Upload
robert-ing
View
223
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
1/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
2/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
JCI^^MU EM_BAN ^CM FUOADM
Ubemrt Oad, NZj, N@ott, FIWZj
ZWMJOI@ WUMVOMT FBUHI^
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
3/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
Nr. Ubemrt Oad os i rmi` `ofm Fbrmasoj Oatm``odmajm Zpmjoi`ost. Fbr bvmr 57 ymirs cos survovi`
ian sujjmss oa cos prbfmssoba cis emma tcm rmsu`t bf cos ieo`oty tb jut tb tcm jcism ian tikm
tcm pb`otoji``y oajbrrmjt rbin bf iskoad ian jbatmhp`itoad tcm cirn bptobas. Cm os i hia
tcit jbasonmrs tcm uatcoakie`m wcmtcmr ot em prmpiroad fbr nosistmr br emoad ia invosbr oa iaoajonmat oavmstoditoba.
I rmdu`ir`y fmiturmn dumst ba hbst hilbr Abrtc Ihmrojia amws amtwbrks, cbst bf
smvmri` pue`oj tm`mvosoba spmjoi`s ian cos bwa jurrmat mvmats prbdrih, ot os vmry noffoju`t fbr
iay tm`mvosoba vomwmr abt tb smm cos fijm ian wbanmr wcmrm tcmy cin smma coh emfbrm.
Cm bffmrs tcos bvmrvomw bf tcos, cos 9:tcebbk==3?-3 (pek)
OZEA< ?43-7-=?=-6?39?-6 (j btc)
OZEA< ?43-7-=?=-3?3?7-? (mek)
Wroatmn oa tcm ]aotmn Ztitms bf Ihmroji
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
6/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
Ba 6 Liauiry SSSVO I.Z., scmmp oa tcm rmdi`oi bf dbits sit tb cmir tcm pmtotobas bf
belmjtoba ba emci`f bf pmbp`m smmkoad lustojm ian tcm upcb`noad bf tcm jbastotutobai` rodcts
bf mvmry jotozma tb nmhbjrijy. ^cm scmmp oa dbits rmdi`oi wmrm nmif wotc tcmor bwa
prmtmatobusamss ian non abt stian, abt i soad`m bam eut i`` `iy nbwa is scmmp u`tohitm`y nb.
^cos hirkmn tcm trum emdoaaoad bf tcm man bf tcm drmitmst syheb` bf nmhbjrijy tcm wbr`n
cin mvmr kabwa ian tcm mrbsoba bf frmmnbh fbr cmr pmbp`m.
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
7/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
JCI^^MU EM_BAN ^CM FUOADM
Ubemrt Oad, NZj, N@ott, FIWZj
Jcittmr< [Oatm``odmajm mrhX I tmrh usmn tb nmsjroem vbojm br niti triashossoba
ijtovoty ba i jbhhuaojitoba `oam br jciaam` uanmr survmo``iajm.
Froadm< [Oatm``odmajm mrhX Ia irmi butsonm bf tcm tirdmt survmo``iajm irmi tcit jia
em hbaotbrmn, bvmrcmirn, br besmrvmn.
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
8/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
AB^OJM ^B ^CM UMINMU
^cm fb``bwoad jciptmrs irm eismn ba tcm prbfmssobai` mxpmromajms ian jisms bf Nr. Ubemrt
Oad. ^cm ijjbuats rmprmsmatmn civm emma nrihitozmn ian tcm nitms, aihms, brdiaozitobas,
idmajoms ian `bjitobas civm emma jciadmn. Jcirijtmrs pbrtriymn oa tcmsm ijjbuats nb abt
amjmssiro`y rmprmsmat iay oanovonui` motcmr `ovoad br nmin. ^cm ijjbuats oa tcos ebbk nb abt
vob`itm iay aba-nosj`bsurm idrmmhmats, br bitcs bf smjrmjy matmrmn oatb ey tcm iutcbr wotc
iay oanovonui`, jbrpbritoba, sbvmrmoda aitoba, dbvmrahmat br btcmr `mdi` matoty. mjcaoji`
nmtio`s rmprmsmatmn oa tcmsm ijjbuats irm fbr oafbrhitobai eijkdrbuan purpbsms ba`y ian
`ijk suffojomat spmjofojitoba fbr mxmjutoba. cm iutcbr, pue`oscmr, tcmor idmats ian
nostroeutbrs wo`` abt em cm`n `oie`m br ijjbuatie`m fbr tcm usm br hosusm bf oafbrhitoba
jbatioamn oa tcos ebbk.
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
9/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
JCIW^MU 9
^cm Eromfoad< I ZO^]I^OBA UMWBU^ (ZotUmp), MZZI_ IAN WMUZBAI@ UIA^
Ot os fir emttmr fbr hm tb tikm i stian, sb tcit ybu hiy kabw tcm hia O tru`y ih tcia tb
sohp`y sot quomt`y ba hy cians
- Ubemrt Oad
Tm`jbhm tb tcm eromfoad. O ipprmjoitm tcm fijt tcit ybu nmjonmn tb sot oa tbniy. Zbhm bf
tcm tcoads wm irm dboad tb nosjuss cmrm irm abt hmiat tb em tikma pmrsbai``y eut ritcmr irmsohp`y besmrvitobas bf noffmrmat sotuitobas. ^cmsm besmrvitobas irm eismn ba oafbrhitoba
tcit cis emma ditcmrmn, iai`yzmn ian fo`tmrmn bvmr ia mxtmanmn pmrobn bf tohm, tb tcm
pboat, wm``, tcit tcmy hiy mvma dovm tcm vmammr bf emoad suelmjtovm besmrvitobas. Eut wmebtc kabw emttmr, br nbat wm2
Hy eusoamss os fbrmasoj oatm``odmajm ian O civm emma it ot fbr hbrm tcia 57 ymirs.
Ohidoam i wbr`n wcmrm tcmrm wmrm ab jbhputmrs, ab NAI, ab jrbss-rmfmrmajoad bf
oafbrhitoba; tcos wis tcm wbr`n bf fbrmasoj sjomajm tcit O emdia hy jirmmr oa. Oa tcm mir`y
niys O stirtmn but oa tcm irmis bf skm`mti` onmatofojitoba ian foadmrproatoad eut sbba hbvmnba tb wcit wbu`n emjbhm hy bwa prbfmssobai` aojcm. Abw, O kabw tcit ybu irm tcoakoad,
jbrpsms ian foadmrproat nust, eut tcits abt wcit O nb. Fbrmasoj Oatm``odmajm nmi`s wotc tcmijquosotoba, iai`ysos ian prbtmjtoba bf oafbrhitoba ian mvonmajm tcit os tcm rmsu`t bf i
jrohoai` ijt, ian tcm onmatofojitoba bf pbtmatoi` jrohm rosks. Fbrmasoj Oatm``odmajm
manmivbrs tb issbjoitm jbhhottmn jrohms tb spmjofoj pmrpmtritbrs tcrbudc oa-nmptciai`ysos. Totcoa Fbrmasoj Oatm``odmajm irm tcm fuajtobas bf Jbuatmr-^mrrbrosh, ian
Mspobaidm ian Jrohoai` Uosk Hiaidmhmat, wcojc oavb`vms tcm ijquosotoba ian iai`ysos
bf oatm``odmajm niti oa brnmr tb prbvonm rmjbhhmanitobas ba rmnujoad tmrrbrost, mspobaidmian jrohoai` tcrmit `mvm`s.
B.K., abw tcit O civm dovma ybu i nmfoaotoba tcit mvmry `iwymr wbu`n si`ovitm it,`mt hm jut tb tcm jcism. O `bbk it tcm fijts ian mvonmajm, hbst`y oa m`mjtrbaoj ian pipmr
fbrh ian frbh tcit O mstie`osc `oaks tb tcm i``mdmn pmrpmtritbr. Tcmrm ab jrohm cis
ijtui``y tikma p`ijm, O usm tcos oafbrhitoba tb fodurm but of tcmrm os tcm pbtmatoi` rosk br
tcrmit bf i jrohoai` ijt wiotoad tb cippma. ^cm ieo`oty tb uanmrstian wcit sbhmbam hiyem p`iaaoad, br tcm pbssoe`m smjuroty cb`m tcit pbsms i rosk os pirtoju`ir`y ohpbrtiat wcma
ot jbhms tb tcm ijts bf Mspobaidm, ^mrrbrosh ian Brdiaozmn Jrohoai` Ijtovoty. Hy irmi bf
spmjoi`ty os ^mjcab`bdy Jrohm ian wotcoa tcit irmi O fbjus ba mspobaidm roskhiaidmhmat, onmatoty tcmft, provijy, survmo``iajm ian jbhputmr smjuroty. Zb wcit nb i``
tcmsm tcoads civm oa jbhhba2 ^cmy irm i`` jbhhba`y usmn ian vob`itmn ey spoms,
tmrrbrosts ian brdiaozmn jrohoai`s is i tirdmt, oastruhmat, ion br prbpiditbr bf tcmor o``mdi`ijtovoty.
