Conceptual model-based problem solving

  • Upload
    roosike

  • View
    221

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    1/267

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    2/267

    !"#$%&'()* ,"-%*./)0%- 12"3*%4 5"*67#8

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    3/267

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    4/267

    !"#$%&'()* ,"-%*./)0%- 12"3*%4 5"*67#8

    !"#$% '()*"+(, -.(% /"#0+.+1 2.33.$)4(.", (5

    '546" 7#(% 80594":,

    9)# 17#8 :7#

    8)0*)" ;+.6"0,.(",( /#3#

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    5/267

    ! #$%$&$ '()*'+ ,*' -./0 1**2 /0 343/5315( ,'*6 -.( 7/1'3'8 *, #*9:'(00$

    %; ?@AB?CBDEF?BGFEBH IJ3J('13)2K

    %; ?@AB?CBDEF?BGFHBF I.3'+13)2K

    %; ?@AB?CBDEF?BGFCB@ I(B1**2K

    &L15/0.(+ 18> ;(90( &L15/0.('0M

    &$N$ TTUUU$0(90(JL15/0.('0$)*6T

    !"#$%&' )$ *+#',-"&& .*.&"

    !55 R/:.-0 R(0('4(+ V EFGE ;(90( &L15/0.('0

    =* J3'- *, -./0 U*'2 638 1( '(J'*+L)(+M 0-*'(+ /9 3 '(-'/(435 080-(6M *' -'3906/--(+

    /9 398 ,*'6 *' 18 398 6(390M (5()-'*9/)M 6().39/)35M J.*-*)*J8/9:M 6/)'*,/56/9:M'()*'+/9: *' *-.('U/0(M U/-.*L- U'/--(9 J('6/00/*9 ,'*6 -.( &L15/0.('M U/-. -.(

    (O)(J-/*9 *, 398 63-('/35 0LJJ5/(+ 0J()/,/)3558 ,*' -.( JL'J*0( *, 1(/9: (9-('(+ 39+

    (O()L-(+ *9 3 )*6JL-(' 080-(6M ,*' (O)5L0/4( L0( 18 -.( JL').30(' *, -.( U*'2$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    6/267

    4

    ; ?@ !?A;>A;5

    !)29*U5(+:(6(9-0 4//

    !1*L- -.( !L-.*' /O

    G$ #*9)(J-L35 W*+(5B130(+ &'*15(6 ;*54/9:>

    S(3). ;-L+(9-0 U/-. 7(3'9/9: X/,!)L5-/(0 -* ;*54( W3-. &'*15(60

    %9-'*+L)-/*9 G

    !5:(1'3 S./92/9: /9 &'*15(6 ;*54/9: G

    W3-.(63-/)35 W*+(5/9: E

    S.(*'(-/)35 Y'36(U*'2> #*9)(J-L35 W*+(5B130(+

    &'*15(6 ;*54/9: H ; !++/-/4( &'*15(6 ;*54/9: G?

    ]9/- G> R(J'(0(9-/9: &3'-B&3'-BQ.*5( I&&QK &'*15(60 EG

    7(00*9 G> %9-'*+L)-/*9 EG

    7(00*9 E> &3'-B&3'-BQ.*5( &'*15(6 R(J'(0(9-3-/*9 ED

    ]9/- E> ;*54/9: &3'-B&3'- Q.*5( I&&QK &'*15(60 HP

    7(00*9 H> ;*54/9: &&Q &'*15(60 HP

    ]9/- H> R(J'(0(9-/9: !++/-/4( #*6J3'( I!#K &'*15(60 C?

    7(00*9 C> R(J'(0(9-/9: !#BW*'( &'*15(60 C? 7(00*9 P> R(J'(0(9-/9: !#B7(00 &'*15(60 DF

    ]9/- C> ;*54/9: !++/-/4( #*6J3'( I!#K &'*15(60 D?

    7(00*9 D> ;*54/9: W/O(+ !# &'*15(60 D?

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    7/267

    S! ;*54/9: W/O(+ &&Q 39+ !# &'*15(60 AH

    7(00*9 @> ;*54/9: 6/O(+ &&Q 39+ !# &'*15(60 AH

    &3'- E> WL5-/J5/)3-/4( &'*15(6 R(J'(0(9-3-/*9 39+ ;*54/9: ?@

    ]9/- D> R(J'(0(9-/9: Z\L35 `'*LJ0 IZ`K &'*15(60 ??

    ]9/- @> ;*54/9: Z\L35 `'*LJ0 IZ`K &'*15(60 GF@

    ]9/- A> R(J'(0(9-/9: WL5-/J5/)3-/4( #*6J3'( IW#K &'*15(60 GGP

    ]9/- ?> ;*54/9: WL5-/J5/)3-/4( #*6J3'( IW#K &'*15(60 GE@

    ]9/- GF> ;*54/9: W/O(+ Z\L35 `'*LJ0 39+ WL5-/J5/)3-/4(

    #*6J3'( &'*15(60 GCG

    &3'- H> ;*54/9: #*6J5(O &'*15(60 GP?

    ]9/- GG> ;*54/9: #*6J5(O Q*'+ &'*15(60 GDG

    ]9/- GE> ;*54/9: W/O(+ WL5-/B;-(J &'*15(60 G@H

    H #*99()-/*9 1(-U((9 W3-.(63-/)35 %+(30> ZO-(9+ WL5-/J5/)3-/4(R(30*9/9: -* `(*6(-'8 7(3'9/9: GAH

    !JJ(9+/O !> ;-L+(9- Q*'20.((-0 G?G

    !JJ(9+/O R(,('(9)( `L/+( EE@

    R(,('(9)(0 ED@

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    8/267

    4//

    DE>,>A;5

    Y/'0-M % U*L5+ 5/2( -* -.392 =/)*5( ;JL'5*)2M 3 J'(B0('4/)( (5(6(9-3'8 -(3).('

    3- &L'+L( ]9/4('0/-8M ,*' .(' :'(3- (,,*'- 39+ )*9-'/1L-/*90 -* -.( (+/-/9: 39+

    J'**,'(3+/9: *, -./0 1**2$ b(' -.*'*L:.9(00 39+ +(-3/5(+ )*66(9-0 .(5J(+ 6(

    -'(6(9+*L058 /9 632/9: 68 U'/-/9: ,5*U 1(--(' 39+ (30/(' ,*' '(3+('0 -* L9+('0-39+$

    ;()*9+M % U*L5+ 5/2( -* -.392 W/00 d*L 7L*M 3 ,*'6(' (5(6(9-3'8 0).**5

    -(3).('M ,*' .(' :'(3- )*9-'/1L-/*90 /9 ,/(5+ -(0-/9: -.( #*9)(J-L35 W*+(5B

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    9/267

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    10/267

    /O

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    11/267

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    12/267

    B

    #b!&SZR G

    !?A!>1;F=./D 1H?/=>, 5?=IJAE

    6&*+7 9%/'&$%3 C#%7 D&*"$#$5 E#--#+/0%#&3 %) 9)04& >*%7 !")20&13

    %=SRNX]#S%N=

    !5-.*L:. !6('/)39 0-L+(9-0 3'( 0-'L::5/9: U/-. 6398 30J()-0 *, 63-.(63-/)0M -.(

    =3-/*935 W3-.(63-/)0 !+4/0*'8 &39(5 .30 /+(9-/,/(+ g35:(1'3 30 3 )(9-'35 )*9)('9i

    I=3-/*935 W3-.(63-/)0 !+4/0*'8 &39(5M EFFAM J$ O///K$ %9-('(0-/9:58M !6('/)39

    0-L+(9-0 -(9+ -* (9f*8 0).**5 63-.(63-/)0 +L'/9: -.( (3'58 (5(6(9-3'8 :'3+(0$b*U(4('M -.(8 1(:/9 -* (OJ('/(9)( +/,,/)L5-8 /9 39+ )*6( -* +/05/2( 63-.(63-/)0 3,-('

    ,*L'-. :'3+( U.(9 5(3'9/9: 1()*6(0 6*'( 310-'3)- *' 0861*5/) 39+ /94*54(0 6*'(

    35:(1'3/) -./92/9: I#3/M 7(UM W*''/0M W*8('M =:M k ;).6/--3LM EFFCK$ %9 J3'-/)L53'M

    0-L+(9-0 U/-. 5(3'9/9: +/031/5/-/(0 *' +/,,/)L5-/(0 /9 63-.(63-/)0 I7XWK 3'( ,355/9:

    ,L'-.(' 1(./9+ -.(/' 9*'635 3)./(4/9: J(('0 30 -.(8 6*4( ,'*6 (5(6(9-3'8 -*

    0()*9+3'8 0).**50$ ! 63f*'/-8 3'( (00(9-/3558 ,3/5/9: -.( 0()*9+3'8 63-. )L''/)L5L6$

    !))*'+/9: -* -.( &39(5M 63-.(63-/)0 3)./(4(6(9- /9 -.( ]$;$ +()'(30(0 0/:9/,/)39-58

    /9 -.( 53-( 6/++5( :'3+(0 U.(9 0-L+(9-0 3'( (OJ()-(+ -* 5(3'9 35:(1'3M U./). '3/0(0

    -.( (00(9-/35 \L(0-/*9> b*U )39 0-L+(9-0M /9)5L+/9: -.*0( U/-. 7&M g1( 1(0- J'(J3'(+

    ,*' (9-'8 /9-* 35:(1'3liI&39(5M J$ O///K$ =* +*L1-M -.( &39(5e0 '(J*'- L9+('0)*'(0 -.(

    /6J*'-39)( *, 35:(1'3B'(3+/9(00 /90-'L)-/*9$

    S.( JL'J*0( *, -./0 )L''/)L5L6 1**2 /0 -* J'(0(9- 3 #*9)(J-L35 W*+(5B

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    13/267

    #b!&SZR G

    G

    (5(6(9-3'8 0).**5 )L''/)L5L6M 35:(1'3 /0 (00(9-/3558 g3 080-(63-/) U38 *, (OJ'(00/9:

    :(9('35/-8 39+ 310-'3)-/*9i I=3-/*935 R(0(3'). #*L9)/5 ^=R#_M EFFGM J$ EPDK$ %9

    35:(1'3M -.( ,*)L0 /0 *9 (OJ'(00/*9 *' '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 *, '(53-/*90 I#3'J(9-('M 7(4/M

    Y'392(M k m('/9:L(M EFFPK$ S.'*L:. -'39053-/9: /9,*'63-/*9 ,'*6 '(35 U*'5+ 0/-L3-(+

    U*'+ J'*15(60 /9-* 0861*5/) (OJ'(00/*90 39+ (\L3-/*90 -.3- 638 /94*54( *9( *'

    6*'( L929*U9 \L39-/-8M 0L). '&."&3&$%*%#)$/0 )*90/+('(+ *9( -8J( *, 3)-/4/-8 -.3-

    /94*54(0 35:(1'3/) -./92/9: I=R#M EFFGK$ Q/-./9 -.( )*9-(O- *, 3'/-.6(-/) J'*15(6

    0*54/9:M 35:(1'3/) -./92/9: g/94*54(0 -.( L0( *, 0861*50 -* :(9('35/[( )('-3/9

    2/9+0 *, 3'/-.6(-/) *J('3-/*90i I#L')/* k ;).U3'-[M G??@M J$ E?DK 39+ -* '(J'(0(9-

    '(53-/*90 I#.3'1*99(3LM G??DK$ !5:(1'3 /0 g3 )5L0-(' *, 6*+(5/9:i -.3- 0('4(0 30

    g3 +*63/9 ,*' 632/9:M (OJ'(00/9: 39+ 3':L/9: :(9('35/[3-/*90i Ih3JL- k *%7&1*%#+*0 >)'&0#$5

    R()(9-58M

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    14/267

    #N=#Z&S]!7 WNXZ7B

    O

    J3'- *, 355 3'(30 *, 63-.(63-/)0 /9)5L+/9: 3'/-.6(-/) 39+ 0.*L5+ 1( /9-'*+L)(+ -*

    355 3:( :'*LJ0 /9)5L+/9: (5(6(9-3'8 0-L+(9-0 IW(43'(). k h'363'02/M EFFAK$ %-

    0.*L5+ 1( 9*-(+ -.3- (9:3:/9: 0-L+(9-0 /9 -.( 6*+(5/9: J'*)(00 +*(0 9*- 9()(003'/58

    6(39 (9:3:/9: 0-L+(9-0 /9 -.( +/0)*4('8 *' /94(9-/*9 *, 63-.(63-/)35 6*+(50 *'

    )*6J5(O 9*-3-/*935 080-(60n .*U(4('M 3))*'+/9: -* 7(0.M X*(''M #3'6*93M 39+

    bf3563'0*9 IEFFHKM /- +*(0 6(39 -.3- U.(9 0L). 6*+(50 *' 080-(60 3'( :/4(9 -* -.(

    0-L+(9-0M g-.( )(9-'35 3)-/4/-/(0 -.3- 0-L+(9-0 9((+ -* (9:3:( /9 /0 -.( L9J3)2/9: *,

    -.( 6(39/9: *, -.( 080-(6i IJ$ EGDKM '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 *, -.( '(35 J'*15(6 0/-L3-/*9 /9 3

    63-.(63-/)35 (OJ'(00/*9 *' 6*+(5M 39+ -.( ,5(O/15( L0( *, -.( 6*+(5 -* 0*54( '(35

    U*'5+ J'*15(60$

    67&)"&%#+*0 H"*1&C)"@P )'&0,2*3&' !")20&1 9)04#$5

    #*9-(6J*'3'8 3JJ'*3).(0 -* 0-*'8 J'*15(6 0*54/9: .34( (6J.30/[(+ -.( )*9)(J-L35L9+('0-39+/9: *, 3 0-*'8 J'*15(6 1(,*'( 3--(6J-/9: 398 0*5L-/*9 -.3- /94*54(0

    0(5()-/9: 39+ 3JJ58/9: 39 3'/-.6(-/) *J('3-/*9 ,*' 0*5L-/*9 Ij*9300(9M EFFHK$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    15/267

    #b!&SZR G

    Q

    EFF?KM % .34( +(4(5*J(+ -.( )'&0,2*3&' !")20&1 9)04#$5 I#NW&;K

    J'*:'36 -.3- /0 )*90/0-(9- U/-. -.( -.(*'(-/)35 ,'36(U*'2 *, 63-.(63-/)35

    6*+(5/9: 39+ )*9)(J-L35 6*+(50 I($:$M *%7&1*%#+*0 =&0*%#)$3

    Z6(':/9: ,'*6 ;

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    16/267

    #N=#Z&S]!7 WNXZ7B

    M

    (6J.30/[(0 39 35:(1'3/) '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 *, 63-.(63-/)35 '(53-/*90 /9 (\L3-/*9 6*+(50

    I($:$M g&3'- p &3'- q Q.*5(i ,*' 3++/-/4( U*'+ J'*15(60n g]9/- R3-( r =L61(' *,

    ]9/-0 q &'*+L)-i ,*' (\L35 :'*LJ 0-'L)-L'(+ 6L5-/J5/)3-/4( U*'+ J'*15(60K$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    17/267

    #b!&SZR G

    \

    -.3- )*9)(J-L35 6*+(5t130(+ '(J'(0(9-3-/*90 J'*6J-(+ 18 Q& 0-*'8 :'3663'

    /6J'*4(+ 0-L+(9-0e J(',*'639)( *9 3'/-.6(-/) U*'+ J'*15(6 0*54/9: 39+ J'*6*-(+

    J'(35:(1'3/) )*9)(J- 39+ 02/55 3)\L/0/-/*9$

    S* (O-(9+ #NW&; -* 6*'( )*6J5(O '(35 U*'5+ J'*15(6 0*54/9:M a/9 k m.39:

    IEFF?K (OJ5*'(+ -.( (,,()-/4(9(00 *, #NW&; /9 0*54/9: J'*15(60 -.3- '(\L/'(

    0(90(B632/9: *, 3 +()/635 0*5L-/*9 I($:$M gW3'/589 /0 JL--/9: .(' #X )*55()-/*9 *,

    GPE #X0 /9-* )31/9(-0$ Z3). )31/9(- )39 .*5+ HD #X0$ b*U 6398 )31/9(-0 +*(0

    0.( 9((+liKM 30 U(55 30 J'*15(60 -.3- '(\L/'( 13)2:'*L9+ /9,*'63-/*9M J/)-*:'3J.

    J'*15(60M 39+ 6L5-/B0-(J J'*15(60$ ! 6L5-/J5( J'*1(M 0/9:5( 0L1f()- +(0/:9 U30 L0(+

    -* (O36/9( -.( /9-('4(9-/*9 (,,()-0 3)'*00 -.'(( C-.B 39+ P-.B:'3+('0 U/-. 7XW$ S.(

    '(0L5-0 /9+/)3-(+ -.3- -.( /9-('4(9-/*9 /6J'*4(+ 0-L+(9- J(',*'639)( *9 '(0(3').('B

    +(0/:9(+ )'/-('/*9 -(0-0 39+ 3 9*'6B'(,('(9)(+ 0-39+3'+/[(+ -(0-$

    R()(9-58M a/9 (- 35$ IEFGGK (6J5*8(+ 3 J'(-(0-BJ*0--(0-M '39+*6/[(+ :'*LJ

    )*6J3'/0*9 +(0/:9 -* )*6J3'( -.( (,,()- *, #NW&; -* :(9('35 .(L'/0-/) /90-'L)-/*9I`b%K -32(9 ,'*6 -.( J3'-/)/J3-/9: 0).**50e (93)-(+ )L''/)L5L6 39+ -(3)./9:

    J'3)-/)($ S.( '(0L5-0 /9+/)3-( -.3- *958 -.( #NW&; :'*LJ 0/:9/,/)39-58 /6J'*4(+

    IU/-. 39 (,,()- 0/[( *, H$GE *4(' -.( )*6J3'/0*9 :'*LJM a/9 (- 35$M EFGGM J$ H?FK

    (5(6(9-3'8 0-L+(9-0e J(',*'639)( *9 -.( )'/-('/*9 -(0- -.3- /94*54(+ 6L5-/J5/)3-/4(

    U*'+ J'*15(60 30 U(55 30 -.( J'(B35:(1'3 6*+(5 (OJ'(00/*9 -(0- I-32(9 ,'*6 -.(

    0).**5B3+*J-(+ 63-. )L''/)L5L6K$ %9 0L663'8M J'(5/6/93'8 ,/9+/9:0 /9+/)3-( -.3-

    -.( #NW&; J'*:'36M U/-. 3 ,*)L0 *9 '(J'(0(9-/9: -.( J'*15(6 /9 /-0 63-.(63-/)35

    6*+(5 I

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    18/267

    #N=#Z&S]!7 WNXZ7B

    ]

    U./). +(J/)- 63-.(63-/)35 '(53-/*90 /94*54(+ /9 -.( J'*15(6M J'*4/+( 0-L+(9-0 U/-.

