Upload
independent
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Natural Products Synthesis
Screening
1991. The larger objective of the program is tostlmulate research and development of potential psychotherapeutic agents (synthetic ornatural). In addition to research grants. thisprogram administers two major contracts:3
• The Chemical Synthesis Program hasbeen ongoing since 1959 and provides alibrary ofunique research tools and drugs
:i~I
I U.8. Efforts in Natural Products Research
J. Cott
At the beginning of the 1990s. the Decadeof the Brain. l many neurobiological toolsneeded for a better understanding.of the myriad systems of the brain and behavior arebecoming aVailable. Despite improvements inthe necessary tools and advances made in thelast three decades (using chemical syntheticapproaches to drug design and sophisti~ated
structure-activity studies), significant progress in the treatment ofmental dis-orders (particularly refractory disorders) has lagged. and the need issilll great for more effective medications. While many thousands ofcompounds have been synthesizedand evaluated. many gaps remainin the therapeutic anmu,nentartumfor psychiatric disordef~.
A major reason for these gaps isthe relative lack of understandIngof theJundamentalneurobiologicalprocesses involved In human learning. memory. emotions. and psychopathology. Since the phannaceuticalindustry Invests primartlyin areas of mental health researchwhere timely and significant commercial success Is l1kely, manyimportant areas remain where itleadership role for the NationalInstitute of Mental Health (NIMH) FIG~ I.-Organizational Chartcould be pivotal. PMDP: Psychotherapeutic Medication Development Program
Psychotherapeutic Drug Discoveryand Development Program
In 1990. the Psychotherapeutic Drug Discovery and Development Program was fonned.It is currently located within the DIvision ofNeuroscience and Behavioral Science (Fig. 1).A specific Program Announcement2 invitingresearch grant applications was released In
173
(Table 1). Custom syntheses ofinvestigational compounds not currently In thel1brary are also available for psychopharmacology researchers In academia.Industry. and govC?rnment.
• The NIMH Screening Program contractfacllltates the phannacologIc profil1ng ofpotential new drugs and natural productextracts. This contract provides state-ofthe-art. in Vitro assays for up to 100different cen~al nervous system (CNS)
Therapeutics
TABLE 1.-NIMH chemical synthesis program inventory
New additions, 1991-93 Catalog # New additions, 1991-93 Catalog #
N-Acetyl-4-0-methyldopamlne
N-Acetyl-3-0-methyldopamlne
N-Acetyl-O-methyltyramine
cis-3-Amlnocyclohexane carboxylic AcidGABA uptake inhibitor
4'-Amlno-PPHT HCI2-[N-(4-amlnophenyl)-N-propyl-S-hydroxytetralln(4'-amlno)-N-0434. Analog of the O2agonist PPHT"
Biotin-poly-O.L-Iyslneblotlnylated marker for living neurons, of sufficientsize (MW ca. 3000) that interneuronal diffusion is low
BTCP ,Dopamine uptake inhibitor; analog of ,,:-CP
5-Carboxamldotryptamlne maleateSHT, agonist
5-(S-Cystelnyl)-L-OOPAConjugate of L-DOPA which may be formed In vivo
1,2-0imethyllsoqulnollnlum iodide \
S(-)-OMBBS(-)·S-Ethyl-S-(1 ,3-dlmethylbutyl)barblturlcacid:sedative, hypnotic
R(+)-OMBBConvulsant
MH-P-701
MH-P-702
MH-P-703
MH-A-701
MH-P-706
MH-B-703
MH-B-701
MH-C-704
MH-C-702
MH-I-705
MH-B-704
MH-B-705
NAPSN-(-Amlnophenethylsplperone): 02 antagonistintermediate for photoafflnlty or radloUgands
(+)-Noreplnephrlne (+)-bltartrate
SKF-104,078Post-junclionally selective 2-adrenoceptorantagonist.
N6-p-SulfophenyladenosineWater-soluble trl.thylammonium salt, A,·adenosineagonist
Telenzepine amine congenerAnalog of the M, muscarinic antagonist telenzepine
UK-14.3045-Bromo-N-(4,S-dlhydro-1H-Imldazol-2-yl)-6quinoxallnamine ~-adrenerglc agonist
YM-09151-2cls-N-(1-Benzyl·2-methylpyrrolidln-3-y/)·S·chloro-2methoxy-4-methylaminobenzamlde: selectivedopamine O2antagonist
In process
A1lantoxanamldeEnantlomers of 7-hydroxy-DPATeH)-labeled R(+)-B-Hydroxy-OP~T5-lodo-6-nltroqulpazlne 1
MH-N-701 "
MH-N-702
MH-8-701
MH-A-702
MH-T-701
MH-U-701
MH-Y-701
MH-B-501MH-H-511MH-T-506
MH-A-501MH-H-S07MH-H-50BMH-H-509MH-H-510MH-T-502
MH-8-S02MH-D-50SMH-D-506MH-D-507
MH-D-50B
A1anine,3-(3-amlnonaphtyl)-Histidine, a-Methyl-, HCIHistidine, 2-methyl-, 2HCIHistidine, 4-methyl·, HC'4-Hydroxytryptophan hemiacetateTyrosine·O·sulfate, L-(-)- potassium salt
Available compounds preparedprior to 1991
Catechols and derivatives
Barbiturates/hydantolns
Amino acid derivatives
BarbituricAcid, 5-ethyl-5-(1·methyl-3-hydroxybutyJ)Hydantoin, S-(2,4,5-trihydroxybenzyl)·2-ThlobarbituricAcid, 5-ethyl-S-(1·methyl-
3-hydroxybutyl)-
Benzoic Acid, 3,4-dimethoxy-S·hydroxy3,4-Dlhydroxyphenylethanol: trlethylenedlamlne3,4-Dimethoxy-5-hydroxybenzolc acida-Dimethyiamlno-3,4-dlhydroxy-acetophenone
methachlorlde4-(a.N,N-"Oimethylaminopropylamino)-1,2
dihydroxybenzene 2HBr
MH-M-702
MH-I-704
MH-B-706
MH-E-701MH-E-702
MH-I-703
MH-I-702
(±)-OMBB
N-Ethyln~rnlcotlne
N-EthylnorcotlnineInternal standards for mass spectrometry.
