1. INTRODUC'.\ 'jY\Q'",t":"'·'njtkQVCro.lI ':lCA.ft.ty 01"16 ~,ul"i+'f oftk.in~+·,+u-tion., 'oIJo.s 5. peffnc\oni non ~tro.hoto. e\'V\pl0 'l

$Page 1: 1. INTRODUC'.\ 'jY\Q'",t":"'·'njtkQVCro.lI ':lCA.ft.ty 01"16 ~,ul"i+'f oftk.in~+·,+u-tion., 'oIJo.s 5. peffnc\oni non ~tro.hoto. e\'V\pl0 'l$
r

U.S, Dl~lf\\C..l C,.C:I-)~\ FCR lHE.. WE..51E.R~ ~lSlRKl Ct 'Wlse.c~H'~

L0l5 VAr:JdOf.I I t)~VlD e;,Rt~\NOOD.

JfMffi Sf>U>..U.'?..~O\.\M~LC"E.l,I\Nl\-\cNY RH\C.\-\,onbe."'a.\~ ()Hnt.V\'I~e~

0.\'\0 in ~o-'nOe.r

?Ia'-IntiffSI

v.

\)~~\l\.\)~\~ ~lRt\~\C1"',

lLUA~ ?c\..\."'?.~, P~,",U.""'lANK.

11 J ~' • ,l'J\\(.)-\ft...tL

l\\ORMf..R,~'~~~~

Soe.6 -,,,, \h..... ' ·''t\o-'''iduo.\ 00"'6 ~Ht.i",\

<:o.po.c..H ies,Defenc:\~ts.

AMENDE.D ~Dt.EJHlC\Y1L Rll21:DS A~1StcJ'Ot-J19B3

1. INTRODUCTIDN

Thi5 ',5 0. c.'oVi I Y"ig"'\~ o.d\on f',le<\ 0'1 tht. pI O:'Yl;\,HS Ll)',~Vo.":>,\ue.1.., Oo."id (,yttY\\NOOO I jo.\I',,,-y

So.\o.Zclt I 3ul', an Lopez I o.",d Jlrdhon'{ RiQc.h for Money clo.m0'.le~ o.",~ 'n~t.>nd""~ reI" :f U'nCe.rYo 0.S.C- S€.c.,lq'il'3. "The ?Io.int\Hs, ~;Q,tt. ?r·,~one.rS 0.; \No.up"'''' (.oY"fe.diono.\ 1.V\st'ttution

(Ave.r '\'ho.; tn\t. 6e.fe.nCO'r'lt~ OOon'lel ~ro.ernel" I~n S"tto.noto., 'Wi llio.m ro\$)or~,?o.vnltlll. 7..an~.

:Jeffrlt'l Go.rbQ.\VY'\Qn ,"""Coho.el ,nur mer 0."'0 <:;'0,.,/ 1\",1<",..10 Su'o~e.d'ld thl1.m,o",e ton\"nue to

S.ub~e,d t~ ,'0 c.e",e',t'~<;of c..onfine.Mt.nt \n Violot..cn of thli'f £.igh-th o.",~ FourteenThAmendmw 'r'\'3n'~ ,\I)"""'-I.),~.c.e.....~'\\\"t ..OV\. ih~ ~\o.\V\'\-HS ~~.,~'!.'" l"<\.. ",~wt. '~o'\Y\Cll.."'<:>~ t,",~

",o..,.,..t.c1 ~\o."V\,"',ffs Ooh~ 6e.fehda.hU Uncll!.r ~$\~ (il.o (o..~)@) ,f~. R, C.\\I, 1'" ().V\~ '0'/ the.... p~5Itio"'S

o.hcl o.-Hi6",vi+~ ,xe.'I\ lec>.Ve ,\1) P,"OC-el!.6'W'l for"",,,, po.upe.r.... UY'\C~r C).~ o,~,<;, ,~e..~, tC\IS,

II. JOR1SD1C,\()N

-1-

Case: 3:11-cv-00806-bbc Document #: 25 Filed: 02/06/12 Page 1 of 17

Ill. PARTlE-S

Di5rnt\Ap;::' In§oImo,t',bn

3. Dckl='~"...:I" Donie\ (3"reJ.!:.rN,c i~ e.m plO'flt.d b.., t~ O~podl"M.n+ of c.orrc..e.tion~ ~ 0.. SuptT

\I',~iT\j oHiUr 1 Q.i~t~l'\""t) o..t W"~T\ C.oTrc..c;.+ioy\/A1 'l.n:,titution, ~Q() ';). t'\ad"~Y\ ~t.,Ylo.up"n,

Wi~,S~%3·0'3SI.

'I. In hiS c.Qpo.eity o.s lit.uT(,nQrrt elf Wc.1. , de.fc.ndQnf Bro.t.I'l""u ',~ rc..~pon'i>ilolt. for ~upc.rvi~i"j

0."'.\ 'jY\Q'",t":"'·'nj tk QVCro.lI ':lCA.ft.ty 01"16 ~,ul"i+'f of tk. in~+·,+u-tion.,

'oIJo.s5. peffnc\oni non ~tro.hoto. e\'V\pl0'l<.d ~I t ....... O<.partrN.n+ of corredioM ~ tllc..5t.C.Ori+y

O'lrc..c..+or 0.+ wo.upun c.o'f'rc..~-tiO"'o.l 'l.n::.ti'l~\On,OlOO':>' MadiScl\'l st,,\No.uflon,wi::'.5~q(,,'?l-O~51.

.. / ~

~, In'"hiS CJ.Ipo.c.av o.~ se.c.ur',+v l)"'c.e.+Or o..t WC.I, c:\efc.."Jo.nt stro.ho'lo. r('.~pon~·lbl<. for ~('."c.lopl~,

o.dl"f\\'i,~\tr·l~,o.l"P ~~r"i~\~ th'l ~<.ne.r"'1 5o.fc..tv 0."6 Sf-OJrHv oft...... \n~t·,+utio'h \'" o..c.c.ordance.1.»\;1-. o()(.. 6"Cc..C:\'IVc..S and ~k ph',l\) sopt." of tk. \n~t\;l.1fto,l'l..

1. Ddf,04Ant 'Wi lIiam:f9\1o.r9 \0;, e\'V\plo'(c.d b" th'l. Oep'lft~n+of <:.orrc..dions 0.:> iN.. WQrckn

o.t woopun COHc..C.~'Ion",\ 'l.n:,tavtion J ~oo 5, M"diSon ~t,) 'IN o.upun,Wi ~, 539G)~-O:>'6\..

~, In h,~ c.o.po.c.a'i o.~ -th<:. wo.r9<tn 0.-\ Wc..~, o~{t\'\d"'n~ PO\\CAfd i~ "<!.~pOf'\~·,b\e. for -\N.- Cjlt.nero.l

C'Pe..ro.~"On 0.",6 ~m'ln.. !>tr/At',o'r\ of t""- i"'l)t',;vt'IOn,

q. Defln4aot pen",\o, 'LCnlli \::. e,""'pIOVc.d b" t~ O~P"Tt~otof CCrrll-dion" o.~ t"-o. ~rtS",+ion

U",\t \,¥\""",,~U 0.-\ WOU'p\>YI c.o'f'r<tc..~"oY\G\\ 'l.nstitotion, J-oo 5, Mo.di~n 5'1, ,'Wo.IJP'Jn )\Ni~.S~q"3-03'51.

1~ 11"1 ht.r c.o.Po,C.-'+'1 0.:' t ...... seg Uy\',T l"\"Io.""d,r ) c:k~\!l'\6(\l\t 2.0.1"11'- i ~ fc.~~"ble for tho.. overo.\lmo.no.St~ot o.nd SopuviSiOYl oH~ 5e.gre,3o.tiol\ 'ou\\~ ..nj.

11. Defgnc\ani ..

~.


_(.ho\,,~"~~ ~e\'vi",c. Un'.1__ ';)up'~rvi:>c>r (),1 VJ .....:'lpUn C.orl~djono.\ l.n~Ht"tion l;'oo .... ' .......c:\i~orL~"\, ,WC:l\)put'l,

_WiV5:!l'Ho~ - O:'~I. _ __

_ld._,_ln hi!> Co.po..c.",ty_ Q.~. o._C.\iY\'.(.o.L~~r.lI'i~[ .ot.kn~nt 'tI1!1', 'rw.~~A.i:Li~d'SSp.oo~ib~or:..:t.kovU_o.IL _

_.c.o.Qrn',nil'lrc,t;o'l) of 'tbL?~'1thu\0l:lito.1..serYic.4Luni'l._ --- _....... -- --.---1,------

--13~Qd'nC.'r,+Mic,pQ,£..1 lh"J'O''S,i'_ u.lf,\~_e,t.l:>ll!(N(,.~Io.-t-U-"-JJ~p,,,d~ot_oliou.4Ldjon.s...o.LWc'LdC!l'\ _

_..G.L'WCM)r'l'l c..ol'({.dim,,\ 'l!\'i:h:tloJ;.i.m, ;'00 S -M-_,'.Qj~S'\., .\i"9.~pJt.l.,W.i\., '5:'''lb;'.- o:?:.51. , _ .

~_ln.h;L<..,fll"(,l·I_Q.~ :f~...._for~ Wl'Ar.d~n ..(ALWc..1., ol(.-{'ln~"nLlhur_~,r:..b().A.:t~ Scl~n.~pPO~ibjJi ..i~ I

.....duti!;~ o" ..Lo.U.\ho\:'.-hI_ o'''_~~J(.·,J ..n.t p"np.rLSe<:.-'i1-~~,•.

_i5._.Ik.:£.<:nA"ni ' \})o.~_e.mp\~(..L~_"\-",.d)(9"rtl'!'<rd. of <:.or rJtdiClnS_Q. ±\-t--c.. P~'fc.hoIOSil>t

~(.rvi'(. onit_wpe.rl/i~or_o.~ Wo.upvn CDr rc.c.tion.., Insii-fofil»1 laoo_5._MQd.iSolL5t, ,_w~oPJ.In,w~.53%3,

11'0, I" hi;' c."p",:.l'( !A\ it,,_ -fortl'..r c..lini£"i ~t.r.\I ;,:.t.s :)'-'I,£,,,j$07', d,<:fe'N~"'nt 'He 'rt ho..d tl><.~me

_re.~pon~'. bi li-li(.l> , 6u-\ie\ Q"d ~T_o..::.ek-{C.n6o.,,-t Gal1\1:)i.i'~. ~«. 'iI.tel o.bovc.._ +_

_Ad~it;cno\ Dll:fcn~~_.._1.1.

----+--------- ----. 4- --- -- --

- .._.-- .. - - - --------_._-- -+------- ---

-----

_dC.

-3-

,

1

------i

+----

--_..... ------_.

- --- . -------j--


Qth(',r \.Q~...);:;,q·,t$

~5. lhQ. pla'",r'tiff!> ho.ve ncrl ~on ot....~r \ ~v:l~lh 'In ~tQ1t.or fe-der..1 C.CUrt r(.\Q+i...~ 10 tt-t. 5o.rne.

fo.d~ ""WOIVed \n +h'l~ 0.,,+',01"\.

doC", lh't pl'''mt''ff Lr..>'I~ \loMIl.le.<', ooe.':l ~c>.V~.. two f~ro.l IG\W&.li1~ ~nd'l\"Ij in Wj~c.on~il'1.

Vo.~qOI~7. V. 1rcc..h·,,"~i} c..G\~(. NO.1-1-(_V. 'r'74. I:>bC.(W.D. \N'5. "'-''3,d.3,~OI~jo. ... ci Vr».qIJU. V.

