CLOSED, LEAD, STD U.S. District Court DISTRICT OF ARIZONA ... · DISTRICT OF ARIZONA (Prescott Division) CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 3:95−cv−01313−RCB Rudebusch, et al v. State

CLOSED, LEAD, STDU.S. District Court

DISTRICT OF ARIZONA (Prescott Division)CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 3:95−cv−01313−RCB

Rudebusch, et al v. State of Arizona, et alAssigned to: Judge Robert C BroomfieldDemand: $0Cause: 42:1983 Civil Rights Act

Date Filed: 06/30/1995Date Terminated: 02/23/2007Jury Demand: PlaintiffNature of Suit: 442 Civil Rights: JobsJurisdiction: Federal Question

Plaintiff

George Rudebusch represented byJess A LoronaDodge Anderson Mableson Steiner Jones&Horowitz Ltd3003 N Central AveSte 1800Phoenix, AZ 85012602−277−3000Fax: 602−277−7478Email: [email protected] ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Rosemary Stathakis CookLaw Ofice of Rosemary Cook818 N 5th AvePhoenix, AZ 85003602−271−0588Fax: 602−271−0133Email: [email protected]: 10/05/2000LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Thomas C Horne1535 W Jefferson4th FloorPhoenix, AZ 85007−0001(602)542−3813TERMINATED: 01/27/2004LEAD ATTORNEY

Plaintiff

Adrian Riskin represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Andrew Odell represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Arnold Johnson represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

mailto:[email protected]


Plaintiff

Burton Brown represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Charles T Way represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Craig Caldwell represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

David Kitterman represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Edward Hood represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Eugene Loverich represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Gary Bateman represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

George Rudebusch represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Gilbert C Pogany represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Guenther Huck represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Harvey Becher represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Howard Salisbury represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

James Edward Bartell represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

James D Simmerman represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

James Windes represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Jay Farness represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

John Bloom represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

John Hill represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Keith Cunningham represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Loren Reser represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEY

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Michael A Falk represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Michael Malone represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Michael Sanera represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Michael Tanner represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Michael Wunsch represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Randy Dillingham represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Richard Packard represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Robert Zoellner represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Stephen Jackson represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Stephen D Lapan represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)

LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Steve Funk represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Thomas Hoisch represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Timothy L Porter represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Wade Harrison represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Wayne Sjoberg represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

William Hildred represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Ken Nicolls represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Plaintiff

Virginia VigilTERMINATED: 08/16/2000

represented byRosemary Stathakis Cook(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Thomas C Horne(See above for address)TERMINATED: 01/27/2004LEAD ATTORNEY

V.

Defendant

Arizona, State ofTERMINATED: 11/24/1995

represented byRebecca Smith CurreyOffice of the Attorney General−1275 W WashingtonPhoenix, AZ 85007−2926(602)542−5025TERMINATED: 11/24/1995LEAD ATTORNEY

Lisa Kaye HudsonOffice of the Attorney General1275 W Washington StPhoenix, AZ 85007−2926602−542−7673Fax: 602−542−7644Email: [email protected] TO BE NOTICED

Defendant

Northern Arizona UniversityTERMINATED: 11/24/1995

represented byRebecca Smith Currey(See above for address)TERMINATED: 11/24/1995LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Lisa Kaye Hudson(See above for address)ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Defendant

Arizona Regents, Board ofTERMINATED: 11/24/1995

represented byKenneth Sean CountrymanKenneth S Countryman PC−1726 N 7th StPhoenix, AZ 85006−2205602−258−2928Fax: 602−258−5070Email: [email protected]: 03/03/1933LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Rebecca Smith Currey(See above for address)TERMINATED: 11/24/1995LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Lisa Kaye Hudson(See above for address)ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Defendant

Eugene HughesIndividually and as President of NorthernArizona University

represented byLisa Kaye HudsonOffice of the Attorney GeneralEmployment Law Section1275 W Washington StPhoenix, AZ 85007−2926602−542−7673Fax: 602−542−7644Email: [email protected] ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED





Defendant

Margaret Hughes represented byLisa Kaye Hudson(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED


Defendant

Eddie BashaIndividually and in his capacity as amember of the Arizona Board of RegentsTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

Jane Doe BashaTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

Rudy E CampbellIndividually and in his capacity as amember of the Arizona Board of RegentsTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

Jane Doe CampbellTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

Esther CapinIndividually, and in her capacity as amember of the Arizona Board of RegentsTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

John Doe CapinTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

Arthur ChapaIndividually and in his capacity as amember of the Arizona Board of RegentsTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

Jane Doe ChapaTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

Andrew D HurwitzIndividually and in his capacity as amember of the Arizona Board of RegentsTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

Jane Doe HurwitzTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

Spencer InsoliaIndividually and as a member of theArizona Board of RegentsTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

Jane Doe InsoliaTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

John F MungerIndividually and as a member of theArizona Board of RegentsTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

Jane Doe MungerTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

Donald PittIndividually and as a member of the

represented byRebecca Smith Currey(See above for address)

Arizona Board of RegentsTERMINATED: 11/24/1995

TERMINATED: 11/24/1995LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Defendant

Jane Doe PittTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

Douglas J WallIndividually and as a member of theArizona Board of RegentsTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

Jane Doe WallTERMINATED: 11/24/1995


Defendant

John DoesTERMINATED: 11/24/1995

Defendant

Jane DoesTERMINATED: 11/24/1995

Defendant

XYZ CorporationsTERMINATED: 11/24/1995

Defendant

ABC Government EntitiesTERMINATED: 11/24/1995

Plaintiff

Theresa Chapas represented byJess A Lorona(See above for address)LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Rosemary Stathakis Cook(See above for address)TERMINATED: 10/05/2000LEAD ATTORNEYATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Thomas C Horne(See above for address)TERMINATED: 01/27/2004LEAD ATTORNEY

Date Filed # Docket Text

06/30/1995 1 COMPLAINT FILED (MAP) (Entered: 07/05/1995)

07/19/1995 2 RETURN OF SERVICE EXECUTED by mail upon dft State ofArizona (by service upon Pat Burg for Grant Woods) on 7/14/95(LAD) (Entered: 07/21/1995)

07/24/1995 3 RETURN OF SERVICE EXECUTED personally upon dft State ofArizona (by service upon Grant Woods by service upon Pat Burg)on 7/14/95 (LAD) (Entered: 07/25/1995)

08/23/1995 4 ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE upon dft AZ Board of Regents, dftEddie Basha, dft Jane Doe Basha, dft Rudy E Campbell, dft JaneDoe Campbell, dft Esther Capin, dft John Doe Capin, dft ArthurChapa, dft Jane Doe Chapa, dft Andrew D Hurwitz, dft Jane DoeHurwitz, dft Spencer Insolia, dft Jane Doe Insolia, dft John FMunger, dft Jane Doe Munger, dft Donald Pitt, dft Jane Doe Pitt,dft Douglas J Wall, dft Jane Doe Wall on 8/21/95 (MAP) (Entered:08/24/1995)

08/31/1995 5 ANSWER by dfts (TCA) (Entered: 09/01/1995)

09/06/1995 6 STIPULATION by the parties that the pre−discovery disclosurestatements shall be exchanged on 11/1/95 (TCA) (Entered:09/08/1995)

09/11/1995 7 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation thatparties will exchange pre−discovery disclosure stmts on 11/1/95(cc: all counsel) (MAP) (Entered: 09/11/1995)

09/11/1995 8 REPORT of parties planning meeting (TCA) (Entered:09/14/1995)

09/14/1995 9 MINUTE ORDER: show cause hearing Re FRCivP 4(m) as toDefendants XYZ Corp 1−100/Does 1−100 John and Jane and ABCGovernmental set for 2:30pm, MONDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 1995before Judge Broomfield, Courtroom #3, Seventh Floor; OSChearing to be vacated upon filing proof of service and/or dismissal.(cc: all counsel) [9−2] (former emp) (Entered: 09/14/1995)

09/18/1995 11 NOTICE by dfts of service of answers to plas first request forproduction of documents (TCA) (Entered: 09/20/1995)

09/19/1995 10 ORDER SETTING RULE 16 SCHEDULING CONFERENCE byJudge Robert C. Broomfield scheduling conf set for 3:30 1/22/96(cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered: 09/19/1995)

09/22/1995 12 MOTION to continue Rule 16 scheduling conference by all(named) dfts [12−1] (LAD) (Entered: 09/26/1995)

09/26/1995 13 RESPONSE by plas George Rudebusch, Virginia Vigil to motionto continue Rule 16 scheduling conference by all (named) dfts[12−1] (former emp) (Entered: 09/29/1995)

09/28/1995 14 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion tocontinue Rule 16 scheduling conference by all (named) dfts[12−1]; Rule 16 scheduling conf reset for 3:00 2/5/96 (cc: allcounsel) (LAD) (Entered: 10/02/1995)

10/19/1995 15 NOTICE by dft of svc of dfts' answers to plas' 1st set ofnon−unfrm intrrgs and resp to Plaintiffs' 2nd req for production ofdocs (MAP) (Entered: 10/20/1995)

11/01/1995 16 STIPULATION to continue discovery disclosures pur to FRCP26(A)(1) (MAP) (Entered: 11/02/1995)

11/13/1995 17 MINUTE ORDER: cnsl advised the court of settlement; showcause hearing re unnamed defts set 11/13/96 VACATED; statushearing re settlement set for 2:30pm, 1/8/96; status hearing to bevacated upon the filing of dismissal (cc: all counsel) [17−3]

(former emp) (Entered: 11/13/1995)

11/13/1995 18 STIPULATION (re vacating order to show cause hearing) (LAD)(Entered: 11/15/1995)

11/24/1995 19 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield that Ms Margaret Hugheswill be included &substituted for Jane Doe Hughes....; dismissingdfts State of Arizona, NAU, AZ Board of Regents, Eddie Basha,Jane Doe Basha, Rudy E Campbell, Jane Doe Campbell, EstherCapin, John Doe Capin, Arthur Chapa, Jane Doe Chapa, Andrew DHurwitz, Jane Doe Hurwitz, Spencer Insolia, Jane Doe Insolia,John F Munger, Jane Doe Munger, Donald Pitt, Jane Doe Pitt,Douglas J Wall, Jane Doe Wall, John Does 1−100, Jane Does1−100, XYZ Corp 1−100, ABC Governmental (cc: all counsel)(LAD) (Entered: 11/24/1995)

11/27/1995 20 MINUTE ORDER: re: order [17−3] pltfs counsel advised the courtby letter dated 11/21/95 that the minute entry of 11/13/95 wasincorrect; status hearing re settlement set for 1/8/96 is VACATEDas it was set in error (cc: all counsel) [20−2] (former emp)(Entered: 11/27/1995)

11/28/1995 21 STIPULATION (re vacating OSC hearing &substitution of party)(LAD) (Entered: 11/28/1995)

01/17/1996 22 MOTION to exceed the page limit (re motion for determination)by all plas [22−1] (motion for determination of class action&certification of 2 subclasses lodged) (LAD) (Entered:01/19/1996)

01/26/1996 23 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion to exceedthe page limit (re motion for determination) by all plas [22−1] (cc:all counsel) (MAP) (Entered: 01/26/1996)

01/26/1996 24 MOTION for determination of class action by pla [24−1] and forcertification of 2 subclasses by pla [24−2] (MAP) (Entered:01/26/1996)

01/29/1996 25 MOTION for extension of time to file response to pla's motion fordetermination of class action &certification of two subclasses byall dfts [25−1] (LAD) (Entered: 01/31/1996)

01/31/1996 26 STIPULATION to continue scheduling conference to be held2/5/96 (LAD) (Entered: 02/01/1996)

02/07/1996 27 ORDER by Judge Broomfield granting stipulation prel schedulingconf vacated; continuing the ddls set forth in the Order dated9/19/95 until after there is a decision rendered on theappropriateness of the class (cc: all counsel) (MAP) (Entered:02/07/1996)

02/07/1996 28 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion forextension of time to file response to pla's motion for determinationof class action &certification of two subclasses by all dfts [25−1];dfts shl file its resp on/b4 2/29/96 (cc: all counsel) (MAP)(Entered: 02/07/1996)

02/28/1996 29 MOTION for extension of time to file response to plas' motion fordetermination of class action &certification of two subclasses byall dfts [29−1] (LAD) (Entered: 02/29/1996)

03/05/1996 30 STIPULATION for a corrected order (MAP) (Entered:03/06/1996)

03/12/1996 31 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion forextension of time to file response to plas' motion for determinationof class action &certification of two subclasses by all dfts [29−1];dft shall file its response to motion for determination of class

action by pla [24−1], motion for certification of 2 subclasses by pla[24−2] on or before 4/15/96 (cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered:03/12/1996)

