Pilot Knowledge Survey

1

Pilot KnowledgeSurvey

By Bob Jackson,MIC, ZSE CWSU

And Accident Study

Weather

??

2

Introduction - 1

• A well known ground school syllabus– allots 2 hours for weather theory.– Assumes pilots will improve their

weather knowledge

• Further weather study SHOULD BE mandatory for pilots.

3

Introduction - 2

• Survey given to Certified Flight Instructors– CFI’s considered by some as the

‘Crème de la Crème of pilots’– Given in 1989– 238 responded

4

The Survey - 1

• Survey consisted of five questions:– What license do you hold?– What is main source of additional

weather knowledge since ground school?

– Are you comfortable with present Weather knowledge?

5

The Survey - 2

• Survey questions continued:– What is the average number of safety

seminars attended per year?– If you could choose a weather topic

for the next safety seminar, what would it be?

6

License Held ?

CommercialPrivate

ATP

7

Comfortable with presentknowledge of weather?

36% Yes

55% No9% Sometimes

8

Source of additional weatherknowledge since receiving

license?

28% Books

6% Classroom

12% Audio/Visual25% Seminars

29% IN FLIGHT !!!

This is notwhere to learn aboutWeather

Trial&

Error

9

Number of safety seminarsattended per year ?

57% -- 1 to 4

8% -- 5 to 8

1% -- 9 to 12

35% --Rarely attend

10

Comfortable with presentknowledge of weather?

36% Yes55% No

9% Sometimes

49% of these rarely attended aviation safety seminars !!

11

What Wx Topic Do You Want to See Next?

• Basic Weather Principles• How to read Weather Charts• How to get the most from a Pilot

Weather Briefing• In-flight weather recognition• Fronts, pressure systems• Icing and Turbulence

12

Weather is a “Weak Point”to most GA Pilots

• ‘Poor’ knowledge gained from ground school

• Little/no additional training • In-flight is Not place to learn

about weather!!

FriendlySkies??

13

Trial and Error

14

How Much of Aviation Training is Trial and Error?

• Take-offs ?• Landings ?• Aeronautics ?• Radio use ?• Aircraft instruments?

15

Survey Suggests

• Proper emphasis NOT put on weather training.

• Weather is Learned by “Trial and Error” !!!!

• Not the way to learn about Weather!!

16

Two NTSB Studies of Non-Fatal (GA) Wx

Accidents

• Unfavorable cross winds major cause

17

Two NTSB studiesFatal (GA) Wx accidents

• Lowering ceilings during flight• Lowering Visibilities during flight• i.e. Continued VFR flight into IFR

conditions• “Violent Weather” was factor in a

SMALL PERCENTAGE of fatal accidents.

18

NTSB RECOMMENDATIONS

• Visit FAA Flight Service Station• Visit NWS Forecast office

– Make arrangements first

• Familiarize with local terrain/weather patterns.

19

National Statistics for 10 Yrs.

• Lightning• Tornado• Hurricane• Flood• Total Fatalities

– 2,023

• Total Fatalities– 3,504

• 1,518 more– Almost twice as

many !!!

US Wx RelatedDeaths

Wx as Causal factorin Aircraft Accidents

20

Familiarize with Local Terrain/Weather Patterns.

• Other pilots• Seminars• Books or Newsletters

21

Example: VFR FlightThrough the Cascades

• 3,000 ft Elevation• Can not see pass in

advance• Narrow, steep sides• No place to do 180

turn• Steep terrain makes

up for low elevation

• 3,800 ft Elevation• Can see pass in

advance• Wider with ‘sides’

further apart• Wide enough to

do 180 turn

Snoqualmie Pass Stampede Pass

22

Example: VFR FlightThrough the Cascades

Stampede Pass

Snoqualmie Pass

23

Example: VFR FlightThrough the Cascades

150 Deg. Curve

A ‘Straight Shot’

24

Example: VFR FlightThrough the Cascades

Box canyons

Left turns

25

Example of local ‘Rule of Thumbs’

• No Rule of Thumb works all the

time.• If you can not fly VFR through

Stampede Pass...– You can not fly VFR through

Snoqualmie Pass

26

Example of local ‘Rule of Thumbs’

• If you can not fly VFR thru the

gorge,

– You can not fly VFR thru the passes.

27

Aircraft Accidents

• Where?• What was the cause?• I’m Experienced !!

– It won’t happen to me -

28

WA Accident Statistics

• Data received from NTSB• 16 Years (1983-1998)• Data for Fatal Accidents only• Looking for patterns

29

WA Accident Causes• Dust/Haze -visibility restriction• Density Altitude• Icing • Turbulence• Wind• Improper IFR operations (IFR pilot)• VFR flight into IMC

30

Density Altitude - 4 Dust/Haze -2

31

Icing - 4

32

Turbulence - 6

33

Wind - 9 (Cross, Tail, Shear)

34

IFR Conditions - 32

35

VFR Flight intoIMC Conditions - 44

36

All Factors

37

Most Frequent Factors

• VFR into IFR• IFR Conditions• Wind• Icing• Density Altitude• Turbulence• Haze/Dust

44 43%32 31%10 9% 6 6% 5 5% 4 4% 2 2%

43%+31% 74%

Factor No. %

38

Discussion - 1

• Total of 191 fatalities• VFR to IFR - Most pilots were

briefed about IFR weather in route.• IFR - Most used “improper IFR

procedures.”

39

Discussion - 2

• Many flying on “Invalid Briefings”(old)

• Most had change to ‘back out’ but didn’t.

• Many “Overconfidence of pilot”

40

Worst Month to Fly?

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

Jan

Mar

May Ju

l

Sep

No

v

Accidents by Month

No of Acdnts.

No conclusions can be made here !

41

Non-Instrument Rated ??

• Tempted to take off in marginal Wx?

• If you decide to go and get caught in IFR conditions, then…

42

Faithful/Fatal Decision• Sky - overcast• You realize that visibility is

becoming restricted.• Ceiling and visibility gradually

lowering.• Map shows high terrain in area.• You’ve flown in worse, so…

– You press on.

43

Faithful/Fatal Decision

• Flight could/should have waited.• Was that appointment so

important?

• When do you decide to do a 180?

44

Faithful/Fatal Decision

• A Safe flight or

CRASH !!• What makes the difference?

45

Summary - 1

• Pilots don’t get good weather training• Weather is a “Weak Point” for most

GA Pilots• Pilots need a good knowledge of

basic weather• Pilots need knowledge of local terrain

and it’s affects on flight.

46

Summary - 2

• Violent, easily recognized weather– is not main cause of aviation

accidents

• IFR weather conditions– main cause of aviation accidents– Recognition and Avoidance needs to

be better taught to pilots

47

TheThe

EnEndd