,::>-trCAhtrla. I e: (\1-, C().~e NO. ·8, {.v .. Q3'/ (f..D. \~JiS. a.ooqXFint.J prdr;<ll Coof'crmc( ~•.Q :l~lr.,..1r'a.1 rror.R.ed'\T"~S i5 S+"'1d).

lV. PLI\\ t\}11 FFS' S1A.l f.MUn OF FAc..1S t

VO,:;,g0e7.'5 Stuk!l'<tn\ of f o,c:.;\S

al lht. plCl\',ntiff LuiS Vo.S'foe'Z. no.':l a history of ~rio\J~ me.ntal he.o.lth pro'oleYl"ls.)o\eis

c..uHllntl'f C.liniCall'j Oi08flO5ltO ~..t'" 0.. ~.-.t"1 ~'th ro."\-·,~ of a.(MH-a.) Wh\c.h f'5'1c.holoSiC-AI

c:.eTvic.f!.~ u~e.51b Of!.n<>\f!. a SeriouS rY'<tnt<.1 illness,

~'i5. Or. Novw-.w 13 ,a.ooco J plo,n+iff \Io.5~~'Z.WG\':l ~emtl.nc.1:.d -t1> ~ 6"',/5 o.d~'iltl"Nl1-t o.nJ 3EIOdo.'t~ \'f08rarr> Se.ar~D.tjon dt.~pitf!. of hiS pS'IdlologieaJ disorclu tr i:Jjf,ri~ behavior.

aq. J>.Htr C-Ornplt:tinj hiS ':le~reg(A1ion ~f!.n1.1"\''L\n "'OVt~r of ~oo" We",o~nh Don $1ro.hcrto,o.~ oan',u ~ro.Ul'lc.r re.c.oml'Nnded t\-lo,\ V~'4v('l. oc ~ub~wt 1t> iY!de.finik AdmJnistmtive. c.on

"'\"Il/"rN..n1 purSUGln'l tb 0. poliC.'f l:ln6er \Ni~. Mrn.c.ode.- Se.c.. ocx. ~'6 QQ,~c.J On ni~ ~h(;\vior ~,"rib(J

o.\oove..

~. ()n ~e.ce.rnber 1.'1, d.CX>1 I in. ac.c.ordM«.. With wi~.Ad ..... · COd(" $«. 00'-~ J iN.. GldItlinisiro.tj~

Confintt'l"u1t Cornrnitt«. ck~rrnin'l.cl thoi vo.~G1ue(..b~ plo.c.td in odm',)'\;~tr.....+ivlt.. c..ol'\~i~~V\-t ~

on ~'trdo.n~ 5tro.hom's c.no (3r4ile~r's re.c.omrNnd"dil>n.

31. .M 0.11 t·IrN.5 fc.\t.VClnt tt> "o.5qv(.'Z.·:; C.on-finf!.YN.nt in tk.. ~rl/.jo,+ion t,)1"1\+ IVCASque" ())~

Sl.>b.>e.c..tc.d tt> o.n t,)nc.O'(l~..\itu-\iO""'\ ?ol>,",/ Or prCAdie.t. unotr Co<:.. '3~ tho.t 6<a.PT·'V~ nim of OIJtdool e..j.l/.rc.i~e.) Sub~td(c! hIm til btre.YN.. \",YV\ito.tion~ of indoor e:l-eTc.iS~ and r«.reFtionli\"l~

S\)Y\\"~h\ o.l"\~ ~ Pll\'"l\t\V(. ~rt.~o;\ioYl '5dtil"lj ·,no.ppf"Prio;\"<t..fat tk.. ~l'ItDolly ill.

1 ~\,)~t. tht. plo;lnHfh C.ol'\~-.tion5"o.lo"e/l m","1 not '5tQtt 0.. c:.Io.il'Y\ uncler tt-Il. e.i.,5ntn or

four~4!.t.l'Ith amtl'lciYN.n!, the.. <.cud ShovlO c.o.....!>idt.r o.Y"\Cl.\\1.\nj ~\Q\nf\~h c.on6Hiol'\!> in'toto.\

Co .... ..L' IIrnU'\,,\o.TIOI'I.·4-


0. (.t.\1 th",+ i ~ Se.po.rCltlld from + op~n - 0"'''+ 10'1 ~ ~O\icl 'M....I 600t I 0.'" entrCln'~h"U, "",cl COrridor

~Hh 0. lol"j Wo-U ~tru<.\or~ 0..; t Untllf O{ t"'-h"u ~ forUl.. e.~trllll"<.. \501,,tlon I ~oe"o.l isol"tion I

';)~n'ilory d~pr..v...tion )",n~ -10 flH.Vtnt ViSl.lQI- hOrYl«n CO\"l1...d /.-Vi+h other inl'l"lCrle S.

33, Vo-::'Ci0t:l. wo.~ <.onfin~ Y"I~o-r ~4- hoors 0.. 00.'11 0.10\,\(..) in 0.. ~rn"'H c..c.1l c..o\'\strue.t<.J With

(.ol'I '-rttc. floor ,lor·,c.\<' Wo.lIS ,o.",c! "- bo)C. c..o.r - 'iotet Idoor that c..G1U~.5 e.,Jltrerr'C. foyc.oto i~ olo.tion I

'5o(..iQ.I "!>ol"tion I':lel\~()r'l de.pl'lVo..+ion l"-nO ~riVo.tioYl of 0',1"«.+ human C-Or>t""t,7h<.. '-WS h",vc. "- 5" Solio Wi'n6ow \\"1 t ...... 0001" tho.t proviclc.s li"",,;hd view of-th'l. oot of cell

~H;(n~h oncl ~ 15" SOlic! ~il\claw in tN. \.l.X.\11 \h"t prou·.<4s lim'ttd View of -fJ-.... outsld~ e ....viron

~ttn\. 7hc. 5" ~licllJ.>indow "H'lik WCAII unitS liHlt 5Uhl\jh+inib+l-<LpICliniiff'S CUI, V~qoel.~

locKed in hi~ '-ell neo.rly ~"I. hours "- c! ...y with \'ll"r'Ii+t-d out of Uti yY!OVotrr'tnt,

3lJ, \lo.~qlJ(.1. l).)""'> CA\I~ ou+ of h·.s cell'Only I.j-heurs aWe.«¥; for "urot"tion or ellerc.iSt. "h

0.. ~mQ.1\ I <;'1"~n\ly ·'III.7I·I..... ..,"'te.o )',ndoor )<:..otxft.t't."::.tr\J(.wr~ r~c.rt.o.t iOn",1 ~~tt·.nj 1\'\+~~ un·,t.7ht. Sl'Yl<l1l iYldoor "e.e.rc."tion,,\ '5e..+tinj ~nta',ns <D SmAil c.~~ ~il"n',I"r to-tn~U~~ fOr COn

fi\"'l\"j w.\c!l o.n·.rn"I~1 0.\"'10 Sever"'l b"rrllc!> Wi",~0V3S h"h up neAr tN..c.~1I1inj o.ncl ovt of~-h:> flrtl,vlnt \nvY'lCl.tt.s from ~u:\nj ou+~"d!/..

!

35. 'Ihq". bc...r~ winclO\.o.>~ \n t\-.c."h~ n:.C.u..cc\ionGl\ ':It.Hinj CM~rn',t \.. tH«.. $vnliSht h~'" upntto-r the c..e.ilr.\'\j (Ano ()..)\ of reo..c.h -t1:o pnv~",t "~ve7... of o·.r(.C.+ c.ontc.d With the hei:l.t andIi9ht ~'IHt.db'l the. Sun, "!.r, OYcltr fo" \fo.~que..'l. -to c.o~'\'n~ 6\"t.<'+ c..onto.c.t ~Hh t ......neA~ or1i'3\oot from;-\-.c. 5ul"l, h(.. WOUld 'nQ.c..A +0 be.. 1.0 fu+ to.ll or srl/.Cltl/.r. 'IIo.~9uU lJ-XlS de..pT·'Vt.O of ~

~\l"'te Sun for 5 'feArs. 'IIo.sqve'l.. wo.s Ioc.'l<.c.d \'" hiS UII neAr\y HoY hours o..~ wit",ou'; QYl'f

A"fte1 ~l>n ~)j.pof>ure ~ tk-bcd'f' 1h~ 1M,,", of <r,nd e)C.posur~ 'tt> tk. 5un e.:AQ.c.l/.rbo..+~V~'l.'S

~to.\ o.~ ~'n-t~I(.Q.'hu..lth. 7r... IQ.GI< of ';)UYl,~ht C.QUst.d Y~CjIl(7... Sl<.in problems, il'la«qUGte~'f (.a1C. ium ) i no.c\tqvG\te. heAlth c..i" wlo.+\OYl) '", o.~utvcdq".bone.. ";)tr<tJ"'[j'th l'ln~~Vo.ie vi to.rty,n 0 \0.\"'I~ ot~r heAlth problems. Vo.~ql>«-l. wo.:. c.ol'\~t",ntl'l <kpT·.Vtd of +\-.c. e.!ot.,....."'·H) nutrients,

Or~nic.. 'i>ub-,.t"n(.e. prov',.;l/.d b'l tk~n) e.~~(..nti",\ -ror 11"h. rnGlin'tvn<lnc.(.. o.ncl~rowth. v~:-qvel.

I).)(\.':I 'i>u\o~(.e:ttJ to c.o'nS+IIl".t ottpr'.Vo.tiOh of clrt.c.1 e.)lPOSUfe.. ~ hloa'" G\I"I~ I~rrt emiHed bt+h(,.SOnto \'Iel/l 5vpport htA I+h c..\ rc.VICAt ion, func:.+ion of tN,...bo~s,() ncl rr.~il"o+Q/''1 ...nc.1I- of bc:1rte. ~rellj+l"lhe.. ICAt'" of heG\lth'l (...kc..ul ..+icn o.rlO bone ,~trlon~th \'n-t<.rfut.C UJiih V~Ci0U.·~ abili~ 1ll (~<lSe'In \fi3orOU!> e.,c(.T'tiSt. C4nO o.c;f,vitie.s.

~. 7he. indoor rc.c.rt."tionGl\ ,::>e..Hin5 provid~ Orlly '" rU\\-~tJ bar. '" fUII"uP bar inapproprio.ie.

for t\-..o.. ~rl-\- ...\I'1 ill. \f~'{ve"Z.'S YMnt", o.nd l'h-/~\Cal c..onoiiioYl mo<olt. it Vl/.pl d iff i ('\,)It ~ I\tt OT

Suppot-\- h\~ OU>r\ ~C.·I~ht. I."fClo.d J va.sqvez. ofttn cl icl not (1"5 ""eo in o.n'( e)l.ert iSot loe.t«uS'/. hiS

vYll/,.Y\t,,\ \\\f\ll~~ pr't.vc.n'kd hIm from empl0'linj i .... o.n'/ e..Hrti!>L or CM..tivit;e.S fur ph'l'~iVlI fitnu~.

-5-


37. 7he.. Small indOOr reu-e..tA.+iono.l 5e.Hin~ die! nof provide Vo.SCf0e., (Pitl-) ",c.(~Ss +0 meGhc,nic;",

v->t.:'5nt~)'fl"\~<.ho.n·,UI\ ~)l~ rC, Sf.. e..ll',t·, (0. I tro. inu, ~c;hQn',c." I ~"~r' i s~ frlt",d,.,..,; II ,1"n'l(.r.o.n·,c.QI eller·

C.ij,(, Q\"'~ or en ....r \<..."O~ ot ......-e.Gh...n·.<. .., (.'J~rCi~It eqoif'rr..n+ fUr +~l'J'.en+.. lly ill.

3"6. 1,... ",ddi1ion ,"ClSCiue1- ofhn ei6 \"\0+ C.n5Col"~ 'In 0.'(\'( e."<.rc;iS~s ~'4US«'of tNt. lill'Mecl

ShoW<.rs)liyY\·rh.ci "iloc<p ,OI"~ lil'Y'lit«.d e-hCAn:l' of Cloth<.-S.

3Q, V(A~Ci\)eL otten dio not ~\"\[j"'tl(..in o.n,/ rUnninj) ~05~iY1j ,or jumpinj .)",Gj(s be..cq,oslt.+""~te.tlt - i ~o(,d ~hoe.5 yYlQck it d iHi<.ujf or irnpo'I;\ibllt. for hWYl +0 run ,~~,or ~pir\5J4<.K in

"l--ItVY\ on ',)(;)'\0 C.C>Y\(.Rtt~Ioors."(AS,Ci~"Z..~ not ,",\I<:>~~ -t.:> ho-Ve...\o\i\ p<r~"l shc>a. He WAJ

01""1 allouxd ib \..Ow.- (A p~ir of '5tutt - i S,\ue.d sh~s of ~)(+r(~ low '1"""li+-l. 7J-..o.. ..h~S o.r( I'I'lG«

i\'\ Vo·,no..'~'1 "'T(.. e.1l1r(.I"I'-Uy thin. Tfv.. Sole.. of+k Shot-s are.. Glbol>+ 0. qtJ<l.r+er of Gln inCh +hidt.,

().~ i.PNn \lCAs.clu~"Z, C\1tcl"Y'~cI to run or~ or ~l>r"P intJ-..r'f\ ,+J-."'S<llid Cl c.rde. flc..'Or in{lidq,J

fX'.n )Scn.YH~~':»)irf·,t"tion o.n~ SlA.l~\\inj 1otM..~~r",I.>rf",r. of 1-K ·fu..-tOIllJ heel.

