View
1
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
Presented by
Drinker Biddle & Reath
191 N. Wacker Drive
Chicago, IL 60606
Mike Rosenbaum Dawn Sellstrom (312) 569-1308 (312) 569-1324 michael.rosenbaum@dbr.com dawn.sellstrom@dbr.com
2017 Health and Welfare Compliance Update June 7, 2017
2
Overview of Today’s Topics
Obamacare/Trumpcare – What is Going on?
Health Plan Headlines
Retirement Plan Litigation Update
Health Plan Governance
OBAMACARE/TRUMPCARE – WHAT IS GOING ON?
Obamacare/Trumpcare – What is Going on?
American Health Care Act (“AHCA”)
- March 24 – Speaker Ryan pulled the AHCA from consideration by the House
- In April, Republicans revived the AHCA by offering series of amendments to
get enough votes from Freedom Caucus members and other Republicans
- May 4 – U.S. House passed AHCA – 217 yes, 213 – no
- 20 Republicans opposed the AHCA and no Democrats voted for the AHCA
AHCA Provisions
- Replaces and repeals portions of Obamacare related to:
• Employer-sponsored group health plans (“GHPs”)
• Individual insurance market
• Medicaid
5
6
AHCA Prospects in the Senate
Currently 52 Republican Senators – need at least 50 (plus Vice-President) to pass AHCA
Likely will undergo major changes – Initial opposition from Republican Senators on the
Medicaid reductions and individual market changes, but support for GHP provisions
Republicans say they will prepare own healthcare bill instead of following/voting on AHCA
If Senate bill isn’t the same as AHCA, must go back to House for approval (likely after
House/Senate conference combines different version into one bill)
Goal when AHCA was passed Senate would release its bill before the end of May
Congress needs to definitively deal with healthcare reform before it can address tax
reform (if it intends to address tax reform using the “reconciliation” process)
- If a bill is approved in Senate using reconciliation process – it can be approved by
simple majority (i.e., 51 votes) and can’t be filibustered (which requires 60 votes)
OVERVIEW OF KEY AHCA PROVISIONS
ACA provisions AHCA provisions
Exchanges (Federal and State) Would continue to exist
Individual mandate Eliminates the penalty on an individual who fails to purchase health insurance and adds continuous coverage requirement (or 30% surcharge allowed)
Employer mandate
Eliminates the penalty on employers who don’t offer coverage, affordable coverage or coverage with a minimum value. Reporting rules can’t be eliminated (due to budget reconciliation process used to approve the AHCA – but Secretary of Treasury has discretion to not enforce)
Subsidies
Lower-income individuals will no longer receive subsidies to help with out-of-pocket costs (co-pays or deductibles). Rather than subsidies, individuals will receives age-based and income tax credits ($2,000-$4,000) to help pay for premiums. Individuals are not eligible for credits if eligible for employer plan.
Health savings accounts Raises the contribution limits for HSAs and expands coverage (i.e., non-prescription medication can be reimbursed in HSA)
Age-ratio Insurers will be able to charge older customers five times as much as younger customers. States can request waivers and charge even more. (ACA has 3:1 limit)
Dependent coverage until 26 Dependents can stay on their parent’s insurance until the age of 26
Pre-existing conditions provision Insurers must cover those with pre-existing conditions
8
ACA provisions AHCA provisions
Essential health benefits (“EHBs”) Under ACA, all plans must cover 10 essential benefits, including maternity care & preventive care; AHCA would allow states to waive this and define or eliminate EHBs.
Prohibitions on annual/lifetime limits
Insurers are not allowed to set a limit on coverage for an individual . However, some think annual and lifetime limits could be allowed for non-essential benefits in states that waive EHB requirements.