    3 +(,/9(+ 35:(1'3/) (\L3-/*9 ,*' 0*5L-/*9$

    &RN`R!W #NW&N=Z=S;

    67& 9+).& *$' 9&X/&$+& )- %7& !")5"*1

    S./0 J'*:'36 3++'(00(0 (5(6(9-3'8 U*'+ J'*15(6 0*54/9: /9)5L+/9: ,*L' 130/)

    *J('3-/*90$ %- 638 0('4( 30 3 0LJJ5(6(9-35 J'*:'36 U/-. 39 3/6 -* .(5J 0-L+(9-0

    U/-. 7XW 5(3'9 1/: /+(30 /9 (5(6(9-3'8 63-. J'*15(6 0*54/9: -.3- /94*54( ,*L'

    130/) *J('3-/*90> 3++/-/*9M 0L1-'3)-/*9M 6L5-/J5/)3-/*9 39+ +/4/0/*9$ S./0 J'*:'36

    U/55 )*4(' 3++/-/4( J'*15(6 0*54/9: I($:$M J3'-BJ3'-BU.*5( 39+ 3++/-/4( )*6J3'(

    J'*15(60KM 39+ 6L5-/J5/)3-/4( J'*15(6 0*54/9: I($:$M (\L35 :'*LJ0 39+ 6L5-/J5/)3-/4(

    )*6J3'( J'*15(60K$ S.( -3020 /94*54(+ /9 -./0 1**2 3'( -.*0( -8J/)3558 ,*L9+ /9(5(6(9-3'8 63-. -(O-1**20M U./). '*L:.58 '(J'(0(9- 31*L- D@u *, -.( (5(6(9-3'8

    63-. )*9-(9-$

    S.( #NW&; J'*:'36 /94*54(0 -.'(( J3'-0> IGK ,/4( L9/-0 *9 3++/-/4( U*'+ J'*15(6

    0*54/9: -.3- /94*54(0 3++/-/*9 39+ 0L1-'3)-/*9n IEK ,/4( L9/-0 *9 6L5-/J5/)3-/4( U*'+

    J'*15(6 0*54/9: -.3- /94*54(0 6L5-/J5/)3-/*9 39+ +/4/0/*9n 39+M IHK -U* L9/-0 *9

    0*54/9: )*6J5(O U*'+ J'*15(60 0L). 30 -.*0( /94*54/9: J/)-*:'3J.0M /''(5(439-

    /9,*'63-/*9M 39+ 6/O(+ 3++/-/4( 39+ 6L5-/J5/)3-/4( 6L5-/B0-(J0$

    %9 1*-. &3'- % 39+ &3'- %%M -.( ,/'0- ]9/- I/$($M ]9/- G *' ]9/- PK (9:3:(0 0-L+(9-0

    /9 5(3'9/9: 63-.(63-/)35 6*+(50 -.'*L:. '(J'(0(9-/9: -.( J'*15(6 /9 -.( 6*+(5

    (\L3-/*9 I0(( Y/:L'( #GBE /9 J3:( P ,*' 39 (O36J5(> L9/- '3-( r s *, L9/-0 q

    J'*+L)-K$ XL'/9: -.( 6*+(5 (\L3-/*9 '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 0-3:(M U*'+ J'*15(6 0-*'/(0

    U/-. 9* L929*U90 U/55 1( L0(+$ S.( JL'J*0( *, J'(0(9-/9: 0-*'8 0/-L3-/*90 U/-.

    9* L929*U90 /0 -* J'*4/+( 0-L+(9-0 U/-. 3 )*6J5(-( '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 *, -.( J'*15(60-'L)-L'( 0* -.3- 63-.(63-/)35 '(53-/*90 /9 -.( J'*15(6 3'( )5(3' -* -.( 0-L+(9-0$

    %9 3++/-/*9M 0(5,B'(:L53-/*9 \L(0-/*90 J('-/9(9- -* ?)"' !")20&1 9%)"S T"*11*"

    Ia/9M Q/5(0M k 7/9M EFFAK I0((Y/:L'( #GBEM 5*U(' J39(5K U/55 1( L0(+ 30 3 .(L'/0-/)

    -* .(5J 0-L+(9-0 39358[( 43'/*L0 0/-L3-(+ U*'+ J'*15(60T0-*'/(0 39+ '(J'(0(9- -.(

    /9,*'63-/*9 ,'*6 -.( J'*15(6 /9 (/-.(' -.( &3'-B&3'-BQ.*5( I&&QK 6*+(5 (\L3-/*9

    *' -.( Z\L35 `'*LJ0 IZ`K 6*+(5 (\L3-/*9$

    S.( 0()*9+ ]9/- /9 &3'-0 G 39+ E I/$($M ]9/- E 39+ ]9/- @K (9:3:( 0-L+(9-0 /9

    0*54/9: (/-.(' &&Q J'*15(60 I&3'- GK *' Z` J'*15(60 I&3'- EK U/-. 39 L929*U9M

    3,-(' -.(8 5(3'9 -.( J'*15(6 0-'L)-L'( '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 /9 ]9/- G$ S.( -./'+ 39+ ,*L'-.

    ]9/-0 /9 &3'-0 G 39+ E I/$($M ]9/- H k Cn 39+ ]9/- A k ?K /9-'*+L)(0 3 43'/3-/*9 *,

    (/-.(' -.( &&Q *' -.( Z` J'*15(6 0-'L)-L'($ %9 J3'-/)L53'M 0-L+(9-0 U/55 5(3'9 -*

    '(J'(0(9- I]9/- HK 39+ 0*54( I]9/- CK 3++/-/4( )*6J3'( J'*15(60 L0/9: 3 43'/3-/*9

    *, -.( &&Q 6*+(5 (\L3-/*9M *' '(J'(0(9- I]9/- AK 39+ 0*54( I]9/- ?K 6L5-/J5/)3-/4()*6J3'( J'*15(60 L0/9: 3 43'/3-/*9 *, -.( Z` 6*+(5 (\L3-/*9$ S.( ,/,-. L9/- /9 &3'-0

    G 39+ E I/$($M ]9/- P 39+ ]9/- GFK U/55 (9:3:( 0-L+(9-0 /9 0*54/9: 6/O(+ 3++/-/4(

    I]9/- PK *' 6/O(+ 6L5-/J5/)3-/4( J'*15(60 I]9/- GFK$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    19/267

    #b!&SZR G

    [

    &3'- H U/55 (9:3:( 0-L+(9-0 /9 39358[/9: 39+ 0*54/9: 6*'( )*6J5(O J'*15(60

    I($:$M J'*15(60 /94*54/9: /''(5(439- /9,*'63-/*9M J/)-*:'3J.0M )*6J'(.(90/*9 *,

    +()/635 390U('0M 39+ 6L5-/B0-(J0K$ Y*55*U/9: 39 /9-'*+L)-/*9 /9 #.3J-(' % 39+

    -.( #NW&; J'*:'36 /9 #.3J-(' %%M 530-58M #.3J-(' %%% U/55 (O-(9+ -.( 1/: /+(3 *,

    6L5-/J5/)3-/4( '(30*9/9: -* -.( 5(3'9/9: *, (5(6(9-3'8 :(*6(-'8 U/-. -.( /9-(9-/*9

    *, -(3)./9: 0-L+(9-0 -.( )*99()-/*9 1(-U((9 63-.(63-/)35 /+(30 -.3- 1*-. 0-'(9:-.(9

    -.(/' 29*U5(+:( 130( 39+ J'*6*-( :(9('35/[315( J'*15(6 0*54/9: 02/550$

    N4('355M -.( J'*:'36 /94*54(0 -.( ,(3-L'(0 1(5*U>

    G$ S.( #NW&; J'*:'36 -(3).(0 6*+(5B130(+ '3-.(' -.39 0*5L-/*9B'L5(B130(+

    J'*15(6 0*54/9:$ %- (6J.30/[(0 -.( '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 *, 63-.(63-/)35 '(53-/*90 /9

    35:(1'3/) 6*+(5 (\L3-/*90$ #NW&; 3/60 -* J'*6*-( )*9)(J-L35 L9+('0-39+/9:

    *, 1/: /+(30 /9 3++/-/4( 39+ 6L5-/J5/)3-/4( J'*15(6 0*54/9:M 30 U(55 30 -.(

    )*99()-/*9 1(-U((9 63-.(63-/)35 /+(30$ !0 0L).M /- /0 /9 5/9( U/-. -.( #*66*9

    #*'( ;-39+3'+0$E$ S.( J'*:'36 3++'(00(0 -.( =3-/*935 W3-.(63-/)0 !+4/0*'8 &39(5e0 )*9)('90

    31*L- 35:(1'3 '(3+/9(00 39+ -.( =3-/*935 #*L9)/5 *, S(3).('0 *, W3-.(63-/)0

    I=#SWKe0 )355 ,*' 35:(1'3 30 3 hBGE (9-('J'/0( IW3-.(63-/)0 !+4/0*'8 &39(5M

    EFFAn =#SWM EFFFK$

    H$ S.( J'*:'36 3++'(00(0 -.( )*99()-/*9 1(-U((9 )*9)'(-(T0(6/B)*9)'(-(

    '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 39+ 310-'3)- 63-.(63-/)35 6*+(5 (OJ'(00/*9$ ;/9:3J*'(

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    20/267

    #N=#Z&S]!7 WNXZ7B

    _

    +/4/0/*9 /9 &3'- E 3'( )*90/0-(9- U/-. -.( 63-. )*9-(9- -8J/)3558 J'(0(9-(+ /9 -./'+

    39+ ,*L'-. :'3+( 63-. )L''/)L53 39+ )39 1( L0(+ 18 C-. *' P-. :'3+( 0-L+(9- U/-. 7X

    I*' (4(9 *5+(' 0-L+(9-0 U/-. 7XWK U.* .34( 9*- 630-('(+ 6L5-/J5/)3-/4( J'*15(6

    0*54/9:$ S./0 J'*:'36 )39 0('4( 30 3 0LJJ5(6(9- -* '(:L53' 0).**5 63-. /90-'L)-/*9$

    !0 -./0 J'*:'36 -(3).(0 1/: /+(30 /9 3++/-/4( 39+ 6L5-/J5/)3-/4( J'*15(6 0*54/9:M

    0-L+(9-0 U/55 1( (\L/JJ(+ U/-. 3 -**5 -* 5(3'9 63-. J'*15(6 0*54/9: 080-(63-/)3558

    39+ .*J(,L558 )3-). LJ U/-. -.(/' 9*'635B3)./(4/9: J(('0 U/-./9 3 0.*'- J('/*+ *,

    -/6( 30 0LJJ*'-(+ 18 J'(4/*L0 '(0(3'). Ia/9 k m.39:M EFF?n a/9 (- 35$M EFGGK$

    S.( #NW&; J'*:'36 )39 1( L0(+ 30 S/(' %% *' S/(' %%% /9-('4(9-/*9 6*+(50 U/-./9

    -.( )*9-(O- *, R(0J*90( -* %9-('4(9-/*9 IR-%K 6*+(5$ %- )39 1( (30/58 /9-(:'3-(+ /9-*

    '(:L53' /9)5L0/*9 )5300'**60 30 J3'- *, S/(' % /90-'L)-/*9$ S.( #NW&; J'*:'36 )39

    1( L0(+ 18 '(:L53' )5300'**6 63-. -(3).('0 I0J()/35 (+L)3-/*9 *' '(:L53' (+L)3-/*9

    -(3).('0KM %90-'L)-/*935 ;LJJ*'-/9: S(36 /9-('4(9-/*9/0-0M 0).**5 J08).*5*:/0-M

    -L-*'0 U.* U*'2 U/-. 0-L+(9-0 U/-. 7XW /9 3,-('B0).**5 J'*:'360M 39+ 398*9( U.*U*'20 U/-. 0-L+(9-0 U/-. 7X /9 63-. J'*15(6 0*54/9:$

    S.( #NW&; J'*:'36 /0 350* L0(,L5 ,*' J'*,(00/*935 +(4(5*J6(9- 39+ ,*' -.( J'(B

    0('4/)( -'3/9/9: *, J'*0J()-/4( (5(6(9-3'8 -(3).('0M 0J()/35 (+L)3-/*9 /9 J3'-/)L53'M

    -* (9.39)( -.(/' )*9-(9- 29*U5(+:( /9 (5(6(9-3'8 63-.(63-/)0 J'*15(6 0*54/9:$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    21/267

    BB

    #b!&SZR E

    !?,15 1H?EH IGK ;/9:3J*'( 13' 6*+(50 I;/9:3J*'( W/9/0-'8

    *, Z+L)3-/*9M G?AGK -* ,3)/5/-3-( -.( -'390/-/*9 ,'*6 -.( 0(6/B)*9)'(-( 6*+(5 -* -.(

    310-'3)- 63-.(63-/)35 6*+(5n IEK C)"' .")20&1 ^Q&_ 3%)"S 5"*11*" Ia/9 (- 35$M

    EFFAK 0(5,BJ'*6J-/9: \L(0-/*90 -* ,3)/5/-3-( J'*15(6 '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 L0/9: #NW&;

    6*+(5 +/3:'360n 39+ IHK 3 )*:9/-/4( .(L'/0-/) XNS; ).()25/0- Ia/9 (- 35$M EFFAK

    -* ,3)/5/-3-( -.( (9-/'( J'*15(6 0*54/9: J'*)(00$ S.(9M % U/55 J'(0(9- 3 :(9('35

    +(0)'/J-/*9 *, -.( /90-'L)-/*935 J.30(0 U.(9 /6J5(6(9-/9: #NW&;M ,*55*U(+ 18 3

    0L663'8 *, 43'/*L0 3++/-/4( 39+ 6L5-/J5/)3-/4( U*'+ J'*15(6 0/-L3-/*90$

    9#$5*.)"& J*" >)'&03 K9J>N %) H*+#0#%*%& %7& 6"*$3#%#)$ %) >*%7&1*%#+*0 >)'&03

    ;

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    22/267

    #b!&SZR E

    BG

    73-('M -.( 13' 6*+(5 U/55 1( ,3+(+ *L- 39+ 0-L+(9-0 U/55 9* 5*9:(' '(58 *9

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    23/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    BO

    F

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    24/267

    #b!&SZR E

    BQ

    M 1)"& *..0&3 %7*$ 8)7$I `)C 1*$S *..0&3 ')&3 8)7$ 7*4&bc *' g

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    25/267

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    26/267

    #b!&SZR E

    B\

    !")20&1 6S.& 9*1.0& !")20&1 9#%/*%#)$3

    &'*+L)- L929*U9 Z6/58 .30 3 0-36J )*55()-/*9 1**2 U/-. 3 -*-35 *, E@ J3:(0M 39+ (3). J3:(

    )39 .*5+ GH 0-36J0$ %, Z6/58 ,/55(+ LJ -./0 )*55()-/*9 1**2M .*U 6398

    0-36J0 U*L5+ 0.( .34(l

    =;-(#5-#>'(#$% .,/5'"%

    #*6J3'(+ 0(-

    L929*U9

    %033) .30 GG 63'15(0$ #36('*9 .30 EE -/6(0 30 6398 63'15(0 30 %033)$

    b*U 6398 63'15(0 +*(0 #36('*9 .34(l

    R(,('(9- 0(-

    L929*U9

    `/93 .30 0(9- *L- CDE J3)23:(0 /9 -.( 530- U((2 ,*' -.( J*0- *,,/)($ `/93

    .30 0(9- *L- EG -/6(0 30 6398 J3)23:(0 30 .(' ,'/(9+ X39($ b*U 6398

    J3)23:(0 .30 X39( 0(9- *L-l

    WL5-/J5/('

    L929*U9

    %- '3/9(+ GC@ /9).(0 /9 =(U d*'2 *9( 8(3'$ %9 Q30./9:-*9 X$#$M /- *958

    '3/9(+ EG /9).(0 +L'/9: -.( 036( 8(3'$ S.( 36*L9- *, '3/9 /9 =(U d*'2 /0

    .*U 6398 -/6(0 -.( 36*L9- *, '3/9 /9 Q30./9:-*9 X$#$ -.3- 8(3'l

    `(9('3558 0J(32/9:M J3'-BJ3'-BU.*5( I*' J3'- p J3'- q U.*5(K /0 3 :(9('35/[315(

    )*9)(J-L35 6*+(5 /9 3++/-/*9 39+ 0L1-'3)-/*9 U*'+ J'*15(60 U.('( .*"%M.*"%M 39+

    C7)0&3'( -.( -.'(( 130/) (5(6(9-0$ %9 )*9-'30-M ,3)-*'B,3)-*'BJ'*+L)- I*' ,3)-*' r

    ,3)-*' q J'*+L)-K /0 3 :(9('35/[315( )*9)(J-L35 6*+(5 /9 6L5-/J5/)3-/*9 39+ +/4/0/*9

    3'/-.6(-/) U*'+ J'*15(60 U.('( -*+%)"M -*+%)"M 39+ .")'/+% 3'( -.( -.'(( 130/)

    (5(6(9-0$ %- 0.*L5+ 1( 9*-(+ -.3- -.( -.'(( 130/) (5(6(9-0 I/9 (/-.(' -.( J3'-BJ3'-B

    U.*5( *' ,3)-*'B,3)-*'BJ'*+L)- 6*+(5K U/55 .34( L9/\L( +(9*-3-/*90 U.(9 3 0J()/,/)

    J'*15(6 0L1-8J( 3JJ5/(0$ Y*' (O36J5(M /9 3 +)12#$&J'*15(6 -8J( I($:$M:1#0S 7*3

    Q .&$+#03 *$' !*% 7*3 [ .&$+#03I `)C 1*$S .&$+#03 ') %7&S 7*4& *00 %)5&%7&"bKM -.(

    9L61(' *, J(9)/50 Z6/58 .30 39+ -.( 9L61(' *, J(9)/50 &3- .30 3'( -.( -U*.*"%3n

    -.(0( -U* J3'-0 632( LJ -.( )*61/9(+ 36*L9- I/$($M g355 -*:(-.('iK *' -.( C7)0&$ %9

    )*9-'30-M /9 39 *''#%#4& +)1.*"&J'*15(6 -8J( I($:$M:1#0S 7*3 _ 3%#+@&"3Z !*% 7*3

    Q -&C&" 3%#+@&"3 %7*$ :1#0SI `)C 1*$S 3%#+@&"3 ')&3 !*% 7*4&bKM -.( 9L61(' *,

    0-/)2('0 Z6/58 .30 /0 -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8 I*' -.( C7)0&36*L9-KM U.('(30 -.( 9L61('