(+)-HA-966 MH-H-702R(+)-3-Amlno-1-hydroxy·2-pyrroUdlnone: antagonistof glycine modulatory site associated with NMOAreceptor "
4'-Methyl-MPP+ IodideDopamlnerglc neurotoxin
1-Methyl-TI01-Methyl-1,2,3,4,-tetrahydrolsoqulnollne:dopamlnerglc neurotoxin
TIO1,2,3,4-Tetrahydrolsoqulnollne
1-Methyl-lsoqulnollne
7-Hydroxy-OPAT MH-M-7017.Hydroxy·2-(N,N-dipropylamlno)telraUn: putative 03agonist
1-Hydroxytacrine maleate MH-H-703(Velnacrine) cholinesterase Inhibitor
IsoMHPG MH-I-7013-Hydroxy+methoxyphenylglycol: norepinephrinemetabolite
, 2'Methyl-MPP+ Iodide MH-M-701Dopaminergic neurotoxin
174
U.S. Efforts in Natural Products Research
TABLE 1.-NIMH chemical synthesis program inventory (continued)
Available compounds preparedprior to 1991 (continued) Catalog #
Available compounds preparedprior to 1991 Catalog #
Catecholsand derivatives (continued) Indoles (continued)
Drugs and other heterocyclic compounds
Adaplperazlne MH-A-5023-(2'-Aminobenzhydroxy)tropane MH-A-S033·(~·Aminoethyl)-S-hydroxybenzolblthiophene MH-A-5042-Amlnotetralln HCI - MH-A-50Sp-Azido-TFMPP MH-A-506Benzo(b)-thlophene,2-cyanomethyl·S-hydroxy- MH-B-S03CarboslyrY1,3-amlno-3,4-dihydro·7-hydroxy- MH...c-S3SHaldol MH-H-S14~·(5-Hydroxy-3·benzo[81thlenyl)-o:-amino-propionlcacid MH-H-S1S3-(3-Hydroxyphenyl)·N-n-propylplperldlne HBr MH-H-516Norcyclazoclne MH-N-S016-Qulrioxallnamine, 5·bromo·ethylthiocarbamate MH-Q-704Qulnoxallne,6-amino- MH-Q-701Qulnoxaline,6-amlno·S-bromo- MH-Q-702Qulnoxallne,5-bromo-6-isothiocyanate MH-Q-70SQulnoxaline,6·lsothiocyanate MH-Q-706Qulnoxallne,6-nitro- MH-Q-703W-S MH-W-501W-7 MH-W-502
Miscellaneous amlnes and derivatives
Hydrazlnoproplonlc acid, 3,4-dlhydroxybenzyl-, OL3·(4-Hydroxy-3-methoxyphenyl)-1-propanol1-(3-Methoxy-4-hydroxyphenyl)·1-hydroxy·
2·aminopropane hydrogen oxalatePhenylacetic Acid, 2,4-dlbenzyloxy-S·methoxy~erlne, 3-(3,4-dltlydroxyphenyl)-, O(+)-threoSerine, 3·(3,4-dlhydroxyphenyl)-, L-(-)-threoPhenylacetic Acid, 2,4-dlmethoxy·Phenylacetic Acid, 3,4,S·trimelhoxy-Pyruvic Acid, 3-methoxy-4·benzyloxyphenyl·
Imipramine and derivatives
Imipramine, 3-ehloro·, desmethyImipramine, dldesmethyl·, HCIImipramine, 2·hydroxyImlpramine,2-hydroxydesmethyl·
Indoles
5-Amlnotryptamine dlpicrateS,6-0lhydroxylndoleN-Oimethyl,lryptamlne, S,6,7-trlmethoxyS-Hydroxyindole-3-~-propionlc acidS-Hydroxy-6-methoxylrypamlne creatinine sullate5-Hydroxy-7-methoxytryptamlne creatinine sulfate4·Hydroxylryptamine creatinine sUlfate6-Hydroxylryptamine creatinine sulfate7-Hydroxylryptamlne creatinine sulfate5-Methoxyindole, 3-(2-aminopropyl)-, HCI6-Methoxylryptamine creatinine sulfate
MH-H-512MH-H-S13MH-M-501
MH-P-S14MH-S-501,MH-8-S02MH-P-51SMH-P-S16MH-P-S17
MH-I-S01MH'-I-502MH-I-S03MH-I-504
MH-D-509MH-D-510MH-H-S01MH-H-502MH-H-S03MH-H-504MH-H-50SMH-H-506MH-M-S02MH-M-503
a-Methylserotonln hydrogen oxalate1-Methylserotonln maleateSerotonin O·sulfateS,6,7-Trihydroxylryptaminecreatinine sulfate
Melatonin
6-Chloro·2-methylmelatonin6·Methoxymelatonin
Acetoxyethyldlmethylethylammonlum IodideHistamine, 2-methyl-, dipicratea-Methylhlstamine oxalateAniline, (m-chlorophenyl)-N-
fy·N'-dlmethylamlnopropyl)-, HCI2-0Ibenzylamlnoproplophenone,4'-benzyloxyOlmethylaminoethyl acetate hydrogen maleate4-(y-N,N·Oimethylaminopropylamino)phenol dlmaleateHistamine, N-dlmethyl-, methyl IodideHistamine, N-methyl-, diplcrate2-Hydrazlno-3·(4-hydroxyphenyl)-propionic acid3-HydroxybenzylaminePlperazlne,N-(2·adamanlyl)-, HCIPlperazlne-dlacroleinTFMPP, p-amlno-, 2HCI3-(y-N,N-Trimethylamlnopropylamino)phenoI2HBr
Natural Products and Derivatives
Isosalsollne HCIKawalnReserpine, 1-(~-dlethylamlno)ethyl-, dlplcrateSalsollne HCI
Nucleosides
6-Amino-2-chloro-9-(2'·methylsullonyl-~-D·
xylofuranosyl)-9-H-purlne
.Phenethylamines
2-Amino-1-(3,4,S·trimethoxyphenyl)-ethanol2-Amino-1-(3,4-dimethoxyphenyl)-ethanol HelAla-Ala-6-hydroxydopamine HCIBoc-Ala·Ala-6·hydroxydopamine, 0(-)-
