22

9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

� ��� � ����� �� �����

��������������� ��!�"#!$&%(' �*),+.-0/1�2)43�5&5&6�7

8 �.-.9:��� 8 �.;<)�9=)�+�)>/?��@ ��A�9B/1�.A�/�!C /DAE/1�GFH/1�JI�7H3�5&5&6

K

Page 2: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

�������������

� ���������������������� K"! K #%$"&�')(�*+*-,/.+0�1)23'4&65�7�891)&�*:*;(<'>=�$"5"*+231).+5"? !6!@!A!@!A!A!@!A!@!A!A!A!A!A! B

C D@E�FHGIFJ�LKM�ONP����QRESNPTUF VWJ! K 8JX3&U*:*ZY/2/'4?3.:?/[ !A!6!@!A!A!@!A!@!A!A!@!A!6!@!A!@!A!A!@!A!@!A!A!A!A!A! \WJ!]W ^_5"'`&@^_5"?a1)')(<0�1).+5"?b(�?/cd=�?e$�&U*+5",�&6&gf3,/(�?/h4.+5"? !A!A!@!A!@!A!A!A!A!A! iWJ!kj lm(<h4honqp�2/rs.+?/5"h`.+1qt�'`&U*:(<1).+5"?I7O5"'u(vh`1)(�'>.:?M'4&�cJnq[�.;(�?a1u,/XP(<h4&w!A!A!A!A! KyxWJ!zB {u&Ucd|.;(�?a1u,/XP(<h4& !@!A!A!@!A!@!A!A!@!A!6!@!A!@!A!A!@!A!@!A!A!A!A!A! Kyj

} ~@����F�E�F9������� �O���������O��� �a j3! K ��&U*:.+2/r���*;(�h`X !A!6!@!A!A!@!A!@!A!A!@!A!6!@!A!@!A!A!@!A!@!A!A!A!A!A! K��

�bFJ������� ���S�<��������������E�F��"����F �3�

� �wT��������y�����������ONP��������NP����E��@�d�P�������O����T �9�

W

Page 3: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

����������� ������������ ���������! "�$#�%��&�'% ()��*&�'�����!� �+���,��*&�+������-�-��! $��. %�-�/����0%��1���2�3����4�/��������

�5�6�&����� ��-87:9;� �<�=#?>�/�@A���&%����0�CBD <��-��!���0%��6(E% F�G-0%�HI@J� ���F�����! F���6��*&�K �������5� �L�+M3*�� ���N�5�'�&�� <�0. ���27POQ�� ��QH+�R��*&%�HS��*��!�+-5/�@J���&%��<�0�?BT�&��MU�������P%���-0BV%����*��V4W% <�V@A� ����� ���X <� ����/3�Q� ���Y���,���3�&��MU�����&�����N% (Z��*��V������-�-��! �@J� ���,� ��� "� ����/���7�['. %�-�/����0%��J% ($��*&�,�����! �\E]U% ��*A-0%^H_� ���F*��0��*F@J� ���"`a(b �%�@c ����J���5� �L������!� �A/&M���%d��*&�J� ��Be@fM3��% ����4f����� ����]� <� ��4"*g����� -���%K������4�/��<�����$7Vh�*&�f��*& �����5@fMU% ���� �L��4"*��! <� 4W���� <�5������4���% (a� ��B)@fM���% ���54������ ����]� <� ��4"*;�����! "���! ��i]3 <�0��j�B������4W <�0]U���$7

j

Page 4: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

� � �������������>��U���

8e1 (�'`h (�'4&>h`&U*+7�["'4(�$9. 1 (<14.:?/[ Y�59c/.:&�h� �uX/.+0 X�.+'4'`&�$"&�'4h`.:Y/* t &Ur�.+1�')(�c/.:(<1).+5"?R.+?a1)56h4,P(<0U&�!� X3&b&�?/&U'`[�t 7O5"' 14X/.:hR')(�c/.:(<1).+5"? .+h h42/,/,3*:.:&�c .:? (�h`1)(�'��u.+14X/5"231 ?e2/0�*:&U(�'v&U?/&�'4[�th`5"2/'`0U&Uh%Yetb1)X3&Rh`145"'4&R5�7�["'4(�$9. 1 (<14.:5"?P(<*�&U?/&�'4[�td5�7�14X/&Rho1 (�'���Yat��%.:'`.;(�*-14X/&U5"'`&Ur�� !� X3& *:5"h`h%5�7 ["'4(y$J. 1 (<14.:5"?/(�*S&U?/&�'4[�tm'4&Uh`2/*+14h .:?H(�h4*:5�� h`X/'4.+?���(�["& 5�7�14X/& h`1)(�'%5�? (14.:r�&h40U(�*:&65�7�1)X/&A5"'4c3&U'u5�7�14X/&��6&�*+$9.:?9n � &�*:r�X/5"* 1�� 14.:r�&����� "!$#&%(')+* ��uX/&U'`&-,./ �(�?3c10 (�'`& 1)X/&vrs(�h4h2�'4(�c/.:23h6(�?/c *:2/r�.:?/5�h4.+1qtd5�7 1)X/&vh`1)(�'6'4&�h4,�&U0�14.+$�&U*+t3�(�?3c4 .:hR14X/&w["'4(�$9. 1 (<14.:5"?P(<*�0�5"?/ho1 (�?a1y!65q?�1)X/&�0U(�h4&M5�7 (Hho1 (�'7�u. 1)X�?e2/0�*:&y(<' &U?/&�'4[�th`5"2/'`0U&Uh 14X/.:h *:5"h`h 5�7 &�?/&U'`[�tH.+h%h423,/,/*:.+&UcHYatd1)X/& ?e2/0�*:&U(�' h45�2/'40�&Uh�8�uX3.:0 XH7O2/'`?/.:h`X14X/&�'`&�9e2/.:'`&Uc &�?/&U'`[�t Yat 0U5"?a$�&U'`14.:?/[ (dh4rs(�*:*�7O')(<0�1).+5"?�5<7>1)X/&sh`1)&�*:*:(�'@rs(�h`h .:?a1)5&�?/&U'`[�tv(�?3c�h`*:5��u*+tR0 XP(�?/[�.:?/[ 14X/&u0 X/&Ur�.:0U(�*30�5"rs,�5"h`.+1).+5"? .+?:��(<1 *+&y(�ho1;��14X/&u&U?/&�'4[�t,3'459c/2/0U.+?/[v'4&�[".:5"?3h�5<7�1)X3&Aho1 (�'�! � X3.:hu0 XP(�?/[�&@.+?b.+?a1)&U'`?P(�*�0 X/&�rs.+0y(�*�0�5"r�,�5"h`.+14.:5"?590U0�2/'4hR5"?<��?/5�'4rs(�*:* t�� r 230 X�*;(�'`["&U'A?e2/0U*+&y(�'R14.:r�&sh`0y(�*+&��>=�?A@��[�.+$"&�?�Yat B�>=�?A@�!C % @ '* D�uX3&U'4&7E .+h 1)X/&7O'4(�0�14.:5"?M5�7�&U?/&�'4[�tI1)XP(<1�["59&Uh>.+?a1)5v?e2/0U*+&y(�'uY/2/'`?/.:?3[/!

891)(�'4h8�u. 1)X65"?/[�5".:?/[_?9230U*:&U(�'�'4&U(�0�14.:5"?3h-.:? 14X/&�0U5"'`&3�XP(y$"& 0 XP(�'4(�0�14&U'`.:h`14.:0�rs(�h`h4&Uh.+?w1)X/&6')(<?/["&Ax3! KF,1G�1)5s\"xH,1G (�?/cb0U&�?e14')(�*-14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&�h�14XP(<1�(�'`&6X/.:["X3&U'>1)XP(<?Kyx I�� !DJ &U0y(<2/h4&?e2/0�*:&y(<'_'4&U(�0�14.:5"?3h_0y(<?I7O2/&U*Z(�?�5"YLK`&U0�1_7O5"'_5"?3*+t�(�MP?3.+1)& ,�&�'4.+5Jcs5�714.:r�&3<5�7P1)X/&_5"'4c/&�'�5�7&�>=2?2@Na.+1�.:h�0�*:&U(�'�14XP(<1 (�?at@,P(�'o1).:0�2/*;(<'�ho1 (�'�rR2/h`1�XP(y$"& 7O5"'`rs&�c(�1%h`5"rs&OMP?/. 1)&61).+rs&6.:?b1)X/&@,P(�ho1y! 8J.:r�.:*:(�'4* t 91)X/&@?9230U*:&U(�'�'4&y(<0�1).+5"?/hP�u.:*:*�Y�&@(�Y/*:&145 ,/'45�$9.:c3&6( h`1)&U(�c3twho1 (<14& 7O5"'_14X/&h`1)(�'_7O5"' 5�?/*+t�(7MP?/.+14& ,�&U'4.+5Jcw.+?a1)5R14X/& 7O231)23'4&�!� Xe2/h>14X/& h`14'42/0 1)2/'`&65�7�1)X/&ho1 (�'_r 2/h`1 &�$"5�*+$"&65�$"&�' 1).+rs& h40y(<*:&Uh_0U5"r�,P(�'4(�Y/*:&P�u.+14X14X/& ?e2/0U*+&y(�'%'4&y(<0�1).+5"?m14.:r�&Rh40U(�*:&<! � X3& rI(�.+?Jnqh`&�9e2/&�?/0U&Q-'4&�c [�.;(�?a1R�h42/,�&U' nq[".:(�?a1R& 1)0<!S�(�'`&1)X/&$<(�'4.+5"2/h>ho1 (�["&�hu.:?w1)X/&6& $"5"*+231).+5"?M5�7�14X/&6h`1)(�'U!

TVU�T W"XZY\[&]_^�^a`(bdcfe&g�[&YihVjlkme�Y\^�^�]�[on�XZhZ^pgqe�b�hZr� X3&%$"&�'`ts&y(�'`*:.:&�h`1�h`1)(�["&�h .:?�1)X/& h`1 (<'�7O5"'`rI(�1).:5�?s,/'`5J0�&Uh`h 0U5"?3h4.:ho1)h 5�7-1)X3&%0U5�?/c/&U?9nh4(<1).+5"?�5<7u(d,/'`5�1)5�h`1 (<'@7O'45�r 1)X/&s.:?a1)&�'4h`14&U*+*;(�'6r�&Uc/.+2/rd!b# ?/0�&�h4230 X (d,/'`5�1)5"ho1 (�'X/(�h�7O5"'4r�&Uc8a14X/&uh42/Y/h`&�9e2/&�?e1u& $"5"*+231).+5"?v.:?a1)5A(6h4&�*+7;nq*+2/r�.:?/5"23h�h`1)(�'q��. !z&�!sa1)X/&uY/.+'`14X5<7�1)X3&Aho1 (�'��AP590U0�2/'4h�5"?d(v$�&U'`tbh`X/5"'`1u14.:r�&h40y(<*:&UhuYatw1)X3&@c3t9?P(<rs.+0y(�*-0�5"*:*:(�,/h`&5�714X/&I,3'45�145"h`1)(�'U!:tLX/&U?�14X/&�0�&U?a1)'4(�* 14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&�5�7>1)X3&Ih`1)(�'RX/(�h Y�&U0U5�rs&sX/.:["X&�?/5"2/[�Xb7O5"'>Xat9c/'`5"["&U?dY/2/'`?/.:?/[v.+?�1)X/&60U&�?a1)&U'u1)5�0U5�rsr�&U?/0�&33$9.:(v&�.+14X/&U' 14X/&6,/'45<n145"? 0 XP(�.+?:�O7O5"'�1)X/&>h`rI(�*+*:&�'�rs(�h4h`&Uhu��5�'�1)X/&>0U(�'4Y�5"? 0 tJ0�*:&v��7O5"'�1)X3&>*;(�'`["&U'�rI(�h`h4&�hu�A14X/& rs(�.:?9nqh4&29e2/&U?/0�& ,/XP(<h4&w�OYetIc/&2M/?/.+14.:5"?x��XP(�h_Y�&�&U?w'4&U(�0 X/&�c-! � X3& h`1)(�' '4&�rI(<.:?/h.+?b14X/&6$J.+0U.+?/.+1qtI5�7�14X/&@rs(�.+?Jnqh`&�9e2/&U?30U&67O5"'�(l��'`&U*:(<1). $"&U* t�*+5"?/[L� 14.:r�&A5<7�1)X3&@5"'`c/&U'

B

Page 5: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

5<7 �>=�?A@��c/')(R�u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/&�'4[�t 7O'45�r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U(�'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5�7 14X/&I*:(�'4["&vh`2/,/,/* t 5�7Xat9c/'`5"["&U? � ����� ���� �_.:?w14X/&6.:?a1)&�'4.:5�'U!

tLX/&�? (�h`.:["?/.sMP0y(<?e1I7O')(�0 1).:5�? 5�7A1)X/& ��� .+? 1)X/&�ho1)&U*+*;(�'s.:?a1)&�'4.+5"'�XP(�hwY�&U&�?0�5"?/h`2/rs&�c8a1)X/&uho1 (�' r�5�$�&Uh (R� (yt 7O'45�r 1)X3&�rs(�.+?Jnqh`&�9e2/&U?30U&�! � X/& .+?/X/5"r�5"["&�?/&U. 1qt.+?�14X/&b.:?a1)&�'4?P(�*>0 X3&Ur�.:0y(<*>0U5"r�,�5�h4.+14.:5"? '`&Uh423*+1).+?/[�7O'45"r 14X/&bXet9c/'`5"["&�? Y/2/'`?/.:?3[0U(�2/h`&Uhu1)X/&6h`1)(�'>1)5�Y/'4.+["Xa1)&�?d(<?/cd&gfJ,P(�?/c8&�uX/.+*:& 14X/&60U5"'`&Ah`X/'4.+?��eh��(�?/cM1)X3&Aho1 (�'r�5�$"&�hb& $"&�?e142P(�*+*+t 145F�_(�'`c 14X/& '4&Uc [".:(�?a1M'4&U[�.:5"?/hw5<7@14X/& � &�'`1���h4,/'`2/?/[<nq{�23h4h4&�*c3.;(�["'4(�rb!BJ tI'4&UcM[".:(�?a1 '`&U[".+5"?/h � &rs&U(�?wX/&�'4& 1)X3&["&U?/&�')(�*Z'4&U[�.:5"?/h_*+t9.:?/[ (�Y�5�$�&(<?/cb145 1)X/&6'4.+["Xa1u5�7�1)X/&6rs(�.:?Jn h4&29923&U?/0�&�!

� X/& &�?/&U'`[�tHh`5"2/'`0U&Uh65�7�14X/& ho1 (�' �uX3.:*:&@.:?H14X/& '4&�c�[".;(<?e1%'4&�[".:5"?3h c/&U,�&U?3c 5�?14X/&�h`1)&�*:*:(�'rI(<h4hA(�?/c 5"? 14X/&�h`1 (<["&v5�7 & $"5"*+231).+5"?�(<?/c�(<'4&v5"?/&�5"'6h45"r�&v0U5"rRY/. n?/(<1).+5"?�5�7u1)X/&�7O5�*:*:5��u.+?/[��["')(y$9.+1)(<1).+5"?P(�*�h45"23'40U& � Xat9c/'45"[�&U?�Y/2/'4?3.:?/[ .:? (Hh`X/&U*+*��X3&U*:.+2/r Y/2/'`?/.:?/[��_0y(<'4Y�5"?�Y/2/'`?/.:?/[�� 5yf9t9["&U? Y/2/'`?/.:?3[��_(<?/c ,�5"h`h4.+Y/*+t Y/2/'`?/.:?3[�5�7ho1).+*:*�X/&U(�$9.+&U'R?e2/0�*:&�. ! � X/&Uh`&I$<(�'4.+5"2/hA?e2/0U*+&y(�'@h45"2/'`0U&�h7�u.:*+*�?/5"'4rs(�*+*+tHY�&I.+["?/. 1)&Uch`&�9e2/&�?e14.;(�*+*+t�.:?�(R[".+$�&U?who1 (�' .:?I14X/& 5"'`c/&U' [".+$�&U?83(�h_1)X3& &�$�5"*:2314.:5"?s,/'4590U&�&Uc/hv��(�honh`2/r�.:?/[61)XP(�1 14X/& ho1 (�' 0y(�?I(<141)(�.:?v1)X3& ?/&�0U&�h4h)(<'`t�.+["?/. 1).:5�? 1)&Ur�,�&U')(�1)2/'`&Uhu�g!�� ho1 (�'rs(ytw(<1�h`5"rs&ho1 (�[�&A.+?M.+1)hu& $"5"*+231).+5"?wXP(y$"&@rs5"'`& 1)XP(<?b5�?/&6&U?/&�'4[�tMh`5"2/'40�&�!��%*+h45�Y�&U0U(�2/h`& h`1 (<'4h%X/(�$9.+?/[�rs(�h4h`&Uh*:&�h4h�1)XP(�?H14X/& ^_X/(�?/c/'4(�h4&2�9X/(�'rI(<h4hO,6@�� 0U(�?/?/5�1(�141 (<.:? (�'`Y/.+14')(�'`.:*+t X/.+["X .:?a1)&�'4?P(<* 1)&Ur�,�&U')(�1)2/'`&Uh��5"?/* t�'4&�*;(<14.+$�&U*+t rs(�h4h`.+$"&Mho1 (�'`h0U(�? (<1`1 (�.+?m'4&U(�*:* td(�c3$<(�?/0�&Uc�h`1)(�["&�h5�7 ?e2/0U*+&y(�' & $"5"*+231).+5"?-! � X3&Uh4& *:(<1)&@h`1)(�["&Uh%5�7& $"5"*+231).+5"?H.+?H1)X/& '`&Uc [".:(�?a1 '4&�[".:5�?/h 590U0U23,etH5"?/*+td(I7�(�.+'4* tdh`rI(<*:*S7O')(�0 1).:5�?H5�7�1)X3&145�1 (<*-*:. 7O& n 14.:r�& 5<7�( h`1)(�'U!