    *, 0-/)2('0 &3- .30 /0 -.( 06355(' \L39-/-8 I*' *9( *, -.( J3'-0K 39+ -.( +/,,('(9)(

    1(-U((9 Z6/58 39+ &3- /0 -.( *-.(' 06355(' \L39-/-8 I-.( *-.(' J3'-Kn )*61/9/9: -.(0(

    -U* J3'-0 /0 -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8 I*' -.( U.*5(K$

    A$3%"/+%#)$*0 !7*3&3

    %90-'L)-/*90 -* )3''8 *L- #NW&; U/55 1( +(5/4('(+ /9 -U* J3'-0> .")20&1 3%"/+%/"&

    "&."&3&$%*%#)$ 39+ .")20&1 3)04#$5$ XL'/9: -.( /90-'L)-/*9 *, .")20&1 3%"/+%/"&

    "&."&3&$%*%#)$M U*'+ 0-*'/(0 U/-. 9* L929*U90 U/55 1( L0(+ -* .(5J 0-L+(9-0

    L9+('0-39+ -.( J'*15(6 0-'L)-L'( 39+ -.( 63-.(63-/)35 '(53-/*90 36*9: -.(\L39-/-/(0$ ;J()/,/)3558M 0-L+(9-0 U/55 5(3'9 -* /+(9-/,8 -.( J'*15(6 0-'L)-L'( 39+ 63J

    -.( /9,*'63-/*9 ,'*6 -.( J'*15(6 -* /-0 )*''(0J*9+/9: #NW&; +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9

    I0((Y/:L'( #GBE,*' 39 (O36J5(> L9/- '3-( O s *, L9/-0 q J'*+L)-K$ XL'/9: -.3- 0-3:(M

    6*20&

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    27/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    B]

    30 355 \L39-/-/(0 3'( :/4(9 /9 -.( 0-*'8 I9* L929*U90K 0-L+(9-0 U/55 1( 315( -* ).()2

    -.( g13539)(i *, -.( (\L3-/*9 -* 0.3J( 39+ '(/9,*')( -.( )*9)(J- *, g(\L35/-8i 39+

    -.( 6(39/9: *, 39 (\L35 0/:9$

    !")20&1 "&."&3&$%*%#)$ /90-'L)-/*9 U/55 1( ,*55*U(+ 18 .")20&1 3)04#$5

    /90-'L)-/*9$ XL'/9: .")20&1 3)04#$5 /90-'L)-/*9M U*'+ J'*15(60 U/-. 39 L929*U9

    \L39-/-8 U/55 1( J'(0(9-(+$ Q.(9 '(J'(0(9-/9: 3 J'*15(6 U/-. 39 L929*U9 \L39-/-8

    /9 -.( #NW&; +/3:'36M 0-L+(9-0 )39 ).**0( -* L0( 3 5(--(' I)39 1( 398 5(--(' -.(8

    J'(,('K -* '(J'(0(9- -.( L929*U9 \L39-/-8$ ;-L+(9-0 3'( (9)*L'3:(+ -* L0( -.( D?;5

    ).()25/0- I0(( ]9/- @K -* :L/+( -.( J'*15(6 0*54/9: J'*)(00$

    N4('355M -.( /90-'L)-/*9 '(\L/'(0 (OJ5/)/- 0-'3-(:8 (OJ5393-/*9 39+ 6*+(5/9: I0((

    -.( !JJ(9+/O ,*' 6*+(5/9: U*'20.((-0 ,*' 0-L+(9-0 -* ,*55*U 35*9: +L'/9: -.(

    /90-'L)-/*9KM +8936/) -(3).('B0-L+(9- /9-('3)-/*9M :L/+(+ J'3)-/)(M J(',*'639)(

    6*9/-*'/9: U/-. )*''()-/4( ,((+13)2M 39+ /9+(J(9+(9- J'3)-/)($ XL'/9: /9+(J(9+(9-

    J'3)-/)(M 0-L+(9-0 U/55 1( J'*4/+(+ U/-. 39 /9+(J(9+(9- U*'20.((- -* 0*54( (/-.('3++/-/4( *' 6L5-/J5/)3-/4( U*'+ J'*15(60 I0(( -.( !JJ(9+/O ,*' /9+(J(9+(9-

    U*'20.((-0K -.(8 .34( fL0- 5(3'9(+$ %- /0 0L::(0-(+ -.3- -.( #NW&; 6*+(5 (\L3-/*90

    1( J'*4/+(+ *9 355 6*+(5/9: 39+ :L/+(+ J'3)-/)( U*'20.((-0M *' (4(9 *9 /9+(J(9+(9-

    J'3)-/)( U*'20.((-0 /9 -.( 1(:/99/9: 0-3:( *, -.( /90-'L)-/*935 J'*:'36$ b*U(4('M

    -.(8 0.*L5+ 1( :'3+L3558 ,3+(+ *L- *9 -.( U*'20.((- *9)( 0-L+(9-0 .34( /9-('935/[(+

    -.( 6*+(50$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    28/267

    &!RS G

    1H?/=>, 5?=IJAE

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    29/267

    GB

    ]=%S G

    H>1H>5>A;JAE 1,5

    7Z;;N= G> %=SRNX]#S%N=

    =%)2#7#8 ?('$"4%M %9-'*+L)-/*9 -* -.( )*9)(J- *, g0L6Mi ;/9:3J*'( C )/')5(0$

    I%, -.( 0-L+(9- )399*- 390U('M 5(- ./6T.(' )*L9-Kn

    ;%)$O%2> b*U 6398 )/')5(0 3'( -.('( /9 -.( 0()*9+ '*Ul

    5'(-%#'0> ;(4(9$

    ;%)$O%2> b*U 6398 )/')5(0 3'( -.('( /9 355l

    5'(-%#'0> Z5(4(9$;%)$O%2> `**+$ S.('( 3'( (5(4(9 )/')5(0 35-*:(-.('$ %, U( U39- -* (OJ'(00 /- /9 63-.

    539:L3:(M U( 038> Y*L' J5L0 0(4(9 /0 (5(4(9 IgC p @ qGGiKM U.('( GG /0 -.( 3/1*,

    C 39+ @$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    30/267

    #b!&SZR E

    GG

    ;%)$O%2M I`/4( *L- )L1(0 /9 -U* +/,,('(9- )*5*'0 K Y/'0-M J5(30( J/)2 *L- A U./-( )*5*'

    )L1(0 39+ ,*'6 3 13'n =(O-M J5(30( J/)2 *L- P :'38 )*5*' )L1(0 39+ ,*'6 39*-.(' 13'$

    IW*9/-*' 0-L+(9-0e 3)-/*90n X/0J538 ;5/+( GBGBE$K

    90#'& B,B,GI A$%")'/+& %7&

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    31/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    GO

    90#'& B,B,QI J*" >)'&0 *$' %7& !!? E#*5"*1 :X/*%#)$

    Part

    8 5 13

    Part

    + =

    Whole

    8(part) 5 (part)

    13 (whole)

    IS(3).(' J*/9-0 -* -.( 13' 6*+(5 /9 ;5/+( GBGBCK

    !0 A /0 *9( J3'- I-.( U./-( 13' 63+( *, A )L1(0K 39+ P /0 -.( *-.(' J3'- I-.( :'38 13'

    63+( *, P )L1(0KM JL--/9: -.( -U* 13'0 -*:(-.(' 632(0 LJ -.( gU.*5(i I-.( 5*9: 13'K$

    S.( gU.*5(i (\L350 -.( 0L6 *, P 39+ A$

    IS(3).(' 9*U J*/9-0 -* -.( &&Q +/3:'36M -.( 5*U(' J39(5 *, ;5/+( GBGBCK

    7(-e0 ,/55 -.( ,/'0- 1*O U/-. A 39+ -.( 0()*9+ 1*O U/-. P ,*' -.( -U* J3'-0 I*' -U* 0.*'-

    13'0KM 39+ GH /9 -.( 1/::(' 1*O *9 -.( *-.(' 0/+( *, -.( (\L35 0/:9 -* '(J'(0(9- -.(

    5*9: 13'M U./). /0 -.( U.*5(M *' 0L6 *, -.( -U* J3'-0$

    %9 0L663'8M -.( 13' 6*+(5 -(550 L0 -.3- -.( U./-( 13' 39+ -.( :'38 13' I-U* 0.*'-

    13'0K 632( LJ -.( 5*9: 13'$ S.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -(550 -.( 036( 0-*'8> N9(J3'- IAK 39+ -.( *-.(' J3'- IPKM U./). '(J'(0(9- -.( -U* 0.*'- 13'0M 632( LJ -.( U.*5(

    IGHKM U./). '(J'(0(9-0 -.( 5*9: 13'$ %9 *-.(' U*'+0M A p P q GH$

    =*U 5(-0e ).()2 -* 0(( U.(-.(' -.( 0L6 *, -.( -U* \L39-/-/(0 *9 -.( 5(,- 0/+( *, -.(

    (\L35 0/:9 /0 -.( 036( 30 I*' (\L350 -*K -.( \L39-/-8 3- -.( '/:.- 0/+( I*, -.( (\L35 0/:9K$

    7(,- 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9 I7;K> ApPqGHM

    R/:.- 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9 IR;K> GH$

    ;%)$O%2> X*(0 GH g(\L35i *' g-.( 036( 30i GHl

    5'(-%#'0> d(0M GH qGH$

    ;%)$O%2> S.3- 6(390 -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 *' -.( 0-3-(6(9- g&3'- 39+ &3'-

    632( LJ -.( Q.*5(i 632(0 0(90(M 39+ -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 /0 )*90/0-(9- U/-.

    -.( 13' 6*+(5$

    ;%)$O%2M7(-e0 5**2 3- ;5/+( GBGBP$IX/0J538 ;5/+( GBGBPK S.('( /0 *9( U./-( 13'M 39+ *9( :'38 13'$ Z3). '(J'(0(9-0

    3 9L61('$ %, -.( -U* 9L61('0 3'( @ 39+ CM U./). 13' '(J'(0(9-0 @l Q./). 13'

    '(J'(0(9-0 Cl

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    32/267

    #b!&SZR E

    GQ

    90#'& B,B,M

    5'(-%#'0MS.( U./-( 13' /0 @M 39+ -.( :'38 13' /0 C$

    ;%)$O%2MQ.8l

    5'(-%#'0> `**+ -./92/9:w %, U( JL- -*:(-.(' -.( -U* 13'0 30 0.*U9 /9 ;5/+( GBGBPB3M

    U.3- U*L5+ 1( -.( -*-35 5(9:-. *, -.( 5*9: 13'l

    90#'& B,B,M,*I

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    33/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    GM

    ;%)$O%2> S.3- 6(390M 7; q R;$ N'M -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 )*''()-58 '(J'(0(9-

    -.( 13' 6*+(5$

    90#'& B,B,M,2I

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    34/267

    #b!&SZR E

    G\

    7Z;;N= E> &!RSB&!RSBQbN7Z &RN S.( 0-*'8 /0 31*L- b(3-.('e0 )'38*90$

    ;%)$O%2> S.3- /0 '/:.-w %- /0 31*L- b(3-.('e0 )'38*90$ b*U 6398 )'38*90 +*(0 0.(

    .34( /9 -.( 1(:/99/9:l

    5'(-%#'> PC$

    ;%)$O%2> PC U.3-l

    5'(-%#'0> PC )'38*90$

    ;%)$O%20> S.(9 .*U 6398 )'38*90 +*(0 0.( :(- ,'*6 .(' 0/0-('M S3'3l

    5'(-%#'0> HE )'38*90$

    ;%)$O%2> !,-(' 0.( '()(/4(+ HE )'38*90 ,'*6 .(' 0/0-('M 0.( (9+(+ LJ U/-. .*U 6398

    )'38*90 /9 -*-35l

    5'(-%#'0> AD )'38*90$

    ;%)$O%2> 7(-e0 0(( /, U( )39 L0( 13' 6*+(50 -* '(J'(0(9- -.( 0-*'8$ % U/55 +'3U 3 )5(3'

    13' -* '(J'(0(9- -.( )'38*90 b(3-.(' .3+ /9 -.( 1(:/99/9: IPCK$ % U/55 -.(9 632( 30.3+(+ 13' -* '(J'(0(9- -.( )'38*90 S3'3 :34( -* .(' IHEK$

    !++/9: -.( -U* 13'0 -*:(-.(' 0.*L5+ '(J'(0(9- -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, )'38*90 b(3-.('

    .30 3- -.( (9+ I;(( ;5/+( GBEBGB3 1(5*UK$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    35/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    G]

    90#'& B,G,B,*

    54 32

    86

    ;%)$O%2> !1*4( /0 3 J/)-*'/35 '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 *, -.( 0-*'8 I/$($M gb(3-.(' .3+ PC )'38*90$

    S.(9M .(' 0/0-('M S3'3M :34( .(' HE 6*'( )'38*90$ =*U b(3-.(' .30 AD )'38*90$iK

    =*UM 5(-e0 0(( /, 8*L )39 63J -.( /9,*'63-/*9 *9-* -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 U(

    .34( 5(3'9(+ I+/0J538 ;5/+( GBEBGB1K

    7(-e0 5**2 3- -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -*:(-.('> g!*"%39+!*"%632( LJ *' (\L35 -.( ?7)0&$i

    =*UM U.* )39 -(55 6( U.3- 9L61(' :*(0 /9-* -.( ,/'0- 1*O /9 -.( &&Q +/3:'36

    (\L3-/*9l

    5'(-%#'0> llll

    ;%)$O%2MQ( .34( 5(3'9(+ -.3- -.( -U* 1*O(0 *9 *9( 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9 '(J'(0(9-

    J3'-0M 39+ -.( 1/: 1*O *9 -.( *-.(' 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9 '(J'(0(9-0 -.( C7)0&*' 6)%*0$

    ;* U.3- 9L61('0 U*L5+ % U'/-( /9 -.( ,/'0- 39+ 0()*9+ 1*O(0 -.3- 3'( 531(55(+ 30 g!*"%cl

    5'(-%#'0> gPCi 39+ gHE$i

    ;%)$O%2> c('8 :**+w Q( )39 U'/-( PC /9 -.( ,/'0- 1*O 39+ HE /9 -.( E9+ 1*On *' U(

    )39 U'/-( HE /9 -.( ,/'0- 1*O 39+ PC /9 -.( E9+ 1*O$ Z/-.(' U38 /0 -.( 036($

    Q.3- 9L61(' +* U( U'/-( /9 -.( 1/: 1*O ,*' -.( C7)0&M *' %)%*0l

    5'(-%#'0> gAD$i;%)$O%2M;LJ('w %- /0M /9 ,3)-M -.( -*-35 *, -.( -U* 0.*'- 13'0M *' -U* J3'-0$ 7(-e0 9*U

    5**2 3- -.( )*6J5(-(+ +/3:'36 30 0.*U9 /9 ;5/+( GBEBGB1$

    90#'& B,G,B, 2

    54 32

    86

    Part

    54 32 86

    Part

    + =

    Whole

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    36/267

    #b!&SZR E

    G[

    7(-0e ).()2 -* 0(( U.(-.(' -.(3/1*, -.( -U* \L39-/-/(0 *9 -.( 5(,- 0/+( *, -.( (\L35

    0/:9 /0 -.( 036( 30 I*' (\L35 -*K -.( \L39-/-8 *9 -.( '/:.- 0/+( *, -.( (\L35 0/:9$

    7;> PC p HE q AD

    R;> AD

    X*(0 AD (\L35M *' /0 /- -.( 036( 30M ADl

    5'(-%#'0Md(0M AD /0 -.( 036( 30 AD$

    ;%)$O%2MS.3- 6(390M 7; q R;$ N'M gJ3'- 39+ J3'- +/+ 632( LJ -.( U.*5(wi !++/9:

    -.( -U* J3'-0 -*:(-.(' Zz]!7; -.( C7)0&$ S.( 13' 6*+(5M 39+ -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M

    -(550 -.( 036( 0-*'8> gb(3-.(' .3+ PC )'38*90$ S.(9 .(' 0/0-('M S3'3M :34( .(' HE

    6*'( )'38*90$ =*U b(3-.(' .30 AD )'38*90$i

    %9 0L663'8M 30 J'(0(9-(+ /9 ;5/+( Z.V.Z.3M 1*-. -.( 13' 6*+(5 39+ -.( +/3:'36

    6*+(5 -(55 L0>!*"%IPCK 39+!*"%IHEK 632( LJ -.( ?7)0&IADKn )"M -U* 0.*'- 13'0 IPC39+ HEK 632( LJ -.( 5*9: 13' IADK$ S.( 13' 6*+(5 39+ -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -(55 -.(

    036( 0-*'8> g!*"%39+!*"%632( LJ -.( ?7)0&$i

    7(-e0 -'8 63JJ/9: -.( 0-*'8 -* -.( 13' 6*+(5M *' +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M U/-. 39*-.(' 0-*'8$

    9%)"S fB,G,G

    H)$O%* O)- QX [*"W%20 7# ) 378 6)0%S ;O%#T Z\ "[ 'O% [*"W%20 W7*'%-T 0" 0O% '""]

    'O"0% "#%0 "('S ;O%# 'O%2% W%2% V\ [*"W%20 *%[' 7# 'O% 6)0%S

    I;-L+(9-0 '(3+ -.( 0-*'8 -*:(-.('K

    ;%)$O%2M Q.3- /0 -./0 0-*'8 355 31*L-l

    5'(-%#'0M S.( 0-*'8 /0 31*L- R3).(5e0 ,5*U('0$;%)$O%2M S.3- /0 '/:.-w b*U 6398 ,5*U('0 +*(0 0.( .34( /9 3 1/: 430( 3- -.( 1(:/99/9:l

    5'(-%#'M CA ,5*U('0$

    ;%)$O%20M S.(9 U.3- .3JJ(9(+ -* -.( ,5*U('0l

    5'(-%#'0M G? *, -.( ,5*U('0 U/5-(+$

    ;%)$O%20M ;* R3).(5 -**2 -.(6 *L- *, -.( 430(M 39+ U30 5(,- U/-. .*U 6398 ,5*U('0

    /9 -.( 430(l

    5'(-%#'0M E? ,5*U('0$

    ;%)$O%2M 7(-e0 +'3U 3 13' -* J'(0(9- -.( CA ,5*U('0 0.( .3+ /9 -.( 1(:/99/9:$ S.(9

    U( -32( 3U38 -.( G?M 39+ -* 0.*U -.3- 0.( /0 5(,- U/-. E? ,5*U('0$

    IS(3).(' +(6*90-'3-(0 -.( +'3U/9:M *9( J3'- 3- 3 -/6($K

    IX/0J538 05/+(0 GBEBGB3K

    ;%)$O%2M7(-e0 5**2 3- ;5/+( GBEBEB3>

    Q( 0-3'- U/-. -.( 5*9: 13' -.3- '(J'(0(9- -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, ,5*U('0 ICAK /9 -.( 430(

