25
RECEIVED MARO 8 2013 Robyn M. Brody (ISB No. 5678) Brody Law Office, PLLC J. Justin May (!SB No. 5818) May, Browning & May, PLLC 1419 W. Washington DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES P.O. Box 554 Rupert, ID 83350 Telephone: (208) 434-2778 Facsimile: (208) 434-2780 [email protected] Fritz X. Haemmerle (ISB No. 3862) Haemmerle & Haemmerle, PLLC P.O. Box 1800 Hailey, ID 83333 Telephone: (208) 578-0520 Facsimile: (208) 578-0564 [email protected] Attorneys for Rangen, Inc. Boise, Idaho 83 702 Telephone: (208) 429-0905 Facsimile: (208) 342-7278 [email protected] BEFORE THE DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES OF THE STATE OF IDAHO IN TIIE MA TIER OF THE PETITION FOR DELIVERY CALL OF RANGEN, INC.'S WATERRIGHTNOS. 36-02551 & 36-07694 STATE OF IDAHO ) ) County of Minidoka ) Docket No. CM-DC-2011-004 AFFIDAVIT OF ROBYN M. BRODY IN SUPPORT OF RANGEN, INC.'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY .ruDGMENT RE: SOURCE Robyn M. Brody, being sworn upon oath deposes and says: 1. My name is Robyn M. Brody. I am an attorney licensed to practice law in the State of Idaho. I represent Rangen, Inc. in the above-captioned matter. The matters contained in this Affidavit are based on my personal knowledge. 2. Attached hereto as Exhibit 1 is a true and correct copy of the Partial Decree for Rangen's Water Right No. 36-15501. AFFIDAVIT OF ROBYN M. BRODY IN SUPPORT OF RANG EN INC. 'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT RE: SOURCE - 1

Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

RECEIVED

MARO 8 2013

Robyn M. Brody (ISB No. 5678) Brody Law Office, PLLC

J. Justin May (!SB No. 5818) May, Browning & May, PLLC 1419 W. Washington

DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES

P.O. Box 554 Rupert, ID 83350 Telephone: (208) 434-2778 Facsimile: (208) 434-2780 [email protected]

Fritz X. Haemmerle (ISB No. 3862) Haemmerle & Haemmerle, PLLC P.O. Box 1800 Hailey, ID 83333 Telephone: (208) 578-0520 Facsimile: (208) 578-0564 [email protected]

Attorneys for Rangen, Inc.

Boise, Idaho 83 702 Telephone: (208) 429-0905 Facsimile: (208) 342-7278 [email protected]

BEFORE THE DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES

OF THE STATE OF IDAHO

IN TIIE MA TIER OF THE PETITION FOR DELIVERY CALL OF RANGEN, INC.'S WATERRIGHTNOS. 36-02551 & 36-07694

STATE OF IDAHO ) )

County of Minidoka )

Docket No. CM-DC-2011-004

AFFIDAVIT OF ROBYN M. BRODY IN SUPPORT OF RANGEN, INC.'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY .ruDGMENT RE: SOURCE

Robyn M. Brody, being sworn upon oath deposes and says:

1. My name is Robyn M. Brody. I am an attorney licensed to practice law in the State of

Idaho. I represent Rangen, Inc. in the above-captioned matter. The matters contained in

this Affidavit are based on my personal knowledge.

2. Attached hereto as Exhibit 1 is a true and correct copy of the Partial Decree for Rangen's

Water Right No. 36-15501.

AFFIDAVIT OF ROBYN M. BRODY IN SUPPORT OF RANG EN INC. 'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT RE: SOURCE - 1

Page 2: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

3. Attached hereto as Exhibit 2 is a true and correct copy of the adjudication file for Water

Right No. 36-07694 as taken from IDWR's online data base.

4. Attached hereto as Exhibit 3 is a true and correct copy of the results of a search I

conducted on March 7, 2013 for Water Right No. 36-15501 in IDWR's Water Right and

Adjudication database.

DATED this 8th day of March, 2013.

SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me this ~day of March, 2013

~.,,.,.,,d"':d!>, e: ,e e • tft:eo ,

BEATRIZ VILLICANA NOTARY PUBLIC STATE OF IDAHO

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

The undersigned, a resident attorney of the State of Idaho, hereby certifies that on the 8th

day of March, 2013 she caused a true and correct copy of the foregoing document to be served

by email and hand delivery upon the following:

-Original: Hand Delivery tu/ Director Gary Spackman U.S. Mail D

Idaho Department of Water Facsimile D

Resources Federal Express D

P.O. Box 83720 E-Mail ~ Boise, ID 83720-0098 Deborah. Gibsonfmidwr.idaho.QOV Garrick Baxter Hand Delivery D

Chris Bromley U.S. Mail D

Idaho Department of Water Facsimile D

Resources Federal Express D

P.O. Box 83720 E-Mail ~ Boise, Idaho 83 720-0098

AFFIDAVIT OF ROBYN M. BRODY IN SUPPORT OF RANGEN INC.'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT RE: SOURCE - 2

Page 3: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

garrick. [email protected] [email protected] Randall C. Budge Hand Delivery D

Candice M. McHugh U.S. Mail D

Thomas J. Budge Facsimile D

RACINE, OLSON, NYE, BUDGE Federal Express ~/ & BAILEY, CHARTERED E-Mail

P.O. Box 1391 101 South Capitol Blvd, Ste 300 Boise, ID 83704-1391 Fax:208-433-0167 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Sarah Klahn Hand Delivery D

Mitra Pemberton U.S. Mail D

WHITE & JANKOWSKI Facsimile D

Kittredge Building, Federal Express D

511 16th Street, Suite 500 E-Mail g/ Denver, CO 80202 sarahk@white-:jankowski.com mitrao(@.white-jankowski.com Dean Tranmer Hand Delivery D

City of Pocatello U.S. Mail D

P.O. Box 4169 Facsimile D

Pocatello, ID 83201 Federal Express ~ dtranmer@p_Qcatello.us E-Mail

John K. Simpson Hand Delivery D

Travis L. Thompson U.S. Mail D

Paul L. Arrington Facsimile D

Barker Rosholt & Simpson, L.L.P. Federal Express ~ 195 River Vista Place, Suite 204 E-Mail

Twin Falls, ID 83301-3029 Facsimile: (208) 735-2444 [email protected] [email protected] C. Thomas Arkoosh Hand Delivery D

Arkoosh Eiguren U.S. Mail D

P.O. Box 2900 Facsimile D

Boise, ID 83702 Federal Express 1/ [email protected] E-Mail

W. Kent Fletcher Hand Delivery D

Fletcher Law Office U.S. Mail D

AFFIDAVIT OF ROBYN M. BRODY IN SUPPORT OF RANGEN INC.'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT RE: SOURCE - 3

Page 4: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

P.O. Box248 Burley, ID 83318 [email protected]

Jerry R. Rigby Hyrum Erickson Robert H. Wood Rigby, Andrus & Rigby, Chartered 25 North Second East Rexburg, ID 83440 [email protected] [email protected] rwood ex-law.com

Facsimile Federal Express E-Mail

Hand Delivery U.S. Mail Facsimile Federal Express E-Mail

D

D

D

D

AFFIDAVIT OF ROBYN M. BRODY IN SUPPORT OF RANGEN INC.'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT RE: SOURCE - 4

Page 5: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

In Re SRBA

Case No. 39576

) ) )

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE FIFTH Jll)JClAL DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF IDAHO, IN AND FOR THE CIJJNTY OF TWIN FALLS

PARTIAL DECREE PURSUANT TO I.R.C.P. 54(b) FOR _________ ) Water Right 36-15501

NAME & ADDRESS:

SOURCE:

QUANTITY:

PRIORITY DATE:

POINT OF DIVERSION:

PURPOSE AND PERIOO Of USE:

PLACE OF USE:

IWIGEN INC PO BOX 706 BUHL ID 83316

MARTIN·CURREN TUNNEL

1.46 CFS

TRIBUTARY: BILLINGSLEY CREEK

THIS RIGHT AND RIGHT NO. 36-02551 ARE LIMITED TO A TOTAL COMBINED FACILITY VOLUME OF 123,2n cu. n.

07/01/1957

T07S R14E S32

PURPOSE OF USE FISH PROPAGATION

FISH PROPAGATION T07S R14E S31

S32

SESWNW Within GOODING County

Within GOCOING County SENE SWNW

RULE 54Cb) CERTIFICATE

PERIOD OF USE QUANTITY 01-01 12-31 1.46 CFS

With respect to the issues determined by the above judglllent or order, it is hereby CERTIFIED, in accordance with Rule 54(b), I.R.C.P., that the court has determined that there is no just reason for delay of the entry of a final judglllel\t and that the court has and does hereby direct that the above judgment or order shall be a final

j- - ""'"' oucutfm "" ·- '"" ~ _., - be.,,,~ n~ by the ldohJ'i,__ DANIEL C. IN~ PRESIDING Jll>GE

PARTIAL DECREE PURSUANT TO I.R.C.P. 54(b) Water Right 36·15501

Snake River Basin Adjudication

PIAINTIFF'S 5XHIBIT

I

PAGE 1 NOV·ZB-1997

Page 6: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE FIFTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF IDAHO, IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF TWIN FALLS

IN RE THE GENERAL ADJUDICATION OF RIGHTS TO THE USE OF WATER FROM THE SNAKE RIVER BASIN WATER SYSTEM.