03/12/1996 32 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation;striking order entered 11/21/95; Ms Margaret Hughes will beincluded &substituted for Jane Doe Hughes....; dismissing theaction against individual dfts Eddie Basha, Jane Doe Basha, RudyE Campbell, Jane Doe Campbell, Esther Capin, John Doe Capin,Arthur Chapa, Jane Doe Chapa, Andrew D Hurwitz, Jane DoeHurwitz, Spencer Insolia, Jane Doe Insolia, John F Munger, JaneDoe Munger, Donald Pitt, Jane Doe Pitt, Douglas J Wall, Jane DoeWall, John Does 1−100, XYZ Corps 1−100 &ABC GovernmentalEntities; dismissing the State of Arizona, Northern ArizonaUniversity &the Arizona Board of Regents from count 2 of thecomplaint; the 1981 &1983 action will be against Eugene&Margaret Ann Hughes (cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered:03/12/1996)

04/12/1996 33 MOTION for judgment on the pleadings by all dfts [33−1] (LAD)(Entered: 04/13/1996)

04/12/1996 34 MOTION to exceed the page limit by all dfts [34−1] (response tomotion for determination lodged) (LAD) (Entered: 04/13/1996)

04/18/1996 35 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion to exceedthe page limit by all dfts [34−1] (re response to motion fordetermination of class action &certification of 2 subclasses) (cc: allcounsel) (LAD) (Entered: 04/18/1996)

04/18/1996 36 RESPONSE by all plas to motion for determination of class actionby all plas [24−1], motion for certification of 2 subclasses by allplas [24−2] (OK to file per order #35 4/18/96) (LAD) (Entered:04/18/1996)

04/29/1996 37 STIPULATION to continue pla's response to motion for judgmenton the pleadings (LAD) (Entered: 05/01/1996)

05/01/1996 38 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulationcontinuing the deadline for pla's response to motion for judgmenton the pleadings by all dfts [33−1] to 5/10/96 (cc: all counsel)(LAD) (Entered: 05/01/1996)

05/20/1996 39 STIPULATION to continue pla's response to dft's motion forjudgment on the pleadings (2nd request) (LAD) (Entered:05/21/1996)

05/22/1996 40 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulationcontinuing the deadline for response to motion for judgment on thepleadings by all dfts [33−1] to 6/2/96 [cc: all counsel] [33−1] (cc:all counsel) (LAD) (Entered: 05/22/1996)

06/03/1996 41 RESPONSE to motion to motion for judgment on the pleadings byall plas and CROSS−MOTION for order allowing limiteddiscovery &dismissing the action as to the State by all plas [41−1]&subsequent order determining 11th amendment is no bar to thisaction against remaining dfts by all plas [41−2] (RE: [33−1] )(LAD) (Entered: 06/04/1996)

06/03/1996 42 REPLY by all plas to response to motion for determination of classaction by pla [24−1], motion for certification of 2 subclasses by pla[24−2] (LAD) (Entered: 06/04/1996)

06/13/1996 43 REPLY by dft to response to motion for judgment on the pleadingsby all dfts [33−1] (former emp) (Entered: 06/14/1996)

09/12/1996 44 MOTION to consolidate cases (with CIV 96−1077 PCT PGR) byall plas [44−1] (LAD) (Entered: 09/13/1996)

09/30/1996 45 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting in part themotion for judgment on the pleadings by all dfts [33−1] as to theState of Arizona &NAU &denying without prejudice as to ABOR&individual dfts; dismissing dfts State of Arizona &NAU ;granting motion for determination of class action by pla [24−1],granting motion for certification of 2 subclasses by pla [24−2] (cc:all counsel) (LAD) (Entered: 09/30/1996)

10/28/1996 46 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting plas 15 days toproperly serve its motion to consolidate cases (with CIV 96−1077PCT PGR) by all plas [44−1] on dfts (cc: all counsel) (LAD)(Entered: 10/28/1996)

11/01/1996 47 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion toconsolidate cases (with CIV 96−1077 PCT PGR) by all plas [44−1](cc: all counsel/cy plcd in CV−96−1077) (former emp) Modifiedon 11/01/1996 (Entered: 11/01/1996)

11/01/1996 48 MINUTE ENTRY: advising cases CIV−95−1313 &CIV−96−1077are consolidated &assigned to the Hon RCB; all pleadngs be filedin lead case &captioned as noted herein [cc: Allcounsel/RCB/PGR] [48−1] re: minute entry [48−1] (former emp)(Entered: 11/01/1996)

11/12/1996 49 NOTICE by all plas of service (of special request for production ofdocuments &special request for admissions) (LAD) (Entered:11/13/1996)

11/14/1996 50 ORDER SETTING R.16 SCHEDULING CONF by Judge RobertC. Broomfield: scheduling conf set for 4:00 3/10/97 (cc: allcounsel) (former emp) (Entered: 11/14/1996)

11/26/1996 51 MOTION for summary judgment by all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313[51−1] (LAD) (Entered: 11/29/1996)

11/26/1996 52 STATEMENT OF FACTS by all dfts re motion for summaryjudgment by all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [51−1] (LAD) (Entered:11/29/1996)

12/18/1996 53 MOTION to strike motion for summary judgment by all plas[53−1] &request the motion be denied by all plas in3:95−cv−01313 [53−2] (LAD) (Entered: 12/19/1996)

12/18/1996 54 NOTICE by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 of service of answers tospecial request for admissions (LAD) (Entered: 12/19/1996)

12/18/1996 55 Answers to special request for admissions by dfts (STR LR 1.2)(former emp) (Entered: 12/21/1996)

12/19/1996 56 NOTICE by dft in 3:95−cv−01313 of srvc of answers to specialintrrogs &resp to special req for prod of docs (former emp)(Entered: 12/21/1996)

12/26/1996 57 RESPONSE by dft to motion to strike motion for summaryjudgment by all plas [53−1], motion the motion be denied by allplas [53−2] (former emp) (Entered: 12/30/1996)

01/03/1997 58 MINUTE ORDER: setting the following motions for MONDAY,MARCH 10, 1997 at 11:00am before Judge Broomfield,Courtroom #3, Seventh Floor: motion to strike motion forsummary judgment by all plas [53−1] and motion for summaryjudgment by all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [51−1]; preliminaryscheduling conference 3/10/96 VACATED and RESET for3:30pm, MONDAY, MAY 19, 1997 (cc: all counsel) [58−2](former emp) (Entered: 01/03/1997)

01/09/1997 59 REPLY by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 to response to motion tostrike motion for summary judgment by all plas [53−1] (REW)(Entered: 01/13/1997)

01/16/1997 61 STIPULATION (former emp) (Entered: 01/23/1997)

01/23/1997 60 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield denying motion for orderallowing limited discovery &dismissing the action as to the Stateby all plas [41−1], denying motion subsequent order determining11th amendment is no bar to this action against remaining dfts byall plas [41−2] (cc: all counsel) (former emp) (Entered:01/23/1997)

01/23/1997 62 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation andthat dfts waive any defense or claim that Guenther Huck did notfile a complaint w/in 90 days of recpt of his right to sue letter dated1/8/97 because Mr Huck has already been included in thecomplaint w/these allegations. (cc: all cnsl) (cc: all counsel)(former emp) (Entered: 01/23/1997)

01/23/1997 63 MOTION to continue discovery deadline for determing whetherthe Az Board of Regents is a state agency by pla [63−1] (formeremp) (Entered: 01/24/1997)

01/31/1997 64 NOTICE by all dfts of service of answers to 3rd request forproduction of documents (LAD) (Entered: 02/03/1997)

02/21/1997 65 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield: granting stipulation;GRANTING plas an additional 120 days to conduct discoverylimited to determining whether the AZ Board of Regents is a stateagency; the Court GRANTS defts leave to refile their motion forsummary judgment as to the AZ Board of Regents within 60 daysthereafter (cc: all counsel) re: order [65−1] (former emp) (Entered:02/21/1997)

02/26/1997 66 MOTION to amend order granting extension of discovery deadlineby all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [66−1] (LAD) (Entered: 02/27/1997)

02/26/1997 67 NOTICE of change of counsel for dfts. Asst AG, Lisa Hudson hasbeen substituted as cnsl of rcrd for dfts, STate of AZ, NAU, AZBoard of Regents and Eugene Hughes in place of Rebecca S.Currey. (former emp) (Entered: 03/03/1997)

03/06/1997 68 STIPULATION (extending dfts' resp to 4th req for prod etc)(former emp) (Entered: 03/07/1997)

03/10/1997 69 MINUTE ENTRY: Crt Rptr: R.Huckaby−Cotton − ECR: takingunder advisement on 3/10/97 the following motions: motion tostrike motion for summary judgment by all plas [53−1], motion themotion be denied by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [53−2], and,motion for summary judgment by all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313[51−1] [69−1] (former emp) (Entered: 03/10/1997)

03/14/1997 70 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion tocontinue discovery deadline for determing whether the Az Boardof Regents is a state agency by pla [63−1]; withdrawing the motionto amend order granting extension of discovery deadline by all dftsin 3:95−cv−01313 [66−1] (cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered:03/14/1997)

03/27/1997 71 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield denying motion to strikemotion for summary judgment by all plas [53−1], granting motionthe motion be denied (for continuance) by all plas in3:95−cv−01313 [53−2]; plas are directed to file a response tomotion for summary judgment within 25 days after the filing ofthis order; granting motion for summary judgment by dfts in3:95−cv−01313 [51−1] of section 1981 sex−based discriminationclaims; staying ruling on the remainder of dfts' motion forsummary judgment (cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered: 03/27/1997)

03/31/1997 72 NOTICE by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 OF TAKING DEPO OFMary McHugh on the following date(s): 4/17/97 at 9 am (LAD)

(Entered: 04/02/1997)

03/31/1997 73 NOTICE by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 OF TAKING DEPO OFJoel Sideman on the following date(s): 4/21/97 at 9 am (LAD)(Entered: 04/02/1997)

04/09/1997 74 NOTICE by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 OF TAKING DEPO OFEugene Hughes on the following date(s): 5/5/97 at 9 am (LAD)(Entered: 04/11/1997)

04/09/1997 75 NOTICE by all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 of service of answers to 1strequest for admissions, 2nd set of interrogatories &4th request forproduction of documents (LAD) (Entered: 04/11/1997)

04/10/1997 76 STIPULATION (that response to motion for summary judgmentbe due 5/9/97 &reply due 5/30/97) (LAD) (Entered: 04/11/1997)

04/18/1997 77 MINUTE ORDER: pending the court's ruling on pendingmotion(s), the following scheduling conference is reset:preliminary scheduling conference 5/19/97 VACATED andRESET for 3:00pm, 10/6/97 (cc: all counsel) [77−2] (former emp)(Entered: 04/18/1997)

04/18/1997 78 NOTICE by all dfts of service of supplmental response to 4threquest for production of documents (LAD) (Entered: 04/21/1997)

05/09/1997 79 RESPONSE by pla to motion for summary judgment by all dfts[51−1] (former emp) (Entered: 05/10/1997)

05/09/1997 80 CROSS−MOTION for summary judgment by plas [80−1] (formeremp) (Entered: 05/10/1997)

05/09/1997 81 STATEMENT OF FACTS by plas in support of response &x−mtnfor sj (#79, 80) (former emp) (Entered: 05/10/1997)

05/09/1997 82 AFFIDAVIT of Michael R. Wagner (former emp) (Entered:05/10/1997)

05/15/1997 83 SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION to certifiy class by all plas in3:95−cv−01313 [83−1] (LAD) (Entered: 05/19/1997)

05/15/1997 84 AFFIDAVIT of Michael R Wagner (BULKY DOCUMENT)(LAD) (Entered: 05/19/1997)

05/27/1997 85 STIPULATION for extension of time (re responses/replies topending motions) (1st request) (LAD) (Entered: 05/29/1997)

06/02/1997 86 NOTICE by all dfts of service of response to 5th request forproduction of documents (LAD) (Entered: 06/03/1997)

06/06/1997 87 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation;granting dfts an extension to 6/16/97 to file their reply to motionfor summary judgment by all dfts in [51−1] &responses tocross−motion for summary judgment by plas [80−1]&supplemental motion to certifiy class by all plas in3:95−cv−01313 [83−1] (cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered:06/06/1997)

06/16/1997 88 RESPONSE by all dfts to supplemental motion to certifiy class byall plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [83−1] (LAD) (Entered: 06/18/1997)

06/16/1997 89 NOTICE TO COURT &COUNSEL RE: AFFIDAVIT of JosephFranco (LAD) (Entered: 06/18/1997)

06/16/1997 89 MOTION (REQUEST) for Rule 56(f) relief by all dfts in3:95−cv−01313 [89−1] (LAD) (Entered: 06/18/1997)

06/16/1997 90 CONSOLIDATED REPLY by all dfts to response to motion forsummary judgment by all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [51−1] (LAD)(Entered: 06/18/1997)

06/16/1997 90 RESPONSE by all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 to cross−motion forsummary judgment by plas [80−1] (LAD) (Entered: 06/18/1997)

06/16/1997 91 STATEMENT OF FACTS by all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 reresponse (opposition) to cross−motion for summary judgment(BULKY DOCUMENT) (LAD) (Entered: 06/18/1997)

06/23/1997 92 SUPPLEMENTAL &AMENDED RESPONSE by all dfts in3:95−cv−01313 to motion for summary judgment by plas [80−1](LAD) (Entered: 06/24/1997)

