Searching for Synergies among Future Internet Ingredients

Antônio Marcos Alberti

Instituto Nacional de Telecomunicações - Inatel 510 João de Camargo, Santa Rita do Sapucaí, Minas Gerais, Brazil

alberti@inatel.brhttp://antonioalberti.blogspot.com

Outline

• Contextualization

• Ingredients

• Synergies

• Guidelines

• Conclusion

Contextualization (1/2)

• Currently, there are many proposals to redesign the Internet.

• Each project has its own set visions, requirements, and design principles.

• Despite the huge diversity, some ingredients are demonstrating to be very popular, simultaneously appearing on many proposals.

• However, a common practice is to adopt certain ingredients just to address some specific part of the project, without exploring more deeply the possible synergies.

Contextualization (2/2)

• This paper has three main contributions:

• It presents some of the most frequently adopted ingredients in the current research panorama.

• It searches for more fundamental synergies among those frequently adopted building blocks

• It proposes a set of guidelines to help future Internet (FI) architects to explore those synergies on their projects.

Ingredients (1/3)

• What is an ingredient?

• Let’s define an ingredient as a material or an abstract building block of the architecture.

• Therefore, it could be a hardware, a software or even a more abstract concept.

Ingredients (2/3)

• What are the Future Internet frequently adopted ingredients?

• State-of-art substrate communication resources.

• State-of-art substrate computing resources.

• Identification/Location (ID/Loc) splitting.

• Hardware virtualization technologies.

• Software-defined networking.

• Internet of things and real-virtual worlds integration.

• Mobility and redundancy support.

Ingredients (3/3)

• Indirection resolution.

• Information- or content-centric design.

• Service-centric or service oriented design.

• *-awareness or generalization of the awareness property.

• Autonomic or self-* property.

• Semantics and context.

• Security, privacy, trust, and self-certification.

• Simplicity, evolvability, and sustainability.

!"#$%

&'()*+,+*(-.

/"#$%/0)#+*(.

)'01+2"023'"/

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

/"03'+25-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2.

9"01)*+/9/

!"#$%

0&*$+(3')2+&*.

&$.#&0)2&'/

!+96#+0)2+&*.

&$.'")#%7+'23)#.

:&'#8/.

+*2"(')2+&*

;*$&'9)2+&*.

9&4+#+25-.

0)01+*(.

0&6+"/-.

0&*/+/2"*05

<7&#7)4+#+25.

&$./"'7+0"/.

)*8.

)66#+0)2+&*/

=/"'%

):)'"*"//

!"'7+0"%

>:)'"*"//?.

@")#%2+9".

$""84)0A.

0&*2'&#.#&&6/.

@&)9+*(?.

/"'7+0"%

9&4+#+25

B"'/+/2"*2

'"6'"/"*2)%

2+&*.&$.'")#.

:&'#8.

+*$&'9)2+&*

C&*2"D2%

>:)'"*"//-.

@"(3#)2+&*%

>:)'"*"//

!"9)*2+0/.

)*8.0&*2"D2.

&$.6"'/+/2"*2.

+*$&'9)2+&*

<D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*.&*./"#$%E?.

)32&*&9+0.

FG

!"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/.

'"H3+'".

/"9)*2+0.)*8.

0&*2"D2.

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/?.

@")#%2+9".

0&9632+*(

;I%4)/"8.

/"03'+25-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2

JBK>.

6'&7+8"/.

$#"D+4#".

0)6)0+25

;ILM&0.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/

!"#$%

&'()*+,+*(.

1)/1.2)4#"/?.

!"9)*2+0.

:"4

!"03'+25-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2.4"1+*8.

'"*8",7&3/

<7&#32+&*%)/%

+2%0&3#8%4"

!+23)2+&*%

):)'"*"//-.

!"#$%

>:)'"*"//

@")#.:&'#8.

+*$&'9)2+&*.

"*'+01

/"'7+0"/.)*8.

)66#+0)2+&*/

C&*2"D23)#+%

,)2+&*.&$.'")#.

:&'#8.

0&##"02"8.

+*$&'9)2+&*

<7&#7)4+#+25.

