Upload
laneymasters
View
219
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/13/2019 BrookingsReport NVLegislature Damore Revised
1/14
!"##$%&'( *#+&,-%& ./(, 0 1/2/34/" 5678 1
!"#$%&'%( *+,-./0% 1/#$"$234/('+%$5 60'+0'-'/37 8#/0#'/9 +:
-./ ;;-.
*/33'+% +: -./ 1/#$"$
8/13/2019 BrookingsReport NVLegislature Damore Revised
2/14
2 !"##$%&'( *#+&,-%& ./(, 0 1/2/34/" 5678
=$>5/ ?7 *+,-./0% 1/#$"$
8/13/2019 BrookingsReport NVLegislature Damore Revised
3/14
!"##$%&'( *#+&,-%& ./(, 0 1/2/34/" 5678 3
Y/"D-G(C ,D/ 3#(, (%'&%H%2-&, E/'%(E-,%#& H#" %&2"/-(%&' -22#+&,-4%E%,BC 9!7a6C S-(
K/,#/F 4B Z#K/"" I-&F#K-E= QD/ E/'%(E-,%#& 2"/-,/( ,D/ P/'%(E-,%K/ d#33%,,// #&
Z#K/"&3/&,-E >K/"(%'D, -&F 922#+&,-4%E%,B S%,D ,D/ -+,D#"%,B ,# 3#&%,#" -&F
%&K/(,%'-,/ E#2-E -&F (,-,/ '#K/"&3/&,-E /&,%,%/( F+"%&' ,D/ %&,/"%3 (/((%#&= 9, ,D/ (,-",
#H ,D/ O_,D
P/'%(E-,%K/ I/((%#& %& 567aC E/'%(E-,#"( S%EE D-K/ ,D/ #GG#",+&%,B ,# #K/""%F/
,D/ Z#K/""L( K/,# -&F /3G#S/" ,D/%" 4#FB S%,D %&2"/-(/F #K/"(%'D, 2-G-2%,B=
>,D/" 4%EE( 4/'%& ,# "/H#"3 J/K-F-L( -&,%V+-,/F %&(,%,+,%#&( ,# 3#"/ /HH/2,%K/EB (/"K/
,D/ (,-,/L( %&2"/-(%&'EB +"4-& -&F F%K/"(/ G#G+E-,%#& -&F -EE/K%-,/ F/2-F/( #H %&/V+%,%/(
%& ,D/ 2#EE/2,%#& -&F F%(,"%4+,%#& #H ,-R "/K/&+/= .%,D "/(G/2, ,# "/K/&+/ "/H#"3C IA?7a
X#"%'%&-EEB G-((/F %& ,D/ Oc,D
(/((%#& -&F V+-E%HB%&' H#" ,D/ 567b 4-EE#,[ -3/&F( ,D/
J/K-F- d#&(,%,+,%#& ,# /E%3%&-,/ ,D/ 2-G #& ,D/ &/, G"#2//F( #H 3%&/"-E( ,-R -&F
"/H#"3%&' ,D/ F%(,"%4+,%#& #H ,D/(/ "/K/&+/(=5 9!c_ "/(,"+2,+"/( -EE#2-,%#&( H"#3 ,D/
P#2-E Z#K/"&3/&, Q-R 1%(,"%4+,%#& 922#+&, X,D/ dN,-R[ "/(+E,%&' %& 3#"/ /V+%,-4E/
-GG"#G"%-,%#&( ,# I#+,D/"& J/K-F-C SD%E/ 9!a68 /-(/( 1%EE#&L( ?+E/ E%3%,-,%#&( #& D#SE#2-E '#K/"&3/&,( 3-&-'/ ,D/%" 4+F'/,( -&F "/(/"K/(e - "/H#"3 ,D-, S%EE G"#K%F/ J#",D
P-( :/'-( S%,D HE/R%4%E%,B ,# 2#&,%&+/ H+&F%&' 2"%,%2-E (/"K%2/(=
QD/ E-(, ,S# Z#K/"&-&2/ 4%EE( ] IA?_ -&F I!855 ]%3G"#K/ I#+,D/"& J/K-F-L( -4%E%,B ,#
(D-G/ (,-,/ G#E%2B= IA?_ -3/&F( ,D/ J/K-F- d#&(,%,+,%#& ,# G"#K%F/ H#" -&&+-E "/'+E-"
E/'%(E-,%K/ (/((%#&(=8 I#+,D/"& J/K-F- 4/&/H%,( H"#3 - P/'%(E-,+"/ S%,D %&2"/-(/F
2-G-2%,B %& ,S# S-B(= Q -&F
%,( f7=5 4%EE%#& 4+F'/, S%EE 2#&,%&+/ ,# 4/ #K/"(//& 4B - 4#-"F E/F 4B &N,"-&(G#",-,%#&
