9
"#$%& '()&*+ " #$%$ &'((')* +) %,- ./0,$)1- 23$0- 45-1 6+778 9':)7-5 $)7 &.; 6$5-) 4+<<'578 =5-*+7-)% ,&)%&-.&* /01 23/3

A Data Commons in the Exchange Space

  • Upload
    3taps

  • View
    146

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

 

Citation preview

Page 1: A Data Commons in the Exchange Space

!!

!!

!!"#$%&!'()&*+!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"!#$%$!&'((')*!+)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!%,-!./0,$)1-!23$0-!

!!

!!!!!!

45-1!6+778!9':)7-5!$)7!&.;!

6$5-)!4+<<'578!=5-*+7-)%!!

!!

!!

!

,&)%&-.&*!/01!23/3!

!!

Page 2: A Data Commons in the Exchange Space

/!

"!#$%$!&'((')*!+)!%,-!./0,$)1-!23$0-!!

4#&!%&*-!56(%(!78--89:;!*&<&*:!%8!(!=>8?@!8<!@(%(!(A($>(.>&!<8*!:B9@$=(%$89C!!D9!%#$:!)()&*1!E&!

@$:=?::!:8-&!8<!%#&!$::?&:!:?**8?9@$9F!%#&!&:%(.>$:#-&9%!8<!(!6(%(!78--89:!<8*!@(%(!*&>(%&@!

:)&=$<$=(>>B!%8!%#&!&G=#(9F&!8<!F88@:1!:&*A$=&:!(9@!$9<8*-(%$89H$9=>?@$9F!=8--&*=&I*&>(%&@!

@(%(C!!!

!

"#&*&!%#&*&!(*&!-(9B!=89%&9%!:8?*=&:!(9@!-(9B!=89%&9%!?:&*:1!(:!$9!%#&!&G=#(9F&!:)(=&1!(!

=>&(*$9F!:B:%&-!%#(%!E$>>!98*-(>$J&!(9@!$9@&G!(>>!=89%&9%!E$>>!#&>)!=89:?-&*:!(9@!@(%(!?:&*:!

-8*&!&<<$=$&9%>B!%#(9!%#&!@$:=*&%&1!.$>(%&*(>!%*(9:<&*:!8<!&G=#(9F&I*&>(%&@!@(%(!.&%E&&9!%E8!

)(*%$&:!%#(%!&G$:%!%8@(BC!!!"&!&9A$:$89!%#&!6(%(!78--89:!(:!(!=8>>(.8*(%$A&!&<<8*%!.&%E&&9!(!

9?-.&*!8<!<8*I)*8<$%!(9@!989I)*8<$%!(=%8*:C!

!

>?! @,A!"!#$%$!&'((')*B!!

='%-)%+$C!.<<+0+-)0+-*!'<!$!#$%$!&'((')*!!

48!&9A$:$89!%#&!)8%&9%$(>!A(>?&!8<!(!6(%(!78--89:1!%#&!)(B-&9%!:B:%&-!8)&*(%$9F!$9!%#&!K9$%&@!

,%(%&:!)*8A$@&:!(!?:&<?>!(9(>8FBC!!D9!%#&8*B1!.(9L:!=8?>@!=>&(*!=#&=L:!(9@!&>&=%*89$=!)(B-&9%:!

.&%E&&9!89&!(98%#&*C!M&=(?:&!%#&*&!(*&!/31333N!.(9L:!$9!%#&!KC,C1!@$*&=%!.$>(%&*(>!%*(9:<&*:!

=8?>@!*&:?>%!$9!/31333!G!/31333!O/33!-$>>$89P!)8$9%:!8<!=899&=%$89!%8!(=#$&A&!:&%%>&-&9%!8<!(>>!

8.>$F(%$89:C!!4#$:!?9E$&>@B!:$%?(%$89!$:!)*&=$:&>B!E#(%!&G$:%:!E$%#!*&:)&=%!%8!&G=#(9F&I*&>(%&@!

@(%(!89!%#&!D9%&*9&%C!!Q8:%!8<!E#(%!E&!=(>>!!"#$%&'#(%*(9:(=%$89I:)&=$<$=!$9<8*-(%$89!(.8?%!

$9@$A$@?(>!$%&-:!8<<&*&@!<8*!&G=#(9F&1!:?=#!(:!(!E(%=#!<8*!:(>&!8*!(!R8.!8<<&*$9FH(*&!<8?9@!89>B!

.B!(!:&(*=#!89!%#&!$9@$A$@?(>!E&.:$%&:!E#&*&!%#&B!>$A&C!!48!@8!(!=8-)*&#&9:$A&!:&(*=#!<8*!(!

)(*%$=?>(*!$%&-!89&!-$F#%!E$:#!%8!.?B!89&!-?:%!A$:$%!9?-&*8?:!:&)(*(%&!:$%&:C!!

!

4#&!K9$%&@!,%(%&:!.(9L$9F!$9@?:%*B!#(:!&A8>A&@!(!-?=#!-8*&!&<<$=$&9%!:B:%&-C!D9:%&(@!8<!

*&S?$*$9F!&(=#!.(9L!%8!=89%(=%!@$*&=%>B!(>>!8%#&*!.(9L:!E$%#!E#$=#!$%!#(:!:&%%>&-&9%!%*(9:(=%$89:1!

%#&!T&@&*(>!U&:&*A&!8)&*(%&:!(!=>&(*$9F!(9@!:&%%>&-&9%!:B:%&-1!%(L$9F!$9.8?9@!.?>L!)(B-&9%:!

(9@!-(L$9F!8?%.8?9@!.?>L!)(B-&9%:!<*8-V%8!&(=#!.(9LC!!4#$:!(**(9F&-&9%!*&:?>%:!$9!/31333!G!2!

O231333P!)8$9%:!8<!=899&=%$89H(!WWCWXY!&<<$=$&9=B!$-)*8A&-&9%!8A&*!(!.$>(%&*(>!:&%%>&-&9%!

:B:%&-C!!Z9&!=(9!(*F?&!E#&%#&*!:?=#!(!=>&(*$9F!(9@!:&%%>&-&9%!<?9=%$89!:#8?>@!.&!$9!%#&!)*$A(%&!

8*!)?.>$=!@8-($91!B&%!%#&*&!$:!>$%%>&!(*F?-&9%!8A&*!%#&!.&9&<$%:!8<!&<<$=$&9=BC!

!