5q?�["&U?3&U')(<*/7O5"'�h`1)(�'4h��u. 1)X , � ,6@��H"1)X/&mMP?P(<*Ph`1 (<["&Uh�(�'`&>'4&U,3'4&Uh`&U?a1)&�c�Yat 1)X3&0�5J5�*:.:?3[O�uX3.+1)& cD�_(�'`7Sho1 (�'`hU!�5q?I14X/&%0U(�h4& 5<7�h`1)(�'4hV�u.+1)X , �o, @��H90U5�?e14')(�0 1).+5"?s145c3&U?/h`.+1).+&Uh r 2/0 X�*;(<'4["&�'�14XP(�?m14X/5"h4&@7O5"2/?/cH.+? �uX/. 1)&Rc � (�'o7�.:h�,�5"h`h4.+Y/*:&<!�� 1%14X/&Uh`&*:(�'4[�&c/&U?/h`.+14.:&Uhu?/&�231)'`5"?/.S�y(<14.:5"?w590U0�2/'4h�5"?d(v*:(�'4[�&h40y(<*:&3�(<?/cb14X/.:hu,/'`5J0�&Uh`h *+&y(�c/h145mc3t9?P(<rs.+0y(�*�0U5"*+*;(�,3h4&v1)5d14X/&I?3&U2314'45"?�ho1 (�'@h`1 (�1)&3�.:?6�uX3.:0 X 1)X3&I?e2/0U*+&U5"?3h (�'4&c3&U["&�?/&U'4(<1)&�(�?/cv&��Z&�0�1)h 5�7�["&�?/&U'4(�*/'4&�*;(<14.+$9.+1qt@r 2/ho1 Y�& 1)(3��&�?s.+?a1)56(�0�0U5"2/?a1U! ld5"'`&rs(�h`h4.+$�&6h`1 (<'4hu0U5"*+*;(�,3h4&Uh 145vY/*;(�0u�IX/5"*:&�hU!

Page 6: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

H, He envelope

H burning shellHe core

R

0.12 R

0.06 R

��.:["2/'`& K %��.:["23'4&Rh`X/5��uhA14X/& .:?a14&U'4?/(�*�ho1)'4230�1)23'4&v5�7 (�h`1)(�'5�7�')(�c3.:2/h6{i�u.+1)X (X3&U*:.+2/r 0�5"'4&A(�?3cd(vXat9c/'45"[�&U?bY/2/'4?3.:?/[vh4X3&U*:*�!

� ��� � � �(� � ��R��� � �R��

� U�T k ��Y\^�^��(g�[xr(b�r����7�1)&�' 1)X/&wXat9c/'45�["&U?�7O2/&�* .:? 14X/&w0U5"'`&w.:h ?3&y(�'`*+t & fJXP(�2/ho1)&�c8 14X/&w?e2/0U*+&y(�' *+2/rs. n?35"h4. 1qt $<(�?3.:h4X3&Uh (�1@14X/&I0�5"'4&<!�J &U0y(<2/h4& 0P��� ��� ���

����14X/&s14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&�["')(<c/.:&�?e1

(<*:h45 $<(�?3.:h4X3&Uh�(�?/cw1)X3&0U5"'`&Y�&�0U5"r�&Uhu.:h`5�1)X3&U'4rs(�*�! � 0U5�'4&��u.+14X/5"231>14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&[�')(�c/.+&U?a1>0U(�?/?/5�1 ,/'45�$9.:c/& 14X/& ,/'`&Uh`h42/'`&A[�')(�c/.+&U?a1 145 h42/,/,�5"'o1>1)X/& rs(<1`1)&U' (�[a(�.+?/h`1[�')(y$9.+1qtR(�?/c X/&�?/0U&>14X/& 0U5�'4& 0�5"?a1)')(<0�1)h�! � X/&>["'4(y$J. 1 (<14.:5"?/(�*a&U?/&�'4[�tR'4&�*:&y(<h4&Uc X3&y(<14h23,H1)X/& 0�5"'4&QZh`5�1)XP(<1 1)X/&@1)&Ur�,�&U')(�1)2/'`&R5�7�14X/& &Uc3["& 5�7�14X/& 0U5�'4& .+?/0U'`&y(�h`&Uh h`2�� n0�.:&�?e14*+ts7O5"' 1)X/&Xat9c/'`5"["&U?d.:?M( h4X3&U*:*�'`&U[".+5"?M(�'`5"2/?/cw1)X3&A0�5"'4&145�23?/c/&U'`["5 7O2/h4.+5"?-!� X3.:h h`X/&U*+*�Y/2/'`?/.:?3[�.:h .:["?/. 1)&�cm7�(�.:'`*+tw'4(�,/.+c/*+t3Z0y(<2/h4.+?/[I1)X3& &U?a$"&�*:5",�& 1)5I& fJ,P(�?/cZ!� 1u14X/.:h>ho1 (�["&6.+?e14&U'`?P(�*-ho1)'4230�1)23'4&A5�7�14X/&6h`1)(�'u.:hu(�huh4X35F�u?d.:?�14X/&A��.:[/! � KF�g!

�P5"'�ho1 (�'`hB�u.+14X , �LjH,1G�,�5��_&�'4&�csYat 14X/&�^�� # 0�t90U*+&3a1)X3&>?9230U*:&U(�'�'`&y(�0 1).:5�?'4(<1)&�$<(�'4.+&Uh (<h (mX/.+["X�,�5��_&�' 5�7! @rI(Q�9.+?/[M1)X/&�0�5"'4&s0U5"?a$�&U0�14.+$�&�! 5 7uXatJc3'45"["&�?.+h 0U5�?/h42/r�&Uc .+?�(��_&�*:*�r�. fJ&�cH0U5"?a$�&U0�14.+$�&s0�5"'4&Q-1)X/&�'4&��u.:*+*�Y�& (�X/&�*:.+2/r 0�5"'4&R5�7(<,/,/'4&�0U.:(�Y/*:&%rI(�h`hu(<1>1)X3& $"&U'otw&U?3cd5�7�0�&U?a1)'4(�*�XatJc3'45"["&�?dY32/'4?/.+?/[/! � X/&60�5"'4&XP(<h145s0�5"*:*:(�,/h`&6(v7�(�.+'>Y/.+1>7O5�'u14X/&61)&Ur�,�&U')(�1)2/'`&A5<7�14X/&@h`X/&U*+*-1)5�.:?/0�'4&U(�h4&Ah42���0�.:&U?a14*+t h`5�14XP(<1u1)X3& ^��%# 0�t90U*+&@0U(�?b*:&y(<cM145sh`.:["?3.SMP0U(�?a1 &�?/&U'`[�tM,/'`5Jc/230�1).+5"?-!�� &�?/0U&61)X3&14')(�?3h4.+14.:5"?b7O'45"r 0U5�'4& Y/23'4?/.+?/[�1)5wh`X/&U*+*�Y/2/'`?/.:?3[�.:h c3.:h40�5"?a1).+?9235"2/hU!@^_5"?a14')(�0 1).:5�?.+h>XP(�* 1)&Ucw14&Ur�,�5"'4(�'4.+*+t�5"?/0�&1)X/&6h4X3&U*:*�Y32/'4?/.+?/[vh`1)(�'`14hU!

" ?/*:.S��&AX/&y(y$etmrs(�h`h ho1 (�'`h��14X/&U'`&R.+h%(�h4r�5J5�14Xd14')(�?/h`.+14.:5"?w7O'45�r 0U5"'`&RY/2/'`?/.:?3[

\

Page 7: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

145@h`X/&U*+*�Y/2/'4?3.:?/[A.:?v0y(<h4&%5<7-*:5�� rI(�h`h h`1 (<'4hU! � X3.:h�.:h Y�&�0y(�23h4&%,9nq,�0 XP(�.:?�5",�&U'4(<1)&�h.+? *:5�� rs(�h4h�h`1)(�'4h2 �uX/.:0 X XP(<h�*:5�� &U'�14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4& h4&U?3h4.+14.+$9.+1qtR(�?/cRX/&U?/0�& 1)X/&_0U5"'`&.+h ?/5�1 0U5"?a$"&�0�14.+$"&<! 891 (�'`hV�u. 1)X�?/5R0�5"?a$"&�0�1). $"& 0�5"'4&�0U5�?/h42/r�&�Xet9c/'`5"["&�?�h42/0 Xs1)XP(<114X/&�tm,/'459c/2/0�&v(�["'45��u.+?/[wX/&U*+.:2/r 0U5�'4& ho1 (�'o1).:?3[M(<1(�U&�'45Mrs(�h4h�! � X/&�'4& 7O5"'4& 14X/&U'`&.+hu( h4r�5J5�14Xw1)')(<?/h4. 1).:5�?�7O'45"r�0U&U?a14')(�*�1)5vh`X/&U*+*�Y/2/'4?3.:?/[/!

� U�� �1hZ[&Y��1h r eD[&]�cfe&bdh r ]_r�� n rmXZY\^�hZ`7Y Y���`�]_r��Db�hZr�P2/'o1)X/&�'&�$�5"*:2314.:5"?�c3&U,�&U?/c/hA5"?H14X/&vh`1)'`2/0�142/')(<*�0 XP(�?/["&�h1)XP(<11)(3��& ,3*;(�0�& .:?H1)X3&X3&U*:.+2/r 0�5"'4&<! ��&U*:.+2/r 0�5"'4& .:hw?/&U(�'4* t .:h`5�1)X3&U'4rs(�* %Y�&U0y(<2/h4& 1)X/& $<(�?/.+h4X/.+?/[ 5�7*+2/r�.:?/5"h`.+1qtd.:r�,/*:.+&Uh�1)X/& $<(�?/.+h4X/.+?/[M5�7 14X/& 1)&�rs,�&U'4(<1)2/'`&v["')(�c3.:&U?a1U! � X3&s&29923.:*:.+YJn'`.:2/r 5�7�h`2/0 X�(sho1 (�'�c/&�,�&�?/c/h%5�?b14X/& (�Y3.:*:. 1qtI5<7�(�?d.:h45<1)X/&�'4rs(�*-0U5�'4& � �u.+14Xdrs(�h4h,�� @��3, �A91)5@h42/,/,�5"'o1 1)X/& &U?a$"&�*:5",�& 5�7-rI(�h`h(� K� �� �p, !B5 1_142/'4?3h 5"231 1)XP(<1�1)X3&ho1 (�Y3.:*:. 1qtM.:h ,�5"h`h4.+Y/*:& 5�?/*+tb.+7�14X/&R7O'4(�0�14.:5"?H5<7�1)X/& rs(�h`h��I.+?m1)X/&R0U5"'`& .:h Y�&�*:5�� (0�&U'o1 (�.+?m0U'`.+14.:0y(<*Z$<(�*:2/&A0y(<*:*:&�cb14X/&R^_XP(�?/c/'4(�h4&2�eXP(�'on 8J0 X/59&U?eY�&U'4[M*+.:r�.+1y! � X/&@rI(�fen.+r 2/r 7O'4(�0�14.:5"? 5�7 (bho1 (�'��kh@rI(<h4h1)XP(�1@0U(�?�&gfJ.:h`1@.:? 1)X3&sh`2/,/,�5"'`14.:?/[b.:h`5�1)X/&�'4rs(�*0�5"'4&6.+h>[".+$�&U?bYet ������� ! ��� @�� x��kjai��! �" =�# � @%$'&�( � KF��uX3&U'4& �" =�#6(�?/c � @ (�'`&@14X/&Rr�&y(�?br�5"*:&�0U2/*:(�'m�_&�.:["Xa1)h .:?b1)X/&A&U?a$"&�*:5",�& (�?3cd1)X3&.+h45�14X/&U'`rI(<*Z0U5�'4&3P'`&Uh`,�&�0�1). $"&�*+t"!

5q?m14X/&A0y(�h`&R5�7�X/.:["XdrI(<h4h�h`1 (<'4h��(�hu1)X/&Ah4X3&U*:*SY/23'4?/.+?/[I.+?/0U'`&y(�h`&Uh��7O')(<0�1).+5"?b5�714X/&wrs(�h4h .+? 1)X/&w0�5"'4&)�:�u.:*+* &gf30�&U&�c*��� @A(�?/c�1)X3&w0U5"'`&a�u.:*:*�?/5�*+5"?/["&�' Y�&�(�Y/*:&145dh`2/,/,�5"'`1A1)X3&�&�?a$"&U*+5",�&�!M8J.+?/0U&s(MrI(�h`h4. $"&vh`1)(�'6h`1 (<'`1)hA5"? 1)X/&�rs(�.:?Jn h4&29923&U?/0�&�u. 1)X '4&�*;(<14.+$�&U*+t *:5���0U&�?e14')(�*>c3&U?/h`.+1qt c/&U[�&U?/&�')(�0 t &��&U0�14hs.+? 1)X/&M0�5"'4&b(�'`&w?/&U[<n*+.:[".+Y/*:&<!M� &�?/0U&�. 1��u.+*:* ?/5�1RY�&I,�5"h`h4.+Y/*:&v7O5"'@14X/&Ic3&U["&�?/&U'4(�0�t�&��&U0�14h 1)5dh42/,/,�5"'o114X/&6&U?a$"&�*:5",�&�! J_&U0U(�2/h`&R5�7�1)X/&6,/'`&Uh4h`2/'4&@.:r Y/(�*;(�?30U&3J1)X/&60U5�'4&O�u.:*:*�h`1)(�'`1 0U5"*+*;(�,3hon.+?/[�(�?3c�1)X/&I&�$"5�*:2314.:5"?1�u.+*:*�,/'4590U&�&Uc (<1 (m7�(�h`14&U' '4(<1)& ���� ! #&% ')+* �0y(�*+*:&�c 1)X3&�&�*+$9.:?Jnq� &�*:r�X/5"*+1N��14.:r�& h40U(�*:&<!+ 2/'`.:?/[ 1)X3.:h�,/XP(�h`&d1)X3&m0U5�'4&H(<?/c 14X/&m&�?e$�&U*+5",�&d'4&�[".:5"?3hsY�&UXP(y$�&H.:? ( $�&U'`tc3. ��&U'4&�?a1��_(yt"! � X/&s0U5"'`&s0�5"?a1)')(<0�1)hR(�?/c 1)X/&�&U?a$"&�*:5",�&I&gfJ,P(�?/c/h2 �uX/.+0 X�0y(<? Y�&23?/c/&U'`h`145J59c�(�h�7O5"*:*+5��uh + 2/'4.+?/[%1)X3.:h�,/XP(<h4&3a14X/&>&�$�5"*:2314.:5"? 590U0�2/'4h (�1�1)X/& �&U* $9.:?Jn��&U*+rsX/5�*+1��s1).:r�&�h`0y(�*+&�! � X/&U'`&�7O5"'`&3_7O5�' 1).:r�&wh40U(�*:&�hvh4X/5"'o1)&�'v14XP(�? 1)X/&:�&U* $9.:?Jn��&U*+rsX/5�*+1��@1).:r�& h40U(�*:&Q�Y�5�14X &�?/&U'`[�t 0U5"?3h4&U'o$<(<1).+5"? �-,/.�0 !21�35476��p�A�(�?/c 1)X3&�%.:'`.;(�*�1)X/&�5"'4&�r W8,9.:0 ! xD%r 2/h`1dX/5"*+c-! � X/.:hb'4&29e2/.:'`&Uh;0 (�?/c<, 1)5�Y�&

i

Page 8: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

h`&U,P(<')(<14&U*+tM0�5"?/h`&U'`$�&Uc-! tL.+14X�, � @ � , " =�#Q&�uX/&�'4&�, � @>(�?3c , " =�#6(�'`&A14X/&Rrs(�h4h0�5"?a1 (�.+?/&Uc .+? 14X/&w0U5�'4&b(�?/c�1)X3&w&U?a$"&�*:5",�&d'`&Uh`,�&�0�1). $"&�*+t 1)X3&brs(�["?3.+1)23c/&�5�7u1)X3&,�5�14&U?a1).:(�*-&U?3&U'4[<tw0y(�?bY�&O�u'`.+1`1)&U?b(�h

� 0 � � 4 , � @ &/ @ . 4 , � @�, " =�#/�� � 1�35476�� � ( � W �

�uX3&U'4& /�� (�?/c / @S(�'`&_1)X3& ')(�c3.:2/h�5�7P1)X/&_h`1 (<'�(�?/c 14X/& 0U5�'4&_'`&Uh`,�&�0�1). $"&�*+t"! �P2/'o1)X/&�'�14X/& *+5J0U(<1).+5"?v5�7�1)X/&%Y/2/'4?3.:?/[@h4X/&�*:*Zc35J&�h_?/5�1_0 XP(�?/[�& h4.+["?/.SM/0y(�?a1)* t 9.:r�,/*+t9.+?/[1)XP(<1Y�5�14X ,�� @ (�?3cl, " =�# (�'4&0�5"?/h`1)(�?a1)h�! � X/&�?� /��� / @ � � , � @, " =�#� � /��/ @� & ( ��jH�

�uX3.:0 Xb.:r�,/*:.+&Uh 14XP(<1u1)X3&A'4(�c/.+2/h>5�7�1)X/&6h`1)(�'>.:?30U'4&U(�h4&�h%(<hu14X/&60U5"'`&60U5"?a1)'4(�0�14hU!� X/&@(�0 1)2P(�*�r�&U0 X/(�?/.:h`r 2/?/c/&�'4* tJ.+?/[ 1)X/&A0U5�'4&60U5"?a14')(�0 1).:5�?m(�?3cb14X/&@&�?a$"&U*+5",�&

&gfJ,P(�?/h`.:5"? .:hv1)X/&b.:?/X35"rs5�["&U?/&�.+14.:&Uh .+?�14X/&m0 X3&Ur�.:0y(<*>0U5"r�,�5�h4.+14.:5"? 5�7 1)X/&dh`1)(�'U!5q?3X/5"r�5"["&U?3&U.+14.:&�h_.:?I0 X/&Ur�.:0U(�*�0�5"r�,�5"h`.+14.:5"?s(�'4.+h4&�h .:?w(@h`1 (<' .:?I14X/& 0�5"2/'4h`&5�7�1)X3&& $"5"*+231).+5"?8aY�&U0U(�2/h4&�5�7�1)X/&>1)'4(�?/ho7O5"'4rs(<1).+5"? 5�7-(�?�&U*:&�rs&�?a1 h4&U'o$9.:?/[@(�h�1)X/&�?e2/0U*+&y(�'7O23&U*�.:?a1)5w(<?/5�1)X3&U'%&�*:&�rs&�?e1%5�7�c/. �Z&�'4&�?e1(<1)5"r�.:06rs(�h4h���&�[� � � � ��� �g! + 2/'`.:?/[ho1)&�*:*;(<' &�$�5"*:2314.:5"?fJ1)X3&Y/2/'4?3.:?/[v5�7S1)X3&A?e2/0�*:&U(�' 7O2/&U*Z.:?/0�'4&y(<h4&Uh>14X/& $<(�*:2/&5<7�r�&y(<?r�5"*+&U0U23*;(�'V�_&�.:["Xa1 P.:?�14X/&6'4&�[".:5"? �uX/&�'4&A?e2/0U*+&y(�'uY/2/'`?/.:?3[�.+h 1 (3�e.+?/[v,/*;(�0�&�!

