Day 14: Participatory Design - Ellie Harmonellieharmon.com/wp-content/uploads/Day-14.pdf ·...

DAY 14: PARTICIPATORY DESIGN

Winter 2014Informatics 131

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 1

QUESTIONS & COMMENTS

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 2

GOING BACK TO THE DESIGN PROCESS

Bill Moggridge

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 3

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 4

Bill Moggridge, Designing Interactions, 2007

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 5

Stanford d.school version

Formative User Research:

InterviewsObservationsCultural ProbesCollages

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 6

Image: Stanford d.school

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 7

Making sense of data & Defining a problem

PersonasMapping & Diagramming Tools

Image: Stanford d.school

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 8

Coming up with solutions

BrainstormingIdeating

Selecting

Image: Stanford d.school

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 9

Making solutions tangible

StoryboardingPrototyping

Image: Stanford d.school

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 10

Trying it out

Cognitive WalkthroughHeuristics

User EvaluationThink Aloud

Diary StudiesInterviews

Observations

Image: Stanford d.school

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 11

How does technology <x> work for people who aren’t me?

Is there something that I can change/fix/improve?

Image: Stanford d.school

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 12

Where are the users?

Image: Stanford d.school

User Research:

InterviewsObservationsCultural ProbesCollages

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 13

Image: Stanford d.school

User Research:

InterviewsObservationsCultural ProbesCollages

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 14

Trying it out

Cognitive WalkthroughHeuristics

User EvaluationThink Aloud

Diary StudiesInterviews

Observations

Image: Stanford d.school

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 15

User Proxies:

personas, storyboards, user stories, research data,

personal memories, market statistics

Image: Stanford d.school

User Research:

InterviewsObservationsCultural ProbesCollages

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 16

Trying it out

Cognitive WalkthroughHeuristics

User EvaluationThink Aloud

Diary StudiesInterviews

Observations

User Proxies:

personas, storyboards, user stories, research data,

personal memories, market statistics

Image: Stanford d.school

PARTICIPATORY DESIGN A Brief Overview

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 17

User Research:

InterviewsObservationsCultural ProbesCollages

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 18

Trying it out

Cognitive WalkthroughHeuristics

User EvaluationThink Aloud

Diary StudiesInterviews

Observations

User Proxies:

personas, storyboards, user stories, research data,

personal memories, market statistics

Image: Stanford d.school

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 19

Image: Stanford d.school

PARTICIPATORY DESIGN?

“a human-centered approach advocating active user and stakeholder engagement throughout all phases of the research and design process, including co-design activities.”

-- Universal Methods of Design

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 20

PD HISTORY: DEMOCRACY

Political aspect reflected in titles of conferences: Systems Design For, With, and By the Users “government of the people, by the people, for the

people” – Abraham Lincoln

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 21

PD HISTORY: ROOTS IN PLACE & TIME

Europe & Scandinavia, 1970sConnected to workplace democracy movementOften involved labor unions – bringing ‘workers’ into workplace IT decisions

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 22

WHAT WAS HAPPENING IN THE 1970S & 80S?

Remember the history readings from week 1?

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 23

1988; 1989

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 24

PD QUESTIONS & CONCERNS

Is it inevitable that technology be applied in ways that constrain, deskill, and devalue human work? Must we always analyze the impact of technology on people, or is there just as strong an impact of people on technology? Is improving peoples' working conditions less important than having cutting edge technology?

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 25

Michael J. Muller and Sarah Kuhn. 1993. Participatory design. Communications of the ACM 36, 6 (June 1993), 24-28. http://doi.acm.org/10.1145/153571.255960

PD QUESTIONS & CONCERNS

Are there ways of designing jobs (and technologies to support jobs) to combine heightened productivity with human growth, challenge, and a high quality of work life for the people who hold those jobs? Is democracy valuable only outside the workplace? Can software professionals recognize and affirm the validity of perspectives other than their own, and value the expertise that comes from experience, not just the knowledge that is attested by academic credentials?

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 26

Michael J. Muller and Sarah Kuhn. 1993. Participatory design. Communications of the ACM 36, 6 (June 1993), 24-28. http://doi.acm.org/10.1145/153571.255960

NEWLY RELEVANT TODAY?

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 27

WISDOM 2.0 IN SF

Technology is moving closer to the body.

Can we remain in control?

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 28

Gopi KallayilChief EvangelistBrand Marketing for Google

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 29

Image: Stanford d.school

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 30

Michael J. Muller and Sarah Kuhn. 1993. Participatory design. Communications of the ACM 36, 6 (June 1993), 24-28. http://doi.acm.org/10.1145/153571.255960

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 31

http://www.maketools.com/articles-papers/PDC2010ExploratoryFrameworkFinal.pdf

A Framework for Organizing the Tools and Techniques of Participatory Design.

Elizabeth B.-N. Sanders, Eva Brandt &Thomas Binder

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 32

Image: Stanford d.school

PARTICIPATORY DESIGN For Ideation

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 33

Harnessing People’s Creativity: Ideation and Expression Through Visual Communication

Elizabeth B-N Sanders & Colin William

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 34

PD METHODS

SAY methods Focus groups Verbal communication

DO methods Applied ethnography Observation

MAKE methods Elicit creative expression

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 35

PD METHODS

SAY methods Focus groups Verbal communication

DO methods Applied ethnography Observation

MAKE methods Elicit creative expression

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 36

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 37

Image: Stanford d.school

TOOLS BEFORE A MEETING

WorkbooksDiariesCameras

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 38

TOOLS AT A MEETING

CollagesCognitive Mapping (+ other maps)Velcro ModelingPlay doughMarkers, templates, erasersSketching

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 39

DESIGN CHARETTE

Small groups of threeSketch for 10 minutesPresent best ideas to whole roomMix up groups & repeat, building on previous ideas

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 40

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 41

DESIGN WORKSHOP

Begin with presentation of what you knowFacilitate group sharing of new ideas Affinity diagrams, with post it notes Through collages With play dough

Present to each other & build on ideas

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 42

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 43

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 44

https://libjournal.uncg.edu/index.php/jls/article/view/503/383

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 45

Image: Stanford d.school

For Tuesday

Do something helpful for your projectBe creative

The Wow! Factor.

SKETCHES Week 7!

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 46

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 47

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 48

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 49

2014-02-20 ELLIE HARMON / INFORMATICS 131: INTRO TO HCI 50