82
BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA Joint Status Report of Southern California Edison Company (U 338-E) and San Diego Gas & Electric Company (U 902-E) For the 2018 Nuclear Decommissioning Cost Triennial Proceeding. ) ) ) ) ) A.18-03-009 (Filed March 15, 2018) JOINT STATUS REPORT WALKER A. MATTHEWS III ELIZABETH C. BROWN Attorneys for SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY 2244 Walnut Grove Avenue Post Office Box 800 Rosemead, California 91770 Telephone: (626) 302-6879 E-mail: [email protected] Dated: April 30, 2019

BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

Joint Status Report of Southern California Edison Company (U 338-E) and San Diego Gas & Electric Company (U 902-E) For the 2018 Nuclear Decommissioning Cost Triennial Proceeding.

) ) ) ))

A.18-03-009 (Filed March 15, 2018)

JOINT STATUS REPORT

WALKER A. MATTHEWS III ELIZABETH C. BROWN Attorneys for SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY 2244 Walnut Grove Avenue Post Office Box 800 Rosemead, California 91770 Telephone: (626) 302-6879 E-mail: [email protected]

Dated: April 30, 2019

Page 2: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

1

BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

Joint Status Report of Southern California Edison Company (U 338-E) and San Diego Gas & Electric Company (U 902-E) For the 2018 Nuclear Decommissioning Cost Triennial Proceeding.

)) ) ) )

A.18-03-009 (Filed March 15, 2018)

JOINT STATUS REPORT

Pursuant to the Decision on Phases 2 and 3 of Southern California Edison Company

(U338E) and San Diego Gas & Electric Company (U902-E) 2015 Nuclear Decommissioning

Cost Triennial Proceeding and Related Proceeding (Decision (D.) 18-11-034) (dated

December 7, 2018), and Second Ruling of Assigned Administrative Law Judge Modifying Phase

2 Proceeding Schedule (dated February 6, 2019) (Second Ruling), Southern California Edison (U

338-E) (SCE), San Diego Gas & Electric Company (U 902-E) (SDG&E), the Public Advocates

Office (Cal PA), The Utility Reform Network (TURN), and Alliance for Nuclear Responsibility

(A4NR), respectfully submit this Joint Status Report (Status Report).

I.

INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND

Decision (D.) 18-11-034 directed SCE and SDG&E (collectively referred to as the

“Utilities”) to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to discuss the following

three issues and to report back on the outcome of those discussions in the 2018 Nuclear

Decommissioning Costs Triennial Proceeding (NDCTP):1

1 D.18-11-034, OP 4-6.

Page 3: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

2

1. Advice Letter Reporting Requirements – Ordering Paragraph (OP) 4 directed

SCE and SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to

“discuss what if any modification will be needed for the annual Tier 2 Advice

Letter process . . . consistent with the adoption of the Milestone Framework.”2

2. Distributed/Undistributed Cost Categorization – OP 5 directed SCE and

SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop

protocols and guidance for recording staff time designated to Distributed activities

and to define what activities will be considered Undistributed and Distributed

activities.”3

3. Comparison of DCEs for Transparency – OP 6 directed SCE and SDG&E to

meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “address how SCE

will meet the requirement to provide transparency as to costs authorized in prior

DCEs with those proposed in future DCEs (including application (A.) 18-03-

009.”4

This Status Report constitutes the “joint report” required by D.18-11-034 and the Second

Ruling to report back on the outcome of workshop discussions. Specifically, Decision 18-11-

034, OP 4 provided that a report regarding any modifications to the advice letter reporting

requirement should be submitted no later than April 30, 2019, but Ordering Paragraphs 5-6

provided that the reports on cost-categorization and DCE comparison issues should be submitted

consistent with the schedule adopted for the 2018 NDCTP. The Second Ruling (issued in the

2018 NDCTP) set May 3, 2019 as the due date for a report on the matters addressed in the

workshops, and required the parties to submit a proposed Phase 3 procedural schedule for

testimony and evidentiary hearings on unresolved issues. In the interest of judicial economy,

the parties are submitting one report by the April 30, 2019 deadline to fulfill these requirements.

2 D.18-11-034, Ordering Paragraph 4, p. 79. 3 D.18-11-034, Ordering Paragraph 5, p. 80. 4 D.18-11-034, Ordering Paragraph 6, p. 80.

Page 4: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

3

II.

SUMMARY OF WORKSHOPS

The Utilities met and conferred with representatives from Energy Division, the Public

Advocates Office (Cal PA), The Utility Reform Network (TURN), Alliance for Nuclear

Responsibility (A4NR), and Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) in a series of three workshops held

January-March, 2019. The content of each workshop presentations5 and resolutions reached are

discussed below.

A. Workshop #1

On January 31, 2019, the following representatives attended the first workshop:

NAME PARTY Walker Matthews SCE Elizabeth Brown SCE Jose Perez SCE Randy Besich SCE Allen Trial SDG&E Wendy Johnson SDG&E Sue Garcia SDG&E Tracy Dalu SDG&E Truman Burns Cal PA John Geesman A4NR Bruce Lacy TURN Laura Krannawitter Energy Division Darcie L. Houck Admin. Law Judge Lindsey How-Downing PG&E Brian Ketelsen PG&E Nathan Wahl PG&E

SCE gave presentations covering each of the three workshop issues – advice letter

reporting requirements, cost categorization, DCE comparisons – including the requirements of

D.18-11-034 and the Utilities’ current practices on each issue. Copies of the three presentations

are included in Attachment A to this Status Report. The Utilities solicited input from workshop

5 This report attaches non-confidential verson of the presentations made during the workshops. Confidential versions were made available to parties who have executed non-disclosure agreements.

Page 5: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

4

attendees, and there was active discussion on the three issues. But no final resolution was

reached during the workshop.

B. Workshop #2

On February 28, 2019, the following representatives attended the second workshop:

NAME PARTY Walker Matthews SCE Elizabeth Brown SCE Jose Perez SCE Randy Besich SCE Allen Trial SDG&E Wendy Johnson SDG&E Sue Garcia SDG&E Tracy Dalu SDG&E Truman Burns Cal PA Matthew Freedman TURN Bruce Lacy TURN Laura Krannawitter Energy Division Darcie L. Houck Admin. Law Judge Lindsey How-Downing PG&E Brian Ketelsen PG&E Nathan Wahl PG&E

SCE’s presentation at the second workshop recapped the parties’ discussions in the first

workshop. A copy of the presentation is included in Attachment B to this Status Report. During

the second workshop, the parties agreed on proposed modifications to the advice letter reporting

requirements and DCE comparison issues. The substance of those agreements is discussed in

Section III below.

C. Workshop #3

On March 14, 2019, the following representatives attended the third workshop:

NAME PARTY Walker Matthews SCE Elizabeth Brown SCE Jose Perez SCE Randy Besich SCE Allen Trial SDG&E Wendy Johnson SDG&E

Page 6: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

5

NAME PARTY Sue Garcia SDG&E Tracy Dalu SDG&E Truman Burns Cal PA Matthew Freedman TURN Bruce Lacy TURN John Geesman A4NR Laura Krannawitter Energy Division Darcie L. Houck Admin. Law Judge Lindsey How-Downing PG&E Brian Ketelsen PG&E

SCE’s presentation at the third workshop summarized the parties’ discussions on the

Distributed/Undistributed cost-categorization issue from the first two workshops. The

presentation reiterated the Commission’s original direction regarding the objective of the

workshop, and summarized SCE’s proposal to comply with that direction and address issues

raised by TURN regarding the cost categorization issue. A copy of the presentation is included

in Attachment C to this Status Report. The parties did not reach agreement on the cost-

categorization issue during the workshops but are continuing to discuss a potential resolution in

subsequent meetings. If no agreement is reached, the parties will submit their respective

recommendations on the issue in testimony submitted in Phase 3 of this proceeding.

III.

SUMMARY OF AGREEMENTS REACHED OR POSITIONS TAKEN

A. Advice Letter Reporting Requirements

The parties agreed to the following modifications to the annual Tier 2 Advice Letter

content reporting requirements:

1. Include “percent expended” on the detailed cost comparison attachment. The

Utilities agreed with Energy Division’s and interested parties’ suggestion that the

Utilities include a to-date “percent expended” for each project line item included

Page 7: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

6

in advice letter reports. The number will generally be calculated as the recorded

costs to date divided by the total forecasted costs in the DCE.6

2. Include the Trust Fund balances. The Utilities also agreed with Energy Division’s

and other interested parties’ recommendation that the Utilities include updates

regarding their respective SONGS 2&3 nuclear decommissioning trust (NDTs)

fund balances. The balance reported will be the liquidation value at the most

recently available date.

3. Provide greater discussion of the status of critical path items from the Milestone

Framework. The Utilities also agreed with TURN’s suggestion that the Utilities

provide additional detail regarding the status of critical path items for

decommissioning.

SCE and SDG&E included these modifications in their advice letters, SCE AL 3988-E

and SDG&E AL 3368-E, submitted on April 15, 2019 and April 25, 2019, respectively. The

Utilities will provide a similar level of information in their annual advice letters going forward.

