23
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

Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!"#$ %&'()*$$!

"#$! ! "%&'()*+&+),(-+%*)!./-!$*0(1,2!34,%-)56%,7!%&'!8(49,:-+)56(-6(+,!;<(-*4&!#+&+),-=!.:-!,6(!>&?+-:&*(&,@!ABCD>! A(&,-:!BE-:&F*+5:!C-:G+541!'(!D&?(),+E45+F&!=!>&)(H4&74!;IG4+&@! ;C-:G+541!BE-+5%1,%-(!8()(4-56!4&'!J+E6(-!

>'%54,+:&!A(&,-(@!A>K>LMB8!! A(&,-:!'(!K()(&?:1?+*(&,:!(!L14&(N4*(&,:!8(E+:&41!'( #+&4)!<(-4+)!;A(&,(-!.:-!8(E+:&41!K(?(1:G*(&,!4&'!

L14&&+&E!:.!,6(!$&+?(-)+'4'(!O('(-41!'(!#+&4)!<(-4+)@!AK#! A1(4&!K(?(1:G*(&,!#(564&+)*!ADB! A(&,-41!D&,(11+E(&5(!BE(&5=!!ADOP8! ! A(&,(-!.:-!D&,(-&4,+:&41!O:-(),-=!8()(4-56!!AD#! A:*+,Q!D&,(-*+&+),(-+41!):R-(!#%'4&S4!':!A1+*4!;D&,(-T#+&+),(-+41!A:**+,,((!:&!A1+*4,(!A64&E(@!ALC>A! A(&,-:!'(!L-(?+)U:!'(!C(*G:!(!>),%':)!A1+*V,+5:)!;A(&,-(!.:-!W(4,6(-!O:-(54),+&E!4&'!A1+*4,(!I,%'+()@!>AMBA!! ! >5:&:*+5!A:**+))+:&!.:-!M4,+&!B*(-+54!4&'!,6(!A4-+RR(4&!>$! ! >%-:G(4&!$&+:&!!O3#A! O%&':!345+:&41!I:R-(!#%'4&S4!A1+*V,+54!;34,+:&41!A1+*4,(!A64&E(!O%&'@!<KL! <-:))!K:*(),+5!L-:'%5,!!<>O! ! <1:R41!>&?+-:&*(&,!O45+1+,=!<J<! E-((&6:%)(!E4)!<DX! K(%,)56(!<()(11)564.,!./-!D&,(-&4,+:&41(!X%)4**(&4-R(+,!!<L#A! <-%G:!'(!L()Y%+)4!(*!#%'4&S4)!A1+*V,+54)!;A1+*4,(!A64&E(!8()(4-56!<-:%G@!;6:%)('!%&'(-!D3L>@!DBK"! ! D&,(-TB*(-+54&!K(?(1:G*(&,!"4&9!D>#! ! D&,(E-4,('!>5:)=),(*!#4&4E(*(&,!D3DB! !D&),+,%,:!345+:&41!'(!D&?(),+E45+F&!=!C(5&:1:EZ4!BE-4-+4!=!B1+*(&,4-+4!;A6+1(@!;34,+:&41!D&),+,%,(!:.!BE-+5%1,%-41!

8()(4-56@!D3L>! D&),+,%,:!345+:&41!'(!L()Y%+)4)!>)G45+4+)!;34,+:&41!D&),+,%,(!:&!IG45(!8()(4-56@!D[D<! D&),+,%,:![+-,%41!'(!#%'4&S4)!<1:R4+)!;[+-,%41!D&),+,%,(!:.!<1:R41!A64&E()@!D3AC!! D&),+,%,:!345+:&41!'(!A+Q&5+4!(!C(5&:1:E+4!;34,+:&41!D&),+,%,(!:.!I5+(&5(!4&'!C(56&:1:E=@!DLAA! D&,(-E:?(-&*(&,41!L4&(1!:&!A1+*4,(!A64&E(!#"IA<! #:'(1:!"-4)+1(+-:!':!I+),(*4!A1+*V,+5:!<1:R41!;"-47+1+4&!<1:R41!A1+*4,(!I=),(*!#:'(1@!

Page 2: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

"#$! "%&%'()*%+!,-!#%.&/%0!-!$-/&+1+2%0!3"%&%'(*4!+5!6/%-&/-!0&,!$-/7&+1+248!""9! "%&%'()*%+!,+!"-%+!9:;%-&(-!3"%&%'(*4!+5!<&=%*+&:-&(8!>96! ! >*20&%?0(%+&!+5!9:-*%/0&!6(0(-'!@A"#! @0%&-1!A*0'%1-%*+'!,-!"B,0&C0'!#1%:D(%/0'!3A*0?%1%0&!@0&-1!+&!#1%:0(-!#70&2-8!@E"#! @10&+!E0/%+&01!'+;*-!"B,0&C0'!#1%:D(%/0'!3E0(%+&01!#1%:0(-!#70&2-!@10&8!F<G<!#HI"9! F-,-! A*0'%1-%*0! ,-! @-'JB%'0'! '+;*-!"B,0&C0'! #1%:D(%/0'!K1+;0%'! 3A*0?%1%0&!K1+;01! #1%:0(-! #70&2-! F-'-0*/7!

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`!

9!=-*4!7%27NP*+;0;%1%(4!(7-!1-''!5*-JB-&(!0&,!:+*-!=0*%0;1-!*0%&5011!L%11!-R0/-*;0(-!L0(-*!%&'-/B*%(4!%&!(7-!'-:%N0*%,!&+*(7-0'(-*&!A*0?%1T!P0*(%/B10*14!%5!P+PB10(%+&!2*+L(7!%'!/+&'%,-*-,Z!K*+B&,L0(-*!*-/70*2-!:04!,%:%&%'7!;4!^X!P-*!/-&(!%&!A*0?%1 '!E+*(7-0'(Z!!

Page 3: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

"! #$%#! &'()*)$+$,-! (.! $/0'1*213! '*$/.*++! $/! 2(4,#51*2,1'/! 6'*7$+! 8$++! 0(9&'(9$21! 0'(&! -$1+32! */3! $/0'1*21! ,#1! .'1:41/0-! */3!$/,1/2$,-!(.!.+((3$/%;!

"!#$%#!&'()*)$+$,-!(.!)$(3$<1'2$,-!+(22=!$/0+43$/%!,#1!%'*34*+!'1&+*0191/,!(.!,#1!"9*7(/!8$,#!2*<*//*#2!*/3!3121',$.$0*,$(/!(.!219$5*'$3!'1%$(/2!$/!>(',#1*2,!6'*7$+;!

"!#$%#!&'()*)$+$,-!,#*,!$/0'1*2$/%!21*!+1<1+!8$++!*..10,!6'*7$+ 2!0(*2,*+!*'1*2;! ?+()*+!0+$9*,1!0#*/%1!0(4+3!'*$21!'*$/.*++!'*,12=!,#42!1@*01')*,$/%!$9&*0,2!0*4213!)-!1'(2$(/!*/3!+*/32+$312;!6'*7$+ 2!/(',#1*2,!$2!&*',$04+*'+-! <4+/1'*)+1! *2! 1'(2$(/!#*2! *+'1*3-!0*4213! 213$91/,*,$(/!(.! '121'<($'2! */3! 24)21:41/,+-! '134013!8*,1'! 2,('*%1! */3!24&&+-!0*&*0$,-;!A#*/,-!,(8/2!B.*<1+*2C=! +(0*,13!(/!2,11&!2+(&12!$/!91,'(&(+$,*/!*'1*2=!*'1!*+2(!12&10$*++-!<4+/1'*)+1!,(!1'(2$(/!*/3!+*/32+$312;!

D+$9*,1!0#*/%1!9*-!$9&*0,!#49*/!#1*+,#=!&*',$04+*'+-!8$,#!,#1!2&'1*3!(.!<10,('5)('/1!3$21*212!B$;1;!31/%41!.1<1'C!*/3!3$21*212!'124+,$/%!.'(9!3$9$/$2#13!8*,1'!:4*+$,-;!

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

Page 4: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#

$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

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

82"9*$*"/&A%0*3/& )$*+",%&)."/0%&1234%-,*3/& <3,%/,*"$&:+1"-,5&

;)-/9##

<'.63,1'.=#/9%#

4:0>).?#

2%@@':'@/'6#4A#86%.0-')7#B%:5%-0/,-%@#-'@%#CD#EFG)+H#I"FAJK#-0'.*033#

-%1,6/').#

L5/':'@/'6#MA#86%.0-')7#B%:5%-0/,-%@#-'@%#CD#NF")+H#"FI"K#-0'.*033#

-%1,6/').#

O.6-%0@%#'.#%P/-%:%#-0'.*033#%&%./@#'.#/9%#Q%@/%-.#4:0>).#0.1#

'.6-%0@%#'.#6).@%6,/'&%#10D@#('/9),/#-0'.#'.#/9%#R0@/%-.#4:0>).#

2)@@'C'3'/D#)*#:)-%#'./%.@%#0.1#*-%S,%./#1-),=9/@#0*/%-#AJ"J#

3)@@#)*#%6)@D@/%:#@%-&'6%@#0.1#C')1'&%-@'/D#'.#/9%#4:0>).#

-%1,6%1#-'&%-#*3)(@H#0**%6/'.=#/-0.@5)-/0/').#0.1#9D1-)%3%6/-'6#5)(%-#

-%1,6%1#9,:'1'/D#0.1#/9,@#*0&)-0C3%#6).1'/').@#*)-#*)-%@/#*'-%@#

-'@T#/90/#/9%#4:0>).#:0D#C%6):%#0#@0&0..09#

':506/@#).#9,:0.#9%03/9H#:'=-0/').#0.1#6)::%-6%#

%**%6/@#).#/9%#/-0.@5)-/0/').#)*#0/:)@59%-'6#9,:'1'/D#/)#/9%#

@),/9%0@/#)*#8),/9#4:%-'60#

;)-/9%0@/# 2%@@':'@/'6#4A#86%.0-')7#B%:5%-0/,-%@#-'@%#CD#AFE)+H#I"FAJK#-0'.*033#

-%1,6/').#

L5/':'@/'6#MA#86%.0-')7#B%:5%-0/,-%@#-'@%#CD#IFN)+H#IJFI"K#-0'.*033#

-%1,6/').#

O.6-%0@%1#6).@%6,/'&%#10D@#('/9),/#-0'.#0.1#0'-#1-D.%@@#

O.6-%0@%1#%&05)/-0.@5'-0/').#*-):#-%@%-&)'-@#

2)@@'C'3'/D#)*#:)-%#*-%S,%./#0.1#'./%.@%#1-),=9/@#

O.6-%0@%1#1%@%-/'*'60/').#-'@T# 2)@@'C3%#@%0#3%&%3#-'@%#

3)@@#)*#%6)@D@/%:#@%-&'6%@#0.1#C')1'&%-@'/D#*-):#/9%#600/'.=0#C'):%#

-%1,6%1#-'&%-#*3)(@H#0**%6/'.=#/-0.@5)-/0/').#0.1#9D1-)%3%6/-'6#5)(%-#

-%1,6%1#0=-'6,3/,-03#5-)1,6/'&'/D#-%@,3/'.=#*-):#'.6-%0@%1#0-'1'/D#

6):5-):'@%1#(0/%-#@%6,-'/D#

':506/@#).#9,:0.#9%03/9H#:'=-0/').H#/),-'@:#0.1#%:53)D:%./#

'.6-%0@%1#@)6'03#6).*3'6/# 5)/%./'03#-%1,6/').#'.#'.#0S,'*%-#-%690-=%#CD#AJ"J#

+%./-03FQ%@/#

<'.63,1'.=#/9%#

20./0.03?#

2%@@':'@/'6#4A#86%.0-')7#B%:5%-0/,-%@#-'@%#CD#NFU)+H#'.6-%0@%1#-0'.*033#

'./%.@'/D#0.1#'--%=,30-'/D#

L5/':'@/'6#MA#86%.0-')7#B%:5%-0/,-%@#-'@%#CD#AFE)+H#'.6-%0@%1#-0'.*033#

'./%.@'/D#0.1#'--%=,30-'/D#

'.6-%0@%1#.,:C%-#)*#%P/-%:%#-0'.*033#%&%./@#0.1#6).@%6,/'&%#10D@#

('/9),/#-0'.*033#

-%1,6%1#0=-'6,3/,-03#5-)1,6/'&'/D# '.6-%0@%1#9%0/#(0&%@#('/9#':506/@#).#9%03/9#0.1#%.%-=D#6).@,:5/').#

'.6-%0@%1#@)6'03#6).*3'6/#

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!=$!&'()T99MJ%!0::*UTT7+238F3/F-.73:.F3/@F*:[email protected]*1@,4T!!

