Demand Response Availability Data System (DADS) Phase I and II

John MouraNERC Staff

Presentation Goals

Introduce the Demand Response Availability System (DADS) to industry stakeholders and provide instruction on how to complete the required data forms for the Phase I pilot program

Solicit feedback from workshop participants and answer program or organization-specific questions Additionally encourage continued feedback comments and suggestions throughout the Phase I pilot program

Provide an overview of the on-going efforts at NERC to collect historical performance data on demand response

NERC amp Demand Response

About NERC

Develop amp enforce reliability standards

Analyze system outages and near-misses amp recommend improved practices

Assess current and future reliability

International regulatory authority for electric reliability in North America

Presentation Goals

Introduce the Demand Response Availability System (DADS) to industry stakeholders and provide instruction on how to complete the required data forms for the Phase I pilot program

Solicit feedback from workshop participants and answer program or organization-specific questions Additionally encourage continued feedback comments and suggestions throughout the Phase I pilot program

Provide an overview of the on-going efforts at NERC to collect historical performance data on demand response

NERC amp Demand Response

About NERC

Develop amp enforce reliability standards

Analyze system outages and near-misses amp recommend improved practices

Assess current and future reliability

International regulatory authority for electric reliability in North America

NERC amp Demand Response

About NERC

Develop amp enforce reliability standards

Analyze system outages and near-misses amp recommend improved practices

Assess current and future reliability

International regulatory authority for electric reliability in North America

About NERC

Develop amp enforce reliability standards

Analyze system outages and near-misses amp recommend improved practices

Assess current and future reliability

International regulatory authority for electric reliability in North America

NERC amp Demand Response

Demand Response is an important component in the overall portfolio of resources required to reliably meet the increasing demands for electricity in North America

In order for NERC to carry out its responsibility to ensure the reliability of the North American bulk power system NERC must be able to

bull Evaluate and understand the benefits of Demand Response and its impact on reliability

bull Quantify the performance of demand-side resources

bull Assess the overall characteristics of Demand Response as it relates to bulk power system planning and operations

NERC amp Demand Response

Recommendations and Conclusions in the 2008 and 2009 Long-Term Reliability Assessment

bull Additional demand-side resources could be an effective option to preserve system reliability over the next ten years In addition they may facilitate the integration of renewable and variable resources

bull Potential reliability impacts of broad-scale use of Demand Response resources must be better understood by industry and regulators

bull Better measurement and verification techniques will be needed to measure and track actual availability of Demand Response under various system conditions

NERC amp Demand Response

NERC acts on these responsibilities through several activitiesbull Long-term assessment of Demand Response projections

Long-Term Reliability Assessment

bull Short-term assessment of Demand Response projections Seasonal (SummerWinter) Reliability Assessments

bull Other assessments or evaluations of Demand Response Demand-Side Management Task Force (completed)

Integration of Variable Generation Task Force

Reliability Impacts of Climate Change Initiatives

Demand Response Data Task Force

NERC Special Reliability Assessments

NERC amp Demand Response

Current Issuebull No feedback loop

Only projections are assessed

Potential concerns of resource availability

bull Measure and validate projections

Current activitiesbull Demand Response Availability

Data System

bull Post-Seasonal Reliability Assessment

Demand Response Data

ProjectionsHistoric

Market Participation Event

Demand Response Availability Data

System

Seasonal Long-Term

NERC Reliability Assessments

ProgramTypes

ProgramTypes

Capacity Energy Reserves Regulation Capacity

Supports EIA-411

submission

Current and Future Demand Response Data Collection Mechanisms

Future Current

NERC amp Demand Response

Current Issuebull No feedback loop

Only projections are assessed

Potential concerns of resource availability

bull Measure and validate projections

Current activitiesbull Demand Response Availability

Data System

bull Post-Seasonal Reliability Assessment

Demand Response Data

ProjectionsHistoric

Market Participation Event

Demand Response Availability Data

System

Seasonal Long-Term

NERC Reliability Assessments

ProgramTypes

ProgramTypes

Capacity Energy Reserves Regulation Capacity

Supports EIA-411

submission

Current and Future Demand Response Data Collection Mechanisms

Future Current

2010 Long-Term Reliability Assessment

Impacts of Resource Mix

Changes to System Stability

andFrequency Response

Changing Resource Mix

Transmission Operations with Vital

Transmission Out-of-Service

During Upgrades

Diminishing Frequency Response

Uncertainty of Sustained

Participation in Demand Response

Consistent Modeling of

Remote Resources

Like

lihoo

dH

igh

Low

Consequence HighLow

Preliminary ResultsmdashNot for Citation

Demand Response Availability Data System (DADS) Overview

What is DADS

DADS = Demand Response Availability Data System

DADS is a system that is aimed to collect demand response event and market participation information to measure the ongoing influence of demand response on reliability

The DADS will enable NERC to receive manage assess and disseminate data on Demand Response Programs products and services administered by retail and wholesale entities throughout North America

DADS will serve as a resource to the industry for information about Demand Response participation and performance

DADS Phase I amp II Report

The Demand Response Availability Data System Phase I and II report was approved by the NERC Planning Committee in September 2009

The report outlines the functional requirements of the Phase I and II system

Provides a framework for a mandatory data request to be issued by NERC

Identifies the required reporting parties as well as the data to be collected by the system

DADS Phase I amp II

DADS Phase I amp IIPhase Implementation

YearResponsible

EntitiesReporting

RequirementDemand Response Type(s)

Reporting Frequency

System Design

I 2010 BA LSE DP PSE Voluntary Dispatchable

ControllableSemi -Annual

In-house Excel

Workbooks

II 2011 BA LSE DP PSE Mandatory Dispatchable

ControllableSemi -Annual

Third Party Software

Developer

Web App

Phase I amp II will focus on reliability or event related Demand Response which is both dispatchable and controllable

Phase I is a voluntary pilot program

Phase II is a mandatory reporting system

DADS Annual Reporting Cycle

Phase I amp II DADS Data Collection amp Deliverable Schedule

Date Action

April 1st ndash September 30th Summer DADS reporting period

December 15th Summer DADS data due to NERC

October 1st ndash March 31st Winter DADS reporting period

June 15th Winter DADS data due to NERC

NERC has restructured the reporting timeframe and deliverable dates bullSemi-annual reporting will be implemented (versus the previously structured quarterly reports)

The reporting periods are designed around summer and winter seasonsmdashthe summer reporting period will occur from April 1st to September 30th and the winter reporting period will occur from October 1st to March 31st Data will be due to NERC approximately 2 12 months after the close of the reporting period

DADS Annual Reporting CycleDA

DS R

espo

nsib

le En

tities

De

man

d Re

spon

se D

ata T

ask F

orce

Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct NovMay Dec

Reporting Period for Q1

Reporting Period for Q2

Reporting Period for Q3

Reporting Period for Q4

Data Gathering for Q1

Data Gathering for Q2

Data Gathering for Q3

Q1DADS data

due

Q2DADS data

due

Q3DADS data

due

Q1Summary

ReportPublished

Quarter 1 (Q1) Quarter 2 (Q2) Quarter 3 (Q3) Quarter 4 (Q4)

