Accenture Confidential

Labor Law

Tabangao Shell Refinery Employees Association vs. Pilipinas Shell Premium Corporation, 720 SCRA 631,April 07, 2014GMA Network, Inc. vs. Pabriga, 710 SCRA 690, November 27, 2013

San Miguel Corporation vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 588 SCRA 179, May 26, 2009Fair Shipping Corp. vs. Medel, 679 SCRA 360, August 29, 2012Datuman vs. First Cosmopolitan Manpower and Promotion Services, Inc., 571 SCRA 41, November 14, 2008Iligan Cement Corporation vs. ILIASCOR Employees and Workers Union—Southern Philippines Federation of Labor (IEWU-SPFL), 586 SCRA 449, April 24, 2009Pfizer, Inc. vs. Velasco, 645 SCRA 135, March 09, 2011Bilbao vs. Saudi Arabian Airlines, 662 SCRA 540, December 14, 2011The Coca-Cola Export Corporation vs. Gacayan, 652 SCRA 463, June 22, 2011Pacific Ocean Manning, Inc. vs. Penales, 680 SCRA 95, September 05, 2012Bank of the Philippines Islands vs. BPI Employees Union-Davao Chapter-Federation of Unions in BPI Unibank, 658 SCRA 828, October 11, 2011Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 589 SCRA 376, June 18, 2009Philippine Airlines, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 634 SCRA 18, October 20, 2010Magsaysay Maritime Corp. vs. Velasquez, 571 SCRA 239, November 14, 2008

Civil Law

Catungal vs. Rodriguez, 646 SCRA 130, March 23, 2011Heirs of Domingo Hernandez, Sr. vs. Mingoa, Sr., 608 SCRA 394, December 18, 2009Country Bankers Insurance Corporation vs. Keppel Cebu Shipyard, 673 SCRA 427, June 18, 2012Republic vs. Jaralve, 684 SCRA 495, October 24, 2012Ochosa vs.Alano, 640 SCRA 517, January 26, 2011Philippine National Bank vs. Aznar, 649 SCRA 214, May 30, 2011Ramon vs. Philippine National Bank, 662 SCRA 479, December 14, 2011Azcueta vs. Republic, 588 SCRA 196, May 26, 2009Manaloto vs. Veloso III, 632 SCRA 347, October 06, 2010Heirs of Romana Saves vs. Heirs of Escolastico Saves, 632 SCRA 236, October 06, 2010Republic vs. Marawi-Marantao General Hospital, Inc., 686 SCRA 546, November 28, 2012R.V. Santos Company, Inc. vs. Belle Corporation, 682 SCRA 219, October 03, 2012

International School Manila vs. International School Alliance of Educators (ISAE), 715 SCRA 343,February 05, 2014Culili vs. Eastern Telecommunications Philippines, Inc., 642 SCRA 338, February 09, 2011Coca-Cola Bottlers Philippines, Inc. vs. Del Villar, 632 SCRA 293, October 06, 2010

The Coca-Cola Export Corporation vs. Gacayan, 638 SCRA 377, December 15, 2010Sugue vs. Triumph International (Phils.), Inc., 577 SCRA 323, January 30, 2009Mindanao Terminal and Brokerage Service, Inc. vs. Nagkahiusang Mamumuo sa Minterbro-Southern Philippines Federation of Labor, 687 SCRA 28, December 05, 2012Alcantara vs. Philippine Commercial and International Bank, 634 SCRA 48, October 20, 2010

Republic vs. Mangotara, 624 SCRA 360, July 07, 2010Torbela vs. Rasario, 661 SCRA 633, December 07, 2011Navida vs. Dizon, Jr., 649 SCRA 33, May 30, 2011Cebu Bionic Builders Supply, Inc. vs. Development Bank of the Philippines, 635 SCRA 13, November 17, 2010Republic - Bureau of Forest Development vs. Roxas, 712 SCRA 177, December 11, 2013People vs. Rebucan, 654 SCRA 726, July 27, 2011Union Bank of the Philippines vs. Tiu, 657 SCRA 86, September 07, 2011Sealoader Shipping Corporation vs. Grand Cement Manufacturing Corporation, 638 SCRA 488, December 15, 2010Carpo vs. Ayala Land, Incorporated, 611 SCRA 436, February 03, 2010