21'&3(1.

0&*2"D23)#+%

,"8./"#"02+7".

6'"//3'"/

N&4+#+25.&$.

/"*/&'/-.

)023)2&'/-.

@J;I.

B&:"'%):)'".

1)*8&7"'?.

C&**"02+7+25%

):)'".93#2+%

1&9+*(

N&4+#".

$'+"*8#5.

*)9+*(.)*8.

0&*2"D23)#O

I"/0'+62&'/.

&$.7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/?.

@")#%2+9".

+*$&'9)2+&*

P3/+*"//%

>:)'"*"//?.

Q"2:&'A%

>:)'"*"//

B"'/+/2"*2.

8"/0'+62&'/.&$.

/"'7+0"/

!"03'+25-.

6'+7)05-.)*8.

2'3/2.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/

!")'01.$&'.

'"0&*$+(3')%

4#".FG

I5*)9+0.

'"/&#32+&*.&$.

;ILM&0.

9)66+*(/

R+'23)#+,)2+&*.

&$.'"0&*$O.

FG?.@")#%

2+9"./366&'2.

$&'."*2+2+"/

!+96#+$+0)2+&*.

&$.9&4+#25.

/366&'2

!")'01)4#".

/34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/

;ILM&0.&$.

$#"D+4#".

1)'8:)'".

'"/&3'0"/.

!"03'+25.)*8.

2'3/2.4"1+*8..

"D6"'+9"*2)#.

$)0+#+2+"/

;ILM&0.&$.

/34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

/")'01.)*8.

+*8+'"02+&*.

'"/&#32+&*.

9"01)*+/9/

!"#$%

6'&2"02+*(-.

/"#$%

&'()*+,+*(-.

/"#$%1")#+*(.

!")'01.

*""8/.

/"9)*2+0.)*8.

0&*2"D2O

<*2+25.

*)9+*(

!34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/.

*""8.

/"9)*2+0.'+01.

8"/0'+62&'/

!"9)*2+0.'+01.

&4S"02+7"/?.

!"#$%9&*+2&'?.

I"/)94+(3+25

!"9)*2+0.

)*8.0&*2"D2.

$&'./"03'+25-.

6'+7)05-."20O

C&*2"D23)#+%

,)2+&*.&$.

"D6"'+9"*2)#.

$)0+#+25.

'"/&3'0"/

T*"%$+2/%)##.

/&#32+&*

T*"%$+2/%)##.

/&#32+&*

.I"0&36#+*(.

FG.U.!G.

"7&#32+&*?.

<7&#32+&*.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8

!"#$%9*(2.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/?.

@")#%2+9".

0&*2'&#.#&&6/

!+96#+$+0)2+&*.

&$./"03'+25-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2.

;96'&7"8.

FG.

"7&#7)4+#+25

>00&9&8)%

2+&*.&$.

/34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/.

"7&#32+&*

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

0&*2"D23)#+%

,)2+&*.

9"01)*+/9/

I+/0&7"'5.&$.

9&4+#".

/"'7+0"/

K"*"')#+,"8.

9&4+#+25.

'"H3+'"/.;IL

M&0.)*8.

3*+H3".;8/

N&4+#+25.&$.

7+'23)#.

"*2+2+"/-."O(O.

RN/?.J)/2.

1)*8&7"'

!"#$%

0&*$+(3'+*(-.

/"#$%

&62+9+,+*(-.

/"#$%1")#+*(.

V')0")4+#+25

&$.9&4+#".

"*2+2+"/?.

!"03'"

)22)019"*2

<D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*.&*.

9&4+#+25.)*8.

93#2+%1&9+*(

;*0'")/"8.

0&**"02+7+25?.

9&4+#+25.&$.

/34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/

!")'01)4#"..

/"*/&'/.)*8.

)023)2&'/

;ILM&0.&$.'")#.

)*8.7+'23)#.

"*2+2+"/O.

=*+H3".;I/O

R+'23)#+,)2+&*.

&$.'")#%:&'#8?.

V+9"#+*"//.&$.

@G;.

+*$&'9)2+&*

@G;./"*/+*(.

)*8.)02+*(?