/RG/",( -&F ,D-, (%'&%H%2-&,EB +&F/"S/%'D,( "/G"/(/&,-,%#& H#" I#+,D/"& J/K-F-=
EF?A $%" G'(./0 H",&$-'+%
Y/"D-G( G#E%2B -"/- "/2/%K/F 3#"/ -,,/&,%#& F+"%&' ,D/ 5678 (/((%#& ,D-& /F+2-,%#&=
*#(, (%'&%H%2-&,EBC I!a6bC SD%2D %&2E+F/( /E/3/&,( #H 9!7c8 -&F I!7_5C G"#K%F/( N H#"
,D/ H%"(, ,%3/ %& ,D/ (,-,/L( D%(,#"B N H+&F%&' H#" @&'E%(D P-&'+-'/ P/-"&/"( X@PP[ -&F
/(,-4E%(D/( ,D/ @&'E%(D *-(,/"B d#+&2%E ,# #K/"(// @PP G#E%2B= I!a6b -E(# G"#K%F/(
8/13/2019 BrookingsReport NVLegislature Damore Revised
4/14
4 !"##$%&'( *#+&,-%& ./(, 0 1/2/34/" 5678
H+&F%&' H#" /-"EB 2D%EFD##F /F+2-,%#& -&F H+EENF-B $%&F/"'-",/& %& (2D##E( (/"K%&' (#3/
#H ,D/ (,-,/L( 3#(, %3G#K/"%(D/F &/%'D4#"D##F(= 9!5 XG-((/F F+"%&' ,D/ 5O,D
IG/2%-E
I/((%#&[ 2#F%H%/( 2E-(( (%T/ ,/-2D%&' "-,%#( H#" MN8 '"-F/(=
d#EE/2,%K/EBC ,D/(/ "/H#"3( 4/'%& ,# -E%'& J/K-F-L( /F+2-,%#&-E G#E%2B -&F H+&F%&' S%,D
,D/ (,-,/L( "-G%FEB 2D-&'%&' F/3#'"-GDB= ;& G-",%2+E-"C I!a6b -GG"#G"%-,/( &/-"EB fb6
3%EE%#& H#" ,D/ 4%/&&%+3 ,# %3GE/3/&, ,D/(/ G#E%2/( %& I#+,D/"& J/K-F- %& -FF%,%#& ,#
,D/ (,-,/ -GG"#G"%-,%#& ,# ,D/ dE-"$ d#+&,B I2D##E 1%(,"%2, XI!a55[=
9E,D#+'D ,D/"/ S/"/ 4%EE F"-H, "/V+/(,( (//$%&' ,# 2#F%HB ,D/ "/H#"3( ,# ,D/ H+&F%&'
#H D%'D/" /F+2-,%#& /&F#"(/F 4B ,D/ I!8Ob X5677[ %&,/"%3 (,+FB 2#33%,,//C 4+F'/,
&/'#,%-,%#&( B%/EF/F ,D/ g&%K/"(%,B #H J/K-F-C P-( :/'-( XgJP:[C J/K-F- I,-,/ d#EE/'/
XJId[C -&F ,D/ d#EE/'/ #H I#+,D/"& J/K-F- XdIJ[ "#+'DEB f8a 3%EE%#& #K/" ,D/ 4%/&&%+3
%& %&2"/-(/F D%'D/" /F+2-,%#& H+&F%&' X"/E-,%K/ ,# 5678[ 4B 3-$%&' (%'&%H%2-&, 2D-&'/( ,#
Z#K/"" I-&F#K-EL( @R/2+,%K/ !+F'/,=b
.D%E/ ,D/ 5678N7a 4+F'/, 4/'%&( ,# -FF"/(( E#&'N(,-&F%&' "/'%#&-E #G/"-,%&' %&/V+%,%/(
%& ,D/ H+&F%&' #H D%'D/" /F+2-,%#&C #,D/" ,D-& "/F%"/2,%&' f7=5 3%EE%#& H"#3 ,D/ @(,-,/
Q-R 922#+&, X9!a65[ H#" ,D/ F/(%'& -&F 2#&(,"+2,%#& #H 4+%EF%&'( -, J/K-F- I,-,/
d#EE/'/ -&F "#EE%&' #K/" GE-&&%&' 3#&/B H#" ,D/ gJP: U#,/E d#EE/'/ !+%EF%&'C
G"#'"/(( S-( 3-F/ #& "/3/FB%&' ,D/ ,D"// (#+,D/"& %&(,%,+,%#&(L 2-G%,-E F/H%2%/&2%/(=
;&F//FC ,D/ #&EB D%'D/" /F+2-,%#& 2-G%,-E G"#W/2, H+&F/F %( ,D/ F/3#E%,%#& #H gJ?L(
Z/,2D/EE P%4"-"B X9!a6a[ ,# 3-$/ S-B H#" - (,+F/&, -2D%/K/3/&, 2/&,/"=
