41
Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 1 / 41

Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    8

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Dieudonneacute module theory part IIthe classical theory

Alan Koch

Agnes Scott College

May 24 2016

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 1 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 2 41

Pick a prime p gt 2

Recall it is unreasonable to think that every finite abelian Hopf algebraH of p-power rank over an Fp-algebra R can be classified withDieudonneacute modules

Last time we focused on Hopf algebras with a nice coalgebrastructure

This time we will make assumptions on both R and H

The assumptions on R are very restrictive and the ones on H aremore palatable

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 3 41

The situation du jour (et demain)

Throughout this talk let R = k be a perfect field of characterisic p

Any finite k -Hopf algebra H can be written as

H sim= Hr r otimes Hr ℓ otimes Hℓr otimes Hℓℓ

whereHr r and Hlowast

r r are both reduced k -algebrasHr ℓ is a reduced and Hlowast

r ℓ is a local k -algebraHℓr is a local and Hlowast

r ℓ is a reduced k -algebraHℓℓ and Hlowast

ℓℓ are both local k -algebras

If p ∤ dimk H then H = Hr r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 4 41

H sim= Hr r otimes Hr ℓ otimes Hℓr otimes Hℓℓ

Reduced k -Hopf algebras are ldquoclassified they correspond to finitegroups upon which Gal(kk) acts continuously

Then Hr r and Hr ℓ are classified and by duality so is Hℓr

Thus the most mysterious Hopf algebras are the ones of the form Hℓℓ

We will call these ldquolocal-localrdquo and assume that all Hopf algebras in thistalk are finite abelian and local-local over the perfect field k

If H is local-local then a result of Waterhouse is that H is a ldquotruncatedpolynomial algebrardquo ie

H sim= k [t1 tr ](tpn1

1 tpnr

r )

so the algebra structure isnrsquot terrible

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 5 41

Suggested readings

M Demazure and P Gabriel Groupes Algeacutebriques - Tome 1Good news partially translated into English as Introduction toAlgebraic Geometry and Algebraic GroupsBad news not the part you need (chapter 5)A Grothendieck Groupes de Barsotti-Tate et Cristaux deDieudonneacuteExplicit connection between Dieudonneacute modules and HopfalgebrasT Oda The first de Rham cohomology group and Dieudonneacutemodules The section on Dieudonneacute modules gave me my firstexplicit examplesR Pink Finite group schemeshttpspeoplemathethzch pinkftpFGSCompleteNotespdfGood intro to Dieudonneacute modules with proofs (group schemepoint of view)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 6 41

The gist

What is a k -Hopf algebra

It is a k -algebra and a k -coalgebra with compatible structures

A Dieudonneacute module is a single module (over a ring TBD) whichencodes both structures

In Mondayrsquos talk the coalgebra structure was assumed and thealgebra structure was encoded by the action of F on Dlowast(H)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 7 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 41

Witt polynomials

For each n isin Zge0 define Φn isin Z[Z0 Zn] by

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Note Φn depends on the choice of prime p which we assume to beldquoourrdquo p

Define polynomials SnPn isin Z[X0 XnY0 Yn] implicitly by

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Fact Yes the coefficients are all integers

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 41

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Example (low hanging fruit)

Φ0(Z0) = Z0

S0(X0Y0) = X0 + Y0

P0(X0Y0) = X0Y0

Exercise 1 Prove

S1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X1 + Y1 minus1p

pminus1983142

i=1

983072pi

983073X i

0Y pminusi0

P1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X p0 Y1 + X p

1 Y0 + pX1Y1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 41

Let W (Z) = (w0w1w2 ) wi isin Z for all i Define addition andmultiplication on W (Z) by

(w0w1 ) +W (x0 x1 ) = (S0(w0 x0)S1((w0w1) (x0 x1)) )

(w0w1 ) middotW (x0 x1 ) = (P0(w0 x0)P1((w0 x1) (w0 x1)) )

These operations make W (Z) into a commutative ring

Actually W (minus) is a Z-ring scheme meaning that for all Z-algebras AW (A) is a ring

In particular set W = W (k) and call this the ring of Witt vectors withcoefficients in k (or ldquoWitt vectorsrdquo for short)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 41

Properties of Witt vectors Show each of the following

Exercise 2 W is a ring of characteristic zero

Exercise 3 W is an integral domain

Exercise 4 (1 0 0 ) is the multiplicative identity of W

Exercise 5 W (Fp) sim= Zp

Exercise 6 W (Fpn) is the unramified extension of Zp of degree n

Exercise 7 The element (0 1 0 0 ) isin W acts as mult by p

Exercise 8 pnW is an ideal of W

Exercise 9 Let Wn = (w0w1 wnminus1) Then Wn is a ring withoperations induced from W

Exercise 10 WpnW sim= Wn In particular W0sim= k

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 41

Of particular importance will be two operators F V on W given by

F (w0w1w2 ) = (wp0 w

p1 w

p2 )

V (w0w1w2 ) = (0w0w1 )

F is called the Frobenius and V is called the VerschiebungShow each of the following

Exercise 11 FV = VF = p (multiplication by p)

Exercise 12 F V both act freely on W only F acts transitively

Exercise 13 If w isin pnW then Fw Vw isin pnW Thus F and V makesense on Wn as well

Exercise 14 Wn is annihilated by V n+1

Exercise 15 Any w = (w0w1w2 ) isin W decomposes as

(w0w1w2 ) =infin983142

i=0

pi(wpminusi

i 0 0 )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 41

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 2: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 2 41

Pick a prime p gt 2

Recall it is unreasonable to think that every finite abelian Hopf algebraH of p-power rank over an Fp-algebra R can be classified withDieudonneacute modules

Last time we focused on Hopf algebras with a nice coalgebrastructure

This time we will make assumptions on both R and H

The assumptions on R are very restrictive and the ones on H aremore palatable

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 3 41

The situation du jour (et demain)

Throughout this talk let R = k be a perfect field of characterisic p

Any finite k -Hopf algebra H can be written as

H sim= Hr r otimes Hr ℓ otimes Hℓr otimes Hℓℓ

whereHr r and Hlowast

r r are both reduced k -algebrasHr ℓ is a reduced and Hlowast

r ℓ is a local k -algebraHℓr is a local and Hlowast

r ℓ is a reduced k -algebraHℓℓ and Hlowast

ℓℓ are both local k -algebras

If p ∤ dimk H then H = Hr r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 4 41

H sim= Hr r otimes Hr ℓ otimes Hℓr otimes Hℓℓ

Reduced k -Hopf algebras are ldquoclassified they correspond to finitegroups upon which Gal(kk) acts continuously

Then Hr r and Hr ℓ are classified and by duality so is Hℓr

Thus the most mysterious Hopf algebras are the ones of the form Hℓℓ

We will call these ldquolocal-localrdquo and assume that all Hopf algebras in thistalk are finite abelian and local-local over the perfect field k