4#&!$>>?:%*(%$89!.&>8E!@&)$=%:!(9!&G(-)>&!%#&!&<<$=$&9=$&:!%#(%!=8?>@!.&!(=#$&A&@!$<!(!6(%(!

78--89:!E&*&!$9!)>(=&!%8!(=%!(:!(!=&9%*(>!=>&(*$9F!:B:%&-!<8*!)8:%$9F:!$9!%#&!&G=#(9F&!:)(=&!89!

%#&!D9%&*9&%1!:$!-$>(*!%8!%#&!*8>&!)>(B&@!.B!%#&!T&@&*(>!U&:&*A&!$9!%#&!.(9L$9F!$9@?:%*BC/!![&*&1!

%#&!:(-&!%&9!=89%&9%!?:&*:!(==&::!@(%(!<*8-!%&9!=89%&9%!)*8A$@&*:!%#*8?F#!-(9B!<&E&*!)8$9%:!

8<!=899&=%$89+!

!

!

1 T8*!%#&!6(%(!78--89:1!=>&(*$9F!(>E(B:!*&<&*:!%8!%#&!-8:%!&<<$=$&9%!:8?*=$9F!(9@!@&>$A&*B!8<!)8:%&@!@(%(!.&%E&&9!

:&&L&*:!(9@!)*8A$@&*:C!!,&%%>&-&9%!*&<&*:!%8!:$%?(%$89!E#&*&!(9!&=898-$=!*&9%!8.>$F(%$89!(>:8!%*(A&>:!E$%#!(!)(*%$=?>(*!

)$&=&!8<!)8:%&@!@(%(C!!D9!:?=#!=(:&:1!:&&L&*:!(9@!)*8A$@&*:!8<!)8:%&@!@(%(!&9=?-.&*&@!E$%#!:&%%>&-&9%!8.>$F(%$89:!

=(9!&$%#&*!=#88:&!%8!=89@?=%!:&%%>&-&9%!.$>(%&*(>>B!O&A&9!$<!%#&!@(%(!<>8E&@!%#*8?F#!%#&!78--89:P!8*!-(B!8)%!%8!

?%$>$J&!:&%%>&-&9%!8)%$89:!@$*&=%>B!%#*8?F#!%#&!6(%(!78--89:!E#&9!:?=#!<$9(9=$(>!$9<*(:%*?=%?*&!&G$:%:C

Page 3: A Data Commons in the Exchange Space

2!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!='%-)%+$C!<'5!>)05-$*-7!D$C:-!&5-$%+')!!

\!6(%(!78--89:!8<<&*:!%#&!)8::$.$>$%B!8<!F*&(%>B!&G)(9@$9F!%#&!A(>?&!=*&(%$89!%#(%!%(L&:!)>(=&!

89!%#&!D9%&*9&%C!!\!>(*F&!)8*%$89!8<!%#(%!A(>?&!$9A8>A&:!%#&!(.$>$%B!%8!5@$:=8A&*;!=89%&9%H&$%#&*!

.B!%*(@$%$89(>!:&(*=#&:!O]88F>&!8*!M$9F!.&$9F!%#&!>&(@&*:P!8*1!$9=*&(:$9F>B1!.B!*&<&**(>!O4E$%%&*!^!

T(=&.88L!.&$9F!%#&!&-&*F&9%!>&(@&*:PC!!!

!

D9!%#&!=8--&*=&!:)(=&1!(!*8.?:%!-(*L&%!$9!(@A&*%$:$9F!(9@!(<<$>$(%&!:(>&:!%#(%!*&E(*@:!>&(@:!

O.8%#!$9!%#&!<8*-!8<!=>$=LI%#*8?F#:!(9@!(=%?(>!:(>&:P!#(:!>&@!%8!(!-89&%$J(%$89!-8@&>!%#(%!(>>8E:!

89&!:&%!8<!E&.:$%&:!%8!.&!*&E(*@&@!<8*!.*$9F$9F!S?(>$<$&@!>&(@:!%8!(98%#&*!:&%!8<!:$%&:!%#(%!-$F#%!

.&9&<$%!<*8-!%#&!$9=*&(:&@!%*(<<$=C!!4#&!&A8>?%$89!8<!%#$:!*&>(%$89:#$)!#(:!>&@!%8!$9=*&(:&@!

$998A(%$89!(9@!&G)&*$-&9%(%$89!.&%E&&9!:$%&:!%#(%!(*&!F88@!(%!F(%#&*$9F!=89%&9%!(9@!%#8:&!

%#(%!(*&!F88@!(%!?:$9F!$%!O(9@!&A&*B%#$9F!$9I.&%E&&9PC2!!!

!

7?**&9%>B1!:$%&:!%#(%!:&&L!%8!$@&9%$<B!(9@!(FF*&F(%&!&G=#(9F&I*&>(%&@!)8:%$9F:H%#8:&!>$L&>B!%8!

>&(@!%8!=>$=LI%#*8?F#!(9@!:(>&:!)(B-&9%!*&E(*@:H-?:%!())*8(=#!O89!%&=#9$=(>1!>&F(>!(9@!

.?:$9&::!%&*-:P!(!>(*F&!9?-.&*!8<!:&)(*(%&!:$%&:C!!_?:%!(:!<8*!KC,C!.(9L:1!(!=&9%*(>$J&@!=>&(*$9F!

:B:%&-1!8*!6(%(!78--89:1!E8?>@!F*&(%>B!*&@?=&!%$-&!(9@!8)&*(%$9F!=8:%:1!8)&9$9F!%#&!(*&9(!%8!

.8%#!:-(>>!(9@!>(*F&!8)&*(%8*:C!!D%!$:!E8*%#!98%$9F!%#(%!$9!:8!@8$9F1!%#&!6(%(!78--89:!E8?>@!

)>(B!(!@&-8=*(%$J$9F!*8>&!$9!%#&!&G=#(9F&!:)(=&C!

!

2!,$%&:!#8:%$9F!=89%&9%!:8-&%$-&:!)(B!<8*!:?=#!*&<&**(>:!(9@!(<<$>$(%&!:(>&:C!!,$%&:!E$:#$9F!%8!.&9&<$%!<*8-!:?=#!

)(B-&9%:!:&&L!%8!F(%#&*!%#&!?9@&*>B$9F!@(%(!%#(%!E$>>!F&9&*(%&!%#&!#$F#&:%!)*8.(.$>$%B!8<!=>$=LI%#*8?F#:!8*!:(>&:!E$%#!