B. DCE Comparison

The parties acknowledged the challenges presented when trying to compare the 2012

DCE to the 2017 DCE and explain variances between them, given various differences between

the DCEs in content and format. Indeed, this challenge was observed in the A.14-12-007 (2014

DCE Proceeding), which involved a comparison of the 2012 and 2014 DCEs. To achieve a

meaningful comparison of the 2012 and 2017 DCE in the 2018 NDCTP, the parties agreed that

SCE must make various assumptions on how to map 2012 DCE activities to 2017 DCE

activities. Based on SCE’s proposal and discussions in the first two workshops, the parties

agreed to the following process for comparing DCEs in the 2018 NDCTP:

6 The recorded costs numerator in SCE’s Spring advice letter will include recorded costs up to the end of the prior year. Because a full year of recorded costs will not be available for the Fall advice letter the recorded costs numerator will include a combination of recorded costs plus forecasted costs.

Page 8: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

7

1. SCE will prepare an appendix table that compares the 2012 and 2014 DCEs to the

2017 DCE.

2. The 2017 DCE generally will be compared to the 2014 DCE at the line-item level

as both DCE contain the same format and DCE line item numbering conventions.

3. The comparison of the 2012 DCE to the 2017 DCE, however, will not necessarily

be a line-item to line-item comparison. Instead, the comparison generally will be

provided as a project-to-project comparison, based on SCE’s assessment of how

to map 2012 DCE activities to 2017 DCE activities. (Attachment B, Slide 6 of

the February 28th workshop presentation provides an illustrative example of the

DCE comparison the Utilities will be able to provide.)

4. SCE will also move the Service Level Agreement costs into one line item for

comparison of the DCEs.

C. Distributed/Undistributed Cost Categorization

The parties were unable to reach agreement on the Distributed/Undistributed cost

categorization issue during the workshops. TURN asserts that forecasted and recorded costs

currently classified as undistributed should be subjected to better tracking, benchmarking, review

and reconciliation. In addition, TURN continues to explore options for allocating utility staff,

contracted services, core contractors, DGC staff and other undistributed labor to Distributed

projects.

The Utilities counter that any attempt to allocate additional utility staff costs to

Distributed projects will create false variances that will make any comparison of forecasted costs

to recorded costs substantially more difficult and less efficient.

The parties will continue to discuss a possible resolution. If no agreement is reached, the

parties will submit their recommendations as to how to proceed on this issue in testimony to be

submitted in Phase 3 of this proceeding.

Page 9: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

8

Because the results of the parties’ discussions could impact the scope and timing of the

issues to be addressed in Phase 3, the parties respectfully propose that the Commission allow the

parties to submit a supplemental report on the outcome of these discussions and propose a Phase

3 schedule no later than May 30, 2019.

IV.

CONCLUSION

The Commission should adopt the agreements reached by the parties with respect to the

annual Tier 2 advice letter reporting requirements and DCE comparisons.

Date: April 30, 2019 Respectfully submitted,

WALKER A. MATTHEWS III ELIZABETH C. BROWN /s/ Walker A. Matthews By: Walker A. Matthews III7

Attorneys for SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY

2244 Walnut Grove Avenue Post Office Box 800 Rosemead, California 91770 Telephone: (626) 302-6879 E-mail: [email protected]

7 Pursuant to Rule 1.8(d) of the Commission’s Rules of Practice and Procedure, I certify that I am authorized by the following parties to sign and tender this document on their behalf: SDG&E, Cal PA, TURN, and A4NR.

Page 10: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

Attachment A

Page 11: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

Cos

t C

ateg

oriz

atio

n

Janu

ary

31, 2

019

A-1

Page 12: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

2

Out

line

•P

urpo

se o

f the

Wor

ksho

p

•W

hat a

re U

ndis

tribu

ted

Cos

ts?

•In

dust

ry P

ract

ice

•M

ilest

one

Fram

ewor

k A

gree

men

t•

SC

E’s

Cha

rgin

g P

ract

ice

for U

tility

Sta

ff

•C

ost C

ateg

oriz

atio

n

•C

oncl

usio

n

A-2

Page 13: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

3

Purp

ose

of W

orks

hop

•20

15 N

DC

TP D

ecis

ion

18-1

1-03

4 st

ated

…[U

tiliti

es]

shal

l mee

t with

Ene

rgy

Divi

sion

sta

ff an

d in

tere

sted

pa

rties

to

deve

lop

prot

ocol

s an

d gu

idan

ce fo

r re

cord

ing

staf

f tim

e de

sign

ated

to D

istri

bute

d ac

tiviti

es,

and

to d

efin

e w

hat a

ctivi

ties

will

be

cons

ider

ed U

ndis

tribu

ted

and

Dis

tribu

ted

activ

ities

.

•W

orks

hops

hel

d to

dev

elop

the

Mile

ston

e Fr

amew

ork

prov

ided

muc

h ba

ckgr

ound

on

this

to

pic

A-3

Page 14: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

4

Wha

t are

Und

istr

ibut

ed

Cos

ts?

•Ty

pica

lly ti

me-

depe

nden

t cos

ts in

curr

ed th

roug

hout

the

dura

tion

of th

e pr

ojec

t (e

.g.,

Util

ity L

abor

and

Sec

urity

For

ce)

•R

ecur

ring

and

unav

oida

ble

expe

nses

, sim

ilar t

o th

ose

incu

rred

dur

ing

plan

t op

erat

ion,

to c

ompl

y w

ith re

gula

tory

and

con

tract

ual r

equi

rem

ents

Una

ssig

nabl

e to

spe

cific

dis

tribu

ted

activ

ities

(i.e

., th

e ph

ysic

al w

ork

to

deco

mm

issi

on th

e pl

ant)

•In

clud

es c

osts

requ

ired

to m

aint

ain

the

plan

t whe

ther

act

ive d

ecom

mis

sion

ing

is

ongo

ing

or n

ot

–Pl

ant s

ecur

ity a

nd o

pera

tions

sta

ffing

–Le

ase

and

ease

men

t pa

ymen

ts–

NRC

fee

s–

Insu

ranc

e–

Envir

onm

enta

l Fe

es a

nd P

erm

its–

Seve

ranc

e

A-4

Page 15: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

5

Indu

stry

Pra

ctic

e

•Pr

evio

us S

ON

GS

2&3

DC

Es, w

hich

wer

e pr

epar

ed b

y AB

Z, d

id

not i

nclu

de U

tility

St

affin

g in

the

dire

ct

activ

ity c

osts

.

Dis

tribu

ted

Cos

ts

Undi

strib

uted

C

osts

AB

Z SO

NGS

2012

DC

E :

A-5

Page 16: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

6

Indu

stry

Pra

ctic

e•

Trea

tmen

t of

keep

ing

Util

ity

Sta

ffing

cos

ts

sepa

rate

from

D

ecom

mis

sion

ing

activ

ity c

osts

(i.e

., no

t inc

lude

d in

the

phys

ical

wor

k to

de

com

mis

sion

pl

ant)

is c

onsi

sten

t w

ith D

iabl

o C

anyo

n an

d P

alo

Verd

e’s

DC

Es,

whi

ch w

ere

prep

ared

by

TLG

S

ervic

es.

2016

Dia

blo

Can

yon

DC

E:20

16 P

alo

Verd

e D

CE:

2016

Dia

blo

Can

yon

DC

E:

6

2016

Pal

o Ve

rde

DC

E:

A-6

Page 17: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

7

Mile

ston

e Fr

amew

ork

Agre

emen

t•

Fram

ewor

k w

as n

egot

iate

d be

twee

n th

e U

tiliti

es a

nd th

e in

tere

sted

pa

rties

dur

ing

a se

ries

of w

orks

hops

and

mee

tings

•R

ecog

nize

d th

at d

istri

bute

d an

d un

dist

ribut

ed a

ctiv

ities

are

diff

eren

t–

Dis

cuss

ed m

any

diffe

rent

opt

ions

for t

reat

men

t of u

ndis

tribu

ted

cost

s in

clud

ing

allo

catio

ns to

dis

tribu

ted

proj

ects

–Ag

reem

ent s

ettle

d on

usi

ng a

“che

ck p

oint

” app

roac

h to

mak

e su

re u

ndis

tribu

ted

cost

s (in

clud

ing

Utili

ty a

nd D

GC

Sta

ffing

) wer

e tie

d to

pro

ject

per

form

ance

Purp

ose

of a

gree

ing

to c

heck

poin

ts w

as to

avo

id u

nnec

essa

ry a

lloca

tions

•“U

ndis

trib

uted

Act

ivity

cos

ts a

re n

ot d

irec

tly re

late

d or

cha

rgea

ble

to a

par

ticul

ar D

istr

ibut

ed A

ctiv

ity, b

ut m

ay b

e in

fluen

ced

by th

e tim

ing

of ‘c

heck

poin

ts.’”

(1)

•U

tility

Sta

ffing

cos

ts w

ere

cons

ider

ed u

ndis

tribu

ted

cost

s in

the

Fram

ewor

kNo

te:

(1) C

omm

issi

on-a

ppro

ved

Mile

ston

e Fr

amew

ork

A-7

Page 18: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

8

Mile

ston

e Fr

amew

ork

Agre

emen

t•

Atta

chm

ent A

incl

uded

in th

e Fr

amew

ork

pres

ents

the

estim

ated

cos

ts b

y N

DC

TP

•U

ndis

tribu

ted

cost

s w

ere

estim

ated

usi

ng th

e 20

14 D

CE

A-8

Page 19: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

9

Mile

ston

e Fr

amew

ork

Agre

emen

t•

For e

xam

ple,

$27

0M in

est

imat

ed U

ndis

tribu

ted

Cos

ts th

at w

ere

sche

dule

d to

be

revie

wed

in

the

2018

ND

CTP

incl

ude

Utilit

y St

aff a

nd D

GC

Sta

ff co

sts

A-9

Page 20: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

10

Util

ity S

taff

•U

ndis

tribu

ted

Util

ity

Staf

fing

cost

s ar

e m

ade

up o

f m

ultip

le

divi

sion

s

Note

:(1

) Tab

le 1

0 is

from

the

SO

NG

S 2

&3

2017

DC

E

A-1

0

Page 21: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

11

Cos

t Est

imat

ing

and

Rec

ordi

ng P

ract

ices

Pers

onne

l Stru

ctur

e

ISFS

IAg

ing

Mng

t.