� X/&R.:?/X/5�rs5"[�&U?/&�.+1).+&Uhm�uX/.+0 X�rI(ytbc/&�$�&U*+5",Hrs(�tbY�& &U. 1)X/&�'%c/.+h40�5"?a1).:?e2/5�2/h%5"'0�5"?a1).+?9235"2/hU! � c/.:h`0U5"?a1).+?e2/.+1qt.+?@0 X3&Ur�.:0y(<*a0U5"r�,�5�h4.+14.:5"?c3&�$"&�*:5",3h�.+?R(uh`1)(�' �uX/.:0 X8�uX3.:*:&R5"? rs(�.+?Jnqh`&�9e2/&U?30U&3Sc/&�'4. $"&Uh6&�?/&U'`[�tH7O'45�r 1)X3&I^��%#�0�t90�*:&�!-5q? h`2/0 X�ho1 (�'`h14X/& 0�5"'4& .:h_0�5"?a$"&�0�1). $"&Q��uX/&U'`& rs5�h`1 5<7-1)X/& 1)X/&�'4r�5"?e2/0U*+&y(�' &U?/&�'4[�ts["&U?3&U')(�1).:5�?I.:h590U0�2/'4'`.:?/[3! � X/&u0U5�?e$�&U0 1).:5�?s.+? 1)X/&>0�5"'4&m�u.:*+*D�<&U&U,v1)X3&�0�5"'4&>0�5"r�,�5"h`.+14.:5"?@2/?/.+7O5�'4r(<?/c 1)X/&>[�')(�c/2/(�*J14')(�?/ho7O5"'4rs(<14.:5"?@5�7�XatJc3'45"["&�?s.+?a1)5 X/&�*:.+2/r �u.:*:*9*:&U(�c 1)5 ( c/.:h`0U5"?Jn14.:?e2/. 1qtM.:?b0U5"r�,�5�h4.+14.:5"?fP.:?��uX/.:0 X ��� � �1)X/&@h42/Y3h40U'`.:,314h��_(�?/c 3 '`&�7O&U'`'4.+?/[s145.+?/h4.+c/& (<?/c 5"2314h4.+c/&_5�7P14X/& 0�5"?a$"&U0 1). $"&u0U5"'`&_'`&Uh4,�&U0 1). $"&U* t"!�� 0U5"?a1).+?e2/5"2/h`*+t6$<(�'`t9.:?3[0�5"r�,�5"h`.+14.:5"?@5�$�&U' (�?�(�,3,/'4&�0U.;(<Y/*:& ,�5"'o1).+5"? 5�7�( h`1)(�'�.:h�c/&�$�&U*:5�,�&�c�Yat ho1 (�'`hB�uX/5"h`&rs(�.+?b&�?/&U'`[�tbh45"23'40U&v�uX/.:*+&65"?b14X/&ArI(�.+?Jnqh`&�9e2/&�?/0U&@.:h>1)X/&A,/'`5�1)5"?d0 XP(�.+?m(�?3cd1)X3&0�5"'4&�.:h ,/'`&Uc/5�rs.+?P(�?a1)* t ')(<c/.;(<14.+$�&�! 5q?�1)X/.+h 0y(�h`&�14X/& Xat9c/'`5"["&U?�(�Y/2/?/c/(�?/0U& �u.:*+*PY�&h`rI(<*:*:&�h`1 (<11)X/& ho1)&�*:*;(<'%0U&�?a1)&U'A(�?3c �u.+*:*�.:?/0�'4&y(<h4& 0U5�?e14.:?e2/5"23h4*+tm5"231>�_(�'4cZ! � Xe2/h.+?�rs5�h`160y(<h4&Uh61)X3& $�(<*:2/& 5�7 .:?/0�'4&U(�h4&�hA.+?H� (�'`c .:? (wh`1 (<'��&U. 1)X/&�'0U5"?a14.:?e2/5"2/h`*+t5�'>c/.:h`0U5"?a1).+?e2/5"2/h`*+t"!

�P5"'u(vh`1)(�'uXP(y$J.+?/[�c/.:h`0U5"?a1).+?e2/.+1qtI.:?M0 X/&Ur�.:0U(�*�0U5�rs,�5"h4. 1).+5"?��u.+14X � � � /145Y�&�.:? &�9e2/.:*+.:Y/'`.:2/r 1)X/&�,/'`&Uh4h`2/'4&I(�?/c 1)&Ur�,�&U')(�1)2/'`&sr 23h`1@Y�&�0U5"?a14.:?e2/5"2/h@(�0�'45"h`h

Page 9: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

14X/& .:?a14&U'`7�(<0U&�!O5q? 5�14X/&U' � 5"'`c/h���� rR2/h`16Y�& 0U5�?e14.:?e2/5"23h6(�0U'`5"h4h 14X/& .:?a1)&�'`7�(�0�&�!^_5�?e14.:?e2/. 1qt@5<7/1)X/& ')(<14.:5���� .:r�,/*:.+&UhS0U5�?e14.:?e2/. 1qt65�7P1)X/& ')(<14.:5���� . 7/1)X3&_&�9e2P(�1).:5�?5<7�14X/& ho1 (<14& .:h 14X/& ,�&U'`7O&�0�16[a(<h *;(R�6! �%(<142/')(<*:*+tM5�?�&U.+14X/&U'%h4.:c3& 5�7 1)X/& .+?a1)&U'o7�(�0U&�uX3&U'4&u1)X3& c/.+h40�5"?a1).:?e2/. 1qt 590U0�2/'4h2+� & rR2/h`1�XP(y$"&��

� !��� � !�8J.:?/0�& �

� � K ��

� � K

.�!k&<!S91)X/&�'4&6r 2/ho1>Y�&6(vc3.:h40�5"?a1).+?923.+1qts.:?wc/&�?/h4. 1qta�u.+14X�� ��� � ! � 5�� 0U5"?3h4.:c3&U' 1)X3&&29e2P(<1).+5"?M5�7�Xet9c/'`5"h`1)(<1).+06&�9e2/.:*+.:Y/'`.:2/r� �� � ! 4 , �� &

� � ��BL�

5 7S14X/&c/&U?3h4.+1qt��vc/.:r�.:?/.+h4X/&�h (�Y3'42/,314*+ts5"231>�_(�'4c6�OY�&�0y(�2/h`&65�7�(�?b(�Y/'`2/,31>5"2J1>� (�'`cc3&U0U'`&y(�h`& .:? �;�14X/&U?H14X/&R$<(�*:23& 5�7 � � ��� � � � �u.+*:*Sc/&U0�'4&U(�h4&�(�Y/'`2/,314*+tb5"231>�_(�'4c (<114X/& c/.:h`0U5"?a14.:?e2/.+1qt�!���&U?/0�&3<h4.:?30U&�� r 2/ho1�Y�&�0�5"?a1).:?e2/5�2/h�(<0U'45�h4h�1)X/& c/.+h40�5"?a1).:?e2/. 1qt (s["'4&U(<1)&�' ')(�c3.;(�*Sc/.+h`1 (<?/0U& Y�&�t�5"?/c�1)X3& c/.:h`0U5"?a14.:?e2/.+1qtb.+h%'4&29e2/.:'`&UcH1)5�(�*:*+5F��� 145$<(�?3.:h4Xl� �uX/&�?I1)X3&%h423'`7�(�0�&%.:h '`&y(�0 X/&�cx�AJ1)XP(�?s.+7�1)X/&�'4&%X/(�cIY�&U&�?�?/5Rc3.:h40�5"?a1).+?923.+1qt.+?M0U5"r�,�5�h4.+14.:5"?Z! � Xe2/hu1)X/&6&U?a$�&U*:5�,�&A& fJ,P(�?3c/h%(<hu14X/&60U5"'`&60U5"?a1)'4(�0�14hU!

� X/&�0�5"?a1)'4(�0�14.:5"? 5�7614X/&�0U5"'`&H0y(<2/h4&�hd( '`&U*:(<1). $"&U* t�*;(�'`["&m&gf3,/(�?/h4.+5"?L5�71)X3&&�?a$"&U*+5",�&�! � X/&& fJ,P(<?/h4.+5"?w5�7�1)X3&&U?a$"&�*:5",�&c/&U0�'4&U(�h4&�hu14X/& &��Z&�0�1). $"&h`2/'`7�(�0�& 1)&�rvn,�&U'4(<1)23'4& (�?3c 0�5J5�*:h 14X/& 5"2J1)&U'*:(yt"&U'`h5�7�1)X3& h`1 (<' h4.+["?/.SM/0y(�?a1)* t �1)X/& Y3*;(�0u�dY�59c3t'4(�c/.:(<1).+5"? 1)Xe2/h�h4X/. 7�1).+?/[�1)5 1)X/&b'4&�c-! � X/&dh`1)(�'�(�h4h`2/rs&�h�14X/&d(�,/,�&y(�'4(�?/0U&b5�7 ('`&Ucs[".;(�?a1U! � X/&%&gfJ,P(�?/h`.:5"?�1)')(<?/h`7O5"'`rsh 1)X3& ho1 (�'�.:?a1)5R(A'`&Uc�[�.;(�?a1�h45@')(�,/.+c/*+tR1)XP(<114X/&U'`& .:h�*:. 141)*+& 0 XP(�?/0�&>5�7�5"Y/h`&U'`$9.+?/[.+1�c/2/'`.:?/[%14X/.:h�h4X/5�'`1�,/X/(�h4& 5<7�&�$"5�*:2314.:5"?-! � X/.:h&gfJ,/*;(�.+?/h 14X/& &gf3.+h`14&U?/0�& 5�7�1)X/&��_&�*:* �e?/5��u? � &�'`1N�Uh4,3'42/?/[M[a(<,8-(�?H(�'4&U(�Y�& 1>�_&�&U?rs(�.+?Jnqh`&�9e2/&U?30U& (�?/cs14X/&�'4&UcI[".;(�?a14h_�u. 1)Xs(@ho1)'4.S�e.:?/[Ac/&2M/0U.:&�?/0�t�5�7Z5"Y/h`&U'`$�&Ucwho1 (�'`h.+?w1)X/&A� &�'`1N�Uh4,3'42/?/[�n {u2/h4h`&U*�c/.;(�[�')(�rb!

� X/& &��Z&�0�1�5�7Jh4X/&�*:*"Y/23'4?/.+?/[u.:h�X/5�� &�$"&�'�"c3. ��&U'4&�?a1S.:?*:5�� rI(<h4h�h`1)(�'4hS0�5"rs,/(�'4&�c145�1)X/(<1w.:? 1)X/&H0U(�h4&�5<71)X/&HX3.:["X rs(�h`h�h`1)(�'4h�! 89.:?/0�&�(�*:5�� rs(�h4hsh`1 (<'�h`1)(�'`14h5�? 14X/&vrI(<.:?Jn h4&�9e2/&�?/0U&-�u. 1)X '4&�*;(<14.+$"&�*+td*;(�'`["& 0U&�?a1)')(<*�c/&U?/h`.+1qt3�14X/& &U*+&U0�14'45"? [a(�h.+? 14X/& 0U5"'`& .+hd(�1b14X/& Y�5"'`c/&U'b5�7Rc/&U["&�?/&U'4(�0�t YatL1)X/& 1).+rs&�Xat9c/'`5"["&U? 7O2/&U*6.:?14X/& 0U5�'4& .:h%& fJXP(�2/ho1)&�c-! �%h 14X/& Y/2/'`?/.:?/[wh`X/&U*+*�0y(<2/h4&�h614X/& 0U5�'4& rs(�h4h%145M& fJ0U&�&Uc� x � K ,1G a14X/&u0U5"'`&�0�5"?a1)'4(�0�14.:5"?w�_5�2/*:c�XP(y$"&�,/'459c/2/0�&Ucsh42���0U.+&U?a1 c/&U["&�?/&U'4(�0�t�h`514XP(<1^_XP(�?/c/'4(�h4&2�eXP(�'on 8J0 X/59&U?eY�&U'4[b*:.+rs. 1uY�&�0U5"r�&Uh .:'`'4&U*+&�$<(�?a1y! � 1 1)X3.:h%ho1 (�[�&@1)X3&0�5"'4&%.:h rs(�c/& 5<7�c3&U["&�?/&U'4(<1)&Q/.:h`5�1)X/&�'4rs(�*ZX3&U*:.+2/r�(�?/cw?/5 '4(�,/.+cw0U5"'`& 0U5"?a14')(�0 1).:5�?590U0�2/'4h�!�� &U?30U&6*:5�� rI(<h4h>h`1)(�'4huc/5 ?35�1u& fJX/.+Y/.+1 14X/&6� &�'`1N�Uh4,3'42/?/[�[a(�,M2/?3*:. �<&%1)X3&X3.:["XMrs(�h4h>ho1 (�'`hU!+ 2/'`.:?/[u1)X3& .+?/.+14.;(�*<,/XP(�h`&3�14X/& [�'45��>1)X@5�7314X/&_0�5"'4&�rI(<h4h�.:hSh4*+5F��(�?/c@14X/&_�uX/5"*:&0�5"'4& h4& 141)*+&Uh�1)5(u1)&Ur�,�&U')(�1)2/'`&_5�7/14X/&_h`2/'4'`5"2/?/c3.:?/[ Xet9c/'`5"["&�? Y/2/'4?3.:?/[ h`X/&U*+* ! � X/.:h

Page 10: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&�.:h�7�(�'�7O'`5"r 1)XP(�1�5�7J1)X/&�.:[�?/.+14.:5"?5�731)X/&�X/&U*+.:2/r � � K�x������g! � X/&U'`&�7O5"'`&14X/&h4X3&U*:*�Y/2/'`?/.:?/[ ,3XP(�h4&.+?w*:5�� rI(<h4h ho1 (�'`h>.:h ( h`*:5�� ,/XP(�h`&6(�?/cw5"?/&&gfJ,�&�0�1)h>145M/?/cdrs(�?atwh`2/0 Xmho1 (�'`h�.+?w1)X/&6hN�at�!