- YO. 1'1'1<. v.m.Mrn. COOIt. ':Ie-c.. DoC. ~oq.~CD Ollo~ pris<:>ners in o.n ',nvOlunt""" u\'\CAs~j~necl

~\"h)~·./lo ~ '\\,\ Oi non· pl.'i'I.,t'o,,(. ':>tr...i~l~ to podic'pGI1'(, i r> ph'ISiC."1 e>ttr( i~~s (:{n.! CA.d ivitic ~'G~ asbtl !k"tb"\1 ,n".-.c\oClII )t,,~\t 'ttnni ~ ,vol''''/ \;'''11 ;footbOil, +rMk (;o"d j p. Id )V-lt!. j,'jlf~ Jif-f i~, I ~to.t',ont\r'l bi~,

0. \lo.y\.t't of e.~~fCi\t m"ch·.~~ ~nd eYer ciS~ trAin',,,", q.qojp~n1.HCVJII-ver, VCA\qV(..'Z. I.On" ('oilS in a

',YWO'U +<1('1 uno.S~4jr-.ul ~+..-tv5 " ...,d 'In '" nOfl-poni1 ~ ';fr..-tvs lJ.)GlS 'jood~dc-d to 0. f' lit., lll'lde.r

\)(X. 7P6 thGli ll11~~dGJ hi ~ eJtr(,~ <k.('rivo.-tion of suc.h ovl~ e1ltr c i~, ph'fSi<:G<1 a.divitl~~ )[And ('.)(UC;~ ec!uipfY'<n.1 "er.~ )S"'r I iT.> help i7laini ... in y;od )~Jfh. 7~ /(M.k cf ~h",njCD./ e,c((

C'\~<,- eqV"prN"t ,tk.I"'k of ovtdoor e)t(rc:i~ Ql"ld phvsic"" c<divifies, Cll"lc! +1-< '''ck of o.dequem.V'!'OV(.\'Y'(l"It, caus«\ V'SCiveZ. S~riouS or Sijn'f1cGlnt htu>/'t/, pr-OblUflS, Su,,/, t:lS hi.," chol~,-rol)

o.b~ ',l" <ll r*:IU\+-/.h,p~r1tnS iOll, rnuS C,\~ w,e kilnt po'I!' )S~'iffMSS ) i'''lo.d.!.qlJq+-: I::o!>-t lelnpU<:l1vre I;nr.td~..efL'.:rI'-. h..£",lth Cl'rcvlc.tion,\hoOl/J1v<lk. he.C1rh·"t", I it,,,,,<Ie.qucrk b"n~ ~/-reljtl1 QI~ (')tl--••r h~h

plbbltmS,

Lfi. The... c.Dn~·,+it>""5 of vc,squez's (onfiNf7'<'.,tOcff~(.~tc!, and <':xo.cerb,,+/I.cl h',s t"'()'lfo.! he~lfh,

to th<l.. ~+(nt, h'l.- o..H~mpt~ Svic.id~ ono Se.lf-harm on se:1/Ii!.ra.\ oc.ca"'''''o'''',

Ll~. 'Udendo."t~ Danie-l 13r<4'<Y""-r, 001'\ '51 r",h :ttl,Wi\l;o,m P \\ard IPCl.l,,<.Ia. ZonkJ :}e.H It)'

c,CArbtlrYIM I Mic..ho.e.1 "Thl)r~r ~",d &ary AnKo.'l"lo Wt.n.. o,lJ.)CAflt. of 'Soc;.h c.o.,..,clitior>\ i\'\ +~

~~r~.j"~·'OYl UnH)Ond t"~_·\n\po.d ',+ l...)"~ c,',uSin..9 ()pcn v(.o·~'wt:(.·S heaHh ,.,..,d Saftf..t l 'Ye",de.~pit1t nCo\v"l"lj (;\(.-/\",1 Kn''Wledj'" of hiS p'i5h-1 ""d·n o.u/horit,( 0... CG,pClc.;f·{ 10 ·t<.. K'l. Corll:c:J;v~


o..<..tioY'\ \Y"\ 0",6'1.f iu prot'l.c.t \I~9u{1.' 5 ~H'" ",.,6 SGlfdy) fG\i I 'l.d ~ ccrr~c.+ +kviolG\'tion or to.l<4

0."'1 r'l.~onC\b\1l- ~~ur't\ -h> pT't>h,<..t VClS'\,_>{'t.' S h.u<lth CI"C S"'1l1.f-( to prl1.v.q,y,+ fvr+Nr /'N.,,+c<1 o.",cl

flh'f\il'" ckhrioratiol"l) '5 ie ;~lZ. at-h".,pfs, '5-(lf-hQtM ,0.",6 PC.'IY\ an~ '5U'ff'l.rlnj.

GrUtJ ().?()<;?O 's 'i:lto.te.~n+ Of Fo.c:.ts IY3. '1h'1... -P\C4\nt'lf.f DG\V'l(~ Greenv.:oo:\ hG\'i ~ hiyh,ry of ser',ou~ ~n+"d N.c.lfh probl'l.ms.

7!lOU.!)h , cll/..Spi-R hiS P~1- C\r16 f'l.c:.'tn+ Suic.-i d<., c.#eml"1:s ) he.. i 'i wr r't"tl'l c..\ ini c,,1 "v d '1"3"'O~'l.cl <lr\ly

~"+h CA \N\"\t<It hl/.Cllth fQ.t'I\"lj Of 1~H-1).

'14, On AUBu&+ a.l ,c;.ooq I pI ',n-\-',H Gne..n~ WC\l, S'l.nh!r'\c-l1.d 1-0 ~ ek>.YS GldJO'otYN."t'5~r~'\tion o.nO '3CoC 6G\yS 6'\~Cipl'an",r'l ':,l/.,p"rCl.+;on f'o'(' Io~h",viorth,,+ (,.Ua..S CA r'l.f>ott O'f h'l~

p')'1"nolcfjko,\ ci"c:r~r,

Lot'S. ~H(r Cornple..+in.j Y'I,S '&tltJ'rezJc<tiWl '5{nhl"\cf2., d'I.--f(ndCl"'+S Don Str-G\ho+<- ~nc! Dcmi'l.l

13ro.~~r '(<.(,omTY"<n~'l.J thctt c;reen~ bQ..Subj~d10 a.6Yh',ni~tr"'+iv~CohTin"~nt pur'il<.:Qn+ iu 0. f>OI"G ( l.Jr'.der Wi .. , MYh, Cock. Sec.,l)oc.. "30"6 'oe-,>'l.d. On hiS Io"h"vior de~c,l",bd aboW.

4(", 0\'\ ~~~mlxr d-~ J ~O\o) '1\'1 Q.<.c-orc.C\nclZ.. W',+h Wl~, Ac.rn. c.odcz.. -S~c.. Doc.. 7::P"! ,+I-.A.. a.c

ft'\iy\',\1rcmve, c.ey;f',~,.,t <.cm",,',Hl(,'t..dlt:tt~m'l\'\.tcl thc,t <br«~ be.. rl~ceJ In o.dministra.-t\V1l.

conf'I~YM""~ bCl.l>"cl On d<L-ttn&l",t~ c;ir"h~'S "n~ 13ra(n"v'5 n:,(oi'hfN"ck-+ion.

l.I1. At 0.1\ +"\')'\'1.5 fe..lt.VGln+·n, 0r~~f1wooclS Conf\h~nt -1\'" tk ~~~c,tio" I'M ,h~w0.5 Subj<Lc.1'1..d -h:> on \,mc.on'O,Hh>+\oY'IOlI pelicy or p'rC\vti(,'l., 1.)h6er Doc.. 1:><=>1) +h",+ d~pr'IV~ him of oufckloi' ~lt'('C.-,I.~1 'ilu~~hd h\m ~ e)l.m~\"1Y"",tCltiohS 0+ 'Iht\cor eHre-j ~~ c."d rll.C-r-<.cdioYl, ;V1o.Jequcrte ~u", "'jh't C\nJ it> P;>hit\~ S~:r~C<Tion Sll...t+i"..5 in"PS'rcpr,ol'k for +~~Y\~\\Y'I\\'

Y'iS. Ai 0.\\ t'IYTlt5 rll.lt.V"nt h C!>rU,nl"Voo.!'S c..or-{lne..V""<-wt'!n tM....$~r-ljCltiOr\ (')Y\it,Gn~nlProd wasStlb~<u:+~ ~ GIn unecnstit'utiO\"\C11 POlity or pnl.C+;u ()(\o<.r DOC oo'jS' rhott d'l.fr'lN!d him of ou-f~ re-c..He..w~ \~C>\CI-htcl'ln 0- (,.tll thovt '1 S. S'~P'I ...G\ttel frvn.-,+~O~Yl-l>r",<t by c;,. Sci i~ Stu I da:>r ,Q.n emr"\'\e'l.hC\I\J~"o. e.ctri~r wH'''' Cllan~ Wall s-truc.furtcl at- ...k. ~y,+tr of-tJ...,h"lI ~ .fo~'t..~~~iS"\Oltian,~ 'Sory d~rl..,extjC+1I"i\d to pru)t.n+ ViSua.\ c..oy\~c.."".

4'1, Q,"«nWocd WClJ C<-~Nd ""-<Z.Ar\.{ ~., ~ htXJYS a. J,,'1 j C<~ Ii h '" 5/71",1 ce,l sfroc~ wlJ>h

(Phc,re-k...f-loor J lor; ck (P"ll~ J "'.,.!. C< 1:;0:>( CAr JOe.,.. i'h'rl-C~ e')C+r"r>-<...fbruc!. r1-6lcdi on I ';cC"ll

\';)C\CI.+1W1 ,').tnSOY'vl ~ri""..tiWl ,Cll"ld ~i"iV'Q,tic.y'l of-J'rt.e.+~ ......~. ';"""C(.111 hcw.... q

'5" i Nh 'Sc.\;t ("u'"",dcw IY"\ ~kJoay f'h...t- Pl'1l'V1Jgj Ii",,:+cc!. Vi eM> e;,f ./'I,~. OU} exf c.e. I ~-t\hJ J ~",d

CAS" S61;J W\~\n.fk-(....>clHth~+pnvlJ".j li/,\,\;~~ \r'i(,.""of--tk.-cN+S;~en.... i\"lSY'~. 7"'-5"

:)cI\e v..iY\~ pruv;~ 1i4'~'S<J1'>\;'11:r'~ 1'h.,,(,(11.

-7-


5Q. GrUI'Jwoed (v"'-1 ~IICLvc.!. rot- of hj~ Cell ani', l.f-hc:vrs ctLv<AJ< for rec/'"flA+-lcn err U<r-c.'Yl- ;1"

CA ')yv,Oltl I S\I~nt1'1 illo""" " <,+td )i "'docr) C<rr>Cr~ '5truc+U>-~.! ru:. "j..v/'+i'!J I V1 .f"k~~ Vl'\if. 7f.-L

5mql\ )~ ree~!:!J ~;"s b ~W1 .. /1 CCt~~ ')i,.,.,:"'r ~ ·fh<!~u}.<d~ CP-noF;nl"J Wild

~/'Ijm.llJ ",.,cI 5eVl!1'"\1 ~~<!. (p;nbVJn$ h:~nVp I"-Vtt' ~Ceill;V c.v>c! 00+ Of'r~c,ch.

