4
Research Journal of Finance and Accounting www.iiste.org ISSN 2222-1697 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2847 (Online) Vol.6, No.23, 2015 16 Dividend Policy, Stock Price Volatility & Firm Size Moderation: Investigation of Bird in Hand Theory in Pakistan Saima Nasir Chaudry Scholars Mohammad Ali Jinnah University Islamabad Sajid Iqbal Faculty of Management Sciences Indus International Institute DG-Khan Maheen Butt Scholars Mohammad Ali Jinnah University Islamabad Abstract The current study hypothesized dividend policy on stock price volatility with moderating impact of firm size with respect to bird in hand theory. The study investigated manufacturing sector of Pakistan. And have found significant impact of firm size between dividend policy facets and stock price volatility. The connivance sampling technique is used for data acquisition and the period of data consists from Jan 2009 to Dec 2013. Thus, up to the bird in hand theory all hypothesis of the study are accepted and study revealed key implication with respect to historic investigations. Keywords: Convenience Sampling, Manufacturing Sector, Pakistan, Hypothesis 1. INTRODUCTION The current study investigates the relationship of dividend policy of Pakistani corporate sector with stock price volatility by moderating impact of corporate size. The dividend policy is rich topic and stock price volatility has revealed hot implications for theorists and practitioners (P arkinson, 1980). Stock prices volatility is a phenomenon where stock prices deviates in index from average level to upward or downward. Such upward and downward trends are re-pronounced as bullish and bearish trends of stock prices. Such trends occurs because of various activities interplayed by companies within their operation. Thus, dividend policy is one of the operational activity and ingredient that pinches corporate stock prices (Roll, 1983; Irfan and Nishat, 2003). Moreover, dividend policy is an operational procedure in order to pay returns towards corporate share holders with extent of their investment in company’s shares. Such investments of shareholder’s are e xecuted by them in companies up to t heir traditional, emotional and rational sentiments. Various financial sentiments are profound and investigated by historic studies regarding shareholders i-e rate of return, return on equity, and return on assets, preemptive right and voting rights. Thus, firm size is one of them that is mainly considered by corporate share holders and is rich in investigation. Moreover, Firm size is usually pronounced as actual size of the company that is measured through the value of net sales volume. It is the firm size that shuffles various financial ingredients of the company including capital structure and amount of investment (Iqbal et al., 2014) Firm size has vital role in determining the level of credit risk and has negative relationship with credit risk (Iqbal, Chaudry and Iqbal, 2015). Moreover, it is the firm size that leads its improvised role with liquidity risk, enhances corporate productivity (Iqbal et al., 2015) and also increases systematic risk (Iqbal, Iqbal & Khan, 2015). Moreover, Zameer at al. (2013) explained in their study that firm size has positive relationship with dividend policy antecedents under the umbrella of bird in hand theory. In this concern, Asghar et al. (2013) revealed in their study that there is positive relationship between dividend policy and stock prices but it is the firm size that shuffles such relationship because of variant nature of firm size in various sector’s and such variability makes the relationship between dividend policy and stock prices more sensitive. Thus, current study aimed to investigate the moderating impact of firm size between dividend policy and stock price’s volatility. Moreover, study aimed is to investigate the nature of decisions and shareholders sentiments towards stock prices volatility and dividend policy. While, bird in hand theory is used as theoretical  base that explains as dividend provisions by the co mpanies enhance corporate value. Moreover, study will reveal key implications for theorists and practitioners of financial world specifically in Pakistan. The part 01 of current study explains introduction and literature citations relevant to theoretical frame- work; part two elaborates the study methodology, including measurement models and hypothesis. Part three explains the study results and analyses. While, part four clarifies the findings and conclusion of study.

27829-30538-1-PB.pdf

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 27829-30538-1-PB.pdf

7/21/2019 27829-30538-1-PB.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/27829-30538-1-pbpdf 1/4

Research Journal of Finance and Accounting www.iiste.org 

ISSN 2222-1697 !a"er# ISSN 2222-2$%7 &nline#

'ol.6( No.2)( 2*1+

16

Dividend Policy, Stock Price Volatility & Firm Size Moderation:

Investigation of Bird in Hand !eory in Pakistan

Sai,a Nasir haudr

Scholars /oha,,ad Ali Jinnah 0niersit Isla,aad

Sa3id I4al

Facult of /anage,ent Sciences Indus International Institute 5-han

/aheen 8utt

Scholars /oha,,ad Ali Jinnah 0niersit Isla,aad

"#stract

he current stud h"othesi:ed diidend "olic on stoc; "rice olatilit with ,oderating i,"act of fir, si:e

with res"ect to ird in hand theor. he stud inestigated ,anufacturing sector of !a;istan. And hae found

significant i,"act of fir, si:e etween diidend "olic facets and stoc; "rice olatilit. he conniance

sa,"ling techni4ue is used for data ac4uisition and the "eriod of data consists fro, Jan 2**9 to 5ec 2*1). hus(

u" to the ird in hand theor all h"othesis of the stud are acce"ted and stud reealed ;e i,"lication with

res"ect to historic inestigations.