    /9 -.( 1(:/99/9: *, -.( J'*15(6$ S.(9M J3'- *, -.( ,5*U('0 U/5-(+M 0* U( 63'2 *,,

    J3'- *, -.( 13' -* '(J'(0(9- -.( ,5*U('0 -.3- U('( -32(9 *L- *, -.( 430( IG?K$ Y/93558M

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    37/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    G_

    -.( 5(,-*4(' 0(:6(9- *, -.( 13' '(J'(0(9-0 -.( ,5*U('0 -.3- U('( 5(,- /9 -.( 430( IE?K$

    !:3/9M 3++/9: -.( ,5*U('0 -.3- U('( U/5-(+ 39+ -.( ,5*U('0 -.3- U('( 5(,- /9 -.( 430(

    0.*L5+ 1( -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, ,5*U('0 -.3- U('( /9 -.( 430( /9 -.( 1(:/99/9: ICAK$

    =*UM 5(-e0 0(( /, 8*L )39 63J -.( /9,*'63-/*9 *9-* -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 U(.34( 5(3'9(+ I+/0J538 ;5/+( GBEBGB1K$

    7(-e0 5**2 3- -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -*:(-.('> g!*"%39+!*"- 632( LJ -.( ?7)0&$i

    ;%)$O%2MQ.* )39 -(55 6( U.3- 9L61('0 0.*L5+ :* /9-* -.( ,/'0- -U* 1*O(0 -.3- 3'(

    531(55(+ 30!*"%/9 -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9l

    5'(-%#'0> G? 39+ E?$

    ;%)$O%2> S.3-e0 '/:.-$ S.( -U* 1*O(0 *9 -.( 5(,- 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9 '(J'(0(9- -.(

    .*"%3M 39+ -.( 1/: 1*O *9 -.( *-.(' 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9 '(J'(0(9-0 -.( C7)0&*' 6)%*0$

    ;*M G? 39+ E?M -.( -U* J3'-0 IU./). 3'( -.( ,5*U('0 -.3- U('( U/5-(+M 39+ -.( ,5*U('0

    -.3- U('( 5(,- *4(' /9 -.( 430(KM U/55 :* /9-* -.( -U* 1*O(0 -.3- 3'( 531(55(+ 30 g!*"%Ic

    Q.3- 9L61(' +* U( U'/-( /9 -.( 1/: 1*O ,*' -.( C7)0&M *' -*-35l

    5'(-%#'0> CAM -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, ,5*U('0$;%)$O%2> ;LJ('$ 7(-e0 9*U 5**2 3- -.( )*6J5(-(+ ;5/+( GBEBEB 1$

    90#'& B,G,G, 2

    19 29

    48

    Part

    19 29 48

    Part

    + =

    Whole

    90#'& B,G,G,*

    19 29

    48

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    38/267

    #b!&SZR E

    OL

    ;%)$O%2M%, U( J((5 *,, -.( 1*O(0 /9 31*4( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M U( :(->

    G? p E? q CA

    7(-0e ).()2 -* 0(( U.(-.(' -.( 0L6 *, -.( -U* \L39-/-/(0 *9 -.( 5(,- 0/+( I7;K *, -.(

    (\L35 0/:9 /0 -.( 036( 30 I*' (\L350 -*K -.( \L39-/-8 *9 -.( '/:.- 0/+( IR;K *, -.(

    (\L35 0/:9$

    7;> G? p E?

    ;%)$O%2MQ.* )39 -(55 6( -.(3/1*, G? 39+ E?l

    5'(-%#'0> CA$

    ;%)$O%2> `**+$ G? J5L0 E? (\L350 CAn -.3- /0M

    7;> G? p E? q CA

    S.( \L39-/-8 *9 -.( R; *, -.( (\L3-/*9 /0> R;q CA$X*(0 CA (\L35M *' /0 /- -.( 036( 30M CAl

    5'(-%#'0> d(0$ CA /0 -.( 036( 30 CA$

    ;%)$O%2MS.3- 6(390M 7; q R;$ %9 *-.(' U*'+0M.*"%39+.*"%'#'632( LJ -.( C7)0&$

    !++/9: -.( -U* J3'-0 -*:(-.(' Zz]!7; -.( U.*5($

    !0 J'(0(9-(+ /9 5*7-% Z.V.Z.3M -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -(550> G? U/5-(+ ,5*U('0

    I*9(.*"%KM 39+ E? ,5*U('0 5(,- /9 -.( 430( I-.( *-.('.*"%KM 632( LJ -.( -*-35 ,5*U('0

    ICAK /9 -.( 430( /9 -.( 1(:/99/9: I-.( C7)0&K$ ;/6/53'58M -.( 13' 6*+(5 -(550> -U*

    0.*'- 13'0 IG? U/5-(+ ,5*U('0 39+ E? 5(,- /9 -.( 430(K 632( LJ -.( 5*9: 13' ICA -*-35

    ,5*U('0K$

    %9 0L663'8M -.( 13' 6*+(5 39+ -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -(55 -.( 036( 0-*'8> gJ3'- 39+

    J3'- 632( LJ -.( U.*5($i %9 *-.(' U*'+0M -.( 9L61(' *, ,5*U('0 /9 -.( 430( /9 -.(1(:/99/9: ICAK /0 -.( 0L6 *, -.( 9L61(' *, ,5*U('0 -.3- U('( U/5-(+ 39+ -32(9 3U38

    !=X -.( 9L61(' *, ,5*U('0 -.3- U('( 5(,- /9 -.( 430($

    7(-e0 -'8 63JJ/9: -.( 0-*'8 -* -.( 13' 6*+(5 39+ +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 U/-. 39*-.('

    J'*15(6$

    9%)"S fB,G,O

    J' 2)7#%- QP 7#$O%0 7# V^^YT )#- 7' 2)7#%- P_ 7#$O%0 7# V^^PS J' 2)7#%- ) '"')* "[

    Z^V 7#$O%0 7# 'O% 'W" R%)20 $"437#%-S

    !,-(' 0-L+(9-0 '(3+ -.( 0-*'8 -*:(-.('>

    ;%)$O%2MQ.3- /0 -./0 0-*'8 355 31*L-l

    5'(-%#'0MS.( 0-*'8 /0 31*L- -.( '3/9,355 /9 EFFD 39+ /9 EFFP$

    ;%)$O%2Md(0$ Q.3- /0 -.( '3/9,355 /9 EFFDl

    5'(-%#'0MCP /9).(0$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    39/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    OB

    ;%)$O%2MQ.3- /0 -.( '3/9,355 /9 EFFPl

    5'(-%#'0MP@ /9).(0$

    ;%)$O%2M% U/55 302 8*L -* )*6( -* -.( 1*3'+ 39+ +'3U -.( 13' 6*+(5 ,*' -.( '3/9,355

    /9 8(3' EFFD 39+ 8(3' EFFP$

    IS(3).(' )3550 *9 4*5L9-(('0 -* +'3U -.( 13' 6*+(50 ,*' -.( '3/9,355 /9 8(3' EFFD 39+

    8(3' EFFP$K

    ;%)$O%2M `**+ f*1 /9 632/9: -.( 13' ,*' -.( '3/9,355 ,*' EFFD 39+ 39*-.(' 13' ,*'

    EFFP$ % U/55 L0( 1'3)(0 -* /9+/)3-( *9 -.( 13' 6*+(5 -.3-M -.( ,/'0- 0.*'- 13' '(J'(0(9-0

    -.( '3/9,355 ICP /9).(0K /9 EFFDM -.( E9+ 0.*'- 13' '(J'(0(9-0 -.( '3/9,355 IP@ /9).(0K

    /9 EFFP$ ;(( ;5/+( GBEBHB3$

    90#'& B,G,O,*

    45 57

    45 57

    102

    ;%)$O%20> ;* -.( -*-35 '3/9,355 +L'/9: -.(0( -U* 8(3'0 U/55 1(l5'(-%#'0> GFE /9).(0$

    ;%)$O%2> Q.* )39 .(5J 6( /9+/)3-(M L0/9: -.( 1'3)(0 30 % .34( fL0- +(6*90-'3-(+M

    -.( -*-35 '3/9,355 *, 1*-. 8(3' EFFD 39+ 8(3' EFFPl

    I;-L+(9-0 3'( (OJ()-(+ -* 632( -.( 1'3)( ,*' -.( (9-/'( 13' 39+ /9+/)3-( -.( 9L61('

    *, /9).(0M GFEM ,*' -.( (9-/'( 13' 30 ,*55*U0K

    ;%)$O%2M7(-e0 5**2 3- -.( 31*4( 13' 6*+(5$

    S.( 0.3+(+ 13' '(J'(0(9-0 -.( '3/9,355 ,*' -.( 8(3' EFFD$ S.( +3'2 13' '(J'(0(9-0

    -.( '3/9,355 ,*' -.( 8(3' EFFP$ !++/9: -.(0( -U* 13'0 -*:(-.(' 0.*L5+ '(J'(0(9- -.(

    -*-35 '3/9,355 ,*' 1*-. EFFD 39+ EFFP$ Q.3- /0 -.( -*-35 '3/9,355 ,*' -.( -U* 8(3'0

    )*61/9(+l

    5'(-%#'0MGFE

    ;%)$O%2MGFE U.3-l

    5'(-%#'0> GFE /9).(0$

    ;%)$O%2> `**+w =*UM % 9((+ 3 4*5L9-((' -* '(J'(0(9- -.( 0-*'8 /9 -.( &&Q +/3:'36

    (\L3-/*9$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    40/267

    #b!&SZR E

    OG

    IS(3).(' J'(0(9-0 -.( &&Q X/3:'36 Z\L3-/*9$ S(3).(' -.(9 )3550 *9 0-L+(9-

    4*5L9-(('0$ ;-L+(9- 4*5L9-(('0 )*6J5(-( -.( 63JJ/9: *, -.( /9,*'63-/*9 -* -.( &&Q

    +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 *9 -.( 1*3'+$ S.( '(0- *, -.( 0-L+(9-0 U/55 U*'2 *9 -.( 0-L+(9-

    U*'20.((-0K$

    ;%)$O%2M 7(-e0 5**2 3- -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -*:(-.('> g&3'- 39+ &3'- 632(

    LJ -.( U.*5($i Q.3- +* -.( -U* 06355 1*O(0 *9 -.( 5(,- 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9

    0-39+ ,*'l

    5'(-%#'0> S.( ,/'0- 1*O 0-39+0 ,*' -.( '3/9,355 +L'/9: -.( 8(3' EFFD$ S.( 0()*9+ 1*O

    0-39+0 ,*' -.( '3/9,355 +L'/9: -.( 8(3' EFFP$

    ;%)$O%2> Q.3- +*(0 -.( 1/: 1*O *9 -.( *-.(' 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9 0-39+ ,*'l

    5'(-%#'0M%- 0-39+0 ,*' -.( -*-35 '3/9,355 +L'/9: 1*-. 8(3'0> EFFD *$'EFFP$

    ;%)$O%2> ;LJ('$ 7(-e0 9*U 5**2 3- -.( )*6J5(-(+ 13' 6*+(5 39+ -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9

    -*:(-.(' I;5/+( GBEBHB1K$

    90#'& B,G,O,2

    45 57

    102

    Part

    45 57 102

    Part

    + =

    Whole

    ;%)$O%2M!'( -.( 13' 6*+(5 39+ -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -(55/9: -.( 036( 0-*'8l

    5'(-%#'0> d(0$ S.( -U* 1*O(0 3'( '(J'(0(9-/9: -.( -U* 0.*'- 13'0M 39+ -.( 1/: 1*O

    '(J'(0(9-0 -.( )*61/93-/*9 *, 1*-. 0.*'- 13'0$

    7(-0e ).()2 U.(-.(' -.( 0L6 *, -.( -U* \L39-/-/(0 *9 -.( 5(,- 0/+( *, -.( (\L35

    0/:9 I7;K /0 -.( 036( 30 I*' (\L35 -*K -.( \L39-/-8 *9 -.( '/:.- 0/+( *, -.( (\L35

    0/:9 IR;K$

    % 9((+ 3 4*5L9-((' -* +* -./0 *9 -.( 1*3'+$

    IS(3).(' )3550 *9 3 4*5L9-(('K

    5'(-%#' I"*(#'%%2M

    7;> CP p P@ q GFE

    ;%)$O%2> **+ f*1ww Q.* )39 (OJ'(00 -.( \L39-/-8 ,*' -.( *-.(' 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9l

    IS(3).(' )3550 *9 39*-.(' 4*5L9-(('$K

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    41/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    OO

    5'(-%#' I"*(#'%%2>

    R;> GFE

    ;%)$O%2> %0 -.( \L39-/-8 *9 -.( 7; *, -.( (\L3-/*9 -.( 036( 30 -.( \L39-/-8 *9 -.(

    R; *, -.( (\L3-/*9l

    5'(-%#'0> d(0$ GFE /0 -.( 036( 30M *' (\L35 -*M GFEw

    ;%)$O%2MS.3- 6(390 8*L .34( )*''()-58 63JJ(+ -.( /9,*'63-/*9 *9-* -.( +/3:'36M

    39+.*"%39+.*"%'#'632( LJ -.( C7)0&$ %9 *-.(' U*'+0M 3++/9: -.( '3/9,355 ,'*6

    EFFD 39+ EFFP ICP /9).(0 39+ P@ /9).(0K (\L350 -.( -*-35 '3/9,355 ,*' 1*-. 8(3'0M

    U./). /0 GFE /9).(0$

    %9 0L663'8M -.( 13' 6*+(5 39+ -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -(55 -.( 036( 0-*'8> &3'-

    39+ &3'- 632( LJ -.( Q.*5($

    =*U 8*L U/55 -'8 -* '(J'(0(9- -.( 0-*'8 *9-* -.( 13' 6*+(5 39+ +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 *9

    8*L' *U9$

    X%RZ#S%N=; YNR SRdB%SBN]S !=X %=XZ&Z=XZ=S QNRh;bZZS

    %9 -.( 1(5*U U*'20.((-0M ,/'0-M 8*L U/55 L0( -.( 13' 6*+(5 -* '(J'(0(9- -.( 0-*'8$

    S.(9 8*L U/55 63J -.( /9,*'63-/*9 /9-* -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9$ !,-(' 8*L

    63J -.( /9,*'63-/*9 /9-* -.( +/3:'36M 8*L U/55 ).()2 U.(-.(' -.( 0L6 *, -.(

    -U* \L39-/-/(0 ,'*6 -.( 5(,- 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9 %; SbZ ;!WZ !;M *' Zz]!7

    -*M -.( \L39-/-8 ,'*6 -.( '/:.- 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9$ %, =NSM 8*L 9((+ -* ).()2

    -.( 3))L'3)8 *, 8*L' 63JJ/9: 3:3/90- -.( 0-*'8 J'*4/+(+$ W32( 0L'( 8*L .34(M1*-.M )*''()-58 (9-('(+ -.( -U* .*"%3 /9-* -.( -U* 06355(' 1*O(0 531(55(+ .*"%M

    39+ -.3- 8*L .34( )*''()-58 (9-('(+ -.( %)%*0 /9 -.( 1/::(' 1*O 531(55(+ C7)0&

    *9 -.( *-.(' 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9$ !,-(' )*''()-/9: -.( 63JJ/9: /9 -.( +/3:'36M

    8*L U/55 ).()2 3:3/9 U.(-.(' -.( 0L6 *, -.( -U* J3'-0 ,'*6 -.( 5(,- 0/+( *, -.(

    (\L3-/*9 %; SbZ ;!WZ !;M *' Zz]!7 -*M -.( \L39-/-8 ,'*6 -.( '/:.- 0/+( *, -.(

    (\L3-/*9$

    6"S #% U/%g!!? 9%)"S =&."&3&$%*%#)$ QZ MZ *$' \

    C$ S.( J*L9+ .3+ D@ +*:0 /9 )3:(0 U3/-/9: -* 1( 3+*J-(+$ N9( U((2M EC *, -.( +*:0

    U('( 3+*J-(+$ S.('( U('( 0-/55 CH 5(,- 3- -.( J*L9+$

    P$ ! 1302(-1355 J538(' 936(+ ;3'3. 0)*'(+ CH J*/9-0 /9 -.( ,/'0- .35, *, 3 :36($ S.(9

    0.( 0)*'(+ GE 6*'( J*/9-0 /9 -.( 0()*9+ .35,$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    42/267

    #b!&SZR E

    OQ

    A$'&.&$'&$% ?)"@37&&%g!!? 9%)"S =&."&3&$%*%#)$ ]Z [ *$' _

    @$ N9( -(3).(' .3+ EH ,530.)3'+0 ,*' ./0 0-L+(9-0$ !9*-.(' -(3).(' .3+ A? ,530.)3'+0$

    %9 -*-35M -.( -U* -(3).('0 .3+ GGE ,530.)3'+0$

    A$ N9( 0-L+(9-e0 6*6 132(+ PD )**2/(0 ,*' -.( )5300 J3'-8$ b(' 0*9 39+ ./0 ,'/(9+0

    3-( HE *, -.( )**2/(0 1(,*'( 0.( U*2( LJ$ S.('( U('( *958 EC )**2/(0 5(,- ,*' -.(

    J3'-8$

    ?$ ! )3- )3L:.- EH 6/)( /9 -.( 0J'/9: 39+ 0L66('$ %9 -.( ,355 39+ U/9-('M -.( 036(

    )3- )3L:.- PH 6/)($ S.( )3- )3L:.- 3 -*-35 *, @D 6/)( -.3- 8(3'$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    43/267

    OM

    ]=%S E

    5?=IJAE 1,5

    7Z;;N= H> ;N7c%=` &&Q &RN

    X/3:'36 &3'-B&3'-BQ.*5( I&&QK X/3:'36 Z\L3-/*9 W*+(5&*0-(' &&Q ?)"' !")20&1 K?!N;%)"S T"*11*"&*0-('

    N4('.(3+ W*+(5/9: W*+(5/9: &&Q J'*15(6 0*54/9: GM EM 39+ H

    ;-L+(9- Q*'20.((-0 W*+(5/9: &&Q J'*15(6 0*54/9: GM EM 39+ H

    S'8 %- NL-t&&Q J'*15(6 0*54/9: CM PM 39+ D

    %9+(J(9+(9- Q*'20.((-t&&Q J'*15(6 0*54/9: @M A

    39+ ?

