ACADEMIC EVALUATION CRITERIA

ACADEMIC EVALUATION CRITERIA

Eastern Mediterranean University Rector's Office sets the following criteria pursuant to the Article 6 of "Eastern Mediterranean University Academic Staff Title By-law" with the approval of Eastern Mediterranean University Executive Board.

ÜYK 12.04.2011 11/577-2

ÜYK 16.12.2020 20/276-10

GENERAL RULES

The following rules apply for all disciplines:

1. All the other criteria regarding the first-time appointment as professorial staff (Assist. Prof., Assoc. Prof. & Prof.) and extension of the period of duty is as stated in EMU Rules and Regulations. Academic Evaluation Criteria are used for first-time appointment and promotional purposes.

2. “National” or “domestic” events refer to events taking place in Turkey, TRNC or home country of the professorial staff which are not regarded as international events.

3. Scoring of joint work is conducted as stated at the end of the discipline score distribution chart, if not defined otherwise. If nothing has been specified about the scoring, the author gets full points in publications with a single author, and the score is divided equally among the authors in publications with multiple authors. The chart in question is not used for joint event scorings in doctoral and assistant professorship evaluations. All publications are evaluated separately based on the principle of “single author”.

4. Criteria for disciplines that are not mentioned in this document is to be added to the present criteria upon the decision of University Executive Board on the matter. However, in case of an urgent need for these disciplines, in accordance with the general applications in other disciplines; Inter-University Council criteria for associate professorship will be sought for promotions to associate professorship, and twice the criteria for associate professorship for promotions to professorship.

5. Bearing in mind the Science Disciplines and Key Words list accessible at TR Inter-University Council’s website (the Associate Professorship Application Requirements tab available under the Associate Professorship Information System page), candidates must specify a science discipline and a minimum of 1 (one), maximum of 3 (three) keywords related to the specified field of science.

6. Language proficiency requirements for applicants;

a. For Associate Professorship application, candidates must score the points specified below out of 100 points from international foreign language exams accepted as equivalent to the central foreign language exams by the Higher Education Council;

i. minimum 80 points for candidates who work in English-medium programs, ii. minimum 65 points for candidates who work in Turkish-medium programs.

b. For Assistant Professorship or Professorship application, at least one of the criteria below should be met;

i. Candidates must obtain following points out of 100 points from international

https://www.uak.gov.tr/docentlik

foreign language exams accepted as equivalent to the central foreign language exams by the Higher Education Council;

1. minimum 80 points for candidates who work in English-medium programs,

2. minimum 65 points for candidates who work in Turkish-medium programs.

ii. The candidate’s mother tongue being English.

iii. Candidate is required to meet the following criteria;

1. Completing at least two of the undergraduate, postgraduate or doctorate degrees in an English-medium Program in the event of working in an English-medium program,

2. Completing at least one of the undergraduate, postgraduate or doctorate degrees in an English-medium Program in the event of working in a Turkish-medium program.

7. Mandatory Total Points might be increased if all the special conditions for disciplines have been met.

8. Each piece of work is scored by being included in only one section of the ADEK score table (including Att. A).

9. For all disciplines, candidates are obliged to get 20 points for Associate Professorship and 40 points for Professorship from the scorecard stated in Att. A (old ADEK scorecard).

ABBREVIATIONS • SCI–Expanded : Science Citation Index-Expanded • SSCI : Social Sciences Citation Index • AHCI : Arts and Humanities Citation Index • ULAKBİM : Turkish Academic Network and Information Center • EU Framework Programs: They are one of the Community Programs established by

the EU in order to bring the national policies and practices of the member and candidate countries in various fields closer to each other.

DEFINITIONS Primary Author: A candidate is referred as the primary author in publications stated below: (a) Single-author article (b) An article written with post graduate student(s) for whom the candidate is the supervisor

(multiple students and a second supervisor can participate in the study) (c) Being listed as the first author of a multiple-author publication (for only disciplines of “Health

Sciences” and “Sports Sciences”) (d) For “Educational Sciences”, “Philology”, “Law” and “Social, Humanities and Administrative

Sciences” disciplines, meeting only one of the above-mentioned criteria ((a), (b) or(c)) is adequate for the Professorship title.

National Publishing House: A publishing house carrying on business at the national level for at least five years, and whose publications are catalogued in university libraries in Turkey and lastly, who has published minimum of 20 books of different authors in the same genre.

International Publishing House: A publishing house carrying on business at the international level for at least five years, and whose publications are catalogued in university libraries around

the world and lastly, who has published minimum of 20 books of different authors in the same genre. International Scientific Meeting: A meeting with a scientific board consisting of scientists from different countries where the presentations are subject to a scientific preliminary examination before they are accepted to the meeting.

National Scientific Meeting: A meeting with a scientific board consisting of scientists from different organizations at a national level where the presentations are subject to a scientific preliminary examination before they are accepted to the meeting.

International Patent: Patent application with a research report by international research offices (PCT - Patent Cooperation Treaty) that the invention contains a new and inventive step.

National Patent: Patent application with a research report by the Turkish Patent Institute that the invention contains a new and inventive step

Published Article: Original, printed or electronically published article, provided that it has contributed to science in its field

Personal Activity/Event: Activities or events such as art, art design and project exhibitions. Solo exhibitions consist of multiple work of the candidate. Maximum 25% of previous studies can take place in the next event/project. Documentation is compulsory.

Exhibition: Solo or joint/group events (minimum 2 participants) containing the art work of the candidate.

Context-oriented Work: Two- or three-dimensional art works designed for a specific place or environment, comprehensive architectural space design applications

Art Workshop / Symposium: An art event attended by elected or invited artists. Participants are required to create and exhibit at least one artwork during the workshop and symposium. It is compulsory to document the invitation letter and the created artwork.

Event Management – Production / Curatorship: Project designing of art events; organizing exhibitions in accordance with the context of the events; inviting artists to the exhibitions whose art form fit the scope of the exhibition; coordinating the press and public relation matters of the exhibition; administering applied events like workshop and symposium.

Exhibiting Art-work in Museums: Personal work such as artwork, design or projects being purchased by public or private museums or donating such work to the museums for exhibitions.

Works/studies Appearing in Publications: Artwork, projects, designs, applications appearing in publishing organs such as books, encyclopedia, catalogue, magazine, TV and movie etc. (with the exception of publications partaking of an announcement or advertisement).

Jury membership: Undertaking duty as a jury member in related projects, design and art events (excluding the Thesis and Associate Professorship juries).

Reviews: Comments, critics and reviews published about important art events (solo/group exhibitions, art biennales, art symposiums, film competitions and festivals) in catalogues, newspapers and magazines.

EDUCATIONAL SCIENCES DISCIPLINE Those who have a doctorate degree in the field of elementary school teacher education will choose elementary education as their scientific field and keywords suitable for their field of study. The same is valid for those who have a doctorate degree in science, social studies and mathematics teacher education programs, all of which are other programs of the field of elementary education.

Area indexes= Education related indexes included in ISI Database: Australian Education Index, British Education Index, Journals Indexed in ERIC, Education Full Text (H. W. Wilson) Database Coverage List

Conditions for the Appointment of a PhD Jury

Educational Sciences Discipline Type Point SPECIAL CONDITION

Appointment of the PhD Jury Total scientific activities 21 Minimum one publication in Type 1.A)

Educational Sciences Discipline Criteria

Application Requirements Type Points Assistant Professorship Associate Professorship Professorship

Special Conditions Minimum Points



1. International Publication

Full research papers in the discipline of science applied (except letter to editor, abstract, compilation, technical note and book review)

A) Paper published in a journal covered by the SSCI, SCI-Expanded or AHCI, not including letters to the editor, abstract or book review

20

A minimum of 2 publications from Type 1.A) (In publications produced from a thesis, the candidate is considered as the primary author.)

24

On the condition that it has not been produced from the postgraduate or specialty theses prepared by the candidate, it is obligatory to get at least 20 points within the scope of Sections A) or B), with at least one item from Section A).

30

After the associate professorship, at least two publications are required under Section A) of this Article, at least one of which should indicate the candidate as the primary author.

