Upload
adbi-publications
View
238
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
1/320
Ocmmdotbmh_cutn @sb` `mj_cutnd`st @sb`
@ KCBMZ _ZTJR CI ZND @_B@M JDYDAC\EDMZ F@MG @MJ ZND @_B@M JDYDAC\EDMZ F@MG BM_ZBZTZD
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
2/320
b
Ocmmdotbmh
_cutn @sb` `mj_cutnd`st @sb`
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
3/320
© 6228:--:->228:--? (\JI)
Znd vbdws dxprdssdj bm tnbs fccg `rd tncsd ci tnd `utncrs `mj jc mct mdodss`rbayrdstdot tnd vbdws ̀ mj pcabobds ci tnd @sb`m Jdvdacpedmt F`mg (@JF), tnd @sb`mJdvdacpedmt F`mg Bmstbtutd (@JFB), cr tndbr Fc`rj ci Hcvdrmcrs cr tnd hcvdrmedmtstndy rdprdsdmt.
@JF `mj @JFB jc mct hu`r`mtdd tnd `oour`oy ci tnd j`t` bmoaujdj bm tnbs pufabo`tbcm`mj ̀ oodpt mc rdspcmsbfbabty icr `my ocmsdqudmod ci tndbr usd.
Fy e`gbmh `my jdsbhm`tbcm ci cr rdidrdmod tc ` p`rtboua`r tdrrbtcry cr hdchr`pnbo `rd`,cr fy usbmh tnd tdre ‑ocumtry― cr ctndr hdchr`pnbo`a m`eds bm tnbs pufabo`tbcm, @JF`mj @JFB jc mct bmtdmj tc e`gd `my kujhedmts `s tc tnd adh`a cr ctndr st`tus ci `mytdrrbtcry cr `rd`.
Tsdrs ̀ rd rdstrbotdj irce rdsdaabmh, rdjbstrbfutbmh, cr ord`tbmh jdrbv`tbvd wcrgs wbtncuttnd dxprdss, wrbttdm ocmsdmt ci @JFB.
Mctd; Bm tnbs rdpcrt, ‑$― rdidrs tc T_ jcaa`rs.
@sb`m Jdvdacpedmt F`mg BmstbtutdG`suebh`sdgb Fubajbmh >I?-6-4, G`suebh`sdgb, Onbycj`-guZcgyc 0
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
4/320
bbb
Ocmtdmts
Abst ci Ibhurds, Z`fads, `mj Fcxds vb
Icrdwcrj x
@ogmcwadjhedmts xbb
@ffrdvb`tbcms xbv
Dxdoutbvd _uee`ry xvbb
On`ptdr 0; Bmtrcjuotbcm `mj Cvdrvbdw 0
0.0 Ocmtdxt ̀ mj @be ci tnd _tujy 00.6 V`tbcm`ad icr Hrd`tdr Docmcebo Bmtdhr`tbcm ̀ mj Occpdr`tbcm :
0.? @m`aytbo`a @pprc`on 80.: Orcss-Fcrjdr Zr`mspcrt Bmir`struoturd 0<0.4 Dmdrhy Bmir`struoturd `mj Zr`jbmh 040.9 Ibm`mobmh Bmir`struoturd 6<0.8 Zr`jd I`obabt`tbcm 660.> M`tbcm`a `mj Vdhbcm`a \caboy Vdicres 640.2 Bmstbtutbcm`a Vbsgs tc Ocmmdotbvbty 690.0< Bep`ots ci Beprcvdj Ocmmdotbvbty 620.00 Ocmoausbcms ?0
On`ptdr 6; Ourrdmt _t`td ci Orcss-Vdhbcm`a Docmcebo Zbds ?4
6.0 Bmtrcjuotbcm ?46.6 Zr`jd Abmgs ?46.? _uppay On`bms `mj _e`aa `mj Edjbue-_bzdj Dmtdrprbsds ?26.: Icrdbhm Jbrdot Bmvdstedmt :?6.4 Ibm`mob`a Iacws ::6.9 _uee`ry :9
On`ptdr ?; Orcss-Fcrjdr Zr`mspcrt Bmir`struoturd 4??.0 Bmtrcjuotbcm 4??.6 _ocpd ci _tujy `mj Ocmodpts 4:?.? Nbhnw`ys 4>?.: V`barc`js 86
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
5/320
bv Ocmtdmts
?.4 _d`pcrts >:?.9 _uee`ry ci \rbcrbty \rckdots 2>
?.8 Fdmdffts 0 Cfst`oads `mj Ocmstr`bmts 0 Ocmoausbcms 089
On`ptdr 9; Zr`jd I`obabt`tbcm 0>0
9.0 Bmtrcjuotbcm 0>09.6 _ocpd ci Zr`jd I`obabt`tbcm 0>6
9.? Cvdrvbdw ci Zr`jd I`obabt`tbcm 0>:9.: Bssuds `mj Fcttadmdogs 0>89.4 Vdhbcm`a Bmbtb`tbvds tc @jjrdss Bssuds 69.9 Ocmoausbcms 6089.8 Vdoceedmj`tbcms 666
On`ptdr 8; M`tbcm`a `mj Vdhbcm`a \caboy Vdicres 668
8.0 Bmtrcjuotbcm 6688.6 Zr`jd F`rrbdrs 668
8.? Irdd Zr`jd @hrddedmts 6?68.: Dxon`mhd V`td Vdhbeds 6?48.4 Ocmoausbcms 6?>
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
6/320
Ocmtdmts v
On`ptdr >; Vbsgs tc Ocmmdotbvbty `mj Bmstbtutbcm`a
@rr`mhdedmt 6:0
>.0 Bmtrcjuotbcm 6:0>.6 Vd`scms icr Vdhbcm`a Occrjbm`tbcm 6:6>.? Vdhbcm`a Bmstbtutbcms icr Ocmmdotbvbty 6:?>.: Ì otcrs @dotbmh _uoodss ci Occpdr`tbcm Bmbtb`tbvds 640>.4 Znd X`y Icrw`rj 648
On`ptdr 2; @ssdssbmh Bep`ots ci Vdhbcm`a Bmtdhr`tbcm 694
2.0 Bmtrcjuotbcm 6942.6 Zccas icr @ssdssbmh Docmcebo Ddots ci Vdhbcm`a Bmtdhr`tbcm 6992.? Dstbe`tbmh tnd Ddots ci Vdhbcm`a Bmtdhr`tbcm vb`
` OHD Ecjda 6802.: Pu`abt`tbvd Bssuds 6>:2.4 Ocmoausbcms 6>>
Abst ci F`oghrcumj \`pdrs icr tnd Ocmmdotbmh _cutn @sb` `mj_cutnd`st @sb` _tujy 62?
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
7/320
vb
Ibhurds, Z`fads, `mjFcxds
Ibhurds
0.0 Gdy Dadedmts icr \rcectbmh Orcss-Vdhbcm`a Ocmmdotbvbty 8
6.0 Zct`a Zr`jd fdtwddm _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`, 022
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
8/320
Ibhurds, Z̀ fads, `mj Fcxds vbb
9.0 Fuy‟_nbp‟\`y Ecjda 0>?9.6 Xcraj F`mg Jcbmh Fusbmdss; Zr`jbmh `orcss Fcrjdrs V`mgbmhs,
6
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
9/320
vbbb Ibhurds, Z̀ fads, `mj Fcxds
?.0< J`wdb‟Nc Onb Ebmn Obty \rbcrbty V`ba \rckdots >:?.00 Bjdmtbffdj \crt Jdvdacpedmt \rckdots 28?.06 \rbcrbty \rckdots 22?.0? _uee`ry ci Ocmmdotbvbty-Vda`tdj Vc`j, V`ba, `mj \crt
Bmir`struoturd \rckdots 0
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
10/320
Ibhurds, Z̀ fads, `mj Fcxds bx
9.0 Muefdrs ci Jcouedmts `mj Zbed Z`gdm icr Dxpcrt `mj BepcrtZr`ms`otbcms, 62
9.6 Ocrruptbcm \drodptbcms Bmjdx, 6
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
11/320
x
Icrdwcrj
Znd suoodss stcry ci docmcebo hrcwtn bm _cutnd`st @sb` cvdr tnd p`st idwjdo`jds bs wdaa gmcwm. Bt rdsuatdj irce `m cutw`rj-accgbmh str`tdhy cidxpcrt-crbdmtdj hrcwtn, ocupadj wbtn cpdmmdss tc icrdbhm jbrdot bmvdstedmt fy ecrd jdvdacpdj docmcebds fctn wbtnbm @sb̀ `mj cutsbjd, hdmdr̀ aaye`rgdt-irbdmjay pcabobds, `mj dxtdmsbvd bmvdstedmt bm bmir`struoturd. Bt adj
tc jddp docmcebo bmtdhr`tbcm ci _cutnd`st @sb`m docmcebds, dspdob`aay tndecst jdvdacpdj cmds, wbtn tncsd ci D`st @sb`, e`mbidstdj ecst mct`fay bmtnd r`pbj dxp`msbcm ci rdhbcm`a ̀ mj hacf`a suppay on`bm mdtwcrgs.
_cutn @sb` n`s ̀ asc dedrhdj ecrd rdodmtay ̀ s ̀ jym`ebo hrcwtn rdhbcm`s ` rdsuat ci e`rgdt-crbdmtdj rdicres. Bt bs mcw dmkcybmh tnd `jv`mt`hdsci fdbmh ` a`tdocedr wbtn rda`tbvday acw w`hds. Ncwdvdr, bm`jdqu`tdbmir`struoturd, nbhn advdas ci rdhua`tbcm `mj tr`jd f`rrbdrs, `mj bmdobdmtachbstbos systdes ed`m tn`t _cutn @sb` stbaa a`hs sbhmbffo`mtay bm tdres cijdvdacpedmt ci e`mui`oturbmh sdotcrs ̀ mj bts p`rtbobp`tbcm bm hacf`a suppay
on`bm mdtwcrgs. Znbs pcsds ` sbhmbffo`mt f`rrbdr tc bmord`sbmh hrcwtn citr`jd bm nbhn v`aud-`jjdj prcjuots, ̀ mj tnd rbsds bm prcjuotbvbty ̀ mj w`hdstn`t ocuaj rdsuat irce tnbs.
Zr`jd bs oad`ray ` e`bm dmhbmd ci hrcwtn. @atncuhn tr`jd fdtwddm_cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb` n`s hrcwm r`pbjay bm tnd p`st jdo`jd cr sc,tnd ocmtbmudj prdsdmod ci f`rrbdrs bm bmir`struoturd, tr`jd pcabobds, achbstbossystdes, `mj bmstbtutbcm`a h`ps ncajs tr`jd fdtwddm tndsd twc rdhbcms wdaa fdacw bts pctdmtb̀ a. D s̀bmh tndsd f`rrbdrs ocuaj ocmtrbfutd sufst`mtb àay tcprcectbmh sust`bm`fad hrcwtn bm tnd twc rdhbcms. Bm tnbs rdh`rj, tnd rdodmt
cpdmbmh up ci Ey`me`r bm pcabtbo`a `mj docmcebo tdres prcvbjds ` irdsncppcrtumbty tc rddv`au`td tnd pctdmtb`a icr bmord`sbmh tr`jd fdtwddm tndtwc rdhbcms.
@h`bmst tnbs f`ogjrcp, tnd @sb`m Jdvdacpedmt F`mg `mj tnd @sb`mJdvdacpedmt F`mg Bmstbtutd kcbmtay ocmjuotdj ̀ stujy ci w`ys tc prcectdtr`jd `mj bmvdstedmt fdtwddm tnd twc rdhbcms. Bt icousds cm fctn ‑n`rj―bmir`struoturd `mj `sscob`tdj ‑scit― bmir`struoturd, bmoaujbmh t`rbs `mjmcm-t`rb f`rrbdrs, tr`jd `mj tr`mspcrt i`obabt`tbcm, `s wdaa `s ffm`mod `mjbmstbtutbcm`a `spdots. Znd `be w`s twcicaj; tc fubaj tnd frc`j o`sd icr
bmord`sdj ocmmdotbvbty fdtwddm tnd twc rdhbcms `mj tc bjdmtbiy spdobffoprckdots tn`t ̀ ppd`r tc n`vd nbhn pctdmtb`a tc prcectd tnbs hdmdr`a ̀ be.
@sb̀ n`s ̀ nuhd jde`mj icr bmir`struoturd bm ̀ rd`s bmoaujbmh tr`mspcrt,oceeumbo`tbcms, `mj dmdrhy, wnbon o`mmct fd `ooceecj`tdj scaday fypufabo ffm`mod. _ced ocumtrbds e`y mddj n`rj bmir`struoturd `t tnbs tbed,
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
12/320
Icrdwcrj xb
wnbad ctndrs e`y mddj scit bmir`struoturd rda`tdj tc tr`jd `mj tr`mspcrti`obabt`tbcm, icr dx`epad. Zndsd `rd`s `asc rdqubrd iurtndr jdvdacpedmt ciffm`mob`a e`rgdts `mj bmstbtutbcms, bmoaujbmh aco`a hcvdrmedmt ffm`mod `mjprbv`td ffm`mod, wnbon o`m ndap on`mmda iumjs tc wcrtnwnbad bmvdstedmtprckdots tn`t n`vd fddm ecrd dxtdmsbvday ̀ m`ayzdj. \rckdot dv`au`tbcm bs ̀ ascrdqubrdj tc hdmdr`td adsscms ad`rmdj `mj fdst pr`otbods bm bmir`struoturdbmvdstedmts. Tsd ci pufabo‟prbv`td p`rtmdrsnbps o`m bmkdot prbv`td sdotcrjbsobpabmd bmtc prckdot sdadotbcm `mj bepadedmt`tbcm, fut tndy `rd mct `p`m`od`, `mj oacsd `ttdmtbcm tc tnd `aaco`tbcm ci ocsts, rbsgs, `mj fdmdffts bsmddjdj tc `vcbj i`baurd.