    R(,('(9)( `L/+( ]9/- G> R(,('(9)( `L/+(t&&Q J'*15(6 0*54/9: Gt?$

    yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

    ;%)$O%2> %9 -.( 530- ]9/-M U( 5(3'9(+ .*U -* L0( -.( 13' 6*+(5 39+ +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9

    -* '(J'(0(9- &&Q J'*15(60$ %9 -./0 L9/-M U( U/55 L0( -.( 13' 6*+(5 39+ -.( +/3:'36

    (\L3-/*9 -* .(5J L0 0*54( '(35 U*'5+ J'*15(60$

    !")20&1 fG,O,B

    !O270'7% 2%)- 'W" 3""]0 "6%2 'O% 0(44%2S ?#% 3""] W)0 Z\U &)8%0 )#- 'O%

    "'O%2 3""] W)0 VY_ &)8%0S G"W 4)#R &)8%0 -7- !O270'7% 2%)- "6%2 'O% 0(44%2`

    I;-L+(9-0 '(3+ -.( 0-*'8 -*:(-.('$K

    ;%)$O%2MU.3- /0 -./0 J'*15(6 355 31*L-l

    5'(-%#'0M S.( J'*15(6 /0 31*L- -.( -U* 1**20 #.'/0-/( '(3+ *4(' -.( 0L66('$

    ;%)$O%2M S.3-e0 '/:.-$ Q.3- (50( +*(0 /- -(55 L0l

    5'(-%#'0M N9( 1**2 /0 G?H J3:(0M 39+ -.( *-.(' 1**2 /0 ED@ J3:(0$

    ;%)$O%2M `**+$ Q.3- 3'( U( 302(+ -* 0*54( ,*'l

    5'(-%#'0M b*U 6398 J3:(0 +/+ #.'/0-/( '(3+ *4(' -.( 0L66('l;%)$O%2M `'(3-$ 7(-e0 L9+('5/9( -.( \L(0-/*9 /9 8*L' U*'20.((-$ I;-L+(9-0 L9+('5/9(

    -.( \L(0-/*9 /9 -.(/' U*'20.((-n -(3).(' +*(0 0* *9 -.( 1*3'+$K

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    44/267

    #b!&SZR E

    O\

    7(-e0 9*U L0( -.( 13' 6*+(50 -* '(J'(0(9- -.( J'*15(6$ % U/55 +'3U 3 13' -* '(J'(0(9-

    -.( 9L61(' *, J3:(0 /9 -.( ,/'0- 1**2 -.3- #.'/0-/( '(3+ IG?HK I;(( ;5/+( EBGB3K$

    Q.* )39 .(5J U/-. +'3U/9: 3 13' -* '(J'(0(9- -.( 9L61(' *, J3:(0 /9 -.( E9+ 1**2

    -.3- #.'/0-/( '(3+l

    IS(3).(' )355 *9 3 0-L+(9- 4*5L9-(('K

    I;-L+(9- 4*5L9-((' +'3U0 3 E9+ 13' 9(O- -* -.( ,/'0- 13' -* '(J'(0(9- -.( 9L61(' *,

    J3:(0 ^ED@_ /9 -.( E9+ 1**2 -.3- #.'/0-/( '(3+$K

    ;%)$O%2M !9+ -.( \L(0-/*9 3020 31*L- -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, J3:(0 #.'/0-/( '(3+ *4('

    -.( 0L66('$ % U/55 632( 3 1'3)( -* /9+/)3-( -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, J3:(0 *4(' -.( -U*

    0.*'- 13'0M U./). '(J'(0(9- -.( 9L61(' *, J3:(0 /9 1*-. -.( ,/'0- 39+ 0()*9+ 1**2

    -.3- #.'/0-/( '(3+$ ;(( 05/+( EBHBGB3$

    90#'& G,O,B,*

    ?

    193 267

    ;%)$O%2M!1*4( /0 3 J/)-*'/35 '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 *, -.( J'*15(6 L0/9: -.( 13' 6*+(5$

    S.( ,/'0- 0.*'- 13' '(J'(0(9-0 -.( 9L61(' *, J3:(0 #.'/0-/( '(3+ /9 -.( ,/'0- 1**2n -.(

    E9+ 0.*'- 13' '(J'(0(9-0 -.( 9L61(' *, J3:(0 /9 -.( E9+ 1**2 -.3- 0.( '(3+$ !++/9:

    -.( -U* 13'0 -*:(-.(' U*L5+ 0.*U -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, J3:(0 /9 1*-. 1**20$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    45/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    O]

    ;%)$O%2M;5/+( EBHBGB3 '(J'(0(9-0 -.( 0-*'8 *, J'*15(6 G$ ;5/+( EBHBGB1 '(J'(0(9-0

    -.( 63-.(63-/)35 '(53-/*9 /9 -.( J'*15(6$ S* ,/9+ *L- -.( 390U(' -* gb*U 6398

    J3:(0 +/+ #.'/0-/( '(3+ *4(' -.( 0L66('Mi U()39 :(9('3-( 3 63-. 0(9-(9)( 130(+

    *9 -.( 13' 6*+(5$ S.3- /0M

    S*-35 s *, J3:(0 q -.( ,/'0- 0.*'- 13' p -.( E9+ 0.*'- 13'M *'

    S*-35 s *, J3:(0 q G?HpED@ q CDF$

    b*U(4('M /, U( L0( -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M -.( 63-. 0(9-(9)( I*' (\L3-/*9K ,*'

    0*54/9: -.( J'*15(6 /0 :/4(9 18 -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9$ S.3- /0M /, U( J((5 *,, -.(

    1*O(0 ,'*6 -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M U( :(-

    G?H p ED@ q l

    N' l q G?H p ED@ q CDF$

    Q.3- /0 3 )*6J5(-( 390U(' -* -./0 J'*15(6l

    5'(-%#'0MS.( 390U(' /0> #.'/0-/( '(3+ 3 -*-35 *, CDF J3:(0 *4(' -.(0L66('$

    ;%)$O%2M;LJ('w

    S.( '(30*9 U( L0( 1*-. -.( 13' 6*+(5 39+ -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 /0 -.3- -.( 13' 6*+(5

    .(5J0 L0 -* L9+('0-39+ -.( 6(39/9: *, -.( J'*15(6M 30 U(55 30 -.( 6(39/9: *, -.(

    +/3:'36$ 73-(' /9 -.( J'*:'36M U( U/55 9*- .34( -* +'3U -.( 13' 6*+(50$ %90-(3+M

    U( )39 +/'()-58 L0( -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -* '(J'(0(9- 39+ 0*54( J'*15(60M 30

    -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 J'*4/+(0 L0 U/-. 3 +(,/9(+ 63-. 0(9-(9)(M *' (\L3-/*9M ,*' *L'

    0*5L-/*9$

    7(-e0 5**2 3- *9( 6*'( J'*15(6 39+ '(J'(0(9- /- U/-. 1*-. 3 13' 6*+(5 39+ -.( +/3:'36

    (\L3-/*9$ !,-(' -.3-M U( U/55 *958 L0( -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -* '(J'(0(9- 39+

    0*54( -.( J'*15(6$

    !")20&1 fG,O,G

    ;O% E72* 5$"('0 W%2% 0%**7#8 $""]7%0 )' 'O% 4)**S ;O%R 32"(8O' \U 3"a%0 "[

    $""]7%0 W7'O 'O%4T )#- 'O%R 0"*- Q_ 3"a%0 'O)' -)RS G"W 4)#R 3"a%0 "[ $""]7%0

    W7** 'O% E72* 5$"('0 O)6% '" ')]% 3)$] O"4%`

    I;-L+(9-0 '(3+ -.( 0-*'8 -*:(-.('$K

    ;%)$O%2MQ.3- /0 -./0 J'*15(6 355 31*L-l

    5'(-%#'0M S.( J'*15(6 /0 31*L- -.( `/'5 ;)*L-0 0(55/9: )**2/(0$ S.(8 .34( 3 -*-35 *,

    ?H 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0M -.(8 0*5+ C@ 1*O(0$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    46/267

    #b!&SZR E

    O[

    ;%)$O%2M Q.3- 3'( U( 302(+ -* 0*54( ,*'l

    5'(-%#'0M b*U 6398 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 U/55 -.( `/'5 ;)*L-0 .34( -* -32( 13)2 .*6(l

    ;%)$O%2M `'(3-$ % U/55 L9+('5/9( -.( \L(0-/*9 *9 -.( 1*3'+M 39+ 8*L U/55 +* /- /9 8*L'

    U*'20.((-$

    =*U 7(-e0 L0( -.( 13' 6*+(5 -* '(J'(0(9- -.( J'*15(6$ % U/55 302 4*5L9-(('0 -* +'3U

    -.( 13' 6*+(5 *9 -.( 1*3'+ -* '(J'(0(9- -.( J'*15(6$

    Q.* U/55 +'3U 3 13' -* '(J'(0(9- -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 -.( :/'5 0)*L-0

    1'*L:.- -* -.( 6355 -* 0(55 I?HKl

    IS(3).(' )3550 *9 3 4*5L9-(('$ S.( 4*5L9-((' 632(0 3 13' -* '(J'(0(9- -.( -*-35 9L61('

    *, 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0$ N-.(' 0-L+(9-0 U/55 +* -.( 036( /9 -.(/' U*'20.((-K;(( ;5/+( EBHBEB3 1(5*U$

    90#'& G,O,G,*

    93

    ;%)$O%2MS.( 31*4( 13' '(J'(0(9-0 -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 -.(8 1'*L:.-

    -* 0(55$ b*U 6398 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 +/+ -.(8 0(55 -.3- +38l

    5'(-%#'0> S.(8 0*5+ C@ 1*O(0$

    ;%)$O%2> %90-(3+ *, 632/9: 39*-.(' 13'M % U/55 63'2 *,, J*'-/*9 *, -.( 5*9: 13' -*/9+/)3-( -.( 9L61(' *, 1*O(0 -.3- U('( 0*5+ I0(( ;5/+( EBHBEB1K$ d*L U/55 +* -.( 036(

    /9 8*L' U*'20.((-$

    90#'& G,O,G,2

    93

    47

    ;%)$O%2> ;* /, -.( (9-/'( 13' '(J'(0(9-0 -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 -.(81'*L:.- I/$($M ?HKM 39+ -.( 0.3+(+ 13' '(J'(0(9-0 -.( 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 0*5+M U.3- +*(0

    -.( )5(3' 13' '(J'(0(9-l

    5'(-%#'0> S.( 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 -.3- U('( 9*- 0*5+$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    47/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    O_

    ;%)$O%2> S.3- /0 '/:.-$ %- /0 -.( 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 -.3- U('( 9*- 0*5+M *'M -.( 9L61('

    *, 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 -.3- -.( `/'5 ;)*L-0 .34( -* -32( 13)2 .*6(M U./). /0 U.3- U(

    3'( 302(+ -* ,/9+ *L-$ % U/55 L0( 3 \L(0-/*9 63'2 -* /9+/)3-( -.( L929*U9 \L39-/-8 *9

    -.( 13' I;5/+( EBHBEB)K

    90#'& G,O,G,+

    47

    93

    ?

    Q.* )39 .(5J U/-. -.( '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 *, -.( J'*15(6 /9 -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9

    1(5*U -.( 13' 6*+(5l IS(3).(' 632(0 -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 6*+(5 1(5*U -.(

    13' 6*+(5M 39+ -.(9 )3550 *9 0-L+(9-0 -* ,/55 /9 -.( 9L61('0 /9 -.( +/3:'36$K

    IS(3).(' )3550 *9 3 4*5L9-(('K

    I;-L+(9- 4*5L9-((' 632(0 -.( '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 /9 -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9K I;(( ;5/+(

    EBHBEB+M -.( 5*U(' J39(5K

    90#'& G,O,G,'

    47

    93

    ?

    Part

    47 ? 93

    Part

    + =

    Whole

    ;%)$O%2M7(-e0 5**2 3- -.( 31*4( ;5/+( EBHBEB+$ S.( -*J J3'- /0 -.( 13' 6*+(5$%9 -.( 13' 6*+(5M -.( ,/'0- 0.*'- 13' '(J'(0(9-0 -.( 9L61(' *, 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 0*5+

    IC@K$ S.( E9+ 0.*'- 13' '(J'(0(9-0 -.( 9L61(' *, 1*O(0 5(,- L90*5+$ S.( (9-/'( 13'

    '(J'(0(9-0 -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 -.(8 1'*L:.- -* 0(55$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    48/267

    #b!&SZR E

    QL

    7(-e0 5**2 3- -.( 5*U(' J39(5M *' -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9>

    S.( ,/'0- 1*O /9 -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 '(J'(0(9-0 -.( 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 0*5+M -.(

    0()*9+ 1*O '(J'(0(9-0 -.( 5(,-*4(' L90*5+ 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0M 39+ -.( 1/: 1*O *9 -.(

    *-.(' 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9 '(J'(0(9-0 -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 ,*' 035($

    !++/9: -.( -U* J3'-0 I1*O(0 0*5+ 39+ -.( 1*O(0 L90*5+K -*:(-.(' 0.*L5+ 632( LJM *'

    (\L35M -.( U.*5($

    %9 0L663'8M -.( 13' 6*+(5 39+ -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 '(J'(0(9-3-/*90 -(55 -.( 036(

    0-*'8 /9 -.( J'*15(6$

    S* ,/9+ *L- -.( 390U(' -* gb*U 6398 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 U/55 -.( `/'5 ;)*L-0 .34( -*

    -32( 13)2 .*6(liU()39 :(9('3-( 3 63-. 0(9-(9)( 130(+ *9 -.( 13' 6*+(5$ S.3- /0M

    /9 *'+(' -* ,/9+ -.( +/,,('(9)( 1(-U((9 -.( 5*9: 13' 39+ -.( 0.*'- 13' U( 0L1-'3)-$ S.(

    63-. 0(9-(9)( U*L5+ '(3+>

    l q ?HtC@S.('(,*'(M l q CD$

    =*U U( 29*U -.3- -.( E9+ 0.*'-M )5(3' 13' /0 CDM 6(39/9: -.('( 3'( CD 1*O(0 *,

    )**2/(0 -.3- U('( 9*- 0*5+M *' CD 1*O(0 -.3- -.( :/'5 0)*L-0 .34( -* -32( 13)2 .*6($

    b*U(4('M /, U( L0( -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M -.( 63-. 0(9-(9)( ,*' 0*54/9: -.(

    J'*15(6 /0 :/4(9 18 -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9$ S.3- /0M /, U( gJ((5 *,,i -.( 1*O(0 ,'*6

    -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M U( :(-

    C@ p l q ?H

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    49/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    QB

    Q.3- /0 3 )*6J5(-( 390U(' -* -./0 J'*15(6l

    5'(-%#'0> S.( 390U(' /0> S.( `/'5 ;)*L-0 U/55 .34( -* -32( CD 1*O(0 *, )**2/(0 13)2

    .*6($

    ;%)$O%2> c('8 :**+w

    Q( .34( :*9( -.'*L:. 0(4('35 J'*15(60 L0/9: 1*-. -.( 13' 6*+(5 39+ -.( &&Q

    +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M 39+ 5(3'9(+ -.3- -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -(550 -.( 036( 0-*'8

    I-.3- /0M g&3'- 39+ &3'- 632( LJ -.( Q.*5(iK 30 -.( 13' 6*+(5$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    50/267

    #b!&SZR E

    QG

    ;%)$O%2M d*L 3'( '/:.-$ %- /0 0-/55 -.( &&Q J'*15(6 0-'L)-L'($ ;* 5(-e0 L0( -.( &&Q

    +/3:'36 -* '(J'(0(9- -.( /9,*'63-/*9 ,'*6 -.( J'*15(6$

    ;%)$O%2M % U/55 632( -.( &&Q +/3:'36 *9 -.( 1*3'+$ % U/55 302 ,*' 8*L' .(5J -* ,/55

    -.( 9L61('0 /9-* -.( &&Q 6*+(5 (\L3-/*9$

    IS(3).(' J'(0(9-0 -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 U/-.*L- ,/55/9: 398 9L61('0 /9 -.( 1*O(0K

    ;%)$O%2M Q.3- /0 -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, 130(1355 )3'+0 S'34/0 (9+(+ LJ U/-. 3,-('

    *'+('/9: 0*6( ,*' ./60(5, 39+ ,*' ./0 1'*-.('l

    5'(-%#'0M GE? 130(1355 )3'+0$

    ;%)$O%20M ;* GE? /0 -.( -*-35M *' -.( U.*5( 36*L9-$

    Q.('( +* % U'/-( gGE?iM -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, 130(1355 )3'+0 /9 -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9l

    5'(-%#'0M %9 -.( 1/: 1*O$;%)$O%2M S.3- /0 '/:.-$ Q( 35U380 /9JL- -.( -*-35M *' -.( U.*5(M /9-* -.( 1/: 1*O *9

    *9( 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9 18 /-0(5,$ IS(3).(' (9-('0 gGE?i /9 -.( 1/: 1*O$ ;-L+(9-0 +*

    -.( 036( /9 -.(/' U*'20.((-0$K

    ;%)$O%2M +* U( 29*U 398 /9,*'63-/*9 31*L- -.( -U* J3'-0M *' -.( -U* *'+('0 S'34/0

    63+( -.3- 632(0 LJ -.( -*-35l

    5'(-%#'0M Q( 29*U .( *'+('(+ DA 130(1355 )3'+0 ,*' ./60(5, -.( ,/'0- -/6($

    ;%)$O%2M Nh$ S.3- /0 *9( J3'-$ 7(-e0 U'/-( gDA /9 -.( ,/'0- 1*O /9 -.( +/3:'36$

    X* U( 29*U -.( *-.(' J3'-l

    5'(-%#'0M Q( +* 9*- 29*U$

    ;%)$O%2M d*L 3'( '/:.-$ Q( +* 9*- 29*U .*U 6398 .( *'+('(+ ,*' ./0 1'*-.('$ Q(

    3'( 302(+ -* 0*54( ,*' -./0 J3'-$

    % U/55 U'/-( 3 gli /9 -.( 0()*9+ 06355 1*O /9 -.( &&Q +/3:'36$ %90-(3+ *, L0/9: 3

    \L(0-/*9 63'2M U( )39 350* L0( 3 5(--(' -* '(J'(0(9- -.( L929*U9 \L39-/-8$ IS(3).('

    U'/-(0 3 5(--(' g3i /9 -.( E9+ 1*O -.3- /0 531(5(+ g&3'-iK$ %9 8*L' U*'20.((-M J5(30(

    U'/-( -.( 5(--(' g3i /9 -.( E9+ 1*O ,*' -.( J3'- -.3- /0 9*- 29*U9$

    =*U 5(-e0 5**2 3- -.( )*6J5(-(+ +/3:'36 I;5/+( EBHBHK

    90#'& G,O,O

    Part

    68 a 129

    Part

    + =

    Whole

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    51/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    QO

    S.( ,/'0- 1*O IDAK '(J'(0(9-0 -.( ,/'0- *'+(' S'34/0 63+( ,*' ./60(5,n -.( E9+ 1*O '(J'(0(9-0

    -.( 0()*9+ *'+(' .( 63+( ,*' ./0 1'*-.(' I-.( L929*U9 \L39-/-8 g3iK$ S.( 1/: 1*O *9 -.(

    *-.(' 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9 '(J'(0(9-0 -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, 130(1355 )3'+0 S'34/0 *'+('(+$

    S.( &&Q +/3:'36 .30 J'*4/+(+ L0 U/-. 3 63-. (\L3-/*9$ !55 U( 9((+ -* +* /0 -*

    gJ((5 *,,i -.( 1*O(0 39+ '(U'/-( /- 30 3 63-. 0(9-(9)(M *' (\L3-/*9$

    S.3- /0M DA p 3 q GE?