Delay of Cadillac Tax Delays it until 2026 (from 2020 under ACA)
FSA contributions limit The current limits would be eliminated and employers could choose higher ones
Small employer tax credit Ultimately repeals this credit (which is paid to a small employer that offers health insurance)
Medicaid expansion Major changes proposed
9
HEALTH PLAN HEADLINES
What to Watch for – Top Design Headlines
12
2015 Supreme Court decision in Obergefell v. Hodges makes
same-sex marriage bans unconstitutional
Employers continue to rethink healthcare coverage for
domestic partners
- Same-sex partners are able to marry
- Eases administration related to domestic partner eligibility and
taxation
Still, some employers are reluctant to take away a
longstanding benefit
13
Recent case law has changed the analysis, at least in the 7th Circuit (which includes Illinois)
Hively v. Ivy Tech Community College of Indiana found sexual orientation discrimination to be sex discrimination under federal employment nondiscrimination law
Other appellate courts are reconsidering the issue
Impact:
- Employers have broadly expanded coverage to same-sex spouses
- But plans covering only same-sex domestic partners may be discriminating against opposite-sex partners
Court: Civil Rights Law Prohibits
Discrimination of LGBT A federal appeals court in Chicago has ruled the 1964 Civil Rights Act protects LGBT
employees from workplace discrimination. | April 4, 2017, at 11:30 p.m.
14
Wellness programs that provide medical care are subject to ERISA
- Medical care can be diagnosis, cure, mitigation, treatment or prevention of disease
- Include wellness initiatives in your medical plan documents
Nondiscrimination rules may apply under:
- HIPAA – Prohibits discrimination based on a health factor
- ADA – Prohibits discrimination based on disability
• Medical examinations or disability-related inquiries generally prohibited unless voluntary
- GINA – Prohibits discrimination based on genetic information
- These rules are still in effect, for now…
15
Wellness Programs and Incentives
Review your wellness programs:
- Regulations prohibit “gatekeeper” approach
• Cannot deny access to medical plan or medical plan option
- Determine which rules apply – HIPAA, ADA, GINA
• Consider notice requirements
• Consider authorization requirement
• Review limits on amount of incentives
16
Wellness rewards are taxable payments unless a specific
exemption applies
Common failures to tax incentives that cannot be excluded as
“medical care:” - e.g., fitness center membership, gift cards, prizes…
Recent IRS Chief Counsel Memorandum warns of scam
wellness program arrangements
17
Common exclusion for services related to gender
reassignment
Nondiscrimination protections
- ACA Section 1557 for health insurers and healthcare providers
• Nationwide injunction in effect
- OFCCP rules apply to federal contractors
- Title VII cases expanding to sexual orientation – is gender
identity next?
18
Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act
Actions are focused on ABA therapy and residential treatment
center benefits (currently)
- Actions and advocates are rampant
Review plan treatment limits
- Quantitative limits
- Non-quantitative limits –
• e.g., medical management, including medical necessity, or based on whether the
treatment is experimental or investigative
19
“I don’t know what HIPAA stands for, but I believe in it,
and I practice it.”
Office of Civil Rights is actively conducting HIPAA privacy and security audits of covered entities and business associates
- Phase 2 audits are proceeding – now moving to on-site phase
- Audits intended to help OCR develop permanent audit program
Review required HIPAA documentation/compliance
- HHS settlement amounts with providers and health insurance plans are high, and the same violations can occur in group health plans
- Operating plan in accordance with its terms is a fiduciary requirement – health plans incorporate HIPAA privacy requirements
20
HIPAA Privacy Compliance
Appoint privacy and security officials
Privacy notice (notice of privacy practices)
- Provide to all plan participants
- On enrollment and within 60 days of material changes to plan
- Notice must be available on request and every 3 years – plan sponsor must
notify participants about notice
Plan provisions regarding privacy and security
Business associate agreements
- Do you have one for each BA?
- Has the agreement been updated?
21
HIPAA Privacy Compliance
Policies and procedures
- To whom plan employees may disclose PHI
- How PHI records will be maintained
- PHI safeguards
- Sanctions for employees who violate privacy procedures
Training
- Identify your “workforce”
- When was last training?