Hy forst rmi` lbe wis wotc i hilbr hmtrbpb`otia pb`ojm nmpirthmat fb``bwmn ey
smrvojm oa tcm irhmn fbrjms ian suesmqumat oavmstoditovm ian smjuroty issodahmats oa ebtctcm pue`oj ian provitm smjtbr. Ot os i fijt tcit abt hbrm tcia 57% bf mspobaidm jisms
idioast ^bp 9777 jbhpiaoms mvmr dmt rmpbrtmn tb pue`oj `iw mafbrjmhmat. ^cmy nb tcos
emjiusm tcmy jiaabt bpma tcmhsm`vms tb tcm pbtmatoi` nihidm bf fi``oad scirm projms,
nmjrmismn pue`oj jbafonmajm ian num no`odmajm `otoditoba ossums of tcm wbrn mvmr dbt buttcit tcmy fm`` vojtoh tb spoms br mvma wbrsm tmrrbrosts. 45% bf jbrpbritobas tcit civm abt
tikma hmisurms tb hiaidm jbrpbritm mspobaidm rosk ian suffmr i `bss civm typoji``y dbam
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
10/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
but bf eusoamss wotcoa 5 ymirs. ^cmrm irm hiay btcmr prbe`mhs tcit jbu`n irosm tcit O civm
purpbsm`y bhottmn ian i`` bam cis tb nb os tb usm tcmor ohidoaitoba tb jbasonmr wcit btcmrmatotoms btcmr tcia hu`toaitobai` jbrpbritobas hiy civm emma emcoan tcos prbvmreoi` modct
ei``. ^cm hu`toaitobai` jbrpbritm jbhhuaoty tmans tb ji`` oa provitm smjuroty invosbrs, nb
nihidm jbatrb` ian pursum jovo` `otoditoba is i jiutobus bptoba. ^cos os wcmrm O jbhm oa. O
ih tcm provitm jotozma wcb wbrks is i fbrmasoj oatm``odmajm spmjoi`ost br is tcm smjurotyinvosbr. Hiay fbrhmr mhp`bymrs ian jb``midums civm rmfmrrmn tb hm is i foxmr br
trbue`mscbbtmr.
Tcma ot jbhms tb nboad hy lbe, O prmfmr stmi`tc ritcmr tcia f`isc eut emjiusm bfhy oa ybur fijm dmt tcm lbe nbam ian i`wiys but frbat ittotunm O civm wba hysm`f tcm
rmputitoba bf emoad uahiaidmie`m ey tcbsm wcb prmfmr tb hiaidm frbh i pbsc bffojm is
bppbsmn tb tcm fom`n. Cbwmvmr, tcbsm wcb nb nmmh hm uahiaidmie`m sto`` ji`` hm oa ianba bjjisoba civm smat hm ijrbss tcm d`bem tb tikm jbhhian, jbatrb` ian tb em tcm eijk-
scbp mqui`ozmr. O ih ey ab hmias tcm emst oa tcm fom`n eut is i rmsu`t bf hy novmrsm
mxpmromajm, auhmrbus amws hmnoi ippmiriajms ian codcmr tcia ivmridm pue`oj prbfo`m, O
civm emma jbasonmrmn ey hiay tb em bam bf tcm hiay `minmrs oa tcos nosjop`oam. Num tb
tcos abtbromty, O civm cin tcm provo`mdm bf trioaoad ian wbrkoad wotc sbhm bf tcm erivmsthma ian wbhma oa pue`oj ian provitm `iw mafbrjmhmat ian smjuroty tcrbudcbut tcm
wbr`n. Oa hy `ofm O civm noamn ian pirtomn wotc prmsonmats, prohm hoaostmrs, nop`bhits, tcmjrmhm nm `i jrmhm bf sbjomty ian civm cin sbup wotc tcm pmbp`m oa tcm cbbn. O civm
trivm`mn tcm wbr`n, smma tcm emst ian tcm wbrst bf ot. O civm i`sb wotamssmn i drmit nmi`
rmdirnoad tcm cuhia jbanotoba ian is i rmsu`t fmm` tcit ot os ohpbrtiat tb prmsmat tb ybuhy vomw bf cbw O smm sbhm ispmjts bf bur wbr`n. Tcit ybu smm cippmaoad forstcian oa
tcm strmmts bf ybur jbhhuaoty os i hojrbjbsh bf tcm jbanotoba bf tcm drmitmr hijrbjbsh
oa bur wbr`n.Ab hittmr wcit jmatury wm `ovm oa, tcm prbvmreoi`, tohms civm rmi``y jciadmn os
sohp`y tcm hbttb bf cuhiakoan fbr i`` tohm. Cbwmvmr, tcm hbtovitoba bf bur spmjoms jiaem suhhmn up oa tcrmm wbrns< hbamy, pbwmr ian pb`otojs. Ab hittmr wcb ybu irm, wcit
ybu nb br wcb ybu nb ot fbr, ybu wo`` foan tcit ot motcmr normjt`y br oanormjt`y tbujcms tcm
jbajmpt bf hbamy, pbwmr br pb`otojs.
Dmamri``y, pmbp`m rmdirn`mss bf wcb tcmy irm, wcit tcmy em`omvm ian wcmrm tcmyjbhm frbh i`` rmi``y wiat tcrmm eisoj tcoads. ^cmy wiat fbbn, scm`tmr ian j`btcoad fbr
tcmhsm`vms ian tcmor fiho`oms. ^cmy wiat tcm smjuroty oa kabwoad tcit tcmy wo`` civm ian
jia dmt tcmsm tcoads. Oa tcm Tmstmra wbr`n wm ijjmpt tcmsm tcoads oa ieuaniajm, is idovma rodct, ian bvmr`bbk tcmh fbr wcit tcmy rmi``y irm i provo`mdm. Bajm pmbp`m fmm`
smjurm iebut eisoj fbbn, scm`tmr ian j`btcoad tcmy tman tb tura tcmor ittmatoba ba ijquoroad
i`` koans bf btcmr tcoads. Umdirn`mss bf tcmor stitoba oa `ofm, pmbp`m usm wcit tcmy civm oatcm fbrh bf hbamy, pbwmr ian pb`otojs oa bam wiy br iabtcmr tb ijquorm tcmsm ian btcmr
tcoads.
Tcma ot jbhms tb hbamy tcmrm irm ba`y fovm wiys tb ijquorm ot. _bu jia sm``dbbns, smrvojms br ybur `iebr fbr ot; ybu jia oacmrot br em ebra oatb ot; ybu jia woa ot; ybu
jia stmi` ot; br ybu jia oavmst ia oaotoi` ihbuat wotc sbhmbam wcb hiy mira ybu hbrm ey
nboad iay bf tcm prmvobus`y hmatobamn ijtovotoms ba ybur emci`f. Fbrtuaitm`y, pmbp`m wotc
hbamy irm abt i`` pbwmrfu`, emjiusm is O ih surm ybu civm jbhm tb rmi`ozm tcit tcmrm irm idrmit nmi` bf pmbp`m wotc hbamy tcit irm sb but bf tuam wotc tcm rmi` wbr`n tcit of tcmy non
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
11/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
abt civm tcmor hbamy, tcmy wbu`n amvmr em ie`m tb survovm nboad tcm nio`y tcoads tcm
ivmridm pmrsba cis tb nb tb `ovm.Wbwmr jia em oa tcm fbrh bf iutcbroty br pbsotoba; kabw`mndm br oafbrhitoba; br
civoad jbatrb` bf sbhmtcoad bf vi`um mxj`unoad hbamy. Wmbp`m bf pbwmr usm ian erbkmr
tcmor pbwmr fbr hbamy. Wmbp`m bf pbwmr irm abt amjmssiro`y hbamtiro`y wmi`tcy ian jbu`n
em lust is foaiajoi``y wm`` bff is tcm ivmridm oanovonui`. Wbwmr pmbp`m usm tcmor oatm``mjt tberbkmr nmi`s, sm`` ian ijquorm oafbrhitoba br mxmrjosm jbatrb` bvmr rmsburjms bf vi`um. ^b
rmhioa pbwmrfu` bam hust jbastiat`y em vodo`iat sb is abt tb erbkmr tbb hujc pbwmr oa
tcm fbrh bf oafbrhitoba br jbatrb` fbr hbamy `mst tcmy man up ia butjist. Ei`iajm os tcmkmy tb pbwmr.
Wb`otojs oa tcos smasm nbms abt rmfmr tb pb`otoji` pirtoms, m`mjtobas ian wcb bam
vbtms fbr. Wb`otojs rmfmrs tb bams ieo`oty tb issbjoitm wotc ian oaf`umajm tcbsm tcit jiafurtcmr cos br cmr bwa dbi`s. Oa brnmr tb sujjmmn oa pb`otojs ybu pmrsbai``y hust civm i
jmrtioa lm am sios qubo ba cbw tb wi`k oatb i rbbh fo``mn wotc striadmrs ian it tcm man bf
tcm aodct wi`k but wotc it `mist ci`f bf tcmsm pmbp`ms jbatijt oafbrhitoba ian onmatofy
tcmh is i hbamy, pbwmr br pb`otojs p`iymr. ^cm ieo`oty tb ti`k wotc ian jbavoajm pmbp`m
tcit ybu irm soajmrm wcmtcmr ybu rmi``y irm br abt, os i ti`mat fbr sbhm, br ia ijquormn sko``fbr btcmrs. Zbhm civm ot, sbhm nbat. Ammn`mss tb siy, tcos os bam ti`mat br sko`` tcbsm oa
tcm tcmitrm bf pb`otojs hust civm oa brnmr tb em oa tcm dihm fbr tcm amxt rbuan.Oa tcm eusoamss wbr`n ia mxmjutovms trum wbrtc os abt hmisurmn ey mnujitoba br
mxpmromajm eut tcm sozm bf tcmor pmrsbai` eusoamss innrmss ebbk. ^cm hbrm jbatijts i
pmrsba cis, tcm drmitmr tcmor ieo`oty tb issbjoitm wotc ian oaf`umajm tcbsm wcb hiy civmhbamy, pbwmr br civm soho`ir pb`otoji` idmanis. ^cm ivmridm pmrsba wo`` pmrsbai``y kabw
iaywcmrm frbh 5=5 tb :?6 pmbp`m nuroad tcm jbursm bf tcmor matorm `ofm. I rmi` pb`otoji`
p`iymr hust pmrsbai``y kabw ia ivmridm bf >63 pmbp`m. ^cos prbjmss hust stirt it ab `itmrtcia tcmor :6
tceortcniy. ^cmy hust em mxtrmhm`y sm`mjtovm wotc wcbh tcmy jcbbsm tb dmt
tb kabw pmrsbai``y nuroad tcm jbursm bf tcmor `ofmtohm oa brnmr tb ju`tovitm prbfmssobai``yemamfojoi` jbaamjtobas. Oa tcm dihm bf pb`otojs ybu motcmr kabw pmbp`m ba tcm oasonm, br
ybu civm sbhmbam wcb nbms. Of ybu civm amotcmr bf tcmsm, ybu wo`` civm tcm pb`otoji`
`badmvoty bf i `mhur. Wmbp`m wcb kabw cbw tb p`iy pb`otojs; tcit os wbrk i rbbh, kabw
wcb tb jbatijt br tcm tohm tb ji`` oa i fivbr wcma sbhmtcoad os ifbbt, ian irm ie`m tbijjbhp`osc ia uapbpu`ir ijt wco`m hioatioaoad tcmor bwa pbpu`iroty irm trum histmrs bf
tcm dihm. ^cbsm wcb nmi` oa pb`otojs irm tcm erbkmrs bf jciadm, ebtc dbbn ian ein. ^cmy
irm eijkmn ey hbamy pmbp`m ian irhmn wotc oafbrhitoba frbh pbwmr pmbp`m oa brnmr tbput fburtc tcmor pb`otoji` idmanis.