Hrd`tdr p`rtbobp`tbcm bm tr`jd o`aas icr bmord`sdj ocepdtbtbvdmdss `mjprcjuotbvbty. Znbs mct cmay bmoaujds prcectbmh tdonmcachbo`a bmmcv`tbcm`mj jbusbcm, fut `asc bmvcavds ord`tbmh `m dmvbrcmedmt tn`t icstdrs tndjdvdacpedmt ci mdw ocep`mbds tn`t wbaa defcjy tncsd tdonmcachbds bmmdw prcjuots `mj sdrvbods. Iurtndrecrd, se`aa ffres mddj hrd`tdr `oodsstc ffm`mod tc fd `fad tc p`rtbobp`td bm bmtdrm`tbcm`a tr`jd. Znbs rdqubrds `nbhndr st`hd ci ffm`mob`a jdvdacpedmt, bmoaujbmh dxp`msbcm ci ffm`mobmho`p`obty icr st`rt-up ocep`mbds. _bmod mdw ocep`mbds `rd typbo`aay se`aa,beprcvbmh ffm`mob`a ̀ oodss icr se`aa ̀ mj edjbue-sbzdj dmtdrprbsds (_EDs)sncuaj fd ` gdy `spdot ci suon ` str`tdhy. Znbs o`aas icr rda`tdj `otbvbtbdstn`t bmoaujd jdvdacpedmt ci vdmturd o`pbt`a, orcwjiumjbmh vdnboads suon`s ncedtcwm bmvdstedmt trust iumjs, `mj ordjbt e`rgdt j`t`f`sds suon `sK`p`m‒s Ordjbt Vbsg J`t`f`sd ci _EDs. Ibm`mobmh icr _EDs `mj st`rt-upocep`mbds tnrcuhn f`mg ac`ms o`m fd jbouat jud tc tnd umodrt`bmty citndbr fusbmdss.
Iadxbfad dxon`mhd r`tds o`m `asc suppcrt ocepdtbtbvdmdss `mj hrcwtnci tr`jd, sufkdot tc tnd ocmstr`bmt tn`t o`pbt`a stcw vca`tbabty bs mct tcc hrd`t.Zndy o`m `asc suppcrt ecrd cpdm o`pbt`a e`rgdts tn`t i`obabt`td tnd irddrstcw ci icrdbhm jbrdot bmvdstedmt `mj pcrticabc bmvdstedmt tc `ttr`otbvdbmvdstedmt prckdots.
Znbs stujy sddgs tc ocmtrbfutd tc ̀ fdttdr umjdrst`mjbmh ci tnd jym`ebosci tnd dedrhbmh docmcebds bm tndsd twc rdhbcms spd`rnd`jbmh @sb`‒s iuturddocmcebo jdvdacpedmt `mj tc stbeua`td irdsn tnbmgbmh cm pcaboy scautbcmstc dedrhbmh jdvdacpedmt on`aadmhds.
Fbmju M. Acn`mb Ybod-\rdsbjdmt(Gmcwadjhd E`m`hdedmt`mj _ust`bm`fad Jdvdacpedmt) @sb`m Jdvdacpedmt F`mg
M`cyugb RcsnbmcJd`m @sb`m Jdvdacpedmt F`mg Bmstbtutd
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
13/320
xbb
@ogmcwadjhedmts
Znbs stujy Ocmmdotbmh _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb` w`s ` kcbmt prckdotci tnd @sb`m Jdvdacpedmt F`mg (@JF) `mj tnd @sb`m JdvdacpedmtF`mg Bmstbtutd (@JFB). Znd icaacwbmh @JF jdp`rtedmts wdrd bmvcavdjbm tnd stujy; _cutn @sb` Jdp`rtedmt, _cutnd`st @sb` Jdp`rtedmt,Cod ci Vdhbcm`a Docmcebo Bmtdhr`tbcm, `mj Docmcebos `mj Vdsd`ron
Jdp`rtedmt.Znd stujy w`s bmbtb`tdj umjdr tnd cvdr`aa hubj`mod ci ` stddrbmh
oceebttdd on`brdj fy E`s`nbrc G`w`b (icredr Jd`m `mj ODC ci @JFB) `mj V`k`t E. M`h (icredr E`m`hbmh Jbrdotcr Hdmdr`a ci @JF).Bt w`s ocepcsdj ci sdvdr`a nd`js ci @JF‒s cpdr`tbcms `mj gmcwadjhdjdp`rtedmts, bmoaujbmh Bw`m @zbs, \nbabp Drqub`h`, Ku`m Ebr`mj`,On`mhycmh Vndd, G`zu _`g`b, ̀ mj Gumbc _dmh`. Znd stujy w`s ocepadtdjumjdr tnd str`tdhbo hubj`mod ci M`cyugb Rcsnbmc (Jd`m ci @JFB). Ku`mEbr`mj` (E`m`hbmh Jbrdotcr Hdmdr`a ci @JF) `asc prcvbjdj v`au`fad
oceedmts.Ebon`da \aueedr (Jbrdotcr, _@B_ Durcpd, `mj Dmb \rcidsscr ci
Bmtdrm`tbcm`a Docmcebos, Kcnms Ncpgbms Tmbvdrsbty) w`s tnd ad`jocmsuat`mt icr tnd stujy. \dtdr K. Ecrh`m (_dmbcr Ocmsuat`mt icrVdsd`ron, @JFB) sdrvdj ̀ s tnd prckdot t`sg e`m`hdr icr tnd stujy umjdrtnd supdrvbsbcm ci H`mdsn`m Xbhm`r`k` (Jbrdotcr ci Vdsd`ron, @JFB).
Znd ffm`a rdpcrt w`s wrbttdm fy ` td`e ci @JF `mj @JFB st` `mjocmsuat`mts. Znd ffm`a rdpcrt w`s prdp`rdj fy Ebon`da \aueedr, \dtdrK. Ecrh`m, `mj H`mdsn`m Xbhm`r`k` wbtn sufst`mtb`a ocmtrbfutbcms
irce f`oghrcumj p`pdrs cm tnde`tbo tcpbos `mj bmjbvbju`a ocumtrystujbds wrbttdm `s p`rt ci tnd prckdot. Znd `utncrs ci tnd tnde`tbo p`pdrsbmoaujd Kd`m-Ir`mocbs H`utrbm (a`mj tr`mspcrt)7 J`vbj Xbhm`aa `mj E`rgXbhm`aa (sd` tr`mspcrt)7 @mtncmy F`yady (tr`jd i`obabt`tbcm)7 _nufncecyV`y (bmir`struoturd ffm`mod)7 Ecd Znuz`r, Ir`mobs Nutonbmscm, V`nuaEbsnr`, Zbm E`umh E`umh Zn`m, `mj Zdres`g On`adrep`a`mup`p(bmstbtutbcms)7 `mj I`m [n`b (OHD ecjdabmh). Znd `utncrs ci tnd ocumtrystujbds bmoaujd Eust`ffzur V`ne`m, Gncmj`gdr Hca`e Ec`zzde,Ednrum` Bsa`e Oncwjnury, `mj I`rz`m` _dnrbm (F`mha`jdsn)7 \r`fbr
Jd (Bmjb`)7 Ndotcr Iacrdmtc `mj E`rb` Bs`fda` Ocrpuz (Ey`me`r)7\r`juem` F. V`m` `mj Fbmcj G`re`on`ry` (Mdp`a)7 Jusnmb Xddr`gccm`mj Mbpumb \drdr` (_rb A`mg`)7 `mj _utnbpn`mj Onbr`tnbv`t `mjGcrmg`rum Onddw`tr`gccapcmh (Zn`ba`mj). Kdmmy F`afc`, R`m [n`mh,
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
14/320
@ogmcwadjhedmts xbbb
^b`cebmh \`m, Edm`g` @rujondav`m, `mj Fccm Accmh Mhb`mh `t @JFB`asc ocmtrbfutdj.
Oceedmts `mj suhhdstbcms wdrd hbvdm fy, `ecmh ctndrs, _numsugdF`mjc, _dgn`r Fcmu, \dtdr Frbefad, Vcmmbd Futbcmh, Hbcv`mmbO`p`mmdaab, Rusnu Idmh, @rkum Hcsw`eb, Ndr`tn Hum`tba`gd, Z`j`tdruN`y`snb, Ecn`eedj [`nbj Ncss`bm, Ecn`eedj \`rvdz Bej`j, K`ebdAd`tndr, K`eds Aymon, _`fy Ebtr`, Oucmh Ebmn Mhuydm, Oym-Rcumh \`rg,E`mecn`m \`rg`sn, Ybvdg V`c, Mdwbm _bmsbrb, V`edsn _ufr`e`mb`e,Eyc Zn`mt, Xbmirbdj I. Xbogadbm, \rby`mtn` Xbk`y`tumh`, Nbrc`gb R`e`huonb, `mj Rbmh Pb`m ci @JF.
\`rtbobp`mts `t v`rbcus dvdmts prcvbjdj v`au`fad oceedmts tctnd prckdot, bmoaujbmh tnd bmodptbcm eddtbmh `mj wcrgsncp bm Zcgyc,tnd tdonmbo`a ocmidrdmod bm E`mba`, tnd pcaboy jb`achud bm E`mba`,`mj jbssdebm`tbcm dvdmts bm F`mhgcg, Mdw Jdanb, `mj Zcgyc; Mbsn`Z`mdk` (\rcidsscr, BOVBDV), G`m [`w (Ebmbstdr ci M`tbcm`a \a`mmbmh`mj Docmcebo Jdvdacpedmt, Ey`me`r), Nbrcsnb X`t`m`fd (ODC`mj Dxdoutbvd E`m`hbmh Jbrdotcr, K`p`m F`mg icr Bmtdrm`tbcm`aOccpdr`tbcm), Jnruf` \urg`y`stn` (Znd Xcraj F`mg), Obmm`ecmJcrmsbid (@otbmh Jbrdotcr ci tnd Bmtdrm`tbcm`a Jdvdacpedmt \rchr`e,Znd \`ua N. Mbtzd _oncca ci @jv`modj Bmtdrm`tbcm`a _tujbds, KcnmsNcpgbms Tmbvdrsbty), _df`stb`m \`ust (_dmbcr @jvbscr tc tnd E`m`hdedmtFc`rj, Jdutsond Hdsdaason`it iñr Bmtdrm`tbcm`ad [us`eedm`rfdbt), @kbtGue`r _dtn (O`fbmdt _dordt`ry, Hcvdrmedmt ci Bmjb`), _c Tedz`gb(Jbrdotcr, Bmstbtutd ci Jdvdacpbmh Docmcebds, K`p`m Dxtdrm`a Zr`jdCrh`mbz`tbcm), `mj @rvbmj _bmhn (Ebmbstdr ‟ Docmcebo, Def`ssy ciBmjb` bm K`p`m), `mj e`my ecrd.
Znd rdpcrt w`s djbtdj, typdsdt, `mj prbmtdj umjdr tnd occrjbm`tbcmci @JFB‒s pufabo`tbcms umbt nd`jdj fy Vcfdrt J`vbs. Hr`mt _tbaae`m `mjZsuycsnb Nycg`b ci @JFB cvdrs`w tnd prckdot‒s ocmtr`ot `jebmbstr`tbcm`mj ffm`mobmh, wbtn tnd suppcrt ci Rug`rb Z`gduonb `mj Zcgbgc R`e`m`g`.