Page 5: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!"#$%&%#'()*+%,'( -&%.#/*(-0#'+*(1",2*3/%,'( 4,/*'/%#&(5.1#3/6(

6):5-):';%1#(0/%-#;%6,-'/<# ':506/;#).#/9%#50./0.03#0.1#6%--01)#='):%;>#'.6-%0;%1#*'-%#-';?#

8),/9%0;/# 2%;;':';/'6#4@#86%.0-')7#A%:5%-0/,-%;#-';%#=<#BCB)+>#'.6-%0;%1#-0'.*033#'./%.;'/<#0.1#'--%D,30-'/<##

E5/':';/'6#F@#86%.0-')7#A%:5%-0/,-%;#-';%#=<#@CB)+>#'.6-%0;%1#-0'.*033#'./%.;'/<#0.1#'--%D,30-'/<##

2);;'=3%#;%0#3%&%3#-';%#

'.6-%0;%1#*-%G,%.6<#)*#*3))1'.D#0.1#30.1;3'1%;# -%1,6%1#0D-'6,3/,-03#5-)1,6/'&'/<#0.1#6):5-):';%1#*))1#;%6,-'/<# '.6-%0;%1#9%0/#(0&%;#('/9#':506/;#).#9%03/9#0.1#%.%-D<#6).;,:5/').# 6):5-):';%1#(0/%-#;%6,-'/<# '.6-%0;%1#;)6'03#6).*3'6/# ':506/;#).#%6);<;/%:;#;,69#0;#/9%#4/30./'6#$0'.*)-%;/#

8),/9# 2%;;':';/'6#4@7#A%:5%-0/,-%;#-';%#=<#@CH)+>#ICJKL#'.6-%0;%#'.#-0'.*033#'./%.;'/<#0.1#'--%D,30-'/<#

E5/':';/'6#F@7#A%:5%-0/,-%;#-';%#=<#JCB)+>#KCIL#'.6-%0;%#'.#-0'.*033#'./%.;'/<#0.1#'--%D,30-'/<##

'.6-%0;%1#%M/-%:%#-0'.*033#%&%./;#0.1#6<63).%;# '.6-%0;%1#*-%G,%.6<#)*#9%0/#(0&%;#0.1#(0-:%-#.'D9/;# 5);;'=3%#;%0#3%&%3#-';%#

9%03/9#':506/;#'.63,1'.D#'.6-%0;%1#)66,--%.6%#)*#/-)5'603#1';%0;%;# 0D-'6,3/,-03#5-)1,6/'&'/<#6):5-):';%1#=<#9'D9%-#/%:5%-0/,-%;#0.1#'./%.;%#-0'.*033#

'.6-%0;%1#6);/#)*#*))1# '.6-%0;%1#*3))1'.D#0.1#30.1;3'1%#-';?# '.6-%0;%1#;)6'03#6).*3'6/# ':506/;#).#%6);<;/%:;#;,69#0;#/9%#4-0,6N-'0#*)-%;/#0.1#50:50;#

!!"##$%&'()!*$!*+,!-('*'./!.(&!0,#$(&!1.*'$(./!2$334('#.*'$(!5627!899:;!627!89<9=!>%'$%'*?!.&.>*.*'$(!%,@,.%#+!.%,.@!'(#/4&,A!

B%$4)+*!'(!*+,!1$%*+,.@*C!.@!D,//!.@!'(!$*+,%!%,)'$(@!$E!*+,!#$4(*%?!.(&!'*@!'3>.#*@!$(!.)%'#4/*4%,!.(&!+?&%$,/,#*%'#!),(,%.*'$(;!

F/$$&@!*+.*!>%,@,(*!.!@,%'$4@!>%$G/,3!'(!H.%'$4@!%,)'$(@C!'(#/4&'()!*+,!3,*%$>$/'*.(!%,)'$(!$E!I'$!&,!J.(,'%$;!

F%$@*!.(&!'*@!'3>.#*@C!3.'(/?!$(!#$EE,,!.(&!$%.(),!#%$>@C!'(!>.%*'#4/.%!'(!*+,!0$4*+!.(&!0$4*+,.@*!%,)'$(@;!

-3>.#*@!$E!#/'3.*,!#+.(),!$(!*+,!>%$&4#*'H'*?!$E!.)%'#4/*4%./!#%$>@!5#$%(C!@$?G,.(C!D+,.*C!,*#K=!$E!#$(@'&,%.G/,!'3>$%*.(#,!*$!L%.M'/ @!NBO;!

P4/(,%.G'/'*?!$E!#$.@*./!M$(,@!G,#.4@,!$E!%'@'()!@,.!/,H,/@C!.(&! '3>/,3,(*.*'$(!$E!.!>%,H,(*.*'H,!.>>%$.#+!'(!@,/,#*'()!@'*,@!E$%!4%G.(!,Q>.(@'$(!.(&!'(&4@*%'./!&,H,/$>3,(*;!

P4/(,%.G'/'*?!'(!*+,!.%,.!$E!+43.(!+,./*+C!,@>,#'.//?!%,/.*,&!*$!*+,!*%.(@3'@@'$(!$E!H.%'$4@!'(E,#*'$4@!&'@,.@,@!D+$@,!H,#*$%@!.(&!>.%.@'*,@!.%,!>.%*'#4/.%/?!@,(@'G/,!*$!#/'3.*'#!#+.(),@!53./.%'.C!&,()4,C!,*#K=;!

-3>.#*@!$E!#/'3.*,!#+.(),!$(!*+,!,/,#*%'#./!@,#*$%!)'H,(!*+,!>%,&$3'(.(#,!$E!+?&%$,/,#*%'#!),(,%.*'$(!'(!*+,!#$4(*%?;!.(&!

2$%./!G/,.#+'()!./$()!L%.M'/'.(!#$.@*/'(,@K!!!!

Page 6: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!!"#$%&$'"()"*+,,$-."/-0"12/--$0"30/4./.&(-"35.&(-6"7(+.8"39$,&5/"!

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

M$*(%'!B E#5#2%0/#'*!%1!.*86(#.!%'!582'#,-7(2(*9!-'6!-6-0*-*(%'!*%!*+#! (/0-$*.!%1!$2(/-*#!$+-'&#C!G+#!J#9!%7N#$*(5#!:-.!*%!.*869!$2(/-*#!$+-'&#!(/0-$*.3!582'#,-7(2(*9!-'6!-6-0*-*(%'!('!*+#!-,#-.!%1!-&,($82*8,#3!#$%.9.*#/.3!7(%6(5#,.(*93!:-*#,!,#.%8,$#.3!$%-.*-2!,#.%8,$#.!-'6!+8/-'!+#-2*+C!

M$*(%'!O E#5#2%0/#'*!%1!1%,#$-.*('&!/%6#2.!*%!/%'(*%,!$2(/-*($!$+-'&#.C!G+#!J#9!%7N#$*(5#!:-.!*%!7#&('!-!0,%$#..!%1!.$(#'*(1($!,#.#-,$+! -'6! 6#5#2%0/#'*! %1! $2(/-*#! ('1%,/-*(%'! .9.*#/.3! :(*+! *+#! &%-2! %1! ,#68$('&! 8'$#,*-('*9! -7%8*! *+#! $-8.#.3! #11#$*.3!/-&'(*86#!-'6!$+-'&#.!%5#,!*(/#!%1!$2(/-*($!$+-'&#.!-'6!*+#!#$%'%/($!-'6!.%$(-2!$%'.#W8#'$#.!%1!5-,(%8.!,#.0%'.#!.*,-*#&(#.C!

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`PR[`M*%OPP_<OPBP[OPP_[E#$,#*%[EaOaRC+*/!!BPB!G+#!>+(#1!%1!Y*-11!%1!*+#!Q,#.(6#'$9!%1!*+#!"#0872($!K&'()(*+%*&%,%*&-.-"*+%*/0(,-+123-%*+%*4(56$"-3%L! (.! *+#!+(&+#.*<,-'J('&!/#/7#,!%1!*+#!XU#$8*(5#!D11($#!%1!4,-)(2!-'6!-!.#'(%,!-(6#!*%!*+#!Q,#.(6#'*C!BPO!=('(.*,(#.!%1V!M&,($82*8,#3!b(5#.*%$J!^!F%%6!Y80029c!Y$(#'$#!^!G#$+'%2%&9c!E#1#'.#c!X68$-*(%'c!F('-'$#c!I-*(%'-2!;'*#&,-*(%'c!d#-2*+c!>(*(#.c!F%,#(&'!M11-(,.c!=('#.!^!X'#,&9c!M&,($82*8,#!E#5#2%0/#'*c!E#5#2%0/#'*3!;'68.*,9!^!F%,#(&'!G,-6#c!X'5(,%'/#'*c!Q2-''('&3!486&#*!^!=-'-&#/#'*c!G,-'.0%,*-*(%'!!

Page 7: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

"#$%!&'#($#)*!+,-*,./(!$-0!1-/2.$!3&(&,$#4#1.$#-)!56,-*,./!-4!7.$#-).8!91$#-)!$-!:-/2.$!;&(&,$#4#1.$#-)!.)3!<#$#*.$&!;,-=*%$ !"#$%&'()*+,->?!&($.28#(%! #)$&*,.$&3!".$&,(%&3!,&(-=,1&!/.).*&/&)$?!.)3! 8#)@!"#$%! $%&!7.$#-).8!A)B#,-)/&)$.8!:-=)1#8CDE!.)3! $%&!F,.G#8#.)!H)#4#&3!I&.8$%!JK($&/L!!

!

M-!8&*.88K!&)4-,1&!$%&!-B&,N.,1%#)*!*-.8(!-4!$%&!67<:O!.!7.$#-).8!:8#/.$&!:%.)*&!6-8#1K!".(!.8(-!+.((&3!#)!;&1&/2&,!PDDQO!"%#1%!

,&1-*)#G&(! $%&! #/+-,$.)1&!-4!18#/.$&!1%.)*&!B=8)&,.2#8#$K!($=3#&(!.)3!$%&!)&&3!$-! #)$&*,.$&!18#/.$&!1%.)*&!.3.+$.$#-)! #)$-!/=)#1#+.8O!

,&*#-).8!.)3!).$#-).8!+-8#1KL!M%&!7.$#-).8!:8#/.$&!:%.)*&!6-8#1K!8#($(!.!7.$#-).8!:8#/.$&!:%.)*&!68.)!.)3!.!7.$#-).8!:8#/.$&!:%.)*&!

R=)3!.(!#)($,=/&)$(!$-!,&.1%!#$(!-2S&1$#B&(L!M%&!F,.G#8#.)!*-B&,)/&)$O!B#.!$%&!<#)#($,K!-4!A)B#,-)/&)$!5<<9>O!#)#$#.$&3!$%&!7.$#-).8!

:8#/.$&!:%.)*&!R=)3!5R7<:>CDT!1-)1=,,&)$8K!"#$%!$%&!7.$#-).8!:8#/.$&!:%.)*&!6-8#1K!#)!;&1&/2&,!PDDQCDU!.)3!-+&,.$#-).8#G&3!$%&!

R7<:!#)!V1$-2&,!PDCDLCDW!M%&!R7<:!,&1&#B&(!.!(#*)#4#1.)$!+-,$#-)!-4!#$(!4=)3(!4,-/!-#8!+,-3=1$#-)!,&B&)=&CDX!.)3!+,-B#3&(!4#).)1#.8!

(=++-,$!$-!#)#$#.$#B&(!$%.$!(&&@!$-!,&3=1&!*,&&)%-=(&!&/#((#-)(O!.((&((!18#/.$&!1%.)*&!#/+.1$(O!-,!.3.+$!$-!18#/.$&!1%.)*&!#/+.1$(L!

!

M%&!F,.G#8#.)!<#)#($,K!-4!J1#&)1&!.)3!M&1%)-8-*K!5<:M>!%.(!.8(-!(=2/#$$&3!F,.G#8 (!Y)#$#.8!.)3!J&1-)3!7.$#-).8!:-//=)#1.$#-)!5<:M!

PDDE?!<:M!PDCD>!$-!$%&!H7R:::L!J#/#8.,!$-!$%&!#)#$#.8!.1$#-)(!-4!$%&!7.$#-).8!:8#/.$&!:%.)*&!6,-*,./O!-)&!-4!$%&!/.#)!-2S&1$#B&(!-4!

$%&! J&1-)3!7.$#-).8! :-//=)#1.$#-)!".(! $-! 4=,$%&,! &8.2-,.$&! .!/&$%-3-8-*#1.8! 4,./&"-,@! $-! &B.8=.$&! B=8)&,.2#8#$K! .)3! .3.+$.$#-)!

/&.(=,&(O! "#$%! $"-!/.#)! 1-/+-)&)$(! 4-1=(&3! -)0! C>! $%&! 3&B&8-+/&)$! -4! /-,&! 3&$.#8&3! 18#/.$&! +,-S&1$#-)(! 4-,! F,.G#8?! .)3! P>! $%&!

+,&8#/#).,K!.).8K(#(!-4!@&K!18#/.$&!1%.)*&!#/+.1$(!"#$%!(+&1#4#1!&/+%.(#(!-)!F,.G#8 (!).$#-).8!1#,1=/($.)1&(L!!

!

M%&!7.$#-).8!Y)($#$=$&!-)!J+.1&!Z&(&.,1%!5Y76A>O!"%#1%!#(!3#,&1$8K!8#)@&3!$-!$%&!<:MO!%.(!2&&)!$%&!).$#-).8!&)$#$K!,&(+-)(#28&!4-,!$%&!