Mes

a

Pro

ject

Sta

ff(D

istri

bute

d)U

ndis

tribu

ted

Util

ity S

taff

Sec

urity

Ove

rsig

ht

A-1

1

Page 22: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

12

Util

ity S

taff

TUR

N’s

reco

mm

enda

tion

in th

e 20

15 N

DC

TP r

ecog

nize

d th

at s

ome

SON

GS

divi

sion

s, w

ithin

the

Util

ity S

taff

cate

gory

, do

not

dire

ctly

sup

port

dist

ribut

ed w

ork

–TU

RN

’s 2

018

ND

CTP

test

imon

y re

affir

ms

this

pos

ition

•TU

RN

exc

lude

d th

ese

divi

sion

s fro

m th

eir r

ecom

men

datio

n–

VP/S

ite M

anag

emen

t –

Nuc

lear

Reg

ulat

ory

Ove

rsig

ht–

Sec

urity

•TU

RN

sug

gest

ed a

lloca

ting

50%

of t

he re

mai

ning

cos

ts to

m

ajor

pro

ject

s

A-1

2

Page 23: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

13

Util

ity S

taff

•S

CE

’s p

ositio

n is

that

rem

aini

ng o

rgan

izat

ions

do

not d

irect

ly s

uppo

rt a

spec

ific m

ajor

pro

ject

(e.g

.)–

Dec

omm

issi

onin

g Fi

nanc

e

–Pl

ant M

anag

emen

t

•S

CE

doe

s no

t bel

ieve

tha

t 50%

of u

ndis

tribu

ted

staf

f cos

ts a

re c

lear

ly a

ttrib

utab

le t

o a

spec

ific

maj

or p

roje

ct•

Utili

ty S

taff

is p

erfo

rmin

g ov

ersi

ght

A-1

3

Page 24: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

14

Hyp

othe

tical

Exa

mpl

e•

Ass

ume

Dec

omm

issi

onin

g O

vers

ight

st

affin

g sh

ould

be

allo

cate

d to

maj

or

proj

ects

(i.e

., TU

RN

’s p

ositi

on)

•Fo

r exa

mpl

e, in

201

7 D

CE

Per

iod

4 (D

&D

/Dry

Sto

rage

):–

Dec

omm

issi

onin

g O

vers

ight

Sta

ffing

of $

128M

(a

ppro

x. $

13M

per

yea

r)

–To

tal d

istri

bute

d w

ork

durin

g th

e pe

riod

was

$1

,189

M

–TU

RN

assu

mes

50%

of s

elec

ted

Utilit

y S

taff

cost

s ca

n be

attr

ibut

able

to m

ajor

pro

ject

s

–Th

is w

ould

onl

y im

pact

the

maj

or p

roje

ct c

osts

by,

at

mos

t, ~5

% ([

$128

M*

50%

] / $

1,18

9M)

A-1

4

Page 25: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

15

SCE’

s C

harg

ing

Prac

tice

For U

tility

Sta

ff•

SC

E h

as re

spon

ded

to n

umer

ous

itera

tions

of t

his

data

requ

est o

ver

the

last

two

ND

CTP

s (1

6-03

-004

and

18-0

3-00

9)

•S

CE

’s c

harg

ing

prac

tice

–“C

harg

e W

here

You

Wor

k”

–C

onsi

sten

t with

the

way

DC

Es fo

reca

st c

osts

, inc

ludi

ng

the

2012

, 201

4 an

d 20

17 D

CEs

A-1

5

Page 26: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

16

SCE’

s C

harg

ing

Prac

tice

For U

tility

Sta

ff

1

No

Yes

Yes

No

A-1

6

Page 27: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

17

Cos

t Cat

egor

izat

ion

•D

.18-

11-0

34 c

onta

ins

spec

ific

requ

irem

ents

:–

“The

revi

sed

cost

cat

egor

izat

ion

stru

ctur

e m

ust s

et fo

rth h

ow c

osts

will

be re

cord

ed in

the

futu

re,

in a

man

ner t

hat c

an e

ffici

ently

com

pare

to fo

reca

sted

cos

ts in

clud

ed in

the

DC

E.”

[Em

phas

is a

dded

]

•E

stab

lishm

ent o

f an

allo

catio

n sc

hem

e w

ould

cre

ate

chal

leng

es–

Fore

cast

ing

wou

ld b

e a

chal

leng

e •

Mor

e de

taile

d re

quire

d th

an ju

st i

dent

ifyin

g “D

GC

Sco

pe” s

uppo

rted

•R

equi

red

to e

stim

ate

cost

s ac

ross

mul

tiple

maj

or p

roje

cts

(e.g

., R

VI s

egm

enta

tion

vs. S

team

Gen

erat

or

Rem

oval

vs.

Lar

ge C

ompo

nent

Rem

oval

etc

.)

•E

stim

ate

this

leve

l of d

etai

l for

the

dura

tion

of th

e D

GC

Sco

pe (e

.g.,

2028

)

–W

ill cr

eate

mis

lead

ing

varia

nces

sol

ely

base

d on

fore

cast

ing

allo

catio

n pe

rcen

tage

s

•W

ill cr

eate

mea

ning

less

var

ianc

es b

etw

een

fore

cast

ed a

nd re

cord

ed c

osts

•W

ill cr

eate

var

ianc

es e

ven

if th

e U

tility

sta

ffing

is th

e sa

me

–W

ould

not

be

an e

ffici

ent p

roce

ss

A-1

7

Page 28: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

18

Idea

s to

Con

side

r

•A

lloca

tions

do

not s

uppo

rt th

e di

rect

ive

to

“effi

cien

tly c

ompa

re” e

stim

ated

cos

ts to

reco

rded

co

sts

•Th

e U

tility

Sta

ff is

in a

n ov

ersi

ght

role

and

doe

s no

t di

rect

ly su

ppor

t spe

cific

maj

or p

roje

cts

•S

CE

’s b

enef

it in

the

“give

/take

” of

Mile

ston

e Fr

amew

ork

nego

tiatio

ns is

that

all

Utili

ty S

taff

cost

s ar

e re

view

ed w

ith U

ndis

tribu

ted

Cos

ts

A-1

8

Page 29: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

Annu

al A

dvic

e Le

tter P

roce

ss

Janu

ary

31, 2

019

A-1

9

Page 30: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

2

Out

line

•P

urpo

se o

f Wor

ksho

p

•G

ener

al In

form

atio

n

•A

dvic

e Le

tter A

ttach

men

ts A-2

0

Page 31: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

3

Purp

ose

of W

orks

hop

•20

15 N

DC

TP D

ecis

ion

requ

ires

SC

E to

mee

t with

E

nerg

y D

ivisi

on a

nd in

tere

sted

par

ties

to d

iscu

ss

wha

t, if

any,

mod

ificat

ions

will

be n

eede

d fo

r the

an

nual

Tie

r 2

Adv

ice

Lette

r pr

oces

s…co

nsis

tent

w

ith th

e ad

optio

n of

the

Mile

ston

e Fr

amew

ork.

•…

each

suc

h A

L m

ust s

how

….re

late

d pr

ogre

ss

tow

ard

spec

ific m

ajor

mile

ston

es in

the

deco

mm

issi

onin

g pr

oces

s co

nsis

tent

with

the

Mile

ston

e Fr

amew

ork…

. A-2

1

Page 32: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

4

Advi

ce L

ette

r Gen

eral

In

form

atio

n•

SC

E F

iles

Two

Tier

2 A

dvic

e Le

tters

Eac

h Ye

ar–

Fall A

dvic

e Le

tter

•P

rovi

des

curr

ent s

tatu

s of

dec

omm

issi

onin

g

•R

eque

sts

auth

oriza

tion

for d

isbu

rsem

ents

fro

m th

e nu

clea

r de

com

mis

sion

ing

trust

s fo

r ide

ntifi

ed y

ear’s

cas

h flo

w

•R

epor

ts re

ques

ted

amou

nts

(i.e.