Security analysis checklist (confirm physical, technical and
administrative safeguards are in place)
22
Sadly, this is fake news!
ACA employer reporting remains in effect
How to address:
- SSN mismatch letters
- Other reporting errors
UPDATING YOUR RETIREMENT AND
HEALTH/WELFARE PLAN GOVERNANCE
Liability Exposure for Those Responsible for Governing/Administering Retirement and Health/Welfare Plans is Very Real
More frequent governmental audits
- Increased audit activity for 401(k), 403(b), defined benefit and health/welfare plans
- First question DOL will ask – have your fiduciaries received appropriate training
- Better training and tools for auditors
New generation of lawsuits against 401(k)/403(b) plans
- Class actions are the norm
- Fiduciary counts are usually included
- Health and welfare plan litigation is likely coming
Best protection: Train your fiduciaries and have a good process and follow it
24
IT IS TIME TO REVIEW YOUR RETIREMENT PLAN GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE AND CONSIDER UPDATING
YOUR PROCESS
26
Retirement Plan Governance Structure – Key Players
Board
CEO
Retirement plan committee
Human resources
Investment consultant
HERE ARE SOME THINGS YOU SHOULD BE DOING ON
A REGULAR BASIS
28
Examples of Fiduciary Responsibilities Include:
Selecting and monitoring service providers (investment consultant, record-keeper, trustee, investment education/advice provider, auditor, self directed brokerage account provider)
- Evaluating the services provided to the plan and reasonableness of provider compensation
Selecting and monitoring the investment options available to Plan participants
- Evaluating the costs of investments, performance, and providing a variety of options
Drafting and updating of investment policy statement
Make administrative/interpretive decisions about the Plan (once Plan design decisions have been made)
Determination of reasonableness for plan expenses and payment from plan assets
WHAT CAN YOU LEARN FROM RETIREMENT PLAN
LITIGATION?
30
31
Practical Lessons from Litigation Over 60 new cases filed in past year
Plaintiffs include current and former participants in
401(k) and 403(b) plans
Defendants include sponsor entities and individual
fiduciaries
Class action attorneys are soliciting plaintiffs via
targeted advertisements
32
No formal RFP for recordkeeping for many years (and
even the suggestion that a 3 year standard is
appropriate)
Revenue sharing:
- Revenue Sharing amounts too high/plan didn’t offer
least expensive share class
- Revenue sharing amounts used to benefit
employer/other plan
Issues Plaintiff Attorneys Are Raising
33
34
Issues Plaintiff Attorneys Are Raising (cont’d)
Committee imprudently retained poorly performing funds
- Consistently underperformed benchmarks
- Fees too high in investment options – higher than comparable investments
- Plan lost money by investing in money market funds vs. stable value
- Plan lost money by investing in target date funds offered by recordkeeper (as
compared to other target fund families)
Administrative expenses paid to recordkeeper were based on
percentage of assets (resulting in uncapped fees that are not
reasonable)
Use of actively managed investment options not appropriate/too
expensive
35
Issues Plaintiff Attorneys Are Raising (cont’d)
Internal plan fiduciaries (including Committee) were not properly monitored
Written plan documents (plan, IPS, charter, etc.) were not followed
Committee failed to monitor all sources of income to recordkeeper
- Recordkeeper benefited from “float” interest
- Also consider short-term trading fees, finders fees, fees for investment advice, etc.
Recordkeeper/investment provider didn’t provide transparency in fees in the required participant disclosures
GETTING STARTED AS A RETIREMENT PLAN
COMMITTEE – INITIAL STEPS TO TAKE
37
Getting Started as a Retirement Plan Committee – Initial Steps to Take
Develop a review of the formal Charter setting forth the
Committee’s specific duties and responsibilities
Select an independent investment consultant
Develop and follow annually the Investment Policy statement
for the plans (defined contribution and defined benefit plans)
Develop and follow annual work plan of issues to cover
during each year
Review allocation and delegation of responsibilities under
plan and other governing documents to ensure consistency
with intent and administration
COULD HEALTH/WELFARE PLANS
BE NEXT?
