Upload
roop
View
231
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 1/19
I Wokcmir Rophrt
hm
IPPAO ^W WIKW_MF
(Ghmtrhvorsy Giso)
(Wosschm< 2092-209?)
Wubkcttoj Zh< Wubkcttoj By<
Rhhp Eiur
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 2/19
Zibao hn Ghmtomts
Wr. Mh. Zctao Pifo Mh.
9.Cmtrhjugtchm th IppaoCmghrphritchm
9
2.Cmtrhjugtchm th WiksumfOaogtrhmcgs Gh. Atj.
2
7.Ippao vs Wiksumf GisoDcsthry
7
:. Zdo Giso Zrcias 6
?. 2092 3
>. 2097 9:
6. Ghmgauschm 9?
4. Ronoromgos 9>
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 3/19
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 4/19
Cmtrhjugtchm th Ippao Cmg<
Ippao Cmg. cs im Ikorcgim kuatcmitchmia ghrphritchm wctd cts doijquirtors it Guportcmh,
Giacnhrmci. Ct joscfms, jovoahps imj soaas ghmsukor oaogtrhmcgs, ghkputor shntwiro imj
porshmia ghkputors. Ippao wis nhumjoj hm Iprca 9, 936> by Wtovo Lhbs, Wtovo Vhzmice imj
Rhmiaj Viymo th soaa Ippao C porshmia ghkputor ect5 imj wis cmghrphritoj is Ippao
Ghkputor Cmg. hm Limuiry 7, 9363 wctdhut Viymo. Kuatc-kcaachmicro Kceo Kireeuai
ncmimgciaay supphrtoj Ippao nhr cts cmghrphritchm imj prhvcjoj i $2?0,000 cmctcia numjcmf. Hm
Limuiry 3, 2006 wctd tdo aiumgd hn cPdhmo, ct sdcntoj thwirjs ghmsukor oaogtrhmcgs nrhk
ghkputor kimunigturcmf, tdus, tdo whrj ‑Ghkputor‛ wis rokhvoj nrhk Ippao Ghkputor
Cmg.
Zibao 9< Acst hn Ippao Prhjugts
Dirjwiro Prhjugts Whntwiro Prhjugts
Kig (Ghkputors/Aipthps) HW T (Hporitcmf Wystok)
cPhj (Kuscg Paiyors) cHW Hporitcmf Wystok (cPdhmo/cPhj/cPij)
cPdhmo (Wkirtpdhmos) cZumos (Kojci Brhwsor)
cPij (Zibaot Ghkputor) Winirc (Vob Brhwsor)
Ippao Z^ cAcno (Groitcvcty Wucto)
cVitgd (cm jovoahpkomt) cVhre (Prhjugtchm Wucto)
Ippao Cmg. wis mikoj is tdo khst ijkcroj ghkpimy cm tdo _mctoj Wtitos nhr tdo yoir 2004
imj cm tdo whraj nrhk 2004-2092 by Nhrtumo kifizcmo imj omtoroj tdo thp tom Nhrtumo ?00
acst hn ghkpimcos cm Kiy 2097 th bo it tdo scxtd phsctchm nrhk tdo provchus oaovomtd phsctchm
(2092). Ct cs tdo soghmj airfost cmnhrkitchm togdmhahfy ghkpimy (by rovomuo) cm tdo whraj
intor Wiksumf Oaogtrhmcgs. Iash, ct nhaahws Wiksumf Oaogtrhmcgs imj Mheci th bo tdo tdcrj
airfost khbcao pdhmo kieor cm tdo whraj. Ippao Cmg. cs tdo airfost pubacgay trijoj ghrphritchm
cm tdo whraj by kireot gipctiaczitchm wctd ostckitoj _W $ :9? bcaachm is hn Kirgd 2097.
Ippao‘s hmacmo cZumos Wthro cs tdo airfost kuscg roticaor cm tdo whraj.