07/02/1997 93 STIPULATION to continue plas' response to supplemental motionto certify class &plas' reply to response to countermotion forsummary judgment.... (LAD) (Entered: 07/07/1997)

07/09/1997 94 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation; thatplas be provided an extension till 7/19/97 to reply to response tomotion to certifiy class by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [83−1]&reply to response to motion for summary judgment by plas[80−1] (cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered: 07/09/1997)

07/18/1997 95 STIPULATION to continue response to supplemental motion tocertify class etc (LAD) (Entered: 07/23/1997)

07/23/1997 96 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation thatplas provided an extn til 8/1/97 to reply to dfts' respnse to plas'supplmntl mtn to certify class &plas' reply to dfts' respnse to pla'scntrmtn for sj &oppositn to dfts' supplmntl stmt of facts (cc: allcounsel) (former emp) (Entered: 07/23/1997)

08/01/1997 97 REPLY by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 to response to supplementalmotion to certifiy class by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [83−1](LAD) (Entered: 08/05/1997)

08/01/1997 98 NOTICE OF HEARING by pla in 3:95−cv−01313 setting motionto certifiy class by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [83−1] at 11:0011/17/97, setting motion for summary judgment by plas [80−1] at11:00 11/17/97, setting motion for summary judgment by all dftsin 3:95−cv−01313 [51−1] at 11:00 11/17/97 (LAD) (Entered:08/05/1997)

08/01/1997 99 MOTION to file reply brief of 17 pgs (re reply in support of crossmotion for summary judgment) by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313[99−1] (reply &statement lodged) (LAD) (Entered: 08/05/1997)

08/05/1997 100 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion to filereply brief of 17 pgs (re reply in support of cross motion forsummary judgment) by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [99−1] (cc: allcounsel) (LAD) (Entered: 08/05/1997)

08/05/1997 101 REPLY by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 to response to motion forsummary judgment by plas [80−1] (OK to file per order #1008/5/97) (LAD) (Entered: 08/05/1997)

08/05/1997 102 OBJECTION by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 to supplementalstatement [91−1] (OK to file per order #100) (LAD) (Entered:08/05/1997)

08/13/1997 103 MINUTE ORDER: as Motions for Summary Judgment are set fororal argument on 11/17/97, preliminary scheduling conference of10/6/97 VACATED and RESET for 2:45pm, MONDAY,FEBRUARY 9, 1998 (cc: all counsel) [103−2] (former emp)(Entered: 08/13/1997)

09/02/1997 104 MINUTE ORDER: the following motions set for oral argument11/17/97 VACATED and RESET for 11:00am, MONDAY,SEPTEMBER 22, 1997: motion for summary judgment by plas[80−1] and motion for summary by all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313[51−1] (cc: all counsel) [104−1] (former emp) (Entered:

09/02/1997)

09/10/1997 105 MOTION for summary judgment by dft AZ Board of Regents in3:95−cv−01313 [105−1] (LAD) (Entered: 09/15/1997)

09/10/1997 106 STATEMENT OF FACTS by dft AZ Board of Regents in3:95−cv−01313 re motion for summary judgment by dft AZ Boardof Regents in 3:95−cv−01313 [105−1] (LAD) (Entered:09/15/1997)

09/22/1997 107 MINUTE ENTRY: Crt Rptr: V.Reger − ECR: taking underadvisement on 9/22/09 the following motions: motion to certifiyclass by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [83−1]; motion for summaryjudgment by plas [80−1]; and, motion for summary judgment byall dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [51−1] [107−1] (former emp) (Entered:09/22/1997)

09/26/1997 108 MOTION (APPLICATION) for leave to file supplement tocomplaint by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [108−1] (supplement tocomplaint lodged) (LAD) (Entered: 09/30/1997)

09/26/1997 109 MOTION for accelerated adjudication of motion (application) forleave to file supplement to complaint by all plas [108−1] by allplas in 3:95−cv−01313 [109−1] (LAD) (Entered: 09/30/1997)

09/30/1997 110 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting in part &denyingin part the motion for summary judgment by all dfts in3:95−cv−01313 [51−1]; denying motion for summary judgment byplas [80−1]; denying motion for Rule 56(f) relief by all dfts in3:95−cv−01313 [89−1]; granting in part &denying in part themotion to certifiy class by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [83−1] (cc:all counsel) (LAD) (Entered: 09/30/1997)

10/01/1997 111 STIPULATION for extension of time (plas to respond to Az Brdof Regent's mtn for sj) (former emp) (Entered: 10/07/1997)

10/07/1997 112 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation thatplas have to 11/10/97 to motion for summary judgment by dft AZBoard of Regents [105−1] (cc: all counsel) (former emp) (Entered:10/07/1997)

10/09/1997 113 JOINT STIPULATION &MOTION (APPLICATION) forcontinuance (to file definitions of class &sub−classes) by all plas,all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [113−1] (LAD) (Entered: 10/10/1997)

10/15/1997 114 RESPONSE by all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 to motion for leave tofile supplement to complaint by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [108−1](LAD) (Entered: 10/16/1997)

10/15/1997 115 MOTION (REQUEST) for oral argument (re response to motionfor leave to file supplement to complaint) by all dfts in3:95−cv−01313 [115−1] (LAD) (Entered: 10/16/1997)

10/16/1997 116 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion forcontinuance (to file definitions of class &sub−classes) by all plas,all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [113−1]; granting plas thru 10/24/97within which to file their proposed definitions of the class&sub−class (cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered: 10/16/1997)

10/16/1997 117 MOTION (REQUEST) for oral argument (on application for leaveto file supplemental complaint) by all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313[117−1] (LAD) (Entered: 10/20/1997)

10/21/1997 118 ORDER (NOTICE OF HEARING) by Judge Robert C.Broomfield granting motion for oral argument (on application forleave to file complaint) by all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [117−1];granting motion for oral argument (re response to motion for leavefile supplement to complaint) by all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313

[115−1]; setting motion for leave to file supplement to complaintby all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [108−1] at 11:00 12/1/97 (cc: allcounsel) (LAD) (Entered: 10/21/1997)

10/24/1997 119 SUBMISSION OF PROPOSED DEFINITIONS OF THE CLASS&SUBCLASSES PURSUANT TO COURT ORDER by all plas(LAD) (Entered: 10/27/1997)

10/28/1997 120 LOCAL RULE 1.10 MOTION for partial reconsideration by allplas in 3:95−cv−01313 [120−1] (LAD) (Entered: 10/29/1997)

11/07/1997 121 RESPONSE by dfts to plas' submission of proposed definitions ofthe class &subclass (former emp) (Entered: 11/12/1997)

11/10/1997 122 STIPULATION for extension of time (respond to mtn for sj)(former emp) (Entered: 11/12/1997)

11/17/1997 123 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation;granting plas till Tues, 11/25/97 to file their response to motion forsummary judgment by dft AZ Board of Regents in 3:95−cv−01313[105−1] [105−1] (cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered: 11/17/1997)

11/25/1997 124 STIPULATION for extension of time (to file a response to dft AZDept of Regents' motion for summary judgment) (LAD) (Entered:11/26/1997)

11/26/1997 125 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield directing dfts to respondto motion for partial reconsideration by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313[120−1] within 15 days from the filing date of this order (cc: allcounsel) (LAD) (Entered: 11/26/1997)

11/26/1997 126 STIPULATION for extn of time (to respnd to mtn for sj) (formeremp) (Entered: 11/28/1997)

11/28/1997 127 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation thatplas hv to 11/26/97 to respond to motion for summary judgment bydft AZ Board of Regents [105−1] (cc: all counsel) (former emp)(Entered: 11/28/1997)

12/01/1997 128 MINUTE ENTRY: Crt Rptr: R.Huckaby−Cotton − ECR: grantingmotion for accelerated adjudication of motion (application) forleave to file supplement to complaint by all plas [108−1] by allplas in 3:95−cv−01313 [109−1]; taking under advisement on12/1/97 the motion for leave to file supplement to complaint by allplas in 3:95−cv−01313 [128−1](former emp) Modified on12/01/1997 (Entered: 12/01/1997)

12/01/1997 130 REPLY by pla to response to motion for leave to file supplementto complaint by all plas [108−1] (former emp) (Entered:12/02/1997)

12/02/1997 129 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation thatplas have til 12/3/97 to respond to motion for summary judgmentby dft AZ Board of Regents [105−1] (cc: all counsel) (former emp)(Entered: 12/02/1997)

12/03/1997 131 RESPONSE by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 to motion for summaryjudgment by dft AZ Board of Regents in 3:95−cv−01313 [105−1](LAD) (Entered: 12/05/1997)

12/03/1997 132 STATEMENT OF FACTS by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 reresponse to motion for summary judgment (LAD) (Entered:12/05/1997)

12/09/1997 133 RESPONSE by all dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 to motion for partialreconsideration by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [120−1] (LAD)(Entered: 12/10/1997)

12/23/1997 134 STIPULATION to extend time to file reply in support of dfts'motion for summary judgment on 11th amendment question(proposed document not provided) (LAD) (Entered: 12/29/1997)

01/07/1998 135 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield denying motion for leaveto file supplement to complaint by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313[108−1] (cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered: 01/07/1998)

01/08/1998 136 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation;granting dfts an extension of time to 1/16/98 to file their reply tomotion for summary judgment by dft AZ Board of Regents in3:95−cv−01313 [105−1] (cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered:01/08/1998)

01/15/1998 137 STIPULATION to extend time to file reply in support of dfts'motion for summary judgment on 11th amendment question (2ndtime) (LAD) (Entered: 01/20/1998)

01/20/1998 138 MINUTE ORDER: as a Motion for Summary Judgment ispending, the following conference set 2/9/98 VACATED andRESET to MONDAY, JUNE 1, 1998 at 3:15pm: preliminaryscheduling conference (Rule 16) (cc: all counsel) [138−2] (formeremp) (Entered: 01/20/1998)

01/21/1998 139 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation;granting dfts an extension of time to file their reply in support ofmotion for summary judgment on 11th amendment question by dftAZ Board of Regents in 3:95−cv−01313 [105−1] (cc: all counsel)(LAD) (Entered: 01/21/1998)

01/22/1998 140 MOTION for 10−day continuance within which to comply withCourt's offer to amend the proposed supplement to the complaintby all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [140−1] (reply lodged at docketclerk's desk) (LAD) Modified on 01/27/1998 (Entered:01/27/1998)

01/28/1998 141 RESPONSE by all dfts to motion for 10−day continuance withinwhich to comply with Court's offer to amend the proposedsupplement to the complaint by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [140−1](reply lodged at docket clerk's desk) (LAD) (Entered: 02/02/1998)

02/02/1998 142 MOTION for leave to file amended supplement to the complaint(lodged document at docket clerk digit 9's desk) by pla GeorgeRudebusch, pla Virginia Vigil in 3:95−cv−01313 [142−1] (KMG)(Entered: 02/04/1998)

02/09/1998 143 REPLY by all plas to response to motion for 10−day continuancewithin which to comply with Court's order to amend the proposedsupplement to the complaint by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [140−1](reply lodged at docket clerk's desk) (LAD) (Entered: 02/11/1998)

02/19/1998 144 RESPONSE by dfts Eugene Hughes and Margaret Hughes in3:95−cv−01313 to motion for leave to file amended supplement tothe complaint by pla George Rudebusch, pla Virginia Vigil in3:95−cv−01313 [142−1] (KMG) (Entered: 02/23/1998)

03/03/1998 145 REPLY by all plas to response to (amended) motion for leave tofile amended supplement to the complaint (lodged document atdocket clerk digit 9's desk) by pla George Rudebusch, pla VirginiaVigil in 3:95−cv−01313 [142−1] (LAD) (Entered: 03/04/1998)

04/28/1998 146 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion for10−day continuance within which to comply with Court's order toamend the proposed supplement to the complaint by all plas[140−1] (reply lodged at docket clerk's desk), denying motion forleave to file amended supplement to the complaint (lodgeddocument at docket clerk digit 9's desk) by pla George Rudebusch,pla Virginia Vigil [142−1] (cc: all counsel) (former emp) (Entered:

04/28/1998)

04/28/1998 147 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting/denying in partmotion for partial reconsideration by all plas in 3:95−cv−01313[120−1]; court's order [110−1] of 9/30/97 is vacated to the extent itgranted Dr. Hughes' mtn for sj on the qualified immunity issue (cc:all counsel) (former emp) (Entered: 04/28/1998)

04/28/1998 148 REPLY by dfts to response to motion for summary judgment bydft AZ Board of Regents in 3:95−cv−01313 [105−1] (former emp)(Entered: 04/28/1998)

05/21/1998 150 NOTICE of Interlocutory Appeal by Eugene Hughes, MargaretHughes from District Court order [147−1] (cc: 9CCA/cnsl/RCB)(REW) Modified on 04/11/2000 (Entered: 06/01/1998)

05/21/1998 Received $105.00 appeal fee (REW) (Entered: 06/01/1998)