$ey%ords: onenience Sa,"ling( /anufacturing Sector( !a;istan( <"othesis

'  I()*D+I*(

he current stud inestigates the relationshi" of diidend "olic of !a;istani cor"orate sector with stoc; "rice

olatilit ,oderating i,"act of cor"orate si:e. he diidend "olic is rich to"ic and stoc; "rice olatilit has

reealed hot i,"lications for theorists and "ractitioners !ar;inson( 19$*#.Stoc; "rices olatilit is a "heno,enon where stoc; "rices deiates in inde= fro, aerage leel to

u"ward or downward. Such u"ward and downward trends are re-"ronounced as ullish and earish trends of

stoc; "rices. Such trends occurs ecause of arious actiities inter"laed co,"anies within their o"eration.

hus( diidend "olic is one of the o"erational actiit and ingredient that "inches cor"orate stoc; "rices Roll(

19$)> Irfan and Nishat( 2**)#. /oreoer( diidend "olic is an o"erational "rocedure in order to "a returnstowards cor"orate share holders with e=tent of their inest,ent in co,"an?s shares.Such inest,ents of shareholder?s are e=ecuted the, in co,"anies u" to their traditional( e,otional

and rational senti,ents. 'arious financial senti,ents are "rofound and inestigated historic studies regarding

shareholders i-e rate of return( return on e4uit( and return on assets( "ree,"tie right and oting rights. hus(

fir, si:e is one of the, that is ,ainl considered cor"orate share holders and is rich in inestigation.

/oreoer( Fir, si:e is usuall "ronounced as actual si:e of the co,"an that is ,easured through the alue of

net sales olu,e.It is the fir, si:e that shuffles arious financial ingredients of the co,"an including ca"ital structure

and a,ount of inest,ent I4al et al.( 2*1%# Fir, si:e has ital role in deter,ining the leel of credit ris; and

has negatie relationshi" with credit ris; I4al( haudr and I4al( 2*1+#. /oreoer( it is the fir, si:e that

leads its i,"roised role with li4uidit ris;( enhances cor"orate "roductiit I4al et al.( 2*1+# and also

increases sste,atic ris; I4al( I4al @ han( 2*1+#. /oreoer( a,eer at al. 2*1)# e="lained in their stud

that fir, si:e has "ositie relationshi" with diidend "olic antecedents under the u,rella of ird in handtheor.

In this concern( Asghar et al. 2*1)# reealed in their stud that there is "ositie relationshi" etween

diidend "olic and stoc; "rices ut it is the fir, si:e that shuffles such relationshi" ecause of ariant nature of

fir, si:e in arious sector?s and such ariailit ,a;es the relationshi" etween diidend "olic and stoc; "rices

,ore sensitie.hus( current stud ai,ed to inestigate the ,oderating i,"act of fir, si:e etween diidend "olic

and stoc; "rice?s olatilit. /oreoer( stud ai,ed is to inestigate the nature of decisions and shareholders

senti,ents towards stoc; "rices olatilit and diidend "olic. Bhile( ird in hand theor is used as theoretical

 ase that e="lains as diidend "roisions the co,"anies enhance cor"orate alue. /oreoer( stud will reeal

;e i,"lications for theorists and "ractitioners of financial world s"ecificall in !a;istan.

he "art *1 of current stud e="lains introduction and literature citations releant to theoretical fra,e-wor;> "art two elaorates the stud ,ethodolog( including ,easure,ent ,odels and h"othesis. !art three

e="lains the stud results and analses. Bhile( "art four clarifies the findings and conclusion of stud.

Page 2: 27829-30538-1-PB.pdf

7/21/2019 27829-30538-1-PB.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/27829-30538-1-pbpdf 2/4

Research Journal of Finance and Accounting www.iiste.org 

ISSN 2222-1697 !a"er# ISSN 2222-2$%7 &nline#

'ol.6( No.2)( 2*1+

17

-'  ).S.")H M.H*D*/*01

he current is e="lorator in nature and e="lores the nature of relationshi" with ,oderating i,"act of fir, si:e

a,ong diidend "olic and stoc; "rice olatilit. hus( the stud contains on one de"endent ariale diidend

 "olic ,easured four "ro=ies? i-e diidend "aout ratio( earnings olatilit( diidend ield and growth in

assets. Bhile( there is one de"endent ariale as stoc; "rice olatilit and one ,oderating ariale na,ed as

fir, si:e.hus( the stud used conniance sa,"ling a""roach to gather the data and to use it further for analses.