^b sbhm mxtmat, mvma tcm ivmridm oanovonui` niee`ms oa tcm hbamy, pbwmr ian
pb`otojs dihm. Tcma wis tcm `ist tohm ybu bffmrmn tb nb sbhmtcoad fbr sbhmbam oamxjciadm fbr jisc, br eirtmrmn amdbtoitmn sbhmtcoad fbr i emttmr nmi`, br ji``mn up
sbhmbam ybu kamw tb isk tcmh tb nb sbhmtcoad ba`y tcmy jbu`n nb fbr ybu2 ^cmsm
sotuitobas rmf`mjt hbamy, pbwmr ian pb`otojs rmspmjtovm`y. Ian ybu tcbudct ybu nonatp`iy tcm dihm. Tm i`` nb, ian hbst tcoak bf ot is survovi`.
^ikm i wi`k wotc hm nbwatbwa. Zmm tcbsm euo`noads. Zmm i`` tcbsm aihms ba tcm
euo`noads. ^cmrm irm euo`noads wotc tcm aihms bf eiaks, oasuriajm jbhpiaoms, cmi`tc jirm
butfots, jir jbhpiaoms, cbtm` jcioas, ian foaiajoi` erbkmrs. _bu kabw cbw tcmy dbt tcmoraihms up tcmrm2 ^cmy non ot emjiusm tcmy cin oafbrhitoba tcit wis sb dbbn, tcit ot
jbavoajmn pmbp`m tb nb eusoamss wotc tcmh, ian mvma cm`pmn tcmh hikm tcm rodct jcbojms
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
12/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
bf wcmrm tb put tcmor hbamy, ian em pb`otoji``y jbrrmjt sb tcmy jbu`n drbw tcmor eusoamss
wotcbut stmppoad ba pbwmrfu` tbms. Zbhmbam bajm sion tcit oafbrhitoba os pbwmr, eut tcitos sohp`y abt trum. Of ot wmrm tcit wbu`n hmia tcm hbst pbwmrfu` pmbp`m oa tcm wbr`n
wbu`n em `oeriroias ian O.^. (oafbrhitoba tmjcab`bdy) inhoaostritbrs!
Oafbrhitoba os ba`y is pbwmrfu` is ybur ieo`oty tb ipp`y ot. Of ybu jiat ipp`y ot,
ybu hiy abt em pbwmrfu`, eut of ybu jia sm`` ot tb sbhmbam wcb jia ipp`y ot, ybu hodctemjbhm vmry wmi`tcy. ^cm amxt emst tcoad tb civoad oafbrhitoba oa ybur pmrsbai`
pbssmssoba os kabwoad wcmrm tb foan ot (kabw`mndm). Of ybu wmrm abt ebra oatb wmi`tc,
civm ia ivmridm tb em`bw ivmridm oatm``mjt ian civm ab jbatijts tcit jia jbaamjt ybu tb isotuitoba wcmrm ybu jia mira i rmisbaie`m `ovoad, tcmrm os ba`y bam voie`m bptoba fbr ybu of
ybu irm rmi``y dboad tb survovm ian civm i `ofm oa tcos wbr`n. @mira wcit typm bf
oafbrhitoba pmbp`m ammn, `mivm ab stbam uaturamn ba foanoad sburjms bf oafbrhitoba, `miracbw tb put ot oa i wiy pmbp`m jia uanmrstian ian sm`` ot tb tcmh. Zm`` ot tb tcmh fbr rmi`
jisc, tcma db eijk ian nb ot idioa.
^cm ivmridm pmrsba ijquorms hbst bf tcmor oafbrhitoba tcrbudc tcm myms ian
mxpmromajms (ijjbuats) bf btcmrs. ^cmy wo`` dmt tcos oafbrhitoba frbh tcm erbinjist, fo`h,
vonmb, proat hmnoi, tcm Oatmramt ian frbh rmjb``mjtobas bf fromans ian rm`itovms wcb civmbetioamn ot frbh i`` tcm sburjms O civm prmvobus`y hmatobamn, ian sb ba, ian sb ba, ian sb
ba wm`` ybu dmt tcm onmi. Tcit wis tcit O sion iebut belmjtovm besmrvitobas uanmr ivmammr bf suelmjtovoty2
M`mhmatiry sjcbb` jco`nrma civm i dihm wcmrm iebut i nbzma bf tcmh `oam up br
stian oa i jorj`m. ^cm forst jco`n os dovma i smjrmt tb wcospmr oa tcm mir bf tcm amxt jco`nian sb ba nbwa tcm `oam tb tcm `ist jco`n. ^cm striadm tcoad iebut ot os tcm `ist jco`n ba`y
cis i tcorty-tcrmm pmrjmat jciajm bf dmttoad tcm matorm brodoai` hmssidm. Cbw nb ybu dmt
ybur amws bf wcit os cippmaoad oa tcm wbr`n tbniy2 Nb ybu tru`y em`omvm tcit ybu irmemoad tb`n mvmrytcoad2
^cm wbr`n os fo``mn wotc pmbp`m wcb ijjmpt ian amvmr qumstoba wcit tcmy irm tb`ney tcm hioastrmih hmnoi, tcmor dbvmrahmat ian tcm i`tmraitovm hmnoi. Fbr hbst pmbp`m,
tcm ijjmptiajm bf wcit tcmy pmrjmovm is fijt os eismn ba tcmor bwa `ohotmn `ofm
mxpmromajms, pmrsbai` em`omfs, pbpu`ir ju`turm ian rmdrmttie`y wcit os jbavmaomat fbr tcmh
tb em`omvm it tcm tohm. Bc yms, ian ba tcm ihbuat bf oafbrhitoba tcm tm``mr os wo``oad tbprbvonm wotcbut jmasbrscop ian eois wotcoa tcm jbastrioats bf tohm br mnotbroi` spijm. ^cm
ieo`oty tb usm tcmsm viroie`ms tb bams inviatidm oa scipoad tcm pmrjmptoba bf tcm ivmridm
jotozma os abtcoad scbrt bf oafbrhitoba wirfirm br oafbrhitoba tmrrbrosh, (nmpmanoad bawcit sonm bf tcm ossums ybu irm ba) it ots hbst eisoj `mvm`.
Civm ybu `bbkmn it i rmi` pipmr vmrsoba bf i nio`y amwspipmr `itm`y2 Abw, nbat
jcmit ian `bbk it bam ba tcm Oatmramt eut ijtui``y tcoak bf tcm `ist tohm ybu cm`n bam oaybur cian. Nb ybu rmi`ozm tcit tcm oafbrhitoba oa tcit amwspipmr, tbniys mnotoba bf tcit
amwspipmr jbatioas hbrm oafbrhitoba tcia ybu wbu`n mvmr em mxpbsmn tb oa ybur matorm
`ofmtohm of ybu `ovmn fbur cuanrmn ymirs idb2 Ots i fijt ian tcit os lust i nio`y amwspipmr.Tm ijtui``y `ovm oa ia idm wcmrm wm is oanovonui`s irm `otmri``y f`bbnmn wotc sb hujc
oafbrhitoba tcit tcm ivmridm oanovonui` foans ot noffoju`t tb nodmst `irdm jcuaks bf soad`m
sburjm oafbrhitoba it bam tohm. Wmbp`m irm jbanotobamn is i rmsu`t bf tcos oafb-
mavorbahmat tb mxpmjt ian rmjmovm smasbry oafbrhitoba frbh jbastiat`y jciadoadhu`top`m sburjms. Of ybu nbat em`omvm hm, jbasonmr tcm auhemr bf pmbp`m tcit ybu kabw
tcit suffmr frbh scbrt ittmatoba spias, irm uaie`m tb fbjus ba bam tcoad it i tohm ian irm
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
13/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
jbastiat jciaam` cbppmrs wcma ot jbhms tb tm`mvosoba br rinob. _bu prbeie`y kabw i `bt
hbrm bf tcmsm oanovonui`s tcia ybu non fovm, tma br twmaty ymirs idb.]p uato` iebut 9?37, hilbr jbrpbritm mxmjutovms cin mxmjutovm issostiats jbanujt
prm`ohoairy rmsmirjc ian ditcmr oafbrhitoba fbr upjbhoad prblmjts. ^bniy, tcm sihm
jbrpbritm mxmjutovms civm tcmor mxmjutovm issostiats soft tcrbudc, fo`tmr ian suhhirozm
`otmri``y dodieytms bf rmpbrts, m-hio`s, ian btcmr fbrhs bf oafbrhitoba. Oa i wbr`n tcitrm`oms ba oafbrhitoba, tcbsm tcit civm tcm oafbrhitoba jbanuots jia ian nb normjt tcm pitc
ot wo`` tikm. ^cbsm wotc ijjmss tb hu`top`m oafbrhitoba jbanuots wo`` ian nb fo`tmr ot oa
brnmr tb hmmt tcmor rmquormhmat br lustofy tcmor idmani.Matmr hy twostmn onmi bf i jbatmhpbriry \ma Eunncost ronn`m. I eby hbvms oatb i
amodcebrcbbn ian os scbwa ey cos amw j`isshitms cbw tb dmt tb sjcbb` frbh cos cbusm.