Q2SummaryReport

Published

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Q1 DataProcessing

Q2 DataProcessing

Q3 DataProcessing

DADS

Res

pons

ible

Entit

ies

Dem

and

Resp

onse

Dat

a Tas

k For

ce

Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct NovMay Dec

Reporting Period for Q1

Reporting Period for Q2

Reporting Period for Q3

Reporting Period for Q4

Data Gathering for Q1

Data Gathering for Q2

Data Gathering for Q3

Q1DADS data

due

Q2DADS data

due

Q3DADS data

due

Q1Summary

ReportPublished

Quarter 1 (Q1) Quarter 2 (Q2) Quarter 3 (Q3) Quarter 4 (Q4)

Q2SummaryReport

Published

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Q1 DataProcessing

Q2 DataProcessing

Q3 DataProcessing

DADS

Res

pons

ible

Ent

ities

De

man

d Res

pons

e Dat

a Tas

k For

ce

April May Jun July Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan FebAug Mar

Reporting Period for Summer

Reporting Period for Winter

Data Gathering Summer

SummerDADS datadue

SummerReport

Published

Summer Winter

Receive Summer

DADS data

Receive Winter

DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Summer DataProcessing

Winter DataProcessing

WinterDADS datadue

Data Gathering Winter

WinterReport

Published

Responsible Reporting Entities

Responsible Entities will be required to maintain Demand Response data in DADS A Responsible Entity is defined as a NERC Registered Entity that either dispatches a Demand Response Resource andor administers a Demand Response Program product or service Responsible Entities for DADS data submittals are limited to

NERC Responsible Entities for DADS DataFunction Name Responsible Entity

Balancing Balancing AuthorityDistribution Distribution ProviderLoad-Serving Load-Serving EntityPurchasing-Selling Purchasing-Selling Entity

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull External Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs for different Reporting Entities

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

LSE

bullReports 10 MW Capacity Program

Submitted Data

BA - 50 MW

LSE -10 MW

Total Enrolled DR

60 MW

bull5 MW are used in BA program

Total Enrolled DR

55 MW

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull Internal Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs within the same entity

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

bullReports 40 MW Energy Program

Submitted Data

50 MW Capacity

40 MW Energy

Total Enrolled DR

90 MW

Total Enrolled DR

50 MW

Energy Program Participants are also

enrolled in the Capacity Program

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Program Criteria

DADS requires data for all Demand Response Programs currently in effect However Responsible Entities are only required to register and submit data on Demand Response Programs if

1) The Demand Response Program has been commercially in-service for more than 12 months or

2) The Demand Response Program has enrolled 10 MW or more of combined Demand Response Resources

Serves to not discourage small scale Demand Response deployment and to encourage the development of pilot Demand Response

Overview of Data to be Collected

Program Registration and Enrollment Data

bull Identification of the Demand Response Program

bull Zone Information

bull Product Type

bull Energy Capacity Reserve Regulation

bull Service Type (ie Capacity ndash Direct Load Control)

bull Program StartEnd Dates

bull RegisteredEnrolled Number of Resources

bull RegisteredEnrolled Capacity

bull Program Relationships

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Reliability Event Data bull Advance Notification DateTimebull Deployment DateTimebull Reduction Deadlinebull ReleaseRecall DateTimebull Committed MW

ContractedRegistered

bull Number of Committed Resourcesbull Dispatched MWbull Hourly Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)bull Hourly Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

DEPLOYMENT PERIOD

RECOVERYPERIOD

RED

UC

TIO

N D

EAD

LIN

E

DEP

LOYM

ENT

RAMPPERIOD

SUSTAINED RESPONSEPERIOD

REL

EASE

REC

ALL

NO

RM

AL

OPE

RA

TIO

NS

DEMAND RESPONSE EVENT

AD

VAN

CE

NO

TIFI

CA

TIO

N(S

)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Market Participation Data (Monthly)bull Total Offer and Self Scheduled Hours

bull ScheduledCleared Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Offered Scheduled Demand Reduction (MW)

bull Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

Demand Response Availability Data System (DADS) Overview

What is DADS

DADS = Demand Response Availability Data System

DADS is a system that is aimed to collect demand response event and market participation information to measure the ongoing influence of demand response on reliability

The DADS will enable NERC to receive manage assess and disseminate data on Demand Response Programs products and services administered by retail and wholesale entities throughout North America

DADS will serve as a resource to the industry for information about Demand Response participation and performance

DADS Phase I amp II Report

The Demand Response Availability Data System Phase I and II report was approved by the NERC Planning Committee in September 2009

The report outlines the functional requirements of the Phase I and II system

Provides a framework for a mandatory data request to be issued by NERC

Identifies the required reporting parties as well as the data to be collected by the system

DADS Phase I amp II

DADS Phase I amp IIPhase Implementation

YearResponsible

EntitiesReporting

RequirementDemand Response Type(s)

Reporting Frequency

System Design

I 2010 BA LSE DP PSE Voluntary Dispatchable

ControllableSemi -Annual

In-house Excel

Workbooks

II 2011 BA LSE DP PSE Mandatory Dispatchable

ControllableSemi -Annual

Third Party Software

Developer

Web App

Phase I amp II will focus on reliability or event related Demand Response which is both dispatchable and controllable

Phase I is a voluntary pilot program

Phase II is a mandatory reporting system

DADS Annual Reporting Cycle

Phase I amp II DADS Data Collection amp Deliverable Schedule

Date Action

April 1st ndash September 30th Summer DADS reporting period

December 15th Summer DADS data due to NERC

October 1st ndash March 31st Winter DADS reporting period

June 15th Winter DADS data due to NERC

NERC has restructured the reporting timeframe and deliverable dates bullSemi-annual reporting will be implemented (versus the previously structured quarterly reports)

The reporting periods are designed around summer and winter seasonsmdashthe summer reporting period will occur from April 1st to September 30th and the winter reporting period will occur from October 1st to March 31st Data will be due to NERC approximately 2 12 months after the close of the reporting period

DADS Annual Reporting CycleDA

DS R

espo

nsib

le En

tities

De

man

d Re

spon

se D

ata T

ask F

orce

Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct NovMay Dec

Reporting Period for Q1

Reporting Period for Q2

Reporting Period for Q3

Reporting Period for Q4

Data Gathering for Q1

Data Gathering for Q2

Data Gathering for Q3

Q1DADS data

due

Q2DADS data

due

Q3DADS data

due

Q1Summary

ReportPublished

Quarter 1 (Q1) Quarter 2 (Q2) Quarter 3 (Q3) Quarter 4 (Q4)

Q2SummaryReport

Published

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Q1 DataProcessing

Q2 DataProcessing

Q3 DataProcessing

DADS

Res

pons

ible

Entit

ies

Dem

and

Resp

onse

Dat

a Tas

k For

ce

Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct NovMay Dec

Reporting Period for Q1

Reporting Period for Q2

Reporting Period for Q3

Reporting Period for Q4

Data Gathering for Q1

Data Gathering for Q2

Data Gathering for Q3

Q1DADS data

due

Q2DADS data

due

Q3DADS data

due

Q1Summary

ReportPublished

Quarter 1 (Q1) Quarter 2 (Q2) Quarter 3 (Q3) Quarter 4 (Q4)

Q2SummaryReport

Published

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Q1 DataProcessing

Q2 DataProcessing

Q3 DataProcessing

DADS

Res

pons

ible

Ent

ities

De

man

d Res

pons

e Dat

a Tas

k For

ce

April May Jun July Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan FebAug Mar

Reporting Period for Summer

Reporting Period for Winter

Data Gathering Summer

SummerDADS datadue

SummerReport

Published

Summer Winter

Receive Summer

DADS data

Receive Winter

DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Summer DataProcessing

Winter DataProcessing

WinterDADS datadue

Data Gathering Winter

WinterReport

Published

Responsible Reporting Entities

Responsible Entities will be required to maintain Demand Response data in DADS A Responsible Entity is defined as a NERC Registered Entity that either dispatches a Demand Response Resource andor administers a Demand Response Program product or service Responsible Entities for DADS data submittals are limited to