� X/&>0�5"?a1)'4(�0�14.:5"? 5�7�14X/& 0U5�'4&v��(<h�.:?R14X/&>0y(<h4&>5�7�X/.+["X rs(�h4h�ho1 (�'`hu��.+h�(�0�0U5"r�,P(�n?3.:&UcdYatm(<?m& fJ,P(<?/h4.+5"?H5�7�1)X/&@Xet9c/'`5"["&�?H'4.+0 Xm&U?a$�&U*:5�,�& 5�231)h`.:c/&61)X/&Ah4X3&U*:*�h45�2/'40�&(<?/cm1)X3&Rh`1)(�'%Y�&U0�5"r�&Uh (s'4&Ucm[".;(�?a1U! � ?atd7O2/'o1)X/&�'%&gf3,/(�?/h4.+5"?H5�7�1)X/&@&U?a$"&�*:5",�& .:h5�?/*+tw,�5"h`h4.:Y3*:&.+7�1)X/&6*+2/rs.+?/5"h`.+1qt�.+?/0U'`&y(�h`&Uh7��(�h�(<1u14X/.:hu,�5".:?a1�h`1)(�'u.:hu0U*+5"h4&1)5v1)X3&� (yta(�h`X/. f�uX3.:0 X�0y(<?/?/5�1Y�&R0�'45"h`h4&�cx� ! � Xe2/h 1)X3& h`1)(�'(�h`0U&U?3c/h2/,H1)X3& '4&�c�[".;(�?a1Y3')(�?/0 Xv(<?/c *:2/r�.:?35"h4. 1qt.:?/0�'4&U(�h4&�h�Yet@r�5"'4&�1)XP(�? ( 7�(�0�145"'�5<7*K�x & �uX/.+*:& ,6@S["'45��uhU!� U�� � ]������� g bpr�h���b e�� [&Y\^d] e&bdh r j;hV[ ] �+eD]�[ bpr [&Y � � �Zbd]_r e

` ��]� Y5 1 0y(�?�Y�& h4X/5��u?�1)X/(<1 1)X3& *:2/r�.:?35"h4. 1qtM5�7 1)X/& ho1 (�'%.:?�'4&�c�[".;(<?e1%,/XP(�h`& c/&U,�&U?3c/h5�?/*+t�5"?I14X/& ,/'`5",�&U'`14.:&�h_5�7�14X/&%0�5"'4&(<?/cw.:h�,/')(<0�1).+0y(�*+*+tv.+?/c/&U,�&U?3c/&U?a1>5�7�14X/& rs(�h4h, ,6@ 5�7�1)X/&6&U?a$�&U*:5�,�&���(�?3cM14X/&U'`&�7O5"'`&@5<7�rs(�h4hP, 5�7�1)X/&6h`1)(�'u�g!

p�&�1623hrs59c/&U*�1)X/&Rh`1 (<'6(�h Y�&U.:?3[w.:?�&�9e2/.+*:.+Y/'4.+2/r �u.+14X (�c/&U["&�?/&U'4(<1)&vX/&�*:.+2/r0�5"'4& 5<7_rs(�h4hv, @%(�?3c 14X/& ')(<c/.:2/h / @ h`2/'4'`5"2/?/c/&�c Yat (<? &gf91)&U?3c/&Uc &U?a$"&�*:5",�&v5�7Xat9c/'`5"["&U? �u. 1)X h`5"rs&IrI(�h`h@7O'4(�0�14.:5"?�� u! �%hR14X/&�h`X/&U*+*_Y/2/'`?/h��14X/&�0U5�'4&�rs(�h4h.+?/0U'`&y(�h`&Uh�(<1u1)X3&A'4(<1)&

�,6@"! 0�� ��P ( � � �

�uX3&U'4&��q .:hS1)X/& &�?/&U'`[�t@*:.:Y�&U'4(<1)&�c@,�&U'�2/?/. 1�rs(�h4h�5�7/1)X3& XatJc3'45"["&�?-!�� h�&�$�5"*:2314.:5"?,3'4590U&U&�c/h� ,6@ .:?/0�'4&y(<h4&UhA(�?3c h`5dc/59&Uhv0m �uX/.:0 X .:h&�h4h`&U?a1).:(�*:* t�["5�$"&�'4?/&�c�YatH1)X3&0�5"'4&_0U5"?/c3.+1).+5"?/h�! � X/&_,/'45",�&U'o1).+&Uh�5<7P1)X/& h`X/&U*+*3(<'4& rs(�.:?3*+tc/& 1)&�'4r�.:?/&�c Yat-,6@�(�?3c/ @u3�uX/.:*+& 14X/&�t (�'4&_(�*:r�5"h`1�.:?/c3&U,�&U?/c/&�?a1 5�7P1)X/&_,/'45",�&U'o1).+&Uh�5�7P14X/& &�?e$�&U*+5",�&<! � X/.:h0U(�?IY�&u2/?/c/&�'4ho1)595Jc�7O'45"r 14X/&>7�(�0�1�1)X/(<1 1)X/&u0U5�'4&�.:h X/.:[�X/*+tR0U5"?/0�&U?a1)'4(<1)&�cw(�?/cv1)X3&[�')(y$9.+1qt6(<1S. 1)hSh423'`7�(�0�&�.+h�$"&U'ot6*;(�'`["&�! � X/&�? (�0�0U5"'`c/.:?/[>145�Xat9c/'`5"h`1)(<1).+0 &29923.:*:.+Y/'4.+2/r:� � ��� ��� � � 4 � � � � %.:hs$"&U'ot *;(<'4["&m(�?/c � c/'`5",/hwYat ,�5��_&�'4hM5�7 K�x �u.+14X/.:? (14X/.:?�rs(�h`h h4X/&�*:*\K`23h`1�(�Y�5�$"&�1)X3&w0U5"'`&wh42/'o7�(�0U&<!15q?�5�14X/&U'�� 5"'4c3h� 1)X/&w&gfJ14&U?/c3&Uc&�?a$"&U*+5",�&d(<Y�5�$"&w14X/.:h *:(�t�&U' .+h ?/&y(<'4*+t6�_&�.:["Xa14*:&Uh`h�(�?/c XP(�h ?/5 .+?��P2/&�?/0U&M5"?�1)X3&Y32/'4?/.+?/[Rh`X/&U*+* !�pS& 1 2/h_(�h4h`2/r�& 1)X/(<1 14X/&%5�,P(�0U. 1qt�(�?/cI14X/&�&U?/&�'4[�ts["&U?3&U')(�1).:5�?s0U(�?Y�&6,P(�'4(�rs& 1)'`. �U&�cwYat

� ! ��� �� �� ( (�?3c �o! � � �

=�� � ��8� ��\H�

Kyx

Page 11: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

� X3&I&�9e2P(�1).:5�? 5�7_h`1)(<1)&�5"2314h4.:c3&�14X/&s0�5"'4&�0y(<?�Y�&v1)(3��&�?�1)5bY�&�14XP(<1@5�7>(�? .:c3&y(�*["(�h �u.+14X

� ! ���� ��� � � i ���&U'`&�� & XP(y$"& ?3&U["*+&U0�14&UcH'4(�c/.:(<1).+5"?M,/'4&�h4h423'4&3Zh4.:?30U&R. 1%.+h ?35�1%.+rs,�5"'o1 (�?a1u7O5"'�*:5��rs(�h`h>h`1 (<'4hU!�t &?/5�� (�h`h42/r�&7O5"'_14X/&6c/&U?/h`.+1qt3/1)&Ur�,�&U')(�1)2/'`&3/,/'`&Uh`h42/'`&R(�?3cb*+5J0U(�**+2/r�.:?/5"h`.+1qt .:?�14X/&M'4&U[�.:5"? 5�7�1)X/&MXat9c/'45�["&U?�Y/2/'`?/.:?/[ h`X/&U*+* 1)XP(<1 14X/&U'`&d&gfJ.:h`14h�(h`.:r�,/*:&%c/&U,�&U?/c3&U?/0 td5�?l,6@ (�?/c / @uP(<hu7O5�*:*:5��uh

� ��� � / @�� � ,����@ / � '@ ( � �H� 7� � � / @�� � ,��@ / � '@ ( � �H�� � � � / @>� � ,���@ / � '@ ( � K�xH� ��� � / @�� � ,����@ / � '@ � � K KF�

� X3& (�Y�5�$"&�h4&�1 5�7�&29e2P(<1).+5"?/h (�'4&uX/5�rs5"*+5"[�tan 1qt9,�&>'4&�*;(<14.:5"?/h�! � XP(�1_.+h_� &%0�5"r�,P(�'4&1>� 5Rho1)&�*:*;(<'�r�59c/&U*+h�5�7�c/. �Z&�'4&U?a1�0U5�'4&%rs(�h`h4&Uh ,6@�(<?/c ,��@ 9(�?3cI0U5�'4&�')(�c/.+. / @�(�?3c/ �@ ! � 5�� � &A0U(�?bc/&2MP?3&@X/5�rs5"*+5"["5"23h_,�5".:?a1)h2 � (�?/c ��� /.+?M14X/&1>�_5�r�5Jc/&�*:h>Yat

�/ @ ! ���

/ �@ �� X3&U'4& 7O5"'4&67O5"'u(�*+*ZX/5�rs5"*+5"["5"23h ,�5�.:?a1m�_&6XP(y$�&

�� �

! � , @, �@ $ � � � / @/ �@ $ � ' ( � K�W � �

! � ,6@, �@ $ ��� � / @/ �@ $ � ' ( � K�jH��� �

! � ,6@, �@ $ ��� � / @/ �@ $ � ' ( � KyBL� �! � ,6@, �@ $ ��� � / @/ �@ $ � ' � � K�� �

��5�� 0U5�?/h4.+c/&U'>1)X3&Aho1)&�*:*;(<' h`14'42/0 1)2/'`&@&2992/(<1).+5"?/hu.:?w1)X3&67O5�'4r� � � 4 ,6@ � � � K� �( � K�\H�

� � � � � � � � � K� ! ��� �� � �� � K� �( � K�i �

�� � � � � � ���u� ! � � �= � � � ���;��� � K �H�

K,K

Page 12: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

5q?v1)X3&u=_9�! � K�\H�A � &uXP(y$"& (�h4h`2/r�&Ucv1)XP(<1 � � ,6@�! 1�35476�� � ( �uX/.:0 X�.:h (h`2���0U.:&�?a1(<,/,/'45yfJ.:rs(<14.:5"?v.:?v1)X3&%'4&�[".:5�?s.+? �uX/.+0 X�� c/'45�,/h 145R?/&�["*:.+[".:Y/*+&_$<(�*:23&UhU!�5q?a14'459c/2/0 n.+?/[ 1)X/&6&29�!\� �D �D2KyxH�_.:?a1)5 14X/&A=_9�!\��i �Z�_&A&y(<h4.:* t�5"YJ1 (�.+?�7O5"' 1)X/&6&gf3,�5"?/&�?a1)h

� � ! � � .�� � ( � � ! � � .�� � � � K �H�t &m?35F� .+?a1)&U[�')(<14&b14X/&H=�9�!(� K�\H� 5�$�&U'�1)X/&dh4X/&�*:*u7O'45"r � � 1)5 � (�?3c 0 X/595"h4& � �h`2���0U.+&U?a1)* t *;(�'`["&U' 1)X/(�? / @R1)XP(�1�� � � � � / @���� � �N��� � / @d�A_(�?/c M/?/c 7O'`5"r 1)X3&=�9�!\� Ky\H� 1)XP(�1

� ��� � / @�� ! ��� � � � / @�� .�� �� ��� � 4 ,6@ � � � K � �3� � 4 ,6@

/ @ � �� � ��� ( � W�xH�

�u. 1)X � ! / @� �9!m5 7B� &Rc/5s1)X/&Ah)(�r�&@7O5�' (<?/5�1)X3&U'%r�59c/&U*8�u. 1)X�,�@ /� � � &�M/?/c7O5�' 1)X/&6,/'`&Uh4h`2/'4&@(<1u1)X3&AX35"rs5�*:5"["5�2/h_'4(�c/.:23h!���

� � � � � � / �@ � 4 ,��@/ �@ � �� � � ��� ! 4 ,��@

/ �@ � ,��@,6@ $ � � � / �@/ @ $ � ' � �� � ��� ( � W1KF�

�uX3&U'4&w14X/&w=�9�!P� K�W �6XP(�h Y�&U&�?�.+?a1)'459c/2/0�&Uc .:?a145m1)X/&w.+?a1)&U[�')(�*�!�^_5�rs,P(<'4.:?3[d1)X3&=�9�!\� W<xH�Z�u.+14Xb14X/&A=_9�!\��W1KF� t9.:&�*:c/h

����� � / @d� � ,����� �@ / � '� �@ ( � W"W �

(<?/cd. 7 �_&A0U5"r�,P(�'`& 1)X/.+h �u.+14XM14X/&A=�9�! � K�xH�A �_&(MP?/c� � ! � � . K ( � & ! � & K8� � W�jH�

� X3&wh)(�r�&w,/'4590U&�c/2/'`&w0y(�? Y�&w0y(�'`'4.:&�c�5"231 23h4.:?3[H1)X/&w&2992/(<1).+5"?/h:� K�i K �H�g!��P5"'14X/&I.+?a1)&U[�')(<14.:5"? .:? 1)X/&�M/'4h`1R0y(�h`&�� &w(�[a(�.+? 0 X35J5"h`& � � h`2���0U.+&U?a1)* t 7�(<'R5"2314h4.+c/&3�uX3&U'4&v1)X3&�14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4& .+hAh`rI(<*:*�0�5"rs,/(�'4&�c 145d. 1)h $<(�*+2/&Uh6.:? 1)X3&�h`X/&U*+*��S7O5"' 1)X3&.+?a1)&U[�')(<14.:5"? 5�7614X/& =_9�!v� K �H� � & 1)(3��& � � ! / @uP�uX/&U'`& 14X/& *:590y(�* *:2/r�.:?35"h4. 1qt$<(�?3.:h4X3&UhU!�t &1)X/&�?d5"YJ1 (�.+?

�OB ��A��� � ! � � .�� � � .�� � ( � W<BL���B ��A��� & ! � & .�� � & .�� & K ( � W"� �

� � ! 4�� � .���� � ( � W�\H�� & ! 4�� & .���� & . j�� � W"i �

K�W

Page 13: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

� X3&6=_9e2P(�1).:5�?/hv� K � PW�jD/W<B�/W"� PW<\D�W"i �;/(�'`& � *:.+?/&y(<'_.:?3X/5"r�5"["&U?3&U5"2/h_(�*:[�&UY/'4(�.:0&29e2P(<1).+5"?/h>7O5"'>1)X3& � & fJ,�5"?/&�?e14h%.+?b14X/&A=_9e2P(�1).:5�?/h�� �D �D2K�x 2K KF� ! � X/&Ah45"*+231).+5"?/h(<'4&

� � ! � �B�.���.��� ( � & ! �* �\�.���.��

� ( � W �H�� � ! K ( � & ! K ( � � ! � � . K (� & ! � & K ( � � ! � . 4�� � ( � & ! j� �� .�4�� & (�u. 1)X � ! K�.�4 . �P!�=�9e2P(<14.:5"?3h ��W �H��(�*+*:5���2/h�1)5Ac/&�14&U'`rs.+?/& 1)X/&>$<(�'`.;(<14.:5"?/h�5�7

14X/&%,3Xet9h`.:0y(<* 9e2P(�?a14.+1).+&Uh 7O'45"r 5"?3& r�5Jc3&U* ��0 XP(<')(�0 1)&U'`. ��&UcwYat�,6@u / @���145 (�?/5�14X/&U'�O0 XP(�'4(�0�14&U'4.S�U&�c Yet , �@ / �@ �g! � X/&m14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&m(�?/c 1)X3&H*:590y(�*u*+2/rs.+?/5"h`.+1qt (<1X35"rs5�*:5"["5�2/h ,�5".:?a1)h $<(�'otM(�h

� ,����@ / � '@ ! ,6@/ @ ( � W �H�

� , ��� = � �@ / � � � � = � '@ � ��j"xH�

� X3.:h�X35"*:c/h�7O5"'�(<*:*eX/5"r�5"*:5�["5"2/hS,�5".:?a1)h2"(�*+h45�7O5"'�14X/&_2/,3,�&�'�Y�5�'4c/&�'�5�7P14X/&_'4(�?/["& 5�7.+?a1)&U[�')(<14.:5"?v�uX/&U'`& ! 0>! � X3&U'4& 7O5"'4& 14X/& *+2/rs.+?/5"h`.+1qt5�7P14X/&Uh`&>h4X/&�*:*Jh45"2/'`0U& r�59c/&U*c3&U,�&U?/c/hv5"?", @R(�?3c�5"?�1)X/&�r�59c/&�5�7�&U?3&U'4[<t�["&U?3&U')(�1).:5�?-! �%hv(�?�.+*:*:23h`1)'4(<1).+5"?(<h4h423rs& �-! � ! x��O&U*+&U0�14'45"?sh40U(<1414&U'4.+?/[L��(�?/c ��! K�j ( 4�! W � ^�� # 0 t90U*:&R�Ae1)X/&�?� � ! %j�(�?/c � & ! i ��jD/h`5�14XP(<1>1)X3&A*+2/r�.:?/5"h`.+1qts.:h>[". $"&�?dYat

0 � , I@ / � ��� � �@ � ��jDKF�

� U�� � Y ��� b�]_r e ` ��]�DY� h%1)X3& X/&U*+.:2/r 0U5�'4& ["'`5��uh .:?Hrs(�h`h YatHXat9c/'45"[�&U? Y/2/'`?/.:?/[I.:?m14X/& h4X/&�*:*�5"231)h`.:c/&. 1R . 1I0�5"?a1).+?923&UhI145�0U5�?e14')(�0 1Ru*:.+Y�&�')(<14.:?/[ ["'4(y$J. 1 (<14.:5"?/(�* &U?3&U'4[<t"! ^_5"?3h4&�9e2/&�?a1)*+t14X/&61)&Ur�,�&U')(�1)2/'`&Uh%.+?b14X/&A0U5"'`& (�?/cb1)X/&Ah4X3&U*:*S["5s5"?m'`.:h`.:?/[��(<0U0U&�*:&�')(<14.:?/[ 7O2/'o1)X/&�'14X/&R'4(<1)&@5�7�14X/&RXat9c/'45�["&U?�Y/23'4?/.+?/[�(�?3cH0U5"'`&R["'`5��>1)X-! � X/& ?/&�&Ucm145I1)'4(�?/ho7O&U' (<?.+?/0U'`&y(�h`.:?/[ &�?/&U'`[�t �P2Jf�5�? 14X/&b5"?/&wXP(�?3c8 (�?3c�14X/&M.:?/0�'4&y(<h4.:?3[ 5�,P(�0U. 1qt 5�7�1)X3&0�5J5�*-&U?a$"&�*:5",�&A5"?b14X/&65�1)X3&U'uXP(�?/cfP0y(�2/h`&A14X/&6&U?a$"&�*:5",�&61)5vY�&�0U5"r�&60U5"?a$�&U0�14.+$�&U*+t23?/h`1)(�Y/*:&<!���&U?/0�&�'`&Uc [".:(�?a1)h�c3&�$"&�*:5", 0�5"?a$"&�0�1). $"&u&U?a$�&U*:5�,�&�h�e& f91)&�?/c/.+?/[7O'45"r K`2/ho15�231)h`.:c/& 1)X/&�Xat9c/'45"[�&U? Y/23'4?/.+?/[ h`X/&U*+*9(�*:*"14X/&V�_(yt61)5u1)X/&�h`14&U*:*:(�'Sh42/'o7�(�0U&<! � X/& YP(�h`&5<7>1)X/&�0�5"?a$"&�0�1). $"&w&�?e$�&U*+5",�&�h '4&U(�0 X/&Uh *:(yt"&U'`h7�uX/&�'4&�?e2/0�*:&y(<' Y/2/'`?/.:?/[m,/'4590U&�h4h4&�h

Kyj

Page 14: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

X/(�$�&w1 (3�<&U?�,/*;(�0�&�&y(<'4*:.+&U' (<?/c 1)Xe2/hvXat9c/'45"[�&U?�Y/2/'4?3.:?/[ (�h`X/&Uhvrs(3��&�14X/&U.+'�� (yt145I1)X3& h`14&U*:*:(�'�h42/'o7�(�0U& (<?/cm1)X3&�tdrI(3�<&R1)X3&U.:' ,/'4&�h4&�?/0U&-�e?/5��u?�1)X/'`5"2/["Xmh4,�&U0�14')(�*h`.:["?/(<1)2/'`& 7O'45"r�1)X/&6h`14&U*+*;(�' ,3X/5�1)5�h4,/X/&�'4&<! � X/.+h>,/'4590U&�h4h�.:h>0U(�*:*+&UcMc/'4&�c/["&gnq2/,-!

