Chronic Renal Failure - Five Flavors Herbssylvanbotanical.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/CRF.pdf ·...

Chronic Renal FailureEric Yarnell, ND, RH(AHG)

2012

Abbreviations

CCl = creatinine clearanceCKD = chronic kidney diseaseCRF = chronic renal failureeGFR = estimated GFRESRD = end-stage renal diseaseGFR = glomerular filtration rateSCr = serum creatinineUSRDS = United States Renal Data System

Screening for Early CRF

• Serum Creatinine (SCr): by the time it is abnormal, it is already too late

• eGFR: same story as SCr

• Urine protein- or albumin-to-creatinine ratio: positive much earlier, need to confirm single abnormals with repeat test in 1--2 months

• Elevated urine protein or albumin is huge risk factor for CV disease anyway

1

2

3

CRF and CV Disease

• References showing urine albuminuria/proteinuria and early CRF are risks for CV disease mortality (more predictive than lipids):

• N Engl J Med 2004;351:1296–305.

• Circulation 2003;108:2154–69.

• Circulation 2002;106:777–82

When Kidneys Fail

Major Causes

• Diabetic nephropathy

• Hypertensive nephropathy

• Inflammatory/autoimmune diseases (glomerulonephritides)

If at all possible, TREAT THE CAUSE!!!

4

5

6

Epidemiology

2011 USRDS Annual Data Report

Condition US Deaths in 2006

Heart disease 629,191

Influenza 56,247

Kidney dz 44,791

Liver dz 27,299

NVSS 2008;56(16)

Pathogenesis of CRFNephron loss

Uremic toxin

buildup

Electrolyte, water

dysregulation

Endocrine dysfunction

Enzyme inhibition,

cellular toxicity

ErythropoietinCarnitine

Vitamin D

NeuropathyFatigue

AcidosisDementia

DyslipidemiaHomocysNausea

HyperkalemiaHyponatremia

HyperaldosteroneEdema

HypertensionIsosthenuria

AnemiaDyslipidemiaHypocalcemia

High phosOsteodystrophy

High PTH

7

8

9

Importance of Protein Trafficking

Renal injury with nephron loss

Glomerular capillary hypertension

Glomerular protein trafficking

Inflammatory cascade activated

Proteinuria

Ann Rev Med 2000;51:315-27

Definitions of CRF

Stage GFR Symptoms

I 60-99 ml/min* NoneII 60-99 ml/min** None

IIIa 45-59 ml/min Mild/NoneIIIb 30-44 ml/min Mild/moderate IV 15-29 ml/min ModerateV <15 ml/min Severe or on dialysis

* = SCr nl; ** = SCr elevated

Nomenclatural Morass

Pathological Syndrome

Clinical Syndrome

Hypertensive nephropathyGlomerulonephritis

Diabetic nephropathy

Asymptomatic proteinuriaChronic renal failure

10

11

12

Limits and Possibilities

Natural Medicine and CRF

• Lack of understanding of renal physiology

• Excessive focus on the liver

• Mainstream medical ignorance of what we do

• Failure to think outside the conventional box

• We can help people with CRF, have to work cooperatively (esp. patients on dialysis)

• What fear means

Things Not to Do

• Push lots of water

• Give herbal diuretics

• Give potassium-rich herbs/food without monitoring

• Promise you can cure kidney failure

• Tell people to go off dialysis

• Give in to ignorance and fear

13

14

15

Realistic Expectations

• Early disease (stage I): stabilization, improvement IF causes are removed

• Moderate disease (stages II, III): stabilization, mild improvement, difficulty removing causes thus frustration

• Severe disease (stages IV, V): progressive but delayed decline, improvement in health while on dialysis

Risk Factors for CRF

• Identical to CV disease really

• Standard American diet

• Obesity

• Smoking

• Sedentariness

• But also can be due to intrinsic kidney dz

Basic Approach to Early CRF• Identify and treat the cause(s) above all else

• Whole-food, plant-centered diet: very safe in stage I-III CRF (monitor labs stage IV); usually treats the cause.