, for

ecas

t) ag

ains

t DC

E b

y D

CE

line

item

•P

rovi

des

varia

nce

anal

ysis

bet

wee

n D

CE

and

fore

cast

(bot

h co

st a

nd s

ched

ule)

–S

prin

g Ad

vice

Let

ter

•P

rovi

des

curr

ent s

tatu

s of

dec

omm

issi

onin

g

•R

epor

ts re

cord

ed c

osts

aga

inst

requ

este

d am

ount

s fro

m a

ssoc

iate

d Fa

ll Adv

ice

Lette

r

•P

rovi

des

high

-leve

l var

ianc

e an

alys

is b

etw

een

reco

rded

cos

ts a

nd p

revi

ousl

y re

ques

ted

amou

nts

A-2

2

Page 33: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

5

Advi

ce L

ette

r Gen

eral

In

form

atio

n•

Adv

ice

Lette

rs r

epor

t cos

ts c

onsi

sten

t with

the

maj

or p

roje

cts

incl

uded

in th

e M

ilest

one

Fram

ewor

k–

SCE

upda

ted

the

Advi

ce L

ette

r stru

ctur

e in

Fal

l 201

8 AL

(i.

e., 2

019

Budg

et)

to re

flect

the

rece

ntly

app

rove

d fra

mew

ork

–SC

E al

so c

ompl

ied

with

Com

mis

sion

’s d

irect

ion

to

incl

ude

a st

atus

of t

he IS

FSI a

nd In

itial

D&D

Maj

or

Proj

ects

A-2

3

Page 34: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

6

Advi

ce L

ette

r Atta

chm

ents

•SC

E pr

evio

usly

wor

ked

with

Ene

rgy

Div

isio

n to

ens

ure

the

Advi

ce L

ette

rs p

rovi

de in

form

atio

n th

at is

nee

ded

by o

r of i

nter

est t

o th

e C

omm

issi

on a

nd o

ther

s•

Prov

ide

com

preh

ensi

ve s

tatu

s up

date

s of

the

deco

mm

issi

onin

g pr

ojec

t cos

t and

sch

edul

e pe

rform

ance

•Fa

ll Ad

vice

Let

ter

Cur

rent

ly C

onta

ins:

11 A

ttach

men

ts

–R

evis

ed s

truct

ure

and

atta

chm

ents

in re

spon

se to

upd

ated

re

quire

men

ts

A-2

4

Page 35: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

7

Advi

ce L

ette

r Atta

chm

ents

•At

tach

men

t 1: G

raph

Tra

ckin

g To

tal D

CE

Estim

ate,

Act

ual,

and

Fore

cast

ed D

ecom

mis

sion

ing

Expe

nditu

res

A-2

5

Page 36: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

8

Advi

ce L

ette

r Atta

chm

ents

•A

ttach

men

t 2: D

escr

iptio

n of

Wor

k Act

iviti

es a

nd P

relim

inar

y Va

rianc

e E

xpla

natio

ns fo

r For

ecas

ted

Exp

ense

s w

ith R

efer

ence

to D

CE

•A

ttach

men

t 3: C

ompa

rison

of D

CE

and

For

ecas

ted

Exp

endi

ture

s by

C

ost C

ateg

ory

and

DC

E L

ine

Num

ber

[A]

[B]

[C=A

-B]

[D]

[E]

[F]

[G]

DC

E N

o.M

ajor

Pro

ject

(1)

Des

crip

tion

(2)

2017

DC

E (3

)Fo

reca

sted

Var

ianc

e

Fore

cast

edIn

cept

ion

To

Dat

e Th

roug

h 20

19(4

)To

tal 2

017

DC

E (3) (

5)C

urre

nt

Star

t C

urre

nt

Fini

sh11

9SN

F-2-

D-C

DP

ISFS

I CD

P Se

ttlem

ent

ISFS

I CD

P Se

ttlem

ent

1.2

1.7

(0.5

)5.

14.

3

8/30

/201

78/

30/2

021

120

ISFS

I Coa

stal

Dev

elop

men

t Per

mit

Sett

lem

ent S

ubto

tal

1.2

$

1.

7$

(0.5

)$

5.1

$

4.3

$

12

112

2SN

F-2-

D-A

M A

reva

ISFS

I Agi

ng M

anag

emen

tA

reva

ISFS

I Rel

icen

sing

3.8

2.8

1.0

5.9

14.1

9/

1/20

1612

/31/

2022

123

SNF-

2-D

-AM

Hol

tec1

ISFS

I Agi

ng M

anag

emen

tH

olte

c IS

FSI I

&M

Pro

gram

Dev

elop

men

t3.

84.

8(1

.0)

7.2

16.7

2/

15/2

017

10/6

/202

012

4IS

FSI A

ging

Man

agem

ent S

ubto

tal

7.6

$

7.

6$

0.0

$

13.2

$

30.8

$

2019

Atta

chm

ent 3

:

A-2

6

Page 37: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

9

Advi

ce L

ette

r Atta

chm

ents

•A

ttach

men

t 4: C

ompa

rison

of D

CE

Est

imat

ed a

nd F

orec

aste

d C

ash

Flow

•A

ttach

men

t 5: I

llust

ratio

n of

Hig

h-Le

vel C

urre

nt D

ecom

mis

sion

ing

Sch

edul

e

A-2

7

Page 38: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

10

Advi

ce L

ette

r Atta

chm

ents

•At

tach

men

t 6: A

djus

ted

Tota

l Am

ount

s R

eque

sted

to

Dat

e,

Incl

udin

g Pr

evio

us A

dvic

e Le

tters

–S

umm

ariz

es R

eque

sted

Am

ount

s To

Dat

e In

:•

2014

$, 1

00%

Sha

re

•N

omin

al $

, 100

% S

hare

•N

omin

al, S

CE

Sha

re

A-2

8

Page 39: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

11

Advi

ce L

ette

r Atta

chm

ents

•At

tach

men

t 7: F

orec

aste

d Es

cala

tion

and

De-

Esca

latio

n Fa

ctor

s –

Use

d to

de-

esca

late

fore

cast

ed/ r

ecor

ded

cost

s to

201

4$ fo

r pu

rpos

es o

f com

paris

on to

DC

E

•At

tach

men

t 8: F

inal

Esc

alat

ion

Fact

or A

djus

tmen

t–

Upd

ates

reco

rded

cos

ts in

sta

ted

in 2

014$

in p

rior A

dvic

e Le

tters

to

acco

unt f

or fi

nal e

scal

atio

n fa

ctor

s

A-2

9

Page 40: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

12

Advi

ce L

ette

r Atta

chm

ents

•At

tach

men

t 9: S

CE

Trus

t Fun

d D

isbu

rsem

ent A

mou

nts

–S

umm

ariz

es re

ques

ted,

app

rove

d, a

nd w

ithdr

awn

amou

nts

at ti

me

the

AL

is fi

led

•A

ttach

men

t 10:

201

7 D

CE

Was

te D

ispo

sal A

djus

tmen

t –

Upd

ated

201

7 D

CE

to a

lign

to p

ropo

sed

mile

ston

e fra

mew

ork

for D

&D

w

aste

dis

posa

l cos

ts

A-3

0

Page 41: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

13

Advi

ce L

ette

r Atta

chm

ents

•At

tach

men

t 11:

Sta

tus

Rep

ort f

or IS

FSI a

nd In

itial

D&D

Ac

tiviti

es–

SC

E a

dded

this

atta

chm

ent p

er re

quire

men

t of D

ecis

ion

18-1

1-03

4

A-3

1

Page 42: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

14

Wor

k w

ith E

nerg

y D

ivis

ion

•P

revio

usly

wor

ked

with

Ene

rgy

Divi

sion

to

mak

e su

re n

eeds

wer

e be

ing

met

•D

urin

g w

orks

hops

for t

he p

rior N

DC

TP, w

e co

nfirm

ed E

nerg

y D

ivisi

on’s

nee

ds w

ere

bein

g m

et

A-3

2

Page 43: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

A-3

3

Page 44: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

2

Out

line

•P

urpo

se o

f Wor

ksho

p•

DC

E C

ompa

rison

s •

Com

paris

on o

f 201

7 D

CE

to 2

014

DC

E P

rovid

ed•

Cha

lleng

es t

o P

erfo

rm C

ompa

rison

to 2

012

DC

E•

Pro

pose

d A

ppro

ach

to C

ompa

re D

CE

s•

Pro

pose

d C

ompa

rison

Tab

le•

Con

clus

ion

A-3

4

Page 45: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

3

Purp

ose

of W

orks

hop

•20

15 N

DC

TP D

ecis

ion

18-1

1-03

4 st

ated

.…m

eet

with

Ene

rgy

Divi

sion

sta

ff to

add

ress

how

SC

E w

ill m

eet t

he re

quire

men

ts t

o pr

ovid

e tra

nspa

renc

y as

to

cos

ts a

utho

rized

in p

rior D

CE

S w

ith th

ose

prop

osed

in fu

ture

DC

Es

(incl

udin

g (A

.)18-

03-0

09)

A-3

5

Page 46: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

4

DC

E To

DC

E C

ompa

rison

•D

.18-

11-0

34 re

quire

s th

at S

CE

com

pare

the

2017

DC

E to

th

e tw

o pr

ior D

CEs

(201

4 an

d 20

12)

–“W

e th

eref

ore

requ

ire S

CE

to p

rovi

de a

com

paris

on o

f any

new

DC

E

with

the

two-

prio

r app

rove

d D

CE

s co

nsis

tent

with

D.1

7-05

-020

.” (D

ecis

ion,

pg.

63)

•Th

e C

omm

issi

on re

cogn

ized

tha

t cha

lleng

es e

xist i

n th

is

com

paris

on–

“The

com

paris

on o

f the

201

8 D

CE

with

the

last

two-

prio

r app

rove

d D

CE

s po

ses

som

e di

fficu

lties

giv

en th

e ch

ange

in fo

rmat

for

reco

rdin

g co

sts,

prio

r erro

rs/o

mis

sion

s ac

know

ledg

ed b

y S

CE

, and

th

e ne

ed fo

r mor

e cl

arity

as

to w

hat i

tem

s m

ay b

e ca

tego

rized

as

Und

istri

bute

d an

d D

istri

bute

d ac

tiviti

es.”

