Bibliography on Responsibility

BIBLIOGRAPHY ON RESPONSIBILITY

KATE PECAROVICH*

This bibliography is an update to the bibliography included in "Freedomand Responsibility: Readings in Philosophy and Law," edited by HerbertMorris and published by Stanford University Press in 1961. The basic subjectis moral and legal responsibility, and the bibliography includes both booksand periodical articles. Since Professor Morris' bibliography includedcitations through 1960, the coverage of this bibliography is from 1961 to1985, and is extensive but not exhaustive. There is a vast amount of literatureavailable on this subject, discussing responsibility in particular types ofsituations and under particular types of circumstances, collectiveresponsibility, the responsibility of the state, the insanity defense, and othertopics. In order to narrow the field, I restricted inclusion to works on theresponsibility of the individual for his actions.

I

BOOKS

Adkins, Arthur W. H. Merit and Responsibility. A Study in Greek Values. Oxford:Clarendon Press, 1960.

Adler, Mortimer J. The Idea of Freedom. Vol. 2, A Dialectical Examination of theControversies about Freedom. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1961.

Allsopp, Bruce. Social Responsibility and the Responsible Society. Stocksfield,Northumberland, England and Boston: Oriel Press, 1984.

Arthur, John, and William H. Shaw, eds. Readings in Philosophy of Law.Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1984.

Ayer, A. J. "Free-will and Rationality." In Philosophical Subjects, edited by Z.Van Straaten. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1980.

Bentham, Jeremy. An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation.Edited byJ. H. Burns and H.L.A. Hart. London: Athlone Press, 1970.

Boas, George. "The Problem of Responsibility." In Essays in Legal History inHonor of Felix Frankfurter. Indianapolis: American Society for LegalHistory, 1966.

Bodenheimer, Edgar. Philosophy of Responsibility. Littleton, Colo.: F.B.Rothman, 1980.

Bodenheimer, Edgar. Treatise on Justice. New York: Philosophical Library,1967.

Copyright © 1986 by Law and Contemporary Problems* Assistant Head of Technical Services, Law Library, UCLA Law School.

LAW AND CONTEMPORARY PROBLEMS

Bree, Germaine. Camus and Sartre: Crisis and Commitment. New York:Delacorte Press, 1972.

Brodie, Michael, and Myles Brand, eds. Action and Responsibility. BowlingGreen, Ohio: Bowling Green State University, 1980.

Clark, Edwin Charles. An Analysis of Criminal Liability. Littleton, Colo.: F. B.Rothman, 1983.

Coleman, Lee. The Reign of Error: Psychiatry, Authority and Law. Boston:Beacon Press, 1984.

D'Angelo, Edward. The Problem of Freedom and Determinism. Columbia:University of Missouri Press, 1968.

Davis, Philip E. Moral Duty and Legal Responsibility. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1966.

Davis, Stephen T., ed. Encountering Evil. Atlanta: Knox Press, 1981.De George, Richard T., ed. Ethics and Society: Original Essays on Contemporary

Moral Problems. Garden City, N.Y.: Anchor, 1966.Dennett, Daniel Clement. Elbow Room: The Varieties of Free Will Worth Wanting.

Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1984.Denning, Alfred Thompson. Responsibility Before the Law. Jerusalem: Hebrew

University, 1961.Dworkin, Gerald, comp. Determinism, Free Will and Moral Responsibility.

Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1970.Easterbrook, James A. The Determinants of Free Will: A Psychological Analysis of

Responsible Adjustive Behavior. New York: Academic Press, 1978.Edwards, Rem Blanchard. Freedom, Responsibility and Obligation. The Hague:

Nijhoff, 1969.Emmet, Dorothy. Rules, Roles and Relations. New York: St. Martin's Press,

1966.Eterovich, Francis H. Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics: Commentary and Analysis.

Washington, D.C.: University Press of America, 1980.Feinberg, Joel. Doing and Deserving: Essays in the Theory of Responsibility.

Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1970.Feinberg, Joel. Harm to Others. Vol. 1, Moral Limits of the Criminal Law. New

York: Oxford University Press, 1984.Feinberg, Joel, ed. Reason and Responsibility. Belmont, Cal.: Wadsworth, 1981.Fingarette, Herbert. Mental Disabilities and Criminal Responsibility. Berkeley and

Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1979.Fingarette, Herbert. On Responsibility. New York: Basic Books, 1967.Fletcher, George. Rethinking Criminal Law. Boston: Little, Brown & Co.,

1978.Flynn, Thomas R. Sartre and Marxist Existentialism. Chicago: University of

Chicago Press, 1984.Follesdal, Dagfinn. "Sartre and Freedom." In Philosophy of Jean-Paul Sartre,

edited by Paul A. Schilpp. La Salle, Ill.: Open Court, 1981.

[Vol. 49: No. 3238

Page 237: Summer 1986]

Frank, Robert Worth. The Responsible Man: The Insights of the Humanities.Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1965.