NERC Responsible Entities for DADS DataFunction Name Responsible Entity

Balancing Balancing AuthorityDistribution Distribution ProviderLoad-Serving Load-Serving EntityPurchasing-Selling Purchasing-Selling Entity

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull External Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs for different Reporting Entities

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

LSE

bullReports 10 MW Capacity Program

Submitted Data

BA - 50 MW

LSE -10 MW

Total Enrolled DR

60 MW

bull5 MW are used in BA program

Total Enrolled DR

55 MW

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull Internal Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs within the same entity

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

bullReports 40 MW Energy Program

Submitted Data

50 MW Capacity

40 MW Energy

Total Enrolled DR

90 MW

Total Enrolled DR

50 MW

Energy Program Participants are also

enrolled in the Capacity Program

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Program Criteria

DADS requires data for all Demand Response Programs currently in effect However Responsible Entities are only required to register and submit data on Demand Response Programs if

1) The Demand Response Program has been commercially in-service for more than 12 months or

2) The Demand Response Program has enrolled 10 MW or more of combined Demand Response Resources

Serves to not discourage small scale Demand Response deployment and to encourage the development of pilot Demand Response

Overview of Data to be Collected

Program Registration and Enrollment Data

bull Identification of the Demand Response Program

bull Zone Information

bull Product Type

bull Energy Capacity Reserve Regulation

bull Service Type (ie Capacity ndash Direct Load Control)

bull Program StartEnd Dates

bull RegisteredEnrolled Number of Resources

bull RegisteredEnrolled Capacity

bull Program Relationships

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Reliability Event Data bull Advance Notification DateTimebull Deployment DateTimebull Reduction Deadlinebull ReleaseRecall DateTimebull Committed MW

ContractedRegistered

bull Number of Committed Resourcesbull Dispatched MWbull Hourly Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)bull Hourly Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

DEPLOYMENT PERIOD

RECOVERYPERIOD

RED

UC

TIO

N D

EAD

LIN

E

DEP

LOYM

ENT

RAMPPERIOD

SUSTAINED RESPONSEPERIOD

REL

EASE

REC

ALL

NO

RM

AL

OPE

RA

TIO

NS

DEMAND RESPONSE EVENT

AD

VAN

CE

NO

TIFI

CA

TIO

N(S

)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Market Participation Data (Monthly)bull Total Offer and Self Scheduled Hours

bull ScheduledCleared Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Offered Scheduled Demand Reduction (MW)

bull Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

What is DADS

DADS = Demand Response Availability Data System

DADS is a system that is aimed to collect demand response event and market participation information to measure the ongoing influence of demand response on reliability

The DADS will enable NERC to receive manage assess and disseminate data on Demand Response Programs products and services administered by retail and wholesale entities throughout North America

DADS will serve as a resource to the industry for information about Demand Response participation and performance

DADS Phase I amp II Report

The Demand Response Availability Data System Phase I and II report was approved by the NERC Planning Committee in September 2009

The report outlines the functional requirements of the Phase I and II system

Provides a framework for a mandatory data request to be issued by NERC

Identifies the required reporting parties as well as the data to be collected by the system

DADS Phase I amp II

DADS Phase I amp IIPhase Implementation

YearResponsible

EntitiesReporting

RequirementDemand Response Type(s)

Reporting Frequency

System Design

I 2010 BA LSE DP PSE Voluntary Dispatchable

ControllableSemi -Annual

In-house Excel

Workbooks

II 2011 BA LSE DP PSE Mandatory Dispatchable

ControllableSemi -Annual

Third Party Software

Developer

Web App

Phase I amp II will focus on reliability or event related Demand Response which is both dispatchable and controllable

Phase I is a voluntary pilot program

Phase II is a mandatory reporting system

DADS Annual Reporting Cycle

Phase I amp II DADS Data Collection amp Deliverable Schedule

Date Action

April 1st ndash September 30th Summer DADS reporting period

December 15th Summer DADS data due to NERC

October 1st ndash March 31st Winter DADS reporting period

June 15th Winter DADS data due to NERC

NERC has restructured the reporting timeframe and deliverable dates bullSemi-annual reporting will be implemented (versus the previously structured quarterly reports)

The reporting periods are designed around summer and winter seasonsmdashthe summer reporting period will occur from April 1st to September 30th and the winter reporting period will occur from October 1st to March 31st Data will be due to NERC approximately 2 12 months after the close of the reporting period

DADS Annual Reporting CycleDA

DS R

espo

nsib

le En

tities

De

man

d Re

spon

se D

ata T

ask F

orce

Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct NovMay Dec

Reporting Period for Q1

Reporting Period for Q2

Reporting Period for Q3

Reporting Period for Q4

Data Gathering for Q1

Data Gathering for Q2

Data Gathering for Q3

Q1DADS data

due

Q2DADS data

due

Q3DADS data

due

Q1Summary

ReportPublished

Quarter 1 (Q1) Quarter 2 (Q2) Quarter 3 (Q3) Quarter 4 (Q4)

Q2SummaryReport

Published

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Q1 DataProcessing

Q2 DataProcessing

Q3 DataProcessing

DADS

Res

pons

ible

Entit

ies

Dem

and

Resp

onse

Dat

a Tas

k For

ce

Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct NovMay Dec

Reporting Period for Q1

Reporting Period for Q2

Reporting Period for Q3

Reporting Period for Q4

Data Gathering for Q1

Data Gathering for Q2

Data Gathering for Q3

Q1DADS data

due

Q2DADS data

due

Q3DADS data

due

Q1Summary

ReportPublished

Quarter 1 (Q1) Quarter 2 (Q2) Quarter 3 (Q3) Quarter 4 (Q4)

Q2SummaryReport

Published

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Q1 DataProcessing

Q2 DataProcessing

Q3 DataProcessing

DADS

Res

pons

ible

Ent

ities

De

man

d Res

pons

e Dat

a Tas

k For

ce

April May Jun July Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan FebAug Mar

Reporting Period for Summer

Reporting Period for Winter

Data Gathering Summer

SummerDADS datadue

SummerReport

Published

Summer Winter

Receive Summer

DADS data

Receive Winter

DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Summer DataProcessing

Winter DataProcessing

WinterDADS datadue

Data Gathering Winter

WinterReport

Published

Responsible Reporting Entities

Responsible Entities will be required to maintain Demand Response data in DADS A Responsible Entity is defined as a NERC Registered Entity that either dispatches a Demand Response Resource andor administers a Demand Response Program product or service Responsible Entities for DADS data submittals are limited to

NERC Responsible Entities for DADS DataFunction Name Responsible Entity

Balancing Balancing AuthorityDistribution Distribution ProviderLoad-Serving Load-Serving EntityPurchasing-Selling Purchasing-Selling Entity

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull External Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs for different Reporting Entities

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

LSE

bullReports 10 MW Capacity Program

Submitted Data

BA - 50 MW

LSE -10 MW

Total Enrolled DR

60 MW

bull5 MW are used in BA program

Total Enrolled DR

55 MW

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull Internal Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs within the same entity

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

bullReports 40 MW Energy Program

Submitted Data

50 MW Capacity

40 MW Energy

Total Enrolled DR

90 MW

Total Enrolled DR

50 MW

Energy Program Participants are also

enrolled in the Capacity Program

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Program Criteria

DADS requires data for all Demand Response Programs currently in effect However Responsible Entities are only required to register and submit data on Demand Response Programs if

