Addressing the barriers of introducing edible insects into the Western World and proposing marketing methods of how to effectively achieve this

7/23/2019 Addressing the barriers of introducing edible insects into the Western World and proposing marketing methods of …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/addressing-the-barriers-of-introducing-edible-insects-into-the-western-world 1/17

"##$%&&'() *+% ,-$$'%$& ./ '(*$.#:>'() %#',4%

'(&%>*& '(*. *+% 9%&*%$( 9.$4# -(# 0$.0.&'()7-$1%*'() 7%*+.#& ./ +.< *. %//%>*'6%43

->+'%6% *+'&;

8:>3 ?-$*'(

!"#$%&&'( &*+ ,%-. /'&:'>.44

90 71*<-6 0>& .<( 3'-%;<

8*<&'$?*>.>5 .<( 1%-&*>%2.4 8*<&'=&- 0JNDI@G

9%>$%<;:.$ 8%&5 A<%L'>-%&5IF

&: 3'2'$#'> G@IC



I

K022*>(%<; &* &:' AH O' <''( &* ?>*("2' E@B $*>' M**( %< &:' <'=& M*>&5 5'.>-Z ^'& O' 2*<&%<"'

&* *L'>?*?"4.&' &:' ?4.<'&T "-' "? >'-*">2'- .<( %;<*>' &:' O.><%<; -%;<-ZY 70Z 3"<<'T PZ J.#5T

G@IWQ \;ZICI6 '<&*$*?:.;5T &:' ?>.2&%2' *M '.&%<; %<-'2&-T %- "<2*$$*< %< &:' V'-&'>< V*>4(T

#"& %- -&.>&%<; &* #' >'2*;<%-'( .- . L.4".#4'T -"-&.%<.#4' M**( -*">2'Z KS& %- '-&%$.&'( &:.& %<-'2&[

'.&%<; %- ?>.2&%-'( >';"4.>45 #5 .& 4'.-& G #%44%*< ?'*?4' O*>4(O%('Y 7P0X *M &:' AHT G@IWQ \;ZI6Z

N:%- (%--'>&.&%*< O%44 '=?4*>' :*O &* -"22'--M"445 $.>_'& '(%#4' %<-'2&- &* &:' O'-& .<( 2>'.&' .

4*<; 4.-&%<; M**( -*">2'Z N* .2:%'L' &:%-T S O%44 M%>-& *"&4%<' &:' $*-& ?>*#4'$.&%2 #.>>%'>- &* &:'

'.&%<; *M %<-'2&- %< &:' V'-&T -"2: .- &:'%> %$.;'T &'=&">'T .--*2%.&%*< O%&: (%-'.-' .<( . ;'<'>.4

4.2_ *M _<*O4'(;' *< '<&*$*?:.;5Z N* "<('>-&.<( :*O &:'-' #.>>%'>- 2.< #' *L'>2*$'T S O%44

.<.45-' 8>%-2*U- #>.<(%<;T O:%2: %- . O'44[_<*O< #>.<( *M -:*>&'<%<; %< 0$'>%2.Z 0- &:%- ?>*("2& %-

$.(' M>*$ %<;>'(%'<&- &:.& O'>' $*>' 2*$$*<45 "-'( %< -*.? .<( 2.<(4'-T &:%- L';'&.#4' M.&

-"#-&.<2' 2*"4( :.L' #''< -''< .- "<.??'.4%<;Z 1*O'L'>T 8>%-2*U- $.>_'&%<; .<( #>.<(%<;

&'2:<%R"'- &"><'( %& %<&* . :*"-':*4( <.$' &:.& :.- #''< *<' *M &:' $*-& ?*?"4.> #>.<(- %<

0$'>%2. M*> *L'> I@@ 5'.>-Z S O%44 &:'< .<.45-' ]<&*T O:%2: %- . ?>*j'2& &:.& :.- #''< 2>'.&'( #5 .

;>*"? *M ('-%;< $.-&'>- -&"('<&-T O:* :.L' #>.<('(T $.>_'&'( .<( 2>'.&'( . $*>' .??'.4%<;

M*>$ *M %<-'2& M**(Z S O%44 '=.$%<' &:'%> $'&:*(- *M #>.<(%<; .<( $.>_'&%<; &* M%<( *"& O:.& &:'%>

$*-& -"22'--M"4 &'2:<%R"'- O'>' .<( :*O &* %$?>*L' .<( '=?.<( *< &:'$Z /5 <'=& -&'? %- &*

'L.4".&' !"?'>M**(- .<( :*O &:'5 :.L' #''< $.>_'&'( &* &:' 2*<-"$'>-T &:>*";: NZnZ .<( &:'

$'(%.Z S O%44 .<.45-' &O* '=.$?4'-+ . NZnZ M'.&">' .<( .< *<4%<' .>&%24'T O:%2: ?>*$*&'

!"?'>M**(-T &* .--'-- O:'&:'> &:' &'2:<%R"'- "-'( 2.< #' &>.<-M'>>'( &* &:' $.>_'&%<; *M '(%#4'

%<-'2&-Z N:>*";:*"& &:%- (%--'>&.&%*< S O%44 >'M'> #.2_ &* &:' #.>>%'>- &:.& :.L' #''< :%;:4%;:&'(

.<( -''%<; :*O #'-& &:'5 2*"4( #' .((>'--'( O%&: '.2: &'2:<%R"' &:.& S :.L' %<L'-&%;.&'(T &*

2>'.&' . -"22'--M"445 $.>_'&'( '<&*$*?:.;5 ?>*("2&Z

S<&>*("2%<; '(%#4' %<-'2&- &* &:' V'-&'>< O*>4(d- (.%45 (%'& :.- $.<5 .(L.<&.;'-Z S& %- .<

'<L%>*<$'<&.445 -"-&.%<.#4' M**( -*">2' &:.& O*"4( 2*<-%('>.#45 >'("2' &:' ?'>2'<&.;' *M

;>''<:*"-' ;.- '$%--%*<- 2."-'( #5 2.&&4' >'.>%<;T O:%2: 2">>'<&45 -&.<(- .& IiBT O*>4(O%('

7P0X *M &:' AHT G@IWQ \;ZDG6Z N:' 4%L'-&*2_ %<("-&>5 .4-* &._'- "? G@B *M &:' O*>4(d- .;>%2"4&">.4

4.<(T O:'&:'> %&d- "-'( M*> ?.-&">'4.<( *> ;>*O%<; M''( M*> &:' 2.&&4'T O:%2: :.- 2."-'( -'L'>'

('M*>'-&.&%*<Z /%<%$.4 -?.2' %- <''('( &* 2"4&%L.&' %<-'2&- .<( 2*"4( 'L'< #' 2*<&.%<'( &*

M.>$%<; O%&:%< O.>':*"-'- 7P%;ZI6Z S<-'2& >'.>%<; %- . R"%2_ ?>*2'--T 'Z;Z &* >.%-' . 2>%2_'& M>*$ ';;

&* .("4&:**( &._'- .??>*=%$.&'45 FC (.5- .<( &:'5 >'R"%>' 4'-- '<'>;5 &* M.>$Z XL'>.44 %<-'2&

>'.>%<; O%44 2*-& -"#-&.<&%.445 4'-- &:.< 2.&&4' >'.>%<; .<( M**( -&*2_ 2.< #' '.-%45 >'?4'<%-:'( %< .

-:*>& .$*"<& *M &%$'Z



G

P%>-&45 &:' R"'-&%*<+ Ò:5 O'-&'>< -*2%'&5 (*'-<U& .4>'.(5 :.L' %<-'2&- %< &:'%> (%'&gd <''(- &* #'

.<-O'>'( &* "<('>-&.<( O:.& :.- #''< -&*??%<; O'-&'>< -*2%'&5 M>*$ '.&%<; %<-'2&-Z S& %- &:*";:&

&:.& >'.>%<; 4.>;' &'>>'-&>%.4 $.$$.4%.< :'>#%L*>'- .<( *$<%L*>'- O'>' $*>' ?*?"4.> .- &:'5

O'>' -''< .- . $*>' ?>*$%-%<; M**( -*">2'Z aN:'-' .<%$.4- <*& *<45 5%'4('( 2*<-%('>.#4'

.$*"<&- *M $'.&l #"& .4-* O.>$&:T $%4_ ?>*("2&-T 4'.&:'>T O**4T ?4*";: &>.2&%*< .<( $'.<- *M

&>.<-?*>&Z S& %- &:*";:& &:.& %& O.- #'2."-' *M &:' "&%4%&5 *M &:'-' .<%$.4- &:.& &:' "-' *M %<-'2&- f

#'-%('- :*<'5#''-T -%4_O*>$- .<( -2.4' %<-'2&- f M.%4'( &* ;.%< $"2: &>.2&%*< %< &:' V'-&Z S<-'2&--%$?45 2*"4( <*& *MM'> &:' -.$' #'<'M%&-Za 7P0X *M &:' AHT G@IWQ \;ZWC6Z