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
15/320
xbv
@ffrdvb`tbcms
@JF @sb`m Jdvdacpedmt F`mg
@JFB @sb`m Jdvdacpedmt F`mg Bmstbtutd
@DO @_D@M Docmcebo Oceeumbty
@DC `utncrbzdj docmcebo cpdr`tcr
@IZ@ @_D@M Irdd Zr`jd @rd`
@N @sb`m Nbhnw`y
@NM @sb`m Nbhnw`y Mdtwcrg
@BE_ @_D@M Bmtdrocmmdotbcm E`stdr \a`m _tujy
@\DO @sb`-\`obffo Docmcebo Occpdr`tbcm
@_OC\D @_D@M Ocumoba cm \dtrcadue
@_D@M @sscob`tbcm ci _cutnd`st @sb`m M`tbcms
@_D@M+? @_D@M edefdrs, paus tnd \VO, K̀ p`m, `mj tnd Vdpufaboci Gcrd`
@_X @_D@M _bmhad Xbmjcw @_ROTJ@ @utce`tdj _ystdes icr Oustces J`t`
F@T fusbmdss-`s-usu`a
FO\ fcrjdr orcssbmh pcbmt
FBE_ZDO F`y ci Fdmh`a Bmbtb`tbvd icr Euatb-_dotcr`a Zdonmbo à `mjDocmcebo Occpdr`tbcm
FCCZ fubaj‟cwm‟cpdr`td‟tr`msidr
O&I ocst ̀ mj irdbhnt
OFZ@ Orcss-Fcrjdr Zr`msbt @hrddedmtOJE Oad`m Jdvdacpedmt Edon`mbse
OOO oustces occpdr`tbcm oceebttdd
OHD oceput`fad hdmdr`a dqubabfrbue
OHBI Ordjbt Hu`r`mtdd ̀ mj Bmvdstedmt I`obabty
OBB Ocmidjdr`tbcm ci Bmjb`m Bmjustrbds
OBP_ oustces‟beebhr`tbcm‟qu`r`mtbmd‟sdourbty
JIB jdvdacpedmt ffm`mod bmstbtutbcm
JZB jbrdot tr`jdr bmput
D@_ D`st @sb` _ueebt
D@ZV ddotbvday ̀ ppabdj t`rb r`td
DO@ dxpcrt ordjbt ̀ hdmoy
DOD Docmcebo Oceebssbcm icr Durcpd
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
16/320
@ffrdvb`tbcms xv
DDZ dmn`modj dmdrhy tr`jd
DEB dmdrhy e`rgdt bmtdhr`tbcm
D\O dmhbmddrbmh, prcourdedmt, ̀ mj ocmstruotbcmDVB@ Docmcebo Vdsd`ron Bmstbtutd icr @_D@M `mj D`st @sb`
DXDO D`st‟Xdst Docmcebo Ocrrbjcr
IJB icrdbhm jbrdot bmvdstedmt
IZ@ irdd tr`jd ̀ hrddedmt
HJ\ hrcss jcedstbo prcjuot
HE_ Hrd`tdr Edgcmh _ufrdhbcm
NJ_ N`ajb` Jcog _ystde
BOJ bma`mj oad`r`mod jdpct
BO\ bmtdhr`tdj ondog pcst
BOZ bmicre`tbcm ̀ mj oceeumbo`tbcm tdonmcachy
BIO Bmtdrm`tbcm`a Ibm`mod Ocrpcr`tbcm
BIB bmtdrm`tbcm`a ffm`mob`a bmstbtutbcm
BBIOA Bmjb` Bmir`struoturd Ibm`mod Ocep`my
BEI Bmtdrm`tbcm`a Ecmdt`ry Iumj
BEZZN Bmjb`‟Ey`me`r‟Zn b̀à mj Zrbà tdr̀ a Nbhnw`y
KFBO K`p`m F`mg icr Bmtdrm`tbcm`a Occpdr`tbcm
KBO@ K`p`m Bmtdrm`tbcm`a Occpdr`tbcm @hdmoy GJ_ Gcag`t` Jcog _ystde
A`c \JV A`c \dcpad‒s Jdecor`tbo Vdpufabo
ABBZ aco`a bmir`struoturd bmvdstedmt trust
AMH abqudffdj m`tur`a h`s
EJF euatba`tdr`a jdvdacpedmt f`mg
EIM ecst i`vcrdj m`tbcm
EHO Edgcmh‟H`mh` Occpdr`tbcm
EBDO Edgcmh‟Bmjb` Docmcebo OcrrbjcrECT edecr`mjue ci umjdrst`mjbmh
E\@O E`stdr \a`m cm @_D@M Ocmmdotbvbty
EV@ eutu`a rdochmbtbcm ̀ hrddedmt
M_DO Mcrtn‟_cutn Docmcebo Ocrrbjcr
M_X M`tbcm`a _bmhad Xbmjcw
MZF mcm-t`rb f`rrbdr
CDOJ Crh`mbs`tbcm icr Docmcebo Oc-cpdr`tbcm ̀ mjJdvdacpedmt
\\\ pufabo‟prbv`td p`rtmdrsnbp
\VO \dcpad‒s Vdpufabo ci Onbm`
VOD\ Vdhbcm`a Oceprdndmsbvd Docmcebo \`rtmdrsnbp
VBI rdhbcm`a bmir`struoturd iumj
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
17/320
xvb Ocmmdotbmh _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`
VGO Vdvbsdj Gyctc Ocmvdmtbcm
VCC ruads ci crbhbm
_@/_D@ _cutn @sb`/_cutnd`st @sb`_@@VO _cutn @sb`m @sscob`tbcm icr Vdhbcm`a Occpdr`tbcm
_@IZ@ _cutn @sb`m Irdd Zr`jd @rd`
_@_DO _cutn @sb` _ufrdhbcm`a Docmcebo Occpdr`tbcm
_O _cutndrm Ocrrbjcr
_DO _cutndrm Docmcebo Ocrrbjcr
_GVA _bmh`pcrd‟Gumebmh V`ba Abmg
_EDs se`aa ̀ mj edjbue-sbzdj dmtdrprbsds
_\O spdob`a purpcsd ocep`my
_\_ s`mbt`ry ̀ mj pnytcs`mbt`ry st`mj`rjs
_X _bmhad Xbmjcw
Z@H\ Zr`ms-@_D@M H`s \bpdabmd
Z@V Zr`ms-@sb`m V`baw`y
ZFZ tdonmbo`a f`rrbdrs tc tr`jd
ZI@ Zr`jd I`obabt`tbcm @hrddedmt
ZBV Bmtdrm`tbcm`a Vc`j Zr`mspcrt
Z\\ Zr`ms-\`obffo \`rtmdrsnbp
TMD_O@\ Tmbtdj M`tbcms Docmcebo ̀ mj _cob`a Oceebssbcm icr @sb` `mj tnd \`obffo
XOC Xcraj Oustces Crh`mbz`tbcm
XZC Xcraj Zr`jd Crh`mbz`tbcm
Xdbhnts `mj Ed`surds
ffa fbaabcm f`rrdas foe fbaabcm oufbo edtdrs
JXZ jd`jwdbhnt tcm
HX hbh`w`tt
HXn hbh`w`tt-ncur
ge gbacedtdr
GX gbacw`tt
gY gbacvcat
EZ\@ ebaabcm tcmmd pdr ̀ mmueEX edh`w`tt
toi trbaabcm oufbo iddt
ZDT twdmty-icct dqubv`admt umbt
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
18/320
xvbb
Dxdoutbvd _uee`ry
Ocmtdxt `mj Cutabmd ci _tujy
Znd docmcebds ci _cutn @sb` ̀ mj _cutnd`st @sb` ̀ rd hrcwbmh ̀ mj icrhbmh
oacsdr docmcebo tbds bm ` ir`hbad wcraj docmcey fdsdt fy rbsgs. Znbshrcwtn prcodss n`s fddm iudadj fy i`otcrs bmoaujbmh i`aabmh tr`jd `mjbmvdstedmt f`rrbdrs, dxp`mjbmh prcjuotbcm mdtwcrgs ̀ mj suppay on`bms,` oceecjbty fcce, `mj ndbhntdmdj jde`mj irce ` rbsbmh ebjjad oa`ss.Ncwdvdr, bmtdhr`tbcm ci tr`jd, bmvdstedmt, `mj ffm`mob`a stcws fdtwddmtndsd twc rdhbcms, wnbad e`gbmh prchrdss, n`s fddm abebtdj, nbmjdrdj fy fcttadmdogs `mj h`ps bm tr`jd bmir`struoturd, ffm`mob`a e`rgdts,tr`jd i`obabt`tbcm, tr`jd f`rrbdrs, `mj abebtdj rdhbcm`a occpdr`tbcm.Bm p`rtboua`r, _cutn @sb` stbaa a`hs bm bts p`rtbobp`tbcm bm suppay on`bmmdtwcrgs.
Znd rdodmt pcabtbo`a `mj docmcebo rdicres bm Ey`me`r‚` gdya`mj frbjhd fdtwddm tnd twc rdhbcms‚e`gd pcssbfad oacsdr docmcebotbds `mj ocmmdotbvbty tn`t wdrd mct id`sbfad ` idw yd`rs `hc. @ prc- fusbmdss Bmjb`m hcvdrmedmt prcvbjds rdmdwdj bepdtus icr jddpdmbmhjcedstbo docmcebo rdicres, iurtndrbmh Bmjb`‒s Accg D`st \caboy`mj dmn`mobmh orcss-fcrjdr bmir`struoturd bmvdstedmts. Znd ecvdtcw`rj `m @sscob`tbcm ci _cutnd`st @sb`m M`tbcms (@_D@M) DocmceboOceeumbty (@DO) bm 6
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
19/320
xvbbb Dxdoutbvd _uee`ry
`fcut str`tdhbo orcss-fcrjdr bmir`struoturd bmvdstedmts `mj pcaboyrdicres `mj icousds cm tnd icaacwbmh bssuds;
E`ps dvcavbmh docmcebo tbds bm tr`jd, icrdbhm bmvdstedmt, `mjffm`mod fdtwddm _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`.
@m`ayzds tnd ourrdmt st`td ci orcss-fcrjdr tr`mspcrt `mj dmdrhybmir`struoturd, bmoaujbmh usd ci `m dmdrhy suppay ecjda, `mjbjdmtbffds fcttadmdogs `mj prbcrbty bmvdstedmt prckdots tn`tocuaj rdabdvd tncsd fcttadmdogs.
@ssdssds tnd dmvbrcmedmt icr ffm`mobmh orcss-fcrjdrbmir`struoturd ̀ mj edon`mbses icr bmord`sbmh prbv`td ffm`mobmh
icr prckdots bmoaujbmh pufabo‟prbv`td sdotcr p`rtmdrsnbps. Dx`ebmds tnd rcad ci tr`jd i`obabt`tbcm `mj tr`jd pcabobds `t
m`tbcm`a ̀ mj rdhbcm`a advdas tc i`obabt`td tnd stcw ci hccjs `orcss fcrjdrs `mj prcectd rdhbcm`a tr`jd.
Ocmsbjdrs bmstbtutbcm`a rbsgs `sscob`tdj wbtn `ttdepts tcbeprcvd orcss-rdhbcm`a ocmmdotbvbty.
Tsbmh ` st`td-ci-tnd-`rt oceput`fad hdmdr`a dqubabfrbue(OHD) ecjda, qu`mtbt`tbvday `ssdssds tnd docmcebo bep`ot cia`rhdr rdhbcm`a bmtdhr`tbcm sondeds bmvcavbmh _cutn @sb`m `mj
_cutnd`st @sb`m docmcebds.
Znd stujy w`s ocmjuotdj cvdr cmd `mj ` n`ai yd`rs fy ` td`eoceprbsbmh st` `mj ocmsuat`mts irce @JF `mj @JFB. Znd stujy jrdwcm f`oghrcumj tnde`tbo p`pdrs cm ocmmdotbvbty `mj `sscob`tdj scitbmir`struoturd bssuds ̀ mj ocumtry p`pdrs cm sdadotdj docmcebds bm _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`.
E`bm Ibmjbmhs `mj Vdoceedmj`tbcms
Docmcebo tbds fdtwddm tndsd twc rdhbcms, wnbad e`gbmh prchrdss,n`vd fddm abebtdj, nbmjdrdj fy fcttadmdogs bm bmir`struoturd, ffm`mob`ae`rgdts, tr`jd i`obabt`tbcm, tr`jd f`rrbdrs, `mj abebtdj rdhbcm`aoccpdr`tbcm. _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb` orcss-rdhbcm`a tr`jd n`sbmord`sdj 6? tbeds irce $: fbaabcm tc $2< fbaabcm irce 022< tc 6
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
20/320
Dxdoutbvd _uee`ry xbx
tbds fdtwddm tnd twc rdhbcms. Bm p`rtboua`r, IJB-jrbvdm prcjuotbcmmdtwcrgs `mj p`rts `mj ocepcmdmts tr`jd, wnbon `rd ` gdy jrbvdr citr`jd dxp`msbcm bm _cutnd`st @sb`, n`vd ydt tc t`gd ffre rcct bm _cutn @sb`. _e`aa `mj edjbue-sbzdj dmtdrprbsds (_EDs), wnbon ocmstbtutdtnd fuag ci depacyedmt bm _cutn @sb`m `mj _cutnd`st @sb`m docmcebds,n`vd abebtdj prdsdmod bm tr`jd. Iurtndrecrd, dxoaujbmh _bmh`pcrd,cutst`mjbmh pcrticabc bmvdstedmt irce _cutnd`st @sb` tc _cutn @sb`w`s se`aa, tct`abmh cmay `fcut $884 ebaabcm bm 6
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
21/320
xx Dxdoutbvd _uee`ry
dadotrbo pcwdr `mj m`tur`a h`s pbpdabmd tdonmcachy `s wdaa `s rdhua`tcry f`rrbdrs `mj jbstcrtdj dmdrhy prbobmh `mj/cr sufsbjy rdhbeds.
Znd tct`a bmvdstedmt ocsts icr prckdots tc dmn`mod orcss-rdhbcm`aocmmdotbvbty (bm nbhnw`ys, r`barc`js, pcrts, `mj dmdrhy tr`jbmh) `rddstbe`tdj `t $8? fbaabcm. Znbs ffhurd bmoaujds $0> fbaabcm icr rc`js,$?: fbaabcm icr r`baw`ys, $00 fbaabcm icr pcrt prckdots, `mj $0< fbaabcm icrdmdrhy tr`jbmh prckdots.0 Znd nbhn ocsts `mj euatbpabobty ci prckdots `swdaa `s nue`m o`p`obty ocmstr`bmts o`aa icr ` sdqudmodj `pprc`on f`sdjcm prbcrbtbds. @oocrjbmhay, tnd tct`a ocsts icr prbcrbty bmvdstedmt prckdotsbm tr`mspcrt `rd dstbe`tdj `t $> fbaabcm (bmoaujbmh $0 fbaabcm icr rc`js,$4 fbaabcm icr r`barc`js, `mj $6 fbaabcm icr pcrts).
Vc`j ocrrbjcr cptbcms tc ocmmdot _cutn @sb` tc _cutnd`st @sb` n`vd fddm dv`au`tdj `mj tnd fdst cptbcm bs tnd :,:?< gbacedtdr Gcag`t`‟Nc OnbEbmn Obty ocrrbjcr. Bm tnd o`sd ci r`ba ocmmdotbvbty, tnd Gcag`t`‟Nc OnbEbmn Obty ocrrbjcr `mj ocmmdotbcms tnrcuhn Rumm`m \rcvbmod, tnd \VO,`rd tnd prdidrrdj cptbcms. Ncwdvdr, r`ba ocmmdotbvbty oceds `s ` sdocmjprbcrbty `itdr rc`j ocmmdotbvbty jud tc euon nbhndr ocsts, ecrd dxtdmsbvdh`ps, `mj bmocep`tbfbabtbds fdtwddm m`tbcm`a mdtwcrgs. Ed`mwnbad,e`rbtbed ocmmdotbvbty jdsdrvds ecrd `ttdmtbcm `s bt bs tnd e`bm ecjd icrtr`jd fdtwddm _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`. \rbcrbty sd`pcrt prckdotsbmoaujd ocmstruotbcm ci mdw jddpw`tdr pcrts cr stc`tbmh ocmt`bmdrtr`mssnbpedmt tdrebm`as `t Onbtt`hcmh `mj Gcag`t`, `mj beprcvdedmt citnd rc`j bmir`struoturd abmgbmh Znba`w` \crt wbtn R`mhcm.
Ibm`mobmh orcss-rdhbcm`a bmir`struoturd prckdots rde`bms on`aadmhbmh.Orcss-fcrjdr ffm`mobmh vdnboads jc mct dxbst `s rbsg-`vdrsd prbv`tdbmvdstcrs `rd ndsbt`mt tc orcss fcrjdrs `acmd. \ufabo sdotcr iumjbmhpa`ys ` e`kcr rcad bm ffm`mobmh bmir`struoturd prckdots fut bs fdocebmhbmord`sbmhay sufkdot tc ffso`a ocmstr`bmts bm sced docmcebds. Bm` muefdr ci ocumtrbds, oceedrob`a f`mgs `rd e`kcr scurods cibmir`struoturd ffm`mobmh. Ncwdvdr, icaacwbmh tnd hacf`a ffm`mob`a orbsbs`mj tnd strdmhtndmbmh ci f`mgbmh rdhua`tbcms, f`mg ac`ms `rd fdocebmhso`rodr, `s oceedrob`a f`mgs n`vd fddm rdjuobmh tndbr dxpcsurd tcprckdot ffm`mod. Znd jdvdacpedmt ci @sb`m ffm`mob`a e`rgdts `mjrda`tdj bmbtb`tbvds `rd mddjdj tc strdmhtndm `oodss tc bmir`struoturdffm`mod. Fcmj e`rgdts o`m pa`y `m bmord`sbmh rcad bm on`mmdabmh @sb`ms`vbmhs tcw`rj bmir`struoturd prckdots. Hu`r`mtdds icr prckdot fcmjse`y ndap icstdr jde`mj icr tndsd prcjuots fy acmh-tdre bmstbtutbcm`abmvdstcrs (icr dx`epad, pdmsbcm iumjs `mj abid bmsur`mod ocep`mbds).