1) The Demand Response Program has been commercially in-service for more than 12 months or

2) The Demand Response Program has enrolled 10 MW or more of combined Demand Response Resources

Serves to not discourage small scale Demand Response deployment and to encourage the development of pilot Demand Response

Overview of Data to be Collected

Program Registration and Enrollment Data

bull Identification of the Demand Response Program

bull Zone Information

bull Product Type

bull Energy Capacity Reserve Regulation

bull Service Type (ie Capacity ndash Direct Load Control)

bull Program StartEnd Dates

bull RegisteredEnrolled Number of Resources

bull RegisteredEnrolled Capacity

bull Program Relationships

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Reliability Event Data bull Advance Notification DateTimebull Deployment DateTimebull Reduction Deadlinebull ReleaseRecall DateTimebull Committed MW

ContractedRegistered

bull Number of Committed Resourcesbull Dispatched MWbull Hourly Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)bull Hourly Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

DEPLOYMENT PERIOD

RECOVERYPERIOD

RED

UC

TIO

N D

EAD

LIN

E

DEP

LOYM

ENT

RAMPPERIOD

SUSTAINED RESPONSEPERIOD

REL

EASE

REC

ALL

NO

RM

AL

OPE

RA

TIO

NS

DEMAND RESPONSE EVENT

AD

VAN

CE

NO

TIFI

CA

TIO

N(S

)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Market Participation Data (Monthly)bull Total Offer and Self Scheduled Hours

bull ScheduledCleared Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Offered Scheduled Demand Reduction (MW)

bull Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

DADS Phase I amp II Report

The Demand Response Availability Data System Phase I and II report was approved by the NERC Planning Committee in September 2009

The report outlines the functional requirements of the Phase I and II system

Provides a framework for a mandatory data request to be issued by NERC

Identifies the required reporting parties as well as the data to be collected by the system

DADS Phase I amp II

DADS Phase I amp IIPhase Implementation

YearResponsible

EntitiesReporting

RequirementDemand Response Type(s)

Reporting Frequency

System Design

I 2010 BA LSE DP PSE Voluntary Dispatchable

ControllableSemi -Annual

In-house Excel

Workbooks

II 2011 BA LSE DP PSE Mandatory Dispatchable

ControllableSemi -Annual

Third Party Software

Developer

Web App

Phase I amp II will focus on reliability or event related Demand Response which is both dispatchable and controllable

Phase I is a voluntary pilot program

Phase II is a mandatory reporting system

DADS Annual Reporting Cycle

Phase I amp II DADS Data Collection amp Deliverable Schedule

Date Action

April 1st ndash September 30th Summer DADS reporting period

December 15th Summer DADS data due to NERC

October 1st ndash March 31st Winter DADS reporting period

June 15th Winter DADS data due to NERC

NERC has restructured the reporting timeframe and deliverable dates bullSemi-annual reporting will be implemented (versus the previously structured quarterly reports)

The reporting periods are designed around summer and winter seasonsmdashthe summer reporting period will occur from April 1st to September 30th and the winter reporting period will occur from October 1st to March 31st Data will be due to NERC approximately 2 12 months after the close of the reporting period

DADS Annual Reporting CycleDA

DS R

espo

nsib

le En

tities

De

man

d Re

spon

se D

ata T

ask F

orce

Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct NovMay Dec

Reporting Period for Q1

Reporting Period for Q2

Reporting Period for Q3

Reporting Period for Q4

Data Gathering for Q1

Data Gathering for Q2

Data Gathering for Q3

Q1DADS data

due

Q2DADS data

due

Q3DADS data

due

Q1Summary

ReportPublished

Quarter 1 (Q1) Quarter 2 (Q2) Quarter 3 (Q3) Quarter 4 (Q4)

Q2SummaryReport

Published

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Q1 DataProcessing

Q2 DataProcessing

Q3 DataProcessing

DADS

Res

pons

ible

Entit

ies

Dem

and

Resp

onse

Dat

a Tas

k For

ce

Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct NovMay Dec

Reporting Period for Q1

Reporting Period for Q2

Reporting Period for Q3

Reporting Period for Q4

Data Gathering for Q1

Data Gathering for Q2

Data Gathering for Q3

Q1DADS data

due

Q2DADS data

due

Q3DADS data

due

Q1Summary

ReportPublished

Quarter 1 (Q1) Quarter 2 (Q2) Quarter 3 (Q3) Quarter 4 (Q4)

Q2SummaryReport

Published

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Q1 DataProcessing

Q2 DataProcessing

Q3 DataProcessing

DADS

Res

pons

ible

Ent

ities

De

man

d Res

pons

e Dat

a Tas

k For

ce

April May Jun July Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan FebAug Mar

Reporting Period for Summer

Reporting Period for Winter

Data Gathering Summer

SummerDADS datadue

SummerReport

Published

Summer Winter

Receive Summer

DADS data

Receive Winter

DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Summer DataProcessing

Winter DataProcessing

WinterDADS datadue

Data Gathering Winter

WinterReport

Published

Responsible Reporting Entities

Responsible Entities will be required to maintain Demand Response data in DADS A Responsible Entity is defined as a NERC Registered Entity that either dispatches a Demand Response Resource andor administers a Demand Response Program product or service Responsible Entities for DADS data submittals are limited to

NERC Responsible Entities for DADS DataFunction Name Responsible Entity

Balancing Balancing AuthorityDistribution Distribution ProviderLoad-Serving Load-Serving EntityPurchasing-Selling Purchasing-Selling Entity

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull External Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs for different Reporting Entities

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

LSE

bullReports 10 MW Capacity Program

Submitted Data

BA - 50 MW

LSE -10 MW

Total Enrolled DR

60 MW

bull5 MW are used in BA program

Total Enrolled DR

55 MW

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull Internal Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs within the same entity

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

bullReports 40 MW Energy Program

Submitted Data

50 MW Capacity

40 MW Energy

Total Enrolled DR

90 MW

Total Enrolled DR

50 MW

Energy Program Participants are also

enrolled in the Capacity Program

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Program Criteria

DADS requires data for all Demand Response Programs currently in effect However Responsible Entities are only required to register and submit data on Demand Response Programs if

1) The Demand Response Program has been commercially in-service for more than 12 months or

2) The Demand Response Program has enrolled 10 MW or more of combined Demand Response Resources

Serves to not discourage small scale Demand Response deployment and to encourage the development of pilot Demand Response

Overview of Data to be Collected

Program Registration and Enrollment Data

bull Identification of the Demand Response Program

bull Zone Information

bull Product Type

bull Energy Capacity Reserve Regulation

bull Service Type (ie Capacity ndash Direct Load Control)

bull Program StartEnd Dates

bull RegisteredEnrolled Number of Resources

bull RegisteredEnrolled Capacity

bull Program Relationships

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Reliability Event Data bull Advance Notification DateTimebull Deployment DateTimebull Reduction Deadlinebull ReleaseRecall DateTimebull Committed MW

ContractedRegistered

bull Number of Committed Resourcesbull Dispatched MWbull Hourly Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)bull Hourly Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