05/27/1998 149 MINUTE ORDER: As Defendant's Motion for SummaryJudgment is still pending before the court, the preliminaryscheduling conference set 6/1/98 VACATED and RESET forMONDAY, OCTOBER 5, 1998 (cc: all counsel) [149−2] (formeremp) (Entered: 05/27/1998)

06/01/1998 REMARK; CADS forwarded to 9CCA this date (REW) (Entered:06/01/1998)

06/02/1998 151 Transcript Designation and Ordering Form; ordering transcript forhearing of 3/10/97 (REW) (Entered: 06/08/1998)

06/03/1998 152 NOTICE of Interlocutory Appeal by George Rudebusch, VirginiaVigil from District Court order [147−1] (cc: 9CCA/allcounsel/RCB) (REW) Modified on 04/11/2000 (Entered:06/09/1998)


06/03/1998 153 NOTICE by pla George Rudebusch, pla Virginia Vigil of transcriptdesignation (not proper form) (REW) (Entered: 06/09/1998)

06/09/1998 REMARK; CADS forwarded to 9CCA this date (REW) (Entered:06/09/1998)

06/15/1998 Notification by 9CCA of Appellate Docket Number 98−16009(REW) (Entered: 06/15/1998)

06/30/1998 Notification by 9CCA of Appellate Docket Number 98−16118(REW) (Entered: 06/30/1998)

07/06/1998 154 Court Reporter's Transcript of Proceedings for the followingdate(s): 3/10/97; re: motion for summary judgment; CtRptr: RoseHuckaby−Cotton (REW) (Entered: 07/14/1998)

07/10/1998 Certificate of Record Transmitted to 9CCA [150−1] (REW)(Entered: 07/14/1998)

08/07/1998 155 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion forsummary judgment by dft AZ Board of Regents [105−1]dismissing Az Board of Regents , (cc: all counsel) (former emp)(Entered: 08/07/1998)

08/13/1998 156 MOTION for reconsideration of the Court's order dated 8/5/98 (recourt did not addres pla's arguments on continued viability ofPennuhust State vs. Halderman) by plas in 3:95−cv−01313[156−1] (LAD) Modified on 08/25/1998 (Entered: 08/14/1998)

08/14/1998 157 ERRATA by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 to motion for reconsiderationof the Court's order dated 8/5/98 [156−1] (LAD) (Entered:08/20/1998)

09/17/1998 158 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield denying motion forreconsideration of the Court's order dated 8/5/98 (re court did notaddres pla's arguments on continued viability of Pennuhust Statevs. Halderman) by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [156−1] (cc: allcounsel/RW) (LAD) (Entered: 09/17/1998)

10/02/1998 159 STIPULATION (pla/dfts) to continue preliminary schedulingconference (former emp) (Entered: 10/05/1998)

10/07/1998 160 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulationvacating the prel scheduling conf set 10/5/98 (cc: all counsel)(former emp) (Entered: 10/07/1998)

08/27/1999 Clerk's record on appeal transmitted to 9CCA; 3 volumes clerk'srecord; 1 transcript (#154); 4 bulkie documents (#24, 82, 84, 91);in two expandos (REW) (Entered: 08/27/1999)

02/08/2000 161 CERTIFIED COPY of 9CCA Mandate; affirming in part andreversing in part the decision of the District Court; we affirm thedistrict court's order denying dft's motion for summary judment onthe basis of qualified immunity and dismiss the cross−appeal forlack of jurisdiction; the panel shall retain jurisdiction over allfuture appeals in this matter, re: 98−16009 and 98−16118 (cc: allcounsel/RCB) (REW) (Entered: 02/08/2000)

02/17/2000 Original Record Received from 9CCA re [152−1], [150−1] 3volumes orig file; 1 rptr trans (#154); 4 bulky doc(s) (#24, 82, 84,91) in two expandos (REW) (Entered: 02/17/2000)

02/18/2000 162 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield ; status hearing set for1:00 3/13/00 (cc: all counsel) (DMT) (Entered: 02/18/2000)

03/13/2000 163 MINUTE ENTRY: before Judge Robert C. Broomfield: Crt Rptr:R. Huckaby−Cotton − ECR: status hearing by telephone re NinthCircuit Mandate and status of this case held: preliminaryscheduling conference set for 2:15pm, 4/24/00 (separate order tofollow to set scheduling conference [163−2] (former emp)(Entered: 03/13/2000)

03/22/2000 164 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield; this action...is designateda standard track case; scheduling conf set for 2:15 4/24/00 (cc: allcounsel) (LAD) (Entered: 03/22/2000)

04/11/2000 REMARK; mandate recalled 2/25/00, corrected mandate issued3/20/00 (REW) (Entered: 04/11/2000)

04/11/2000 165 CERTIFIED COPY of 9CCA Mandate affirming the decision ofthe District Court, dismissing the cross−appeal; affirming thedistrict court's order denying dft's motion for summary judgmenton the basis of qualified immunity and dismissing the cross−appealfor lack of jurisdiction; panel shall retain jurisdiction over allfuture appeals in this matter, re: 98−16009 and 98−16118 (cc: allcounsel/RCB) (mandate filed 2/8/00 was recalled 2/25/00, thiscorrected mandate was issued 3/20/00) (REW) (Entered:04/11/2000)

04/21/2000 166 RULE 16 JOINT REPORT joint pretrial order 8/15/00 or dfts'position 60 days after a ruling on dispositive motions; Discoverycutoff 6/30/00; Motion filing ddl is 7/31/00 (former emp) (Entered:04/24/2000)

04/24/2000 167 MINUTE ENTRY: before Judge Robert C. Broomfield: Crt Rptr:R.Huckaby−Cotton − ECR: preliminary scheduling conferenceheld; discovery ddl set for 6/30/00; dispositive motions due7/31/00; PTO ddl set for 8/15/00; sample form of Pretrial Orderhanded to counsel in courtroom; Pretrial conference set for3:45pm, 9/11/00; 3−4 day jury trial set for 9:00, 11/14/00; counselin chambers at 8:30am. (former emp) (Entered: 04/24/2000)

04/24/2000 168 SCHEDULING ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield ;discovery due 6/30/00 ; dispositive motions due 7/31/00 ; pretrialorder due 8/15/00 ; Pretrial conference set for 3:45 9/11/00 (formeremp) (Entered: 04/25/2000)

05/31/2000 169 JOINT MOTION for one week postponement (of witness list andreport on settlement by plas, dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [169−1](LAD) (Entered: 06/01/2000)

06/07/2000 170 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting joint motion forone week postponement (of witness list and report on settlement byplas, dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [169−1]; granting a 1 weekpostponement of the witness list and report on settlement to a newdeadline of 6/8/00 (cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered: 06/07/2000)

06/08/2000 171 WITNESS LIST by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 (LAD) (Entered:06/13/2000)

06/08/2000 172 WITNESS LIST by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 (LAD) (Entered:06/13/2000)

06/08/2000 173 JOINT STATUS REPORT by plas, dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 (LAD)(Entered: 06/13/2000)

06/28/2000 174 STIPULATION AND MOTION to continue deadlines set in4/24/00 scheduling order (by 60 days) by plas, dfts in3:95−cv−01313 [174−1] (LAD) (Entered: 06/30/2000)

07/18/2000 175 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion tocontinue deadlines set in 4/24/00 scheduling order (by 60 days) byplas, dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [174−1] ; discovery ddl reset for8/30/00; dispositive motions ddl reset to 9/1/00; PTO ddl reset for10/16/00; Pretrial conference reset for 3:15 11/13/00; jury trialreset for 9:00 1/15/01 (cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered:07/18/2000)

07/31/2000 176 DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESS (Michael R Wagner,PhD) by plas (LAD) (Entered: 08/02/2000)

08/02/2000 177 MINUTE ORDER: 3−4 day jury trial 1/15/01 VACATED as thisdate is a Monday and a Federal Holiday; trial is RESET toTUESDAY, JANUARY 23, 2001 at 9:00am with counsel inchambers at 8:30am. (cc: all counsel) [177−2] (former emp)(Entered: 08/02/2000)

08/08/2000 178 STIPULATION to substitute plas' class representative (TheresaChapas in place of Virginia Vigil) by plas, dfts in 3:95−cv−01313(LAD) (Entered: 08/09/2000)

08/08/2000 179 MOTION to vacate 1/23/01 trial date and reset to 11/14/00 by plasin 3:95−cv−01313 [179−1] (LAD) (Entered: 08/09/2000)

08/14/2000 180 RESPONSE by dfts to motion to vacate 1/23/01 trial date and resetto 11/14/00 by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [179−1] (LAD) (Entered:08/15/2000)

08/16/2000 181 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation;ORDERED granting plas to substitute Theresa Chapas as classrepresentative (cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered: 08/16/2000)

08/21/2000 182 REPLY by plas to response to motion to vacate 1/23/01 trial dateand reset to 11/14/00 plas [179−1] (former emp) (Entered:08/22/2000)

09/05/2000 183 MINUTE ENTRY: before Judge Robert C. Broomfield: Crt Rptr:V. Reger − ECR: by telephone: Thomas Horne for Pla; LisaHudson for Dfts: granting motion to vacate 1/23/01 trial date andreset to 11/14/00 by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [179−1]; dispositivemotions (Motion(s) for Summary Judgment) due 9/25/00; response

to be filed by 10/10/00; any reply to be filed by 10/30/00; parties toserve motion, response and any reply personally or by fax to befollowed up by regular mail; 3−4 day jury trial of 1/23/01VACATED and RESET to TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 14, 2000 at9:00am; counsel in chambers at 8:30am. [183−2] (former emp)(Entered: 09/06/2000)

09/25/2000 184 MOTION for summary judgment (on all remaining claims in CIV95−1313 as Eugene Hughes is entitled to qualified immunity andon pla's Title VII claims in CIV 96−1077) by dfts in3:95−cv−01313 [184−1] (LAD) (Entered: 09/26/2000)

09/25/2000 185 STATEMENT OF FACTS by dfts re motion for summaryjudgment (on all remaining claims in CIV 95−1313 as EugeneHughes is entitled to qualified immunity and on Title VII claims inCIV 96−1077) by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [184−1] (LAD) (Entered:09/26/2000)

10/03/2000 186 MOTION for Court approval of definition of class and sub− classmembers as submitted 10/24/97 by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [186−1](LAD) (Entered: 10/05/2000)

10/03/2000 187 MOTION to approve notice to class and sub−class members andorder directing distribution of notice to class and sub−classmembers by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [187−1] (LAD) (Entered:10/06/2000)

10/05/2000 189 NOTICE by pla George Rudebusch, pla Theresa Chapas of changeof name of plas' counsel and withdrawal of co− counsel RosemaryCook (LAD) (Entered: 10/06/2000)

10/06/2000 188 MINUTE ENTRY: before Judge Robert C. Broomfield: Crt Rptr:Bridget Brittan: Counsel by telephone: Thomas Horne for Plas:Lisa Hudson for Dfts: hearing held to Reset jury trial currently setfor 11/14/00 in Prescott: jury trial RESET for 9:00am, 12/5/00 inPrescott, AZ; counsel in chambers at 8:30am (damages portion tofollow liability issues − trial estimated 5−7 days) [cc: counsel ofrecord/Pct cal] [188−2] (former emp) Modified on 10/06/2000(Entered: 10/06/2000)

10/10/2000 190 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield that dfts must enter on orbefore 10/16/00 any and all objections to plas' proposed ordersgranting approval of the definition of the class and sub−class andgranting approval of pla's notice and distribution of class andsub−class members (cc: all counsel) re: order [190−1] (LAD)(Entered: 10/10/2000)

10/10/2000 191 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield re: notice of withdrawalof co−counsel Rosemary Cook and change of name [189−1] ;ORDERED that Rosemary Cook is withdrawn as counsel and pla'scounsel's name of Horne Bistrow &Dulberg PC is change to HorneDucar Lorona &Slaton LLP (cc: all counsel/Cook) (LAD)(Entered: 10/10/2000)

10/13/2000 192 MOTION to exceed the page limit (re response to motion forsummary judgment and cross motions) by plas in 3:95−cv−01313[192−1] (response and cross motions, response to statement andseparate statement/affidavit are lodged at docket clerk's desk)(LAD) (Entered: 10/17/2000)

10/20/2000 193 OBJECTIONS by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 to proposed (class)notice (LAD) (Entered: 10/23/2000)

10/20/2000 193 MOTION (REQUEST) to extend time (for making proposedobjections) by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [193−1] (LAD) (Entered:10/23/2000)

10/20/2000 194 NOTICE by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 of filing original signaturepage of Stephen Chambers (re his affidavit) (LAD) (Entered:10/23/2000)

10/24/2000 201 RESPONSE by pla George Rudebusch in 3:95−cv−01313 toobjection [193−1] to proposed class notice (former emp) (Entered:10/27/2000)

10/25/2000 195 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion to exceedthe page limit (re response to motion for summary judgment andcross motions) by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [192−1] (response andcross motions, response to statement and separatestatement/affidavit are lodged at docket clerk's desk) (cc: allcounsel) (LAD) (Entered: 10/25/2000)

10/25/2000 196 RESPONSE to motion for summary judgment by plas in3:95−cv−01313 and CROSS−MOTION for summary judgment (asthere was no manifest imbalance and no valid Title VIIAffirmative Action Plan) by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [196−1][184−1] ) (LAD) (Entered: 10/25/2000)