(Dec

isio

n, p

g. 6

0)

A-3

6

Page 47: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

5

Com

paris

on O

f 201

7 D

CE

To 2

014

DC

E Pr

ovid

ed•

SCE

incl

uded

a d

etai

led

com

paris

on b

etw

een

the

2017

DC

E an

d 20

14 D

CE

whi

ch w

as in

clud

ed in

the

2018

ND

CTP

test

imon

y(1)

•Th

e 20

14 a

nd 2

017

DC

Es u

tiliz

e th

e sa

me

Wor

k Br

eakd

own

Stru

ctur

e (W

BS)

–Th

e sa

me

stru

ctur

e al

low

s fo

r a “c

ross

-wal

k” b

etw

een

DC

Es

and

faci

litat

es c

ompa

rison

–C

ompa

rison

was

per

form

ed a

t the

maj

or p

roje

ct le

vel a

nd fo

r un

dist

ribut

ed a

ctiv

ities

Not

es:

(1) S

ee S

CE

-03C

Tabl

e IV

-2, R

econ

cilia

tion

of 2

017

DC

E to

201

4 D

CE

A-3

7

Page 48: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

A-3

8

Page 49: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

7

Cha

lleng

es T

o Pe

rfor

m

Com

paris

on T

o 20

12 D

CE

•A

one-

to-o

ne m

appi

ng o

f the

WB

S in

clud

ed in

th

e 20

12 a

nd 2

014/

2017

DC

Es

does

not

exis

t•

Ass

umpt

ions

abo

ut w

here

201

2 D

CE

act

iviti

es

map

to th

e 20

14/2

017

DC

E s

truct

ure

will

be

requ

ired

•D

ue to

all

the

assu

mpt

ions

, a

mea

ning

ful “

line

item

act

ivity

leve

l” co

mpa

rison

is n

ot p

ract

ical

A-3

9

Page 50: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

A-4

0

Page 51: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

9

Cha

lleng

es T

o Pe

rfor

m

Com

paris

on T

o 20

12 D

CE

•In

the

2014

DC

E, l

ead

and

asbe

stos

aba

tem

ent

is b

roke

n in

to e

ssen

tial a

nd n

on-e

ssen

tial

syst

ems,

so

each

bu

ildin

g in

the

2012

DC

E w

ould

nee

d to

be

cate

goriz

ed

into

ess

entia

l vs.

non

-ess

entia

l in

orde

r to

map

to th

e 20

14 D

CE

WB

S

•In

the

2017

DC

E, t

hese

cos

ts a

re n

ot b

roke

n ou

t se

para

tely

due

to th

e st

ruct

ure

of th

e fix

ed p

rice

cont

ract

A-4

1

Page 52: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

A-4

2

Page 53: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

11

Prop

osed

App

roac

h To

C

ompa

re D

CEs

•A

ssum

ptio

ns w

ill n

eed

to b

e m

ade

for

activ

ities

incl

uded

in th

e 20

12 D

CE

•S

CE

will

pre

pare

and

sub

mit

an a

ppen

dix

to

prov

ide

a co

mpa

rison

tabl

e of

the

DC

Es

–S

CE

doe

s no

t int

end

to p

erfo

rm a

var

ianc

e an

alys

is b

etw

een

the

2017

DC

E to

the

2012

D

CE

–H

igh-

leve

l com

paris

on in

201

4$

A-4

3

Page 54: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

A-4

4

Page 55: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

13

Prop

osed

App

roac

h To

C

ompa

re D

CEs

•C

ompa

rison

of u

ndis

tribu

ted

cost

s–

Labo

r-Sta

ffing

–N

on-L

abor

–D

GC

Sta

ffing

A-4

5

Page 56: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

A-4

6

Page 57: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

15

Idea

s to

Con

side

r•

SCE

will

pre

pare

and

sub

mit

an a

ppen

dix

to p

rovi

de a

co

mpa

rison

tabl

e of

the

DC

Es–

SC

E d

oes

not i

nten

d to

per

form

a v

aria

nce

anal

ysis

bet

wee

n th

e 20

17 D

CE

to th

e 20

12 D

CE

–H

igh-

leve

l com

paris

on in

201

4$•

A m

ore

deta

iled

com

paris

on m

ay n

ot b

e po

ssib

le–

If po

ssib

le, w

ould

tak

e si

gnifi

cant

ly m

ore

time,

reso

urce

s, a

nd m

ay n

ot p

rovi

de

any

addi

tiona

l val

ue–

Wou

ld lik

ely

need

to re

-eng

age

ABZ

and

pote

ntia

lly E

nerg

ySol

utio

ns to

sup

port

a de

taile

d co

mpa

rison

•G

oing

forw

ard

and

with

dec

omm

issi

onin

g st

arte

d, S

CE

pla

ns to

kee

p th

e D

CE

line

item

stru

ctur

e (i.

e., W

BS

stru

ctur

e) th

e sa

me,

and

th

eref

ore

thes

e sp

ecifi

c ch

alle

nges

are

likel

y m

itiga

ted

in fu

ture

co

mpa

rison

s

A-4

7

Page 58: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

Attachment B

Page 59: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

2

Intr

oduc

tion

•N

o co

mm

ents

rece

ived

to-d

ate

•W

ill re

cap

wha

t was

dis

cuss

ed d

urin

g w

orks

hop

#1

and

revi

ew S

CE

’s p

ropo

sal o

n ea

ch to

pic

•G

oal o

f thi

s w

orks

hop

is to

reac

h ag

reem

ent o

n th

ese

issu

es

Page 60: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

3

Rec

ap o

f Wor

ksho

p #1

A

dvic

eLe

tters

•P

rovi

ded

an o

verv

iew

of t

he S

prin

g an

d Fa

ll A

dvic

e Le

tters

and

dis

cuss

ed th

eir p

urpo

se•

Wal

ked

thro

ugh

each

atta

chm

ent i

nclu

ded

in th

e A

dvic

e Le

tters

to d

escr

ibe

thei

r pur

pose

Con

firm

ed th

at S

CE

had

upd

ated

the

Adv

ice

Lette

rs to

inco

rpor

ate

the

Com

mis

sion

’s d

irect

ion

rega

rdin

g th

e M

ilest

one

Fram

ewor

k an

d th

e st

atus

of

maj

or p

roje

cts

Page 61: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

4

SCE’

s Pr

opos

alA

dvic

eLe

tters

•B

ased

on

wor

ksho

p co

mm

ents

from

the

Ene

rgy

Div

isio

n, S

CE

agr

ees

to in

clud

e:–

“Per

cent

Exp

ende

d” o

n th

e de

taile

d co

st c

ompa

rison

at

tach

men

t–

Trus

t Fun

d B

alan

ces

•C

ontin

ue to

incl

ude

the

“Sta

tus

Rep

ort”

atta

chm

ent

as d

irect

ed b

y th

e C

omm

issi

on

Page 62: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

5

Rec

ap o

f Wor

ksho

p #

1D

CE

Com

paris

ons

•S

CE

disc

usse

d ch

alle

nges

to p

erfo

rm a

com

paris

on

betw

een

the

SO

NG

S 2

017

DC

E a

nd th

e 20

12 D

CE

•S

CE

will

nee

d to

mak

e as

sum

ptio

ns o

n w

here

to m

ap

2012

DC

E a

ctiv

ities

to th

e 20

17 D

CE

cat

egor

ies

•D

evel

opin

g a

com

paris

on w

ill h

ave

chal

leng

es, w

hich

w

ere

reco

gniz

ed b

y th

e C

omm

issi

on–

The

2012

DC

E is

bas

ed o

n a

diffe

rent

DC

E li

ne n

umbe

r st

ruct

ure

than

the

2014

/201

7 D

CE

s, w

hich

will

mak

e a

“line

by

line

activ

ity le

vel”

com

paris

on n

ot p

ract

ical

Page 63: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff
Page 64: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

7

SCE’

s Pr

opos

alD

CE

Com

paris

ons

•S

CE

will

prep

are

and

subm

it an

app

endi

x to

pr

ovid

e a

com

paris

on ta

ble

of th

e D

CE

s–

Hig

h-le

vel c

ompa

rison

in 2

014$

•W

illno

te a

ny m

ajor

issu

es c

reat

ing

varia

nces

–B

ased

on

com

men

ts d

urin

g th

e w

orks

hop,

SC

E

agre

ed to

mov

e th

e S

ervi

ce L

evel

Agr

eem

ent

(form

erly

A&

G) c

osts

into

one

line

item

, sim

ilar t

o pr

evio

us d

ata

requ

ests

•G

oing

forw

ard,

SC

E p

lans

to k

eep

the

DC

E li

ne it

em

stru

ctur

e th

e sa

me,

and

ther

efor

e m

itiga

ting

futu

re

com

paris

ons

com

plic

atio

ns

Page 65: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

8

Rec

ap o

f Wor

ksho

p #1

Cos

tCat

egor

izat

ion

•D

iscu

ssed

the

defin

ition

of u

ndis

tribu

ted

cost

s

•P

rovi

ded

exam

ples

of t

he in

dust

ry’s

pra

ctic

e of

sep

arat

ing

undi

strib

uted

cos

ts, i

nclu

ding

Util

ity a

nd D

GC

sta

ffing

, fro

m

dist

ribut

ed a

ctiv

ities

•P

rovi

ded

an o

verv

iew

of S

CE

’s c

harg

ing

prac

tices

•R

each

ed a

gree

men

t tha

t allo

catio

ns o

f util

ity s

taff

cost

s w

ill cr

eate

“fa

lse

varia

nces

” whe

n co

mpa

ring

reco

rded

and

est

imat

ed c

osts

•S

CE

out

lined

its

posi

tion

on w

hy th

e ag

reed

upo

n M

ilest

one

Fram

ewor

k al

read

y ac

hiev

es “l

inki

ng” u

ndis

tribu

ted

cost

s to

pro

ject

pe

rform

ance

Page 66: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

9

SCE’

s Pr

opos

alC

ostC

ompa

rison

•C

ontin

ue to

follo

w th

e ag

reed

upo

n M

ilest

one

Fram

ewor

k fo

r tim

ing

and

scop

e of

und

istri

bute

d co

st

revi

ews

•M

ilest

one

Fram

ewor

k ac

hiev

es th

e C

omm

issi

on’s

de

sire

s–

“The

revi

sed

cost

cat

egor

izat

ion

stru

ctur

e m

ust s

et fo

rth h

ow c

osts

will

be

reco

rded

in th

e fu

ture

, in

a m

anne

r tha

t can

effi

cien

tly c

ompa

re to

fo

reca

sted

cos

ts in

clud

ed in

the

DC

E.” [

Em

phas

is a

dded

]