1--,3#).$#)*!18#/.$&!/-3&8#)*!.)3!4=$=,&!18#/.$&!1%.)*&!(1&).,#-(!.)3!.3.+$.$#-)!,&(&.,1%!5<:M!PDCD>L!Y)!+.,$#1=8.,O!Y76A (!:8#/.$&!

:%.)*&!Z&(&.,1%![,-=+!5[6<:>!%.(!$.@&)!$%&!8&.3!"#$%!18#/.$&!/-3&8#)*O!B=8)&,.2#8#$K!.).8K(&(O! .)3!#/+.1$!.)3!.3.+$.$#-)!($=3#&(L!

M%&![6<:!%.(!1-)(#3&,.28&!1.+.1#$K!(#)1&!#$!1-88.2-,.$&(!"#$%!,&(&.,1%&,(!4,-/!3#B&,(&!.1.3&/#1!.)3!,&(&.,1%!#)($#$=$&(O!#)18=3#)*!$%&!

H)#B&,(#$K!-4!J\-!6.=8-O!H)#B&,(#$K!-4!:./+#).(O! .)3!F,.G#8#.)!R-=)3.$#-)!4-,!J=($.#).28&!;&B&8-+/&)$O!.(!"&88!.(!F,.G#8#.)! 4&3&,.8!

*-B&,)/&)$!#)($#$=$#-)(!(=1%!.(!$%&!F,.G#8#.)!A)$&,+,#(&!4-,!9*,#1=8$=,.8!Z&(&.,1%!.)3!$%&!F,.G#8#.)!7.$#-).8!Y)($#$=$&!4-,!<&$&-,-8-*K!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!CD]!<<9O!%$$+0^^"""L//.L*-BL2,^&($,=$=,.(^(&3,_3&(&,$#4^_.,`=#B-(^+.)_2,.(#8_+-,$=*=&(L+34!!CDE!<<9O!%$$+0^^"""L//.L*-BL2,^+-,$^1-)./.^+,-1&((-(^FQPRE];R^Z&8.$R#).8[M93.<=3:8#_PDDXDEDPCL+34!!CDT!<<9O!%$$+0^^"""L//.L*-BL2,^(#$#-^#)3&'L+%+a#3-b1-)$&=3-L/-)$.c#3A($,=$=,.bPTC!!CDU![-B&,)/&)$!-4!F,.G#8O!%$$+0^^"""L+8.).8$-L*-BL2,^11#B#8_D]^_9$-PDDWNPDCD^PDDQ^d&#^dCPCCEL%$/!!CDW![-B&,)/&)$!-4!F,.G#8!%$$+0^^"""L+8.).8$-L*-BL2,^11#B#8_D]^_9$-PDDWNPDCD^PDCD^;&1,&$-^;W]E]L%$/!!CDX!911-,3#)*!$-!$%&!:Y9!e-,83!R.1$2--@O!F,.G#8!#(!,.)@&3!Q$%!*8-2.88K!#)!$-$.8!2.,,&8(!-4!-#8!+,-3=1&3!+&,!3.K?!S=($!.2-B&!f=".#$!5CD$%>!.)3!g&)&G=&8.!5CC$%>L!:Y9O!

%$$+(0^^"""L1#.L*-B^8#2,.,K^+=28#1.$#-)(^$%&N"-,83N4.1$2--@^,.)@-,3&,^PCW],.)@L%$/8L!!

Page 8: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

"#$%&'()*+,!'-.!/0%1!23!4566.789:!;<6=27>!<7!2?@6<A27>!8-.!6.>2<7B9!492?B8.!?<C.9D!E<[email protected]!8<!27495C.!C:7B?24!A.>.8B82<7!B7C!4-B7>.3! 27! 9B7C!53.)**+!G99! 8-.! 2?@6<[email protected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email protected].!278.6C2342@927B6:!6.3.B64-!7.8;<6=!<7!492?B8.!4-B7>.!;28-!L6BM292B7!B7C!278.67B82<7B9!6.3.B64-!>6<5@3!"%1'!J+*+()!'-.!#$1'!23!-<53.C!;28-27!#$0&!B7C!@6<[email protected].!8<!O.C.!1P#%G)!'-.!?B27!<KQ.482A.3!<E!O.C.!1P#%G!B6.!8<!C233.?27B8.!492?B8.!4-B7>.!6.3.B64-!B7C!-.9@!.38BK923-!BCC282<[email protected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

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!*+,!#$0&Z11N'D!-88@[ZZ?5CB74B3492?B824B3)[email protected])27@.)K6Z!**+!1566.78!?<C.93!B335?.!8-B8!.F23827>!A.>.8B82<7!23!7<8!B98.6.C!K:!492?B8.!4-B7>.D!-<;.A.6D!492?B8.!4-B7>.!;<59C!B98.6!A.>.8B82<7!8:@.!B7C!C.7328:!B7C!C:7B?24!?<C.927>!4B7!27495C.!8-.3.!.EE.483)!!!!***#$0&D!-88@[ZZ;;;)4438)27@.)K6Z2748Z!**J!#$0&D!-88@[ZZ;;;)4438)27@.)K6Z6.C.492?BZ!**S!R<65?492?BD!-88@[ZZ;;;)E<65?492?B)<6>)K6!!**H!0L%1D!-88@[ZZ;;;)@K?4)4<@@.)5E6Q)K6Z27C.F)@-@\B6.B]-238<62B!**Y!0L%1D!-88@[ZZ;;;)@K?4)4<@@.)5E6Q)K6Z@<68B62BSY^)@CE!

Page 9: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#

$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

"#$%&'()*$*+,! (%-! (-(.+(+*/%! (0+*/%12!34&!5678!-*'&0+$,! 1#../'+1! (0+*"*+*&1! /#+$*%&-! *%! +4&!9(+*/%($!8$*:(+&!84(%;&!5$(%<! *%0$#-*%;!1#../'+*%;!1+(+&!(%-!:#%*0*.($!./$*0,!-&"&$/.:&%+!/%!0$*:(+&!04(%;&!:*+*;(+*/%!(%-!(-(.+(+*/%2!34&!=*'1+!9(+*/%($!>11&11:&%+!?&./'+!

*1!(%+*0*.(+&-!+/!)&!0/:.$&+&!@/'!ABCA2!!!!"#$%&'(&)%*&+,-%./0%/1&2,$343%5&"/6&7%8,.15&.%9$%413/:&;6"81"13,/&<%%65=&2.3,.313%5&"/6&2$"//%6&;413,/5&

<"0%&,9&2,$34*&;413,/& +,-%./0%/1&>3-353,/&7%58,/53#$%&

?1"1@5& ?%41,.A5B&,9&C,4@5& ?@00".*&6%54.3813,/&

;< #=0/').03#+3':0/%#+90.>%#

2-)>-0:;;?#

@'.'A/-B#)*#86'%.6%#0.1#

C%69.)3)>B#

DA/0E3'A9%1#'.#

F"""#

@,3/'GA%6/)-03#

'.A/'/,/').03#60506'/B#/)#E%//%-#,.1%-A/0.1#63':0/%#690.>%H#'1%./'*B#

':506/A#'.#I-0J'3H#0.1#A,55)-/#5)3'6B#1%&%3)5:%./#0/#/9%#.0/').03#0.1#

'./%-.0/').03#3%&%3<#C9'A#'.63,1%A#A,55)-/'.>#5-%50-0/').#)*#/9%#

8%6).1#=0/').03#+)::,.'60/').#)*#I-0J'3#K@+C#F";"L<#

F< #M.'/'03#=0/').03#

+)::,.'60/').#/)#/9%#

N=O+++#;;P#

@'.'A/-B#)*#86'%.6%#0.1#

C%69.)3)>B##

$%3%0A%1#Q%6#

F""R#

@,3/'GA%6/)-03# S'/9#-%>0-1A#/)#0105/0/').H#/9%#;A/#=0/').03#+)::,.'60/').#5-%A%./A#

63':0/%#690.>%#':506/A#'.#/9%#A%:'G0-'1#-%>').H#6)0A/03#J).%H#9%03/9H#

%3%6/-'603#A%6/)-H#0>-'6,3/,-%H#1'A0A/%-#5-%50-%1.%AAH#0.1#-%>').03#

63':0/%#:)1%3'.><#C9%#'./%>-0/').#)*#63':0/%#690.>%#'AA,%A#'A#03A)#

5-%A%./%1#E,/#'A#:)A/3B#0553'60E3%#/)#:'/'>0/').<##

T< #=0/').03#+3':0/%#+90.>%#

230.;;!#

M./%-G@'.'A/%-'03#+)::'//%%#

).#+3':0/%#+90.>%#

+):53%/%1#

8%5/%:E%-#

F""!#0.1#

)5%.#*)-#

5,E3'6#

6).A,3/0/').#

@,3/'GA%6/)-03# I-'%*3B#011-%AA%A#/9%#'1%./'*'60/').#)*#63':0/%#690.>%#':506/AH#

&,3.%-0E'3'/B#:055'.>#0.1#0105/0/').#)5/').A<#4105/0/').#:%0A,-%A#

'1%./'*'%1#'.63,1%#AB.%->'%A#('/97#=0/').03#2-)>-0:#/)#+):E0/#

Q%A%-/'*'60/').#0.1#Q-),>9/#@'/'>0/').#K24=#I-0A'3LU#O-0:%()-V#*)-#

/9%#8,A/0'.0E3%#S0/%-#$%A),-6%A#@0.0>%:%./#)*#/9%#2-0/0#

S0/%-A9%1U#/9%#()-V#0.1#-)3%#)*#=0/').03#D.&'-).:%./03#+),.6'3#/)#

'1%./'*B#0.1#01)5/#0105/0/').#:%0A,-%AU#0.1#60506'/B#E,'31'.>#/)#

E%//%-#011-%AA#63':0/%#&0-'0E'3'/B#('/9'.#/9%#N.'*'%1#W%03/9#8BA/%:<##

R< #=0/').03#+3':0/%#+90.>%#

2)3'6B;;X#

2,E3'6#01:'.'A/-0/').## DA/0E3'A9%1#

Q%6%:E%-#

F""X#

@,3/'GA%6/)-03# 2-):)/%A#0105/0/').#:%0A,-%A#/)#-%1,6%#%.&'-).:%./03H#A)6'03H#0.1#

%6).):'6#&,3.%-0E'3'/B#/)#63':0/%#690.>%#/9-),>9#/9%#'./%>-0/').#)*#

0105/0/').#:%0A,-%A#'.#3)603H#-%>').#0.1#.0/').03#5)3'6BU#5-):)/').#

)*#E'30/%-03H#-%>').03H#0.1#:,3/'G30/%-03#'./%-.0/').03#6))5%-0/').#*)-#

*'.0.6'.>H#60506'/B#1%&%3)5:%./H#0.1#-%A%0-69#*)-#0105/0/').#

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!CCD!783<!4++.EFFGGG2:0+2;/"2)'F*%-&H2.4.F0/%+&%+F"*&GFIIDJB24+:$K+$+!!CCI!L9=888<!4++.EFF#%@0002*%+F&11&%+*($M)(0N;'/#%-F$*)'(',F*+&:1FOJPP2.4.Q1#04RST1,:)/$R6?>F8U7FCVAB6VAB8U5WVABCVABX9YK)&;!CCZ!77><!4++.EFFGGG2::(2;/"2)'F&1+'#+#'(1FCDPFM('[#*"/1FCDPMAPBPABBZBIOA\\2.-@!!CCP!Y/"&'%:&%+!/@!6'(]*$<!4++.EFFGGG2.$(%($+/2;/"2)'F00*"*$MBOFM(+/ABBI^ABCBFABBPF$&*F$CACZI24+:!!

Page 10: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!"#$%&'%(&)*+,%-+.*&/% 0&1$2/#$/.%3*1*4*&/%5$46&/4*7)$%

8.".94% 8$+.&2:4;%&'%<&+94% 89##"2,%=$4+2*6.*&/%

06/').;<#

=< #8%6).1#>0/').03#+)::,.'60/').#/)#/9%#?>@+++"AB##

C'.';/-D#)*#86'%.6%#0.1#E%69.)3)FDG#,.1%-#/9%#>0/').03#+3':0/%#+90.F%#2-)F-0:#

$%3%0;%1#>)&%:H%-#AB"B#

C,3/'I;%6/)-03# J'/9#-%F0-1;#/)#0105/0/').G#/9%#8%6).1#>0/').03#+)::,.'60/').#5-%;%./;#/9%#-%F').03#63':0/%#:)1%3#KL/0I+2EL+#C)1%3M#0.1#'./-)1,6%;#/9%#CN8+O#03).F#('/9#/9%#':506/;#)*#63':0/%#690.F%#).#/9%#;%:'I0-'1#-%F').G#,-H0.#0-%0;G#6)0;/03#P).%G#9,:0.#9%03/9G#%.%-FD#0.1#(0/%-#-%;),-6%;G#*)-%;/;G#0F-'6,3/,-%#0.1#3'&%;/)6QG#0.1#1';0;/%-#5-%50-%1.%;;<#4;#'.#/9%#@'-;/#>0/').03#+)::,.'60/').G#'./%F-0/').#)*#63':0/%#690.F%#';;,%;#';#*)6,;%1#5-':0-'3D#).#:'/'F0/').<#

R< #E9'-1#>0/').03#+)::,.'60/').#/)#/9%#?>@+++#

C'.';/-D#)*#86'%.6%#0.1#E%69.)3)FD##

+,--%./3D#H%'.F#6):5'3%1#

C,3/'I;%6/)-03# J'33#5-%;%./#,510/%1#0.1#-%*'.%1#0.03D;';#)*#63':0/%#690.F%#':506/;#0.1#0105/0/').G#*)-#%S0:53%G#('33#5-%;%./#5-)F-%;;#('/9#/9%#CN8+O#KC+E#AB"BM<#

!!"#!$%%&'(#)*+,(+(-.'#)/(-.'##"#$! %&''$()! *+*,)*)-.(! *%)-.(/! .&)0-($+! -(! "*10$! 2! '$30$%)! )#./$! )#*)! /-4(-3-%*()05! '$05! .(! %.()'-1&)-.(/! 3'.6! $7)$'(*0! +.(.'/8! "#-/!

