EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE 2011- European Commission WORKSHOP ON EU LEGISLATION WASTE © 2010 Microsoft...

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

WORKSHOP ON EU LEGISLATION

WASTE

© 2010 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.

The EU Waste Shipment Regulation

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission 2

Outline

1. Introduction: waste management in the EU; facts on waste shipments

2. International and European law on waste shipments

3. Scope, legal basis and structure of Regulation (EC) No 1013/2006

4. The new control system: prohibition, notification or information

5. The system of annexes and waste lists

6. Objections to shipments of waste

7. Other key instruments

8. Export of green-listed waste for recovery

9. Implementation problems and current points of discussion

10. How to get more information

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Introduction: waste management in the EU

• Almost all waste for disposal is disposed of within the EU.• Differing recycling quotas: 50% and more in Central Europe, less than 10%

in most new Member States (2005).• Waste incineration (with or without energy recovery) in Central Europe and

Scandinavia; landfilling dominant in new Member States, UK, Ireland, Greece and Italy.

• Quadrupling of notified waste streams within EU 1997-2005, mostly for recovery: „recycling economy“.

• Multiplication of waste paper, plastics and scrap exports 1998-2008, mostly to Asia.

• Most used electronic goods + cars from EU probably end up in Africa + Asia.

3

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Waste shipments (1)

4

Shipments of notified waste from EU Member States to other EU and non-EU countries, 1997-2005

(Source: EEA Report „Waste without borders in the EU?“, 2009)

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Waste shipments (2)

5

Source: EEA Report „Waste without borders in the EU“, 2009

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Waste shipments (3)

6

Source: EEA Report „Waste without borders in the EU“, 2009

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

International and European law on waste shipments

7

UNEP OECD EU

Basel Convention

Decision C(2001)107

Final Reg. (EC)1013/2006

Reg. (EC) 1418/2007

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Structure of Regulation (EC) No. 1013/2006

• Title I (Art. 1-2): Scope and definitions• Title II (Art. 3-32): Shipments within the EU• Title III (Art. 33): Internal shipments in Member States• Title IV (Art. 34-40): Exports from EU to third countries• Title V (Art. 41-46): Imports into the EU• Title VI (Art. 47-48): Transit• Title VII (Art. 49-64): Other provisions

8

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Scope and legal basis

Scope • Shipments between Member States, export from EU, import, transit;

not within a Member State!• Except waste under special rules: ship-generated waste, „on board

vehicles“, radioactive w., animal by-products etc. (Art. 1(3) WSR)

Legal basis• EP and Council: Art. 175(1) EC only (= now Art. 192 TFEU).• Challenged by Commission: dual basis (Art. 175 and 133 EC).• ECJ of 8.9.2009 (C-411/06): action dismissed; aim environmental

not commercial, unlike Reg. 304/2003 (cases C-94/03, 178/03).

9

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

The new control system: Prohibition, notification or information

• „Basel Ban“ since 1998: no export of hazardous waste (+ waste for disposal) to non-OECD countries; Art. 36 WSR

• Notification procedure for shipments of hazardous waste, waste for disposal + certain other wastes in EU/OECD + of „green“ waste to others (where so provided); Art. 3(1), 4, 37, 38 WSR

• Information requirements for other green waste;Art. 3(2), 18 WSR

10

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Notification procedure (1)

11

NotifierCompetent Authority

(CA) of dispatch

applies for consent + submits notification + movement documents, contract, financial guarantee …

assesses sufficiency + forwards documents within 3 days and informs notifier

CA of destination

CA of transit

Original notification

copy

- if not sufficient, demands completion

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Notification procedure (2)

12

assesses notification + decides within 30 days:

- written consent with or without conditions

- objections

no objection of CA of transit = tacit consent

CA CA CACA of destination

CA of transit

Notifier

requests additional info or acknowledges notification within 3 days, informs other CAs

CA of dispatch

supplies additional info

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Information procedure (Art. 18 WSR)

13

Waste shipmentto be accompanied by

Annex VII document

Contract

Person who arranges the

shipmentsigns

Recovery facility / consignee

CA CA CA

may inspect

+

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

The system of annexes and waste lists• Annexes IA + IB: Notification document, movement document