51. 1 he. b().rr~ (p·ln6cl.c~ \n -tk 'lneoor fu.rl/.""tlon<,1 S~t+\nJ C\dmi-t IjTt'~ SUnl \Jht h\ah uf

nw,r tk. CQ..·ll"'3 CAno Ql.)i- of ~(h~ prev(.,.,t Gf'I/..tl.nWood of d iru+' confc<crr V'ith +~h<u:lt"nd

I~ht ~YYl', t'kd '0,( tkSurt. 'l.n ordQ r for Gn..'U"l!J..'OOd 1'l c..e~ ',ntb di~e..t c.ol1+r>..c+ (pi1'h t4heo.7Of' \\g~ ·freh'\ +k'ilon jn't. wwld Y\~d '*'" \O<!.- 10 f«k fcl.H or 8~ter. C'::>r«n(.A)()cd ())as deprilled en:~OCI'f<2. SL>n for $eV<l..rC\.1 "(ee.r-s. ,.... .... <:'NJUlWcod lP<tS \<X.~ '1)" hi S C'!.II f'\e.<lrl'( ICa'1 hem's CAWHK

l).)\thCLJt o.ny d\T~+ 'ij\)n e..j.po-;L>r~ <\\>-tN...\:X:~'f' 7k.ICl.Ckof d·,r«.+ '7-JlfOS tit. to+: SUI? ~c.c.ub(.~:teJ

e.re.l/.n~'S ~$\ G\\'l~ p"",/Si(.q.\ heAlt1-., 7klGLckof SUnl;j'nf caused G~""ocd <,il<iY\ pn:blt""s,

\n~uC\\q,hQ,Q. \'\"h C\rc,,,I,,,ti em ,)n Cl<k.ctV(\1"~_'ben It. Stnl"\8#1 , i l'\ O\dq,qt.ICtk. Vi+«r» i h D ,G\",J ott-..r- hl/.~I/h

i '.i':.u(,~. (b'r«I"\~ l)-'Oo..~ Ccl'\stel'ltl'( depf'''Vld of tk e,1~fH.hts J nvtri «....ts I orSCl.... ,t. Svb<;,f<l.nc:~ prev',~~ 'o'lt~ ~\)nj <!..~S~hH .. \ fo'("\if~ rn"·,,,,tlnQhc't..(;\"'<!- {jr-c.;>V-:Jth. (,rl/.l/.l1(,<)ood (pc..~s~'o~<L<:.+~ nCOnsh...+ OIl.p""·,VG\110l'\ of d-irl/..c1 ~ SUrlt.. +t- hsl.C\.+ "'nc\. \\5""+ erv-\t~d- b'f +I--<...SL>n ~ N.II' suppod

htCllth Cirl,v\o.+lon I~c:ti On of +H:. Ioc~S) OI"'~ Y'l'\OIi",te..i-\Q"ce. o'f bo''''l.. :'ltrv.t]+h. 'N..-IQ.ck of SU<h

h'!.o.l+h'f Circ.<.>Ic..+ion (.;\1'\6 bent/... ...,t<'~th \n~r·ft.t'l/.d With 6rtl-t-nW'OOCl'S CAbili+-, ft> en8~·,n v;sorauS <!..llVo;)II. o.r>d Qc,nv"rtie5.

sa.. I~i~r r(..Cr~C\.+iOnG\\ SII..:H-ir\j P'rOv"~ Oh"f CI. pull-L>P b",r, A pI) I-up bc,r i l"'IClppra

pi,CI'f(... for +k rr-<-nt<\\\'{ i\\ . C'::Ir«n~'5 ~""+"'I "",c!. phYSiCAl CCndi1ioYl rnCl<!R.. it d',ffi c:."I+ to lif+

or~ pporl h,s ow", \J-)lZ.\jwt. Grql/.I"\l.>-X:cd of<N.n did,..,o+ enJetjll. in ""V e.ur<-i~·<..JOIUt\USQ hiS ~",1c.1 ill·nu.S ~n\{tfltt~h.-n~ rQrT'u p<&l~ in "'(1"( <!..)I..I/.rCiSI/.. or odiv,ties -lOr- phy<.iCaI f';+""t$s.

53. 1 r.~ ~'('r\C\1I i r.d00l" rt.e:.rtA+lo",.-\ Si/...+ti"'j did- n P'rOIrlc!<t- 6r'!.lnUX>Q:l. wi·\-h Q.c.<.Q.,l>5 -h, ~v~l'\; c:A I

U:>Q.,'~nt<., ~~",',tOll <!..)l.e,rC:'~lt <!..\ l.tiCAI trr(,l"I~r I~c,h",V\\c...eI' I/...lCHC\\1I.. t'ro.<:'<!rt\\1 I I '(Y\<l.Ch", "': c.-I <!..J<e re·,s...

b"'M~ Or O'tkr 'kl"e') of ~h"n\tAIU-er ;~~oif',...,........tft>.-+k..Y'M.nI<IlIy "dl.

5'1. 1.n o,dd\+llm, or«nW Ofttn ~;o net e..n3"jet. '1 Y\ Gl"'f ~rc',StI":~ bU.CW11/..., of+klil"'\ttJ S""c\'u~rSJ

\',fY\'h,J C;CGlp,G\nO \',,,,,,1-td oh"",,,tL. of viet.........

55. GN.(f\W~ often dio.n<>t '!.Y\j~ \n ......'f ('\)",n',,,:) J~Cl*ff\:~' ,or jO~f'l"'j ja.~k.s ~(o..os~t"~"il+C\+(i~s~ ,&nO'l.'> Y\'\o.ck.\'t ~\offiu;1+ or iiV\pt>s",\blIl...1O'f Y\,rt\ ~ Y"Un l~~ lor J h\rl~ JCAGk in +~h'1 Ol"l Scl\d

c..oncn~ .flOOl"S. 0l"UnwocJ wo.s I"Ot o,l\w;ed <fc howq,. h,\ perSon",1 shcll..s "'t"\ ~~. He. was Qrlly GllloOJ<!.d

-\1) \J.leClr 'S·t"i<. - i SSued <;;""~ of ~+r(.Yr-<..\~ ctClG\I",+'{. 7N... <;.hol/.5 o.re. YYl<\ck i r\ <.k,n". , k.ot' rl/.. e.)(+re"'Q.I~

-tg-


t"'\Y\.,N... '\iell!. o.f +k '5h~ o.~ abo<>+- 0.. qu<tr-kr o.f- ctn il'\ch thick I w,'\d w\.-...", G~"wco:I C\.+t~~cl

i'b run or ~~ or jUl'Y>.p \n tk-W1 j+k- '5clid Gor-cr~:k ftcor iY\'flit:+~d f'Clin ISO~M.-S~ I o.""~ liwe.\\"~ -h>

t~ ul'l~r'Dl.lrio.cet of +~-fcot C\1"ld ~I.

SID, IN..Wi~.I'.dl'"'\,~ '5~, ooc.. "30<1."3"- C(ltcv>~ frac........s '11'\ 0.'" involu",+o.r'1 \)l"\e>.s~(jN.d sto.-tvS,

o.l'\d 'lh G\ nO"" p':l\'\,t·,Vll. ~+us ,~ Po.r1icipofet. in rl-Yliccd e.~rca~s ~d ae:t-ilrifie.l ~I,)Ch "s ba..skd

bGlII)ho."obo.ll J-tabl~ +~m,,·,S .vc\lIt"fbo.lI •-fuc:rtbQ/I }+/"Q.(/k Clnd f;1? Id) (,Il(~W.,·t fj,fti!5 )S+(d-ibno.r'j hl~S I C\

\/'o:r; ~+'f of ~?l-~"'c',~~ j'na"h\N.-S G\nd e~rCiS~ tro...Y'\"~ eq",ipI'N."'+, }1cI.;.;1tV<.r t 0reen(.I-iCCJ who Wet, in CA

h'WcI~Y'lt<:lr'f un",s~\1't.d 51-a-tus o.nd. '111 '" non-pu"',.f,'V'e <:.1uiuc;. wa.s '\i\..~'l...c«d 10 0- pQli l '{ lmd('f

t1=l<- 00'{, t"'Q1 S\.)b~('.d('.l h'm'1 '"' u+r~i'}'.q..depr\vcdiof)of 'OlXh Ou+-Clcor e.-)£erCi~1 p"''is''U$ o..c+ivitie5,

~I'\c! e;;.~r<:.i!>e eA"'ip~"t n'l...llt\~o.r'f 1TI Noll' m"';l'\~i,", sooJ ~I+h. Iklo.ck of l'Nt-c.h",,,,ic,,1 Utr ciS,,

eAuipYN-n+ l +k \CA.Ck of ourJoo~ ~It('(.-i~~~nc!.. ph'f~iccl\ ~c \vi't-i~, ) t:'lnc\.tkl<l.Ck of o.d'I...'lUCl~moy-q./N"t,

CA",s~ <:>reV"w~St.,..; o,,~ NG\.\+h P'ro~~""S I ,;uc..h Cl~ h\jh chc!eS1<td j YYlu,<.It. t;.\(\c) ~ int pai",. stiffness,

11') aekquctte- \tu.<;d+h C irtul",tiO'(\ I ",wCU\uG\+e. 100\'\'1.. ~+rensTh C\",d oJ-kr N-a/+'h probl ms."The. ccnc,tiO(lS of Gree-¥l~'S Co(lfl~+o..ffltcA-e6 Qn'" e)(.G\.C<rb4~JhIS ~n.fql ~o.l+l-o)+~

tNt. It.>Chn+,~ CAtteY"'ptfd C;;uic:..id ... C\nd 'ii'l.lof-hC\rrn on 'S~vlt,...,1 oc:..C<\S~iC1h';.

51, D~fen&>.nts Do.n',el O\'"G\(,~r, $On S-tro.'hot-a. IWH1"c",...... PCllo.rdlPo.rM.lC\ LAY'\k. ,OInA M"c.hae-l

lhur~( VJl/.r", CA~r'" of- Suc.h ccnd i"t,ons in 'l-k. Setl~G\+ion On'l+ / and +k)YYlpCld i+ wo..s CAuS i"j

Upon <:>r«nUJoc6'S n~"th C\~ SG\fe.+Y • yq,.+. oe.spitt h",vi~ o.cto<d pettSC\l"l"\ KnO<A>I f.~ ... of- h i~ pl~h+

GAnci t'k. CA<Jth",rity or (,G\p,,-cj+y +0 +<-~ Cerr<.d-i vc lilC-t\CIn ~ prott.e+ h.S k.:,lth c.",d SClfe:t-j I fo.,i l(cj

-to Cornc+ Tk- vlQIG\.;;on or +altlt. 0."'1 re....sor\G'I>l'" \"NO..~<.:rlt.-.\ -\l> protu.+ 0r=n~'S heC\Hh CI..,.l ~GI.-fe+y.

Sg.

5o..\o.1Ar'S Sta:h,t'Nrrt of F",<:.ts

59, 1'h~ plCl',ntiff '}C\v'ltr 'So.l'n.<>r hClS Ci\ histof'l OT S~(iOUS ~"+'\l k.=1+h problems, 1hDyJ'h I

~e,l>1"'tt- 'his f''rt>I0''jl.! PS'fChbh~SiCC\\ Oi~O'r6~(, he.iS c..urr(l'\+ly c..lini(C\II'fdiGltiho~~onl'l wit'" o..~tl'\tC\1

netcd+h r-Gl.+inj ~ i(MH-i),

<00. OY\ \'i\~r(,h \lJO-CO'i5 I -P\C\h-,tiff 'SC\IG\'Ulr (Pe.t, ~en-j'(nuJ -fb (1../0 del'/S of di:'C.iplil1G\ry

S~PG\ rOltion -for Q. rUIt. vi 01 <l\tiQI') ,

-9-


Col. I\fttr <:.oyv,p\'<...+in~h i ~ ~ear~BC\+ion Sl!h~n~~l dQ..-fI!~C\n+S' DOh '5tr'lhc>tt:l o. ....~ Dani-'!-I

()rQtml!r r~<'bYYH'NI1~+ho.+ So.IGI"LClr lolL 'ilub~e.d +0 G\dm"'nlstrqt1v~ c..oY\fiY'.e-\'"'t't"'+ f'urSl.>G\nf

,~ <A pl:lli<.,( ~ndeT' Doc. 3o'fS bCA..~d on +k o.b:>II~~ho.vicr.

