJǩ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�• PDWWJUD#FLVFR�FRP���ǔǘǚǘǜǔNJǩ�njǏǚǛǒǩ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǒ�ǝǛǏǡǏǗǗNJǩ�ǞNJǖǒ-

Ǖǒǩ�

ƬƴǘǗǜNJǔǜǏƴƸƶƹƪƷƲlj�ƬƴƸƷƼƪƴƼƯ�ǙǘǢǕNJ�ǏǣǏ�ǎNJǕǦǢǏ��ǡǏǖ�ljǗǎǏǔǛ��ǒ�ǗǏ�ǜǚǏNjǝǏǜ�ǎNJǐǏ�ǖǒǗǒǖNJǕǦǗǘǍǘ�ǔǘǕǒǡǏǛǜnjNJ�ǛǒǖnjǘǕǘnj�nj�ǒǖǏǗǒ�

• LYDQRY#FRUS�YN�FRP���ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�• QFKD#FRUS�YN�FRP� �� ǙǏǚnjNJǩ� NjǝǔnjNJ� ǒǖǏǗǒ� ǒ� ǗǏǛǔǘǕǦǔǘ� ǙǏǚnjǥǟ�

Njǝǔnj�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǒ�• OW#FRUS�YN�FRP���ǙǏǚnjǥǏ�Njǝǔnjǥ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǒ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǒ�

0DLO�UXƬ� LJƼƸƳ� ƴƸƶƹƪƷƲƲ� ǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǝǏǜ�ǏǎǒǗǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǏ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕǘ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗǒǩ�ǒǖǏ-Ǘǒbȃ�nj�ǗǏǖ�ǎǘǕǐǗǘ�ǙǚǒǛǝǜǛǜnjǘnjNJǜǦ�ǗNJǙǒǛNJǗǒǏ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǒ�ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔNJ�ǕNJ-ǜǒǗǒǠǏǓ��ƲǛǙǘǕǦǑǘnjNJǗǒǏ�ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔNJǖǒ�ǎǘǖǏǗǗǘǓ�ǡNJǛǜǒ�nj�njǒǎǏ�PDLO�UX�ǗǏ�ǎǘǙǝǛǔNJǏǜǛǩ��ƷNJǙǚǒǖǏǚ�

158 ƹƺƲƵƸưƯƷƲlj

Page 160: User identification analysis

• DUJXQRY#FRUS�PDLO�UX���ǜǘǕǦǔǘ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�• G�NDORVKLQ#FRUS�PDLO�UX� �� ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǒ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�

ǚNJǑǎǏǕǒǜǏǕǦbȃ�ǜǘǡǔǝ�

)DFHERRNƬ�ƴƸƶƹƪƷƲƲ�ƹƸ�ƽƶƸƵǁƪƷƲLj�ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǜǛǩ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗ�>ǒǖǩ���ǜǘǡǔNJ���ǞNJǖǒ-Ǖǒǩ@�� ǘǎǗNJǔǘ�ǚǝǔǘnjǘǎǒǜǏǕǒ�njǥǛǢǏǍǘ� ǑnjǏǗNJ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�Ǚǚǒ�ǐǏǕNJǗǒǒ�Ǚǘǎǘ-NjǚNJǜǦ�ǛǏNjǏ�NJǕǦǜǏǚǗNJǜǒnjǗǘǏ�ǒǖǩ�ǎǕǩ�ǧǕǏǔǜǚǘǗǗǘǍǘ�ǩǣǒǔNJ�

• PDULQD�SXVWRYR\WRYD#IE�FRP���ǒǖǩ�ǒ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�ǡǏǚǏǑ�ǜǘǡǔǝ�• PDUN#IE�FRP���ǒǖǩ�ƻǚǏǎǒ�ǛNJǖǥǟ�ǚNJǛǙǚǘǛǜǚNJǗǏǗǗǥǟ�ǢNJNjǕǘǗǘnj��ǒǛǙǘǕǦǑǝǏǖǥǟ�Ǚǚǒ�njǥ-

NjǘǚǏ�ǒǖǏǗǒ�ǔǘǚǙǘǚNJǜǒnjǗǘǓ�Ǚǘǡǜǥ��ǔNJǔ�nj�ǔNJǡǏǛǜnjǏ�ǐ?Ǜǜǔǒǟ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕ��ǜNJǔ�ǒ�ǗǏǐ?Ǜǜǔǒǟ�ǖǗǏǖǘǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ���ǛǕǏǎǝǨǣǒǏ��ǛǙǒǛǘǔ�ǗǏǙǘǕǗǥǓ��

