36
© Naval Projects 2014 3D Ships – RCS – Modeling 12 th Little Crow Conference – IMT, Simonstown

3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    7

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2014

3D Ships – RCS – Modeling 12th Little Crow Conference – IMT, Simonstown

Page 2: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

The Radar Signature

2

A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own Radar Signature is a crucial factor for the success of active /passive countermeasures in an ASMD scenario. 2) It is mandatory to minimise the signature of the own ship to increase the effectiveness of countermeasures.

Page 3: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

RCS analysis and optimisation

3

window effects

Optimisation through: Actions taken by design for a new to build ship The use of Radar Absorbing Material in an retrofit

Page 4: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

RCS Measurement

4

Page 5: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Determination and analysis of the Radar Signature

5

Page 6: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

RCS Hotspots

6

Page 7: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Methods to illustrate the RCS

7

Page 8: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Operational Course to Steer Recommendation with SoFiA

8

Page 9: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Simulation of a real tested ASMD-Situation

9

Page 10: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Characteristics of the RCS

10

Page 11: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Determination of the Radar Signature

11

Page 12: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Display of the ship´s RCS in a Signature Management task

12

Page 13: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Influence of the Ships Manoeuvre in the ASMD scenario

13

Page 14: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

The Display of SigMa_RCS

14

Page 15: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Simulation of a real tested ASMD-Situation

15

Page 16: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2014

Softkill Scenario

16

Page 17: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Status April 2014

17

SigMa_D1Threat

Data

RCS

Database

External

interface

Graphical Operator Interface

VHF Modem

Weather Data Ships Kinematik Data

Threat

Properies

RESM

Radar

CMS

Decoy

System

CADRCS

OSSMS

Environmental Data

Repository File

Database

System Border

GPS / INS

Page 18: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Status April 2014

18

SigMa_D1Threat

Data

RCS

Database

External

interface

Graphical Operator Interface

VHF Modem

Ships Kinematik Data

Threat

Properies

Decoy

System

CADRCS

Environmental Data

Repository File

Database

System Border

GPS / INS

Page 19: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Status April 2014

19

Page 20: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Recorder for ships kinematic Data

20

Page 21: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

First Tests 07/2014 aboard WTD71 Ship “KRONSORT”

21

GPS-Antenna

INS/GPS-Sensor

Page 22: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

First Results: “measured RCS vs. calculated RCS”

22

RCS Measurement System “MarSig” (WTD71)

SigMa_RCS (Realtime Simulation)

Frequency: 8 GHz / hh

Range: ~ 98oo meter

Time [s]

RC

S [d

B]

Page 23: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

First Results: “measured RCS vs. calculated RCS”

23

RCS Measurement System “MarSig” (WTD71)

SigMa_RCS (Realtime Simulation)

Frequency: 8 GHz / hh

Range: ~ 98oo meter

Time [s]

RC

S [d

B]

Page 24: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Influence of the CAD-Model Resolution

24

CAD-Model with twenty (20) thousand elements

Page 25: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Further Trials with high resolution CAD-Model

25

CAD-Model with two (2) million elements

Page 26: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Photogrammetric 3D-Shipmodeling (feasibility checkout)

26

Page 27: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

27

Page 28: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Engineering Office P. Huber & Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

From Point cloud to CAD-Model

28

Page 29: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Workflow – CAD Modelling

29

(with twenty (200) thousand elements)

Page 30: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Engineering Office P. Huber & Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Cloud Compare

30

Page 31: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Engineering Office P. Huber & Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

RCS Calculation – Results vs. Real Measurements

33

Page 32: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

IR Signature vs Aspect / Elevation Angle

P. 34

Page 33: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

360º

10º

-10º

Roll Angle

Aspect

Angle

CI

W/sr

+ Aspect

Angle

- Roll

Angle

3D Surface Plot Representation

35

Page 34: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

IR Signature vs Aspect/Roll Angle (-10 to 10º)

Most vulnerable aspect at -10º roll

Least vulnerable aspect at -10º roll

P. 36

Page 35: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

Anti Ship Missile Defence – Computer Aided Training

39

Page 36: 3D Ships RCS Modeling...Christoph Bormann © Naval Projects 2015 3D-Ships RCS Modelling The Radar Signature 2 A consideration from operational view: 1) The Knowledge about the own

© Naval Projects 2015 Christoph Bormann

3D-Ships RCS Modelling

40