N-Acelyloctopamlne, OL·2-Chloropropadrine HCI~-(p-Chlorophenyl) alanine, OLp-Chloroamphetamine HCI3,4-0ibenzoyloxyphenylalanlne, L·(+)-2,4-0ihydroxyphenylalanlne
MH-M-504MH-M-50SMH-8-S03MH-T-S03
MH-c-S36MH-M-506
MH-A-S08MH-H-517MH-M-S07MH-A-509
MH-D-S11MH-D-512MH-D-513MH-H-S18MH-H-519MH-H-520MH-H-521MH-P-S18MH-P-S19MH-T-504MH-T-SOS
MH-I-SOSMH-K-501MH-R-501MH-8-S04
MH-A-514
MH-A-510MH-A-511~H-A-S12
MH-A-513
MH-e-537MH-C-S38MH~-S39
MH-D-514MH-D-515
175
Therapeutics
r!jiI
TABLE 1.-NIMH chemical synthesis program inventory (continued)
Available compounds preparedprior to 1991 (continued) Catalog #
Available compounds preparedprior to 1991 Catalog #
176
I,I
-j
I!j
!.~\I
-)
1I
'\
II~
I
MH-P-510MH-P-S11MH-P-50SMH-P-S12MH-P-513MH-T-501MH-T-511
MH-H-528MH-P-S28
4-HydroxyphenylglycolPropylene glycol. 4-hydroxy-3·methoxyphenyl·,
diazablcyclo(2.2.21 octane salt, DL·
Phenylgylcols
Chlorpromazine, 7-acetoxy-, hydrogen maleate MH-C-S04Chlorpromazlne,8·benzyloxy·7-methoxy. MH-C-S05Chlorpromazine, 7.8-dlacetoxy Hydrogen Maleate MH-C-S06Chlorpromazine, 7,8-diacetoxy-7-semlcarbazone-, HCI MH-C-507Chlorpromazlne,7,8-dibenzyloxy· MH-C-50SChlorpromazine, dldesmethyl-, HCI MH-C-S09Chlorpromazine.6,9·dihydroxy· MH-C-S10
•Chlorpromazine, 7,8-dlhydroxy-, HCI MH-C-S11Chlorpromazine, 7,S-~ihydroxydldesmethyl-HCI MH-C-S12Chlorpromazine,7,8-dimethoxy-HCI MH-C-S13Chlorpromazlne,7,S-(dimethylmethylenedloxy)· MH-C-S14Chlorpromazlne,7.S-dloxo-HCI MH-C-S1SChlorpromazine. 7,8-dioxodidesmethyl-, HCI MH-C-S16Chlorpromazine,6·hydroxy- MH-C-S17Chlorpromazine,7-hydroxy-HCI MH-C-S1SChlorpromulne,7-hydroxy-glucuronide MH-C-S19Chlorpromazine, 7-hydroxydesmelhyl·, HCI MH-C-S20Chlorpromazine, 7·hydroxy-methiodide MH-C-S21Chlorpromazlne,9-hydroxy- MH-C-S22Chlorpromazine-S-oxide HCI MH-C-S24Chlorpromazlne-N-Oxlde MH-C-S25Chlorpromazine sulfone HCI MH-C-526Chlorpromazine sulloxide HCI MH-C-S27Chlorpromazine sulfoxide, 7-hydroxy- MH-C-528nor1.Chlorpromazine sulloxlde HCI MH-C-S32nor2-Chlorpromazlne, 7-hydroxy-B-methoxy-, HCI MH-C-S31nor1.Chlorpromazlne HCr MH-C-S29nor2-Chlorpromazine HCI MH-C-S30nor1-Chlorpromazlne sulloxide, N-acetyl·7-acetoxy- MH-C-S33Compazine, 3-hydroxy-, desdimethyl MH-C-5342,4-Dlchloropromazine HCI MH-D-5293,7-Dichlorophenothiazlne MH-D-530Perphenazlne, 7.8-dihydroxy•• 2HCI MH-P-501Phenothiazine. 2-chloro·7·hydroxy-S-methoxy- MH-P-507Phenothiazine, 2-chloro-1 O-(2-dlnlElthylamlnoethyl)-. HCIMH-P-S03Phenothiazine, 2-chloro-1 O-(3-amlnopropyl)- MH-P-S02Phenothlazine,2·chloro-6,9-dioxo- MH-P-50SPhenothlazlne,2-ehloro·7,8-dioxo· '\ MH-P-S06Phenothiazine, 2-methoxy· MH-P-509Phenothiazine, 2-ehloro-1 O-(3-dlmethylamlno-2- MH-P-S04
·hydroxypropyl)·, maleatePhenothiazine. N-methyl-Phenothiazine, N·methyl·2-(trifluoromethyl)Phenothiazine, 3-hydroxy·Phenothlazlne·5-0xldenor1-Promazlne Sulfoxide HCITrlfluoperazlne-S·OxideTrlfluorpromazlne, desmethyl-. HCI
MH-H-52SMH-H-S26MH-H-527
MH-D-516MH-D-517MH-D-518MH-D-S19MH-D-S20MH-D-521
MH-D-S22MH-D-523MH-D-524MH-D-S2SMH-D-526MH-D-S27MH-D-528MH-D-501MH-D-502MH-D-S03MH-D-504MH-G-501MH-G-S02MH-H-S22MH-H-S23
MH-M-S08MH-M-S09MH-M-510MH-D-S01MH-N-502MH-P-701MH-P-702MH-P-703MH-P-520MH-P-521MH-P-S22MH-P-S23MH-P-S2SMH-P-S26MH-P-527MH-T-S07MH-T-S08MH-T-509MH-T-S10
MH-C-S01MH-C-S02MH-C-503
Phenethylamines (continued)
(+/-)-3,4-Dihydroxyphenylalanyr-GABA(-)-2,4-Dlhdroxyphenylalanlne4,5-Dihydroxyphenylalanlne, 3:Cl1loro-, DL-, HBr2,3-Dihydroxy-p·phenethylamine HBr2,4-Dihydroxyphenethylamine HCI3,4-DI-(p-trlmethylammonlum-ethoxy)phenethylamine
dichloride HCI3,4-Diethylcarbonatophenethylamlne carbamate3,4-Dihydroxyphenethylamine, N-acetyl3,4-Dihydroxyphenylalanine, 2-chloro-, Dt-. HBr3,4-Dihydroxyphenylalanlne. 6-chloro-. DL-, HBr2,4-Dlhydroxyphenylalanlne, DL3,4-Dihydroxyphenylalanyl-GABA Ethanol, DLDimethyladrenaline methlodide, DL-Dopamine, 6-hydroxy-, HBrDopamine, 6-hydroxy-, HCIDopamine, 2-methyl-6-hydroxy-, HBrDopamine, 4-0-sulfate-y-Glutamyl dopamine4-0-(P-D-Glucopyranusiduronlc acld)-dopamine2-Hydroxy-p-phenethylamlne HCI3-Hydroxy-(p-dlmethylaminoethoxy)