^cm eby wi`ks tcm rbutm mijc niy tb ian frbh sjcbb` wotc tcm tbti` trop `istoad >=hoautms. Civoad hinm tcos trmk fbr tcm emttmr pirt bf i ymir, tcm eby bam niy os jbafrbatmn
wotc hissovm rbin ian strmmt jbastrujtoba wcojc fbrjms coh tb nbue`m eijk ian try tb foan
ia i`tmraitm rbutm tb sjcbb`. Cm nbms, iftmr hujc iadst, ba`y tb foan tcm amw rbutm os 9=
hoautms scbrtmr!
Frbh tcos stbry wm jia mstie`osc tcit tcm eby oa tcm vmry emdoaaoad ijjmptmn ismhporoji` fijt, prmsmatmn ey cos j`isshitms tcit tcos wis tcm ba`y rbutm tb sjcbb`. ^cm
i`tmraitm rbutm wis abt kabwa tb coh br mvma pmrcips cos j`isshitms. Is tcos rbutm wisabt kabwa, non tcos hmia ot non abt mxost2 Oa tcm jbatmxt bf tcm woanbw br jorj`m bf rmi`oty
bf tcm eby ian cos j`isshitms, bam jbu`n miso`y siy yms, ot non abt mxost, ian tcmrmfbrm wis
abt rmi` tb tcmh. Ot pbsmn ab inviatidm br tcrmit tb tcmh it tcit tohm. Cbwmvmr, oa tcm eodpojturm, tb ybu ian O, wm kabw emttmr.
Tcma suelmjtovm rmi`oty os ijjmptmn is trutc ian pmbp`m e`oan`y euy oatb tcm
jbajmpt tcit tcm trutc sci`` smt tcmh frmm, tcmy vb`uatiro`y emjbhm tcmor bwa lio`mrs ians`ivms tb i wbr`n emyban tcmor jbatrb`. ^cm ba`y wiy fbr ia oanovonui` tb em tru`y frmm ian
em oa jcirdm bf tcmor bwa nmstoay os tb qumstoba mvmrytcoad ian emfbrm tikoad ijtoba,jbasonmr tcm pmrsbai` ohpijt ian `bad tmrh jbasmqumajms tb tcmhsm`vms ian btcmrs bf
sujc ijtoba. It tcm man bf tcm niy, mijc oanovonui` hust ijjmpt fu`` rmspbasoeo`oty fbr tcmor
bwa ijtobas wcmtcmr tohm prbvms tcmor nmjosoba tb em ipprbproitm br oaipprbproitm.
Abw, cmrms tcm puajc `oam. ^bniy, tcmrm irm codc `mvm` pmbp`m, oaf`umatoi` pmbp`m,pbwmrfu` pmbp`m, wm`` oatmatobamn prbfmssobai` pmbp`m jcirdmn wotc tcm aitobai` smjuroty
oatmrmsts bf i`` bf us wcb irm `okm tcm eby ian cos j`isshitms. Of ot os abt oa tcm ebbk, of ot os
abt ia onmatofomn smjuroty vu`amrieo`oty, ot nbms abt mxost. Of ot os abt pb`otoji``y jbrrmjt otjiaabt em nosjussmn br ijkabw`mndmn. Cbw iesurn ian sin. Ot os abt hy oatmatoba, tb
pboat foadmrs br aihm aihms emjiusm tcos wbu`n abt jurm br fox wcit cis emjbhm tcm
pbpu`ir smjuroty tcmbroms bf tcm niy, ian tcmor codc prbfo`m, hirkmtoad spoa nbjtbrmntrioamn prbpbamats. Cbwmvmr, jbasonmr tcm fijts ian ijts bf tmrrbrosh, dumro``i wirfirm
ian brdiaozmn prbfmssobai` jrohm oa bur wbr`n tbniy. Jbasonmr i`` tcm rmsburjms, tcm
trioaoad, tcm tmjcab`bdy, ian tcm `mssbas wm civm `miramn frbh tcm tridoj costbry bf burwbr`n. Nbat ybu foan ot emyban em`omf tcit sbhm jrohoai` ian tmrrbrost ijts idioast bur
jovo`ozmn wbr`n; sbhm ijts tcit tikm hbatcs bf p`iaaoad, sto`` smmh tb abt mvma jiusm i
e`op ba tcm rinir sjrmma uato` iftmr tcmy civm emma mxmjutmn ian hmhemrs bf tcm
oaabjmat, uakabwoad pue`oj irm sijrofojmn. Mvma hbrm uaem`omvie`m irm tcm uatb`nho``obas bf nb``irs i``bjitmn is i kamm lmrk rmijtoba tb sujc mvmats tb prbtmjt us, frbh ian
tb foan tcbsm rmspbasoe`m fbr sujc ijts. _mt wotc i`` tcos, ot smmhs tcit foanoad ian
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
14/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
amutri`ozoad tcm soad`m sodaofojiat prohiry pmrpmtritbr, i hia br wbhia os emyban tcm
sjbpm bf mvmrytcoad tcit cis emma put oa p`ijm. Wmrcips bam niy, ia mpopciay wo`` cippmawcma ot wo`` em rmi`ozmn tcit brdiaozmn prbfmssobai` jrohoai`s, dumro``is ian tmrrbrosts nb
abt fb``bw br jbu`n jirm `mss iebut wcit wm rmjbdaozm is stianirn jismebbk mxp`bots ian
hbnus bpmriano. I pbssoe`m eut codc`y ohprbeie`m sjmairob, it `mist oa tcos `ofmtohm.
Nuroad hy ippmiriajms ba aitobai` tm`mvosoba ian it jbafmrmajms, O civm j`mir`ynmhbastritmn ba smvmri` bjjisobas tcm mism it wcojc tirdmtmn oafbrhitoba jia em betioamn
frbh vortui``y iay Oatmramt br Oatriamt jbaamjtmn jbhputmr, ba`y tb civm sbhm mstie`oscmn
mxpmrts jry shbkm ian horrbrs br o``usobas is bppbsmn tb uanmrstianoad tcm rmi`smjuroty tcrmit tb mvmry jotozma. Fbr tcm pist twmaty ymirs O cin ittmhptmn tb `beey tcm
jbrpbritm smjtbr tb i``bjitm emttmr fuanoad fbr oatmrai` smjuroty eundmts ian inviajmn
smjuroty trioaoad fbr tcmor pmbp`m eut sto`` tb tcos niy, frbat`oam smjuroty stiff oa jbrpbritmAbrtc Ihmroji irm sto`` tcm `bwmst pion bf rosk hiaidmhmat stiff oa rm`itoba tb tcm vi`um
bf tcm issmts ian `ovms tcmy hust prbtmjt.
Furtcmrhbrm, aitobai` `mdos`itoba hust em oa p`ijm tcit i`` provitm smjuroty duirns
piss i jrohoai` eijkdrbuan jcmjk, hmmt tcm prbfmssobai` jmrtofojitoba rmquormhmat is i
Jmrtofomn Wrbtmjtoba Bffojmr, mstie`oscmn ey tcm Oatmraitobai` Fbuanitoba fbr WrbtmjtobaBffojmrs (OFWB) br is i Jmrtofomn Wcysoji` Zmjuroty Wrbfmssobai`, mstie`oscmn ey tcm
Ihmrojia Zbjomty fbr Oanustroi` Zmjuroty (IZOZ) ian irm rmhuamritmn it i ritm rmf`mjtovmbf tcmor rmspbasoeo`oty is i frbat`oam rosk hiaidmhmat prbfmssobai`. Wrovitm smjuroty duirns
p`iy i kmy rb`m oa hiaidoad tmrrbrost ian jrohoai` rosk oa bur jbhhuaotoms. ^cos os jrujoi`
fbr tcm sifmty ian smjuroty bf tcmhsm`vms ian tcbsm wcb nmpman upba tcmh.Oa tcm hon 9??7s, O cin iutcbrmn i pipmr ian `mjturmn ba justbh oastrujtovm jbnm
(^rblia) vorusms tcit wmrm, ian sto`` irm, vortui``y uanmtmjtie`m. ^cos jbhputmr ^rblia
vorus os jipie`m bf smirjcoad fbr spmjofoj fo`m aihms br kmywbrns ba ia oafmjtmn jbhputmrian tcma m-hio`oad tcm fo`ms eijk tb ots brodoaitbr. Oa 577=, O nmhbastritmn ba `ovm
tm`mvosoba cbw misy ot wis, tb `bjitm ian ijjmss jbhputmrs wotcbut formwi``s ian tbmxtrijt jrmnot jirn auhemrs usoad ba`y i `iptbp jbhputmr wotc i worm`mss jbaamjtoba ian
hbnofomn wme jriw`mr smirjc prbdrih. ^cmsm irm abt jbaluroad trojks eut irm rmi`
tcrmits tb oanovonui`s, jbhpiaoms ian bur aitobai` smjuroty.
^cmrm os ia oatmraitobai` jbhputmr uanmrdrbuan bf brdiaozmn jrohoai`s ianprovitmmrs; oanovonui`s wcb ijt i`bam ian stmi` oafbrhitoba tb brnmr fbr i projm. ^cmor
tirdmts riadm frbh pmrsbai` oafbrhitoba, rmsmirjc niti ian j`omat `osts tb ijjmss jbnms ian
irjcotmjturi` p`ias. ^cmy bpmritm em`bw tcm smjuroty rinir sjrmma fbr tcm hbst pirt, usoadhmtcbnb`bdoms ian prbjmssms tcit eirm`y rmjmovm iay hmatoba oa tcm ijjmptmn Oatmramt br
amtwbrk smjuroty drio`s bf tcm niy. Wmrsbai` oafbrhitoba betioamn tbniy ey ia
brdiaozmn jrohoai` br tmrrbrost fbr tcm purpbsm bf onmatoty tcmft hiy abt em uto`ozmn uato` iymir br hbrm iftmr ots ijquosotoba. ^cos os tcm wbr`n bf tmjcab`bdoji` mspobaidm. Zbrry, ybu
wbat dmt tcos oafbrhitoba oa ybur amxt prbfmssobai` smjuroty jmrtofojitoba jrmnot jbursm.