And the sector of inestigation is ,anufacturing sector of !a;istan ,ainl where ce,ent sector( "har,ac sector(

8eerages sector( Food Sector and electronics sectors are used as stud inestigation units. hus( the data

consists fro, 2**9 to 2*1). he nature of data of the stud is "anel. /oreoer( regarding instru,entation stud

used descri"tie analses( data reliailit and alidit tests( correlation analses and ,oderating regression

analses. So the the,atic ,odel of the stud is as follows(

In aoe ,entioned ,odel there is one inde"endent ariale as diidend "olic and it is ,easured four "ro=?s i-e diidend "aout ratio 5!&#( growth in Assets A#( earnings olatilit C'# and diidend ield

5D# res"ectiel. here is one de"endent ariale as stoc; "rice olatilit !'# and one ,oderating ariale as

fir, si:e FS#.

So on the ases of aoe ,odel and theoretical fra,e wor; h"othesis of the stud are(

/ain <"othesis#

 H1: There is positive relationship between dividend policy facets and stock price volatility

 H2: There is moderating relationship of firm size between dividend policy facets and price volatility

Su <"othesis#

 H1: There is positive relationship of dividend payout ratio with price volatility

 H2: There is positive relationship of growth in assets with price volatility

 H3: There is positive relationship of dividend yield with price volatility

 H4: There is positive relationship of earnings volatility with price volatility

 H: There is a moderating relationship of firm size between dividend payout and price volatility

 H!: There is a moderating relationship of firm size between growth in assets and price volatility

 H": There is a moderating relationship of firm size between dividend yield and price volatility

 H#: There is moderating relationship of firm size between earnings volatility and price volatility

hus( the ,easure,ent ,odels on the ases of aoe h"othesis of ,entioned ariales are as follows(

Page 3: 27829-30538-1-PB.pdf

7/21/2019 27829-30538-1-PB.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/27829-30538-1-pbpdf 3/4

Research Journal of Finance and Accounting www.iiste.org 

ISSN 2222-1697 !a"er# ISSN 2222-2$%7 &nline#

'ol.6( No.2)( 2*1+

1$

2'  ).S+/S

ale *1

5escri"tie Statistics#

'ariales /ean /edian

5!& *.7$ 1.71

C' 1.+6 ).%%5D ).%+ 6.*9

A 7.$9 11.11

FS 2.)1 7.))

!' 11.+6 2%.+6

he tale *1 e="lains the results of descri"tie statistics where the ,ean alue of 5!& is *.7$ and

standard deiation is 1.71( C' has ,ean alue as 1.+6 and standard deiation alue is ).%%( 5D ,ean alue is

).%+ and deiation alue is 6.*9( growth in assets ,ean alue is 7.$9 and deiation alue I 1.11( fir, si:e has

,ean alue as 2.)1 and standard deiation alue is 7.))( "rice olatilit has ,ean alue as 11.+6 and deiation

alue is 2%.+6 res"ectiel.

ale *2

Reliailit Analses#

'ariales No of &seration ronach?s Al"ha

5!& 22$9 *.$9

C' 22$9 *.71

5D 22$9 *.77

A 22$9 *.$2

FS 22$9 *.76

!' 22$9 *.7+

he tale *2 elaorates the reliailit results where total nu,er of oserations consists of 22$9 ofthe entire sa,"le tested in current stud. /oreoer( reliailit al"ha alue of diidend "aout 5!&# is *.$9(

earnings olatilit C'# is *.71( diidend ield 5'# *.77( growth in assets A# *.$2( fir, si:e FS# is *.76 and

 "rice olatilit !'# is *.7+ res"ectiel. <ence( data of all ariales is reliale and suitale for testing ecause

their reliailit alues are found greater than *.71.

ale *)

orrelation Analses#'ariales 5!& C' 5D A FS !'

