Observation vs. Inference - L. Frazier Banks Middle …...How do observations and inferences differ?...

Preview:

Citation preview

Observation vs. Inference

• Observation – Anything you can see, hear, smell, touch, taste, (Using your senses).

• Observation Basics.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Observation Basics.

– Our perceptions are not photographs, they are constructions - something that our minds manufacture.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Observation Basics.

– Our perceptions are not photographs, they are constructions - something that our minds manufacture.

– What we perceive is partially determined by what we know or believe.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Observation Basics.

– Our perceptions are not photographs, they are constructions - something that our minds manufacture.

– What we perceive is partially determined by what we know or believe.

– Constructive perception has survival value - it helps us make sense of the world.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Observation Basics.

– Our perceptions are not photographs, they are constructions - something that our minds manufacture.

– What we perceive is partially determined by what we know or believe.

– Constructive perception has survival value - it helps us make sense of the world.

– So, seeing is not necessarily believing.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

Do these red lines bend?

• Video Link! Amazing Anamorphic Illusions

– http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tBNHPk-Lnkk

• Please write down the phrase that you will see on the next slide? You get just a second.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

Mary had

had a little lamb

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

“Write down what it said in your journal?”

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

“Did your brain act faster than

your eyes?”

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

Mary had

had a little lamb

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

Mary had

had a little lamb

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

Mary had

had a little lamb

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

Our brains are programmed for normal right side-up.

Remember…

• An observation is the act of gathering information by using your senses

• Observation Basics.

– Our perceptions are not photographs, they are constructions - something that our minds manufacture.

– What we perceive is partially determined by what we know or believe.

– Constructive perception has survival value - it helps us make sense of the world.

– So, seeing is not necessarily believing.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

What is an inference?

• An inference is the process of drawing a conclusion from given evidence.

Catalyst: Look at the following picture. What is happening? Write a short paragraph/story

about what you think happened.

So for the Catalyst…

• Possible observations might be:- there are two sets of tracks- one set of tracks is smaller than the other- the two sets of tracks meet - only one set of tracks is visible after the two sets meet

So, for the Catalyst…

• Possible inferences might be:- two animals were walking toward one another- the animals had a fight- the bigger animal ate the smaller animal

How do observations and inferences differ?

• An observation is only what you can actually see, smell, taste, touch or hear

• An inference is what you decide based on those observations

Why Is It So Important to Differentiate Between Observations and Inferences?

• In science, we need to base our hypotheses and experiments on facts and observations

• If we base our hypotheses and experiments on opinions or inferences, we can never prove anything!

• Science is based on facts and observations, not INFERENCES! However, your inferences could help guide future experimentation.

• Activity! How well do you observe the world around you.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Activity! How well do you observe the world around you.

– Observe the scene for 1 minute and then answer some questions afterward.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions about the previous scene.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the street scene.

–How many vehicles were driving?

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the street scene.

–How many vehicles were driving?

• Two were driving, two were parked.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the street scene.

–What type of vehicles were they?

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the street scene.

–What type of vehicles were they?

• Utility van with no labels and small 4 door SUV.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the street scene.

–What colors were they?

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the street scene.

–What colors were they?

• Utility van was white, SUV was dark blue

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the street scene.

–Was it raining?

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the street scene.

–Was it raining?

–Answer: No. But the SUV’s wipers were on, conditions were overcast and the SUV could have just possibly come from the rain or driven through a sprinkler.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

Inference

• Questions for the street scene.

–What was the speed limit?

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the street scene.

–What was the speed limit?

• 35 mph

• What country is this picture in?

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the street scene.

–What was the speed limit?

• 35 mph

• What country is this picture in?

• The United States most likely because 35 mph is not Metric. The U.S. is one of the few countries to use the Old English System.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

Inference

• Questions for the street scene.

–How many witnesses were there, what were they doing?

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the street scene.

–How many witnesses were there, what were they doing?

• One witness, mowing the lawn.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the street scene.

–What season was it?

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the street scene.

–What season was it?

• Summer, the leaves were well established and green.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions about the previous scene.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• What is this a picture of?

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• What is this a picture of?

• What else?

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• What is this a picture of?

• What else?

– A women (adult) with blonde hair, maroon shirt and wearing eyeglasses.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the ocean scene?

– Specifically, where was this photo taken?

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

• Questions for the ocean scene?

– Specifically, where was this photo taken?

– Picture taken by passenger on a bus or train (tinted windows). Image is of a women sitting by the window seat. No smoking sign can be seen in the reflection. Her left arm is against her cheek.

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

Copyright © 2010 Ryan P. Murphy

Recommended