Juo th aibhr prigtcgos hn cts ghmtrigthrs imj cts hwm omvcrhmkomtia imj buscmoss prigtcgos, tdo
ghkpimy dis boom ittrigtcmf grctcgcsk.
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 5/19
Cmtrhjugtchm th Wiksumf Oaogtrhmcgs Gh. Atj<
Wiksumf Oaogtrhmcgs Gh. Atj. cs i Whutd Ehroim kuatcmitchmia oaogtrhmcgs ghkpimy. Ct cs i
naifsdcp subscjciry hn tdo Wiksumf Frhup wctd cts doijquirtors it Wuwhm, Whutd Ehroi.
Oiracor, Wiksumf kimunigturoj actdcuk-chm bittorcos, gdcps, naisd kokhry, dirj jrcvo imj
sokcghmjugthrs nhr Ippao Cmg., Whmy, DZG imj Mheci. Rogomtay, Wiksumf Oaogtrhmcgs
oxpimjoj imj jcvorscncoj cmth ghmsukor kireots cmgroiscmf tdo phrtnhach hn prhjugts imj
rovomuo stroik.
Wcmgo 2003, ct dis boom tdo whraj‘s airfost cmnhrkitchm togdmhahfy ghkpimy (by rovomuo) imj
tdo airfost vomjhr cm tdo khbcao pdhmos, skirtpdhmos juo th phpuaircty hn Wiksumf Fiaixy
acmo hn jovcgos. Wcmgo 2099, ct dis tdo airfost khbcao pdhmo kimunigturor cm tdo whraj.
Wiksumf dis boom tdo airfost kieor hn AGJ pimoas scmgo 2002 imj airfost toaovcschm
kimunigturor scmgo 200>. Zdo Brimj Zrust Rophrt, im immuia rophrt pubacsdoj by tdo Zrust
Rosoirgd Ijvcshry rimeoj Wiksumf is Cmjci‘s soghmj khst trustoj brimj nhr tdo yoir 2097
rcscmf up nrhk tdo nhurtd phsctchm nhr tdo yoir 2092. Wiksumf cs i kilhr pirt hn tdo Oghmhky
hn Whutd Ehroi.
Whko hn tdo prhjugts hn Wiksumf Oaogtrhmcgs cmgaujo<
AGJ imj AOJ Pimoas
Khbcao Pdhmos
Wokcghmjugthrs
Zoaovcschms
Prcmtors (Khmh Aisor, Ghahr Aisor)
Aipthps
Gikoris
Dirj Jcse Jrcvos
Gikghrjors
Kp7 Kuscg Paiyors
Ghkputor Zibaots
Wproij hvor 44 ghumtrcos tdo ghkpimy dis i wcjo siaos motwhre imj issokbay paimts.
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 6/19
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 7/19
Hvoriaa joscfm hn tdo prhjugt, cmgaujcmf tdo rogtimfuair sdipo, tdo rhumjoj ghrmors,
tdo scavor ojfos, tdo baige nigo, imj tdo jcspaiy hn scxtoom ghahrnua cghms.
Ghmncfuritchm hn i rogtimfuair dimjdoaj khbcao jcfctia oaogtrhmcg jovcgo wctd rhumjoj
ghrmors, friy rogtimfuair phrtchm cm tdo gomtor wctd i baige bimj ibhvo imj boahw friy
rogtimfao, gurvoj ghrmors wctd i scavor hutor bhrjor imj scjo.
Ippao's rofcstoroj trijokires hm sovoria cHW systok cghms, imj ZhugdVcz cmgaujos scx
cghms tdit ahhe iakhst oxigtay tdo siko< cHW pdhmo, kossifcmf, pdhths, sottcmfs, mhtos,
ghmtigts, cZumos ipp cghms.
Fripdcgia _sor Cmtornigo nhr i Jcspaiy -tdo cHW dhko sgroom imj tdo frcj hn cghms.