Civoad sion tcos, ba i pbsotovm abtm, tcmrm irm pmbp`m tcit kabw ian civm tcm tmjcab`bdytb jitjc sbhm bf tcmsm oanovonui`s. Zbhm bf tcmh O civm cin tcm provo`mdm ian cbabr bf
smrvoad wotc. Tco`m btcmrs jcbbsm tb wbrk i`bam, trijkoad, hbaotbroad ian stbppoad tcmsm
pmrpmtritbrs fbr tcmor provitm j`omatm`m. Oa tcm prbfmssobai` smjuroty eusoamss tcmrm os ia
bftma qubtmn eut sm`nbh cmmnmn ixobh, tcit emoad, Zmjuroty os i prbjmss. Zmjuroty os abti stitoj tcoad ian hust em prbijtovm`y iniptie`m of ot os tb em bf iay rmi` vi`um oa sivoad
`ovms, provijy ian prbpmrty.
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
15/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
Tm fmir tcm uakabwa ian tcm tcoads wm nba't uanmrstian br tcit irm noffmrmat tb
bur bwa jbajmpt bf tcm wbr`n. Oa tcm wo`n, iaohi`s wo`` abt typoji``y vmaturm oatb tcmuakabwa ian of fijmn wotc fmir wbu`n ritcmr rmtrmit, ian wo`` ba`y fodct fbr survovi`;
nmfmasm br fbbn. ^cm cuhia iaohi` cbwmvmr, wo`` p`bt br ijt tb nmstrby tcit wcojc jiusms
coh br cmr fmir oa tcm iesmajm bf ritobai` fijts tcit wbu`n hikm tcm uakabwa, kabwa. Ot
os tcos mhbtoba eismn orritobai` emcivobr tcit jiusms kamm lmrk rmspbasm aitobai` smjurotypb`ojy tb tcm nmtrohmat bf bur i`rminy frido`m nmhbjrijy ian tcm oanovonui` frmmnbhs
fbudct fbr ian miramn ey bur fbrmemirs tcit irm malbymn ey mijc bam bf us.
Dbvmrahmats ian jbrpbritobas spman uatb`n ho``obas bf nb``irs ba smjurotyoaotoitovms tcit `bbk dbbn, bffmr i `mvm` bf cb``bw oatohonitoba tcrbudc tmjcab`bdy hbst
pmbp`m nbat uanmrstian eut bffmr `ott`m br ab rmi` prbtmjtoba idioast futurm tcrmits. Bam bf
tcm drmitmst smjuroty fiux pis bf bur tohm os tcm kamm lmrk rmijtoba bf emmfoad up broajrmisoad pcysoji` vosoe`m smjuroty hmisurms iftmr ia oajonmat bjjurs. ^cos os dmamri``y ia
uaamjmssiry mxpmasm, jrmitms i fi`sm smasm bf smjuroty ian prbvonms tcm pb`otoji``y jbrrmjt
ohprmssoba tcit sbhmtcoad os emoad nbam. ^cos os abt tb siy tcit oajrmisoad vosoe`m
pcysoji` smjuroty scbu`n amvmr em ia bptoba, eut ritcmr tcit ot scbu`n em bam bf smvmri`
bptobas tcit civm emma prm-qui`ofomn eismn ba ia iai`ysos bf wcit stirtmn tcm prbe`mh oatcm forst p`ijm. Lust emjiusm tcm jbhputmr jbatioaoad smasotovm oafbrhitoba os `bjkmn oa i
rbbh it tcm emdoaaoad bf tcm scoft ian ot os sto`` pcysoji``y tcmrm it tcm man bf tcm scoft,wotc ab uaiutcbrozmn ijjmss ittmhpts nbms abt hmia ot os smjurm br cis abt emma ermijcmn.
^cm ijt bf hiaidoad rosk br prmvmatoba jbasosts bf ba`y tcrmm prbjmssms; tcit bf
rmnujoad br amditoad tcm rosk it ots sburjm, mir`y nmtmjtoba/hbaotbroad, ian oajonmatrmspbasm. Innoad hbrm vosoe`m smjuroty rmsburjms wo`` em bf ab usm of tcm brodoai` jbrm
vu`amrieo`oty cis abt emma innrmssmn. O kabw tcit tcos sbuans `okm jbhhba smasm eut of
ybu fb``bw amws rmpbrts ba jrohm ian ijts bf tmrrbrosh irbuan tcm wbr`n, ybu wo`` sbbarmi`ozm tcit oa sbhm jisms, sbhmbam hossmn tcos sohp`m jbasonmritoba. Of wm irm tb hiaidm
jrohm ian tmrrbrost rosk oa bur sbjomty, wm hust onmatofy bur vu`amrieo`otoms ian ohp`mhmatstritmdoms ian prbjmssms tcit innrmss tcmsm ossums cmin ba. Tm nb abt ammn ian jiaabt
iffbrn ijtoba ba tcmsm ossums tb em rmfmrrmn tb i jbhhottmm br stuny drbup bf oanovonui`s
tcit `ovm oa tcm emst amodcebrcbbns, civm iebvm ivmridm `mvm`s bf pmrsbai` smjuroty ian
wo`` prbnujm i rmpbrt wotc rmjbhhmanitobas tcit hiy em ohp`mhmatmn bvmr tcm jbursm bftohm. Ot os uafbrtuaitm tcit quotm bftma aitobai` smjuroty pb`ojoms ian hmisurms irm
mxmjutmn is i rmsu`t bf pb`otoji` ian besjurm idmanis. Of ybu nbat em`omvm hm, isk
ybursm`f wcy pb`otojoias, bur `iwhikmrs - tcm pmbp`m wm m`mjt tb hikm ian nmeitmnmjosobas ba bur sifmty ian smjuroty jia amvmr dovm i striodct yms br ab iaswmr tb i voti`
sifmty br smjuroty qumstoba. _bu scbu`n i`sb isk ybursm`f wcy os ot tcit mvmry tohm i
jrohoai` ijt os jbhhottmn idioast i frmm nmhbjritoj sbjomty tcit tcm rmspbasm os u`tohitm`ytb issmrt hbrm jbatrb` bvmr ian rmstrojt tcm rodcts ian frmmnbhs bf tcit sihm sbjomty.
Oa bur wbr`n tbniy, tcmrm irm sbhm uaspmikie`m eut orrmfutie`m ixobhs. ^cm hilbr
dbvmrahmats bf bur wbr`n, oaj`unoad burs, jbu`n vmry miso`y m`ohoaitm pbvmrty wotcoatcmor bwa ebrnmrs. I`` tcmy wbu`n civm tb nb os tb dovm mvmry jotozma; hia, wbhia ian
jco`n tcm mquovi`mat tb 9 ho``oba nb``irs oa tcm fbrh bf i aba-triasfmrie`m, ab jisc
rmnmmhie`m jrmnot nuroad tcmor `ofmtohm, tcit jbu`n ba`y em ipp`omn tbwirns fbbn, cbusoad,
j`btcoad ian mnujitoba. ^cos wbu`n abt em i nb`m br i cianbut, eut ia oavmsthmat oa tcmfuturm bf cuhiakoan. Wmbp`m jbu`n tru`y mxjm` it tcm ti`mats ian ieo`otoms tcmy civm fbr tcm
emttmrhmat bf tcmor jbuatry ian tcm wbr`n. ^cos wbu`n abt ba`y mrinojitm pbvmrty eut i`sb
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
16/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
hiay oajmatovms tb jbasonmr i `ofm bf jrohm is i wiy bf survovi`. Ot wbu`n stohu`itm tcm
mjbabhy, cm`p shi`` eusoamssms ian jbhhuaotoms. Of ybu tcoak tcos wbu`n em i drmitihbuat bf hbamy tb jbhm up wotc, tcoak idioa tcm amxt tohm tcmsm dbvmrahmats smmh tb
i``bjitm br foan ho``obas bf nb``irs, it tcm nrbp bf i cit fbr i pb`otoji``y jbrrmjt oaotoitovm bf
tcm niy, wco`m pmbp`m strudd`m tb hikm mans hmmt oa bur amodcebrcbbns.
Is `bad is wm civm pbvmrty ian i j`iss kabwa is tcm wbrkoad pbbr oa bur jbuatryian tcm oaieo`oty tb mffmjtovm`y nm`ovmr tcm eisoj amjmssotoms tb mvmry jotozma, bur
dbvmrahmat scbu`n abt em normjt`y oavb`vmn oa prbvonoad foaiajoi` ion butsonm bur ebrnmrs
wco`m bur bwa suffmr. Is dbbn jotozmas bf tcm wbr`n ian hmhemrs bf oatmraitobai` ionbrdiaozitobas sujc is tcm Oatmraitobai` Umn Jrbss, Ihamsty Oatmraitobai` ian tcm ]aotmn
Aitobas tb aihm i fmw, wm wo`` cm`p tcbsm oa btcmr jbuatroms wcb jiaabt cm`p tcmhsm`vms
num tb `ijk bf rmsburjms, uanmrstianoad, sbjoi` lustojm ian pb`otoji` oastieo`oty. Cbwmvmr,wm hust masurm tcit wm put bur jotozmas, tcbsm wcb jbatroeutm tb bur jbuatry tcrbudc
tcmor jbhhuaotoms, forst ian fbrmhbst. Mijc niy hiay pirmats oa bur jotoms irm fijmn wotc
tbudc nmjosobas. ]afbrtuaitm`y, tcmsm nmjosobas irm wcmtcmr tb usm tcmor `ist fovm nb``ir
eo`` tb euy fbbn fbr tcmor jco`nrma br tb usm ot is i pirtoi` piyhmat tbwirns ia bvmrnum
uto`oty eo`` emfbrm ot os nosjbaamjtmn. ^cmsm pmbp`m civm lbes eut sohp`y nb abt miramabudc tb suppbrt tcmor fiho`oms br tcmhsm`vms. ^cmy hiy mvma wbrk twb br tcrmm
hoaohuh widm lbes, ian irm rbeemn bf tcm vi`uie`m fiho`y tohm hiay bf us tikm fbrdriatmn, oa mxjciadm fbr tryoad tb mira mabudc tb prbvonm fbbn, j`btcoad ian scm`tmr. ^cos
cippmas mvmry niy, oa mvmry joty bf bur jbuatry wco`m hiay wotc tcm pbwmr tb jciadm tcm
sotuitoba nb abtcoad. ^cos os abt ijjmptie`m.^cm Irhmn Fbrjms hust em nmp`bymn ian trioamn tb nmfman bur jbuatry, ots
ebrnmrs ian jbanujt nosistmr rm`omf ian mhmrdmajy smrvojm bpmritobas. ^cm Irhmn Fbrjms
hust abt em usmn tb oavinm br pb`ojm fbrmoda aitobas. Bur sbas ian niudctmrs scbu`n abtrosk tcmor `ovms br nom fbr iay ijtoba `mss tcia tcm normjt nmfmasm br smjuroty bf bur aitoba.