QD/ P/'%(E-,+"/ -E(# E-%F ,D/ '"#+&FS#"$ H#" (/G-"-,%&' J/K-F-L( 2#33+&%,B 2#EE/'/(
H"#3 ,D/ J/K-F- IB(,/3 #H U%'D/" @F+2-,%#& XJIU@[= I!8^7 2"/-,/( -& %&,/"%3
2#33%,,// ,# (,+FB "/H#"3( ,# ,D/ '#K/"&-&2/ -&F H%&-&2%&' #H ,D/ (,-,/L( 2#33+&%,B
2#EE/'/(= J/K-F- %( #&/ #H ,S# (,-,/( SD/"/ 2#33+&%,B 2#EE/'/(C H#+" B/-" 2#EE/'/(C -&F
+&%K/"(%,%/( -"/ '#K/"&/FC -F3%&%(,/"/FC -&F H+&F/F %& ,D/ (-3/ 3-&&/"e - (,"+2,+"/
,D-, D%&F/"( ,D/ 2#33+&%,B 2#EE/'/(L -4%E%,B ,# G-",&/" S%,D E#2-E %&F+(,"%/(C 2#3G/,/ H#"
S#"$H#"2/ ,"-%&%&' '"-&,(C -&F "/(G#&F ,# J/K-F-L( F%K/"(/ F/3#'"-GD%2 -&F /2#%2
&//F(= h/,C -( %( F/,-%E/F 4/E#SC /K/& - 4%EE -( 2#33#&(/&(%2-E -( I!8^7 S-(
-3/&F/F ,# E%3%, E/'%(E-,%K/ #K/"(%'D, #K/" ,D/(/ %&(,%,+,%#&(=
I%:0$3-0,&-,0/ $%" H&+%+J'& K/#/5+LJ/%-
9E,D#+'D I#+,D/"& J/K-F- %( ,D/ /&'%&/ #H ,D/ (,-,/L( /2#BC E#2-E '#K/"&3/&,( -"/
#H,/& "/(G#&(%4E/ H#" F/K/E#G%&' -&F 3-%&,-%&%&' ,D/ "/'%#&L( %&H"-(,"+2,+"/C (+2D -( ,D/
8/13/2019 BrookingsReport NVLegislature Damore Revised
5/14
!"##$%&'( *#+&,-%& ./(, 0 1/2/34/" 5678 5
P-( :/'-( !/E,S-B -&F /RG-&(%#&( ,# ,D/ *2d-""-& ;&,/"&-,%#&-E 9%"G#", -&F ,D/ P-(
:/'-( d#&K/&,%#& d/&,/"C S%,D E%,,E/ (,-,/ -((%(,-&2/= .D%E/ 3#(, #H ,D/ 2-G%,-E G"#W/2,(
4+F'/, X9!a6a[ -FF"/((/( 4-2$E#''/F 3-%&,/&-&2/ G"#W/2,(C ,D/ P/'%(E-,+"/ G-((/F H#+"
4%EE( ,D-, S%EE -((%(, S%,D /2#%2 F/K/E#G3/&, -&F F%K/"(%H%2-,%#& %& I#+,D/"& J/K-F-=
9!77b -+,D#"%T/( ;&,/"&/, '-3%&' %& J/K-F- -&F -EE#S( ,D/ (,-,/ ,# /&,/" %&,#
-'"//3/&,( S%,D #,D/" (,-,/( ,# F/E%K/" #&E%&/ G#$/"= QD/ E/'%(E-,%#& G#(%,%#&( I#+,D/"&
J/K-F- ,# 4/ -& %&F+(,"B E/-F/" %& #&E%&/ '-3%&'C SD%E/ E%&$%&' ,D/ (,-,/L( 2#"/
/2#%2 F"%K/" S%,D ,D/ "/'%#&L( /3/"'%&' ,/2DE#'B (/2,#"= 9!88a 2"/-,/( ,D/
g&%K/"(%,B #H J/K-F-C P-( :/'-( d-3G+( ;3G"#K/3/&, 9+,D#"%,B ,# #K/"(// ,D/
gJP:J#S (,-F%+3 G"#W/2,= I#+,D/"& J/K-F- N ,D/ G"/3%/" 2#&K/&,%#& -&F
/&,/",-%&3/&, F/(,%&-,%#& %& ,D/ &-,%#& N %( +&-4E/ ,# 2#3G/,/ H#" /K/&,( ,D-, S#+EF
/RG-&F J/K-F-L( 2#"/ /2#%2 (/2,#" 4/2-+(/ ,D/ "/'%#& E-2$( - 2/&,"-EEB E#2-,/F
H-2%E%,B ,D-, %( 2-G-4E/ #H D#(,%&' /K/&,( ,D-, -,,"-2, 3#"/ ,D-& 56C666 G/#GE/= 9!8aa %(
-& %3G#",-&, H%"(, (,/G %& -FF"/((%&' ,D%( F/H%2%/&2B=