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

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!PQJ!LM"=!#)),TUUBBB86%)84.981'U-(+$78,#,U%.()$()U9-$BU2QVWXY8#)60!PQP!@>@=!#)),TUUBBB8*/*1'*/-08.'481'UN.')*0UZ(3.'6*%.$/8*/,[MK\]L^AO_PP`J!!

Page 11: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#

$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

"#$%&'(#"!&')*+)#!*,-#"!.*/',"&#01!2"&$%"&+3!4"*$!5&,-&'!,-#!6%,&'!7$#"&.%'!"#8&*'9!7'!#:.#2,&*'!! ;-#! +&$&,#(! '/$<#"! *4!

0*+#+3!="%>&+&%'!2"*?#.,0!4/'(#(!<3!+%"8#@0.%+#!#:,#"'%+!4/'(#"0!$%3!"#4+#.,!&',#"'%,&*'%+!"#.*8'&,&*'!*4! &',#"'%+!.%2%.&,39!!!!!"#$%&!'(!)*++&,-!./#0-#-12,!.3-12,4!1,!5+#61%!

7#8&! 9$:&3-1;&4! <*,/&+=4>! ?80%&8&,-1,@!.@&,3A=4>!

"A0&!2B!0+2:&3-!

C*+#-12,! D+12+1-A!E&3-2+=4>!

F&2@+#0G13!B23*4!=1B!#,A>!

7#-12,#%!.3-12,!

;< #$')#1%#=0.%'-)#8,>/0'.0?3%#

@./%A-0/%1#B6)>C>/%:#

D0.0A%:%./#'.#

2-)1,6/'&%#E0.1>605%>#)*#

/9%#F)-/9GF)-/9(%>/%-.#

H3,:'.%.>%HII#

I9%#0':#)*#/9'>#5-)J%6/#*)-#K-0L'3#'>#/)#011-%>>#

/9-%0/>#/)#?')1'&%->'/C#)*#A3)?03#':5)-/0.6%M#

-%&%->%#30.1#1%A-010/').#'.#0A-'6,3/,-03#

30.1>605%>M#%.90.6%#60-?).#>%N,%>/-0/').O#

0.1#'.6-%0>%#0(0-%.%>>#0/#033#3%&%3>#)*#/9%#

&03,%#)*#01)5/'.A#0.#'./%A-0/%1#%6)>C>/%:>#

:0.0A%:%./#P@BDQ#055-)069#'.#:0.0A'.A#

.0/,-03#-%>),-6%><#I9'>#5-)J%6/#90>#*),-#

6):5).%./><#+):5).%./#;#>,55)-/>#530..'.A#

*)-#@BD#06/').><#+):5).%./#"#>,55)-/>#

>C>/%:>#*)-#01)5/'.A#@BD#0.1#>,>/0'.0?3%#

:0.0A%:%./#5-06/'6%><#+):5).%./#R#>,55)-/>#

)-A0.'L0/').#0.1#60506'/C#?,'31'.A#*)-#@BD<#

+):5).%./#S#*'.0.6%>#5-)J%6/#:0.0A%:%./O#

:).'/)-'.AO#0.1#%&03,0/').<#

TBHO#6)G

*'.0.6'.A#

#

"#$%&'(##TBH7#

U8V;R<W"#

:'33').#

8%6-%/0-'0/#)*#

4A-'6,3/,-%O#

H'>9%-'%>#0.1#

$,-03#

X%&%3)5:%./#

P8B4224Q#

+0506'/C#

K,'31'.AM#

2)3'6C#

H)-:0/').#

0.1#

'./%A-0/').##

"YYW "Y;;## B6)>C>/%:#

6).>%-&0/').#

F)-/9G

F)-/9(%>/%-

.#50-/>#)*#$')#

1%#=0.%'-)#

8/0/%#

"< #D,3/'53C'.A#K%>/#2-06/'6%#

'.#4105/0/').#/)#+3':0/%#

+90.A%;"R#

/9%#5-)J%6/#>%%Z>#/)#5-%50-%#/9%#-,-03#

5)5,30/').#/)#6)5%#/9-),A9#/9%#

':53%:%./0/').#)*#5-)&%.#3)603#>/-0/%A'%><#I9'>#

'.63,1%>#%[50.>').#)*#%['>/'.A#'--'A0/').#5'3)/#

5-)J%6/>O#%>/0?3'>9'.A#)*#0#.%/()-Z#)*#

:,.'6'503'/'%>#0.1#)-A0.'L0/').>#>%%Z'.A#/)#

1'>>%:'.0/%#>,66%>>*,3#0105/0/').#:%0>,-%>O#

0.1#5-)&'>').#)*#/-0'.'.A#:%0>,-%><#

KDU#

#

"#$%&'(#!\;O"S;#

+%./-)#+3':0O#

U.'&%->'101%#

H%1%-03#1)#$')#

1%#=0.%'-)#

H'%31#

':53%:%./0/'

).#

"YY! "Y;Y## $,-03#0-%0>M#

H-%>9(0/%-#

>,553C##

F)-/9%-.#

K-0L'3#

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!ABB!C*"+(!=%'D1!-,,2EFF5#<95*"+(<%'D9*"8F#:,#"'%+F2"*?#.,0F$%&'G2%8#HIJKLBMNKBOP2&HIJONBNQP,-#R&,#HIJLQSLAP$#'/HIJBBMLBLPH"*?#.,&(JHQOTNOS!!ABN!=UV1!-,,2EFF5559<$/@D+&$%0.-/,>&'&,&%,&)#9(#F#'F2"*?#.,0G2JBP(JLTO!!

Page 12: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!"#$% &'($)*+,$-% ./01$23-4% 5#67$#$0*+08%98$0):3-4%

;:6$%<=%62<($)*%

>/2"*+<0% ?2+<2+*:%@$)*<23-4%

A$<82"6B+)%=<)/-%3+=%"0:4%

"; #<).'/)-'.=#+3':0/%>$%3%&0./#?')1'&%-@'/A#('/9#$%=0-1#/)#<'/'=0/').#0.1#4105/0/').BCD#

E9%#5-)F%6/#0':@#/)#6)./-'G,/%#/)#G%//%-#,.1%-@/0.1#/9%#3'.H@#G%/(%%.#/)#63':0/%#690.=%#0.1#G')1'&%-@'/A#GA#9%35'.=#/)#6))-1'.0/%#G')1'&%-@'/A#:).'/)-'.=#'.#@%3%6/%1#?-0I'3'0.#5-)/%6/%1#0-%0@;#J/#('33#5-)&'1%#'.*)-:0/').#-%3%&0./#/)#1%6'@').@#).#:'/'=0/').;#J/#'@#03@)#0./'6'50/%1#/90/#/9%#5-)F%6/#('33#9%35#5-%50-%#*)-#1%6'@').@#-%30/%1#/)#5-)/%6/%1#0-%0@#0.1#63':0/%#690.=%;##

?<K##"#$%&'(#"LMNNLNNN#

J.@/'/,/)#+9'6)#<%.1%@#1%#+).@%-&0OP)#10#?')1'&%-@'101%L#<<4L#@/0/%#%.&'-).:%./03#0,/9)-'/'%@L#)/9%-@##

$%@%0-69Q#+0506'/A#G,'31'.=#

CNBN CNB"## ?')1'&%-@'/A## #

?"2*+)+6"*+<0%+0%C$8+<0"7%"01%A7<'"7%9)*+<0-%

D; #$%&'%(#)*#/9%#R6).):'6@#)*#+3':0/%#+90.=%#'.#8),/9#4:%-'60BCM#

E9%#5,-5)@%#)*#/9%#@/,1A#'@#/)#:0H%#0#@)6')%6).):'6#0.03A@'@#)*#/9%#':506/@#)*#63':0/%#690.=%#'.#@%3%6/%1#6),./-'%@#)*#8),/9#4:%-'60L#1%&%3)5#:'/'=0/').#0.1#0105/0/').#5)3'6'%@#0.1#3%&%-0=%#*'.0.6'03#-%@),-6%@;#J.#011'/').L#/9'@#5-)F%6/#'.63,1%@#0#6):5).%./#*)6,@%1#).#/9%#':506/#)*#63':0/%#690.=%#'.#6)0@/03#0-%0@ +"4#S+0:G')#+3':0/'6)#%.#30@#+)0@/0@#1%#4:%-'60#T0/'.0#A#+0-'G%U;##

J4V?L#KWL#V%.:0-HL#850'.L#RKL#X%-:0.A#

R+T4+# 4@@%@@:%./Q#2)3'6A#*)-:0/').#0.1#'./%=-0/').#

CNN! CNNY# +)0@/03#I).%#:0.0=%:%./Q#X)&%-.:%./#

)&%*+,-.(!4-=%./'.0L#?)3'&'0L#?-0I'3L#+9'3%L##+)3):G'0L#R6,01)-L#20-0=,0AL#2%-,L#K-,=,0AL#Z%.%I,%30#

/,!"0-1*.(![,-/9%-#'.*)-:0/').#-%\,'-%1;#

M; #]%03/9#Z,3.%-0G'3'/A#0.1#+3':0/%#+90.=%#4105/0/').#4@@%@@:%./@BC^#

E)#5-)&'1%#.0/').03#3%&%3#%&'1%.6%#)*#/9%#3'.H0=%@#G%/(%%.#63':0/%#0.1#9%03/9Q#':5-)&%#,.1%-@/0.1'.=#)*#3)603#0.1#@5%6'*'6#9%03/9#-'@H@#0.1#&,3.%-0G'3'/'%@Q#5-)&'1%#/9%#)55)-/,.'/A#*)-#60506'/A#G,'31'.=Q#0.1#@%-&%#0@#0#G0@%3'.%#0.03A@'@#/)#:).'/)-#9)(#9%03/9#-'@H@#:0A#G%#'.*3,%.6%1#GA#0#690.='.=#63':0/%#)&%-#/':%;#

_)-31#]%03/9#`-=0.'I0/').#

a0/').03#<'.'@/-'%@#

4@@%@@:%./Q#+0506'/A#G,'31'.=#

CNN! CNBN## ],:0.#9%03/9# 2.+3-.(!BM#6),./-'%@#'.63,1'.=#?)3'&'0L#?-0I'3L#+0:G)1'0L#+)@/0#$'60L#X90.0L#J.1'0L#WA-=AI#

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$!%&'(!)**+,--.../01234561789)2*:6;6*67*6<=/>=-=;-+?@A=9*8B+C"D>CEFG!!"#F!HIJKI(!)**+,--.../=9579/@?L->177)-;@*69678-;@*69678-#-MF#M#-8717;6=L@N?=99/+>O!"#E!PQR(!)**+,--.../.)@/6;*-L5@0759)7;L=-1=>679=;*?=-=<=;*8-#G"G-9@8*7N?697N9@;825*7*6@;N#GGS"G-=;-6;>=T/)*15!!