~a., 01"\ O~i'Y1\o~r a"!l, a.oo~ I in o..u:.of<!Ance. with W\~ .",em. c..cOlt- '5«.., DOC~ /k... odY'Y)'ln'!5tr",..tiv~ Go'rlf 'I ~Vl'-tn<t <:-omYY".,+t~ 6~+t r Y'n',~cl +h ",t S 0.10.(..<1 r \.;)~ piGl.cl!d l'n M/'l1i\'1i ~tr.x+iVQ

c..o~+',~~~ b(AS(O on elC~n6l'\n+S str",ho+c. on.! (3T1:l~~r'S r~O'(Y'l"...,n~",+icn.,

CO~, At <>.11 tiYN.~ r~\(,vC\'I"\+ 'h> Mr. So.\o.uxr'S ~"l'\..U"l"<ht ih +~Sl!cVli:~J''l+ionuY\it ,hitW~'i>\i'o~\t.cn~ to an U'ncons+iM-ioncl/ POli'-', Or prC\c+l<.Q.. Lm&r Doc"3~ +hcrl depl'ivec/ hilllofoutdoor ~ltrc.ise) Sulo~<tc...ttd h',m-tt. e.)l;tr~ l'orn,tC\+ions 0+ 'IT'I<:kor e)t.ercl~l1..-C\nd n,c.Ye.e...tiOl"\ l inG\6<tquerh:.. 'i) nl't'Jht CIne! fu ¥'unihv'{. '5~~cd·jo""se+tih3 inc<ppr-oprieo.t« -fur+~Ynel'1't'C41h/ in. I

(,I.j, At G\\I t'I~~ rt\t..vG\r'\t h:> SC\\<A"1.Glr'S c..onf',n~+ 'on t""-.St.{jr<'5<t-MOn un,+, h~lAC-S .. ub.}e.cte.d

10 an unGorostl-MicY\C\\ pClit'l or PY'o.ctice. l)~~r DOc. '3C'g +hC\1 d\!.pr',ve.d h',,,,, of ouh! y re.c::..~ l)JaS

i ~otC\+t.l "'''' a. Cll-II +h••t '1l. S\!.po.l'<\hd -fn::,,,,,, +k 0P'l" -Un i+ by "'- Sol id S+e.. t c:ioor) Cln en+r"n.c'l. ho.l/ J

ono COITidO(' wi+'h '" \on~ WC\ll str\x:turoJ o.++kcenftr o,Ft'k-h"/l1o force- ~mi'N- iSOlC\+;Cn QVldSv-.Scry ~p""lVo.tion. ' J 1

<05, Se-\G\U\r lPtl~ CDr'\fil'\~ Y"Iec,,'I'( a.4-hourS 0.. 130.'-/ J C\lon'l..l in OI.Srnq/1 cell Constructed {J..)j*,

COh c.re.tt, flwr 1'ori tk (;>0.1 IS I Cl VIti 0. \ocXC<:\r c:kor +h«+ cauSe. S e.)t+rerJ"<. -fOl'"'«J ';<:IA+1""'. Soc.; "I i ;Cllo.titll,

S't(\~c:>r'16<tpr-'ovG\+;o""l arlO Jeprivcd-ior> of dire.c.+ hu,....,.,,,, COn+<..c+. 7;""" cellS hAve.. 0. 5" SOlid l,N\1'l<lcw

in +)...,. cloer +h,,+ provic:le~ l'IY\littd View of+N.- ou+ of cell svHi~,Q~ 0. 5" solid tpindotv \n.+~

().)Cl\\ thAt- Oycoric:le..s rll'Yli~d V'Ie.1..> of t-k.~i<k.envirof'\~"+, 'Tk5" Sc:>\id w',k""", previoC-S' only\',++I~ '[,<>",\,....+ 'n-lt> ~c...l\,

G,f" St\ laY'r WGIS allowed ovt of ""'5 Cell only 4-houf"S 0.. (,C«K ,fo,.. r'l.c.f'U.\.+10Yl or \t.l'e .... c.i~ in 0.

Small ISltJ""tly \\\"'''''''n.OO+-td,·'V'ldcer, cencr~ '51'Yu<.,*"rec! re<. S~of-j'2J in +N.. S";:J 0"',+. 7h'l. 5"""1/ in

doer n ..c. $<t++i':j centa,>"'IS <D Svn,," CAje.5 S;rh~\G\r tb thol.e., u~d fi:>r Con-fih;~ LUil.! UV\irv-'lls/aVld

~ev(r~t 'roGlntO w"n~u>n h'19h up neqr +4.. C.Q,HI\~ Clnel cot 0+ ~G\.ch, He...Wo..>le ne~J 0.. tG\1 \ 10:+'.,.

~ Y"<A~h t ..... W">"'IOow,

COl, 1ht..b",rred W',I"\OQV..)~"Y\ tk.\nOOCr re.c.r<.Po+\ono,\ '5e1+i l1j Oodm;+ Ii#k Sun 10 h\jh up Y\llD-r

tho. C.e.'oll'. "j "Inc! ou+ of re.c\~h it> prl?,venf SCllcl'z."r of d."r«.+ co~J. t,Ui+h t~ he",+ c<nd t"'~I-\'t e"",'.+tt<l

b'{ t ..... Su". 1n order 'fur Sql,q.M ~ <..oW'<. \ I"I-h> d.\nc.+- con+o-cot with +'k. ~Gl+ or IlJh+ 17-0...... +k~uYl ,/-Ill.

(pOUI6 he....1 oj" c.l\mlo C\ \c,ter. SC<\G\"lA wcq d..tpr\~ o,F c;<.<:\e<luc:.-k ~UY1 fi>r S\!.ve.r<>.l 'i~ri .. 'So.lo.'lA

W~ \.1OC.~ \n hi\ c.1t!1 neG\rl'l \ 10'1 koun IAu->«K lP\-ThO<.>t 0....."/ d1rctd Su"" e Yo('cSIJre. -m t'~bcd.t. 7"-

ICl.tko.f SUY'l\~h+ eXGI.c(,r-loo.ted SC\IC<'lar'S r'Nf'\t<I\ "nc:\ ph'{5iccd ~l+h, "'kl'l.ckcf 'ilunl~h+ C'u)Sed

-lD-


~Cl.IC\<-<l.r ~}<.·,n prob~,,,, 5) pG\I~~<" in C\,kq<>q,tt 'h~" I+h c..lrc.ul",+i on )', n o.dutvc.fe.. bonO!: '<.-tr~'1J"h ,1 ...

Me.q\.'lCl-k i+c..I'.·..,n D) W'le ~r NAHh problems. ':>CI.\c<U\r WCI.\ CoY\'<.t<..",+ly de.pr\vt6 of +~ elt

~"h,hutri~"1S )or3"''''·'(.. Sub~te.."u.. pr-cvleec! 'o'{+J....... Sun 1 e.Skntlc" fur life.. fY'o. ih+en.....c:.e. e.tV>d 8r-ov.>+~,

~C\IAU\r was ~ub~ected 11:> (.01"\5+'...,+ de.priV<\tl~" of J', r«A- e.t-posc..;re..-ro ~+ o."J-1 ijhf emiHed b-t +N..

';)lln fb kIp 'i>uppcr·j- N",1+h c..iroAcdior> I fuY\cfloh of+k-~ , a",d mc<i..,+~r"'<nc""of bon e..

':>trU'~h . 1M.. lo.<:\c.. of <z,u(,h ~1+hY C-\l"<:'-u\Cl.1-10n "''"'0 \oc~ 'ii+r~nj+'h 111-k,..<f~red wltl'l SCdC12<lr'S

tAoilirr hl ~r'.5CLJI{..""" V$orous e.)L~rc.H.(,. c...,d ac.+i.,;+ies. 7fliS in-krftr<...,c~ e>u:<co'locd~~ ~ell"V"r'S

ph'/Si(C,\ ~C\ I+h.

(D~. IN. ino.cor Y-e-cre,,+ion,,1 <;)~+ti';,J prov\oe<! 0\'\\'( ~PUII-L)p \oo.r. A ruH-up G\r ''''''Wl'"C>pria:\q,.

fur t'k. ~'"'te.II'! iI \ . ~ClI "'l-C\r ''i. ~",te.l q...,J ~h'fl, C."I COndlti un ,.,..,,,ck i·f- d,+fi c.v +--fe Iiff or Sup.

port hi~ ow,.... We'jl-vt, $,,1,,1.'" of+eo'1 dieln't e.n"Clj~·II"'\""~I e)l.er~is-e-lo~,,&(us~hHtN,,+e.i illnefS

fll"t\/'(nH.I hi"",~ f'/>,r+\t-;pt:\t1 ....J i", "r\'f e)Ler-C;.l~Oy",C+ivjtleJ ~I" ('h'fSicc'I'fjtnd~.

G'l. '1~ C;t"Y\C\\I ',no=r r«r(.",+;o""'\ '5~++i'\5die not provide SC\IQ~C\r o-cce..s to ~c.h"... jC4' ()J(j,!lhtl,

~c.'ho..n'lc." 1 e.y.~rc;~ el'iti <AI trC\ iY\tr I ~chQn\ c,,\ e)te rc. i5~ +re.<lcl,.,...,il/ J ~ChC\""{AI e.)tQ rcl~b\KeS

or otkr 'K\n¢. of ~ho",iCC\1 e."trCi~ lV'l\)ip~",t -Nr+M..Y"r"-tnte:\II'! ',I\,

10, ~n odd'lnoA, SC\ICI~"r often di6 not ef\{J~in em'l e~rC;S~hec.al>se- of-t'k limited Shov.>lr'J

l'im\+tc! '5~ ,CIne! I',\'"·,,W che\l"8~of Glotk.'i>,

11. 5C\lcrLC\r ofte,..., d',d not ~n~~ "\""I A"'! run"i'2j ).i0trlinj,or .jUY'n~i~ .),,:c.ks pec",~sQ. +h"

s.t«k-i~~J Sh()e-~ ('r\"'~1L '"t-d iffi (u It or i Y'npOSS ibl~ -fur h, \'Y\ to rOn 10<:9 ,0r 0un-.p ""'j -Io,cv, in

+N."", on SOliJ Co ..... c re·te {loorS, Sc<IC\'l-C\r W",-} hot- Oll()\j.>td-ro h",1r'C ""\S persof\C( shoes (.J..>y,·,Ilt ',n

S~. \-h....w~ 0"'\'( al\o~ -\owwr~ -i55vd 5110< of e)(:+re,..,....., kx..u qUCIji+Y. 7kshoes are...

)'YlCld... ',h ch',n" .ih 'I.. Shoe.! <'Ire e.)(tre~ly thin. 1h\l. Sole. 0+ -t4- 'Snoe.5 o.re.. abCO+ Co'- qUCI..,.ttr of on

·lhc.n +h', c.k \ (Mel l,UNn S o.lc."Z-C\r C\+temp1tcl ~ run )j'2:! .0.,.. SuV>-p ',V) tN"" j+kscI i c..o",cre-k 1= Imr

"r"\fli c. hr1 'PeI',n \SoreneSI J c<nd Sv..>e II ',nj -ro H ...~ un~rc;urf;:\.ce- of-t'M.-.fCo+ Qnr1 he.tl,

la... ,hI{.. \}J'l~, Ar1rn. Code. 'i:>e.c" Doc. ~o'l,31o CI\lOlJ,J~ pl"i~o'NrS iY'\ o-n ',nVbl""+C\\"1 un"-Sli(}V1~c:l

Stcd\)~) o..,~ "h C. non- puni+iv~ S+o.1\J~ to p"l"tiC.ipc:l't1t. i n ph'f~i("1 ue rCi~~ o...d o-c.+ivit\es ,Sud" 'tS

bQ:;Kdbo,\I )ht,nd6GIll,+tlbk+e"ni ~ ,V C>\lt'f bcil \) fuc,l-bcli ,) +ret"k CIne! field) WeJjh+ I jf+; nj 1S+cttion"rvbi~) ) 0. Vl\l"'d...,. of e.)ler(i~e rr-o.c.h',Y'-lt-S ",no Ue'rci ~I{..+rC\', ,....,Y\j' et:lu;p~. ~\.>jt.ver l Sq,\ca",,.. Who l,Ua.I

',Y\ 0.. \Y\V<:>":)\,\+""'IlJY\"\~~Nd S+o.+u~ and -."" "- \"\"'h-pun,+'~ ~+o.N~ILJ.,.;~ 'SlJb~ex:.t~ -to 0. pOl'IC'!

U'f\&r Qoc... 'b~ t\-'le.t '.iub~«.ttd \-'I.,,.,.... 11:> e;;:.+rerr-t-c:kpr;vwt,o}'\ of Such Ou+dCOr e-Y-erci 5'l.., phySical

CAt,-t,\V,t.,'l.~)o.nd e:Jler-(i 5e. e'lu', prr-~;I'...t Y'\ec.tSSQ''{ h ~Ip fY\Ctin+""h 8c::cd r-:.I+h.7~ 10.(1<. of me.