CIVIL CASE NUMBER: 39576

Ident. Number: A36-07694 Date Received: 7/27/1988 Receipt No: ~Ootl.3'/ Received By: _...:s_,_c=~=-- --

NOTICE OF CLAIM TO A WATER RIGHT ACQUIRED UNDER STATE LAW

1. Name: RANGEN, INC. Address: P.O. BOX 706

BUHL, ID

2. Date of Priority: APR 12, 1977

208-543-6421

83316

3. Source: CURRAN TUNNEL Trib. to: BILLINGSLEY CREEK

4. Point of Diversion:

Township 07S

Range 14E

Section 32

1/4 of 1/4 of 1/4 SW NW

Lot County GOODING

5. Description of diverting works: CONCRETE DAM WITH STEEL PIPELINES.

6. Water is used for the following purposes:

7.

8.

9.

10.

11.

Purpose From To C.F.S (or) A.F.A. FISH PROPAGATION 01/01 12/31 26.000

Total Quantity Appropriated is: 26.000 C.F.S. (and/or)

Total consumptive use is

Non-irrigation uses:

Place of use:

Township Range Section 1/4 of 07S 14E 31 SE

32 SW

Place of use in counties: GOODING

A36-07694 Page 1

A.F.A.

Acre Feet Per Annum.

1/4 Lot NE NW

~ P!J.;INT.IFF'S 1 E~HIBIT

f Jj!t_

Use FISH FISH

Acres

Date: 07/27/88

I . • t ,lf i > • I I _ _,

FEB O 4 1993

Page 7: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

( I

12. Do you own the property listed above as place of use? YES

13. Other Water Rights Used: A36-00134B, A36-00135A, A36-02551

14. Remarks: FACILITY VOLUME= 287,640 CUBIC FEET. SOURCE KNOWN LOCALLY AS CURRAN TUNNEL. THIS RT. WHEN COMBINED WITH RT. 36-2551 SHALL NOT EXCEED 76.0 CFS. A MEASURING DEVICE OF A TYPE APPROVED BY THIS DEPT. SHALL BE MAINTAINED ON THE OUTLET WORKS.

15. Basis of Claim: LICENSE

16. Signature(s)

(a.) By signing below, I/We acknowledge that I/We have received, read and understand the form entitled "How you will recei;,<notice in the Snake River Basin Adjudication." ( b.) I/We do do not wish to receive and pay a small annual fee for monthly copie"sci1 the doc et sheet.

Number of attachments: 0 -~----For Organizations:

A36-07694

or affirm that I am

that

below as

true and correct.

Page 2

of

in the

Date: 07/27/88

FEB O ~ 1993

Page 8: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

State of Idaho

County of ~Gu /1-' fa.llj ss.

Subscribed and sworn (or affirmed) before me

19 ~y Notary Public

seal Residing at fw,,__ -tat,/.t My Commission Expires z/20/t:;.J

A36-07694 Page 3 Date: 07/27/88

i >

FEB O 4 1993

Page 9: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

(

6/9/94

CO:MMUNICATION DOCUMENTATION

Claim No. A36-07694

This form is to be used to document public record information requests regarding any SRBA claim or claims. The form may also be used to document IDWR communications requesting information regarding any SRBA claim or claims when the request is not made in writing or the claim verification report is not readily available to document the request. This form is to be filed in all relevant claim files or a central office file.

IDWR Employee/ Agent Steve Clelland

March 22, 1995 10:17am

NAME: KA'l'HY BARNES & J.D. MAY CALLIN

RE: REQUEST FOR PROOFS

THEY ASKED FOR PROOF REPORTS FOR THE CLAIM A36-07694. PROOFS OF THE CLAIM, LICENSE & DIR. REP. ALSO WILL LOOK IN THE FILE FOR ANY OBJECTIONS ON FILE.