Page 13: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!"#$% &'($)*+,$-% ./01$23-4% 5#67$#$0*+08%98$0):3-4%

;:6$%<=%62<($)*%

>/2"*+<0% ?2+<2+*:%@$)*<23-4%

A$<82"6B+)%=<)/-%3+=%"0:4%

$%5,;3'6<#=).>)3'0#0.1#?,.'@'0#

"#!$%&'()*!4@@%@@:%./#6):53%/%1#0.1#@9)-/#@,::0-A#0&0'30;3%BCDE#

FB #+3':0/%#+90.>%#G,3.%-0;'3'/A#H&03,0/').#)*#+)0@/03#0.1#=0-'.%#4-%0@CD!#

?9'@#5-)I%6/#'@#50-/#)*#/9%#J;%-)K4:%-'60.#2-)>-0::%#).#/9%#H&03,0/').#)*#J:506/@<#G,3.%-0;'3'/A#0.1#4105/0/').#/)#+3':0/%#+90.>%#L2J4++M#0.1#0':@#/)#1%/%-:'.%#/9%#':506/@#)*#63':0/%#690.>%#).#/9%#6)0@/@#)*#0.A#6),./-A#'.#850.'@9#0.1#2)-/,>,%@%#@5%0N'.>#6),./-'%@#)*#O0/'.#4:%-'60#0.1#/9%#+0-';;%0.B#J/#90@#0#50-/'6,30-#*)6,@#).#/9%#1A.0:'6@#)*#;%069%@<#%@/,0-'%@<#30>)).@<#1%3/0@<#63'**@#0.1#1,.%@<#6)0@/03#%-)@').<#*3))1#-'@N@#0.1#6)0@/03#'.*-0@/-,6/,-%B#?9'@#'.'/'0/'&%#'@#3'.N%1#/)#/9%#

+%./-03#4:%-'60#K# CDP#*,.1%1#;A#J4QR<#ST<#Q%.:0-N<#850'.<#HS#0.1#U%-:0.AB#

850'.# H+O4+<#S.'&%-@'/A#)*#+0./0;-'0<#.0/').03#6),./%-50-/@#

+0506'/A#;,'31'.>V#4@@%@@:%./V#T.)(3%1>%#6)::,.'60/').#

DWWP DWCC# +)0@/03#X).%#:0.0>%:%./##

=)@/#$JY++#6),./-'%@CZW#'.63,1'.>7##4->%./'.0<#R-0X'3<#+9'3%<#+)3):;'0<#H6,01)-<#2%-,<#S-,>,0A#0.1#G%.%X,%30#

"#!$%&'()*![,-/9%-#'.*)-:0/').#-%\,'-%1B#

EB #+3':0/%#2)3'6A#DWCD7#H]/%.@').#)*#/9%#>3);03#

Q%&%3)5:%./#*)-#2)3'6A#=0N%-@#/)#411-%@@#+3':0/%#

CZC##

?9%#S^Q2#$%>').03#R,-%0,#*)-#O0/'.#4:%-'60#0.1#/9%#+0-';;%0.#90@#%]50.1%1#).#/9%#>3);03#

-%>').#/)#5-)&'1%#/%69.'603#@,55)-/#/)#.0/').03#5)3'6A#:0N%-@#0.1#'/@#+),./-A#Y**'6%@#0.1#@/-%.>/9%.#60506'/A#).#;,1>%/0-A#'@@,%@#-%30/%1#/)#/9%#5)@/KDWCD#63':0/%#-%>':%B#46/'&'/'%@#'.63,1%#/%69.'603#;06N@/)55'.>#*)-#

850'.<#S^Q2##$+,-./*#S8_ZBF#:'33').#

S^Q2# +0506'/A#;,'31'.>V#2)3'6A#*)-:0/').#0.1#'./%>-0/').#

DWWP DWCC# U)&%-.:%./## 012!3.-(4#*!4->%./'.0<#R)3'&'0<#R-0X'3<#+9'3%<#+)3):;'0<#+)@/0#$'60<#+,;0<#Q):'.'60.#$%5,;3'6<#

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$!%&&'!()*+!,--.'//00010,2134-/5627869,845&/:&;389&4-<&/&=&4->/#?"?/92>-8@<398@924>A6-8-324@#??$"?/%BCCDEF@C848A>@G<8H36@ID1.;J!"#K!EL*MM+!,--.'//000168<329914&-/<3299@.<3493.86/&>/.<2N&9-2>@343938-3=8>/.<2N@:8<[email protected],-:!!"#O!%&&!PMQDM+!,--.'//0001&968912<5/:&R392/98:732963:8-392/34;&R1,-:6!"S?!T,&!#"!:&:7&<!92A4-<3&>!2J!EL*MM!8<&'!D<5&4-348+!G263=38+!G<8H36+!M,36&+!M262:738+!M2>-8!E398+!MA78+!U2:343984!E&.A7639+!P9A8;2<+!P6!%86=8;2<+!VA8-&:868+!)24;A<8>+!C&R392+!W398<85A8+!X848:8+!X8<85A8N+!X&<A+!X2<-A586+!%.834+!B<A5A8N!84;!I&4&HA&681!"S"!BWUX+!,--.'//0001A4;.9912<5/924-&4-/89-@68-34Y&418>.R!84;!,--.'//0001A4;.12<5/963:8-&9,845&/;29>/PPV@Z6N&<@PW1.;J!

Page 14: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!"#$% &'($)*+,$-% ./01$23-4% 5#67$#$0*+08%98$0):3-4%

;:6$%<=%62<($)*%

>/2"*+<0% ?2+<2+*:%@$)*<23-4%

A$<82"6B+)%=<)/-%3+=%"0:4%

6),./-'%;#/90/#<%='.#/)#6).;'1%-#0105/0/').#/)#63':0/%#690.=%#'.#/9%'-#>0/').03#?%&%3)5:%./#230.;@#

A6,01)-B#A3#803&01)-B#C,0/%:030B#D).1,-0;B#E%F'6)B#>'60-0=,0B#20.0:0B#20-0=,0GB#2%-,B#H-,=,0GB#0.1#I%.%J,%30#

"#!$%&'()*!K,-/9%-#'.*)-:0/').#-%L,'-%1@#

!@ #E'/'=0/').#0.1#4105/0/').#/)#+3':0/%#+90.=%#'.#8,;/0'.0<3%#K)-%;/#E0.0=%:%./#'.#M<%-)N4:%-'60OPQ#

20-/#)*#2M4++B#/9';#5-)R%6/#0':;#/)#=%.%-0/%#.%(#'.*)-:0/').#0.1#S.)(3%1=%#0.1#;/-%.=/9%.#/9%#60506'/G#)*#-%;%0-69#'.;/'/,/').;#'.#/9%#*)-%;/-G#;%6/)-#).#3'.S'.=#;,;/0'.0<3%#*)-%;/#:0.0=%:%./#('/9#0105/0/').#0.1#:'/'=0/').#/)#63':0/%#690.=%@#T9';#'.63,1%;#;/-%.=/9%.'.=#;5%6'*'6#-%;%0-69#06/'&'/'%;B#1%&%3)5'.=#0.1#1';;%:'.0/'.=#:%/9)1)3)='%;#0.1#60;%#;/,1'%;B#;/-%.=/9%.'.=#9,:0.#-%;),-6%;#0.1#*);/%-'.=#/9%#-%5-%;%./0/').#)*#/9%#*)-%;/#;%6/)-#'.#/9%#-%=').03#0.1#'./%-.0/').03#1'03)=,%@#

850'.# M>M4B#+MKU$B#+4TMAB#2)3G/%69.'603#H.'&%-;'/G#)*#E01-'1##

+0506'/G#<,'31'.=V#$%;%0-69V#W.)(3%1=%#6)::,.'60/').##

QXXY QXOO# K)-%;/-G# $MU++#6),./-'%;B#'.63,1'.=7##4-=%./'.0B#Z)3'&'0B#Z-0J'3B#+9'3%B#+)3):<'0B#A6,01)-B#20-0=,0GB#2%-,B#H-,=,0GB#0.1#I%.%J,%30#

"#!$%&'()*!K,-/9%-#'.*)-:0/').#-%L,'-%1@#

Y@ #M./%=-0/%1#0.1#8,;/0'.0<3%#E0.0=%:%./#)*#T-0.;<),.10-G#[0/%-#$%;),-6%;#'.#/9%#4:0J).#$'&%-#Z0;'.#+).;'1%-'.=#

T)#;/-%.=/9%.B#'.#0#6))-1'.0/%1#0.1#6)9%-%./#:0..%-B#/9%#'.;/'/,/').03#*-0:%()-S#*)-#530..'.=#0.1#%F%6,/'.=#06/'&'/'%;#*)-#/9%#5-)/%6/').#0.1#;,;/0'.0<3%#:0.0=%:%./#)*#/9%#(0/%-#-%;),-6%;#)*#/9%#4:0J).#$'&%-#

CAKB#6)N*'.0.6'.=##$+,-./*#H8\#"O@"#:'33').##

H>A2B#4:0J).#+))5%-0/').#T-%0/G#U-=0.'J0/').B#U48#

+0506'/G#<,'31'.=V#2)3'6G#*)-:0/').#0.1#'./%=-0/').#

QXXY QXO]## [0/%-;9%1#:0.0=%:%./##

0.-(1#&)*!Z)3'&'0B#Z-0J'3B#+)3):<'0B#A6,01)-B#C,G0.0B#2%-,B#

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$!%&'()*+'!,-./!0++123344451&'()*+'6785*'63!

Page 15: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!"#$% &'($)*+,$-% ./01$23-4% 5#67$#$0*+08%98$0):3-4%

;:6$%<=%62<($)*%

>/2"*+<0% ?2+<2+*:%@$)*<23-4%

A$<82"6B+)%=<)/-%3+=%"0:4%

+3':0/%#;0-'0<'3'/=#0.1#+90.>%#?@@##

A0B'.C#%.1%0&)-'.>#/)#-%03'D%#0#B90-%1#&'B').#)*#B,B/0'.0<3%#1%&%3)5:%./#'.#/9%#-%>').#<0B%1#,5).#/9%#5-)/%6/').#0.1#'./%>-0/%1#:0.0>%:%./#)*#/-0.B<),.10-=#(0/%-#-%B),-6%B#0.1#0105/0/').#/)#63':0/'6#690.>%BE#

8,-'.0:%C#;%.%D,%30#

"#!$%&'()*!F,-/9%-#'.*)-:0/').#-%G,'-%1E#

?HE #$%>').03#I.B/-,:%./B#*)-#4105/0/').#/)#+3':0/%#+90.>%#<=#/9%#J%03/9#8%6/)-?@K#

L9%#5-)M%6/#0':B#/)#6-%0/%#:%690.'B:B#/)#<-)01%.#N.)(3%1>%#)*#6,--%./#0.1#*,/,-%#':506/B#)*#63':0/%#).#9%03/9#'.#/9%#5)5,30/').E#

I4OAC#6)P*'.0.6'.>###$+,-./*#Q8R?CSHSCHHH#

I4OA# T.)(3%1>%#6)::,.'60/').U#$%B%0-69#

SH?H#P#V# J,:0.#9%03/9# 012!3.-(4#*!A)3'&'0C#A-0D'3C#+)3):<'0C#W%X'6)C#20-0>,0=#

"#!$%&'()*!F,-/9%-#'.*)-:0/').#-%G,'-%1E#

??E #I./%>-0/'.>#+3':0/%#+90.>%#4105/0/').#'./)#Y0/').03#O%&%3)5:%./#2-)6%BB%B#'.#Z0/'.#4:%-'60#0.1#/9%#+0-'<<%0.#

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

850'.##$+,-./*!Q8RKC@[\CS@@#

QY]2# 4BB%BB:%./U#+0506'/=#<,'31'.>U#5)3'6=#*)-:0/').#0.1#'./%>-0/').#

SH?H SH?@## ^)&%-.:%./U#4>-'6,3/,-%U#F-%B9(0/%-#B,553=#

012!3.-(4#*!290B%#?7#?_#$I`++#6),./-'%B?@\###290B%#S7#@P\#6),./-'%B#aO):'.'60.#$%5,<3'6#?B/#6),./-=#B%3%6/%1b#

"#!$%&'()*!F,-/9%-#'.*)-:0/').#-%G,'-%1E#

?SE #8,B/0'.0<3%#W0.0>%:%./#)*#/9%#c0/%-#$%B),-6%B#)*#/9%#30#230/0#A0B'.#('/9#$%B5%6/#/)#/9%#]**%6/B#)*#

L)#B/-%.>/9%.#/-0.B<),.10-=#6))5%-0/').#0:).>#/9%#-'50-'0.#6),./-=#>)&%-.:%./B#)*#4->%./'.0C#A)3'&'0C#A-0D'3C#20-0>,0=C#0.1#Q-,>,0=#/)#%.B,-%#:0.0>%:%./#)*#B90-%1#

^]FC#.0/').03#>)&%-.:%./B##$+,-./*#

QY]2C#`48C#Y0/').03#%.&'-).:%./03#:'.'B/-'%B#

+0506'/=#<,'31'.>U#2)3'6=#*)-:0/').#0.1#

SH?? SH?\# c0/%-B9%1#:0.0>%:%./#

3.-(4#&)*#4->%./'.0C#A)3'&'0C#A-0D'3C#20-0>,0=#0.1#

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"##!$%&'()*+,!-../0112345678985.123&/7:;5<.=1>=/?""@ABBCA"DEF!68G!-../0113339:.<69:7H9I71H5J6K1!!"#C!$)LM,!-../011333926GI9:7H1581.:/2<=175H2:864&28.5H76.2:81/7:;5<.&28J:7K6.2:8,#[email protected]*P&Q"RF"!"#E!Q-5!"B!*$STT!<:U8.725=!6750!)7H58.286,!M:42V26,!M76W24,!T-245,!T:4:KI26,!T:=.6!*2<6,!TUI6,!L:K282<68!*5/UI42<,!(<U6G:7,!(4!X64V6G:7,!PU6.5K646,!Y:8GU76=,!Z5[2<:,!+2<676HU6,!\686K6,!\676HU6],!\57U,!^7UHU6]!68G!_585WU5469!