60

B) Paper published in journals covered by international indexes, not including letters to the editor, abstract or book review.

15

C) A book review publication that contributes to science in the relevant field of publications specified in Sections A) or B) of this article

5

2. National Publication

On the condition that the paper is related to the discipline of science applied and has not been produced from the postgraduate or specialty theses prepared by the candidate

A) Papers published in national refereed journals covered by ULAKBIM 8

It is mandatory to publish at least three papers, two of which should be under Section A) of this article. If candidates other than those with Turkish citizenship and candidates who have applied for the recognition/equivalency of the associate professorship obtained abroad cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the same number of publications under Sections A) and / or B) of Article 1 instead.

8

For candidates with Turkish citizenship, a minimum of three publications, two of which are within the scope of Section A) of this article, are required. If the candidates cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the same number of publications in scope of Sections A) and/or B) of Article 1 instead.

16

B) Articles published in national refereed journals other than those specified in Section A).

4

3.

Publications Produced from Postgraduate Theses

On the condition that the paper is related to the postgraduate or specialty theses prepared by the candidate

A) Book published by international publishers 10

At least 1 publication is required in scope of this article. A maximum of 10 points can be obtained from this article.



B) Chapter in a book published by international publishers 8

C) Book published by national publishing houses. 5

D) Chapter in a book published by national publishing houses 4

E) Paper published in a journal covered by SSCI, SCI, SCI-Expanded and AHCI. 8

F) Paper published in journals covered by an international index 6

G) Paper published in journals covered by ULAKBIM 4

4. Book

On the condition that it has not been produced from the postgraduate or specialty theses

A) Book published by international publishers 20 Within the scope of this article, only original scientific books, other than textbooks, can be scored; Only one of the chapters in the same book is taken into account.

Within the scope of this article, only original scientific books, other than textbooks, can be scored. Only one of the chapters in the same book is taken into consideration. Three or

Within the scope of this article, only original scientific books, other than textbooks, can be scored. Only one of the chapters in the same book is taken into consideration. Three or

B) Editorship of a book or authorship of a book chapter published by international publishers

10






prepared by the candidate and is related to the field of science applied

C) Book published by national publishing houses 15 Three or more of field-specific encyclopedia articles are considered a book chapter.

more of field-specific encyclopedia articles are considered a book chapter.

more of field-specific encyclopedia articles are considered a book chapter. Translation of a book for Professorship is considered only under Section D) of this article. 50 points at most can be obtained within the scope of this article.

D) Editorship of a book or authorship of a book chapter published by national publishers

8

5. Citations

A)

Regardless of the number of citations in the text, for each cited work of the candidate, published in journals, not authored by the candidate, but covered by SCI, SCI-Expanded, SSCI and AHCI and in books, again not authored by the candidate, but published by international publishing houses

3

A maximum of 30 points can be obtained in scope of this article.

20 A maximum of 80 points can be obtained in scope of this article.

50 B)

Regardless of the number of citations in the text, for each cited work of the candidate published in journals, not authored by the candidate, but covered by indexes other than SCI, SCI-Expanded, SSCI and AHCI and in each of the publications published by international publishing houses as a chapter in books, again not authored by the candidate,

2

C) Regardless of the number of citations in the text, for each cited work of the candidate published in national refereed journals and books published by national publishing houses and not authored by the candidate,

1

6. Postgraduate Thesis Supervision

From the Completed Postgraduate Theses Supervised

A) PhD Thesis Supervision 4

A maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a second / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B), and the secondary supervisor receives half.

A maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B), and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from A), B) and C) Sections of Article 1. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from A), B) and C) Sections of Article 1.

6

A maximum of 40 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary/co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B) and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from A), B) and C) Sections of Article 1, with at least 1 from the A) Section of Article 1. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A), B), and C) Sections of Article 1, with at least 1 from Section A of Article 1.

12

B) Master’s Thesis Supervision 2

7. Scientific Research Project

A) Coordinator/ chief researcher in an ongoing or successfully completed EU Framework Program scientific research project.

15

A maximum of 20 points can be obtained from this article.



B) Co-researcher in an ongoing or successfully completed EU Framework Program scientific research project.

10

C) Undertaking duties (not including compilation and report writing work) in ongoing or successfully completed, internationally supported scientific research projects, other than those specified in Sections A) and B).

6

D) Undertaking duties in scientific research projects, either ongoing or successfully completed, carried out with public institutions other than the universities.

4

8. Scientific Meeting Activity

On the condition that the work is related with the field of science applied and not produced from the postgraduate theses prepared by the candidate

A) Work presented in international scientific meetings (excluding posters), with the full text or abstract published in the proceedings booklet either in print or electronically.

3

A maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. Two papers presented at the same meeting are scored at most.

4

A maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. Only one paper presented at the same meeting is scored at most.

6

A maximum of 25 points can be obtained in scope of this article. A maximum of two papers presented in the same meeting are scored.

12

B) Work presented in national scientific meetings (excluding posters), with the full text or summary published in the proceedings booklet either in print or electronically.

2






9. Educational Activity

Open, distance or face-to-face course offered after the completion of PhD. studies.

A) A master’s or PhD course for one semester. 3

A maximum of 4 points can be obtained in scope of this article. Those who have been involved in educational activities in domestic or international higher education institutions recognised by the Council of Higher Education (YÖK) for a minimum period of 2 years are deemed to have obtained 2 points.

3


6

B) An associate or undergraduate course for one semester 2

Total Required Points 28 Total Required Points 73 Total Required Points 156

Minimum Points 30 Minimum Points 120 Minimum Points 240

Total Minimum Points 30 Att-A By adding 20 points to be

taken from the former ADEK Score Table

140 Att-A By adding 40 points to be


280

Having at least one hundred and twenty (120) points in scientific activity on the basis of the unit points assigned to the work above in the field of associate professorship applied in the Educational Sciences discipline and provided that at least one hundred and ten (110) points of it have been obtained from

the work carried out after the obtainment of the doctoral title. Each piece of work is scored only in one section in the table above.

In publications with a single author, the author gets full points. For publications with multiple authors, the score is divided equally among the authors.

PHYSICAL SCIENCES AND MATHEMATICS DISCIPLINE


Physical Sciences and Mathematics Discipline

Type Point SPECIAL CONDITION


Physical Sciences and Mathematics Discipline Criteria

Application Requirements Type Points

Assistant Professorship Associate Professorship Professorship




1. Publications

Full research papers in the field of science applied (except letter to editor, abstract, compilation, technical note and book review)

A) Paper published in a journal covered by the SSCI, SCI-Expanded or AHCI, 20

A minimum of 2 publications from Type 1.A) . (In publications produced from a thesis, the candidate is considered as the primary author)

24

On the condition that it has not been produced from the postgraduate theses prepared by the candidate, the candidate is expected to be the primary author in at least one paper in scope of this Article’s Section A) after having completed PhD studies.

45

After the associate professorship, at least two publications indicating the candidate as the primary author are required under the Section A) of this article. After the associate professorship, in the fields of Biological Sciences and Molecular Biology and Genetics, only one primary author requirement is sought.

In the event of the minimum score requirement of 90 not being obtained for these fields only, the missing score up to 15 points can be additionally obtained from Article 1.C).

90

B) Papers published in other international, refereed journals 8

C) Papers published in national, refereed journals covered by ULAKBIM 8

In scope of this Article, the obtainment of a minimum of 8 points is required. If candidates other than those with Turkish citizenship and candidates who have applied for the recognition/equivalency of the associate professorship obtained abroad cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the same amount of points under Section A) of this Article instead.

8

For candidates with Turkish citizenship, a minimum of 8 points within the scope of Section C) of this article, is required. If the candidates cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the same amount of points in scope of the Section A) of Article 1 instead.

16

2.


On the condition that the paper is related to the postgraduate theses prepared by the candidate

A) Paper published in a journal covered by the SSCI, SCI-Expanded or AHCI 10




B) Paper published in other international and national refereed journals. 5

C) Oral presentation, contributing to science in the relevant field, delivered at an international symposium / congress and published in full text

5

D) Oral presentation, contributing to science in the relevant field, delivered at a national symposium/congress and published in full text.