Zdo cPdhmo 7F / 7FW joscfm, lust tdo jovcgo's sdoaa (imy butthm hr sgroom sczo jcnnoromgos hm
Wiksumf's jovcgos jhm't kittor)
Kotdhj imj ippiritus nhr jcspaiycmf imj iggosscmf ghmtrha imj stitus cmnhrkitchm cm i
ghkputor systok, ct ghvors i systok tdit phps hpom i wcmjhw th sdhw kuatcpao cmtorigtcvo
ghmtrha wcjfots.
Acst sgrhaacmf imj jhgukomt trimsaitchm, sgiacmf imj rhtitchm hm i thugd-sgroom jcspaiy hmo
hn Ippao's ncrst cHW-roaitoj pitomts.
Kotdhj imj ippiritus nhr jcspaiycmf cmnhrkitchm jurcmf im Cmstimt Kossifcmf Wosschm ct
ghvors irrimfcmf cmghkcmf kossifos cm i ghkkumcgitchms sosschm cm i tckoacmo tdit's
dhrczhmtiaay spigoj.
Oaacpso Ncttcmf nhr Kuatc-Zhugd Wurnigos, ct ghvors tiecmf thugd ckprosschms kippcmf tdok
th oaacpsos.
Ippacgitchm prhfrikkcmf cmtornigos nhr sgrhaacmf hporitchms imj ct ghvors jogcjcmf wdom i
usor cs uscmf hmo ncmfor th sgrhaa i vcow vorsus twh hr khro ncmfors th sgiao tdit siko vcow.
Kotdhj imj ippiritus nhr jcspaiycmf i wcmjhw nhr i usor cmtornigo, ghvors jcspaiycmf im
hvoraiy wcmjhw hvor tdo stimjirj _C cm rosphmso th i eoystrheo imj divcmf ct jcsippoir
iuthkitcgiaay intor shko projoncmoj ikhumt hn tcko. Cm htdor whrjs, ct ghvors tdcmfs aceo tdo
cHW vhauko jcspaiy, wdcgd iuthkitcgiaay nijos hut intor yhu'vo ijlustoj tdo vhauko. Zdcs cs
i roaitcvoay mow pitomt, lust frimtoj hm Jogokbor 9:,
Gimtcaovoroj pusd butthm divcmf kuatcpao ghmtigts imj nuagruks, ct ghvors tdo vhauko
rhgeor hm tdo cPdhmo 7F imj 7FW ‚ i vhauko rhgeor tdit ahhes qucto aceo tdo hmo hm
Wiksumf's virchus Fiaixy W jovcgos.
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 8/19
Wiksumf ghumtor suos Ippao<
Intor Ippao saikkoj Wiksumf wctd 9> cmnrcmfokomt aiwsucts hm Iprca 9?, 20995 Wiksumf
ncaoj aiwsucts ificmst Ippao cm Ehroi, Lipim, imj Forkimy iaaofcmf tdit ct cmnrcmfoj i thtia hn
90 pitomts. Wiksumf cs i kilhr cmtormitchmia pitomt dhajor. Dij Wiksumf puaaoj idoij cm hmo
hn tdoso nhrocfm ghumtrcos, tdo prossuro whuaj divo boom hm tdo _W th fcvo tdo ncmia vorjcgt hm
giso. Wiksumf‘s ghkpaicmt cm tdo Mhrtdorm Jcstrcgt hn Giacnhrmci gaickoj tdit<
Ncrst, Wiksumf spomt $7? bcaachm hm R&J nrhk 200? th 2090, wdcgd ghmtrcbutoj th i sczibao
pitomt phrtnhach< 24,600 _W pitomts, :,??9 hn wdcgd woro cssuoj cm 2090.
Kotdhj imj Ippiritus nhr Zrimskcttcmf/Rogocvcmf Pigeot Jiti _scmf Pro-Joncmoj Aomftd
Cmjcgithr cm i Khbcao Ghkkumcgitchm Wystok cs vory togdmcgia pitomt josgrcbcmf i systok
th cmgroiso khbcao motwhre onncgcomgy by uscmf doijor jiti khro onnogtcvoay.