Frankena, William K. Ethics. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1963.Frankfurt, Harry G. "What Are We Morally Responsible For?" In How Many

Questions?, edited by Leigh S. Cauman. Indianapolis: Hackett, 1983.Friedrich, Carl J., ed. Responsibility. New York: Liberal Arts Press, 1960.Gardner, Barbara Brudno. Moral Responsibility: A Modern Aristotelian Analysis.

New York: Pageant, 1965.Gerber, Rudolph Joseph. The Insanity Defense. Port Washington, N.Y.:

Associated Faculty Press, 1984.Glover, Jonathan. Responsibility. New York: Humanities Press, 1970.Gluckman, Max, ed. The Allocation of Responsibility. Manchester, England:

Manchester University Press, 1972.Goldman, Alvin I. A Theory of Human Action. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-

Hall, 1970.Gustafson, James M., comp. On Being Responsible: Issues in Personal Ethics. New

York: Harper & Row, 1968.Hacker, P. M. S., and J. Raz, eds. Law, Morality, and Society: Essays in Honour of

H.L.A. Hart. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1977.Fulton, James Street, Paul M. Van Buren, Arthur L. Harding, and R. Dale

Vliet. Responsibility in Law and in Morals. Edited by Arthur Leon Harding.Dallas: Southern Methodist University Press, 1960.

Harris, John. Violence and Responsibility. Boston: Routledge & Kegan Paul,1980.

Hart, H.L.A. Essays in Jurisprudence and Philosophy. Oxford: Clarendon Press;New York: Oxford University Press, 1983.

Hart, H.L.A. Punishment and Responsibility. Essays in the Philosophy of Law.Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1968.

Hayes, Susan C. and Robert Hayes. Simply Criminal. Sydney: The Law BookCo., 1984.

Harmann, Donald H. The Insanity Defense: Philosophical, Historical and LegalPerceptions. Springfield, Ill.: Thomas, 1983.

Hogan, T. Brian. Criminal Liability Without Fault: An Inaugural Lecture Deliveredin the University of Leeds on 2 December 1968. Leeds: Leeds University Press,1969.

Honderich, Ted, ed. Essays on Freedom of Action. Boston: Routledge & KeganPaul, 1978.

Horosz, William. The Crisis of Responsibility: Man As the Source of Accountability.Norman, Okla.: University of Oklahoma Press, 1975.

Hospers, John. Human Conduct: Problems in Ethics, 2d ed. New York: HarcourtBrace Jovanovich, 1982.

Howard, Colin. Strict Responsibility. London: Sweet & Maxwell, 1963.Hucker, Stephen J., Christopher D. Webster, and Mark H. Ben-Aron, eds.

Mental Disorder and Criminal Responsibility. Toronto: Butterworths, 1981.

BIBLIOGRAPHY


Inwagen, Peter Van. An Essay on Free Will. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1983.Irwin, Terence H. "Reason and Responsibility in Aristotle." In Essays on

Aristotle's Ethics, edited by Amelie Oksenberg Rorty. Berkeley and LosAngeles: University of California Press, 1981.

Jacobs, Francis Geoffrey. Criminal Responsibility. London: Weidenfeld andNicolson, 1971.

Keeton, George Williams. Guilty But Insane. London: MacDonald, 1961.Kenny, Anthony. Freewill and Responsibility. Boston: Routledge & Kegan Paul,

1978.Kneale, William. The Responsibility of Criminals. Oxford: Clarendon Press,

1967.Lamont, Corliss. Freedom of Choice Affirmed. New York: Horizon Press, 1967.Little, H. Ganse. Decision and Responsibility: A Wrinkle in Time. Tallahassee,

Fla.: American Academy of Religion, 1974.Margolis, Joseph. Psychotherapy and Morality: A Study of Two Concepts. New

York: Random House, 1966.Moberly, Walter H. Legal Responsibility and Moral Responsibility. Philadelphia:

Fortress Press, 1965.Moran, Richard. Knowing Right from Wrong. The Insanity Defense of Daniel

McNaughtan. New York: Free Press, 1981.Morris, Herbert. On Guilt and Innocence: Essays in Legal Philosophy and Moral

Psychology. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press,1976.

Morris, Norval. Madness and the Criminal Law. Chicago: University of ChicagoPress, 1982.

Murphy, Jeffrie G. Retribution, Justice and Therapy. Dordrecht, Holland: Reidel,1979.

Nissman, David M. Beating the Insanity Defense: Denying the License to Kill.Lexington, Mass.: Lexington Books, 1980.

Pearl, Leon. Four Philosophical Problems: God, Freedom, Mind and Perception. NewYork: Harper & Row, 1963.

Pears, David Francis, ed. Freedom and the Will. New York: Macmillan, 1963.Pols, Edward. The Acts of Our Being: A Reflection on Agency and Responsibility.

Amherst, Mass.: University of Massachusetts Press, 1982.Richman, Robert J. God, Free Will and Morality: Prolegomena to a Theory of

Practical Reasoning. Dordrecht, Holland and Boston: Reidel, 1983.Roberts, Moira. Responsibility and Practical Freedom. New York: Cambridge

University Press, 1965.Ross, Alf. On Guilt, Responsibility, and Punishment. Berkeley and Los Angeles:

University of California Press, 1975.Ross, Stephen David. The Nature of Moral Responsibility. Detroit: Wayne State

University Press, 1973.Rychlak, Joseph F. Discovering Free Will and Personal Responsibility. New York:

Oxford University Press, 1979.

