View
224
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
1/27
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
2/27
2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
REPORT OVERVIEW
2
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
3/27
2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
REPORTO
VERVIEW
About the Study
In June 2009 Real Results Marketing and Al Dente Marketing partnered to study marketing spend and tactics during the recession. This
report details our survey results question by question, as well as offers respondent verbatims.
This study, in conjunction with secondary research and first hand interviews with executives growing their companies during the recession,
was used to form Eat the Stunned a comprehensive presentation highlighting observations and implications for marketing success in the
recession.
Eat the Stunned was first delivered at the Business Marketing Associations Annual National Conference on June 12, 2009 and will be
available in upcoming webinars and onsite workshops. For more information and dates, please contact the researchers.
Survey Administration & Report Details
1. Survey administered between June 2-8, 2009
2. Distributed to:
Marketing Executive Networking Group (MENG), an
association of current and former Marketing Vice
Presidents worldwide
Opt-In news subscribers of the researchers
newsletters
LinkedIn network
3. 188 marketers responded
4. Snapshot of marketing spend and tactics to manage
through and drive growth where possible during therecession
5. Includes complete results including selected and
representative verbatim comments.
Raw data may be made available to interested parties wishing to
conduct their own analysis.
What To Expect
This report offers the reader summary data for each question, aswell as visuals to better illustrate the findings.
Due to the overwhelming number of verbatim comments,selected and representative quotes highlight and reinforcenumerical findings.
The researchers would like to thank all those who participated inthe study and hope you find the information useful in your questfor marketing excellence.
Enjoy!
Ian G. Heller Andy Martin
Real Results Marketing Al Dente Marketing
3
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
4/27
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
5/27
2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
S1-3
1) Are you spending MORE on marketing, LESS on marketing or about
the same on marketing in 2009 vs. 2008? [n=184]
2) Please indicate how much more you are spending on marketing in
2009 vs. 2008. [n=41]
3) Please indicate how much LESS you are spending on marketing in
2009 vs. 2008. [n=71]
There is a 60% gap between the average DECREASE of companies
spending LESS vs. the average INCREASE of companies spending
MORE on marketing.
Observation
Only 42% of respondents indicated their organization is spending
less on marketing in 09 vs. 08.
Observation
5
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
6/27
2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
4
4) Please indicate how your 2009 OVERALL SALES have changed vs.2008. Choose the answer that best represents your situation. It's okayto estimate. [n=160] 1. We are in the affluent client banking industry and sales are
down -15% mainly due to investment losses.
2. We are a private lender and capital is very tight.
3. My business segment is represented almost exclusively by
small-to-medium sized businesses. Some have posted strong
growth results, but a majority are struggling with this
economy.
4. The home building industry has seen a significant decline in
both new builds and remodeling is just starting to increase.
5. Our business has seen a decline in capital projects. As a result,we are experiencing modest growth on the maintenance side
of the model.
6. Some clients have reduced our fees by x% in lieu of
discontinuing our services.
7. We are seeing organic volume with existing customers
decline, but have been able to offset with new business.
8. Spending 200% more time on marketing, 70% less in dollars.
9. Sales are new money investments but also recurring revenue
is tied to the stock market so that source of revenue is down
36%.
10. Sales isn't the issue. Retention is.
Verbatim Comments
Observation
Sharp sales declines are common, with more than -25% the
most frequent response.
6
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
7/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
4(CONTINUED)
Verbatim Comments (continued)
11. We focus on mid-cap clients and they have reduced spending
in many cases much more substantially. We have gained some
new clients to mitigate the revenue per client.
12. We think the increased marketing has minimized sales losses,
even though the economy stinks.
13. February and March were brutal. I lost all of my clients. Since
then I've engaged with 3 new clients, I'm close to deals on
four other clients, and I'm also re-engaging with two of my
past clients.
14. Our sales come from a biennial tradeshow. It's interesting to
note overall booth sales were approximately 10% higher than
our previous event in 2007 ... BUT ... these increased sales
came from approximately 50 fewer exhibiting companies.
15. Our business is in agriculture, specifically post harvest
agricultural chemicals for disease control. Farmers are more
focused on saving as much of their crop as possible because of
their return from the increased price of food to the consumer.
16. Many customers in new home construction have had drasticlay offs or have gone out of business directly affecting my
business. Framers, Drywallers, electricians, etc.