• Consider Paleolithic diet in patients with diabetic nephropathy

• Regular exercise, stress reduction

• Nonspecific nephroprotective herbs

16

17

18

Low-Protein Diet• 0.6--0.8 g protein/kg body weight qd (most

Americans eat double this amount)

• Slows but doesn’t stop progression, which doesn’t seem all that useful as a result (Ann Intern Med 1996;124:627-32)

• A more pescovegan, legume-based approach may be superior to standard high-carb low-protein diet (Lancet 1992;339:1131-4)

• Unnecessary prior to stage IV

• Better to treat the cause specifically if possible

Renin-Angiotensin-Aldosterone System

Renin

LiverAngiotensinogen

Angiotensin I(1-10)

Angiotensin II(1-8)

Lungs

Angiotensin-convertingenzyme (ACE)

Aldosterone

stimulates

High-molecular weightKininogen

Bradykinin

Inactive

ACE

Kallikrein

Angiotensin(1-9)

Angiotensin(1-7)

ACE

ACE2

ACE2

Kidneys

Kidneys

19

20

21

ACE Inhibitors

• Reduce progression of CRF in some populations independent of lowering BP

• Most helpful in diabetic nephropathy and glomerulonephritis

• Five best studied for CRF patients: benazepril, captopril, enalapril, quinapril, ramipril

• All available generic (ramipril most expensive)

ACEi Adverse Effects

• Irritating cough (bradykinin excess; common)

• Hypotension (rare)

• Hyperkalemia (uncommon)

• Mild elevated SCr (common)

• Angioedema (rare but dangerous)

• CI in pregnancy; don’t combine with NSAIDs

Natural ACEIs• Lespedeza capitata (round-headed lespedeza)

• Crataegus spp (hawthorn)

• A$ium sativum (garlic)

• Ganoderma lucidum (reishi, ling zhi)

• Hibiscus spp (roselle)

• Do so much more than drug ACEi, milder ACEi, safer, also cheap

22

23

24

Lespedezacapitata

Planta Med 1992;58:297.

Lespedeza capitata Range

Crataegus laevigataPhytomedicine 2001;8(1):47-52.

© 2012 Yarnell

25

26

27

Ganoderma lucidum (reishi)

J Biosci Bioeng 2004;97:24-8;Chem Pharm Bull 1986;34:3025-8

© 2012 Yarnell

Hibiscus waimeae

© 2012 Yarnell

Apigenin

Kaempferol Quercetin

O

OH

OH

OOH

HO

Luteolin

O

OH O

HO

OH

OH

OH

O

OH O

HO

OH

OH

ACEi Flavonols and Flavones

Phytother Res 2007;21:32--36

O

OH O

HO

OH

28

29

30

Angiotensin Receptor Blockers

• Antagonize angiotensin II AT1 receptors

• Vasodilatory, decrease ADH & aldosterone

• Newer, more expensive

• “Me too” syndrome like ACEi (puts the lie to drug companies as innovative, see Angell Truth About the Drug Companies)

• Losartan, irbesartan, candesartan, valsartan

ARB Toxicity

• Adverse effects: orthostatic hypotension, HA, hyperkalemia, incr SCr

• Rare: neutropenia, angioedema

• May increase risk of getting cancer, without increasing mortality (Lancet Oncol 2010;11:627-36).

• Valsartan at least is a vit D blocker

• Drug interactions: NSAIDs, lithium, diuretics

Nephroprotective Herbs

31

32

33

Urticadioicaseed

Slide courtesy of Jonathan Treasure MNIMH.

Urtica seed for CRF

Slide courtesy of Jonathan Treasure MNIMH.

Urtica seed for CRF

34

35

36

Rheum palmatum

© 2012 Yarnell

© 2012 Heron Botanicals, used with permission

0

2.5

5.0

7.5

10.0

Pre-Tx Post-Tx

Daio group Control group

Creatinine Clearance with Rheum

Am J Chin Med 2003;31:267-75

SCr

Parietaria officinalis© 2012 Heron Botanicals, used with permission

37

38

39

Orthosiphon spp

© 2012 Yarnell

Hyperkalemia

Glycyrrhiza glabra

© 2012 Yarnell

40

41

42

O

CH3

HOCH3

OH

O

CH2OH

O

CH3

CH3OH

O

CH2OH

O

11B-HSD2

Cortisol Cortisone

Glycyrrhetinic acidPotassiumwasting

Kidney Int 2009;76:877-84n=10 on hemodialysis, DBPC3 mon on each tx (500 mg GA bid vs. dextrose in cookies)9 of 10 had lowered K+ on GA; 70% nl during GA vs. 24% placeboNo htn or weight gain on GA