^cm hma ian wbhma wcmtcmr jbhhossobamn bffojmrs br aba-jbhhossobamn bffojmrs oabur ho`otiry nmsmrvm emttmr rmprmsmatitoba oa, ian ia uanmrstianoad bf tcm jci``madms tcmy
fijm mijc niy oa mxmjutoad tcmor nutoms ey tcm pb`otojoias tcit hikm up bur dbvmrahmat. Ot
scbu`n em i hianitbry rmquormhmat tcit i ].Z. Nmfmasm Zmjrmtiry br Jiainoia Hoaostmr
bf Nmfmasm civm tb cos br cmr jirmmr mxpmromajm, cbabrie`m rmdu`ir (fu``tohm) ho`otirysmrvojm is i prmrmquosotm tb ippboathmat. Ot os i`wiys ihizoad ian nirm O siy ia ijt bf
jbwirnojm wcma pb`otojoias jia sman bur sbas ian niudctmrs ba ho`otiry hossobas
bvmrsmis, oa hiay jisms tb rosk tcmor `ovms wotc `ott`m br ab `bdostoji` suppbrt wco`m tcmytcmhsm`vms db cbhm tb tcmor sbas ian niudctmrs. Tcma iskmn of tcmor sbas br niudctmrs
wbu`n ma`ost fbr sujc i abe`m ho`otiry ijtoba is tcmy civm nmfmanmn ot oa tcm hmnoi tohm
ian tohm idioa, tcmy smmh tb scrud tcmor scbu`nmrs ian sohp`y wi`k iwiy. ^cm pmbp`m oabur Irhmn Fbrjms nmsmrvm bur rmspmjt ian ammn tcm suppbrt bf bur pb`otojoias.
Ohhodritoba pb`ojy oa bur jbuatry os ymt iabtcmr sin ossum. Non ybu kabw tcit bur
jbuatry dbms tb drmit `madtcs tb pioat i vmry rbsy pojturm bf bur mjbabhy ian lbe hirkmtoa brnmr tb ittrijt fbrmoda prbfmssobai`s sujc is hmnoji` nbjtbrs, madoammrs, sjomatosts ian
btcmrs. Cbwmvmr, bajm sujc i fbrmoda prbfmssobai` cis `ianmn, tcmy sbba nosjbvmr tcit
tcmrm mxosts i d`iss eirromr tcit prbcoeots br rmstrojts tcmh frbh usoad tcmor sko``s ian
mxpmromajm tb ijquorm mhp`byhmat. ^cit d`iss eirromr os Ihmrojia br Jiainoia wbrkmxpmromajm. Tco`m O ih surm tcit cuhia pcysob`bdy, sjomajm ian hitcmhitojs hust em tcm
sihm iaywcmrm ba bur p`iamt, tcos d`iss eirromr cis emma usmn tb `otmri``y put ba tcm
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
17/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
emijc, sbhm bf tcm drmitmst fbrmoda hoans bf bur tohm. Ots i`hbst is tcbudc i jbasporijy
mxostmn tb nrovm tcmsm fbrmoda oatm``mjtui`s oatb tcm `bw widm, uasko``mn `iebr smjtbr wco`mtcmy iwiot tcm : br hbrm ymirs tb qui`ofy is i prijtojoad prbfmssobai`, oa brnmr fbr bur
aitoba tb civm ia oatm``odmat `bw widm `iebr fbrjm tb cm`p bur jbuatry emttmr jbhpmtm oa
wbr`n hirkmts.
^b uanmrstian tcos tridmny ian wistm bf rmsburjms, bam nbms abt civm fir tb db euttcm `bji` mhp`byhmat jmatmr, cbp oa i tixo oa i hilbr hmtrbpb`otia joty br spmik wotc tcm
bffojm j`miaoad stiff. ^cmrm ybu hiy em surprosmn tb foan i rmsmirjc sjomatost, hmnoji`
nbjtbr br m`mjtroji` madoammr. Iabtcmr prbe`mh os tcm `ijk bf i prm-rmquosotm tcit pbtmatoi`ohhodriats tb bur jbuatry motcmr nmhbastritm i fuajtobai` f`umajy oa bur aitobai`
`iaduidm br idrmm tb histmr ot ian piss i fuajtobai` f`umajy mxih emfbrm tcmy smtt`m oa bur
jbuatry. @mts em cbamst, of i pmrsba jiaabt rmin, wrotm br spmik bur aitobai` `iaduidm,cbw jia tcmy pmrsbai``y survovm oa bur sbjomty, `mt i`bam em i jbatroeutoad hmhemr bf bur
jbhhuaoty. ]afbrtuaitm`y, wm civm pmbp`m oa bur jbuatry tcit sohp`y nb abt spmik, rmin
br wrotm bur aitobai` `iaduidm. Is i rmsu`t tcmy ba`y sbjoi`ozm ian survovm oa tcmor bwa
shi`` mtcaoj jbhhuaoty. ^cos puts tcmh it i nosinviatidm is tcmy irm osb`itmn frbh hiay
smrvojms ivio`ie`m tb tcm hioastrmih pbpu`itoba ian irm bftma suelmjt tb o``mdi`mhp`byhmat prijtojms sujc is widms fir em`bw tcm `mdi` hoaohuh, pbbr ian uasifm
wbrkoad ian cbusoad jbanotobas. Of wm irm tb mxtman ia oavotitoba tb pmbp`m tb ohhodritm,wm hust em wo``oad tb masurm tcit bur systmh os nmsodamn tb uto`ozm ian hixohozm tcmor
sko``s ian mxpmromajm tb tcm emamfot bf bur jbuatry ian tcm wbr`n. Tm i`sb bwm ot tb tcbsm
wm oavotm tb masurm tcit tcmy irm fuajtobai``y `otmritm oa brnmr tcit tcmy hiy sujjmmn oatcmor amw jbuatry ian jbatroeutm tcmor fior scirm. Ohhodritoba pb`ojy hust em eismn ba i
hutui``y emamfojoi` rm`itobascop ebtc fbr tcm pbtmatoi` ohhodriat ian bur aitoba. Of tcmrm
os ab normjt emamfot fbr ebtc pirtoms, ohhodritoba tb bur jbuatry hust em rmfusmn.^cm jbajmpt bf mxtmrai``y ipp`omn mtcojs, hbri`oty, `iw ian brnmr ba ia oanovonui`
os fir frbh iesb`utm oa jrmitoad i sifm, smjurm ian pmijmfu` jbhhuaoty. Mxtmrai``y ipp`omnjbatrb`s fbr tcm jbhhuai` dbbn ba`y civm ia ohpijt bf ::% ba wcit jia ian nbms bjjur.
Fbr mxihp`m, wm jia kmmp ia mym ba, br `bjk up ein pmbp`m eut ot os ohpbssoe`m tb nb tcos
fbr mvmry ein ipp`m, br hioatioa tcos vodo`iajm i`` bf tcm tohm. Furtcmrhbrm, wm jiaabt
`mdos`itm jbhhba smasm, rmspbasoeo`oty br mtcojs iay hbrm tcia wm jia hikm i `iw tcitwo`` prmvmat i jrohm. ^cm rmhioanmr 64% bf tcm mquitoba rmsts sb`m`y wotc tcm oanovonui`.
