1
addition to characterize the dominant microbiota in infancy, we looked forward to an understanding of the relationships between the intestinal microbiota and disease develop- ment. By enrolling twin pairs (n=14) in our study, we found a difference in bacterial families of intestinal microbiota composition (0-12 months) existed in dizygotic twins although they lived in the same environment. Among infants from twin (n=14) or singleton (n=7) pregnancy, the initial colonizer was restricted to bacteria from Proteobacteria (Escherichia/Shigella or Sphingopyxis) and Firmicutes (Bacillus or Staphylococcus). During the study period, 52.4% of these subjects developed allergic symptoms, mainly nasal and skin manifestations. Most importantly, we found a distinctive feature of gut microbiota pattern in allergic infants (n= 11) as compared with the healthy babies (n=10). The former harbored relative abundance of Firmicutes bacteria, particularly those from families Clostridiaceae and Lachnospiraceae of Firmicutes. Increasing Clostridiaceae in allergic subjects (72.7%) was observed from 1st to 6th month after birth, and thereafter declined gradually to an undetectable level at 12th month ; whereas the presence of Clostridiaceae in healthy babies was maintained in low frequency from 1st to 12th months (p<0.01). On the other hand, rapid growth of Lachnospira- ceae bacteria in allergic infants (63.6%) started from 6th month to 12th month, while this pattern was rarely found in healthy control subjects (10%; p<0.01). In addition, reduced colonization of Bifidobacteriaceae was found apparently in allergic subjects, as compared with that of controls (p<0.05). In conclusion, our observation confirmed the link between gut micorbiota patterns and the risk of allergy development. This link may provide some hints for future therapeutic strategies. (Grant Taiwan NSC102-2628-B-002 -027 -MY3 ) 45 Decreased Diversity of the Fecal Microbiome in Pediatric Carriage of Clostridium difficile Suchitra Hourigan, Zoya Grigoryan, SuBin Kim, Sankar Chirumamilla, Shervin Rabizadeh, Jonathan Golub, Shehzad A. Saeed, Charles O. Elson, Maria Oliva-Hemker, Cynthia L. Sears, Martin Blaser, Lea Ann Chen Background: Certain populations have increased rates of asymptomatic carriage of Clostridium difficile (C. difficile), such as patients with inflammatory bowel disease and young children. There is decreased diversity and compositional changes of the fecal microbiome in patients with recurrent C. difficile disease. However the diversity of the fecal microbiome in those with asymptomatic carriage has not previously been investigated. Methods: Stool samples were tested from a previously collected fecal bank from pediatric gastroenterology patients (mean age 12.5 ± 4.3 yrs, range 4-21yrs) at two large academic medical centers. Many of these patients were being evaluated or treated for IBD, a risk factor for C. difficile; no patient had exposure to concurrent antibiotics. Toxigenic C. difficile testing was performed on stool samples by selective anaerobic culture and cytotoxic assay. All C. difficile testing was performed for non-clinical indications. The v4 hypervariable region of the 16S rRNA gene was sequenced using the Illumina MiSeq platform. 2x250 bp paired end reads were generated. De-multi- plexed sequences were filtered for quality and clustered into operational taxonomical units (OTUs) using QIIME 1.7.0 software and the May 2013 Greengenes 16S reference. Alpha rarefaction and taxa plots were generated using QIIME software. Results: At all sequencing depths, patients without C. difficile carriage had significantly increased bacterial diversity compared to C. difficile positive patients. This relationship is consistent for rarefaction curves using both observed species and Chao1 metrics for estimating alpha diversity. Taxa plots demonstrate an increase in the relative abundance of the phylum Proteobacteria in C. difficile negative patients (6.1% vs. 0.3%), which consists largely of bacteria from the Enterobacteriales order. Interestingly, the C. difficile positive patients carry relatively fewer bacteria from the Clostridiales order. Genus level data further reflect the decreased bacterial diversity seen in C. difficile positive patients. Clostridium spp and similarly related organisms contributed a minute fraction of the overall bacterial composition of both C. difficile positive and negative patients. Conclusions: Pediatric patients with C. difficile carriage have decreased bacterial diversity compared to C. difficile negative patients. These data suggest that C. difficile coloniza- tion is sufficient to reduce microbiota diversity and that reduced diversity is not necessarily a hallmark of disease. Although the microbiota of C. difficile positive and negative patients are largely similar on higher taxonomic (phylum) levels, genus level data are more reflective of the microbiome differences between these two groups. S-13 AGA Abstracts Taxa plot based on Clostridium difficile status 46 Murine Weanling Undernutrition Reveals Sexual Dimorphisms in Weight Faltering, Small Intestinal Transcriptome, and Dysbiosis Sean R. Moore, Elizabeth A. Maier, Geoffrey