3






3. Book

On the condition that it has not been produced from the postgraduate theses prepared by the candidate and is related to the field of science applied


In scope of this article, two chapters in the same book are taken into consideration at most. A maximum of 20 points can be obtained in scope of this article.

In scope of this article, two chapters in the same book are taken into consideration at most. Translation of a book for Professorship is considered only under Section D) of this article. 50 points at most can be obtained within the scope of this article.


10

C) Book published by national publishing houses 15


8

4. Patent Provided that it is related to the field of science applied for

A) International patent 20 In patents, points are divided by the number of people.

In patents, points are divided by the number of people.


B) National patent 10

5. Citations

A)

Regardless of the number of citations in the text, for each cited work of the candidate, published in journals, not authored by the candidate, but covered by SCI-Expanded, SSCI and AHCI and in books, again not authored by the candidate, but published by international publishing houses

3



50 B)

Regardless of the number of citations in the text, for each cited work of the candidate published in journals, not authored by the candidate, but covered by indexes other than SCI-Expanded, SSCI and AHCI and in each of the publications published by international publishing houses as a chapter in books, again not authored by the candidate,

2

C)

Regardless of the number of citations in the text, for each cited work of the candidate published in national refereed journals and books published by national publishing houses and not authored by the candidate,

1



A) PhD. thesis supervision 4

A maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B), and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A) and B) sections of Article 1. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A) and B) Sections of Article 1.

6

* A maximum of 40 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B), and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from A) Section of Article 1. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from Section A) of Article 1.

12

B) Master’s thesis supervision 2



15





10


6


4









3


4


6

A maximum of 25 points can be obtained in scope of this article. Two papers presented at the same meeting are scored at most

12

B) Work presented in national scientific meetings (excluding posters), with the full text or abstract published in the proceedings booklet either in print or electronically.

2





3

A maximum of 8 points can be obtained in scope of this article. Those who have been involved in educational activities in domestic or international higher education institutions recognised by the Council of Higher Education (YÖK) for a minimum period of 2 years are deemed to have obtained 2 points

6








280

Having at least one hundred and twenty (120) points in scientific activity on the basis of the unit points assigned to the work above in the field of associate professorship applied in the Physical Sciences and Mathematics discipline and provided that at least one hundred and ten (110) points of it have been

obtained from the work carried out after the obtainment of the doctoral title. Each piece of work is scored only in one section in the table above.

In publications with a single author, the author gets full points. In publications with two authors, the primary author gets 0.8 of the total score whilst the secondary author gets 0.5 of it. In articles with three or more authors, the primary author gets half of the total score, while the other authors share the

other half equally. For articles with two or more authors in which the primary author has not been specified, the total score is divided equally among the authors. In other publications (papers, books), the total score is divided equally among the authors.

PHILOLOGY DISCIPLINE


Philology Discipline Type Point SPECIAL CONDITION


Philology Discipline Criteria






1. International Publications

On the condition that it is related with the applied field of science


20

On the condition that it has not been produced from the postgraduate or specialty theses prepared by the candidate.

Being the primary author in at least one paper produced in scope of the present article’s Section A)

B) Paper published in a journal covered by an international index, not including letters to the editor, abstract or book review.

10

C) A book review paper that contributes to science in the relevant field of publications in scope of Sections A) or B) of this article

5

2 National Publications


A) Papers published in national, refereed journals covered by ULAKBIM 8

It is mandatory to publish at least four papers, two of which are under Section A) of this article. If candidates other than those with Turkish citizenship cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the same number of publications under sections A) or B) of Article 1 instead.

It is mandatory to publish at least five papers, three of which are under Section A) of this article. Three of these publications, at least two of which should be from Section A), must have been produced after the obtainment of the assistant professorship. If candidates other than those with Turkish citizenship and candidates who have applied for the recognition/equivalency of the associate professorship obtained abroad cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the same number of publications under Sections A) or B) of Article 1, instead.

It is mandatory to publish at least nine papers, six of which are under Section A) of this article. Three of these publications, at least two of which should be from Section A), must have been produced after the obtainment of the associate professorship. Candidates with Turkish citizenship can complete their fifth and further publications in accordance with Sections A) and B) of Article 1 “International Publications”. If candidates other than those with Turkish citizenship and candidates who have applied for the recognition/equivalency of the professorship obtained abroad cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the missing amount of publications under Sections A) or B) of Article 1, instead.

B) Papers published in national, refereed journals other than those specified in Section A)

4

3.










E) Paper published in a journal covered by SSCI, SCI-Expanded and AHCI. 8








4. Book

On the condition that it has not been produced from the postgraduate or specialty theses prepared by the candidate and is related to the field of science applied


Within the scope of this article, only original scientific books, other than textbooks, can be scored; Only two of the chapters in the same book are taken into account. Three or more of field-specific encyclopedia articles are considered a book chapter

Within the scope of this article, only original scientific books, other than textbooks, can be scored; Only two of the chapters in the same book are taken into account. Three or more of field-specific encyclopedia articles are considered a book chapter. In scope of this article, at least one publication from Sections A), B) or C) is required.

Within the scope of this article, only original scientific books, other than textbooks, can be scored; Only two of the chapters in the same book are taken into account. Three or more of field-specific encyclopedia articles are considered a book chapter. In scope of this article, at least one publication from Sections A), B) or C) is required. Translation of a book for Professorship is considered only under section D) of this article. 50 points at most can be obtained within the scope of this article


10

C) Book published by national publishers 15


8

5. Citations

A)


3



17 B)


2


1




A maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B), and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A), and B) sections of the Article 1. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A) and B) sections of Article 1.

6

A maximum of 40 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary/co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B) and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A) section of Article 1. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from Section A) of Article 1.

12




15





10


6


4






8. Scientific Meeting



3 A minimum of 4 points should be obtained from this section, from which a maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. Two papers presented at the same meeting are scored at most.

4

A minimum of 8 points should be obtained from this section, from which a maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. Only one paper presented at the same meeting is scored at most.

6

A maximum of 25 points can be obtained in scope of this article. A maximum of two papers presented in the same meeting are scored at most.

12

B) Work presented in national scientific meetings (excluding posters), with the full text or summary published in the proceedings booklet either in print or electronically

2





3


6








280

Having at least one hundred and twenty (120) points in scientific activity on the basis of the unit points assigned to the work above in the field of associate professorship applied in the Philology discipline and provided that at least one hundred and ten (110) points of it have been obtained from the work

carried out after the obtainment of the doctoral title. Each piece of work is scored only in one section in the table above.


LAW DISCIPLINE Conditions for the Appointment of a PhD Jury

Law Discipline Type Point SPECIAL CONDITION

Appointment of the PhD Jury Total scientific activities 21 Minimum one publication in Type 1.A) or two publications in Type 2.A)

Law Discipline Criteria








20

On the condition that it has not been produced from the postgraduate or specialty theses prepared by the candidate

Being the primary author in at least one article in scope of Section A) of this Article.


10

C) A book review article that contributes to science in the relevant field of publications in scope of Sections A) or B) of this article

5



A) Papers published in national refereed journals covered by ULAKBIM 10

It is mandatory to publish at least 2 papers from Section A) of this article. If candidates other than those with Turkish citizenship and candidates who have applied for the recognition/equivalency of the assistant professorship obtained abroad cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national, refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the missing number of publications under sections A) or B) of Article 1 instead.

It is mandatory to publish at least five papers, three of which should be under Section A) of this article. Three of these publications, at least two of which should be from Section A), must have been produced after the obtainment of the assistant professorship. Candidates with Turkish citizenship can complete their fifth and further publications in accordance with Sections A) and B) of Article 1 “International Publications”. If candidates other than those with Turkish citizenship and candidates who have applied for the recognition/equivalency of the associate professorship obtained abroad cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the missing number of publications under Sections A) or B) of Article 1, instead.