Q<I/.!"#$%

9*(2?.!"#$%

8+//"9+*O

!"03'+25-.

6'+7)05-.)*8.

2'3/2.&$.

/"*/&'/.)*8.

)023)2&'/

@G;.

"D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*-.0O$O.

J;@<-.K<Q;

!0)#)4+#+25.

)*8.34+H3+25.

&$./"*/&'/.

)*8.)023)2&'/

;*$&'9)2+&*.

;ILM&0?.

=*+H3".;I/?.

!366&'2.$&'.

634L/34.

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

+*$&'9)2+&*%

0"*2'+0.

)66'&)01"/

<D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*.&*.

+*$&'9)2+&*%

0"*2'+0.

*"2:&'A/

!"#$%0"'2+$5+*(

*)9"/.)*8.

+*$&'9)2+&*?.

)321"*2+0)2"8

'"*8",7&3/

!"#$%

0"'2+$5+*(-.

/"#$%

&'()*+,+*(.

0&*2"*2

B"'/+/2"*2.

+*$&'9)2+&*.

/")'01.)*8.

#&0)#+,)2+&*

!+96#+$+0)2+&*.

&$.

+*$&'9)2+&*%

0"*2'+0.

8"/+(*/

!"9)*2+0.

:"4

;8"*2+25%

>:)'"*"//

!"#$%E.2&.

9)*)(".

0&96#"D+25

!"#$%E.U.

0&(*+2+&*.'"HO.

E%>:)'"*"//.

2&.6'&7+8".

)8)62)4+#+25

>66#+0)2+&*%

>:)'".

/"032+'5-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2

!"'7+0"%

>:)'"*"//-.

W&!

!"'7+0"%

>:)'"*"//-.

!"#$%/0)#+*(.

/34/2')2"

!"'7+0".

0&96&/"%

)4+#+25.

'"H3+'"/.

/")'01

;ILM&0.&$.

/"'7+0"/.)*8.

8"/0'+62&'/

<D6&/3'".&$.

'"/&3'0"/?.

!366&'2.$&'.

'")#%2+9".

/"'7+0"/

>32&*&9+0.

/"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/

!"03'+25-.

6'+7)05-.)*8.

2'3/2.&$.

/"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/

!"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/.

"D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*.$)0+#2+"/

C)6)0+25.)*8.

/0)#)4+#+25.$&'.

/"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/

C)6)0+25-.

=4+H3+25.)*8.

!0)#)4+#+25

J)/2.B'&2&2O

<D6"'+9O.U.

@"0&*$+(3%

')4#".FG

R+'23)#+,)%

2+&*.U.@")#%

2+9".!366&'2

!"#$%E.)*8.

C&(*+2+&*

!")'01.)*8.

;*8+'"02+&*.

@"/&#32+&*

;ILM&0.

!6#+22+*(-.

=*+H3".;I/

!"03'+25-.

B'+7)05-.

V'3/2-.

V')0")4+#+25

@")#%R+'23)#.

G&'#8/.

;*2"(')2+&*

!"'7+0"%

0"*2'+/9

;*$&'9)2+&*%

0"*2'+/9

>8)62)4+#+25.

)*8.

E%>:)'"*"//

!"9)*2+0-.

C&*2"D2-.

T*2&#&(5-.

Q)9+*(

K"*"')#+,"8.

N&4+#+25.U.

N3#2+%1&9+*(

!+96#+0+25-.

!3/2)+*)%

4+#+25.)*8.

<7&#7)4+#+25

Synergies (1/2)

Information-

centric

Service-centric

*-Aware

Real-virtual

Integrat.

MobilityMulltih.

SemanticContext

SimplicitySustaina-

bility

Self-*Cognitive

Security, Privacy,Trust

Virtualiz.Real-time

Experim.Protot.

SearchIndirec.Resolut.

ID/LocUnique

IDs

Substrate Resource

Synergies (2/2)

!"#$%

&'()*+,+*(-.

/"#$%/0)#+*(.

)'01+2"023'"/

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

/"03'+25-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2.

9"01)*+/9/

!"#$%

0&*$+(3')2+&*.