A. Preidis, Toni-Ann Mistretta, Emily B. Hollister, Tor Savidge, Michael A. Helmrath, Ernest Fischer, Yael Haberman, Lee Denson Background: Early weaning of infants in low- and middle-income countries to multideficient diets leads to profound deficits in children's growth and neurodevelopment. For reasons poorly understood, male children under 5 years of age are more likely than females to become underweight and stunted in these settings. We sought to mimic this sexual dimorphism in mice and test the hypothesis that gender influences gut transcriptome and microbiome responses to undernutrition. Methods: C57BL/6 dams with 10-day-old pups were random- ized to ad lib access to a standard purified control diet (CD; 65% carbohydrate, 20% protein, 15% fat) or an isocaloric, multideficient regional basic diet (RBD; 88% carbohydrate, 7% protein, 5% fat) we have previously shown produces features of environmental enteropathy in mice (Ueno AJP 2011). On day of life 21, suckling pups were weaned to their dams' diet and segregated by sex. Upon sacrifice at 6 weeks of age, we harvested jejunal segments for RNA-seq analysis and stool for 16s rRNA analysis. Results: Suckling male and female RBD mice exhibited significant failure to thrive (P<.0001). At weaning, we detected no sex- specific differences in weight; however, by 6 weeks of age we observed that RBD females achieved weight parity with CD females, while RBD males remained 25% underweight relative to CD males (P<.0001). Interestingly, RBD males remained underweight at 12 weeks of age, even when weaned to CD. RNA-seq analysis of jejunal segments (n=3 mice per group) revealed 7 transcripts with 2-fold differential expression between male vs. female CD mice, 97 transcripts between RBD vs. CD males, and a remarkable 3667 transcripts between RBD vs. CD females. Microbiome analysis of stool revealed a more profound (ANOVA Q<.05 for 18 vs. 14 of 96 genera) and homogenous (principle component analysis) shift in microbial communities in female vs. male RBD mice, respectively. Several notable genera were significantly altered in stool from 6-week RBD mice compared to controls. Alistipes and E. coli/Shigella were increased in males. Alistipes was also increased in females, although E. coli/Shigella was notably not detected. Akkermansia, Clostridium XlV, Barnesiella, and Sporobacter were reduced in females, whereas Parasutterella and Allobaculum were more abundant. Conclusions: Male mice exhibit more severe growth faltering than females in response to early undernutrition, thus mimicking growth patterns seen among children in low-resource settings. Further studies are needed to determine whether a more robust transcriptional-microbiome program in the female gut enhances energy harvest in the setting of undernutrition. Such studies, in turn, may provide novel strategies to reduce an unaccepta- bly high burden of childhood undernutrition in the developing world. 47 Fecal Metabolomics Distinguishes Responders From Non-Responders to a Dietary Intervention in Children With Irritable Bowel Syndrome Bruno P. Chumpitazi, Emily B. Hollister, James Versalovic, Tor Savidge, Robert J. Shulman Background: In a small pilot study we previously demonstrated that children with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) had a decrease in GI symptom severity (e.g. abdominal pain frequency) when placed on a low fermentable substrate diet (LFSD). We also demonstrated that Respond- ers (decrease in abdominal pain frequency 50%) had a different microbiome composition as compared to Non-Responders. The current study sought to determine whether fecal metabolites also could distinguish Responders from Non-Responders to the LFSD. Methods: Children (n=8) with pediatric Rome III defined IBS completed a 7-d baseline habitual diet period followed by a 7-d LFSD. Stool samples from the baseline and LFSD intervention period had previously been analyzed for each subject for microbiome composition using 16S rRNA pyrosequencing with determination of operational taxonomic units (OTUs). In the current study the same stool samples were used for fecal metabolite characterization. Stool samples were divided into 3 fractions: 1 for analysis by ultra-performance liquid chromatography tandem mass spectroscopy (UPLC/MS/MS2; positive mode), 1 for UPLC/ MS/MS2 (negative mode), and 1 for gas chromatography mass spectroscopy (GC/MS). Raw data were extracted, peak-identified, and processed using proprietary hardware and software. Differences in stool metabolites between Responders and Non-responders at baseline and during the LFSD were evaluated using repeated measures ANOVA. Potential relationships between OTUs identified in our previous study and metabolites identified in this study were evaluated using an all vs. all Spearman correlation of OTUs and metabolites, followed by Benjamin-Hochberg corrections for multiple comparisons in R. Subject -OTU-metabolite relationships were visualized using a hive plot approach. Results: At baseline, 22 fecal metabolites differed between Responders and Non-Responders at the P<0.05 level. During the LFSD, 39 fecal metabolites, including Isovalerate, citrulline, D-urobilin, and cholate AGA Abstracts