10/25/2000 197 RESPONSE by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 to statement [185−1](LAD) (Entered: 10/25/2000)

10/25/2000 197 STATEMENT OF FACTS by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 re motionfor summary judgment (as there was no manifest imbalance and novalid Title VII Affirmative Action Plan) by plas in 3:95−cv−01313[196−1] (LAD) (Entered: 10/25/2000)

10/25/2000 197 AFFIDAVIT of Michael R Wagner, PhD (LAD) (Entered:10/25/2000)

10/25/2000 202 MOTION to extend ddl for dfts response and reply to mtn for sumjgm and cross mtn through 11/13/00 by plas and dfts [202−1](former emp) (Entered: 10/27/2000)

10/27/2000 198 STIPULATION approving ntc of class action by pla in3:95−cv−01313 (former emp) (Entered: 10/27/2000)

10/27/2000 199 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation. IT ISHEREBY ORDERED approving plas' ntc and distribution to classand sub−class members. (cc: all counsel) (former emp) (Entered:10/27/2000)

10/27/2000 200 AMENDED NOTICE of class action (former emp) (Entered:10/27/2000)

10/30/2000 203 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion to extendddl for dfts response and reply to mtn for sum jgm and cross mtnthrough 11/13/00 by plas and dfts [202−1] (cc: all counsel) (DMT)(Entered: 10/30/2000)

10/31/2000 204 SUPPLEMENT TO LIST OF WITNESSES AND DISCLOSUREby plas in 3:95−cv−01313 to [172−1] (LAD) (Entered:11/06/2000)

11/13/2000 206 MOTION to strike affidavit of Michael Wagner by dfts in3:95−cv−01313 [206−1] and alternative motion for relief (pursuantto Rule 56(f) so they may take Wagner's deposition) by dfts in3:95−cv−01313 [206−2] (LAD) (Entered: 11/16/2000)

11/13/2000 207 CONSOLIDATED REPLY by dfts to response to motion forsummary judgment (on all remaining claims in CIV 95−1313 asEugene Hughes is entitled to qualified immunity and on pla's TitleVII claims in CIV 96−1077) by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [184−1](LAD) (Entered: 11/16/2000)

11/13/2000 207 RESPONSE (OPPOSITION) by dfts to cross motion for summaryjudgment (as there was no manifest imbalance and no valid Title

VII Affirmative Action Plan) by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [196−1](LAD) (Entered: 11/16/2000)

11/13/2000 208 MOTION (REQUEST) for oral argument (on dfts' motion forsummary judgment and motion to strike) by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313[208−1] (LAD) (Entered: 11/16/2000)

11/14/2000 205 MINUTE ENTRY: before Judge Robert C. Broomfield: Crt Rptr:Juanita Hyatt − ECR: Thomas Horne for Pla; LisaHudson/Deborah Nastro for Dfts: Status hearing Re trial of 12/5/00held: Dfts oral motion to continue trial GRANTED and trial dateof 12/5/00 VACATED and RESET to 12/12/00 at 9:00am; counselat 8:30am. Counsel advised the court that the liability portionshould take 3 days; if pla prevails a request for a special master toappointed for any damage issue. Counsel advised the court ofstipulation to a magistrate judge to hear the trial. Court will inquireinto the availability of a magistrate judge. Plfs oral motion for a 5minute telephone deposition of Dr. Hughes DENIED. Court willrequire pla to file response to Motion to Strike by 11/27; reply, ifany, by 12/1; response/reply to be hand delivered or faxed. pretrialconference set 11/13/00 VACATED [205−2] (former emp)Modified on 11/15/2000 (Entered: 11/15/2000)

11/20/2000 209 REPLY by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 to response to motion forsummary judgment (as there was no manifest imbalance and novalid Title VII Affirmative Action Plan) by plas in 3:95−cv−01313[196−1] (DMT) (Entered: 11/21/2000)

11/22/2000 210 MOTION to strike affidavit of George Rudebusch by dfts in3:95−cv−01313 [210−1] (LAD) (Entered: 11/27/2000)

11/27/2000 211 RESPONSE by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 to motion to strike affidavitof Michael Wagner by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [206−1] (LAD)(Entered: 11/29/2000)

11/30/2000 212 ERRATA by pla George Rudebusch in 3:95−cv−01313, plaVirginia Vigil in 3:95−cv−01313 to exhibit B of plas' reply insupport of crossmotions for summary judgment [209−1] (formeremp) (Entered: 12/01/2000)

11/30/2000 213 AFFIDAVIT of George Rudebusch &Michael Wagner re reply insupport of crossmotion for summary judgment [207−1] (formeremp) (Entered: 12/01/2000)

12/01/2000 214 RESPONSE by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 to motion to strike affidavitof George Rudebusch by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [210−1] (DMT)(Entered: 12/04/2000)

12/01/2000 215 REPLY by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 to response to motion to strikeaffidavit of George Rudebusch by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [210−1](DMT) (Entered: 12/04/2000)

12/05/2000 216 MOTION in limine that dfts not be permitted to introduce evidenceof alleged efforts to mitigate damages in this liability portion of thetrial by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [216−1] (DMT) (Entered:12/05/2000)

12/05/2000 217 SUPPLEMENTAL memorandum by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 tomotion to strike affidavit of Michael Wagner [206−1] (DMT)(Entered: 12/05/2000)

12/05/2000 218 MINUTE ENTRY: before Judge Robert C. Broomfield: Crt Rptr:R.Huckaby−Cotton − ECR: telephone status hearing Re Prescott,AZ trial date of 12/12/00 held. 3−4 day jury trial for 12/12/00 at9:00am in confirmed. counsel in chambers at 8:30am. Counselstipulate to 8 but not less than 6 jurors to deliberate. [218−1] re:minute entry [218−1] (former emp) (Entered: 12/05/2000)

12/05/2000 219 REPLY by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 to response to motion to strikeaffidavit of George Rudebusch by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [210−1](former emp) (Entered: 12/06/2000)

12/06/2000 220 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield: granting in part anddenying in part motion to strike affidavit of Michael Wagner bydfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [206−1]; denying motion for relief(pursuant to Rule 56(f) so they may take Wagner's deposition) bydfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [206−2]; granting in part and denying inpart motion for summary judgment (on all remaining claims inCIV 95−1313 as Eugene Hughes is entitled to qualified immunityand on pla's Title VII claims in CIV 96−1077) by dfts in3:95−cv−01313 [184−1]; denying motion for summary judgment(as there was no manifest imbalance and no valid Title VIIAffirmative Action Plan) by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [196−1],denying as moot motion to strike affidavit of George Rudebuschby dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [210−1], denying as moot motion fororal argument (on dfts' motion for summary judgment and motionto strike) by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [208−1] (cc: all counsel)(former emp) (Entered: 12/06/2000)

12/08/2000 221 PROPOSED Voir dire submitted by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 (LAD)(Entered: 12/11/2000)

12/08/2000 222 PROPOSED Jury Instructions by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 (LAD)(Entered: 12/11/2000)

12/08/2000 223 REQUESTED Jury Instructions by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 (LAD)(Entered: 12/12/2000)

12/08/2000 224 PROPOSED FINAL PRE−TRIAL ORDER by plas, dfts in3:95−cv−01313 received (LAD) (Entered: 12/12/2000)

12/08/2000 225 MOTION (REQUEST) for attorney−conducted voir dire by plas in3:95−cv−01313 [225−1] (LAD) (Entered: 12/12/2000)

12/08/2000 226 PROPOSED Jury Questionnaire by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 (LAD)(Entered: 12/12/2000)

12/08/2000 227 MEMORANDUM RE VOIR DIRE by plas in 3:95−cv−01313(LAD) (Entered: 12/12/2000)

12/08/2000 228 PROPOSED Voir dire questions submitted by plas in3:95−cv−01313 (LAD) (Entered: 12/12/2000)

12/11/2000 229 RESPONSE (OPPOSITION) by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 to motionin limine that dfts not be permitted to introduce evidence of allegedefforts to mitigate damages in this liability portion of trial by plasin 3:95−cv−01313 [216−1] (LAD) (Entered: 12/12/2000)

12/11/2000 230 SUPPLEMENT by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 to proposed juryinstructions [222−1] (LAD) (Entered: 12/12/2000)

12/11/2000 231 MEMORANDUM re jury instruction on qualified immunity byplas in 3:95−cv−01313 (LAD) (Entered: 12/12/2000)

12/12/2000 232 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting in part anddenying in part the motion in limine that dfts not be permitted tointroduce evidence of alleged efforts to mitigate damages in thisliability portion of the trial by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 [216−1]consistent with this order (cc: all counsel) (LAD) (Entered:12/12/2000)

12/12/2000 233 MINUTE ENTRY: before Judge Robert C. Broomfield: Crt Rptr:R.Huckaby−Cotton − ECR: Thomas Horne/Jess Lorona for Plas;Dr. George Rudebusch, Pla, present: Lisa Hudson/Deborah Nastrofor Dfts; Dean Pickett representative for Arizona Board ofRegents; Eugene Hughes, Dft, present: Tuesday, December 12,2000 − day 1 jury trial: 8:30am − In chambers conference with

counsel. 9:30am − Court in session, counsel/parties present; 27prospective jurors present and sworn. "Witness Rule" invoked atsidebar. Court excuses: Karen Clancy, Kenneth Birchett, LindaLaulo and Verla Quintero. 12:35pm − A panel of 8 jurors sworn,admonished. 12:46pm − Court in noon recess until 1:45pm.1:50pm − Court resumes with court's opening instructions to thejury. 2:08pm − Plaintiffs' opening statement. 2:42pm − Defendants'opening statement. 3:35pm − Plas case: Karen Schairer sworn,examined; x−exam; re−direct and excused. 3:59pm − Dr. MichaelR. Wagner sworn, examined. 4:40pm − Court in recess until9:00am, Wednesday, December 13, 2000 for continued direct ofDr. Wagner. [233−2] (former emp) Modified on 12/13/2000(Entered: 12/13/2000)

12/12/2000 236 MEMORANDUM of law re qualified immunity by dfts in3:95−cv−01313 (LAD) (Entered: 12/15/2000)

12/13/2000 234 MINUTE ENTRY: before Judge Robert C. Broomfield: Crt Rptr:R.Huckaby−Cotton − ECR: Counsel/parties present: Wednesday,December 13, 2000 − day 2 jury trial: 8:55am − Court in session,jury not present. Dft objections to portions of Dr. Wagner'stestimony and charts to be used. Argument held: Court will allowthe use of Senate Committee with clarification; charts can be usedwith clarification; the single chart will be ruled on as needed.Exhibits 35 and 25 argued. Ex 35 will be redacted from page 17. Aclean copy of Ex 25 will be present to the court and marked as25A. 9:23am − Jury present. Plas case continues with direct of Dr.Wagner. Ex 25A adm'd; Ex 35 adm'd; x−exam. 12:30pm − Courtin noon recess until 1:30pm. 1:30pm − Court resumes withcontinued x−exam of Dr. Wagner; Ex 35B adm'd; re−direct andexcused. 3:23pm − Dr. Eugene M. Hughes sworn, examined;x−exam, Ex 11 adm'd. 4:28pm − Jury in recess until 9:00am,Thursday, December 14, 2000 for continued x−exam of Dr.Wagner, counsel at 8:30pm. [234−1] re: minute entry [234−1](former emp) (Entered: 12/13/2000)

12/14/2000 235 MINUTE ENTRY: before Judge Robert C. Broomfield: Crt Rptr:R.Huckaby−Cotton − ECR: Counsel/parties present: Thursday,December 13, 2000 − day 3 jury trial: 8:33am−8:53am − Court insession without jury with argument Re manifest imbalance heldand court restricts to the salary content. 9:04am − 9:06am − Jurypresent and Juror Hahn has a personal problem. 9:27am − Jury notpresent. Mr. Roger Hahn is excused as a juror. 9:30am − Jurypresent and Dr. Wagner continues on x−exam. Exs 17ABmarkedand Ex 17A adm'd; re−direct and excused. 11:01am − Jury notpresent. Pla advises the court that they will rest. Dft's oral Rule 50Motion, Judgment as a matter of Law, argued and DENIED asplaced on the record. 11:40am − Jury present. Pla rests. Dfts case:Dr. Stephen Leroy Chambers sworn, examined; Ex 37 adm'd.12:30pm − Court in noon recess until 1:30pm. 1:37pm − Courtresumes with direct of Dr. Chambers: Ex 46 adm'd; x−exam;re−direct and excused. 5:05pm − Jury in recess utnil 8:30am,Friday, 12/15/00. Court/counsel go over jury instructions/verdictform. 5:15pm − Court in recess until 8:00am for counsel. [235−1]re: minute entry [235−1] (former emp) Modified on 12/15/2000(Entered: 12/15/2000)

12/14/2000 239 OBJECTIONS by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 to requested juryinstructions [223−1] (LAD) (Entered: 12/20/2000)