Ch"h', {Cll et-~ rC i~ equi prr--tn+ \'tk \ C\c.k of outdoor e.'J.t"-c.; ~e. OIn~ ph'(>iC«\ ac+'''; t''l.5 j

-11-


0.1\0 t-k \CA.ck.of C\.oe9c.>C\-k.~~, cau~ecl SC\IC\"Z-<\r ")Jt,.i()<..>~ ~a.t+h pr-obll!fY\$ ,Such a.S

yY\U')(,ltt. C\ ....o~o\m 'Po"'Y'\ J S+iff/'\.l1~s , \Y)Q,du:t'-''''ook hecd+h c. i \"cula<+lon , i h<:<cllG'llXl boN.- S<l-N:n,gfh J

omo ct~r N.o. I+h problems. 7 k c.onJ-i+iol'"ls of SCjic,Z-",,.'5 Confi~+ C\.ffec:ted a ....cl e.;,l.ClCU

'c",t~ V\i~ ~nt<I\ Cin~ emotioYl",1 N.ctlth J+Ot~e-Ji-h",+,k.e<..o.t-kmp+tol SUit.-ld~ c<"''; 'i~lf--h",,.,,,, 0'"

'" llVerGlI ()t.("'>:>ic,",'i> J lout ~ve·,... r<.port(d ~uch ',nC'id(n1) \oUClUSet..k. d ',~""+wa,,+ ~ Io~ pill-etc! i"'''''olose rv",ti by! 'i:><tnftJ'i>.

73. Qet..fet'"\OCl,,+S' Oc.roie,1 (3r<:leYl"-tr / Don strclhetf-q ) W\\\'C\W\ pollard I PCl~l~ "ZA",k, CIne!

1"I.,,,ho..el "lh..,rrY'"tr were.. o.WClrlLof Such condit/oros j h +N.- S'iJRjo.-Hon UYll+, <;\r1d +f-s>... 'Im

PlAC:f \t- ~"-~ Cau,)i","" UPOYl SC1la"t-C\r' S ~cd+h CIne! S«fe+-t , ve+ I de spik hc:wj~ O\.cft.lc« PUSoi'l<\1

Knt!lJ..)\ed3et..of hi~ pltJh-1 c.nd.+N.- o.<..>thorHy or C4PGlC;~f10 +a\<.e.. Co rr=+l IIIL o.cs+iOY\ +0 prot(d

hi~ NQ.lth and '5o.~""",)-fe<ileJ fo c..orr(..c1 +~ Violet·Hot"' Or-+«kILCUI'i rellSOi'labkfNClSL'r~S'it>

prt>+«+ r- i) ~d.fh C\l1~ SClfe-f'-j.

LoQ12..:4.1S f:>t,,-to'N,nt 0 f Fo.c,ts14. II-...... pl'"ntiff 71u\.,<:<>'1 Lope.<. hCAS V\ histor'f of S~r;(X)s ~n+c.1 N.cd+h probleYrlf.

15. on ~\')f\~ l..f J <1-oc>/ I fl\GA"I'\~ff Lope-1.. ~CA.S ':>~ntenc(c:I- fu ~G::O d-o..'f s Pro8rGlrYI '()e.arejCAt\OYl fer

0. rule.. vioICl+;on. A.fter CO""f'Ie.ti~ hiS S~Br(.3Cl+icY"l ~I'"\+enC(...Jd{..fendGtn+S' DoY\ ~tr"",,+c<.

Oono t>Gl.n'.~\ Q,ro.~r ,("'l..Col'r\yY'-4.(\o(cl ;-h~ L.o(Xl-z...Ioe- SuJ.:JJe..cf 11::. cdm,nilfr",tille conf"i ne~".,f

rl..lr~"ntttl CO\. pelit'( vn6e,... Doc oo'is" IoC.l.S~J on +ko.b~Vi()la.tlcYl.

1(0. 01\ M",'f O-bJo.0IO 1\Y\ o..Ct.oro.o.nclL W""'h \,\.li .... Adm. (,ode..~~. t)Oc.."1PiI J+k~dl'Y1inis+rGltive.

CoYlf·!ne.rN",t GoI'Y\Ynitt<l.t 6~"""""""',"-(J+"",0\- Lofln..~ plC\Cte! in o.dminist...."'tilr'1.. C"On~·\ .....................+'oo..S'l.d on 6~fencl.c'n+s' S+-rc.he+c.. Ct.,6 I3rG1~YJ"(r'S ruo\.,.,~nd."'tl'oh.

1'7. .1'\;- "II t'l~~ n..ltV"'",+ tc Lop~<.·s CoY"\f-i ~rrt.n+·1 n +k.. S~8r~"'+iOhuni+, Yl.R..CPct.S SubS«(.-kd

tb 0.1'"\ uY"lcons+it1.>tlOY'a\ pOlit'-( or (-H"Glc+lCe.. U'f'der DC<.. "30~ +he<+d~pr-',ved him of outd r rec.)

SU\:)~H+e~hi rn 1"\ e)l.+r'l.rr~. \....",i+wnlms o-F ",h~OOt u~ rc.l~et..F{"¢. 11) i hctdtujuct+e. UhI0ht-) a"J 10rUl"'it\VIG-Sear~C\Vion "\'\CAppropn cl~.fur +k ~nt<ll\'f HI.

l~. P \G<\nt\ff Lop~"Z. wo..~ i\<:>\C'~d .. Y"\ 0... c.<1.\1 thc,t i \ ~~pw-Cl~d froW\ ++.e,. Of'('n-Uh '..t b'1 C\ Solid

~~tl dot.'r J Gin ~n+r""'tllhC\II, 0.. C.O'"Ticlcll" t-Ulth V\ tOl'lj Wo.l\ <;,trut.+ur(d 0.+ +kc.¢n+~r of+4..ho,lI

tI> -fur~e)l.ml'l'-t.. \\<:>\0'+;0\'),0"'0 <;e..nSor~1 d~Pl'i vC\t{CYl,


lQ. Lope;t, (.O~ Cc>nfinl/,d ntAr1ya-4-hoorS Qeo.Y1CAlohe) in CA. Sh1<\11 C~II cc>",s+ruct~e! u:>i+h

(..oncr..h floor )lar icY, l-UGI'I~ J G4 ",cl 0\ \o::>lI-Cc.r coor thor+- CC1USe.S U+~ forc.ed iSol",tion, ~~",Sor'1'

clepr',va;ticn ,D.nd de pr"II<'\-non of c',rec+ hom"", con+G<.c+. 7~ Cell ~ h"'ve Q 5" Selid Wlndo\J.:> iY)

tI-A- Coo( +nOl+ pn>v-lde\ \ iVV-ltfd vie,lJ.) o·f +kou+- of cw S~t+in" ,a"'c 0\. '5" '5\::>I\d W',ndow IY,

+kWall that pruvid.t-':> lil'V'l~cl vi e.(,..> 0{- tkootsjc:l~ey,Vjronvr-<n+.7;"""5" SOlie! v.>'V\dov-> OY\ly

prt>v)~e\ liirtl'L SUYI\\jYlt \~~ce~l.

60.lope-z. WGLS O\llc:u.>~ 001- of hi~ c.ell on"1 /./-h<:x.>rS etwe.ek fel" r-q.Cre.<\+lon ore)(er-ciSe. in

Q.. <;'yY\Co\II I 'i>lia'n+ly \\lul'V'in",ttJ, in6oor,c.oncrlt.'k -otruvNrtd re..c.. '5e.;H-inj IV' +J...t..S~ unIt. 7ne..'o",ne~ v.>\Y\oCU)'> 'Int~ ''''door re..CN..Q.tlonQI S~t+i"j O-dmit- I i++I<.Sl>Y\Ii3hf- l->i8'" up near +)..L

C-1I...·.\liY'lj ",,,e! out of r~,ch ft, prl(ven+ Lope?,. of diruA- Corrta-cJ (j..)i+h +kN«+-c<nd. liJh+ Of +k.'bun. '1.1'1 OrOtr -fur Lop-e'!- -h> COo'Y"t. inh:> ei r-e.c.A-- Con+t'<c<t- ,-,-,ith +k~+or- I iJ1-I1- i'r-um +M Sun,

hll... w<.::u16 nuc\ -\'I;) c,I'l'Y'Ib 0.. \c.1-er. Lo~'"l. WQ.~ (kprl~cl of o-deql.la+e- '5UYl fur S~verC\ I 'ieo..--S.

lop~~ wa.~ \<>,,~d up In hi~ Gell V'leo.rl,( lbi-I "'ourS a(,u-e-~k WithOut 0-Y'l'1 d,ylZ.cA- S'UY"I e><po5ut'l(

-h> +-~ 'bcl'1. 74 \G<.ck of 'Sunl"ht l2-J'.-",-ce.rbGli-ed L-o)O~'!-' S ~n+a,1 and ph'1SiCA I h.=/fl->. 7 N.. \"-Ck

Of <;,uy,\tJ'h't- C=S~ Lo~l.- "'..... \1"\ prob ems; po.ll(ntss. ',nc,,!equn+e.. Nc.1-rh Ci\"CUIC\~C>'YI )i ....~uate.

i;x,ne,.~e+ ,h"",6eJjVctK. V'lt" I'V".~ D .ano ot'NrNa,/-rh p-,.-olot.ems. 'T~I=k of Sun I ijn+/""d

h\!.Ql-I-h fl"O'QlemJ,iy,\~rft..-t<l wi-l-h Lop-eL'5 Clioilit--/ ttl en3ao~ '11"\ vl9oroo5 ~:I't..-cl~o."d cwt\lritles.

~1. l'~ S~ un'lt Ohl\( provi6e~ 0\. pUll-up bar o.t rt.c... A PUII-u" bar in"'ppropriC\-k-rorfk~VI"""'f ill. l.o~1.'S~ ....1-«1 Cln<l ph'1Siccll Col'lditi()y> Yl'\OIC.rz.. if dl.f-f'-iwl+ fr> lift C>l" Suppod hi S

c>~"" \.>-'e.....'lYlt. Lope'!- of-kn <:\ IdY\'+ enB"'3l1.." 1"\ Glny ei-er~ hi S YNnt-e\"j ClY\,-/ e)l.ercl ~l(.,S <>r O\.ctivi+le5 -fer pt-yS; Clli -fi+~H.7~ See e,m i} di~ 1"\01- frovi<k

Lopez. o-(.ces -h:> rr-«.h"Y\~C.q\ ej.l(('Ci~cz.. equiprr-<nf- -ftor h..w.Hh fi+~SS. Xn C!ddifion, Lopez oHe.n did

1'\ot e..Y\~o.5Q..\n an'f l2:1--erc-'!>lL';, 'oe..ullJSlt. of the Ihy,'~d Showv-s Ilim',W Soo.p,CI,.,d lim; d cJ,""'J~ of

Clo+N-5.

'5a.. Lope1.- often 6-'0. 1'\01 en8G\~<l- In 0."'1 rvnY\i",5 ,.)C5:f,nj l0r .jU\'Y\pi'j jo.ck.~ ~()SQ..+4 stcd~i'&~~d -sho<!-s ",",,,,de.. \-\- diff', c..., It or \YYlpOSS',b1e..W-r h\"", ttl rOn l.}~ )or Jurrofinj vuc,k in t~rn on5~\"~ Cbt\crete. -fll,;-ors. Lop<l-'l. WGl.~ ne+ OI\\owed -h. he;we.. "",$ pe;r&::nal Sh~ l,LI'n-'Ie..\V\ Ses. He. WG\.S

On\\( C\\lou.>ec.H1> wwr sto.-k- 'I~S\l~d sh~,~ of eJ'.-+r~rr-<..low qlX\IHy. 7J-.e.. Scle..of +~ 'f>hee,s 0.1"(..

o.'oout 0.. quarnr Of- an \nc.h -\h',,,,k IClno w~" Lope.?,. o.t~ .......ptep To run j j~ ,or JOI'Y'P i l"l fk.ffll-r~ Solid

CO\'\C,re.-k-flbOr \I"\-f\\c..ted fClih I~-rel"\ess I and SL~I\',"'j t.. t~ uY'dtrSor-f"-'e..of tk%t and heeL

~3. 'Jo-l'I::'.Mm. CoCe.. 'Sec. Doc. 30'1.310 o.\lou->~ pr',scNo ,n 0.. 'I\WOh""te.T'1 Uh"-'il5itJ~ 5+",+05, and in

"'_ noY\- PUh\t,Ve.. ~t-e.1v~iTh ~l'-nc:,p«tt.\n ph'f~iCG\l «.)(trc\Se o.,,~ o..c.iivitie5)$ueh <:U bCl5Kdbcdl,hG,n~bo.l\ l table. +t",,; 5, vo\ltybQII. -fOotbG\II, tr-o.cl<. a" 0 -f i (.Ic! ll.'le.ijh~ r.fti n~ ,stcd-j Onary 10',k~S)