• ǒǖǩ���ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�• ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǒǖǏǗǒ���ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�• ǒǖǩ���ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǒ�• ǞNJǖǒǕǒǩ�• ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǒǖǏǗǒ���ǙǏǚnjNJǩ�NjǝǔnjNJ�ǞNJǖǒǕǒǒ�• ǒǗǒǠǒNJǕǥ�Ƭ�ǜǏǟbǐǏ�ǔǘǖNjǒǗNJǠǒǩǟ�ǚNJǑǎǏǕǒǜǏǕǩǖǒ�ǛǘǛǜNJnjǗǥǟ�ǡNJǛǜǏǓ�ǒǖǏǗǗǘǓ�

ǡNJǛǜǒ�NJǎǚǏǛNJ�ǖǘǍǝǜ�NjǥǜǦ�ǜǘǡǔNJ�ǒǕǒ�ǎǏǞǒǛ�Ƭ�ǠǏǕǘǖ�ǖǘǐǗǘ�ǛǎǏǕNJǜǦ�njǥnjǘǎ�ǘ�ǜǘǖ��ǡǜǘ�ǔǚǝǙǗǥǏ�Ζ7�ǔǘǖǙNJǗǒǒ�ǎǘ-

njǘǕǦǗǘ�ǕǒNjǏǚNJǕǦǗǘ�Ǚǘǎǟǘǎǩǜ�ǔ�njǘǙǚǘǛǝ�ǘ�ǙǚǒǛnjǘǏǗǒǒ�ǔǘǚǙǘǚNJǜǒnjǗǘǍǘ�NJǎǚǏǛNJ�ǛǘǜǚǝǎǗǒǔǝ��ǗNJǔǕNJǎǥnjNJǩ�� ǔNJǔ�ǙǚNJnjǒǕǘ��ǘǎǗǘ�ǎnjNJ�ǗǏǛǝǣǏǛǜnjǏǗ-Ǘǥǟ�ǜǏǟǗǒǡǏǛǔǒǟ�ǘǍǚNJǗǒǡǏǗǒǩ�

159

Page 161: User identification analysis

ƷNJǝǡǗǘǏ�ǒǑǎNJǗǒǏ

ƵǏnjǘnjNJ�ƲǚǒǗNJ�LjǚǦǏnjǗNJ��ǂǝǔǕǒǗ�ƭǕǏNj�ƷǒǔǘǕNJǏnjǒǡ���ƴNJǑNJǚǦǩǗ�ƴNJǚǏǗ�ƺNJǑǖǒǔǘnjǒǡ�ǒ�ǎǚ�

ƺǏǎNJǔǜǘǚɊƭ�ɌƷ�ɊǂǝǔǕǒǗƴǘǚǚǏǔǜǘǚɊƷ�Ɍƻ�ɊƶNJǓǘǚǘnjNJ

ƿǝǎǘǐǏǛǜnjǏǗǗǘǏ�ǘǞǘǚǖǕǏǗǒǏ��ǔǘǖǙǦǨǜǏǚǗNJǩ�njǏǚǛǜǔNJ��ƪ�Ɍƹ�ɊƹǝǜǒǕǘnj

ƹǘǎǙǒǛNJǗǘ�nj�ǙǏǡNJǜǦ�������������ƫǝǖ��ǘǞǛǏǜǗNJǩ��ƾǘǚǖNJǜ��������/���ƭNJǚǗǒǜǝǚNJ�2SHQ�6DQV��ƹǏǡNJǜǦ�ǘǞǛǏǜǗNJǩ��ƽǛǕ��ǙǏǡ��Ǖ������ƼǒǚNJǐ�����ǧǔǑ�

ƱNJǔNJǑ�ȟ���ƹ

ƸǜǙǏǡNJǜNJǗǘ�ƸƸƸ�mƲǑǎNJǜǏǕǦǛǜnjǘ�mƹǚǘǛǙǏǔǜ}��������Ǎ��ƶǘǛǔnjNJ��Ǚǚ�ǜ�ƬǏǚǗNJǎǛǔǘǍǘ����

ƪǗNJǕǒǑ�ǚNJǑǕǒǡǗǥǟ�NJǛǙǏǔǜǘnj�ǒǎǏǗǜǒǞǒǔNJǠǒǒ�nj�ǒǗǜǏǚǗǏǜǏ�ǒbǚǏǔǘǖǏǗǎNJǠǒǒ�ǙǘbǚǏǍǝǕǒǚǘnjNJǗǒǨ