phenethylamlne 2HCI4-Hydroxyphenethylamine. 2-amino-, 2HBrthreo-p-p-Hydroxyphenylserlne4-Hydroxy-3(-p-trimethylammonium methoxy)-
-phenethylamlne chloride HCI3-Methoxy-a-methyldopa-4-0-sulfate potassium saltN-MethylphenethanalamlneN-Methyltyramlne hydrobromideOctopamine, 0(-)-Norepinephrine,6-fluoro-oxalatePhenethylamlne, N-acetyl-3-hydroxy-4-methoxyPhenethylamlne, N-acetyl-4-hydroxy-3-methoxyPhenethylamine. N-acetyl-4-methoxyPhenethylamine 3,4-di-(p-dlmethylamlnoethoxy) 3HCIPhenethylamine. 3,4-dibenzyloxy-. HCIPhenethylamlne. 2,S-dlmethoxy-Phenethylamine, N-acetyl-3.4-dihydroxy·Phenylalanine. -1l-3,4-dihydroxy-2-methyl-. DL·Phenylalanine, 3-hydroxy-4-methoxy-, DLPhenylethylamlne, 2,4-dlmethoxy-2,3,4-Trlhydroxyphenethylamine HC11-2,3,4-Trihydroxyphenylalanine, D-Tyramine O-sulfateTyrosine, 2-amlno-
Phenothiazines
2-Chlorophenothiazlne, 10-carboethoxy2-Chlorophenothlazlne. N-ethylChlorpromazine
p
U.S. Efforts in Natural Products Research
TABLE 2.-Avallable receptor binding andenzyme activity assays
Amino acids
aulsqualate Glycine (nonstrychnlne)Kainate Glycine (strychnine)MK-801 GABAANMDA GABABPCP Benzodiazeplne
Biogenic amines*
Adrenergic (a, ~, & Serotonergic (1, 1A,subtypes) and 2)
Muscarinic (M1-3) Histaminergic (H1, H2)
Peptldes
Angiotensin II Arg-vasopressin V1Bombesin CCKcentrai
Substance P Substance KNeurotensin Neuropeptide Y
VIP Somatostatin
Peptide factors Channel proteins
ANF Calcium (N,T,L)NGF ChlorideEGF Potassium
Second messengers Miscellaneous
Forskolln Adenosine (A1,A2)Phorbol ester Opiate (nonselective)
Inositol triphosphate AIDS (e;g., gp120)~igma
Enzyme assays
Monoamine oxidase I Acetylchollnestrase
• Initial ligands nonselective followed by selective for subtype
receptors (examples of basic assays InTable 2). Samples that are active (hits) Inone or more receptor assays are tested Ina functional bioassay to determine agonist or at:ltagonlst activity CTable 3). Thescheme. for processing and evaluatingsamples Is depicted In Figure 2. To date.more than 600 pure· synthetic sampleshave been promed for receptor activity. Asummary of the receptor binding activityofthese compounds Is shown In Figure 3.
177
NIMH Interest in Natural ProductsResearch
I~ North America. half of all prescriptionsWritten are for plant products or for productsbased on plants. In the early 1900s. manypharmaceutical firms and academic investigators were Involved In collecting and testingnatural products for biological activity. Psychopharmacologists.ln particular. were Interested In natural products research. primarUybecause of the hallucinogens. During the1960s, these naturally occurring substances.which Induced unique states of consciousness. were the subject of thousa~ds ofresearch papers and sclentlflc symposia- anotable one sponsored by NIMH.4 Once thepha,rmacology of the hallucinogens was betterunderstood and their use became megal.ethnopharmacologlc research virtually halted.Aniong the other reasons for the decl1ne Innatural products research. low rates of payoffand high costs of discovery. development. andformulation were probably the mostimportant.
Recent global economic and environmentalpressures. however. are resulting In a renewedinterest In natural products research. Perhapsthe most c6mpell1ng Is the rapid disappearance of the flora and fauna of the tropical rainforests. If these natural sources of fuedlclnalchenucals are not explored now. they maydisappear forever. A second development hasbeen the technical advancement of highcapacity. In vitro assays that greatly Increasethe speed and decrease the cost ofdrug screenIng for precisely speCified pharmacologicactivities.