%#&!>&(:%!<*$=%$89C!!Q8:%!8<!]88F>&`:!)*8<$%:!@&*$A&!<*8-!8)%$-$J$9F!=>$=LI%#*8?F#:!89!$%:!8E9!(9@!%#$*@!)(*%B!:$%&:a!(9@!

\-(J89`:!)*8<$%:!%88!(*&!>$L&E$:&!:?.:%(9%$(>>B!F&9&*(%&@!.B!F(*9&*$9F!O(9@!)(B$9F!<8*P!(<<$>$(%&!:(>&:!<*8-!%#$*@!

)(*%$&:!E#8!-(B!#(A&!?:&*:!.?%!>$%%>&!8*!98!:&>>(.>&!=89%&9%!8<!%#&$*!8E9C!!!,8-&!8%#&*!E&.:$%&:!@$>$F&9%>B!(%%&-)%!%8!

L&&)!(>>!%#&$*!(=%$A$%B!(9@!>&(@!F&9&*(%$89!$9I:$%&!O$C&C!7*($F:>$:%P!.B!*&<?:$9F!%8!)(B!<8*!*&<&**(>:!8*!:#(*&!:(>&:!

)*8=&&@:C!![8E&A&*1!$%!$:!E8*%#!98%$9F!%#(%!(>-8:%!(>>!=8--&*=&I.(:&@!:$%&:1!E$%#!%#&!&G=&)%$89!8<!)*$A(%&!&G=#(9F&:1!

)8:%!%#&!<(=%:!(.8?%!%#&$*!8<<&*$9F:!:S?(*&>B!$9!%#&!)?.>$=!A$&EC!

Page 4: A Data Commons in the Exchange Space

b!

D9!(@@$%$891!.B!:?.:%(9%$(>>B!$9=*&(:$9F!%#&!&<<$=$&9=B!8<!=89%&9%!@$:=8A&*B1!(!6(%(!78--89:!

E8?>@!F*&(%>B!&G)(9@!%#&!%B)&!(9@!(-8?9%!8<!@(%(!(==&::$.>&!%8!.?:$9&::&:!(9@!989I)*8<$%:!

$9%&*&:%&@!$9!-(L$9F!?:&!8<!$%C!!Q8*&!&<<$=$&9%!=>&(*$9F!8<!$9<8*-(%$89!.&%E&&9!:&&L&*:!(9@!

)*8A$@&*:!8<!@(%(!$9!%#&!=8--&*=$(>!E8*>@!E8?>@!.&!&G)&=%&@!%8!>8E&*!%#&!=8:%!8<!&:%(.>$:#$9F!

(<<$>$(%&!:(>&:!(9@!8%#&*!@$*&=%!-(*L&%$9F!)*8F*(-:C!!Z?%:$@&!%#&!=8--&*=$(>!*&(>-1!$9=*&(:&@!

&<<$=$&9=$&:!(9@!>8E&*!=8:%:!=8?>@!<(=$>$%(%&!&G=#(9F&I*&>(%&@!)*8R&=%:!%#(%!:$-)>B!E&*&!98%!

<&(:$.>&!$9!%#&!)(:%C!!!

!

!

>>?! @,$%!E+1,%!$!#$%$!&'((')*!F''G!F+G-B!!

D9!%#$:!:&=%$89!E&!@$:=?::!E#(%!(!6(%(!78--89:!-$F#%!>88L!>$L&!(:!(!)*(=%$=(>!-(%%&*C!!"&!

&9A$:$89!(!6(%(!78--89:!(:!-?=#!-8*&!%#(9!(!:$-)>&!*&)8:$%8*BC!!\!6(%(!78--89:!%#(%!

$9=>?@&:!:?=#!<?9=%$89:!(:!98*-(>$J(%$89!8<!*(E!E8?>@!<(=$>$%(%&!-&(9$9F<?>!:&(*=#!(=*8::!-(9B!

#?9@*&@:!@(%(!8<!:8?*=&:!(%!89=&C!!M&=(?:&!%#&!78--89:!E8?>@!#8>@!:?=#!@(%(1!$%!=8?>@!(>:8!

:?))8*%!(9B!9?-.&*!8<!())>$=(%$89:!<8*!8?%.8?9@!)*8@?=%:!:?=#!(:!#$F#>B!=?:%8-$J&@!@(%(!

:%*&(-:C!!4#&!$>>?:%*(%$89!.&>8E!:#8E:!(!)8::$.>&!-8@&>!<8*!(!6(%(!78--89:+!!!

!

!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

D9!%#$:!&G(-)>&1!%#&!6(%(!78--89:!E8?>@!&<<&=%$A&>B!.&!.8?9@&@!89!%#&!$9=8-$9F!(9@!8?%F8$9F!

:$@&:!.B!())>$=(%$89!)*8F*(--$9F!$9%&*<(=&:!O\'D:PC!!4#&!\'D:!E8?>@!@&<$9&!$9%&*(=%$89:!.&%E&&9!

&9%$%$&:!8?%:$@&!%#&!78--89:!(9@!%#&!78--89:!$%:&><C!!"&!(9%$=$)(%&!%#(%!%#&!<8>>8E$9F!\'D:!

E8?>@!<(=$>$%(%&!%#&!&<<$=$&9%!-(9(F&-&9%!8<!*(E!@(%(!=8>>&=%&@!.B!%#&!78--89:+!

!

• ='*%+)1!"=>!c!%8!*&F?>(%&!S?(>$%B!8<!$9=8-$9F!*(E!@(%(!)8:%$9F:1!&CFC1!=89<$*-$9F!@(%(!

:8?*=&:!(9@!L&&)$9F!*&@?9@(9%!)8:%$9F:!<*8-!&9%*B!%8!%#&!78--89:a!

Page 5: A Data Commons in the Exchange Space

d!

!• H'5($C+I$%+')!"=>!JJ!%8!:&%!:%(9@(*@:!<8*!$9=8-$9F!@(%(!98*-(>$J(%$89

b1!$9=>?@$9F!F&8I

=8@&:1!%&G%!=(%&F8*$J(%$89!(9@!#(:#%(F:1!(998%(%$89:d!O:?=#!(:!$-(F&:1!&%=CP1!(9@!%8!(@@!