!'2*<(45T &:' #.>>%'>- *M '.&%<; %<-'2&- <''( &* #' %('<&%M%'(Z N:' -&%;$. .>*"<( '(%#4' %<-'2&- 2.<

#' 2."-'( #5 &:' M'.> *M &:' "<_<*O<Z 0 4.2_ *M _<*O4'(;' *< . -"#j'2& 2.< -*$'&%$'- -&''>

?'*?4' .O.5 M>*$ &>5%<; <'O &:%<;-Z KV:%4' -"2: `*&:'>O*>4(4%<'--d 2.< ?>*L*_' 2">%*-%&5 .<(

'L'< O*<('> %< -*$' ?'*?4'T &:' $*>' &5?%2.4 :"$.< >'-?*<-' &* &:' "<_<*O< %- &:.& *M M'.> .<(

(%-(.%<Z P*> $*-& ?'*?4'T %<-'2&-T .<( *&:'> %<L'>&'#>.&'-T >'$.%< 4.>;'45 .4%'< .<( "<M.&:*$.#4'Y

7!ZJZ c'44'>&T IkkWQ \;ZiCG6Z N:' O'-&'>< .L'>-%*< &* %<-'2&- %- K(%L'>-'T 2*$?4'= .<( $"4&%M.2'&'(Y

7/*>>%-T G@@FQ \;IiW6 ("' &* 2"4&">.4 L%'O-Z S :.L' 24'.>45 *"&4%<'( &:' #.>>%'>-T O:%2: .>' -?4%& %<&*

&O* $.%< 2.&';*>%'-Z N:' M%>-& 2.&';*>5 %- (%-;"-& .- O'-&'>< -*2%'&5 .--*2%.&'- &:' ?>.2&%2' *M

'.&%<; %<-'2&- .- ?>%$%&%L' #':.L%*"> 7P0X *M &:' AHT G@IWQ \;ZWD6Z N:'%> .??'.>.<2' .<( %$.;%<'(

&'=&">' $%;:& 2*<&>%#"&' &* &:%-Z 0<*&:'> #.>>%'> .--*2%.&'( O%&: (%-;"-& %- &:.& %<-'2&- .>' -''< .-

(%>&5T 2.>>%'>- *M (%-'.-' .<( 2*"4( ?*%-*< *> 2."-' #*(%45 :.>$T %Z'Z #'' -&%<;T aO%&: .&&%&"('- *M

M'.>T .<&%?.&:5T .<( .L'>-%*<dd 7c'44'>& IkkWT ?ZiCI6Z 0- O'44 .- &:.&T -*$' %<-'2&-T -"2: .- $.;;*&-

.<( M4%'-T .>' .--*2%.&'( O%&: ('.&: .<( >*&&%<; M4'-:Z N:' *&:'> 2.&';*>5 %- . 4.2_ *M _<*O4'(;' *<

5');2 8Z \>.j%>&> 7G@IF6 !"#$%#&' )&*+,- .#/:



W

&:' -"#j'2& *M '<&*$*?:.;5Z P*> %<-&.<2'T M.>$%<; .<( O:'>' &* #"5T :*O &* -&*>' .<( 2**_

%<-'2&-T O:.& $'.4- &* %<24"(' &:'$ %<T O:.& &:'%> :'.4&: .<( <"&>%&%*<.4 #'<'M%&- .>'T ?4"- O:.&

&:' '<L%>*<$'<&.4 .(L.<&.;'- *M '.&%<; %<-'2&- .>'Z

S< *>('> &* ?>*?*-' %('.- *< :*O &* #>'._ (*O< &:'-' #.>>%'>-T &:' M*44*O%<; .<.45-%- -:*O- &O*

'=.$?4'-T *<' :%-&*>%2.4 .<( *<' 2*<&'$?*>.>5Z S< &:'-' %<-&.<2'-T "<.??'.4%<; M**(- :.L' #''<

$.>_'&'( -"22'--M"445Z 0 &:%>( '=.$?4' -:*O- :*O !"?'>M**(- :.L' #''< $.>_'&'( &* .4&'> &:'$

M>*$ 'L'>5(.5 M**( &* M**( &:.& :'4? &* `-.L' 5*"> 4%M'dZ

='&*.$'> JN-704% D I$'&>.

8>%-2*T .< 0$'>%2.< M*>$ #>.<( *M -:*>&'<%<; 2>'.&'( #5 \>*2&'> h o.$#4' 7\ho6T O.- M%>-& ?"& *<

&:' $.>_'& %< IkII .<( %- $.(' M>*$ L';'&.#4' .<( 2*&&*<-''( *%4Z 0& &:' &%$' *M %&- >'4'.-'T \ho

O'>' O'44 _<*O< M*> ?>*("2%<; .<( -'44%<; 2.<(4'- .<( -*.?Z 8>%-2* O.-<U& 4%_' .<5 *&:'> M**( &:'

2*<-"$'> :.( 2**_'( O%&: #'M*>' .<( &:'%> 4.2_ *M ?>*("2& _<*O4'(;' 2*"4( :.L' ?>'L'<&'(

&:'$ M>*$ "-%<; %&Z

N* $._' 2*<-"$'>- 2*$M*>&.#4' O%&: "-%<; 8>%-2*T \ho ;.L' *"& .- $"2: %<M*>$.&%*< .- ?*--%#4'

[ &:' $*>' &:' 2*<-"$'>- _<'OT &:' $*>' 4%_'45 &:'5 O*"4( &>"-& &:' ?>*("2& .<( #"5 %&Z \ho

%<&>*("2'( .< '.>45 L'>-%*< *M &:' M*2"- ;>*"?T 2.44'( `8>%-2* N'.-dZ 0& &:'-' ;.&:'>%<;-

24"#O*$'< O'>' %<L%&'( &* '=?'>%$'<& O%&: &:' ?>*("2& &* '=.$%<' %&- ?*&'<&%.4 "-'- %< 2**_%<;Z

N:'-' M*2"- ;>*"?- .>' . O.5 &* "<('>-&.<( :*O &* ('L'4*? . ?>*("2& M>*$ &:' $.>_'&d-

M''(#.2_T #"& &:'5 2*"4( .4-* .--'-- &:' ?.>&%2%?.<&-d _<*O4'(;' *M '<&*$*?:.;5Z \4"-T $.>_'&'>-

2.< ;.";' 2*<-"$'>-d >'.2&%*<-T '<-">%<; %& %- &:' >%;:& >'.2&%*<T #'M*>' >'4'.-%<; &:' ?>*("2& &*

&:' ;'<'>.4 ?"#4%2Z KN:' %<&'>L%'O'> *> $*('>.&*> 2.< '=?4*>' &:' >'-?*<-'- ;%L'< &* R"'-&%*<- *>

2*$$'<&- .<( &:"- (%-2*L'> $*>' .#*"& %<(%L%(".4-U ?'>2'?&%*<- .<( L%'O-Z N:'5 2.< ?>*#' &:'

.22">.25 *M 2*$$'<&- 7$.5#' %< >'-?*<-' &* <*<[L'>#.4 2"'-T -"2: .- ;'-&">'- *> M.2%.4

'=?>'--%*<-6 .<( .-_ M*44*O["? R"'-&%*<- &* 24.>%M5 *> R".4%M5 >'-?*<-'- ;%L'<ZY >49 0#&71</'6 39

;,3<&#7"6 8??52 =795JZ N* "-' &:'-' ;>*"?- 'MM'2&%L'45 &:' 2*$?.<5 2*"4( &.4_ &* &:' -.$'

?'*?4' &:>*";:*"& &:' ('L'4*?$'<& -&.;' &* 4%-&'< &* &:'%> M''(#.2_ .<( M*>'2.-& :*O &:'%>

?>*("2& $.5 #' %<&>*("2'( %< &:' >'.4 O*>4(Z P%L' &* -%= *M &:'-' M*2"- ;>*"?- 2*"4( #' "-'( .- .<

'=?'>%$'<& &* ;.";' O:.& &:' >'.2&%*< *M &:' ?"#4%2 $%;:& #'Z



F

0<*&:'> O.5 &* '<2*">.;' &:' "-' *M 8>%-2* O.- &* -'<( M>'' -.$?4'- .<( 2**_#**_- &* ;>*2'>-

.<( ?*&'<&%.4 2*<-"$'>- 7P%;ZG6Z 3*%<; &:%- 2*"4( :'4? &* %<-?%>' '=?'>%$'<&.&%*< O%&: . ?>*("2&T

&* %<2>'.-' %&- ?*?"4.>%&5 .<( ?>*L%(' _<*O4'(;' *M :*O &* "-' %& %< &>%'( .<( &'-&'( >'2%?'-Z N:%-

.44*O- &:' 2*<-"$'>T O:* $.5 #' O.>5 *M &:' %<;>'(%'<&T &* *L'>2*$' &:' M'.> *M <*& _<*O%<;

O:.& &* (* O%&: %& .<( '<2*">.;'- &:'$ &* 2*<&%<"' #"5%<; %&Z 95 ;%L%<; *"& M>'' -.$?4'T &:'

2*<-"$'> O*"4( M''4 &:.& &:'5 :.( `<*&:%<; &* 4*-'d #5 &>5%<; %& *"& .<( _<*O O:.& &:'5 .>'

#"5%<; %< &:' M"&">'T ;.%<%<; $*>' &>"-& %< &:' $.<"M.2&">'> .<( &:'%> ?>*("2&Z 1*O'L'>T &:'>' %- .