The 1988 National Advisory Mental HealthCouncil (NAMHC) Report to Congress on theDecade of the Brain1 provides the backgroundfor the current Interest and activities In natural products research. Specifically. theNAMHC recommended that NIMH:
• Cooperate with the National Cancer Institute (NCI) to obtain representative samples that are being collected under theirnatural products collection program
• Formulate speclflc plans for a naturalproducts screening program to be implemented through a series of contracts.
Therapeutics
Valuable Medicinals
Agency for International Development to release a Request for ApplicaUons entitled "InternationalCooperative BIodiversIty Groups."6The purpose of such groups Is tosearch for new medications fromnatural sources. The program Isadmin1stered by the Fogarty International Center.
An apprecIation of the history ofphannacology Involves...an apprecIation of naturally occurring compounds. ThIs research Is enrichedby other dIscIplInes such asethnobotany (the study of the relationship between man and his ambIent vegetation) and ethnopharmacology (the study of the use ofplants and animals for their toxicor medicinal properties by local cultures and peoples). PharmacologyItselfbegan with attempts to understand the valuable bIological properties ofmedicinal plants. The "discovery" and introduction ofpsychoactive products such as curare,atropine, ouabain. morphine. reserpine, and digitalis Into modernmedicIne were the genesIs of thediscipline of psychophannacology.
While Western medIcine adoptedmost of these drugs dUring the1950s, many of them are ancIentmedIcInals. ReserpIne use datesback almost 3000 years to theancient Hindu Ayurvedic medIclneas a treatment for InsanIty andother disorders. The first Western
sclentlftc description oflts use as a tranquWzerwas In 1931.7 The active alkaloIds were firstIsolated In root extracts of Rauwolfiaserpentina In 1952,8 and Its structure wasdescribed In 1954.9 Nathan KlIne pIoneered Itsuse In the Western world In 1954.10
Astute clInical observations have played amajor role In discovering the therapeutic useofsynthetic compounds. Examples Include theantipsychotic effects of chlorpromazInell and'the antidepressant activity of lmlprarnine12
(both developed originally as antlhlstamlnes
178
TABLE 3.-Receptor binding and functional assays·
Receptor affinity (ligand) Functional assay
Adenosine A1 ~H-bPCPX) cAMPAdenosine A2 ~H-CGS 21680) rat vas deferens~-adrenerglc ~H.prazosln) rat vas deferens~-adrenerglc ~H-rauwolscine) rat vas deferensp-adrenerglc (3H-DHA) mouse anticonvulsantAngiotensin II (1261-angiotensin II) G.P. tracheaBenzodlazeplne (3H.flunltrazepam) I.C.V.Bradykinin (BKS- 3H.bradyklnln) G.P.lleumDopamine 0 1 ( H·SCH 23390) G.P. atriaDopamine O2 ~H-racloprlde) cAMPCa++ (l) ~H-nitrendiplne) rat portal veinCCKA (3H.L-364718) G.P.lleumCCKB (3H-CCK-S) G.P.lleumGABAA (3H.mucimol) mouse anticonvulsantGlycine (3H·glycine) I.C.V.Glutamate (3H.glutamate) IP3Histamine H1 ~H-pyrilamine) gastric acidity in vivoInterleukln.1cx (1261-IL-1a) G.P.lleum5-HT1 (3H·S.HT) fibroblast PGE2 release5-HT1A (3H-S-OH-DPAT) G.P;i1eum5~HT2 (3H.ketanserln) IP35-HT3(3H.GR-65630) rat aortaKain81e ~H.kalnlc acid) G.P.lleumLeukotrlene B4 (3H-LTB4) mouse anticonvulsantleukotriene 04 ~H-LTD4l neutrophil enzyme releaseMuscarinic M1 (3H.pirenzipine) G.P.lleumMuscarinic M2 (3H-NMS) G.P.lleumMuscarinic M3~H.NMS) G.P. atriaNeurokln!n 1 ~H.substa!1ce P) G.P.lleumNeuropeptlda Y ~H-NPY) G.P.lleumNM~A (3H-CGS 19755) G.P. atriaPCP (3H·TCP) G.P. vas deferensPhorbol'Ester ~H-PDBu) platelet aggregationPlatelet Activating Factor ~H-PAF) r:.abbit ,platelet aggregationQuisqualate ~H·AMPA) mouse anti.convulsantNa+ (Site 2, 3H.batrachotoxln) G.P. atriaK+ rat portal veinSigma ~H-DTG) G.P. vas deferens
* Ugands and bloassays are representative examples only.
These ,requests have both been addressed.The Psychotherapeutic Drug Discovery andDevelopment Program has recently focused onstimulating natural products research. ThIsnew emphasIs was recently profiled IIi theWashtngton Insight Natural Products Newslet~,
ter.5 , Also, recognizIng that a fundamentalmechanism for managing bIodiversIty may beto link conservation with economic diversIty,on June 1. 1992. NIl\4H joIned with theNational Institutes of Health (NIH), theNational.Sclence Foundation. and the U.S.