45 Decreased Diversity of the Fecal Microbiome in Pediatric Carriage of Clostridium difficile

  • Upload
    lea-ann

  • View
    212

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 45 Decreased Diversity of the Fecal Microbiome in Pediatric Carriage of Clostridium difficile

addition to characterize the dominant microbiota in infancy, we looked forward to anunderstanding of the relationships between the intestinal microbiota and disease develop-ment. By enrolling twin pairs (n=14) in our study, we found a difference in bacterial familiesof intestinal microbiota composition (0-12 months) existed in dizygotic twins although theylived in the same environment. Among infants from twin (n=14) or singleton (n=7) pregnancy,the initial colonizer was restricted to bacteria from Proteobacteria (Escherichia/Shigella orSphingopyxis) and Firmicutes (Bacillus or Staphylococcus). During the study period, 52.4%of these subjects developed allergic symptoms, mainly nasal and skin manifestations. Mostimportantly, we found a distinctive feature of gut microbiota pattern in allergic infants (n=11) as compared with the healthy babies (n=10). The former harbored relative abundanceof Firmicutes bacteria, particularly those from families Clostridiaceae and Lachnospiraceaeof Firmicutes. Increasing Clostridiaceae in allergic subjects (72.7%) was observed from 1stto 6th month after birth, and thereafter declined gradually to an undetectable level at 12thmonth ; whereas the presence of Clostridiaceae in healthy babies was maintained in lowfrequency from 1st to 12th months (p<0.01). On the other hand, rapid growth of Lachnospira-ceae bacteria in allergic infants (63.6%) started from 6th month to 12th month, while thispattern was rarely found in healthy control subjects (10%; p<0.01). In addition, reducedcolonization of Bifidobacteriaceae was found apparently in allergic subjects, as comparedwith that of controls (p<0.05). In conclusion, our observation confirmed the link betweengut micorbiota patterns and the risk of allergy development. This link may provide somehints for future therapeutic strategies. (Grant Taiwan NSC102-2628-B-002 -027 -MY3 )