If H is local-local then a result of Waterhouse is that H is a ldquotruncatedpolynomial algebrardquo ie

H sim= k [t1 tr ](tpn1

1 tpnr

r )

so the algebra structure isnrsquot terrible

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 5 41

Suggested readings

M Demazure and P Gabriel Groupes Algeacutebriques - Tome 1Good news partially translated into English as Introduction toAlgebraic Geometry and Algebraic GroupsBad news not the part you need (chapter 5)A Grothendieck Groupes de Barsotti-Tate et Cristaux deDieudonneacuteExplicit connection between Dieudonneacute modules and HopfalgebrasT Oda The first de Rham cohomology group and Dieudonneacutemodules The section on Dieudonneacute modules gave me my firstexplicit examplesR Pink Finite group schemeshttpspeoplemathethzch pinkftpFGSCompleteNotespdfGood intro to Dieudonneacute modules with proofs (group schemepoint of view)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 6 41

The gist

What is a k -Hopf algebra

It is a k -algebra and a k -coalgebra with compatible structures

A Dieudonneacute module is a single module (over a ring TBD) whichencodes both structures

In Mondayrsquos talk the coalgebra structure was assumed and thealgebra structure was encoded by the action of F on Dlowast(H)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 7 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 41

Witt polynomials

For each n isin Zge0 define Φn isin Z[Z0 Zn] by

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Note Φn depends on the choice of prime p which we assume to beldquoourrdquo p

Define polynomials SnPn isin Z[X0 XnY0 Yn] implicitly by

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Fact Yes the coefficients are all integers

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 41

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Example (low hanging fruit)

Φ0(Z0) = Z0

S0(X0Y0) = X0 + Y0

P0(X0Y0) = X0Y0

Exercise 1 Prove

S1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X1 + Y1 minus1p

pminus1983142

i=1

983072pi

983073X i

0Y pminusi0

P1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X p0 Y1 + X p

1 Y0 + pX1Y1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 41

Let W (Z) = (w0w1w2 ) wi isin Z for all i Define addition andmultiplication on W (Z) by

(w0w1 ) +W (x0 x1 ) = (S0(w0 x0)S1((w0w1) (x0 x1)) )

(w0w1 ) middotW (x0 x1 ) = (P0(w0 x0)P1((w0 x1) (w0 x1)) )

These operations make W (Z) into a commutative ring

Actually W (minus) is a Z-ring scheme meaning that for all Z-algebras AW (A) is a ring

In particular set W = W (k) and call this the ring of Witt vectors withcoefficients in k (or ldquoWitt vectorsrdquo for short)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 41

Properties of Witt vectors Show each of the following

Exercise 2 W is a ring of characteristic zero

Exercise 3 W is an integral domain

Exercise 4 (1 0 0 ) is the multiplicative identity of W

Exercise 5 W (Fp) sim= Zp

Exercise 6 W (Fpn) is the unramified extension of Zp of degree n

Exercise 7 The element (0 1 0 0 ) isin W acts as mult by p

Exercise 8 pnW is an ideal of W

Exercise 9 Let Wn = (w0w1 wnminus1) Then Wn is a ring withoperations induced from W

Exercise 10 WpnW sim= Wn In particular W0sim= k

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 41

Of particular importance will be two operators F V on W given by

F (w0w1w2 ) = (wp0 w

p1 w

p2 )

V (w0w1w2 ) = (0w0w1 )

F is called the Frobenius and V is called the VerschiebungShow each of the following

Exercise 11 FV = VF = p (multiplication by p)

Exercise 12 F V both act freely on W only F acts transitively

Exercise 13 If w isin pnW then Fw Vw isin pnW Thus F and V makesense on Wn as well

Exercise 14 Wn is annihilated by V n+1

Exercise 15 Any w = (w0w1w2 ) isin W decomposes as

(w0w1w2 ) =infin983142

i=0

pi(wpminusi

i 0 0 )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 41

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 3: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Pick a prime p gt 2

Recall it is unreasonable to think that every finite abelian Hopf algebraH of p-power rank over an Fp-algebra R can be classified withDieudonneacute modules

Last time we focused on Hopf algebras with a nice coalgebrastructure

This time we will make assumptions on both R and H

The assumptions on R are very restrictive and the ones on H aremore palatable

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 3 41

The situation du jour (et demain)

Throughout this talk let R = k be a perfect field of characterisic p

Any finite k -Hopf algebra H can be written as

H sim= Hr r otimes Hr ℓ otimes Hℓr otimes Hℓℓ

whereHr r and Hlowast

r r are both reduced k -algebrasHr ℓ is a reduced and Hlowast

r ℓ is a local k -algebraHℓr is a local and Hlowast

r ℓ is a reduced k -algebraHℓℓ and Hlowast

ℓℓ are both local k -algebras

If p ∤ dimk H then H = Hr r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 4 41

H sim= Hr r otimes Hr ℓ otimes Hℓr otimes Hℓℓ

Reduced k -Hopf algebras are ldquoclassified they correspond to finitegroups upon which Gal(kk) acts continuously

Then Hr r and Hr ℓ are classified and by duality so is Hℓr

Thus the most mysterious Hopf algebras are the ones of the form Hℓℓ

We will call these ldquolocal-localrdquo and assume that all Hopf algebras in thistalk are finite abelian and local-local over the perfect field k

If H is local-local then a result of Waterhouse is that H is a ldquotruncatedpolynomial algebrardquo ie

H sim= k [t1 tr ](tpn1

1 tpnr

r )

so the algebra structure isnrsquot terrible

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 5 41

Suggested readings

M Demazure and P Gabriel Groupes Algeacutebriques - Tome 1Good news partially translated into English as Introduction toAlgebraic Geometry and Algebraic GroupsBad news not the part you need (chapter 5)A Grothendieck Groupes de Barsotti-Tate et Cristaux deDieudonneacuteExplicit connection between Dieudonneacute modules and HopfalgebrasT Oda The first de Rham cohomology group and Dieudonneacutemodules The section on Dieudonneacute modules gave me my firstexplicit examplesR Pink Finite group schemeshttpspeoplemathethzch pinkftpFGSCompleteNotespdfGood intro to Dieudonneacute modules with proofs (group schemepoint of view)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 6 41

The gist

What is a k -Hopf algebra

It is a k -algebra and a k -coalgebra with compatible structures

A Dieudonneacute module is a single module (over a ring TBD) whichencodes both structures

In Mondayrsquos talk the coalgebra structure was assumed and thealgebra structure was encoded by the action of F on Dlowast(H)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 7 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 41

Witt polynomials

For each n isin Zge0 define Φn isin Z[Z0 Zn] by

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Note Φn depends on the choice of prime p which we assume to beldquoourrdquo p

Define polynomials SnPn isin Z[X0 XnY0 Yn] implicitly by

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Fact Yes the coefficients are all integers