U.S. Efforts in Natural Products Research
! (active)
2...:s percent of total 1-2 percent of total
active~
FlOURE 2.-Chemlcalsample flowsheet
for use as sedatives); the antidepressant actlv-.ity ofmonoamine oxidase inhibitors (developedfor the treatment of tuberculosis)l3; and theant1manic effects ofllthium (discovered dUringattempt~ to solubilize urates in guinea pigs). 14
Pursuit of the mechanism of action of reserpine lead Arvid Carls,son, at the UIiiversity ofGoteborg, Sweden, to the .discovexy of a newbrain transmitter, dopamine.1~ PreViouslybell~ved to be orIly a precursor in the synthesisofnorepmephrine, Carlsson provided evidencethat dopanline was not only a transmitter butthat its .insufficiency resulted in the mysterious neurological disturbances in. Parkinson'sdisease, and its ovemctlvity might be associ-'ated with schizophrenia. His fortunate discoverY of chlorpromazine's activity in sch1zophrerna led him to investigate the mechamsm ofthis dIJ1g, and in 1963, he proposed that the"ne~roleptic" mechanism '\\Tas a blockade ofbrain dopamine recepiPrs. 16
Thus, the study of psychoactive medicinalplants has prOVided opportunities forunpredicted discoveries in neurobiology,including neurotransmitters, receptor substances, second 'messengers, ion channels,and soon. A sign1ftcant scientific constmlnt isplaced on drug development when we mustl1m1t our search to chemicals that interact with
biological systems in predicted ways. Truly'urnque medications are unllk~ly to emerge.nus is especially true for research in areaswith. no effective drug treatments, such ascognitive disorders. nus lack impedes even theincremental ~me too" advances associated withpurely synthetic approaches. A final advantagefor further development of herbal medicine isthat it lends itself to standard methods ofpharmacologic evaluation already in use. Thesame cannot be said for many other types ofpotentially beneficial, alternative medicalpractices.
Natural Products Workshop
A workshop was held in April 1992 entitled"The Potential for Derivtng New Psychothera."peutic Medications From Natural Sources."nus workshop assembled many notable natural product scientists from the Urnted Statesto help in the planning of an expanded initiative. Many topics were discussed at the meeting, and all were pleased to see that NIMH hadagain become interested in natural products.The participants made several conclusionsand recommendatitms:
179
"1404.--.-----'------··----·· ---,------.- ----.---..---------"---
UIO r-------.-------------------~tested. Govern~ent
Agencies, phannaceutical companies, privatebotanical museums,and Independent investigators with an Interestin natural prodnchcould seNe as sourcesfor plant and animalsamples that havealready been collected.For example, John Dalyofthe National Instituteof Diabetes, Digestiveand Kidney Disorders,reported an animalproduct with very interesting and novel pharmacologic properties. 17A new peptide from frogskin enhanced .thebinding ofadenoslne Alreceptors, while otherassociated compoundsantagonized' these
same receptors. Effects of this drug inman were unUke any other described sofar.
• As a followup to the first NAMHC recommendation, proposals for ways in whi~h
to effect a mutually ben~ficial 'use ofresources was discussed with representatives from NCI. NIMH will explore methods for. preselecting compounds from theNCI natural products libraxy and requestsamples for psychoactive screel)ing by anNIMH contractor. One specific e?ffiII1plewould be to match compounds in thelibraxy that the ,~atural product database. NAPRALERr. suggests have psychother~peuticutility.
• Many "naturopathic" remedies such asthose found commercially in health foodstores have been shown to possess signifIcant biological activity. Usually, the fewactive compounds identified have notbeen evaluated by modern phannacologlcmethods. This may provide a. startingplace for the NIMH screening program.Tests should probably be done with properly identified. fresh plant samplesextracted by standardized procedures
o
20,.....,....__.::=:::~-·::::-,~::••····_·:::~:::::=:::::_::::·-.::::_:::::_:::::-:::._.::::-::::_:::~_::::._.::::-:::::-:::::_:::-:::::-:::::_::::_:~:_:::::_:::~_.:::_:::::_:::::_::::'_'::::_:::::_:::::_:::'_':::'-':--1.. ::1: .. ::I:.::I::::::::I~:i::~::.~::::::::Ii:;:::::::=:~:~~:::::.:~~':;,: ::.::::::::'::::::::
I ,
~S~~~ij~§~~~~~i~~~;~~~~~~;~~!~~~~~~ ~~z ~ ~ ~~~m~ 0 ~~~~w ~ ~~8 ~~ ~ ~ g8~~ ~ QZ ~~
. 0 mz ~ ~o ~ (/l
• Wh1le inexpensive, high-capaCity screensare available for'CNS drug development,in vitro screens such as receptor bindingare generally l1mited' to the identlficationof compounds similar to those alreadyavailable. due to their reliance on standard receptor mechanisms. An idealscreen would not depend on predetermined notions of mechanism, e.g., wouldbe one that measures a more complexfunctional activity such as whole animalbehavior. One could then work backwardto unravel a potentially novel mechanism.of action.
• Extraction procedures should not onlyoptlm1ze the alkaloid fraction but retain thepolar, water soluble compounds. An Initialcrude extmct With methanol would reducethe possibility of extmctlng amino acidsthat could result In false positives In receptor binding. A water extract of the remaining material should also be prepared.Molecu~sizing would be unnecessaty.
• While plants would be the major focus.any samples that have shown interestingactivity. either in preliminaxy screens orby ethnopharmacologlc data. should be
Therapeutics
~
.~ 120
~ 100I-tll ----.--~-~--------------iu.o 80',.....,1--··_....._....._....._....._...._... _..._... ..-.-.._._._....-.. ..--...:~
a:wlD60,-tII...·_··_·-····..:,···;·-·····-····-·····-·····_····_··.._•..._....._...._....._....._....._....._...._....._....._....._...._....._....,_...._....._....._...._...··..,...·····_·····"-7......:.·····_·····_·····_····_·.•._.... .:...'••._.•• _._~
::e:;) .. .. ,..:::~::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::~::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::~::::::::::::::::::: .. :.:: .Z40-tI--I-lI--I-..----------..--...:..--...:.....:............::.:.....:.....:....:.::.::....:.::.::....:.::.:~
. ASSAYFIGURE 3.- Receptor-BlndJng Activity ofSynthetic Compounds. Receptor proftle fromNovaScreen ofapproxImately 550 compounds submItted to the rrogram through theend of 1992. -Hits- indicate at least 50-percent displacement 0 the radIollgand atafinal assay concentration of 10-5 M.
t. ;,
!,I .~,J'1
ii,JilII:/
~II
l
180
U.S. Efforts in Natural Products Research
rather than usIng the commercIally avaIlable extracts.