Page 67: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

Attachment C

Page 68: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

Cos

tC

ateg

oriz

atio

n

Mar

ch 1

4, 2

019

Page 69: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

2

Out

line

•P

urpo

se o

f the

Wor

ksho

p

•S

CE

’s C

urre

nt G

uida

nce

•R

easo

nabl

enes

s R

evie

w C

riter

ia

•S

CE

’s P

ropo

sal F

rom

Las

t Wor

ksho

p

Page 70: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

3

Purp

ose

of W

orks

hop

•20

15 N

DC

TP D

ecis

ion

18-1

1-03

4 st

ated

…[U

tiliti

es] s

hall

mee

t w

ith E

nerg

y D

ivis

ion

staf

f and

inte

rest

ed p

artie

s to

dev

elop

pr

otoc

ols

and

guid

ance

for r

ecor

ding

sta

ff tim

e de

sign

ated

to

Dis

tribu

ted

activ

ities

, and

to d

efin

e w

hat a

ctiv

ities

will

be

cons

ider

ed U

ndis

tribu

ted

and

Dis

tribu

ted

activ

ities

.•

Com

mis

sion

s’ g

oals

–“T

he re

vise

d co

st c

ateg

oriz

atio

n st

ruct

ure

mus

t set

forth

how

cos

ts w

ill

be re

cord

ed in

the

futu

re, i

n a

man

ner t

hat c

an e

ffici

ently

com

pare

to

fore

cast

ed c

osts

incl

uded

in th

e D

CE.

” [E

mph

asis

add

ed]

–“[A

]ddr

ess

how

SC

E w

ill in

the

futu

re p

rovi

de m

ore

deta

iled

dire

ctio

ns

and

inst

ruct

ions

to it

s st

aff s

o th

at re

cord

kee

ping

will

dire

ctly

and

tran

spar

ently

be

refle

cted

in th

e ap

prop

riate

loca

tion,

and

with

the

appr

opria

te d

etai

l.” [E

mph

asis

add

ed]

Page 71: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

4

SCE’

s C

harg

ing

Prac

tice

For U

tility

Sta

ff

No

Yes

•S

CE

’s g

uida

nce

stat

es th

at

pers

onne

l sho

uld

char

ge th

eir t

ime

to w

here

they

wor

k. I

f you

wor

k on

a

proj

ect t

he c

harg

es s

houl

d be

re

cord

ed to

that

pro

ject

.

•S

ON

GS

reco

rded

cos

ts c

urre

ntly

al

ign

to th

e D

CE

and

inco

rpor

ate

indu

stry

pra

ctic

es fo

r est

imat

ing

undi

strib

uted

cos

ts, i

nclu

ding

ca

tego

rizin

g U

tility

Sta

ff co

sts

as

undi

strib

uted

.

•S

CE

pro

vide

s di

scus

sion

on

all

undi

strib

uted

cos

ts a

s pa

rt of

the

ND

CTP

test

imon

y.

Page 72: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

5

Rea

sona

blen

ess

Stan

dard

“[W]e

def

ine

reas

onab

lene

ss fo

r dec

omm

issi

onin

g ex

pend

iture

s co

nsis

tent

with

prio

r Com

mis

sion

fin

ding

s; i.

e., t

hat t

he re

ason

able

ness

of a

par

ticul

ar

man

agem

ent a

ctio

n de

pend

s on

wha

t the

util

ity k

new

or

sho

uld

have

kno

wn

at th

e tim

e th

e m

anag

eria

l de

cisi

on w

as m

ade.

”1

•S

CE

has

dem

onst

rate

d its

will

ingn

ess

to e

xten

d be

yond

the

reas

onab

lene

ss s

tand

ard

to re

ach

agre

emen

t with

inte

rest

ed p

artie

s.

–S

CE

has

agr

eed

to th

e M

ilest

one

Fram

ewor

k, w

hich

sub

ject

s re

view

to “c

heck

poin

ts” v

s. re

view

s co

sts

ever

y th

ree

year

s

Sou

rce:

(1) S

ee D

.10-

07-0

47, p

. 10;

D.1

6-12

-063

, pp.

9-1

0; a

ccor

d D

.02-

08-0

64, p

p. 5

-6.

Page 73: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

6

SCE’

s Pr

opos

al F

rom

Las

t W

orks

hop

•Id

entif

y K

ey O

vers

ight

Per

sonn

el (K

OP

) w

ho

“driv

e” th

e pr

ojec

t–

Cre

ate

an u

ndis

tribu

ted

staf

f cat

egor

y ca

lled

KO

P

–A

dd tw

o “c

heck

poin

ts” f

or u

ndis

tribu

ted

cost

s in

ND

CTP

s th

at d

o no

t alre

ady

have

“che

ckpo

ints

” in

the

Mile

ston

e Fr

amew

ork

(202

4, 2

030)

–Th

e K

OP

wou

ld b

e su

bjec

t to

all “

chec

kpoi

nts”

•A

ll ot

her u

ndis

tribu

ted

cost

s w

ill n

o lo

nger

be

subj

ect t

o “c

heck

poin

ts”

Page 74: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

Dat

a R

eque

st 1

3 - Q

uest

ion

1a.

2016

-201

7 R

ecor

ded

SCE

Lab

or C

osts

In U

ndis

trib

uted

Lin

e It

ems

(201

4 D

olla

rs In

Mill

ions

, 100

% S

hare

) 2016

2017

DC

E L

ine

Des

crip

tion

Div

isio

n

SCE

Lab

or

(Inc

ludi

ng

Ove

rhea

ds)

Est

imat

ed

SCE

Ave

rage

H

eadc

ount

SCE

Lab

or

(Inc

ludi

ng

Ove

rhea

ds)

Est

imat

ed

SCE

Ave

rage

H

eadc

ount

1U

tility

Sta

ffSi

te M

anag

emen

t & A

dmin

istra

tion

3.2

$12

2.7

$9

2U

tility

Sta

ffD

ecom

mis

sion

ing

Fina

nce

--

0.4

3(1

)

3U

tility

Sta

ffR

egul

ator

y A

ffairs

& N

ucle

ar O

vers

ight

2.3

81.

77

4U

tility

Sta

ffO

pera

tions

9.3

457.

540

5U

tility

Sta

ffR

adio

logi

cal C

ontro

l & C

hem

istry

4.8

242.

617

6U

tility

Sta

ffM

aint

enan

ce &

Wor

k C

ontro

l4.

827

4.5

247

Util

ity S

taff

Engi

neer

ing

3.9

242.

916

8U

tility

Sta

ffEP

Pla

nnin

g0.

83

0.6

39

Util

ity S

taff

Secu

rity

Adm

in2.

5(2

)1.

9(3

)

10U

tility

Sta

ffD

ecom

mis

sion

ing

Ove

rsig

ht1.

611

1.8

1011

Util

ity S

taff

Sub

tota

l33

.3$

26.5

$12 13

Secu

rity

Forc

eSe

curit

y20

.2(2

)17

.4(3

)

14 15C

ontra

cted

Ser

vice

sSi

te M

anag

emen

t & A

dmin

istra

tion

0.1

10.

0-

16C

ontra

cted

Ser

vice

sD

ecom

mis

sion

ing

Fina

nce

0.4

2-

-17

Con

tract

ed S

ervi

ces

Reg

ulat

ory

Affa

irs &

Nuc

lear

Ove

rsig

ht0.

0-

--

18C

ontra

cted

Ser

vice

sO

pera

tions

0.1

10.

0-

19C

ontra

cted

Ser

vice

sM

aint

enan

ce &

Wor

k C

ontro

l0.

32

0.0

-20

Con

tract

ed S

ervi

ces

Engi

neer

ing

0.0

--

-21

Con

tract

ed S

ervi

ces

Dec

omm

issi

onin

g O

vers

ight

0.0

-0.

01

22C

ontr

acte

d Se

rvic

es S

ubto

tal

0.8

$6

0.1

$1

23 24Th

ird P

arty

Leg

alN

/A(1

.2)

-0.

0-

25 26Se

vera

nce

N/A

1.2

-3.

6-

27 28U

ndis

trib

uted

Tot

al54

.3$

313

47.5

$27

8

Gen

eral

Not

e:A

mou

nts m

ay n

ot ti

e du

e to

roun

ding

.

Not

es:

(2) T

he to

tal s

ecur

ity d

ivis

ion

estim

ated

hea

dcou

nt in

201

6 is

153

.(3

) The

tota

l sec

urity

div

isio

n es

timat

ed h

eadc

ount

in 2

017

is 1

48.