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 41

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Example (low hanging fruit)

Φ0(Z0) = Z0

S0(X0Y0) = X0 + Y0

P0(X0Y0) = X0Y0

Exercise 1 Prove

S1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X1 + Y1 minus1p

pminus1983142

i=1

983072pi

983073X i

0Y pminusi0

P1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X p0 Y1 + X p

1 Y0 + pX1Y1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 41

Let W (Z) = (w0w1w2 ) wi isin Z for all i Define addition andmultiplication on W (Z) by

(w0w1 ) +W (x0 x1 ) = (S0(w0 x0)S1((w0w1) (x0 x1)) )

(w0w1 ) middotW (x0 x1 ) = (P0(w0 x0)P1((w0 x1) (w0 x1)) )

These operations make W (Z) into a commutative ring

Actually W (minus) is a Z-ring scheme meaning that for all Z-algebras AW (A) is a ring

In particular set W = W (k) and call this the ring of Witt vectors withcoefficients in k (or ldquoWitt vectorsrdquo for short)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 41

Properties of Witt vectors Show each of the following

Exercise 2 W is a ring of characteristic zero

Exercise 3 W is an integral domain

Exercise 4 (1 0 0 ) is the multiplicative identity of W

Exercise 5 W (Fp) sim= Zp

Exercise 6 W (Fpn) is the unramified extension of Zp of degree n

Exercise 7 The element (0 1 0 0 ) isin W acts as mult by p

Exercise 8 pnW is an ideal of W

Exercise 9 Let Wn = (w0w1 wnminus1) Then Wn is a ring withoperations induced from W

Exercise 10 WpnW sim= Wn In particular W0sim= k

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 41

Of particular importance will be two operators F V on W given by

F (w0w1w2 ) = (wp0 w

p1 w

p2 )

V (w0w1w2 ) = (0w0w1 )

F is called the Frobenius and V is called the VerschiebungShow each of the following

Exercise 11 FV = VF = p (multiplication by p)

Exercise 12 F V both act freely on W only F acts transitively

Exercise 13 If w isin pnW then Fw Vw isin pnW Thus F and V makesense on Wn as well

Exercise 14 Wn is annihilated by V n+1

Exercise 15 Any w = (w0w1w2 ) isin W decomposes as

(w0w1w2 ) =infin983142

i=0

pi(wpminusi

i 0 0 )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 41

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 4: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

The situation du jour (et demain)

Throughout this talk let R = k be a perfect field of characterisic p

Any finite k -Hopf algebra H can be written as

H sim= Hr r otimes Hr ℓ otimes Hℓr otimes Hℓℓ

whereHr r and Hlowast

r r are both reduced k -algebrasHr ℓ is a reduced and Hlowast

r ℓ is a local k -algebraHℓr is a local and Hlowast

r ℓ is a reduced k -algebraHℓℓ and Hlowast

ℓℓ are both local k -algebras

If p ∤ dimk H then H = Hr r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 4 41

H sim= Hr r otimes Hr ℓ otimes Hℓr otimes Hℓℓ

Reduced k -Hopf algebras are ldquoclassified they correspond to finitegroups upon which Gal(kk) acts continuously

Then Hr r and Hr ℓ are classified and by duality so is Hℓr

Thus the most mysterious Hopf algebras are the ones of the form Hℓℓ

We will call these ldquolocal-localrdquo and assume that all Hopf algebras in thistalk are finite abelian and local-local over the perfect field k

If H is local-local then a result of Waterhouse is that H is a ldquotruncatedpolynomial algebrardquo ie

H sim= k [t1 tr ](tpn1

1 tpnr

r )

so the algebra structure isnrsquot terrible

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 5 41

Suggested readings

M Demazure and P Gabriel Groupes Algeacutebriques - Tome 1Good news partially translated into English as Introduction toAlgebraic Geometry and Algebraic GroupsBad news not the part you need (chapter 5)A Grothendieck Groupes de Barsotti-Tate et Cristaux deDieudonneacuteExplicit connection between Dieudonneacute modules and HopfalgebrasT Oda The first de Rham cohomology group and Dieudonneacutemodules The section on Dieudonneacute modules gave me my firstexplicit examplesR Pink Finite group schemeshttpspeoplemathethzch pinkftpFGSCompleteNotespdfGood intro to Dieudonneacute modules with proofs (group schemepoint of view)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 6 41

The gist

What is a k -Hopf algebra

It is a k -algebra and a k -coalgebra with compatible structures

A Dieudonneacute module is a single module (over a ring TBD) whichencodes both structures

In Mondayrsquos talk the coalgebra structure was assumed and thealgebra structure was encoded by the action of F on Dlowast(H)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 7 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 41

Witt polynomials

For each n isin Zge0 define Φn isin Z[Z0 Zn] by

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Note Φn depends on the choice of prime p which we assume to beldquoourrdquo p

Define polynomials SnPn isin Z[X0 XnY0 Yn] implicitly by

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Fact Yes the coefficients are all integers

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 41

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Example (low hanging fruit)

Φ0(Z0) = Z0

S0(X0Y0) = X0 + Y0

P0(X0Y0) = X0Y0

Exercise 1 Prove

S1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X1 + Y1 minus1p

pminus1983142

i=1

983072pi

983073X i

0Y pminusi0

P1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X p0 Y1 + X p

1 Y0 + pX1Y1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 41

Let W (Z) = (w0w1w2 ) wi isin Z for all i Define addition andmultiplication on W (Z) by

(w0w1 ) +W (x0 x1 ) = (S0(w0 x0)S1((w0w1) (x0 x1)) )

(w0w1 ) middotW (x0 x1 ) = (P0(w0 x0)P1((w0 x1) (w0 x1)) )

These operations make W (Z) into a commutative ring

Actually W (minus) is a Z-ring scheme meaning that for all Z-algebras AW (A) is a ring

In particular set W = W (k) and call this the ring of Witt vectors withcoefficients in k (or ldquoWitt vectorsrdquo for short)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 41

Properties of Witt vectors Show each of the following

Exercise 2 W is a ring of characteristic zero

Exercise 3 W is an integral domain

Exercise 4 (1 0 0 ) is the multiplicative identity of W

Exercise 5 W (Fp) sim= Zp

Exercise 6 W (Fpn) is the unramified extension of Zp of degree n

Exercise 7 The element (0 1 0 0 ) isin W acts as mult by p

Exercise 8 pnW is an ideal of W

Exercise 9 Let Wn = (w0w1 wnminus1) Then Wn is a ring withoperations induced from W

Exercise 10 WpnW sim= Wn In particular W0sim= k

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 41

Of particular importance will be two operators F V on W given by

F (w0w1w2 ) = (wp0 w

p1 w

p2 )

V (w0w1w2 ) = (0w0w1 )

F is called the Frobenius and V is called the VerschiebungShow each of the following