&$.#&0)2&'/

!+96#+0)2+&*.

&$.'")#%7+'23)#.

:&'#8/.

+*2"(')2+&*

;*$&'9)2+&*.

9&4+#+25-.

0)01+*(.

0&6+"/-.

0&*/+/2"*05

<7&#7)4+#+25.

&$./"'7+0"/.

)*8.

)66#+0)2+&*/

=/"'%

):)'"*"//

!"'7+0"%

>:)'"*"//?.

@")#%2+9".

$""84)0A.

0&*2'&#.#&&6/.

@&)9+*(?.

/"'7+0"%

9&4+#+25

B"'/+/2"*2

'"6'"/"*2)%

2+&*.&$.'")#.

:&'#8.

+*$&'9)2+&*

C&*2"D2%

>:)'"*"//-.

@"(3#)2+&*%

>:)'"*"//

!"9)*2+0/.

)*8.0&*2"D2.

&$.6"'/+/2"*2.

+*$&'9)2+&*

<D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*.&*./"#$%E?.

)32&*&9+0.

FG

!"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/.

'"H3+'".

/"9)*2+0.)*8.

0&*2"D2.

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/?.

@")#%2+9".

0&9632+*(

;I%4)/"8.

/"03'+25-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2

JBK>.

6'&7+8"/.

$#"D+4#".

0)6)0+25

;ILM&0.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/

!"#$%

&'()*+,+*(.

1)/1.2)4#"/?.

!"9)*2+0.

:"4

!"03'+25-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2.4"1+*8.

'"*8",7&3/

<7&#32+&*%)/%

+2%0&3#8%4"

!+23)2+&*%

):)'"*"//-.

!"#$%

>:)'"*"//

@")#.:&'#8.

+*$&'9)2+&*.

"*'+01

/"'7+0"/.)*8.

)66#+0)2+&*/

C&*2"D23)#+%

,)2+&*.&$.'")#.

:&'#8.

0&##"02"8.

+*$&'9)2+&*

<7&#7)4+#+25.

21'&3(1.

0&*2"D23)#+%

,"8./"#"02+7".

6'"//3'"/

N&4+#+25.&$.

/"*/&'/-.

)023)2&'/-.

@J;I.

B&:"'%):)'".

1)*8&7"'?.

C&**"02+7+25%

):)'".93#2+%

1&9+*(

N&4+#".

$'+"*8#5.

*)9+*(.)*8.

0&*2"D23)#O

I"/0'+62&'/.

&$.7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/?.

@")#%2+9".

+*$&'9)2+&*

P3/+*"//%

>:)'"*"//?.

Q"2:&'A%

>:)'"*"//

B"'/+/2"*2.

8"/0'+62&'/.&$.

/"'7+0"/

!"03'+25-.

6'+7)05-.)*8.

2'3/2.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/

!")'01.$&'.

'"0&*$+(3')%

4#".FG

I5*)9+0.

'"/&#32+&*.&$.

;ILM&0.

9)66+*(/

R+'23)#+,)2+&*.

&$.'"0&*$O.

FG?.@")#%

2+9"./366&'2.

$&'."*2+2+"/

!+96#+$+0)2+&*.

&$.9&4+#25.

/366&'2

!")'01)4#".

/34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/

;ILM&0.&$.

$#"D+4#".

1)'8:)'".

'"/&3'0"/.

!"03'+25.)*8.

2'3/2.4"1+*8..

"D6"'+9"*2)#.

$)0+#+2+"/

;ILM&0.&$.

/34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

/")'01.)*8.

+*8+'"02+&*.

'"/&#32+&*.

9"01)*+/9/

!"#$%

6'&2"02+*(-.

/"#$%

&'()*+,+*(-.

/"#$%1")#+*(.

!")'01.

*""8/.

/"9)*2+0.)*8.

0&*2"D2O

<*2+25.

*)9+*(

!34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/.

*""8.

/"9)*2+0.'+01.

8"/0'+62&'/

!"9)*2+0.'+01.

&4S"02+7"/?.

!"#$%9&*+2&'?.

I"/)94+(3+25

!"9)*2+0.