(1)

In Ju

ly 2

017,

the

Dec

omm

issi

onin

g Fi

nanc

e di

visi

on re

verte

d ba

ck fr

om a

Ser

vice

Lev

el A

gree

men

t to

the

Dec

omm

issi

onin

g A

gent

Org

aniz

atio

n. T

he h

eadc

ount

re

flect

s the

ave

rage

hea

dcou

nt o

ver t

he fu

ll ye

ar.

1 O

f 5

Page 75: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

Dat

a R

eque

st 1

3 - Q

uest

ion

1a.

2016

-201

7 R

ecor

ded

SCE

Lab

or C

osts

In D

istr

ibut

ed L

ine

Item

s(2

014

Dol

lars

In M

illio

ns, 1

00%

Sha

re)

2016

2017

DC

E N

o.D

escr

iptio

n

SCE

Lab

or

(Inc

ludi

ng

Ove

rhea

ds)

Est

imat

ed

SCE

FT

Es (1

)

SCE

Lab

or

(Inc

ludi

ng

Ove

rhea

ds)

Est

imat

ed

SCE

FT

Es (1

)

1LT

-2-D

-2.1

9Im

plem

ent C

old

and

Dar

k (R

epow

er S

ite)

1.5

$7

-$

-2

LT-2

-D-2

.20

Inst

all 1

2 kV

Ser

vice

Lin

e to

Pow

er T

emp

Pow

er R

ing

0.7

40.

11

3LT

-2-D

-2.2

1D

rain

& D

e-En

ergi

ze N

on-E

ssen

tial S

yste

ms (

DEC

Pro

cess

)0.

63

0.0

-4

Initi

al D

&D

Act

iviti

es S

ubto

tal

2.8

$14

0.1

$1

5 6LT

-2-D

-2.2

6In

stal

l Spe

nt F

uel P

ool S

yste

m M

odifi

catio

ns -

Uni

t 20.

0-

--

7LT

-2-D

-2.2

7In

stal

l Spe

nt F

uel P

ool S

yste

m M

odifi

catio

ns -

Uni

t 30.

0-

--

8Sp

ent F

uel P

ool I

slan

ding

Sub

tota

l0.

0$

--

$

-

9 10LT

-2-D

-2.2

2Se

lect

Dec

omm

issi

onin

g G

ener

al C

ontra

ctor

(DG

C)

1.1

3-

-11 12

LT-2

-D-L

OED

Larg

e O

rgan

ism

Exc

lusi

on D

evic

e M

odifi

catio

n0.

11

0.0

-13 14

SNF-

2-D

-8.0

8D

esig

n IS

FSI E

xpan

sion

, Fue

l Ins

pect

ion,

and

Ove

rsig

ht0.

52

0.8

515

SNF-

2-D

-8.0

9C

onst

ruct

ISFS

I Exp

ansi

on0.

11

(0.0

)-

16 17SN

F-2-

D-8

.12

Load

Fue

l Can

iste

rs a

nd F

uel T

rans

fer O

pera

tions

- U

nit 2

--

0.0

18SN

F-2-

D-8

.13

Load

Fue

l Can

iste

rs a

nd F

uel T

rans

fer O

pera

tions

- U

nit 3

--

0.0

19L

oad

Fuel

Can

iste

rs a

nd F

uel T

rans

fer

Ope

ratio

ns S

ubto

tal

-$

-0.

0$

120 21

SNF-

2-D

-AM

Are

vaA

reva

ISFS

I Rel

icen

sing

--

0.0

-22

SNF-

2-D

-AM

Hol

tec1

Hol

tec

ISFS

I I&

M P

rogr

am D

evel

opm

ent

--

0.0

-23

ISFS

I Agi

ng M

anag

emen

t Sub

tota

l-

$-

0.1

$-

24 25SR

-1-D

-14.

01M

esa

Site

Pha

se I

and

II Si

te A

sses

smen

t and

Lea

se S

urre

nder

(0.0

)-

0.1

126 27

SR-3

-D-1

6.05

Obt

ain

CEQ

A P

erm

it &

App

rova

ls0.

62

0.3

128 29

SR-3

-D-1

6.03

Initi

al R

eal E

stat

e A

utho

rizat

ion

Ren

ewal

and

Pla

nt E

asem

ent

0.2

10.

11

30 31D

istr

ibut

ed T

otal

5.5

$24

1.5

$10

Gen

eral

Not

e:A

mou

nts m

ay n

ot ti

e du

e to

roun

ding

.

Not

e:(1

) The

hea

dcou

nt o

r FTE

s of S

CE

pers

onne

l rec

ordi

ng to

dis

tribu

ted

activ

ities

is n

ot a

vaila

ble.

The

refo

re, t

he F

TEs w

ere

estim

ated

bas

ed o

n an

ave

rage

rate

cal

cula

ted

for e

ach

DC

E lin

e ite

m.

2 O

f 5

Page 76: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

Dat

a R

eque

st 1

3 - Q

uest

ion

1b.

2016

- 20

17 R

ecor

ded

Cor

e C

ontr

acto

r C

osts

In U

ndis

trib

uted

Lin

e It

ems

(201

4 D

olla

rs In

Mill

ions

, 100

% S

hare

)

2016

2017

DC

E L

ine

Des

crip

tion

Div

isio

nC

ontr

act

Lab

or C

osts

Con

trac

t L

abor

Cos

ts1

Util

ity S

taff

Site

Man

agem

ent &

Adm

inis

tratio

n0.

0$

1.3

$2

Util

ity S

taff

Dec

omm

issi

onin

g Fi

nanc

e-

0.1

3U

tility

Sta

ffR

egul

ator

y A

ffai

rs &

Nuc

lear

Ove

rsig

ht0.

20.

44

Util

ity S

taff

Ope

ratio

ns0.

20.

85

Util

ity S

taff

Rad

iolo

gica

l Con

trol &

Che

mis

try0.

20.

86

Util

ity S

taff

Mai

nten

ance

& W

ork

Con

trol

0.3

0.2

7U

tility

Sta

ffEn

gine

erin

g1.

21.

28

Util

ity S

taff

EP P

lann

ing

0.1

0.0

9U

tility

Sta

ffSe

curit

y0.

20.

210

Util

ity S

taff

Dec

omm

issi

onin

g O

vers

ight

5.6

5.9

11U

tility

Sta

ff S

ubto

tal

Util

ity S

taff

Sub

tota

l8.

1$

11.0

$12 13

Secu

rity

Forc

eSe

curit

y0.

40.

914 15

Und

istr

ibut

ed T

otal

8.6

$11

.9$

Gen

eral

Not

es:

(ii) A

mou

nts m

ay n

ot ti

e du

e to

roun

ding

.

(i) T

he h

eadc

ount

of c

ore

cont

ract

ors r

ecor

ding

to u

ndis

tribu

ted

labo

r lin

e ite

ms i

s not

trac

ked.

The

refo

re, h

eadc

ount

in

form

atio

n ca

nnot

be

prov

ided

.

3 O

f 5

Page 77: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

Dat

a R

eque

st 1

3 - Q

uest

ion

1b.

2016

- 20

17 E

stim

ated

Con

trac

tor

Hea

dcou

nt In

Dis

trib

uted

Lin

e It

ems

DC

E N

o.D

escr

iptio

n

2016

Est

imat

ed

Con

trac

tor

Hea

dcou

nt

2017

Est

imat

ed

Con

trac

tor

Hea

dcou

nt1

LT-2

-D-2

.18

Plan

ning

& D

esig

n Fo

r Col

d an

d D

ark

2LT

-2-D

-2.1

9Im

plem

ent C

old

and

Dar

k (R

epow

er S

ite)

3LT

-2-D

-2.2

0In

stal

l 12

kV S

ervi

ce L

ine

to P

ower

Tem

p Po

wer

Rin

g4

LT-2

-D-2

.21

Dra

in &

De-

Ener

gize

Non

-Ess

entia

l Sys

tem

s (D

EC P

roce

ss)

5LT

-2-D

-2.2

9Im

plem

ent C

ontro

l Roo

m M

odifi

catio

ns (C

omm

and

Cen

ter R

eloc

atio

n)6

Initi

al D

&D

Act

iviti

es S

ubto

tal

12(1

)T

BD

(2)

7 8LT

-2-D

-2.2

6In

stal

l Spe

nt F

uel P

ool S

yste

m M

odifi

catio

ns -

Uni

t 29

LT-2

-D-2

.27

Inst

all S

pent

Fue

l Poo

l Sys

tem

Mod

ifica

tions

- U

nit 3

10Sp

ent F

uel I

slan

ding

Sub

tota

l1

(1)

TB

D(2

)

11 12LT

-2-D

-2.2

2Se

lect

Dec

omm

issi

onin

g G

ener

al C

ontra

ctor

(DG

C)

6-

13 14SN

F-2-

D-8

.08

Des

ign

ISFS

I Exp

ansi

on, F

uel I

nspe

ctio

n, a

nd O

vers

ight

916

15 16SN

F-2-

D-A

M A

reva

Are

va IS

FSI R

elic

ensi

ng17

SNF-

2-D

-AM

Hol

tec1

Hol

tec

ISFS

I I&

M P

rogr

am D

evel

opm

ent

18IS

FSI A

ging

Man

agem

ent S

ubto

tal

1(1

)1

(1)

19 20SR

-1-D

-14.