17. Gross sales (initial applications for product purchase) are up,
net sales (those that can obtain financing after desiring the
product) are down about 5%.
18. Weak demand across the entire IT spectrum, especially for
hardware (servers, storage, PC's, et). Only bright spot is in
services (IT consulting & management). Capital budgets for IT
have either been drastically cut or severely scaled back.
19. I have several clients with whom work had dried up almostcompletely. Fortunately they have been replaced by several
steady gigs. I have had to branch out into areas I hadn't
worked in before, though.
20. As a marketing consultant I am working on less pieces of
business, but the size of project has increased.
7
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
8/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
5
5) Please indicate how your 2009 marketing expenditures haveINCREASED or DECREASED for STAFF. [n= 127 to 134]
1. Hiring freeze on consultants.
2. Most have remained steady although we added to the
retainer of one of our outsourced sales consultants.
3. We have not used telemarketing very much in the past...but
plan to begin to use it more in 2009 and beyond.
4. increase in public seminars
5. We are not replacing people who leave and we are looking for
interns and temporary labor in the peak season.
6. Created strategic alliances with nearby competitors to co-market non-competitive products.
7. Used to have full-time webmaster, now we outsource web
development. Used to have a PR agency, now we use a PR
consultant. Built out new inside sales team (previously we had
no inside sales).
8. In my small business no change. As President of a non-profit
we have for the first time in 10 years hired a marketing
consultant to help with our promotional events.
9. Over 50% of the Corporate Marketing staff have been
eliminated. A large shift has gone into lowering fixed costs and
shifting more dollars into variable cost programs. (Less
expensive headcount, off-shoring, etc).
Verbatim Comments
Observation
Almost half of respondents are not changing staffing levels with a
slight overall bias to reductions.
Consultants appear to be suffering the most cutbacks.
.8
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
9/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
6
Observation
Some bias towards spending more on internet marketing. Biggest
change is in email marketing.
6) Please indicate how your 2009 marketing expenditures have INCREASED or DECREASED for INTERNET MARKETING, including social media. [n=137]
9
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
10/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
6(CONTINUED)
Verbatim Comments
1. Doing a lot more with LinkedIn.
2. More email newsletters.
3. Internet Marketing is all we do. Launching blog in one month.
4. Social Media expenditures is really an expense of "time" vs
"money.
5. Started using a company for SEO organic search. Using lead
nurturing program called Market2Lead for nurture campaigns.
Chief Strategy Officer has blog and podcast (launched in '08).
Don't currently do banner ads or webinars (trying to jump
start webinar program).
6. bigger push towards online
7. we have increased staff time devoted to social media, but not
really any dollar outlay... we have increased both staff time
AND dollars to e-mail marketing.
8. We are doing a lot more in social media but it isn't costing any
more.
9. Using more web seminars for lead gen.
10. Our use of the Social Media has increased, but at no additional
cost.
11. Virtually the entire budget focus is on "digital" and "social
media".
12. Will be adding webinars 3Q 2009.
13. Actually, planning to do webinars for the b2b segment.
Haven't done it yet, and budget is not yet approved, but
appears to be likely.
10
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
11/27
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
12/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
7(CONTINUED)
Verbatim Comments
1. Participating in a few more local shows.
2. Drop in expenditure not necessarily in delivery - prices are
down
3. We are using blast faxing.
4. Don't do any 'traditional' media. Will start going to some
tradeshows this year.
5. Skipping NAB, NATPE, CTIA, E3, and CES this year. Cutting
budgets for all other advertising by 1/2 for 09.
6. Traditional media still focused on events/tradeshows (we havea small budget so can't afford anything else).
7. Traditional media not used much. cut back on presenting at
big industry tradeshow, "what's the return? Most
competition also dropped out also.
8. Increased speaking at industry events.
9. For the non-profit we were the recipient of a $100,000 grant.
We are using it for PSA's on cycling safety. We also purchased
commercial time for these same ads. We never used television
before.
10. All forms of traditional media have been cut, some more thanothers. In cases where cuts have not been made outright,
shifts in funding have been made from traditional media to
digital media.
11. Event and tradeshows took a big hit - this is a primary
opportunity for reaching new and existing clients in the b2b
segment. However, the high price tag was deemed
unnecessary and many tradeshows and events that were not
spent or committed have been cut for Mar-Dec.