>%-_ :'>'T #'2."-' &:' 2*-& .<( >'-*">2'- >'R"%>'( $.5 #' O.-&'( %M &:' ?>*("2& %-<d& O'44

>'2'%L'(Z ]L'< &:*";: &:' $.<"M.2&">'> O%44 :.L' 2*<M%('<2' %< %&- ?>*("2&T &:' "-' *M M*2"-

;>*"?- %- L%&.4 #'M*>' '$#.>_%<; *< &:' <'=& -&.;' *M $.>_'&%<;Z o%L%<; *"& M>'' -.$?4'- *M %<-'2&-

&* 2*<-"$'>- 2*"4( ?*--%#45 ?"& &:'$ *MMT .- &:' -%;:& *M &:' %<-'2& .4*<' O%44T $*-& 4%_'45T #' -''<

.- (%-;"-&%<;Z 1*O'L'>T 2>'.&%<; M>'' -.$?4'- *M %<-'2& M**(T -"2: .- . `9'' !.4.(dT 2*"4(

'<2*">.;' &:'$ &* &>5 %& .<( ;.%< _<*O4'(;' *M :*O %<-'2&- 2.< #' "-'( %< 'L'>5(.5 (%-:'-Z

8>'.&%<; . 2**_#**_ O%&: >'2%?'- %<24"(%<; %<-'2&- O%44 '<.#4' &:' 2*<-"$'> &* ;.%< _<*O4'(;' *M

:*O &* 2>'.&' .<( 2**_ &:'-' M**(- %< &:' 2*$M*>& *M &:'%> *O< :*$'Z \'*?4' :.L' .4>'.(5

-&.>&'( &* (* &:%-T *<' '=.$?4' %- &:' ].&[.[9"; 8**_#**_ #5 3.L%( o'*>;' o*>(*< 7P%;ZW6Z N:'5

O%44 #' .#4' &* M*44*O . >'2%?' %< &:'%> *O< &%$' O%&:*"& &:' ?>'--">' *M '.&%<; %& %< . ?"#4%2

'<L%>*<$'<&Z 0- O'44 .- &:.&T &:' 2*$M*>& %< _<*O%<; &:.& &:'5 &:'$-'4L'- :.L' 2>'.&'( &:' M**(T

$'.<- &:.& &:'5 _<*O '=.2&45 O:.& %- %< %& .<( &:' ?>%(' *M 2**_%<; .< %<&'>'-&%<; .<( "<"-".4 (%-:

2*"4( '<2*">.;' &:'$ &* 2**_ %& M*> M>%'<(- .<( M.$%45T &:'>'#5 ;.%<%<; . O%('> ."(%'<2'Z

5');@ 8Z 9%;;'>-&.MM 7G@IW6 N/$*,< D I<@

:#/G+-$&7 -/A:L+' &A-/$-$<&9

5');G 3ZoZ o*>(*< 7G@IW6 !"+ F#-D#DCA7 N<<GK<<G

H+O$*+'9



C

S<&>*("2%<; '(%#4' %<-'2&- %<&* &:' :*$'- *M &:' V'-&'>< V*>4( 2*"4( :'4? &* $._' &:%- . 4*<;

4.-&%<; M**( -*">2' >.&:'> &:.< . &>'<(Z S& O%44 :*?'M"445 #'2*$' . M.$%45 M.L*">%&' .<( &:' >'2%?'-

2*"4( #' ?.--'( (*O< &:>*";: ;'<'>.&%*<-Z

0- 8>%-2* %- . L';'&.#4' #.-'( -:*>&'<%<;T %& O.- >';.>('( .- . _*-:'> %<;>'(%'<& .<( \ho

'=?4*%&'( &:%- :'.L%45 #5 &.>;'&%<; $.<5 *M &:'%> .(L'>&- .& &:' e'O%-: 2*$$"<%&5Z KJ.##%

/.>;*4%'- *M H'O ^*>_ -.%( &:.& &:' 1'#>'O J.2' :.( #''< O.%&%<; F@@@ 5'.>- M*> 8>%-2*Y 7/Z1Z

H'%4T IkIF+ \;Ik6Z \ho &:'< ?"#4%-:'( &:%- R"*&' %< &:'%> 2**_#**_ M*> &:' e'O%-: 1*"-'O%M'

7P%;ZF6Z

0%$%<; &:' ?>*("2& .& $*>' &:.< *<' $.>_'&T -"2: .- &:' e'O%-: 2*$$"<%&5T %- . M*>$ *M

`-';$'<&'( $.>_'&%<;dZ N:%- $'.<- &* -'?.>.&' 5*"> $.>_'& %<&* (%MM'>'<& 2*<-"$'> ;>*"?- .<(

-:.?' 5*"> .(L'>&%-%<; .<( #>.<(%<; &* 2.&'> M*> '.2: ;>*"?d- .&&>%#"&'-T <''(- .<( #':.L%*">- 70Z

9">>.&*T ,Z o>*--'&T 9Z n%-2*4.<% G@@D+ \;Z IGDG6Z N:' 2*<-"$'> 2*"4( &:'< M''4 .- %M &:%- ?>*("2&

:.- #''< $.(' M*> &:'$ .<( $''&- . <''(T 'Z;Z 8>%-2* -*4L'( . ?>*#4'$ M*> &:' e'O%-:

2*$$"<%&5T #'2."-' &:'5 :.( <'L'> :.( . -*4%(%M%'( M.& M*> 2**_%<; #'M*>'Z /.>_'&%<; '(%#4'

%<-'2&- &* <%2:' ;>*"?- %- .< 'MM'2&%L' O.5 &* -&.>&Z X<2' &:' ?>*("2& :.- #'2*$' ?*?"4.>T '.2: *M

&:'-' ;>*"?- 2*"4( #' ;>*O< &* %<24"(' . #>*.('> $.>_'&Z !&.>&%<; O%&: -&>*<; M*"<(.&%*<- *M

5');A ,Z !2:%$'4 7G@@D6 N/$*,< H+,$L+* 1</ -"+ 4+@$*" I<A*+@$1+



D

?*?"4.>%&5 .44*O- &:' 2*<-"$'> &* M''4 &:.& &:' $.<"M.2&">'> .<( &:' ?>*("2& %- >'4%.#4' .<(

&>"-&O*>&:5Z S< . #**_ 2.44'( 8>]0N'+ '.&%<;T ('-%;< .<( M"&">' M**( #5 N:' P"&">' ,.#*>.&*>5T

&:'5 &.4_ .#*"& . L.>%'&5 *M *?'< $%<('( <%2:' $.>_'&- .<( &:' 2:.>.2&'>%-&%2- *M &:>'' 2*"4( #'

$*>' *?'< $%<('( &* &:' %('. *M %<-'2&- .- . M**( -*">2'Z N:'5 .>' .- M*44*O-+

JN*$%7% I.((.'&&%:$&

KN:' $*>' *#-2">' &:' %<;>'(%'<&-T &:' $*>' 2*$?4'= &:' 2**_%<; ?>*2'-- &:' $*>'

M"4M%44%<; &:' (%<%<; '=?'>%'<2' M*> &:' ]=&>'$' 8*<<*%--'">-Z P*> &:'-' -"?'>[M**(%'-T 4%M'

%- .#*"& &:' ?">-"%& *M &:' $*-& '=&>.*>(%<.>5 '.&%<; '=?'>%'<2'- M*> #*&: _"(*- .<(

?'>-*<.4 M"4M%44$'<&ZY 78>]0N'T G@@iQ \;ZIDF6

"$7>+-'$ JN04.$%$&

KN:'-' *>(%<.>5 ?'*?4' .>' O%44%<; &* '=?'>%$'<& .<( :.L' 4'M& &:' 2*"2: &* -?'<( $*>'