It is mandatory to publish at least nine papers, six of which should be under Section A) of this article. Three of these publications, at least two of which should be from Section A), must have been produced after the obtainment of the associate professorship. Candidates with Turkish citizenship can complete their fifth and further publications in accordance with Sections A) and B) of Article 1 “International Publications”. If candidates other than those with Turkish citizenship and candidates who have applied for the recognition/equivalency of the professorship obtained abroad cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the missing amount of publications under Sections A) or B) of Article 1, instead.

B) Articles published in national refereed journals other than those specified in Section A.

5

3.










E) Paper published in a journal covered by SSCI, SCI-Expanded and AHCI. 8








4. Book


A) Book with a single author published by international publishing houses 25

In scope of this article, only original scientific books with international literature (monographs), other than textbooks, can be scored.

In scope of this article, only original scientific books with international literature (monographs), other than textbooks, can be scored. At least one publication in scope of Sections A), or C) of this article is required.

In scope of this article, only original scientific books with international literature (monographs), other than textbooks, can be scored. Following the obtainment of associate professorship, a minimum of one publication in scope of Sections A) or C) of this article is compulsory, Translation of a book for Professorship is considered only under section D) of this article. 50 points at most can be obtained within the scope of this article

B) Editorship of a book or authorship of book chapters published by national or international publishing houses or refereed article published in ‘armağans’ with an ISBN code.

10

C) Book with a single author published by national publishing houses 25

D) Book with multiple authors published by national or international publishing houses

15

5. Citations

A)


3



34 B)


2


2




A maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B), and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A, and/or B Sections of Article 1 and/or Article 2. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A and/or B sections of Article 1 and/or Article 2.

6

A maximum of 40 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary/co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B) and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from Section A of Article 1 and/or Article 2. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from the Section A of Article 1 and/or Article 2.

12




15





10


6

D) Undertaking duties in scientific research projects, either ongoing or successfully completed, carried out with public institutions other than the universities

4

8. Scientific Meeting Activities



3 A minimum of 4 points should be obtained from this section, from which a maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. Maximum two papers presented at the same meeting are scored.

4


6

A maximum of 25 points can be obtained in scope of this article. A maximum of two papers presented in the same meeting are scored at most

12

B) Work presented in national scientific meetings (excluding posters), with the full text or summary published in the proceedings booklet either in print or electronically.

2










3


6








280

Having at least one hundred and twenty (120) points in scientific activity on the basis of the unit points assigned to the work above in the field of associate professorship applied in the Law discipline and provided that at least one hundred and ten (110) points of it have been obtained from the work carried

out after the obtainment of the doctoral title. Each piece of work is scored only in one section in the table above.


ARCHITECTURE, PLANNING AND DESIGN DISCIPLINE

International area indexes: • The Avery Index to Architectural Periodicals • DAAI (Design and Applied Arts Index) • Art Index (Art Research Database, EBSCO) • ICONDA (The International Construction Database) • Ergonomics Abstracts (Ergo-Abs)


Architecture, Planning and Design Discipline



Architecture, Planning and Design Field Criteria






1. Publications


A) Paper published in a journal indexed by the SSCI, SCI-Expanded, AHCI or International Area Indexes

20 A minimum of 2 publications from Type 1.A). (In publications produced from a thesis, the candidate is considered as the primary author)

24

On the condition that it has not been produced from the postgraduate theses prepared by the candidate, the candidate is expected to be the primary author in at least one paper in scope of this Article’s Section A or in at least four papers produced in scope of Sections B) and/or C) after having completed PhD studies

40

After the associate professorship, at least two publications under the Section A of this Article indicating the candidate as the primary author are required

80 B) Paper published in other international, refereed journals 8


2.



A) Paper published in journals indexed by SCI-Expanded, SSCI, AHCI or area indexes or book or book chapter published by international publishing houses.

10


At least 1 publication is required in scope of this article. A maximum of 10 points can be obtained from this article

At least 1 publication is required in scope of this article. A maximum of 10 points can be obtained from this article

B) Paper published in other international and national refereed journals 5


5


3

3. Book



In scope of this article, two chapters in the same book are taken into consideration at most. A maximum of 20 points can be obtained in scope of this article


In scope of this article, two chapters in the same book are taken into consideration at most. Translation of a book for Professorship is considered only under section D of this article. 50 points at most can be obtained within the scope of this article.


10



8

4.

Competition, Application, Software and Patent

Provided that it is related to the field of science applied for

A)

Degree or honorable mention in competitions in the fields of planning, architecture, urban design, landscape design, interior design, industrial design and other relevant fields of architecture, organized by relevant organizations (Professional Chambers, Local Administrations, Ministries, International Organizations) within the framework of applicable laws, regulations and principles.

15

In patents, points are divided by the number of people

A minimum of 15 points should be obtained in scope of this article (those who cannot meet the competition, application, software and patent conditions are required to publish at least one paper in scope of Sections 1A and 1B). In patents, points are divided by the number of people.”

15

A minimum of 15 points should be obtained in scope of this article (those who cannot meet the competition, application, software and patent conditions are required to publish at least one paper in scope of Sections 1A and 1B). In patents, points are divided by the number of people.”

30

B)

Within the framework of the applicable laws, regulations and principles, an article, book chapter or book written by the applicant or another person about an application project the applicant produced through the Revolving Fund or institutions affiliated to the university or during his/her time outside the University

15

C) Being a software developer or patent holder in the fields of project and construction management, design and planning

15






5. Citations

A)


3



50 B)


2


1



A) PhD thesis supervision 4

A maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B), and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A) and B) sections of Article 1. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A and B sections of Article 1.

6

* A maximum of 40 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B), and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from Section A) of Article 1. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from Section A of Article 1.

12




15





10

C) Undertaking duties (not including compilation and report writing work) in ongoing or successfully completed, internationally supported scientific research projects, other than those specified in Sections A and B.

6


4




3

A minimum of 4 points should be obtained in scope of this article. A maximum of 10 points can be obtained. Maximum two papers presented at the same meeting are scored.

4

A maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. Only one paper presented at the same meeting is scored.

6

A maximum of 25 points can be obtained in scope of this article. Two papers presented at the same meeting are scored at most

12


2










3


6








280

Having at least one hundred and twenty (120) points in scientific activity on the basis of the unit points assigned to the work above in the field of associate professorship applied in the Architecture, Planning and Design discipline and provided that at least one hundred and ten (110) points of it have been

obtained from the work carried out after the obtainment of the doctoral title. Each piece of work is scored only in one section in the table above.



ENGINEERING DISCIPLINE


Engineering Discipline Type Point SPECIAL CONDITION


Engineering Discipline Criteria






1. Publications



A minimum of 2 publications from Type 1.A) (In publications produced from a thesis, the candidate is considered as the primary author)

24

On the condition that it has not been produced from the postgraduate or specialty theses prepared by the candidate, the candidate is expected to be the primary author in at least one paper in scope of this Article’s Section A) after having completed PhD studies.

45

After the associate professorship, at least two publications indicating the candidate as the primary author are required under the Section A) of this Article.

90

B) Papers published in other international, refereed journals 8


In scope of this Article’s Section C), the obtainment of a minimum of 8 points is required. If candidates other than those with Turkish citizenship and candidates who have applied for the recognition/equivalency of the associate professorship obtained abroad cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the same amount of points under Section A) of this Article instead.

8

For candidates with Turkish citizenship, a minimum of 8 points within the scope of Section C) of this article, is required. If the candidates cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the same amount of points in scope of the Section A) of Article 1 instead.

16

2.



A) Paper published in a journal covered by the SSCI, SCI-Expanded or AHCI 10




B) Paper published in other international and national, refereed journals. 5


5


3

3. Book






10



8











5. Citations

A)


3



50 B)


2


1



A) PhD. thesis supervision 4

A maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B), and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A) and B) sections of Article 1. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A) and B) sections of Article 1

6

* A maximum of 40 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B), and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from Section A) of Article 1. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from Section A) of Article 1.

12




15





10

C) Undertaking duties (not including compilation and report writing work) in ongoing or successfully completed, internationally supported scientific research projects, other than those specified in Sections A and B.