)*8.0&*2"D2.

$&'./"03'+25-.

6'+7)05-."20O

C&*2"D23)#+%

,)2+&*.&$.

"D6"'+9"*2)#.

$)0+#+25.

'"/&3'0"/

T*"%$+2/%)##.

/&#32+&*

T*"%$+2/%)##.

/&#32+&*

.I"0&36#+*(.

FG.U.!G.

"7&#32+&*?.

<7&#32+&*.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8

!"#$%9*(2.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/?.

@")#%2+9".

0&*2'&#.#&&6/

!+96#+$+0)2+&*.

&$./"03'+25-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2.

;96'&7"8.

FG.

"7&#7)4+#+25

>00&9&8)%

2+&*.&$.

/34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/.

"7&#32+&*

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

0&*2"D23)#+%

,)2+&*.

9"01)*+/9/

I+/0&7"'5.&$.

9&4+#".

/"'7+0"/

K"*"')#+,"8.

9&4+#+25.

'"H3+'"/.;IL

M&0.)*8.

3*+H3".;8/

N&4+#+25.&$.

7+'23)#.

"*2+2+"/-."O(O.

RN/?.J)/2.

1)*8&7"'

!"#$%

0&*$+(3'+*(-.

/"#$%

&62+9+,+*(-.

/"#$%1")#+*(.

V')0")4+#+25

&$.9&4+#".

"*2+2+"/?.

!"03'"

)22)019"*2

<D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*.&*.

9&4+#+25.)*8.

93#2+%1&9+*(

;*0'")/"8.

0&**"02+7+25?.

9&4+#+25.&$.

/34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/

!")'01)4#"..

/"*/&'/.)*8.

)023)2&'/

;ILM&0.&$.'")#.

)*8.7+'23)#.

"*2+2+"/O.

=*+H3".;I/O

R+'23)#+,)2+&*.

&$.'")#%:&'#8?.

V+9"#+*"//.&$.

@G;.

+*$&'9)2+&*

@G;./"*/+*(.

)*8.)02+*(?

Q<I/.!"#$%

9*(2?.!"#$%

8+//"9+*O

!"03'+25-.

6'+7)05-.)*8.

2'3/2.&$.

/"*/&'/.)*8.

)023)2&'/

@G;.

"D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*-.0O$O.

J;@<-.K<Q;

!0)#)4+#+25.

)*8.34+H3+25.

&$./"*/&'/.

)*8.)023)2&'/

;*$&'9)2+&*.

;ILM&0?.

=*+H3".;I/?.

!366&'2.$&'.

634L/34.

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

+*$&'9)2+&*%

0"*2'+0.

)66'&)01"/

<D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*.&*.

+*$&'9)2+&*%

0"*2'+0.

*"2:&'A/

!"#$%0"'2+$5+*(

*)9"/.)*8.

+*$&'9)2+&*?.

)321"*2+0)2"8

'"*8",7&3/

!"#$%

0"'2+$5+*(-.

/"#$%

&'()*+,+*(.

0&*2"*2

B"'/+/2"*2.

+*$&'9)2+&*.

/")'01.)*8.

#&0)#+,)2+&*

!+96#+$+0)2+&*.

&$.

+*$&'9)2+&*%

0"*2'+0.

8"/+(*/

!"9)*2+0.

:"4

;8"*2+25%

>:)'"*"//

!"#$%E.2&.

9)*)(".

0&96#"D+25

!"#$%E.U.

0&(*+2+&*.'"HO.

E%>:)'"*"//.

2&.6'&7+8".

)8)62)4+#+25

>66#+0)2+&*%

>:)'".

/"032+'5-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2

!"'7+0"%

>:)'"*"//-.

W&!

!"'7+0"%

>:)'"*"//-.

!"#$%/0)#+*(.

/34/2')2"

!"'7+0".

0&96&/"%

)4+#+25.

'"H3+'"/.

/")'01

;ILM&0.&$.

/"'7+0"/.)*8.

8"/0'+62&'/

<D6&/3'".&$.

'"/&3'0"/?.

!366&'2.$&'.

'")#%2+9".

/"'7+0"/

>32&*&9+0.