Accenture Confidential

National Housing Authority vs. Basa, Jr., 618 SCRA 461, April 20, 2010Century Savings Bank vs. Samonte, 634 SCRA 261, October 20, 2010Republic vs. De Guzman, 652 SCRA 101, June 15, 2011Sta. Lucia Realty & Development, Inc. vs. City of Pasig, 652 SCRA 44, June 15, 2011Fernando, Jr. vs. Acuna, 657 SCRA 499, September 14, 2011Binayug vs. Ugaddan, 687 SCRA 260, December 05, 2012Cachopero vs. Celestial, 668 SCRA 619, March 21, 2012Jarantilla, Jr. vs. Jarantilla, 636 SCRA 299, December 01, 2010Gabriel vs. Jamias, 565 SCRA 443, September 17, 2008Ormoc Sugarcane Planters' Association, Inc. (OSPA) vs. Court of Appeals, 596 SCRA 630, August 24, 2009BPI Family Savings Bank, Inc. vs. Avenido, 661 SCRA 758, December 07, 2011Republic vs. Capco de Tensuan, 708 SCRA 367, October 23, 2013Fontana Resort and Country Club, Inc. vs. Tan, 664 SCRA 382, January 30, 2012MCA-MBF Countdown Cards Philippines, Inc. vs. MBF Card International Limited, 668 SCRA 214, March 14, 2012Ching vs. Enrile, 565 SCRA 402, September 17, 2008Magkalas vs. National Housing Authority, 565 SCRA 379, September 17, 2008Fernandez vs. Amagna, 601 SCRA 330, September 30, 2009Garcia vs. Villar, 675 SCRA 80, June 27, 2012Durawood Construction and Lumber Supply, Inc. vs. Bona, 664 SCRA 204, January 25, 2012Rufloe vs. Burgos, 577 SCRA 264, January 30, 2009People vs. Velasquez, 669 SCRA 307, April 11, 2012Morla vs. Belmonte, 661 SCRA 717, December 07, 2011Republic vs. Lorenzo, 687 SCRA 478, December 10, 2012Tarona vs. Court of Appeals, 589 SCRA 474, June 18, 2009Republic vs. Heirs of Evaristo Tiotioen, 568 SCRA 152, October 08, 2008Dela Cruz vs. Segovia, 555 SCRA 453, June 26, 2008Suatengco vs. Reyes, 574 SCRA 187, December 17, 2008Bank of the Philippine Islands vs. Reyes, 664 SCRA 700, February 01, 2012Philippine Deposit Insurance Corporation vs. Bureau of Internal Revenue, 698 SCRA 311, June 13, 2013Government Service Insurance System vs. Commission on Audit, 680 SCRA 376, September 11, 2012Republic vs. Mangotara, 633 SCRA 64, October 13, 2010Republic vs. Heirs of Maxima Lachica Sin, 720 SCRA 41, March 26, 2014Decaleng vs. Bishop of the Missionary District of the Philippine Islands of Protestant Episcopal Church in the United States of America, 675 SCRA 145, June 27, 2012Capistrano vs. Limcuando, 579 SCRA 176, February 13, 2009Imelda, Leonardo, Fidelino, Azucena, Josefina, Anita and Sisa, all surnamed Syjuco vs. Felisa D. Bonifacio and VSD Realty & Development Corporation, GR No 148748, January 14, 2015CLT Realty Development Corporation vs. Phil-Ville Development and Housing Corporation, et al., G.R. No. 160728, March 11, 2015Bank of the Philippine Islands Vs. Amador Domingo, G.R. No. 169407, March 25, 2015 Philnico Industrial Corporation vs. Privatization and Management Office, G.R. No. 199420, August 27, 2014

Remedial LawDepartment of Foreign Affair vs. Falcon, 629 SCRA 644, September 01, 2010HPS Software and Communication vs. Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company (PLDT), 687 SCRA 426, December 10, 2012Government Service Insurance System (GSIS) vs. Group Management Corporation (GMC), 651 SCRA 279, June 08, 2011Smart Communications, Inc. vs. Aldecoa, 705 SCRA 392, September 11, 2013Government Service Insurance System vs. Regional Trial Court of Pasig City, Branch 71, 608 SCRA 552,December 18, 2009

Accenture Confidential

Manila International Airport Authority vs. Ding Velayo Sports Center, Inc., 662 SCRA 399, December 14, 2011The Board of Regents of the Mindanao State University vs. Osop, 666 SCRA 467, February 22, 2012Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company vs. Eastern Telecommunications Philippines, Inc., 690 SCRA 1, February 06, 2013City of Dumaguete vs. Philippine Ports Authority, 656 SCRA 102, August 24, 2011People vs. Saludo, 647 SCRA 374, April 06, 2011Leynes vs. Former Tenth Division of the Court of Appeals, 640 SCRA 25, January 19, 2011BF Homes, Inc. vs. Manila Electric Company, 636 SCRA 495, December 06, 2010

Lonzanida vs. People, 593 SCRA 273, July 20, 2009NM Rothschild & Sons (Australia) Limited vs. Lepanto Consolidated Mining Company, 661 SCRA 328,November 28, 2011Rodriguez vs. Court of Appeals, 698 SCRA 352, June 13, 2013People vs. Serrano, 620 SCRA 315, May 06, 2010Solid Builders, Inc. vs. China Banking Corporation, 695 SCRA 101, April 03, 2013Jacob vs. Sandiganbayan Fouth Division, 635 SCRA 94, November 17, 2010PCI Leasing and Finance, Inc. vs. Milan, 617 SCRA 258, April 05, 2010F.A.T. Kee Computer Systems, Inc. vs. Online Networks International, Inc., 641 SCRA 390, February 02, 2011People vs. Basao, 683 SCRA 529, October 10, 2012Dela Rosa vs. Heirs of Juan Valdez, 654 SCRA 467, July 27, 2011Albaña vs. Belo, 602 SCRA 140, October 02, 2009People vs. Zafra, 700 SCRA 106, June 26, 2013Reyes vs. Ortiz, 628 SCRA 1, August 11, 2010Bautista vs. Causapin, Jr., 652 SCRA 442, June 22, 2011

Palm Tree Estates, Inc. vs. Philippine National Bank, 682 SCRA 194, October 03, 2012De La Salle University vs. De La Salle Employees Association (DLSUEA-NAFTEU), 679 SCRA 33, August 23, 2012Antiquina vs. Magsaysay Maritime Corporation, 648 SCRA 659, April 13, 2011Heirs of Maximino Derla vs. Heirs of Catalina Derla Vda. de Hipolito, 648 SCRA 638, April 13, 201Suarez, Jr. vs. National Steel Corporation, 569 SCRA 331, October 17, 2008People vs. Taculod, 712 SCRA 562, December 11, 2013California Bus Lines, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 562 SCRA 403, August 20, 2008Angeles vs. Secretary of Justice, 614 SCRA 478, March 09, 2010Heirs of Teofilo Gabatan vs. Court of Appeals, 581 SCRA 70, March 13, 2009Luna vs. Allado Construction Co., Inc., 649 SCRA 262, May 30, 2011Banahaw Broadcasting Corporation vs. Pacana III, 649 SCRA 196, May 30, 2011Heirs of Cornelio Miguel vs. Heirs of Angel Miguel, 719 SCRA 413, March 19, 2014Manguiob vs. Arcangel, 666 SCRA 39, February 15, 2012People vs. Santos, 709 SCRA 500, November 13, 2013People vs. Espenilla, 706 SCRA 134, September 18, 2013Philux, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 564 SCRA 21, September 03, 2008Besana vs. Mayor, 625 SCRA 203, July 21, 2010