Exercise 11 FV = VF = p (multiplication by p)

Exercise 12 F V both act freely on W only F acts transitively

Exercise 13 If w isin pnW then Fw Vw isin pnW Thus F and V makesense on Wn as well

Exercise 14 Wn is annihilated by V n+1

Exercise 15 Any w = (w0w1w2 ) isin W decomposes as

(w0w1w2 ) =infin983142

i=0

pi(wpminusi

i 0 0 )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 41

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 5: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

H sim= Hr r otimes Hr ℓ otimes Hℓr otimes Hℓℓ

Reduced k -Hopf algebras are ldquoclassified they correspond to finitegroups upon which Gal(kk) acts continuously

Then Hr r and Hr ℓ are classified and by duality so is Hℓr

Thus the most mysterious Hopf algebras are the ones of the form Hℓℓ

We will call these ldquolocal-localrdquo and assume that all Hopf algebras in thistalk are finite abelian and local-local over the perfect field k

If H is local-local then a result of Waterhouse is that H is a ldquotruncatedpolynomial algebrardquo ie

H sim= k [t1 tr ](tpn1

1 tpnr

r )

so the algebra structure isnrsquot terrible

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 5 41

Suggested readings

M Demazure and P Gabriel Groupes Algeacutebriques - Tome 1Good news partially translated into English as Introduction toAlgebraic Geometry and Algebraic GroupsBad news not the part you need (chapter 5)A Grothendieck Groupes de Barsotti-Tate et Cristaux deDieudonneacuteExplicit connection between Dieudonneacute modules and HopfalgebrasT Oda The first de Rham cohomology group and Dieudonneacutemodules The section on Dieudonneacute modules gave me my firstexplicit examplesR Pink Finite group schemeshttpspeoplemathethzch pinkftpFGSCompleteNotespdfGood intro to Dieudonneacute modules with proofs (group schemepoint of view)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 6 41

The gist

What is a k -Hopf algebra

It is a k -algebra and a k -coalgebra with compatible structures

A Dieudonneacute module is a single module (over a ring TBD) whichencodes both structures

In Mondayrsquos talk the coalgebra structure was assumed and thealgebra structure was encoded by the action of F on Dlowast(H)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 7 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 41

Witt polynomials

For each n isin Zge0 define Φn isin Z[Z0 Zn] by

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Note Φn depends on the choice of prime p which we assume to beldquoourrdquo p

Define polynomials SnPn isin Z[X0 XnY0 Yn] implicitly by

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Fact Yes the coefficients are all integers

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 41

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Example (low hanging fruit)

Φ0(Z0) = Z0

S0(X0Y0) = X0 + Y0

P0(X0Y0) = X0Y0

Exercise 1 Prove

S1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X1 + Y1 minus1p

pminus1983142

i=1

983072pi

983073X i

0Y pminusi0

P1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X p0 Y1 + X p

1 Y0 + pX1Y1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 41

Let W (Z) = (w0w1w2 ) wi isin Z for all i Define addition andmultiplication on W (Z) by

(w0w1 ) +W (x0 x1 ) = (S0(w0 x0)S1((w0w1) (x0 x1)) )

(w0w1 ) middotW (x0 x1 ) = (P0(w0 x0)P1((w0 x1) (w0 x1)) )

These operations make W (Z) into a commutative ring

Actually W (minus) is a Z-ring scheme meaning that for all Z-algebras AW (A) is a ring

In particular set W = W (k) and call this the ring of Witt vectors withcoefficients in k (or ldquoWitt vectorsrdquo for short)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 41

Properties of Witt vectors Show each of the following

Exercise 2 W is a ring of characteristic zero

Exercise 3 W is an integral domain

Exercise 4 (1 0 0 ) is the multiplicative identity of W

Exercise 5 W (Fp) sim= Zp

Exercise 6 W (Fpn) is the unramified extension of Zp of degree n

Exercise 7 The element (0 1 0 0 ) isin W acts as mult by p

Exercise 8 pnW is an ideal of W

Exercise 9 Let Wn = (w0w1 wnminus1) Then Wn is a ring withoperations induced from W

Exercise 10 WpnW sim= Wn In particular W0sim= k

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 41

Of particular importance will be two operators F V on W given by

F (w0w1w2 ) = (wp0 w

p1 w

p2 )

V (w0w1w2 ) = (0w0w1 )

F is called the Frobenius and V is called the VerschiebungShow each of the following

Exercise 11 FV = VF = p (multiplication by p)

Exercise 12 F V both act freely on W only F acts transitively

Exercise 13 If w isin pnW then Fw Vw isin pnW Thus F and V makesense on Wn as well

Exercise 14 Wn is annihilated by V n+1

Exercise 15 Any w = (w0w1w2 ) isin W decomposes as

(w0w1w2 ) =infin983142

i=0

pi(wpminusi

i 0 0 )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 41

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 6: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Suggested readings

M Demazure and P Gabriel Groupes Algeacutebriques - Tome 1Good news partially translated into English as Introduction toAlgebraic Geometry and Algebraic GroupsBad news not the part you need (chapter 5)A Grothendieck Groupes de Barsotti-Tate et Cristaux deDieudonneacuteExplicit connection between Dieudonneacute modules and HopfalgebrasT Oda The first de Rham cohomology group and Dieudonneacutemodules The section on Dieudonneacute modules gave me my firstexplicit examplesR Pink Finite group schemeshttpspeoplemathethzch pinkftpFGSCompleteNotespdfGood intro to Dieudonneacute modules with proofs (group schemepoint of view)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 6 41

The gist

What is a k -Hopf algebra

It is a k -algebra and a k -coalgebra with compatible structures

A Dieudonneacute module is a single module (over a ring TBD) whichencodes both structures

In Mondayrsquos talk the coalgebra structure was assumed and thealgebra structure was encoded by the action of F on Dlowast(H)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 7 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 41

Witt polynomials

For each n isin Zge0 define Φn isin Z[Z0 Zn] by

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Note Φn depends on the choice of prime p which we assume to beldquoourrdquo p

Define polynomials SnPn isin Z[X0 XnY0 Yn] implicitly by

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Fact Yes the coefficients are all integers

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 41

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Example (low hanging fruit)

Φ0(Z0) = Z0

S0(X0Y0) = X0 + Y0

P0(X0Y0) = X0Y0

Exercise 1 Prove

S1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X1 + Y1 minus1p

pminus1983142

i=1

983072pi

983073X i

0Y pminusi0

P1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X p0 Y1 + X p

1 Y0 + pX1Y1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 41

Let W (Z) = (w0w1w2 ) wi isin Z for all i Define addition andmultiplication on W (Z) by

(w0w1 ) +W (x0 x1 ) = (S0(w0 x0)S1((w0w1) (x0 x1)) )

(w0w1 ) middotW (x0 x1 ) = (P0(w0 x0)P1((w0 x1) (w0 x1)) )

