Upload
linda-austin
View
74
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Chapter 6
4 Classic Theories Of Ethics
By
Fli
ckr
use
r V
Cal
sidyr
ose
Decision-making tools
4 classic
theories of ethics that can help you make moral decisions in journalism.
By Flickr user AJ Cann
The 4 Theories
1. Rule-based thinking.
2. Ends-based thinking.
3. The Golden Rule.
4. Aristotle’s Golden
Mean.
1. Rule-based Thinking
• Follow the rule, no matter what the consequences. “Let the chips fall where they may.”
• Strength: Simple
• Weakness: Rigid. A journalist with an ethical dilemma would be paralyzed by indecision
• Also called: deontology from the Greek (deon) for duty, or
duty-based thinking
By P
ette
r D
uvan
der
1. Rule-based Thinking
• Examples:
• Would never quote an anonymous source.
• Would name a rape victim
• Would name a child charged with a crime
• Would include all the mistakes committed by the dead person in that person’s obituary
By P
ette
r D
uvan
der
2. Ends-based thinking
• Seek the greatest good for the greatest number. “Ends can justify the means.”
• Strength: Flexibility
• Weaknesses: Flexibility: decision may be self-serving instead of morally correct; and consequences sometimes hard to predict.
• Also called:
• teleology from the Greek (telos) for end, or
• consequentialism, or
• utilitarianism
By P
hil
Wh
iteh
ou
se
2. Ends-based thinking
• Examples:
• Would pretend to be someone he or she is not if it were the only way to get an important story
• Would leave out harmful facts from a person’s obituary if they are irrelevant to the story’s main point. Would inflict only the harm necessary to put the story in perspective.
By P
hil
Wh
iteh
ou
se
Rule-based or ends-based?
Did Robin Hood use rule-based or ends-based thinking?
3. The Golden Rule
• Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. Put yourself in the place of the person affected by the decision. Found in all the world’s major religions.
• Strength: Easy to understand and apply. Based on love, not self-interest.
• Weakness: Cannot tell a journalist how to decide among competing stakeholders
• Also called:
• Rule of reversibility
By W
ait
ing F
or
Th
e W
ord
3. The Golden Rule
• Examples:
• Would not write a story subjecting people to ridicule because the reporter does not want to be ridiculed.
• Would not secretly record a source because the reporter would not want to be secretly recorded.
By W
ait
ing F
or
Th
e W
ord
4. Aristotle’s Golden Mean
• Avoids extremes to find a moderate solution.
• Strength: May lead you to an ethical resolution of an impasse.
• Weaknesses: Not every situation offers a golden mean.
• Examples:
• Warning audience members about a graphic photo
• Taxing tobacco, banning advertising and sales to children of tobacco, requiring warnings on tobacco B
y I
mage
Ed
itor
Aristotle, Greek philosopher,
lived 385-322 B.C.
Blending Two Theories
Journalists can benefit from:
• The stability of newsroom policies and ethics codes (rule-based thinking) …
• While sensing when the circumstances might dictate a different solution (ends-based thinking).
By P
ette
r D
uvan
der
By Phil Whitehouse
When to break the rules
• Don’t decide on a whim to deviate from policy.
• Analyze carefully to identify the reasons for a different course.
• Consult with your supervisor.
In 1971, did The New York Times use rule-based or ends-
based thinking in deciding to publish the Pentagon Papers?
Rule-based or ends-based?
Question
In 1971, what would The New York Times have done if it used
rule-based thinking in the Pentagon Papers case?
Rule-based or ends-based?
In 2010, did The New York Times use rule-based or ends-
based thinking in deciding to publish the previously secret
cables released by Julian Assange of Wikileaks?
Question
In 2010, what would The New York Times have done if it had
used rule-based thinking in deciding whether to publish the
previously secret cables released by Julian Assange of
Wikileaks?