5!& 1C' *.21EE 1

5D *.)1EE *.))EE 1

A *.)6EE *.)9EE *.%%EE 1

FS *.++EE *.+7EE *.61EE *.67EE 1

!' *.+2EE *.+$EE *.6%EE *.67EE *.72EE 1

he tale *) e="lains the correlation ,atri= of stud. hus( diidend "aout is correlated with earnings

olatilit as *.21EE "*.*1#( earnings olatilit is significantl correlated with diidend ield as .))EE "*.*1#(diidend ield is significantl correlated with growth in assets as *.%%EE "*.*1#( growth in assets are

significantl correlated with fir, si:e *.67EE "*.*1# and fir, si:e is significantl correlated with *.72EE

"*.*1#. /oreoer( rice olatilit is significantl correlated as *.+2EE "*.*1#( *.+$EE "*.*1#( *.6%EE

"*.*1# @ *.67EE "*.*1# res"ectiel.

Page 4: 27829-30538-1-PB.pdf

7/21/2019 27829-30538-1-PB.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/27829-30538-1-pbpdf 4/4

Research Journal of Finance and Accounting www.iiste.org 

ISSN 2222-1697 !a"er# ISSN 2222-2$%7 &nline#

'ol.6( No.2)( 2*1+

19

ale *%

/oderated Regression Analses#

!redictor?s G R 2  $R 2

Ste" *1

5!& *.*+EE .++) .7%+

C' .2)+EE5D .17$EE

A .26+EE

FS 1.29EE

Ste" *2

5!&EFS .1+7 .%)1 .**%

C'EFS .*$7

5DEFS .11)

AEFS .17%

he ,oderated regression analses are used of fir, si:e in current stud ecause the stoc; ,ar;et

 "erfor,ance and ,atter of return to shareholders are "inched s,all and large si:e of the fir,s. hus( tale *%

re"orted ,oderated regression of fir, si:e etween diidend "olic and stoc; "rice olatilit. In ste" one

diidend "aout eta is found *.*+ "*.*1#( earnings olatilit *.2)+EE "*.*1#( diidend ield *.17$EE

"*.*1#( growth in assets *.26+EE "*.*1# and fir, si:e 1.29EE "*.*1# res"ectiel. here all ariales are

 "redicted significant in current stud with "rice olatilit.

/oreoer( in third ste" interaction ter,s are generated for the "ur"ose to test fir, si:e ,oderation. So

fir, si:e ,oderates diidend "aout ratio with 1.+7( earning olatilit is ,oderated with *.$7( diidend ield is,oderated with .11) and growth in assets is ,oderated with 17%. hus( oer all diidend "olic is ,oderated

fir, si:e as *.+)1. <ence( there is insignificant interaction of fir, si:e with e="lanator ariale facets.

3'  *(/+SI*(

he current stud found significant "ositie relationshi" etween diidend "olic facets i-e diidend "aouts(

growth in assets( earning olatilit( diidend ield and stoc; "rices olatilit. /oreoer( there is found a,oderation of fir, si:e etween diidend "olic facets and stoc; "rices. hus( the ,anagers hae to focus fir,

si:e ,ore i,"ortantl in their decisions and hae to e=ecute the "olicies in a wa that inest,ent of shareholders

,a oost that will rise cor"orate share "rices towards "re,iu, "rices that will gie ,ore returns to co,"anies

and diidend to shareholders.

).F)"(.SAsghar et al 2*1%#. I,"act of 5iidend !olic on Stoc; !rice Ris;H C,"irical Cidence fro, C4uit /ar;et of

!a;istan. %ar &ast 'ournal of (sychology ) *usiness+ ,ol 4 -o 1 .2/110 

 Nishat. /. and . /. Irfan. 0n"ulished#. 5iidend !olic and Stoc; "rice 'olatilit in !a;istan.

Roll( R. 19$) he turn of the ear effect and return "re,iu, of s,all fir,s( Journal of !ortfolio

/anage,ent.1*H1$-2$

S. I4al et al.( 2*1%#. a"ital Structure Antecedents. A ase of /anufacturing Sector of !a;istan.  nternational

 'ournal of 3!/o anagement eview+ ,ol /2+ ssue /2 .2/140

S. I4al et al.( 2*1+#. I,"act of i4uidit ris; on Fir, S"ecific Factors. A ase of Isla,ic 8an;s of

!a;istan . 'ournal of *usiness and anagement esearch+ ,ol+ / pp+ 2!52!/+

S. I4al( S. N. haudr @ 5. N. I4al.( 2*1+#. I,"act of Fir, S"ecific Factors on redit Ris;> A ase ofarachi Stoc; C=change. esearch 'ournal of %inance and 6ccounting+ ,ol+ 117 -o+ /! .2/10a,eer et al( 2*1)#. 5eter,inants of 5iidend !olicH A ase of 8an;ing Sector of !a;istan.  iddle &ast

 'ournal of 8cientific esearch7 1#./30: 41/5424