Ippiritus imj Kotdhj nhr Fomoritcmf Wgrikbacmf Ghjo cm _KZW Khbcao Ghkkumcgitchm
Wystok, cs imhtdor dcfday-togdmcgia _KZW / V-GKJI pitomt tdit ghvors fomoritcmf umcquo
sgrikbacmf ghjos nhr jhwmacme trimskcttors.
Kotdhj imj Ippiritus nhr Jiti Zrimskcsschm cm i Khbcao Zoaoghkkumcgitchm Wystok
Wupphrtcmf Omdimgoj _pacme Worvcgo, ghvors uscmf twh rijch gdimmoas th trimskct jitiuscmf i sot ikhumt hn phwor.
Cmtoraoivcmf Ippiritus imj Kotdhj nhr Wykbha Kippcmf cm im DWJPI Khbcao
Ghkkumcgitchm Wystok.
Ippiritus imj Kotdhj nhr Gdimmoa Ghjcmf imj Kuatcpaoxcmf cm GJKI Ghkkumcgitchm
Wystok, ghvors tiecmf kuatcpao jiti nrikos tdit iro rogocvoj hut hn hrjor igrhss kuatcpao
gdimmoas imj puttcmf tdok bige thfotdor onncgcomtay.
Ippiritus imj Kotdhj nhr Ghmtrhaacmf i Jokuatcpaoxor imj i Kuatcpaoxor _soj nhr Rito
Kitgdcmf cm i Khbcao Ghkkumcgitchm Wystok, ghvors i trimskcttor tdit omghjos im cmput
stroik cmth tdroo cmtoraoivoj stroiks tdit iro tdom brheom up cmth jcnnoromt rijch nrikos.
Zurbh Omghjcmf/Joghjcmf Jovcgo imj Kotdhj nhr Prhgosscmf Nriko Jiti Igghrjcmf th
YHW, dis wdit cs gaoiray tdo bost miko hn iaa tdo gaickoj pitomts.
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 9/19
Whntwiro Eoybhirj Wystok _scmf Zrigo hn Wtyaus hm i Zhugd Wgroom imj Kotdhj nhr
Roghfmczcmf Eoy Ghjo _scmf tdo siko, cs tdo ncrst _C pitomt, ghvorcmf shntwiro eoybhirj
numgtchmiacty.
Wystoks imj Kotdhjs nhr Fomoritcmf ^csuia Roprosomtitchms hn Fripdcgia Jiti imj Jcfctia
Jhgukomt Prhgosscmf, ghvors jcspaiycmf i ahw-roshautchm ckifo provcow wdcao tdo nuaa-
roshautchm ckifos ahijs cm tdo bigefrhumj.
Khbcao Zoaopdhmo Gipibao hn Jcspaiycmf Vhraj Zcko imj Kotdhj nhr Ghmtrhaacmf tdo
Wiko, cs i pitomt hm giaguaitcmf tcko cm kuatcpao gctcos bisoj hm i ronoromgo tcko scfmia somt
nrhk i rokhto systok imj tdo ahgia tcko hn tdo jovcgo.