� X/&uho1)'4230�1)23'4&u5�7�h42/0 Xs(h`1)(�'B�u.+14Xv(60�5"?a$"&�0�1). $"&�5"2314&U'�'4&�[".:5�? .:hB� &U*+*P(�,/,/'`5yf9n.+rI(�1)&Uc�Yet�1)X/&M� (�t"(�h4X3. 1)')(<0u� (�?/c�14X/&wh`1)(�' ?/5�� & $"5"* $"&�hs(<*:5"?/[d1)X/&M� (�t"(�h4X3.14')(�0u��! 5q? 1)X/&s� &�'`1���h4,/'`2/?/[<nq{�23h4h4&�* c/.:(�["')(<r 1)X3&Uh4&sh`1)(�'4hR(�'4&vh)(<.:c 145d0�*:.+r Y 2/,14X/&wh4*:(�?a1)&�c�'`&U[�[".:(�?a1 Y/'4(�?/0 X�1)5��_(�'4c X/.+["X/&U'R*:2/r�.:?/5�h4.+14.:&�hR(�?3c�h`*:.+["Xa1)*+t *+5F� &U'&��Z&�0�14.+$"& 14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&�hU! � X/& '`&Uc�[".:(�?a1%Y3')(�?/0 X .+?m1)X/& � &U'o1���h4,/'`2/?/[<nq{�2/h`h4&�*�c/. n(<["')(�r '45�2/["X/* tm0�5".:?/0�.:c/&�h��u.+14XH1)X/&vY�5"2/?/cP(<'`tH5<7�14X/&v�%(yt"(�h4X/.�7O5"'`Y/.:c3c/&U?���5"?/&�!� X3&%h`1)(�'�c/5J&�h_?/5<1_,/'`&U0�.:h4&�*+t 7O5"*+*:5�� 14X/& �%(yta(�h`X/.�14')(�0u�x9h4.+?/0U&�1)X/&�X/&U*+.:2/r 0�5"'4&�.:h0�&U?a1)'4(�*:* tm.+h45�14X/&U'`rI(<* !@=�$�&U?a1)2/(�*:* t -1)X3&�0�5"'4& 14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4& Y�&U0�5"r�&Uhh42 �s0�.:&�?e14*+tX3.:["Xw7O5"'>X/&�*:.+2/r�145s.+["?/. 1)&�!

� ��� ��� � ���RR��� ��������U���

^_5�'4&wX/&�*:.:23r .+["?/. 1).:5�? .+h 5"?/&w5�7>14X/&wr�5"h`1 c3')(�rs(<1).+0I(<?/c �_5�?/c/&U'o7O2/*>&�$�&U?a1)h�.:?ho1)&�*:*;(<'s& $"5"*+231).+5"?-! ld5�h`1w.+rs,�5"'`1)(�?a1)* t _. 1�h`&U,P(�'4(<1)&�h�1)X/&mX/.:["X�7O'45"r *:5�� rs(�h4hho1 (�'`h_.+?�(v�_(yts14XP(<1 c/&U,�&U?3c/h>5"?s14X/&%&29e2P(<1).+5"?�5�7-h`1 (�1)&�!�� X/.+["XIrs(�h4h h`1)(�'�L�u.+14X?35"?Jnqc3&U["&�?/&U'4(<1)&X/&�*:.+2/r 0U5"'`&3/.+h_7�(�.:'`*+t�X/5�1>(<1 1)X3&%1).+rs& .+1)h_Xet9c/'`5"["&�?b0�5"'4& 142/'4?3h5 ��! ^_5"?a1)')(<0�1).+5"?�c/59&Uh?/5<16XP(y$"& 1)5M.:?30U'4&U(�h4& 14X/& 1)&�rs,�&U'4(<1)23'4& 5"' c3&U?/h`.+1qtH$�&U'`t7�(<'Y�& 7O5"'4& 14X/&v0U5"'`& '4&y(<0 X/&Uh61)X/&v0�&U?a1)'4(�*�1)&�rs,�&U'4(<1)2/'`&v5�7 (�Y�5�231 K�x��u��'4&29923.:'4&�c7O5�'%1)'`.:["["&�'4.+?/[s14X/& 1)'`.:,/*+&�� '`&y(�0 1).+5"?-!R8J.:?/0�&R1)X3& 0U5"'`& .:h ?3&y(�'`*+td.:h45<1)X/&�'4rs(�*�(�?3c0 X3&Ur�.:0y(<*:*+t%X/5"r�5"["&�?/&U5"23h��1)X/&�'4&U(�0�14.:5"?61)XP(�1�ho1 (�'o1)h�.:?61)X/&�0U&�?a1)&U'�')(�,3.:c/* t &U?3["2/*+7Oh14X/&O�uX/5"*:&A0U5�'4&@(�?/cd14X/&R.+?/0U'`&y(�h`&@.+?d&�?/&U'`[�tb'4&�*:&y(<h4&Rho1)5",3h�14X/&R0�5"'4&A0U5"?a14')(�0 1).:5�?14X/'45�2/["X/5"2J1y! � X/&Hh`1)(�'I'`&y(�cFK`2/h`14h�.+14hsho1)'4230�1)23'4&H5"? 1)X/&dc3t9?P(�r�.:0y(<*u14.:r�&Uh`0y(�*+&3Y�&U0U(�2/h`&s1)X3&s&�?e$�&U*+5",�&s.:h60U5�?e$�&U0 1).+$�&w(�?/c 9e2/.:0u�e* t '4&y(<0 X/&Uh Xat9c/'`5"h`1)(<1).+0s&29923.:*:.+YJn'`.:2/rb! � X/& *+2/r�.:?/5"h`.+1qt@,/'459c/2/0�&UcsYetR1)X/&u1)'`.:,/*+&�H'4&U(�0�14.:5"?�.:h�X/.+["X�(�?/c�'4&U(�0�14.:5"?/hY�&U[�.:? .:? (�r�5"'4&w5"' *+&Uh`h .:c/&U(�* [a(�h &�?a$J.+'45"?3rs&�?e1U! � X/&b0U5"'`&wXP(�h 1)Xe2/h 1 (<,/,�&�c( *;(<'4["&�?3&2� &�?/&U'`[�t h45"23'40U&��uX/.+0 X h`145",/h�.+14h ')(�,/.+c 0U5"?a1)'4(�0�14.:5"?f_(�?3c�14X/&dho1 (�'(<[a(�.:? '`&y(�0 X3&Uhd( ho1 (�[�& 5<7R0�5"rs,3*:&�14& �O14X/&U'`rI(<*(�?/c XatJc3'45"ho1 (<14.:0���&29923.:*:.+Y/'4.+2/rb!� X3&m&�$�5"*:2J1).:5�? .:h 9e2P(�*+.+1 (�1).+$�&U* t�h4.+rs.+*;(�'R7O5�'I(�*+*>h`1)(�'4hs.:? �uX3.:0 X ��&mY/2/'`?/.:?3[�.:h.+["?/. 1)&UcmY�& 7O5"'4&R14X/& 0�5"'4& Y�&U0�5"rs&�h c/&�["&U?/&�')(<14&�! � X/.:h.+?/0U*+2/c/&�h h`14&U*:*:(�'�rI(�h`h4&�h5�7h4(yt W �]� ,1G �$, � K�x ,1G�! � &�'`1N�Uh4,3'42/?/[�n {u2/h4h`&U*>c/.:(�["')(<r �u.+1)X�&�$"5�*:2314.:5"?P(<'`t14')(�0u�eh�7O5"'�h`1 (<'4h�.:? 14X/& rs(�h4h�'4(�?/["& 7O'45"r BL,1G�1)5�� ,1G �7O'`5"r 14X/&>rs(�.:?Jn h4&29923&U?/0�&14X/'45�2/["XMX/&U*+.:2/r�Y/2/'`?/.:?/[v.+h>h4X/5��u?m.+?w1)X/&A��.+[/! ��W � !

KUB

Page 15: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

��.:["2/'`&W �� &U'o1���h4,/'`2/?/[<nq{�2/h`h4&�*�c/.;(�[�')(�r �u.+14Xw&�$�5"*:2314.:5"?/(�'`tv1)'4(�0u�eh 7O5"'_ho1 (�'`h>.:?14X/&%rs(�h`h '4(�?/["&�7O'45"r BL,6Gd1)5 �H,1G 97O'45"r 14X/&%rs(�.:?9nqh4&29e2/&U?/0�& 14X/'45"23["X�X/&�*:.:23rY32/'4?/.+?/[/! � X/& Y/'`5 ��&�?�*:.:?3&@.+?/c/.:0U(<1)&�h�14X/&v^_&�,/X/&U.+c�h`14'4.:,Z! � X/.+h MP["23'4&R.+h 1)(3��&�?7O'`5"r �.+,/,�&�?/XP(�X3? � K � �"xH�g!

�mU�T � Y\^�bpg ��^�]���p�5�� rs(�h4h h`1 (<'4h��h42/0 X (<h8J2/?fZc/5�?35�1 &gf3,�&U'`.:&�?/0U& h`2/0 X (�9e2/.+&�1 .:["?/. 1).+5"?M5�7 X/& n*+.:2/r 0U5�'4&�Y/2/'4?3.:?/[/! � X/& t (�'4&v0�5J5"*+&U'��uX/&�? 14X/&U.+'0U5"'`&�Xat9c/'`5"["&U? .:h6& fJXP(<2/h`14&Uc(<?/c�h45"r�&2�uX/(<1r�5"'4&@0U&U?a14')(�*+*+tb0U5"?3c/&U?/h`&Uc Y�&�0y(�23h4&v5�7�1)X3& *:5�� &U' '`5"*:&@5�7�')(�c/.:(�n14.:5"?M,/'`&Uh`h42/'`&R.:?M1)X3&U.:'u.+?e14&U'`?P(�*�h`14'42/0 1)2/'`&�! � *+14X/5"2/["Xw14X/&�tbXP(y$"&A.:?3.+1).:(<1)&�cb^�� #Y32/'4?/.+?/[b.:? (M14X/.:? h4X3&U*:*�h`2/'4'`5"2/?/c3.:?/[M1)X/&�0U5�'4&�c/2/'4.+?/[w1)X/&�.:'A(�h`0U&U?a1@1)5M1)X/&v'4&�c[�.;(�?a1 Y/')(�?30 X8-*:.S��&A1)X/&@X/.:["XmrI(�h`h%ho1 (�'`h�Z14X/.:h�.:h%(�*:h`5I& fJXP(<2/h`14&Uc ')(�,/.+c/*+t�! � X3&U.:'0�5"'4&�h 0U5�?e14.:?e2/&�1)5 0�5"?a1)')(<0�1y! � X3& 0U5"'`&%c/&�?/h4. 1qtI0�'45"h`h4&�h_1)X/& 1)X/'`&Uh4X35"*:cI7O5�' ,P(<'`1).:(�*c3&U["&�?/&U'4(�0�t3Zc/&�h4,/. 1)&61)X/&@X/.:["XM1)&�rs,�&U'4(<1)23'4&3�Y�&�7O5"'`&A14X/&A0U'4. 1).+0y(�*Z14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&A.:h'`&y(�0 X3&UcM7O5"'>0U5"'`&X/&U*+.:2/r�.:["?3.+1).+5"?�(<?/cMY�&�0U5"r�&Uh>,/'`5"["'`&Uh4h`.+$�&U*+t�rs5"'`&c/&U[�&U?/&�')(<14&(<h614X/&�0U5"?a1)'4(�0�14.:5"? 0U5�?e14.:?e2/&�hU! " *+14.:rs(<1)&�*+t �1)X/.+hAh`*:5��uh1)X/&�0U5�?e14')(�0 1).+5"?8SY/231@.+1r�&y(<?/h�1)X/(<1�1)X3&_1)X/&�'4r�5JcJtJ?/(�rs.+0_&�?e$9.+'45"?/r�&U?a1�.+h�?/5<1�1)XP(�1�5�7�(�? .+c/&y(�*J[a(�h�(�1�1)X3&r�5"r�&U?a1�5<7�0U5"'`& X/&U*+.:2/r .:[�?/.+14.:5"?-! � Xe2/h�14X/&>*:5�� rs(�h4h�h`1 (<'4h �u. 1)X c/&�["&U?/&�')(<14&>X/& n*+.:2/r 0�5"'4&>.+["?/. 1)&UhS1)X3& X/&U*+.:2/r �uX/&�? 1)X/&>0�5"'4&_14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4& '4&U(�0 X/&Uh K�x��u�L(�?/c 1)X3&0�5"'4&RrI(�h`h .:h�,6@ � x��zBe� ,6G�!6� 5�� &�$"&�'��1)X3& � & Y32/'4?/h6(�1%1)X3& 0U5"'`& & fJ,/*+5"h4. $"&U* t"!� X3.:hv.:hvY�&U0y(<2/h4&��uX/&U?�1)X/&M?e2/0�*:&y(<'�'`&y(�0 1).+5"?/h�(�'4&w14'4.:[�["&U'`&Uc .:? 7O2/*:* t�c3&U["&�?/&U' n(�1)&brI(<1`1)&�'� 14X/&b.:?/0�'4&y(<h4&m.+?�14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&bc/59&Uh�?/5�1s*:&U(�c 145�( 0U5"'`'4&Uh`,�5�?/c/.:?3[.+?/0U'`&y(�h`& .:?�,/'`&Uh`h42/'`&l��(�h%1)X3& &�9e2P(<14.:5"? 5�7�h`1)(<1)& � � ��� � � c35J&�h?/5�16c/&�,�&�?/c 5�?14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&R� ! � X/&%rI(<14&U'`.;(�*P1)X3&U'4& 7O5"'4&0U(�?/?/5<1 & fJ,P(<?/cb(�?/cw0U595"*�! � X/& .+?/0U'`&y(�h`&.+?�14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4& (�0�0U&U*+&U'4(<1)&�h�14X/& '`&y(�0 1).+5"?s'4(<1)& �uX/.+0 XI.:?v1)23'4?I.+?/0U'`&y(�h`&Uh�1)X/&u1)&�rvn

K��

Page 16: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

,�&U'4(<1)23'4&3e(<*:*L�u.+1)X35"231 ( c3t9?P(<rs.+0y(�*9'4&U(�c K`2/ho1)r�&U?a1 5�7�1)X/&>0�5"'4&_c/2/& 1)5?350 XP(�?/["&�h.+?H1)X/&v,/'`&Uh`h42/'`&�! � X/&v'4&Uh`2/*+16.+h6(�1)X/&�'4r�5"?e2/0U*+&y(�''`2/?P(R� (yt�!wtL. 1)X/.+? (�7O&2� h`&U0gn5�?/c/h�/14X/& 1)&�rs,�&U'4(<1)23'4&'4.+h4&�h>h`1)&�&U,/* tM(<1�(�*+rs5�h`1 0�5"?/ho1 (�?a1�c/&U?3h4.+1qtw(�?/cw1)X/&*+5J0U(�*?e2/0�*:&U(�'6,�5�� &U'A'4&y(<0 X/.:?/[d(�Y�5"231 K�x � � 0_G ��'45�2/["X/* t �1)X/&v*+2/rs.+?/5"h`.+1qtd5�7>(�? &U?a14.:'4&["(�*;(�f9tD� ! ��5��_& $"&U'2u(�? 5"2314h4.:c3&b5�Y/h4&�'`$"&�' � 5"2/*+c ?35�1vY�&b(R�_(�'4&b5�7�1)X/&M.:?a14&U?/h`&0�&U?a1)'4(�*�&gfJ,/*:5"h`.:5"?f�(<h%.+1 .:h (�*+rs5"ho1�&U?a1).+'4&U* t:9923&U?/0 X/&�c YetM14X/& &U?3&U'4[<tm(<Y/h45"'`Y/.:?3[ho1)&�*:*;(<' &�?e$�&U*+5",�&<! � Xe2/h�Z14X/&U'`& .:h ?/5w(�,3,P(�'4&�?a10U*+2/&R.+?m1)X/&R� &�'`1���h4,/'`2/?/[<nq{�23h4h4&�*c3.;(�["'4(�r 1)5H1)X3&d��& ��(�h`X-! 8J595"?8�1)X3&w0U5"'`&M14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&wY�&U0�5"r�&Uh h42 �s0�.:&�?e14*+tX3.:["XM7O5"'u1)X/&Ac/&U[�&U?/&�')(�0 td145IY�&@*+.+7�1)&�c8P1)X/&A,/'`&Uh4h`2/'4&Rh42/c/c3&U?/* td.+?/0U'`&y(�h`& (�?3cd1)X3&0�5"'4&6'4(�,/.:c3*+ts& fJ,P(�?/c3h%(�?3cb14X/&6X/&U*+.:2/r�Y/2/'4?3.:?/[vY�&U0U5�rs&�h�ho1 (�Y3*:&�!