240 [Vol. 49: No. 3


Sartre, Jean Paul. Of Human Freedom. Edited by Wade Baskin. New York:Philosophical Library, 1966.

Schoeck, Helmut, and James W. Wiggins, eds. Psychiatry and Responsibility.Princeton: Van Nostrand, 1962.

Semin, G. R. The Accountability of Conduct: A Social Psychological Analysis. NewYork: Academic Press in association with the European Association ofExperimental Social Psychology, 1983.

Shotter, John. Social Accountability and Selfhood. New York: Blackwell, 1984.Simon, Michael A. Understanding Human Action: Social Explanation and the Vision

of Social Science. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1982.Smith, J. C. Legal Obligation. London: Athlone Press, 1976.Tiles, J. E. "Ability, Possibility and Responsibility." In Contemporary

Philosophy, edited by Guttorm Floistad. Boston: Nijhoff, 1982.Trusted, Jennifer. Free Will and Responsibility. Oxford: Oxford University

Press, 1984.Watson, Gary, ed. Free Will. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1982.White, Alan R., ed. The Philosophy of Action. London: Oxford University Press,

1968.White, Michael J. Agency and Integrality. Philosophical Theories in the Ancient

Discussions of Determinism and Responsibility. Boston: Reidel, 1985.Williams, Clifford. Free Will and Determinism. A Dialogue. Indianapolis:

Hackett, 1980.Young, Robert. Freedom, Responsibility, and God. London: Macmillan, 1975.Zink, Sidney, The Concepts of Ethics. New York: St. Martin's Press, 1962.

II

ARTICLES

Anderson, Thomas C. "Is a Sartrean Ethics Possible?" Philosophy Today 14(1970): 116-40.

Antony, Louise. "Why We Excuse." Tulane Studies in Philosophy 28 (1979): 63-70.

Arrington, Robert L. "Practical Reason, Responsibility, and the Psychopath."Journal for the Theory of Social Behavior 9 (1979): 71-80.

Atwell, John E. "The Accordion Effect Thesis." Philosophical Quarterly 19(1969): 337-42.

Atwell, John E. "Schopenhauer's Account of Moral Responsibility." PacificPhilosophical Quarterly 61 (1980): 396-410.

Audi, Robert. "Moral Responsibility, Freedom, and Compulsion." AmericanPhilosophical Quarterly 11 (1974): 1-14.

Baker, Brenda. "Acting Under Duress." Canadian Journal of Philosophy 3(1974): 515-23.

Baldwin, Thomas. "Foresight and Responsibility." Philosophy 54 (1979): 347-60.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

242 LAW AND CONTEMPORARY PROBLEMS [Vol. 49: No. 3

Barnhart, J. E. "Democracy as Responsibility." Journal of Value Inquiry 3(1969): 281-90.

Basoff, Bruce. "Free Will and Determinism." Journal of Existentialism 4 (1964):259-62.

Bates, Stanley. "The Responsibility of Random Collections." Ethics 81(1971): 343-49.

Bayles, Michael D. "Character, Purpose, and Criminal Responsibility." Lawand Philosophy 1 (1982): 5-20.

Bazelon, David L. "Concept of Responsibility." Georgetown Law Journal 53(1964): 5-18.

Bazelon, David L. "The Dilemma of Criminal Responsibility." Kentucky LawJournal 72 (1984): 263-77.

Bazelon, David L. "Morality of the Criminal Law." Southern California LawReview 49 (1976): 385-405.

Beardsley, Elizabeth L. "Determinism and Moral Perspectives." Philosophyand Phenomenological Research 21 (1960): 1-20.

Becker, Lawrence C. "Determinism As a Rhetorical Problem." Philosophy andRhetoric 4 (1971): 20-28.

Bedau, Hugo Adam. "Rough Justice: The Limits of Novel Defenses: Excusesand Justifications, Mitigations and Exculpations." Hastings Center Report 8(1978): 8-11.

Belaief, Lynne. "Responsibility and Conscience." Philosophy Today 13 (1969):60-79.

Benditt, Theordore M. "Liability for Failing to Rescue." Law and Philosophy 1(1981): 391-418.

Benedek, Istvan. "Freedom and Schizophrenia." Metamedicine 3 (1982): 337-42.

Benjamin, Martin. "Can Moral Responsibility be Collective andNondistributive?" Social Theory and Practice 4 (1976): 93-106.

Bernstein, Mark. "Moral Responsibility and Free Will." Southern Journal ofPhilosophy 19 (1981): 1-10.

Berofsky, Bernard. "The Metaphysics of Freedom." Journal of ChinesePhilosophy 4 (1977): 161-86.

Binavince, E. S. "Ethical Foundation of Criminal Liability." Fordham LawReview 33 (1964): 1-38.

Blatz, Charles W. "Accountability and Answerability." Journal for the Theory ofSocial Behavior 2 (1972): 101-20.