Page 10: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

R PR F VR

MAP PH T Ml C

----

h1ICP..t...1ru .. 1 , , .. :u

FEB O 4 1993·

Page 11: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

AUJWIU\IIU!t ~U\IM~ ~KlJUt KtAUINb Ktt'UKI (REGIONAL)

~age 1

Water Right Nuioer - R36-07694

+ - • • · · · · Last Nmne •

-• C CURRENT OIINER ***

Prefix Translation:

+ • First Name •

RESEARCH V,RIREO BY \-\- ~ r

Old (D) NL.llt>er · ---.;__ ___ _

• • + • + + • • • • • • - • • Address · · · · · - - · · - • - - .. +

RANGEN INC

+··Priority Date· · + 04/12/19IT

+ • • • Reg! on · - · + 17 SOUTHERN

1 • PO BOX 706 2 • 3 • City· BUHL Phone· 208·543·6421

+ • • - Stage - · · + L LICENSE

State· ID Zip· 83316

+ - - . Status - • · - +

+ • • · - Source · HARTIN-CURREN TUNNEL

-----+ + • • • • - • • • Tributary · · · · · · · • • · · • • · - · + BILLINGSLEY CREEK

+ • · · · - Point of Ofverslon • · · • · · · · · · • · · - · - • · · · · · - · • · • · · + Twn Rng Sec Tract Lot RFlg County

07S 14E 32 SE S\I NW (47) GOODING

+ • · • - - • · · · · · · • • • · • ··Water Use --··-------"'··------ - -·-·-·+ Code Description Period From Period To Diversion Rate Diversion Voll.Ille

19 · FISH PROPAGATION 01/01 12/31 26.000

+ • Total Div. Rate • + + • Total Div. Volune · + + • Total Consur.,tive Use · + + • ICII Usage · + 26.000

+ • • Twn Rng Sec

07S 14E 31 07S 14E 32

Tract Lot

SE NE SW IN

Total Acres:

··Place of Use· · · · - · · · · · · · · · · • Acres Code Description

19 FISH PROPAGATION 19 FISH PROPAGATION

+ - • Diversion Means· CONCRETE DAM WITH STEEL PIPELINES.

+ • • Non-Irrigation Use ·

+ • • Other Rights for Same Use· 36·02551

o.o

············+ C01.r1ty

(47) GOODING (47) GOOOING

+ • • • • • • • • • - • • • • • - - - • • • - • - - • • • • • Remarks • · · · • · · • · · • - · - · · · • • • • • • • • • • • • • + FACILITY VOLUME=287,640 CU. FT. THE FOLLO\IING RIGHTS ARE ALSO DIVERTED THROUGH POINT OF

DIVERSION DESCRIBED ABOVE: 36·00102, 36·00134A, 36•00134B, 36·00134C, 36·00135A, 36·00135B, 36·00135C, 36-10140, 36·10142 & 36·02551.

a -.J ., ....

...:t-.J c:::,

, I Ct)

~ ~

Page 12: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

,w-awu.,u &VN 1..&.NU"I~ rrcuur 11.CIUI.I.IU,1 ftC,..Ul'U

(REGIONAL)

Water right nuit>er • R36·07694 Prefix Translation: RESEARCH

+ • • •••••••••••

+··············· No Old Water Right Num>ers Found

+ • • •••••••••••••••••

+ • • • • Decree Plafntfff · • - +

· Old Water Right NU!lbers • · · · · · · · · - • • • · · +

· Old Water Right N~rs • · · +

· Conditions of Approval • • · · • • · • • • • · • · · • • • • · · · • · · • - + No Conditions of Approval found.

+ • • • • Decree Oefendant • · · + + • Oecree Date · + 00/00/0000

+ • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ·Canments· • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • + Date: 08/07/1992 User Id: IIORSTELL Subject: COPIED FROM REMARKS

FACILITY VOLUME= 287,640 CUBIC FEET. SOURCE KN0\111 LOCALLY AS CURRAN TUNNEL. THIS RT. WHEN COM81NED WITH RT. 36•2551 SHALL NOT EXCEED 76.0 CFS. A MEASURING DEVICE OF A TYPE APPROVED BY THIS DEPT. SHALL BE MAINTAINED ON THE OUTLET WORKS.