&%$' .& >'-&.">.<&- .<( %< &:' _%&2:'<T "-%<; &'2:<*4*;5 &* 2*<2*2& *> 2*<<'2& &* . O%('

>.<;' *M M**(-Y 78>]0N'T G@@iQ \;ZIEG6

J*+'>-4 J-*%$

KP*> &:' ]&:%2.4 ].&'>T M**( %- . ?*4%&%2.4 %--"'Z ]&:%2.4 ].&'>- O'>' '.>45 .(*?&'>- *M

P.%>&>.('T *>;.<%2 .<( 4*2.445 ?>*("2'( M**(-T .<( &:'-' >'$.%< &:' '--'<2' *M &:'%> (%'&Z

\>%2' %- &:' *<45 #.>>%'> O*"4( >'-&>%2& -"2: M**(- M>*$ $._%<; "? &:'%> '<&%>' $'<"ZY

78>]0N'T G@@iQ \;ZIED6

X<2' -*$' .>' *< #*.>( O%&: &:' %('. $*>' O%44 -**< M*44*OT .- &:%- %- :*O &>'<(- ;>*OZ KN:'

>'.-*<- ?'*?4' ?.-- *< %<M*>$.&%*< .<(T &:'>'#5T %<("2' &>'<(-T .>' <"$'>*"-Z P*> -*$'T %& %-

.#*"& _''?%<; "? O%&: &:' e*<'-'-[ ?'*?4' O.<& &* .??'.> &* #' `%< &:' _<*O >.&:'> &:.< #':%<(

&:' &%$'-Td -.%( 9'>;'>Za 7cZ J5--(.4T eZ 9'>;'>T G@IW6Z 1*O'L'>T &:%- &>'<( <''(- &* ('L'4*? %<&* .

?'>$.<'<& M**( -*">2'Z N* 2*$#.& &:%- M*44*O%<; *&:'> $'&:*(- -"2: .- &:' 2**_#**_- ?>'L%*"-45

$'<&%*<'( O%44 #' L%&.4 &* '<-">' &:.& '<&*$*?:.;5 #'2*$'- . -&.?4' M**( %< &:' (%'& *M &:'

O*>4(Z

I.(*%70.$-$3 JN-704% L J(*.

S& %- %$?*>&.<& &* 'L.4".&' O:.& *&:'>- :.L' (*<' %< >'4.&%*< &* $.>_'&%<; '<&*$*?:.;5Z

N:'>'M*>'T &:' <'=& '=.$?4' %- . 2*<2'?& 2.44'( ]<&*T O:%2: O.- 2>'.&'( #5 . ;>*"? *M -&"('<&-O:* .>' . ?.>& *M &:' S<<*L.&%*< 3'-%;< ]<;%<''>%<; /.-&'>- ?>*;>.$ .& &:' J*5.4 8*44';' *M 0>&



E

.<( S$?'>%.4 8*44';' %< ,*<(*<Z N:'5 .>' ('L'4*?%<; . O.5 *M $._%<; %<-'2&- $*>' .&&>.2&%L' #5

?>'-'<&%<; &:'$ M.L*">.#45 .- M**(Q ?>*$*&%<; &:'%> .(L.<&.;'-T %Z'Z '<L%>*<$'<&.4 .<(

<"&>%&%*<.4 #'<'M%&-Q '=?4*>%<; &:' #>.<(%<; &* M%& &:>'' 2:.>.2&'>%-&%2-+ KM"&">%-&%2T <.&">.4 .<(

M>%'<(45Y 7!Z ,.#.>>'T G@IG69 ]<&*d- %$.;'T O%&: %&- -%$?4%-&%2 4*;* 7P%;ZE6 .<( M>'-:T #>%;:& 2*4*">

-2:'$' 7P%;ZChD6 2>'.&'- . -'<-' *M '2*[M>%'<(45 L.4"'- #'2."-' &:' "-' *M #>*O<-T ;>''<- .<(

*>.<;'- 2.< #' .--*2%.&'( O%&: <.&">'Z 1*O'L'>T &:' 4*;* %- 4%$%&'( %< *>%;%<.4%&5 .<( M''4- .-

&:*";: %& :.- #''< -''< #'M*>'T M*> '=.$?4' &:' ]L.<- ,*;* 7P%;Zi6Z V:'< ('-%;<%<; . 4*;*T %& %-

'--'<&%.4 &* 2>'.&' .< %$.;%<.&%L' .<( $'$*>.#4' ('-%;< &:>*";: &'=& .<( -:.?'Z

KV%&: &:' >%;:& #>.<(%<;T #"-%<'--'- 2.< %<2>'.-' &:'%> ?>*("2&U- ?'>2'%L'( L.4"'T '-&.#4%-:

>'4.&%*<-:%?- O%&: &:'%> 2"-&*$'>- &:.& 2.< -?.< .;'- .<( #*>('>-T .<( <">&">' &:*-' >'4.&%*<-:%?-

%<&* . 4%M'4*<; #*<(ZY 73Z 0%>'5T G@IFQ \;Z D6Z P*> '=.$?4'T &:' 8.(#">5 4*;* %- %<-&.<&45

>'2*;<%-.#4'T #'2."-' *M %&- (%-&%<2&%L' 2*4*"> .<( -%$?4%-&%2 M*>$ 7P%;Zk6Z ]<&*d- #>.<(%<; O%&: %&-

*<[&>'<( %$.;' *M -"-&.%<.#%4%&5 :.- #''< .%$'( .& . 5*"<;'> ."(%'<2'T .- &:'5 $.5 #' $*>'

.(L'<&">*"- &* &>5%<; <'O M**(Z N:' ?.2_.;%<; 7P%;Z DhE6 4**_- .- %M %& %- $.(' M>*$ >'2524'(

2.>(#*.>(T O:%2: :'4?- &* #**-& &:' %$.;' *M -"-&.%<.#%4%&5Z S<24"('( %< &:' #*= %- .< "<"-".4 -'&

*M #.$#**T 2:*?-&%2_ -&54' "&'<-%4- 7P%;ZI@6T O:%2: .>' '.-5 &* "-' .<( &:'%> ;%$$%2_5 M''4 $.5

.&&>.2& &:' "-'> #5 .((%<; %<&>%;"' &* &:' ?>*("2&Z

5');F !Z ,.#.>>' 7G@IG6 F&-< C<E

5');C ]<&* 7<Z(6 F&-< 0<7<

5');K !Z ,.#.>>' 7G@IG6 F&-< BAL+/:#/G+-

5');H ]L.<- 7<Z(6 FO#&* 0<7<

5');2O !Z ,.#.>>' 7G@IG6 F&-< C<E !@++M+/*5');E 8.(#">5 7<Z(6 N#'KA/Z 0<7<



i

N* *L'>2*$' &:' #.>>%'> *M %<-'2&-T -''< .- (%>&5 .<( 2.>>%'>- *M (%-'.-'T &:' #>.<( %$.;' .<(

?.2_.;%<; <''(- &* <*>$.4%-' '.&%<; %<-'2&- #5 .--*2%.&%<; %& O%&: *&:'> M**(-Z P*> '=.$?4' -*$'

*M ]<&*d- M**( 4**_- -%$%4.> &* -"-:% 7P%;ZD6Z N* %('<&%M5 %<-'2&- .- . <*>$.4 M**( &:' 2:.>.2&'>%-&%2-

M>*$ '=%-&%<; M**( ?.2_.;%<; 2.< #' >'?4%2.&'(T #"& &:' ('-%;< -&%44 <''(- &* %<&>%;"' &:' 2*<-"$'>

&* $._' %& ('-%>.#4'Z N:'>'M*>'T %$.;'- *M %<-'2&- '%&:'> <''( &* #' :'.L%45 (%-;"%-'( *> <*& -:*O<

.& .44 O%&:%< %&- %$.;'>5 -* &:.& &:' 2*<-"$'> %-<d& ?"& *MMT #"& <*& &** (%-;"%-'( &* .L*%(

$%-4'.(%<; &:'$Z S<24"(%<; . ;%$$%2_ O%&:%< &:' ?.2_.;%<; *M .< %<-'2& M**( $%;:& '<2*">.;' &:'

2*<-"$'>T #"& &:'>' %- . ?*--%#%4%&5 &:.& %& 2*"4( $._' &:' ?>*("2& $*>' *M . M.( >.&:'> &:.< .