-&%(I@(%(!O:?=#!(:!:8?*=&!@&:=*$)%$89:1!@(%&I%$-&!:%(-)!*&=&$A&@1!&%=CP!(::8=$(%&@!E$%#!

%#&!)8:%$9F:a!(9@!!

• E')+%'5+)1!"=>!c!%8!)&*-$%!%#8:&!-(9(F$9F!%#&!78--89:!!%8!*&A$&E!$9<8*-(%$89!89!

%#*8?F#)?%!$9%8!%#&!78--89:!(9@!@(%(!S?&?&!.&#(A$8*:!%#(%!%(L&!)>(=&!&9!*8?%&!$9%8!

%#&!78--89:C!!!4#&:&!$9.8?9@!\'D:!E8?>@!:?))8*%!(=#$&A&-&9%!8<!(!)*$9=$)(>!8.R&=%$A&!8<!%#&!6(%(!78--89:+!

%8!$9@&G1!:%8*&!(9@!*&)8*%!89!*&(>!%$-&!?)@(%&:!8<!:$-$>(*!%B)&:!8<!@(%(!8*$F$9(%&@!<*8-!-(9B!

@$A&*:&!:8?*=&:C!!4#$:!*&)8:$%8*B!8<!98*-(>$J&@!@(%(!E8?>@!.&!?:&<?>!%8!(!E$@&!A(*$&%B!8<!?:&*:!$9!

%#&!=8--&*=$(>1!(=(@&-$=!(9@!989I)*8<$%!:)#&*&:1!(9@!E8?>@!(<<8*@!(!:?.:%(9%$(>!$-)*8A&-&9%!

$9!%#&!&<<$=$&9=B!E$%#!E#$=#!&G=#(9F&I*&>(%&@!@(%(!=(9!.&!(==&::&@C!!!

!

4#&!<8>>8E$9F!\'D:!E8?>@!)*8A$@&!@(%(!$9!8?%.8?9@!A$:?(>$J(%$89!<8*-(%:1!?:&<?>!<8*!(!E$@&!

9?-.&*!8<!)8%&9%$(>!?:&*:+!!

• 2-$50,!"=>!II!(>>8E:!?:&*:!%8!)&*<8*-!<*&&!<8*-!:&(*=#!89!L&BE8*@:!8*!:%*?=%?*&@!:&(*=#!

89!$9@&G&@!%&*-:a!@&>$A&*:!%*(@$%$89(>!:&(*=#!*&:?>%:!$9!(!>$:%!A$&EC!

!

• 2%5-$(!"=>!c!(>>8E:!?:&*:!%8!A$&E!(!=89:%(9%!:%*&(-!8<!$9@$A$@?(>!)8:%$9F:!$9!*&(>!%$-&!

(%!(!:)&=$<$&@!*(%&!<8*!(9B!=*$%&*$(!%#(%!=(9!.&!:)&=$<$&@!$9!%#&!,&(*=#!\'DC!!4#&!@(%(!

:%*&(-!-(B!.&!(!:(-)>&!8<!-(%=#$9F!)8:%$9F:!$<!%#&!9?-.&*!8<!-(%=#!*&:?>%:!&G=&&@:!

%#&!?:&*`:!:)&=$<$&@!:%*&(-!*(%&1!8*!%#&!:%*&(-!-(B!=89%($9!(!-$G!8<!*&(>!%$-&!(9@!

#$:%8*$=(>!)8:%$9F:!$<!%#&!9?-.&*!8<!*&(>!%$-&!-(%=#!*&:?>%:!(*&!>&::!%#(9!%#&!:)&=$<$&@!

:%*&(-!*(%&C!!4#&!,%*&(-!\'D!-(B!(>:8!.&!$-)>&-&9%&@!(:!(!E$@F&%!%#(%!=(9!.&!.?$>%!$9%8!

"&.!(9@!-8.$>&!())>$=(%$89:!E#&*&!(!:%*&(-$9F!A$&E!8<!@(%(!$:!.8%#!?:&<?>!(9@!&B&I

=(%=#$9FC!

!• H'%+<+0$%+')!"=>!c!(>>8E:!?:&*:!%8!=89@?=%!)&*:$:%&9%!:&(*=#&:1!E#&*&.B!9&E!-(%=#!

*&:?>%:!(*&!)?:#&@!%8!(!E&.:$%&!8*!-8.$>&!@&A$=&!(:!%#&B!8==?*C!!e8%$<$=(%$89:!-(B!.&!

#$F#>B!:&>&=%$A&!$<!.(:&@!89!L&BE8*@!-(%=#&:!8<!$9<*&S?&9%>B!?:&@!%&*-:1!8*!%#&B!-(B!.&!

A8>?-$98?:!5<$*&!#8:&:;!8<!@(%(!$<!%#&B!(*&!.(:&@!89!.*8(@!=(%&F8*$&:!8*!F&8F*()#$&:!8<!

=*$%&*$(C!!

3 D9!8*@&*!%8!-(L&!@(%(!=8-)(*(.>&!(=*8::!(>>!:8?*=&:1!%#&!78--89:!&-)>8B:!$%:!8E9!$9@&)&9@&9%!=(%&F8*$J$9F!>8F$=!

(9@!-())$9F!*?>&:!%8!(9@!(::8=$(%&!@(%(!E$%#!(!)(*%$=?>(*!-&%*8)8>$%(9!(*&(!E#&*&!*&>&A(9%C!!\>>!$9.8?9@!)8:%$9F:!(*&!

-())&@!.(:&@!89!%*(9:>(%$89!%(.>&:!(9@!<8*E(*@!(9@!*&A&*:&!F&8I=8@$9F!-&=#(9$:-:!)*8-?>F(%&@!.B!%#&!78--89:!

<8*!?:&!.B!(9B!:?.-$%%&*C 4 ,%*?=%?*&@!(998%(%$89:!(*&!%B)$=(>>B!8*F(9$J&@!(:!L&B!A(>?&!)($*:!:?=#!(:!5.*(9@fT8*@;!8*!5-8@&>f4#?9@&*.$*@;!8*!

5E&$F#%f/3>.;!%#(%!(*&!=89%&G%?(>>B!*&>&A(9%!%8!:8-&!=(%&F8*$&:!8<!)8:%$9F:

Page 6: A Data Commons in the Exchange Space

g!

4'K-5)$)0-!$)7!;3-5$%+')$C!.C-(-)%*!'<!$!#$%$!&'((')*!!