+ • • Audit Fields · · + 08/11/92 THORNTON

+ . ..................... . - · Adjudication Rights Oates and Flags Area · · · · · · • • • · .. - • .. .. .. - - - - +

Court Report Filing Objection Fi led Date Response Filed Date Claim Received Date

· 00/00/00DO · 00/00/0000 · 00/00/0000 · 07/27/1988

Field Inspection Made Field Inspection Flag Verified Date Last Amended Date Receipt Nunber POU OWnership Flag Name Connector

· 00/00/0000

· 08/11/1992 · 00/00/0000 · 5001134 • y

Civil Case Num>er 39576 Old Case Nud:ler Old Judicial District Teq:,orary Right • P Water District • 36A Federal/State Indicator · S Presumption Flag Notice of Error Flag

Page 13: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

PAGE: 11

DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES ADJUDICATION CLAIM VERIFICATIDII REPORT

07/03/90

QUICKLOOK INFORMATION CLAIM NUMBER: A36-07694

WR ELEMENT

PRIORITY DATE

POINT OF DIV

SOURCE

PLACE Ol" USE

DIV , AMOUNT CPS/VOLUME

CONSUMPTIVE USE

PURPOS&S

PERIOD OF USE

BASIS OF CLAIM

REMARKS

FIELD EXAM Y/1'1

y

y

y ,J

I I I I I I I I

- -----• • 1 ,f [ y

I

CORRESPONDENCE SEIIT/ RECEIVED BY WHOM/DATE

FIELD EXAM BY WIIOM/'DATE

CHANGE CLAIM

Y/1!1

I 'l· r~~'fl> I

II • I

s c.c..(NII( "'

__ 1 ____ 11) 11> Ac . 1111

KY)

"VERIFIED BY" CODES

TOPO MAP/ORTHO-PQ : 1 ASCS MAP ~ 2 WATERMASTER RECORDS m 3 NAPP PHOTOS a 4 FIELD EXAM ~ 5 OTHER (SEE REMARKS) ~ 6

VERIFIED BY CODE

COMPLETED REVIEW t!KOM/ DATE

THESE CODES ARE USED TO INDICATE HOW THE FIELD EXAMINER VERIFIED TR£ IIIFOllMATION USED FOR THIS FIELD EXAMINATIOII. INDICATED ARB ALL CODES WHICH APPLY.

If

'Jl ,

COMPLETED DATA ENTRY

WHOM/DATE

IJtJ t(J-/7- fQ

VERIFIED / DATE ;;, C"')

WHOM/DATE u ~ ~ I ..:.! ____ .;;:.. 1..:.--

\..) ~ ;· * I I I I I

Page 14: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES ADJUDICATION CLAIM VERIFICATION RBPORT

PAGE : 1 GENERAL INFORMATION

LAST: RARGEN INC . ADDRESS: P.O. BOX 706 CITY : BUHL PHONE NUMBER: 208-543-6421

OWNER CODE: C

FIELD EXAJII REQUIRED?

VERIFICATION REQUIRED DUE TO REMARKS?

FIRST:

STATE: ID

DATABASE y

ZIP: 83316

l"IELD EXAMINER

CLAIM REMARKS : FACILITY VOLUME• 287,640 CUBIC FEET. SOURCE ltNOWll LOCALLY AS CURRAN TUNNEL. THIS RT. WHEN COMBINED WITH RT. 36-2551 SHALL ROT EXCEED 76.0 CFS. A MEASURING DEVICE OF A TYPE APPROVED BY THIS DEPT. SHALL BE MAINTAINED OR THE OUTLET WORKS.

FIELD EXAMINATION INFORMATION

CONTACT PERSON: lyAJy i:?1&,M(fif}v DATE OF FIELD EXAM : j_/ jJ_/ ~ APPOINTMENT MADE : YI __ RI

ACCOMPANIED BY : -----------------------REL AT IO RS HIP TO CLAIMANT:

DIRECTIONS TO PROPERTY / REMARKS:

PHO RE NUMBER: I

TI ME: ___ _

PHONE NUMBER:

07/03/90

CLAIM NUMBER: A36-07694

!

I [;? S!:j

-.:,-, c::, Q:)

~

Al_) Pl_

Page 15: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

....

A. AJ CLAIM: I A36-07694 PRIORITY DATE: 04-12-1977 STAGE: L

a. WR RECORD: t 36-07694 PRIORITY DATE: 04-12-1977 STAGE: L

c. FIELD EXAM REQUIRED? l'IELD DATABASt EXAMINER

DUE TO PRIORITY DATE DISCR&PAl'ICY? (Y/N) N .JI._

ARB THERE OBVIOUS REASONS TO QUESTION THE PRIORITY DATE CLAIMED? IF YES EXPLAIN.

Y(_) N{ ~

REMARKS:

RECOMMENDED PRIORITY DATE: 04-12- 19 71

REVIEWED BY DATE J • .2..0 - 10

,_ ~ .... _ S?:?