Blizek, William L. "The Social Concept of Responsibility." Southern Journal ofPhilosophy 9 (1971): 107-12.

Blumberg, David. "Determinism and Moral Responsibility." Journal of ValueInquiry 5 (1971): 207-11.

Blumenfeld, David and Gerald Dworkin. "Necessity, Contingency, andPunishment." Philosophical Studies 16 (1965): 91-93.

Page 237: Summer 19861 BIBLIOGRAPHY 243

Blumfeld, David. "The Principle of Alternate Possibilities." Journal ofPhilosophy 68 (1971): 339-44.

Bondeson, William. "Aristotle on Responsibility for One's Character and thePossibility of Character Change." Phronesis 19 (1974): 59-65.

Boonin, Leonard. "Guilt, Shame and Morality." Journal of Value Inquiry 17(1983): 295-304.

Brady, James B. "State Responsibility." Philosophical and PhenomenologicalResearch 33 (1973): 408-11.

Branden, N. "Free Will, Moral Responsibility and the Law." SouthernCalifornia Law Review 42 (1969): 264-91.

Brett, P. "Strict Responsibility: Possible Solutions." Modern Law Review 37(1974): 417-38.

Bronaugh, Richard N. "Freedom As the Absence of an Excuse." Ethics 74(1964): 161-73.

Brown, B. "'Ordinary Man' in Provocation: Anglo-Saxon Attitudes and'Unreasonable Non-Englishman.' " International and Comparative LawQuarterly 13 (1964): 203-35.

Bulmash, Kathleen Jones. "The Irony of the Insanity Defense: A Theory ofRelativity." Journal of Psychology and Law 10 (1982): 285-308.

Campbell, Robert. "Duress and Responsibility for Action." Journal of AppliedPhilosophy 1 (1984): 133-140.

Carr, J. L., and F. E. Linn. "Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity." California StateBar Journal 39 (1964): 349-357.

Cherry, Christopher. "The Limits of Defeasibility." Analysis 34 (1974):101-8.

Clarke, M. J. "Impact of Social Science on Conceptions of Responsibility."British Journal of Law and Society 2 (1975): 32-44.

Cohen, DavidJ. "Some Linguistic Associations of 'Responsibility.'" Dialogue20 (1977): 13-19.

Cohen, Stephen. "Rationality and Responsibility: A Central Thesis." PacificPhilosophical Quarterly 63 (1982): 75-85.

Coleman,Jules L. "Moral Theories of Torts: Their Scope and Limits." Parts1, 2. Law and Philosophy 1 (1982): 371-90; 2 (1983): 5-36.

ComptonJohnJ. "Responsibility and Agency." Southern Journal of Philosophy11 (1973): 83-89.

Conn, Walter E. "H. Richard Niebuhr On 'Responsibility.'" Thought 5(1976): 82-98.

Conn, Walter E. "Michael Polanyi: The Responsible Person." HeythropJournal 17 (1976): 31-49.

Crabb, J. H. "Fault and Faute." Inter-American Law Review 5 (1963): 151-61.Dagi, T. Forcht. "Cause and Culpability." Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1

(1976): 349-71.

Dahl, Norman 0. "Ought and Blameworthiness." Journal of Philosophy 64(1967): 418-28.


Dalrymple, Houghton B. "Determinism and Moral Responsibility."Proceedings of the New Mexico and West Texas Philosophical Society (1972): 65-70.

Dalrymple, Houghton B. "Wants, Actions and Responsibilities." SouthwestPhilosophical Studies 6 (1981): 48-54.

Davis, Frederick. "Strict Liability or Liability Based Upon Fault? AnotherLook." University of Dayton Law Review 10 (1984): 5-36.

Davis, Nancy. "Utilitarianism and Responsibility." Ratio 22 (1980): 15-35.Duff, Anthony. "Intention, Responsibility and Double Effect." Philosophical

Quarterly 32 (1982): 1-16.Duff, R. A. "Legal Obligation and the Moral Nature of Law." Juridical Review

(1980): 61-87.Dutile, Fernand N. and Thomas H. Singer. "What Now for the Insanity

Defense?" Notre Dame Law Review 58 (1983): 1104-11.Dworkin, Gerald. "Reply to MacIntyr's 'How Moral Agents Become

Ghosts.' " Synthese 53 (1982): 313-18.Eagle, Morris N. "Responsibility, Unconscious Motivation, and Social

Order." International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 6 (1983): 263-91.Eggerman, Richard W. "The Language of Soft Determinism." Southwest

Journal of Philosophy 7 (1976): 91-99.Ehman, Robert R. "Causality and Agency." Ratio 9 (1967): 140-54.Ehman, Robert R. "Moral Responsibility and the Nature of Self." Review of

Metaphysics 16 (1963): 442-49.Elliott, I. D. "Regina v. Jekyll, sub. nom. Hyde: Metaphors of the Divided

Self in Criminal Responsibility." Melbourne University Law Review 14(1984): 369-409.

Ennis, Robert H. "The Responsibility of a Cause." Philosophy of Education:Proceedings 29 (1973): 86-93.