� X/.+h .:hR14X/&wX/&�*:.:23r �P(�h4X8�(H?e2/0�*:&y(<' ,/'4590U&�h4h 1)XP(�1 .:h h`,�&�0U.sMP0�1)5�*+5F��rs(�h4hho1 (�'`hU!�. 1_.+h .+rs,�5"'`1)(�?a1 1)5R?35�1)&�1)XP(<1 1)X/& 0U5"'`&%c/&�["&U?3&U')(<0�ts.:h�?/5�1 23?/. 9e2/&�1)5@14X/&Uh`&ho1 (�'`h�/?35"'_.+h_.+1_2/?/.S9923&%1)5R14X/.:h h`1)(�["& 5�7S& $"5"*+231).+5"?-!�= (�0 XM?e2/0�*:&y(<' 7O2/&�*Z0y(<?w.:["?/. 1)&23?/c/&U'Mc/&�["&U?3&U')(�1)& 0U5"?3c/.+14.:5"?/hs7O5"'�,/'`5"["'4&�h4h`.+$"&�*+t r�5"'`&HrI(<h4h4. $"&�ho1 (�'`hwY�&�0y(�2/h`&5<7A14X/&H0�5"2/*:5�r Y YP(�'`'4.:&�'U! 5q? (�c/c3.+1).+5"?8 14X/&H1)&�rs,�&U'4(<1)2/'`&Hc/&�,�&�?/c/&U?30U& (�?/c��$<(�*+2/&A5�7 h42/0�0U&�h4h4. $"&vh`1)(�["&�h%5�7 ?e2/0�*:&U5�h`t9?a1)X/&�h4.:h0U(�2/h`&Uh 1)X3&R'423?P(R� (ytH'`&y(�0 1).+5"?d145Y�&U0�5"r�&I,/'`5"["'4&�h4h`.+$"&�*+t r�5"'4&v$9.:5"*+&U?a1y! � X/&IX3&U*:.+2/r ��(�h`X�.:hAc/.:h`'42/,J1).+$�&IY/2J1 ?/5�10U(<1 (<h`1)'`5",/X/.+0�!B5q?v0�5"?a1)')(<h`1R90y(<'4Y�5"?vY/2/'4?3.:?/[60y(<?sY�&U[".+?v2/?/c/&�' h`.:r�.:*;(<'4*+t623?/h`1)(�Y/*:&0�5"?/c/. 1).+5"?/h�aY3231 .+1 0U(�?v*:&y(<cv1451)X/&u& fJ,/*+5"h4.+5"?v5�7�1)X/&uh`1)(�'U! � X/&�rs5"ho1 h4,�&U0 1 (�0�2/*;(�'&gf3(�rs,3*:&�5�7 1)X3&s1)X3&U'4r�5"?e2/0�*:&y(<'@'`2/?P(R� (yt�.:hO�uX/&U?�14X/&I'`&y(�0 1).+5"?/hRY�&U[�.:?�5�? 1)X3&h`2/'`7�(<0U&w5�7 (Hh`1)(�'���uX/&�'4&�14X/&w5�$"&U'`*+t9.:?3[�rI(�h`h .:h@?/5�1�(y$<(�.:*:(�Y/*:& 145�0U5"?a1 (<.:? 1)X3&&gfJ,/*:5"h`.:5"?s?/5"'�1)5 c/. �Z23h4&%14X/&%'4(�c/.;(�1).:5�?-! � X/.+h_.+h 1)X3&%0y(<h4& �u. 1)X���nq')(yt�?/5�$<(�&(�?3c,�&U'`XP(�,/hu[a(<rsrs( ')(ytwY/23'4h`14hU!

� 7O')(�0 1).:5�?s5�7�1)X/& '4&�c�[".;(<?e14h�eX/5�� &�$"&�'�Pc/5@?/5�1_(<141)(�.:?�X/&�*:.:23r .:["?3.+1).+5"?-! � X/.:h.+h�c/2/& 145 1)X/&>&��Z&�0�1 5�7�rs(�h4h�*+5"h4h�1)XP(<1�0 XP(�')(<0�1)&�'4.S�U&Uh�14X/&>'4&�c�[�.;(�?a1�ho1 (�[�&�! + 2/'`.:?/['`&Uc�[".;(<?e1 ,3XP(�h4&Q+�uX3&U?s14X/&uh`14&U*:*:(�'�&�?e$�&U*+5",�&�.:h�0�5"?/h`.:c/&�')(�Y/* t *:&�h4h ["'4(�$9. 1 (<14.:5"?P(<*:*+tY�5"2/?3cd1)X/(�?d.+?b14X/&ArI(�.+?Jnqh`&�9e2/&�?/0U&A,/XP(�h`&3P1)X3&@ho1)&U*+*;(�' �u.+?/cm.+?a1)&U?3h4.SM/&UhU!_� &�?/0U&Q*+5�� rs(�h`h '4&�c [�.;(�?a1)h%*:5"h`&R1)X/&�.:' h`rI(<*:*�&U?a$"&�*:5",�&Uh6Y�&�7O5"'`& 1)X/& 0�5"'4& X/(�h6(�0 XP(�?/0�&145 '4&U(�0 X h42 �s0�.:&�?e14*+t X/.:[�X 1)&�rs,�&U'4(<1)2/'`&m'`&�9e2/.:'`&Uc 7O5"'sX/&U*+.:2/r 145 .:[�?/.+14&�! � X3&c3&U["&�?/&U'4(<1)& X/&U*+.:2/r 0�5"'4&�0U5�?e14.:?e2/&�h . 1)h 0U5"?a14')(�0 1).:5�?�(�?/c�h423Y/h4&29923&U?a1)* t�*:&U(y$"&Uh 1)X3&'`&Ucb[".;(<?e1uY3')(�?/0 XM1)5vY�&U0�5"rs&6X/&�*:.+2/r �uX/. 1)&cD�_(�'o7 !

Ky\

Page 17: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

� � ���RR��� ��������U� � y� � � � �u� ���

� X3& ,/XP(�h`& 5�7�ho1 (�Y3*:&%X3&U*:.+2/r Y/2/'`?/.:?3[ .:?�1)X/& ho1)&�*:*;(<'�0�5"'4&%.:h�h4.:[�?/.SMP0U(�?a1)* tvh4X/5"'o1)&�'14XP(�?I14X/&%rs(�.+?Jnqh`&�9e2/&U?30U&%,3XP(�h4&%5�7�0U5�'4&%Xat9c/'`5"["&U?wY32/'4?/.+?/[/! � X3& '4&U(�h45"?s7O5"'�14X/.:h.+h 1>�_5v7O5"*+c � 14X/&%7O2/h`.:5"?I5�7SX/&U*+.:2/r .+?e145R0U(�'4Y�5"?M(�?/cI5�f9t9["&�?bh`2/,/,/*+.:&�h 5"?/* tI(<Y�5"2J1 K��1Kyx<1)Xs5�714X/&6&U?/&�'4[�tM,�&U'>23?/.+1urs(�h4huh`2/,/,/*+.:&UcMYatw1)X3&AXat9c/'`5"["&U?M7O2/h`.:5"?8/(�?/c� 1)X/&@h`1)&�*:*:(�'u*:2/r�.:?/5�h4.+1qtI.:h�X/.:[�X/&U'�Yatmr�5"'4&14XP(�?�(�?d5"'4c3&U'%5<7�rI(<["?/.+142/c/&60U5�rvn,/(�'4&�c:�u. 1)Xw1)X/&6rs(�.:?9nqh4&29e2/&U?/0�&6*:2/r�.:?/5�h4.+1qts5�7�1)X/&6h4(�rs&ho1 (�'�!5q? 7�(�0 1RSX/&U*+.:2/r Y/2/'`?/.:?/[ � 5"2/*+c XP(y$�&sY�&U&�? ho1).:*+*�h`X/5"'`14&U'2\� &U'`&s. 17O5"' 1)X/&�(�c3c/. n14.:5"?/(�*�&�?/&U'`[�t�h45�2/'40�&s,/'`5�$J.+c/&Uc YatH1)X3&�Xat9c/'`5"["&U? Y/2/'`?/.:?3[b.+?�1)X/& h`X/&U*+*�5"231)h`.:c/&14X/&60U5"'`&�!

5q? *+5�� rI(<h4hbh`1 (<'4h ��x�� �H,1G 145 W ,6G �A��uX/.+0 X 2/?/c/&�'4["5 1)X/& X/&U*+.:2/r �P(�h4X814X/&mh`2/Y/h`&�9e2/&U?a1d')(�,3.:c &gfJ,P(�?/h`.:5"?L(�?3c 0U595"*:.+?/[ 5�7 1)X3&H0U5"'`&m*+&y(�c/h�1)5 c3&U0U'`&y(�h`&.+?�1)&�rs,�&U'4(<1)2/'`&.:?I14X/&6XatJc3'45"["&�?MY/2/'4?3.:?/[vh4X3&U*:*-(�?/c�1)X3&A?e2/0�*:&U(�' &U?3&U'4[<twh42/,3,/*+tc3.:r�.:?/.+h4X/&�hU! � X/.:h2 0U5"r Y3.:?/&�c �u.+1)X�14X/&wc/.:r�.:?3.:h4X3&Uc�ho1)&�*:*;(<' ')(�c3.:2/h2�0y(�2/h`&Uh 1)X3&*+2/r�.:?/5"h`.+1qt@1)5Ac/'45",I(�?/c�1)X/&�h`1)(�' .+h h4(�.:cv1)5@c/&Uh`0U&�?/c�7O'45"r 1)X/& '4&Ucs[".;(<?e1�Y/'4(�?/0 X-!89.:?/0�&v14X/&v&��&U0 1).+$�&�14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&vXP(<hA.+?/0U'`&y(�h`&Uc8S1)X3&sho1 (�'6r�5�$�&Uh61)5w1)X3&�*+&�7�1A.:?14X/& ��&U'o1��Uh`,/'423?/[<n {u2/h`h4&U*Zc/.;(�[�')(�rb! � X3& *:5�� &U' 14X/&%ho1)&�*:*;(<'�rs(�h`h�J14X/&%[�'4&y(�1)&U' 1)X3&'`&Uc/230�1).+5"?R.+?@. 1)h�*:2/r�.:?35"h4. 1qt%7O'45�r 1)X/&�Y�&�[".:?3?/.:?/[�5�7J1)X/& 0U5"'`& .+["?/.+14.:5"?145�14X/&_ho1 (�?Jnc/(�'4cHc35"2/Y/*+&@h`5"2/'40�& h`14'42/0 1)2/'`&�! � X/&Rho1 (�' ?/5�� XP(�h 1>� 5w?e2/0U*+&y(�'�Y/2/'`?/.:?3[a�U5"?3&Uh�14X/&M0U5"'`&b(�?/c ( h`X/&U*+*>h42/'`'45"23?/c/.:?3[ 14X/&M0U5"'`&b.+? �uX/.:0 X ^�� # ,3'4590U&Uh`h4.+?/[ 1)(3��&�h,3*;(�0�&�! � X/&Hr�5"ho1w.:r�,�5�'`1 (<?e1�0�5"?a1)'4.+Y/2314.:5"? 145�1)X3&�&U?/&�'4[�t ,/'459c/2/0 1).+5"? 0U5"r�&Uh7O'`5"r 14X/&dX3.:["X/* t &gf359&U'`[".:0MX/&�*:.+2/r 7O2/h`.:5"?-! � X/&bh`1)&�*:*:(�' *:2/r�.:?35"h4. 1qt�.+h�c3.:'4&�0�14*+t,3'45",�5"'`14.:5"?/(�*�145H1)X/&wX3&U*:.+2/r 0U5"'`&�rI(<h4h�Z,6@u�(�?3c�X3&U?/0�&bho1 (�'`h��u.+14X 1)X/&wh4(�rs&, @ &�$"&�? �u.+14X c/. �Z&�'4&U?a1s1)5�1)(�*urI(�h`ha, �u.:*:*uY�&d*+5J0U(<1)&�c .+? 1)X3&H� &�'`1N�Uh4,3'42/?/[�n{u2/h`h4&U*�c/.:(�["')(<r 5"?�(�? (�,3,/'45yfJ.:rs(<1)&�*+tmX/5"'4.S�U5"?a1)(�*�h`14'4.:,f�0U(�*:*+&Uc�1)X/&�X/5"'`. ��5"?a1 (�*Y3')(�?/0 XZ! � X/.+hX/5"'`. �U5�?e1)(�*�Y/')(�?30 X .+h(�X/5"'`. ��5"?a1 (�*�h`1)'`.:,Hho1)'`&�1)0 X3.:?/[MY�&�1>� &U&U? 1)X3&rs(�.+?Jnqh`&�9e2/&U?30U&u(�?/c 14X/&>'4&�c [".;(<?e1�Y/')(�?30 X8a0U5"'`'4&�h4,�5"?/c/.+?/[ 1)5*+2/rs.+?/5"h`.+1).+&Uh�5�7P1)X3&5�'4c/&�'�5<7�14X/&@��x 0_G 145 Kyx"x 0_G�! � X/&�'4&61)X/& tMcD�_&�*:*-7O5"'�(�Y�5"231 Kyx � t"&U(�'4h�! � *:*Z14X/&Uh`&ho1 (�'`hvXP(y$"&M&�9e2P(�*+*+t�rI(�h`h4. $"&M0U5"'`&M(<1 1)X3&b&�?/c�5�7 14X/&M'4&�c�[�.;(�?a1v,/XP(<h4&�! ��&U?/0�&14X/&U.+'sc3. ��&U'4&�?a1�,�5"h4. 1).:5�?/hI(<*:5"?/[ 1)X3&HX/5"'`. �U5�?e1)(�*uY/')(<?/0 X .:hsc/&�14&U'`rs.+?/&Uc Yat 1)X3&&�?a$"&U*+5",�&Ars(�h`hU! � X/&6X/.:[�X/&Uho1 &�?a$"&U*+5",�&Ars(�h`h4&Uh�(�'`&7O5"2/?/cb(<1u1)X3&'4&Uc1��h`.:?/0�&6*:5��&��Z&�0�14.+$"&@1)&Ur�,�&U')(�1)2/'`&�� &�?/c�5�7�1)X3& Y/')(<?/0 X8f�uX/&�'4&R14X/& Xat9c/'45�["&U? h4X3&U*:*�Y/2/'`?/.:?3[0�5"?a1)'`.:Y/2314&Uh�r�5"ho1�5�714X/&H&U?3&U'4[<t (�?/c 1)X/&H0�5"?a$"&�0�1). $"& &U?a$�&U*:5�,�& �khwho1)'4230�1)23'4&�.:hh`.:r�.:*:(�' 145d1)X/(<1A5�7_14X/&s'`&Uc [".;(�?a14hU!���'`5J0�&U&Uc3.:?/[b1)5�� (<'4c 14X/&�Y/*:2/&�&U?3c8 � & M/?/c

K�i

Page 18: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

h`rI(<*:*:&�'u&U?a$"&�*:5",�&Rrs(�h4h`&Uh(<?/c � &y(3�<&U' Xat9c/'45�["&U?�Y/23'4?/.+?/[Ih`X/&U*+*:hU! � X/& &�?a$"&U*+5",�&.+?w1)X/.+h>0y(�h`&@(<'4&6')(�c3.;(<14.+$"&%')(<14X/&U'>1)X/(�?d0�5"?a$"&�0�1). $"&<!

��.:["X rs(�h4h�ho1 (�'`h .:["?/. 1)& X/&U*+.:2/r 9e2/.:& 1)*+t37�uX/&�? 14X/&�0U&�?e14')(�* 14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&'`&y(�0 X3&UhA(�Y�5"231�Kyx��u� !�8J23Y/h4&29923&U?a1)* t S1)X/& '4(<1)&R5�7�&U?/&�'4[�tmh42/,/,3*+tHYatd1)X/& X/&�*:.+2/rY32/'4?/.+?/[b0U5"'`&sho1)&y(<c/.:* t .:?/0�'4&y(<h4&Uh2 �uX/.+*:& 1)X3&s'4(<1)&�5�7 &�?/&U'`[�t h42/,3,/*+t Yat 1)X/&�Xatanc3'45"["&�?�Y/2/'`?/.:?/[wh`X/&U*+*�c/&�0U'4&U(�h4&�hU! � h 1)X/&@1)&Ur�,�&U')(�1)2/'`& .:?H14X/& Y/2/'`?/.:?/[wh`X/&U*+*�(<114X/&HYP(<h4&�5�761)X3&H&U?a$"&�*:5",�& c/'45�,/h�u1)X/&m&U?a$"&�*:5",�&�0U595"*:h�1)595 (�?/c & $"&U?a142P(�*:* t �.+1ho1 (�'o1)h 0U5"?a1)'4(�0�14.:?/[3! � 1 1)X/.+h ,�5".:?a1�1)X/&@h`1)(�'4h *:&y(y$�&R1)X/&@'4&�cH[".;(<?e1 Y/'4(�?/0 XH.+?d1)X3&��&U'o1��Uh`,/'423?/[<n {u2/h`h4&U*�c/.;(�[�')(�r Yatd*:595",/.+?/[ 1)5�� (<'4cm14X/&RX/.+["X/&�' &��Z&�0�1). $"&A1)&Ur�,�&U'on(�1)2/'`&�!�� .+["X/&U' 14X/&6rI(<h4h�J1)X/&6r�5"'4&&gfJ14&U?/c3&Ucm14X/&6*:595",-!+ 2/& 145X/.:[�X 1)&Ur�,�&U')(�1)2/'`& h4&�?/h4. 1).+$9. 1qtR5�7�14'4.:,3*:& (<*:,/XP( '`&y(�0 1).+5"?8"X/&�*:.+2/r Y32/'4?Jn.+?/[w590U0U23'4hA.:? (w0U5"?a$�&U0�14.+$�&I0U5�'4&�!�895d*+5"?/[M(�h1)X3& .:?/?/&�'60U5"'`& .:h0U5�?e$�&U0 1).+$�&3�.+1)h0�5"r�,�5"h`.+14.:5"?�.+h>0U5"?3h`1 (<?e14*+twr�. fJ&�cM(�?/cM1)2/'`?/hu["')(�c32P(�*:* tv7O'45"r�X/&U*+.:2/r�1)5v0y(�'`Y�5�?(<?/cm5yf9t9["&U?8�&�$�&U?Jn 1)X/5�2/["X�X/&�*:.:23r Y/2/'`?/.:?/[D��uX/.:0 Xm$<(�'`.:&�h �u. 1)Xb1)&Ur�,�&U')(�1)2/'`&R(�h� � � .+h 0U5"? MP?/&Uc�145�.+1)h@$"&U'ot 0�&U?a1)&�'U!6tLX3&U?�1)X/&w.+?/?/&�' 0U5"?a$�&U0�14.+$�&b0�5"'4&wY�& n0�5"r�&Uh c/&U,3*:&�14&Ucs5�7ZX3&U*:.+2/r (�?3csX/&�?/0U&�Y/2/'`?/.:?3[v�u. 1)X/.+?�. 1 h42/Y3h4.:c3&Uh�90U5�?e$�&U0 1).:5�?I.:h9e2/&�?/0 X/&�c�(�h � &U*+* ! � X/&>h`1)(�'�0U5�?/h4.+h`1)h�5<7Z( 0U(�'4Y�5"?Jn 5yfJt9["&�? 0U5"'`&3ah`2/'4'`5"2/?/c/&�csYat (X3&U*:.+2/r *;(yt"&�'�n�'4&Ur�?P(�?a1 5�7�1)X3&�5�'4.:[�.:?P(�*9X/&�*:.:23r 0�5"'4&QL�uX3.:0 Xv.:? 1)23'4?v.:h�h`&U,P(�'4(<1)&�c7O'`5"r�14X/&6XatJc3'45"["&�?m'`.:0 XM&U?a$"&�*:5",�&AYetI1)X/&6Xat9c/'45"[�&U?mY32/'4?/.+?/[vh4X/&�*:*�!