People vs. Basallo, 689 SCRA 616, January 30, 2013The Learning Child, Inc. vs. Ayala Alabang Village Association, 624 SCRA 258, July 07, 2010Toshiba Information Equipment (Phils.), Inc. vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 614 SCRA 526,March 09, 2010Pilipino Telephone Corporation vs. Radiomarine Network, Inc., 626 SCRA 703, August 04, 2010Muñoz vs. Yabut, Jr., 650 SCRA 344, June 06, 2011

General Milling Corporation vs. Casio, 615 SCRA 13, March 10, 2010

Selga vs. Brar, 658 SCRA 108, September 21, 2011

Accenture Confidential

Limbauan vs. Acosta, 556 SCRA 614, June 30, 2008Valdez vs. Government Service Insurance System, 556 SCRA 580, June 30, 2008Anunciacion vs. Bocanegra, 594 SCRA 318, July 30, 2009Philippine National Bank vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 662 SCRA 424, December 14, 2011People vs. Gani, 711 SCRA 78, November 27, 2013Philippine National Bank vs. Gateway Property Holdings, Inc., 666 SCRA 251, February 15, 2012Malayang Manggagawa ng Stayfast Phils. Inc. vs. National Labor Relation Commission, 704 SCRA 24,August 28, 2013Dycoco vs. Court of Appeals, 702 SCRA 566, July 31, 2013Sampiano vs. Indar, 608 SCRA 597, December 21, 2009People vs. Veloso, 690 SCRA 586, February 13, 2013Republic vs. Domingo, 657 SCRA 621, September 14, 2011University Physician's Services, Incorporated vs. Marian Clinics, Inc., 629 SCRA 535, September 01, 2010The Baguio Regreening Movement, Inc. vs. Masweng, 692 SCRA 109, February 27, 2013People vs. Malicdem, 685 SCRA 193, November 12, 2012Office of the Ombudsman vs. Reyes, 658 SCRA 626, October 05, 2011The Law Firm of Raymundo A. Armovit vs. Court of Appeals, 658 SCRA 554, October 05, 2011Rizal Commercial Banking Corporation vs. Hilario, 681 SCRA 335, September 19, 2012People vs. Figueroa, 669 SCRA 391, April 11, 2012Cahilig vs. Terencio, 661 SCRA 261, November 28, 2011Ley Construction & Development Corporation vs. Philippine Commercial & International Bank, 621 SCRA 526, June 23, 2010People vs. Morante, 686 SCRA 602, November 28, 2012Development Bank of the Philippines vs. Traverse Development Corporation, 658 SCRA 614, October 05, 2011BP Philippines, Inc. (Formerly Burmah Castrol Philippines, Inc.) vs. Clark Trading Corporation, 681 SCRA 365, September 19, 2012Vda. de Feliciano vs. Rivera, 681 SCRA 323, September 19, 2012Astorga and Repol Law Offices vs. Roxas, 678 SCRA 374, August 15, 2012Oropesa vs. Oropesa, 671 SCRA 174, April 25, 2012Tindoy vs. People, 564 SCRA 39, September 03, 2008Gatus vs. Social Security System, 640 SCRA 553, January 26, 2011Heirs of Domingo Valientes vs. Ramas, 638 SCRA 444, December 15, 2010Tagle vs. Court of Appeals, 592 SCRA 283, July 08, 2009Go vs. Villanueva, Jr., 581 SCRA 126, March 13, 2009People vs. Gil, 569 SCRA 142, October 15, 2008RN Development Corporation vs. A.I.I. System, Inc., 555 SCRA 513, June 26, 2008Mangungutang vs. The House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal, 574 SCRA 806, December 18, 2008Bases Conversion Development Authority vs. Provincial Agrarian Officer of Pampanga, 675 SCRA 7,June 27, 2012Office of the Deputy Ombudsman for Luzon vs. Francisco, Sr., 662 SCRA 439, December 14, 2011People vs. Niegas, 711 SCRA 46, November 27, 2013Gregorio Araneta University Foundation vs. Regional Trial Court of Kalookan City, Br. 120, 580 SCRA 532, March 04, 2009Heirs of the Deceased Carmen Cruz-Zamora vs. Multiwood International, Inc., 576 SCRA 137, January 19, 2009Mariñas vs. Florendo, 578 SCRA 502, February 12, 2009People vs. Paniterce, 617 SCRA 389, April 05, 2010Philippine Charter Insurance Corporation vs. Explorer Maritime Co., Ltd., 657 SCRA 165, September 07, 2011Heirs of Rodolfo Crisostomo vs. Rudex International Development Corporation, 656 SCRA 205, August 24, 2011Guerrero vs. Domingo, 646 SCRA 175, March 23, 2011Philippine Stock Exchange, Inc. vs. Manila Banking Corporation, 559 SCRA 352, July 23, 2008

Accenture Confidential

Datu vs. People, 637 SCRA 754, December 13, 2010Air Transportation Office (ATO) vs. Court of Appeals (Nineteenth Division), 727 SCRA 196, June 25, 2014Agdeppa vs. Office of the Ombudsman, 723 SCRA 293, April 23, 2014Prieto vs. Alpadi Development Corporation, 702 SCRA 736, July 31, 2013Herminio M. De Guzman, et al. vs. Tabangao Realty, Incorporated, G.R. No. 154262, February 11, 2015BPI Securities Corporation vs. Edgardo V. Guevarra, substituted by Ofelia B. Guevarra, et al., G.R. No. 167052, March 11, 2015Solid Bank Corporation vs. Goyu & Sons, Inc., G.R. No. 142983, November 26, 2014Feliciano Duyon vs. Court of Appeals, G.R. No. 172218, November 26, 2014

