Building and Managing IP Portfolio · 1 Building and Managing IP Portfolio Surya Raghu Advanced...

1

Building and Managing IP Portfolio

SuryaRaghuAdvancedFluidicsLLC&ETCubeInternational

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLankaSept.17-21,2018

©S.RaghuWIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018

OUTLINE

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 2

CreatingExploitableIPPatentScapeandTechScapeManagingRisksDiscussionandConclusion

YearlyPatentsforLargeIndustry

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 3

https://medium.com/@IBMResearch/why-we-patent-66ce5a986331

CreatingExploitableIP

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 4

IndustryPatentstrategies:OffensiveandDefensiveOffensive Defensive

Blockcompetitorsfromgainingentryintoyourtechnologyandbusinesssector

Onlydefendyourbusinessarea

Filepatentsforallreasonableinventionsinthatfieldoftechnology

Fileforpatentsonlynecessaryforyourbusiness

Createaggregatedpatentportfolioforlicensingorsale

Notinterestedinsellingpatents

Patenttrolls??

UniversityStrategy

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 5

ExploitableIP•  Wecannotaffordindustry-styleoffensiveor

defensivestrategies

•  ChangingIPtrends:Itisnotonlypatentsbutalsocopyrights(software+others),designs,innovations,Apps,Clinicaltesting,EducationalmethodsandTrainingtools.

UniversityStrategy

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 6

Inventions:Developastrategyformarketinghighestvalue-addedIPInventionshouldhave(near-term)application(insight)HigherTRLforastrongpatentMarketsizePotentiallicensingpath–contactsandrelationshipswiththerightindustry

CreatingaIPPortfolio

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 7

CreatingaportfolioofrelatedpatentsandotherIPwillprovideabetterpackageformarketingExample:Chemicalcompound+methodofextraction+optimizedprocessingtechnology+processcontrolmethods+possiblereactions+catalysts+applications+softwarealgorithms(?)+designsMayneedlotofinterdisciplinarywork

Technology-needmapping

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 8

ElectricityAccessRenewableEnergy

TransportationAgriculture,Horticulture,Foodprocessing,Dairy

Healthcare

OverlaythiswiththeUniversityIPMap

PatentsSoftwareDesigns

OtherIP

Note:PossiblecommonIPtodifferentsectors!

PatentPortfolioMapping

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 9

PatentportfoliomapofFranhaufferInstitute(https://heronscientific.com)

Morecontinuousspectrum?

ManagingIPCosts

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 10

Cannotpatentallinventionsreceived–onlydemand-based?Pre-patentmarketingofinventions-technologybriefs(Shouldyoupublishrestoftheinventionssothatotherscannotpatent?–thismayhelpincreasetheUniversityreputationanddrawattentionfromIndustryinthefuture)

Protectbycopyrights(andotherformsofIP??)–somechallengesofcopyrighting??

Managingthe“un-groupables”

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 11

ElectricityAccessRenewableEnergy

TransportationAgriculture,Horticulture,Foodprocessing,Dairy

Healthcare

PatentsSoftwareDesigns

OtherIP

Maybeahigh-valueIP?Shouldwegetasecondopinion?

MovinguptheTechnologyLevel

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 12

Investseedfundingtoadvancethetechnologytoastagewhereitcanbemarketed–industry“needssolutions,nottechnologies”Encouragestart-upsfromUniversity–theycanactastechnologydevelopersfromexternalfundingandbeboughtoutbylargecompaniesdowntheroad.

IPDonations

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 13

SolicitandmanageIPdonationsCompaniesgettaxbenefitsbypatentdonationCompaniesdonatepatentsordofree-licensing(Patentmaintenancefeesmayalsobedonated)

IPDonationbyCompanies

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 14

Company Whatwasdonated Receivedby Year

Dupont 257Patents DEDO 2007

Dupont Patentsforanewpapermakingtechnology

UniversityofMaine 2001

Dupont $64Millionworthofpatents

PennStateU.ofIowaVPI

1999

Boeing PatentsforMedicalapplications

U.Penn 2001

ProctorandGamble 196patents Vanderbilt 2000

Shell >$83.5Million U.Texas

DonationbyFree-Licensing

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 15

Company Whatwaslicensed Receivedby

Syngenta technologytoproducevitaminAenrichedrice

GoldenRicePatentPool

BoehringerIngelheim

Grantedfree-licensesofpatentscoveringaHIVdrugforaperiodof5yearstoAspenPharmacare

Aspen(SACompany)

Novartis,Roche Donotfileorenforcepatentsinleastdevelopedcountries

WatchyourownIPuse

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 16

UniversitiesshouldalsobeawareofIPuseandinfringement

Getpermissionwheneveritisnecessary–thisestablishestrustandgoodreputationandmaypreventpunitivedamages!

ManagingRisks

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 17

WhataretherisksinvolvedinIPmanagement?PrematuredisclosuresLicensingtothewrongcompanyUnder-valuationoftechnologyNon-profitableand/orunworkabledealsExclusivelicensedealswithnoreturns-shouldtheTTOstilllicensesuchIP??

Summary

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 18

SomeactionitemsforTTOtobuildandmanageIPportfolio“TechnologyMapping”GreaterRisktaking–getUniversityapprovalforthis–howdoyousharetheriskwiththecompany??Developseed-fundsforfurtherdevelopmentoftechnology–helpsbroaderclaimsinpatentsEncourageUniversityStart-upsSolicitandmanageIPdonations

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018

©S.Raghu 19

ThankYou!

Creatinga“PatentScape”(Innography.com)

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 20

https://www.innography.com/

“PatentScapes”or“TechScapes”forHealth/AgriculturalSciences?

WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 21

Area2

Area1Area3

Area7

Area6

Area4

Area8Area5

Companies

Area2Area5Area8

Start-upSpaces?