45

Decreased Diversity of the Fecal Microbiome in Pediatric Carriage ofClostridium difficileSuchitra Hourigan, Zoya Grigoryan, SuBin Kim, Sankar Chirumamilla, ShervinRabizadeh, Jonathan Golub, Shehzad A. Saeed, Charles O. Elson, Maria Oliva-Hemker,Cynthia L. Sears, Martin Blaser, Lea Ann Chen

Background: Certain populations have increased rates of asymptomatic carriage of Clostridiumdifficile (C. difficile), such as patients with inflammatory bowel disease and young children.There is decreased diversity and compositional changes of the fecal microbiome in patientswith recurrent C. difficile disease. However the diversity of the fecal microbiome in thosewith asymptomatic carriage has not previously been investigated. Methods: Stool sampleswere tested from a previously collected fecal bank from pediatric gastroenterology patients(mean age 12.5 ± 4.3 yrs, range 4-21yrs) at two large academic medical centers. Many ofthese patients were being evaluated or treated for IBD, a risk factor for C. difficile; no patienthad exposure to concurrent antibiotics. Toxigenic C. difficile testing was performed on stoolsamples by selective anaerobic culture and cytotoxic assay. All C. difficile testing was performedfor non-clinical indications. The v4 hypervariable region of the 16S rRNA gene was sequencedusing the Illumina MiSeq platform. 2x250 bp paired end reads were generated. De-multi-plexed sequences were filtered for quality and clustered into operational taxonomical units(OTUs) using QIIME 1.7.0 software and the May 2013 Greengenes 16S reference. Alphararefaction and taxa plots were generated using QIIME software. Results: At all sequencingdepths, patients without C. difficile carriage had significantly increased bacterial diversitycompared to C. difficile positive patients. This relationship is consistent for rarefaction curvesusing both observed species and Chao1 metrics for estimating alpha diversity. Taxa plotsdemonstrate an increase in the relative abundance of the phylum Proteobacteria in C. difficilenegative patients (6.1% vs. 0.3%), which consists largely of bacteria from the Enterobacterialesorder. Interestingly, the C. difficile positive patients carry relatively fewer bacteria from theClostridiales order. Genus level data further reflect the decreased bacterial diversity seen inC. difficile positive patients. Clostridium spp and similarly related organisms contributed aminute fraction of the overall bacterial composition of both C. difficile positive and negativepatients. Conclusions: Pediatric patients with C. difficile carriage have decreased bacterialdiversity compared to C. difficile negative patients. These data suggest that C. difficile coloniza-tion is sufficient to reduce microbiota diversity and that reduced diversity is not necessarilya hallmark of disease. Although the microbiota of C. difficile positive and negative patientsare largely similar on higher taxonomic (phylum) levels, genus level data are more reflectiveof the microbiome differences between these two groups.

S-13 AGA Abstracts

Taxa plot based on Clostridium difficile status

46

Murine Weanling Undernutrition Reveals Sexual Dimorphisms in WeightFaltering, Small Intestinal Transcriptome, and DysbiosisSean R. Moore, Elizabeth A. Maier, Geoffrey A. Preidis, Toni-Ann Mistretta, Emily B.Hollister, Tor Savidge, Michael A. Helmrath, Ernest Fischer, Yael Haberman, Lee Denson