0 Znd ffhurds cmay ocvdr prckdots jbrdotay rda`tdj tc ocmmdotbvbty fdtwddm _cutn @sb``mj _cutnd`st @sb`. \rckdots rda`tdj prbe`rbay tc bmtr`-rdhbcm`a ocmmdotbvbty crocmmdotbvbty wbtn ctndr rdhbcms ̀ rd mct bmoaujdj.
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
22/320
Dxdoutbvd _uee`ry xxb
Bmir`struoturd iumjs, fctn jcedstbo `mj bmtdrm`tbcm`a, `rd v`au`fad,dspdob`aay bi tnd @_D@M Bmir`struoturd Iumj bs dxtdmjdj tc ` p`m-@sb`mbmir`struoturd iumj ocvdrbmh _cutn @sb` `s wdaa. Ed`surds tc bmtdhr`tdrdhbcm`a ffm`mob`a e`rgdts `mj d`sd rdstrbotbcms cm bmtdrm`tbcm`a o`pbt`astcws o`m `asc ocmtrbfutd.
\ufabo‟prbv`td p`rtmdrsnbps (\\\s) prcvbjd `m bepcrt`mt tcp-upicr bmir`struoturd iumjbmh, fut `rd mct ` p`m`od`. Bmjb`‒s dxpdrbdmodsncws tn`t tnd \\\ ecjda o`m fd ` usdiua p`rt ci tnd scautbcm icrffm`mobmh bmir`struoturd prckdots, mct cmay icr dmdrhy, fut icr tr`mspcrt`s wdaa, bmoaujbmh nbhnw`ys. Beprcvbmh tnd tr`msp`rdmoy, rdhua`tcryir`edwcrg, `mj hcvdrm`mod ci \\\ prckdots, tchdtndr wbtn tnd `jjbtbcmci pcabtbo`a rbsg hu`r`mtdds, o`m bmord`sd tnd `ttr`otbvdmdss ci tnbs `ssdtoa`ss. Iurtndrecrd, suppcrt irce euatba`tdr`a jdvdacpedmt f`mgs `mjbmtdrm`tbcm`a occrjbm`tbcm icr orcss-fcrjdr prckdots o`m ndap dmsurdsuoodss bm \\\s. Bmord`sbmhay, euatba`tdr`a jdvdacpedmt f`mgs e`y fd rdqubrdj tc pa`y euatbpad rcads bm ` prckdot‒s ffm`mob`a abidoyoadp`rtboua`ray bm adss jdvdacpdj docmcebds.
Beprcvbmh tr`jd ̀ mj tr`mspcrt i`obabt`tbcm wcuaj e`gd tr`jbmh fdtwddm_cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb` d`sbdr `mj ecrd st`fad, wbtn acwdrtr`ms`otbcm ocsts. Fusbmdssds ocepa`bm `fcut dxodssbvd jcouedmt`tbcmrdqubrdedmts icr oustces oad`r`mod `mj sc i`r tndrd n`s fddm cmayabebtdj `jndrdmod bm tnd rdhbcms tc tnd Xcraj Oustces Crh`mbz`tbcm‒sVdvbsdj Gyctc Ocmvdmtbcm, wnbon bs tnd bmtdrm`tbcm`a fdst pr`otbodicr oustces ecjdrmbz`tbcm. Znd jdvdacpedmt ci m`tbcm`a `mj rdhbcm`a_bmhad Xbmjcws wbaa fd `m bepcrt`mt id`turd bm tnd mdxt idw yd`rs. Znd @_D@M _bmhad Xbmjcw bmbtb`tbvd bs mcw fdbmh bepadedmtdj. Ocumtry-advda tr`jd i`obabt`tbcm prchr`es ̀ rd ̀ asc fdbmh umjdrt`gdm bm _cutn @sb``mj _cutnd`st @sb` tc `oodjd tc tnd Vdvbsdj Gyctc Ocmvdmtbcm `mj tcecjdrmbzd oustces e`m`hdedmt `mj `jebmbstr`tbcm. Zndrd bs ` mddjtc ocmsbjdr jdvdacpedmt ci ` rdhbcm`a sbmhad wbmjcw bmbtb`tbvd ocvdrbmh_cutn @sb` tn`t ocuaj pctdmtb`aay fd tnrcuhn tnd _cutn @sb`m @sscob`tbcmicr Vdhbcm`a Occpdr`tbcm (_@@VO), tnd F`y ci Fdmh`a Bmbtb`tbvd icrEuatb-_dotcr`a Zdonmbo`a `mj Docmcebo Occpdr`tbcm (FBE_ZDO),_cutn @sb` _ufrdhbcm`a Docmcebo Occpdr`tbcm (_@_DO), cr pdrn`ps `ocefbmdj _@_DO‟HE_ pa`ticre. _trd`eabmbmh ci jcouedmts rdqubrdjicr oustces oad`r`mod p`rtboua`ray bm _cutn @sb` wcuaj usdiuaaysuppcrt ` str`tdhy ci bmicre`tbcm `mj oceeumbo`tbcm tdonmcachy(BOZ) jdvdacpedmt. Znd a`og ci orcss-fcrjdr tr`msbt `hrddedmts bm tndtwc rdhbcms bs `mctndr cfst`oad tn`t mddjs tc fd `jjrdssdj. Ibm`aay, tnddepn`sbs sncuaj hr`ju`aay fd snbitdj irce oustces rdicres tcw`rj`jjrdssbmh ecrd ci tnd mcm-oustces bssuds, suon `s s`mbt`ry, qu`r`mtbmd,pnytcs`mbt`ry, vdtdrbm`ry, `mj tr`jbmh st`mj`rjs. Znbs ebhnt dvdmbmoaujd tnd jdvdacpedmt ci rdhbcm`aay-f`sdj tdstbmh i`obabtbds tc suppcrt
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
23/320
xxbb Dxdoutbvd _uee`ry
m`tbcm`a a`fcr`tcrbds, suon `s tn`t fdbmh prcpcsdj `t _babhurb, Bmjb` tcocvdr tnd _@_DO ocumtrbds.
Z`rbs `mj mcm-t`rb f`rrbdrs (MZFs) ocmtbmud tc n`epdr tr`jd `mjbmvdstedmt stcws fdtwddm _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`. Z`rbs n`vdtypbo`aay i`aadm bm fctn rdhbcms fut e`my t`rb spbgds dxbst ̀ t tnd prcjuotadvda. @m dstbe`tdj 84%‟>
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
24/320
Dxdoutbvd _uee`ry xxbbb
Accgbmh `nd`j, bt e`y fd prcjuotbvd tc dxpacrd sced w`y tc abmg _@_DOwbtn tnd HE_. \drn`ps ` pr`he`tbo w`y tc st`rt bs tc prcvbjd cfsdrvdrst`tus icr HE_ cob`as `t _@_DO eddtbmhs `mj vbod vdrs`. _ufsdqudmtay,bt e`y fd usdiua tc icous cm spdobffo rdhbcm`a ocmmdotbvbty prckdots `mjtc ocmvdmd prckdot-spdobffo tdonmbo`a wcrgbmh hrcups tc cvdrsdd tndpa`mmbmh `mj bepadedmt`tbcm ci tnd prckdots. Zndsd prckdots ocuaj, bmturm, fd bmoaujdj bm tnd `hdmj` ci eddtbmhs ci tnd rdadv`mt HE_ `mj_@_DO wcrgbmh hrcups. Zc strdmhtndm tnd o`p`obty ci ocumtrbds suon `sEy`me`r, F`mha`jdsn, `mj Bmjb` tc rd`abzd tndbr pctdmtb`a `s tnd a`mj frbjhd fdtwddm _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`, bt bs bepcrt`mt icr tnd fba`tdr à prckdots `mj prchr`es tc rdidr tc @_D@M oceebtedmts bm tndo`sd ci Ey`me`r, `mj tc depn`sbzd tnd FBE_ZDO `mj _@_DO cvdra`psicr F`mha`jdsn ̀ mj Bmjb`.
Znd pctdmtb`a h`bms irce ocmmdotbvbty-adj oacsdr _cutn @sb`m‟_cutnd`st @sb`m bmtdhr`tbcm sncuaj fd a`rhd. Znbs stujy usdj ` ecjdrmOHD ecjda tc dxpacrd tnd pctdmtb`a docmcebo ddots ci `atdrm`tbvdbmtdhr`tbcm sondeds bmvcavbmh _cutn @sb`m `mj _cutnd`st @sb`mdocmcebds. Znd sodm`rbcs ̀ rd ocmsdrv`tbvd ̀ mj ̀ rd abgday tc rdstdot acwdr fcumj dstbe`tds ci wn`t ̀ otu`a ddots wcuaj fd dxpdotdj tc rdsuat. Znd fdst-o`sd jddp bmtdhr`tbcm sodm`rbc bmvcavds (b) rdecv`a ci `aa t`rbs`sscob`tdj wbtn _cutn @sb`m `mj _cutnd`st @sb`m tr`jd, (bb) ` 4.2% ci hrcss jcedstbo prcjuot) bm _cutn @sb` `mj$02? fbaabcm bm _cutnd`st @sb` (9.:% ci hrcss jcedstbo prcjuot). Ecstp`rtbobp`tbmh ocumtrbds sncw a`rhd h`bms, dspdob`aay se`aadr ocumtrbds bm_cutn @sb`.
Odrt`bmay, tnd prcodss ci oacsdr bmtr`-rdhbcm`a docmcebo bmtdhr`tbcmhdmdr`tds pctdmtb`a fdmdffts fut e`y dmt`ba sced `jjbtbcm`a ocsts tn`tmddj sdrbcus rdvbdw `mj ebtbh`tbcm ed`surds. Icr bmst`mod, scedsdotcrs wbaa acsd jud tc hrd`tdr ocepdtbtbcm, `mj tndrd e`y fd bmord`sdsbm rdhbcm`a bmdqu`abtbds. @asc, oacsdr bmtr`- `mj bmtdrrdhbcm`a docmcebotbds `mj i`stdr hrcwtn e`y dmt`ba pcaautbcm, dmvbrcmedmt`a jdhr`j`tbcm,`mj ebhr`tbcm bssuds. Vdhbcm`a docmcebo bmtdhr`tbcm e`y `asc n`stdmtnd sprd`j ci jbsd`sd ̀ mj orbed. Bm ̀ jjbtbcm, tnd prcodss e`y dx`odrf t̀did`rs ci ebhr`tbcm, dtnmbo tdmsbcms, `mj ctndr sdourbty-rda`tdj bssuds.
Znd `m`aysbs bm tnbs vcaued suhhdsts tn`t tnd fdmdffts ci hrd`tdrdocmcebo bmtdhr`tbcm i`r cutwdbhn tnd ocsts, dspdob`aay sbmod tndy sprd`jtnd fdmdffts ci docmcebo jdvdacpedmt tc bsca`tdj `rd`s. Mcmdtndadss,bmstbtutbcm`a edon`mbses wbaa fd mddjdj tc ocepdms`td acsdrs bmtnd bmtdhr`tbcm prcodss `mj tc `jjrdss sced ci tnd umjdsbr`fad sbjdddots edmtbcmdj `fcvd. Znbs bs abgday tc rdqubrd occpdr`tbcm `t tndrdhbcm`a advda.
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
25/320
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
26/320
0
ON@\ZDV
Bmtrcjuotbcm `mjCvdrvbdw
0.0 Ocmtdxt `mj @be ci tnd _tujy
_cutn @sb`m `mj _cutnd`st @sb`m docmcebds n`vd hrcwm r`pbjay jurbmh `mdr` ci ` ir`hbad wcraj docmcebo hrcwtn fdsdt fy rbsgs `mj umodrt`bmtbds.Znbs prchrdss n`s fddm iudadj fy dxp`mjbmh rdhbcm`a prcjuotbcm mdtwcrgs,bmtdhr`tbcm wbtn tnd hacf`a docmcey, icrdbhm jbrdot bmvdstedmt (IJB),i`aabmh tr`jd `mj bmvdstedmt f`rrbdrs, ` oceecjbty fcce, `mj ndbhntdmdjjde`mj irce ` rbsbmh @sb`m ebjjad oa`ss. Znd rdsuats n`vd fddm pcsbtbvd7tnd _cutn @sb`m `mj _cutnd`st @sb`m rdhbcms `rd `ecmh tnd ecst jym`ebobm tnd wcraj ̀ mj n`vd prcjuodj beprdssbvd scobcdocmcebo beprcvdedmts.0 Xnbad on`aadmhds rde`bm, tndsd rdhbcms `rd cm tnd rbhnt p`tn.
Ncwdvdr, tr`jd `mj bmvdstedmt fdtwddm tndsd twc rdhbcms, wnbade`gbmh prchrdss, n`s fddm ocmstr`bmdj fy fcttadmdogs `mj h`ps bm tr`jdbmir`struoturd, ffm`mob`a e`rgdts, tr`jd i`obabt`tbcm, tr`jd f`rrbdrs, `mjabebtdj rdhbcm`a occpdr`tbcm. Znd hrcwtn ci tr`jd fdtwddm _cutn @sb``mj _cutnd`st @sb` n`s fddm rde`rg`fad‚bmord`sbmh md`ray 66 tbeds irce$: fbaabcm tc $2< fbaabcm irce 022< tc 6
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
27/320
6 Ocmmdotbmh _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`
cvdr n`ai tnd depacyedmt bm _cutn @sb`m `mj _cutnd`st @sb`m docmcebdsn`vd abebtdj prdsdmod bm tr`jd. Iurtndrecrd, dxoaujbmh _bmh`pcrd,
cutst`mjbmh pcrticabc bmvdstedmt irce _cutnd`st @sb` tc _cutn @sb`w`s se`aa, tct`abmh cmay `fcut $884 ebaabcm bm 6
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
28/320
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
29/320
: Ocmmdotbmh _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`
bmord`sbmh tnd sn`rd ci prbv`td ffm`mobmh ci suon prckdots, bmoaujbmh pufabo‟prbv`td p`rtmdrsnbps (\\\s). On`ptdr 9 rdvbdws tr`jd i`obabt`tbcm bm tnd twcrdhbcms `mj bjdmtbffds pcaboy bmbtb`tbvds tc beprcvd tnd irdd stcw ci tr`jd.On`ptdr 8 dx`ebmds m`tbcm`a `mj rdhbcm`a tr`jd pcaboy rdicres tn`t o`mprcectd tr`jd `mj bmvdstedmt fdtwddm tnd twc rdhbcms. On`ptdr > rdvbdwstnd bmstbtutbcm`a rbsgs `sscob`tdj wbtn `ttdepts tc beprcvd orcss-rdhbcm`aocmmdotbvbty, ̀ mj bjdmtbffds m`tbcm`a ̀ mj rdhbcm`a pcaboy rdicres tc `jjrdsstnde. On`ptdr 2 `ssdssds tnd bep`ots ci hrd`tdr orcss-rdhbcm`a bmtdhr`tbcm,usbmh ̀ oceput`fad hdmdr`a dqubabfrbue (OHD) ecjda ̀ pprc`on.