6


4




3


4


6


12


2










3


6








280

Having at least one hundred and twenty (120) points in scientific activity on the basis of the unit points assigned to the work above in the field of associate professorship applied in the Engineering discipline and provided that at least one hundred and ten (110) points of it have been obtained from the work

carried out after the obtainment of the doctoral title. Each piece of work is scored only in one section in the table above.



HEALTH SCIENCES DISCIPLINE Conditions for the Appointment of a PhD Jury

Health Sciences Discipline Type Point SPECIAL CONDITION


Health Sciences Discipline Criteria







A) Original research paper published in journals indexed by SSCI, SCI- Expanded or AHCI

20

A minimum of 2 publications from Type 1.A) (In publications produced from a thesis, the candidate is considered as the primary author)

24

On the condition that it is not produced from the postgraduate or specialty theses prepared by the candidate, the candidate is expected to be the primary author in at least one paper in scope of this Article’s Section 1. A) after having completed PhD studies.

45

After the associate professorship, at least two publications indicating the candidate as the primary author are required under the Section A) of this Article. In case the minimum score requirement of 90 has not been met, missing points up to 15 can be obtained from Article 2.

90 B)

Original research paper published in journals covered by international indexes (other than those specified in Section A)

10

C) Case presentation published in journals specified in A) 5



A) Original research paper published in national, refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM.

8

In scope of this Article’s Section A), the obtainment of a minimum of 8 points is required. If candidates other than those with Turkish citizenship and candidates who have applied for the recognition/equivalency of the associate professorship obtained abroad cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the missing amount of points under Sections A) or B) of Article 1 instead.

8

In scope of this article’s Section A), a minimum of 16 points is required. If the candidates other than those with Turkish citizenship and those applying for the recognition/equivalency of the professorship obtained abroad cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are required to provide the missing amount of points from Sections A) or B) of Article 1 instead.

16

3.

Publications Produced from Postgraduate or Specialty in Medicine Theses

On the condition that it is related with the postgraduate or specialty in medicine theses prepared by the candidate





B) Paper published in other international and national refereed journals. 5


5


3

4. Book


A) Book published by international publishing houses 20





10



8






6. Citations

A)


3



50 B)


2


1

Health Sciences Discipline Criteria






Supervision of ongoing or completed master’s PhD. or specialty in medicine theses

A) PhD./ PhD Equivalent Specialty thesis supervision 4

A maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B), and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A), B) and C) sections of Article 1. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A), B) and C) sections of Article 1

6

A maximum of 40 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A) and B), and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from Sections A), B) and C) of Article 1, with at least one from Section A). * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from Sections A), B) and C) of Article 1, with at least one from Section A).

12




15





10

C) Undertaking duties (not including compilation and report writing work) in ongoing or successfully completed, internationally supported scientific research projects, other than those specified in Items A and B.

6


4




3 A minimum of 4 points should be obtained from this section, from which a maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. Two papers presented at the same meeting are scored at most

4

In scope of this article, 10 points can be obtained at most. Only one paper presented at the same meeting is scored.

6

In scope of this article, 25 points can be obtained at most. Two papers presented at the same meeting are scored at most.

12


2



A) A master’s or PhD or PhD equivalent course for one semester. 3


3


6








280

Having at least one hundred and twenty (120) points in scientific activity on the basis of the unit points assigned to the work above in the field of associate professorship applied in the Health Sciences discipline and provided that at least one hundred and ten (110) points of it have been obtained from the

work carried out after the obtainment of the doctoral title. Each piece of work is scored only in one section in the table above.



SOCIAL, HUMANITIES AND ADMINISTRATIVE SCIENCES DISCIPLINE International Area Indexes = Related indexes in ISI Database or SCOPUS. Conditions for the Appointment of a PhD Jury

Social, Humanities and Administrative Sciences Discipline



Social, Humanities and Administrative Sciences Discipline Criteria






Full research papers in the field of science applied (except letter to editor, abstract, review, technical note and book review)


20

A minimum of 2 publications from Type 1.A) (In publications produced from a thesis, the candidate is considered as the primary author.

24

On the condition that it is not produced from the postgraduate theses prepared by the candidate, at least one paper produced in scope of this article’s Section 1.A).

45

After the associate professorship, at least one publication is required under Section A) of this article indicating the candidate as the primary author.

90


10


5

D) Paper published in journals covered by international indexes, not including Section B) of this article and excluding letters to the editor, abstract or book review.

5


On the condition that the paper is related to the field of science applied and has not been produced from the postgraduate or specialty theses prepared by the candidate


It is mandatory to publish at least three papers, two of which are under Section A) of this article. If candidates other than those with Turkish citizenship and candidates who have applied for the recognition/equivalency of the associate professorship obtained abroad cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the same number of publications under Sections A) or B) of Article 1 instead.

10

For candidates with Turkish citizenship, a minimum of three publications, two of which are within the scope of Section A) of this article, are required. If the candidates cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the same number of publications in scope of Sections A or B of Article 1 instead.

18

B) Papers published in national refereed journals other than those specified in Section A).

4

3.

Papers Produced from Postgraduate Theses









E) Paper published in journals covered by SSCI, SCI-Expanded and AHCI 8








4. Book



Within the scope of this article, only original scientific books, other than textbooks, can be scored; Only one of the chapters in the same book is taken into account. Three or more of field-specific encyclopedia articles are considered a book chapter.

Within the scope of this article, only original scientific books, other than textbooks, can be scored. Only one of the chapters in the same book is taken into consideration. Three or more of field-specific encyclopedia articles are considered a book chapter. It is compulsory to have published at least one book or two book chapters within the scope of this article.

10

Within the scope of this article, only original scientific books, other than textbooks, can be scored. Only one of the chapters in the same book is taken into consideration. Three or more of field-specific encyclopedia articles are considered a book chapter. It is compulsory to have published at least one book or two book chapters within the scope of this article. Translation of a book for Professorship is considered only under Section D of this article. 50 points at most can be obtained within the scope of this article.


10



8

5. Citations

A)


3

30 points at most can be obtained in scope of this article. (The minimum citation score in the fields of Archeology and Philosophy is 14.)

20

80 points at most can be obtained in scope of this article. (The minimum citation score in the fields of Archeology and Philosophy is 34)

50 B)


2


1


Supervision of Completed Postgraduate Theses


A maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A and B, and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A, B and C sections of Article 1. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A, B and C sections of Article 1.

6

A maximum of 40 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A and B, and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from Section A of Article 1 * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from Section A of Article 1.

12




15





10

C) Undertaking duties (not including compilation and report writing work) in an ongoing or successfully completed in internationally supported scientific research projects, other than those specified in Items A and B.

6


4




3 A minimum of 4 points should be obtained from this section, from which a maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. Two papers presented at the same meeting are scored at most

4


6


12


2







Open, distance or face-to-face course offered after the completion of PhD. Studies.



3


6








280

Having at least one hundred and twenty (120) points in scientific activity on the basis of the unit points assigned to the work above in the field of associate professorship applied in Social, Humanities and Administrative Sciences discipline and provided that at least one hundred and ten (110) points of it

have been obtained from the work carried out after the obtainment of the doctoral title. Each piece of work is scored only in one section in the table above.

In publications (article, book, presentation) with a single author, the author gets full points. For publications with multiple authors, the score is divided equally among the authors.

SPORTS SCIENCES DISCIPLINE International Area Indexes = Indexes in the education/sports sciences in ISI Database, Australian Education Index, British Education Index, Journals Indexed in ERIC, Education Full Text (H. W. Wilson) Database Coverage List.


Sports Sciences Discipline Type Point SPECIAL CONDITION


Sports Sciences Discipline Criteria







Full research papers in the field of science applied (except letter to editor, abstract, review, technical note and book review)


20

A minimum of 2 publications from Type 1.A) (In publications produced from a thesis, the candidate is considered as the primary author.

24

On the condition that the publication has not been produced from the postgraduate thesis prepared by the candidate, obtainment of at least 20 points as the PRIMARY AUTHOR from Sections A) or B) (minimum one should be from Section A) of this article after the doctoral studies.