Page 16: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

·-

A. AJ CLAIM POINT OF DIVERSION AND SOURCE:

RIGHT

A36-D7694

TWP.

01S

OTHER A3 CLAIMS A PREl"IX 1136-00134A A36-00134B 1136-00135A 1136-10141 1136-10142

RGE.

14E

SEC.

32

WITH SAME AJ POD R PREFIX

NONE

SOURCE: CURRAN TUNNEL

e. Wll POINT or DIVERSION ARD SOURCE:

RIGHT

36-07694

TWP.

01S

RGE.

14E

SEC.

32

OTHER WR RECORDS WITH SAME WJl POD

36-00134 36-00135 36-02551

SOURCE: SPRINGS

C. FIELD EXAM REQUIRED?

1/4

1/4

1/4 1/4 LOT

SW NW

WR RECORDS IN SAME 40 ACRE TRACT

36-00134 36-00135 36-02551

TRIB: BILLINGSLEY CREEK

1/4 1/4 LOT

SW NW

AJ CLAIMS IN SAME 40 ACRE TllACT A PREFIX R PREFIX

A36-00134A NONE A36-00134B A36-0013SA A36-10141 A36-10142 A36-D0189A A36-00102

TRIB: BILLINGSLEY CREEK

DUE TO POD DISCREPANCY? (Y/N) DUE TO SOURCE DISCREPA&CY? (Y/N)

DATABASE y y

CNTY

GOODING ~ 2? ~

c:::,

:: ~

CNTY

GOODING

Page 17: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

REMARKS:

~ I

-:t------------------------------------------------------------------,-~- c:::,-

s0011.cs, ftlAlt:rnJ-fu.\Rer+> T~ l!EVIEWED BY: __

TllIB :----'-B-=':1L""'L,,...1r,Ju ___ s~~- 'f.....,£- tt- el...,<.. _ __ _ DATE: "7-~ Q

:am•===•=a=•=cs=ac=~-=- =••••••••-••a••DaQ===========z=====--===sc:=::=~a=a~•m•========~a===m===c=~====s••=••Qam====~====c=s~======-aa

Page 18: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

PLACE OF USE REVIEW SHEET

A. ROOT WATER RIGHT NUMBERS: A36-07694

B. POU LISTING AJ

TWP RNG SEC 1 / 4 1/ 4 LOT NAME I/ACRES

075 14E 31 SE NE RANGEN IIIC. A36-07694 I RANGEN, INC. A36-10269 I RANGER INC. A36-02S51 I CANDY , MARGARET A36-00134A /10.0 RANGER INC. A36-00134B / RANGER INC. A36-00135A / 5.0 HIGH i FRITCHMAN co. HIGH, FRITCHMAN co.

07S 14E 32 SW NW RANGER INC. A36-07694 I llANGEN INC. A36-02551 I CANDY , MARGARET A36-00134A I 1.0 RA!IIGEN INC. A36-D0134B I RAl!IGEl!I INC. A3'-00135A I HIGH, FRITCHMAN co. HIGH, l'RITCBNAN co. RANGEN INC.

TOTAL ACRES A36-D7U4

ARE IRRIGATED ACRES FOUND IN TRACTS OTHER THAN INDICATED ABOVE, Y ( II ( IF YES SEE ATTACHED SHEET:

C. FIELD EXAM REQUIRED?

DUE TO POU DISCREPANCY? (!/NI

PRESUMPTION FLAG:

REMARKS:

RECOMMENDATIONS:

TOTAL ACRES:

REVIEWED B'l :

DATABASE y

FIELD EWNER

DATE:

WR 8/ACRES

36-07694 I I

36-02551 I I I I

36-D0134 I 36-00135 I

36-07694 I 36-02551 I

I I I

36-00134 I 36-00135 I 36-08048 /20.0

LANDSAT DATA

29.0

35.0

64.00

FIELD EXAM.

aECOMM . ACRES

• I

Page 19: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

A. AJ Cr.AIMED USES:

PURPOSES A36-076!14 PISH PROPAGATION

B. ff1l RECORDED USES:

PURPOSES 36-07694 PISH PROPAGATION

PRESUMPTION FLAG:

.__, c. FIELD EXAM REQUIRED?