Falk, G. J. "Sociological Approach to the 'Right-Wrong' Test in CriminalProcedure." Criminal Law Quarterly 7 (1964): 331-42.

Feinberg, Joel. "Duties, Rights, and Claims." American Philosophical Quarterly 3(1966): 137-44.

Feinberg,Joel. "Problematic Responsibility in Law and Morals." PhilosophicalReview 71 (1962): 340-51.

Fethe, Charles B. "Rationality and Responsibility." Personalist 53 (1972):193-98.

Fingarette, Herbert. "Criminal Insanity and Criminal Responsibility."Humanitas 9 (1973): 153-66.

Fingarette, Herbert. "Insanity and Responsibility." Inquiry 15 (1972): 6-29.Finkel, Norman J., and Steven R. Sabat. "Split-brain Madness: An Insanity

Defense Waiting to Happen." Law and Human Behavior 8 (1984): 225-52.Fischer, John Martin. "Incompatibilism." Philosophical Studies 43 (1983): 127-

37.

[Vol. 49: No. 3


Fischer, John Martin. "Responsibility and Control." Journal of Philosophy 79(1982): 24-40.

Fishman, N. W. "Law of Criminal Responsibility." Illinois Bar Journal 56(1968): 914-24.

Flynn, Thomas. "Vision, Responsibility, and Factual Belief in ExistentialistEthics." Journal of Chinese Philosophy 7 (1980): 27-36.

Frankena, William K. "J. D. Wild on Responsibility." Philosophical andPhenomenological Research 27 (1966): 90-96.

Frankfurt, Harry G. "Alternate Possibilities and Moral Responsibility."Journal of Philosophy 66 (1969): 829-39.

Frankfurt, Harry G. "Three Concepts of Free Action: Part 2." The AristotelianSociety Supp. Vol. 49 (1975): 113-25.

Frey, R. G. "Causal Responsibility and Contributory Causation." Philosophicaland Phenomenological Research 39 (1978): 106-19.

Gahringer, R. E. "Punishment and Responsibility." Journal of Philosophy 66(1969): 291-306.

Galloway, Donald. "Patterns of Trying: A Critique of Fletcher on CriminalAttempts." Queen's Law Journal 7 (1982): 232-52.

Gendin, Sidney. "Insanity and Criminal Responsibility." AmericanPhilosophical Quarterly 10 (1972): 99-110.

Gomberg, Paul. "Free Will As Ultimate Responsibility." American PhilosophicalQuarterly 15 (1978): 205-11.

Gontar, David P. "Permitting Harm: A Reply to Eric Mack." Southwest Journalof Philosophy 9 (1978): 15-22.

Gosselin, Phillip D. "Freedom and Moral Responsibility: A Reply to Hunter'sReply." Dialogue (Canada) 19 (1980): 572-74.

Gosselin, Phillip D. "Is There a Freedom Requirement for MoralResponsibility." Dialogue (Canada) 18 (1979): 289-306.

Gosselin, Phillip D. "Moral Responsibility and the Possibility of DoingOtherwise." Philosophy Research Archives 8 (1982): 499-512.

Graham, George. "Doing Something Intentionally and MoralResponsibility." Canadian Journal of Philosophy 16 (1981): 667-78.

Green, L. "Duties, Risks, Causation, Doctrines." Texas Law Review 41 (1962):42-74.

Green, 0. Harvey. "Killing and Letting Die." American Philosophy Quarterly 17(1980): 195-204.

Green, 0. Harvey. "Refraining and Responsibility." Tulane Studies inPhilosophy 28 (1979): 103-13.

Grenander, M. E. "The Fourfold Way: Determinism, Moral Responsibility,and Aristotelian Causation." Metamedicine 3 (1982): 375-96.

Gunn, John. "Questions of Responsibility and the Sutcliffe Case." Poly. LawReview (London) 7 (1982): 66-70.

Halberstam, Joshua. "Trying and Responsibility." Tulane Studies in Philosophy28 (1979): 115-24.

BIBLIOGRAPHY


Halper, T. " 'Responsibility': An Effort at Clarification." Loyola UniversityLaw Review (Los Angeles) 12 (1978): 7-35.

Halverson, William H. "Moral Freedom and Metaphysics." PhilosophicalForum (Pacific) 4 (1966): 61-70.

Handy, Rollo. "Determinism, Responsibility, and the Social Setting."Philosophical and Phenomenological Research 20 (1960): 469-76.

Hansen, Chad. "Freedom and Moral Responsibility in Confucian Ethics."Philosophy East and West 22 (1972): 169-86.

Harris, John. "Williams on Negative Responsibility and Integrity."Philosophical Quarterly 24 (1974): 265-73.

Hart, H.L.A. "Varieties of Responsibility." Law Quarterly Review 83 (1967):346-64.

Hausman, D. B. "Compatibilism Again." Canadian Journal of Philosophy 4(1975): 509-14.

Haydon, Graham. "On Being Responsible." Philosophical Quarterly 28 (1978):46-57.

Held, Virginia. "Can a Random Collection of Individuals Be MorallyResponsible?" Journal of Philosophy 67 (1970): 471-80.