39
Also Time to Update Your Health/Welfare Plan Governance Structure
Same ERISA rules apply to health and welfare plans
Significant DOL audits already occurring
Litigation against health plans is coming
As you already know, the most effective way to
reduce/eliminate the fiduciary liability risk on the retirement
plan side is to have organized, regular and effective review
process (typically using a committee)
Same process makes sense for health/welfare plans
40
Also Time to Update Your Health/Welfare Plan Governance Structure (cont’d)
Consider health and welfare plan committee vs. HR vs. Finance or other
Your current health and welfare plan documents/SPD call for certain fiduciary actions to be performed (consider who is fulfilling these duties today – if anyone?)
Key fiduciary duties include selecting, monitoring and replacing plan vendors (TPA, PBM, Consultant, Broker, Flex Spending, COBRA, etc.) is a fiduciary responsibility
Other fiduciary responsibilities include:
- Making sure fees paid by the plan are reasonable
- Interpreting plan provisions
- Exercising discretion in denying or approving claims
Consider regular audits of key service providers (i.e., TPA, BPM, behavioral health provider, etc.)
HERE IS WHAT A HEALTH/WELFARE PLAN
GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE MIGHT LOOK LIKE
FINAL THOUGHTS ON A BETTER
HEALTH/WELFARE PLAN GOVERNANCE PROCESS
44
Steps to a Better Health/Welfare Plan Governance Process
Set-up a good fiduciary process – best defense is good process
Remember, it is the process that really matters, not the result. Show that a prudent process was followed in making decisions.
Make sure plan documents and delegation documents (including charter for committee) are accurate and consistent
Focus process on areas most likely to get audited or sued
- Written plan documents being followed (plan, charter, SPD, etc.)
Process to monitor internal fiduciaries – update Board at reasonable intervals
- Process to monitor fees and performance of service providers paid by the plan
45
Steps to a Better Health/Welfare Plan Governance Process
Good process doesn’t just happen – it must be planned
- Make sure meetings are held (several per year)
- Develop annual work plan of issues and follow a consistent process
Each meeting should include key vendors and include a presentation/update by selected vendors (TPA, PBM, consultants, brokers, etc.)
- These vendors will regularly bring new ideas/recommendations on how to save costs, provide benefits more efficiently, implement more effective programs
- Helps demonstrate you are following the process necessary to satisfy its fiduciary duties under ERISA
- You will also likely see added benefits (better control over healthcare costs, new ideas, cost savings, cutting edge strategies, etc.)
Create a Charter
- Purpose and responsibilities of the committee; meeting procedures; method to appoint and monitor committee members; issues/items that Committee will monitor
46
Steps to a Better Health/Welfare Plan Governance Process
Selecting and monitoring service providers
- Fully evaluate services, capabilities, fees
- Fully document the selection process
Review service provider contracts to ensure they contain clear
terms and commercially reasonable terms
- Avoid conflicts of interest/prohibited transactions
- Monitor performance of all service providers on an ongoing
basis. Plan administrator continues to have duty to monitor its
selection, services, fees, etc.
47
Steps to a Better Health/Welfare Plan Governance Process
Document in minutes:
Follow consistent format – plan(s), topics, action items. Distribute
draft minutes for review and comment; finalize timely and on
schedule
Record discussions, decisions and reasoning, including advisors’
recommendations, if any
Retain documents used at meetings
Be careful – do not include discussions that are not fiduciary in
nature. For example, plan design, economics of plan design or
decisions
Review prior minutes to create next agenda – follow up items
QUESTIONS?
88713749
Recommended