45

After the associate professorship, at least two publications are required under Section A) of this article indicating the candidate as the PRIMARY AUTHOR. In case the minimum score requirement of 90 has not been met, the missing score up to 15 points can be additionally obtained from Section A) of Article 2.

90 B) Paper published in a journal covered by an international index, not including letters to the editor, abstract or book review.

15


5


On the condition that the paper is related to the field of science applied and has not been produced from the postgraduate or specialty theses prepared by the candidate


It is mandatory to publish at least three papers in scope of this article. If candidates other than those with Turkish citizenship and candidates who have applied for the recognition/equivalency of the associate professorship obtained abroad cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the same number of publications under sections A) or B) of Article 1 instead.

8

It is mandatory to publish at least three papers in scope of this article. If candidates other than those with Turkish citizenship and candidates who have applied for the recognition/equivalency of the professorship obtained abroad cannot meet the requirement for papers published in national refereed journals indexed by ULAKBİM, they are expected to provide the same number of publications under sections A) or B) of Article 1 instead.

16

B) Papers published in national refereed journals other than those specified in Section A).

4

3.




At least 1 publication is required in scope of Sections A), B), C), D) and E) of this article. A maximum of 10 points can be obtained from this article.






E) Paper published in journals covered by SSCI, SCI-Expanded and AHCI 8








4. Book


A) Book published by international publishers 20 Within the scope of this article, only original scientific books, other than textbooks, can be scored; Only one of the chapters in the same book is taken into account. Three or more of field-specific encyclopedia articles are considered a book chapter. In the event of having more than one author, the scores are divided by the number of authors.

Within the scope of this article, only original scientific books, other than textbooks, can be scored; Only one of the chapters in the same book is taken into account. Three or more of field-specific encyclopedia articles are considered a book chapter. In the event of having more than one author, the scores are divided by the number of authors.

Within the scope of this article, only original scientific books, other than textbooks, can be scored; Only one of the chapters in the same book is taken into account. Three or more of field-specific encyclopedia articles are considered a book chapter. In the event of having more than one author, the scores are divided by the number of authors. Translation of a book for Professorship is considered only under Section D of this article. 50 points at most can be obtained within the scope of this article.


10



8

5. Citations

A)


3


20 A maximum of 80 points can be obtained from this article.

50 B)


2


1


Supervision of completed postgraduate theses


A maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A and B, and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A, B and C sections of Article 1. * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from the A, B and C sections of Article 1.

6

A maximum of 40 points can be obtained in scope of this article. In the event of a secondary / co-supervisor, the primary supervisor receives all of the points stipulated for Sections A and B, and the secondary supervisor receives half. 4 times of the missing points must be obtained from Sections A), B) and C) of Article 1, with at least one from Section A). * For candidates who apply for fields which have no postgraduate programs with thesis, 1.5 times of the missing points must be obtained from Sections A), B) and C) of Article 1, with at least one from Article 1, Section A).

12




15





10

C) Undertaking duties (not including compilation and report writing work) in an ongoing or successfully completed in internationally supported scientific research projects, other than those specified in Items A and B.

6


4









3 A minimum of 4 points should be obtained from this section, from which a maximum of 10 points can be obtained in scope of this article. Two papers presented at the same meeting are scored at most.

4


6


12


2


Open, distance or face-to-face course offered after the completion of PhD. Studies



3


6








280

Having at least one hundred and twenty (120) points in scientific activity on the basis of the unit points assigned to the work above in the field of associate professorship applied in the Sports Sciences discipline and provided that at least one hundred and ten (110) points of it have been obtained from the

work carried out after the obtainment of the doctoral title. Each piece of work is scored only in one section in the table above.



FINE ARTS DISCIPLINE CRITERIA FOR CINEMA, PLASTIC ARTS, DESIGN, TRADITIONAL TURKISH ARTS, RESTORATION AND CONSERVATION OF MOVABLE CULTURAL ASSETS SCIENCE/ART DISCIPLINES


In the Fine Arts Discipline (CINEMA, PLASTIC ARTS, DESIGN, TRADITIONAL TURKISH ARTS, RESTORATION AND CONSERVATION OF MOVABLE CULTURAL ASSETS SCIENCE AND ART DISCIPLINES)


Appointment of Proficiency in Art Jury Total scientific/artistic activities 21 Minimum one activity in Type 1.A)

CINEMA, PLASTIC ARTS, DESIGN, TRADITIONAL TURKISH ARTS, RESTORATION AND CONSERVATION OF MOVABLE CULTURAL ASSETS

Sub-discipline

Type Points





1

CINEMA, PLASTIC ARTS, DESIGN, TRADITIONAL TURKISH ARTS, RESTORATION AND CONSERVATION OF MOVEABLE CULTURAL ASSETS

A)

Participating in at least two personal events (exhibition, biennial, show, concert, festival and screening) with original works of art, designs or interpretation work. For each activity;

20

20

On the condition that the work has not been produced from the candidate’s postgraduate work/s.

40

On the condition that the work has not been produced from the candidate’s postgraduate work. After the obtainment of Associate Professorship, one event each in the FINE ARTS Discipline, organized / supported by International Organizations in Categories A and B.

80

B)

Participating in group-joint events (exhibitions, biennials, shows, concerts, films, festivals, screenings, national and international competitions) with original works of art, designs or interpretation works and / or permanent display of one or more work/s in the public space or its/their purchase. For each activity:

5 10 20

C)

Participating in events such as symposiums, festivals, workshops and biennials with one’s works or having supervised or coordinated a postgraduate thesis / work or text. For each activity;

7.5

10

15 30

D)

Publishing a book or at least two papers or having translated at least five articles related to the field or at least two books related to the field. For each activity; * One book = 12.5 * One article = 6.25 * A translated article = 2.5 * A translated book = 6.25

12.5 25 50

E)

Participating in scientific / artistic meetings such as symposiums, congresses and panels with more than one paper. For each activity;

5 10 20



Total Minimum Points 30 Att-A By adding 20 points to be taken from

the former ADEK Score Table 140

Att-A By adding 40 points to be taken from the former ADEK Score

Table 280

Based on the unit points assigned to the work above, involvement in a scientific / artistic activity with a value of a minimum of one hundred and twenty (120) points, on the condition that it is related with the associate professorship discipline applied, that it has not been produced from the postgraduate

work(s) of the candidate and that at least one hundred and ten (110) points have been obtained from work carried out after the obtainment of the PhD. Title. Each piece of work is scored only in one section in the table above.


Att-A

OLD ACADEMIC EVALUATION CRITERIA

SCORING TABLE

DISTRIBUTION OF POINTS IN COOPERATIVE ACTIVITIES

One person: 1 unit

Two people: 0.8 unit each

Three people: 0.6 unit each

Four people: 0.4 unit each

Five people or more: 1/(N-1) unit each

In addition to the Scoring Table, ONLY the YELLOW HIGHLIGHTED sections of the

following articles are taken into account for scoring related matters.

Same points are used for all disciplines.