• When consIderIng eventual commercIaldevelopment ofan active compound, synthetic capab1l1ty would be the Ideal. ThIsIs especIally Important when current regulatory requIrements are consIdered.However, If total synthesIs Is economIcally unfeaSIble, partial synthesIs couldbe an option. In addItion. communications with the U.S. Food and DrugAdministration should be established to explorethe possibiJities for development of standardized extracts.
• The cost of Implementing a modest drugscreening program depends on the degreeof cost-sharlhg by other.instltutions andby whatever financIal incentives can beprovided to prIvate-sector firms interested In drug development.
• This inItiative in pharmacognosy must becombined with ethnopharmacology toincrease the likelihood ofobtaining usefulmedictnals that are collected. extracted.and ~adm1nistered in the ,proper fashion(e.g., as a tea) to faCilitate extraction oftheactive cOl}stituent(s). The way the compound is handled may also give preliminary information about its stability (e.g.,dried root, whIch is good for months:fresh leaf preparation for each use).
• An important aspect for the chemist is tohave a readily avaIlable screening procedure (in vivo or in vitro) that can be usedto follow the activity dUrlhg the isolationprocess as fractionation and purIficationproceeds.
Topics discussed that clearly need additional work include the identlftcation of usefulscreening methods for novel psychoactivecompounds. Future NIMH workshops will dealwith this subject in greater depth. '
( -
Current Program Activities
NIMH is evaluating several natural productsreported to have therapeutic properties in thecentral nervous system. The literature regard.ing ethnopharmacologic approaches to thetreatment of memory disorders such as
AlzheImer's disease show that several plantsare extensively used for thIs purpose. Many areavaIlable in the United.States in health foodstores as extracts and as the powdered plants.One of the most widely studied natural cognitive enhancers in recent years is Ginkgo biloba.Extracts from the leaves of the ginkgo treecontaIn pharmacologically active glycosidesand ginkgolides. They are reported to enhancememory and to increase cerebral blood perfusion. 18- 21 A patented extract contaIning standardized amounts of the active constituents ismarketed In Germany and France. Gotu kola(Centella asiatica) is also used as a memoryenhancer and Is often sold in combination Withginkgo. These and a few other locally avaIlable"dietary supplements" with reported behavioral activity in animals or plants were analyzed in the NIMH-NovaScreen receptor binding assays. Preliminary' results of receptorbinding with the crude extr;lcts are shown inTable 4. Note that 25 additionalreceptors werealso tested at -6 /-lg/ml of these extracts butwere inactive (data not shown).
These affinity estimates assume startingmaterial to be approximately 1 g/ml freshplant (yielding approximately 20 mg/ml crudeextract), which is then diluted 10: 1 In 4-percent dimethylsulfoxide and 10: 1 agaIn in assaybuffer. At a final concentration of 20 /-lg/ml inthe Initial screening assay. samples inhibitingbinding at least 50 percent are then tested atconcentrl:\,tions of 20, 2, 0.2, and 0.02 /-lg/ml.This yields an approximate ICso. Assumingthat the crude extract contains 5 percent oftheactive compound(s) by weight, the affinity forthese receptors would be in the low nanomolarrange-well withIn pharmacologically relevantconcentrations. .
While the apparent in vitro activity of theseextracts is consistent with. the behavioral
>. effect~ reported in anImals. additional studiesusing standardized extraction and fractionation techniques will be necessary to confirmthese estimates. A graphic summary of' theresults of receptor-binding profiles for themore than 100 natural product samples profiled by the ·NIMH screening program as ofDecember 1992 is shown in Figure 4.
A collaborative effort for identlftcatioh anddevelopment of antiagmg. memory-enhancingdrugs has been ongoing since 1991 with Dr.Renuka Misra of NIH. This consists ofscreening
lSI
70-y---- -;- -,
ASSAYFlOURE 4. - Receptor-BlndJng Activity ofNatural Products. Receptor profile fromNovaScreen ofapproximatelY 150 compounds submitted to the program throuldtthe end of 1.992. -Hits- IndJcate at least 50-percent displacement of tileradloligand at concentrations between 40 and 300 Jlg/mlln the final assay.
TOTAL SCREENED. 146
NIMH, together with the NUl Offic~ for theStudy ofAlternative Medical Practice~ and theFogarty International Center, 'isspoIisodngworkshops and conferences on various aspectsof natural products research during 1993 and1994.
Current research initiatives ideal for jointIndo-U.,S. natural products research includepharmacologic characterization. isolation, and
~ 60-!--------------···-------------IZ:J 50 .....----------.oQ.::E 4O.tI-__-~-------.-I!!!!!I!!!!!!!!'I!!!!!!!!I!!!~!!!!!!I!!!!!!I!!!!!!!~.'-..-.--Ioo 30..-..._----------------------fW " ..
>.~ 20-t-.....-I1---------------=--:::--:-:-:".=....=.. ---:::=1o< lo-t-.=-FIFI~...Flir_=:=.:.:.:.:....-::..----------:::··:-:·'="':--"--:"-="-:"::-~-:-I'*"
crude plant extracts based on AyUlveda andAyur-vedic crude drugs used in the traditionalsystem of mediCine in India. Dr. Misra developed this collaborative progriun with Dr. SukhDev, Indian Institute ofTechnology, under theUnited Natlons Development Program throughthe Council of Scientific and IndustrialResearch. More than 100 plant samples andseveral Ayurvedic drugs (Rasayan) were collected and extracted in coldmethanol' for screening. Several crude extracts and fractions have lnltially shown significant receptor activity inseveral assays.