QD/ P/'%(E-,+"/ -E(# /R,/&F/F /&-4E%&' E/'%(E-,%#& ,# ,D/ dE-"$ d#+&,B d#33%((%#&
X9!b78[ ,# %&2"/-(/ ,D/ E#2-E 2#3G#&/&, #H ,D/ '-( ,-R= QD/ "/K/&+/ '/&/"-,/F 4B ,D%(
%&2"/-(/ S%EE /RG/F%,/ S#"$ #& E#&' &/'E/2,/F ,"-&(G#",-,%#& G"#W/2,( %& I#+,D/"&
J/K-F- -&F #HH(/, E%3%,/F (,-,/ %&K/(,3/&, %& ,D/ "/'%#&L( "#-FS-B(= P-(,EBC F+"%&' ,D/
5677 (/((%#&C ,D/ Z#K/"" -&F ,D/ P/'%(E-,+"/ H-%E/F ,# H+&F ,D/ MSE/F'/
8/13/2019 BrookingsReport NVLegislature Damore Revised
6/14
6 !"##$%&'( *#+&,-%& ./(, 0 1/2/34/" 5678
,D-, 4/2-+(/ IA?78 %( - E/'%(E-,%K/ "/H/"/&F+3C '+4/"&-,#"%-E -2,%#& %( "/V+%"/F=
QD+(C Z#K/"" I-&F#K-E S-( %""/E/K-&, ,# ,D/ #+,2#3/C -EE#S%&' 3-W#"%,B 1/3#2"-,( ,#
2#&,"#E ,D/ G"#2/(( S%,D E%,,E/ "/'-"F H#" ?/G+4E%2-& G"/H/"/&2/(=
M'(,0/ ?7 N+-'%( O+$5'-'+%3 '% -./ 1/#$"$
?"$753
8/13/2019 BrookingsReport NVLegislature Damore Revised
7/14
!"##$%&'( *#+&,-%& ./(, 0 1/2/34/" 5678 7
,"-&(G#",-,%#& /RG/",( S%,D "/G"/(/&,-,%#& G"#G#",%#&-,/ ,# G#G+E-,%#&= 9( %( F/,-%E/F
%& Q @R/2+,%K/ !#-"FC
8/13/2019 BrookingsReport NVLegislature Damore Revised
8/14
8 !"##$%&'( *#+&,-%& ./(, 0 1/2/34/" 5678
- ",D/"& Z#K/"" N - B/-" 4/H#"/ "//E/2,%#& N S#+EF 4/ F/&B%&' ,D"//NV+-",/"( #H ,D/
(,-,/L( G#G+E-,%#& /V+-E "/G"/(/&,-,%#& #& - $/B (,-,/S%F/ G-&/E= QD%( -E(# S#+EF D-K/
'%K/& ,D/ P/'%(E-,+"/ ,D/ #GG#",+&%,B ,# #K/""%F/ ,D/ K/,#e - E%$/EB #+,2#3/ '%K/& ,D-,
I#+,D/"& J/K-F- E/'%(E-,#"( 2#&(,%,+,/ - (+G/"N3-W#"%,B %& 4#,D 2D-34/"(=
9E,/"&-,%K/EBC Z#K/"" I-&F#K-E 2#+EF D-K/ (%'&/F I!855 -&F %& (# F#%&'C E#(/ - $/B
",D/"& -((/, ,D-, +&F/" D%( S-,2D #G/&/F ,D/ faa6 3%EE%#& ;&,/"(,-,/ a_6 G"#W/2,
/RG-&F%&' 2-G-2%,B 4/,S//& ?/ -&F d-"(#& d%,B ,# ,/& E-&/( -&F '"//&NE%'D,/F $/B
2#3G#&/&,( #H ,D/ d-"(#& d%,B !BG-(( G"#W/2,=_ */-&SD%E/C ,D/ ;&,/"(,-,/ 77 G"#W/2,
E%&$%&' P-( :/'-( -&F YD#/&%R N ,D/ ,S# E-"'/(, 3/,"#G#E%,-& "/'%#&( %& ,D/ 2#+&,"B ,
2#&&/2,/F 4B -& %&,/"(,-,/ N "/3-%&( #& ,D/ F"-S%&' 4#-"F=
I!8^7 ,/EE( - (%3%E-" (,#"B= >"%'%&-EEB S"%,,/& ,# ,"-&(H/" 2#&,"#E #H J/K-F-L( 2#33+&%,B
2#EE/'/( H"#3 ,D/ JIU@ ,# ,D/ I,-,/ !#-"F #H @F+2-,%#&C ,D/ 4%EE S-( -3/&F/F -&F
+&-&%3#+(EB G-((/F #+, #H ,D/ I/&-,/ @F+2-,%#& d#33%,,// -( -& %&,/"%3 (,+FB ,#