/"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/

!"03'+25-.

6'+7)05-.)*8.

2'3/2.&$.

/"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/

!"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/.

"D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*.$)0+#2+"/

C)6)0+25.)*8.

/0)#)4+#+25.$&'.

/"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/

C)6)0+25-.

=4+H3+25.)*8.

!0)#)4+#+25

J)/2.B'&2&2O

<D6"'+9O.U.

@"0&*$+(3%

')4#".FG

R+'23)#+,)%

2+&*.U.@")#%

2+9".!366&'2

!"#$%E.)*8.

C&(*+2+&*

!")'01.)*8.

;*8+'"02+&*.

@"/&#32+&*

;ILM&0.

!6#+22+*(-.

=*+H3".;I/

!"03'+25-.

B'+7)05-.

V'3/2-.

V')0")4+#+25

@")#%R+'23)#.

G&'#8/.

;*2"(')2+&*

!"'7+0"%

0"*2'+/9

;*$&'9)2+&*%

0"*2'+/9

>8)62)4+#+25.

)*8.

E%>:)'"*"//

!"9)*2+0-.

C&*2"D2-.

T*2&#&(5-.

Q)9+*(

K"*"')#+,"8.

N&4+#+25.U.

N3#2+%1&9+*(

!+96#+0+25-.

!3/2)+*)%

4+#+25.)*8.

<7&#7)4+#+25

!"#$%

&'()*+,+*(-.

/"#$%/0)#+*(.

)'01+2"023'"/

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

/"03'+25-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2.

9"01)*+/9/

!"#$%

0&*$+(3')2+&*.

&$.#&0)2&'/

!+96#+0)2+&*.

&$.'")#%7+'23)#.

:&'#8/.

+*2"(')2+&*

;*$&'9)2+&*.

9&4+#+25-.

0)01+*(.

0&6+"/-.

0&*/+/2"*05

<7&#7)4+#+25.

&$./"'7+0"/.

)*8.

)66#+0)2+&*/

=/"'%

):)'"*"//

!"'7+0"%

>:)'"*"//?.

@")#%2+9".

$""84)0A.

0&*2'&#.#&&6/.

@&)9+*(?.

/"'7+0"%

9&4+#+25

B"'/+/2"*2

'"6'"/"*2)%

2+&*.&$.'")#.

:&'#8.

+*$&'9)2+&*

C&*2"D2%

>:)'"*"//-.

@"(3#)2+&*%

>:)'"*"//

!"9)*2+0/.

)*8.0&*2"D2.

&$.6"'/+/2"*2.

+*$&'9)2+&*

<D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*.&*./"#$%E?.

)32&*&9+0.

FG

!"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/.

'"H3+'".

/"9)*2+0.)*8.

0&*2"D2.

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/?.

@")#%2+9".

0&9632+*(

;I%4)/"8.

/"03'+25-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2

JBK>.

6'&7+8"/.

$#"D+4#".

0)6)0+25

;ILM&0.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/

!"#$%

&'()*+,+*(.

1)/1.2)4#"/?.

!"9)*2+0.

:"4

!"03'+25-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2.4"1+*8.

'"*8",7&3/

<7&#32+&*%)/%

+2%0&3#8%4"

!+23)2+&*%

):)'"*"//-.

!"#$%

>:)'"*"//

@")#.:&'#8.

+*$&'9)2+&*.

"*'+01

/"'7+0"/.)*8.

)66#+0)2+&*/

C&*2"D23)#+%

,)2+&*.&$.'")#.

:&'#8.

0&##"02"8.

+*$&'9)2+&*

<7&#7)4+#+25.

21'&3(1.

0&*2"D23)#+%

,"8./"#"02+7".

6'"//3'"/

N&4+#+25.&$.

/"*/&'/-.

)023)2&'/-.

@J;I.

B&:"'%):)'".

1)*8&7"'?.

C&**"02+7+25%

):)'".93#2+%

1&9+*(

N&4+#".

$'+"*8#5.

*)9+*(.)*8.

0&*2"D23)#O

I"/0'+62&'/.

&$.7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/?.

@")#%2+9".