    ;%)$O%2MS* 0*54( ,*' -.( L929*U9 /9 -.( 31*4( (\L3-/*9M U.3- +* U( +*l

    5'(-%#'0> x

    ;%)$O%2>

    3 q GE?tDA$Q.3- /0 -.( 390U(' -* -.( 31*4( 63-. 0(9-(9)(l

    5'(-%#'0> DG$

    ;%)$O%2> Q.3- /0 -.( )*6J5(-( 390U(' -* -.( J'*15(6l

    5'(-%#'0> S'34/0 *'+('(+ DG 130(1355 )3'+0 ,*' ./0 1'*-.('$

    ;%)$O%2> ;LJ('1 f*1$

    S* ).()2 ,*' -.( 3))L'3)8 *, *L' 390U('M U( )39 '(J53)( -.( L929*U9 *U/-. *L'

    390U(' IDGK -* ).()2 U.(-.(' *L' 390U(' /0 )*''()-$

    %, U( '(J53)( -.( 5(--(' */9 -.( (\L3-/*9 U/-. *L' 390U(' DGM -.( (\L3-/*9 U/55 1(>

    DA p DG q GE?$

    7(,- 0/+( I7;K *, -.( (\L3-/*9 q DApDG

    Q.3- /0 -.( 0L6 *, DA 39+ DGl

    5'(-%#'0> GE?$

    ;%)$O%2> 0* 7; qGE?M

    R/:.- 0/+( IR;K *, -.( (\L3-/*9 U30 :/4(9$ R; q GE?$

    %0 GE? -.( 036( 30 GE?l

    5'(-%#'0Md(0$

    ;%)$O%2> ;* 7; q R;$ S.3- 6(390 *L' 390U('M DGM /0 )*''()-$

    %9 0L663'8M U( )39 +/'()-58 L0( -.( &&Q +/3:'36 -* '(J'(0(9- &&Q J'*15(60M 39+

    L0( -.( :/4(9 (\L3-/*9 -* 0*54( ,*' -.( L929*U9$ Q.(9 U( '(J'(0(9- -.( J'*15(6 /9 -.(

    &&Q +/3:'36M -.( 2(8 /0 -* ,/9+ *L- U.3- 36*L9- /0 -.( U.*5( I-*-35KM 39+ U.3- 36*L9-0

    632( LJ -.( J3'-0M 39+ -.(9 63J -.(6 /9-* -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 3))*'+/9:58$

    =*U 8*L U/55 -'8 /- *L- 39+ 0*54( -.'(( 6*'( &&Q J'*15(60$

    !")20&1 fG,O,Q

    ;W" &%"&*% 7# ) &)2'7$(*)2 4(07$ 82"(& O)6% W27''%# QX 0"#80S J[ "#% 4%43%2

    O)0 W27''%# V_ "[ 'O% 0"#80T O"W 4)#R 0"#80 O)0 'O% "'O%2 "#% W27''%#`

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    52/267

    #b!&SZR E

    QQ

    I

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    53/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    QM

    E$ Q.3- /0 -.( -*-35 *' C7)0&/9 -./0 0-*'8l

    t-.( -*-35 9L61(' *, 5(--('0 -.( 63/5639 9((+0 -* +(5/4('M U./). /0 -.( L929*U9

    \L39-/-8 I*K -.3- U( 9((+ -* 0*54( ,*'$

    H$ Q.3- 3'( -.( -U* J3'-0 -.3- 632( LJ -.( C7)0&M *' -*-35l

    tb( +(5/4('(+ EFH 5(--('0$ b( 0-/55 .30 GCA 5(,- /9 ./0 13: L9+(5/4('(+$ S.( 5(--('0

    +(5/4('(+ 39+ -.( 5(--('0 5(,- /9 -.( 13: 3'( -.( -U* J3'-0 -.3- 632( LJ -.( -*-35

    9L61(' *, 5(--('0 -.( 63/5639 9((+(+ -* +(5/4('$

    S.( 63/5639 .30 HPG 5(--('0 /9 ./0 13: 3- -.( 1(:/99/9: *, -.( +38$

    !")20&1 fG,O,\

    W3'8 U'*-( PC J*(60 *4(' -.( 0L66('M 1L- -.(9 0.( '(35/[(+ 0.( +/+9e- 5/2( 0*6(

    *, -.(6 39+ -*'( -.(6 LJ$ !,-('U3'+0M 0.( .3+ *958 HP J*(60 5(,-$ b*U 6398 +/+

    0.( -(3' LJl

    h(8 J*/9-0 /9 :L/+/9: 0-L+(9-0 -* '(J'(0(9- -.( J'*15(6 /9 -.( &&Q +/3:'36 39+

    0*54/9: -.( J'*15(6$

    G$ %0 -./0 J'*15(6 3 &3'-B&3'-B Q.*5( 0/-L3-/*9l

    td(0M W3'8 U'*-( 3 -*-35 *, PC J*(60M 1L- 0.( -*'( 0*6( J*(60 0.( U'*-($

    !,-('U3'+0M 0.( *958 .3+ HP J*(60 5(,-$ Q( 3'( 302(+ -* ,/9+ *L- -.( 9L61(' *,

    J*(60 0.( -*'( LJ$

    E$ Q.3- /0 -.( g-*-35i *' gU.*5(i /9 -./0 0-*'8l

    t-.( -*-35 9L61(' *, J*(60 W3'8 U'*-(M -.3- /0M PC$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    54/267

    #b!&SZR E

    Q\

    H$ Q.3- 3'( -.( -U* J3'-0 -.3- 632( LJ -.( U.*5( *' -*-35l

    t0.( -*'( LJ 0*6( J*(60M U./). /0 -.( L929*U9 \L39-/-8 U( 3'( 302(+ -* ,/9+ *L-M

    39+ 0.( 5(,- *958 U/-. HP J*(60$

    *p HP q PC$

    S.('(,*'(Z *q PCtHPM *' *q G?

    !90U('> W3'8 -*'( LJ G? J*(60 -.3- 0.( U'*-($

    ;]WW!Rd

    %9 -./0 5(00*9M U( .34( L0(+ &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -* '(J'(0(9- 39+ 0*54( -.( &&QJ'*15(60$ Y/:L'( EtH I/9 9(O- J3:(K J'(0(9-0 3 0-*'8 :'3663' J'*6J- )3'+ Ia/9 (-

    35$M EFFAK -.3- 0-L+(9-0 )39 L0( -* ,3)/5/-3-( 6(39/9:,L5 J'*15(6 '(J'(0(9-3-/*9$ !0

    J'(0(9-(+ /9 Y/:L'( EtHMU*'+ J'*15(6 I?!N 3%)"S 5"*11*"\L(0-/*90 39+ J'*6J-0

    U('( :(9('3-(+ /9 3))*'+39)( U/-. -.( -.'(( (5(6(9-0 /9 -.( &&Q X/3:'36 Z\L3-/*9

    -* .(5J 0-L+(9-0 L9+('0-39+ -.( J'*15(6 0-'L)-L'( 39+ )*''()-58 63J /9,*'63-/*9

    ,'*6 -.( J'*15(6 -* -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9$ !0 0.*U9 /9 Y/:L'( EtHM -.( +/3:'36

    (\L3-/*9 (6J.30/[(0 35:(1'3/) (OJ'(00/*9 *, 63-.(63-/)35 '(53-/*90 36*9: 2(8

    (5(6(9-0 *, -.( J'*15(6 0-'L)-L'($ ;J()/,/)3558M 3!*"%,!*"%,?7)0&I&&QK J'*15(6

    +(0)'/1(0 39 3++/-/4( '(53-/*9 1(-U((9 6L5-/J5( J3'-0 39+ -.( U.*5( I/$($M J3'-0

    632( LJ -.( U.*5(K$ %- /9)5L+(0 J'*15(60 0L). 30 )*61/9( I($:$M

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    55/267

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    56/267

    Q_

    ]=%S H

    H>1H>5>A;JAE !?,1 K

    1H?/=>,5

    7Z;;N= C> RZ&RZ;Z=S%=` !#BWNRZ &RNF

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    57/267

    #b!&SZR E

    ML

    ;%)$O%2M 7(-e0 L9+('5/9( -./0 )*6J3'/0*9 0(9-(9)($ Y'*6 -./0 0(9-(9)(M U( 29*U

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    58/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    MB

    ;%)$O%2M=*U 5(-e0 5**2 3- ;5/+( HBCBGB1$ S.( ,/'0- 13' I-.( 0.*'- *9(K '(J'(0(9-0

    -.( 9L61(' *, -*8 )3'0 #.'/0-/9( .30n -.( 0()*9+ 13' I-.( 5*9:(' *9(K '(J'(0(9-0 -.(

    9L61(' *, -*8 )3'0 %, U( 5**2 3- -.( 5*9:(' 13' I

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    59/267

    #b!&SZR E

    MG

    90#'& O,Q,B,+

    43

    109

    43

    Christine

    Bob

    66

    Part

    43

    Smaller DifferenceBigger

    66 109

    Part

    + =

    Whole

    7;> CH p DD q GF?

    R;> GF?

    X*(0 GF? (\L35 GF?l

    5'(-%#'0> d(0M -.(8 3'( -.( 036($

    ;%)$O%2> S.3- 6(390M 7; q R;$ N' gJ3'-i 39+ gJ3'-i /9 -.( +/3:'36 +/+ 632( LJ -.(gU.*5($i S.( 13' 6*+(5 39+ -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -(55 -.( 036( 0-*'8 I-(3).('

    J*/9-0 -* -.( &&Q 6*+(5 /9 ;5/+( HBCBGB) -* (OJ53/9K>

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    60/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    MO

    I;-L+(9-0 '(3+ -.( 0-*'8 -*:(-.('$K

    ;%)$O%2M Q.3- /0 -./0 J'*15(6 355 31*L-l

    5'(-%#'0M S./0 0-*'8 )*6J3'(0 -.( 9L61(' *, )3'9/435 -/)2(-0 73L'(9 .30 -* -.(

    9L61(' *, -/)2(-0 !5(O .30$

    ;%)$O%20M `'(3-M /- /0 39 3++/-/4( )*6J3'/0*9 I!#K J'*15(6$ S.3- /0 )*''()-M 73L'(9 .30 6*'(M 39+ 8*L -*5+ 6( 73L'(9 .30 PF 6*'( -.39

    !5(OM -.3- /0M -.( +/,,('(9)( 1(-U((9 73L'(9e0 13' 39+ !5(Oe0 13' /0 PF$

    I;(( ;5/+( HBCBEB1K

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    61/267

    #b!&SZR E

    MQ

    90#'& O,Q,G,2

    Lauren

    60 50

    110

    60

    Alex

    ;%)$O%2M=*U 5(-e0 5**2 3- ;5/+( HBCBEB1$ S.( ,/'0- 13' I-.( 5*9:(' *9(K '(J'(0(9-0

    -.( 9L61(' *, -/)2(-0 73L'(9 .30 IGGFKn -.( 0()*9+ 13' I-.( 0.*'-(' *9(K '(J'(0(9-0

    -.( 9L61(' *, -/)2(-0 !5(O .30 IDFKM U./). /0 PF 5(00 -.39 -.( ,/'0- 13' ,*'

    73L'(9$ %9 *-.(' U*'+0M 73L'(9 .30 PF 6*'( -.39 !5(O$ %9 0.*'-M -.( +/,,('(9)(

    1(-U((9 -.( -U* 13'0 /0 PFM U./). /0 /9+/)3-(+ 18 -.( )5(3' J3'- *, -.( 5*9:('

    13'$ IS(3).(' J*/9-0 -* '(5(439- 0(:6(9-0 /9 31*4( 13' 6*+(5 +L'/9: ./0 *' .('

    (OJ5393-/*9$K

    ;%)$O%2M%, U( 5**2 3- -.( 5*9:(' 13' I73L'(9KM /- /0 3)-L3558 63+( LJ *, -U* J3'-0>

    I*K -.( ,/'0- J3'- I0.3+(+ J3'-KM U./). 0.*L5+ 1( -.( 036( 30 !5(O IDFKM 39+ I 2K -.(

    0()*9+ J3'- I)5(3' 13'KM U./). /0 -.( 3++/-/*935 -/)2(-0 IPFK -.3- 73L'(9 .30$ S.(0(

    -U* J3'-0 I* 39+2K 632(0 LJ -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, -/)2(-0 -.3- 73L'(9 .30$

    =*U U( 3'( '(3+8 -* '(J'(0(9- -.( 036( 0-*'8 /9 -.( &&Q 6*+(5 +/3:'36$

    90#'& O,Q,G,2

    Lauren

    60 50

    110

    60

    Alex

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    62/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    MM

    IS(3).(' J'(0(9-0 -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9K

    Q.* )39 -(55 L0 -.( \L39-/-/(0 ,*' -.( -U* J3'-0 -.3- U( 0.*L5+ U'/-( /9 -.( -U* 06355

    1*O(0 531(5(+ gJ3'-i *9 -.( 5(,- 0/+( *, -.( &&Q (\L3-/*9l

    5'(-%#'0> DF 39+ PF$

    ;%)$O%2M`'(3-w % U/55 U'/-( DF 39+ PF /9 -.( -U* 06355 1*O(0 -.3- 3'( 531(5(+ gJ3'-i

    /9 -.( &&Q +/3:'36$

    Q.3- 9L61(' U/55 U( U'/-( /9 -.( 1/: 1*O -.3- /0 531(5(+ gU.*5(i ,*' -.( 1/::('

    \L39-/-8 /9 -.( )*6J3'/0*9 0-*'/(0l

    5'(-%#'0MGGF$

    ;%)$O%2> S.3- /0 )*''()-$ S.( 1/: 1*O /0 ,*' -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, -/)2(-0 73L'(9 .30

    I-.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8K$ % U/55 U'/-( GGF /9 -.( 1/: 1*O -.3- /0 531(5(+ gU.*5(i ,*' -.(1/::(' \L39-/-8$ d*L U/55 +* -.( 036( /9 8*L' U*'20.((-$ ;(( ;5/+( CBHBEB) ,*' -.(

    )*6J5(-(+ 13' 6*+(5 39+ -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 6*+(5$

    90#'& O,Q,G,+

    60 50

    110

    Part

    60

    Smaller DifferenceBigger

    50 110

    Part

    + =

    Whole

    ;%)$O%2M !0 0.*U9 /9 -.( 31*4( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M ,*' '(J'(0(9-/9: -.(

    +)1.*"#3)$ 0-*'8 *9-* -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M -.( 31*00&" \L39-/-8 I!5(O /9

    -./0 )30(K *, -.( -U* 1(/9: )*6J3'(+ I73L'(9 39+ !5(OK !=X -.( '#--&"&$+&36*L9-

    1(-U((9 -.( 1/::(' 39+ 06355(' \L39-/-/(0 I*' 1(-U((9 73L'(9 39+ !5(Oe0 #3'9/435

    -/)2(-0 /9 -./0 0-*'8K U/55 632( LJ -.( gU.*5(Mi U./). /0 -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8 I73L'(9

    /9 -./0 )30(KM 30 0.*U9 /9 -.( 13' 6*+(5$

    7(-0e ).()2 -* 0(( U.(-.(' -.( 0L6 *, -.( -U* \L39-/-/(0 *9 -.( 5(,- 0/+( I7;K *, -.( (\L35

    0/:9 /0 -.( 036( 30 I*' (\L35 -*K -.( \L39-/-8 *9 -.( '/:.- 0/+( IR;K *, -.( (\L35 0/:9$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    63/267

    #b!&SZR E

    M\

    7;> DF p PF q GGF

    R;> GGF

    X*(0 GGF (\L35 GGFl

    5'(-%#'0> d(0M -.(8 3'( -.( 036($

    ;%)$O%2MS.3- 6(390M 7; q R;$ N' gJ3'-i 39+ gJ3'-i +/+ 632( LJ -.( gU.*5($i S.(

    13' 6*+(5 39+ -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -(550 -.( 036( 0-*'8 I-(3).(' J*/9-0 -* -.(

    &&Q 6*+(5 /9 ;5/+( HBGB) -* (OJ53/9K> 73L'(9 .30 -.( 53':(' \L39-/-8 I-.( gU.*5(iKn

    0.( .30 PF 6*'( -.39 I-.( +/,,('(9)(K U.3- !5(O .30 I-.( 06355(' \L39-/-8K$

    IS(3).(' J*/9-0 -* -.( 13' 6*+(5K S.( 9L61(' *, -.( -/)2(-0 73L'(9 .30 I-.( 5*9:('

    13'K /0 63+( *, -U* J3'-0> IGK 9L61(' *, -/)2(-0 !5(O .30M !=X IEK -.( 3++/-/*935

    -/)2(-0 73L'(9 .30M U./). /0 -.( +/,,('(9)( 36*L9- 1(-U((9 -.( -U* I/$($M PFK$

    !")20&1 fO,Q,O

    H"3 O)0 _\ 8*(% 0'7$]0S @%*7&% O)0 UX 8*(% 0'7$]0S H"3 O)0 QZ 4"2% 8*(% 0'7$]0

    'O)# @%*7&%S

    I;-L+(9-0 '(3+ -.( 0-*'8K

    ;%)$O%2M Q.3- /0 -./0 J'*15(6 355 31*L-l

    5'(-%#'0M S./0 0-*'8 )*6J3'(0 -.( 9L61(' *, :5L( 0-/)20 R*1 .30 -* -.( 9L61(' *, 0-/)20

    Y(5/J( .30$ R*1 .30 @? 39+ Y(5/J( .30 HAn 39+ R*1 .30 CG 6*'( :5L( 0-/)20 -.39 Y(5/J($

    ;%)$O%2M `'(3-w

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    64/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    M]

    5'(-%#'0M CGl

    ;%)$O%2M g%0 CG -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, 0-/)20 R*1 .30M *' /0 CG -.( '#--&"&$+& *1)/$%