DEPLOYMENT PERIOD

RECOVERYPERIOD

RED

UC

TIO

N D

EAD

LIN

E

DEP

LOYM

ENT

RAMPPERIOD

SUSTAINED RESPONSEPERIOD

REL

EASE

REC

ALL

NO

RM

AL

OPE

RA

TIO

NS

DEMAND RESPONSE EVENT

AD

VAN

CE

NO

TIFI

CA

TIO

N(S

)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Market Participation Data (Monthly)bull Total Offer and Self Scheduled Hours

bull ScheduledCleared Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Offered Scheduled Demand Reduction (MW)

bull Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

DADS Phase I amp II

DADS Phase I amp IIPhase Implementation

YearResponsible

EntitiesReporting

RequirementDemand Response Type(s)

Reporting Frequency

System Design

I 2010 BA LSE DP PSE Voluntary Dispatchable

ControllableSemi -Annual

In-house Excel

Workbooks

II 2011 BA LSE DP PSE Mandatory Dispatchable

ControllableSemi -Annual

Third Party Software

Developer

Web App

Phase I amp II will focus on reliability or event related Demand Response which is both dispatchable and controllable

Phase I is a voluntary pilot program

Phase II is a mandatory reporting system

DADS Annual Reporting Cycle

Phase I amp II DADS Data Collection amp Deliverable Schedule

Date Action

April 1st ndash September 30th Summer DADS reporting period

December 15th Summer DADS data due to NERC

October 1st ndash March 31st Winter DADS reporting period

June 15th Winter DADS data due to NERC

NERC has restructured the reporting timeframe and deliverable dates bullSemi-annual reporting will be implemented (versus the previously structured quarterly reports)

The reporting periods are designed around summer and winter seasonsmdashthe summer reporting period will occur from April 1st to September 30th and the winter reporting period will occur from October 1st to March 31st Data will be due to NERC approximately 2 12 months after the close of the reporting period

DADS Annual Reporting CycleDA

DS R

espo

nsib

le En

tities

De

man

d Re

spon

se D

ata T

ask F

orce

Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct NovMay Dec

Reporting Period for Q1

Reporting Period for Q2

Reporting Period for Q3

Reporting Period for Q4

Data Gathering for Q1

Data Gathering for Q2

Data Gathering for Q3

Q1DADS data

due

Q2DADS data

due

Q3DADS data

due

Q1Summary

ReportPublished

Quarter 1 (Q1) Quarter 2 (Q2) Quarter 3 (Q3) Quarter 4 (Q4)

Q2SummaryReport

Published

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Q1 DataProcessing

Q2 DataProcessing

Q3 DataProcessing

DADS

Res

pons

ible

Entit

ies

Dem

and

Resp

onse

Dat

a Tas

k For

ce

Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct NovMay Dec

Reporting Period for Q1

Reporting Period for Q2

Reporting Period for Q3

Reporting Period for Q4

Data Gathering for Q1

Data Gathering for Q2

Data Gathering for Q3

Q1DADS data

due

Q2DADS data

due

Q3DADS data

due

Q1Summary

ReportPublished

Quarter 1 (Q1) Quarter 2 (Q2) Quarter 3 (Q3) Quarter 4 (Q4)

Q2SummaryReport

Published

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Q1 DataProcessing

Q2 DataProcessing

Q3 DataProcessing

DADS

Res

pons

ible

Ent

ities

De

man

d Res

pons

e Dat

a Tas

k For

ce

April May Jun July Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan FebAug Mar

Reporting Period for Summer

Reporting Period for Winter

Data Gathering Summer

SummerDADS datadue

SummerReport

Published

Summer Winter

Receive Summer

DADS data

Receive Winter

DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Summer DataProcessing

Winter DataProcessing

WinterDADS datadue

Data Gathering Winter

WinterReport

Published

Responsible Reporting Entities

Responsible Entities will be required to maintain Demand Response data in DADS A Responsible Entity is defined as a NERC Registered Entity that either dispatches a Demand Response Resource andor administers a Demand Response Program product or service Responsible Entities for DADS data submittals are limited to

NERC Responsible Entities for DADS DataFunction Name Responsible Entity

Balancing Balancing AuthorityDistribution Distribution ProviderLoad-Serving Load-Serving EntityPurchasing-Selling Purchasing-Selling Entity

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull External Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs for different Reporting Entities

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

LSE

bullReports 10 MW Capacity Program

Submitted Data

BA - 50 MW

LSE -10 MW

Total Enrolled DR

60 MW

bull5 MW are used in BA program

Total Enrolled DR

55 MW

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull Internal Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs within the same entity

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

bullReports 40 MW Energy Program

Submitted Data

50 MW Capacity

40 MW Energy

Total Enrolled DR

90 MW

Total Enrolled DR

50 MW

Energy Program Participants are also

enrolled in the Capacity Program

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Program Criteria

DADS requires data for all Demand Response Programs currently in effect However Responsible Entities are only required to register and submit data on Demand Response Programs if

1) The Demand Response Program has been commercially in-service for more than 12 months or

2) The Demand Response Program has enrolled 10 MW or more of combined Demand Response Resources

Serves to not discourage small scale Demand Response deployment and to encourage the development of pilot Demand Response

Overview of Data to be Collected

Program Registration and Enrollment Data

bull Identification of the Demand Response Program

bull Zone Information

bull Product Type

bull Energy Capacity Reserve Regulation

bull Service Type (ie Capacity ndash Direct Load Control)

bull Program StartEnd Dates

bull RegisteredEnrolled Number of Resources

bull RegisteredEnrolled Capacity

bull Program Relationships

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Reliability Event Data bull Advance Notification DateTimebull Deployment DateTimebull Reduction Deadlinebull ReleaseRecall DateTimebull Committed MW

ContractedRegistered

bull Number of Committed Resourcesbull Dispatched MWbull Hourly Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)bull Hourly Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

DEPLOYMENT PERIOD

RECOVERYPERIOD

RED

UC

TIO

N D

EAD

LIN

E

DEP

LOYM

ENT

RAMPPERIOD

SUSTAINED RESPONSEPERIOD

REL

EASE

REC

ALL

NO

RM

AL

OPE

RA

TIO

NS

DEMAND RESPONSE EVENT

AD

VAN

CE

NO

TIFI

CA

TIO

N(S

)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Market Participation Data (Monthly)bull Total Offer and Self Scheduled Hours

bull ScheduledCleared Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Offered Scheduled Demand Reduction (MW)

bull Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

DADS Annual Reporting Cycle

Phase I amp II DADS Data Collection amp Deliverable Schedule

Date Action

April 1st ndash September 30th Summer DADS reporting period

December 15th Summer DADS data due to NERC

October 1st ndash March 31st Winter DADS reporting period

June 15th Winter DADS data due to NERC

NERC has restructured the reporting timeframe and deliverable dates bullSemi-annual reporting will be implemented (versus the previously structured quarterly reports)

The reporting periods are designed around summer and winter seasonsmdashthe summer reporting period will occur from April 1st to September 30th and the winter reporting period will occur from October 1st to March 31st Data will be due to NERC approximately 2 12 months after the close of the reporting period

DADS Annual Reporting CycleDA

DS R

espo

nsib

le En

tities

De

man

d Re

spon

se D

ata T

ask F

orce

Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct NovMay Dec

Reporting Period for Q1

Reporting Period for Q2

Reporting Period for Q3

Reporting Period for Q4

Data Gathering for Q1

Data Gathering for Q2

Data Gathering for Q3

Q1DADS data

due

Q2DADS data

due

Q3DADS data

due

Q1Summary

ReportPublished

Quarter 1 (Q1) Quarter 2 (Q2) Quarter 3 (Q3) Quarter 4 (Q4)