12/15/2000 237 MINUTE ENTRY: before Judge Robert C. Broomfield: Crt Rptr:R.Huckaby−Cotton − ECR: Counsel/parties present. − Friday,December 15, 2000 − day 4 jury trial: 8:01am − Court resumeswithout jury and a juror question discussed. Court/counsel go overjury instructions with any objections placed on the record. 8:40am− Jury present. Dfts case continues. Normando De Halle sworn,

examined; Ex 49 adm'd; x−exam; re−direct and excused. 9:58am −Dr. Eugene Hughes recalled; x−exam, Ex 4 adm'd; re−direct andexcused. 10:44am − Dfts rests. 10:46am − No rebuttal by pla.10:46am − Jury at noon recess until 12:45pm. 10:55am − Pla andDft oral motion(s) and any renewed oral motion for Judgment as aMatter of Law argued and DENIED as placed on the record.11:19am − Jury instructions continues. 12:15pm − Court in noonrecess until 12:45. 12:47pm − Court resumes. Pla closing. 1:51pm− Dfts closing. 3:30pm − Pla rebuttal. 3:50pm − Court instructsjury. 4:10pm − Bailiff sworn. 4:15pm − Jury retires to deliberate.4:20pm − Court in recess. 4:50pm − Court in session, jury present.Jury to return Monday, 12/18/00 at 8:00am to continuedeliberations. 5:10pm − Court in recess. [237−1] re: minute entry[237−1] (former emp) (Entered: 12/18/2000)

12/15/2000 240 Court's Given Jury Instructions (LAD) (Entered: 12/20/2000)

12/18/2000 241 MINUTE ENTRY: before Judge Robert C. Broomfield: Crt Rptr:R.Huckaby−Cotton − ECR: Monday, December 18, 2000 − day 5jury trial: 8:00am − Jury continues to deliberate 11:34am−11:42am− Counsel by telephone, jury note #1 addressed 4:05pm − Court insession, Mr. Horne, for Pla, by telephone: Dfts counsel incourtroom: Jury present: the jury has reached its verdict. We, thejury, duly empaneled determine liability As to the Plaintiffs' equalprotection race claim: FOR DEFENDANT; As to the Plaintiffs'equal protection gender claim: FOR DEFENDANT; and, As to thePlaintiffs' Title VII civil rights claim: FOR DEFENDANT. Jurynot polled. Jury thanked and released from their admonition andexcused. 4:10pm − Court adjourned. The clerk is directed to enterJudgment for Defendants. [cc: dktng] [241−3] (former emp)Modified on 12/20/2000 (Entered: 12/20/2000)

12/18/2000 242 Jury Notes (LAD) (Entered: 12/22/2000)

12/18/2000 243 Jury List by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 (LAD) (Entered: 12/22/2000)

12/18/2000 244 ORDER re Return of Exhibits by Judge Robert C. Broomfield (cc:all counsel) re: order [244−1] (LAD) (Entered: 12/22/2000)

12/18/2000 245 EXHIBIT LIST submitted by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 (LAD)(Entered: 12/22/2000)


12/18/2000 247 Jury Verdict finding: for dfts as to plas' equal protection raceclaim; for dfts as to pla's equal protection gender claim; for dfts asto plas' Title VII civil rights claim (LAD) (Entered: 12/22/2000)

12/20/2000 238 OBJECTIONS by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 to requested juryinstructions [222−1] (LAD) (Entered: 12/20/2000)

12/29/2000 248 JUDGMENT: re: minute entry [241−3] to dismiss case ;ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that judgment is entered againstthe plas and in favor of dfts and the complaint and this action arehereby dismissed (cc: all counsel/jgm drawer) (LAD) (Entered:12/29/2000)

01/11/2001 249 BILL OF COSTS submitted by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 Hearing setfor: none set (LAD) (Entered: 01/16/2001)

01/24/2001 250 NOTICE OF APPEAL by all plas from District Court judgment[248−2], verdict [247−1], and minute entry [241−3] (cc: 9CCA/AllCounsel/RCB) (REW) Modified on 01/29/2001 (Entered:01/29/2001)


02/09/2001 251 Transcript Designation and Ordering Form by all plas; orderingtranscripts for hearings of 12/12/00 − 12/18/00 (REW) (Entered:02/16/2001)

02/27/2001 Notification by 9CCA of Appellate Docket Number 01−15287 (pertime schedule order) (REW) (Entered: 02/27/2001)

04/11/2001 252 Court Reporter's Transcript of Proceedings for the followingdate(s): 12/12/00; re: jury trial − day 1; CtRptr: RoseHuckaby−Cotton (REW) (Entered: 04/14/2001)





04/13/2001 Certificate of Record Transmitted to 9CCA [250−1] (REW)(Entered: 04/14/2001)

04/17/2001 Amended Certificate of Record Transmitted to 9CCA [250−1](REW) (Entered: 04/27/2001)

08/06/2001 257 Transcript Designation and Ordering Form by all appellees/dfts;ordering transcripts for hearings of 12/12/00, 12/13/00, 12/14/00,12/15/00 and 12/18/00 (REW) (Entered: 08/13/2001)

02/01/2002 Clerk's record on appeal transmitted to 9th Circuit re [250−1]; 5volumes clerk's record; 6 transcripts (#154, 252, 253, 254, 255,256); 4 bulkie documents (#24, 82, 84, 91) in three expandos(REW) (Entered: 02/01/2002)

02/20/2002 LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL from 9th Circuit acknowledgingreceipt of District Court record. (re: [250−1] ) (REW) (Entered:02/20/2002)

03/26/2002 258 TAXATION OF COSTS for dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 in the amountof $ 2,185.72 against plas in 3:95−cv−01313 (cc: all counsel)(LAD) (Entered: 03/26/2002)

02/18/2003 259 CERTIFIED COPY of 9th Circuit Mandate affirming in part,reversing in part and remanding the decision of the District Court;we affirm the finding of qualified immunity for the universitypresident (Hughes); as for the Title VII claim, we cannot agree thatsummary judgment was appropriate for all aspects of this claimbecause a material dispute of fact prevents us from determinaingwhether the adjustments did more than attain a balance; wetherefore remand for further consideration; finally, with respect tothe Franco letter, we conclude that any error was harmless; eachparty to bear its own costs on appeal, re: 01−15287 [Appeal[250−1] ] Case reopened [259−1] [259−1] (cc: all counsel/judge)(REW) (Entered: 02/18/2003)

02/18/2003 Request sent for USDC file to be returned from 9th Circuit (REW)(Entered: 02/18/2003)

03/12/2003 Original Record Returned from 9th Circuit re [250−1]; 5 volumesclerk's record; 6 transcripts (#154, 252, 253, 254, 255, 256); 4bulkie documents (#24, 82, 84, 91) in three expandos (REW)

(Entered: 03/12/2003)

03/12/2003 260 MINUTE ORDER: IT IS ORDERED setting a status hearing onMonday, March 31, 2003 at 3:00 p.m., before the HonorableRobert C. Broomfield, Courtroom 606, 6th floor. (cc: allcounsel/RCB/CD) [260−2] (LCF) (Entered: 03/12/2003)

03/31/2003 261 MINUTE ENTRY before Judge Robert C. Broomfield . Crt Rptr:Vicki Reger. Present: Jess Lorano for Plas. Dean Picket and LisaHudson for Dfts. Status hearing held. No mandate has beenreceived from the Ninth Circuit, so another status hearing has beenset for Monday, July 14, 2003 at 2:00 p.m., before the HonorableRobert C. Broomfield, Courtroom 606, 6th floor. [cc: RCB/CD][261−3] (LCF) (Entered: 03/31/2003)

07/14/2003 262 MINUTE ENTRY before Judge Robert C. Broomfield . Crt Rptr:Vicki Reger. Appearances: Jess Lorona for plas; Lisa Hudson fordft. Status hearing held. IT IS ORDERED that plas shall submit ademand letter, through counsel, to counsel for dft by 8/15/03; dft torespond by 9/15/03. IT IS ORDERED setting status hearing for10/20/03 at 2:15 p.m. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED setting Pretrialconference for 12/15/03 at 2:45 p.m. IT IS FURTHER ORDEREDsetting jury trial for 1/6/04 at 9:00 a.m., 8:30 for counsel. Pretrialorder to be filed by 11/28/03; voir dire questions and proposedinstructions may be submitted by 1/2/04. [cc: RCB] [262−2](LMR) (Entered: 07/16/2003)

10/20/2003 263 MINUTE ENTRY before Judge Robert C. Broomfield. ECR:Vicki Reger. Appearances: Jess Lorona for the plaintiffs and LisaKay Hudson for the defendants. Status Hearing held. The Courtaffirms the dates currently set for Pretrial Conference and JuryTrial as follows: Pretrial Conference is set on Monday, December15, 2003 at 2:45 p.m. in Phoenix, Arizona. Jury Trial (estimated 4days) is set on Tuesday, January 6, 2004 at 9:00 a.m. in Prescott,Arizona. Counsel to be present at 8:30 a.m. [cc: RCB, all counsel][0−2] (KSB) (Entered: 10/20/2003)

12/09/2003 264 NOTICE by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 of change of address: Jess ALorona, Esq, Ducar Lorona &Parks PC, 411 N Central, Ste 520,Phoenix, AZ 85004 (address already updated in system) (LAD)(Entered: 12/12/2003)

12/09/2003 265 NOTICE by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 to Court re potential conflict(as to 12/15/03 pretrial conference) (LAD) (Entered: 12/12/2003)

12/17/2003 266 MINUTE ORDER: The Court Orders that the Pretrial Conferenceset on December 15, 2003 be moved to Friday, December 19, 2003at 1:00 p.m. before the Honorable Robert C. Broomfield. (cc:RCB, all counsel) [266−2] (KSB) (Entered: 12/17/2003)

12/19/2003 267 MINUTE ENTRY before Judge Robert C. Broomfield. ECR:Vicki Reger. Appearances: Jess Lorona (telephonically) for theplaintiff. Lisa Hudson for the defendants. Status Hearing/PretrialConference held. Upon stipulation of counsel, trial will be to theCourt rather than to jury. IT IS ORDERED AFFIRMING thematter currently set for Trial on Tuesday, January 6, 2004, beforethe Honorable Robert C. Broomfield in Phoenix, Arizona.Estimated trial length: 2 days. [cc: RCB] [0−2] (KSB) (Entered:12/19/2003)

12/22/2003 268 PRETRIAL ORDER approved by Judge Robert C. Broomfield(LAD) (Entered: 12/22/2003)

01/06/2004 269 MINUTE ENTRY before Judge Robert C. Broomfield. ECR:Vicki Reger. Bench Trial − Day 1. 9:02 a.m. Court convenes.Appearances: Plaintiffs, George Rudebusch, Edward Hood, andTim Porter are present with counsel, Jess Lorona and Greg

McClure. Defendants are represented by Lisa Hudson, CelinaNormandin, and Dean Pickett. With respect to the exhibits, counselstipulate to using the numbering system used in the first trial.Counsel make opening statements to the Court. Plaintiff's case: Mr.Lorona provides the Court with record references. Mr. Loronamoves for the admission of exhibits 100C, 100D, 100E, 100F,100G, and 100I, which Motion is DENIED on objection of Ms.Hudson. On oral motion of Mr. Lorona, there being no objection,Exhibit 17A is admitted into evidence. On oral motion of Mr.Lorona, there being no objection, Exhibit 35A is admitted intoevidence. Ms. Hudson stipulates that any exhibits admitted at thetime of the original trial may be admitted into evidence for thepurposes of this trial. On oral motion of Mr. Lorona, there being noobjection, Exhibits 11, 25A, 37, and 46 are admitted into evidence.Ms. Hudson advises the Court that Exhibit 37 was admitted at theoriginal trial; however, the original exhibit tag tore and defensecounsel replaced same. Counsel stipulate that the jury trialtranscript may be received into evidence in its entirety andconsidered by the Court for the purposes of this trial. Mr. Loronamoves for the admission of Exhibits 62 and 62A, which Motion isDENIED on objection of Ms. Hudson. The Court GRANTScounsel leave to discuss the information contained in exhibits 62and 62A, and to the extent it is in the record, counsel may utilize itand include it in their findings of fact and conclusions of law.10:35 a.m. Court stands at recess. 10:55 a.m. Court reconvenes,same counsel and parties present. The Court notes that Jess Loronais attorney of record for plaintiffs and has been on the casethroughout. The Court DIRECTS the Clerk to substitute JessLorona, Esq., as counsel of record for plaintiffs in place of ThomasHorne, Esq. Defendant's case: Joshua Allen is sworn andexamined. On oral motion of Ms. Hudson, over the objection ofMr. Lorona, Exhibit 54 is admitted into evidence. 12:00 p.m. Courtstands at recess. 1:35 p.m. Court reconvenes, same counsel andparties present. Discussion held regarding exhibits. The Courtnotes that counsel have stipulated that all the testimony andexhibits offered and admitted at the original trial may be offeredand received at this trial. Pursuant to the stipulation of counsel,Exhibits 11, 17A, 25A, 35A, 35B, 37, 46, and 49 are admitted intoevidence. Joshua Allen is cross−examined and excused. Ms.Hudson advises the Court that she will provide record references inher proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law. Both sidesrest. The Court DIRECTS counsel to submit their proposedfindings of fact and conclusions of law within 30 days of today'sdate. [cc: RCB] [269−3] (KSB) (Entered: 01/06/2004)