These operations make W (Z) into a commutative ring

Actually W (minus) is a Z-ring scheme meaning that for all Z-algebras AW (A) is a ring

In particular set W = W (k) and call this the ring of Witt vectors withcoefficients in k (or ldquoWitt vectorsrdquo for short)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 41

Properties of Witt vectors Show each of the following

Exercise 2 W is a ring of characteristic zero

Exercise 3 W is an integral domain

Exercise 4 (1 0 0 ) is the multiplicative identity of W

Exercise 5 W (Fp) sim= Zp

Exercise 6 W (Fpn) is the unramified extension of Zp of degree n

Exercise 7 The element (0 1 0 0 ) isin W acts as mult by p

Exercise 8 pnW is an ideal of W

Exercise 9 Let Wn = (w0w1 wnminus1) Then Wn is a ring withoperations induced from W

Exercise 10 WpnW sim= Wn In particular W0sim= k

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 41

Of particular importance will be two operators F V on W given by

F (w0w1w2 ) = (wp0 w

p1 w

p2 )

V (w0w1w2 ) = (0w0w1 )

F is called the Frobenius and V is called the VerschiebungShow each of the following

Exercise 11 FV = VF = p (multiplication by p)

Exercise 12 F V both act freely on W only F acts transitively

Exercise 13 If w isin pnW then Fw Vw isin pnW Thus F and V makesense on Wn as well

Exercise 14 Wn is annihilated by V n+1

Exercise 15 Any w = (w0w1w2 ) isin W decomposes as

(w0w1w2 ) =infin983142

i=0

pi(wpminusi

i 0 0 )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 41

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 7: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

The gist

What is a k -Hopf algebra

It is a k -algebra and a k -coalgebra with compatible structures

A Dieudonneacute module is a single module (over a ring TBD) whichencodes both structures

In Mondayrsquos talk the coalgebra structure was assumed and thealgebra structure was encoded by the action of F on Dlowast(H)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 7 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 41

Witt polynomials

For each n isin Zge0 define Φn isin Z[Z0 Zn] by

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Note Φn depends on the choice of prime p which we assume to beldquoourrdquo p

Define polynomials SnPn isin Z[X0 XnY0 Yn] implicitly by

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Fact Yes the coefficients are all integers

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 41

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Example (low hanging fruit)

Φ0(Z0) = Z0

S0(X0Y0) = X0 + Y0

P0(X0Y0) = X0Y0

Exercise 1 Prove

S1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X1 + Y1 minus1p

pminus1983142

i=1

983072pi

983073X i

0Y pminusi0

P1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X p0 Y1 + X p

1 Y0 + pX1Y1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 41

Let W (Z) = (w0w1w2 ) wi isin Z for all i Define addition andmultiplication on W (Z) by

(w0w1 ) +W (x0 x1 ) = (S0(w0 x0)S1((w0w1) (x0 x1)) )

(w0w1 ) middotW (x0 x1 ) = (P0(w0 x0)P1((w0 x1) (w0 x1)) )

These operations make W (Z) into a commutative ring

Actually W (minus) is a Z-ring scheme meaning that for all Z-algebras AW (A) is a ring

In particular set W = W (k) and call this the ring of Witt vectors withcoefficients in k (or ldquoWitt vectorsrdquo for short)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 41

Properties of Witt vectors Show each of the following

Exercise 2 W is a ring of characteristic zero

Exercise 3 W is an integral domain

Exercise 4 (1 0 0 ) is the multiplicative identity of W

Exercise 5 W (Fp) sim= Zp

Exercise 6 W (Fpn) is the unramified extension of Zp of degree n

Exercise 7 The element (0 1 0 0 ) isin W acts as mult by p

Exercise 8 pnW is an ideal of W

Exercise 9 Let Wn = (w0w1 wnminus1) Then Wn is a ring withoperations induced from W

Exercise 10 WpnW sim= Wn In particular W0sim= k

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 41

Of particular importance will be two operators F V on W given by

F (w0w1w2 ) = (wp0 w

p1 w

p2 )

V (w0w1w2 ) = (0w0w1 )

F is called the Frobenius and V is called the VerschiebungShow each of the following

Exercise 11 FV = VF = p (multiplication by p)

Exercise 12 F V both act freely on W only F acts transitively

Exercise 13 If w isin pnW then Fw Vw isin pnW Thus F and V makesense on Wn as well

Exercise 14 Wn is annihilated by V n+1

Exercise 15 Any w = (w0w1w2 ) isin W decomposes as

(w0w1w2 ) =infin983142

i=0

pi(wpminusi

i 0 0 )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 41

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 8: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 41

Witt polynomials

For each n isin Zge0 define Φn isin Z[Z0 Zn] by

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Note Φn depends on the choice of prime p which we assume to beldquoourrdquo p

Define polynomials SnPn isin Z[X0 XnY0 Yn] implicitly by

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Fact Yes the coefficients are all integers

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 41

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Example (low hanging fruit)

Φ0(Z0) = Z0

S0(X0Y0) = X0 + Y0

P0(X0Y0) = X0Y0

Exercise 1 Prove

S1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X1 + Y1 minus1p

pminus1983142

i=1

983072pi

983073X i

0Y pminusi0

P1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X p0 Y1 + X p

1 Y0 + pX1Y1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 41

Let W (Z) = (w0w1w2 ) wi isin Z for all i Define addition andmultiplication on W (Z) by

(w0w1 ) +W (x0 x1 ) = (S0(w0 x0)S1((w0w1) (x0 x1)) )

(w0w1 ) middotW (x0 x1 ) = (P0(w0 x0)P1((w0 x1) (w0 x1)) )

These operations make W (Z) into a commutative ring

Actually W (minus) is a Z-ring scheme meaning that for all Z-algebras AW (A) is a ring

In particular set W = W (k) and call this the ring of Witt vectors withcoefficients in k (or ldquoWitt vectorsrdquo for short)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 41

Properties of Witt vectors Show each of the following

Exercise 2 W is a ring of characteristic zero

Exercise 3 W is an integral domain

Exercise 4 (1 0 0 ) is the multiplicative identity of W

Exercise 5 W (Fp) sim= Zp

Exercise 6 W (Fpn) is the unramified extension of Zp of degree n

Exercise 7 The element (0 1 0 0 ) isin W acts as mult by p

Exercise 8 pnW is an ideal of W

Exercise 9 Let Wn = (w0w1 wnminus1) Then Wn is a ring withoperations induced from W

Exercise 10 WpnW sim= Wn In particular W0sim= k

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 41

Of particular importance will be two operators F V on W given by

F (w0w1w2 ) = (wp0 w

p1 w

p2 )

V (w0w1w2 ) = (0w0w1 )

F is called the Frobenius and V is called the VerschiebungShow each of the following

Exercise 11 FV = VF = p (multiplication by p)

