34
A fresh look at marine magnetic anomalies, one of e key datasets in the development of plate tectonic Ian Norton, Larry Lawver, Lisa Gahagan Institute for Geophysics University of Texas at Austin From Vine and Matthews, 1963: culated with reversals Observed Calculated with constant magnetization Carlsberg Rid ge Sandwell gravity

A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

A fresh look at marine magnetic anomalies, one ofthe key datasets in the development of plate tectonics.

Ian Norton, Larry Lawver, Lisa GahaganInstitute for Geophysics

University of Texas at Austin

From Vine and Matthews, 1963:

Calculated with reversals Observed

Calculated with constant magnetization Carlsberg Ridge

Sandwell gravity

Page 2: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

The EDSAC-2 computer used by Vine & Matthews http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EDSAC_2

EDSAC = Electronic Delay Storage Automatic Calculator

Page 3: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

PLATES Database

• Plate model• Database: oceanic magnetic and tectonic (plate boundaries, paleomagnetic, hot spots, geological and geophysical data to extend the span and accuracy of global plate reconstructions)• This talk: a look at magnetic anomalies.

Crust Code

Page 4: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Green – Cande & Stock, 2004Black – Granot et al., 2013

Data from Global Magnetics Database http://www.soest.hawaii.edu/PT/GSFML/ML/index.html

Database run by Paul Wessel (Hawaii) & Dietmar Müller (Sydney)

Australia

Antarctica

-60

-50

-40

100 140

Page 5: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

115˚E 120˚E

60˚S

Mismatches 5-6 km to as much as 35 km• Great dataset, needs work to use

Green – Cande & Stock, 2004Black – Granot et al., 2013

Data from Global Magnetics Database http://www.soest.hawaii.edu/PT/GSFML/ML/index.html

Page 6: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Example magnetic profile from Mascarene Basin

Base: Sandwell free air gravity 23.1

Page 7: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Base: Sandwell vertical gravity gradient 23.1

Example magnetic profile from Mascarene Basin• VGG emphasizes fracture zones and extinct ridges

Page 8: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

ModMag model of Mascarene Basin profile• Really good match between synthetic and observed• Easy to map details of age interpretation

ModMag: Matlab program by Mendel, Munschy & Sauter, 2005. This profile is from example data files that are included with download.

Computers & Geosciences, Volume 31, Issue 5, June 2005, Pages 589–597

Young end at max +ve, old end at max -ve

Page 9: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

ModMag GUI

Page 10: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Entry in magnetic anomaly database

Base: Sandwell free air gravity 23.1

Page 11: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

M-anomalies in the Mozambique Basin

Data from König and Jokat, 2010

Page 12: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

M-anomalies in the Mozambique Basin

Data from König and Jokat, 2010

Line 11

Page 13: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Line SO183-11 from Mozambique Basin• Good match over parts of profile• Need multiple lines for regional identifications• Mapping of young-old edges of anomalies not quite so accurate

Data from König and Jokat, 2010

Young end close to max –ve, old end close to max +ve

Page 14: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Greenland motion: Plates project database

Page 15: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Overlap between Greenland and Barents – Svalbard margin

Overlap

Page 16: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Overlap between Greenland and Barents – Svalbard margin

Next slide

Page 17: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Overlap between Greenland and Barents – Svalbard margin

120-130 km

Page 18: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Point path visualization, Greenland relative to Europe

Gaina et al. (2009) poles 100 km

Page 19: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

The Svalbard Margin – Paleocene-Eocene foldbelt followed by some rifting (age?)

Leever et al. 2011 after Bergh et al., 1997 and Braathen et al. 1999FG = Forlandsundet Graben

Leever et al. 2011 after Faleide et al. 2008

Page 20: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

G

E

Stylized present-day

G

E

Stylized 33 Ma(e.g. Engen et al. 2008)

GE

Stylized Oligocene(overlap to account for transtension)

G

E

Stylized Paleocene(gap to account for transpression)

Reconstructions should show (in sequence) transpression to transtension to oblique divergence with spreading

Present-day

47 Ma

Should show a gap at 47 Ma, not overlap

Page 21: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

120-130 km overlap

47 Ma reconstruction

Europe fixed, Gaina et al. 2009 poles

Page 22: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

47 Ma reconstruction – can Greenland be shifted to avoid overlap with Svalbard?• Check magnetic lineation identifications in Labrador Sea

Page 23: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Greenland

Canada

Labrador Sea magnetic data

Data from http://gdr.agg.nrcan.gc.ca/gdrdap/dap/index-eng.php?dapid=8127

Page 24: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Canada

Labrador Sea magnetic data – modeled profile

Data from http://gdr.agg.nrcan.gc.ca/gdrdap/dap/index-eng.php?dapid=8127

Greenland

Page 25: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Canada

Labrador Sea Vertical Gravity Gradient – shows extinct ridge

Sandwell 2014

Greenland

Page 26: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Extract topography/bathymetry

Sandwell topography

Page 27: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Extract sediment fill

http://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/mgg/sedthick/index.html

Page 28: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Get basement depth

km

Meters

Extinct ridge

Page 29: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

ModMag model• This version provides a reasonable match

Page 30: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

This is the currently accepted interpretation• These essentially sinusoidal anomalies are hard to identify with certainty, need

regional context to settle on interpretation

This area not modeled

Page 31: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

Magnetic anomalies around N Atlantic triple junction

Maus et al. 2008 magnetics

Page 32: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

120-130 km overlap

47 Ma reconstruction

Europe fixed, Gaina et al. 2009 poles

Page 33: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

47 Ma reconstruction – can Greenland be shifted to avoid overlap with Svalbard?• Labrador Sea identifications not definitive• Triple junction provides strong constraint – can’t move Greenland• How to fix the overlap? Hopefully PhD student Bereke Karainov at UiS can figure it out!

Triple junction

Page 34: A Fresh Look at Marine Magnetic Anomalies, One of the Key Datasets in the Development of Plate Tectonics by Ian Norton - 2014 PaleoGIS & PaleoClimate Users Conference

It’s all in the stripes…