12
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
13/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
8
8) Please indicate how you are allocating resources in 2009 forMARKET RESEARCH & ANALYSIS. [n=136]
1. It's all in the data. We just have to define, track, and gain
better understanding of the results. Gotta get faster at failing
so we can do it less expensively and move along and find the
successes.
2. We are a marketing research and strategy firm. So, ourinclination is to expand in these areas anyway, but our clients
have demanded it.
3. Sadly, virtually all of the metric programs have either been
drastically cut or eliminated all together.
4. Working with sales team to show value of spend is very
important.
Verbatim Comments
Observation
Most marketers are not cutting resources for market research and
analysis.
13
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
14/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
9
9) Please indicate how you are allocating resources in 2009 forPRODUCT AND SERVICE DEVELOPMENT. [n=136]
1. Spending a lot of time on the product. Making an investment
where our competition can't.
2. We have recently expanded our operation to capture more of
the repair business.
3. We are developing new products or enhancing old products to
match the market...more "right-sizing", turnaround, re-
financing, etc.
4. Purchased a managed service provider early 2009 and are
currently building out our managed services offering (more
affordable than installing products in-house, security expertise
not required, etc.)
5. Wrapping more services around existing clients.
6. For the non-profit we have started a membership drive and
are offering incentives for bringing in new members.
Verbatim Comments
Observation
Only about 15% of respondents are cutting resources for new
product and service development. About 3X as many respondents
are increasing resources in these areas.
14
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
15/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
10
10) Please indicate how your distribution strategy and channels havechanged in 2009. [n=131]
1. More social media, community outreach.
2. Using contract sales agent for cold-calling, lead generation.
3. Added services offering that's piped directly through the
channel.
4. Investigating online sales.
5. We have added more customized IP.
6. We added a new service line sold through e-commerce and
distributors.
Verbatim Comments
Observation
Major increased focus on number of products and services,
selling direct to customers and online sales.
15
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
16/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
11
Observation
As would be expected, lots of focus on broad categories such as
Current and New.
Niche and Green more commonly targeted.
Not much activity towards Government and Stimulus targets.
11) Please indicate how your customer targeting has changed in 2009. [n=131]
Verbatim Comments
1. Higher focus on immigrants - Asian, South Asian.
2. The non-profit is expanding our contacts and trying to get our
brand out there.
3. Working to get a broader base of software as service and
broader into manufacturing sales.
16
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
17/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
12
12) Please indicate how your pricing tactics have changed due toeconomic pressures in 2009. We are: [n=127]
1. Price structure remains fairly constant....trying to "add value"
in other ways.
2. Larger discounts if customers purchase more than one of our
products.
3. Reduced fee increases on renewals for clients who are
stressed financially (B to B).
4. Lowered prices for multiple engagements. Share more
information on how pricing is done versus just a project cost.
5. Packaging/bundling services. Pilot program, same services,
fewer keywords=package.
6. Maximizing each current relationship through cross-selling at
many touch points - online, direct mail, etc.
Verbatim Comments
Observation
Marketers are meeting competitors prices and improving value
propositions to be more competitive.
17
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
18/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
13
Observation
Overall pricing has remained stable with a slight bias towards
discounting.
13) Please indicate how your 2009 OVERALL PRICING has changed. Choose the answer that best represents your situation. It's okay to estimate. [n=129]
18
1. Based on our reputation in the current (repair) market, we
have only changed our pricing to reflect cost of living. In the
new product market and as a manufacturer's rep, we are at
the mercy of the factory.
2. COGS have been reduced significantly. resulting in significant
GP% increases, on lower physical volume and lower salesvolume.
3. Moving more and more towards software subscription based
pricing as software budgets are moving to operational
budgeting from capital budgets.
4. pricing is holding firm, and we are offering more
package pricing options
Verbatim Comments
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
19/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
14
14) In my opinion, the economy is: [n=130]
1. We're not experiencing any backslash due to the crisis. Our
globe is the market and we're still penetrating lots of
countries through the Web.
2. Will get worse before any turn-around.
3. Specifically aviation and aerospace is going to move into
decline in 2010.
4. I believe we are approaching the bottom - but it's going to be
a long bottom.