2>'(%#4' M**(Z

V%&:%< &:%- (%;%&.4 .;'T %& %- L%&.4 &* :.L' .< *<4%<' ?>'-'<2'T .- 2*<-"$'>- :.L' %<-&.<& .22'-- &*

&:' ?>*("2& .<( 2*$?.<5 %<M*>$.&%*<Z !*2%.4 $'(%. %- .< '=2'44'<& O.5 M*> .< '(%#4' %<-'2&

?>*("2& &* #' .(L'>&%-'( M*> M>'' .<( .4-* .2&- .- . 2*<-&.<& >'$%<('> &* &:*-' O:* M*44*O &:'

.22*"<&Z J'2*$$'<(.&%*<- *M &:' ?>*("2& 2.< #' R"%2_45 -:.>'( M>*$ *<' 2*<-"$'> &* .<*&:'>T

O:%2: %- . ?*-%&%L' .-?'2&Z 1*O'L'>T %M &:' M''(#.2_ -:.>'( %- <';.&%L'T *#L%*"-45 &:%- 2.< (.$.;'

&:' 2*$?.<5d- >'?"&.&%*<Z ]<&* ?>*$*&'( &:'%> #"-%<'-- #5 *>;.<%-%<; ?*?["? >'-&.">.<&- .&

4*2.&%*<- %< ,*<(*<Z N:'5 ?"#4%-:'( "?[&*[(.&' %<M*>$.&%*< .#*"& &:'-' 'L'<&- &:>*";: P.2'#**_

.<( &O%&&'>Z 8*<L'>-.&%*<.4 4.<;".;' O.- "-'( O%&:%< &:' ?*-&- .??'.>%<; *< 2*<-"$'>d- ?'>-*<.4

M''(-T .<( &:%- M''4- .- &:*";: &:'5 O'>' ;'&&%<; . (%>'2& $'--.;' M>*$ &:' 2*$?.<5 .<( O'>'

?>%L%4';'( &* ;'& &:' %<M*>$.&%*<Z 0 ;>*O%<; 2*$?.<5 O%44 <''( &* :.L' . M"445 M"<2&%*<%<;T "?[&*[

(.&' O'#-%&' O:%2: :.- ?4'<&5 *M ?>*("2& %<M*>$.&%*<T 'MM'2&%L' %$.;'- .<( 2*<&.2& %<M*>$.&%*<Z

A<M*>&"<.&'45T ]<&*d- O'#-%&' (*'-<d& $''& .44 *M &:%- 2>%&'>%. .<( %M &:%- %- . 2*<-"$'>d- M%>-&

%<&'>.2&%*< O%&: &:'$T %& O%44 >'M4'2& #.(45 *< &:' *L'>.44 %$?>'--%*< *M &:'%> >'4%.#%4%&5 .- .

#"-%<'--Z S& %- . ;**( %('. &* :.L' . M*>"$ *< &:' O'#-%&' M*> 2*<-"$'>- &* %<&'>.2&T %Z'Z -O.?

>'2%?'-T >'2*$$'<( %<;>'(%'<&-b?>*("2&-T '&2Z S<M*>$.&%*<T -"2: .- :*O &* -*">2' .<( -&*>'

%<-'2&- .<( :'.4&: .<( <"&>%&%*<.4 #'<'M%&-T 2.< #' .22'--'( *< O'#-%&'- -"2: .- &:'-'Z \>*("2&-

2.< .4-* #' L%'O'( .<( ?">2:.-'( &:>*";: . O'#-%&' .<( 2*"4( '<.#4' . 2*$?.<5 &* $*L' %<&*

&:' O*>4(O%(' $.>_'& #5 ?>*$*&%<; &:'%> ;**(- .#>*.(T &:"- 2>'.&%<; . 4.>;'> ."(%'<2'Z



k

0<*&:'> $'.<- *M ?>*$*&%<; ]<&*d- M**( O.- &* .&&'<( $.>_'&-bM.%>-Z X<' *M &:'%> M%>-& -&.44- O.-

.& J%L'> 8*&&.;' P**( P.%>T O:'>' &:' ?"#4%2 O'>' .#4' &* -.$?4' .<(b*> #"5 &:'%> ?>*("2&-

7P%;ZII6Z

J%L'> 8*&&.;' %- . ?*?"4.> .<( &>"-&'( #>.<(T O:%2: O.- M*"<('( #5 1";: P'><4'5[V:%&&%<;-&.44

.<( :.- ;>*O< %<&* . 4.>;' '<&'>?>%-' ?>*$*&%<; :'.4&:5T M*>O.>( &:%<_%<;T -"-&.%<.#4' 2**_%<;T

;>*O%<; .<( :.>L'-&%<;Z 95 ]<&* .&&'<(%<; &:'%> M**( M.%>T 2*<-"$'>- O*"4( _<*O &:.& %& %-

'<(*>-'( #5 J%L'> 8*&&.;' #5 .--*2%.&%*<T $._%<; %& . >'?"&.#4' #"-%<'--Z V%&: %<-'2& '.&%<; #'%<;

. &.#** %< &:' V'-&T &:' '=2%&'$'<& *M &>5%<; -*$'&:%<; <'O .<( <*L'4T O*"4( 2>'.&' . #"mm

.#*"& &:' M**(Z P*> '=.$?4'T %M &:' 2*<-"$'> -:.>'( &:'%> '=?'>%'<2' *<4%<'T &:%- O*"4( 2>'.&'

Ò*>( *M $*"&:d ?"#4%2%&5 .<( 2*"4( %<&>%;"' &:' 2*<-"$'>d- M*44*O'>- &* %<L'-&%;.&' '<&*$*?:.;5

.<( #"-%<'--'- &:.& .>' ?>*("2%<; %<-'2& M**( 7P%;ZIG6Z e%$ /'':.< -.5- %< &:' #**_ `8*<&.;%*"-+

V:5 N:%<;- 8.&2: *<d #5 e*<.: 9'>;'> KN:' $*-& ?*O'>M"4 $.>_'&%<; %- ?'>-*<.4 >'2*$$'<(.&%*<

l H*&:%<; %- $*>' L%>.4 .<( %<M'2&%*"- &:.< *<' *M 5*"> M>%'<(- ;*%<; &* . ?4.2' .<( ;%L%<; %& :%- M"44

>'2*$$'<(.&%*<K 7G@IWQ \;ZWG6Z N:' #"-%<'-- 2*"4( -:.>' %<M*>$.&%*< L%. -*2%.4 $'(%. -?>'.(%<;

&:' O*>( R"%2_45 &* . O%(' ."(%'<2' "-%<; 4%<_-T ?:*&*-T '&2Z 1.L%<; .< *<[4%<' ?>'-'<2' &* ?>*L%('

%<M*>$.&%*< .#*"& &:' #'<'M%&- *M '.&%<; %<-'2&- O*"4( :'4? &* -*4L' &:' ?>*#4'$ *M 2*<-"$'>-

:.L%<; . 4.2_ *M _<*O4'(;' .#*"& &:%- L.4".#4' M**( -*">2'Z S<M*>$.&%*< -"2: .-+ >'2%?'-T -&*>.;'

&'2:<%R"'-T .>&%24'- .#*"& :'.4&: .<( '<L%>*<$'<&.4 #'<'M%&- .<( O:'>' &* #"5 &:' %<-'2& M**(T

2*"4( #' -:.>'( #5 2*$?.<%'- .<(b*> *&:'> 2*<-"$'>- R"%2_45 .<( '.-%45Z

Acl.>> Gbtm (4:>0) Gbtm nt Tcvgr Imttnlg Amm` Ancr! (Anigdmmh) Acl.>4 I. Gosmb (4:>0) Pfnbhs amr tfg Gxpgrcgbig! (Pwcttgr)



I@

B+% M$.7.*'.( ./ Z^:0%$/..#&T

/.>_'&'>- :.L' 2:.<;'( &:' 2*<-"$'>-d ?'>2'?&%*< *M -%$?4' M**(T -"2: .- `#>*22*4%dT %<&* .