Exercise 12 F V both act freely on W only F acts transitively

Exercise 13 If w isin pnW then Fw Vw isin pnW Thus F and V makesense on Wn as well

Exercise 14 Wn is annihilated by V n+1

Exercise 15 Any w = (w0w1w2 ) isin W decomposes as

(w0w1w2 ) =infin983142

i=0

pi(wpminusi

i 0 0 )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 41

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 9: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Witt polynomials

For each n isin Zge0 define Φn isin Z[Z0 Zn] by

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Note Φn depends on the choice of prime p which we assume to beldquoourrdquo p

Define polynomials SnPn isin Z[X0 XnY0 Yn] implicitly by

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Fact Yes the coefficients are all integers

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 41

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Example (low hanging fruit)

Φ0(Z0) = Z0

S0(X0Y0) = X0 + Y0

P0(X0Y0) = X0Y0

Exercise 1 Prove

S1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X1 + Y1 minus1p

pminus1983142

i=1

983072pi

983073X i

0Y pminusi0

P1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X p0 Y1 + X p

1 Y0 + pX1Y1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 41

Let W (Z) = (w0w1w2 ) wi isin Z for all i Define addition andmultiplication on W (Z) by

(w0w1 ) +W (x0 x1 ) = (S0(w0 x0)S1((w0w1) (x0 x1)) )

(w0w1 ) middotW (x0 x1 ) = (P0(w0 x0)P1((w0 x1) (w0 x1)) )

These operations make W (Z) into a commutative ring

Actually W (minus) is a Z-ring scheme meaning that for all Z-algebras AW (A) is a ring

In particular set W = W (k) and call this the ring of Witt vectors withcoefficients in k (or ldquoWitt vectorsrdquo for short)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 41

Properties of Witt vectors Show each of the following

Exercise 2 W is a ring of characteristic zero

Exercise 3 W is an integral domain

Exercise 4 (1 0 0 ) is the multiplicative identity of W

Exercise 5 W (Fp) sim= Zp

Exercise 6 W (Fpn) is the unramified extension of Zp of degree n

Exercise 7 The element (0 1 0 0 ) isin W acts as mult by p

Exercise 8 pnW is an ideal of W

Exercise 9 Let Wn = (w0w1 wnminus1) Then Wn is a ring withoperations induced from W

Exercise 10 WpnW sim= Wn In particular W0sim= k

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 41

Of particular importance will be two operators F V on W given by

F (w0w1w2 ) = (wp0 w

p1 w

p2 )

V (w0w1w2 ) = (0w0w1 )

F is called the Frobenius and V is called the VerschiebungShow each of the following

Exercise 11 FV = VF = p (multiplication by p)

Exercise 12 F V both act freely on W only F acts transitively

Exercise 13 If w isin pnW then Fw Vw isin pnW Thus F and V makesense on Wn as well

Exercise 14 Wn is annihilated by V n+1

Exercise 15 Any w = (w0w1w2 ) isin W decomposes as

(w0w1w2 ) =infin983142

i=0

pi(wpminusi

i 0 0 )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 41

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 10: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Φn(Z0 Zn) = Z pn

0 + pZ pnminus1

1 + middot middot middot+ pnZn

Φn(S0 Sn) = Φn(X0 Xn) + Φn(Y0 Yn)

Φn(P0 Pn) = Φn(X0 Xn)Φn(Y0 Yn)

Example (low hanging fruit)

Φ0(Z0) = Z0

S0(X0Y0) = X0 + Y0

P0(X0Y0) = X0Y0

Exercise 1 Prove

S1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X1 + Y1 minus1p

pminus1983142

i=1

983072pi

983073X i

0Y pminusi0

P1((X0X1) (Y0Y1)) = X p0 Y1 + X p

1 Y0 + pX1Y1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 41

Let W (Z) = (w0w1w2 ) wi isin Z for all i Define addition andmultiplication on W (Z) by

(w0w1 ) +W (x0 x1 ) = (S0(w0 x0)S1((w0w1) (x0 x1)) )

(w0w1 ) middotW (x0 x1 ) = (P0(w0 x0)P1((w0 x1) (w0 x1)) )

These operations make W (Z) into a commutative ring

Actually W (minus) is a Z-ring scheme meaning that for all Z-algebras AW (A) is a ring

In particular set W = W (k) and call this the ring of Witt vectors withcoefficients in k (or ldquoWitt vectorsrdquo for short)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 41

Properties of Witt vectors Show each of the following

Exercise 2 W is a ring of characteristic zero

Exercise 3 W is an integral domain

Exercise 4 (1 0 0 ) is the multiplicative identity of W

Exercise 5 W (Fp) sim= Zp

Exercise 6 W (Fpn) is the unramified extension of Zp of degree n

Exercise 7 The element (0 1 0 0 ) isin W acts as mult by p

Exercise 8 pnW is an ideal of W

Exercise 9 Let Wn = (w0w1 wnminus1) Then Wn is a ring withoperations induced from W

Exercise 10 WpnW sim= Wn In particular W0sim= k

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 41

Of particular importance will be two operators F V on W given by

F (w0w1w2 ) = (wp0 w

p1 w

p2 )

V (w0w1w2 ) = (0w0w1 )

F is called the Frobenius and V is called the VerschiebungShow each of the following

Exercise 11 FV = VF = p (multiplication by p)

Exercise 12 F V both act freely on W only F acts transitively

Exercise 13 If w isin pnW then Fw Vw isin pnW Thus F and V makesense on Wn as well

Exercise 14 Wn is annihilated by V n+1

Exercise 15 Any w = (w0w1w2 ) isin W decomposes as

(w0w1w2 ) =infin983142

i=0

pi(wpminusi

i 0 0 )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 41

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 11: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Let W (Z) = (w0w1w2 ) wi isin Z for all i Define addition andmultiplication on W (Z) by

(w0w1 ) +W (x0 x1 ) = (S0(w0 x0)S1((w0w1) (x0 x1)) )

(w0w1 ) middotW (x0 x1 ) = (P0(w0 x0)P1((w0 x1) (w0 x1)) )

These operations make W (Z) into a commutative ring

Actually W (minus) is a Z-ring scheme meaning that for all Z-algebras AW (A) is a ring

In particular set W = W (k) and call this the ring of Witt vectors withcoefficients in k (or ldquoWitt vectorsrdquo for short)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 41

Properties of Witt vectors Show each of the following

Exercise 2 W is a ring of characteristic zero

Exercise 3 W is an integral domain

Exercise 4 (1 0 0 ) is the multiplicative identity of W

Exercise 5 W (Fp) sim= Zp

Exercise 6 W (Fpn) is the unramified extension of Zp of degree n

Exercise 7 The element (0 1 0 0 ) isin W acts as mult by p

Exercise 8 pnW is an ideal of W

Exercise 9 Let Wn = (w0w1 wnminus1) Then Wn is a ring withoperations induced from W