Page 16: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!"#$% &'($)*+,$-% ./01$23-4% 5#67$#$0*+08%98$0):3-4%

;:6$%<=%62<($)*%

>/2"*+<0% ?2+<2+*:%@$)*<23-4%

A$<82"6B+)%=<)/-%3+=%"0:4%

+3':0/%#;0-'0<'3'/=#0.1#

+90.>%?@A#

# #

(0/%-#-%B),-6%B#)*#/9%#$'&%-#230/%#'.#0.#

'./%>-0/%1#B,B/0'.0<3%#:0..%-C#('/9'.#/9%#

6)./%D/#)*#63':0/%#&0-'0<'3'/=#0.1#690.>%C#

(9'3%#605'/03'E'.>#).#1%&%3)5:%./#

)55)-/,.'/'%BF#

G8HAIFJ#

:'33').#

#

'./%>-0/').# G-,>,0=#

"#!$%&'()*!K,-/9%-#'.*)-:0/').#-%L,'-%1F#

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

@$)*<2% ?2<6<-$1%91"6*"*+<0%9)*+<0-%

.<2$-*-% MD50.1#/9%#L,0./'/=#0.1#L,03'/=#)*#10/0#0.1#'.*)-:0/').#.%%1%1#*)-#63':0/%#690.>%#&,3.%-0<'3'/=C#':506/#0.1#0105/0/').#B/,1'%BC#0.1#,B%#:%/9)1B#

0.1#/))3B#/90/#5%-:'/#0#<%//%-#-%>').03#0.1#3)603#%&03,0/').#)*#*)-%B/#%6)B=B/%:BN#% MD50.1#B6'%./'*'6#O.)(3%1>%#).#/9%#5)/%./'03#':506/B#)*#63':0/%#690.>%#).#*)-%B/B#0.1#).#/9%#5-)1,6/'&%#*)-%B/#B%6/)-#'.#>%.%-03C#0B#(%33#0B#

'1%./'*=#/9%#B=B/%:B #&,3.%-0<'3'/'%BN#% P).'/)-#/9%#%6).):'6#0.1#%.&'-).:%./03#':506/B#)*#%D/-06/'&%#06/'&'/'%BC#%:590B'E'.>#/9%#5%-:0.%./#*)33)(Q,5#).#1'-%6/#0.1#'.1'-%6/#

%.&'-).:%./03#':506/B#)*#3)>>'.>N#% R'BB%:'.0/%#'.*)-:0/').#).#03-%01=#5%-6%'&%1#':506/B#0.1#/9%'-#3)60/').BC#0.1#5-)S%6/#/9%#%D5%6/%1#':506/B#)*#>3)<03#63':0/%#690.>%#*-):#1'&%-B%#

%:'BB').B#B6%.0-')BC#(0-.'.>#0<),/#/9%#'--%&%-B'<3%#':506/BC#%B/':0/'.>#/9%#1'**%-%./#-'BOB#0.1#'1%./'*='.>#)55)-/,.'/'%B#-%30/%1#/)#63':0/%#690.>%N#% R%&%3)5#/%69.)3)>'%BC#:%/9)1B#0.1#5-06/'6%B#/)#:0O%#*)-%B/B#:)-%#-%B'3'%./#/)#/9%#':506/B#)*#63':0/%#690.>%N#% MB/0<3'B9#:%/9)1)3)>'%B#0.1#5-06/'6%B#/)#1%*'.%#5-')-'/=#0-%0B#*)-#/9%#6-%0/').#)*#%6)3)>'603#6)--'1)-B#'.#%6)B=B/%:B#/90/#0-%#B%.B'/'&%#/)#63':0/%#

690.>%F%

982+)/7*/2$%"01%L+,$-*<)M%

P05#0>-'6,3/,-%#0.1#3'&%B/)6O#B%6/)-#&,3.%-0<'3'/'%B#'.#/9%#6),./-=N#

MB/0<3'B9#0.1#':53%:%./#B)3'1#8TUV#5-)>-0:B#).#/9%#%&03,0/').#)*#>3)<03#63':0/%#690.>%#':506/B#).#0>-'6,3/,-%#0.1#5)BB'<3%#0105/0/').#:%0B,-%BC#

6).B'1%-'.>#/9%#:0'.#0>-'6,3/,-03#0.1#*)11%-#6-)5BC#'.63,1'.>#B'>.'*'60./#%D/-%:%#%&%./B#*)-#0>-'6,3/,-%N#

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!DKL!MNIOP"Q>2!'&&1GRR$65()/%;%(&R$6I1/+S(-&#RT#1UDDBVWWJLWXDY!!

Page 17: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!!"

#$%&$'"()"*+,,$-."/-0"12/--$0"30/4./.&(-"35.&(-6"7(+.8"39$,&5/"!

!"#$%&' (&%)%*"+',+-)$-$.%/',#$.%/*'

:%/2+/.$".8$";4/.&/2"0&;.,&<+.&(-"()"42/-."0&;$/;$;"</;$0"(-"5+,,$-."52&9/.$"5(-0&.&(-;"/-0"=2(</2"/-0",$=&(-/2"52&9/.$"58/-=$"$;.&9/.$;>"

?942$9$-."/=,(52&9/.(2(=&5/2"/-0"/=,(@$5(2(=&5/2"A(-&-=>"

B$%$2(4"/-0"&942$9$-.".8$,9/2"5(9)(,.".$58-(2(=&$;")(,"2&%$;.(5C"4,(0+5.&(-";D;.$9;>""

?942$9$-."&-.$=,/.$0"4,(0+5.&(-";D;.$9;"/-0"5,(4@2&%$;.(5C@)(,$;.";D;.$9;>""

B$%$2(4",$;$/,58"(-"$9&;;&(-;"()".8$"9/&-"=,$$-8(+;$"=/;$;"&-"0&))$,$-."/,$/;"/-0"42/-.&-="9$.8(0;"E0&,$5."42/-.&-="F".,/0&.&(-/2"42/-.&-=G"E4+24H"

=,/&-;H";+=/,5/-$H"$.5IG"/-0")(,$;.;>""

:%/2+/.$".8$"$))$5.;"()"=,('&-="*JK"5(-5$-.,/.&(-;"&-".8$";(&2@42/-.";D;.$9"()"$F&;.&-="/=,&5+2.+,/2"$5(;D;.$9;"&-".8$"5(+-.,DH".(=$.8$,"'&.8"

4,(L$5.$0"&-5,$/;$;"&-".$94$,/.+,$H"'/.$,"</2/-5$"/-0"-+.,&$-.;>""

B$%$2(4"=$-$.&5"&94,(%$9$-.;")(,"/-&9/2;"/-0"42/-.;".("0$/2"'&.8"-$'"52&9/.$"5(-0&.&(-;"/-0".8$"&-5,$/;$"&-"4$;."/-0"0&;$/;$"&-5&0$-5$>""

B$%$2(4",+,/2"$F.$-;&(-"/&9$0"/."/0/4.&-=".8$"4,(0+5.&%$";$5.(,".(".8$"$))$5.;"()"=2(</2"52&9/.$"58/-=$H"/&9$0"/."4,(%&0&-="=+&0/-5$"/<(+."

/0/4./.&(-"9$/;+,$;>"

?942$9$-."&-.$=,/.$0"7MN?"/5.&(-;"/&9$0"/.")((0";$5+,&.D"&-",+,/2"/,$/;H"$;4$5&/22D";$9&@/,&0",$=&(-;>""

?942$9$-."4+<2&5"4(2&5&$;"=+&0$0"<D"9(0$,-";5&$-.&)&5"/-0".$58-(2(=&5/2"C-('2$0=$"&-"/=,(-(9D".8/."9/F&9&A$"/-0"&-.$-;&)D".8$"+;$"()"<&(9$"

/,$/;".8/."'$,$"/2,$/0D"/2.$,$0H".(=$.8$,"'&.8"4(2&5&$;")(,"/00&-="%/2+$H"%&/"&-0+;.,&/2&A/.&(-H".("4,&9/,D"/=,&5+2.+,/2"(,")(,$;."4,(0+5.;I"

0.%+.1"&*.$2' 7+,%$D"()"4/2$($5(2(=&5/2H"4/2$($-%&,(-9$-./2"/-0"4/2$(52&9/.$"&;;+$;"/-0"$-%&,(-9$-./2"/-0"$5(2(=&5/2",$5(,0;H"&-5(,4(,/.&-="C-('2$0=$"()".8$"

5+,,$-."0&;.,&<+.&(-"()";4$5&$;"/-0"5(99+-&.&$;H",$5(-;.,+5.&(-"()"9&=,/.(,D"4,(5$;;$;"/-0"$%(2+.&(-"()".8,$/.$-$0")/+-/"/-0")2(,/"5(99+-&.&$;"

&-"$/58";./.$>"

#$;.,+5.+,$"/-0"&-.$=,/.$"&-&.&/.&%$;",$2/.$0".("<&(2(=&5/2"&-%$-.(,&$;"E;4$5&$;"/-0"=$-$.&5"%/,&/<&2&.DG"/-0"$-%&,(-9$-./2"&-)(,9/.&(-"E;.+0D"()";(&2;"

/-0"52&9/.$"/-0"8D0,(2(=&5/2"0/./G"/-0"&942$9$-."/"-/.&(-/2"4,(=,/9".8/."&-52+0$;".8$"4,&%/.$";$5.(,>"

7+44(,.".8$"5(-;(2&0/.&(-"()"/-"(,=/-&A$0"/-0";8/,$0"&-),/;.,+5.+,$"()"0/./"E<&(2(=&5/2"/-0"/<&(.&5G".8,(+=8".8$"0D-/9&5"&-.$=,/.&(-"()"0&;.,&<+.$0"

&-)(,9/.&(-";D;.$9;"'&.8".8$"/0(4.&(-"()"&-.$,-/.&(-/22D"/55$4.$0";./-0/,0;"/-0"4,(.(5(2;".8/.")/5&2&./.$".8$"0$%$2(49$-."()"5(-;&;.$-."/-/2D;$;"

/-0"4,$0&5.&%$"9(0$2&-=>"

?94,(%$"/-0"0$%$2(4"9(0$2;".8/."/,$"/<2$".(";&9+2/.$";D-$,=&5"$))$5.;"/;;(5&/.$0"'&.8"$5(;D;.$9;"E52&9/.$"58/-=$H")&,$H"52&9/.$"$F.,$9$;H";(&2"

+;$H";(5&($5(-(9&5"/;4$5.;"/-0"$5(2(=&5/2"-&58$")(,";4$5&$;G>"

B$;&=-"/-0"&942$9$-."9(-&.(,&-=";D;.$9;")(,"=2(</2"52&9/.$"58/-=$"&94/5.;"(-";4$5&$;"E-/.&%$H"$-0$9&5H".8,$/.$-$0H"$F(.&5GH"0$)&-&-=".8$"

<&(2(=&5/2"&-0&5/.(,;"()".8$"&94/5."(-";4$5&$;H"4(4+2/.&(-;"/-0"$5(;D;.$9;>"

B$%$2(4"9(0$2;".(",$5(%$,"0$=,/0$0"/,$/;H",$;.(,$"$5(;D;.$9;"/-0"5(-.,(2"<&(2(=&5/2"&-%/;&(-;>"

?942$9$-.",$;$/,58"4,(=,/9;".8/.";.+0D".8$",(2$"()"$5(2(=&5/2"5(942$F&.D"/-0"&-.$,/5.&%&.D"&-"$5(;D;.$9")+-5.&(-&-=H"&-52+0&-="$5(48D;&(2(=&5/2"

;.+0&$;",$2/.$0".("'/.$,"/-0".8$,9/2";.,$;;>"

#$%&$'"5(-;$,%/.&(-"4,&(,&.&$;"/-0"$;./<2&;8"$5(2(=&5/2"5(,,&0(,;H"./C&-="&-.("/55(+-.".8$"&94/5."()"=2(</2"52&9/.$"58/-=$"(-"<&(0&%$,;&.D>"

7.,+5.+,$".8$"O/.&(-/2"1,(=,/9")(,"P&(2(=&5/2"#$;(+,5$"*$-.$,;"E())@;&.$"5(-;$,%/.&(-H";+58"/;"=$,942/;9GI"

!"3.4-&.+' 3;;$;;".8$"%+2-$,/<&2&.D"()";$9&@/,&0"/,$/;".("2/-0"+;$"58/-=$H"52&9/.$"58/-=$H"4(4+2/.&(-"&-5,$/;$;"/-0"5(-)2&5.",$=/,0&-=".8$"+;$"()"-/.+,/2"

,$;(+,5$;H"&-52+0&-="/",&;C"/-0"%+2-$,/<&2&.D"9/4H"&-.$=,/.&-=".8$"0&))$,$-.";$5.(,&/2"%+2-$,/<&2&.&$;>"