`!"?'>M**(d &* '<2*">.;' &:' 2*<-"$'> &* '.& &:%- `$%>.24'd ?>*("2' %< &:' :*?' &:.& %& O%44 $._'

&:'$ 4%L' 4*<;'> .<( ?>'L'<& -'>%*"- (%-'.-'-Z S< !'?&'$#'> G@ICT SNnd- N:%- /*><%<; ?>*;>.$$'

%<24"('( . -';$'<& 2.44'(+ `N*? P%L' !"?'>M**(- .<( :*O &* '.& &:'$dT M'.&">%<; e.$%' X4%L'> 7SNnT

G@IC6Z 1' O.- ?>*$*&%<; &:' #'<'M%&- *M !"?'>M**(- .<( $._%<; >'2%?' -";;'-&%*<-Z 0- :' %- .<

.$#.--.(*> *M :'.4&:5 '.&%<;T . 2'4'#>%&5 2:'M .<( . :*"-':*4( <.$'T &:' ."(%'<2' >';.>( :%$ .-

. >'-?'2&.#4' .<( &>"-&'( -*">2'T &:%- %- O:5 "-%<; . 2'4'#>%&5 2:'M %< &:' ?>*$*&%*< *M '(%#4'

%<-'2&- O*"4( #' #'<'M%2%.4Z N:' ?>'-'<&'>- `1*445 V%44*";:#5 .<( \:%44%? !2:*M%'4(d .>' &:'>' &*

4%-&'< &* &:' M.2&- .<( '=?'>%'<2' &:' M**(Z N:'5 .>' .2&%<; .- >'?>'-'<&.&%L'- M*> &:' ."(%'<2'

O:* O%44 &>"-& &:'%> *?%<%*<T .- &:'5 $.5 M''4 &:.& &:'5 _<*O &:'$ ?'>-*<.445T #'2."-' *M &:'%>

4*<;[-&.<(%<; >'4.&%*<-:%? O%&: &:' L%'O'>- &:>*";: &:' -:*OZ N:'>'M*>'T %M &:' 2:'M 2.< ?'>-".('

&:' ?>'-'<&'>- &* &>5 .< '(%#4' %<-'2& $'.4 &:'5 .>' 24*-'> &* ?'>-".(%<; &:' L%'O'>Z X4%L'>d-

?.--%*< M*> :'.4&:5 '.&%<; %- -:*O< %< &:' O.5 :' ('4%L'>- %<M*>$.&%*<T &:>*";: #*(5 4.<;".;' .-

O'44 .- &:' -?''2: :' "-'-T O:%2: O*"4( #' '=&>'$'45 "-'M"4 M*> &:%- '<&:"-%.-$ &* #' &>.<-M'>>'(

&* '(%#4' %<-'2&- .- %& $%;:& %<-?%>' &:' L%'O'>-Z 1' ?>'-'<&- -2%'<&%M%2 M.2&-T .- O'44 .- :%-&*>%2.4

'L%('<2'T *M :*O &:'-' !"?'>M**(- O'>' '.&'<T O:%2: ;%L'- &:' ."(%'<2' $*>' ?>**M *M :*O

&:'-' M**(- 2*"4( O*>_ M*> &:'$Z P*> '=.$?4'T -'.O''( O.- -:*O< .<( %&- <"&>%&%*<.4 #'<'M%&-

O'>' ?>*$*&'(Z 1' .4-* ?>'(%2&- &:.& &:%- M**( O%44 #' $.--%L'45 ?*?"4.> %< &:' <'.> M"&">'T O:%2:

:%<&- &:.& :' %- ;%L%<; *"& %<-%('> %<M*>$.&%*< M>*$ &:' M**( %<("-&>5Z /*L%<; M*>O.>( M>*$ &:%-

-';$'<&d- #>%'M %<&>*("2&%*< &* &:' O*>4( *M !"?'> M**(-T &:' O:*4' ?.2_.;' O.- &:'< 2*$?4'&'(

O:'< !2:*M%'4( $'<&%*<'( X4%L'>d- <'O 998 -'>%'- &%&4'( è.$%'d- !"?'> P**(d .<( :%- <'O >'2%?'

#**_ `]L'>5 3.5 !"?'> P**(d O:%2: O%44 2>'.&' . 4*<;'> 4.-&%<; %$?>'--%*< *< &:' ."(%'<2'Z N:%-

$'&:*( %- . ?*O'>M"4 &**4 &* ?'>-".(' &:' ."(%'<2' *M &:' #'<'M%&- *M '.&%<; %<-'2&-T .- &:'5 .>'

?>'-'<&'( O%&: &:' `?>**Md &:.& &:%- M**( 2.< #' #'<'M%2%.4 M*> &:'%> :'.4&: .<( .4-* M*> &:'

'<L%>*<$'<&Z 95 .&&.2:%<; .< '<&:"-%.-&%2 2'4'#>%&5 2:'M &* &:' 2.$?.%;< &* %<&>*("2' %<-'2&- .- .

M**( -*">2' O%44 :'4? &* %<-?%>' &:' 2*<-"$'>-Z S& O*"4( .4-* &'.2: &:' 2*<-"$'>- .#*"& &:'

#'<'M%&- *M &:%- M**( .<( ?>*$*&' &:' .(L.<&.;'- *M %<&>*("2%<; . $*>' -"-&.%<.#4' M**( -*">2'Z

0 -'2*<( '=.$?4' %- . `1'44*pd $.;.m%<'d- *<4%<' .>&%24' 71'44*$.;.m%<'Z2*$T G@IC6 2.44'(

`8'4'#>%&5 !"?'>M**( !'2>'&-+ V:* %- '.&%<; O:.& .<( O:5dZ N:' 2'4'#>%&5 '<(*>-'$'<&- %< &:%-

.>&%24'T ;%L'< #5 M.$*"- O*$'<T .>' &>5%<; &* ?'>-".(' &:' >'.('>-:%? &* %<24"(' !"?'> M**(- %<

&:'%> (%'&Z 0- &:'-' O*$'< .>' >';.>('(T #5 -*$'T .- #'%<; ?'>M'2&45 #'."&%M"4 :"$.< -?'2%$'<-T

&:' $.;.m%<'d- ."(%'<2' $.5 #'4%'L' &:.& &:'5 2*"4( '$"4.&' ?.>& *M &:' 2'4'#>%&%'-d 4%M'-&54' &*



II

#'2*$' .- `?'>M'2&d .- &:'$Z q"*&'- M>*$ &:'-' 2'4'#>%&%'-T -"2: .- K!%<;'> .<( ^ .#,-</ e"(;'

J%&. X>. -O'.>- #5 -?%<.2:T &O''&%<; . ?%2&">' *M ;>''< 4'.L'- O%&: &:' $'--.;'+ a].& %& &:'<

\*?'5'ZalY 71'44*$.;.m%<'Z2*$T G@ICZ \4"-T %$.;'- *M &:'%> $'.4-T ;%L'- ."&:'<&%2%&5 &* &:'

.>&%24'T .- O'44 .- -2%'<&%M%2 M.2&- M>*$ . <"&>%&%*<%-&T O:%2: ?>*L%('- 2>'(%#%4%&5Z 04-* &:%- *<4%<'

.>&%24' %- .22'--%#4' &* $*-& ?'*?4' .<( %&- `#4*;d 4%_' M*>$ ;%L'- %& &:' M''4%<; &:.& &:' >'.('> %-

?'>-*<.445 2*<<'2&'( &* &:' 2'4'#>%&5Z N>.<-M'>>%<; &:%- &'2:<%R"' &* '(%#4' %<-'2&- O*"4( :'4? &*

>.%-' .O.>'<'-- *M &:%- M**( .<( '<(*>-'$'<&- M>*$ :%;: ?>*M%4' 2'4'#>%&%'- 2*"4( -&.>& . <'O

O.L' *M %<-'2& '.&%<; .- 2'4'#>%&%'- -&.>& &>'<(-Z 1*O'L'>T ?"#4%-:%<; .< .>&%24' 4%_' &:%- .#*"&

'<&*$*?:.;5 2*"4( &>%L%.4%-' %& .<( $._' %& . ;%$$%2_5 &>'<( &:.& $.5 <*& 4.-& .<( #' R"%2_45

(%-$%--'(Z

N:>*";: &:%- '--.5 S :.L' #''< .((>'--%<; &:' ?>*#4'$- *M %<&>*("2%<; '(%#4' %<-'2&- %<&* &:'V'-&'>< O*>4(T "-%<; $.>_'&%<; &'2:<%R"'-Z S :.L' ?>*?*-'( $.<5 %('.- *< :*O ('-%;<'>- .<(

$.>_'&'>- $%;:& (* &:%-Z X<' *M &:' $*-& '--'<&%.4 ?*%<&- &:.& S :.L' &.4_'( .#*"& %- . #"-%<'--

:.L%<; .< *<4%<' ?>'-'<2'Z X<4%<' 2*<<'2&%L%&5 %- M*>'L'> ;>*O%<; .<( %& %- . ?*O'>M"4 &**4 &:.& 2.<

#' "-'( %< ?>*$*&%<; '<&*$*?:.;5Z 8*$?.<%'- 2.< 2*<<'2& O%&: &:*"-.<(- *M ?'*?4' .44 *L'> &:'

O*>4(T O%&:*"& :.L%<; &* $*L' M>*$ &:'%> 2*$?"&'>Z S&d- . 2:'.? >'-*">2' &* ;'& ?'*?4' *< #*.>(

O%&: %('.-T ?>*("2&-T #"-%<'--'-T '&2Z X&:'>T '--'<&%.4 M*>$- *M $.>_'&%<; .>' &:' $'(%. .<( NZnZT

O:%2: 2.< #' "-'( &* %<M*>$ .<( ?>*$*&' '(%#4' %<-'2&- &* &:' ;'<'>.4 ?"#4%2Z H'O-?.?'>- .<(

$.;.m%<'- %<M*>$ &:' O*>4( .#*"& (.5[&*[(.5 <'O- .<( -*$'T -"2: .- N:' N%$'- <'O-?.?'> *>

o**( P**( /.;.m%<'T O:'&:'> *<4%<' *> *< ?.?'>T .>' >'4%.#4' -*">2'- *M %<M*>$.&%*<Z 8*<-"$'>-