0. YGlriet'( of ~~~',~/2.. mc..chineS and e.)(li.r<.i~<1..tr<>i""'''.S eqUlpn-<.nt. Howtl-v~rI Lopez tpno wa.s in G\

invoh.m+<>Y''/ uno.sS'lj"-U:! St",tu5 "''''0 ',n 0.. noY'\-pu(),+"v~ ~TO\W51 W<l.S S b~e.d(d 10 "'poli'y o",der

Qat. '30'6 tho:t SLlb~ec.+~him to €..J<tre~ <ie.p1'iv,,-"\ion of o0+docr €-J'-erc.i~Jt..,r'h"~ic.C\\ G\ctiv',+ies ,aY'le,;,terc.\~~ e<t\.l\I'rN.nt rv<.ce'S~«r'1 hJ Nip me,int,,',n 8c::ed N.C\/fh. 7klG\ck of /'l'<t.c,h<>'''ic.«' U~rc.l~~

e.qu"f'l14.nt \tk\eu;'K. of outdoor ~er(:,~I(..o.n6 p}..'/,>i<.al a.di'v·,tl~s 10. 1"\0 +""- Ia.c.\'i of adeqtJo:te.l""\ove

~nt I <..A\)$~d L pe't. SeY",ou5 heCllth pl"Ob\el"'\$. Such 0.5 \"Y\-.>Sc,I(.. o.nd jOin\- p"'ir'l I 'i>t-\ff,,'lsS Iil"\o.del'/""*k

h~lt", CircuI"t',Ol')I\Y'\~~ banI(.. "6+re'1J+h ."nd ot...... r h.ec:o.I+h probkl'\'1S. 7~c..o"dit-jon5 0+ (,onfine;nel'1-1

o-ff«:nd oV'le e,)(.o.<:.erb<:>nd LO~"L' ~ vr-tn+n \ or><:! emo+ion", \~ Ith I fT> -tke.)(~n+ 1 he... o..t+tmpted S\.licide

o.no. '&~\"i-'n",rm,bllt never nportecl Suvh ·II"\Ci~nts.

~y, D~,:hnOants' DGlniel tJrGlt.fT'-V, Don 5+r-Clho+a,WilliC:In'l POII"rd / p"'l'N-la -Z<:>nkJa"d MicJ-,a",f

7hvrTN.f !P(.Y'I/.. (;lL->c.r ..... of Sl.>ch cend i+ions j n +1-<.. ~l<8re"C\tioY'1 unit, anoi.+~ ',t'Y'pCI£:,+ i+VJ~ CQ.US"l'\j

upoV' Lo{l~.;z.' S No.\-\'h Md ';,C\.fd'1\ '1~+ /<:\e.spi-k ho.viY'\j pe('Scn<\1 \<."ou.>\~e..o1 hiS pl!.9n+ (;\nd fN...~u-\-hO'r'I+-i 0'1 C~o.G·,+Y 10 +cd<:.e... corre.div'l. o-cmon 10 pro+e.c+ hiS NCllfh and 5afe-tyj -f"i/ed +0 c.orred

~v\O\",-\\on •

.R'1O,cH'i 5te.,iI~a+ of fo..GtS~5. 7hl(.. pkl,ntiff A~thony R'G\Gh ha.~ o..hiS-rory of S~..iouS ~h+o.l ~c:<I+hproblems.

~~, On Mo.'{ ~~ la-ceq. f'\C\'nl,-H Anthoh'{ Ri"c.h lP~'!> p\o.c.tcl 'm Pro9r<lrr'l ~3re8o.tfo\'l-for ~ho.vjor

th",+ W~ 0. -re..<;\J\-\ 0+ hiS p~'(d".lo8ic,oldisor<kr. J>.fh.r CO"'"'llltl..+i'J h,~ ~~8~C\t\tn ~~c.e.l(k"~..,cc,,,-bl

DOn StrC\h* GIno. DGlniell3ro.efl"tr r«.om~~th"t R\o.c.-h be..subjec.-hoc:! +0 odmihistrcd'lv~ c..onf',ne

YN.nt o~r Doc. '3O'il b~~ On t~ ClbClV~ 'oe,.havior, (}n Apri \ 8.1 10010 j',n G\C(or6<:>nce.v.> i-lh W i~. Ad"".CAO" sec., Ooc ~)+N. oO;ni""Mro.-nve c.or"fih~"""'''+ c.om"",',t+t.e..de..~r""iNd +h..t- R,C\Ch ~pl"c~J in CIdm\l\i..tr","IV'l. CcY'fH"-u"I"-(ffl'o~ on o/2..f(~....t-s' ,&tr"hot<t and- Gro.en-er' s r«-Ol'\'1rN·n&:..tiOl?

~7 . .1'1+ all t-\~S n.\~VC\nt +0 RiC\c.h' 5 c..onf\~rNn+ ''''~+~'5''6rejcdioY'l l)Y'l"+j klP~ sllbje..c..tqd -to an1)""c,onS-¥'wncn,,\ rO\\c,'1 or pro.dic,e..lJnOer Doc... "3C1fi th~+ oepT',v-ed him of ().)tdoor re.cI'i>ubJed~cl himto

e;,t.Tr~n-'L-'" \'n;te.t\ons of \ V1Ooo'f e:llerC \S'l.lo."O -h;, \ n o.d<Ujuc,l\!. 'Sun'~h: ,and -h> ?UY"rtW~ ~~G\'t j on i Y'I approP'rlo.-te.. fer +~~n+o..\\y ',11.

'8'%. p,,,,',nti-ff RiQc.h WG\'; \ ':><:>\<>.-ttd \Y'I CI. <:'1:.1 \ -thC4t 15 5~p",r<"ted from tN.-Opell-onif by <A So lid S+eel

door I an ~n+r'lnc'"hQII 10. <:'01' (",Oor w\tl-l 0\, \on.5 lJ,)G\\l 'i>troc.-\\lrq,d 0..+ t ....... (R"ter Of tM.- h<l.ll t<:> force

e.J'-,\-rq,~\~C>I",tlon ,o.r'lO '5"n~or'l ckpl':,,,C\1-\on.

Al'1thol"\'l fl.',lAth (PG'5 cey,,~',~ n~r\'f 0..'1- noor5 CA. oc..'f I o.lone., \\'"1 0.. Small ce...ll construc:.ted (.Pithc.oncr~tt floor ,bl"c.I<.lPal\~ )0.",6 0. ~U\r door thed" c.~uS<l.S e.:)l1-ren-e...-forc..e.d- \ ~olCltion ISenSol""'( clerri

vo.tionj"nodepr;"Clt\on of ~\rec.thu""'Q" COnteu:.t, 74ceH5 hav<t-Cl5/ 1 Solid w-""OCvJ\",+N...OOor


th,,+ prov'16~) \'IY\',i-kd vie"" C>f~oohlcorse.Hi"j ,,,,,<I a 5" solid wi nckx.e j n +-J-....Wo.ll tha+ provieks

lim;-tt<l vie~ of -t~oonide flnvironl'Nnf. 7~5" Solid \.PinclclJ.) 0'(")',/ providltS IIt+le.. 'S1..""li8h+inhltkceli.

'D'l, R"\o.c,h WOo:) o.lIcl."Q....~ re..<:... ":,<2.++i \'"\j i "'+~S~ uni+,7k barred (..Uil"<low~ i", t-~ in

ckor re.c:.. 5<2.++i nj Cldm',+ \it+'~ 'i>unlijh1 hijh up neClrt"!-o. Ceilli'j and Ol>t of reGlch to p~vent Iftk. Son, 7.,...., order fOr R: ","ch -to Co~ .,.....-Il> 6\rCW+- co.....-t«<t(pith t-~Y-.=t or \\~Yrt .fTum 1-N..-')uV'l. ~()..>cuI6 ~ Th Climb G\. \".j-(r. RiClCh WCt~ dep'rivttd of o.dequc..rl-e..~L>n for C\. flro\on~d "mount-of tifT""' .. H'Ll..l..laJ lool<.td. j h hH C.~II nearly IbL( hoorS tu.J.JUJ( wi+hout 0."'1

6\re>-t 'i)u'n e..J'fOsure.<N+-k-~'f' T~ lo.d< of Sl>nliJht e}(.C\cerbGl+ecl Rjo.ch'S ~nt..1 and phYSiCol heo.lt/l.

7klo.ckcrf S<ml~htCoVSed RjG\Cn £',Kin pro\:)lemS) po.len(.SSl \no.Oe.ct<)"'~ hl2.cl.l+h Cirwt"'+io\l'lli",cd€quc\"t..

bone.Str(nBthl'm~t>~Vj+Cl\'>\·,,, D,and O+~r h~£l.Hh probkmS". -rht. lOotKof S(){\\'\5ht,o....l \"Ie..o.ll-h i~~e.sl

'lr\~rfer<d (p\'lh Rio.ch'S C\l:li\i+-/-Kl en5'\je i", Vi.s0rC<J5 e.xu(.i~<t..and o-c.+ivitie..S.

CH.I N...~un',,\- (>n''( "Y"bvic~S 0-. PUll-Up bar 0.+ ru... A pUll -up bG\T iho.PPTop~i"fq..1Or-t~~n+"Ii'l'

'In. R\o.t.v,' S Yl'-tnttl\ C\ nO ph'1Si <'0.1 eo'f\cht-illt'\ mod... H diff i tu/1 tt> Iift Or Support h j S O\»n we.i.sht. 12; G\Ch

ofhYl <:\ id\')'t e", ~~IL "' n OlYl'l €)(trC,iS/L betc\l>!oz. hi S\')'<,no}"Ql i II~~ pNve ....+ed hi"'" fro.." dOinj 0.",/ eltert.iS<1S

or o.e;+iv·,-noz.\ -fur ph'/S' <.<\1 f',t~~~. 7""-. Sej un i+ d i cln'-f pn>vi de (lio..ch o.c.(.ess ie rN.che:tI'\OC<l\ ~q,rci \oz.s

eql)', pl'K.n1 fer h.e..H..... f i+~~5. '1" "'~i-t;OVl I R i G\.(.h offen ciid n01 lUlf:J"fJe "V'I ""'I u-e r<; !e,S bect:luse of fk.

1', ",',~J <;'hoWtr~ .'""""·,hd So<>p ,a~ \ i "",',W vh'ln~eof vI~~. Ri "-c '" often d.id T\o+ e"'1l"j-<1.. in Cl"', T'\ll'\"'\')j I

j0881"~ ,oy- ~u",pi ~ ~o.ck~ b«.<u.>se..+k-Sterk.- i ssuoz.d~~ mC\de. H d iffituri or ;mpo'5Sib/e for him tt> rVt),

.}DjJor ~I,)MP\l'"\3 ~,,(k ',Yl ·tNl...... on 'SO\i~ COnt.rele flcon. RiC\.th l..l..la.~ Ylo+- allowed~ hClv<t..hiS pnSoY'\o.\

sheoz.,~ \.pn;\t. .,'" Sej. He l..t>t:t.l on\ f OI\lol>.>/l,d +0 IPe.ar~t-o.+t.- i~S ~cl shoe- l,Uith o..qU4rter of 'VI ',,,,c.h Scl'l..

Aroo W\-...", R-it:l.d'l ~H("'fhd 1tJ run Jd~ ,or ~()Y>"fJ i ("\ t~", J +kScliJ C Y"c.rete.. floor irvHli CIted fC'lil'\ ,Soreness,

Q.~ lIlJ.>Ol'll"\j uMq,r5<x.fCl(.~d of ·t'k fDo+ Ct"d nee i.