5. A month ago the fire hose was turned on.
6. The tax climate will further dampen profits. Increased
regulation and government mandates will mitigate US position
in a global economy. Lay-offs will continue and will mute
returning consumer enthusiasm. This creates a downward
cycle as the realization of the significance of government debt
is increasingly recognized and manifested in inflation. More
pressure to raise taxes. More downward pressure on
consumer spending. Keynes' theories are dead but our
government officials obviously did not attend the funeral.
7. Believe it bottomed out a few months ago but the effect won't
be felt for several months to come.
8. Was improving, prior to GM bankruptcy.
Verbatim Comments
Observation
64% believe the economy is either improving, or not getting any
worse.
19
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
20/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
15
Observation
47.5% of respondents believe improvement in the US economybegan or will begin before Dec. 2009. 82.5% believe the
improvement will have begun by June, 2010.
15) In my opinion, the US economy began to improve or will improve: [n=130]
20
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
21/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
15(CONTINUED
)
Verbatim Comments
1. Commercial property is now struggling. Access to stimulus
money for small businesses is not happening. Commercial
credit is not available. With the banks, insurance companies
(AIG), and now the car companies in trouble, and state
funding to cities and counties slashed, it is going to take some
time to stabilize and regain consumer trust.
2. We will recover from capitalism to enter into a new era of
socialism....comrade.
3. What if it won't improve at all for five to ten years?
4. Everyone I speak to is having a rough year....and I feel, it's
going to get far worse before it gets better. Remember the old
adage......."As GM goes, so goes America!
5. When a new Congress is elected and there is a balance of
power between Liberals and Conservatives
6. Not until the bailout money trickles through the system and
auto makers are dissolved as they are pending.
7. I feel the impact of the bailout of the auto-industry will holdthe US economy down through the remainder of 2009.
8. Consumers are showing signs of life - although with altered
habits. I think we're going to need to see more consistent
gains on Wall St. to make all the 401K owners feel like it's ok
to spend again. I think this will likely happen when some of
the $8 trillion that was removed from the action begins to
come back into play - Q2 2010.
9. Budgets have been cut for 2009 and are not coming back in
the year for btb world.
10. Companies are getting used to slower sales and they are
starting to invest for the recovery so they are not left behind.
11. Unfortunately, I feel as though the current up-tick in attitude
is a false feeling. With the GM and other bailouts and theastronomical, crushing national debt, we are in for more
difficult economic times.
12. I feel the impact of the bailout of the auto-industry will hold
the US economy down through the remainder of 2009.
13. Americans get tired of being pessimistic.
21
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
22/27 2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
16
16) [Optional, open ended question only] Please tell us your advice for marketers who are trying to drive revenue and profit growth during the
recession and prepare for the upcoming economic turnaround. [n=54]
1. Partnerships, cooperative marketing, joint marketing
efforts...all to maximize efficiency.
2. Stick to fundamentals. Know your customer base. Get out in
the field more. Don't forget to define longer term strategyduring these difficult times.
3. As one of my clients put it, "we do not acknowledge that there
is a recession.
4. Stop wringing your hands and get out there, understand what
the current needs are and find ways to reconfigure your
expertise to serve those needs. Think about helping others
out of their difficulties with cost-effective expert solutions andsmart products.
5. Stick to the tried and true basics. Make sure your brand is
relevant and differentiated. Be open and transparent. Engage
in and build communities. Make sure you clearly understand
what your customers WANT and VALUE from you. Make sure
value is well understood and clearly communicated (value is
not always low/lowest price).
6. 1. Spend more not less on sales teams. 2. Add more value
added and DIFFERENTIATED services/products which
command a higher revenue and margin. 3. Cut every ounce of
fat - even excess WebEx accounts!
7. Targeting specific audiences makes sense and does lift
response to your offer.
8. Invest to grow share now to leverage up turn. Accept lower
margins but avoid "price" brand label. Improve channelpartnerships.
9. Hang in there. Get the great value for reasonable price
message out there. Don't dwell on the bad or current state of
the economy, go for basics and bright future. Keep costs in
line.
10. Never stop prospecting for new products, services and new
customers that fit your ideal customer. Don't try to beeverything to everyone. Drive clarity on your competitive
advantages and how they help your customers improve their
performance.
11. It is the best time to grow market share as most competitors
cutback in recessions. You can buy more media so a double
whammy - more media for the $ with less competition
marketing against you.