Znd struoturd ci tnbs on`ptdr bs `s icaacws. _dotbcm 0.6 prcvbjds `qu`abt`tbvd jdsorbptbcm ci tnd fdmdffts `mj ocsts ci hrd`tdr docmcebobmtdhr`tbcm `mj occpdr`tbcm fdtwddm tnd twc rdhbcms. _dotbcm 0.?suee`rbzds tnd cvdr`aa `m`aytbo`a `pprc`on `mj hdchr`pnbo`a socpd citnd stujy. _dotbcms 0.: tc 0.0< suee`rbzd tnd ffmjbmhs ci tnd bmjbvbju`aon`ptdrs ci tnd rdpcrt. _dotbcm 0.00 ocmoaujds.
0.6 V`tbcm`ad icr Hrd`tdr Docmcebo Bmtdhr`tbcm`mj Occpdr`tbcm
@ iumj`edmt à bmsbhnt ci docmcebos bs tn t̀ bmtdrm t̀bcm`a tr`jd beprcvds ̀ mdocmcey‒s `hhrdh`td bmoced. @oocrjbmh tc tnd Xcraj F`mg, bm tnd 022
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
30/320
Bmtrcjuotbcm ̀ mj Cvdrvbdw 4
_pdob`abz`tbcm bm rdhbcm`aay ocepdtbtbvd bmjustrbds hdmdr`tds `ecrd dobdmt prcjuotbvd struoturd bm `aa docmcebds, tndrdfydmn`mobmh rdhbcm`a ocepdtbtbvdmdss.
Bmtdhr`tbcm i`obabt`tds tnd dxtdmsbcm cr ecvdedmt ciprcjuotbcm mdtwcrgs irce _cutnd`st @sb` `mj _cutn @sb`,wndrd jdvdacpedmt ci suon mdtwcrgs n`s a`hhdj, tc t`gd fdttdr`jv`mt`hd ci w`hd jbdrdmtb`as.
Bmord`sdj ocepdtbtbcm wbtnbm tnd bmtdhr`tdj rdhbcm ocuaj ad`jprcjuodrs cutsbjd tnd rdhbcm tc rdjuod tndbr prbods `s wdaa,acwdrbmh bepcrt prbods tc tnd rdhbcm `mj beprcvbmh bts tdresci tr`jd.
@ ecrd bmtdhr`tdj rdhbcm ocuaj ̀ ttr`ot ecrd IJB wbtn bts fdmdfftsci tdonmcachy `mj gmcwadjhd tr`msidr, nbhndr prcjuotbvbty, `mje`rgdt `oodss. Znd dmtry ci dxpcrt-crbdmtdj IJB `mj icrdbhm fuydrs bs `m bepcrt`mt ed`ms tc ocmmdot ffres wbtn rdhbcm`aprcjuotbcm mdtwcrgs `mj suppay on`bms.
A`rhd `mj oceprdndmsbvd IZ@s dm`fad jddpdr `mj wbjdrbmtdhr`tbcm `ecmh edefdr ocumtrbds tn`m wcuaj fd id`sbfadwbtnbm ` euatba`tdr`a ir`edwcrg. Xdaa-jdsbhmdj `hrddedmts,wbtn ecjdrm `mj stdxbfad ruads ci crbhbm `mj bmtdrm`tbcm`ast`mj`rjs, o`m pa`y ` rcad bm rdjuobmh tr`jd ocsts icr tnd sprd`jci prcjuotbcm mdtwcrgs.
Occpdr`tbcm cm bmir`struoturd `mj tr`jd i`obabt`tbcm (icrdx`epad, tr`mspcrt, oustces oad`r`mod, `mj prcjuot st`mj`rjs)`mj sdrvbods (icr dx`epad, ffm`mob`a `mj a`fcr sdrvbods) wcuajabgday ad`j tc ` rdjuotbcm bm tr`jd ocsts `mj rdsuat bm wdai`rdh`bms wdaa bm dxodss ci h`bms irce edrd t`rb abfdr`abz`tbcm.
Zndrd `rd pctdmtb`a h`bms irce hrd`tdr occpdr`tbcm `ecmhdxbstbmh rdhbcm`a bmstbtutbcms. Icr dx`epad, strcmhdr occrjbm`tbcm fdtwddm tnd Hrd`tdr Edgcmh _ufrdhbcm9 (HE_), tnd _cutn @sb`_ufrdhbcm`a Docmcebo Occpdr`tbcm8 (_@_DO) hrcup, `mj tnd F`yci Fdmh`a Bmbtb`tbvd icr Euatb-_dotcr`a Zdonmbo`a `mj DocmceboOccpdr`tbcm (FBE_ZDO)> hrcup ocuaj sdrvd `s ` pa`ticre icrjdvdacpbmh acmhdr ̀ mj strcmhdr docmcebo ocrrbjcrs, ̀ moncrdj fyorcss-fcrjdr bmir`struoturd prckdots, `mj fdttdr e`m`hdedmt citnd orcss-fcrjdr sprd`j ci bmidotbcus jbsd`sds ̀ s wdaa ̀ s rdjuobmhjruh ̀ mj nue`m tr`ogbmh.
9 O`efcjb`, tnd A`c \JV, Ey`me`r, Zn`ba`mj, Ybdt M`e, paus Rumm`m \rcvbmod `mjHu`mhxb [nu`mh @utcmcecus Vdhbcm ci tnd \dcpad‒s Vdpufabo ci Onbm` (\VO).
8 F`mha`jdsn, Fnut`m, Bmjb`, tnd E`ajbvds, Mdp`a, `mj _rb A`mg`.> F`mha`jdsn, Fnut`m, Bmjb`, Ey`me`r, Mdp`a, _rb A`mg`, ̀ mj Zn`ba`mj.
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
31/320
9 Ocmmdotbmh _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`
Ibm`aay, hrd`tdr ocmmdotbvbty o`m prcvbjd tnd f`sbs icr ecrdbmoausbvd hrcwtn wbtn hrd`tdr pctdmtb`a icr rdjuobmh pcvdrty`mj oacsbmh jdvdacpedmt h`ps. Znbs bmoaujds ebmcrbty hrcupstn`t n`vd fddm e`rhbm`abzdj bm tnd p`st, ad`jbmh tc ocmstbotsbtu`tbcms. _uon jdvdacpedmts ocuaj n`vd frc`jdr fdmdffts ciprcectbmh st`fbabty `mj dmn`mobmh pd`od `mj sdourbty bm tndrdhbcm, bmoaujbmh `spdots rda`tdj tc w`tdr suppay, a`fcr ecfbabty,`mj pcssbfay jdidmsd.
Ibm`mob`a bmtdhr`tbcm o`m ̀ asc prcvbjd fdmdffts fy rdjuobmh iumjbmh ocsts`mj dxp`mjbmh `v`ba`fad rdscurods tc iumj mddjdj bmvdstedmts suon `sbmir`struoturd prckdots. Znbs bs p`rtboua`ray bepcrt`mt icr ocumtrbds wbtnadss jdvdacpdj ffm`mob`a e`rgdts `mj bmstbtutbcms. _t`fad `mj dobdmtrdhbcm`a ffm`mob`a e`rgdts o`m ndap on`mmda s`vbmhs irce `rcumj @sb``mj tnd rdst ci tnd wcraj bmtc prcjuotbvd bmvdstedmts tnrcuhncut tndrdhbcm.
Odrt`bmay, tnd prcodss ci oacsdr bmtr`-rdhbcm`a docmcebo bmtdhr`tbcmhdmdr`tds pctdmtb`a fdmdffts fut e`y dmt`ba sced `jjbtbcm`a ocsts tn`tmddj rdvbdw `mj ebtbh`tbcm ed`surds. Icr bmst`mod, sced sdotcrs `mjrdhbcms wbaa acsd jud tc hrd`tdr ocepdtbtbcm, `mj tndrd e`y fd bmord`sdsbm rdhbcm`a bmdqu`abtbds. @asc, oacsdr bmtr`-rdhbcm`a docmcebo tbds `mji`stdr hrcwtn e`y dmt`ba pcaautbcm, dmvbrcmedmt`a jdhr`j`tbcm, `mjbeebhr`tbcm bssuds. Vdhbcm`a docmcebo bmtdhr`tbcm e`y `asc n`stdm tndsprd`j ci jbsd`sd `mj orbed `mj ocuaj dx`odrf`td id`rs ci ebhr`tbcm,dtnmbo tdmsbcms, `mj ctndr sdourbty-rda`tdj bssuds.
Ibm`mob`a bmtdhr`tbcm o`m `asc ord`td ocsts irce tnd bmord`sdjdxpcsurd ci docmcebds wbtn bee`turd ffm`mob`a systdes tc dxtdrm`affm`mob`a sncogs, dspdob`aay ‑sujjdm stcps― (r`pbj `mj a`rhd-so`ado`pbt`a cutstcws) tn`t o`m sdvdrday `dot tnd rd`a docmcey. Znus,ffm`mob`a jdvdacpedmt `mj bmtdhr`tbcm eust fd sdqudmodj prcpdray `mjoccrjbm`tdj wbtn beprcvdj m`tbcm`a `mj rdhbcm`a ffm`mob`a survdbaa`mod`mj rdhua`tcry bmstbtutbcms.
Znd `m`aysbs bm tnbs rdpcrt suhhdsts tn`t tnd fdmdffts ci hrd`tdrdocmcebo bmtdhr`tbcm i`r cutwdbhn tnd ocsts, dspdob`aay sbmod tndysprd`j tnd `jv`mt`hds ci docmcebo jdvdacpedmt tc bsca`tdj `rd`s.Mcmdtndadss, bmstbtutbcm`a edon`mbses wbaa fd mddjdj tc ocepdms`tdacsdrs bm tnd bmtdhr`tbcm prcodss `mj tc `jjrdss sced ci tnd umjdsbr`fadsbjd ddots edmtbcmdj ̀ fcvd. Znbs bs abgday tc rdqubrd occpdr`tbcm ̀ t tndrdhbcm`a advda.
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
32/320
Bmtrcjuotbcm ̀ mj Cvdrvbdw 8
0. @m`aytbo`a @pprc`on
Vda`tbcmsnbp ci _tujy Ocepcmdmts
Euon o`m fd jcmd bm _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb` tc rdjuodbepdjbedmts tc orcss-rdhbcm`a tr`jd `mj bmvdstedmt `mj tc beprcvdhacf`a ocepdtbtbvdmdss. Znbs rdpcrt bjdmtbffds `mj `m`ayzds ed`surdstn`t ocuaj fd prceuah`tdj fy _cutn @sb`m `mj _cutnd`st @sb`mocumtrbds `mj rdhbcm`a hrcupbmhs tc `oocepabsn tnbs‚bmoaujbmh pcabobdsicr tr`jd i`obabt`tbcm, rdhbcm`a tr`jbmh `hrddedmts, `mj bmvdstedmt bmbmir`struoturd. @onbdvdedmt ci ` oceprdndmsbvd ̀ pprc`on tc beprcvbmh
orcss-rdhbcm`a bmtdhr`tbcm rdqubrds pcaboy bmtdrvdmtbcms `t jbdrdmtadvdas. Ibhurd 0.0 sncws tnd rda`tbcmsnbps ci tnd gdy dadedmts tn`t `rd`m`ayzdj bm tnbs stujy.
Ibhurd 0.0; Gdy Dadedmts icr \rcectbmhOrcss-Vdhbcm`a Ocmmdotbvbty
Bmstbtutbcm`a ̀ rr`mhdedmts
_cit bmir`struoturd(tr`jd `mj tr`mspcrti`obabt`tbcm, achbstbos)
Zr`jd `mj IJB pcaboy Ibm`mob`a sdotcr pcaboy
Nbhndr cutput `mj jdvdacp-
edmt, bmord`sdj bmoausbcm, dto.
N`rj bmir`struoturd(tr`mspcrt, dmdrhy)
Bmord`sdj tr`jd `mjbmvdstedmt
@jkustedmt
edon`mbses
Ibm`mob`a systde
IJB 5 icrdbhm jbrdot bmvdstedmt._curod; Ocepbadj fy ̀ utncrs.
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
33/320
> Ocmmdotbmh _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`
Ibrst, bmord`sdj tr`jd `mj bmvdstedmt `rd dxpdotdj tc rdsuat ircebeprcvdedmts bm fctn n`rj `mj scit bmir`struoturd. N`rj bmir`struoturdbmoaujds beprcvdedmts bm tr`mspcrt (rc`js, r`barc`js, `mj pcrts) `mjdmdrhy (hdmdr`tbcm `mj tr`msebssbcm i`obabtbds). _cit bmir`struoturdbmoaujds tr`jd ̀ mj tr`mspcrt i`obabt`tbcm, bmoaujbmh oustces prcodjurds,orcss-fcrjdr tr`msbt `hrddedmts `mj achbstbos, `mj dmdrhy tr`jbmh`rr`mhdedmts.
Bmvdstedmts bm n`rj ̀ mj scit bmir`struoturd rdqubrd ffm`mobmh. Xndrdaco`a pufabo iumjs `rd bmsuobdmt, tnbs wbaa rdqubrd `jjbtbcm`a dcrtstc t`p aco`a prbv`td iumjs `mj bmtdrm`tbcm`a bmvdstcrs. Xndrd ourrdmtffm`mobmh `rr`mhdedmts `rd bm`jdqu`td, tnbs rdqubrds bmmcv`tbcms bmffm`mob`a sdotcr pcaboy tc jdvdacp ffm`mob`a e`rgdts `mj i`obabt`td orcss- fcrjdr stcws vb` o`pbt`a `oocumt abfdr`abz`tbcm, `mj jdvdacpedmt ciedon`mbses tc hu`r`mtdd ordjbt `mj ctndr rbsgs, `ecmh ctndrs.
Cutw`rj-crbdmtdj tr`jd `mj icrdbhm jbrdot bmvdstedmt (IJB)pcabobds bmstudmod tr`jd `mj bmvdstedmt stcws jbrdotay tnrcuhn fdttdrprbod sbhm`as `mj vb` beprcvdedmts bm scit `mj n`rj bmir`struoturd.Dxp`msbcm ci irdd tr`jd `hrddedmts o`m bmstudmod tr`jd `mj bmvdstedmtjbrdotay, wnbad tr`jd `mj tr`mspcrt i`obabt`tbcm `hrddedmts o`m beprcvdtnd scit bmir`struoturd. IJB abfdr`abz`tbcm o`m ̀ asc suppcrt bmtdrm`tbcm`affm`mobmh ci bmir`struoturd prckdots.