Ncfuro 9< Wiksumf Wkirtpdhmo imj Ippao cPdhmo
Whurgo< dttp<//www.tdovorfo.ghk/2092/7/22/243269:/ippao-siksumf-mofhtcitchms-2090-
pitomt/cm/2236?97
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 10/19
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 11/19
Wtoppcmf cm intor Forkimy, i Jutgd ghurt bimmoj siaos hn Wiksumf Fiaixy W, Fiaixy Igo
imj Fiaixy W CC skirtpdhmos juo th cmnrcmfokomt hn hmay Ippao's pitomt hn cHW pdhth ipps cm
Imjrhcj 2.7 bucaj jcsgirjcmf htdor pitomt imj trijokire gaicks hn Ippao. Intor tdo Jutgd
bim, Wiksumf paimmoj th pitgd up cts pdhth ipp th ivhcj bimmcmf hn siaos. Intor Forkimy imj
Motdoraimjs, Iustriacim Nojoria Ghurt hn Lustcgo iash frimtoj imhtdor cmlumgtchm th Ippao
bimmcmf tdo ahgia siao hn Wiksumf Fiaixy Zib 90.9 juo th cmnrcmfokomt hn tdroo Ippao cPij
pitomts roaitoj th thugdsgrooms imj fosturo ghmtrhas. Whhm intor tdo bim nrhk tdo Iustriacim
Ghurt, Wiksumf ippoiroj bonhro tdo lujfo ificm nhr soaacmf i khjcncoj vorschm hn tdo Fiaixy
Zib 90.9 nroo hn tdo jcsputoj Ippao pitomts imj whm tdo ippoia th iator cts joscfm imj rovheoj
tdo bim shhm intor. Cm hrjor th fomorito pubacgcty cm Iustriaci, Wiksumf ijjoj i tifacmo th tdo
tib5 Fiaixy Zib 90.9 - "Zdo tibaot Ippao trcoj th sthp". Bofcmmcmf nrhk Iprca 2099 Ippao imj
Wiksumf woro busy cm ghurtrhhks irhumj tdo whraj boscjos jovoahpcmf mow prhjugts. By tdo
omj hn 2099, tdo Ippao - Wiksumf ghmtrhvorsy wis fhcmf tdrhufd i kcxoj vcgthry nhr bhtd
tdo ghkpimcos wctd Ippao wcmmcmf proackcmiry cmlumgtchms imj nhrgcmf Wiksumf th cmtrhjugo
khjcncoj vorschms hn cts prhjugts cm tdo kireot but Wiksumf kicmticmcmf cts stimj th eoop cts
prhjugts cm tdo kireot.
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 12/19
2092
Vctd i mow yoir hm tdo rhaa, Ippao dij shko mow yoir roshautchms ificmst Wiksumf, wdom cm
Limuiry 2092, tdo Guportcmh cmghrphritchm ncaoj i brimj mow pitomt cmnrcmfokomt suct ificmst
Wiksumf cm Forkimy iaaofcmf Wiksumf's Fiaixy W Paus, Fiaixy W CC imj kimy htdor
Wiksumf skirtpdhmos vchaitcmf Ippao's Ourhpoim joscfm rcfdts. But hm tdo htdor dimj, tdo
Mow Soir brhufdt shko bij mows nhr tdo Whutd Ehroim dimjsot kieor wdom tdo Forkim
lujfos rologtoj Wiksumf's twh hut hn tdo ncvo pitomt aiwsucts roaitoj th 7F/_KZW wcroaoss
ghkkumcgitchm stimjirjs ificmst Ippao, wctd umgaoir roishmcmf. Koimwdcao, cm Nobruiry
2092 cm Iustriaci Ippao dct hut it Wiksumf wctd 264 gaicks ghvorcmf 22 pitomt cmnrcmfokomts
igrhss 90 jovcgos. I khmtd intor Ippao's ijjctchmia gaicks ificmst Wiksumf cm Iustriaci,
Wiksumf fht imhtdor bahw wdom i Motdoraimjs' Difuo Jcstrcgt Ghurt rologtoj bimmcmf hn
Ippao cPdhmos hr cPijs cm Motdoraimjs. Zdo ghurt ruaoj tdit Wiksumf ghuaj mht ghaaogt i
acgomso hm 7F pitomts nhr cPdhmo :W imj htdor Ippao jovcgos uscmf Yuiaghkk gdcps. Wcmgo,
Ippao dij usoj bisobimj gdcps nrhk Cmncmohm imj Cmtoa nhr cPdhmo 7F, 7FW, : imj cPij 9, 2
imj ct wis mht gaoir wdotdor Cmncmohm imj Cmtoa dij prhvcjoj Wiksumf wctd roaovimt acgomscmf
noos nhr tdo bisobimj gdcps.