/R-3%&/ ,D/ F/K#E+,%#& #H ,D/ (,-,/L( 2#33+&%,B 2#EE/'/(= ;&2E+F/F %& ,D/ 4%EE S-( -E/'%(E-,%K/EB F%"/2,/F -+F%, #H ,D/(/ JIU@ -F3%&%(,/"/F %&(,%,+,%#&(C ,D"// #H SD%2D -"/
E#2-,/F %& ",D/"& J/K-F-= !/,S//& ,D/ ,%3/ ,D-, I!8^7 S-( %&,"#F+2/F -&F ,D/&
+&-&%3#+(EB G-((/F #+, #H ,D/ I/&-,/ @F+2-,%#& d#33%,,//C ,D"// (,-,/ -'/&2%/(
GE-2/F H%(2-E ,/( -'-%&(, ,D/ #"%'%&-E 4%EE= @K/& ,D#+'D ,D/ ,/( S/"/ %""/E/K-&, ,# ,D/
-3/&F/F K/"(%#& #H I!8^7C ,D/ 4%EE S-( "/N"/H/""/F ,# I/&-,/ &2/
-'-%&C ,D/ 4%EE S-( D/EF +&,%E ,D/ (/((%#&L( /&FC ,D%( ,%3/ (# ,D-, - 4%G-",%(-& 2#-E%,%#& #H
",D/"& J/K-F- I/&-,#"( 2#+EF /&'%&//" - j2#3G"#3%(/k ,D-, "/3#K/F ,D/ -+F%,
E-&'+-'/ H"#3 ,D/ 4%EEC SD%E/ -E(# -FF%&' &NE/'%(E-,#"( ,# ,D/ (,+FBL( (+4N2#33%,,//(=
A+(, -( S%,D I!855C ,D/ 4%EEL( (G#&(#"C I/&-,#" !-"4-"- d/'-K($/C S-( E/H, S%,D ,%3/ ,#
(//$ 2D-&'/( ,# ,D/ 4%EE -&F S-( H#"2/F ,# -22/G, ,D/ j2#3G"#3%(/=k .%,D#+, ,D/ -+F%,C
,-RG-B/"( D-K/ E%,,E/ S-B #H $S%&' SDB ,D/(/ %&(,%,+,%#&( D-K/ 4//& +&-4E/ ,# -22/((
"/E/K-&, H/F/"-E G"#'"-3( X%=/=C *%"%,B #" U%(G-&%2 I/"K%&' ;&(,%,+,%#& (,-,+( #"
Q99dddQ S#"$H#"2/ ,"-%&%&' '"-&,([= 9& -+F%, 3%'D, -E(# /RGE-%& ,D/ #"%'%&( #H ,D/
3%EE%#&( %& 2-(D ,D-, ,D/ JIU@ "/K/-E/F E-,/ %& ,D/ (/((%#& ,# #HH(/, ,D/ E/'%(E-,%K/EB
%3G#(/F 2+,( ,# ,D/ ",D/"& 2#33+&%,B 2#EE/'/C -( S/EE -( -FF"/(( E%&'/"%&' 2#&2/"&(
-4#+, ,D/ 3-&-'/3/&, #H ,D/(/ %&(,%,+,%#&( 4"#+'D, ,# E%'D, %& "/2/&, 3/F%- "/G#",(=^
AB?C $%" Q/R+%"
9%F/F 4B "/'+E-" 3//,%&'( #H ,D/ I#+,D/"& J/K-F- d-+2+( %& d-"(#& d%,B -&F I#+,D/"&
J/K-F-C F+"%&' ,D/ 5678 (/((%#& E/'%(E-,#"( H"#3 I#+,D/"& J/K-F- (+22/((H+EEB
-FK-&2/F - &+34/" #H "/'%#&-E G"%#"%,%/(= Q# 4/ (+"/C ,D%( #+,2#3/ F%F , D-GG/& 4B
8/13/2019 BrookingsReport NVLegislature Damore Revised
9/14
!"##$%&'( *#+&,-%& ./(, 0 1/2/34/" 5678 9
2D-&2/C 4+, "-,D/" S-( ,D/ "/(+E, #H - 4%G-",%(-& 2#-E%,%#& F/E%K/"%&' 2#&(/&(+( G#E%2%/(
,D-, 4/'%& ,# G+, ,D/ "/'%#& #& - G-,D ,# 2#&,"#E -&F F/K/E#G %,( -((/,( -&F G"#K%F/
(#3/ #H ,D/ "/(#+"2/( ,D/ "/'%#& &//F( ,# /F+2-,/ ,D/ &/R, '/&/"-,%#& #H J/K-F-&(=
;& E%'D, #H ,D/(/ /HH#",(C - &+34/" #H E/'%(E-,#"( F/(/"K/ "/2#'&%,%#& H#" ,D/%" S#"$
F+"%&' ,D/ OO,DI/((%#& #H ,D/ J/K-F- P/'%(E-,+"/= 9( ,/F -4#K/C I/&-,#"( *-"$