Exercise 10 WpnW sim= Wn In particular W0sim= k

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 41

Of particular importance will be two operators F V on W given by

F (w0w1w2 ) = (wp0 w

p1 w

p2 )

V (w0w1w2 ) = (0w0w1 )

F is called the Frobenius and V is called the VerschiebungShow each of the following

Exercise 11 FV = VF = p (multiplication by p)

Exercise 12 F V both act freely on W only F acts transitively

Exercise 13 If w isin pnW then Fw Vw isin pnW Thus F and V makesense on Wn as well

Exercise 14 Wn is annihilated by V n+1

Exercise 15 Any w = (w0w1w2 ) isin W decomposes as

(w0w1w2 ) =infin983142

i=0

pi(wpminusi

i 0 0 )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 41

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 12: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Properties of Witt vectors Show each of the following

Exercise 2 W is a ring of characteristic zero

Exercise 3 W is an integral domain

Exercise 4 (1 0 0 ) is the multiplicative identity of W

Exercise 5 W (Fp) sim= Zp

Exercise 6 W (Fpn) is the unramified extension of Zp of degree n

Exercise 7 The element (0 1 0 0 ) isin W acts as mult by p

Exercise 8 pnW is an ideal of W

Exercise 9 Let Wn = (w0w1 wnminus1) Then Wn is a ring withoperations induced from W

Exercise 10 WpnW sim= Wn In particular W0sim= k

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 41

Of particular importance will be two operators F V on W given by

F (w0w1w2 ) = (wp0 w

p1 w

p2 )

V (w0w1w2 ) = (0w0w1 )

F is called the Frobenius and V is called the VerschiebungShow each of the following

Exercise 11 FV = VF = p (multiplication by p)

Exercise 12 F V both act freely on W only F acts transitively

Exercise 13 If w isin pnW then Fw Vw isin pnW Thus F and V makesense on Wn as well

Exercise 14 Wn is annihilated by V n+1

Exercise 15 Any w = (w0w1w2 ) isin W decomposes as

(w0w1w2 ) =infin983142

i=0

pi(wpminusi

i 0 0 )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 41

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 13: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Of particular importance will be two operators F V on W given by

F (w0w1w2 ) = (wp0 w

p1 w

p2 )

V (w0w1w2 ) = (0w0w1 )

F is called the Frobenius and V is called the VerschiebungShow each of the following

Exercise 11 FV = VF = p (multiplication by p)

Exercise 12 F V both act freely on W only F acts transitively

Exercise 13 If w isin pnW then Fw Vw isin pnW Thus F and V makesense on Wn as well

Exercise 14 Wn is annihilated by V n+1

Exercise 15 Any w = (w0w1w2 ) isin W decomposes as

(w0w1w2 ) =infin983142

i=0

pi(wpminusi

i 0 0 )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 41

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 14: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 41

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 15: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

The Dieudonneacute ring

Now let wσ be the Frobenius on w isin W (invertible since k is perfect)

Let E = W [F V ] be the ring of polynomials with

FV = VF = p Fw = wσF wV = Vwσw isin W

We call E the Dieudonneacute ring

Note that E is commutative if and only if k = Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 41

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 16: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

One more construction

Let us view Wn as a group scheme (as opposed to the ring Wn(k))

Let W mn be the mth Frobenius kernel of the group scheme Wn ie for

any k -algebra A

W mn (A) = (a0 a1 anminus1) ai isin A apm

i = 0 for all 0 le i le n minus 1

Some properties of W mn

Clearly F Wn rarr Wn restricts to F W mn rarr W m

n Also V Wn rarr Wn restricts to V W m

n rarr W mn

For each k -algebra A W (k) acts on W (A) through the algebrastructure map k rarr AEvery local-local Hopf algebra represents a subgroup scheme ofsome (W m

n )r

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 41

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 17: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

There are maps ι W mn rarr W m+1

n (inclusion) and ν W mn rarr W m

n+1(induced by V ) such that

W mn

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n983117983117983175ν ν

983117983117983175

W mn+1

ιminusminusminusminusrarr W m+1n+1

Then W mn is a direct system (where the partial ordering

(nm) le (nprimemprime) is given by the conditions n le nprime m le mprime)

Let983153W = limminusrarr

mnW m

n

(Not standard notation)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 41

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 18: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Let H be a local-local Hopf algebra Define

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

The actions of F and V on 983153W induces actions on Dlowast(H) as does theaction of W (k)

Thus Dlowast(H) is an E-module

Furthermore Dlowast(minus) is a covariant functor despite the fact this isreferred to as ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 41

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 19: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Properties of DlowastDlowast(H) is killed by some power of F and V Dlowast(H) is finite length as a W -modulelengthW Dlowast(H) = logp dimk HDlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)Note Spec(H1 otimes H2) sim= Spec(H1)times Spec(H2)

Theorem (Main result in Dieudonneacute module theory)Dlowast induces a categorical equivalence

983110983114

983112

p- power ranklocal-local

k-Hopf algebras

983111983115

983113 minusrarr

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113

We call E-modules satisfying the above Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 41

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 20: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

This is not everyonersquos definition

Dieudonneacute modules can also be used to describep-power rank Hopf algebras (local separable)p-divisible groupsgraded Hopf algebrasprimitively generated Hopf algebrasa slew of other things

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 41

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 21: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Another legal disclaimer

983110983114

983112

E-modulesof finite length over W (k)

killed by a power of F and V

983111983115

983113 = ldquoDieudonneacute modulesrdquo

Some literature will describe a Dieudonneacute module as a triple (MF V )where

M is a finite length W (k)-moduleF M rarr M is a nilpotent σ-semilinear mapV M rarr M is a nilpotent σminus1-semilinear map

This is just a different way to describe the same thing

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 41

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 22: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

A Hopf algebra interpretation

Dlowast(H) = Homk -gr983054983153W Spec(H)

983055

Each W mn is an affine group scheme represented by

Hmn = k [t0 tnminus1](tpm

1 tpm

2 tpm

nminus1)

with comultiplications induced from Witt vector addition

∆(ti) = Si((t0 otimes 1 ti otimes 1) (1 otimes t0 1 otimes ti))

In theory we could possibly write something like

Dlowast(H) = Homk -Hopf(H limlarrminusmn

Hmn)

However I have never found this to be helpful

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 41

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 23: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

No wait come back

Suppose we are given a Dieudonneacute module What is thecorresponding Hopf algebra

Suppose V N+1M = 0 Let H = k [Tm m isin M] subject to therelations

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

T(w0w1 )m = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

mm1m2 isin M (w0w1 ) isin W

Define ∆ H rarr H otimes H by

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nmotimes1TV Nminus1motimes1 Tmotimes1) (1otimesTV Nm 1otimesTm))

Then H is a local-local k -Hopf algebra

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 41

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 24: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