Q2SummaryReport

Published

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Q1 DataProcessing

Q2 DataProcessing

Q3 DataProcessing

DADS

Res

pons

ible

Entit

ies

Dem

and

Resp

onse

Dat

a Tas

k For

ce

Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct NovMay Dec

Reporting Period for Q1

Reporting Period for Q2

Reporting Period for Q3

Reporting Period for Q4

Data Gathering for Q1

Data Gathering for Q2

Data Gathering for Q3

Q1DADS data

due

Q2DADS data

due

Q3DADS data

due

Q1Summary

ReportPublished

Quarter 1 (Q1) Quarter 2 (Q2) Quarter 3 (Q3) Quarter 4 (Q4)

Q2SummaryReport

Published

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Q1 DataProcessing

Q2 DataProcessing

Q3 DataProcessing

DADS

Res

pons

ible

Ent

ities

De

man

d Res

pons

e Dat

a Tas

k For

ce

April May Jun July Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan FebAug Mar

Reporting Period for Summer

Reporting Period for Winter

Data Gathering Summer

SummerDADS datadue

SummerReport

Published

Summer Winter

Receive Summer

DADS data

Receive Winter

DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Summer DataProcessing

Winter DataProcessing

WinterDADS datadue

Data Gathering Winter

WinterReport

Published

Responsible Reporting Entities

Responsible Entities will be required to maintain Demand Response data in DADS A Responsible Entity is defined as a NERC Registered Entity that either dispatches a Demand Response Resource andor administers a Demand Response Program product or service Responsible Entities for DADS data submittals are limited to

NERC Responsible Entities for DADS DataFunction Name Responsible Entity

Balancing Balancing AuthorityDistribution Distribution ProviderLoad-Serving Load-Serving EntityPurchasing-Selling Purchasing-Selling Entity

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull External Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs for different Reporting Entities

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

LSE

bullReports 10 MW Capacity Program

Submitted Data

BA - 50 MW

LSE -10 MW

Total Enrolled DR

60 MW

bull5 MW are used in BA program

Total Enrolled DR

55 MW

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull Internal Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs within the same entity

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

bullReports 40 MW Energy Program

Submitted Data

50 MW Capacity

40 MW Energy

Total Enrolled DR

90 MW

Total Enrolled DR

50 MW

Energy Program Participants are also

enrolled in the Capacity Program

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Program Criteria

DADS requires data for all Demand Response Programs currently in effect However Responsible Entities are only required to register and submit data on Demand Response Programs if

1) The Demand Response Program has been commercially in-service for more than 12 months or

2) The Demand Response Program has enrolled 10 MW or more of combined Demand Response Resources

Serves to not discourage small scale Demand Response deployment and to encourage the development of pilot Demand Response

Overview of Data to be Collected

Program Registration and Enrollment Data

bull Identification of the Demand Response Program

bull Zone Information

bull Product Type

bull Energy Capacity Reserve Regulation

bull Service Type (ie Capacity ndash Direct Load Control)

bull Program StartEnd Dates

bull RegisteredEnrolled Number of Resources

bull RegisteredEnrolled Capacity

bull Program Relationships

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Reliability Event Data bull Advance Notification DateTimebull Deployment DateTimebull Reduction Deadlinebull ReleaseRecall DateTimebull Committed MW

ContractedRegistered

bull Number of Committed Resourcesbull Dispatched MWbull Hourly Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)bull Hourly Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

DEPLOYMENT PERIOD

RECOVERYPERIOD

RED

UC

TIO

N D

EAD

LIN

E

DEP

LOYM

ENT

RAMPPERIOD

SUSTAINED RESPONSEPERIOD

REL

EASE

REC

ALL

NO

RM

AL

OPE

RA

TIO

NS

DEMAND RESPONSE EVENT

AD

VAN

CE

NO

TIFI

CA

TIO

N(S

)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Market Participation Data (Monthly)bull Total Offer and Self Scheduled Hours

bull ScheduledCleared Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Offered Scheduled Demand Reduction (MW)

bull Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

DADS Annual Reporting CycleDA

DS R

espo

nsib

le En

tities

De

man

d Re

spon

se D

ata T

ask F

orce

Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct NovMay Dec

Reporting Period for Q1

Reporting Period for Q2

Reporting Period for Q3

Reporting Period for Q4

Data Gathering for Q1

Data Gathering for Q2

Data Gathering for Q3

Q1DADS data

due

Q2DADS data

due

Q3DADS data

due

Q1Summary

ReportPublished

Quarter 1 (Q1) Quarter 2 (Q2) Quarter 3 (Q3) Quarter 4 (Q4)

Q2SummaryReport

Published

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Q1 DataProcessing

Q2 DataProcessing

Q3 DataProcessing

DADS

Res

pons

ible

Entit

ies

Dem

and

Resp

onse

Dat

a Tas

k For

ce

Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct NovMay Dec

Reporting Period for Q1

Reporting Period for Q2

Reporting Period for Q3

Reporting Period for Q4

Data Gathering for Q1

Data Gathering for Q2

Data Gathering for Q3

Q1DADS data

due

Q2DADS data

due

Q3DADS data

due

Q1Summary

ReportPublished

Quarter 1 (Q1) Quarter 2 (Q2) Quarter 3 (Q3) Quarter 4 (Q4)

Q2SummaryReport

Published

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

Receive Q1DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Q1 DataProcessing

Q2 DataProcessing

Q3 DataProcessing

DADS

Res

pons

ible

Ent

ities

De

man

d Res

pons

e Dat

a Tas

k For

ce

April May Jun July Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan FebAug Mar

Reporting Period for Summer

Reporting Period for Winter

Data Gathering Summer

SummerDADS datadue

SummerReport

Published

Summer Winter

Receive Summer

DADS data

Receive Winter

DADS data

DADS Annual Reporting Schedule

Summer DataProcessing

Winter DataProcessing

WinterDADS datadue

Data Gathering Winter

WinterReport

Published

Responsible Reporting Entities

Responsible Entities will be required to maintain Demand Response data in DADS A Responsible Entity is defined as a NERC Registered Entity that either dispatches a Demand Response Resource andor administers a Demand Response Program product or service Responsible Entities for DADS data submittals are limited to

NERC Responsible Entities for DADS DataFunction Name Responsible Entity

Balancing Balancing AuthorityDistribution Distribution ProviderLoad-Serving Load-Serving EntityPurchasing-Selling Purchasing-Selling Entity

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull External Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs for different Reporting Entities

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

LSE

bullReports 10 MW Capacity Program

Submitted Data

BA - 50 MW

LSE -10 MW

Total Enrolled DR

60 MW

bull5 MW are used in BA program

Total Enrolled DR

55 MW

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull Internal Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs within the same entity

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

bullReports 40 MW Energy Program

Submitted Data

50 MW Capacity

40 MW Energy

Total Enrolled DR

90 MW

Total Enrolled DR

50 MW

Energy Program Participants are also

enrolled in the Capacity Program

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Program Criteria

DADS requires data for all Demand Response Programs currently in effect However Responsible Entities are only required to register and submit data on Demand Response Programs if

1) The Demand Response Program has been commercially in-service for more than 12 months or

2) The Demand Response Program has enrolled 10 MW or more of combined Demand Response Resources

Serves to not discourage small scale Demand Response deployment and to encourage the development of pilot Demand Response