MONTH/DAY FROM 01-01 TO 12-31

TOTAL DIVERSION RATE/VOLUME Cr.AIMED

MONTH/DAY FROM 01-01 TO 12-31

TOTAL DIVERSION RATE/VOLUME Cr.AIMED

DUE TO WATER-USE DISCREPANCY? (Y/N) DUE TO DIVERSION RATE DISCREPANCY? (Y/N) DUE TO PERIOD FROM/TO DISCREPANCY? (Y/N)

DATABASE N N N

D. PERIOD OF USE:

RECOMMEND AS Cr.AIMED?

RECOMMEND TO WR STANDARDS OR OTHER?

REMARKS:

Y(X> N(

Y(

DIVERSION QUANTITY 26.000 CPS

26.000 CFS

f;? ._ ~ - -DIVERSION QUANTITY } c::::>

26.000 CPS Q:)

26.000 CP'S ·- tt: ~ . --

Explain in ro••rks, below.

Page 20: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

A. DOES DIVERSION RATE CLAIMED AGREE WITH EXISTING RECORDS? Y(r'"I N(_I

B.

AJ TOTAL CLAIMED DIVERSION RATE : 26 . 000 26.000

CFS CFS WR ROOT RIGHT TOTAL DIVERSION RATE:

••• IF NO or IF STATUTORY CLAIM or BENEFICIAL USE then tlov measurement required. ••• •• If an amount smallor than the original diversion rate is •• •• claimed and an exam is NOT required, expla i n in roaarka. ••

FLOW MEASUREMENT REQUIRED? FIELD

DUE TO STAGE OR DIVERSION RATE DISCREPANCY? ( Y/ N) DA:ABASE EN NER

PLOW MEASUREMENT

MEASUREMENT METHOD _.J2(""-'--------------• SEB ATTACHED CALCULATIONS.

c . ARE OTHER WATER RIGHTS USED? Y~ N( ) IF YES COMPLETE OVERLAP REVIEW. ~ql c.4-. OTHER RIGHTS LISTED IN CLAIM: A36-00134B ,.-~ 36 8 81JS~ t A36-02551 /"'

LIST ALL RIGHTS WITH A SAME POU AND IRRIGATION USAGE:

DIV. CLAIM SOURCE lilAME DIV. RATE RATE/ACRE

A36-00134A CURRAN SPRING CANDY , MARGARET 1.000 0.019 A36-00134A CURRAN SPRING CANDY , MARGARET 1.000 0 .019 A36-00134B CURRAN TUNNEL RANGER INC. 1.460 0.208 A36-00135A CURRAN TUNNEL RAIIIGEll INC. 0.160 0.022

LIST ALL RIGHTS WITH SAME POU BUT IIIOT USED FOR IRRIGATION.

CLAIM NO. PURPOSES NAME MONTH/DAY

A36-07694 FISH PROPAGATION RANGER INC. FROM 01-01 TO 12-31 A36-10269 DOMESTIC RANGER, INC. FROM 01-01 TO 12-31 A36-02551 FISH PROPAGATION llARGER INC. FD.OM 01-01 TO 12-31 A36-02551 DOMESTIC RANGER INC . FROM 01-01 TO 12-31 A36-00134B DOMESTIC RANGER INC. P'llOK 01-01 TO 12-31 A36-00134B FISH PROPAGATION BANGER INC. P'ROK 01-01 TO 12-31 A36-00135A DOMESTIC RANGER I!IC. FROM 01-01 TO 12-31 A36-00135A P'ISR PROPAGATION RANGER INC. FllOK 01-01 TO 12-31

'I

DIV. DIV. VOL. VOL./ACllE

RATE VOLUME

26.000 CP'S .040 CFS 50.000 CFS .100 CFS .100 CFS 1. 460 CFS .10D CFS .160 CP'S

Page 21: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

D, RATE/VOLUME CALCULATIONS:

la. IRRIGATION RATE ACRES _____ x 0.02 CFS/ ACRE• ____ _

(Taken from p/ u review ) CFS

DOES AMOUNT CLAIMED EXCEED 0.02 CFS/ACRE? Y(_I N(

*** IF YES ADDITIONAL WATER USE FORM FILED AND ATTACHED? Y(

2. IRRIGATION CONSUMPTIVE USE

CLAIMED CONSUMPTIVE USE= AF/ A

NI

ACRES x CONSUMPTIVE VOL. AF/A FOR AREA ______ =

TOTAL CONSUMPTIVE USE

J. IRRIGATION DIVERSION VOLUME

CLAIMED DIVERSION VOLUME=

------ AF/A

AF/ A

ACRES X DIVERSION VOL. AF/A FOR AREA _____ _

TOTAL DIVERSION VOLUME _______ AF/ A

Q cALCULATIONS FOR USES OTHER THAN IRRIGATION:

SEE ATTACHED SHEET? !( N(~ )

REMAllKS: (Inc lude limitations on CONSUMPTIVE USE for combined rights.)

