Upload
informa-australia
View
762
Download
2
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Steffen RisagerChief Operating Officer
Regional Ports ConferenceCairns
THE ROLE OF TOWAGE IN PORT EFFICIENCY
2
DRAFT
Melbourne
Newcastle
Cairns
MourilyanLucinda
Bowen – Abbott Point
Brisbane
Sydney
Port Kembla
WesternportGeelong
Port Adelaide
Whyalla
Port Pirie
Ardrossan
Port Giles
Project MagnetPort Bonython
Port LincolnThevenard
Albany
Kwinana
Fremantle
Geraldton
Koolan Island
Cockatoo IslandDarwin
Darwin LNG
Eden
Bunbury
Australia
Gorgon LNG
Wheatstone
LNG
Harbour towage
Terminal towage
Aabenraa
EsbjergFredericia
Oxelosund Nynashamn
Norrkoping
Stenungsund
Brofjorden
GothenburgWalhamm
Uddevalla
CopenhagenMalmo
Sweden
Denmark
Frederikshavn
Aalborg
StigsnæsKalundborg
Avonmouth
Belfast
Felixstowe
Greenock
ImminghamLiverpool
London Medway
Port Talbot
Southampton
Tees
Tyne
Felixarc
Forth
South Hook LNGDragon LNG
SCANDINAVIAUK
SVITZER HARBOR TOWAGE… … LEADER IN EUROPE AND AUSTRALIA
3
DRAFT
EACH PORT MUST ENSUREIT’S OWN SUCCESS
• A safe and healthy workplace
in which all employees are
looking out for each other
• A working environment built
on mutual respect where
everyone understands the
challenges, contributes to the
solutions and shares in the
rewards
• A profitable and financial
sustainable business unit
3
4
DRAFT
SAFETY – REMAINS OUR #1 PRIORITY
Proactive reporting has direct impact on TRCf
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
550
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
Jul-13 Jan-14 Jul-14Jan-13 Jul-15Jan-15
Proactive reporting
TRCf
Initiatives in last 24 months
• Introduced Harmonized
Management System taking
Svitzer to OVMSA level
2 compliance
• Significant investments
in Marine Standards
organization
• Annual Global Safety Day
• Improving Proactive Safety
Reporting
• STOP WORK Authority
• SOVIQ audits
• Safety Ambassadors
• Global planned maintenance
system
5
DRAFT
PART OF THE PORT COMMUNITY – ENGAGEMENT
Courtesy of Maersk Line
• We are partof a bigger value chain
• We are discussing optimisationswith customers and their agents
• We are similar to pilots in our optimisationchallenges and opportunities
8
DRAFT
HOW DO WE MEASURE (ON-TIME) PERFORMANCE
In 2013 SVITZER implemented a new operations system (HELM)
• All job information is entered into the
system (vessel size, job time, etc.)
• Tugs enter the mobilization,
demobilization, job start time and job
end time directly into the system via an
Onboard system
• Tug times are compared to
Request/Order times to identify
whether a job started
on-time or was delayed
• Booking procedure and timestamps are
equally important
9
DRAFT
Former setup – sparecapacity on existing tugs
New setup – tugs better utilized but least used tug rarely used
CAPACITY IS ABOUT TUGS…
* Utilization index is the average daily steam time
Looking across the vessel fleet …
Marginal tugs, # Utilization index* Utilization index*
Tug # 2
Tug # 4
Tug # 5
Tug # 6
Tug # 7
Tug # 1PortJackson
Tug # 3PortBotany
10
DRAFT
… AND VERY MUCH ABOUT AVAILABILITYSWEDISH WEST COAST CLUSTER, APRIL-AUGUST, 2013
Source: SVITZER HELM and P&L data; team analysis
• The marginal
tugs come at
significant
additional cost
• Tug #4 is already
2x cost of tug #1
• In addition
comes special
features on tugs
and availability of
crew – including
call-out time
Looking at the vessels …
… given the job pattern, these vessels will have different utilizationrates …
… we get a total cost dilution effect lookingat costs/hour worked
Marginal tugs, # Utilization index Total cost per hour per
marginal tug, SEK
100Tug # 1 Cheap1.0x
68Tug # 2 1.1x
41Tug # 3 1.4x
22Tug # 4 2.0x
12Tug # 5 3.3x
6Tug # 6 5.9x
2Tug # 7 13.3x
1Tug # 8 Expensive28.8x
11
DRAFT
TRAINING & COMPETENCY BUILDING
• SVITZER cooperates with FORCE Technology
and uses their 3600 full mission simulators in
Copenhagen, Singapore, and Brisbane
• SVITZER owns 5 mobile simulators:
– Gothenburg, Sweden
– UK (containerized)
– Dubai, UAE
– Soyo, Angola
– Miami, USA
• Trainings together with pilots and tanker
captains in specific operating conditions
• SVITZER cooperates with FORCE Technology
and uses their 3600 full mission simulators in
Copenhagen, Singapore, and Brisbane
• SVITZER owns 5 mobile simulators:
– Gothenburg, Sweden
– UK (containerized)
– Dubai, UAE
– Soyo, Angola
– Miami, USA
• Trainings together with pilots and tanker
captains in specific operating conditions
Mobile simulator in Gothenburg
International legislation requirements (IMO) STCW 2010 Flag state requirements SVITZERrequirements
International legislation requirements (IMO) STCW 2010 Flag state requirements SVITZERrequirements
Hands-on training360 deg full mission simulatorMobile simulatorsClass room trainingE-learning
Hands-on training360 deg full mission simulatorMobile simulatorsClass room trainingE-learning
CertificatesCompetenciesProficienciesSkills
CertificatesCompetenciesProficienciesSkills
12
DRAFT
KEY IS TO IMPROVE PREDICTABILITY
• We have little/no
influence on demand
– and will therefore
have to adjust our
supply to improve
utilization
• Our supply is made up
of tugs and crew –
these must be seen
separately in our
optimization
• In addition, our pricing
has to reflect, not only
the cost to serve, but
also our cost to be
prepared for all
eventualities – we aim
to have the actual