01/06/2004 271 EXHIBIT LIST submitted by plas in 3:95−cv−01313 (LAD)(Entered: 01/13/2004)

01/06/2004 272 EXHIBIT LIST submitted by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 (LAD)(Entered: 01/13/2004)

01/27/2004 273 MINUTE ORDER: re exhibits: ORDERED that the exhibitsmarked and/or admitted for bench trial on 1/6/04 in the aboveentitled case are to be returned to counsel/agents of record; counselis directed to retain custody of the exhibits until the case has beencompletely terminated, including all appeals; counsel is furtherdirected to make the exhibits available for review by opposingcounsel/pla as necessary for appeal (cc: all counsel) [0−1] (exhibitsreturned to respective counsel/representative by CD on 1/27/04) re:order (minute) [0−1] (LAD) (Entered: 01/27/2004)

02/05/2004 274 STIPULATION to extend time for filing the statement of facts andconclusion of law (until 2/6/04) by plas in 3:95−cv−01313, dfts in3:95−cv−01313 (no proposed document) (LAD) (Entered:02/10/2004)

02/06/2004 275 PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT and conclusions of law by plas(LAD) (Entered: 02/10/2004)

02/12/2004 276 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation toextend time for filing the statement of facts and conclusion of law(until 2/6/04) by plas in 3:95−cv−01313, dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 in3:95−cv−01313 (cc: all counsel) (received 2/12/04) (LAD)(Entered: 02/12/2004)

06/30/2004 277 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield hearing to establishnecessary discovery deadlines and trial date on damages set for2:00 7/26/04 in 3:95−cv−01313, in 3:96−cv−01077 (cc: allcounsel) (LAD) (Entered: 06/30/2004)

07/15/2004 278 MOTION to continue hearing set for 7/26/04 by dfts in3:95−cv−01313 [278−1] (LAD) (Entered: 07/15/2004)

07/26/2004 279 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield in court hearing reset for2:30 8/9/04 in 3:95−cv−01313, in 3:96−cv−01077 (cc: all counsel)(LAD) (Entered: 07/26/2004)

08/09/2004 280 MINUTE ENTRY before Judge Robert C. Broomfield. ECR:Vicki Reger. Appearances: Jess Lorona for the plaintiffs. LisaHudson for the defendants. Discussion held. At counsel's request,IT IS ORDERED setting this matter for another Status on Monday,September 13, 2004 at 2:15 p.m. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED thatcounsel for both parties shall prepare a proposed schedule fordiscovery related to damages, a pretrial order, a deadline forproposed pretrial order, as well as a trial date. [cc: RCB, counsel][280−3] (KSB) Modified on 08/10/2004 (Entered: 08/10/2004)

09/13/2004 281 MINUTE ENTRY before Judge Robert C. Broomfield. Crt Rptr:Vicki Reger. Appearances: Jess Lorona for plas, Lisa Hudson fordfts Status hearing held. Parties stipulate to proposed schedulingdates. Court orders parties to submit proposed order. [cc: RCB][281−2] (TCA) (Entered: 09/16/2004)

09/13/2004 282 JOINT CASE MGT PLAN/REPORT: joint pretrial order ddl8/1/05; discovery cutoff 5/13/05; dispositive motions filing ddl7/1/05 (LAD) (Entered: 09/17/2004)

09/13/2004 282 MOTION (REQUEST) for scheduling order by plas in3:95−cv−01313, dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [282−1] (received9/16/04) (LAD) (Entered: 09/17/2004)

10/29/2004 283 NOTICE of service of initial disclosure statement pursuant toFRCivP 26(a) by dft Eugene Hughes , dft Margaret Hughes (KCS)(Entered: 11/01/2004)

11/15/2004 284 NOTICE of service of initial disclosure statement pursuant toFRCivP 26(a) by pla George Rudebusch in 3:95−cv−01313 (KCS)(Entered: 11/17/2004)

01/06/2005 285 NOTICE of service of discovery by plas in 3:95−cv−01313. (LAD)(Entered: 01/07/2005)

01/24/2005 286 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield ; discovery ddl set for5/12/05 in 3:95−cv−01313, in 3:96−cv−01077 ; dispositivemotions due 7/1/05 in 3:95−cv−01313, in 3:96−cv−01077 ; PTOddl set for 8/1/05 in 3:95−cv−01313, in 3:96−cv−01077 ; Pretrialconference set for 1:30 9/12/05 in 3:95−cv−01313, in3:96−cv−01077 (cc: all counsel) (SRB) (Entered: 01/24/2005)

01/28/2005 287 NOTICE of compliance of initial disclosure statement pursuant toFRCivP 26(a) by pla George Rudebusch in 3:95−cv−01313 (SRB)(Entered: 01/31/2005)

02/08/2005 288 NOTICE of service of discovery by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313. (SRB)(Entered: 02/09/2005)

03/10/2005 289 MOTION to extend time to continue deadline for expert disclosureby dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [289−1] (SRB) (Entered: 03/11/2005)

03/10/2005 290 NOTICE of compliance of initial disclosure statement pursuant toFRCivP 26(a) by pla George Rudebusch in 3:95−cv−01313 (SRB)(Entered: 03/11/2005)

04/12/2005 291 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion to extendtime to continue deadline for expert disclosure by dfts in3:95−cv−01313 [289−1] in 3:95−cv−01313 (cc: all counsel) (SRB)(Entered: 04/12/2005)

04/12/2005 292 NOTICE of service of discovery by dfts in 3:95−cv−01313. (LAD)(Entered: 04/13/2005)

04/26/2005 293 STIPULATED MOTION to continue deadlines for 90 days(discovery to 8/10/05; dispositive motions to 9/29/05 and jointpretrial order to 10/31/05) by plas in 3:95−cv−01313, dfts in3:95−cv−01313 [293−1] (LAD) (Entered: 04/27/2005)

05/03/2005 294 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting motion tocontinue deadlines for 90 days (discovery to 8/10/05; dispositivemotions to 9/29/05 and joint pretrial order to 10/31/05) by plas in3:95−cv−01313, dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 [293−1] in3:95−cv−01313 ; discovery ddl set for 8/10/05 in 3:95−cv−01313,in 3:96−cv−01077 ; dispositive motions due 9/29/05 in3:95−cv−01313, in 3:96−cv−01077 ; PTO ddl set for 10/31/05 in3:95−cv−01313, in 3:96−cv−01077 (cc: all counsel) (SRB)(Entered: 05/03/2005)

05/12/2005 295 NOTICE of service of discovery by pla in 3:95−cv−01313. (DMT)(Entered: 05/13/2005)

05/20/2005 296 STIPULATED MOTION to extend time until July 8, 2005 for dftsexpert disclosure (second request) by plas in 3:95−cv−01313, dftsin 3:95−cv−01313 (CMM) (Entered: 05/23/2005)

05/25/2005 297 ORDER by Judge Robert C. Broomfield granting stipulation toextend time until July 8, 2005 for dfts expert disclosure (secondrequest) by plas in 3:95−cv−01313, dfts in 3:95−cv−01313 in3:95−cv−01313 (cc: all counsel) (CMM) (Entered: 05/25/2005)

07/08/2005 298 Notice of service of defendants' expert witness disclosure byEugene Hughes, Margaret Hughes (RDS) (Entered: 07/09/2005)

07/11/2005 299 Notice re service of Dfts' supplemental disclosure statement byEugene Hughes, Margaret Hughes (LSP, ) (Entered: 07/12/2005)

08/10/2005 300 Second MOTION to Continue Discovery by Arizona, State of,Northern Arizona University, Arizona Regents, Board of. (Hudson,Lisa) (Entered: 08/10/2005)

08/31/2005 301 ORDER granting Motion To Extend Time For Discovery 300 .Deadline for discovery is re−set to 8/31/2005. Signed by JudgeRobert C Broomfield on 8/29/05. (RCB) (This is a TEXT ENTRYONLY. There is no.pdf document associated with this entry.)(Entered: 08/31/2005)

09/01/2005 302 Minute Order. Due to a conflict on the Court's calendar, IT ISORDERED re−setting the Pretrial Conference in this matter for10/17/2005 at 2:15 PM in Courtroom 606, 401 West WashingtonStreet, Phoenix, AZ 85003 before Judge Robert C Broomfield.

https://ecf.azd.uscourts.gov/doc1/02501425158?pdf_toggle_possible=1&de_seq_num=6924316&caseid=116333


This is a text−only entry, no.pdf document is attached. (KAR, )(Entered: 09/01/2005)

09/01/2005 Copy of document number 302, mailed to Thomas Horne on thisdate. (KAR, ) (Entered: 09/01/2005)

10/17/2005 303 Minute Entry (text only entry) for proceedings held before JudgeRobert C Broomfield : Appearances: Jess Lorona for plas, LisaHudson telephonic for dfts Conference held on 10/17/2005. Courtwill reset this matter for a pretrial conference, if necessary, afterthe ruling on the pending dispositive motion. (Court ReporterVicki Reger.) (TCA, ) (Entered: 10/18/2005)

10/31/2005 304 STIPULATION TO EXTEND TIME TO FILE PLAINTIFFS'RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARYJUDGMENT AND PLAINTIFFS' CROSS MOTION FORSUMMARY JUDGMENT by George Rudebusch. (McClure,Gregory) (Entered: 10/31/2005)

11/02/2005 305 Cross MOTION for Summary Judgment and Reponse toDefendants' Motion for Summary Judgment by George Rudebusch.(Lorona, Jess) (Entered: 11/02/2005)

11/02/2005 306 STATEMENT of Statement of Facts In Support of Plaintiffs'Response to Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment andPlaintiffs' Cross Motion for Summary Judgment re 305 CrossMOTION for Summary Judgment and Reponse to Defendants'Motion for Summary Judgment by Plaintiff George Rudebusch.(Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A# 2 Exhibit B part 1# 3 Exhibit B Part2# 4 Exhibit C# 5 Exhibit D Part 1# 6 Exhibit D Part 2# 7 ExhibitE# 8 Exhibit F# 9 Exhibit G# 10 Exhibit H# 11 Exhibit I Part 1#12 Exhibit I Part 2# 13 Exhibit I Part 3# 14 Exhibit J# 15 ExhibitK# 16 Exhibit L Part 1# 17 Exhibit L Part 2# 18 Exhibit L Part 3#19 Exhibit L Part 4# 20 Exhibit L Part 5# 21 Exhibit M# 22Exhibit N# 23 Exhibit O# 24 Exhibit P)(Lorona, Jess) (Entered:11/02/2005)

11/09/2005 307 ORDERED granting 304 STIPULATION TO EXTEND TIME TOFILE PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS' MOTIONFOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND PLAINTIFFS' CROSSMOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT. Signed by JudgeRobert C Broomfield on 11/2/05.(RCB)(.pdf document attached)(Entered: 11/09/2005)

11/23/2005 308 ORDER granting the stipulated motion. Defendants may submittheir Reply to Plaintiffs' Response to Defendants' Motion forSummary Judgment with their response to Plaintiffs' Cross Motionfor Summary Judgment.. Signed by Judge Robert C Broomfield on11/21/05. (TLJ, ) (Entered: 11/23/2005)

12/02/2005 309 ORDER that Defendants are granted an extension of time from12/2/05 to 12/23/05, in which to Reply to Plaintiff's Response toDefendant's Motion for Summary Judgment and to Respond toPlaintiffs' Cross Motion for Summary Judgment.. Signed by JudgeRobert C Broomfield on 11/30/05. (LCF) (Entered: 12/02/2005)

01/04/2006 310 TRANSCRIPT DESIGNATION AND ORDER FORM by GeorgeRudebusch, George Rudebusch for proceedings held on10/17/2005 before Judge Robert C Broomfield. (BAS, ) (Entered:01/05/2006)

01/06/2006 311 STIPULATION TO EXTEND TIME FOR FILING PLAINTIFFS'REPLY TO DEFENDANTS' RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS'CROSS−MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT by GeorgeRudebusch. (Lorona, Jess) (Entered: 01/06/2006)



































01/11/2006 312 Notice re Change of Firm of Counsel for Plaintiff by GeorgeRudebusch (Lorona, Jess) (Entered: 01/11/2006)

01/12/2006 313 ORDER granting 311 STIPULATION TO EXTEND TIME FORFILING PLAINTIFFS' REPLY TO DEFENDANTS'MOTIONFOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT and RESPONSE TOPLAINTIFFS' CROSS−MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENTby George Rudebusch. (Lorona, Jess). Time for filing is extendedto 01/23/06 . Signed by Judge Robert C Broomfield on 01/10/06.(DNH, ) (Entered: 01/12/2006)

01/23/2006 315 REPLY to Response to Motion re 305 Cross MOTION forSummary Judgment and Reponse to Defendants' Motion forSummary Judgment filed by George Rudebusch. (Lorona, Jess)(Entered: 01/23/2006)