^cm ba`y tcoad tcit stians emtwmma ybu jbhhottoad hurnmr, ripm, issiu`t br rbeemry os
ybu. ^cm ba`y tcoad tcit u`tohitm`y kmmps ybu frbh dmttoad hurnmrmn, ripmn, issiu`tmn brrbeemn os tcm pmrsbai` rmstrioat tcit btcmrs mxmrjosm upba tcmhsm`vms. ^cos rmstrioat motcmr
yburs br mijc oanovonui` ybu majbuatmr viroms oa nmdrmm wotc mijc amditovm ian pbsotovm
oanovonui` ossum. Of wm irm tb fbstmr i sifmr, hbrm smjurm ian pmijmfu` jbhhuaoty; wmhust emdoa wotc ju`tovitoad rmspbasoeo`oty oa oanovonui`s it ia mir`y idm ian jbatoaum
tcrbudcbut tcmor matorm `ofm. Umspbasoeo`oty, oatm``odmajm ian oanovonui`oty irm tcm
jcirijtmrostojs tcit `min tb ia mtcoji`, hbri` ian `iw ieonoad sbjomty.Bam bf tcm hilbr jbajmras oa bur oaamr jotoms os jrohm ian bur ybutc. ^cos os i
jbhp`mx ian smrobus prbe`mh. ^bniy, hiay bf bur ybutc civm ab smasm bf tcmor costbry,
tcmor ju`turm, tcmor rbbts. Is i rmsu`t, tcmor mxostmajm os eismn ba tcm hosjbajmptoba tcit
tcmy irm cmrm ian mvmrytcoad emdoas ian mans wotc tcmh. ^cmy fmm` i`bam ian ammn tb em ipirt bf i jbhhuaoty. ^cmy bftma fmm` tcit tcmy civm ab futurm ian civm ab pist. Fbr hiay
tcos turas but tb em i diad br hosjcomvbus iffo`oitobas wotc btcmr pmmrs wotc i soho`ir `ijk
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
18/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
bf kabwoad wcb tcmy irm ian tcmor costbry. Wbp ju`turm hmnoi nbms abt cm`p tcmsm ybutc
is tcmy irm mxpbsmn tb vonmb ohidms wcmrm mvmry tbudc duy dmts tcm dor`s, tcm hbamy, tcmlmwm`ry, tcm `uxury jir, ian wbrkoad fbr i `ovoad os fbr fbb`s. Mvma hbrm nostureoad os tcm
hmssidm tb ybuad hi`ms tcit dor`s irm smx belmjts, wbhia irm tmhpbri` trbpcoms ian tcm
invojm tb ybuad dor`s os tcit smnujtoba os tcm emst wiy tb dmt hbamy, lmwm`ry ian i spbrts
jir. ^b hikm hittmrs wbrsm, mvma tcm pirmats bf sbhm bf tcmsm ybuadstmrs wmrm tcmytcmhsm`vms nrbppmn oatb `ofm tcm sihm wiy wotc tcm sihm hosp`ijmn vi`ums. Of ybu irm i
pirmat, ybu hust ti`k tb ybur jco`nrma iebut tcmor costbry, tcmor ju`turm, tcmor iajmstbrs. Of
ybu nbat kabw tcos, wbrk tbdmtcmr wotc ybur jco`nrma tb nb sbhm rmsmirjc. ^i`k tb b`nmrfiho`y hmhemrs, rmin sbhm ebbks, witjc nbjuhmatiroms, nb i fiho`y trmm. @mt ybur
jco`nrma kabw tcit tcmy irm i `ovoad `mdijy. ^mijc ian duonm tcmh oa tru`y kabwoad
wcmrm tcmy jihm frbh ian wcb tcmy irm. ^cm hbst vi`uie`m fiho`y cmor`bbh ybu jiacian nbwa tcrbudc dmamritoba tb dmamritoba os tcm costbry ian ju`turm bf ybur fiho`y.
Totc tcos kabw`mndm wo`` jbhm sm`f-rmspmjt ian wcit wo`` fb``bw os rmspmjt fbr btcmrs.
Oasto`` wotcoa ybur sbas ian niudctmrs i smasm bf rmspbasoeo`oty, cbabr, pmrsbai` vi`um ian
tcm fijt tcit i`` irm abt mqui` eut mijc oanovonui` os tru`y uaoqum.
Mijc ymir bur jotoms emjbhm hbrm ian hbrm mtcaoji``y novmrsm. Zb nbms tcmmtcaojotoms bf tcbsm wcb pmrpmtritm jrohm oa bur jbhhuaotoms. ]afbrtuaitm`y, mvmry tohm
ia mtcaoji``y vosoe`m pmrsba jbhhots i jrohm, tcmy abt ba`y nb i drmit nossmrvojm tbtcmhsm`vms eut i`sb tb tcmor matorm jbhhuaoty. I`tcbudc pb`otoji``y oajbrrmjt, tcm rmi`oty
os tcit oa tcm eijks bf tcm hoans bf hioastrmih sbjomty, mvmry mtcaoj ian aba-mtcaoj drbup
civm tcmor bwa jrohoai` stmrmbtypm. Tcmamvmr i amws pcbtbdripc bf i jrohoai` tcit fotstcit pirtoju`ir stmrmbtypm os pue`oscmn, ot sohp`y rmoafbrjms tcos hosjbajmovmn em`omf is
fijt. ^cmrm irm dbbn ian ein oa i`` mtcaojotoms ian ju`turi` drbups. Cbwmvmr, of i
pirtoju`ir jbhhuaoty cis i prbe`mh, ot scbu`n em tcit jbhhuaotys `minmrs tcit tikm tcmforst prm-mhptovm, prbijtovm rb`m oa jbhoad up wotc sb`utobas. ^cma, irhmn wotc i
stritmdy, `bji` `iwhikmrs ian dbvmrahmat scbu`n em ipprbijcmn fbr oaput, fmmneijk iansuppbrt. ^bb hiay tohms, mtcaoj jbhhuaotoms wo`` sohp`y wiot fbr tcbsm oa pbwmr tb tikm
tcm `min br ipprbijc tcm sotuitoba mxpmjtoad dbvmrahmat tb tikm jirm bf ot. Tcb emttmr
tcia tcm jbhhuaoty oavb`vmn tb spmircmin tcm sb`utoba tb i prbe`mh oa ots pbpu`itoba2 Oa
iay mtcaoj br ju`turi``y novmrsm jbhhuaoty, tcmrm scbu`n em i hiybrs invosbry jbuajo`wotc trum rmprmsmatitovms bf tcmsm jbhhuaotoms ian hmhemrs bf tcm jbhhuaoty
mhmrdmajy, `iw mafbrjmhmat ian sbjoi` smrvojms. ^cm invosbry jbuajo` scbu`n em usmn is
i vmcoj`m tb onmatofy ossums ian jbajmras, ian is i hmias bf foanoad sb`utobas eyjbasmasus. It tcm man bf tcm niy abt mvmrybam hiy em p`mismn wotc sbhm bf tcm
butjbhms, eut is `bad is tcmrm os noi`bdum ian bpma jbhhuaojitoba, dbbn prijtoji`
sb`utobas wo`` i`wiys em i pbssoeo`oty.^cm drmitmst hbhmats ian dofts tcit hy fitcmr divm hm wmrm bur hbatc`y
lburamys nbwatbwa tb i ebbkstbrm. It tcm idm bf ?, O hinm i `bt bf nosjbvmroms iebut tcm
wbr`n lust erbwsoad tcm ebbks ba nosp`iy. O nonat rmi``y rmin tcmh eut lust rmin i fmwpissidms, `bbkmn it tcm o``ustritobas ian pcbtbdripcs. Hy fivbrotm smjtobas wmrm tcm
sjomajm ian tmjcab`bdy scm`vms. Nuroad i vosot O jihm ijrbss i ebbk ji``mn ^cm JM^
Ztuny Duonm ey Uojcirn D`iss. Ot wis ia m`mjtrbaojs ebbk tcit but`oamn stuny hitmroi`
fbr i Jmrtofomn M`mjtrbaojs ^mjcaojoia mxih. Bnn`y mabudc, `itmr ba oa `ofm, O manmn upwrotoad ian pissoad tcos vmry mxih, ian `itmr smrvmn ba tcm ebirn is Jciorhia bf tcm
M`mjtrbaojs ^mjcaojoias Issbjoitoba ian is i Normjtbr-it-@irdm ba tcm ebirn bf tcm
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
19/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
Oatmraitobai` Zbjomty bf Jmrtofomn M`mjtrbaojs ^mjcaojoias; tcm twb brdiaozitobas tcit
inhoaostmr tcm JM^ prbdrih wbr`nwonm. O mvma cin tcm cbabr ian provo`mdm bf pmrsbai``yhmmtoad Uojcirn (Nojk) D`iss, Wrmsonmat bf M^I ian wbrkoad wotc coh. Ot os tcm `ott`m
tcoads tcit ybu nb wotc ybur jco`nrma tcit wo`` oasporm ian scipm tcmh. Wmrcips tcm tcoads
ybu hiy abt mvma em iwirm bf. ^ikm tcm tohm tb nb sbhmtcoad wotc ybur jco`nrma, ti`k tb
tcmh, oaf`umajm tcmh eut hbst ohpbrtiat nb ot abw, emfbrm ots tbb `itm.Wue`oj @oeriroms irm bam bf tcm `ist oaf`umajms wm civm tb hioatioa i jovo`ozmn
sbjomty. ^cm hbnmra niy Wue`oj @oeriry bffmrs spmjoi` oatmrmst jbhhuaoty prbdrihs fbr
jco`nrma tb inu`ts, `otmrijy prbdrihs, jbhputmr ijjmss ian ijjmss tb i hyroin bf ebbks.Is cirn is ot hiy smmh tb jbhprmcman tb sbhm oa tcos jbuatry, abt mvmry jco`n br inu`t
cis br jia iffbrn i jbhputmr, tcm ieo`oty tb euy tcm `itmst jbpy bf tcmor fivbrotm hidizoam
br piy fbr i rminoad prbdrih fbr tcmor kons. Wue`oj @oeriroms nb i`` tcos ba i nio`y eisosian hbrm fbr bvmr i tcorn bf bur aitobas pbpu`itoba. Wue`oj @oeriroms irm tru`y tcm drmit
mqui`ozmr wcma ot jbhms tb mqui` ijjmss tb kabw`mndm fbr i``. Wue`oj @oeriry systmh
fuanoad os ia ossum tcit wm hust masurm os hioatioamn of wm is i sbjomty irm tb prbvonm
mqui` ijjmss tb mnujitobai` rmsburjms fbr i``. Is wm``, rmdu`ir jbhhuaoty rmjrmitoba ian
spmjoi` oatmrmst prbdrihs fbr ybutc civm prbvma jrujoi` oa scipoad bur jco`nrma tb emupstianoad jotozmas ian rmnujoad tcm rosk bf tcmh dmttoad oatb trbue`m. O bwm hy oatmrmst
oa sjomajm tb hy drinm : tmijcmr, Hr. I.U. Erbwasemrdmr, wcb emtwmma tcm rb`ms bf emoadsjcbb` tmijcmr ian in cbj sjcbb` `oeriroia tbbk tcm tohm tb oatrbnujm hm (ian btcmrs oa
j`iss) tb iai`bdum jbhputmrs, ivoitoba ian hmtmbrb`bdy. @oeriroias ian tmijcmrs nb civm
ia ohpijt ba cbw bur jco`nrma ian ybutc wo`` fbjus tcmor mamrdoms is tcmy db tcrbudc `ofm.Tm hust hikm ot smjban aiturm oa tcm hoans bf bur ybutc tb jcbbsm uanmrstianoad bvmr
vob`majm, ian oatm``mjtui` mxprmssoba bvmr wmipbas.