:%/2+/.$"'/.$,"4(.$-.&/2"&-".8$"'/.$,;8$0;"/-0"8D0,(=$(2(=&5/2"</;&-;"&-";$9&@/,&0"/,$/;>"

Page 18: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!"#$%&' (&%)%*"+',+-)$-$.%/',#$.%/*'

;&03,0/%#*))1#<%6,-'/=#'.#<%:'>0-'1#0-%0<?# +).1,6/#0#:,3/'>6-'/%-'0#0.03=<'<#*)-#:055'.@#-%@').03#&)60/').#0.1#5-)5)<'.@#055-)5-'0/%#5)3'6'%<#*)-#'1%./'*'%1#-%@').03#&)60/').<?# A%&%3)5#0553'%1#-%<%0-69#1'-%6/%1#0/#%&03,0/'.@#@3)B03#63':0/%#690.@%#':506/<#0.1#:055'.@#/9%'-#-'<C<D#0.1#'1%./'*=#&,3.%-0B3%#5)5,30/').<#/)#%</0B3'<9#0105/0/').#:%0<,-%<?#

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

0/"&12'-/+'3-$"&'4"*%5&#"*'

;30B)-0/%#63':0/%#&,3.%-0B'3'/=#:05<#B=#(0/%-<9%1#/0C'.@#'./)#066),./#/9%#:,3/'53%#,<%<#)*#(0/%-?## $%1,6%#@%.%-0/').#&,3.%-0B'3'/=#'.#/9%#%3%6/-'6'/=#<=</%:#B=#'./%@-0/'.@#%.%-@=#<),-6%<#0.1#%./%-5-'<%<#0/#&0-'),<#<603%<?## A%&%3)5#:)1%3<#*)-#/9%#%.%-@=#<%6/)-#6050B3%#)*#/0C'.@#'./)#066),./#@3)B03#63':0/%#690.@%#<6%.0-')<#/)#'.6-%0<%#/9%#-%3'0B'3'/=#)*#<':,30/').#-%<,3/<#*)-#/9%#<%6/)-?##

A%&%3)5#'./%@-0/').#</-0/%@'%<D#0/#/9%#9=1-)%3%6/-'6#@%.%-0/').#530..'.@#0.1#)5%-0/').#3%&%3<D#0<#(%33#0<#(0/%-#-%<),-6%#530.<D#*)-#0<5%6/<#/'%1#/)#@3)B03#63':0/%#690.@%#/)#-%1,6%#/9%#&,3.%-0B'3'/=#)*#%.%-@=#0.1#(0/%-#<,553=?##

$%&'%(#)5%-0/').03#-,3%<#*)-#9=1-)%3%6/-'6#530./<#/0C'.@#'./)#066),./#/9%#5)<<'B3%#':506/<#)*#@3)B03#63':0/%#690.@%?## $%&'%(#9=1-)%3%6/-'6#@%.%-0/').#0--0.@%:%./<#'.#/9%#03-%01=#'.</033%1#50-CD#:0'.3=#'.#-%30/').#/)#/9%#:,3/'53%#,<%<#)*#(0/%-D#(9%/9%-#*)-#%F/-%:%#1-),@9/#0.1#*3))1'.@#5%-')1<#)-#/)#@,0-0./%%#B%//%-#0105/0/').#/)#5)5,30/').#0.1#%6).):'6#@-)(/9#.%%1<#)*#(0/%-<9%1<?##

4<<%<<#/9%#*06/)-<#/90/#60.#'.*3,%.6%#0@-'6,3/,-03#6-)5<#*)-#036)9)3#0.1#B')1'%<%3#5-)1,6/').?## $%<%0-69#0.1#1%&%3)5:%./D#1%:).</-0/').#0.1#1%53)=:%./#/90/#<5%%1<#,5#5-)1,6/').#)*#3'@.)6%33,3)<'6#B')*,%3<#).#0#6)::%-6'03#<603%#('/9'.#/9%#6)./%F/#)*#<,</0'.0B3%#-%@').03#1%&%3)5:%./?##

;</0B3'<9#</-0/%@'%<#/)#</':,30/%#@-%0/%-#6)./'.%./03#0.1#-%@').03#'./%@-0/').#B%/(%%.#(0/%-<9%1<#0.1#%3%6/-'6#<=</%:<?# 2-):)/%#/9%#H0/').03#I0/%-#$%<),-6%#2)3'6=D#<,55)-/'.@#/9%#':53%:%./0/').#)*#'/<#:0.0@%:%./#'.</-,:%./<#J<,69#0<#/9%#I0/%-#$%<),-6%#230.<D#630<<'*'60/').#)*#(0/%-#B)1'%<D#3'6%.<'.@#0.1#690-@'.@#*)-#/9%#,<%#)*#(0/%-K#0.1#'/<#:0.0@%:%./#<=</%:#J<,69#0<#I0/%-#L0<'.#+)::'//%%<#0.1#I0/%-#4@%.6'%<K?##

2-):)/%#:0.0@%:%./#)*#(0/%-#-%<),-6%#1%:0.1#J-0/').03#,<%D#:,3/'53%#,<%<D#-%,<%D#<0&'.@#%M,'5:%./D#3)<<#6)./-)3K?## E./%.<'*=#0.1#%F50.1#<%6/)-#%.%-@=#%**'6'%.6=#5-)@-0:<?## 2-):)/%#0#<0&'.@<#5)3'6=#0.1#5-)1,6/').#'.6%./'&%<#*)-#-%1,6'.@#6).<,:5/').#0.1#'.6-%0<'.@#%.%-@=#%**'6'%.6=#'.#-%<'1%./'03D#'.1,</-'03#0.1#<%-&'6%#<%6/)-<G#

6%-*$-7'8%/"*' N05#0.1#'1%./'*=#:)-%#<,<6%5/'B3%#-%@').<#0.1#/9%#%&)3,/').#)*#/9%'-#)66,50/').D#6).<'1%-'.@D#0:).@#)/9%-#/9'.@<D#,-B0.#0-%0<D#5)-/#-%@').<D#5,B3'6#-)01<D#5-)1,6/').#06/'&'/'%<#0.1#B')1'&%-<'/=?##

2-%<%-&%#O#-%6)&%-#/9%#/%69.'603#-%6)-1<#)*#6)0</03#0.1#5)-/#%.@'.%%-'.@#()-C<D#'.63,1'.@#60-/)@-059'6#'.*)-:0/').D#/%69.'603#1-0('.@<D#':0@%<#0.1#-%5)-/<?##

;30B)-0/%#-'<C#</,1'%<#*)-#6)0</03#P).%<D#6).<'1%-'.@#%.&'-).:%./03D#/%69.'603D#%.@'.%%-'.@#0.1#<)6')%6).):'6#0<5%6/<?##

Page 19: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!"#$%&' (&%)%*"+',+-)$-$.%/',#$.%/*'

;:53%:%./#5%-:0.%./#<#3).=>/%-:#%.&'-).:%./03#:).'/)-'.=#5-)=-0:?#'.&)3&'.=#:%/%)-)3)='603@#)6%0.)=-059'6@#=%)1%?'6#<#=%):)-59)3)='603#50-0:%/%-?A##

;:53%:%./#0.#%.&'-).:%./03#:).'/)-'.=#?B?/%:#*)-#/9%#:)?/#/9-%0/%.%1#%6)?B?/%:?#C?,69#0?#:0.=-)&%?@#6)-03#-%%*?@#%/6DEA## F510/%#30.1#60-/)=-059B#)*#/9%#6)0?/03#?/-'5#G%/(%%.#"#0.1#H"#:%/%-?#)*#03/'/,1%@#('/9#0#I#:%/%-#&%-/'603#-%?)3,/').@#)-#=-%0/%-@#&%-/'603#10/,:#6):50/'G3%#('/9#.0,/'603#690-/?@#%.6):50??'.=#/9%#%./'-%#('1/9#)*#6)0?/03#530'.?#*-):#/9%#6)0?/3'.%A##

J30G)-0/%#=,'1%3'.%?#0.1#/%69.'603#.)-:?#*)-#6)0?/03#0.1#:0-'/':%#()-K?#/90/#'.6)-5)-0/%#5)??'G3%#=3)G03#63':0/%#690.=%#':506/?#).#()-K?#<#6).?/-,6/').?A##

L%&%3)5#/%69.'M,%?#*)-#G')3)='603#':5-)&%:%./#)*#:0.=-)&%?@#0':%1#0/#-%*)-%?/0/').A## 2-):)/%#;./%=-0/%1#+)0?/03#N0.0=%:%./#/9-),=9#/9%#'./%=-0/').#)*#(0/%-#-%?),-6%#:0.0=%:%./#5-)=-0:?#0.1#530.?#('/9#/9)?%#*)-#6)0?/03#:0.0=%:%./D#

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

$%>.0/,-03'Q%#C-%6-%0/%#:'6-)#63':0/%?@#-%>&%=%/0/').@#1-0'.0=%@#-%&'/03'Q0/').#)*#(0/%-6),-?%?E#,-G0.#0-%0?A## 41)5/#6).?/-,6/').#/%69.'M,%?#/90/#60.#0105/#/)#9'=9%-#/%:5%-0/,-%?@#?,69#0?#%6)3)='603#-))*?@#G,'31'.=?#('/9#.0/,-03#'33,:'.0/').#0.1#&%./'30/').@#%/6D#

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

+).1,6/#-%?%0-69#/)#':5-)&%#/9%#:)1%3#*)-#:)-G'>:)-/03'/B#5-)O%6/').?#CP-0Q'3'0.#+3':0/%#0.1#U%03/9#N)1%3E#('/9#/9%#)GO%6/'&%#)*#5-)&'1'.=#%0-3B#(0-.'.=?#/)#/9%#5)5,30/').#*-):#690.=%?#'.#(%0/9%-#0.1#63':0/%#6).1'/').?A#

JS/%.1#-%=').03#63':0/%#:)1%3'.=#?/,1'%?#/)#5-)1,6%#63':0/%#?6%.0-')?#*)-#?9)-/%-#5%-')1?#)*#/':%@#0':%1#0/#6-%0/'.=#6):50/'G'3'/B#('/9#?)6')%6).):'6#0.1#9%03/9#?6%.0-')?A#

;1%./'*B#/9%#':506/?#)*#=3)G03#63':0/%#690.=%#).#9,:0.#9%03/9#0.1#'/?#59B?'603#0.1#*'.0.6'03#M,0./'*'60/').@#'.63,1'.=@#0:).=#)/9%-?@#'.*)-:0/').#).#*))1#5-)1,6/').@#%.1%:'6#'.*%6/'),?#1'?%0?%#/-%0/:%./#6)?/?#0.1#/9)?%#-%30/%1#/)#0'-#5)33,/').@#:)-/03'/B#0.1#:0/%-'03#':506/?A#

;./%=-0/').#G%/(%%.#6'&'3#1%*%.?%#10/0G0?%?#C:,.'6'503'/'%?#0.1#?/0/%?E#0.1#:%1'603#60-%#G)1'%?@#0':%1#0/#':5-)&%:%./?#'.#/9%#M,03'/B#)*#-%6)-1?#).#9%03/9#5-)G3%:?#60,?%1#GB#%S/-%:%#63':0/%#%&%./?A#

;:53%:%./#?B?/%:?#1'-%6/%1#0/#%.&'-).:%./03@#%5'1%:')3)='603#0.1#%./):)3)='603#?,-&%'330.6%#'.#?5%6'*'6#3)60/').?#0.1#?'/,0/').?#0':%1#0/#/9%#%0-3B#1%/%6/').#)*#?'=.?#)*#63':0/%#690.=% ?#G')3)='603#%**%6/?#C59%.)3)=B@#=%)=-059'6#1'?/-'G,/').#)*#?5%6'%?@#%/6ED#

Page 20: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!

!"#$%%&%%'&()#"#$%&' (! #$)&*!+,-.-/&,!*+0+'-)/+.1!2$(!2+')+*!+.$3'+! 12+!,-4.1#5! 1-!34&'*!,-.(&*+#$3'+! &.1+#.$'!,$)$,&15! 1-!$**#+((!,'&/$1+!,2$.6+!

$*$)1$1&-.!7&12!(&6.&8&,$.1'5!'+((! &.1+#.$1&-.$'!$((&(1$.,+!12$.!-12+#!*+0+'-)&.6!,-4.1#&+(9!:1(!;$1&-.$'!<'&/$1+!<2$.6+!=#-6#$/!'+*!1-!

12+!*+0+'-)/+.1!-8!12+!;$1&-.$'!<'&/$1+!<2$.6+!='$.>!72&,2!&(!'+6$''5!#+&.8-#,+*!35!12+!;$1&-.$'!<'&/$1+!<2$.6+!=-'&,5!$.*!8&.$.,&$''5!

(4))-#1+*! 35! 12+! ;$1&-.$'! <'&/$1+! <2$.6+! ?4.*9! "#$%&'! 2$(! &.0+(1+*! 2+$0&'5! &.1-! 12+! *+0+'-)/+.1! $.*! )#-6#+((&0+! #+8&.+/+.1! -8!