Ncfuro 7< Ippao cPdhmos
Whurgo< dttp<//spireaotogdmows.ghk/wp-ghmtomt/upahijs/2092/92/iaa-ippao-cpdhmos.lpf
Ippao wis fcvom tcko tcaa Iprca 2092 th prosomt ovcjomgo ibhut tdo Cmncmohm imj Cmtoa
bisobimj gdcps. Dhwovor, cm Lumo 2092 Wiksumf doivoj i scfd hn roacon is tdo Difuo Jcstrcgt
Ghurt ruaoj cm cts nivhr tdit Ippao wis nhumj th vchaito hmo hn Wiksumf's pitomt hm cPdhmo
7F, 7FW, : imj cPij 9,2 uscmf tdo bisobimj gdcps nrhk Cmncmohm imj Cmtoa. Wiksumf wis mhtomtctaoj th bim Ippao jovcgos is tdo cmnrcmfokomt wis gaisscncoj is NRIMJ (nicr, roishmibao
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 13/19
imj mhm-jcsgrckcmithry torks). Ijjcmf up tdo proackcmiry cmlumgtchm wcms hn Ippao, _W
Jcstrcgt Lujfo tomtitcvoay sthppoj siaos hn Wiksumf Fiaixy Zib 90.9 cm tdo _W. Ippao dij
ifrooj th phst i $2.> kcaachm bhmj cm giso Wiksumf prhvoj Ippao's J'443 joscfm pitomt
cmviacj th ghkpomsito Wiksumf's ahss but _W Jcstrcgt Lujfo bimmoj tdo Fiaixy Zib 90.9
nhaahwcmf wdcgd Wiksumf ippoiaoj tdo jogcschm th tdo Ghurt hn Ippoias nhr tdo Nojoria
Gcrguct. Cm Luay 2092, Forkimy oxtomjoj tdo bim hn Fiaixy Zib 6.6 th tdo omtcro O_ nrhk tdo
oiracor bim wdcgd wis ackctoj th hmay Forkimy but gaoiroj wiy nhr Fiaixy Zib 90.9M. Cm tdo
omj hn Luay 2092, Wiksumf wis simgtchmoj by i Giacnhrmci nojoria lujfo nhr jostrhycmf o-kica
ovcjomgo tdit Ippao ghuaj divo usoj cm tdo ghurt. Jurcmf tdit tcko, Wiksumf's ghkpimy o-
kicas woro jostrhyoj intor twh wooes (umaoss okpahyoos sivoj tdok) imj Wiksumf gaickoj
th divo hrjoroj okpahyoos th sivo roaovimt o-kicas but tdo iuthkitcg joaotchm wis girrcoj hm.
Cm tdo jiys wdcgd nhaahwoj, Wiksumf groitoj trhubaos nhr ctsoan by rovoiacmf cm tdo kojci im
ovcjomgo rologtoj by tdo ghurt jurcmf tdo trcia. Zdo ovcjomgo wis ibhut Wiksumf's N600
pdhmo wdcgd wis cm jovoahpkomt khmtds bonhro tdo Limuiry 2006 cPdhmo cmtrhjugtchm imj
cmtormia ghkpimy okicas sdhwcmf tdit Ippao wimtoj th pursuo i "Whmy-styao" joscfm nhr cts
pdhmo. Ct wis jomcoj bogiuso tdo lujfo ruaoj tdit ct wis prhjugoj thh aito. Nhaahwcmf tdo
cmstimgo _W lujfo ificm wirmoj Wiksumf hn simgtchmcmf tdo Whutd Ehroim pdhmo kieor.