'la, \Ni';,·Mm, ~'l. 5ee.. 00<.. 30"1.3<0 Cf/lex.us pr-;::'ONiI" in 0. ',nVOhm1-c.,,'f ()n"sS,,~d stC17vS I r.md il"(}o. hon-pun',1',ve ::,t<.tvs,1"t> pad1C',p",tIL in ph'(\ic,a\ e..)l-erc.;S<lS o.nO o-.c.tivities, b\X,h ~ bas/£.r+ball,

h""a\:lo.I\ ,tClble..te nn; SJ VO 1I/t'1bt:lII , fOclbal \ j trad( and -f l~Jd J Weia'rvt \if+i '2J )S+ctti OMr'l bi Ic.es, '"v<\r-iet-t

o-f e..Hr(,i~ rno.c.\o\\\'\Q.$ Orod e-J'.e~cise. tr",,"",nj eql>jprNnt. HoUJ,/-vu' J I<io.c.h (,Uno \.Pas ',n 0.. \ vWO\l>VYl-ary

UY\o.S~i.9Nd~~lan.l \\'\ (;\.nol'l- pun·,+iv~ S+utv~. (,Utl.S Sl.lb~e.v+ed fo o..poliWllndQr Doc. 3~ +f"I"t Sub

c\e<+ecl "",m tI:> <U'-1nl"r4.od'tfl'r"V<.\+ioh of ocl~oor V'Hci~, ph"Si<:<t1 a.d·,vitiQS ,o.nd eJ<.e("C.'l$C.. eqvip~.,t

YH~.C.e.~C\r'{ 1t> ~Ip '('rI"'''rrtt<''n 5~ ~I+h. 7klatk of Y'l"C.thl\n' '41 eJl.e rGol~ €.<lui pl'Nnf J +1-<.. IAc.k of out·

cIoor e.)l.Q rC,i se. Cl nd ph'/Sie" \ Glc,ti vities • C\nd +k. Io..(k of adequCj'k mover)"tn1-, c:.Gll>sed R iC\c.h 'Seri 00 ShealJh

problQ\"n\, SUC~ 0..\ mO\(.Ie..o.n<!-.iO',Y\t pa',n I ~+iff~s ,"nocle.q()qk,. hlUl\+h c.iy-c.u\G\.·\-\o\,\ 1'\Y\C\ckqUo,ftt. bonQ.

~he-"£lth ,G\nd c»-kr ~I+h proQ ems. ill<... CbnditiOI'lS of- c..o"fi"-O,\'"I"O.nt o..+fe..c~d anJ e~u.rbC1t«1 R i"-<.h' ~

YN-I'l+t:l\ hl2.cl.l+1, l1-e +-ku-kl'l+, t--.t..'na.s ",tternp+ed -ft, harm himStlf On ~evtr«1 oUc",Si Y\S ,bu(\ n~ver

-15-


Q3. n~f~r)et\nts' DClnie,ll3rtltYNf l Don Str",hote..)Wi\\"o.m pollard) PCl~Ia. 2A\'\K,c;\nd MiC-ho.~1

'Thorl'N.r wu-t. ClV:>G\~ Of ~\,)c.1-) coY\c.it-ions ',n+~~r~cmcn l)n',+, Clnd +k iYY\ptl.e:t i+ Wtl..S

CG\0~iY\5 Upon R',o.(;h·~ he,p.l+h1ye-+- j de-spH"I!-hG\vinj ~~cY\"\ I'\nov.>l~o!8~o~ hl~ prijhT a,,<!tko.u+h"r',t-( or C"f'Gl.c...-t-t -to tllK~ COY-f~e.t"VILcu,:ticn -ttl prt>kc.1- hiS ~ql1'h c:v.d Stl..fd-/ Ifall~ 10 CCrre<:t

-tk..v i..I",+lcYl,

V. £XHA.l.lS110N (Jr ADMINl'51AA1IVL RllV\rnl~

qt.\. 1ht. PICl\\,ytH-f5 1 hCWL ~hc,,)ste.d the"r od.rn',ni~+r'l+iV~rE.~i~s w',th reSp-E.c.T to +~do.i)'\'\S

in +h,~ CAS~. (1) hi,') vCI.:)"{ue1.. ~ (..orYIpl,,',r)t Numbers 1 We-I. - 0..011 -1'1(,ao J a.Ol/ - 14(Q~O Ia.OII

\1.1"61.11) a.oll-ilolo07. G'l Do.vid GreE:I10x:0d: c..omplc',nt Numbers' Wc..1- Otoll- 14~"3'6)~,otI, '4~3'1,

8,011- 1l004'6 J (i..0l \-1 (0'1%. (3) JGlV ie r .scllo:z.G\T : ComplCAint Num~rs I wc..:r. -0t01I - aYrB-b, (i..OII

1"~7, ~ol\. 1'1'i'b'& ) OlOII- \15"1. eLf) "30\ i ClI"\ Lope-z.: Col'Y'p\c"rrl- NL>n'\lxrs' We-:I - e;toll-l<.a?t7 J

~\\-t('77'1J(;l.oI\-ICoCf'$lJC)l.OJI-/b'l91. C5') Anthon,,! RiGlch: C.Or-npl"'irrl ,A.Jvmbtrs' Wc.l.-e;toll

1~1T3J a..c\I-IS5fiil' 1~11" 1(,,03"3) a,o\:l ·IG'S'3b.

VI. CLAl fv\S FOR RlLlE.-F a.

Q5. (\~h+h AYNr>6YNnt Claim C\jQinS+ d~fet1dQn+S'Do,niel f3ro.e~rlDon S+n:tnofc< ,\N;lli~M

?O\\Clrc\ l pGlrN.1" ,,<:Ihk jand MlChq(./ 7 hurrY'«. r l-fur 'SU\:)J~di~ p\""htif+S J LoiS VCIS'Iue7.J Do.vid(;~lU1lPOQ:l) 00vier SQ\c.'Z~r);Jo\iClYlLopez..a~ Arrthon'( 12;o..(.h J 10 an unc.onS+'futi'oY1cd pOliC-V

Of ~Y'~t1-iCQ.. Lmd~( \I,rl~.Mm. CodE:.. S~.c... Doc. 3o<jf Ii-hOlt depr-.w.d +~rY\ of-ex>+dror e:>cerciseJSvb

Jec.+eJ t~rn til <q(+rt<~r.mi-\-G\+i on On e.krc.i~ Qr1c\. re.c~onI 'Sl.lb.i~+ec:l fJ-e;n it> inc<cle

quo:tcL. 'S n"',fn't IQ~ fc et-mrr-e-.furud iSc:>\cdiOY'l, Sensor'! def''rivcdionlCl.nd..fu puni+-ivrlS~l'\JGl41o(l env; rv-nYNtn+ ',nGlppropr; C<k., -fur 1'4.. n"-Ul1-ol1l'1 i1/ J -t/1Q7 ) Cot l+hCXO h J CA. non- pun\tiV'L'5+crNS) ~cll,S ~clY1,,+fons tJ-.... rnGlintc(lc.nce...of pr-i.$un Cot"ld-i+ions -t'hc.tinfril1je vfX'Yl~ mc',n-!-en",,, C~ of lif~ ClIne! VPCh 1'4 Consti-h>noi'lc<1 r-iJ"MS o+fkpJc..inhfHj for rnCtinfo.iniy

().. COmmon Pyo.t.+-,~of i~o\<\+;~ ~V\cl (tl-\o""""3 +N..~nt"\\'1 ill pIGli",-HffS in 0- rona"ve 'iit<:VU",:iion

Sd+iYl~ ,\Y\Clprrtll'I"'C(1e for +~~"tq\\'f\1\-my prolCYl~ Glmwwt Of +il'N.1uYlcler htl.rs~ col'lditiOt's ,+hQtle.Vtl"l +hOL>(jh) not o.ofhoyi-Uc b't Wr",Hth lo.WI\~ S bfOCld CAnd peTSi1+t,,+ a"d.I/Ve/1 es-tr0/isJ-,P ~~-hI

demcl'\5trGIte. fA. (,u~to\'Yl or-L>S~ v.:>i+h'l1 tk.for«.. of t"w.

a. l'hll. coort ~hol)ld c..oh~·lder anGlhz.inj fl tI.',n\iffS Conditicns in totCl.I GOrnbin ion. znaddifjM j

0.1\'1 'f..."ti 0'" o.d6it',OY\O,I -ft.(:h CI.\ l"jt<d ',n p\'I',Y'1tiffs ~GI+(/Nrr+ Sh,,11 not b.ll..dUm nor- irrlerj)r(f 11> raiSeo.~O'I-t\<>"'''\ (..\'I',m5 bll.(GI~ :ll.X.h 'f"<.'h "'it re\tl.r<lnt ""tkc:.e""llI<'i"t for i (l 50ppor't o-f Pic" ,,+,ff5 c..la.irn5.

-1~-


, pur 1...'",,1 to 0.""6 O.S.c,. ~f'_c.. 1< "-I },.~ \Gl\f\·L-ffS ~C.lc.,f~ 0nd~I' pe cH'{ of~.1'; l.)f'/ thC\~ -+1--:. fC'r~Jo"l"j \~ hu~. qn~ Corrq,.d .

• 1.1'\ ",Mltion Iplll·I.·r~H. c.eri-;f,!· ~1-htit 5i!:f,,,:.fwt+/I.rl to1·j..".be.~+ ()++;"'t~rK"'OI.<'h''''J::';ll'rf'Orrr''';tiCfl

o(\cllo~r,,~.f f""Nc! o.Hcr r('c.)on",b~ ',nqoir<{ l~' 1l:J~cY'\ <»,!j..". C.Ol'l'p\G4int (Art I,lJt.1\ errolJn~:",

fo.d 0\"";' t ICi""S..:M i~ \))<,r!", .• +~d by e;li\~"nj l/Av., or o.j~ ir.l\th o.'·Jv~rrI ft... 1J-.. e;o/1~ ... 'S;onl

yy,ncf,{i cC4tioI1 1c-r I"e\ln~cu 0{ e)l; ~;'I1>-' lOlA' (l,,~ .. h ..t t}- •. f ',Ii ':j of +J-... (C.'no, f' Iclini j ~ r,o+'\ ~{upc",cI

fur (j\"'fi~'YIllroj>(fpvrpo~ IS..,'..., 0$ tb'h~r"'$S or CCl\)~~.' nr.I'.lf"£<,r'! clClo.y or n~~lc1is',\,,$y(?,~ ,..~

c.e~+ of litj3fJ1ien. ,his joiI'l1Iltf.J.>$\lj·' wit!, ""lIH:pk i$r",. f 1- I itijll.d1 r-m'(H.di~ fres.:..l~nui

h'\cr(Q.~ -+1-<.. ,.~ c-f \ i1ijGlti?Y1 • R"tkr I H d.(l.e ,.-" Sot.l +J_ (col bu {;I <.>\:e. if (,l,)"JJ/c1 (.'s Ie S~ te Ii IiJ=,1e1 • O~ \,,~\)i1 ~>Hh p'I,liipill. inm«tl'S thM, Sit 5-tf"rc,,+c l'lt-SlIi+s or' hi", S de...li'J v.~·"H",-TK

.5a~ t s)v(~ i ,t WClOk4 o.voic:l rnuH:plt. COI''- '·fr,..:i ",tt;OflS •

.."hc.. fi\Q',rrt',ih CA"ru.. if> h.w~ LoiS VcHquO.. ta~~ c.nt.:l ..~'t 0( +~~ l"'I.,A.,~)i1~Ct(·d ~fJr~'twith tN.

:tr"t~6·1C.<i~'i ~ion ~"'2J ""Q<!J{. 7k. plaintiffs "ISo ~re~-ib-rf:rY'~;n ;rl (enj'i d tJJr/h ~ClGhofJ-~r

th~hou1 tt-.. ~trldf:li<.d('~:\ion ~:"'j m~~ irdh;\ case.

. The.. plc...n't',Hs de./T'Q,."j 0. jl,r,/1rio.l ih ihiS (flcrr+tr.

• 7h'!. pl~i"f'Hs WGlrn ,h-ff"<!"''''+S iYlthiS e<dicn in (;,t3I'........'~/ih"T,~ ..y ",dvtr£l- O~'+;~I/'l 0.03°',":;1p""Y'l!;H,\ {'t'Y' {',Iitl +",i\ 1~",,\oi1 """"f c.o,,\tj·hrk r~;"';C\lio,,, i'''I V;~ICA'ljtl~ oft,..~ J~+ A~,..JrYV<!YI •

~ ..fl£M.v~

LUI';) \/f>.S9uf,.7.

ce.1he pluintii'h C.~rtH·! th"i tlv.'I will

b~\'V>",..\ "j '" '~P'l of t/-.c.. G\rN",lt.dGClmfliQ\nt.vi~ u·S. pust" , ~rvi~ Ito

o~ftnJo.t'1h aHt>Yru..y c.or~'1 FrClnciS

Fin~~lo-t.'ttrlG\t Oo~ ,P.O. (301C 1'657 J

/VIl:lcli~oY1, \f<.li~. 5~107-11-

(JJlfl4lfaD~"t

..i.!.-M 0 if? It.D"',-,-:1.;:..t_

ad//hluDf\iE

,

Documents

1. INTRODUC'.\ 'jY\Q'",t":"'·'njtkQVCro.lI ':lCA.ft.ty 01"16 ~,ul"i+'f oftk.in~+·,+u-tion., 'oIJo.s 5. peffnc\oni non ~tro.hoto. e\'V\pl0 'l