*-&/&F# -&F !-"4-"- d/'-K($/ 2-""%/F ,S# #H ,D/ "/'%#&L( 3#(, %3G#",-&, 4%EE(i I!855
-&F I!8^7= 9((/34EB *-W#"%,B P/-F/" .%EE%-3 U#"&/ -&F .-B( -&F */-&( dD-%"
*-''%/ d-"E,#& ,##$ ,D/ E/-F %& &/'#,%-,%&' ,D/ D%'D/" /F+2-,%#& 4+F'/,= I!a6b "/HE/2,(
,D/ D-"F S#"$ #H I/&-,#" *-W#"%,B P/-F/" *# 1/&%( -&F 9((/34EBS#3/& >E%K%- 1%-T=
I/&-,/ *%"%,B P/-F/" *%2D-/E ?#4/"(#& /RG/F%,/F ,D/ V+-E%H%2-,%#& #H IA?7a H#" ,D/
567b 4-EE#, (# ,D-, K#,/"( S%EE D-K/ ,D/ #GG#",+&%,B ,# /"-F%2-,/ G/"D-G( ,D/ 3#(,
'E-"%&' "/'%#&-E %&/V+%,B #H -EE= 9((/34EB 9((%(,-&, *%"%,B P/-F/" d"/(2/&, U-"FB S-(
- (,"#&' -FK#2-,/ H#" 9!b78C SD%E/ I/&-,#" Q%2$ I/'/"4E#3 -&F 9((/34EBS#3/& P+2B
8/13/2019 BrookingsReport NVLegislature Damore Revised
10/14
10 !"##$%&'( *#+&,-%& ./(, 0 1/2/34/" 5678
?/H#"3 ,D/ (,-,/L( H+&F%&' H#"3+E- H#" MN75 /F+2-,%#&C ,D/ :0;%3% F1%"= QD/H#"3+E- -EE#2-,/( "/(#+"2/( H#" @PPC E#S %&2#3/ -&F -, "%($ (,+F/&,(C #" '%H,/F
-&F ,-E/&,/F (,+F/&,(= .D%E/ I!a6b G"#K%F/( #&/N,%3/ "/(#+"2/( H#" (#3/ #H
,D/ "/'%#&L( MN75 /F+2-,%#&-E &//F(C 2#&,%&+/F H##,NF"-''%&' 3-B "/(+E, %& E/'-E
-2,%#& -&F ,D/ %3G#(%,%#& #H G#E%2B "/3/F%/( H"#3 #+,(%F/ ,D/ P/'%(E-,+"/
Y-((-'/ #H E/'%(E-,%#& "/#"'-&%T%&' ,D/ '#K/"&-&2/ -&F -F3%&%(,"-,%#& #H ,D/(,-,/L( 2#33+&%,B 2#EE/'/( -&F F/K/E#G%&' E#2-E H+&F%&' (,"/-3( H#" ,D/(/
%&(,%,+,%#&(= P#2-E 2#&,"#E #H ,D/(/ G#,/&,%-EEB K-E+-4E/C 4+, G"/(/&,EB G##"EB
+,%E%T/F -((/,( S%EE -EE#S ,D/(/ %&(,%,+,%#&( ,# 4/ "/H#"3/F -( - ,##E H#" /2#%2
F/K/E#G3/&, -&F /3G#S/"3/&,C SD%E/ -E(# %3G"#K%&' "/(G#&(%K/&/(( ,#
I#+,D/"& J/K-F-L( F%K/"(/ -&F '"#S%&' G#G+E-,%#&=
;& -FF%,%#& ,# S#"$%&' S%,D $/B "/'%#&-E (,-$/D#EF/"( ,# 4"%&' ,D/ gJP:J#SY"#W/2, ,# H"+%,%#&C (#+,D/"& E/'%(E-,#"( 3+(, 2#&,%&+/ ,# -FK#2-,/ H#" ;&,/"(,-,/
77 -&F 3-$/ 2/",-%& ,D-, ,D/ G"#W/2, %( "/2/%K%&' ,D/ -GG"#G"%-,/ -,,/&,%#& -&F
"/(#+"2/(= QD/ 2#3GE/,%#& #H 4#,D %&H"-(,"+2,+"/ G"#W/2,( %( 2"%,%2-E ,# ,D/"/'%#&L( /2#%2 F/K/E#G3/&,=
QD/ "/'%#&L( E/'%(E-,#"( 3+(, (/2+"/ ,D/ "/(#+"2/( ,# H-2%E%,-,/ gJP:L( -(2/&, ,#d-"&/'%/ ?/(/-"2D g&%K/"(%,B :/"B U%'D I,-,+(= l+%,/ (%3GEBC I#+,D/"& J/K-F-L(
H+,+"/ %( J/K-F-L( H+,+"/ -&F S%,D#+, - D%'D 2-G-2%,BC "/(/-"2DN%&,/&(%K/