Political Law

New Sun Valley Homeowners' Association, Inc. vs. Sangguniang Barangay, Barangay Sun Valley, Parañaque City, 654 SCRA 438, July 27, 2011Bedol vs. Commission on Elections, 606 SCRA 554, December 03, 2009Rimando vs. Commission on Elections, 600 SCRA 591, September 18, 2009Letter of Judge Josefina D. Farrales, Acting Presiding Judge, RTC, Br. 72, Olongapo City Re: 30 Cases and 84 Motions Submitted for Decision/Resolution in the Said Court, 575 SCRA 365, December 24, 2008Bernaldo vs. Ombudsman, 562 SCRA 60, August 13, 2008Espina & Madarang Co. vs. Indar Al Haj, 662 SCRA 380, December 14, 2011Yap vs. Commission on Audit, 619 SCRA 154, April 23, 2010Land Bank of the Philippines vs. Umandap, 635 SCRA 116, November 17, 2010Land Bank of the Philippines vs. Santiago, Jr., 682 SCRA 264, October 03, 2012Pacanan, Jr. vs. Commission on Elections, 597 SCRA 189, August 25, 2009Reyes vs. Court of Appeals, 606 SCRA 580, December 03, 2009Re: Report on Financial Audit Conducted at MCTC, Santiago-San Esteban, Ilocos Sur, 663 SCRA 117,January 17, 2012Civil Service Commission vs. Macud, 599 SCRA 52, September 10, 2009Office of the Ombudsman vs. Bernardo, 692 SCRA 557, March 06, 2013Tolentino vs. Loyola, 654 SCRA 420, July 27, 2011Office of the Court Administrator vs. Aguilar, 651 SCRA 13, June 07, 2011Panlilio vs. Commission on Elections, 593 SCRA 139, July 15, 2009Pontejos vs. Desierto, 592 SCRA 64, July 07, 2009Ramos vs. Ragot, 609 SCRA 14, December 23, 2009Marimla vs. People, 604 SCRA 57, October 16, 2009Office of the Court Administrator vs. Perello, 575 SCRA 394, December 24, 2008Heirs of Celestino Teves vs. Felicidario, 709 SCRA 315, November 13, 2013Corpuz vs. Pascua, 658 SCRA 239, September 28, 2011Magdadaro vs. Saniel, Jr., 687 SCRA 401, December 10, 2012

Neri vs. Senate Committee on Accountability of Public Officers and Investigations, 549 SCRA 77, March 25, 2008Neri vs. Senate Committee on Accountability of Public Officers and Investigations, 564 SCRA 152,September 04, 2008Boracay Foundation, Inc. vs. Province of Aklan, 674 SCRA 555, June 26, 2012Buklod nang Magbubukid sa Lupaing Ramos, Inc. vs. E.M. Ramos and Sons, Inc., 645 SCRA 401, March 16, 2011People vs. Delos Reyes, 656 SCRA 417, August 31, 2011People vs. Tuan, 628 SCRA 226, August 11, 2010Banda vs. Ermita, 618 SCRA 488, April 20, 2010Fernandez vs. House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal, 608 SCRA 733, December 21, 2009Government Service Insurance System (GSIS) vs. Commission on Audit (COA), 658 SCRA 796, October 11, 2011Soriano vs. Bravo, 638 SCRA 403, December 15, 2010Agra vs. Commission on Audit, 661 SCRA 563, December 06, 2011

Accenture Confidential

Panaligan vs. Valente, 677 SCRA 582, July 30, 2012Dela Cruz vs. Zapico, 565 SCRA 658, September 18, 2008Philippine National Oil Company vs. Maglasang, 570 SCRA 560, November 11, 2008Sesbreño vs. Gako, Jr., 570 SCRA 398, November 03, 2008Go vs. Hortaleza, 555 SCRA 406, June 26, 2008Office of the Court Adminstrator vs. Bustamante, 720 SCRA 619, April 07, 2014Addition Hills Mandaluyong Civic & Social Organization, Inc. vs. Megaworld Properties & Holdings, Inc., 670 SCRA 83, April 18, 2012Alano vs. Sahi, 727 SCRA 171, June 25, 2014Falsification of Daily Time Records of Ma. Emcisa A. Benedictos, Administrative Officer I, RTC Malolos City, Bulacan, 659 SCRA 403, October 19, 2011Leave Division, Office of Administrative Services, Office of the Court Administrator vs. Gutierrez III, 666 SCRA 29, February 15, 2012Arienda vs. Monilla, 698 SCRA 47, June 10, 2013Valdez vs. Torres, 672 SCRA 89, June 13, 2012Bulilis vs. Nuez, 655 SCRA 241, August 09, 2011Regir vs. Regir, 595 SCRA 455, August 07, 2009Mallonga vs. Manio, 586 SCRA 335, April 24, 2009Marabe vs. Tan, 586 SCRA 92, April 21, 2009Barbo vs. Commission on Audit, 568 SCRA 302, October 10, 2008Menor vs. Guillermo, 574 SCRA 395, December 18, 2008San Buenaventura vs. Migriño, 714 SCRA 367, January 22, 2014Anonymous Complaint Against Otelia Lun G. Maceda, Court Interpreter, Municipal Trial Court, Palapag, Northern Samar, 720 SCRA 27, March 26, 2014Office of the Court Administrator vs. Macusi, Jr., 705 SCRA 377, September 11, 2013Coalition of Associations of Senior Citizens in the Philippines Inc. [Senior Citizens Party-List] vs. Commission on Elections, 701 SCRA 786, July 23, 2013National Artist for Literature Virgilio Almario, et al. vs. The Executive Secretary, 701 SCRA 269, July 16, 2013Santos vs. Committee on Claims Settlement, 583 SCRA 152, April 02, 2009Quirog vs. Aumentado, 570 SCRA 582, November 11, 2008Angeles vs. Mamauag, 570 SCRA 63, October 24, 2008Francisco, Jr. vs. Desierto, 602 SCRA 50, October 02, 2009Atty. Alicia Risos-Vidal vs. Commission on Elections and Joseph Ejercito Estrada, G.R. No. 206666, January 21, 2015