#+6&-.$'!,'&/$1+!/-*+'(!1-!$((+((!,'&/$1+!,2$.6+!&/)$,1(!&.!"#$%&'!$.*!@-412!A/+#&,$9!B&12!12+!*+0+'-)/+.1!-8!12+!"#$%&'&$.!C'-3$'!

<'&/$1+!@5(1+/!D-*+'>!"#$%&'!7&''!$'(-!(--.!3+!$.!&/)-#1$.1!,-.1#&341-#!$1!12+!&.1+#.$1&-.$'!'+0+'!8-#!12+!$((+((/+.1!-8!6'-3$'!,'&/$1+!

,2$.6+9!!

!

E2+!"#$%&'&$.!6-0+#./+.1!2$(!$'(-!+.2$.,+*!12+!1+,2.&,$'!,$)$,&15!1-!$**#+((!,'&/$1+!,2$.6+!$*$)1$1&-.!12#-462!12+!,#+$1&-.!-8!(-,&$'!

,$)&1$'!0&$!12+!*+0+'-)/+.1!-8!#+(+$#,2!.+17-#F(>!(4,2!$(!12+!"#$%&'!C'-3$'!<'&/$1+!<2$.6+!G+(+$#,2!;+17-#F>!72&,2!$&/(!1-!3+11+#!

-#6$.&%+! $.*! (5.+#6&%+! +88-#1(! 3+17++.! #+(+$#,2+#(! 12#-462! 12+! *&((+/&.$1&-.! -8! ,'&/$1+! /-*+'&.6! #+(+$#,2! 8-#! 4(+! &.! 04'.+#$3&'&15!

$.$'5(&(! #+(+$#,29! :.! $**&1&-.! 1-! $! 1+,2.&,$'! $))#-$,2>! 12+! "#$%&'&$.! 6-0+#./+.1! 2$(! $'(-! &.0+(1+*! &.! /4'1&H(1$F+2-'*+#>! )43'&,!

+.6$6+/+.1!0&$!12+!"#$%&'&$.!<'&/$1+!<2$.6+!?-#4/>!1-!(++F!8++*3$,F!8#-/!12+!)43'&,!$.*!*&0+#(+!6#-4)(!-.!$*$)1$1&-.!,2$''+.6+(!$.*!

)#&-#&1&+(9!E2+!;$1&-.$'!<'&/$1+!<2$.6+!?4.*!)#-0&*+(!*&#+,1!8&.$.,&$'!(4))-#1!1-!(4))-#1!#+(+$#,2!12$1!$**#+((+(!$*$)1$1&-.!)#&-#&1&+(9!

D-#+-0+#>!12+!(+,-.*!B-#F&.6!C#-4)!-8!12+!"#$%&'&$.!=$.+'!-.!<'&/$1+!<2$.6+!7&''!)#-0&*+!$!(5.12+(&(!-8!,'&/$1+!,2$.6+!04'.+#$3&'&15>!

&/)$,1(!$.*!$*$)1$1&-.!-)1&-.(!&.!12+!?&#(1!;$1&-.$'!A((+((/+.1!G+)-#1>!72&,2!&(!$.1&,&)$1+*!1-!3+!#+'+$(+*!1-!12+!)43'&,!&.!IJKI9!

!

E2+!.4/+#-4(! &.(1&141&-.(!$.*!)-'&,&+(!$**#+((&.6!,'&/$1+!,2$.6+!$*$)1$1&-.! &.!"#$%&'!,-.8+#!$!,+#1$&.! '+0+'!-8!84.,1&-.$'!#+*4.*$.,5!

+.(4#&.6! 12$1!0$#&-4(!/+,2$.&(/(!$#+! &.!)'$,+! (-! 12$1! ,'&/$1+!,2$.6+!/&1&6$1&-.!$.*!$*$)1$1&-.!/$5!3+! &.1+6#$1+*! &.1-!)-'&,5! $,#-((!

0$#&-4(! (,$'+(! $.*! (+,1-#(9!L-7+0+#>! 12&(! -0+#'$)!/$5! $'(-! )#+(+.1! $! ,2$''+.6+! 8-#! $,,-4.1$3&'&15! (&.,+! &.(1&141&-.$'! #+()-.(&3&'&15! &(!

)--#'5!*+8&.+*>!$(!&(!$))$#+.1!&.!12+!;$1&-.$'!<'&/$1+!<2$.6+!=-'&,59!E24(!&1!#+/$&.(!1-!3+!(++.!2-7!M4&,F'5!$.*!+88+,1&0+'5!$*$)1$1&-.!

)-'&,5!7&''!)#-6#+((9!D-#+-0+#>!+0+.!12-462!,'&/$1+!,2$.6+!$*$)1$1&-.! &(!#+,-6.&%+*!$(!3+&.6! &.+0&1$3'+! &.!3-12!12+!;$1&-.$'!<'&/$1+!

<2$.6+!='$.!$.*!12+!@+,-.*!;$1&-.$'!<-//4.&,$1&-.>!12+#+!&(!#+'$1&0+'5!'&11'+!+/)2$(&(!)'$,+*!-.!&1!,-/)$#+*!1-!/&1&6$1&-.9!!

!

E2+! #+,+.1! +/)2$(&(! )'$,+*! -.! ,'&/$1+! /-*+'&.6! $.*! $((+((/+.1! -8! ,'&/$1+! ,2$.6+! &/)$,1(! 7&''! +.$3'+! "#$%&'! 1-! *+0+'-)! +88+,1&0+!

$*$)1$1&-.!)'$.(!&.!12+!.+$#!8414#+9!"#$%&' (!(1#-.6!&.1+#.$'!,$)$,&15!7&''!$'(-!$((&(1! &1!7&12!)'$..&.6>! &/)'+/+.1$1&-.!$.*!+0$'4$1&-.!-8!

8414#+!$*$)1$1&-.!)#-6#$//&.69!A(!(4,2!"#$%&'!&(!7+''!)-(&1&-.+*!1-!#+()-.*!1-!12+!,2$''+.6+!-8!,'&/$1+!,2$.6+9!

!

Page 21: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!

!"#"$"%&"'()

"#$%&'!()*)!+,-!*+.%,/0'!1)!234456)!"&&%&&7%,8!09!.%/:0,+#!&%+&0,+#!;.%-:<8+=:#:8>!?&:,/!8@%!ABCDEF!.%/:0,+#!<#:7+8%!70-%#:,/!&>&8%7!

0$%.!F0?8@!"7%.:<+)!!"#$%&'(()&*)+,-.$)&G44H!IIJKIL4)!

!

"&&+-'!C)'!+,-!A:,80'!M)F)!2344N6)!'/0#1+,#2.$&3)$4-)&#&-&2$5-&3#$3%-6+-&7-&(%$7089$&-3%:1$)-&2$&;%-<+))!FO0!A+?#0H!C*PB"A"K

DCA"QBERSTED"*A)!N3;)!

!

D%,8.0!-%!U%&%,$0#$:7%,80!%!A#+,%V+7%,80!B%/:0,+#!-+!S,:$%.&:-+-%!W%-%.+#!-%!*:,+&!Q%.+:&RW?,-+XO0!Y&Z+#-0!D.?[!

\DCUCA("BRWEYDBS]^!2344N6)!=07-28-<&1)+,>.+1-<?&,+3%-8@#<&#&<-A7#B&1#2>%+$<&(-%-&$&C$%7#<.#&;%-<+)#+%$?&DEEEFDEGEH!P%#0!M0.:[0,8%H!

DCUCA("BRWEYDBS])!

!

D07:&:_,!C<0,_7:<+!;+.+!"7`.:<+!(+8:,+!>!%#!D+.:=%!\CD("D^!234456)!(+!%<0,07a+!-%#!<+7=:0!<#:7b8:<0!%,!"7`.:<+!(+8:,+ Fa,8%&:&!

3445)!F+,8:+/0'!D@:#%H!E7;.%&0!%,!T+<:0,%&!S,:-+&)!c5;;)!

!

D@0?'!F)D)'!*+.%,/0'!1)")'!(>.+'!")")'!F?%:.0'!Q)'!A%&d?%.0'!1)W)'!"#$%&'!()*)'!e+>'!Q)'!P%88&'!B)'!D@+/+&'!U)1)'!Q07%&'!1)()'!%8!+#H'!234GG6)!

U0Z,&<+#:,/!09!F0?8@!"7%.:<+!;.%&%,8!<#:7+8%!-.:$%,!=>!fK7%7=%.!M+-D*I!.?,&)!D#:7+8%!U>,+7:<&!UYEH!G4)G44JR&44IN3K4GGK

G443KN)!

!

D%,8.+#!E,8%##:/%,<%!"/%,<>!\DE"^!234GG6)!P.+[:#)!!"#&I$%)7&J-1.4$$K)!B%8.:%$%-!9.07!@88;&HRRZZZ)<:+)/0$R#:=.+.>R;?=#:<+8:0,&R8@%K

Z0.#-K9+<8=00gR/%0&R=.)@87#!!

!

(%Z:,&0@,'!h)*)!+,-!A.+-0'!A)E)!2344L6)!M0Z!7+,>!&;%<:%&!+.%!8@%.%!:,!P.+[:#i!*$2<#%5-.+$2&;+$)$3L)!G5H!cG5Kc3f)!

!

*+.<0$:8<@'!1)!2%-)6!%8!+#)'&234G46)!M1$2$,+-&7-&,07-28-&7$&1)+,-&2$&;%-<+)B&10<.$<&#&$($%.02+7-7#<H&FO0!A+?#0H!EPCA!Q.b9:<+'!N3;)!B%8.:%$%-!9.07!

@88;HRR!ZZZ)%<0,07:+-0<#:7+)0./)=.R9:#%&R=:=#:08%<+R!C<0,07:+j-0j<#:7+);-9!!!

!

Page 22: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

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`$#9/7/#L!"/&/9?%$/(!2(!"%/(!,-./%&?%+!abNN+!3%?$/%8%2!H$(-!5??NLRR-<2#&4#947/-#?/4#9+4N?%4+/&N%+.$Rc$-47/-#RN2H9RN$(2dN$(./(R=<-#$/(+N2H!!!"/&/9?^$/(!2%!;/e&4/#!%!1%4&(7('/#!f";1g!CDEEbG+!60%7#" -(/+#&#%"(8%&#1+%"(!1$$3+#,%&#1+(&1(&9'(:+#&';(8%&#1+-(<0%$'=10>(!1+?'+&#1+(1+(!"#$%&'(!9%+5'.!`$#9/7/#L!"/&/9?$J!(H!=4/%&4%!#&2!1%45&(7('J+!DQaNN+!3%?$/%8%2!H$(-!5??NLRR<&H444+/&?R$%9(<$4%R2(49R&#?4R.$#0/7&4P%+N2H!!!"/&/9?^$/(!2%!;/e&4/#!%!1%4&(7('/#!f";1g!CDEPEG+!60%7#".(@',1+;(8%&#1+%"(!1$$3+#,%&#1+(14(60%7#"(&1(&9'(:+#&';(8%&#1+-(<0%$'=10>(!1+?'+&#1+(1+(!"#$%&'(!9%+5'.!`$#9/7/#L!=%4$%?#$/#!2%!6(7h?/4#9!J!6$('$#-#9!2%!M&8%9?/'#4/]&!J!@%9#$$(77(+!3%?$/%8%2!H$(-!5??NLRRIII+-4?+'(8+.$R/&2%V+N5NR4(&?%&?R8/%IRSDUFTb+5?-7!!!6#$$J)!"+:+)!;#&0/#&/)!O+A+)!6#7<?/i(H)!*+6+)!8#&!2%$!:/&2%&!6+*+)!#&2!j#&9(&)!;+B+!CB29G!CDEEQG+!!"#$%&'(!9%+5'(ABBCD(/$E%,&-F(%;%E&%&#1+(%+;(?3"+'0%G#"#&*.(!1+&0#G3&#1+(14(H10>#+5(I013E(//(&1(&9'(<130&9(J--'--$'+&(K'E10&(14(&9'(/+&'051?'0+$'+&%"(L%+'"(1+(!"#$%&'(!9%+5'+!;#-.$/2'%)!klL!;#-.$/2'%!k&/8%$9/?J!6$%99+!FQUNN+!3%?$/%8%2!H$(-!5??NLRRIII+/N44+45RN<.7/4#?/(&9d#&2d2#?#RN<.7/4#?/(&9d/N44dH(<$?5d#99%99-%&?d$%N($?dI'Dd$%N($?d/-N#4?9d#2#N?#?/(&d#&2d8<7&%$#./7/?J+5?-!!6%9m<%$()!*+A+)!;5(<)!=+;+)!X(.$%)!;+,+)!#&2!"#$%&'()!*+,+!CDEPEG+!;7/-#?%!2(I&94#7/&'!(8%$!=(<?5!,-%$/4#!H($!PFUPKPFQE!<9/&'!?5%!B?#!"(2%7+!M9'10'&#,%"(%+;(JEE"#';(!"#$%&1"15*.!FFL!QaKFS+!!

Page 23: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · 0.1# 6).>%-&0/').# # # "#$%&'(# > ).#!!!!! abb!!"#

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

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

! !