The gist part 2

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

The action of F describes the (interesting) algebra structure

The action of V describes the coalgebra structure

Exercise 16 Show that the N above need not be minimal

Exercise 17 Let M be a Dieudonneacute module Show that T0 = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 25: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 41

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 26: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = SN((TV Nm1 TVm1 Tm1) (TV Nm2

TVm2 Tm2)

Twm = PN((wpminusN

0 wpminusN

N ) (TV Nm TVmTm)

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

ExampleThe simplest possible (nontrivial) E-module is a k -vector space M ofdimension 1 with F and V acting triviallyIn other words M = EE(F V ) In particular N = 1 Let M havek -basis x and let H be the Hopf algebra with Dlowast(H) = M

Exercise 18 Prove H is generated as a k -algebra by t where t = Tx

Sincetp =

983054Tx

983055p= TFx = T0 = 0

we have H = k [t ](tp) Also by the formulas above t is primitive

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 41

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 27: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Primitively generated flashback

Suppose H is primitively generated (and local-local) and letM = Dlowast(H)

Since

∆(Tm) = SN((TV Nm otimes 1 Tm otimes 1) (1 otimes TV Nm 1 otimes Tm))

it follows that we may take N = 0

Thus VM = 0 hence M can be viewed as a module over k [F ] with

TFm = (Tm)p

Tm1+m2 = Tm1 + Tm2

Twm = w0Tm

In this case itrsquos the same module as yesterday

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 41

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 28: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

ExampleLet M = E(F mV n) = Dlowast(H)

Exercise 19 What is pM

Exercise 20 Exhibit a k -basis for M

Exercise 21 Prove that

H = k [t1 tn](tpm

1 tpm

n )

Exercise 22 Write out the comultiplication (in terms of Witt vectoraddition)

Exercise 23 Show that Spec(H) = W mn

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 41

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 29: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Let H = k [t ](tp5) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp3i otimes tp3(pminusi)1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose there is an x isin M such that t = Tx Then

0 = tp5=

983054Tx

983055p5= TF 5x

so F 5x = 0 from which it follows that F 5M = 0 but F 4M ∕= 0 Also

∆(t) = S1983054((Tx)

p3 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p3 1 otimes Tx)

983055

= S1983054TF 3x otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes TF 3x 1 otimes Tx)

Then N = 1 (ie V 2M = 0) and Vm = F 3m Thus

M sim= EE(F 5F 3 minus V V 2) = EE(F 5F 3 minus V )

This can be confirmed by working backwardsAlan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 41

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 30: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Let H = k [t1 t2](tp2

1 tp2

2 ) with

∆(t1) = t1 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t1

∆(t1) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

What is Dlowast(H)Let M = Dlowast(H) and suppose x y isin M satisfy t1 = Tx t2 = Ty Clearly F 2x = F 2y = 0 and

∆(t1) = S0(Tx otimes 1 1 otimes Tx)

= S1((0 otimes 1Tx otimes 1) (1 otimes 0 1 otimes Tx))

∆(t2) = S1983054((Tx)

p otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes (Tx)p 1 otimes Ty )

983055

= S1983054(TFx otimes 1Ty otimes 1) (1 otimes TFx 1 otimes Ty )

983055

Thus Vx = 0 and Vy = Fx So

M = Ex + Ey F 2M = V 2M = 0Vx = 0Fx = Vy

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 41

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 31: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Exercises

Write out the Hopf algebra for each of the following Be as explicit asyou can

Exercise 24 M = E(F 2F minus V )

Exercise 25 M = EE(F 2V 2)

Exercise 26 M = EE(F 2 pV 2)

Exercise 27M = Ex + Ey F 4x = 0F 3y = 0Vx = F 2y V 2x = 0Vy = 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 41

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 32: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

More exercises

Find the Dieudonneacute module for each of the following

Exercise 28 H = k [t ](tp4) t primitive

Exercise 29 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi1 otimes tp(pminusi)

1

Exercise 30 H = k [t1 t2](tp3

1 tp2

2 ) t1 primitive and

∆(t2) = t2 otimes 1 + 1 otimes t2 +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i1 otimes tp2(pminusi)

1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 33: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 41

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 34: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

How does duality work

Very nicely with the proper definitions

For an E-module M we define its dual Mlowast to be

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

This is an E-module where F and V act on φ M rarr W [pminus1]W asfollows

(Fφ)(m) = (φ(Vm))σ

(Vφ)(m) = (φ(Fm))σminus1

Note The σ σminus1 make Fφ Vφ into maps which are W -linear

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 41

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 35: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Mlowast = HomW (MW [pminus1]W )

PropertiesIf M is a Dieudonneacute module so is Mlowast(EE(F nV m))lowast = EE(F mV n)ldquoDuality interchanges the roles of F and V rdquoDlowast(Hlowast) = (Dlowast(H))lowast

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 41

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 36: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

An example

Let H = Fp[t ](tp3) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tp2i otimes tp2(pminusi)

The choice of k = Fp is only for ease of notation

Then M = EE(F 3F 2 minus V ) = kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x as W -modules

We wish to compute HomW (MW [pminus1]W ) = HomZp(MQpZp)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 41

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 37: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

HomZp(EE(F 3F 2 minus V )QpZp)

Note that any φ kx oplus kFx oplus kF 2x rarr QpZp is determined by theimages of x Fx and F 2x

Note also that V (Fx) = V (F 2x) = 0 which will be useful later

Since px = FVx = F (F 2x) = F 3x = 0

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

where φ isin Mlowast is given by

φ(x) = wφ(Fx) = y

φ(F 2x) = z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 41

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 38: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

φ(x) = w φ(Fx) = y φ(F 2x) = z

Mlowast sim= (w y z) isin (QpZp)3 pw py pz isin Zp

Now F acts on φ by

(Fφ)(x) = (φ(Vx))σ = (φ(F 2x))σ = zσ = z (Fφ)(y) = (Fφ(z)) = 0

and V acts on φ by

(Vφ)(x) = (φ(Fx))σminus1

= yσminus1= y

(Vφ)(Fx) = (φ(F 2x))σminus1

= zσminus1= z

(Vφ(z)) = 0

Thus F (w y z) = (z 0 0) V (w y z) = (y z 0)Clearly for all u = (w y z) we have V 3u = 0 and V 2u = FuIt follows that Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 41

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 39: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

H = Fp[t ](tp3) Mlowast = EE(V 3V 2 minus F )

Exercise 31 Using Mlowast give the algebra structure for Hlowast (Hint Itrequires two generators)

Exercise 32 Using Mlowast give the coalgebra structure for Hlowast

Exercise 33 What changes if k ∕= Fp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 41

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 40: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

Outline

1 Overview

2 Witt Vectors

3 Dieudonneacute Modules

4 Some Examples

5 Duality

6 Want More

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 41

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41

Page 41: Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory...Dieudonné module theory, part II: the classical theory Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 24, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott

More is coming tomorrow

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 41