Preserving Public HousingRoundtable Discussion

Carver HousesApril 16, 2013

2

Introductions

Conversation Guidelines

3

Let’s hear from everyone No interruptions Treat everyone with respect Respect different opinions No videotaping Facilitators will take comments and questions at

tables Note-takers are capturing ideas and opinions. No

names will be used.

NYCHA’s Land Lease Proposal

Proposal to lease land to a developer for construction of a new apartment building.

All revenue will go to building improvements at Carver Houses and other

NYCHA developments.4

5

Overview of Land Lease Proposal Building Site and Design Options Request for Proposal Project Timeline Comments and Q & A

Discussion Topics

6

Overview of Land Lease Proposal

$13.4 Billion Unmet Capital Need NYCHA Wide for the Next 5 Years

Carver Houses has $41Million needed

for capital improvements

Only $8.5 million of work is planned over the next 5

years7

Overview: Land Lease Proposed Plan

NYCHA would lease (not sell) 14 parcels of land located within 8 developments

Income generated will be dedicated to building improvements for public housing

The developers will finance, construct, and operate new residential buildings.

Approximately 80% of the apartments will be market rate and 20% will be permanently low income 8

Setting the Record Straight: At Carver the Development Plan Will: Not increase rent for NYCHA residents

due to the new developments.

Not demolish public housing apartments

Not move NYCHA families

Not privatize – NYCHA will still be the landlord

Not sell the land; NYCHA will own the land under the new buildings.

Not result in job losses or increased work requirements for NYCHA personnel.

9

NYCHA’s Core Principles for Development

All new buildings located along street fronts to encourage pedestrian traffic and campus integration with the neighborhood and reduce construction impact

Replacement of all parking spaces for all current resident legal permit holders

NYCHA will remain your landlord and retain ownership of the land under the new buildings via 99-year ground leases

10

Benefits NYCHA Wide

This initiative will generate between $30 million and $50 million of funding on a yearly basis for 99 years (term of ground lease)

All revenue will be used to improve the quality of life of NYCHA residents by funding a portion of critical capital improvements – example: roofs, elevators, boilers, electrical system, apartment upgrades

11

Benefits for Carver Houses Residents

Alternative power for systems during blackouts such as hallway and stair lighting, heat and hot water, elevators and security

Construction and permanent jobs opportunities for NYCHA residents

Enhanced security features for the entire development

Preference for low income apartments in the new buildings

Affordability restrictions are permanent12

13

Carver Houses

Land Lease Plan

Carver Houses Today

142,787 residents live at Carver Houses

E 102nd St & Madison Ave Site Site Area: 14,000 SF

E 102nd St & Park Ave Site

Site Area: 23,000 SF

Proposed Floor Area

242,000 SF Residential Floor Area / 262 Apartments* (Approx.)

500,000 SF Community Facility Floor Area (Revenue Generating Community Facility eg. Medical Facility, Student Dormitory)

1Affordable units will be available to households with incomes at or BELOW60% of Area Median Income (AMI)

Development Opportunity at Carver Houses

15

Maximum Allowable Income

1 person $ 36,120

2 persons $ 41,280

3 persons $ 46,440

4 persons $ 51,540

1Based on Dept. of Housing and Urban Development 2013 (HUD) Standards*Assumption based on 925 SF / Apartment

16

Comments and Concerns about Land Lease Proposal

Group Discussion #1

17

Building Site and Design Options

Possible Relocation of Site Uses

18

Park Avenue & E 102nd Street Site Development Site

Madison Avenue & E 102nd Street Site Development Site

Carver Houses: Development Sites

Carver Houses: New Parking and Improved Open Space

Park Ave @ E 105th St Landscaped Area New Parking Lot

E 106th St Landscaped Area New Parking Lot

Madison Ave @ E 100th St New Parking

Lot

Park Ave Parking Lot @ E 100th St Expanded

E 99th St Parking Lot Expanded

Group Discussion #2

21

Design Options Parking Relocation Security

22

Process to ask developers for their ideas based on specific

guidelines that NYCHA provides

Request for Proposal

RFP is currently in development

23

Guidelines Under Consideration Alternate power source

Distribution of apartment units

Employment opportunities & training

Preference for Carver Houses residents for affordable units

Financial literacy training

Group Discussion #3

24

Request for Proposal Alternate power source

Distribution of apartment units

Employment opportunities & training

Preference for Carver Houses residents for affordable units

Financial literacy training

Next Steps in 2013

25

RFP out end of April Round of resident discussions Proposals submitted July/August Round of resident discussions Designation of developer Fall 2013 Round of discussions with residents, NYCHA Staff

and designated developer

Key Milestones 2014-2016Ongoing resident discussions

26

Environmental review

Submission of Section 18 application

HUD Review of Section 18 application

Upon approval, enter lease agreement

Construction preparation & groundbreaking

27

Q & A

28

Land Lease Websitehttp://on.nyc.gov/landlease

Public comments can be submitted online and in writing to:New York City Housing Authority

Land Lease CommentsPO Box 3422

New York, NY 10008