06/09/2006 316 ORDER that dfts' Motion for Summary Judgment (doc.16 in casenumber CV 96−1077−PCT−RCB) is Denied. FURTHERORDERED that plas' Cross−Motion Summary Judgment (doc. 305in case number CV 95−1313−PCT−RCB) is Granted in part andDenied in part. FURTHER ORDERED that, absent either sideproviding within twenty days of the date of this order competentevidence that would establish actual percentage increases foradministrative positions, the judgment for plas will include a 22%increase for each pla who occupied an administrative position.FINALLY ORDERED that, absent a contention by either partythat they have competent evidence to establish the purpose of the1995 adjustments and provides such evidence within twenty daysof the date of this order, the Court shall presume that the"understandings" in both Toutkoushian's and Thomas' reportscannot be established, and, consequently, the 1995 adjustmentscannot and will not be taken into account in determining plas'damages. Signed by Judge Robert C Broomfield on 6/7/06. (KMG,) (Entered: 06/09/2006)

06/23/2006 317 Minute Entry (text only entry) for proceedings held before JudgeRobert C Broomfield : Apr. Jess Lorona for plas, Lisa Hudson fordfts Telephone Conference held on 6/23/2006 re: Motion to extendtime to submit additional evidence. The motion is granted. (CourtReporter Gary Moll.) (TCA, ) (Entered: 06/23/2006)

06/27/2006 318 MEMORANDUM re: Plaintiffs' Evidence to Court RegardingPurpose of 1995 Adjustment by Plaintiff George Rudebusch.(Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Exhibits A, B, and C)(Lorona, Jess)(Entered: 06/27/2006)

06/27/2006 319 MEMORANDUM re: Plaintiffs' Evidence to Court RegardingPercentage Increases for Administrative Positions by PlaintiffGeorge Rudebusch. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Exhibit A)(Lorona,Jess) (Entered: 06/27/2006)

07/26/2006 320 OBJECTION Plaintiff's Objection and Response to Defendants'Submission of Evidence Re: 1995 Salary Adjustments by PlaintiffsGeorge Rudebusch, George Rudebusch filed by GeorgeRudebusch, George Rudebusch. (Lorona, Jess) (Entered:07/26/2006)

08/14/2006 321 ORDER re 316 ORDER that dfts' Motion for Summary Judgment.Directing counsel for Plaintiff's to submit a proposed judgment,based on the Court's order dated 6/7/06 and this order, thirty (30)days from the date of this order. Defendants must file anyobjection thay have to such proposed judgment ten (10) days fromthe date of its filing. . Signed by Judge Robert C Broomfield on8/14/06. (LCF) (Entered: 08/14/2006)

09/08/2006 322 STATEMENT of Defendants' Submision of Evidence Re: 1995Salary Adjustments and Administrative Appointments Replacing















Doc #24 by Defendants Arizona, State of, Northern ArizonaUniversity, Arizona Regents, Board of. (Attachments: # 1Affidavit # 2 Exhibit 1# 3 Exhibit 2# 4 Affidavit # 5 Exhibit # 6Affidavit)(Hudson, Lisa) (Entered: 09/08/2006)

09/13/2006 323 SUPPLEMENT of Plaintiffs' Submission of Updated FinancialDamages by Plaintiff George Rudebusch. (Attachments: # 1Exhibit Dr. Robert K. Toutkoushian Report)(Lorona, Jess)(Entered: 09/13/2006)

09/13/2006 324 DOCUMENT 324 WITHDRAWN PURSUANT TO ORDER 329FILED ON 10/19/06. LODGED Proposed Judgment submitted onSeptember 13, 2006. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion toLeave to File or Amend is granted. filed by George Rudebusch(Lorona, Jess) Modified on 10/19/2006 (DNH, ). (Entered:09/13/2006)

09/26/2006 325 MOTION to Withdraw Judgement Filed on September 13, 2006 byGeorge Rudebusch. (Lorona, Jess) (Entered: 09/26/2006)

09/26/2006 326 STIPULATION To Extend Time For Filing Judgment andObjections by George Rudebusch. (Lorona, Jess) (Entered:09/26/2006)

09/27/2006 327 First MOTION for Leave to File Motion for Attorneys' Fees byGeorge Rudebusch. (Lorona, Jess) (Entered: 09/27/2006)

10/18/2006 328 ORDER granting 326 STIPULATION To Extend Time For FilingJudgment and Objections. Plaintiffs' proposed form of Judgmentshall be filed on October 31, 2006 and Defendants shall file anyobjection to the form of Judgment on November 10, 2006. Signedby Judge Robert C Broomfield on 10/13/06.(RCB)(.pdf documentattached) (Entered: 10/18/2006)

10/19/2006 329 ORDER granting 325 Plaintiffs' Motion to Withdraw 324 LodgedProposed Judgment filed on 09/13/06 . Signed by Judge Robert CBroomfield on 10/13/06. (DNH) (Entered: 10/19/2006)

10/31/2006 330 STIPULATION TO EXTEND TIME FOR FILING STIPULATEDJUDGMENT (Second Request) by George Rudebusch. (Lorona,Jess) (Entered: 10/31/2006)

11/13/2006 331 ORDERED granting 330 STIPULATION TO EXTEND TIMEFOR FILING STIPULATED JUDGMENT (Second Request).Plaintiffs shall file their proposed form of Judgment by November14, 2006. Signed by Judge Robert C Broomfield on 11/2/06.(RCB)(.pdf document is attached) (Entered: 11/13/2006)

11/14/2006 332 STIPULATION Motion to Extend Time for Submission of Form ofJudgment by George Rudebusch, Theresa Chapas, Adrian Riskin,Andrew Odell, Arnold Johnson, Burton Brown, Charles T Way,Craig Caldwell, David Kitterman, Edward Hood, EugeneLoverich, Gary Bateman, George Rudebusch, Gilbert C Pogany,Guenther Huck, Harvey Becher, Howard Salisbury, James EdwardBartell, James D Simmerman, James Windes, Jay Farness, JohnBloom, John Hill, Keith Cunningham, Loren Reser, Michael AFalk, Michael Malone, Michael Sanera, Michael Tanner, MichaelWunsch, Randy Dillingham, Richard Packard, Robert Zoellner,Stephen Jackson, Stephen D Lapan, Steve Funk, Thomas Hoisch,Timothy L Porter, Wade Harrison, Wayne Sjoberg, WilliamHildred, Ken Nicolls, Eugene Hughes, Margaret Hughes.(Attachments: # 1 Text of Proposed Order Extend Time for FilingStipulation Judgment)(Hudson, Lisa) (Entered: 11/14/2006)

11/17/2006 333 ORDERED granting 332 STIPULATION to Extend Time forSubmission of Form of Judgment. The time for filing Plaintiffs'proposed form of judgment, or a stipulated form of judgment, is



























extended until 12/14/06. Defendants' proposed form of judgment,if any, shall be filed within 10 days thereafter. Signed by JudgeRobert C Broomfield on 11/16/06. (RCB)(.pdf document isattached) (Entered: 11/17/2006)

12/14/2006 334 Notice re Lodging by George Rudebusch, Theresa Chapas, AdrianRiskin, Andrew Odell, Arnold Johnson, Burton Brown, Charles TWay, Craig Caldwell, David Kitterman, Edward Hood, EugeneLoverich, Gary Bateman, Gilbert C Pogany, Guenther Huck,Harvey Becher, Howard Salisbury, James Edward Bartell, James DSimmerman, James Windes, Jay Farness, John Bloom, John Hill,Keith Cunningham, Loren Reser, Michael A Falk, MichaelMalone, Michael Sanera, Michael Tanner, Michael Wunsch,Randy Dillingham, Richard Packard, Robert Zoellner, StephenJackson, Stephen D Lapan, Steve Funk, Thomas Hoisch, TimothyL Porter, Wade Harrison, Wayne Sjoberg, William Hildred, KenNicolls, Eugene Hughes, Margaret Hughes (Attachments: # 1 Textof Proposed Order Judgment)(Hudson, Lisa) (Entered: 12/14/2006)

12/14/2006 335 MOTION for Attorney Fees by George Rudebusch. (Lorona, Jess)(Entered: 12/14/2006)

12/14/2006 336 AFFIDAVIT in Support re 335 MOTION for Attorney Fees.(Lorona, Jess) (Entered: 12/14/2006)

12/14/2006 337 MEMORANDUM re: Memorandum in Support of Motion forAttorneys' Fees re 335 MOTION for Attorney Fees by PlaintiffGeorge Rudebusch. (Lorona, Jess) (Entered: 12/14/2006)

12/19/2006 338 ORDER granting Plas' Motion Requesting Leave of Court to FileMotion for Attorneys' Fees and Costs Pursuant to L.R. Civ. 54.2,prior to entry of final judgment. FURTHER ORDERED directingPlas to file their Motion for Attorneys' Fees and Costscontemporaneously with Plaintiff's Proposed Judgment. Signed byJudge Robert C Broomfield on 12/18/06.(KMG) (Entered:12/19/2006)

12/20/2006 339 First MOTION for Extension of Time for Defendants' Response toPlaintiffs' Motion for Attorneys Fees by Arizona, State of,Northern Arizona University, Arizona Regents, Board of.(Attachments: # 1 Text of Proposed Order Order toExtend)(Hudson, Lisa) (Entered: 12/20/2006)

12/28/2006 340 ORDER granting Dfts' Unopposed 339 Motion for Extension ofTime for Dfts' Response to Plas' Motion and Memorandum inSupport of an Award of Attorneys Fees as follows: Dfts aregranted an extension of time to 1/29/07 in which to respond to Plas'motion. Signed by Judge Robert C Broomfield on 12/22/06.(KMG)(Entered: 12/28/2006)

01/03/2007 341 Notice re Lodging Amended Judgment by George Rudebusch,Theresa Chapas, Adrian Riskin, Andrew Odell, Arnold Johnson,Burton Brown, Charles T Way, Craig Caldwell, David Kitterman,Edward Hood, Eugene Loverich, Gary Bateman, Gilbert C Pogany,Guenther Huck, Harvey Becher, Howard Salisbury, James EdwardBartell, James D Simmerman, James Windes, Jay Farness, JohnBloom, John Hill, Keith Cunningham, Loren Reser, Michael AFalk, Michael Malone, Michael Sanera, Michael Tanner, MichaelWunsch, Randy Dillingham, Richard Packard, Robert Zoellner,Stephen Jackson, Stephen D Lapan, Steve Funk, Thomas Hoisch,Timothy L Porter, Wade Harrison, Wayne Sjoberg, WilliamHildred, Ken Nicolls, Eugene Hughes, Margaret Hughes Judgment(Attachments: # 1)(Hudson, Lisa) (Entered: 01/03/2007)

01/29/2007 342 OBJECTION To Plaintiffs' Motion for Attorneys Fees byDefendants Arizona, State of, Northern Arizona University,Arizona Regents, Board of, Eugene Hughes, Margaret Hughes
















filed by Arizona, State of, Northern Arizona University, ArizonaRegents, Board of, Eugene Hughes, Margaret Hughes.(Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1# 2 Exhibit 2a# 3 Exhibit 2b# 4 Exhibit2c# 5 Exhibit 2d# 6 Exhibit 3)(Hudson, Lisa) (Entered:01/29/2007)

02/08/2007 343 REPLY to Response to Motion re 335 MOTION for Attorney Feesfiled by George Rudebusch. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A# 2Exhibit B# 3 Exhibit C# 4 Exhibit D# 5 Exhibit E)(Lorona, Jess)(Entered: 02/08/2007)

02/23/2007 344 JUDGMENT − IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Dfts Motion forSummary Judgment ( 16 in case number CIV 96−1077 PCT RLB)is denied. FURTHER ORDERED that Plas Cross−Motion forSummary Judgment ( 305 in case number CIV 95−1313 PCTRCB) is GRANTED in all respects but for Plas request forattorneys fees which was not properly filed in accordance withLocal Rule 54.2. FURTHER ORDERED that Plas shall beawarded damages as indicated within. IT IS ORDERED that Plasno longer employed by NAU shall provide NAU with income taxwithholding forms (IRS W−4) within 10 days of the entry ofjudgment. FURTHER ORDERED that the above amounts shall bepaid within 15 business days after receipt of all of the individualPlaintiffs tax withholding forms. All payments to the Plas shall beforwarded to Plaintiffs counsel and shall be considered "paid" uponPlas' counsel's receipt. Payments to the ASRS and ORP shall beconsidered "paid" when transmitted by NAU. FURTHERORDERED that post−judgment interest shall be awarded inaccordance with 28 U.S.C. 1961. Signed by Judge Robert CBroomfield on 2/23/07. (KMG) (Entered: 02/23/2007)

09/21/2007 345 ORDER that plas' motion for attorneys' fees and costs doc. 335 isGRANTED in the amount of $287,636.34 in attorneys' fees; and$41,364.19 in costs; andFURTHER ORDERED that dfts shall paythose amounts to plas within thirty (30) days of the date of thisOrder. Signed by Judge Robert C Broomfield on 9/20/07.(KMG)(Entered: 09/21/2007)


















Documents

CLOSED, LEAD, STD U.S. District Court DISTRICT OF ARIZONA ... · DISTRICT OF ARIZONA (Prescott Division) CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 3:95−cv−01313−RCB Rudebusch, et al v. State