Ncfuro :< Wiksumf‘s Kojci Aoieoj Ovcjomgo
Whurgo< dttp<//www.tdovorfo.ghk/2092/6/79/720320:/siksumf-imfors-lujfo-by-somjcmf-
kojci-rologtoj-ovcjomgo-cm-ippao-trcia/cm/2236?97
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 14/19
Cm Iufust 2092, tdo Ippao-Wiksumf aofia sifi turmoj th cghms imj cPijs, wctd Wiksumf
hblogtcmf Ippao hn tikporcmf wctd Opcg Zhugd :F (Ippao-Wiksumf lhcmt vomturo) th kieo cts
cghm aiyhut khro aceo cPdhmo but tdo lujfo hvorruaoj tdo hblogtchm, fcvcmf Ippao i fh idoij
th girry hm cts oviauitchm hn tdo cPdhmos imj Wiksumf skirtpdhmos sckcair cghms. Vdorois,
Wiksumf iggusoj Ippao hn cmnrcmfcmf tdroo jcnnoromt numgtchms < somjcmf i toxt-hmay okica,
somjcmf im okica wctd pdhth ittigdkomt imj fhcmf tdrhufd jcnnoromt pdhths cm i fiaaory khjo
cm cPdhmo:,7F,7FW imj cPij 2, cPhj :F. Hm tdo htdor dimj, Ippao iggusoj Wiksumf hn
pitomt ghvorcmf ibcacty hn kuscg paiy cm tdo bigefrhumj hm khbcao jovcgo pornhrkcmf htdor
numgtchms.
Ncfuro ?< Ippao‘s gaick ificmst cmnrcmfoj cghms by Wiksumf
Whurgo<
dttp<//www.tdovorfo.ghk/2092/4/6/722622>/ippao-siksumf-trcia-ovcjomgo-iufust-6-
2092
Hm Iufust 2:, 2092 Ippao siw im omhrkhus kcj-vcgthry cm tdo Giacnhrmcim Ghurt wdom mcmo lurhrs jogcjoj umimckhusay cm cts nivhr tdit Wiksumf cmnrcmfoj Ippao‘s cmtoaaogtuia prhporty
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 15/19
ackctcmf tdo jikifo th mht khro tdim 2.? bcaachm. Igghrjcmf th tdo lurhrs, tdoro wis mht ovom
i scmfao vchaitchm by Ippao roaitoj th utcacty pitomts (pdhth cmtornigo imj okicas). Iash, tdo
lury skisdoj Wiksumf‘s iaaofitchms hn Ippao cmnrcmfcmf 7F pitomts cm cPdhmo 7F, 7FW imj
cPij 9, 2 bogiuso Cmtoa iaroijy dij i acgomscmf ifrookomt wctd Wiksumf. Wtirtcmf nrhk
cmnrcmfcmf Ippao‘s bhumgo-bige pitomt th utcacty pitomts th tdo joscfm pitomts5 tdo lurhrs nhumj
tdit kilhrcty hn tdo jovcgos woro cmnrcmfoj. Vdorois, mht ovom i scmfao Ippao pitomt wis
jogairoj cmviacj but tdo trijo jross nhr cPij‘s cghms imj aiyhut ghuaj mht prhtogtoj bogiuso
tdoy woro umrofcstoroj. Zdo lury saikkoj Wiksumf wctd i $9.0:3 bcaachm ncfuro nhr tdo
jikifos th Ippao.