Criminal Law

People vs. Balunsat, 626 SCRA 77, July 28, 2010

People vs. Camat, 677 SCRA 640, July 30, 2012People vs. Arpon, 662 SCRA 506, December 14, 2011People vs. Jastiva, 716 SCRA 125, February 12, 2014People vs. Magundayao, 667 SCRA 310, February 29, 2012People vs. Padilla, 651 SCRA 571, June 08, 2011People vs. Dominguez, Jr., 636 SCRA 134, November 24, 2010People vs. Garchitorena, 597 SCRA 420, August 28, 2009People vs. Adallom, 667 SCRA 652, March 07, 2012People vs. Abella, 610 SCRA 19, January 06, 2010Ambito vs. People, 579 SCRA 69, February 13, 2009People vs. Asis, 624 SCRA 509, July 07, 2010People vs. Banzuela, 712 SCRA 735, December 11, 2013People vs. Amansec, 662 SCRA 574, December 14, 2011

People vs. Samandre, 666 SCRA 577, February 22, 2012

Accenture Confidential

People vs. Regalario, 582 SCRA 738, March 31, 2009People vs. Buban, 603 SCRA 205, October 09, 2009People vs. Ocden, 650 SCRA 124, June 01, 2011People vs. Laurian, Jr., 712 SCRA 636, December 11, 2013People vs. Sabangan, 712 SCRA 522, December 11, 2013Ong vs. People, 661 SCRA 104, November 23, 2011People vs. Castillo, 710 SCRA 761, November 27, 2013People vs. Alcober, 709 SCRA 479, November 13, 2013People vs. Ortega, 664 SCRA 273, January 25, 2012People vs. Pepino-Consulta, 704 SCRA 276, August 28, 2013People vs. Tabarnero, 613 SCRA 492, February 24, 2010People vs. Pascual, 576 SCRA 242, January 19, 2009People vs. Amistoso, 688 SCRA 376, January 09, 2013People vs. Dela Cruz, 646 SCRA 707, March 30, 2011People vs. Dequina, 640 SCRA 111, January 19, 2011People vs. Mariano, 590 SCRA 74, June 19, 2009People vs. Cadag, 586 SCRA 580, April 24, 2009People vs. Rosas, 570 SCRA 117, October 24, 2008People vs. Vasquez, 714 SCRA 78, January 15, 2014People vs. Manjares, 661 SCRA 227, November 23, 2011People vs. Aguilar, 696 SCRA 838, April 17, 2013People vs. Cuaycong, 706 SCRA 644, October 02, 2013People vs. Ocfemia, 706 SCRA 312, September 25, 2013People vs. Diu, 695 SCRA 229, April 03, 2013People vs. Bagos, 610 SCRA 1, January 06, 2010People vs. Dion, 653 SCRA 117, July 04, 2011People vs. Miranda, 617 SCRA 298, April 05, 2010People vs. Jadap, 617 SCRA 179, March 30, 2010People vs. De Jesus, 690 SCRA 180, February 06, 2013People vs. Punzalan, Jr., 687 SCRA 687, December 10, 2012People vs. Ulat, 658 SCRA 695, October 05, 2011People vs. Brainer, 683 SCRA 505, October 10, 2012People vs. Delpino, 589 SCRA 515, June 18, 2009People vs. Asilan, 669 SCRA 405, April 11, 2012People vs. Padua, 625 SCRA 220, July 21, 2010People vs. Grande, 609 SCRA 93, December 23, 2009People vs. Daco, 568 SCRA 348, October 10, 2008People vs. Somoza, 701 SCRA 525, July 17, 2013People vs. s, 700 SCRA 23, June 26, 2013People vs. Caoili, 697 SCRA 638, June 05, 2013

People vs. Maongco, 708 SCRA 547, October 23, 2013People vs. Vilbar, 664 SCRA 749, February 01, 2012People vs. Gratil, 652 SCRA 551, June 22, 2011People vs. Sobusa, 610 SCRA 538, January 21, 2010People vs. Sarcia, 599 SCRA 20, September 10, 2009

Accenture Confidential

People vs. Quesido, 695 SCRA 572, April 10, 2013People vs. Milan, 653 SCRA 607, July 06, 2011

People vs. Lagat, 657 SCRA 713, September 14, 2011People vs. Nacua, 689 SCRA 819, January 30, 2013People vs. Dejillo, 687 SCRA 537, December 10, 2012People vs. Del Rosario, 687 SCRA 318, December 05, 2012People vs. Padigos, 687 SCRA 245, December 05, 2012People vs. Batula, 686 SCRA 575, November 28, 2012People vs. Viojela, 684 SCRA 241, October 17, 2012People vs. Baroquillo, 656 SCRA 250, August 24, 2011People vs. Osma, Jr., 679 SCRA 428, August 29, 2012People vs. Tejero, 674 SCRA 244, June 20, 2012People vs. Fontillas, 638 SCRA 721, December 15, 2010People vs. Ogarte, 649 SCRA 395, May 30, 2011Vallacar Transit, Inc. vs. Catubig, 649 SCRA 281, May 30, 2011People vs. Mendoza, 667 SCRA 357, February 29, 2012People vs. Ulama, 662 SCRA 599, December 14, 2011People vs. Magayon, 626 SCRA 58, July 28, 2010People vs. Dumalang, 696 SCRA 628, April 17, 2013People vs. Vidaña, 708 SCRA 592, October 23, 2013People vs. Enriquez, 706 SCRA 337, September 25, 2013People vs. De los Santos, Jr., 668 SCRA 784, March 21, 2012People vs. Flores, 638 SCRA 631, December 15, 2010People vs. Celocelo, 638 SCRA 576, December 15, 2010People vs. Republo, 624 SCRA 542, July 08, 2010Simbolon, Jr. vs. People, 601 SCRA 405, September 30, 2009Loguinsa, Jr. vs. Sandiganbayan (5th Division), 579 SCRA 161, February 13, 2009People vs. Lopit, 574 SCRA 372, December 17, 2008People v. Castro, 574 SCRA 244, December 17, 2008People vs. Buenaventura, 661 SCRA 216, November 23, 2011People vs. Legaspi, 661 SCRA 171, November 23, 2011People vs. Velasco, 710 SCRA 784, November 27, 2013People vs. Clarite, 666 SCRA 306, February 15, 2012People vs. Deligero, 696 SCRA 822, April 17, 2013People vs. Espera, 706 SCRA 704, October 02, 2013People vs. Alinao, 706 SCRA 116, September 18, 2013People vs. Aleman, 702 SCRA 118, July 24, 2013People vs. Candellada, 701 SCRA 19, July 10, 2013People vs. Vergara, 700 SCRA 412, July 03, 2013People vs. Resurreccion, 698 SCRA 437, June 13, 2013People vs. Pamintuan, 697 SCRA 470, June 05, 2013People vs. Bustamante, 697 SCRA 411, June 05, 2013People vs. Vitero, 695 SCRA 54, April 03, 2013People vs. Sabadlab, 663 SCRA 426, January 18, 2012