Erythropoietin

Epoetin

• If Hgb incr. above 13 g/dl, incr. CV mortality (>50% of dialysis patients were over limit)

• Amgen and Johnson and Johnson were pushing unsafe prescribing, paying doctors to use (dose tripled from introduction in 1991 to 2001)

• Single largest drug expense for Medicare

• Synthetic alternative: darbepoietin (no better)

New York Times 9 May 2007

43

44

45

Adaptogens and Bone

• Guishao Sijunzi Tang (Four Nobles with Danggui and Paeonia) (J Tradit Chin Med 1999;19:3-9)

• Baoyuan Tang (Zhon)uo Zhong Xi Yi Jie He Za Zhi 1992;12(8):461-4, 451-2.)

• Astragalus membranaceus

• Panax ginseng

Symptom Management

• Anorexia: Swertia radiata, Mahonia aquifolium, Gentiana lutea, other bitters

• Dysgeusia: bitters

• Nausea: Zingiber officinale, Mentha x piperita, Matricaria recutita

• Dyslipidemia: Allium sativum, plant or fish essential fatty acids (esp. Perilla frutescens)

46

47

48

Case Examples

Base FormulaHerb Extract Amount

Urtica dioica seed Tincture 20-25%

Lespedeza capitata herb Tincture 20-25%

Parietaria judaica herb Tincture 15-20%

Codonopsis pilosula root Tincture 15-20%

Ceanothus gre)ii root Tincture 5-10%

Glycyrrhiza glabra root Glycerite 5-10%

Diabetic Nephropathy Case 1

0

2.5

5.0

7.5

10.0

11/1

3/02

7/30

/03

9/9/

03

4/22

/04

8/26

/04

9/23

/04

10/1

9/04

11/2

3/04

1/18

/05

2/15

/05

4/12

/05

5/15

/05

5/17

/05

6/30

/05

8/9/

05

Serum creatinine (mg/dL)Serum potassium (mmol /L)

49

50

51

0

45

90

135

180

7/30

/03

9/9/

03

4/22

/03

10/1

9/04

1/18

/05

2/15

/05

4/12

/05

6/30

/05

8/9/

05

Serum glucose (mg/dL)

Diabetic Nephropathy Case 1

Lespedeza capitata herb Tincture 23%

Parietaria judaica herb Tincture 22%

Urtica dioica seed Tincture 12%

Panax ginseng root Tincture 12%

Astragalus membr. root Tincture 10%

Rheum palmatum root Tincture 10%

Foeniculum vulgare fruit Tincture 5%

Diabetic Nephropathy Case 1

Diabetic Nephropathy Case 2

1.30

1.45

1.60

1.75

1.90

2.05

2.20

6/10 8/10 10/10 2/11

Creatinine, serum

52

53

54

Herbal FormulaCrataegus monogyna herb Glycerite 30%Fumaria officinalis herb Tincture 20%Piper methysticum root Tincture 20%

Urtica dioica seed Tincture 10%Glycyrrhiza glabra root Fluid extract 5%

Rauvolfia serpentina root Fluid extract 5%Ceanothus gre)ii root Tincture 5%

Zingiber officinale rhizome Tincture 5%

Polycystic Kidney Case

8.000

9.167

10.333

11.500

12.667

13.833

15.000

12/06 3/07 7/07 9/07

Creatinine, serum

On formula On formula

Off formula

Polycystic Kidney CaseUrtica dioica seed Tincture 25%

Lespedeza capitata herb Tincture 25%

Astragalus membr. root Glycerite 15%

Phytolacca americana root Tincture 15%

Salvia miltiorrhiza root Tincture 10%

Rheum palmatum root Tincture 10%

55

56

57

Hypertensive Nephropathy Case

0

0.475

0.950

1.425

1.900

2/26/10 3/2/10 4/22/10 5/13/10 8/10/10 3/26/11 6/6/11 8/8/11 3/26/12

SCr

Hypertensive Nephropathy CaseWithania somnifera root Tincture 20%

Ammi visnaga fruit Tincture 15%Catharanthus roseus herb Tincture 15%Crataegus monogyna herb Glycerite 12.5%

Urtica dioica seed Tincture 10%Piscidia piscipula bark Tincture 10%

Cephalotaxus fortunei seed Tincture 5%Phytolacca americana root Tincture 5%

Taxus brevifolia leaf Tincture 5%Rauvolfia serpentina root Fluid extract 2.5%

58

59