    U.(9 R*1 /0 )*6J3'(+ -* Y(5/J( *9 -.( 9L61(' *, 0-/)20 -.(8 .34(l

    5'(-%#'0M CG /0 -.( +/,,('(9)( 36*L9-M 30 /- 0380 gR*1 .30 CG 1)"&:5L( 0-/)20 -.39

    Y(5/J($i

    ;%)$O%2M S.3- /0 '/:.-$ CG /0 -.( 3++/-/*935 36*L9- *, 0-/)20 R*1 .30M /9 3++/-/*9 -*

    -.( 9L61(' *, 0-/)20 Y(5/J( .30$ =*U 3:3/9M U.3- /0 -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, :5L( 0-/)20

    R*1 .30 0* -.3- % )39 U'/-( -.3- /9 -.( 1/: 1*O ,*' R*1l

    5'(-%#'0M @?$

    ;%)$O%2M `'(3-$ S.3- /0 -.( 9L61(' *, :5L( 0-/)20 R*1 .30$ IS(3).(' U'/-(0 @? /9 -.(1/: 1*O 936(+ R*1$ ;-L+(9-0 +* -.( 036( /9 -.(/' U*'20.((-$K

    ;%)$O%2M=*U U( 9((+ -* ,/55 -.( -U* 06355 1*O(0 /9 -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9$ Q.3-

    9L61(' :*(0 /9-* -.( 06355 1*O 936(+ Y(5/J(l

    R*1 .30 @? :5L( 0-/)20$ Y(5/J( .30 HA :5L( 0-/)20$ R*1 .30 CG 6*'( :5L( 0-/)20 -.39

    Y(5/J($

    5'(-%#'0M HAM 30 Y(5/J( .30 HA :5L( 0-/)20$

    ;%)$O%2M `'(3-$ Q.3- 9L61(' +* % U'/-( /9 -.( E9+ 06355 1*O -.3- /0 ,*' -.( +/,,('(9)(

    36*L9-l

    5'(-%#'0M CG$

    ;%)$O%2M ;LJ('M 30 CG/0 -.( 3++/-/*935 0-/)20 -.3- R*1 .30M *' -.( +/,,('(9)( 36*L9-$

    d*L U/55 )*6J5(-( -.( +/3:'36 /9 8*L' U*'20.((-$

    I;-L+(9-0 63J -.( 9L61('0 /9-* -.( +/3:'36 /9 -.(/' U*'20.((-0K

    IS(3).(' J'(0(9-0 -.( )*6J5(-(+ &&Q +/3:'36M 0(( ;5/+( HBCBH 1(5*UK

    90#'& O,Q,O

    Part

    38

    Smaller(Felipe) DifferenceBigger(Rob)

    41 79

    Part

    + =

    Whole

    ;%)$O%2M !0 0.*U9 31*4(M U.(9 '(J'(0(9-/9: -.( +)1.*"#3)$ 0-*'8 *9-* -.(

    &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M -.(31*00&"\L39-/-8 IY(5/J( /9 -./0 )30(K *, -.( -U* 1(/9:

    )*6J3'(+ IR*1 39+ Y(5/J(K !=X -.( '#--&"&$+&36*L9- 1(-U((9 -.( 1/::(' 39+ -.(

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    65/267

    #b!&SZR E

    M[

    06355(' \L39-/-/(0 I*' 1(-U((9 R*1 39+ Y(5/J(e0 :5L( 0-/)20 /9 -./0 0-*'8K U/55 632(

    LJ -.( gU.*5(Mi *' -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8 IR*1e0 :5L( 0-/)20K$

    7(-0e ).()2 -* 0(( U.(-.(' -.( 0L6 *, -.( -U* \L39-/-/(0 *9 -.( 5(,- 0/+( I7;K *, -.(

    (\L35 0/:9 /0 -.( 036( 30 I*' (\L35 -*K -.( \L39-/-8 *9 -.( '/:.- 0/+( IR;K *, -.( (\L35

    0/:9$

    7;> HA p CE q @?

    R;> @?

    X* U( .34( 3 13539)(+ (\L3-/*9l N' /0 -.( 0L6 ,'*6 -.( 7; *, -.( (\L3-/*9 (\L35 -*

    -.( \L39-/-8 *9 -.( R; *, -.( (\L3-/*9l

    5'(-%#'0Md(0M 7; q R;$;%)$O%2M-.3- 6(390 U( .34( )*''()-58 '(J'(0(9-(+ -.( 0-*'8 /9 -.( &&Q +/3:'36$

    X%RZ#S%N=; YNR SRdB%SBN]S !=X %=XZ&Z=XZ=S QNRh;bZZS

    %9 -.( U*'20.((-0 1(5*UM 8*L U/55 L0( -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -* '(J'(0(9-

    -.( 0-*'8$ !,-(' 8*L '(3+ 39+ L9+('0-39+ -.( 0-*'8M /, /- /0 39 3++/-/4( )*6J3'/0*9

    J'*15(6M 8*L U/55 ,/9+ 3 )*6J3'/0*9 0(9-(9)( -.3- -(550 U.* .30 6*'( 39+ .*U 6398

    6*'($ S.3- /0 U.('( 8*L U/55 +()/+( U.* .30 -.( 53':(' \L39-/-8 39+ U.* .30 -.(

    06355(' \L39-/-8$ =36( -.( 1/::(' 1*O 39+ 06355(' 1*O /9 -.( +/3:'36 0* -.3- 8*L

    632( 0L'( -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8 :*(0 -* -.( 1/: 1*O *9 *9( 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9M 39+

    -.( 06355(' \L39-/-8 :*(0 -* -.( 06355(' 1*O *9 -.( *-.(' 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9$ S.(

    0-3-(6(9- *, gb*U 6398 6*'(i -(550 -.( +/,,('(9)( 36*L9-$ S.( 06355(' \L39-/-8

    39+ -.( +/,,('(9)( 36*L9- 0.*L5+ 632( LJM *' (\L35M -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8 *9 -.( *-.('0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9$

    %, 8*L 3'( (4(' )*9,L0(+ 31*L- -.( 0-*'8 0/-L3-/*9M +'3U -.( 13' 6*+(5 -* .(5J 8*L

    L9+('0-39+ -.( 0-*'8M *' 0J()/,/)3558M U.3- 3'( -.( -U* J3'-0 -.3- 632( LJ -.( U.*5(M

    *' -*-35 I*' -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8 /9 -.( )*6J3'/0*9 0-*'/(0K$

    6"S #% )/%gF< 9%)"S =&."&3&$%*%#)$ QZ MZ *$' \

    Ih)%&> ;L::(0-(+ +/3:'36 '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 /0 J'(0(9-(+ /9 -.( J3'(9-.(0(0 ,*55*U/9:

    (3). *, -.( J'*15(60K

    C$ X/(:* .30 HF )3-0$ R*935+ .30 DC 6*'( )3-0 -.39 X/(:*$ R*935+ .30 ?C )3-0$

    IHF p DC q ?CK

    P$ #(5/93 .30 GGE 1/2(0$ !50*M #(5/93 .30 DC 6*'( 1/2(0 -.39 !L-L69$ !L-L69 .30CA 1/2(0$ICA p DC q GGEK

    D$ S'3)(8 .30 GFD 9()253)(0$ ;/6*9( .30 D? 9()253)(0$ S'3)(8 .30 H@ 6*'( 9()253)(

    -.39 ;/6*9($ ID? p H@ q GFDK

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    66/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    M_

    A$'&.&$'&$% ?)"@37&&%iF< 9%)"S =&."&3&$%*%#)$ ]Z [ *$' _

    @$ W35)*56 .30 DG 13550$ X35( .30 DF 6*'( 13550 -.39 W35)*56$ X35( .30 GEG 13550$

    A$ W(5/003 .30 GG? 1**20$ ;.( .30 @E 6*'( 1**20 -.39 !5/)/3$ !5/)/3 .30 C@ 1**20$

    ?$ !4('8 .30 HP 6*'( 9*-(1**20 -.39 W3'-/9$ W3'-/9 .30 DP 9*-(1**20$ !4('8

    .30GFF 9*-(1**20$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    67/267

    #b!&SZR E

    \L

    7Z;;N= P> RZ&RZ;Z=S%=` !#B7Z;; &RNF

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    68/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    \B

    90#'& O,M,BL,*

    Cristal

    29

    29 71

    100 Warren

    %9 ;5/+( HBPBGFB3M -.( E9+ 13' '(J'(0(9-0 -.( 9L61(' *, J(90 Q3''(9 .30M 3 -*-35

    *, GFF$ !0 /9+/)3-(+ /9 -.( 13' 6*+(5M /- /0 @G 5*9:(' -.39 #'/0-35e0 13'n *' /9 *-.('U*'+0M 30 0-3-(+ /9 -.( 0-*'8M #'/0-35 .30 @G -&C&"J(90 -.39 Q3''(9$ %9 0.*'-M -.(

    +/,,('(9)( 1(-U((9 -.( 9L61(' *, J(90 #'/0-35 .30 39+ -.( 9L61(' *, J(90 Q3''(9

    .30 /0 @GM U./). /0 /9+/)3-(+ 18 -.( )5(3' J3'- *, -.( 5*9:(' 13' IS(3).(' J*/9-0 -* -.(

    0(:6(9- *, -.( 13' -.3- /0 9*- 0.3+(+ /9 -.( 5*9:(' 13'K

    ;%)$O%2M%, U( 5**2 3- -.( 5*9:(' 13' IQ3''(9e0 13'KM /- /0 3)-L3558 63+( LJ *, -U*

    J3'-0> I3K -.( ,/'0- J3'- I0.3+(+ 13'KM U./). /0 -.( 036( 30 #'/0-35 IE?Kn 39+ I1K -.(

    0()*9+ J3'- I)5(3' 13'KM U./). /0 -.( 3++/-/*935 J(90 -.3- Q3''(9 .30$ S.(0( -U* J3'-0

    I3 39+ 1K 632( LJ -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, J(90 -.3- Q3''(9 .30$

    ;* 9*U U( 3'( '(3+8 -* '(J'(0(9- -.( 036( 0-*'8 /9 -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9$

    IS(3).(' J'(0(9-0 -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9K

    Q.* )39 -(55 L0 -.( -U*.*"%0 I-.3- 632( LJ -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8K -.3- U( 0.*L5+ (9-('

    /9-* -.( -U* 06355 1*O(0 *9 -.( 5(,- 0/+( *, -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9l

    5'(-%#'0ME? 39+ @G$

    ;%)$O%2MS.3- /0 )*''()-$ % U/55 U'/-( E? /9 -.( ,/'0- 06355 1*O -.3- /0 531(5(+ g06355('$i

    % U/55 U'/-( @G /9 -.( E9+ 06355 1*O -.3- /0 531(5(+ g+/,,('(9)($i

    Q.3- 0.*L5+ % U'/-( /9 -.( 1/: 1*O ,*' -.( g53':('i \L39-/-8 *9 -.( *-.(' 0/+( *, -.(

    (\L3-/*9l

    5'(-%#'0> GFF$

    ;%)$O%2> S.3- /0 )*''()-$ S.( 1/: 1*O /0 ,*' -.( -*-35 9L61(' *, J(90 Q3''(9 .30$

    % U/55 U'/-( GFF /9 -.( 1/: 1*O -.3- /0 531(5(+ g1/::('i *' gU.*5($i d*L U/55 +* -.(036( /9 8*L' U*'20.((-$ ;(( ;5/+( HBPBGFB1 ,*' 3 )*6J5(-(+ 13' 6*+(5 39+ &&Q

    +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    69/267

    #b!&SZR E

    \G

    90#'& O,M,BL,2

    Cristal

    29

    29 71

    100 Warren

    Part

    29

    Smaller DifferenceBigger

    71 100

    Part

    + =

    Whole

    ;%)$O%2M!0 0.*U9 /9 -.( 31*4( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 I-.( 5*U(' J39(5 *, ;5/+(

    HBPBGFB1KM U.(9 '(J'(0(9-/9: -.( +)1.*"#3)$0-*'8 *9-* -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M

    -.( 31*00&"\L39-/-8 I#'/0-35 /9 -./0 )30(K *, -.( -U* 1(/9: )*6J3'(+ I#'/0-35 39+

    Q3''(9K !=X -.( '#--&"&$+&36*L9- 1(-U((9 -.( 1/::(' 39+ -.( 06355(' \L39-/-/(0M

    *' 1(-U((9 #'/0-35 39+ Q3''(9e0 J(90 I30 /9+/)3-(+ 18 g@G ,(U(' x -.39i /9 -./0

    0-*'8K U/55 632( LJ -.( gU.*5(i *' -.(

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    70/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    \O

    (\L3-/*9 I1L- /, 8*L ,((5 8*L 9((+ -.( 13' 6*+(5 -* .(5J 8*LM J5(30( ,((5 ,'(( -*

    L0( 1*-.K$

    !")20&1 fO,M,BB

    >(8%#% 0)R0 O% O)0 XX $)2-0S J[ N2M 0* U.3- 9L61(' +* % U'/-( /9 -.( 06355(' 1*O -.3- /0 936(+ !1/:3/5l

    5'(-%#'0> PH$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    71/267

    #b!&SZR E

    \Q

    ;%)$O%2MQ.3- 9L61(' +* % U'/-( /9 -.( 1/::(' 1*O -.3- /0 936(+ 30 ZL:(9(l

    5'(-%#'0> AA$

    ;%)$O%20> ;LJ('w Q.3- 9L61(' +* % U'/-( /9 -.( E9+ 06355 1*O -.3- /0 ,*' -.(

    g+/,,('(9)(i 1(-U((9 -.( ZL:(9( 39+ !1/:3/5M *' 1(-U((9 -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8 39+

    -.( 06355(' \L39-/-8l

    5'(-%#'0> HP$

    ;%)$O%20M`'(3- f*1$ S.( )*6J3'/0*9 0(9-(9)( g!1/:3/5 .30 HP ,(U(' )3'+0 -.39

    ZL:(9(i 9*- *958 -(55 U.* .30 ,(U(' I!1/:3/5 /9 -./0 0-*'8K 39+ U.* .30 6*'(

    IZL:(9( /9 -./0 )30(KM 1L- 350* -(550 -.( (O3)- +/,,('(9)( 1(-U((9 -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8

    IZL:(9(K 39+ -.( 06355(' \L39-/-8 I!1/:3/5K$

    =*U 5(-e0 0(( ;5/+( sHBPBGGB1T -.( )*6J5(-(+ &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 ,*' -.( !#

    0-*'8 0/-L3-/*9>

    90#'& fO,M,BB,2

    Part

    53

    Smaller Abigail DifferenceBigger Eugene

    35 88

    Part

    + =

    Whole

    ;%)$O%2M !0 0.*U9 /9 -.( 31*4( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M U.(9 '(J'(0(9-/9: -.(

    +)1.*"#3)$ 0-*'8 *9-* -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M -.( 31*00&" \L39-/-8 I!1/:3/5

    /9 -./0 )30(K *, -.( -U* 1(/9: )*6J3'(+ I!1/:3/5 39+ ZL:(9(K !=X -.( '#--&"&$+&36*L9- 1(-U((9 -.( 1/::(' 39+ -.( 06355(' \L39-/-/(0 I*' 1(-U((9 ZL:(9( 39+

    !1/:3/5K U/55 632( LJ -.( gU.*5(Mi U./). /0 -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8 IZL:(9( /9 -./0

    )30(KM 30 0.*U9 /9 -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9$

    7(-0e ).()2 -* 0(( U.(-.(' -.( 0L6 *, -.( -U* \L39-/-/(0 *9 -.( 5(,- 0/+( I7;K *, -.(

    (\L35 0/:9 /0 -.( 036( 30 I*' (\L35 -*K -.( \L39-/-8 *9 -.( '/:.- 0/+( IR;K *, -.( (\L35

    0/:9$

    7;> PH p HP q AA

    R;> AA

    X*(0 -.( 7; (\L35 -.( R; *, -.( (\L3-/*9 39+ U.8l

    5'(-%#'0Md(0M -.(8 3'( -.( 036(M 1()3L0( gAAi ,'*6 -.( 7; /0 -.( 036( 30 AA ,'*6

    -.( R; *, -.( (\L3-/*9$

    ;%)$O%2M S.3- 6(390M g&3'-i 39+ gJ3'-i ,'*6 -.( 5(,- 0/+( I7;K *, -.( +/3:'36

    (\L3-/*9 +/+ 632( LJ -.( gU.*5(i *9 -.( '/:.- 0/+( IR;K *, -.( (\L3-/*9$ !9+ -.(

    &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 )*''()-58 '(J'(0(9-0 -.( 0-*'8$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    72/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    \M

    7(-e0 L0( -.( &&Q +/3:'36 -* '(J'(0(9- 39*-.(' *''#%#4& +)1.*"&I!#K 0-*'8 -.3-

    /94*54(0 3 )*6J3'/0*9 0-3-(6(9- -.3- -3520 31*L- g6*'(i *' g5(00$i

    !")20&1 fO,M,BG

    ,%*700) O)0 ZZ\ 3""]0S ,%*700) O)0 _V 4"2% 3""]0 'O)# =*U U( 29*U -.( 06355(' 1*O 1(5*9:0 -* !5/)( 39+ -.( 1/::(' 1*O 1(5*9:0

    -* W(5/003$

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    73/267

    #b!&SZR E

    \\

    90#'& O,M,BG,*

    Part

    Smaller Alicia DifferenceBigger Melisa

    Part

    + =

    Whole

    % U/55 302 -U* 4*5L9-(('0 -* JL- -.( 06355(' \L39-/-8 /9 -.( 1*O 936(+ 30 !5/)/3M 39+

    JL- -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8 /9 -.( 1*O 936(+ W(5/003$

    IS(3).(' )3550 *9 -.( 4*5L9-(('0 39+ 0-L+(9- 4*5L9-(('0 /9JL- -.( 06355(' \L39-/-8

    I!5/)/3e0K /9 -.( 06355(' 1*O 39+ -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8 IW(5/003e0K /9 -.( 1/::(' 1*O$K

    ;%)$O%2> =*U U.3- 9L61(' +* U( /9JL- /9-* -.( 1*O 531(5(+ gX/,,('(9)(li

    S.3- /0M U.3- /0 -.( +/,,('(9)( 1(-U((9 !5/)/3e0 1**20 39+ W(5/003e0 1**20l

    5'(-%#'0> @E$

    ;%)$O%2MN2 5(-e0 )*6J5(-( -.( 63JJ/9: *, -.( +/3:'36 39+ 0(( U.3- /- -(550$

    I;(( ;5/+( U.P.ZV.3L

    90#'& O,M,BG,2

    Part

    47

    Smaller Alicia DifferenceBigger Melisa

    72 119

    Part

    + =

    Whole

    ;%)$O%2M !0 0.*U9 /9 -.( 31*4( &&Q +/3:'36 6*+(5M U.(9 '(J'(0(9-/9: -.(

    +)1.*"#3)$0-*'8 *9-* -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M -.(31*00&"\L39-/-8 I!5/)/3 /9 -./0