People vs. Calimon, 577 SCRA 116, January 29, 2009

Accenture Confidential

People vs. Manalao, 690 SCRA 106, February 06, 2013People vs. Alviz, 690 SCRA 61, February 06, 2013People vs. Estoya, 687 SCRA 376, December 05, 2012People vs. Bulagao, 658 SCRA 746, October 05, 2011People vs. Guru, 684 SCRA 544, October 24, 2012People vs. Laurio, 680 SCRA 560, September 13, 2012People vs. Montaner, 656 SCRA 605, August 31, 2011People vs. Lanuza, 656 SCRA 293, August 24, 2011People vs. Duca, 603 SCRA 159, October 09, 2009People vs. Calantiao, 727 SCRA 20, June 18, 2014People vs. Lapasaran, 687 SCRA 663, December 10, 2012People vs. Dulay, 687 SCRA 558, December 10, 2012People vs. Rarugal, 688 SCRA 646, January 16, 2013People vs. Mangune, 685 SCRA 578, November 14, 2012People vs. Escleto, 671 SCRA 149, April 25, 2012People vs. Marquez, 648 SCRA 694, April 13, 2011Yambot vs. Tuquero, 646 SCRA 249, March 23, 2011People vs. Magbanua, 597 SCRA 287, August 27, 2009Lopez vs. People, 555 SCRA 525, June 26, 2008David, Jr. vs. People, 562 SCRA 22, August 13, 2008Manzano, Jr. vs. Garcia, 661 SCRA 350, November 28, 2011People vs. Barra, 701 SCRA 99, July 10, 2013People vs. Hatsero, 700 SCRA 597, July 03, 2013People vs. De la Cruz, 699 SCRA 145, June 19, 2013People vs. Piosang, 697 SCRA 587, June 05, 2013People vs. Diaz, 698 SCRA 535, June 13, 2013People vs. Zapuiz, 691 SCRA 510, February 20, 2013People vs. Olaco, 659 SCRA 171, October 17, 2011People vs. Broca, 704 SCRA 369, August 28, 2013People vs. Ayochok, 629 SCRA 324, August 25, 2010People vs. Las Piñas, 730 SCRA 571, July 23, 2014People vs. Paldo, 712 SCRA 659, December 11, 2013People vs. Roxas, 725 SCRA 181, June 04, 2014People vs. Besmonte, 725 SCRA 37, June 04, 2014People vs. Paras, 724 SCRA 691, June 04, 2014People vs. Gallemit, 724 SCRA 359, June 02, 2014People vs. Dadao, 714 SCRA 524, January 22, 2014People vs. Pareja, 714 SCRA 131, January 15, 2014People vs. Aquino, 714 SCRA 107, January 15, 2014People vs. Vergara, 714 SCRA 64, January 15, 2014People vs. Delen, 722 SCRA 334, April 21, 2014People vs. Abat, 720 SCRA 557, April 02, 2014People vs. Burce, 720 SCRA 212, March 26, 2014People vs. Constantino, Jr., 719 SCRA 177, March 12, 2014People vs. Gahi, 717 SCRA 209, February 19, 2014

Accenture Confidential

People vs. Castillo, 717 SCRA 113, February 19, 2014People vs. Morate, 715 SCRA 115, January 29, 2014People vs. Linsie, 711 SCRA 124, November 27, 2013People vs. Villacorta, 657 SCRA 270, September 07, 2011People vs. Bayrante, 672 SCRA 446, June 13, 2012People vs. Galvez, 641 SCRA 472, February 02, 2011People vs. Ochoa, 656 SCRA 382, August 31, 2011People vs. Bernabe, 604 SCRA 216, October 16, 2009People of the Philippines vs. Carlos Estonillo Sr. G.R. No. 201565 , October 13, 2014People of the Philippines vs. Leonardo Cataytay y Silvano, G. R. No. 196315, October 22, 2014People of the Philippines vs. Democrito Paras, G.R. No. 192912 , October 22, 2014

Commercial Law

Philippine Trust Company vs. Court of Appeals, 635 SCRA 518, November 22, 2010Philippines National Bank vs. Hydro Resources Contractors Corporation, 693 SCRA 294, March 13, 2013South Cotobato Communications Corporation vs. Sto. Tomas, 638 SCRA 566, December 15, 2010Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited-Philippine Branches vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 724 SCRA 499, June 04, 2014Liban vs. Gordon, 639 SCRA 709, January 18, 2011Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company vs. Wilfred Chiok, G.R. No. 172652, November 26, 2014Nestor Ching vs. Subic Bay Gold and Country Club, Inc., G.R. No. 174353, September 10, 2014

Taxation

Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Manila Bankers' Life Insurance Corporation, 645 SCRA 500,March 16, 2011

Fort Bonifacio Development Corporation vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 602 SCRA 159, October 02, 2009Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Hambrecht & Quist Philippines, Inc., 635 SCRA 162, November 17, 2010Silicon Philippines, Inc. (formerly Intel Philippines Manufacturing, Inc.) vs. Commission of Internal Revenue, G.R. No. 173241, March 25, 2015Fort Bonifacio Development Corporation vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, G.R. No. 175707, November 19, 2014City of Manila vs. Hon. Angel Valera Colet, G.R. No. 120051, December 10, 2014