Att-A

POINTS

1 RESEARCH AND PUBLICATION ACTIVITIES

1.1 INTERNATIONAL

1.1.1 PAPER

1.1.1.01 Paper published in a journal covered by the SCI, SSCI, or AHCI core list, not including letters to the editor, technical notes, case studies, or discussion papers

15 20 20 20

1.1.1.02 Paper published in a journal covered by the SCI expanded list, not including letters to the editor, technical notes, case studies, or discussion papers

12 - 15 -

1.1.1.03 Paper published in a refereed and periodical journal

covered by an international index

10 10 10 10

1.1.1.04 Research report, research note and technical notes in full paper format published in a journal covered by SCI, SSCI, AHCI and Expanded SCI. Paper published in a periodical selectively covered by the SSCI; paper published in a periodical journal (covered by a

“branch” index such as the international AI, API, RIBA, and DAAI) recommended by the Faculty Council and approved by the University Executive Board)

UEB 11/582-7:

The evaluation of publications within the scope of 1.1.1.04 published prior to the approval of the 1.1.1.04 list by the University Executive Board

10 15 15 15

1.1.1.05 Book review, technical note, case study, letter to the

editor, or discussion type paper published in periodicals

described in 1.1.1.01, 02, 03 and 04

3-5

1.1.2 BOOK

1.1.2.01 Monograph, scientific/professional/artistic book or textbook published abroad and of an international nature (the nature of the international publisher, whether the publisher is well-known in the area of the book, the refereeing / editing process, and the number of copies printed will be examined)

40 40 40 40

1.1.2.02 Scientific/professional/artistic book of an international nature outside the definition in 1.1.2.01

25 25 25 25

1.1.2.03 Chapter in a book published abroad and of an international

nature as defined in 1.1.2.01

15 15 15 15

1.1.2.04 Chapter in a book published abroad and of an international

nature as defined in 1.1.2.02

10 10 10 10

1.1.2.05 Editorship of a book defined in 1.1.2.01 15 15 15 15


1.1.3 PATENT

1.1.3.01 Patent 30 30 30 30

1.1.4 CONFERENCE

1.1.4.01 Full paper, poster. a) Paper/poster presented and published (either in print or electronically) in full in the proceedings of an international and refereed conference or symposium, 5 points b) Paper/poster presented and published (either in print or electronically) in full in the proceedings of a conference or symposium listed in Web Of Science, 8 points

5 / 8 5 / 8 5 / 8 5 / 8

1.1.4.02 Paper abstract. Paper presented in full and its abstract published in the proceedings of an international and refereed conference or symposium

2 2 2 2

1.1.4.03 Organizing an international conference with proceedings 7

1.1.4.04 Editing the proceedings of an international conference 5

1.1.4.05 Participating as an elected or invited person in an activity of an international organisation including an exhibition, project, application, design, performance etc. with one’s own product.

2

Att-A

1.2.4.06 Organising a workshop as a speaker/invited designer/artist within the scope of international activities

1

1.1.5 CITATIONS

1.1.5.01 N = Number of citations by other authors in books, or in

journals covered by SCI, SSCI, and AHCI lists

N/2 N/2 N/2 N/2

1.2 NATIONAL/LOCAL

1.2.1 PAPER

1.2.1.01 Type A paper. Paper published in a Type A national

periodical journal according to the list recommended by the Faculty and approved by the University (In the grouping of journals, the following criteria will be considered: the nature of the board of publishers; academic referees and blind peer review; regularity of publication; conformity to the scientific format; circulation; “coefficient of efficiency”; citation density; refusal rate; rate of contributions from outside the institution and from abroad. Unless any amendments are made, the METU list will be valid.)

6 10 10 5

1.2.1.02 Type B paper. Paper published in a Type B national

periodical journal according to the list recommended by the Faculty and approved by the University

2 6 6 3

1.2.1.03 Type C paper. Paper published in a Type C national

periodical journal according to the list recommended by the Faculty and approved by the University

1 2 2 2

1.2.2 BOOK

1.2.2.01 Authorship of a scientific, artistic or professional book or textbook

(superior in terms of publisher, refereeing process, number

of copies printed, and format)

20 20 20 20

1.2.2.02 Authorship of a scientific, artistic or professional book outside the

definition in 1.1.2.01

10 10 10 10

1.2.2.03 Chapter in a book defined in 1.2.2.01 8 8 8 8

1.2.2.04 Chapter in a book defined in 1.2.2.02 6 6 6 8



1.2.2.07 Authentic scientific book correspondent with Inter-Universities Council pursuant to Higher Education Law 24/b/2.

- - - 40

1.2.3 PATENT

1.2.3.01 Patent 20 20 20 20

1.2.4 CONFERENCE

1.2.4.01 Full paper, poster.

Paper/poster presented and published (either in print or electronically) in full in the proceedings of a national and refereed conference or symposiums

2 2 2 2

1.2.4.02 Paper abstract.

Paper presented in full and its abstract published in the proceedings of a national and refereed conference or symposium.

1 1 1 1

1.2.4.03 Organizing a national conference with proceedings (either in print or electronic format)

4

1.2.4.04 Editing the proceedings (either in print or electronic format) of a national conference

2

1.2.4.05 Participating as an elected or invited person in an activity of a national organisation including an exhibition, project, application, design, performance etc. with one’s own product.

3

1.2.4.06 Organising a workshop as an invited speaker/designer/artist within the scope of national activities

2

1.2.4.07 Organising a national competition/festival/biennial with a printed catalogue

4

1.2.5 CITATIONS

1.2.5.01 N = Number of citations by other authors in books or journals N/5 N/5 N/5 N/5

1.2.5.02 N= Number of citations of scientific publications in court decisions N/2 N/2 N/2 N/2

2 OTHER RESEARCH AND PROFESSIONAL ACTIVITIES

2.1 RESEARCH PROJECTS

Att-A

2.1.1 REPORTS

2.1.1.01 Type A research project. Finalized. Report on a project supported by NATO-SFS, EU, UN, NSF, TUBITAK (1001 and similar scale) and similar organizations or other international research projects (The nature of the support obtained and of the contribution made by the individual to a regular project open to international participation, based on competition, will be considered.)

20 20 20 20

2.1.1.02 Type B research project. Report on a national/local project supported by TÜBİTAK (1002 and similar scale) or the Ministry of National Education and Culture (Type B) or other similar projects supported by the University’s own resources (Type A)

10 10 10 10

2.1.1.03 Type C research project. Report on other finalised national projects

5 5 5 5

2.1.2 ARCHITECTURE, DESIGN AND WORKS/ACTIVITIES OF ART

2.1.2.01 Realized international prize-winning project/work. Awarding of a prize to a realized work in the field of architecture, planning, design or arts by an internationally recognized institution and/or a prize considered to be permanent upon the evaluation of an international evaluation board.

- - 20 -

2.1.2.02 Realized and internationally published-on project/work. A work on which evaluation has been conducted upon as defined in 1.1.1. or

1.1.1.2 a) If the work is directly under examination: 10 points b) If the work is mentioned for its originality: 5 points or the work, project, design and application appearing in international publications (e.g. book, encyclopedia, catalogue, periodical art journals, TV documentaries, films etc...)

-

-

5, 10

-

2.1.2.03 Realized national prize-winning project/work. Awarding of a prize to a realized work in the field of architecture, planning, design or arts by a nationally recognized institution and/or a prize considered to be permanent.

- - 10 -

2.1.2.04 Realized and nationally published-on work. A work on which evaluation has been conducted upon as defined in 1.2.1. or 1.2.2 a) If the work is directly under examination: 5 points, b) If the work is mentioned for its originality: 3 points or the work, project, design and application appearing in national publications (e.g. book, encyclopedia, catalogue, periodical art journals, TV, documentaries, films etc...)

- - 3 / 5

-

2.1.2.05 Internationally reviewed work/project (Work accepted/appearing at international organisations/exhibitions).

- - 5 -

2.1.2.06 Nationally reviewed work/project (Work accepted/appearing at international organisations/exhibitions).

- - 3 -

2.1.3 INTELLECTUAL/COMPETITION PROJECT

2.1.3.01 International Project Competition. The competition in the field of architecture, design, or arts has to be conducted in accordance with the competition regulations of international professional institutions (UIA, ISOCARP, ICSID, IDA, IFI, ICOGRADA etc.). First three places: 40; honorable mentions: 20

- - 20 / 40 -

2.1.3.02 National Project Competition. The competition in the field of architecture, design, or arts has to be conducted in accordance with the competition regulations of Ministries and related professional institutions. First three places: 25; honorable mention: 15.

- - 15 / 25 -

2.1.3.03 Internationally published intellectual project. A work on which a paper has been published of the type defined in 1.1.1, or 1.1.2 a) If the work is directly under examination: 10 points b) If the work is mentioned for its originality: 5 points

5 / 10

2.1.3.04 Nationally published intellectual project. A work on which a paper has been published of the type defined in 1.2.1, or 1.2.2 a) If the work is directly under examination: 5 points b) If the work is

mentioned for its originality: 3 points

3 / 5

2.1.4 WORK/PRODUCTS IN THE FIELD OF COMMUNICATION AND MEDIA

2.1.4.01 Work on media either presented to the public or applied and awarded international prizes: for example online communication networks, newspapers, journals, multimedia journalism, works of graphic design, works of web design, blogs, public relation campaigns, advertising campaigns, film production, radio programs, script writing, program construction, artistic work, shows, work on interactive multimedia etc...