+&%K/"(%,B %& %,( ,S# 3%EE%#& G/"(#& 'E#4-EEB 2#&&/2,/F 3/,"#G#E%,-& /2#%2
/&'%&/C J/K-F- S%EE 2#&,%&+/ ,# H-EE H-",D/" 4/D%&F %,( "/'%#&-E -&F 'E#4-E
2#3G/,%,#"(= d/&,"-E ,# ,D%( 3%((%#& %( ,D/ F/K/E#G3/&, #H - gJP: E/F 3/F%2-E
(2D##E= 9( ,D/ E-"'/(, 3/,"#G#E%,-& -"/- %& ,D/ 2#+&,B S%,D#+, - 3/F%2-E (2D##EC
,D/ "/'%#& D-( %&-F/V+-,/ D/-E,D 2-"/ 2-G-2%,B ,# (/"K/ %,( "/(%F/&,( -&F %(
3%((%&' - $/B -((/, &//F/F H#" /2#%2 F%K/"(%H%2-,%#& -&F F/K/E#G3/&,=
.D%E/ ,D/ H#+&F-,%#&( H#" 3-&B #H ,D/(/ G#E%2%/( S/"/ F/K/E#G/F F+"%&' ,D/ 5678
(/((%#&C /RG/F%,%&' ,D/ F/E%K/"B #H ,D/(/ -&F #,D/" "/'%#&-E G"%#"%,%/( &/2/((%,-,/( ,D-,
,D/ I#+,D/"& J/K-F- F/E/'-,%#& /R/", "/'%#&-E D/'/3#&B #K/" ,D/ E/'%(E-,%K/ G"#2/((=
;&F//FC #&/ #H ,D/ 3#(, %3G#",-&, E/((#&( H"#3 ,D/ 5678 (/((%#& %( ,D-, S%,D#+,
I#+,D/"& J/K-F-&( 2#&,"#EE%&' ,D/ E/K/"( #H E/'%(E-,%K/ G#S/"C /V+%,-4E/ (,-,/
%&K/(,3/&, %& ,D/ "/'%#& S%EE 2#&,%&+/ ,# 4/ F/E-B/F -&F "/H#"3( ,# J/K-F-L( #+,3#F/F
'#K/"&-&2/ %&(,%,+,%#&( S%EE 4/ #4(,"+2,/F= .D%E/ ,D/ 4+"F/& %( -ES-B( '"/-,/" H#" ,D#(/
2D-EE/&'%&' ,D/ (,-,+( V+#C H#" J/K-F- ,# H+EH%EE %,( G#,/&,%-EC ,D/ "/'%#& 3+(, D-K/
%&K/(,3/&, 2#33/&(+"-,/ S%,D %,( G#G+E-,%#& -&F 2#&,"%4+,%#& ,# ,D/ (,-,/m( /2#BC
SD%E/ 4/%&' '%K/& ,D/ -+,#B ,# F/K/E#G %,( -((/,( -&F "/(#+"2/(=
8/13/2019 BrookingsReport NVLegislature Damore Revised
11/14
!"##$%&'( *#+&,-%& ./(, 0 1/2/34/" 5678 11
!""#$%&'
)*+,- !./0 123456 7-8*942: ;2: * ?-64@,*32:@
9!:;
9!7?@;
>?@7!!8A7
9!,/W-", H K H H H K K H H H H H H H H B8
U/%J% >W-&$ H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H 766
YG"#&/ YN#3S(#& P P H H H H H P H H H P H H H 766*/E%((- .##J4+"G H K H H H K K P H H H H H H H BA
8/13/2019 BrookingsReport NVLegislature Damore Revised
12/14
12 !"##$%&'( *#+&,-%& ./(, 0 1/2/34/" 5678
!"#$%"
9/:;%& /'-;($/ = ? = = = ? ? = = = ? = = ? ? @6
*# 1/&%( = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = 766
8/13/2019 BrookingsReport NVLegislature Damore Revised
13/14
BrookingsMountainWest|December2013 13
ENDNOTES
1Attheendofthe77
thSession,theLasVegasMetroChamberofCommercereleasedareportdetailing
SouthernNevadaslegislativeprioritiesthatformthebasisoftheanalysispresentedhere.