(IRRIGATION)

lb, CALCULATIONS '"\ ;

-::- ~ ·.;J E.?

Page 22: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

--·

RECOMMERDATIOl'IS:

REC. PURPOSES

FISH PROPAGATION

TOTAL FOR THIS RIGHT

REC. PERIOD PROM TO

01-01 12-31

REC. DIV RATE CFS

DATABASE EXAMINER 26.000

26.000

REC. DIV REC. CONS. VOL. AF/A USE

DATABASE EXI\MINER DATABASE EXAMINER ' ~ o.o j 2)

o.o ~ ·, c:::,

REVIEWED BY: $ ~ DATE: 7_,,:20.-o/Q 5 t:; ===m•====c•a==u======::====c======s==~=;:==•-~=-•m====••==• =m••~==••••=•=•a=~~•==sz=c======~==m~•===a====•==:===••==Ea=immmm==m-----

Page 23: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

BASIS OP CLAIM REVIEW SHEET

A. CHECK ONLY THE FOLLOWING THAT APPLY:

OWNERSHIP FORFEIT/ABANDON----------------­ADDITIONAL DIV, AMOUNT

ACCEPTED

AS CLArr.

UN

NEEDS REVIEW I I < I I >

----------------------------------------------------------- g: B. SPLIT WATER RIGHT REVIEW

ROOT WATER RIGHT NUMBER: 36-07694

TOTAL DIVERSION RATE or WR SPLITS

SPLITS:

OLD RIGHT NUMBERS

CURRENT CLAIM NUMBERS

A36-07694

TOTAL CFS

DIVERSION RATE REVIEW

DATABASE 26 . 000

DIVERSION RATE

26.000

26.000

EXAMINER

CURRENT "R" CLAIM RUM.

DO THE SUM CFS RATE OF THE SPLITS EQUAL THE ROOT RIGHT CFS RATE? (Y/NI IP NO, is the written rev i ew sheet attached? (Y/Nl

REMARKS:

AUTHENTICATION:

SIGNATURE: Sf:w..._.~ Qp D DATE: 7 - ,<0 - 10 IIAl'IE OP FIELD EXAMINER:

___________________ TITLE:

"R" DIV. RATE

DATABASE y

CFS

WR RIGHT NUMBERS

36-07694

FIELD

E~

DIVERSION RATE

26.000

26.000

-..J ;!? ~

:-)

Page 24: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s
Page 25: Affidavit of Robyn M. Brody in Support of Rangen, Inc.'s

Page 1 of 1

• llome Contact Us

D,tpan,nent of

Water Resources

Water Right and Adjudication Search

t Choose One or More Search Items

Name

Ad1udiqtion. Water Right ft Basin or Transfer Klick to expand or collapse)

Location of Use or Diversion

Sources

t Click ·search" To Enter Your Parameters

• All

Search for a spodttc Name

1 All

,;, Search for a specific Bas1n, Right or Tnmsfer number • Basin Humber: 36 • Sequonce Number. 15501

o All

Search for a specific Location by legal descr1ptlon

o All

Search for Surface Water, Ground Water or a specific Source ft/orTrlbut,uy

Water Use

Dates

Water Right Types

Status

"All

Search for a specific Water Use

u All

Search for a speclfk Date T~ ft range of Dates

» AU

Search for one or more specific Water Right Types

o All

Search for both Active ft Inactive Records

Seatch R~ults (11 (( I ick to ecpal)d o, coUao..-1

( Export Results to ~ ij Clear All Ltems (. §la!t ~ I

Options Basin Sequence Suffix

Click any column to sort table

Application Number

Basis Status Priority

Date

Div. Rate \ds)

Source Water Use

Oemls

More Options

36 15501 Deoftd Actlve 07101 / 1957 1.46 ASH

SPRINGS PROPAGATION

I Expolt Resll!ts to Excel ~ Clear AD Items Start Search I

• Harne Dlsctolme< About POf Fil,;~ Contact U. St,le of Idaho ,\tees, bft,ty Privacy & Security

" ; I

http://www.idwr.idaho.gov/apps/ExtSearch/WRAJSearch/SearchPage.aspx

Owner

RANGEN IHC

PLAINTIFF'S ID<HIBIT

~

3/7/2013