20

2.1.4.02 Work on media either presented to the public or applied and awarded national prizes (please refer to 2.1.4.01 for examples)

10

Att-A

2.1.4.03 Work on media at an international level either presented to the public or applied (please refer to 2.1.4.01 for examples)

5

2.1.4.04 Work on media at a national level either presented to the public or applied (please refer to 2.1.4.01 for examples)

3

2.2 TRANSLATIONS

2.2.1.01 Published professional or scientific book translation 6 6 6 6

2.2.1.02 Published professional or scientific paper translation 1 1 1 2

2.2.1.03 Published court ruling translation - - - 1

2.3 PROFESSIONAL EXHIBITIONS/PRESENTATIONS

2.3.1.01 International individual art presentation, exhibition etc.(published with a program)

10

2.3.1.02 National individual art presentation, exhibition etc. (published with a program)

5

3 EDUCATIONAL ACTIVITIES

3.1 THESIS

3.1.1 Ph.D. THESIS

3.1.1.01 Thesis Supervision: Completed thesis supervision. In the event of having more than one thesis supervisor, 4 points are assigned to the (main) thesis supervisor, 2 points are assigned to the co-supervisor, and 3 points are assigned to both supervisors in the event of the presence of two co-supervisors.

6 6 6 6

3.1.2 MASTER’S THESIS

3.1.2.01 Thesis Supervision: Completed thesis supervision. In the event of having more than one thesis supervisor, 2 points are assigned to the (main) thesis supervisor, 1 point is assigned to the co-supervisor and 1.5 points are assigned to both supervisors in the event of the presence of two co-supervisors.

3 3 3 3

3.1.3 PROFICIENCY IN ARTS SUPERVISION

3.1.3.01 Completed proficiency in arts supervision. In the event of having more than one thesis supervisor, 3 points are assigned to the (main) thesis supervisor, 2 points are assigned to the co-supervisor and 2.5 points are assigned to both supervisors in the event of the presence of two co-supervisors.

5 5 5

3.2 INSTRUCTION

3.2.1 VARIOUS INSTRUCTIONAL ACTIVITIES

3.2.1.01 Laboratory Development: Having developed a laboratory for a course or for research purposes.

10

3.2.1.02 Please refer to Minimum Conditions for Appointment and Promotion: Note-2

3.2.1.03 For the publication of each course book printed upon the approval of EMU Publishing or the Faculty Board 5 points are assigned; for each complementary coursebook, 3 points are assigned.

3 / 5

3.2.1.04 3 points are assigned for the development of a portfolio or website for a course, 2 points are assigned for the preparation of comprehensive lecture notes or the development of computer programs; 1 point is assigned for the development and organisation of courses offered by the Institute for Distance Education

1-3

3.2.1.05 Studio-focused instruction. Transfer of the professional and academic accumulation to the studio instruction. (Approval of the Faculty Board is sought)

2

4 AWARDS AND MEMBERSHIPS

4.1 INTERNATIONAL

4.1.1 AWARDS

4.1.1.01 Achievement Prize: Award of a prize as a result of a permanent evaluation / competition open to international participation for a piece of research, publication or professional work in the relevant field of science/arts/design. (First three places 40, honorable mentions 20, plaque 10)

10-40

4.1.2 MEMBERSHIPS

Att-A

4.1.2.01 Membership of an international award evaluation board, of the board of editors in a periodical publication or of a jury; or undertaking duties as a jury member of projects and arts events in the field of international design

2 x Year

4.1.2.02 Editorship in an international periodical publication: 4 points x year, co-editorship: 2 points x year

2-4 x Year

4.1.2.03 Refereeing in 1.1.1 type international publications (number of articles evaluated x 1 point)

1 x no. of papers

4.1.2.04 Refereeing in 1.1.4 type international conferences (number of evaluated presentations x 0.5 points, on the condition that the total point obtained does not exceed 6)

0.5-6

4.1.2.05 Refereeing a project supported by NATO-SFS, EU, UN, NSF, TUBITAK

5 x no. of projects

4.2 NATIONAL/LOCAL

4.2.1 AWARDS

4.2.1.01 Achievement Prize: Award of a prize as a result of a permanent evaluation / competition open to national/local participation for a piece of research, publication or professional work in the relevant field of science/arts/design. First three places: 20; honorable mentions: 10; plaque: 5

5 / 10 / 20

4.2.1.02 TUBITAK Science Award 40

4.2.2 MEMBERSHIPS

4.2.2.01 Membership of an national award evaluation board, of the board of editors in a periodical publication or of a jury; or undertaking duties as a jury member of projects and arts events in the field of national/local design

1 x Year

4.2.2.02 Editorship in an national/local periodical publication: 2 points x year, co-editorship: 1 point x year

1-2 x Year

4.2.2.03 Refereeing in 1.2.1 type national/local publications (number of articles evaluated x 0.5 point)

0.5 x no. of. papers

5 SERVICES

5.1 GENERAL

5.1.1 ACADEMIC ADMINISTRATIVE DUTY

5.1.1.01 Senior Administrative Position at other Institutions: High Level

administrative experience in institutions (local or in another country) other than EMU.

1xYear

5.1.2 PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE AND NON-ACADEMIC ADMINISTRATIVE DUTY

5.1.2.01 Professional experience in the relevant field of science. 1xYear

5.1.2.02 Senior level professional administrative experience in public, private and KIT (Public Economic Enterprises) sectors.

0.5xYear

5.2 SERVICES TOWARDS EMU AND COMMUNITY

5.2.1 SERVICES TOWARDS EMU

5.2.1.01 Administrative duties in the university: Administration, vice-administration, and council membership duties at academic units specified in EMU regulations and by-laws, and membership in committees established upon the decision of the University Senate and the University Executive Board (vice rectors, deans and school directors are assigned 5 points; department chairs, vice deans, academic staff undertaking administrative duties at the Rector’s Office are granted 4 points, assistant directors and assistant department chairs are granted 3 points, center chairs are granted 2 points, members of boards, and elected members of the Senate and the Faculty Council, and commission/committee members determined by the Senate, University Executive Board, Institute/School/Faculty Council, Faculty Executive Board and Department Board are granted 1 point)

(1-5) x Year

5.2.1.02 Establishment and Development activities: To undertake duties in the establishment of a new unit in EMU (Faculty: 15 points; department: 10 points; a new program within the department: 5 points; and research center: 3 points)

3-15

5.2.1.03 Commission membership in international accreditation projects. For each year, 4 points are assigned. For national accreditation work (ISO etc.), 2 points are assigned for each year.

2 / 4 x Year

5.2.1.04 In-service training and/or seminar activities targeted towards university staff: For each training session or seminar, 1 point is assigned.

1

Att-A

5.2.1.05 1 point is assigned for the preparation of questions for each internal examination organised by EMU Exam Commission formed upon the decision of the University Executive Board. 1 point is assigned for the evaluation of questions in the aforesaid exams, and 2 points are granted for the organisation of the said exams.

1 / 2

5.2.2 SERVICES TOWARDS COMMUNITY

5.2.2.01 Educational activities: In-service training activities targeted towards the staff of state departments and/or non-governmental organisations; preparation and/or evaluation of exams for promotion, ranking, selecting, and competition purposes. 1 point is assigned for each.

1

5.2.2.02 Informing: For each activity appearing in printed or visual media organs with the purpose of informing the public in one’s own field, 1 point is assigned

1

5.2.2.03 Preparation of an expert report: Each expert report demanded by organisations and prepared in one’s own field of expertise; 2 points are assigned for international and 1 point for national reports.

1 / 2

Documents

ACADEMIC EVALUATION CRITERIA