2
Under
present
arrangements,
roughly
half
of
the
revenue
generated
from
the
net
proceeds
of
mineralstaxisreturnedtothecountyfromwhichitwasderived.
3SJR8willneedtopasstheLegislatureagainin2015beforereachingtheballotin2016.
4Inafutureanalysis,theauthorwillexamineindetailhighereducationfundinginNevada.
5NDOTsstructurewascreatedin1957whenNevadawastheleastpopulatedstateinthecountryand
isoverseenbyaboardcomposedofgubernatorialappointeesfromthreegeographicdistricts,aswell
astheGovernor,LieutenantGovernor,AttorneyGeneral,andController. SB322replacestheAttorney
GeneralwithasecondSouthernNevadaappointee. Nevadaistheonlystatewhereelectedpoliticians
overseetransportation
policy.
6BillsthatcreatefiscaldeviationsfromtheGovernorsExecutiveBudgetarerereferredtoeitherthe
SenateFinanceortheAssemblyWaysandMeansCommittees.
7The120daysessionlengthwasimposedbya1998amendmenttotheNevadaConstitutionauthored
byBillRaggio(R Reno);arareinstanceoflegislatorsgivingupakeylegislativeprerogative.
8TheU.S.CensusBureaureportsthatin2010and2011CarsonCitylostpopulation. Incomparison,
between2010and2012ClarkCountyaddedover48,000Nevadansorroughly88%ofthetotal
populationofCarsonCity.
9Seeforinstance,SecondCollegeofSouthernNevadaOfficialResignsAmidFinancialAidScandal,
LasVegasReviewJournal,September19,2013;TMCCPresidentNoLongerFinalistforArizonaJobAfterQuestionsoverPalmDesertFraud.RenoGazetteJournal,February1,2013;andDidCSNTrytoSilenceWhistleblower?LasVegasSun,November18,2011
8/13/2019 BrookingsReport NVLegislature Damore Revised
14/14
!"##$%&'( *#+&,-%& ./(, 0 1/2/34/" 5678 14
!"##$%&'( *#+&,-%& ./(,
9(,-4:%(;/< %& 566= -( - >-",&/"(;%> 4/,?//& ,;/
!"##$%&'( @&(,%,+,%#& -&< ,;/ A&%B/"(%,C #D E/B-#:%,-& -"/-( '"#? %& "#4+(,F %&2:+(%B/F -&-2,F -:,/"&-,%B/ /&/"'CF
-&< "/-: /(,-,/ %&B/(,3/&,M P( ,;/ *#+&,-%& ./(,
/3/"'/( -( - &/? P3/"%2-& Q/-",:-&:-C -&
%&2"/-(%&':C (%'&%D%2-&, "#:/ %& (;->%&' &-,%#&-: >#:%2C
"#B%#:%2C (#:+,%#&( ,# ;/:>
%3>"#B/ ,;/ L+-:%,C #D :%D/ %& ,;/ ./(,M
G/-"& 3#"/ -,R
0,,12334"##$%&'(5,&6/(,7+&897/:+3
;-",3/&, #D O#:%,%2-: X2%/&2/ -,
A&%B/"(%,C #D E/B-+4:%2
>#:%2C -, ,;/ (,-,/ -&< &-,%#&-: :/B/:(M 1"M1-3#"/ /-"&/< ;%( O;M1M D"#3 ,;/ A&%B/"(%,C #D
Z-:%D#"&%-F 1-B%( I5666JF ;%( *MPM D"#3 ,;/
A&%B/"(%,C #D Y/#"'%- I7==[JF -&< ;%( !MPM D"#3
,;/ A&%B/"(%,C #D Z-:%D#"&%-F X-& 1%/'# I7==5J -::
%& O#:%,%2-: X2%/&2/M