Legal Ethics

Agno vs. Cagatan, 558 SCRA 1, July 14, 2008PHILASIA Shipping Agency Corporation vs. Tomacruz, 678 SCRA 503, August 15, 2012Valencia vs. Antiniw, 556 SCRA 503, June 30, 2008

Bank of the Philippine Island vs. BPI Employees Union-Davao Chapter-Federation of Union in BPI UniBank,627 SCRA 590, August 10, 2010Boy Scouts of the Philippines vs. Commission on Audit, 651 SCRA 146, June 07, 2011Dee Ping Wee vs. Lee Hiong Wee, 629 SCRA 145, August 25, 2010

San Roque Power Corporation vs. Commissioner of Internal Reveue, 727 SCRA 565, June 30, 2014Silkair (Singapore) PTE., Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 613 SCRA 638, February 25, 2010

Jaka Investments Corporation vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 626 SCRA 17, July 28, 2010Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Bank of Commerce, 709 SCRA 390, November 13, 2013

Re: Letter of the UP Law Faculty Entitled "Restoring Integrity: A Statement by the Faculty of the UP College of Law on the Allegations of Plagiarism and Misrepresentation in the Supreme Court, 644 SCRA 543, March 08, 2011Laurel vs. Francisco, 624 SCRA 1, July 06, 2010Re: Judicial Audit Conducted in the RTC, Br. 14, Davao City, Presided Over by Judge William M. Layague,552 SCRA 1, April 18, 2008Barillo vs. Lantion, 615 SCRA 39, March 10, 2010Uy vs. Javellana, 680 SCRA 13, September 05, 2012

Accenture Confidential

Bank of America NT & SA vs. Philippine Racing Club, 594 SCRA 301, July 30, 2009Wong vs. Moya II, 569 SCRA 256, October 17, 2008Marquez vs. Pacariem, 568 SCRA 77, October 08, 2008Re: Request of Thelma J. Chiong for Investigation of the Alleged "Justice for Sale" in CA-Cebu, 546 SCRA 387, February 22, 2008Heirs of Late Rev. Fr. Jose O. Aspiras vs. Ganay, 608 SCRA 379, December 17, 2009Abanado vs. Bayona, 677 SCRA 595, July 30, 2012Memoranda of Judge Eliza B. Yu Issued to Legal Researcher Mariejoy P. Lagman and to Court Stenographer Soledad J. Bassig, all of Metropolitan Trial Court, Branch 47, Pasay City, 678 SCRA 386,August 15, 2012Hipe vs. Literato, 671 SCRA 9, April 25, 2012Re: Letter of the UP Law Faculty Entitled Restoring Integrity: A Statement by the Faculty of the University of the Philippines College of Law on the Allegations of Plagiarism and Misrepresentation in the Supreme Court, 651 SCRA 1, June 07, 2011Amante-Descallar vs. Ramas, 638 SCRA 358, December 15, 2010Aranda vs. Elayda, 638 SCRA 336, December 15, 2010Bernas vs. Reyes, 625 SCRA 190, July 21, 2010Talento vs. Paneda, 609 SCRA 1, December 23, 2009Inonog vs. Ibay, 594 SCRA 168, July 28, 2009Wilkie vs. Limos, 570 SCRA 1, October 24, 2008Re: Cases Submitted for Decision before Hon. Teofilo D. Baluma, Former Judge, Branch 1, Regional Trial Court, Tagbilaran City, Bohol., 704 SCRA 415, September 02, 2013Senarlo vs. Paderanga, 617 SCRA 247, April 05, 2010Duque vs. Garrido, 580 SCRA 321, February 27, 2009Winternitz vs. Guiterrez-Torres, 580 SCRA 166, February 24, 2009Re: Cases Submitted for Decision before Hon. Teresito A. Andoy, former Judges, Manufacturing Trial Court, Cainta, Rizal, 620 SCRA 298, May 06, 2010Fuentes vs. Buno, 560 SCRA 22, July 28, 2008Bernardo, Jr. vs. Montojo, 634 SCRA 1, October 20, 2010Anres vs. Majaducon, 574 SCRA 169, December 17, 2008Office of the Court Administrator vs. Indar, 714 SCRA 381, January 22, 2014Bayaca vs. Ramos, 577 SCRA 93, January 29, 2009Florencio Saldaga vs Atty. Arturo Astorga, A.C. No. 4697, November 25, 2014

Accenture Confidential

Year Subject Leonardo-De Castro: Tally of Cases per Bar Subject2014 Labor Labor Law 212011 Labor Political Law 632010 Labor Civil Law 592014 Labor Taxation 102013 Labor Criminal Law 1612010 Labor Commercial Law 102009 Labor Remedial Law 1032012 Labor Legal Ethics 342010 Labor Total: 4612009 Labor2012 Labor2008 Labor2009 Labor2011 Labor2011 Labor2011 Labor2012 Labor2011 Labor2009 Labor2010 Labor2008 Labor

2010 Civil2011 Civil2011 Civil2010 Civil2013 Civil2011 Civil2011 Civil2010 Civil2010 Civil2011 Civil2009 Civil2012 Civil2012 Civil2011 Civil2011 Civil2011 Civil2009 Civil2010 Civil2010 Civil2012 Civil2012 Civil

Accenture Confidential

2010 Civil2010 Civil2011 Civil2011 Civil2011 Civil2012 Civil2012 Civil2010 Civil2008 Civil2009 Civil2011 Civil2013 Civil2012 Civil2012 Civil2008 Civil2008 Civil2009 Civil2012 Civil2012 Civil2009 Civil2012 Civil2011 Civil2012 Civil2009 Civil2008 Civil2008 Civil2008 Civil2012 Civil2013 Civil2012 Civil2010 Civil2014 Civil2012 Civil2009 Civil2015 Civil2015 Civil2015 Civil2014 Civil