A computer search of theethnopharmacology data base(NAPRALER11 at the University of Illinois in Chicago isongoing. Potentially fruitfulareas for psychotherapeuticdrug developme.nt gleanedfrom this data base will resultin more detailed plans foradditional research. The NCIbotanical library has agreed tosupply any plant materialsalready available in theirlibrary for NIMH evaluation.
182
-
u.s. E;fforts in Natural Products Research.
structuralldentlftcat10n of active molecules Inmedicinal plants used In herbal medicine (e.g.,the AyUlveda). Thempeutlc areas of Interestwould include depression, psychotic disorders, anxiety disorders, and memory disorders. However, AyurvedIc d1agnosls and treatment of mental diSorders would likely useother tennlnology.Care must be taken tounderstand the prepamtlon and method ofadmJnistrat10n of medicinal plants. For obvious reasons, single plant prepamtlons are preferred for testing, and their botanical Identitymust be known.
REFERENCES
1. NIMH. Approaching the 21st centwy: Opportunlties for NIMH Neuroscience Research. DHHSPub. No. (ADM)88-1580. Washington, DC:Supt; of Docs., Govt. Print. Off., 1988.
2. Psychotherapeutic Drug Discovery and Development Program, PA-92-15, 1991.
3. Haigler, H., Cott, J.M., RUdorfer, M.,Schoenfeld, RI., Potter, W.Z., Vitiello, B., andEverist, H.D. Psychophann Bull 29:241-247,1992.
4. Efron, D.H., Holmstedt, B., and KI1ne, N.S.-Ethnophannacologic Search for PsychoactiveDrugs.- Proceedings of a -Symposium held inSan Francisco, CA, January 28-30, 1967.
183
5. Persinos, G.J., ed. Washington Insight, 5(4):7,1992.
6. International Cooperative Biodiversity Groups,RFA 1W-92-Ql, 1992.
7. Sen, G., and Bose, K.C. Indian Med World2:194, 1931.
8. Muller. J.M., SchUtter, E., and Beln, H.J.Experlentia 8:338, 1952.
9. Dorfman, L., Furlenmeler, A, Huebner, C.F., etaI. Hew GhtmActa 37:59, 1954.
10. KI1ne, N.S. Ann NYAcad Sci 59:107, 1954.11. Lehmann, H.E., and Hanrahan, G.E.AMAArch
Neural Psychiatry 71:227, 1954.12. Kuhn, RAm J Psychiatry 115:459, 1958.13. KI1ne, N.S. J GUn Exp Psychopathol 19(suppl):
72-78, 1958.14. Cade, J.F.J. MedJAus 2:349, 1949.15. Carlsson, A Pharmacal Rev 11:490, 1959.16. Carlsson, A, and Llndqvlst, M. A~ta Pharmacal
Toxtcol 20: 140, 1963.17. Daly, J.W.• Caceres,J.• Monl, RW.,et al. Proc
NatlAcad Sci 89:i0960, 1992.18. Gessner, B., Voelp, A, and Klasser, M.Arznetm·
Forsch/Drug Res 35: 1459, 1985.19. Vorberg, G. GUn TIials J 22:149, 1985.20. De Feudls. F.V. Ginkgo bUobaExtract (EGb 761).
Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1991.21. UlI, T.M., Le Bars; P.• Eralp, E., and Itll, K.Z.
Presented at the American College of Neuropsychophannacology, San Juan, Puerto Rico,1992.
DECADE .OF THE BRAIN
India/USA R:~search in, (.~ .
Mental Health and Neurosciences
Editors
Stephen H. KoslowR. Srinivasa Murthy
George V. Coelho
u.s. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICESPUblic Health Service
National Institutes of Health
National Institute of Mental Health5600 Fishers Lane
Rockville, MD 20857
;.:.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
These proceedings and the Decade of the Brain Symposium could not have beensuccessfully completed without the diligent contributions from many individualsin,I1?;,Pia ~fl ~e, U,Jli~ed ~~tes of A1J,)erica. Spec~aI thapks ~e pu~ ~ membe~pfth~ ,DePaibne,lltsof, '~sychiatry;· N,a~onal Institute qf:Meiltal Hea!~ and NeuroSclences;"'Babgalbre. 'India:;' tlie hosts for the meeting. in particular. Mrs. P.V.Bhargavi. for coordinating the meeting and collating the Indian contributions andDrs. T.G. Sriram and Kishore Kumar for documentation support and organizationof the scientiflc sessions.
The US delegation Is extremely indebted to Mrs. Delores Dorman. Division ofNeuroscience and Behavioral Science. National Institute of Mental Health.National Institutes ofHealth. USA. for her scrupulous attention to the details andarrangements to coordinate all of the needed documents and schedules for travelto and from1ndia. and 'coordination of the editing of the final volume.
, .": • . ' ,;;,. 'i.' • , ."'. j ".
Special thanJtS are due to the US Embassy staff. in partlc;ular the Scientiflc"tA~ta9~e. Mr:qray' Handley ,and':'his as!'lstant Mr. ,M~ohan ("Bllla") Saxena"Without whose' guidance and care this Symposium would not have been the greatsuccess it was.
Ftnally. great appreciation Is due to the staff of the Office of International Healthof the Office of the Assistant Secretary ~or ~ealth. In particular. to Mrs. LindaVogel. Director. Office ofInternational Health. and Ms. Tina Chung. Public HealthAdviser for providing technical guidance and admtnistrative support throughoutall stages of the preparation for, the US delegation's travel to India.
COPYRIGHT STATIJS
The table and figures appearing on pages 44-52. 54. 73. 75. 78. 87. 132. 187.206-209. and 216 are copyrighted and are reproduced herein with permission ofthe copyright holder. Further reproduction of these copyrighted materials Isprohibited without specIfic permission of the copyright holder. All other materialcontained In this volume is in the public domain and may be used or reproducedwithout permission from the Institute or the authors. Citation of the source isappreciated.
Printed 1995
~ . 1,·1