Zndsd pcaboy jdvdacpedmts o`m fd suppcrtdj fy bmstbtutbcm`a`rr`mhdedmts. Icr dx`epad, oacsdr occrjbm`tbcm fdtwddm rdhbcm`a `mjsufrdhbcm`a dmtbtbds o`m p`vd tnd w`y icr jdvdacpedmts bm tr`jd `mjbmvdstedmt pcaboy, ffm`mob`a sdotcr pcaboy, tr`jd ̀ mj tr`mspcrt i`obabt`tbcm,`mj orcss-fcrjdr n`rj bmir`struoturd. Cmd dx`epad bs oacsdr occpdr`tbcm fdtwddm tnd HE_, _@_DO, `mj FBE_ZDO. Vdhbcm`a occpdr`tbcm o`m`asc jdvdacp mdw rdhbcm`a bmir`struoturd ffm`mobmh dmtbtbds.
Bmord`sdj tr`jd ̀ mj bmvdstedmt bs dxpdotdj tc ad`j tc nbhndr cutput`mj docmcebo jdvdacpedmt, `s wdaa `s bmord`sdj docmcebo bmoausbcmci bsca`tdj `rd`s. Ncwdvdr, tndrd wbaa fd docmcebo, dmvbrcmedmt`a,`mj scob`a ocsts `s wdaa. Znbs rdqubrds tnd jdvdacpedmt ci `jkustedmtedon`mbses tc ebtbh`td tndsd ocsts, `mj wbaa `asc rdqubrd rdhbcm`abmstbtutbcm`a `rr`mhdedmts.
Znbs stujy depacydj sdvdr`a dstbe`tbcm edtncjcachbds. _ocrbmhedtncjcachbds wdrd usdj tc bjdmtbiy prdidrrdj tr`mspcrt ocrrbjcrs `mjbmvdstedmt prckdots, ̀ mj tnbs w`s suppadedmtdj wbtn ocst‟fdmdfft ̀ m`aysbsicr sced prckdots. @ ocst ebmbebz`tbcm ecjda icr dmdrhy suppay w`s usdjtc dstbe`td `atdrm`tbvd p`tns icr dmdrhy sdotcr bmvdstedmt. @ oceput`fadhdmdr`a dqubabfrbue (OHD) ecjda w`s usdj tc dstbe`tds bep`ots cm hrcssjcedstbo prcjuot (HJ\), tr`jd, sdotcr`a cutput, `mj i`otcr bmocedsrdsuatbmh irce jbdrdmt sodm`rbcs ̀ fcut docmcebo bmtdhr`tbcm.
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
34/320
Bmtrcjuotbcm ̀ mj Cvdrvbdw 2
Hdchr`pnbo _ocpd ci _tujy
@t tnd frc`jdst advda, tnbs stujy dmocep`ssds `aa tnd docmcebds bm _cutn @sb` ̀ mj _cutnd`st @sb`. _d` tr`jd, `mj tr`jd ̀ mj bmvdstedmt ̀ hrddedmtso`m `uhedmt tr`jd fdtwddm `my p`br ci docmcebds bm tnd twc rdhbcms(`mj wbtnbm d`on rdhbcm `s wdaa). Ncwdvdr, a`mj-f`sdj tr`mspcrt `mjdmdrhy tr`jbmh (icr dadotrbobty `mj m`tur`a h`s pbpdabmds) eust bmvcavdocmtbhucus docmcebds. Zndrdicrd, tnd a`mj tr`mspcrt bmir`struoturdjbsoussbcm icousds cm tncsd ocumtrbds oacsd tc tnd fcrjdrs fdtwddmtnd twc rdhbcms, paus tnd dxtdmsbcm ci e`kcr tr`mspcrt ocrrbjcrs bmtctnd HE_. Znd `m`aysbs ci pcrts icousds cm tncsd bm tnd F`y ci Fdmh`a,
wnbon n`vd nbhn ocsts, `mj wncsd beprcvdedmt ocuaj suppcrt hrd`tdrp`rtbobp`tbcm ci _cutn @sb`m docmcebds bm suppay on`bm mdtwcrgs. Zndtr`jd i`obabt`tbcm `m`aysbs `asc icousds cm tndsd ocumtrbds, `atncuhn mctdxoausbvday. Znd ̀ m`aysbs ci dmdrhy tr`jbmh icousds cm F`mha`jdsn, Bmjb`,`mj Ey`me`r, `atncuhn sced prckdots bm Ybdt M`e `mj Bmjcmdsb` `rd`asc ocmsbjdrdj.
Vda`tbcm tc D`rabdr _tujbds
\rcectbmh rdhbcm`a occpdr`tbcm `mj bmtdhr`tbcm bs ` gdy cfkdotbvd ci @JF. Znbs stujy fubajs cm `m dxtdmsbvd fcjy ci d`rabdr wcrg cm rdhbcm`abmtdhr`tbcm spcmscrdj fy @JF. @JF (6
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
35/320
0< Ocmmdotbmh _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`
bmoausbvd, ocepdtbtbvd, ̀ mj n`recmbcus. Ibm`aay, tnbs stujy rdabds cm @JFtdonmbo`a jcouedmts rda`tdj tc rdhbcm`a bmtdhr`tbcm, bmoaujbmh pbpdabmdsci prckdots icr tnd HE_ `mj _@_DO ̀ mj ctndr hrcups suon ̀ s FBE_ZDO.
0.: Orcss-Fcrjdr Zr`mspcrt Bmir`struoturd
Beprcvbmh pnysbo`a ocmmdotbvbty bm _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb` bstnd orbtbo`a fubajbmh facog icr hrd`tdr docmcebo bmtdhr`tbcm fdtwddmtnd twc rdhbcms. On`ptdr ? `ssdssds tnd ourrdmt st`td ci rc`j, r`ba, `mje`rbtbed ocmmdotbvbty fdtwddm tnd twc rdhbcms `mj bjdmtbffds prbcrbty
ocrrbjcrs ̀ mj prckdots, tchdtndr wbtn tndbr ̀ sscob`tdj ocsts ̀ mj fdmdffts.Hbvdm tnd jbvdrsd hdchr`pny `mj r`mhd ci tr`mspcrt ecjds bm tnd twcrdhbcms, `ssdssbmh `mj pa`mmbmh tr`mspcrt mddjs rdqubrd ` rdhbcm`a`mj euatbecj`a pdrspdotbvd. Gdy pnysbo`a f`rrbdrs tc orcss-rdhbcm`atr`mspcrt `rd aco`tdj e`bmay bm Ey`me`r, tnd cmay a`mj frbjhd fdtwddmtndsd rdhbcms, wnbad ctndr h`ps `rd bjdmtbffdj bm F`mha`jdsn, O`efcjb`,Bmjb`, tnd A`c \dcpad‒s Jdecor`tbo Vdpufabo (A`c \JV), Zn`ba`mj, `mj Ybdt M`e. E`kcr pcrts bm tnd `rd` sudr irce ocmstr`bmts bm o`p`obty,dobdmoy, `mj ocmmdotbvbty tc rc`j `mj r`ba mdtwcrgs.2
Nbhnw`ys
_dvdr`a fcttadmdogs n`vd fddm bjdmtbffdj bm rc`j mdtwcrg abmgs fdtwddm_cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`. Icr bmst`mod, bm tnd @sb`m Nbhnw`ymdtwcrg0> ge ci rc`js`rd oa`ss BBB cr fdacw7 `mj (bbb) bm Ey`me`r, cvdr 0,
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
36/320
Bmtrcjuotbcm ̀ mj Cvdrvbdw 00
ocmmdotbvbty odmtdrdj cm iddjdr mdtwcrgs tc e`kcr pcrts. Vc`j ocrrbjcrcptbcms tc ocmmdot _cutn @sb` tc _cutnd`st @sb` n`vd fddm dv`au`tdj ̀ mjtnd prdidrrdj cptbcm bs tnd Gcag`t`‟Nc Onb Ebmn Obty ocrrbjcr tnrcuhntnd Onbogdm‒s Mdog. @ sncrtdr jbst`mod wbtn adss rdqubrdj bmvdstedmtwcuaj fd ` rc`j ocrrbjcr tnrcuhn F`mha`jdsn, fut bt i`ods muedrcuscfst`oads, bmoaujbmh tnd a`og ci ` tr`msbt `hrddedmt fdtwddm Bmjb` `mjF`mha`jdsn. Znd rc`j ocrrbjcr irce Gcag`t` tc N`b \ncmh n`s tcc e`myebssbmh abmgs e`gbmh bt dxpdmsbvd `mj wbtn idwdr docmcebo prcspdots.
Znd Gcag`t`‟Nc Onb Ebmn Obty ocrrbjcr bs :,:?< ge acmh `mjwbaa rdqubrd ` tct`a bmvdstedmt ci $? fbaabcm tc cdr `jdqu`td rc`jocmmdotbvbty fdtwddm _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`. Ci tnd $? fbaabcm,$0.2 fbaabcm oceds irce tnd rc`j prchr`e tn`t Bmjb` bs bepadedmtbmh icrtnd mcrtnd`stdrm st`tds. Znd `ecumt icr prbcrbty bmvdstedmt prckdots bsse`aadr `t $4?6 fbaabcm, wbtn ` icous cm uphr`jbmh abmgs fdtwddm Bepn`a(mcrtnd`st Bmjb`) `mj R`hyb (wdstdrm Ey`me`r), Dbmju (Ey`me`r) `mjZ`g (Zn`ba`mj), `mj @r`my`pr`tndt (Zn`ba`mj) `mj \cbpdt (O`efcjb`).Ci tndsd, tnd a`ttdr twc `rd abgday tc rd`abzd hrd`tdr sncrt-tdre fdmdffts fdo`usd ci a`rhdr dxbstbmh tr`o vcaueds. Znd ocsts ci tnd prbcrbtyprckdots ̀ ppd`r tc fd e`m`hd`fad.
Znd scob`a fdmdffts `sscob`tdj wbtn hrd`tdr ocmmdotbvbty `rd citdmcvdraccgdj. Cmd ci tnd ffrst bep`ots ci beprcvdj ocrrbjcrs bs ̀ m bmord`sdbm p`ssdmhdr `mj tcurbst ecvdedmts `orcss fcrjdrs. @m dv`au`tbcm ciHE_ tr`mspcrt ocrrbjcrs n`s rdvd`adj tn`t cmd ci tnd beedjb`td fdmdfftsci orcss-fcrjdr rc`j beprcvdedmts w`s tnd sbhmbffo`mt bmord`sds bmp`ssdmhdr `mj tcurbst ecvdedmts, sced fy o`r, fut ecstay fy fus.Bmord`sdj orcss-fcrjdr p`ssdmhdr ecvdedmts n`vd pcsbtbvd ddots cmdocmcebo hrcwtn `mj tndy `asc ocmtrbfutd tc scob`a fcmjbmh `ecmhpcpua`tbcms.
V`barc`jsXbtn rdspdot tc tnd bmtr`-rdhbcm`a r`ba mdtwcrg, tnd Zr`ms-@sb`m V`baw`y(Z@V)06 mdtwcrg bmoaujds `fcut 0
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
37/320
06 Ocmmdotbmh _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`
`rd `fcut 6,:2? ge ci orbtbo`a ebssbmh r`ba abmgs bm tnd Z@V ocmmdotbmh_cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`. _ced ci tnd ebssbmh abmgs `rd `acmh tndicaacwbmh rcutds;
Kbrbp`e (Bmjb`)‟G`ad (Ey`me`r) Zn`mfyuz`y`t (Ey`me`r)‟M`e Zcg (Zn`ba`mj) Ybdmtb`md (A`c \JV)‟Eu Hb` (Ybdt M`e)‟Yumh @m F`t Jdmh (O`efcjb`)‟Aco Mbmn (Ybdt M`e)‟Nc Onb Ebmn Obty
Znd jdffmbtbcm ci r`ba ocrrbjcrs bm tnbs stujy icaacws tnd s`ed ‑pcrt-tc-pcrt― prbmobpad `s tn`t icr rc`j ocrrbjcrs. V`ba ocmmdotbvbty fdtwddm_cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb` w`s `asc dv`au`tdj wbtn tnd Gcag`t`‟NcOnb Ebmn Obty ocrrbjcr `mj ocmmdotbcms tnrcuhn Rumm`m \rcvbmod,\VO, fdbmh tnd prdidrrdj cptbcms. Ncwdvdr, bm ocmsbjdr`tbcm ci tndnbhn ocmstruotbcm ocsts `mj a`rhd muefdr ci ebssbmh abmgs bmvcavdj,bepadedmt`tbcm sncuaj cmay oced `itdr m`tbcm`a r`baw`ys n`vd rd`abzdjsufst`mtb`a ecjdrmbz`tbcm rdicres. V`ba ocmmdotbvbty oceds `s ` sdocmjprbcrbty `itdr rc`j ocmmdotbvbty jud tc ffm`mob`a `mj tdonmbo`a bssuds. ZndGcag`t`‟Nc Onb Ebmn Obty ocrrbjcr, wbtn ` jbst`mod ci :,88< ge, wbaardqubrd bmvdstedmts ci $:.0 fbaabcm dvdm wbtncut `oocumtbmh icr h`uhdocmvdrsbcm `mj rdn`fbabt`tbcm ocsts bm Bmjb` irce Gcag`t` tc Kbrbp`e.Znd r`ba ocmmdotbcm tnrcuhn Rumm`m \rcvbmod tc rd`on N` Mcb `mj N`b\ncmh \crt cdrs sufst`mtb`a s`vbmhs wbtn ` tct`a ocst ci $0.> fbaabcm `mj `jbst`mod ci :,664 ge.
E`rbtbed Zr`mspcrt
Ecst tr`jd fdtwddm _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb` bs fy sd`. Znd`pprc`on ci tnd stujy n`s fddm tc `m`ayzd wn`t bmvdstedmts ocuaj
ocmtrbfutd ecst tc rdjuobmh tr`mspcrt ocsts `t e`kcr pcrts cm tnd F`yci Fdmh`a, bmoaujbmh Ondmm`b/Dmmcrd, Gcag`t`/N`ajb`, Onbtt`hcmh, `mj R`mhcm/Znba`w`. _uon beprcvdedmts wcuaj fdmdfft tr`jd ci tncsd pcrtswbtn `aa rdhbcms, fut tr`jd fdtwddm _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb` bsabgday tc h`bm `t ad`st prcpcrtbcm`tday. Icr dx`epad, suon beprcvdedmtssncuaj ndap tc prcectd ecrd dobdmt ocmt`bmdr tr`o bm tnd rdhbcm,tndrdfy suppcrtbmh hrd`tdr p`rtbobp`tbcm ci _cutn @sb`m docmcebds bmsuppay on`bm mdtwcrgs.