Helm, Paul. "Hume on Exculpation." Philosophy 42 (1967): 265-71.Henderson, G. P. "Censure Under Control." Ratio 15 (1973): 44-56.Hertzberg, Lars. "Blame and Causality." Mind 84 (1975): 500-15.Hogan, T. B. "Crime, Punishment and Responsibility." Villanova Law Review

24 (1979): 690-705.Holborow, L. C. "Blame, Praise and Credit." Proceedings of the Aristotelian

Society 72 (1971-72): 85-100.Holdcroft, David. "A Plea for Excuses." Philosophy 44 (1969): 314-29.Horgan, Terence. "'Could,' Possible Worlds and Moral Responsibility."

Southern Journal of Philosophy 17 (1979): 345-58.Houlgate, Laurence D. "Knowledge and Responsibility." American

Philosophical Quarterly 5 (1968): 109-16.Hunter, J. F. M. "Acting Freely and Being Held Responsible." Dialogue

(Canada) 12 (1973): 233-45.Hunter, J. F. M. "Reply to Phillip Gosselin's 1979 'Dialogue' Criticism."

Dialogue (Canada) 19 (1980): 569-71.Inwagen, Peter Van. "Ability and Responsibility." The Philosophical Review 87

(1978): 201-24.Jarboe, Mark A. "Justice Otis and the Individual's Responsiblities: Balancing

of Policy and Culpability." Hamline Law Review 6 (1983): 23-28.Jones, David H. "Neurosis and Moral Responsibility." Philosophy in Context 12

(1982): 42-50.Jones, Gary E. "Sartre, Consciousness, and Responsibility." Philosophical and

Phenomenological Research 41 (1980): 234-37.Joseph, James A. "Response to Herbert W. Schneider." Philosophy of

Education Society Proceedings 25 (1969): 74-76.

[Vol. 49: No. 3

Page 237: Summer 1986] BIBLIOGRAPHY 247

Joseph, Joanne M., and James T. Tedeschi. "Perceived Responsibility andthe Least of Evils Principles." Law and Human Behavior 7 (1983): 53-58.

Julian, M. V. "Determinist's Perspective of Criminal Responsibility." AlbertaLaw Review 8 (1970): 376-88.

Kaplan, Leonard V. "The Mad and the Bad: An Inquiry into the Dispositionof the Criminally Insane." Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 2 (1977): 244-304.

Kaplan, Leonard V. "Punishment and Responsibility in Aquarius." BuffaloLaw Review 20 (1970): 181-230.

Kaufman, Arnold S. "Ability." Journal of Philosophy 60 (1963): 537-50.

Kekes, John. "Freedom." Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 61 (1980): 368-83.

Kleinig, John. "Consent As a Defense in Criminal Law." Archivfur Rechts- undSozialphilosophie (Berlin) 65 (1979): 329-46.

Kornblith, Hilary. "Justified Belief and Epistemically Responsible Action."Philosophy Review 92 (1983): 33-48.

Ladd, John. "The Ethical Dimensions of the Concept of Action." Journal ofPhilosophy 61 (1965): 633-44.

Lakoff, Sanford A. "Moral Responsibility and the 'Galilean Imperative.'"Ethics 91 (1980): 100-16.

Lang, Berel. "The Neurotic as Moral Agent." Philosophical andPhenomenological Research 29 (1968): 216-31.

Lilly, J. Robert, and Richard A. Ball. "A Critical Analysis of the ChangingConcept of Criminal Responsibility." Criminology 20 (1982): 169-84.

Lloyd-Bostock, S. "Ordinary Man, and the Psychology of Attributing Causesand Responsibility." Modern Law Review 42 (1979): 143-68.

Luizzi, Vincent. "The Bounds of Liability and Responsibility." Journal ofSocial Philosophy 14 (1983): 21-33.

Lynch, A. C. E. "The Mental Element in the Actus Reus." Law QuarterlyReview 98 (1982): 109-42.

Lyons, P. "Responsibility Without Individual Responsibility?: TheControversy over Defining Legal Insanity." University of Colorado LawReview 45 (1974): 391-435.

Lyons, R. "Intention and Foresight in Law." Mind 85 (1976): 84-89.

Mack, Eric. "Bad Samaritanism and the Causation of Harm." Philosophy andPublic Affairs 9 (1980): 230-60.

Mackinnon, Peter. "Making Sense of Attempts." Queen's Law Journal 7 (1982):253-73.

Mandelbaum, Maurice. "Determinism and Moral Responsibility." Ethics 70(1960): 204-19.

Margolis, Emanuel. "In Defense of the Insanity Defense." Connecticut BarJournal 58 (1984): 389-409.

Matthews, Gareth B. "On Being Immoral in a Dream." Philosophy 56 (1981):47-54.


Measor, Nicholas. "Persons, Indeterminacy and Responsibility." PhilosophicalReview 87 (1978): 414-22.

Mellema, Gregory. "On Being Fully Responsible." American PhilosophicalQuarterly 21 (1984): 189-94.

Mendus, Susan. "Personal Identity and Moral Responsibility." Locke News(1978): 75-86.