12. Seek out opportunities for new products and services to niche
markets. Identify new opportunities for application of your
core competencies in new market niches.
22
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
23/27
2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
QUESTION
16(CONTINUED
)
16) [Optional, open ended question only] (continued)
13. Focus on these keys: Creating leads to drive sales. Do it as
inexpensively as possible. Measure marketing effectiveness
versus sales. Cut anything that does not lead to sales in 18
months.
14. We're spending less and focusing our remaining resourcesmore on high potential customers and prospects. Good
customer targeting and segmentation strategies can deliver
strong returns on smaller investments. And by cultivating
these valuable customers/prospects now, we'll have a
stronger base from which to build when things do turn
around.
15. Understand the meaning of "value" to your current customer.
Value is not just price, be sensitive to the 4 P's - right productat the right price in the right place properly promoted.
16. Differentiate as much as possible. Drive attention to cost /
energy savings. Farm existing accounts hard for incremental
revenue. Leverage web presence.
17. Understand customers. Focus on communities. Personalize
customer experience. Integrate channels. Expand internet
channels. Grow value-add services. Measure - focus on ROI.Stop "spray and pray" spending on marketing - Start
knowledge-based marketing investment.
18. Now is not the time to cut back on advertising and marketing.
do not lower prices but ad value to what you are doing. Those
who live by price will die by price
19. Concentrate on key customer needs and provide
products/services to meet those needs. Cut out the noise andconcentrate on the core. Don't settle for second place.
Develop new products with customers. Get wrapped into
customer workflow hang on tight & be resourceful!
20. Learn from history -- now is the time to strike! Understand the
meaning of "value" to your current customer. Value is not just
price, be sensitive to the 4 P's - right product at the right price
in the right place properly promoted.
21. Measure. Measure. Measure. Wouldn't invest in anything
without a clear metric for success. Use and expand your
measurement capability and make it a core value-add to
customers you sell to.
22. Increased market penetration thru research (analytics) and
customer contact (touches).
23
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
24/27
2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
RESPONDENT PROFILES
24
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
25/27
2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
RESPONDENTPROFILES
17) My company is primarily: [n=128]
20) My company's total number of employees is: {n=126]
19) My company's approximate annual marketing budget is: [n=126]
18) My company's approximate annual revenues are: [n=126]
25
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
26/27
2009 Real Results Marketing & Al Dente Marketing. All rights reserved.
ABOUT US
26
8/14/2019 Marketing in a Recession (Survey Results)
27/27
ABOUTUS
About Us
Real Results Marketing is a consulting firm specializing in strategic planning, marketing planning, sales force optimization and market
intelligence and research. We have a core of consultants located in Boulder, Orlando, Miami and Los Angeles and we regularly engage
exceptional independent contractors as needed by our clients.
Founded in 2003, Real Results Marketing has helped dozens of clients improve their business results by applying cutting-edge analytics, a
sound, process-based approach to business solutions and the experience of our thoroughly-trained and classically educated consultants.
Al Dente Marketing is a high-octane marketing consulting firm providing solutions that ignite aggressive revenue and profit growth.
Everything we do is geared to help clients sell more, to more customers, more often. We recognize that results matter, and the rest while
interesting, is academic. As our name implies, Al Dente provides just the right amount of analysis, innovation and execution to drive
performance.
Our expertise comes from our ability to adapt world-class, Fortune 500 techniques to entrepreneurial and mid-sized firms. We are not
career consultants. Our marketing and insights practitioners have track records of building brands, products, and services to create
breakthrough outcomes across diverse industries and cultures. We have been in your shoes, delivered results and know how to win.
Real Results Marketing
Ian Heller
Senior Partner
Ian@RealResultsMarketing.com
Direct: (720) 565-3071
Mobile: (720) 470-0806
Real Results Marketing
PO Box 19315
Boulder, CO 80308
www.RealResultsMarketing.com
Al Dente Marketing
Andy Martin
President
AMartin@AlDenteMarketing.com
Direct: (407) 578-6247
Mobile: (407) 617-8148
Al Dente Marketing
1800 Pembrook Dr, Suite 300
Orlando, FL 32810
www.AlDenteMarketing.com
27
http://www.realresultsmarketing.com/http://www.aldentemarketing.com/http://www.aldentemarketing.com/http://www.realresultsmarketing.com/Recommended