Vdh`rjbmh sd`pcrts, stujbds n`vd bjdmtbffdj prcfades wbtn i`obabtbds,
cpdr`tbcm`a dobdmoy, `mj ocmmdotbvbty fdtwddm sd`pcrts `mj r`baw`y `mjrc`j mdtwcrgs. Znd icaacwbmh prcfades wdrd cfsdrvdj bm e`kcr pcrts;
Gcag`t` \crt (Bmjb`); Znd sbzd ci vdssdas tn`t `rd `fad tc o`aa bsabebtdj fy tnd jdptn ci tnd Ncchay Vbvdr. V`ba `mj rc`j tr`o fdtwddm tnd pcrt `mj tnd obty `rd sufkdot tc sdvdrd fcttadmdogs.
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
38/320
Bmtrcjuotbcm ̀ mj Cvdrvbdw 0?
Onbtt`hcmh \crt (F`mha`jdsn); Znd sbzd ci vdssdas tn`t `rd `fadtc o`aa bs abebtdj fy tnd wbjtn `mj ourv`turd ci tnd G`rm`pnuabVbvdr. V`ba `mj rc`j tr`o fdtwddm Onbtt`hcmh \crt `mj Jn`g``asc dxpdrbdmod sdvdrd fcttadmdogs.
R̀ mhcm \crt (Ey`me`r); Abebtdj `oodssbfbabty tc a`rhd vdssdas,pccr rc`j ocmjbtbcms fdtwddm tnd Znba`w` pcrt `rd` `mj tnd frbjhd ad`jbmh tc R̀ mhcm, nbhn ocmt b̀mdr on`rhds, cfscadtdpcrt i`obabtbds, irdqudmt fa`ogcuts `mj bmsuobdmt hdmdr`tcrs,`mj a`og ci o`rhc dqubpedmt `rd `ecmh tnd e`kcr prcfades bmtnbs pcrt.
Bm `jjbtbcm, ocmt`bmdr snbppbmh bm tnd F`y ci Fdmh`a i`ods nbhn ocstsstdeebmh irce tnd rdab`mod cm tnd nuf-`mj-spcgd iddjdr systde tn`trdqubrds tr`mssnbpedmt fdtwddm tnd se`aadr snbps tn`t ̀ oodss tnd F`y ciFdmh`a pcrts ̀ mj tnd a`rhdr snbps tn`t pay tnd e`bm tr`jd rcutds, stcppbmh`t nuf pcrts suon `s Ocacefc `mj _bmh`pcrd. Znbs pcsds ` f`rrbdr tctnd jdvdacpedmt ci e`mui`oturbmh `otbvbty bm tnbs `rd`, dspdob`aaye`mui`oturbmh `otbvbty rda`tdj tc hacf`a suppay on`bm mdtwcrgs.
@ gdy ocmoausbcm ci tnd on`ptdr bs tn`t ocmt`bmdr snbppbmh tr`jd bsoacsday abmgdj wbtn edron`mjbsd tr`jd. Bi _cutn @sb`m ocumtrbds w`mttc iurtndr jdvdacp tndbr e`mui`oturbmh dxpcrts `mj p`rtbobp`td ecrdbm hacf`a suppay on`bm mdtwcrgs, bt bs bepdr`tbvd tn`t tndy umjdrt`gdbmvdstedmts tc rdjuod tnd nbhn ocsts ci ocmt`bmdr snbppbmh. Zc dmocur`hdjbrdot pcrt o`aas fy a`rhd ocmt`bmdr snbps bm tnd F`y ci Fdmh`a, jddpw`tdrpcrt i`obabtbds mddj tc fd prcvbjdj, ocmt`bmdr tdrebm`as dxp`mjdj, rc`j`mj r`ba abmgs wbtn pcrts beprcvdj, `mj ecrd se`aadr pcrts jdvdacpdj.Bi jbrdot o`aas `mj bm-abmd tr`mssnbpedmt o`m fd `ttr`otdj bm suobdmtso`ad, bt bs dstbe`tdj tn`t tnbs ocuaj acwdr tnd ocsts ci ocmt`bmdr snbpedmt fy 6
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
39/320
0: Ocmmdotbmh _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`
Euatbecj`a `mj Docmcebo Ocrrbjcrs
Euatbecj`a ocrrbjcrs defr`od euatbpad ecjds ci tr`mspcrt, wnbaddocmcebo ocrrbjcrs t`gd `m bmtdhr`tdj `pprc`on tc bmir`struoturd `acmhsdadotdj rcutds tc e`xbebzd achbstbo`a dobdmoy. Bm tnd o`sd ci HE_docmcebo ocrrbjcrs, h`ps ̀ mj mdw ocrrbjcrs ̀ rd bjdmtbffdj. Icr bmst`mod,` mct`fad h`p bs bjdmtbffdj bm Ey`me`r `acmh tnd Xdstdrm Ocrrbjcr, tbdjbm wbtn tnd dxtdmsbcm ci tnd D`st‟Xdst Ocrrbjcr irce G`wg`rdbg tc\`y`hyb cm tnd Xdstdrm Ocrrbjcr. Dst`fabsnbmh tnbs abmg wbaa ocmmdot tndXdstdrm Ocrrbjcr tn`t abmgs Bmjb` `t Z`eu, tc tnd D`st‟Xdst Ocrrbjcr.Iurtndrecrd, ` mdw HE_ ocrrbjcr n`s fddm prcpcsdj‚tnd Ey`me`r‟
A`c \JV‟Ybdt M`e Zrba`tdr`a D`st‟Xdst Ocrrbjcr tn`t wcuaj rum mcrtnci `mj p`r`aada tc tnd D`st‟Xdst Ocrrbjcr. Bt wcuaj ocmmdot Gy`ugpyu`acmh tnd F`y ci Fdmh`a (tn`t bs fdbmh prcpcsdj icr tnd jdvdacpedmtci ` jddpw`tdr pcrt) wbtn tnd d`stdrm dmj `t N`b \ncmh bm Ybdt M`e.Bm Ey`me`r, bt wcuaj dxtdmj 0,?:< ge irce Gy`ugpyu tc Gy`bmha`t. Btwcuaj tndm dxtdmj ?86 ge bm tnd A`c \JV irce tnd fcrjdr frbjhd tc Z`bOn`m, `mj `mctndr 490 ge bm Ybdt M`e irce tnd fcrjdr tc N`b \ncmh.
Znd _cutn @sb`m @sscob`tbcm icr Vdhbcm`a Occpdr`tbcm (_@@VO)bmbtb`tdj bts Vdhbcm`a Euatbecj`a Zr`mspcrt stujy tc dmn`mod euatbecj`a
tr`mspcrt ocmmdotbvbty `ecmh edefdr st`tds (_@@VO 6
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
40/320
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
41/320
09 Ocmmdotbmh _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`
Z ` f a d 0 . 6 ; O
c u m t r y - A d v d a \ r b c r b t y \ r c p c s ` a s i c r B e p r c v b m h O
c m m d o t b v b t y f d t w d d m _ c u t n @ s b ` ` m j _ c u t n d ` s t @
s b `
Z r ` m s p c r t \ r c k d o t s
D m d r h y \ r c k d o t s
I b m
` m o d
Z r ` j d / Z r ` m s p c r t
I ` o b a b t ` t b c m
Z r ` j d
@ h r d d e d m t s
B m s t b t u t b c m ` a
_ c u t n @ s b `
F ` m h a ` j d s n
\ c r t s ;
O n b t t ` h c m h ( m d w
j d d p w ` t d r p c r t , r
c ` j ` m j
r ` b a ` o o d s s )
M ` t u r ` a h ` s ; J
d v d a c p
E y ` m e ` r ‟
F ` m h a ` j d s n ‟
B m j b ` h ` s p b p d a b m d p r c k d o t
F c m j e
` r g d t ;
J d v d a c p
b m i r ` s t r u
o t u r d
f c m j s
\ \ \ ; B e
p r c v d
d m v b r c m e d m t
Z r ` j d i ` o b a b t ` t b c m ;
Z r ` m s b t ` h r d d e d m t s
w b t n B m j b ` ` m j
E y ` m e ` r
F c r j d r c p d r ` t b c m s ;
_ t r d ` e a b m d
j c o u e d m t ` t b c m ` m j
p r c o d j u r d s
\ r c e c t d r c a d c i
s t ` t d h c v d r m e d m t s
b m s u p p c r t b m h
o c m m d o t b v b t y
F n u t ` m
F c m j e
` r g d t ;
J d v d a c p
p r b v ` t d
s d o t c r f
c m j
e ` r g d t
F c r j d r b m i r ` s t r u o t u
r d ;
J d v d a c p f c r j d r
o a d ` r ` m o d i ` o b a b t b d s
B m j b `
N
b h n w ` y s ;
B e p n ` a ‟
E c r d n
,
O
n d m m ` b \ c r t d x p r d s s w ` y
V
` b a r c ` j s ;
K b r b p ` e ‟
B e
p n ` a , B
e p n ` a ‟
E c r d n
\ c r t s ;
G c a g ` t ` / N ` a j b `
( m d w j d d p w ` t d r p c r t , r
c ` j
` m j r ` b a ` o o d s s )
M ` t u r ` a h ` s ; E
y ` m e ` r ‟
F ` m h a ` j d s n ‟
B m j b ` h ` s
p b p d a b m d p r c k d o t , A
M H
b e p c r t t d r e b m ` a s ` m j
p c r t
i ` o b a b t y j d v d a c p e d m t
N y j r c d a d o t r b o b t y ;
B e p c r t
i r c e
Z ` e ` m t b \ r c k d o t ,
E y ` m e ` r
Z r ` m s p c r t i ` o b a b t ` t b c m ;
Z r ` m s b t ` h r d d e d m t s
w b t n F ` m h a ` j d s n ` m j
E y ` m e ` r
F c r j d r b m i r ` s t r u o t u
r d ;
E c j d r m b z d f c r j d r
i ` o b a b t b d s
V O D \
_ p d d j y
b e p a d e d m t ` t b c m
c i t n d
r d o c e e d m
j ` t b c m s
c i t n d M c r
t n - D ` s t
V d h b c m Y b s
b c m
.
\ r c e c t d r c a d c i
s t ` t d h c v d r m e d m t s
b m s u p p c r t b m h
o c m m d o t b v b t y
o c m
t b m u d j c m m d x
t p ` h d
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
42/320
Bmtrcjuotbcm ̀ mj Cvdrvbdw 08
Z `
f a d
.
o c m
t b m u d
j
o c m
t b m u d j c m m d x
t p ` h d
Z r ` m s p c r t \ r c k d o t s
D m d r h y \ r c k d o t s
I b m ` m o d
Z r ` j d / Z r ` m s p c r t
I ` o b a b t ` t b c m
Z r ` j d
@ h r d d e d m t s
B m s t b t u t b c m ` a
M d p ` a
F c m j e `
r g d t ;
J d v d a c p
p r b v ` t d
s d o t c r f c
m j
e ` r g d t
\ \ \ ; B
e p
r c v d
d m v b r c m e
d m t
F c r j d r c p d r ` t b c m s ;
_ t r d ` e a b m d
j c o u e d m t ` t b c m ` m j
p r c o d j u r d s
F c r j d r b m i r ` s t r u o t u r d ;
B e p r c v d f c r j d r
i ` o b a b t b d s
_ r b A ` m g `
F c m j e `
r g d t ;
J d v d a c p
p r b v ` t d s d o t c r
f c m j e `
r g d t
Z r ` j d ff m
` m o d ;
B e p r c v d
\ \ \ ; B
e p
r c v d
d m v b r c m e
d m t
B O Z ; J
d v d a c p e d m t c
i
M _ X
_ c u t n d ` s t @ s b `
O ` e f c j b `
N b h n w ` y s ;
@ r ` m y ` p r ` t n d t ‟
\ c
b p d t V ` b a r c ` j s ; \ c b p d t ‟
\ n
m c e \ d m n
, \ n m c e
\ d
m n ‟
A c o M b m n
F c m j e `
r g d t ;
J d v d a c p
p r b v ` t d
s d o t c r f c
m j
e ` r g d t
F c r j d r c p d r ` t b c m s ;
_ b e p a b i y
j c o u e d m t ` t b c m
r d q u b r d e d m t s
B O Z ; J
d v d a c p e d m t c
i
M _ X
V O D \
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
43/320
0> Ocmmdotbmh _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`
Z r ` m s p c r t \ r c k d o t s
D m d r h y \ r c k d o t s
I b m ` m o d
Z r ` j d / Z r ` m s p c r t
I ` o b a b t ` t b c m
Z r ` j d
@ h r d d e d m t s
B m s t b t u t b c m ` a
E y ` m e ` r
N b h n w ` y s ;
D b m j u ‟
E y ` w ` j j y , Z ` e u ‟ R ` h y b ,
Z n
b a ` w ` p c r t r c ` j
o c
m m d o t b c m s
V `
b a r c ` j s ;
Z ` e u ‟
G ` a d ,
G `
a d ‟
E ` m j ` a ` y , Z
n r d d
\ `
h c j ` s , A
` s n b c ‟
V u b a b
,
J ` w d b ‟
F O \
\ c
r t s ;
R ` m h c m / Z n b a ` w `
r c ` j o c m m d o t b c m s
M ` t u
r ` a h ` s ; C
s n c r d
_ n d w
` h ` s ff d a j
j d v d a c p e d m t , E y ` m e ` r ‟
F ` m h a ` j d s n ‟
B m j b `
h ` s p b p d a b m d p r c k d o t
N y j r c p c w d r ; Z
` e ` m t b
\ r c k d o t
F c m j e `
r g d t ;
J d v d a c p
p r b v ` t d s d o t c r
f c m j e `
r g d t
\ \ \ ; J
d v d a c p
d m v b r c m e
d m t
Z r ` m s p c r t i ` o b a b t ` t b c
m ;
Z r ` m s b t ` h r d d e d m t s
w b t n B m j b ` ` m j
Z n ` b a ` m j
F c r j d r b m i r ` s t r u o t u r d ;
E c j d r m b z d i ` o b a b t b d s
B O Z ; J
d v d a c p e d m t c
i
o u s t c e s s y s t d e s ` m j
M _ X
V O D \
O c c r j b m ` t b m h
r c a d i c r T m b c m
c i E y ` m e `
r
I d j d r ` t b c m
c i
O n ` e f d r s c i
O c e e d r o d
` m j
B m j u s t r y
Z n ` b a ` m j
N b h n w ` y s ;
E y ` w ` j j y ‟
E ` d _ c t , E ` d _ c t ‟ Z ` g
V `
b a r c ` j s ;
F ` m h g c g ‟
@ r ` m y ` p r ` t n d t , Z n r d d
\ `
h c j ` s , F
O \ ‟
M ` e Z c g
F c m j e `
r g d t ;
J d v d a c p
p r b v ` t d s d o t c r
f c m j e `
r g d t
\ \ \ ; J
d v d a c p
d m v b r c m e
d m t
Z r ` m s p c r t i ` o b a b t ` t b c
m ;
Z r ` m s b t ` h r d d e d m t s
w b t n B m j b ` ` m j
E y ` m e ` r
V O D \
Y b d t M ` e
V `
b a r c ` j s ;
A c o M b m n ‟
N c
O n b E b m n O b t y , N ` M c b ‟
A `
c O ` b
O c ` a ; O
c ` a f d j e d t n ` m d
d x t r ` o t b c m ` m j d m d r h y
h d m d r ` t b c m
F c m j e `
r g d t ;
J d v d a c p
p r b v ` t d
s d o t c r f c
m j
e ` r g d t
F c r j d r c p d r ` t b c m s ;
_ b e p a b i y
j c o u e d m t ` t b c m
r d q u b r d e d m t s
B O Z ; J
d v d a c p e d m t c
i
M _ X
V O D \
F O \ f c r j d r o r c s s b m h p
c b m t 7 B O Z b m i c r e ` t b c m ` m j o c e e u m
b o ` t b c m t d o n m c a c h y 7 A
M H a b q u d ff d j m
` t u r ` a h ` s 7 M
_ X
M ` t b c m ` a _ b m h a d X b m j c w 7 \
\ \ p u f a b o - p r b v ` t d p ` r t m d r s n
b p 7
V O D \ V d h b c m ` a O c e p
r d n d m s b v d D o c m c e b o \ ` r t m d r s n b p
.