users pay
Newcastle
Swedish West Coast
Labour to match demand vs. FTE employed average day Mar 12-Feb 13
0
5
10
15
20
25
21 22 232016 1711 2412 1815 191410 13987654321
Demand coverage
People employed
Hours from low-tide
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.2
0.4
0% 45%
Freja
2%
34%
Frigga
1%
Fenja
3%
30%
Bonden
38%
33%
Boss
28%
Svitzer
Geo
67%
30%
Svitzer
Hymer
74%
26%
Svitzer
Gaia
81%
29%
Bob
81%
33%
Svitzer
Tyr
86%
30%
Svitzer
Oden
91%
32%
67%
Utilization
Percent
Servicing “Base load”
demand Servicing “peak
demand” investigate
flexible crewing models
Not fully dedicated to
Swedish West Coast Cluster
Tugs,#
13
DRAFT
• Tell us what you need and why
• Help identify who will benefit (and pay)
• Ask the same from all operators
• Tell us what you need and why
• Help identify who will benefit (and pay)
• Ask the same from all operators
BRINGING IT TOGETHER THROUGH CLEAR GUIDELINES
13
14
DRAFT
NON-EXCLUSIVE LICENCES WITH MINIMUM TOWAGE STANDARDS CAN BENEFIT ALL STAKEHOLDERSNon-Exclusive Licences
• Non-Exclusive licences are where any towage operator can enter a port provided they meet specific criteria
determined by the port authority e.g., tug capabilities, number of tugs, availability, and minimum environmental,
safety and other relevant standards
Port Authorities Customer Towage providers
• Prevents a “race to the bottom” when in comes to safety and
service standards as all operators
would be equipped to meet the
port’s long term needs
• Encourages greater investmentby operators in assets and
people as they will see it as a
long term venture i.e. return on
capital based on 20-25 years;
exclusive licences 5-8 years
• Prevents a port being held
“hostage” to industrial action (threatened or real)
• Drives up port productivity as
operators compete to deliver their
service as safely and as
efficiently as possible
• A better service: in order to
maintain their market share and
win new customers operators
would have to compete on the
basis of price and reliability
• Greater choice: they can “shop
around” for a better price and/or a
service better tailored to their
needs e.g. tanker customers may
require different service levels to
container customers
• Ensures a level playing field on
which everyone is playing by the
same rules, allowing them to
focus on delivering the best
possible product
• Security from competitors “cherry picking” volumes in
ports for customers needing
1-2 tugs
• This creates an unsustainable
position as operators need this
volume to finance the fleet to also
cover the concurrent jobs or jobs
that require 3, 4 or 5 tugs
15
DRAFT
NON-EXCLUSIVE LICENCES ARE SEEN IN A NUMBEROF EUROPEAN PORTSLISBON AND BREMERHAVEN OFFER DIFFERENT EXAMPLES OF THIS
Requirement
for licence
Requirement
for licence
Bremerhaven
• Operators are required to meet a BP requirement for
their tugs to operate in the port
• Operators must have a local operations centre and
management in Bremerhaven
• Operators are required to have enough tugs to tow
the largest ships entering the port
• Operators must also meet the quality and safety
standards for the port
Lisbon
Is there competi-
tion in the port?
Is there competi-
tion in the port?
• Yes. Bremerhaven sees multiple operators• Yes. There are two operators offering towage
services in Lisbon
How the port
benefits from
the licence
How the port
benefits from
the licence
• This ensures that any vessel entering the port can be
handled by either provider
• They have tow parties competing for business on
equal footing
• Svitzer have a strong market share through their
service levels, quality and pricing
• There is no risk for the port that either operator just
focuses on the more frequent and profitable 1-2 tug
work, and ignores the more marginal 3-4 tug work
• There are multiple operators that have to ensure they
have capacity to manage their contracts
• Bremerhaven are concerned that the quality and
power of the tugs in the port is to a certain level, this
is dictated by the pilots
How the towage
operators benefit
from the licence
How the towage
operators benefit
from the licence
• Yes. Bremerhaven sees multiple operators• Yes. There are two operators offering towage
services in Lisbon
16
DRAFT
EFFICIENCIES BY GROUPING PORTS – SCANDINAVIA EXAMPLE
Aabenraa
Esbjerg
Fredericia
OxelosundNynashamn
NorrkopingStenungsundBrofjorden
Gothenburg
Walhamn
Uddevalla
Copenhagen
Malmo
Sweden
Denmark
Frederikshavn
Aalborg
Stigsnæs
Kalundborg
• Serving 20+ ports with 25 tugs, with
majority of ports requiring multiple tugs on
any one job
• Sub-clusters of tugs within the cluster
serving ”base load” with frequent sharing of
tugs within the cluster to service ”peak
demand”
• Service level commitment with
Gothenburg, Brofjorden and Fredericia
ports to be available within 20 minutes
• Benefits for ports: Few of the ports have
the towage volumes to sustain the required
number of tugs for peak volumes at an
acceptable price level, as such the ”sharing
of tugs” between ports enhances the ports
competetiveness in regards to cost as well
as service level
• Benefits for Svitzer: Keeping vessel
investments and vessel costs at a
minimum with a streamlined fleet of tugs
and through improved utilizations also
lowering crew costs per tug job.
Lindö
Aarhus
Helsingborg
3 TUGS
8 TUGS
3 TUGS
9 TUGS
2 TUGS