D9!8*@&*!%8!<?9=%$89!&<<&=%$A&>B1!(!6(%(!78--89:!<8*!%#&!&G=#(9F&!:)(=&!89!%#&!D9%&*9&%!E$>>!

*&S?$*&!(!9?-.&*!8<!F8A&*9(9=&!(9@!8)&*(%$89(>!&>&-&9%:C!!D9!%#$:!:&=%$89!E&!8?%>$9&!:8-&!

E(B:!$9!E#$=#!%#&:&!8*F(9$J(%$89(>!&>&-&9%:!8<!%#&!78--89:!-(B!E8*L!%8F&%#&*C!!!

!

7&*%($9!&9%$%$&:!-(B!.&:%!.&!:?$%&@!%8!:?))>B!8*!8A&*:&&!)(*%$=?>(*!8*F(9$J(%$89(>!8)&*(%$89:C!T8*!

&G(-)>&1!(!9&?%*(>!&9%$%B!=8?>@!:&*A&!(9!$-)8*%(9%!*8>&!$9!F8A&*9(9=&!%8!.*$9F!$9%&*&:%&@!)(*%$&:!

%8F&%#&*1!)*8-8%$9F!@$(>8F?&!(9@!(*%$=?>(%$9F!=8--89!:%(9@(*@:!%#(%!F8A&*9!%#&!78--89:1!

E$%#!(9!&B&!<8*!5%#&!=8--89!F88@C;!'*$A(%&!)(*%$&:!-(B!@*$A&!%#&!:#()&!8<!=&*%($9!

8*F(9$J(%$89(>!&>&-&9%:C!!"&!@8!98%!F8!$9%8!(9B!F*&(%!@&%($>!#&*&!(.8?%!#8E!:?=#!*8>&:!E8?>@!

.&!@&<$9&@1!.?%!*(%#&*!#8)&!%#(%!%#&:&!98%&:!-(B!)*8A&!%#&!.(:$:!<8*!?:&<?>!@$:=?::$89C!!!!

!

!

!

!

D9!%#$:! $>>?:%*(%$891!%#&!6(%(!78--89:!$:!

)$=%?*&@!(:! (!9?-.&*!

8<!

$9=*&(:$9F>B!

8)&*(%$89(>!=8-)89&9%:!%8E(*@:!%#&!

=&9%&*C!!h(=#!=8-)89&9%!-?:%!(>$F9!E$%#!

%#&! 8%#&*:!$9!8*@&*!<8*!%#&!78--89:!%8!

8)&*(%&!&<<&=%$A&>B!(9@!$9!<?><$>>-&9%!8<!

$%:! F8(>:C!!\!.*$&<!@&:=*$)%$89!8<!%#&:&!A(*$8?:!

=8-)89&9%:!<8>>8E:1!(:!%#&B!-$F#%!.&!

@&A&>8)&@+!

!

='C+0A! 0')*+7-5$%+')*!c!]8(>:!(9@!F&9&*(>!)*$9=$)>&:!<8*!%#&!6(%(!78--89:! -?:%!.&!E&>>!@&<$9&@!(:!%#&B!E$>>!)*8A$@&!%#&!.(:$:!<8*!

(>>!$-)>&-&9%(%$89!&<<8*%:C!

!

4'K-5)$)0-!c!"&!(9%$=$)(%&!%#(%!-?=#!8<!%#&!E8*L!%8!&:%(.>$:#!(9@!-($9%($9!%#&!6(%(!

78--89:!=(9!.&!(==8-)>$:#&@!E$%#8?%!&>(.8*(%&!8*!<8*-(>!F8A&*9(9=&!:%*?=%?*&:C!!\:!E&!)8$9%!

8?%!(.8A&1!89&!8<!%#&!)*$-(*B!.&9&<$%:!8<!%#&!6(%(!78--89:!E$>>!.&!%#&!:$F9$<$=(9%!&<<$=$&9=B!

$-)*8A&-&9%:!(A($>(.>&!%8!%#8:&!:&&L$9F!(==&::!%8!-(::!&G=#(9F&I*&>(%&@!@(%(C!!D9!8?*!A$&E1!

(9B!F8A&*9(9=&!:%*?=%?*&!<8*!%#&!78--89:!-?:%!.&!=89:$:%&9%!E$%#!$%:!%&=#9$=(>!&<<$=$&9=$&:1!$9!

%#(%!]8A&*9(9=&!:#8?>@!98%!:&&L!%8!$-)8:&!?99&=&::(*B!<*$=%$89!89!?:&*:!E#8!E(9%!%8!:#(*&!

(9@!(==&::!78--89:!@(%(C!!!

!

"&!.&>$&A&!%#(%!F8A&*9(9=&!:%*?=%?*&:!9&=&::(*B!%8!-(9(F&!%#&!78--89:!=(9!.&!&-.8@$&@!$9!

(!*&>(%$A&>B!:-(>>!9?-.&*!8<!:%(9@(*@!=89%*(=%?(>!)*8A$:$89:1!-8:%!>$L&>B!:&%!<8*%#!$9!%#&!

78--89:`!%&*-:!8<!?:&!O4ZKPC!!"&!@$:=?::!:8-&!8<!%#&!$::?&:!%#&:&!:%(9@(*@!=89%*(=%?(>!

)*8A$:$89:!E$>>!9&&@!%8!(@@*&::!$9!%#&!<8>>8E$9F!:&=%$89!8<!%#$:!)()&*C!!

!

Page 7: A Data Commons in the Exchange Space

0!

"=>*!c!!\:!98%&@!$9!:8-&!@&%($>!(.8A&1!E&!&9A$:$89!%#(%!(!:&*$&:!8<!\'D:!E$>>!:&%!%#&!.8?9@(*$&:!8<!

%#&!6(%(!78--89:1!(9@!@&:=*$.&!$9!%&=#9$=(>!%&*-:!%#&!<8*-!(9@!-&(9:!.B!E#$=#!@(%(!-(B!

%*(A&>!$9%8!(9@!8?%!8<!%#&!78--89:C!!!

!

;3-5$%+')$C!=5'%'0'C*!c!4#8:&!-(9(F$9F!%#&!6(%(!78--89:!E$>>!9&&@!%8!@&A&>8)!(9@!-($9%($9!

(!9?-.&*!8<!8)&*(%$89(>!)*8%8=8>:!%8!:?))8*%!%#&!:-88%#!%#*8?F#)?%!8<!@(%(!$9%8!(9@!8?%!8<!%#&!