� � �� � �m��� ���� � �� ��� ��� �R��� ��� � � � ����U����

�P5"*+*:5��u.:?3[�14X/& 0U&�?e14')(�*�& fJXP(�2/ho1).+5"?�5�7�X/&U*+.:2/r:�1)X/& ho1 (�' .+["?/. 1)&Uh�1)X/& X3&U*:.+2/r '4.+0 Xh`X/&U*+*"h423'4'45�2/?/c/.+?/[ 1)X/& 0U(�'4Y�5"?Jn 5�f9t9["&�?A0�5"'4& (<?/c6rs5�$"&�h�(�[a(�.+?%1)5��_(�'4c1)X3& � (yta(�h`X/.14')(�0u��! � X/&b&U?a$"&�*:5",�&d0�5"?a$"&�0�1).+5"? c3&U&U,�&U?3h�(�?/c�0y(<? Y/'`.:?/[�145 14X/&bh42/'o7�(�0U&w1)X3&,3'459c/2/0�14hu5�7�,3'4&�$9.+5"2/hu0U5"rRY/2/h`14.:5"?3h 7O'45"r 14X/&c/&�&U,m.+?a1)&U'`.:5"'�! � X/.+h�.+h 1)X/&h`&U0�5"?/c14.:r�&_1)X/(<1�*:5�� rs(�h`h�ho1 (�'`h h42���&U'�(6,/X/&U?35"rs&�?/5"?�?/5�� 0U(�*:*+&Ucvc/'4&�c/["&gnq2/,8a14X/&mMP'4ho1590U0�2/'4'`&Ucdc/2/'4.+?/[�Xet9c/'`5"["&�?Hh4X/&�*:*SY/2/'`?/.:?3[/! � X/&@h42/Y3h4&�9e2/&�?a16X/.:ho1)5"'otw5�7�14X/&@ho1 (�'.+h��(�h�(�*s� (yt9h�P[�5�$�&U'`?/&UcHYatw14X/&65",/,�5"h4. 1).:5�?w5�7�&�?/&U'`[�tM'4&�*:&U(�h4&AYat�7O2/h4.+5"?d(�[a(�.+?/h`1[�')(y$9.+1qt"! � X3&A0�&U?a1)'4(�*�X/&�*:.:23r .:h_0U5"?/h`2/r�&Ucd(�?/cw1)X/&6ho1 (�'>.+h>Y/2/'4?3.:?/[ X/&�*:.+2/r (�?3cXat9c/'`5"["&U?�.:? 1>�_5d0U5"?a1).+["2/5"23h@h`X/&U*+*:hU! tL.+14X 14X/&I&gf3X/(�2/h`14.:5"? 5�7 0�&U?a1)'4(�* X/&U*+.:2/r:14X/&�0U5�?e14'4.+Y/231).+5"? 5�761)'`.:,/*+& � 7O23h4.:5�? *;(�0u�ehMh42���0�.:&U?a1M*+2/rs.+?/5"h`.+1qt 1)5�rs(�.:?a1)(�.:?14X/&6XatJc3'45"ho1 (<14.:06h`14'42/0 1)2/'`&@5�7�1)X3&Aho1 (�'u(<?/cd&�?/&U'`[�tw.+h>h42/,/,3*:.:&�cdYatM( 0�5"?/h4&29e2/&U?a10�5"?a1)'4(�0�14.:5"?�(�?/c (<?�.:?30U'4&U(�h4&s5�7_14X/&I& ��0U.:&�?/0�t 5�7 Xet9c/'`5"["&�? h4X/&�*:*�Y/2/'`?/.:?/[3!a5q?14X/&���&U'o1��Uh`,/'423?/[<n {u2/h`h4&U*_c/.;(�[�')(�r 14X/.:hAr�&y(�?/hA1)XP(�1@14X/&Iho1 (�'A.:hA["5".+?/[dY/(�0u� 5�?

K �

Page 19: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

��.:["2/'`&�j� 5q?a1)&�'4?P(<*�ho1)'4230�1)23'4&�5�7-1)X3& ho1 (�'�5�7-'4(�c/.+2/h�{vH�uX/.+0 XI.:h�(�,3,/'45a(<0 X/.:?/[61)X3&(<h`t9rs,J1)5�14.:0[".:(�?a1>Y/')(<?/0 X-!

. 1)h�,/'4& $9.:5"2/h ,P(<14X8Z'`&�1)'4(�0U.+?/[�.+1)h h`14&U,/h 23,m1)X/&@[".;(<?e1�Y/'4(�?/0 XH145F�_(�'`cHc/&U0�'4&U(�h4.+?/[&��Z&�0�14.+$"& 14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4& (<?/c (�h40�&U?/c/.+?/[M,P(�'4(�*:*+&U*S1)5w1)X/&v� (yta(�h`X/.�1)'4(�0u��! � X/&vX/& n*+.:2/r h`X/&U*+*3Y/23'4?/.+?/[c/5"r�.:?P(�1)&Uh�5�$"&�'�1)X/& Xat9c/'`5"["&U?���^�� #O��h4X3&U*:*JY/2/'`?/.:?/[ (�?/c 1)X3&ho1 (�'R0U5"?a1).+?e2/&UhR14X/&�& $"5"*+231).+5"?�(�*+5"?/[d14X/&w(�hot9rs,3145�1).+0I[".:(�?a1RY3')(�?/0 Xf�.+?/0U'`&y(�h`.:?/[,3'45"["'`&Uh`h4.+$�&U* t .+? *+2/r�.:?/5"h`.+1qt�!�8914'42/0 1)2/'`&I5�7_1)X/&�h`1)(�'R(�1@14X/.:h6h`1)(�["&s.:hA(�hAh4X/5��u?.+? 1)X/&M��.:[/! ��jH�g! �%hot9rs,3145�1).+0w[".;(<?e1 Y/')(�?30 X�.+hv(�? & f91)&�?/h4.+5"?�5�7u1)X/&w'`&Uc�[".;(�?a1Y3')(�?/0 X 1)5��_(�'4c�14X/&MX/.:["X3&U' *+2/rs.+?/5"h`.+1).+&Uh@(�?/c *:5�� &U'v&��&U0 1). $"&w1)&�rs,�&U'4(<1)2/'`&Uhv(<114X/&�Y�5"2/?/c/(�'`t 5�7>14X/&w�%(yt"(�h4X/. 7O5"'4Y/.+c/c/&�? �U5"?3&�!���&U?/0�&wh`1 (<'4hR.+?�1)X3.:hR,3XP(�h4&I5�7& $"5"*+231).+5"? � �e?/5��u?M(�h (<h`t9rs,J1)5�14.:0u[".;(<?e1 Y/'4(�?/0 X�ho1 (�'`hu� (<'4&�&�$"&�?wY/.:[�["&U' 1)XP(<?s1)X3&7O5�'4r�&U'R'`&Uc [".:(�?a1)h@n14X/&�t�(�'4&�?35F��Y�&U0U5�rs.+?/[�h42/,�&U' nq[".:(�?a1)h�! � X/&w0�5"'4&w.+h ?/5��0�5"r�,�5"h`&Uc�5�7 � & � �14X/& c/.+'4&�0�1 ,3'459c/2/0�1 5�7�1)'`.:,/*+&�� Y32/'4?/.+?/[�Z(�?/c�5�7 ����� �uX/.+0 X.+h 7O5"'`rs&�cH0U5�,/.:5"23h4*+tbYatb1)X/& '`&y(�0 1).+5"? � & � � � ��� (�� � ����� �uX3.:0 X�.:h�1)X/&Rc/5"r�.:?P(�?a1'`&y(�0 1).+5"?�5�$"&�'R1)'`.:,/*+& �L.:? 1)X/& MP?P(�*�h`1)(�["&UhR5�7>0U5�'4&I7O2/h`.:5"?Z! � X/&I0U5"'`&IY�&U0U5�rs&�h.+?/0U'`&y(�h`.:?/[�*+tsc/&U["&�?/&U'4(<1)&Q�c/2/&1)5�0U5"?a14')(�0 1).:5�?-!

� *:5"?/[�1)X/&_(�h`t9r�,31)5<1).:0�[".:(�?a1�Y/'4(�?/0 XR14X/&_h`.+142P(<1).+5"?A.:h�h`.:r�.:*:(�'Z1)5�1)X/&_'4&UcR[".;(�?a1Y3')(�?/0 XZ! � X/&urI(�.+? c/. ��&U'`&U?/0�& ?35F� .:h�14XP(<1�1)X3&�ho1 (�'`h rs(�.+?e1)(�.:?RX/&U*+.:2/r (�?/cs^�� #h`X/&U*+*ZY/23'4?/.+?/[v(<1 14X/&h)(�r�&%14.:r�& (�h 14X/& 0U5�'4&Y�&U[".+?/h ,/'`5J0�&Uh4h`.:?/[v0U(�'4Y�5"?-! � X/.+h .:h�uX3&U'4&14X/&5"?/.+5"?wh`14'42/0 1)2/'`&0U5"r�&Uh>.+?-! � X/&.:?a14&U'4.+5"'_.+h>?/5�� c3.+$9.:c/&�cw.:?a1)5 h`&�$�&U')(<*0 X3&Ur�.:0y(<*:*+tIc/.:ho1).+?/0�1P�U5�?/&Uh2Z(�?3cd1)X3&@ho1)')(�1).SM/0y(<14.:5"?bY�&�0U5"r�&Uh�,/'`5"["'4&�h4h`.+$"&�*+tMr�5"'4&&gf91)'4&�rs&Z�u.+1)XR&y(�0 X ?/&A��h`1 (<["& 5�7�0�5"'4& ,3'4590U&Uh`h4.+?/[/!�p�5���rI(<h4h�ho1 (�'`h � , � K ,1G �X/(�$�&�c/&�["&U?/&�')(<14&I0�5"'4&�h (�?/c�5"?/*+t rs(�h`h4.+$�&sho1 (�'`h (�'`&I(<Y/*:&v1)5d'4&y(<0 X�1)X/&s0U&�?e14')(�*14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&v?/&�0U&�h4h)(<'`t 1)5b.:["?/. 1)& 0U(�'4Y�5"?-! � X3&sX/&�*:.+2/r h4X3&U*:*�*+.:&�hA.+rsr�&Uc3.;(<14&U*+t5�231)h`.:c/&w1)X3&b0�5"'4&b(<1 $�&U'ot h`rI(<*:*_rs(�h`hv7O'4(�0�14.:5"?f 1qt9,/.+0y(�*+*+t (�'45"23?/c W�x�� 5�7�1)X3&ho1)&�*:*;(<' rs(�h4h�!6p�5F� rs(�h4h h`1)(�'4h5"?3*+tb2/?/c/&�'4["5wX3&U*:.+2/r h4X/&�*:*�Y/2/'`?/.:?/[DZ,/'`5Jc/230U.:?3[(<?�& f91)&�?/h4. $"&0�5"?a$"&U0 1).+5"? �U5"?3&%1)XP(�1 r�5�$�&Uh_145�� (�'`cI1)X3& h42/'o7�(�0U&<! ��'4&Uh`2/rs(�Y/*+t3/(<114X/.:huho1 (�["&QP1)X/&AX/.:[�Xd*+2/rs.+?/5"h`.+1qtsc/'4. $"&Uh�rs(�h4h�*:5"h`h�(�?/cd14X/&A&U'45�h4.:5�?d5�7�XatJc3'45"["&�?&�?a$"&U*+5",�&�'4&�c/2/0U&�hR1)X3&Irs(�h4hR(�?/c 5",/(�0U. 1qt 5�$�&U'`*+t9.:?/[b1)X/&sX/&U*+.:2/r Y32/'4?/.+?/[mh`X/&U*+* !tLX3&U? 1)X3&Irs(�h4h@5�7>1)X/&sh4X/&�*:*�Y�&�0U5"r�&Uh@h4rs(�*:*+&U'1)X/(�?�(�Y�5"231 x�� K�,1G �. 1R0U(�?/?/5�1(�141 (<.:?M1)X/&@,/'4&�h4h423'4& ?/&�0U&�h4h)(<'`tm145�.:?3c/2/0U&61)X3&R0U5�r Y/2/ho1).:5�?8Z(<?/cH*:5�� rs(�h`h ho1 (�'`h*+&y(y$"&14X/&A(�h`t9r�,31)5�14.:0[".:(�?a1uY/')(<?/0 X-!

� X/&d(�hotJr�,3145�1).+0�[".;(<?e1 Y/')(�?30 X .:hR0U5"r�,/*:.+0y(<14&Uc�Yat 14X/&w7�(�0�1 14XP(<1 1>� 5 $�&U'`t

K �

Page 20: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&Ih4&U?3h4.+14.+$�&w?9230U*:&U(�' 7O2/&�*:h Y/23'4? h4.+r 2/*+1)(�?/&�5"2/h4* t .:?�14X/&U.+' h4X/&�*:*+hU! 5q?7�(<0�1R91)X/.+h ?/5"?9nq0U&�?a1)')(<*-,/'4590U&�h4h`.:?/[v.:h ( 2/?/. 9e2/&6(<?/cw2/?/ho1 (�Y/*+&h`1)(�["& 5�7S14X/&&�$�5"*:2Jn14.:5"?Z! � Xe2/h%14X/&U'`& (�'`&@1)X3'4&U&R5"231)ho1 (�?3c/.:?/[s0 XP(�'4(�0�14&U'4.+h`14.:0Uh 7O5"' � h`t9r�,31)5�14.:0@[".;(�?a1Y3')(�?/0 Xbh`1)(�'4h� ��2/0U*+&y(�' Y/2/'`?/.:?/[@1 (3�<&Uh ,/*:(�0U& .:?I1>� 5 h4X3&U*:*+h�n�(@1)X3&U'4rs(�*+*+tv2/?/ho1 (�Y3*:&%0�5"?DMP[�2/')(�n14.:5"?In�*+&y(�c3.:?/[ 145I( *:5�?/[ h4&�'4.:&�h 5<7�14X/&U'`rI(�*Z,/2/*:h`&Uh2� � X/&I*+2/r�.:?/5"h`.+1qtd.:h62/?/.S9e2/&U* t c/&�14&U'4r�.:?3&Uc Yet 14X/&s0�5"'4&vrs(�h4h2�.+?/c/&�,�&�?/c/&U?a1R5�714X/&1)5�1)(�*-rs(�h4hu5�7�1)X3&Aho1 (�'2� � ho1)'`5"?/[vh`14&U*:*:(�'_�u.:?/cMc/& $"&U*+5",/hu(�h ( '4&Uh`2/*+1u5<7�1)X/&X/.+["X�'4(�c/.;(�1).:5�?I,/'`&Uh4h`2/'4&A.:?14X/&6&U?a$"&�*:5",�&3P14X/&6h`1 (<' 1)Xe2/h�*:5"h`.:?/[v( h4.+["?/.sMP0y(�?a1>7O'4(�0�14.:5"?w5�7�.+14h>rI(�h`hU!

p�&�1_2/h_?35F�L0�5"?/h`.:c/&�'_&y(<0 Xw0 XP(�')(<0�1)&�'4.+h`1).+0Uh .:?Ir�5"'`&�c3&�1 (<.:* ! � X/&%1>� 5 Y/2/'`?/.:?3[h`X/&U*+*:h 14XP(<1Ah42/,3,/*+t�&�?/&U'`[�t c/2/'`.:?/[w14X/& �%h`t9r�,31)5<1).:0 [�.;(�?a16,/XP(<h4&�(�'4&vh`&U,P(�'4(<1)&�cYat (mX/&�*:.+2/r *;(yt"&�'U! � X/&�&gf91)&U'`?P(�* h4X/&�*:* �(<1@1)X/&sY�5�1`1)5"r 5<7 1)X/&sXatJc3'45"["&�?�'4.+0 X&�?a$"&U*+5",�&3aY/2/'`?/h�Xat9c/'45"[�&U?8"14X923h�.:?/0�'4&y(<h4.:?3[%1)X/&_X/&U*+.:2/r *;(yt�&U'��zh�rs(�h4h�! � X/&>.+?/?/&U'h`X/&U*+* -5�? 145", 5�7�1)X/&v0y(<'4Y�5"?Jnq5yf9t9["&U? 0�5"'4&Q�Y32/'4?/h6X/&�*:.+2/r��1)Xe2/h6&y(<14.:?/[w.+?a1)5�1)X3&X3&U*:.+2/r *:(yt"&U'�(�?3cdY/23.:*:c3.:?/[ 2/,M1)X3&A0U(�'4Y�5"?Jn 5yfJt9["&�?m0�5"'4&<!Z5q?b,/'4.+?/0U.+,/*:&QP(vh`1)&U(�c3tho1 (<14& 0U5"23*:c Y�& (�0 X/.:& $"&�c8\�u. 1)XH14X/& 1>�_5bY/2/'`?/.:?3[�7O'45"?a1)h6(<c3$<(�?/0U.+?/[M5"231>�_(�'4c (<114X/&_h4(�r�& '4(<1)&<!���5F� &�$�&U'2e14X/&�["'4&U(<1�c3. ��&U'4&�?/0U& Y�& 1>�_&�&U? 14X/& 1>� 5 ?e2/0U*+&y(�'�Y/2/'`?/.:?3[,3'4590U&Uh`h4&�h�c35 ?/5�1>(<*:*:5�� h`2/0 Xd(Rh`14&y(�c3tIh`1)(<1)&%145 c/&�$�&U*+5",-! � X/& 1>� 5vh4X/&�*:*:h c/5 ?/5�1h`2/,/,/* tw&U?3&U'4[<tMh4.:rR2/*+1)(�?/&U5�2/h4* t 3Y3231�.:?w1)2/'`?8P.:?b( 0�t90�*:.:06,/'`5J0�&Uh`h��(�?/cM1)X/&6rs(�h4h5<7�14X/&6X/&U*+.:2/r�*;(yt"&�'�h`&U,P(<')(<14.:?/[ 1)X3&Ur 0 XP(<?/["&Uh�,�&U'4.+5Jc3.:0y(<*:*+t�!