+*$&'9)2+&*

P3/+*"//%

>:)'"*"//?.

Q"2:&'A%

>:)'"*"//

B"'/+/2"*2.

8"/0'+62&'/.&$.

/"'7+0"/

!"03'+25-.

6'+7)05-.)*8.

2'3/2.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/

!")'01.$&'.

'"0&*$+(3')%

4#".FG

I5*)9+0.

'"/&#32+&*.&$.

;ILM&0.

9)66+*(/

R+'23)#+,)2+&*.

&$.'"0&*$O.

FG?.@")#%

2+9"./366&'2.

$&'."*2+2+"/

!+96#+$+0)2+&*.

&$.9&4+#25.

/366&'2

!")'01)4#".

/34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/

;ILM&0.&$.

$#"D+4#".

1)'8:)'".

'"/&3'0"/.

!"03'+25.)*8.

2'3/2.4"1+*8..

"D6"'+9"*2)#.

$)0+#+2+"/

;ILM&0.&$.

/34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

/")'01.)*8.

+*8+'"02+&*.

'"/&#32+&*.

9"01)*+/9/

!"#$%

6'&2"02+*(-.

/"#$%

&'()*+,+*(-.

/"#$%1")#+*(.

!")'01.

*""8/.

/"9)*2+0.)*8.

0&*2"D2O

<*2+25.

*)9+*(

!34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/.

*""8.

/"9)*2+0.'+01.

8"/0'+62&'/

!"9)*2+0.'+01.

&4S"02+7"/?.

!"#$%9&*+2&'?.

I"/)94+(3+25

!"9)*2+0.

)*8.0&*2"D2.

$&'./"03'+25-.

6'+7)05-."20O

C&*2"D23)#+%

,)2+&*.&$.

"D6"'+9"*2)#.

$)0+#+25.

'"/&3'0"/

T*"%$+2/%)##.

/&#32+&*

T*"%$+2/%)##.

/&#32+&*

.I"0&36#+*(.

FG.U.!G.

"7&#32+&*?.

<7&#32+&*.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8

!"#$%9*(2.&$.

7+'23)#+,"8.

'"/&3'0"/?.

@")#%2+9".

0&*2'&#.#&&6/

!+96#+$+0)2+&*.

&$./"03'+25-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2.

;96'&7"8.

FG.

"7&#7)4+#+25

>00&9&8)%

2+&*.&$.

/34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/.

"7&#32+&*

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

0&*2"D23)#+%

,)2+&*.

9"01)*+/9/

I+/0&7"'5.&$.

9&4+#".

/"'7+0"/

K"*"')#+,"8.

9&4+#+25.

'"H3+'"/.;IL

M&0.)*8.

3*+H3".;8/

N&4+#+25.&$.

7+'23)#.

"*2+2+"/-."O(O.

RN/?.J)/2.

1)*8&7"'

!"#$%

0&*$+(3'+*(-.

/"#$%

&62+9+,+*(-.

/"#$%1")#+*(.

V')0")4+#+25

&$.9&4+#".

"*2+2+"/?.

!"03'"

)22)019"*2

<D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*.&*.

9&4+#+25.)*8.

93#2+%1&9+*(

;*0'")/"8.

0&**"02+7+25?.

9&4+#+25.&$.

/34/2')2".

'"/&3'0"/

!")'01)4#"..

/"*/&'/.)*8.

)023)2&'/

;ILM&0.&$.'")#.

)*8.7+'23)#.

"*2+2+"/O.

=*+H3".;I/O

R+'23)#+,)2+&*.

&$.'")#%:&'#8?.

V+9"#+*"//.&$.

@G;.

+*$&'9)2+&*

@G;./"*/+*(.

)*8.)02+*(?

Q<I/.!"#$%

9*(2?.!"#$%

8+//"9+*O

!"03'+25-.

6'+7)05-.)*8.

2'3/2.&$.

/"*/&'/.)*8.

)023)2&'/

@G;.

"D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*-.0O$O.

J;@<-.K<Q;

!0)#)4+#+25.

)*8.34+H3+25.

&$./"*/&'/.

)*8.)023)2&'/

;*$&'9)2+&*.