Menkiti, I. A. "Criminal Responsibility and the Mentally Ill." Journal of ValueInquiry 14 (1980): 181-94.

Miethe, Terance D. "The Impact of Victim Provocation on Judgments ofLegal Responsibility: An Experimental Assessment." Journal of Criminal

Justice 12 (1984): 407-14.Mooney, Edward F. "Care, Guilt, and Responsibility: Notes on 'The

Stranger.' " Humanities 9 (1973): 173-85.Moore, M. S. "Responsibility and the Unconscious." Southern California Law

Review 53 (1980): 1563-1675.Morillo, Carolyn R. "Comments on Gorr's and Green's 'Omissions.'"

Tulane Studies on Philosophy 28 (1979): 125-34.Morris, Grant H. "Dealing Responsibly with the Criminally Irresponsible."

Arizona State Law Journal (1982): 855-99.Morris, Norval. "The Criminal Responsibility of the Mentally Ill." Syracuse

Law Review 33 (1982): 477-531.Morse, Judith A., and Gregory K. Thoreson. "Criminal Law: Abolishing the

Volitional Prong of the Insanity Defense." Notre Dame Law Review 60(1984): 177-90.

Morse, Stephen J. "Excusing the Crazy: The Insanity DefenseReconsidered." Southern California Law Review 58 (1985): 777-836.

Morse, Stephen J. "Failed Explanations and Criminal Responsibility:Experts and the Unconscious." Virginia Law Review 68 (1982): 971-1084.

Mueller, G. 0. W. "'Devil May Care'-Or Should We? A Reexamination ofCriminal Negligence." Kentucky Law Journal 55 (1966): 29-49.

Mullock, P. "Responsibility, Propensity and Choice." Mercer Law Review 16(1964): 1-11.

Murphy, Jeffrie G. "Moral Death: A Kantian Essay on Psychopathy." Ethics82 (1972): 284-98.

Nesbitt, W., and S. Candlish. "On Not Being Able to Do Otherwise." Mind82 (1973): 321-30.

Norrie, Alan. "Freewill, Determinism and Criminal Justice." Legal Studies 3(1983): 60-73.

Northrup, Judith A. "Guilty But Mentally Ill: Broadening the Scope ofCriminal Responsibility." Ohio State Law Journal 44 (1983): 797-820.

O'Connor, John. "Psychology, Moral Philosophy, and Determinism." Zygon4 (1969): 44-52.

Oddie, Graham, and Pavel Tichy. "The Logic of Freedom andResponsibility." Studia Logica 41 (1982): 227-48.

[Vol. 49: No. 3

Page 237: Summer 1986] BIBLIOGRAPHY 249

O'Doherty, E. F. "Men, Criminals and Responsibility." Irish Jurist (NewSeries) 1 (1966): 285-91.

Oppenheim, Felix. "'Constraints on Freedom' as a Descriptive Concept."Ethics 95 (1985): 305-9.

Paske, Gerald M. "Responsibility and the Incompatibility Principle."Personalist 51 (1970): 477-85.

Perkins, Rollin M. "Criminal Liability Without Fault: A Disquieting Trend."Iowa Law Review 68 (1983): 1067-81.

Pitcher, George. "Hart on Action and Responsibility." Philosophical Review 69(1960): 226-35.

Pols, Edward. "The Conditions of Ontic Responsibility." Review ofMetaphphysics 35 (1981): 297-320.

Potter, Nelson T. "The Social and the Causal Concepts of Responsibility."Southern Journal of Philosophy 10 (1972): 97-99.

Pritchard, Michael S. "Responsibility, Understanding, and Psychopathology."Monist 58 (1974): 630-45.

Radcliff, Peter. "Matson and Hospers on Free Will and Responsibility."Philosophical and Phenomenological Research 32 (1971): 250-58.

Rankin, Nani L. "Metaphysical Freedom and the Determination ofResponsibility." Journal of Value Inquiry 1 (1967-68): 184-89.

Rankin, Nani L. "The Unmoved Agent and the Ground of Responsibility."Journal of Philosophy 64 (1967): 403-8.

Richman, Robert J. "Responsibility and the Causation of Actions." AmericanPhilosophical Quarterly 6 (1969): 186-97.

Roberts, Lawrence D . "Indeterminism, Chance and Responsibility." Ratio13 (1971): 195-99.

Robinson, Paul H. "Element Analysis in Defining Criminal Liability: TheModel Penal Code and Beyond." Stanford Law Review 35 (1983): 681-761.

Robinson, Paul H. "Imputed Criminal Liability." Yale Law Journal 93 (1984):609-76.

Rolston, Holmes. "Schlick's Responsible Man." Philosophical andPhenomenological Research 36 (1975): 261-67.

Rotenstreich, Nathan. "Historical Inevitability and Human Responsibility."Philosophical and Phenomenological Research 23 (1963): 380-96.

Sadoff, R. L. "Tortious Liability of the Insane: A Psychiatric Evaluation."Pennsylvania Bar Association Quarterly 39 (1967): 73-83.