Overview of Data to be Collected

Program Registration and Enrollment Data

bull Identification of the Demand Response Program

bull Zone Information

bull Product Type

bull Energy Capacity Reserve Regulation

bull Service Type (ie Capacity ndash Direct Load Control)

bull Program StartEnd Dates

bull RegisteredEnrolled Number of Resources

bull RegisteredEnrolled Capacity

bull Program Relationships

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Reliability Event Data bull Advance Notification DateTimebull Deployment DateTimebull Reduction Deadlinebull ReleaseRecall DateTimebull Committed MW

ContractedRegistered

bull Number of Committed Resourcesbull Dispatched MWbull Hourly Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)bull Hourly Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

DEPLOYMENT PERIOD

RECOVERYPERIOD

RED

UC

TIO

N D

EAD

LIN

E

DEP

LOYM

ENT

RAMPPERIOD

SUSTAINED RESPONSEPERIOD

REL

EASE

REC

ALL

NO

RM

AL

OPE

RA

TIO

NS

DEMAND RESPONSE EVENT

AD

VAN

CE

NO

TIFI

CA

TIO

N(S

)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Market Participation Data (Monthly)bull Total Offer and Self Scheduled Hours

bull ScheduledCleared Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Offered Scheduled Demand Reduction (MW)

bull Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

Responsible Reporting Entities

Responsible Entities will be required to maintain Demand Response data in DADS A Responsible Entity is defined as a NERC Registered Entity that either dispatches a Demand Response Resource andor administers a Demand Response Program product or service Responsible Entities for DADS data submittals are limited to

NERC Responsible Entities for DADS DataFunction Name Responsible Entity

Balancing Balancing AuthorityDistribution Distribution ProviderLoad-Serving Load-Serving EntityPurchasing-Selling Purchasing-Selling Entity

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull External Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs for different Reporting Entities

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

LSE

bullReports 10 MW Capacity Program

Submitted Data

BA - 50 MW

LSE -10 MW

Total Enrolled DR

60 MW

bull5 MW are used in BA program

Total Enrolled DR

55 MW

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull Internal Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs within the same entity

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

bullReports 40 MW Energy Program

Submitted Data

50 MW Capacity

40 MW Energy

Total Enrolled DR

90 MW

Total Enrolled DR

50 MW

Energy Program Participants are also

enrolled in the Capacity Program

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Program Criteria

DADS requires data for all Demand Response Programs currently in effect However Responsible Entities are only required to register and submit data on Demand Response Programs if

1) The Demand Response Program has been commercially in-service for more than 12 months or

2) The Demand Response Program has enrolled 10 MW or more of combined Demand Response Resources

Serves to not discourage small scale Demand Response deployment and to encourage the development of pilot Demand Response

Overview of Data to be Collected

Program Registration and Enrollment Data

bull Identification of the Demand Response Program

bull Zone Information

bull Product Type

bull Energy Capacity Reserve Regulation

bull Service Type (ie Capacity ndash Direct Load Control)

bull Program StartEnd Dates

bull RegisteredEnrolled Number of Resources

bull RegisteredEnrolled Capacity

bull Program Relationships

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Reliability Event Data bull Advance Notification DateTimebull Deployment DateTimebull Reduction Deadlinebull ReleaseRecall DateTimebull Committed MW

ContractedRegistered

bull Number of Committed Resourcesbull Dispatched MWbull Hourly Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)bull Hourly Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

DEPLOYMENT PERIOD

RECOVERYPERIOD

RED

UC

TIO

N D

EAD

LIN

E

DEP

LOYM

ENT

RAMPPERIOD

SUSTAINED RESPONSEPERIOD

REL

EASE

REC

ALL

NO

RM

AL

OPE

RA

TIO

NS

DEMAND RESPONSE EVENT

AD

VAN

CE

NO

TIFI

CA

TIO

N(S

)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Market Participation Data (Monthly)bull Total Offer and Self Scheduled Hours

bull ScheduledCleared Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Offered Scheduled Demand Reduction (MW)

bull Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull External Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs for different Reporting Entities

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

LSE

bullReports 10 MW Capacity Program

Submitted Data

BA - 50 MW

LSE -10 MW

Total Enrolled DR

60 MW

bull5 MW are used in BA program

Total Enrolled DR

55 MW

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull Internal Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs within the same entity

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

bullReports 40 MW Energy Program

Submitted Data

50 MW Capacity

40 MW Energy

Total Enrolled DR

90 MW

Total Enrolled DR

50 MW

Energy Program Participants are also

enrolled in the Capacity Program

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Program Criteria

DADS requires data for all Demand Response Programs currently in effect However Responsible Entities are only required to register and submit data on Demand Response Programs if

1) The Demand Response Program has been commercially in-service for more than 12 months or

2) The Demand Response Program has enrolled 10 MW or more of combined Demand Response Resources

Serves to not discourage small scale Demand Response deployment and to encourage the development of pilot Demand Response

Overview of Data to be Collected

Program Registration and Enrollment Data

bull Identification of the Demand Response Program

bull Zone Information

bull Product Type

bull Energy Capacity Reserve Regulation

bull Service Type (ie Capacity ndash Direct Load Control)

bull Program StartEnd Dates

bull RegisteredEnrolled Number of Resources

bull RegisteredEnrolled Capacity

bull Program Relationships

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Reliability Event Data bull Advance Notification DateTimebull Deployment DateTimebull Reduction Deadlinebull ReleaseRecall DateTimebull Committed MW

ContractedRegistered

bull Number of Committed Resourcesbull Dispatched MWbull Hourly Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)bull Hourly Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

DEPLOYMENT PERIOD

RECOVERYPERIOD

RED

UC

TIO

N D

EAD

LIN

E

DEP

LOYM

ENT

RAMPPERIOD

SUSTAINED RESPONSEPERIOD

REL

EASE

REC

ALL

NO

RM

AL

OPE

RA

TIO

NS

DEMAND RESPONSE EVENT

AD

VAN

CE

NO

TIFI

CA

TIO

N(S

)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Market Participation Data (Monthly)bull Total Offer and Self Scheduled Hours

bull ScheduledCleared Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Offered Scheduled Demand Reduction (MW)

bull Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

Why the ldquoDuplicativerdquo Reporting

bull Internal Relationships

bull A single Demand Response resource can be used in multiple programs within the same entity

Balancing Authority

bullReports 50 MW Capacity Program

bullReports 40 MW Energy Program

Submitted Data

50 MW Capacity

40 MW Energy

Total Enrolled DR

90 MW

Total Enrolled DR

50 MW

Energy Program Participants are also

enrolled in the Capacity Program

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Program Criteria

DADS requires data for all Demand Response Programs currently in effect However Responsible Entities are only required to register and submit data on Demand Response Programs if

1) The Demand Response Program has been commercially in-service for more than 12 months or

2) The Demand Response Program has enrolled 10 MW or more of combined Demand Response Resources

Serves to not discourage small scale Demand Response deployment and to encourage the development of pilot Demand Response

Overview of Data to be Collected

Program Registration and Enrollment Data

bull Identification of the Demand Response Program

bull Zone Information

bull Product Type

bull Energy Capacity Reserve Regulation

bull Service Type (ie Capacity ndash Direct Load Control)

bull Program StartEnd Dates

bull RegisteredEnrolled Number of Resources

bull RegisteredEnrolled Capacity

bull Program Relationships

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Reliability Event Data bull Advance Notification DateTimebull Deployment DateTimebull Reduction Deadlinebull ReleaseRecall DateTimebull Committed MW

ContractedRegistered

bull Number of Committed Resourcesbull Dispatched MWbull Hourly Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)bull Hourly Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