    )30(K *, -.( -U* 1(/9: )*6J3'(+ IW(5/003 39+ !5/)/3K !=X -.( '#--&"&$+&36*L9-

    1(-U((9 -.( 1/::(' 39+ -.( 06355(' \L39-/-/(0 I*' 1(-U((9 W(5/003 39+ !5/)/3K U/55

    632( LJ -.( gU.*5(Mi U./). /0 -.(

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    74/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    \]

    X*(0 -.( 7; (\L35 -* -.( R; *, -.( (\L3-/*9 39+ U.8l

    5'(-%#'0> d(0M -.(8 3'( -.( 036(M 1()3L0( gGG?i ,'*6 -.( 7; /0 -.( 036( 30 gGG?i

    ,'*6 -.( R; *, -.( (\L3-/*9$

    ;%)$O%2M S.3- 6(390M gJ3'-i 39+ gJ3'-i ,'*6 -.( 5(,- 0/+( I7;K *, -.( +/3:'36

    (\L3-/*9 +/+ 632( LJ -.( gU.*5(i *9 -.( '/:.- 0/+( IR;K *, -.( (\L3-/*9M 39+ -.(

    &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 )*''()-58 '(J'(0(9-0 -.( 0-*'8$

    ;]WW!Rd

    %9 -./0 L9/-M U( .34( L0(+ &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -* '(J'(0(9- -.( !# J'*15(60$

    Y/:L'( HtPJ'(0(9- 3 0-*'8 :'3663' J'*6J- )3'+ Ia/9 (- 35$M EFFAK -.3-0-L+(9-0 )39L0( -*

    ,3)/5/-3-( 6(39/9:,L5 '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 *, !# J'*15(60$ !0 J'(0(9-(+ /9Y/:L'( HtPMU*'+

    J'*15(6 I?!N 3%)"S 5"*11*"\L(0-/*90 39+ J'*6J-0 U('( :(9('3-(+ /9 3))*'+39)(U/-. -.( 2(8 (5(6(9-0 /9 -.( !# 0-*'/(0 I*' J'*15(60K -* .(5J 0-L+(9-0 L9+('0-39+

    -.( J'*15(6 0-'L)-L'( 39+ )*''()-58 63J /9,*'63-/*9 ,'*6 -.( J'*15(6 -* -.( &&Q

    +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9$ !0 0.*U9 /9 Y/:L'( EtHM -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 (6J.30/[(0 35:(1'3/)

    (OJ'(00/*9 *, 63-.(63-/)35 '(53-/*90 36*9: 2(8 (5(6(9-0 *, -.( J'*15(6 0-'L)-L'($

    ;J()/,/)3558M 39 3++/-/4( )*6J3'( I!#K J'*15(6 +(0)'/1(0 *9( \L39-/-8 30 g6*'( -.39i

    -.( *-.(' \L39-/-8 I/$($M -.( !#B6*'( -8J(K *' g5(00 -.39i -.( *-.(' \L39-/-8 I/$($M -.(

    !#B5(00 -8J(K$ &5(30( '(,(' -* S315( #EBG /9 #.3J-(' E IJ3:( GPK ,*' -.'(( 43'/3-/*90 *,

    !#B6*'( J'*15(6 0-'L)-L'( 39+ -.'(( 43'/3-/*90 *, !#B5(00 J'*15(6 0-'L)-L'($

    Additive Compare (AC)

    An AC problem describes one quantity as more or less than the other quantity

    AC WP Story Grammar Questions

    Smaller Difference Bigger

    Part Part Whole

    + =

    Which sentence (or question) describes one quantity as more or

    less than the other? Write the differenceamount in the diagram.Who has more, or which quantity is the bigger one?

    Who has less, or which quantity is the smaller one? Name the biggerbox and smaller box.

    Which sentence (or question) tells about the smaller quantity?Writethat quantity in the smaller box next to the differenceamount.

    Which sentence (or question) tells about the bigger quantity? Writethat quantity in the bigger box on one side of the equation by itself.

    H#5/"& OgMI F''#%#4&

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    75/267

    #b!&SZR E

    \[

    X%RZ#S%N=; YNR SbZ %=XZ&Z=XZ=S QNRh;bZZS

    %9 -.( U*'20.((-0 1(5*UM 8*L U/55 L0( -.( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 I0(( Y/:L'( HtPK

    -* '(J'(0(9- -.( 0-*'8$ !,-(' 8*L '(3+ 39+ L9+('0-39+ -.( 0-*'8M /, /- /0 39 3++/-/4(

    )*6J3'/0*9 I!#K J'*15(6 I0(( +(,/9/-/*9 *, !# J'*15(6 /9 Y/:L'( HtP> !# J'*15(6

    3%)"S 5"*11*"J'*6J- )3'+KM 8*L U/55 ,/9+ -.( +)1.*"#3)$ 3&$%&$+&-.3- -(550 U.*

    .30 g6*'(Mi *' g5(00i I*' U./). \L39-/-8 /0 -.( 1/::(' *9( 39+ U./). \L39-/-8

    /0 -.( 06355(' *9(L 39+ .*U 6398 6*'( I*' 5(00K$ ]9+('5/9( -.3- 0(9-(9)( 30 -.(

    +)1.*"#3)$ 3&$%&$+&/0 U.('( 8*L U/55 +()/+( U.* .30 -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8 39+ U.*

    .30 -.( 06355(' \L39-/-8$

    %- U/55 1( .(5J,L5 /, 8*L 936( -.( 1/::(' 1*O 39+ 06355(' 1*O /9 -.( +/3:'36 0*

    -.3- 8*L 632( 0L'( -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8 :*(0 /9-* -.( g1/::('i 1*O *9 *9( 0/+( *,

    -.( (\L3-/*9M 39+ -.( 06355(' \L39-/-8 :*(0 -* -.( g06355('i 1*O *9 -.( *-.(' 0/+(

    *, -.( (\L3-/*9$ Q.(9 -.('( /0 39 L929*U9 /9 -.( J'*15(6M

    -.( L929*U9 \L39-/-8 638 1( -.( 1/::(' *' 06355(' \L39-/-8$ S.('(,*'(M 8*L +*

    9*- fL+:( -.( g1/:i *' g06355i 18 5**2/9: 3- -.( 0/[( *, -.( 9L61('0 :/4(9 /9 -.(

    J'*15(6n 8*L 9((+ -* '(3+ -.( +)1.*"#3)$ 3&$%#&$+&M U./). -(550 8*L U.* .30 6*'(M

    *' U./). \L35/-8 /0 -.( 1/::(' *9($ R(6(61('M -.( L929*U9 \L39-/-8 8*L 3'( 302(+

    -* 0*54( ,*'M 6/:.- 1( -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8w %9 -.( 9(O- ]9/-M 8*L U/55 5(3'9 .*U -* L0(

    -.( +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9 -* 0*54( '(35 !# J'*15(60 U.(9 -.('( /0 39 L929*U9$

    S.( )*6J3'/0*9 0(9-(9)( 350* -(550 .*U 6398 6*'( *' .*U 6398 5(00M U./). /0

    -.( '#--&"&$+&\L39-/-8 -.3- :*(0 /9-* -.( E9+ 06355 1*O /9 -.( &&Q +/3:'36 531(55(+

    g+/,,('(9)(i$ S.( 31*00&"\L39-/-8 39+ -.( '#--&"&$+&36*L9- 0.*L5+ 632( LJM *'

    (\L35M -.( 2#55&"\L39-/-8 *9 -.( *-.(' 0/+( *, -.( (\L3-/*9$

    %, 8*L 3'( (4(' )*9,L0(+ 31*L- -.( 0-*'8 0/-L3-/*9M +'3U -.( 13' 6*+(5 -* .(5J 8*L

    L9+('0-39+ -.( 0-*'8M *' 0J()/,/)3558M -.( -U* J3'-0 -.3- 632( LJ -.( U.*5(M *' -*-35

    IU./). /0 -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8 /9 )*6J3'/0*9 0-*'/(0K$

    A$'&.&$'&$% ?)"@gF< !")20&1 =&."&3&$%*%#)$ fBOZ BQZ j BM

    Ih)%&> ;L::(0-(+ +/3:'36 '(J'(0(9-3-/*9 /0 J'(0(9-(+ /9 -.( J3'(9-.(0(0 ,*55*U/9:

    (3). *, -.( J'*15(60K

    GF$ j*':( .30 CH ,53:0$ S(''(55 .30 AF ,53:0$ j*':( .30 H@ ,(U(' ,53:0 -.39 S(''(5$

    ICH pH@ q AFK

    GG$ h385/9 .30 CA )39+/(0$ h385/9 .30 @F ,(U(' )39+/(0 -.39 W(5*+8$ W(5*+8 .30

    GGA )39+/(0$ ICA p @F q GGAK

    GE$ W35)*56 .30 PG 13550$ X35( .30 DF 6*'( 13550 -.39 W35)*56$ X35( .30 GGG 13550$

    IPG p DF q GGGK

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    76/267

    \_

    ]=%S C

    5?=IJAE !?,1 K,5

    7Z;;N= D> ;N7c%=` W%aZX !# &RN

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    77/267

    #b!&SZR E

    ]L

    !")20&1 fQ,\,B

    ,)*$"*4 O)0 PZ '%##70 3)**0S D)67- O)0 Y^ 4"2% '%##70 3)**0 'O)# ,)*$"*4S G"W

    4)#R '%##70 3)**0 -"%0 D)67- O)6%`

    I;-L+(9-0 '(3+ -.( J'*15(6 -*:(-.('$K

    ;%)$O%2M Q.3- /0 -./0 J'*15(6 355 31*L-l

    5'(-%#'0M S./0 0-*'8 )*6J3'(0 -.( 9L61(' *, -(99/0 13550 W35)*56 .30 -* -.( 9L61('

    *, -(99/0 13550 X34/+ .30$

    ;%)$O%2M #*''()-w %- /0 3 +)1.*"#3)$ J'*15(6 -.3- +(0)'/1(0 *9( \L39-/-8 30

    6*'( -.39 -.( *-.(' \L39-/-8$ #39 8*L -(55 6( U./). 0(9-(9)( /0 -.( )*6J3'/0*9

    0(9-(9)(l

    5'(-%#'0M X34/+ .30 DF 6*'( -(99/0 13550 -.39 W35)*56$

    ;%)$O%2M S.3- /0 )*''()-$ S./0 )*6J3'/0*9 0(9-(9)( -(550 L0 -.( 9L61(' *, -(99/0 13550

    X34/+ .30 /0 6*'( -.39 -.( 9L61(' *, -(99/0 13550 W35)*56 .30M 39+ -.( +/,,('(9)(

    1(-U((9 -.( -U* \L39-/-/(0 /0 gDF$i

    7(-e0 L9+('5/9( -.( )*6J3'/0*9 0(9-(9)( 39+ U'/-( -.( +/,,('(9)( 36*L9- /9 -.( &&Q

    +/3:'36 I-(3).(' J'(0(9- -.( &&Q +/3:'36 *9 -.( 1*3'+$ S(3).(' 3020 3 0-L+(9-

    4*5L9-((' -* L9+('5/9( -.( )*6J3'/0*9 0(9-(9)( 39+ U'/-( gDFi /9 -.( E9+ 06355 1*O

    531(5(+ g'#--&"&$+&i /9 -.( &&Q +/3:'36K$

    ;%)$O%2M Y'*6 -.( )*6J3'/0*9 0(9-(9)(> gX34/+ .30 DF 6*'( -(99/0 13550 -.39

    W35)*56Mi )39 8*L -(55 6( U.* .30 6*'(M 39+ U.* .30 5(00 -(99/0 13550l5'(-%#'0M X34/+ .30 DF 6*'( 0* X34/+ .30 6*'(M 39+ W35)*56 .30 5(00$

    ;%)$O%2M S.3- /0 )*''()-$ % U/55 302 3 4*5L9-((' -* 936( -.(31*00&"1*O 39+ 2#55&"

    1*O ,*' 6( *9 -.( &&Q +/3:'36$

    IS(3).(' 3020 -.( 4*5L9-((' -* 936( -.( 1/::(' 1*O ^/$($M X34/+_ 39+ -.( 06355('

    1*O ^/$($M W35)*56_ *9 -.( 1*3'+ /9 -.( &&Q +/3:'36$ ;(( ;5/+( CBDBGB3K

    90#'& Q,\,B,*

    Part

    Smaller Malcolm DifferenceBigger David

    Part

    + =

    Whole

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    78/267

    #NW&; &RN`R!W

    ]B

    IS(3).(' J'(0(9-0 -.( !# ?)"' !")20&1 V?!W 9%)"S T"*11*"&*0-('K

    ;* U( .34( ,/:L'(+ /- *L- U.* .30 6*'( 39+ U.* .30 5(00 39+ U( .34( 936(+

    -.( 1/::(' 1*O 39+ 06355(' 1*O 39+ (9-('(+ -.( +/,,('(9)( 1(-U((9 -.( -U* /9 -.(

    +/3:'36$ % 36 :*/9: -* ).()2 *,, -.( ,/'0- 5/--5( 1*O /9 -.( Q& 0-*'8 :'3663' J*0-('$

    Q( U/55 9*U ,/9+ *L- -.( 0(9-(9)( -.3- -(550 31*L- -.( 1/::(' \L39-/-8M *' -.( -(99/0

    13550 -.3- X34/+ .30$

    ;%)$O%2> b*U 6398 -(99/0 13550 +*(0 X34/+ .34(l

    N9( 0-L+(9- 390U('(+> X34/+ .30 DF 6*'( -(99/0 13550$

    ;%)$O%2> gX34/+ .30 DF 6*'( -(99/0 13550i -(550 31*L- -.( +/,,('(9)( 1(-U((9 -.(9L61(' *, -(99/0 13550 -.3- X34/+ .30 39+ -.( 9L61(' *, -(99/0 13550 -.3- W35)*56

    .30$ X* U( 29*U -.( 9L61(' *, -(99/0 13550 -.3- X34/+ .30l

    5'(-%#'0M=*M U( +* 9*- 29*U$ Q( 3'( 302(+ -* 0*54( ,*' /-$

    ;%)$O%2Md*L 3'( '/:.-$ S.3- /0 -.( L929*U9 \L39-/-8 U( 9((+ -* 0*54( ,*'$ Y'*6 9*U

    *9M U( U/55 L0( 5(--(' g3i -* '(J'(0(9- 39 L929*U9 \L39-/-8$ ;* % U/55 U'/-( 5(--(' g3i /9

    -.( 1/::(' 1*O -.3- /0 936(+ gX34/+$i I;-L+(9-0 U/55 +* -.( 036( /9 -.(/' U*'20.((-$K

    ;%)$O%2MQ./). 0(9-(9)( -(550 31*L- -.( 06355(' \L39-/-8M *' -.( -(99/0 13550 -.3-

    W35)*56 .30l

    5'(-%#'0MW35)*56 .30 PG -(99/0 13550$;%)$O%2M`'(3-M 5(-e0 U'/-( PG /9 -.( 06355 1*O 936(+ gW35)*56$i

    I;-L+(9-0 +* -.( 036( /9 -.(/' U*'20.((-K

    ;%)$O%2M=*U U( .34( )*6J5(-(+ -.( E9+ 39+ H'+ 0-(J0 /9 -.( ?! 3%)"S 5"*11*"

    J*0-('$ % U/55 ).()2 *,, -.( -U* 1*O(0 /9 -.( ?! 9%)"S T"*11*"J'*6J- )3'+M 39+ U(

    .34( ,/9/0.(+ 63JJ/9: -.( /9,*'63-/*9 *9-* -.( +/3:'36$ ;(( ;5/+( CBDBGB1$

    90#'& Q,\,B,2

    Part

    51

    Smaller Malcolm DifferenceBigger David

    60 a

    Part

    + =

    Whole

  • 8/12/2019 Conceptual model-based problem solving

    79/267

    #b!&SZR E

    ]G

    ;%)$O%2M!0 0.*U9 /9 -.( 31*4( &&Q +/3:'36 (\L3-/*9M -.( 31*00&"\L39-/-8 I-.(

    9L61(' *, -(99/0 13550 -.3- W35)*56 .30K *, -.( -U* 1(/9: )*6J3'(+ IX34/+ 39+

    W35)*56K !=X -.( '#--&"&$+&36*L9- 1(-U((9 -.( 1/::(' 39+ -.( 06355(' \L39-/-/(0M

    *' 1(-U((9 X34/+ 39+ W35)*56e0 -(99/0 13550 I30 /9+/)3-(+ 18 gDF 6*'( -(99/0 13550

    -.39xKU/55 632( LJ -.( gU.*5(i *' -.(

    PG p DF q *M *'

    *q PGp DF$

    Q.3- /0 -.( 390U(' *, PG p DFl

    5'(-%#'0MGGG;%)$O%2MU.3- /0 3 )*6J5(-( 390U(' -* -./0 J'*15(6l

    5'(-%#'0MX34/+ .30 3 -*-35 *, GGG -(99/0 13550$

    !")20&1 fQ,\,G

    h385/9 .30 CA )39+/(0$ ;.( .30 @F ,(U(' )39+/(0 -.39 W(5*+8$ b*U 6398 )39+/(0

    +*(0 W(5*+8 .34(l

    I;-L+(9-0 '(3+ -.( J'*15(6 -*:(-.('$K

    ;%)$O%2M Q.3- /0 -./0 J'*15(6 355 31*L-l

    5'(-%#'0M S./0 0-*'8 )*6J3'(0 -.( 9L61(' *, )39+/(0 h385/9 .30 -* -.( 9L61(' *,

    )39+/(0 -.3- W(5*+8 .30$

    ;%)$O%2M #*''()-w %- /0 3 +)1.*"#3)$J'*15(6 -.3- +(0)'/1(0 *9( \L39-/-8 30 1)"& *'

    0&33 -.39 -.( *-.(' \L39-/-8$

    IS(3).(' J'(0(9-0 -.( !# ?)"' !")20&1 V?!W 9%)"S T"*11*"&*0-('K

    !0 /- /0 3 )*6J3'/0*9 J'*15(6 -.3- /94*54(0 g6*'( -.39i *' g5(00 -.39i '(53-/*90./J0

    1(-U((9 -.( -U* \L39-/-/(0M U( U/55 L0( -.( !# Q& 0-*'8 :'3663' J*0-(' -* :L/+(

    *L' J'*15(6 '(J'(0(9-3-/*9$

    ;* -.( ,/'0- 0-(J /0 -* /+(9-/,8 -.( )*6J3'/0*9 0(9-(9)($ #39 8*L -(55 U./). 0(9-(9)(

    /0 -.( )*6J3'/0*9 0(9-(9)(l Ib/9-> /- /0 -.( 0(9-(9)( -.3- -(550 *9( \L39-/-8 /0 6*'(

    *' 5(00 -.39 -.( *-.('$K

    5'(-%