2.< &>"-& %< O:.& &:'5 >'.( %< &:'-' .>&%24'- .<( %& O%44 :*?'M"445 %<&'>'-& &:'$ &* -'' -*$'&:%<;

.#*"& '.&%<; %<-'2&- .<( :*O &* 2**_ &:'$Z A-%<; Nn ?>*;>.$$'-T '-?'2%.445 -:*O- -"2: .- UN:%-

/*><%<;U .<( 2**_'>5 ?>*;>.$$'-T 2.< .4-* #' . L'>5 L.4".#4' &**4 &* ?>*$*&' M**(-Z N:'-' .>'

M.<&.-&%2 O.5- &* #"%4( '=2%&'$'<& .<( '<&:"-%.-$ .#*"& . <'O M**(Z 0 2'4'#>%&5 2:'MT -"2: .-

1";: P'.><4'5[V:%&&%<;-&.44T 2*"4( ?>*$*&' &:%- <'O O.L' *M M**( #5 %<-&.<&45 '<2*">.;%<; .<(

%<-?%>%<; &:' L%'O'>- &* &>5 2**_%<; &:' M**(T #'2."-' *M :%- ?.--%*< M*> '<(*>-%<; -"-&.%<.#4' .<(

'&:%2.4 M**( -*">2'-Z S<M*>$.&%*<T -"2: .- <"&>%&%*<.4 #'<'M%&- .<( 2**_%<; $'&:*(-T 2.< #' -:.>'(

#5 &:'-' 2'4'#>%&%'- .<( %& 2.< $._' &:' L%'O'> M''4T .- &:*";:& &:'5d>' U%< &:' _<*OU .<( .>' "? &*

(.&' O%&: &:' 4.&'-& 2'4'#>%&5 &>'<(-Z N:%- O%44 :*?'M"445 ?"-: &:' L%'O'> &* &>5 &:' %<-'2&-T 4%_'

&:'$ .<( -&.>& 2**_%<; O%&: &:'$Z N:'-' &5?'- *M -:*O- :.L' $%44%*<- *M L%'O'>-T O:%2: $'.<-

&:.& %M .& 4'.-& . R".>&'> *M &:'-' ?'*?4' -&.>& &* '.& %<-'2&- %& O%44 2>'.&' ('$.<(Z X<2' *&:'>-

-&.>& &* -'' &:' ('$.<( >%-%<;T %<-'2& '.&%<; O%44 #'2*$' 4'-- *M . &.#** .<( &:'5 $%;:& &>5 %& M*>

&:'$-'4L'-Z



IG

8**_#**_- .<( >'2%?' M*>"$- .>' ;>'.& &* :'4? &:' 2*<-"$'> &* _<*O O:.& &* (* O%&: 2**_%<;

%<-'2&-Z N:%- <'O M**( %- L'>5 (%MM'>'<& M>*$ O:.& $*-& 2**_ *< . (.%45 #.-%-T >'2%?'- 2.< :'4? &:'

2*<-"$'> &* 4'.>< O:.& &* (* .<( $.5 'L'< '<2*">.;' &:'$ &* '=?'>%$'<& *<2' &:'5 :.L' 4'.><

&:' #.-%2- .<( ?*&'<&%.4 *M 2**_%<; %<-'2&-Z J'2%?' M*>"$- 2.< .4-* (%>'2& 2*<-"$'>- &* &:' 4.&'-&

%< %<-'2& '.&%<; .<( '<.#4' &:'$ &* 2*44.#*>.&' O%&: %('.- .<( 2>'.&' -*$' ('4%2%*"- $'.4-Z N:'

$*>' &:' ('4%2%*"- &:' M**( &:' $*>' ?*?"4.> '(%#4' %<-'2&- O%44 #'2*$'Z

0 2*$#%<.&%*< *M -*$' *> .44 *M &:' &'2:<%R"'- S :.L' (%-2"--'( %< &:%- '--.5 O%44 :'4? &* *L'>2*$'

&:' -&%;$. &:.& &:' O'-&'>< O*>4( :.- .;.%<-& '(%#4' %<-'2&-T O:%2: O%44 #' .< '=&>'$'45 (%MM%2"4&

&.-_ .- %& O%44 &._' &%$' .<( ?.&%'<2' &* *L'>2*$' &:'-' %<;>.%<'( #.>>%'>-Z 1*O'L'>T . -*4"&%*<

O%44 :.L' &* #' M*"<(T .- &:' O*>4(U- ?*?"4.&%*< %- ;>*O%<; &:' .$*"<& *M M**( %- >.?%(45 ('?4'&%<;Z

N:%- >.%-'- &:' R"'-&%*<+ O%44 O' 'L'> -'' . &%$' O:'< &:' V'-&'>< V*>4( O%44 O%('45 '$#>.2' &:'

%('. *M '.&%<; %<-'2&- *< . (.%45 #.-%- *> %< &:' '<( O%44 O' O%44 :.L' <* 2:*%2'g

V*>( 2*"<&+ FWik



IW

Y',4'.)$-0+3

F'<&* 7<Z(6 F'$K%+ )&*+,-* D T"$," )&*+,-* N#& Y<A F#-P 0L.%4.#4' .&+ :&&?+bbF'<&*Z2*$b'(%#4'[

%<-'2&-[O:%2:[2.<[5*"['.&b rGIbI@bICs

0Z 3"<<'T PZ J.#5 7G@IW6 BL+,A%#-$O+ FO+/Z-"$&7T 8.$#>%(;'T /.--.2:"-'&&-T N:' /SN \>'--Z

9Z /*>>%- 7G@@D6 )&*+,-* #&' IA:#& 0$1+9 X=M*>(T 9'>; \"#4%-:'>-Z

8Z 9%;;'>-&.MM 7G@IW6 N/$*,< D I<@ :#/G+-$&7 -/A:L+' &A-/$-$<&9 0L.%4.#4' .&+

:&&?+bbOOOZ>'.4M**(:*"-&*<Z2*$bG@IWb@CbG@b2>%-2*[:*O[$.>_'&%<;[&>"$?'([<"&>%&%*<b

rGEbI@bIC6

8Z \>.j%>&> 7G@IF6 !"#$%#&' )&*+,- .#/:9 0L.%4.#4' .&+

:&&?+bbOOOZ:"MM%<;&*<?*-&Z2*$bG@IFb@ibGCb'(%#4'[%<-'2&[M.>$'>-[&:.%4.<(t<tCE@DEkCZ:&$4

r@EbIGbICs

8.(#">5 7<Z(6 N#'KA/Z 0<79 0L.%4.#4' .&+ :&&?+bbOOOZj"%25-&"MMZ2.b.>&%24'-bO?[

2*<&'<&b"?4*.(-bG@IIbI@b8.(#">5[,*;*IZj?; rkbIGbICs

N#& F#-$&7 )&*+,-* B#O+ -"+ T</%' Z r&'4'L%-%*< ?>*;>.$$'s \>*("2'( .<( (%>'2&'( #5 c.>% ,%.T

\4"$ \%2&">'-T AcT 7GI+@@6 Iib@WbIWT 998 P*">T Ci+CEZ

8>%-2* 7<Z(6 X"> 1%-&*>5Z 0L.%4.#4' .&+ :&&?+bbOOOZ2>%-2*Z2*$b.#*"&t2>%-2*b:%-&*>5Z.-?=

rIFbI@bICs

N/$*,<W Q :#/G+-$&7 /+O<%A-$<&9 r>.(%* ?>*;>.$$'s !.>.: o.>(<'>T /.>_'& \4.2'T 7@DZ@@6 IGbIIb@ET