DEPLOYMENT PERIOD

RECOVERYPERIOD

RED

UC

TIO

N D

EAD

LIN

E

DEP

LOYM

ENT

RAMPPERIOD

SUSTAINED RESPONSEPERIOD

REL

EASE

REC

ALL

NO

RM

AL

OPE

RA

TIO

NS

DEMAND RESPONSE EVENT

AD

VAN

CE

NO

TIFI

CA

TIO

N(S

)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Market Participation Data (Monthly)bull Total Offer and Self Scheduled Hours

bull ScheduledCleared Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Offered Scheduled Demand Reduction (MW)

bull Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Program Criteria

DADS requires data for all Demand Response Programs currently in effect However Responsible Entities are only required to register and submit data on Demand Response Programs if

1) The Demand Response Program has been commercially in-service for more than 12 months or

2) The Demand Response Program has enrolled 10 MW or more of combined Demand Response Resources

Serves to not discourage small scale Demand Response deployment and to encourage the development of pilot Demand Response

Overview of Data to be Collected

Program Registration and Enrollment Data

bull Identification of the Demand Response Program

bull Zone Information

bull Product Type

bull Energy Capacity Reserve Regulation

bull Service Type (ie Capacity ndash Direct Load Control)

bull Program StartEnd Dates

bull RegisteredEnrolled Number of Resources

bull RegisteredEnrolled Capacity

bull Program Relationships

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Reliability Event Data bull Advance Notification DateTimebull Deployment DateTimebull Reduction Deadlinebull ReleaseRecall DateTimebull Committed MW

ContractedRegistered

bull Number of Committed Resourcesbull Dispatched MWbull Hourly Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)bull Hourly Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

DEPLOYMENT PERIOD

RECOVERYPERIOD

RED

UC

TIO

N D

EAD

LIN

E

DEP

LOYM

ENT

RAMPPERIOD

SUSTAINED RESPONSEPERIOD

REL

EASE

REC

ALL

NO

RM

AL

OPE

RA

TIO

NS

DEMAND RESPONSE EVENT

AD

VAN

CE

NO

TIFI

CA

TIO

N(S

)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Market Participation Data (Monthly)bull Total Offer and Self Scheduled Hours

bull ScheduledCleared Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Offered Scheduled Demand Reduction (MW)

bull Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

Overview of Data to be Collected

Program Registration and Enrollment Data

bull Identification of the Demand Response Program

bull Zone Information

bull Product Type

bull Energy Capacity Reserve Regulation

bull Service Type (ie Capacity ndash Direct Load Control)

bull Program StartEnd Dates

bull RegisteredEnrolled Number of Resources

bull RegisteredEnrolled Capacity

bull Program Relationships

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Demand-Side Management

DemandResponse

EnergyEfficiency

Dispatchable Non-Dispatchable

Reliability Economic

Capacity RegulationEnergy -

VoluntaryReserves

Direct Control LoadManagement

Interruptible Load

Critical Peak Pricing(CPP) with control

Load as a Capacity Resource

EmergencySpinning Reserves

Non-Spinning Reserves

Energy -Price

Demand Biddingamp Buy -Back

Time-Sensitive Pricing

Time-of-Use (TOU)

Critical Peak Pricing (CPP)

Real -Time Pricing(RTP)

System Peak ResponseTransmission Tariff

(4CP Response)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Reliability Event Data bull Advance Notification DateTimebull Deployment DateTimebull Reduction Deadlinebull ReleaseRecall DateTimebull Committed MW

ContractedRegistered

bull Number of Committed Resourcesbull Dispatched MWbull Hourly Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)bull Hourly Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

DEPLOYMENT PERIOD

RECOVERYPERIOD

RED

UC

TIO

N D

EAD

LIN

E

DEP

LOYM

ENT

RAMPPERIOD

SUSTAINED RESPONSEPERIOD

REL

EASE

REC

ALL

NO

RM

AL

OPE

RA

TIO

NS

DEMAND RESPONSE EVENT

AD

VAN

CE

NO

TIFI

CA

TIO

N(S

)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Market Participation Data (Monthly)bull Total Offer and Self Scheduled Hours

bull ScheduledCleared Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Offered Scheduled Demand Reduction (MW)

bull Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

Overview of Data to be Collected

Demand Response Reliability Event Data bull Advance Notification DateTimebull Deployment DateTimebull Reduction Deadlinebull ReleaseRecall DateTimebull Committed MW

ContractedRegistered

bull Number of Committed Resourcesbull Dispatched MWbull Hourly Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)bull Hourly Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

DEPLOYMENT PERIOD

RECOVERYPERIOD

RED

UC

TIO

N D

EAD

LIN

E

DEP

LOYM

ENT

RAMPPERIOD

SUSTAINED RESPONSEPERIOD

REL

EASE

REC

ALL

NO

RM

AL

OPE

RA

TIO

NS

DEMAND RESPONSE EVENT

AD

VAN

CE

NO

TIFI

CA

TIO

N(S

)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Market Participation Data (Monthly)bull Total Offer and Self Scheduled Hours

bull ScheduledCleared Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Offered Scheduled Demand Reduction (MW)

bull Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

Overview of Data to be Collected

Market Participation Data (Monthly)bull Total Offer and Self Scheduled Hours

bull ScheduledCleared Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Estimated Realized Energy Reduction (MWh)

bull Offered Scheduled Demand Reduction (MW)

bull Estimated Realized Demand Reduction (MW)

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

Overview of Data to be Collected

Ancillary Services Product Data (Monthly) bull Registered amp Qualified Resources (MW)

bull Total Offered and self-Scheduled Hours

bull Total Committed Hours

bull Offered or Self Scheduled Capacity (MW)

bull Total Committed Capacity (MW x Hours)

bull Average Hourly Committed Capacity (MW)

bull Deployment Hours (Regulation Only)

bull Total Deployments

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

Overview of Data to be Collected

Confidentiality of Submitted Databull Any data submitted that is classified as confidential shall be managed in

accordance with NERCrsquos treatment of confidential information as described in Section 1500 of the Rules of Procedure Confidential data will not be accessible by others except the Responsible Entity that submitted that data and NERC staff who will be responsible for its analysis however aggregate data may be used for metrics and presented to third parties as necessary or appropriate

bull DADS data may be classified as Confidential Business and Market Information Critical Energy Infrastructure Information Non-Confidential

The following data will be classified as confidential when deemed so by a Responsible Entity

bull Enrollment Data (Number of Registered Resources and Registered MWs)bull All Reliability EventMarket ParticipationAncillary Product Data

DADS is intended to serve as a valuable tool not only for reliability and resource adequacy analysis but for research outside of NERC

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

Other Important Notes

All data is aggregatedbull No single demand resource identified

NERC is working on developing a procedure to minimize reporting burdenbull If the entity does not have qualifying demand response programsbull If the entityrsquos entire portfolio of resources are included in another

entityrsquos program

Phase I voluntary submission dates are flexible bull The goal is to learn and understand the reporting procedure

which programs shouldshould not be reported and develop enhancements for Phase II

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

DADS Status amp Next Steps

Statusbull PHASE I in progress (Voluntary Data)

bull Letter to industry participants confirming restructured data submission requirements

Next Steps bull Coordinate mandatory requirements

bull First mandatory data submittal aimed for December 15th 2011

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm

Question amp Answer

Contact

John MouraTechnical Analyst Reliability Assessments amp Performance Analysisjohnmouranercnet6095247047

ReferencesDADS Website httpwwwnerccompagephpcid=4|357

DRDTF Website httpwwwnerccomfilezdrdtfhtml

DADS Phase I Technical Conference httpwwwnerccomfilezDADSindexhtm