� 5 Y�&U[�.:? �u.+14X Xat9c/'45�["&U? .:h Y/2/'`?a1I.+? 14X/&M& f91)&�'4?P(<*�h`X/&U*+* _�uX/.:*+&�1)X/&M.+?/?/&U'h`X/&U*+* .:hI& f91).+?/0�1U! � hd( '`&Uh`2/*+1��14X/&�X/&U*+.:2/r *;(yt�&U'�h`&U,P(�'4(<1).+?/[ 1)X3&�h4X/&�*:*:hw[�'45��.+? rs(�h4h�! tL.+14X ?/5 &U?3&U'4[<t h423,/,/*+t3>1)X/.+h�*;(yt"&�'I0�5"?a1)')(<0�1)hM(<?/c X/&y(�1)h�2/, 23?e14.:*14X/&�1)&�rs,�&U'4(<1)23'4&w(<1 .+1)h@YP(�h`&wY�&�0U5"r�&Uh h`2���0U.:&�?a1)*+t�X/.:[�X�7O5"' X/&�*:.+2/r 1)5�.:[�?/.+14&�!��&U*+.:2/r Y32/'4?/.+?/[�.:?M1)X/.+hu14X/.:?bh4X3&U*:*S.+hu14X/&U'`rI(<*:*+tI2/?/ho1 (�Y/*+&R(<?/cd. 1�'4&Uh`&Ur Y3*:&Uhu1)X3&X3&U*:.+2/r �P(�h4Xm(�?/cb?9230U*:&U(�'u&U?/&�'4[�tM[�&U?/&�')(<14.:5"?M')(�1)&6'4&U(�0 X/&Uh K�x�� 0_G�! � X/&A&U?/&�'4[�t.+h�(�Y/h45�'4Y�&UcHYatw1)X3&R5�$"&�'4*+t9.+?/[s*:(yt"&U'`h�x�uX/.:0 Xm& fJ,P(�?/cH(�?/cm0�5J5�* ! � h�14X/&Uh`&R*:(�t�&U'`h0�5"?a1 (�.+? 14X/&mXat9c/'45�["&U? Y32/'4?/.+?/[�h`X/&U*+* _14X/&m'4(<1)&b5�7Xat9c/'`5"["&U? Y/2/'4?3.:?/[69923.:0u�e*+tc3&U0U*+.:?/&�hU!\5q?R( h`X/5"'o1�,�&U'`.:59c5�791).:r�&3y14X/&�X/&�*:.:23r Y/2/'`?/.:?3[ 7O'45"?a1�(�c3$<(�?30U&UhS1)X3'45"2/[�X14X/&X/&�*:.:23r h4X3&U*:* J142/'4?/.+?/[ X/&�*:.:23r�.+?e145v0y(�'`Y�5"?M(<?/cd5yf9t9["&U?fP2/?a1).:*Z.+1>0U(<1)0 X/&�hu2/,�u. 1)Xw1)X3&A?35F� & f91).+?/0�1�Xat9c/'45�["&U?dh4X/&�*:* !

� X/& ,/'45yfJ.:r�.+1qtR5�7Z14X/&�X/5�1�X/&U*+.:2/r Y/2/'`?/.:?/[67O'45�?e1 0y(<2/h4&�h 1)X3&�Xat9c/'`5"["&U?s1)5A'4& n.+["?/. 1)&�! J_&�0y(�2/h`&>5�7�.+14h�*:&�h4h`&U'�h4&�?/h4. 1). $J. 1qt61)5 1)&�rs,�&U'4(<1)23'4&3�Xet9c/'`5"["&�?�Y32/'4?/.+?/[.:? (h`X/&U*+*/.:h�h`1 (<Y/*:&<! � X/&>1)&�rs,�&U'4(<1)23'4&u(�?/cvc/&�?/h4. 1qt (�cFK`2/h`1 .+?e145 1)X/&�'4rs(�*/&29923.:*:.+Y/'4.+2/rb!

W<x

Page 21: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

� 1�1)X/& h4(�r�&_1).+rs&Q<X/&�*:.+2/r Y/2/'4?3.:?/[.+h 9e2/&U?30 X/&Ucs(�h�( '`&Uh423*+1�5<7P1)X/&>'`&U*;(�1).+$�&U* t6*:5��14&Ur�,�&�')(<142/'4&s?/5�� ,3'4&�$<(�.+*:.+?/[d.+?�1)X3&�XatJc3'45"["&�?�Y/2/'`?/.:?/[mh4X/&�*:* (<?/c�.+14h@$9.:0�.:?/. 1qt"!� Xe2/hR(d?/&A� 0�t90�*:&�Y�&�[".:?/h�! � X/&�*;(�ho1).+?/[M'4&Uh`2/*+1@5�7_&y(�0 X 0 t90U*:&�.:h14X/&s[�'45��>1)X 5�714X/&60y(�'`Y�5�?Jnq5yf9t9["&U?b0U5"'`&�!

=�$"5�*:2314.:5"?P(<'`tv0y(<*:0U23*;(<14.:5"?/h�h`X/5�� 1)XP(�1 14X/&%*+2/rs.+?/5"h`.+1qt 5<7�(R(<h`t9rs,J1)5�14.:0�[".;(�?a1Y3')(�?/0 Xmh`1 (<'4h%.+hq9e2/. 1)&R(�0U0�2/')(<14&U* td'`&U,/'`&Uh`&U?a1)&�c8Z7O5"'�0U5"'`&Rrs(�h4h�,6@ � x � � ,6G �Yat14X/&7O5"*:*+5��u.:?/[ '`&U*:(<1).+5"?

00_G ! \�� K�x � � , 1

,1G �x��]� $ � ��jaW �

� Xe2/hA1)X/&vho1 (�'`h@5�7 1)X/&�h)(<rs&v0U5�'4&vrI(<h4h@(�'4& 7O5"2/?3c�(<1614X/&sh4(�r�&�X3&U.:[�Xe1A5"? 1)X3&(<h`t9rs,J1)5�14.:0w[".:(�?a1sY3')(�?/0 X .:?�1)X3&m��&U'`1N�Uh`,/'42/?3[<n {u2/h4h`&U*�c/.;(<["')(�r: '4&�[a(�'4c3*:&Uh`hv5�714X/&U.+' &U?a$�&U*:5�,�&brI(<h4hU!�891 (�'`h '4&U(�0 X�14X/&M(�hotJr�,3145�1).+0w[".;(�?a1 Y3')(�?/0 X (<1vc/. �Z&�'4&�?e1,�5".+?e14h��c/&�,�&�?/c/.+?/[M5"?H1)X/&vrs(�h4h%5�7 14X/& 0U5�'4&v(<114X/& &U?/c 5�7�1)X3& 0U&U?a14')(�*�X/&�*:.+2/rY32/'4?/.+?/[Rho1 (�[�&�! � X/& tI0�*:.+r Yv2/,s14X/&%Y/'4(�?/0 X83(�h 1)X/&�0U5"'`&%0�5"?a1).:?e2/&�h 145R["'`5F� c/2/'on.+?/[@14X/& 14X/&U'`rI(<*�,/23*:h4&�h h`1)(�["&<!�� 1_1)X3&%h)(<rs&�1).:r�&u1)X/& &U?a$"&�*:5",�& rs(�h4h c/&U0�'4&y(<h4&Uh2?35�1u5"?/* tw(<1 14X/&6& fJ,�&U?/h`&@5�7�1)X3&0U5"'`&A[�'45��>1)X83Y/231�rI(<.:?/* tsY�&U0U(�2/h`&A5<7�rs(�h4h>*+5"h4h(�1 1)X/&h`2/'`7�(<0U&�! # Y/h`&U'`$<(<14.:5"?3h 5�7�'4&�cb[�.;(�?a1)h (�?/cwh423,�&�'onq[�.;(�?a1)h>'`&�$�&y(�*Z14XP(<1 14X/&Uh`&ho1 (�'`hu*:5"h`&rI(�h`h�(<1>1)X/&6'4(<1)&�h�'4(�?/[".+?/[ 7O'45�r K�x�� ����� ,1G 145 Kyx�� � � � ,1G ,�&U'>t"&U(�'U!

� X/&7O2/'o1)X/&�'>&�$�5"*:2314.:5"?w5<7�14X/&h`1)(�'>c/&U,�&U?3c/h 5�?a�uX/&�14X/&U'u1)X/&0U(�'4Y�5"?Jn 5yfJt9["&�?0�5"'4&��u.:*:*�2/?/c3&U'4[�5�?9230U*:&U(�'�Y/23'4?/.+?/[�5"'�?/5<1y! 5 761)X/&�rs(�h`h�.:hs*:&Uh`hI1)X/(�?LBL,1G ?e2/0�*:&U(�'@Y32/'4?/.+?/[bc/5J&�h@?35�1R590U0�2/'@(�?/c 14X/&�YP(�h4.+0v?9230U*:&U(�'A&�$"5�*:2314.:5"? 5�7 14X/&sho1 (�'0�5"r�&Uhu1)5s(�?d&�?/c�(<1u14X/.:huh`1)(�["&@(�?/cd.+1uY�&U0U5�rs&�h%(v0y(�'`Y�5�?m5yf9tJ[�&U? �uX/. 1)&6cD�_(�'`7 !�P5"'%X/.:["X3&U' rs(�h4h%h`1 (<'4h � � BL,6G � .+1 .:h ,�5"h4h`.:Y/*+&R7O5"'%14X/& 0y(<'4Y�5"?Jnq5yf9t9["&U? 0�5"'4& 145.+["?/. 1)&(�?3cb14X/&6?9230U*:&U(�'>&�$�5"*:2J1).:5�?b0�5"?a1).+?923&UhU!

� N3��Fm������������� n � 7�14&U'61)X/&�rI(<.:?Jn h4&�9e2/&�?/0U&�8J2/? &�$"5�*+$"&�h@145H(M'4&Uc�[".;(�?a1ho1 (�[�&3x� �uX/.:0 X7�u.+*:*e590U0U23'�.:?R(�Y�5"231�� Y/.:*+*:.+5"? t"&U(�'4h��A �uX/&�? 1)X/& 8J2/?��zh�,/X/5<1)5"h`,/X/&U'`&�u.+*:*a'`&y(�0 X ?3&y(�'`*+t1)5�1)X/& 5"'4Y3.+1�5�7�lm(<'4hU!�1)X/&_= (�'`14XR1)XP(<?�� &U*:*9.:?3h4.:c3& 14X/&>892/?8a(�?3c&gfJ,�5"h`&Uc�1)5b1)&�rs,�&U'4(<1)2/'`&Uh 5<7 1)X/5�2/h)(�?3c/h 5�7>c/&�["'4&�&Uh2_�u.+*:* ["'4(�c/2P(�*+*+tH$<(�,�5"'`. �U&�hU!^ (<*:0U23*;(<14.:5"?/h%h42/["[�&Uh`1A1)X/(<161)X/&s= (�'`14X �u.+*:*�h`,/.:'4(�*�.:?H�_(�'4c 1)5��_(�'4c 1)X/& $"&�'`t X/5�1.+?a1)&U'`.:5"'�5�7�1)X/& 8J23?8a'4&U(�0 X/.:?3[A. 1)h M/?P(�*/&�?/c�(�Y�5�231 K�x 1)X35"2/h)(<?/c t"&y(<'4h�(<7�1)&�'�Y�&U.:?3[h�� (<*:*:5�� &UcwYatI14X/&A8J2/?Z!�� 1 1)X/& 14.:,�5<7�1)X/&'`&Ucw[".:(�?a1 ,/XP(<h4&33X/&U*+.:2/r ��(�h`XM5J0�0U2/'`h(<?/cv(<7�1)&�'�h45�rs&_14.:r�& X3&U*:.+2/r 0U5"r Y32/h`14.:5"? ho1 (�Y3.:*:.S�U&�h�.:?@1)X/&>0�5"'4&Q3�uX/.:0 Xv&gf3,/(�?/c/h2�uX3.:*:& 14X/&I&�?e$�&U*+5",�&I0U5"?a1)'4(�0�14hU!b��.+?P(�*:* t 8J23? Y�&�0U5"r�&UhR(d0U(�'4Y�5"?�5yf9t9["&U? �uX3.+1)&c � (�'o7 !

W�K

Page 22: 9=) + )>/? @ A9B/1 .A/ !dipankar/ph217/contrib/redgiant.pdf · 5= ?A@ c/')(R u.:?3[m.+14h6&U?/& '4[ t 7O'45 r 1)X/&s?9230U*:&U( 'AY/2/'4?3.:?/[b5 7 14X/&I*:( '4["&vh`2/,/,/*

� ���"�(������u�

� K�� �%Y�&U*+* 3|v!]# !S/ld5"'`'4.:h`5"?8 + !S3(�?/cat 5"* � /8�!k0<! K � �"i ������� ��������� ��� ������ �"!#� ��$% �&�(')�ADM/7�1)Xb&Uc3.+1).+5"?8/^ J>8d^_5�*:*:&�["& ��2/Y/*+.:h4X3.:?/[/!

� W��R^_5yf +*3! ��!s�(�?3c�|.:2/*+. �{6! � ! K �"\ �D-,.�/���10&�2����3'4 ��65����&���7���65����/8�0&��89�(�A\� 5"* !]W |65�'4cP(�?b(�?3c J_'`&y(�0 Xf�8J0U.+&U?/0�& ��2/Y/*+.:h`X/&U'`h�&5q?/0<!S ��&2�;:�5�'N��!

� j<�@=�'4.S�<(�J 5"X/r n � . 1)&�?/h4& (K � �aW+>=/� �?�( �@�8 0&�?�� ��A�� B5����&���7���DC�'&���3 3 �FE)'&��03'A_� 5"* !kjD^ (�r Y/'`.:c/[�& " ?/. $"&U'`h4. 1qtw,/'4&�h4h2Z^ (<r Y/'4.+c/["&<!

� B����.:,/,�&U?3XP(�X/?8J{6!SJ(�?/c�t &U.+["&U'o1R �R! K � �"x �5��G�&���7����5����/8�0&��89�(�H����@I� % ��J8F�?�� ��&8J,/'`.:?/["&�'on � &U'4*:(�[ ��2/Y/*+.:0y(�1).:5�?/h�DJ_&U'`*:.:?Z!

� ��� ��(<c/rI(<?P(�Y/XP(<?8 � ! �W�x�x"xDLKM� �3 ��(�&�?��0N���OC�'&���3 3 �FE)'&��03'A�� 5"* !]W �^ (�rRY/'4.+c/["& " ?/. n$"&�'4h4. 1qt ��'4&Uh`hU!

� \<� ��'4.:(�*:?/.S�x + ! sW�x"x"xD+=&� ���3 �@�8 0&���� ��P�G Q��� �RKM� �3 ��&E� ��S5��G�&���7���T5����/8�0&��8F�3�U����@� % ��J89���� ��&�^ (�r Y3'4.:c3["& " ?/. $"&�'4h4. 1qtM,/'4&�h4h2Z^ (<r Y/'4.+c/["&<!

� i��R8JX/5�'4&3 8�! �A! W�x"x"jDVKM� �WK �& �3'&�?�/EX ��ZYR �@F�&�/�[C�'&���( 3 �FEO'&��03'A tL.+*:&�tan5q?a1)&U'`h40�.:&U?30U&3 � &A�\*�&�'4h4& t"!

W�W