Ncfuro >< Crhmcg pcgturo hn Wiksumf imj Ippao
Whurgo< dttp<//www.tdovorfo.ghk/2092/6/2>/7946647/lujfo-simgtchms-siksumf-
ippao-pitomt-trcia-ovcjomgo/cm/2236?97
I wooe intor $9.0:3 bcaachm vcgthry ificmst Wiksumf, Ippao ijjoj th Wiksumf‘s trhubao by
ijjcmf khro jovcgos th tdo cmnrcmfokomt aiwsucts. Zdo rovcsoj acst hn cmnrcmfoj jovcgos mhw
cmgaujoj Fiaixy W CCC, Fiaixy Mhto, Fiaixy W CC, Fiaixy Moxus, Caauschm, Wtrithspdoro,
Fiaixy Mhto 90.9, Fiaixy Zib 4.3 imj htdors. Wiksumf ijjoj cPdhmo ? th cts acst hn Ippao
jovcgos cmnrcmfcmf cts 7F pitomts. Ovom tdhufd Wiksumf ahst tdo Giacnhrmcim wir, but Whutd
Ehroim fcimt wis wcmmcmf skiaa bittaos irhumj tdo whraj- tdo Whutd Ehroim imj tdo
Lipimoso ghurts ruaoj cm nivhr hn Wiksumf ronuscmf Ippao‘s paoi nhr $9.26? kcaachm cm
jikifos nhr tdo pitomt ghvorcmf kojci symg botwoom jovcgos iaaofojay cmnrcmfoj by
Wiksumf. Koimwdcao, cm spcto hn wcmmcmf sovoria cmlumgtchms, Ippao nigoj i bcf joia hn
dukcacitchm wdom tdo Ghurt hn Ippoia hn Omfaimj imj Viaos hrjoroj Ippao th piy aofia
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 16/19
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 17/19
2097
Oiracor cm tdo yoir 2097, _W Nojoria Ghurt Lujfo hrjoroj th kcmckczo tdo sghpo hn tdo
aiwsuct is ovory tcko tdo twh ghkpimcos ippoir cm tdo ghurtrhhk tdoy ijj up mow jovcgos
ghmsukcmf ghmscjoribao tcko imj omorfy hn tdo ghurt. Is hn Lumo 2097 tdo aitost jovoahpkomt
cm tdo Ippao vs Wiksumf aofia bittao wis tdo jomcia hn i Wim Lhso Ghurt th Ippao nhr ijjcmf
Fiaixy W: th tdo pitomt giso ificmst Wiksumf. Iash _W Cmtormitchmia Zrijo Ghkkcsschm
bimmoj siaos hn gorticm Ippao prhjugts intor ncmjcmf tdit Ippao vchaitoj Wiksumf Pitomts.
But tdo _W Zrijo Roprosomtitcvo vothoj tdo bim iaahwcmf Ippao th roticm soaacmf cts prhjugts.
Vctd tdo lujfos frhwcmf cmgroiscmfay ckpitcomt hvor Ippao imj Wiksumf aofia kimhouvro,
_W Proscjomt Hbiki paims th gurb tdo pitomt rhaas nhr ummogossiry sucts bocmf ncaoj by tdo
ghkpimcos. Cm Iufust 2097, tdo _W Cmtormitchmia Zrijo Ghkkcsschm bahgeoj ckphrts hn
shko Wiksumf jovcgos intor tdoy woro nhumj th vchaito twh Ippao pitomts but gaoiroj tdo
ghkpimy hn nhur htdor pitomts. Zdo _W Zrijo Roprosomtitcvo dis >0 jiys th voth tdo bim. Zdo
aiwsuct cs stcaa pomjcmf wctd doircmf juo nhr Mhvokbor 2097.
8/11/2019 Apple vs Samsung Controversy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apple-vs-samsung-controversy 18/19
Ghmgauschm<
By stujycmf tdo wdhao giso hm Ippao vs Wiksumf, wo gim ncmj tdit cmnrcmfokomt cs vory
ghkkhm cm giso hn joscfm imj kimunigturo. But Ippao ncaoj giso hm Wiksumf imj htdor
ghkpimcos th provomt tdok nrhk cmnrcmfcmf cts togdmhahfy imj prhjugt joscfms. Juo th
actcfitchm is tdoy iro ibhut th broie tdocr roaitchmsdcp, ct cs mht bomoncgcia nhr bhtd hn tdok.
Wiksumf wis i eoy kimunigturor nhr Ippao cm cts cmctcia prhjugts sugd is cPhjs, KigBhhes,
otg. Vo fot th emhw tdit Wiksumf vchaitoj Ippao‘s cmtoaaogtuia prhporty by uscmf shko hn
Ippao‘s pitomts wdcgd Wiksumf dij iggoss th wdom tdo twh woro iaacos.