;ILM&0?.

=*+H3".;I/?.

!366&'2.$&'.

634L/34.

!0)#)4+#+25.&$.

+*$&'9)2+&*%

0"*2'+0.

)66'&)01"/

<D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*.&*.

+*$&'9)2+&*%

0"*2'+0.

*"2:&'A/

!"#$%0"'2+$5+*(

*)9"/.)*8.

+*$&'9)2+&*?.

)321"*2+0)2"8

'"*8",7&3/

!"#$%

0"'2+$5+*(-.

/"#$%

&'()*+,+*(.

0&*2"*2

B"'/+/2"*2.

+*$&'9)2+&*.

/")'01.)*8.

#&0)#+,)2+&*

!+96#+$+0)2+&*.

&$.

+*$&'9)2+&*%

0"*2'+0.

8"/+(*/

!"9)*2+0.

:"4

;8"*2+25%

>:)'"*"//

!"#$%E.2&.

9)*)(".

0&96#"D+25

!"#$%E.U.

0&(*+2+&*.'"HO.

E%>:)'"*"//.

2&.6'&7+8".

)8)62)4+#+25

>66#+0)2+&*%

>:)'".

/"032+'5-.

6'+7)05.)*8.

2'3/2

!"'7+0"%

>:)'"*"//-.

W&!

!"'7+0"%

>:)'"*"//-.

!"#$%/0)#+*(.

/34/2')2"

!"'7+0".

0&96&/"%

)4+#+25.

'"H3+'"/.

/")'01

;ILM&0.&$.

/"'7+0"/.)*8.

8"/0'+62&'/

<D6&/3'".&$.

'"/&3'0"/?.

!366&'2.$&'.

'")#%2+9".

/"'7+0"/

>32&*&9+0.

/"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/

!"03'+25-.

6'+7)05-.)*8.

2'3/2.&$.

/"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/

!"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/.

"D6"'+9"*2)%

2+&*.$)0+#2+"/

C)6)0+25.)*8.

/0)#)4+#+25.$&'.

/"'7+0".

$')9":&'A/

C)6)0+25-.

=4+H3+25.)*8.

!0)#)4+#+25

J)/2.B'&2&2O

<D6"'+9O.U.

@"0&*$+(3%

')4#".FG

R+'23)#+,)%

2+&*.U.@")#%

2+9".!366&'2

!"#$%E.)*8.

C&(*+2+&*

!")'01.)*8.

;*8+'"02+&*.

@"/&#32+&*

;ILM&0.

!6#+22+*(-.

=*+H3".;I/

!"03'+25-.

B'+7)05-.

V'3/2-.

V')0")4+#+25

@")#%R+'23)#.

G&'#8/.

;*2"(')2+&*

!"'7+0"%

0"*2'+/9

;*$&'9)2+&*%

0"*2'+/9

>8)62)4+#+25.

)*8.

E%>:)'"*"//

!"9)*2+0-.

C&*2"D2-.

T*2&#&(5-.

Q)9+*(

K"*"')#+,"8.

N&4+#+25.U.

N3#2+%1&9+*(

!+96#+0+25-.

!3/2)+*)%

4+#+25.)*8.

<7&#7)4+#+25

Guidelines

• Generalize the application of selected ingredients in the architecture as much as possible.

• Integrate ingredients in a cohesive and synergistic way.

• Make the design “as simple as possible, but not simpler.”

Conclusion

• Some ingredients are adopted so frequently in Future Internet design, and in so many efforts, that they can be precisely determined.

• There are several unexplored synergies, e.g. to extend the ID/Loc splitting for services and to generically apply autonomicity, indirection resolution, mobility, and *-awareness.

• Current projects could take more advantage of the synergy among the ingredients adopted.

• The synergistic and cohesive integration of ingredients is a possible path to simplify the design.

감사합니다!Thank you!Obrigado!

Antônio Marcos Alberti

Instituto Nacional de Telecomunicações - Inatel 510 João de Camargo, Santa Rita do Sapucaí, Minas Gerais, Brazil

alberti@inatel.brhttp://antonioalberti.blogspot.com