/.>_'&?4.2'T Gk+@ET 0L.%4.#4' .&+

:&&?+bbOOOZ$.>_'&?4.2'Z*>;b&*?%2-b-"-&.%<.#%4%&5b2*<-"$'(b2>%-2*[$.>_'&%<;[>'L*4"&%*<

rIFbI@bICs

3Z 0%>'5 7G@IF6 0<7< 3+*$7& 0<O+W Q 7A$'+ -< ,/+#-$&7 $,<&$, K/#&' $'+&-$-$+*9 7G<( '(Z6 9'>_'4'5T

8.4%M*><%.T \'.2:?%& \>'--Z



IF

3Z 9Z 9'>$.< 7G@@k6 3< \<<' 3+*$7&W I<@ 3+*$7&+/* N#& N"#&7+ -"+ T</%'9 9'>_'4'5T 8.4%M*><%.T

H'O J%('>-Z

3ZoZ o*>(*< 7G@IW6 N:' ].&[.[9"; 8**_#**_ J'L%-'(T 9'>_'4'5T 8.4%M*><%.T N'< !?''( \>'--Z

3+O+%<L:+&-6 ,*<(*<T N.54*> .<( P>.<2%-Z

]Z 0<&:'- 7G@IC6 ,*L'45 ;>"#+ .>' %<-'2&- &:' M"&">' *M M**(g QLL/<L/$#-+ !+,"&<%<7Z6 A@7I6T ??Z

WI[WFZ

]<&* 7G@IF6 ]<&* .& >%L'> 2*&&.;' M**( M.%>pT .#,+K<<G6 GFb@CbIFZ 0L.%4.#4' .&+

:&&?-+bbOOOZM.2'#**_Z2*$b'<&*M**(b?*-&-bDCGEFkFEFiIiiiE rICbIIbICs

]<&* 7<Z(6 F&-< 0<7<9 0L.%4.#4' .&+ :&&?+bb'.&['<&*Z2*Z"_b2"-&*$%$.;'-b]<&*,*;*Z?<; rI@bI@bICs

]<&* 7<Z(6 F&-<9 0L.%4.#4' .&+ :&&?+bbOOOZ'.&['<&*Z2*Z"_ rI@bI@bICs

]<&* P**(- ,&(Z 7G@IF6 N:.<_- M*> &:' ]=?'>%'<2'p !@$--+/6 GDb@CbIFZ 0L.%4.#4' .&+

:&&?-+bb&O%&&'>Z2*$b2_'4-*<iib-&.&"-bFEI@EE@GFiCFIEkiF@ r ICbIIbICs

`]?%-*(' GdT !<:<//<@V* .<<'9 r&'4'L%-%*< ?>*;>.$$'s \>*("2'( .<( (%>'2&'( #5 \'<<5 \.4$'>T

998 !2%'<2' .<( \>*("2&%*<T AcT 7GI+@@6 W@bIIbICT 998 X<'T CE+CkZ

]L.<- 7<Z(6 FO#&* 0<7<9 0L.%4.#4' .&+

:&&?+bbOOIZ?>O'#Z2*$b?>M%4'-bG@IIb@EbIFbiDFGiCCb]n0H!t4*;*Zj?; rGCbIIbICs

P**( .<( 0;>%2"4&">' X>;.<%m.&%*< *M &:' A<%&'( H.&%*<- 7G@IW6 F'$K%+ $&*+,-*W 1A-A/+ L/<*L+,-* 1</

1<<' #&' 1++' *+,A/$-Z9 r?(Ms J*$'+ A<%&'( H.&%*<-Z 0L.%4.#4' .&+

:&&?+bbOOOZM.*Z*>;b(*2>'?b@Iib%WGCW'b%WGCW'Z?(M rIIbI@bICs

P"&">' ,.#*>.&*>5 7G@@i6 N/FQ!+W +#-$&7 '+*$7& #&' 1A-A/+ 1<<'9 9'>4%<T o'-&.4&'<Z

oZ 1.>(5 7G@II6 !$.-:%<; ,*;* 3'-%;<+ N:' 0>& *M 8>'.&%<; n%-".4 S('<&%&%'-Z 8:%2:'-&'>T V'-&

!"--'=T V%4'5 .<( !*<-T ,&(Z



IC

1Z ,**5T PZnZ 3"<_'4T eZJZ V**( 7G@IF6Z 1*O &:'< -:.44 O' '.&g S<-'2&['.&%<; .&&%&"('- .<(

-"-&.%<.#4' M**(O.5-Z Q7/$,A%-A/+ #&' IA:#& S#%A+*6 G27I6T ??Z IWI[IFIZ

1'44*$.;.m%<'Z2*$ 7G@IC6 8'4'#>%&5 -"?'>M**( -'2>'&-+ O:* %- '.&%<; O:.& .<( O:5T I+%%<[T

IDbI@bICZ 0L.%4.#4' .&+ :&&?+bbOOOZ:'44*$.;.m%<'Z2*$b2"%-%<'bG@ICI@IDGE@Wkb2'4'#>%&5[

-"?'>M**([-'2>'&-[#'<'M%&-b rGCbI@bICs

)&*$'+/6 IF&: /.5Z 0L.%4.#4' .&+ :&&?+bbOOOZ#"-%<'--%<-%('>Z2*$b"<['.&%<;[%<-'2&-[&*[-*4L'[O*>4([

:"<;'>[G@IW[CgSJuN rICbI@bICs

eZ 9'>;'> 7G@IW6 N<&-#7$<A*W T"Z !"$&7* N#-," X&9 AcT !%$*< .<( !2:"-&'>Z

eZ ,.<;M*>(T 3Z /23*<.;: 7G@@W6 .<,A* \/<ALW BALL</-$&7 F11+,-$O+ =/<'A,-

4#:$+_* -<L 1$O+ *AL+/1<<'* r&'4'L%-%*< ?>*;>.$$'s ]='2"&%L' \>*("2'>+ ]$$. o*>$4'5T SNnT AcT

7II+II6 I@b@kbICT SNnT E+GkZ 0L.%4.#4' .&+ :&&?+bbOOOZ%&LZ2*$b&:%-$*><%<;bM**(bj.$%'[*4%L'>[&*?[

M%L'[-"?'>M**(- rGFbI@bICs

eZ V'4-: 7G@IW6 A<%&'( H.&%*<-+ !&.>L%<; \'*?4' !:*"4( ].& 9";-Z CA*$&+**

cZ J5--(.4T eZ 9'>;'> 7G@IW6 T"Z @+ 1<%%<@ -/+&'* >+O+& K#' <&+*J9 0L.%4.#4' .&+

:&&?+bbOOOZ$.>_'&?4.2'Z*>;bG@IWb@Wb@Db4%M'b#%;[#**_bO:5[O'[M*44*O[&>'<(-['L'<[#.([*<'-

rICbIIbICs

,Z !2:%$'4 7G@@D6 N/$*,< H+,$L+* 1</ -"+ 4+@$*" I<A*+@$1+6 0L.%4.#4' .&+

:&&?-+bbOOOZM4%2_>Z2*$b?:*&*-b('-.5"<*'<2.$.bIGiiEGiIEb rGEbI@bICs

/Z1Z H'%4 7IkIF6 !"+ B-</Z <1 N/$*,<T 8%<2%<<.&%T N:' /23*<.4( ?>%<&%<; 2*Z

!Z ,.#.>>' 7G@IG6 N<A%' !"$* B%$,G =#,G#7$&7 N<&O$&,+ =+<L%+ -< F#- CA7*P 0L.%4.#4' .&+

:&&?+bbOOOZM.-&2*('-%;<Z2*$bIDDkIiWb2*"4([&:%-[-4%2_[?.2_.;%<;[2*<L%<2'[?'*?4'[&*['.&[#";-vW

rIFbI@bICs



ID

!Z ,.#.>>' 7G@IG6 ]<&* 9*=Z 0L.%4.#4' .&+

:&&?+bbMZM.-&2*$?.<5Z<'&b$"4&%-%&'tM%4'-b2*('-%;<b-4%('-b'<&*['<&*#*=[24*-'"?GZj?; rIFbI@bICs

!Z ,.#.>>' 7G@IG6 F&-< BAL+/:#/G+-9 0L.%4.#4' .&+

:&&?+bb:ZM.-&2*$?.<5Z<'&b$"4&%-%&'tM%4'-b2*('-%;<b%$.;'2.2:'b-4%('-:*Ot4.>;'b-4%('-b'<&*[

-"?'>$.>_'&Zj?; rIFbI@bICs

!ZJ c'44'>& 7IkkW6 n.4"'- .<( \'>2'?&%*<- *M S<L'>&'#>.&'-9 N<&*+/O#-$<& C$<%<7ZW !"+ 4<A/&#% <1

-"+ B,<,$+-Z 1</ N<&*+/O#-$<& C$<%<7Z9 n*4 EZ \;- iFC[iCCZ

!Z V" .<( VZ V.<;7G@IF6 S$?.2& *M 8!J \'>2'?&%*< *< 9>.<( S$.;'T 9>.<( 0&&%&"(' .<( 9"5%<;

V%44%<;<'--+ 0 !&"(5 *M . o4*#.4 8.MwZ )&-+/&#-$<&#% 4<A/&#% <1 ;#/G+-$&7 B-A'$+*6 K7D6T ??Z FW[CDZ

nZ/Z 1*4& 7IiiC6 T"Z &<- +#- $&*+,-*P V:%&-&.#4'T \>5*> \"#4%2.&%*<-

Documents

Addressing the barriers of introducing edible insects into the Western World and proposing marketing methods of how to effectively achieve this