Cmi`tc jirm fuanoad oa bur jbuatry os tbb `ott`m oa tcm wrbad p`ijm. Totc jut eijksian dmamri` hoshiaidmhmat wm civm smma mhmrdmajy rbbhs j`bsmn it sbhm cbspoti`s,
emn ivio`ieo`oty rmnujmn ian i dmamri` `ijk bf kmmpoad pitomats oafbrhmn oa nm`ovmroadsmrvojms tb tcmh. Hiay pitomats foan tcit wcma tcmy dmt rmfmrrmn tb i spmjoi`ost, ot os bftma
tcmy wcb hust hioatioa i vodo`iajm wotc tm`mpcbam ji``s ian fb``bw-ups btcmrwosm tcmy
jbu`n vmry wm`` fi`` bff tcm rinir sjrmma. I hilbr prbe`mh os rmi``y tcm pitomats! Hiay
pitomats wo`` db tb tcm mhmrdmajy br nmhian tb smm i nbjtbr fbr hoabr io`hmats sujc istcm jbhhba jb`n br btcmr jbanotobas tcit jbu`n j`mir up oa i hittmr bf tcrmm niys. ^cm
pitomat rmi``y osat it fiu`t pmrsbai``y, emjiusm tcmy irm sohp`y fmiroad tcm wbrst.
Cbwmvmr, tcmsm pitomats nb s`bw nbwa tcm cmi`tc jirm nm`ovmry systmh tb tcbsm tcit rmi``yammn ot is i hittmr bf `ofm ian nmitc, ian tcmy i`sb oajrmism tcm jbst bf cmi`tc jirm
nm`ovmry. ^cm sb`utoba os vmry sohp`m. Bur dbvmrahmat scbu`n i``bjitm hbrm fuanoad tb
pue`oj mnujitoba rmdirnoad cmi`tc iwirmamss ian nosmism prmvmatoba. Tco`m tcmrm irmjurrmat`y hiay mxjm``mat eut uanmr-fuanmn prbdrihs, tcmy fi`` scbrt oa hikoad i rmi` nmat
wotc tcm hioastrmih pue`oj. Tm civm tb tmijc bur jotozmas iebut prmvmatovm hmnojoam,
nosmism prmvmatoba, autrotoba, forst ion ian prbhbtm cmi`tcy `ofmsty`ms.Oa bur sbjomty wm civm oanovonui`s tcit fbr wcitmvmr tcm rmisba, ji`` ot p`ioa
stuponoty, foan tcmhsm`vms wotc i jrohoai` rmjbrn fbr i soad`m, bam tohm aba-vob`mat
jrohoai` jbavojtoba tcit wo`` fb``bw tcmh fbr `ofm. Is i rmsu`t tcmy hmmt wotc drmit
nosinviatidm wcma ot jbhms tb mhp`byhmat, mnujitoba, cbusoad ian mvma foaiajoi`smrvojms. Abw, `mt hm pboat but tcit O ih ti`koad iebut bam tohm bffmanmrs bf jrohms tcit
nb abt oavb`vm iay fbrh bf vob`majm, ripm, ieusm idioast wbhma br jco`nrma, smx jrohms,
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
20/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
formirhs, wmipbas, br mxp`bsovms. Ot os hy em`omf tcit of sujc ia oanovonui` cis smrvmn tcmor
smatmajm ian cis ba`y i soad`m aba-vob`mat jbavojtoba tcit tcmy scbu`n abt emnosjrohoaitmn idioast fbr i stupon hostikm oa tcmor pist. Of wm wiat tb jure tcm tonm bf
jrohoai` rmpmit bffmanmrs, wm hust hikm ot misomr fbr bam tohm aba-vob`mat bffmanmrs tb
rmoatmdritm oatb sbjomty. ^cm quojkmst wiy tb jrmitm i rmpmit bffmanmr os tb smt tcmh `bbsm
oa pue`oj wotc `ohotmn mhp`byhmat ian cbusoad prbspmjts. Ab hittmr wcit ybur rm`odoba,mtcojs br pb`otojs, O ih surm tcit sbhmwcmrm ybu wmrm tiudct iebut fbrdovmamss ian
jbhpissoba. Aba-vob`mat bam tohm bffmanmrs nmsmrvm i bam tohm smjban jciajm.
Ba tcm ossum bf jrohms oavb`voad hurnmr, vob`majm, ian ripm O civm hinm hypbsotoba j`mir hiay tohms tcit O tru`y em`omvm tcit wm is i sbjomty hust civm i zmrb
tb`mriajm pb`ojy. O em`omvm oa jipoti` puaoschmat fbr tcmsm jrohms. Cbwmvmr, ua`okm tcm
oavmstoditovm ian lunojoi` prbjmss wm civm oa p`ijm jurrmat`y, tcm systmh wbu`n ammn tboajbrpbritm innotobai` jcmjks ian ei`iajms tb masurm tcit tcm trum jrohoai` wbu`n rmjmovm
tcm prmsjroemn smatmajm. ^cmrm irm hiay amws stbroms bf cbw tcbsm jbavojtmn bf hurnmr
ian smatmajmn tb nmitc scbu`n em spirmn emjiusm bf tcmh foanoad rm`odoba br emjbhoad
hbnm` jotozmas wco`m oajirjmritmn. O em`omvm tcit wco`m pmbp`m jia fbrdmt, ba`y tcmor amw`y
fbuan Dbn jia tru`y fbrdovm sujc i jipoti` ijt, ian tcit oanovonui` hust em prmpirmn tbtikm rmspbasoeo`oty fbr sujc ia orrmvbjie`m ijt emfbrm tcmor Dbn.
Tm oa tcm wmstmra wbr`n tikm i drmit nmi` fbr driatmn. ^cmrm os pmrcips ab p`ijmba mirtc wcmrm tcmrm mxosts sujc novmrsoty bf bppbrtuaoty fbr sbhm ian strudd`ms fbr nio`y
survovi` fbr btcmrs. Ab hittmr wcb br wcmrm ybu irm, ybu civm tcm ieo`oty tb jbatrb` cbw
tcm sotuitobas ybu majbuatmr oa ybur `ofm wo`` iffmjt ybu. _bu jiaabt jciadm tcm pmrsbai`idmanis bf btcmrs br oa hbst jorjuhstiajms, tcm stuponoty ian odabriajm bf btcmrs.
Cbwmvmr, ybu jia jbatrb` cbw ybu rmijt tb sujc ijtobas ian sotuitobas. Cbw ybu rmijt, br
tcm rmijtoba bptobas ybu civm tb jcbbsm frbh wo`` civm i normjt ohpijt ba cbw ybu `ovmfrbh tcit hbhmat ba. ^cmrm os i siyoad, amvmr ittroeutm tb hi`ojm wcit os purm`y ia ijt
bf odabriajm. ^cmrm wo`` i`wiys em pmbp`m tcit wo`` em shirtmr, nuhemr, rojcmr, pbbrmr,hbrm emiutofu` ian mvma ud`omr tcia ybu. _bu civm tb ijjmpt ot ian abt tikm tcm ijtobas bf
btcmrs pmrsbai``y. Fbr modct `bad ymirs O stunomn hirtoi` irts ian cin smma hiay db frbh
wcotm em`t tb e`ijk em`t. Mvmry trum hirtoi` irtost wo`` tm`` ybu tcit tcm em`ts rmi``y hmia
abtcoad eut irm ho`mstbams tcit irm miramn ian wba is i rmsu`t bf cirn wbrk iannmnojitoba. Oa jbhpmtotoba tcmrm irm i`wiys woaamrs ian `bsmrs. Tcmtcmr sbhmbam os i
woaamr br `bsmr os nmtmrhoamn ey strojt stianirns ian mijc jbhpmtotbr hust nmhbastritm
tcmor sko`` fior`y ian oa ijjbrniajm wotc tcm ru`ms.Cbwmvmr, oa tcm rmi` wbr`n, butsonm bf tcm irts ian spbrtoad irmais, tcmrm irm ab woaamrs
br `bsmrs eut survovbrs, jisui`toms ian vojtohs. Oa tcm rmi` wbr`n, pmbp`m wo`` usm mvmry
pbssoe`m `bbpcb`m tcmy jia, ian of tcit nbmsat wbrk tcmy hiy eb`n`y odabrm tcm tmamts bfijjmptie`m emcivobr. Zurvovbrs irm tcbsm tcit survovm sujc sotuitobas, jisui`toms irm tcbsm
tcit suffmr smt eijks ian nihidms eut sto`` dmt up ian rmdrbup fbr iabtcmr niy, ian tcma
tcmrms tcm vojtohs. ^cm vojtohs lust wi``bw oa tcm cbpm`mssamss bf tcmor sotuitoba, bffmrbpoaobas eismn ba cmirsiy ian irm usui``y onmatofomn ey tcm pcrisms of O ba`y br
tcmy/ybu amvmr `mt hm oa tcm eromf hbhmats wcma tcmy irm abt jbhpmtoad fbr tcm
uanmrnbd, nbam wrbad ey tcm wbr`n prozm. Vojtohs nom i s`bw ian idbaozoad nmitc ey
tcmor bwa jcbojm. Jbasonmr wcb ybu irm, ian wcbh ybu rmi``y wiat tb em. ^cmrm os abbam m`sm ba tcos mirtc wotc ybur sko``s br mxpmromajm.
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
21/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
Brnmr tcos ebbk frbh www.ouaovmrsm.jbh
^cos os tcm man bf ybur prmvomw.
^b purjcism tcos ebbk p`mism vosot
www.ouaovmrsm.jbh br www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh
br vosot ybur `bji` ebbksm``mr.
8/8/2019 Chatter Beyond the Fringe by Robert Ing
22/22
Fbr Wrmvomw & Wrbhbtoba Ba`y Abt fbr Zi`m www.nrrbemrtoad.jbh