78--89:C!!4#&:&!)*8%8=8>:!:#8?>@!$9=>?@&!S?(>$%B!(::?*(9=&!(=%$A$%$&:!(9@!8%#&*!(=%$A$%$&:!

*&>(%&@!%8!F&9&*(%$9F!(9@!-(9(F$9F!-&%(I@(%(!O&CFC1!@(%(!:8?*=&!$9<8*-(%$89!A&*:?:!$9<8*-(%$89!

(.8?%!%#&!@(%(!$%:&><PCg!

!

D9!(@@$%$891!(!:?==&::<?>!6(%(!78--89:!-?:%!58)&*(%$89(>$J&;!*&S?$*&-&9%:!<8*!=8-)>B$9F!E$%#!

$%:!>&F(>!(9@!=89%*(=%?(>!<*(-&E8*L:C!!O"&!@$:=?::!$9!-8*&!@&%($>!.&>8E!$::?&:!%#(%!-(B!=(>>!<8*!

:)&=$(>$J&@!=89%*(=%?(>!)*8A$:$89:CP!!T8*!&G(-)>&1!%#8:&!-(9(F$9F!%#&!78--89:!E$>>!

?9@8?.%&@>B!9&&@!%8!@&A&>8)!)*8%8=8>:!%8!)*&A&9%!@$:=>8:?*&!8<!=&*%($9!%B)&:!8<!:&9:$%$A&!@(%(1!

(9@!%*(=L$9F!(9@!8%#&*!(=%$A$%$&:!%8!:?))8*%!=8**&=%!)(B-&9%:!(::8=$(%&@!E$%#!8%#&*!:)&=$<$=!

%B)&:!8<!@(%(C!!Z9&!:)&=$<$=!&G(-)>&!8<!(!>&F(>!8.>$F(%$89!%#(%!-?:%!.&!8)&*(%$89(>$J&@!$:!%#&!

6$F$%(>!Q$>>&99$?-!78)B*$F#%!\=%!O67Q\P!%(L&@8E9!*&:)89:$.$>$%$&:!%#(%!E$>>!(*$:&!<8*!%#&!6(%(!

78--89:!E#&9!@(%(!$:!-$:%(L&9>B!:?.-$%%&@!8*!-$:=>(::$<$&@!$9!%&*-:!8<!=8)B*$F#%C!!!

!

D%!$:!E8*%#!98%$9F!%#(%!E#$>&!$9%&>>&=%?(>!)*8)&*%B!(9@!=89<$@&9%$(>$%B!=89=&*9:!)>(=&!(!.?*@&9!8<!

*&:)89:$.$>$%B!89!%#&!6(%(!78--89:!%8!>$-$%!:8-&!:B9@$=(%$89!*&S?&:%:1!%#&!$9A&*:&!$:!(>:8!%*?&+!

$9!@&(>$9F!E$%#!)?.>$=>B!(A($>(.>&1!<(=%?(>!@(%(1!%#&!6(%(!78--89:!#(:!(!*&:)89:$.$>$%B!%8!(::?*&!

%#(%!:?=#!@(%(!$:!<*&&!(9@!<($*>B!(==&::$.>&!%8!(>>1!89!(9!&S?(>!.(:$:!O$C&C!E$%#8?%!@$:=*$-$9(%8*B!

)&*-$::$89I.(:&@!$9%&*<&*&9=&!.B!(9B!%#$*@!)(*%BPC!!

!

&')*+7-5$%+')*!<'5!%,-!4'K-5)$)0-!95$(-L'5GM!!#$%$J23-0+<+0!>**:-*!!\:!E&!98%&!(.8A&1!@&A&>8)$9F!(!>$-$%&@!9?-.&*!8<!:%(9@(*@$J&@1!@(%(I:)&=$<$=!=89%*(=%:!O8*!

>$=&9:&:1!$9!%#&!=(:&!8<!@(%(!E$%#!(::8=$(%&@!$9%&>>&=%?(>!)*8)&*%B!*$F#%:P!$:!(!L&B!&>&-&9%!$9!%#&!

&:%(.>$:#-&9%!8<!(!6(%(!78--89:C!!4#&:&!@(%(I:)&=$<$=!=89%*(=%:!(*&!8<!)(*%$=?>(*!$-)8*%(9=&!

.&=(?:&!%#&B!E$>>!)&*-$%!%#&!:-88%#!<?9=%$89!(9@!8)&*(%$89:!8<!(!6(%(!78--89:!<*8-!(!

F8A&*9(9=&!(9@!>&F(>!:%(9@)8$9%H(9!(:)&=%!8<!%#&!78--89:!%#(%!$:!(%!>&(:%!(:!$-)8*%(9%!(:!%#&!

%&=#9$=(>!&>&-&9%:!%#(%!(>>8E!&(:B!(==&::!%8!%#&!78--89:`!@(%(C!!!

!

48!-$9$-$J&!%*(9:(=%$89!=8:%:!(::8=$(%&@!E$%#!6(%(!78--89:!8)&*(%$89:1!%#&!=89%*(=%?(>!

<*(-&E8*L!:?))8*%$9F!%#&!78--89:!-?:%!@&<$9&!%#&!8.>$F(%$89:!8<!%#&!A(*$8?:!)(*%$&:!$9!(!=>&(*!

-(99&*1!E$%#!(!-$9$-?-!9?-.&*!8<!:)&=$(>$J&@!)*8A$:$89:C!!\%!%#&!:(-&!%$-&1!%#$:!=89%*(=%?(>!

<*(-&E8*L!:#8?>@!(@&S?(%&>B!(@@*&::!>&F$%$-(%&1!@(%(I:)&=$<$=!$::?&:!:8!%#(%!@(%(!)*8A$@&*:!(9@!

?:&*:!@8!98%!<&&>!%#&!9&&@!%8!=*&(%&!:$@&!(F*&&-&9%:!%#(%!=8?>@!$-)$9F&!89!%#&!78--89:`!

&<<&=%$A&9&::C!!!

!!!

4#8:&!@&A&>8)$9F!%#&!=89%*(=%?(>!<*(-&E8*L!-?:%!.&(*!$9!-$9@!%#(%!&A&*B!:)&=$(>$J&@!

=89%*(=%?(>!)*8A$:$89!E$>>!*&:?>%!$9!%#&!@&A&>8)-&9%!8<!=8**&:)89@$9F!)*8A$:$89:!$9!78--89:`!