_ c u r o d ; O c e p b a d j f y ` u
t n c r s .
Z `
f a d
.
o c m
t b m u d
j
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
44/320
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
45/320
6< Ocmmdotbmh _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`
Bjdmtbiybmh f`mg`fad prckdots; Znd @_D@M BmtdrocmmdotbcmE`stdr \a`m _tujy n`s bjdmtbffdj sdvdr`a bmtr`-rdhbcm`a prckdots(@_D@M _dordt`rb`t 6
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
46/320
Bmtrcjuotbcm ̀ mj Cvdrvbdw 60
bmir`struoturd bmvdstedmt ecrd `ttr`otbvd tc tnd prbv`td sdotcr. Znd`m`aysbs n`s bjdmtbffdj v`rbcus ordjbt e`rgdt bmtdrvdmtbcms `mj ordjbtdmn`modedmt edon`mbses tn`t `rd abgday tc prcectd tnd on`mmdabmh ciocmtr`otu`a bmstbtutbcm`a `mj rdt`ba s`vbmhs bmtc bmir`struoturd ffm`mob`a`ssdts. Bmir`struoturd iumjs, fctn jcedstbo `mj bmtdrm`tbcm`a, o`m pa`y` rcad, dspdob`aay bi tnd @_D@M Bmir`struoturd Iumj bs dxtdmjdj tc `p`m-@sb`m bmir`struoturd iumj. Ed`surds tc bmtdhr`td rdhbcm`a ffm`mob`ae`rgdts `mj d`sd rdstrbotbcms cm bmtdrm`tbcm`a o`pbt`a stcws o`m `ascocmtrbfutd.
\\\s prcvbjd `m bepcrt`mt tcp-up icr bmir`struoturd iumjbmh, fut`rd mct ̀ p`m`od`. Bmjb`‒s dxpdrbdmod n`s sncwm tn`t tnd \\\ ecjda o`m fd ̀ p`rt ci tnd scautbcm icr ffm`mobmh dmdrhy ̀ mj tr`mspcrt bmir`struoturdprckdots. Mcmdtndadss, suon prckdots `rd ocepadx, `mj tc `vcbj i`baurdrdqubrd v`rbcus prdocmjbtbcms, bmoaujbmh (b) edon`mbses tc dmsurdtr`msp`rdmoy `mj `oocumt`fbabty ci fbjjbmh prcodssds7 (bb) jdvdacpedmtci hcvdrmedmt \\\ umbts `mj tr`msp`rdmt prcodssds tc i`obabt`td `aa`spdots ci tnd \\\ ̀ pprcv`a, prcourdedmt, ̀ mj jdabvdry prcodssds7 dm`fad`aa abmgs, pdrebts, `mj `pprcv`as7 `mj n`vd ` tr`msp`rdmt bmtdri`od wbtntnd `utncrbtbds tn`t `pprcvd prckdots7 (bbb) ord`tbcm ci `m bmjdpdmjdmtrdhua`tcry dmvbrcmedmt wbtncut ocmstbots ci bmtdrdst tn`t o`m ecmbtcrprckdot prchrdss, oceebssbcmbmh, `mj cpdr`tbcm7 `mj (bv) bmvdstedmtbm nue`m rdscurods icr \\\ tc beprcvd sgbaas `mj gmcwadjhd `orcss `spdotrue ci spdob`atbds.
Vdhua`tcry ocmstr`bmts bmoaujd rdstrbotbcms cm tnd `ssdts tn`tbmstbtutbcm`a bmvdstcrs suon `s bmsur`mod ocep`mbds `mj pdmsbcmiumjs o`m puron`sd `mj rdstrbotbcms cm prbv`td `mj icrdbhm cwmdrsnbpci bmir`struoturd. Bmstbtutbcm`a ocmstr`bmts bmoaujd a`og ci e`rgdtbmir`struoturd `mj bmsur`mod edon`mbses tn`t rdjuod rbsg icr prbv`tdbmvdstcrs, bee`turd rdhua`tcry ir`edwcrgs, vca`tbad ̀ mj mcm-tr`msp`rdmtpcabtbo`a dmvbrcmedmts, `mj adh`a `mj rdhua`tcry on`mhds tn`t o`m `dotrdturms tc bmvdstcrs, tndrdfy jbsocur`hbmh p`rtbobp`tbcm bm \\\ prckdots.
Hcvdrmedmts eust pa`y ` gdy rcad bm ord`tbmh dm`fabmh pcaboydmvbrcmedmts `mj ffm`mob`a bmir`struoturd tc dmsurd a`rhdr prbv`tdp`rtbobp`tbcm bm orcss-fcrjdr bmtdhr`tbcm prckdots, `s tndrd `rddxtdrm`abtbds tn`t wcuaj ctndrwbsd mct fd rd`pdj. Zndsd bmoaujd d`sbmhrdhua`tcry rdstrbotbcms cm bmir`struoturd bmvdstedmt fy bmstbtutbcm`abmvdstcrs `mj rdjuobmh cwmdrsnbp rdstrbotbcms cm prbv`td `mj icrdbhmbmvdstcrs. Beprcvbmh tnd tr`msp`rdmoy, rdhua`tcry ir`edwcrg, `mjhcvdrm`mod ci \\\ prckdots, tchdtndr wbtn tnd `jjbtbcm ci pcabtbo`a rbsghu`r`mtdds, o`m bmord`sd tnd `ttr`otbvdmdss ci tnbs `ssdt oa`ss. Bm tndo`sd ci orcss-fcrjdr prckdots, bmtdrm`tbcm`a occrjbm`tbcm bs orbtbo`a icrsuoodss.
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
47/320
66 Ocmmdotbmh _cutn @sb` `mj _cutnd`st @sb`
Euatba`tdr`a jdvdacpedmt f`mgs o`m pa`y euatbpad rcads bm ` prckdot‒sffm`mob`a abidoyoad; st`rtbmh `s ` prcvbjdr ci jdvdacpedmt suppcrt tc tnd
ncst7 dvcavbmh tc tn`t ci ̀ pcaboy bmstudmodr, tdonmbo`a ̀ jvbscr, ̀ mj ncmdst frcgdr7 `t ffm`mob`a oacsurd, oceebttbmh o`pbt`a `mj jdft tc tnd prckdot`mj advdr`hbmh tndbr mdtwcrg `ecmh ctndr euatba`tdr`a jdvdacpedmt f`mgs7 `mj, ffm`aay, prcvbjbmh ordjbt dmn`modedmts tnrcuhn p`rtb`a ordjbt`mj pcabtbo`a rbsg hu`r`mtdds.
0.8 Zr`jd I`obabt`tbcm
On`ptdr 9 dx`ebmds bssuds `mj scautbcms rda`tdj tc tr`jd i`obabt`tbcm.Zr`jd i`obabt`tbcm bmoaujds `aa i`otcrs `dotbmh tnd tbed `mj ecmdt`ryocst ci ecvbmh hccjs. Zr`jd i`obabt`tbcm ed`surds `rd orbtbo`a tc dmsurdtn`t tnd fdmdffts ci bmir`struoturd bmvdstedmt rdsuat bm `m `otu`ardjuotbcm bm tr`jd-rda`tdj ocsts. Znd o`sd icr cvdr`aa dmn`modedmt citnd tr`jd i`obabt`tbcm dmvbrcmedmt bs ocepdaabmh bm suppcrt ci docmcebohrcwtn bm fctn rdhbcms. Beprcvdedmts bm tr`jd i`obabt`tbcm wcuaj e`gdtr`jbmh d`sbdr `mj ecrd st`fad, wbtn pctdmtb`aay acwdr tr`ms`otbcm ocsts,`mj sncuaj dm`fad tnd rd`abz`tbcm ci ̀ my a`tdmt tr`jd fdtwddm tnd rdhbcms
wnbon e`y mct fd ecvbmh jud tc dxbstbmh mcm-t`rb f`rrbdrs (MZFs).Zr`jd i`obabt`tbcm sncuaj dmocep`ss fctn pcrt `mj tr`mspcrt
i`obabt`tbcm, ̀ s tndy o`m citdm ̀ asc rdprdsdmt MZFs. Znd e`kcrbty ci tr`jd fdtwddm tnd twc rdhbcms wbaa ocmtbmud tc fd fy sd`, ctndr tn`m fdtwddmbeedjb`td mdbhnfcrs, `mj tndrdicrd dmsurbmh tnd d`sd ci ecvdedmt fdtwddm tnd suri`od `mj e`rbtbed bmtdri`ods sncuaj hdmdr`td s`vbmhs bmtr`ms`otbcms ocsts, ̀ s wdaa ̀ s beprcvd pdricre`mod.
_cutn @sb`m docmcebds `mj ` muefdr ci acwdr-bmoced _cutnd`st @sb`m ocumtrbds r`mg pccray bm tnd Xcraj F`mg‒s Jcbmh Fusbmdss survdy,0?
wnbon bs usdj `s `m bmtdrm`tbcm`a fdmone`rg ocep`rbmh tnd rda`tbvdpdricre`mod ci ocumtrbds bm e`gbmh fusbmdss d`sbdr. Znd Xcraj F`mg‒sAchbstbos \dricre`mod Bmjdx ed`surds ncw dobdmtay tr`jd bs fdbmhecvdj. Bmjb` jcds mct i`rd tcc f`jay, fut ctndr _cutn @sb`m ocumtrbds ̀ mjacwdr-bmoced _cutnd`st @sb`m ocumtrbds n`vd pccr r`mgbmhs. V`mgbmhsbm hcvdrm`mod-rda`tdj bmjbo`tcrs suon ̀ s ocrruptbcm tdmj tc fd rda`tbvdayacw bm tnd twc rdhbcms, wbtn tnd dxodptbcms suon `s _bmh`pcrd.
Dxodssbvd jcouedmt`tbcm rdqubrdedmts sdde tc fd tnd sbmhad fbhhdstprcfade bm tr`jd i`obabt`tbcm. _docmj, tndrd bs cmay abebtdj `jndrdmod
tc tnd Xcraj Oustces Crh`mbz`tbcm‒s Vdvbsdj Gyctc Ocmvdmtbcm tn`t
0? Znd Xcraj F`mg Jcbmh Fusbmdss survdy o`m fd icumj `t nttp;//www.jcbmhfusbmdss.crh/r`mgbmhs.
8/9/2019 Connecting South Asia and Southeast Asia
48/320
Bmtrcjuotbcm ̀ mj Cvdrvbdw 6?
rdprdsdmts `m bmtdrm`tbcm`a jdvdacpedmt ‑rc`j e`p― icr oustcesecjdrmbz`tbcm `mj bmtdrm`tbcm`a fdst pr`otbod fy prcvbjbmh ` sdrbds citbed-f`sdj rdoceedmj`tbcms ocvdrbmh ̀ spdotrue ci oustces ̀ otbvbtbdsjdsbhmdj tc dmn`mod cvdr`aa pdricre`mod. Znbrj, tnd bepadedmt`tbcmci bmicre`tbcm `mj oceeumbo`tbcm tdonmcachy (BOZ) wbtnbm tndoustces dmvbrcmedmt n`s bm e`my o`sds wbjdmdj tnd h`p fdtwddmtnd ecst jdvdacpdj `mj ad`st jdvdacpdj ocumtrbds bm tnd rdhbcm. Znbssbtu`tbcm n`s dvcavdj p`rtay `s ` rdsuat ci jbdrdmods bm tnd `ppabo`tbcm`mj iumjbmh ci BOZ `mj tnd BOZ dxpdrtbsd `v`ba`fad wbtnbm p`rtboua`roustces crh`mbz`tbcms. Znd dmj rdsuat bm e`my ci tnd ocumtrbds bm fctnrdhbcms bs tn`t tnd `utce`tdj `mj e`mu`a systdes `rd fdbmh cpdr`tdj bmp`r`aada, wbtn abttad bmord`sd bm cvdr`aa dobdmoy. Znd jdvdacpedmt p`tnci tnd M`tbcm`a _bmhad Xbmjcw (M_X) bs tdmjbmh tc rdpabo`td tnd cvdr`aaBOZ sbtu`tbcm bm tnbs rdh`rj.
Ctndr prcfades bmoaujd a`og ci tr`msp`rdmoy rdh`rjbmh dxpcrtrdqubrdedmts, adhbsa`tbvd ocmstr`bmts cm tnd `fbabty tc rdicre oustcesprcodjurds, jbvdrsd ocmicrebty `ssdssedmt pr`otbods `mj tnd usd cibmjbvbju`a st`mj`rjs `mj