Background: Early weaning of infants in low- and middle-income countries to multideficientdiets leads to profound deficits in children's growth and neurodevelopment. For reasonspoorly understood, male children under 5 years of age are more likely than females to becomeunderweight and stunted in these settings. We sought to mimic this sexual dimorphism inmice and test the hypothesis that gender influences gut transcriptome and microbiomeresponses to undernutrition. Methods: C57BL/6 dams with 10-day-old pups were random-ized to ad lib access to a standard purified control diet (CD; 65% carbohydrate, 20% protein,15% fat) or an isocaloric, multideficient regional basic diet (RBD; 88% carbohydrate, 7%protein, 5% fat) we have previously shown produces features of environmental enteropathyin mice (Ueno AJP 2011). On day of life 21, suckling pups were weaned to their dams' dietand segregated by sex. Upon sacrifice at 6 weeks of age, we harvested jejunal segments forRNA-seq analysis and stool for 16s rRNA analysis. Results: Suckling male and female RBDmice exhibited significant failure to thrive (P<.0001). At weaning, we detected no sex-specific differences in weight; however, by 6 weeks of age we observed that RBD femalesachieved weight parity with CD females, while RBD males remained 25% underweightrelative to CD males (P<.0001). Interestingly, RBD males remained underweight at 12 weeksof age, even when weaned to CD. RNA-seq analysis of jejunal segments (n=3 mice pergroup) revealed 7 transcripts with ≥2-fold differential expression between male vs. femaleCD mice, 97 transcripts between RBD vs. CD males, and a remarkable 3667 transcriptsbetween RBD vs. CD females. Microbiome analysis of stool revealed a more profound(ANOVA Q<.05 for 18 vs. 14 of 96 genera) and homogenous (principle component analysis)shift in microbial communities in female vs. male RBD mice, respectively. Several notablegenera were significantly altered in stool from 6-week RBD mice compared to controls.Alistipes and E. coli/Shigella were increased in males. Alistipes was also increased in females,although E. coli/Shigella was notably not detected. Akkermansia, Clostridium XlV, Barnesiella,and Sporobacter were reduced in females, whereas Parasutterella and Allobaculum were moreabundant. Conclusions: Male mice exhibit more severe growth faltering than females inresponse to early undernutrition, thus mimicking growth patterns seen among children inlow-resource settings. Further studies are needed to determine whether a more robusttranscriptional-microbiome program in the female gut enhances energy harvest in the settingof undernutrition. Such studies, in turn, may provide novel strategies to reduce an unaccepta-bly high burden of childhood undernutrition in the developing world.

47

Fecal Metabolomics Distinguishes Responders From Non-Responders to aDietary Intervention in Children With Irritable Bowel SyndromeBruno P. Chumpitazi, Emily B. Hollister, James Versalovic, Tor Savidge, Robert J. Shulman

Background: In a small pilot study we previously demonstrated that children with irritablebowel syndrome (IBS) had a decrease in GI symptom severity (e.g. abdominal pain frequency)when placed on a low fermentable substrate diet (LFSD). We also demonstrated that Respond-ers (decrease in abdominal pain frequency ≥50%) had a different microbiome compositionas compared to Non-Responders. The current study sought to determine whether fecalmetabolites also could distinguish Responders from Non-Responders to the LFSD. Methods:Children (n=8) with pediatric Rome III defined IBS completed a 7-d baseline habitual dietperiod followed by a 7-d LFSD. Stool samples from the baseline and LFSD interventionperiod had previously been analyzed for each subject for microbiome composition using16S rRNA pyrosequencing with determination of operational taxonomic units (OTUs). Inthe current study the same stool samples were used for fecal metabolite characterization.Stool samples were divided into 3 fractions: 1 for analysis by ultra-performance liquidchromatography tandem mass spectroscopy (UPLC/MS/MS2; positive mode), 1 for UPLC/MS/MS2 (negative mode), and 1 for gas chromatography mass spectroscopy (GC/MS). Rawdata were extracted, peak-identified, and processed using proprietary hardware and software.Differences in stool metabolites between Responders and Non-responders at baseline andduring the LFSD were evaluated using repeated measures ANOVA. Potential relationshipsbetween OTUs identified in our previous study and metabolites identified in this study wereevaluated using an all vs. all Spearman correlation of OTUs and metabolites, followed byBenjamin-Hochberg corrections for multiple comparisons in R. Subject -OTU-metaboliterelationships were visualized using a hive plot approach. Results: At baseline, 22 fecalmetabolites differed between Responders and Non-Responders at the P<0.05 level. Duringthe LFSD, 39 fecal metabolites, including Isovalerate, citrulline, D-urobilin, and cholate

AG

AA

bst

ract

s