• Annex IC: Specific instructions for completing the documents

• Annex II: Information + documentation related to notification

• Annex III: Green-listed waste (subject only to info requirements)

• Annex IIIA: Green waste mixtures (pending Basel decision)

• Annex IV: Amber-listed waste (subject to notification)

• Annex V: Basel lists (export prohibition yes or no) + European Waste List

• Annex VI: Form for pre-consented facilities

• Annex VII: Information document accompanying green waste shipments

• Annex VIII: Guidelines on environmentally sound management

• Annex IX: Additional questionnaire for Member State reports

14

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Objections to shipments of waste - Grounds for objection (1)

15

Shipments for disposal (Art. 11)

• Principles of proximity, priority for recovery and self-sufficiency• National legislation on environmental protection, public

order/safety, health protection (related to actions in objecting country)

• Bad record of notifier/consignee• Import ban for hazardous waste under Basel Convention• Conflict with international conventions• Violation of Directive 2006/12/EC (e.g. waste management plan)• Failure to apply best available techniques (IPPC Directive)• Violation of binding EU environmental protection standards • Mixed municipal waste from private households

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Grounds for objection (2)

16

Shipments for recovery (Art. 12) • Violation of Directive 2006/12/EC (e.g. waste management plan)• National legislation on environmental protection, public

order/safety, health protection (related to actions in objecting country)

• Lower treatment standards at destination (unless EU legislation etc)

• Bad record of notifier/consignee• Conflict with international conventions• Doubtfulness of recovery (ratio of recoverable waste etc.)• Failure to apply best available techniques (IPPC Directive)• Violation of binding EU environmental protection standards /

recycling obligations

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Other key instruments

Simplified arrangements:• General notification for several shipments (Art. 13)• Pre-consented recovery facilities (Art. 14)• Border-area agreements (Art. 30)

Enforcement tools:• Financial guarantee (Art. 6)• Take-back obligations (Art. 22-25)• Effective, proportionate + dissuasive penalties for infringements (Art. 50.1)• Inspections of establishments, spot checks on shipments (Art. 50.2-4)• Duties of cooperation + information; correspondents, focal points,

designated authorities (Art. 50-57)

17

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Exports of green-listed wastes for recoveryTo OECD-Decision countries (Art. 38):• Information requirements apply mutatis mutandis.• Notification procedure for shipments of waste mixtures for interim operations, if

subsequent operations take place in non-OECD states

To non-OECD Decision countries (Art. 36, 37):• Commission has asked non-OECD countries about their import rules.• Answers incorporated in Regulation (EC) No 1418/2007 as amended.• 4 alternatives: (a) prohibition, (b) prior written notification and consent,

(c) no control, (d) other control procedures under national law• For (c) and (d) EU information requirements apply mutatis mutandis.

18

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Implementation problems and current points of discussion

• Illegal or dubious shipments to Africa and Asia, also due to difficult distinction waste/non-waste for electrical goods + vehicles („When does waste begin to be waste?“).

• Very different control standards in the Member States – distortion of competition.

• „Lower standards“ objections vs. free trade / internal market.• „Bureaucratic“ information procedure; confidentiality problem with

Annex VII document.• Need of a business address for notifiers in the state of dispatch.• Responsibility for take-back and costs in certain cases.

19

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

Measures to improve implementation

• Action Plan of the Commission (to be adopted)• Better cooperation: IMPEL-TFS, regular high-level meetings• Correspondents‘ Guidelines• Awareness-raising events• Infringement proceedings as last resort• Binding criteria for waste shipment inspections?• EU implementation agency for waste shipments?

20

EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE

2011- European Commission

How to get more information

Internet links• EU Commission: http://ec.europa.eu/environment/waste/shipments/• FAQ on the EU Waste Shipment Regulation:

http://ec.europa.eu/environment/waste/shipments/pdf/faq.pdf • Commission reports on implementation of the WSR; feasibility study

on EU waste implementation agency: http://ec.europa.eu/environment/waste/shipments/reports.htm http://ec.europa.eu/environment/waste/pdf/report_waste_dec09.pdf

• Secretariat of the Basel Convention: http://www.basel.int/ • IMPEL-TFS: http://impeltfs.eu/

21