2010 Remedial2012 Remedial2011 Remedial2013 Remedial2009 Remedial

Accenture Confidential

2013 Remedial2010 Remedial2010 Remedial2010 Remedial2011 Remedial2011 Remedial2012 Remedial2013 Remedial2011 Remedial2011 Remedial2011 Remedial2010 Remedial2010 Remedial2009 Remedial2011 Remedial2013 Remedial2010 Remedial2013 Remedial2010 Remedial2010 Remedial2011 Remedial2012 Remedial2011 Remedial2009 Remedial2013 Remedial2010 Remedial2011 Remedial2011 Remedial2012 Remedial2012 Remedial2011 Remedial, 201 Remedial2008 Remedial2013 Remedial2008 Remedial2010 Remedial2009 Remedial2011 Remedial2011 Remedial2014 Remedial2012 Remedial2013 Remedial2013 Remedial2008 Remedial2010 Remedial

Accenture Confidential

2008 Remedial2008 Remedial2009 Remedial2011 Remedial2013 Remedial2012 Remedial2013 Remedial2013 Remedial2009 Remedial2013 Remedial2011 Remedial2010 Remedial2013 Remedial2012 Remedial2011 Remedial2011 Remedial2012 Remedial2012 Remedial2011 Remedial2010 Remedial2012 Remedial2011 Remedial2012 Remedial2012 Remedial2012 Remedial2012 Remedial2008 Remedial2011 Remedial2010 Remedial2009 Remedial2009 Remedial2008 Remedial2008 Remedial2008 Remedial2012 Remedial2011 Remedial2013 Remedial2009 Remedial2009 Remedial2009 Remedial2010 Remedial2011 Remedial2011 Remedial2011 Remedial2008 Remedial

Accenture Confidential

2010 Remedial2014 Remedial2014 Remedial2013 Remedial2015 Remedial2015 Remedial2014 Remedial2014 Remedial

2008 Political2008 Political2012 Political2011 Political2011 Political2010 Political2010 Political2009 Political2011 Political2010 Political2011 Political2011 Political2009 Political2009 Political2008 Political2008 Political2011 Political2010 Political2010 Political2012 Political2009 Political2009 Political2012 Political2009 Political2013 Political2011 Political2011 Political2009 Political2009 Political2009 Political2009 Political2008 Political2013 Political2011 Political2012 Political

Accenture Confidential

2012 Political2008 Political2008 Political2008 Political2008 Political2014 Political2012 Political2014 Political2011 Political2012 Political2013 Political2012 Political2011 Political2009 Political2009 Political2009 Political2008 Political2008 Political2014 Political2014 Political2013 Political2013 Political2013 Political2009 Political2008 Political2008 Political2009 Political2015 Political

2012 Criminal2011 Criminal2014 Criminal2012 Criminal2011 Criminal2010 Criminal2009 Criminal2012 Criminal2010 Criminal2009 Criminal2010 Criminal2013 Criminal2011 Criminal2010 Criminal2012 Criminal

Accenture Confidential

2013 Criminal2012 Criminal2011 Criminal2010 Criminal2009 Criminal2009 Criminal2009 Criminal2011 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2011 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2012 Criminal2013 Criminal2010 Criminal2009 Criminal2013 Criminal2011 Criminal2011 Criminal2009 Criminal2009 Criminal2008 Criminal2014 Criminal2011 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2010 Criminal2011 Criminal2010 Criminal2010 Criminal2013 Criminal2012 Criminal2011 Criminal2012 Criminal2009 Criminal2012 Criminal2010 Criminal2009 Criminal2008 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal

Accenture Confidential

2013 Criminal2011 Criminal2009 Criminal2011 Criminal2013 Criminal2012 Criminal2012 Criminal2012 Criminal2012 Criminal2012 Criminal2011 Criminal2012 Criminal2012 Criminal2010 Criminal2011 Criminal2011 Criminal2012 Criminal2011 Criminal2010 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2012 Criminal2010 Criminal2010 Criminal2010 Criminal2009 Criminal2009 Criminal2008 Criminal2008 Criminal2011 Criminal2011 Criminal2013 Criminal2012 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2012 Criminal

Accenture Confidential

2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2012 Criminal2011 Criminal2012 Criminal2012 Criminal2011 Criminal2011 Criminal2009 Criminal2014 Criminal2012 Criminal2012 Criminal2013 Criminal2012 Criminal2012 Criminal2011 Criminal2011 Criminal2009 Criminal2008 Criminal2008 Criminal2011 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2013 Criminal2011 Criminal2013 Criminal2010 Criminal2014 Criminal2013 Criminal2014 Criminal2014 Criminal2014 Criminal2014 Criminal2014 Criminal2014 Criminal2014 Criminal2014 Criminal2014 Criminal2014 Criminal2014 Criminal2014 Criminal2014 Criminal

Accenture Confidential

2014 Criminal2014 Criminal2013 Criminal2011 Criminal2012 Criminal2011 Criminal2011 Criminal2009 Criminal2014 Criminal2014 Criminal2014 Criminal

2010 Commercial2011 Commercial2010 Commercial2010 Commercial2013 Commercial2010 Commercial2014 Commercial2011 Commercial2014 Commercial2014 Commercial

2014 Taxation2010 Taxation2011 Taxation2010 Taxation2013 Taxation2009 Taxation2010 Taxation2015 Taxation2014 Taxation2014 Taxation

2011 Ethics2010 Ethics2008 Ethics2010 Ethics2012 Ethics2008 Ethics2012 Ethics2008 Ethics

Accenture Confidential

2009 Ethics2008 Ethics2008 Ethics2008 Ethics2009 Ethics2012 Ethics2012 Ethics2012 Ethics2011 Ethics2010 Ethics2010 Ethics2010 Ethics2009 Ethics2009 Ethics2008 Ethics2013 Ethics2010 Ethics2009 Ethics2009 Ethics2010 Ethics2008 Ethics2010 Ethics2008 Ethics2014 Ethics2009 Ethics2014 Ethics