25
MIKHAIL BLUMENKRANTZ FROM NIMROD TO THE GRAND INQUISITOR: THE PROBLEM OF THE DEMONISATION OF FREEDOM IN THE WORK OF DOSTOEVSKIJ KEY WORDS: Freedom, Dostoevskij, Christian World View , Stavrogin, Kierkegaard A cultural cri sis begins with the n ecrosis of the spirit and its degener- ation into a hard-set system of dogmas; it ends with the destruction of the hierarchical vertical and its replacement by the historical horizontal of collectively or individually chosen values whose characteristics are wholly conditioned by social norms and prac- tice. Tillich clearly saw the danger of this in relation to the present era civilisation pted in favour of s~ularisation. That was a great and very necessary decision . t dethroned the Church - the Chur ch having establis hed tself by the mig ht of oppression and prejudice. It sanctified nd fill ed ith meaning our d~ly life and labour; but it repudiated those profound things symbolised by religion: he feeling of the inexhaustible ystca of life he penetration nto the ultimate meaning of existence and the invincible power of unconditional devotion. Such things should not be repudiated. If we turn them away in their godly forms they will return in satanic forms: and so now in the declining centu ry of our s~ularise~ l orld w e have becom e witne sses o the most monstrous nlanifestation s f those demoni c forms; we have seen further into the depths of evi l Sa n mo st previous generat ions ... I Denial of the hierarchical principle in accordance with Sartre's thesis there are as many truths as there are people, or the supplant- ing of the cosmic hierarchy by the false hierarchy of popular ideology, leads to the demonisation of human existence and the destruction of the spiritual basis of culture. Man does not attain personal virtue by a 'move forwards,' but by rising above that plane where one moves 'forwards' or 'backwards.' Forward movement is possible even in darkness, and it may be that the darkness entices us by the very supplant ing of true 'attainments' by movement back and forth. 'z At the very beginning of this century Buber warned of the threat of the demonic reincarnation of contemporary culture: Studies in East Europ ean Thought 48: 231-254, 1996.

Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 1/24

Page 2: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 2/24

Page 3: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 3/24

Page 4: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 4/24

Page 5: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 5/24

Page 6: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 6/24

Page 7: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 7/24

Page 8: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 8/24

Page 9: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 9/24

Page 10: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 10/24

Page 11: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 11/24

Page 12: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 12/24

Page 13: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 13/24

Page 14: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 14/24

Page 15: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 15/24

Page 16: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 16/24

Page 17: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 17/24

Page 18: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 18/24

Page 19: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 19/24

Page 20: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 20/24

Page 21: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 21/24

Page 22: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 22/24

Page 23: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 23/24

Page 24: Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

8/13/2019 Blumenkrantz, M.-from Nimrod to the Grand Inquisitor

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/blumenkrantz-m-from-nimrod-to-the-grand-inquisitor 24/24