\'D:!(9@!8)&*(%$89(>!)*8%8=8>:C!!D@&9%$<B$9F!%#8:&!$::?&:!%#(%!>&F$%$-(%&>B!-&*$%!:)&=$(>$J&@!

=89%*(=%?(>!%&*-:!(%!%#&!8?%:&%!=(9!#&>)!(A8$@!@$<<$=?>%$&:!$9!%#&!<?%?*&C!!4#$:!$:!:8!&A&9!$<!%#&!

5 4#&!6(%(!78--89:!$%:&><!=*&(%&:!98!8*$F$9(>!@(%(1!.?%!%#&!6(%(!78--89:!-(B!=*&(%&!-?=#!@&*$A(%$A&!@(%(!%#*8?F#!

&<<8*%:!%8!98*-(>$J&!(9@!(998%(%&!@(%(!(=*8::!:8?*=&:!(9@!%8!&9*$=#!%#&!@(%(!E$%#!-&%(I@(%(C

Page 8: A Data Commons in the Exchange Space

i!

78--89:!@8&:!98%!$9$%$(>>B!:?))8*%!(>>!%B)&:!8<!&G=#(9F&I*&>(%&@!@(%(C!!4#&!78--89:!=(9!

.&%%&*!%(L&!$9%8!(==8?9%!)*8F*&::$A&!&G)(9:$89:!8<!$%:!?9$A&*:&!8<!@(%(!$<!%#&!(==8--8@(%$89:!

9&&@&@!%8!:?))8*%!9&E!%B)&:!8<!@(%(!(*&!=89:$@&*&@!$9!(@A(9=&C!!!

!

"&!$@&9%$<B!<8?*!.*8(@!=(%&F8*$&:!8<!@(%(!%#(%!#(A&!$-)>$=(%$89:!<8*!%#&!=89%*(=%?(>!<*(-&E8*L!

9&=&::(*B!%8!:?))8*%!%#&!=8--89:+!!

!

• 78)B*$F#%&@!(9@!)(%&9%&@!E8*L:!%#(%!=(**B!:%*89F!!"#$%%$&#'(%)*+,*$+#-)+!./#0)(9@!*&:)89:$.$>$%$&:a!

!!

• 789<$@&9%$(>!(9@!8%#&*E$:&!*+!1(#$)2(#(!E#&*&!&$%#&*!%#&!$@&9%$%B!8<!%#&!:&9@&*!9&&@:!%8!.&!L&)%!(989B-8?:!(9@V8*!%#&!$@&9%$%B!(9@!=&*%($9!8%#&*!@&%($>:!(*&!89>B!(?%#8*$J&@!<8*!

@&>$A&*B!%8!)(*%$=?>(*!?:&*:!8<!:?=#!=89%&9%a!(9@!

!

• T(=%:1!(9@!8)$9$89:!(.8?%!<(=%:1!*'3%!&%-)(1(!%(3%$!(9@!$9!%#&!*'3%!&)2,4(!"!%#(%!(*&!:?.R&=%!%8!.*8(@!)*8%&=%$89:!?9@&*!%#&!T$*:%!\-&9@-&9%!*$F#%!%8!<*&&!:)&&=#!O%#&!<*&&!

&G=#(9F&!8<!<(=%?(>!$9<8*-(%$89!$9!%#&!)?.>$=!@8-($9!-(B!(>:8!.&!:?.R&=%!8%#&*!>&F(>!

)*8%&=%$891!$9=>?@$9F!%#(%!8<!(9%$%*?:%!>(EPa!(9@!

!

• 6(%(!(::8=$(%&@!E$%#!(!*$F#%!%8!)(B-&9%!8<!89&!L$9@!8*!(98%#&*1!E#$=#!E&!*&<&*!%8!#&*&!

(:!$&,",4!&)+!./#05)\!:$F9$<$=(9%!=8-)89&9%!8<!%#$:!@(%(!=89:$:%:!8<!)8:%$9F:!<*8-!

=8--&*=$(>!E&.:$%&:!%#(%!#(A&!&:%(.>$:#&@!(@A&*%$:$9F!8*!(<<$>$(%&!:(>&!)*8F*(-:C!!

78--&*=$(>!E&.:$%&:!-(B!(>:8!E$:#!%8!&:%(.>$:#!:%(9@(*@!%&*-:!<8*!%#$*@!)(*%$&:!%8!?:&!

%#&$*!@(%(!(:!)(*%!8<!78--89:!)*8F*(-:1!(9@!=8?>@!@&A$:&!E(B:!%8!-(L&!?:&!8<!%#&!6(%(!

78--89:!%8!@$:%*$.?%&!%#&$*!%&*-:!8<!?:&!O4ZKP!(9@!(%%&9@(9%!@(%(!%*(=L$9FC!!!

!

4#&!-(%*$=&:!.&>8E!)*8A$@&!89&!A$&E!8<!#8E!%#&:&!@(%(!=(%&F8*$&:!$9%&**&>(%&!<8*!)?*)8:&:!8<!

@&A&>8)$9F!())*8)*$(%&!=89%*(=%?(>!)*8A$:$89:C!!!

!

=-5(+**+')!$)7!=$A(-)%!J!4#&!<$*:%!-(%*$G!@&)$=%:!%#&!$9%&**&>(%$89:#$)!8<!$9%&>>&=%?(>!)*8)&*%B!

OD'P!*$F#%:!(9@!&=898-$=!*$F#%:!OhUP!(::8=$(%&@!E$%#!@(%(!-8A$9F!%#*8?F#!%#&!78--89:+!!

! D'!U$F#%:! h=898-$=!U$F#%:!!

T(=%:! e8!)&*-$::$89!*&S?$*&@! '(B-&9%!(%!@$:=*&%$89!8<!:8?*=&1!

$9@&)&9@&9%!8<!)&*-$::$89!%8!?:&!

!

7*&(%$A&!"8*L:! '&*-$::$89!(%!@$:=*&%$89!8<!:8?*=&! '(B-&9%!(%!@$:=*&%$89!8<!:8?*=&1!%$&@!

%8!&=898-$=!*$F#%:!

!

!

\:!%#&!-(%*$G!-(L&:!=>&(*1!$%!$:!9&=&::(*B!%8!@$:%$9F?$:#!*$+4!00!,"!%8!?:&!@(%(!%#(%!-(B!#(A&!D'!