01M

esa

Site

Pha

se I

and

II Si

te A

sses

smen

t and

Lea

se S

urre

nder

21SR

-2-D

-15.

09M

esa

Bui

ldin

gs -

Dem

o, M

aint

enan

ce22

Mes

a Si

te T

urno

ver

Subt

otal

1(1

)1

(1)

23 24LT

-3-D

-DC

ED

CE

Upd

ate

-1

25 26SR

-3-D

-16.

05O

btai

n C

EQA

Per

mit

& A

ppro

vals

1-

27 28SN

F-1-

D-7

.05

Cyb

er S

ecur

ity M

odifi

catio

ns4

129 30

Dis

trib

uted

Tot

al35

20

Not

es:

(1) E

stim

ated

hea

dcou

nt is

onl

y av

aila

ble

at th

e m

ajor

pro

ject

leve

l and

is n

ot b

roke

n ou

t by

indi

vidu

al D

CE

line

item

.(2

) Est

imat

ed h

eadc

ount

will

be

popu

late

d on

ce th

e in

form

atio

n is

ava

ilabl

e.

4 O

f 5

Page 78: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

Dat

a R

eque

st 1

3 - Q

uest

ion

1c.

2016

-201

7 R

ecor

ded

SCE

Lab

or C

osts

In S

ervi

ce L

evel

Agr

eem

ents

(201

4 D

olla

rs In

Mill

ions

, 100

% S

hare

)

2016

2017

Serv

ice

Lev

el A

gree

men

t

SCE

Lab

or

(Inc

ludi

ng

Ove

rhea

ds)

Aut

hori

zed

FTE

s (1)

SCE

Lab

or

(Inc

ludi

ng

Ove

rhea

ds)

Aut

hori

zed

FTE

s (1)

1A

udit

Serv

ices

-$

-0.

2$

2.0

2C

ontro

llers

--

0.6

4.2

3C

orpo

rate

Com

mun

icat

ions

0.2

1.0

0.1

1.0

4C

orpo

rate

Sec

urity

--

0.1

0.9

5D

ecom

mis

sion

ing

Fina

nce

0.7

5.0

0.4

5.0

6En

viro

nmen

tal P

olic

y-

-0.

20.

77

Envi

ronm

enta

l Ser

vice

s0.

10.

60.

42.

68

Hum

an R

esou

rces

--

0.7

4.7

9In

form

atio

n Te

chno

logy

1.6

14.0

1.2

13.0

10Le

gal

--

1.1

3.9

11Lo

cal P

ublic

Affa

irs-

-0.

10.

512

Rea

l Pro

perti

es0.

21.

00.

00.

313

Ris

k M

anag

emen

t-

-0.

00.

214

Supp

ly M

anag

emen

t0.

74.

00.

63.

015

Tax

--

0.0

0.3

16Tr

ansp

orta

tion

Serv

ices

--

(0.0

)-

17Tr

easu

rers

--

0.2

1.6

18T

otal

3.5

$25

.65.

9$

43.7

Gen

eral

Not

e:A

mou

nts m

ay n

ot ti

e du

e to

roun

ding

.

Not

e:(1

) FTE

s are

equ

al to

the

num

ber o

f FTE

s agr

eed

to in

Ser

vice

Lev

el A

gree

men

ts (i

.e.,

are

not b

ased

on

reco

rded

co

sts)

.

5 O

f 5

Page 79: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

Joint Application of Southern California Edison Company (U 338-E) and San Diego Gas & Electric Company (U 902-E) For the 2018 Nuclear Decommissioning Cost Triennial Proceeding

)))))) 

A.18-03-009 (Filed March 15, 2018)

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that, pursuant to the Commission’s Rules of Practice and Procedure, I have this day served a true copy of JOINT STATUS REPORT on all parties identified on the attached service list(s) A.18-03-009. Service was effected by one or more means indicated below:

☒ Transmitting the copies via e-mail to specified parties who have provided an e-mail address.

☒ Placing the copies in sealed envelopes and depositing such copies in the United States mail with first-class postage prepaid to the offices of the Commissioner(s) or other addressee(s).

ALJ Darcie Houck California Public Utilities Commission Division of ALJs 300 Capitol Mall, Suite 518 Sacramento, CA 95814

Executed on April 30, 2019, at Rosemead, California.

___/s/ Edith Leon________________ Edith Leon Legal Administrative Assistant SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY

2244 Walnut Grove Avenue Post Office Box 800 Rosemead, California 91770

Page 80: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

CPUC Home

CALIFORNIA PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSIONService Lists

PROCEEDING: A1803009 - EDISON AND SDG&E - F FILER: SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY LIST NAME: LIST LAST CHANGED: FEBRUARY 20, 2019

Download the Comma-delimited File About Comma-delimited Files

Back to Service Lists Index

Parties

WALKER A. MATTHEWS, III ALLEN K. TRIAL ATTORNEY AT LAW ATTORNEY SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY 2244 WALNUT GROVE AVENUE / PO BOX 800 8330 CENTURY PARK COURT ROSEMEAD, CA 91770 SAN DIEGO, CA 92123 FOR: SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY FOR: SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY

MATTHEW FREEDMAN JOHN L. GEESMAN ATTORNEY ATTORNEY THE UTILITY REFORM NETWORK DICKSON GEESMAN LLP 785 MARKET STREET, 14TH FL. 1999 HARRISON STREET, STE. 2000 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94103 OAKLAND, CA 94612 FOR: TURN FOR: ALLIANCE FOR NUCLEAR RESPONSIBILITY

WILLIAM MAGUIRE CALIF PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION LEGAL DIVISION 300 Capitol Mall Sacramento, CA 95814 FOR: PUBLIC ADVOCATES OFFICE

Information Only

MRW & ASSOCIATES, LLC BRUCE LACY EMAIL ONLY LACY CONSULTING GROUP, LLC EMAIL ONLY, CA 00000 433 WILEY BLVD., NW CEDAR RAPIDS, IA 52405

Page 1 of 3CPUC - Service Lists - A1803009

4/30/2019https://ia.cpuc.ca.gov/servicelists/A1803009_85397.htm

Page 81: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

FOR: TURN

LAURA L. KRANNAWITTER DANIEL DOUGLASS CALIF PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION ATTORNEY MARKET STRUCTURE, COSTS AND NATURAL GAS DOUGLASS & LIDDELL 320 West 4th Street Suite 500 4766 PARK GRANADA, SUITE 209 Los Angeles, CA 90013 CALABASAS, CA 91302

CASE ADMINISTRATION SIMONE S. BRYAN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY PROJECT / PROGRAM ANALYST 8631 RUSH STREET SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY ROSEMEAD, CA 91770 2244 WALNUT GROVE AVE ROSEMEAD, CA 91770

DONALD KELLY, ESQ. CENTRAL FILES EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR SAN DIEGO GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY UTILITY CONSUMERS' ACTION NETWORK 8330 CENTURY PARK COURT, CP31E 3405 KENYON STREET, STE 401 SAN DIEGO, CA 92123 SAN DIEGO, CA 92110

EMMA D. SALUSTRO WENDY D. JOHNSON ATTORNEY REGULATORY CASE MGR SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY 8330 CENTURY PARK COURT, CP32D 8330 CENTURY PARK COURT, CP32F SAN DIEGO, CA 92123 SAN DIEGO, CA 92123 FOR: SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY

ROCHELLE BECKER DAVID PECK EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR CALIF PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION ALLIANCE FOR NUCLEAR RESPONSIBILITY PRESIDENT PICKER EMAIL ONLY ROOM 4108 EMAIL ONLY, CA 93406 505 VAN NESS AVENUE SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94102-3214

ERIC GREENE TRUMAN L. BURNS CALIF PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION CALIF PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION MARKET STRUCTURE, COSTS AND NATURAL GAS ENERGY COST OF SERVICE & NATURAL GAS BRA AREA 4-A ROOM 4205 505 VAN NESS AVENUE 505 VAN NESS AVENUE SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94102-3214 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94102-3214

YAKOV LASKO AMIE BURKHOLDER CALIF PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION BUCHALTER, A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION ENERGY COST OF SERVICE & NATURAL GAS BRA 55 SECOND STREET, STE. 1700 ROOM 4101 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94105 505 VAN NESS AVENUE SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94102-3214

CASE COORDINATION KELSEY PIRO PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY CASE MGR. PO BOX 770000; MC B9A, 77 BEALE STREET PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94105 77 BEALE STREET SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94105

Page 2 of 3CPUC - Service Lists - A1803009

4/30/2019https://ia.cpuc.ca.gov/servicelists/A1803009_85397.htm

Page 82: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE …...SDG&E to meet with Energy Division Staff and any interested parties to “develop protocols and guidance for recording staff

MIKE CADE JENNIFER POST BUCHALTER, A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY 55 SECOND STREET, SUITE 1700 PO BOX 770000, MAIL CODE B30A SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94105 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94177

LINDSEY HOW-DOWNING DARCIE HOUCK ATTORNEY CALIF PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION LAW OFFICES OF LINDSEY HOW-DOWNING EXECUTIVE DIVISION 3060 EL CERRITO PLAZA, NO. 175 300 Capitol Mall EL CERRITO, CA 94530 Sacramento, CA 95814

TOP OF PAGE BACK TO INDEX OF SERVICE LISTS

Page 3 of 3CPUC - Service Lists - A1803009

4/30/2019https://ia.cpuc.ca.gov/servicelists/A1803009_85397.htm