Sankowski, Edward. "Responsibility of Persons for Their Emotions."Canadian Journal of Philosophy 7 (1977): 829-40.

Sankowski, Edward. "The Sense of Responsibility and the Justifiability ofEmotions." Southwest Journal of Philosophy 13 (1975): 215-33.

Schleifer, Michael. "The Responsibility of the Psychopath." Philosophy 45(1970): 231-32.

250 LAW AND CONTEMPORARY PROBLEMS [Vol. 49: No. 3

Schneewind, J. B. "Responsibilities and Liability." Journal of Philosophy 62(1965): 649-50.

Schoeman, Ferdinand. "Responsibility and the Problem of Induced Desires."Philosophical Studies 34 (1978): 293-301.

Scott-Taggart, M. J. "It Makes No Difference Whether Or Not I Do It: Part2." The Aristotelian Society. Supp. Vol. 49 (1975): 191-209.

Sellars, Wilfrid. "Reply to Alan Donogan On 'My Views on Determinism andFreedom.' " Philosophical Studies 27 (1975): 149-84.

Silver, Stuart B., and Michael K. Spodak. "A Retrospective Assessment of

Criminal Responsibility by the Psychiatric Staff of the Clifton T. PerkinsHospital Center." American Academic of Psychiatry and Law Bulletin 11(1983): 383-91.

Slovenko, Ralph. "The Meaning of Mental Illness in CriminalResponsibility." Journal of Legal Medicine 5 (1984): 1-61.

Slowinski, Kenneth. "Criminal Responsibility: Changes in the InsanityDefense and the 'Guilty But Mentally Ill' Response." Washburn Law

Journal 21 (1982): 515-54.

Smith, Steven D. "Rhetoric and Rationality in the Law of Negligence."

Minnesota Law Review 69 (1984): 277-323.

Snyder, 0. C. "Criminal Responsibility." Duke Law Journal (1962): 204-18.

Srzednicki, J. T. J. "Freedom and Capacity." Philosophy 59 (1984): 343-48.

Stalley, R. F. "Mental Health and Individual Responsibility in Plato's'Republic.'" Journal of Value Inquiry 15 (1981): 109-24.

Stamey, Joseph D. "Determinism, Indeterminism and Responsibility."Southwest Philosophical Studies 2 (1977): 14-20.

Stern, Axel. "The Two Kinds of Moral Responsibility." Journal of the British

Society for Phenomenology 3 (1972): 126-34.

Stern, Lawrence. "Freedom, Blame, and Moral Community." Journal ofPhilosophy 71 (1974): 72-84.

Stocker, M. "Responsibility Especially for Beliefs." Mind 91 (1982): 398-417.

Thalberg, Irving. "Hart on Strict Liability and Excusing Conditions." Ethics

81 (1971): 150-60.

Thomson, Judith Jarvis. "Remarks on Causation and Liability." Philosophyand Public Affairs 13 (1984): 101-33.

Usdin, G. L. "Criminal Responsibility and the Psychiatrist." American CriminalLaw Quarterly 3 (1965): 116-23.

Vernon, Richard. "Unintended Consequences." Political Theory 7 (1979): 57-73.

Vold, L. "Legally Responsible Cause Flexibly Construed." Vanderbilt Law

Review 19 (1966): 285-302.

Walker, Owen S. "Why Should Irresponsible Offenders Be Excused?"Journal of Philosophy 66 (1969): 279-90.


Walsh, W. H. "Pride, Shame, and Responsibility." Philosophical Quarterly 20(1970): 1-13.

Walter, Edward, and Arthur Minton. "Soft Determinism, Freedom, andRationality." Personalist 56 (1975): 364-84.

Walton, Douglas N. "Omissions and Other Negative Actions." Metamedicine1 (1980): 305-24.

Walton, Douglas N. "Philosophical Perspectives on the Insanity Defense."The Human Context 7 (1976): 546-60.

Weil, Vivian M. "Neurophysiological Determinism and Human Action."Mind 89 (1980): 90-95.

Weinrib, Ernest J. "Toward a Moral Theory of Negligence Law." Law andPhilosophy 2 (1983): 37-62.

Weinryb, Elazar. "Omissions and Responsibility." Philosophical Quarterly 30(1980): 1-18.

Wheeler, Arthur M. "Margolis on Responsibility in Psychotherapy." MentalHygiene 53 (1969): 309-10.

White, Alan. "Responsibility, Liability, Excuses and Blame." StudiInternazionali Filosofia (Torino, Italy) 5 (1973): 63-68.

White, Steven. "Rehabilitating Daniel McNaughtan: Richard Moran's'Knowing Right from Wrong.'" Criminal Law Journal 6 (1982): 203-20.

Whittier, Duane H. "Causality and the Self." Monist 49 (1963): 290-303.Will, Frederick L. "Intention, Error, and Responsibility." Journal of Philosophy

61 (1964): 171-78.Wolf, Susan. "The Importance of Free Will." Mind 90 (1981): 386-405.Zimmerman, Michael J. "Moral Responsibility, Freedom and Alternate

Possibilities." Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 63 (1982): 243-54.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Documents

Bibliography on Responsibility