*$F#%:!(::8=$(%&@!E$%#!$%!<*8-!(9!hU!+!./#)#,)*(-4$"#)%#(%!-$F#%!.&!(::8=$(%&@!E$%#!%#(%!

)&*-$::$891!8*!E#$=#!-$F#%!(*$:&!E#&9!:?=#!@(%(!$:!?:&@!(:!)(*%!8<!(!@$*&=%!(@A&*%$:$9F!)*8F*(-C!!

6&A&>8)$9F!:%(9@(*@!=89%*(=%?(>!)*8A$:$89:!%#(%!F8A&*9!)&*-$::$89:!(9@!)(B-&9%:!E$>>!F*&(%>B!

&9#(9=&!&<<$=$&9=$&:!(::8=$(%&@!E$%#!?:&!8<!%#&!6(%(!78--89:C!!!D%!$:!E8*%#!98%$9F!#&*&!%#(%!

)?*&>B!<(=%?(>!@(%(!%#(%!$:!)?.>$=>B!(A($>(.>&!-(B!-8A&!<*&&>B!$9%8!(9@!8?%!8<!%#&!78--89:1!

E$%#8?%!%#&!9&&@!<8*!:)&=$(>$J&@!=89%*(=%?(>!)*8A$:$89:C!!

!

Page 9: A Data Commons in the Exchange Space

X!

=5+K$0A!$)7!&')<+7-)%+$C+%A!N4#$:!-(%*$G!:#8E:!%#&!$9%&**&>(%$89:#$)!.&%E&&9!A(*$8?:!)*$A(=B!

(9@!=89<$@&9%$(>$%B!*$F#%:!%#(%!=8?>@!.&!(::8=$(%&@!E$%#!@(%(!-8A$9F!%#*8?F#!%#&!78--89:C!!

[&*&!E&!&9A$:$89!:$%?(%$89:!$9!E#$=#!$9<8*-(%$89!=8-$9F!$9%8!%#&!78--89:!-(B!.&!)(*%$(>>B!8*!

&9%$*&>B!?9(A($>(.>&!%8!%#&!)?.>$=!A$&EC!!!

!!

! '?.>$=!789%&9%! '*$A(%&!789%&9%!

,$F9&@! \>>!?:&*:!=(9!:&&!=89%&9%!(9@!

$@&9%$%B!8<!=89%*$.?%8*!

!

,)&=$<$&@!)(*%$&:!=(9!:&&!=89%&9%!

(9@!$@&9%$%B!8<!=89%*$.?%8*!

,&-$I(989B-8?:! \>>!?:&*:!=(9!:&&!=89%&9%a!78--89:!

O8*!$9%&*-&@$(*BP!=>8(L:!$@&9%$%B!8<!

=89%*$.?%8*!

!

,)&=$<$&@!)(*%$&:!=(9!:&&!=89%&9%+!

78--89:!O8*!$9%&*-&@$(*BP!=>8(L:!

$@&9%$%B!8<!=89%*$.?%8*!

\989B-8?:! \9B89&!=(9!:&&!=89%&9%a!$@&9%$%B!8<!

=89%*$.?%8*!?9L98E9!

!

,)&=$<$&@!)(*%$&:!=(9!:&&!=89%&9%+!

$@&9%$%B!8<!=89%*$.?%8*!?9L98E9!

!

"&!&9A$:$89!%#(%!:?=#!:$%?(%$89:!=8?>@!(*$:&!$9!(!A(*$&%B!8<!=89%&G%:1!(!<&E!&G(-)>&:!8<!E#$=#!E&!

>$:%!.&>8E+!

!

• 4#&!@(%(!$:!:?.R&=%!%8!=>($-:!8<!)*$A(=B1!&CFC1!)&*:89(>>B!$@&9%$<$(.>&!-&@$=(>!$9<8*-(%$89!

O:?=#!@(%(!-(B!(>:8!.&!:?.R&=%!%8!A(*$8?:!>&F(>!(9@!*&F?>(%8*B!*&F$-&:Pa!

!

• \!.?B&*!8*!:&>>&*!=#88:&:!%8!*&-($9!(989B-8?:!$9!(!=8--&*=$(>!%*(9:(=%$89a!

!

• \!E#$:%>&.>8E&*!:&&L:!%8!(989B-8?:>B!*&)8*%!.&#(A$8*!%#(%!-(B!A$8>(%&!%#&!>(Ea!(9@V8*!!

!

• 4#&!A$=%$-!8<!(!=*$-&!:&&L:!&-&*F&9=B!*&:)89:&C!!!

!

\:!=(9!.&!:&&9!<*8-!%#&:&!:=&9(*$8:1!%#&!9&&@!<8*!)*$A(=B!8*!=89<$@&9%$(>$%B!-(B!(*$:&!<8*!(!

A(*$&%B!8<!*&(:89:1!E#$=#!E$>>!=(>>!<8*!(!9?-.&*!8<!@$<<&*&9%!=89%*(=%?(>!)*8A$:$89:!(9@!*&>(%&@!

8)&*(%$89(>!:?))8*%C!!!

!

>>>?!!!! &')0C:*+')!!

\!6(%(!78--89:!E8?>@!F*&(%>B!$9=*&(:&!&<<$=$&9=B!8<!(==&::!%8!&G=#(9F&I*&>(%&@!@(%(C!!"&!

.&>$&A&!%#(%!%#&:&!&<<$=$&9=$&:1!(9@!%#&!(%%&9@(9%!@&=*&(:&!$9!=8:%:!!(9@!@&-8=*(%$J(%$89!8<!

(==&::1!E&>>!R?:%$<B!%#&!E8*L!$9A8>A&@!$9!&:%(.>$:#$9F!:?=#!(!78--89:C!!!

!

4#&!$@&(:!8?%>$9&@!(.8A&!(.8?%!#8E!(!6(%(!78--89:!-$F#%!.&!:%*?=%?*&@!*&)*&:&9%!8?*!$9$%$(>!

%#8?F#%:!89!E#(%!E$>>!?9@8?.%&@>B!.&!(!=8-)>&G!(9@!-?>%$I:%(F&!)*8R&=%C!!"&!#8)&!%#(%!E&!

#(A&!F$A&9!*&(@&*:!<88@!<8*!%#8?F#%1!(9@!E&>=8-&!(!@$(>8F?&!(.8?%!E#&%#&*!(9@!#8E!%8!

)*8=&&@C!!!!

!

! !